Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ethical Minefields When Lawyers Serve as Expert Witnesses
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everybody. My name is Mike Douglas, and
- 0:07I'm the chair of the HBA's ethics and legal malpractice
- 0:12law section. Thank you for joining us in our
- 0:16first CLE session of 2026. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:22our speakers, Joel Osmond and Adam Telanoff.
- 0:27Joel is a partner and the general counsel at
- 0:30Parker Shafi. where he concentrates his practice
- 0:34on complex litigation and trials. Joel has been
- 0:39working for decades and brings tons of experience
- 0:41across professional liability, general liability,
- 0:45product liability, construction defect, and commercial
- 0:49litigation practice areas with a particular focus
- 0:53on the defense of lawyers and on legal ethics.
- 0:58Joel has tried numerous jury trials to verdict.
- 1:00testifies as an expert witness and is widely
- 1:05respected for his leadership in professional
- 1:07responsibility matters. Adam Telanoff is senior
- 1:11counsel at Parker Shaffee where he focuses on
- 1:15professional liability and commercial litigation
- 1:17for clients ranging from small businesses to
- 1:21large enterprises. Adam's Adam brings a distinctive
- 1:26blend of litigation experience and in -house
- 1:29leadership, having successfully represented clients
- 1:33before administrative tribunals, arbitrations,
- 1:37state and federal courts across multiple jurisdictions.
- 1:41Adam also offers a strong business perspective
- 1:44shaped by his roles as general counsel and co
- 1:49-founder in the entertainment, finance, and technology
- 1:53sectors. So with that, let's get started. Joel,
- 1:57you want to begin? I'll be happy to. First of
- 2:00all, thank you, Mike. And also thanks generally
- 2:04to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for the
- 2:06opportunity to present today. I do want to compliment
- 2:10Beverly Hills Bar Association. Their marketing
- 2:13materials are always interesting and in this
- 2:19particular instance are more colorful than the
- 2:21title of the presentation that you're about to
- 2:25to witness the marketing materials talk about
- 2:29ethical minefields, which is a lot more sexy
- 2:31than our current topic. But notwithstanding the
- 2:37lack of sexiness in this topic, let's start.
- 2:39Adam, do we have the next slide, please? And
- 2:43the next one after that. Yes. Adam and Joel are
- 2:47adequately pretty, but that's not why we're here.
- 2:49Let's start with a couple of basic things. Our
- 2:53objectives for this exercise is to understand
- 2:56ethical framework for attorneys as experts and
- 2:58to identify conflict and confidentiality risks
- 3:02in those contexts. Next frame, please. In order
- 3:07for us to do that, we have to first start off
- 3:09with some brief comments about the elements of
- 3:12legal malpractice. And I should say in preface
- 3:15that we're contemplating lawyers as experts in
- 3:19the context of legal malpractice. So what are
- 3:22the elements of legal malpractice cases? Well,
- 3:25there are four, basically. The first one, of
- 3:27course, is duty. And that really boils down to
- 3:30the existence of an attorney -client relationship.
- 3:32Was there such a relationship? And if so, do
- 3:35these flow from that? Generally speaking, the
- 3:39existence of an attorney -client relationship
- 3:41is a legal question for the court. You can take
- 3:44a look at the case cited below. the responsible
- 3:48citizens versus pure court case in 1993 case.
- 3:52But in consideration of those factors, they're
- 3:55usually factual issues which underpin this determination
- 3:58and courts frequently find expert testimony useful
- 4:01in determining those factual issues that underpin
- 4:05the determination. It's a little redundant, I
- 4:08apologize for that. Next slide, please. The second
- 4:13element of a legal malpractice case is breach.
- 4:17or as we say here, the standard of care. Did
- 4:20the attorney breach the applicable standard of
- 4:22care? Expert test one is generally required on
- 4:26the issue of breach. Take a look at the O'Shea
- 4:29versus Lindbergh case in 2021, and also the Unigard
- 4:34versus Cofflerty matter, which is a 1995 case,
- 4:38which tells us among other things that as a general
- 4:42rule, the standard of care against which the
- 4:45professional's acts are measured remains a matter
- 4:48peculiarly within the knowledge of experts. Once
- 4:53again, it's hard to conceive of a possible legal
- 4:56malpractice case in which there was not going
- 4:58to be expert testimony on the subject of breach.
- 5:03Anything you want to add to that, Al? No, I mean,
- 5:06technically you may have something that's so
- 5:08egregious that it does not require an expert
- 5:11testimony, but I don't think we're ever going
- 5:13to run across those. And I think generally as
- 5:16a matter of, it's generally understood that you
- 5:19have to have an expert to establish the expert
- 5:24testimony to establish the elements of a legal
- 5:26malpractice case. I can't really imagine the
- 5:29situation in which even the most egregious breach
- 5:32of the standard of care did not require expert
- 5:34testimony. And this is both plaintiff side and
- 5:38defense side are going to need their experts
- 5:40on the issue of standard of care. In fact, there's
- 5:44case law which suggests that the absence of expert
- 5:46testimony in a legal malpractice case, basically,
- 5:51you can't, you have to have the expert and if
- 5:54you don't, you could be subject to an onsage.
- 5:58So let's move on to the next element of our legal
- 6:01malpractice. And that would be causation, the
- 6:05third element. This is basically, but for the
- 6:08attorney's negligence, or acts or negligent acts
- 6:12or omissions, the client would have achieved
- 6:14a more favorable result. The basic premise is
- 6:18set forth in Viner versus Sweet, the 2003 case.
- 6:23But it's worth noting for our purposes here that
- 6:26causation and damages are generally linked and
- 6:29generally require what we refer to as a case
- 6:32within a case analysis. That is to say, in order
- 6:35to prove up causation and damages, you actually
- 6:38have to effectively try the underlying case as
- 6:43part of your malpractice case. And it's more
- 6:47often than not, in fact, it's almost always required
- 6:49that to be expert testimony to establish the
- 6:52causal link in the case within a case analysis.
- 6:56Anything you choose to add on that, Adam? No,
- 6:59I think it's just that this is really key and
- 7:04you're not going to necessarily have the advantage
- 7:07of everything that was available in the underlying
- 7:11case. And that's a situation where the experts
- 7:13can come in handy to accelerate the case within
- 7:18a case. Okay. Then our final element of legal
- 7:24malpractice is damages. Generally speaking, proof
- 7:29of damages often injured. changes on expert evaluation,
- 7:35specifically dealing with questions of loss of
- 7:37recovery, settlement values, or verdict potential.
- 7:41In most cases, plaintiffs can't merely rely.
- 7:45This is not an auto case where somebody could
- 7:47have an opinion as to how much their damages
- 7:49were. This is a legal malpractice case, and plaintiffs
- 7:53cannot rely merely on lay test money to establish
- 7:56the damage element of a malpractice claim. Yeah,
- 8:02and I think, and this one is the distinction
- 8:03between the experts who would be calculating
- 8:06damages and the legal malpractice expert, the
- 8:11attorney as an expert who would be opining about
- 8:15the availability of damages. Yeah, I agree with
- 8:22that. By the way, we are going to be posting
- 8:25Q &A in the... potential questions in the Q &A
- 8:31section, which I don't actually see on my screen
- 8:35right now, but Mike will be monitoring it for
- 8:38us. We would like to, and I realize that people
- 8:41can't speak to us right now, but our plan is
- 8:44if we have any time at the end of the proceedings,
- 8:47we will take questions from the Q &A, any Q &A
- 8:52that's posted. So we encourage everybody to post
- 8:54their Q &A. Are there questions? And we'll get
- 8:57to them if the opportunity presents itself. Yes.
- 9:00Post your Q and we'll try and get to the A. That's
- 9:04very clever. I wish I'd said that. Next slide,
- 9:07please. So in summary, having talked about the
- 9:13elements of the legal malpractice cause of action,
- 9:16it's pretty clear to us that attorneys are uniquely
- 9:19positioned as experts in the context of legal
- 9:22malpractice. Having said that, next slide, please.
- 9:29So I guess this is where I can jump in. Attorneys
- 9:34are subject to the rules of professional conduct,
- 9:38all the professional ethical requirements, regardless
- 9:41of what you're doing. So presumably, all of us
- 9:43here are attorneys. We all signed on to be governed
- 9:47by the ethical rules. impact us in everything
- 9:51we do, not just when we're representing a client.
- 9:55This goes back to the case of Librarian versus
- 9:58State Bar, 1943. I think everybody has probably
- 10:03been practicing after that date who's on this.
- 10:07But professional responsibilities do not turn
- 10:09on whether a member of the State Bar acts as
- 10:11a lawyer. So you will find yourself subject to
- 10:15the ethical requirements in any capacity in which
- 10:18you are acting. now that you are a member of
- 10:21the bar. Now, there are some situations when
- 10:27you're not acting as an attorney where there
- 10:28are specific rules of professional conduct. We
- 10:32put these here, it's 2 .4 when you're acting
- 10:35as a neutral, 2 .4 .1, the specific neutral that
- 10:39is a temporary judge. Rule 3 .3 has to do with
- 10:42candor to the court. This applies in whatever
- 10:45capacity you are addressing the court, not just
- 10:48when you are a lawyer. I know we generally think
- 10:51about it that way, but if you are testifying
- 10:53as an expert, you will be covered by 3 .3. And
- 10:583 .7 is when a lawyer is also acting as an advocate.
- 11:02There are specific rules. How about when you
- 11:05are acting as an expert witness? The answer is
- 11:09no. There is not yet a rule that governs when
- 11:12an attorney acts as an expert, which is why we're
- 11:15having this presentation. Okay, here we go. You
- 11:22actually anticipated me, thank you very much.
- 11:25We don't actually yet have a rule of professional
- 11:28conduct which addresses lawyers acting as experts.
- 11:32But we do have a couple of things that are worth
- 11:34noting. First of all, we have the interim opinion
- 11:42published by the standing committee for California
- 11:46State Bar standing committee for professional
- 11:48responsibility and conduct. That's interim opinion
- 11:51number 2000 -001. That interim opinion, the public
- 11:57comments have closed on that. We looked in preparation
- 12:03for this for this presentation and we couldn't
- 12:06find that it actually been formally published,
- 12:08but I expect it will be published thereafter
- 12:11shortly. shortly after this presentation. And
- 12:16I direct your attention to that interim opinion,
- 12:19which we'll discuss in the next slide. There's
- 12:21also an ADA formal opinion, number 97 -407, which
- 12:28is actually in many ways quite similar to the
- 12:31Co -PRAC Interim Opinion 2000 -001. There are
- 12:36minor differences. You should be aware that neither
- 12:40the Co -PRAC opinion nor the ADA opinion are
- 12:44controlling authority, but presuming that both
- 12:48of them are ultimately finalized, they are persuasive
- 12:51authority, and they provide a lot of the basis
- 12:54for what we're going to be discussing regarding
- 12:57our ethical minefields here. Yes. Do you have
- 13:01anything to add, please, Adam? No, we will be
- 13:04addressing those issues later on in the presentations,
- 13:07so this is a preview for you. OK, so let's take
- 13:10a look. We have one quote on the next slide of
- 13:13the interim opinion. A lawyer acting solely as
- 13:16a testifying expert is not representing the party
- 13:19on whose behalf the lawyer is testifying. This
- 13:23is a key and important distinction. Lawyers who
- 13:28are testifying as experts still have to adhere
- 13:30to the general rules of professional conduct,
- 13:32which Adam's already discussed in some detail.
- 13:37Yeah, I think. Go ahead, please, Sam. Yeah, I
- 13:40was going to say this is something that came
- 13:42in and was borrowed from the ABA model rules,
- 13:46which spend a lot of time differentiating between
- 13:49a testifying expert witness and a consulting
- 13:52expert witness. It's something that we're going
- 13:54to touch on as well. But this is actually the
- 13:58original interim opinion has changed to specify
- 14:01this testifying expert witness designation. And
- 14:04the other key is the use of the word representing,
- 14:07which we're going to be addressing. shortly as
- 14:09well. And then finally, as we look at the comments
- 14:14or this quote or paraphrasing of the interim
- 14:18opinion, there's a key distinction that with
- 14:22respect to experting and confidentiality. In
- 14:27essence, when we serve as an expert first, when
- 14:32we're first engaged, perhaps as an expert consultant,
- 14:34that engagement and all the information that
- 14:37was provided to the potential clients in that
- 14:40engagement are confidential unless and until
- 14:43we are actually designated as expert and provide
- 14:48our files, the files that we've generated in
- 14:52connection with that designation and ultimately
- 14:54testify that once the file is provided pursuant
- 14:59to a designation as an expert witness, there's
- 15:03no confidentiality. confidentiality that attaches
- 15:06to that file and there's certainly no confidentiality
- 15:09that attaches to any testimony in connection
- 15:11with that file. Anything you care to elaborate
- 15:15on? Yeah, I think that that ties in with the
- 15:18representation and we'll see that's the basis
- 15:20for the analysis and the interim opinion 20 -0001
- 15:25that we'll be getting to in just a moment. So
- 15:29as a practical matter, and I think Mike mentioned
- 15:32in our in his introduction, I and a couple of
- 15:38my partners actually do expert engagements on
- 15:40a fairly regular basis. One of the things we
- 15:44are very cognizant of is when we do an expert
- 15:50engagement letter is to define the scope of our
- 15:52expert engagement and to also define and make
- 15:55clear to the parties who are retaining us. We're
- 16:01your expert consultant unless and until you decide
- 16:03you want us to be your expert testifier and there
- 16:07are differences in our conduct and what we can
- 16:09and cannot do and what we can and cannot maintain,
- 16:14confidentiality that we can and cannot maintain,
- 16:16when those differences, when you progress from
- 16:19being an expert consultant to being an expert
- 16:21testifying witness. And that's a key distinction
- 16:24that's going to be evident throughout our discussion
- 16:26this afternoon. So I think we're ready. I'm looking
- 16:33at Adam's waiting for him to say something, and
- 16:35I'm not sure we're saying it. I am saying that
- 16:38ties us into the questions that we're going to
- 16:40be answering or attempting to answer today. OK.
- 16:44We basically have three questions, which are
- 16:49here in summary form, and we'll get to each separate
- 16:51questions. But these are basically common ethical
- 16:54questions to use to paraphrase from the marketing
- 16:59materials These are potential ethical minefields
- 17:03that need to be addressed any time a lawyer is
- 17:05serving as an expert. Can an attorney act as
- 17:09an expert in a position adverse to a former client?
- 17:14Second question, can an attorney act as an, can
- 17:19an attorney act as an attorney adverse to a party
- 17:23for whom the attorney acted as an expert? And
- 17:26the final question, can an attorney act as an
- 17:30expert adverse to a client of their own law firm?
- 17:36Hopefully, you guys will find this interesting
- 17:38and useful and we'll fill up your entire hour
- 17:41and give you many, many insights as we do so.
- 17:46Taking off to the first question, Adam, please
- 17:49tell us what it's about. All right. So the first
- 17:51question is whether or not an attorney can act
- 17:53as an expert in a position adverse to a former
- 17:57client. And the answer is yes. But we have a
- 18:01star. But it's a qualified yes. It is a qualified
- 18:04yes. As with so many things in the law, we can
- 18:07say, yeah, but, and we'll talk about some of
- 18:11those buts now. And you'll notice that we're
- 18:14going to use a lot of that star or the asterisk
- 18:17to let you know that our answers are hedged.
- 18:20So when we're looking at the role of an attorney
- 18:24acting as an expert in a position adverse to
- 18:28a former client, we're going to start with the
- 18:30rules of professional conduct. And rule of professional
- 18:34conduct 1 .9 is something that hopefully you
- 18:37are all familiar with in your practice. It requires
- 18:41a lawyer to not take a position adverse to a
- 18:45former client. Now the key here is that The lawyer
- 18:49who has formerly represented a client in a matter
- 18:52shall not thereafter represent another person
- 18:55in the same or substantially related matter.
- 18:58The key term here is, of course, representation.
- 19:04And the question is going to be whether or not
- 19:07the expert is representing the client. Because
- 19:12to the extent that you are acting as an expert
- 19:15or somebody is acting as an expert, they should
- 19:18not be representing the client. And that is an
- 19:21important distinction. And that distinction allows
- 19:24the expert to not be bound by the requirements
- 19:27of 1 .9 that only reply or relate to representation.
- 19:33But of course, there's always a caveat. And that
- 19:36is there may still be confidentiality issues
- 19:39that arise despite the fact that there is no
- 19:42representation in the expert witness role. In
- 19:47order to help us with that, we can kind of look
- 19:50at what's the difference between an advocate
- 19:52and a witness. The advocate is providing the
- 19:56legal advice. They're looking forward. They're
- 19:58kind of come up with strategy and tactics focused
- 20:02on the result. And I'm sure everybody here is
- 20:05persuasive. The witness, on the other hand, and
- 20:09an expert witness in particular, is not providing
- 20:12advice, but is providing their expert opinion.
- 20:15They're looking backwards at what has happened.
- 20:17They're not looking forward to what is going
- 20:19to be happening. They should not be concerned
- 20:22with strategy or tactics because the expert witness
- 20:26is supposed to be dispassionately applying the
- 20:29rules and norms to the past actions. These distinctions
- 20:34should be clean cut between being an advocate
- 20:37and being a witness. I think in actual practice,
- 20:42and Joel may want to chime in on this, that the
- 20:45line between being an advocate and a witness
- 20:47gets blurred. And one of the things that practitioners
- 20:51should be concerned about is helping the expert
- 20:55witness to maintain that distinction between
- 20:59acting as a witness and acting as an advocate.
- 21:02Let me interject here, because there are a couple
- 21:05of practice points here I want to point out.
- 21:08First of all, whenever you do an expert engagement,
- 21:12you obviously want to have a written engagement
- 21:15agreement, retainer agreement. And we think,
- 21:19and we certainly try to do this, it's important
- 21:22in that agreement to make it clear that the lawyer
- 21:27who's being retained to serve as an expert witness
- 21:31is not being retained to represent either the
- 21:35attorneys who have engaged him or the clients
- 21:38who those attorneys represent. In fact, we go
- 21:42to some lengths in our own practice to make sure
- 21:44that that distinction and that disclaimer of
- 21:47representation is made very, very clear in our
- 21:50retainer agreement. And this is one of those
- 21:53things, just sort of a general practice point.
- 21:56Your retainer agreement is your friend. It defines
- 21:59the scope of any engagement. It defines the limits
- 22:02to that scope of engagement. And in this particular
- 22:05instance, it defines when, for instance, whether
- 22:09we're representing either the attorneys or their
- 22:12clients or whether we're actually serving solely
- 22:14as an expert. And that's an important distinction
- 22:16and one that you should bear in mind in any expert
- 22:21engagement, whether you're actually being hired
- 22:23as an expert or whether you're hiring an expert.
- 22:26Another point is you're going to see some references
- 22:29In the next slide to the Businesses and Professions
- 22:32Code, the State Bar Act, BNP Code Section 6000
- 22:39at SEC. And of course, you've already seen references
- 22:41to the Rules of Professional Conduct. Just as
- 22:44a general reminder, the Rules of Professional
- 22:47Conduct are promulgated by the State Bar and
- 22:51blessed by the Supreme Court. The Businesses
- 22:55and Professions Code and the State Bar Act is
- 22:57a creature of the legislature. The RPC and the
- 23:03BNP code are substantially similar, but by virtue
- 23:07of the fact that they're promulgated by different
- 23:09organizations, there are frequently some minor
- 23:13differences. There's a lot of redundancy, but
- 23:16there is some difference. Whenever you're dealing
- 23:20with either the State Bar Act and the RPC, The
- 23:25careful practitioner wants to make sure that
- 23:26you look at both and are cognizant of any differences
- 23:29between the two. And as sort of a matter of practical
- 23:32reality, sometimes the motivations between the
- 23:39legislature and the state bar are slightly different,
- 23:42and that is reflected in the differences between
- 23:44the RPC and the BNP code. With that, back to
- 23:49you, Adam. Well, actually, John, I'm hoping you
- 23:52could touch on There's a pressure that arises
- 23:55between the attorney prosecuting the case or
- 23:58defending the case, and the expert witness who
- 24:01is opining, and, inadvertently or inadvertently,
- 24:06there may be efforts that push the expert out
- 24:09of the role of an expert and towards the role
- 24:12of the advocate. That's a good point, and thank
- 24:16you for bringing it up again. when you're engaged
- 24:22as an expert or actually when you're engaged
- 24:24as an attorney and you have a limited scope engagement
- 24:28or any sort of engagement agreement which limits
- 24:30the scope of what you're going to do or not do,
- 24:33there's a phenomena which we refer to in our
- 24:35offices of mission creep. I think the mission
- 24:39creep is particularly potentially egregious when
- 24:45you're talking about an expert engagement because
- 24:47when we engage as experts, whether we're we're
- 24:51testifying yet or not, whether we're nearly consulted
- 24:53or not, there's a lot of back and forth between
- 24:56the attorneys who've engaged us, their clients,
- 24:59and us. And that back and forth sometimes tends
- 25:02to push us close to the line between what we're
- 25:07doing as an expert and whether we're actually
- 25:09advocating or advising the attorneys who represent
- 25:13us in a way that might be considered the practice
- 25:16of law. Our goal as an expert is to not cross
- 25:20that line. And I'll tell you, as a matter of
- 25:23personal experience, it's really hard sometimes
- 25:26to keep those roles separate and to not cross
- 25:30the line from one area of working as a dispassionate
- 25:36expert and another crossing the line into advocacy
- 25:39or advice. I personally struggle with this on
- 25:45a regular basis and do a lot of, well, Please
- 25:48remember, I'm not the attorney. I'm not the advocate
- 25:51here. I'm simply offering you my hopefully dispassionate,
- 25:57hopefully not biased expert opinions. In fact,
- 26:05on a personal level, one of the things I want
- 26:07to avoid doing is I don't like being impeached.
- 26:11So I want to avoid looking in any expert engagement
- 26:14as if I'm actually partisan. in favor of one
- 26:17or the other parties. My goal here is to try
- 26:19to look like I'm the most impartial, non -partisan
- 26:25purveyor of expert opinions possible, because
- 26:29frankly, being impeached based upon my apparent
- 26:32bias is embarrassing. I don't really want to
- 26:35do that. Do you have a similar experience, Adam?
- 26:39I don't from the... end of being the expert witness,
- 26:42but from being an attorney putting on a case,
- 26:45very often we try and work closely with the experts
- 26:47in framing. So when you're dealing with a non
- 26:49-attorney expert, a doctor or construction expert,
- 26:54any kind of expert, you really look to them to
- 26:56help frame the way you're going to put the case
- 26:59forward. And that can work in every situation
- 27:04except for the one where the attorney is acting
- 27:06as an expert witness. because the non -attorneys
- 27:09can never be confused with being an advocate.
- 27:13And so that natural propensity to help frame
- 27:16your case and present your case with the expert
- 27:20works in other situations that doesn't work here.
- 27:25The other problem is the attorney expert witness,
- 27:28if they do start giving advice on strategy or
- 27:32tactics or how things may play, now you are discussing
- 27:37work products with a testifying expert, and everything
- 27:41that you tell that expert is discoverable, and
- 27:44now you may have inadvertently opened the door
- 27:47to the other side, getting access to your own
- 27:51work product. So it's not just the expert who
- 27:54needs to be watching out for this, but the petitioner,
- 27:57the advocate, needs to be just as wary of blurring
- 28:01the line between the attorney expert witness
- 28:05as an expert and as an advocate. Well said. All
- 28:13right. So then I'll go to the next slide, which
- 28:14is confidentiality obligations. If you remember
- 28:18back, not only do we have the concerns about
- 28:21not boring the line between being an expert and
- 28:25an advocate, but there may be confidentiality
- 28:29obligations that arise even though there was
- 28:31not representation in the role of being an expert
- 28:35witness. These come from business and professions
- 28:37code 6068E1, which we all should know, but this
- 28:42is the obligation to maintain and violate the
- 28:46confidences of a client at every parallel to
- 28:48yourself. So this is the big one. Remember it.
- 28:53Don't break it. And to the extent that an expert
- 28:58witness has learned confidential information
- 29:00from a former client, they have to maintain that
- 29:04confidentiality. This is also reflected in RPC
- 29:071 .6, which is, you can see directly referencing
- 29:11Business and Professions Code 6068E1. And it
- 29:15shows up again in RPC 1 .9c, which prohibits
- 29:22using information that has been received from
- 29:24a client to the disadvantage of that former client.
- 29:29This can get tricky determining whether or not
- 29:33the expert who was now acting adverse to a former
- 29:37client can do so without disclosing any of the
- 29:41confidences of that former client. And we get
- 29:44guidance here as we do in many cases from the
- 29:47cases. So let's move on. Two main cases, the
- 29:51first one. that really we want to pay attention
- 29:54to is Oasis West Realty versus Goldman. It's
- 29:58a 2011 case, and it should be near and dear to
- 30:02the Beverly Hills Bar Association since it arises
- 30:05out of Beverly Hills and a hotel development
- 30:08in Beverly Hills. This is one case where we want
- 30:12to talk about the facts. The facts in this case
- 30:15are that the attorney was hired by developers
- 30:19to help get the necessary approvals from the
- 30:22city for a hotel project. However, a couple of
- 30:26years later, that same attorney Goldman was personally
- 30:31opposed to the project. And he joined a group
- 30:34of citizens that were protesting and trying to
- 30:37stop the development that he had worked on just
- 30:39a couple of years earlier. Oasis West brought
- 30:43a lawsuit against him. he filed an anti -slap
- 30:46motion. This was denied by the trial court, reversed
- 30:51by the court of appeal, but ultimately the Supreme
- 30:54Court agreed with the trial court and said there
- 30:56was at least a minimal likelihood of success.
- 31:01And what we get out of this is the notion that
- 31:05even when you are not acting as an advocate,
- 31:09you may still be prevented from acting. or open
- 31:14to liability for acting, if you're using confidential
- 31:16information of a former client, this definitely
- 31:20could be used to trigger liability or recusal
- 31:25against an expert witness. And it's something
- 31:27to be cognizant of. And Brand versus 21st century
- 31:32insurance is a more current case, 2004, or an
- 31:36older case, 2004, which, again, looks to the
- 31:40substantial relationship between the lawyer's
- 31:43current employment and their former representation
- 31:46of a client and whether or not there's an ability
- 31:48to keep confidential information actually separate.
- 31:54Not to belabor the confidentiality thing too
- 31:56much because we already talked about it some,
- 31:59but it's important to bear in mind that once
- 32:03you transition from being an expert consultant
- 32:06to being a testifying expert, all the confidentiality
- 32:10stuff stops being a factor. because everything
- 32:12that's been disclosed to you as a consultant,
- 32:15once you are designated as an expert and you
- 32:19produce your file for expert deposition, it's
- 32:22not confidential anymore. It's all part of what's,
- 32:26there is no confidentiality attached to that
- 32:29expert testimony once your file has been disclosed.
- 32:35Yes. Thank you. All right. Well, now I'm going
- 32:39to turn it back to Joel. Okay, so now let's consider,
- 32:43can an attorney act as an expert adverse to a
- 32:46party for whom the attorney has acted as an expert
- 32:49in a different matter? Again, we have a qualified
- 32:55yes. And let's talk about that qualification
- 32:59a little bit. We have, I'll preview this, it's
- 33:05not gonna be a surprise, but the answer to all
- 33:07three of our questions are qualified yeses. which
- 33:11is to say, yes, you can do so, but you should
- 33:15be very careful about doing it. And you may actually
- 33:18consider whether even if you could technically
- 33:20do any of these things, say yes to any of these
- 33:23questions, whether it's necessarily a good idea
- 33:26that you do so. Opinions vary as to how conservative
- 33:32attorneys or ethics attorneys or experts should
- 33:36be on a personal level. I tend to be a very conservative
- 33:42ethics attorney and expert. And when in doubt,
- 33:46I would probably say, yeah, you could do that.
- 33:49But do I really want to do that? Is that really
- 33:51in the best interests of the people I've been
- 33:53hired to work for? Is it sometimes a better idea
- 33:57to not stretch that boundary and say, no, we
- 34:01would be better off having somebody else serve
- 34:03as your expert rather than me? That's sort of
- 34:07a personal mindset on my part, but I want to
- 34:10remind everybody that our qualified yeses here
- 34:13are definitely qualified. Can we see the next
- 34:16slide? Yes. Here again, we go back to RPC 1 .7,
- 34:23one of the two basic conflict rules in the Rules
- 34:26of Professional Conduct. The lawyer shall not,
- 34:30without informed written consent, and by the
- 34:32way, in the Rules of Professional Conduct, anytime
- 34:34you see something with an asterisk, that's a
- 34:36defined term. Lawyers shall not, without informed
- 34:39written consent from each effective client, represent
- 34:43a client if there is a significant risk the lawyer's
- 34:47representation of the client will be materially
- 34:49limited by the lawyer's responsibilities to or
- 34:53relationships with another client, a former client,
- 34:56or a third person by the lawyer's own interest.
- 35:00So let's break this down a little bit. What is
- 35:03it actually telling us here? Well, gee, I've
- 35:06got it. I formally represented a client as an
- 35:11expert, or I was formally engaged by an attorney
- 35:14representing a client to serve as an expert.
- 35:18And now I'm contemplating a new engagement against
- 35:24somebody who was, against a party who was previously
- 35:29adverse to me. Is my representation of that client
- 35:35going to be materially limited by my responsibilities
- 35:43or relationships with the prior client, with
- 35:46a former client, or a third person, or by my
- 35:49own interests. In this instance, my own interests
- 35:52might be defined as geez, be kind of embarrassing
- 35:55to be on both sides of this issue and be adverse
- 35:59to a former client. Do I want to do that or do
- 36:02I not want to do that? Your answers may vary,
- 36:07but, and I think there's actually some, there's
- 36:10a piece of this slide that's missing, Adam. Yes,
- 36:13that's the, oops. Oops. So at this point here
- 36:18is again, does this, you know, this rule applies
- 36:21to representation, but the interim opinion and
- 36:25the ADA opinion tell us that you're not necessarily
- 36:29representing a client when you're serving as
- 36:31an expert. So there is an out, you could get
- 36:34away with it. But again, it may not be a comfortable
- 36:38out, and it may not be ultimately a good idea
- 36:40to do so, hence the ethical minefield. Yeah,
- 36:43and I think that's going to be a recurring theme
- 36:46that we're going to keep bringing up. And we're
- 36:50going to hammer it home later, I think, but it
- 36:52is these rules allow you to do things. So but
- 36:57the lack of a prohibition is not the same thing.
- 37:02as be a good idea. Speaking of recurring themes,
- 37:10let's get our next slide, please. No expectation
- 37:16of confidentiality. I don't have any expectation
- 37:19of confidentiality with respect to a prior engagement.
- 37:23I don't have any expectation of confidentiality
- 37:25once my new engagement turns from being an expert
- 37:29consultant to being a testifying expert. And
- 37:34furthermore, if in my prior engagement I've received
- 37:39confidential information, there's no expectation
- 37:41that A, I have to maintain those confidences
- 37:44in the prior engagement, particularly if I haven't
- 37:46testified. But I can't expect confidentiality
- 37:51with respect to what I learned from those people
- 37:54in the new engagement. Did I say that backward?
- 38:00I don't know. I was thinking about the next thing
- 38:02I was going to say, so I missed it. But I'm sure
- 38:05everybody else did. Let's move on to the next
- 38:07thing you're going to say. We won't worry about
- 38:08whether I said it wrong. Well, this is, I think,
- 38:11kind of the transition between a consulting expert
- 38:14to a testifying expert. And there is a bright
- 38:18line that appears so, and it's not at the designation.
- 38:23So a person can be designated and then withdrawn
- 38:26and still maintain their status as a confidential,
- 38:32maintain confidentiality as a consulting expert.
- 38:35But once their report is turned over, then they
- 38:39are moving into the realm of a testifying expert.
- 38:42So testifying expert does not mean you're actually
- 38:44in court testifying or even giving a deposition.
- 38:48It is when your expert report is turned over
- 38:51to the other side. Which probably give rise to
- 38:57the motion in your slide that's missing from
- 38:59this. Oh, and it does. And that was the caveat.
- 39:05Well done. It's like I practice this or something.
- 39:09Okay. Next slide, please. So in contrast and
- 39:17continuing with our theme about confidentiality,
- 39:19there may be an expectation of confidentiality,
- 39:23particularly if you have contractual obligation
- 39:28to do so. Something about your engagement makes
- 39:33it clear by the terms of that engagement. that
- 39:36you're obligated to maintain the confidentiality.
- 39:40This is particularly acute when you're talking
- 39:41about a potential third person. Or if there's
- 39:44something like a protective order, which prevents
- 39:47the use of any confidential information in your
- 39:49expert engagement, even if it's the subject of
- 39:51testimony. I don't see any motion in this slide,
- 39:57Alex, but if you have anything you want to add
- 40:00to that, please do. Now, I think this is just
- 40:07another reminder that is not just the rules that
- 40:10govern. You're going to have outside forces that
- 40:14may require confidentiality and may impact the
- 40:17ability of an expert to act as an expert. So
- 40:22let's turn to the next slide in this section.
- 40:25One more time, though, we need to revisit the
- 40:28Oasis West case, which tells us basically that
- 40:31there are two things that a lawyer is forbidden
- 40:34to do after severing a relationship with a former
- 40:37client. You can't do anything which will injuriously
- 40:41affect the former client in any manner in which
- 40:43he's formally represented in, and that could
- 40:46obviously apply to an expert situation. And two,
- 40:51you can't use the former client's knowledge or
- 40:54information acquired by virtue of the previous
- 40:57relationship, and that obviously implicates confidentiality
- 41:01once again. So how do we make this simpler for
- 41:05ourselves? Well, we understand the simplest thing
- 41:10to understand is that once we transition into
- 41:13a designated and testifying expert who's going
- 41:18to be producing their expert file, all that confidentiality
- 41:22stuff goes out the board. We can't do it. So
- 41:25if we're not precluded by some other contractual
- 41:30obligation to maintain confidentiality, once
- 41:32we testified or once we're designated and produce
- 41:35our files for testimony, there's no expectation
- 41:39of confidentiality and we're not going to be
- 41:41required to do that. But if the lesson until
- 41:43that happens, we do still have confidentiality
- 41:46concerns that need to be maintained. And our
- 41:51last question, Heather? Our last question is,
- 41:55can an attorney act as an expert adverse to a
- 41:58client of their own firm? And as Joel hinted
- 42:02at earlier, the answer is a yes, this time with
- 42:05a red asterisk, because this is really a strong
- 42:09caveat. This is a yes that we would prefer to
- 42:13say as a no, but technically it is still a yes.
- 42:19Where does this come in? Well, RPC 1 .10 has
- 42:25imputation. When a lawyer is associated in a
- 42:29firm, None of them shall knowingly represent
- 42:33a client when any one of them practicing alone
- 42:36would be prohibited from doing so by rules 1
- 42:40.7 or 1 .9. This makes it seem very difficult
- 42:45to imagine a circumstance where an attorney could
- 42:49be acting as an expert witness when their firm
- 42:52is representing the adverse client. We were trying
- 43:01to figure out where this could actually take
- 43:03place. Aside from a firm that has poor conflict
- 43:07checking, I'm not sure that it really could.
- 43:13So while it may... Go ahead. There are obviously
- 43:17big law and extremely large law firms which tend
- 43:21to have... conflict waivers built into some of
- 43:26the things because if you've got a 3 ,000 lawyer
- 43:28law firm, not every lawyer knows every matter
- 43:33and every potential conflict. So they try to
- 43:36be very careful about their conflict checking
- 43:38and they try to build in waivers of such conflicts.
- 43:44So I suppose it's theoretically possible, but
- 43:47as a practical matter, and we live in a 17 lawyer
- 43:51law firm, so it's there's really no way that
- 43:55I would say, yeah, technically you could do this,
- 43:59but there's really no way I'm going to be adverse
- 44:01to my own firm. Yes. And I think that is even
- 44:05with the big firm, because we still have the
- 44:08firm -wide conflict risk and just want to touch
- 44:11on some of these, we're going back to RPC 1 .6,
- 44:15which is the general duty, but this now of the
- 44:17entire firm to protect confidential information.
- 44:21And there is the need to make sure that there's
- 44:25insulation between the attorneys who are working
- 44:27with the client and getting confidential information
- 44:30and the expert who is acting adverse to that
- 44:34client, make sure that they do not have access
- 44:36to the confidential information, even accidentally.
- 44:401 .7a, there's a prohibition of representation
- 44:44adverse to another client. So that would have
- 44:49to be addressed and maybe you could do it with
- 44:51a conflict waiver. RPC 1 .7b, which is a limitation
- 44:57on the ability of a firm to consider, recommend,
- 45:00or carry out an appropriate course of action.
- 45:04And, well, that would not necessarily be directly
- 45:07impacting the expert because he is not recommending
- 45:11a course of action. It could work the other way
- 45:15where the expert's role on behalf of a client,
- 45:19especially as a consulting expert, may impact
- 45:22the firm's ability to represent the first client.
- 45:27As we touched on earlier, 1 .7C1 sets forth the
- 45:32need to have written disclosure of conflicts.
- 45:36And of course, we know there's a duty of loyalty
- 45:38to our clients, and now you have a duty of loyalty
- 45:42to two opposing parties. And there's a duty of
- 45:46communication, which means that the firm must
- 45:51let both sides know, both the expert client and
- 45:57the adverse direct client, know about the fact
- 46:00that the firm is taking both sides. And again,
- 46:04these are things that can be done. Practically,
- 46:07it just doesn't seem to make any sense. And that's
- 46:13the reason for the red asterisk when it comes
- 46:16to this issue of imputation. Anything else you
- 46:21want to talk about? The firm -wide Joel, or I
- 46:24think? No, I think we should go and recap our
- 46:27common ethical questions. Well, great. Here we're
- 46:30going to, except we changed the format, which
- 46:34is why you're missing the yes to the last question.
- 46:36That's not an editorial mix. I'm feeling very
- 46:41editorially edgy. Yes. So the answer to all these
- 46:45questions are. qualified yeses and in the case
- 46:48of the last question, a really qualified yes,
- 46:52it's theoretically possible to do all these things.
- 46:54But again, is it really a good idea? Is it really
- 46:58going to make things better for you or for your
- 47:01client or for the attorneys who are retained
- 47:03by to represent your client to do this stuff?
- 47:07Or is it sometimes better to say no, I don't
- 47:11want to risk the potential? cross -examination,
- 47:17I don't want to risk the potential embarrassment
- 47:18of being in this situation. It's better that
- 47:21somebody else be the expert. Obviously, opinions
- 47:26vary. Obviously, my opinion tends towards being
- 47:29conservative and avoiding the embarrassment,
- 47:31potential embarrassment. Yes, it can possibly
- 47:34be done. Just not sure it's worth it. No, and
- 47:38as the advocate, I don't want my experts to be
- 47:40embarrassed or cross -examined to have it turn
- 47:44out through cross -examination that my expert
- 47:47has turned out to be just another advocate is
- 47:50certainly going to weaken my presentation to
- 47:53my case as the jury will start discounting that
- 47:56expert's testimony. And I don't want that to
- 48:00happen as the advocate. So I think now we mentioned
- 48:08the ABA. Yeah, we already mentioned the ABA formal
- 48:12opinion. Again, remembering that the formal opinion
- 48:18both for the ABA and for COPAC are not controlling
- 48:24authority, they're persuasive authority. And
- 48:29there are some minor differences both with the
- 48:31ABA model rules and the ABA formal opinions based
- 48:34upon those model rules that vary from California
- 48:38law. As a matter of persuasive authority, I think
- 48:48the ABA opinion and the ABA model rules are useful
- 48:52and basically consistent with what we've talked
- 48:57about today so far. Yes. And I think one of the
- 48:59things that the ABA model rules do is really
- 49:03clarify and harp on the distinction between the
- 49:07consulting expert and the testifying expert.
- 49:13So to sum up, Let's talk about some basic points
- 49:16here. And we'll start with engagement agreements.
- 49:23We collectively firmly believe in the importance
- 49:26of engagement agreements for all the reasons
- 49:28I've already expressed. It sets the limits of
- 49:32your expectations with respect to what you are
- 49:34and are not going to do. It's a terrific opportunity
- 49:38to get your expressed disclaimers. No, I am not.
- 49:42here to be your lawyer. I'm not here to be your
- 49:44advocate. I'm here solely to be your expert.
- 49:47I'm not here to give you legal advice. I'm simply
- 49:51here to be a dispassionate, hopefully impartial
- 49:54expert. And again, in every engagement agreement,
- 49:59whether it's an expert agreement or a agreement
- 50:02to be retained as a practicing attorney on whatever
- 50:08the scope of whatever the engagement may be.
- 50:10Defining the scope of that engagement is critically
- 50:13important. I strongly advise people to pay attention
- 50:16to their engagement agreements and to pay particular
- 50:19attention to defining the scope of whatever they're
- 50:22engaging to do, be it expert or otherwise. And
- 50:29so some red flags that you should be watching
- 50:31out for, both as an expert and as the attorney
- 50:34who's hiring the expert, is whether or not you're
- 50:37giving access to confidential files. Remember,
- 50:40a consulting expert will keep those confidential.
- 50:44But once they become a testifying expert, whatever
- 50:46they have seen is now discoverable by the other
- 50:48side. And that can include your work product.
- 50:51So be very careful about what access is given.
- 50:56Again, looking at the vague engagement letters,
- 50:59we want to make sure that this is very clear.
- 51:01And both the advocate and the expert will want
- 51:04to make very clear that there are no dual rules,
- 51:09that the expert is acting as an expert and only
- 51:11as an expert, and the attorney is acting as the
- 51:14attorney. You want to just keep these things
- 51:17separate. Let's close with a reminder of some
- 51:22best practices. And this is applicable, obviously,
- 51:27to expert engagements, but it's applicable to
- 51:29any engagements. First, last, and always, you
- 51:33want to conflict check. If there's any changes
- 51:36in the parties to any engagement, whether it's
- 51:38an expert engagement or not, you want to be sure
- 51:41that you rerun your conflict checks anytime there's
- 51:43any substantial changes, if there's new parties
- 51:46added or anything else, you want to go back and
- 51:48recheck your conflict check. Number two, you
- 51:51want to make sure that if there are disclaimers
- 51:53built into your expert engagement, that they
- 51:55are clear and not subject to any misinterpretation
- 51:59and best understood by the parties at the time
- 52:02of the engagement. And then finally, again, this
- 52:06is somewhat consistent theme in this presentation
- 52:08by me is, if things look questionable, if things
- 52:12look like they're problematic, if things look
- 52:14like they're going to be an embarrassment or
- 52:17not provide your client with the best possible
- 52:21opportunity to get expert testimony, just say
- 52:25no. I don't want to sound like Nancy Reagan,
- 52:27but sometimes it's just better to say no. I'm
- 52:30not the right person for this engagement for
- 52:32one reason or another. find somebody else. And
- 52:38then the last couple of things, and I think we've
- 52:41harped on this in different ways. I'm just going
- 52:43to say it again. The role of clarity is essential.
- 52:46We have to make sure that the expert is clearly
- 52:50an expert and only acting as an expert, not slipping
- 52:53into advocacy that confidentiality needs to be
- 52:59addressed. It can't just be assumed. You have
- 53:02to be proactive, both as the expert and as the
- 53:04advocate, to make sure that we know what is supposed
- 53:08to be confidential, what is not, what can be
- 53:10disclosed, and what doesn't. What is the expert
- 53:13allowed to discuss after the end of the representation?
- 53:17And that's one thing that really, I think, as
- 53:20the practitioner, you want to be aware of is
- 53:24what can the expert use after they leave your
- 53:28employee in the broadest sense and go on and
- 53:34become an expert for somebody else. And then
- 53:37the final thing, which again is in red, is you
- 53:39have to assume scrutiny. This applies across
- 53:41the board. It applies in this specific instance
- 53:44as well. Assume that other people are going to
- 53:46be looking at this and the people who are looking
- 53:48at this are going to be adverse to you. So make
- 53:52sure you document, make sure everything is clear
- 53:54so that when somebody else comes looking at this
- 53:57and trying to find a way to undermine you or
- 54:00your expert that you are protecting. With that,
- 54:07I think we have a few more minutes left and I
- 54:11haven't been monitoring the Q &A, but I will
- 54:14turn to Mike and ask him if there's questions
- 54:16that he thinks that we can address. Yeah, there
- 54:18are a few questions in the chat. One question
- 54:22goes back to the beginning of the presentation.
- 54:25It was a general question about the need for
- 54:29expert testimony. And the question is, would
- 54:32missing the statute of limitations require an
- 54:36expert opinion, given the seeming simplicity
- 54:39of a statute of limitations date? expressed earlier,
- 54:47there's case law which suggests that you have
- 54:49to have an expert testifying in support of a
- 54:54legal malpractice case. So even in this particular
- 54:58instance where a blown statute is pretty darn
- 55:01obvious, I think as a matter of course you have
- 55:05to have an expert. The expert's not going to
- 55:08have a whole lot to say if it's a clear cut of
- 55:11a blown statute, but I think it's probably necessary
- 55:14to do so. These feel differently, Adam? Yeah.
- 55:17Well, I want to expand on that a little bit because
- 55:19there are enough circumstances where we are not
- 55:22clear as to when the statute has begun or what
- 55:27may have taken place to toll it when we were
- 55:29using what the discovery issue. There can be
- 55:33muddling of when the statute actually runs. Also,
- 55:37there's the fact that the statute of limitations
- 55:39is an affirmative defense. And so There's a question
- 55:43about what happens if the other side doesn't
- 55:45raise the statute of limitations defense. So
- 55:50yes, it seems clear, but it's not always clear
- 55:53and you're better off having an expert. And chances
- 55:57are, if they blew the statute, they blew something
- 55:58else. And by the way, just as an aside, we could
- 56:04do a whole hour just on California's statute
- 56:07of limitations and the issues. We're not doing
- 56:10that today. If we have the opportunity, we may
- 56:13do it another time. But the statute of limitations
- 56:18at CCP 340 .6 has a bunch of nuances built into
- 56:25it, which again, augers in favor of using an
- 56:29expert to testify even in a blown statute case.
- 56:34So we have another interesting question in chat.
- 56:37It appears it's an ongoing matter. Be careful
- 56:42that we're not providing legal advice here, but
- 56:45I'm going to read this to you. I'm an attorney
- 56:49who is also an architect. I had a construction
- 56:51case with a day prior to repair. The expert had
- 56:56a serious problem. I ended up going to the site
- 56:59and doing the architectural observation myself
- 57:02and prepared a report. I changed over to being
- 57:06an expert and assigned to an attorney in my office.
- 57:11I guess the continuation of the representation.
- 57:16Is there going to be a problem? And can I address
- 57:19this through agreements? Well, first problem
- 57:27is going to be that if you go from being a advocate
- 57:31to being an expert, in the same matter, you're
- 57:35likely to be subject to impeachment. You may
- 57:40also be subject to disqualification if you've
- 57:43changed your role. Those are the two that come
- 57:46off the top of my head. What do you think, Adam?
- 57:49Yeah, the other one is you're still going to
- 57:53be compelled to comply with the ethical requirements
- 57:59of an attorney, even when you're acting as the
- 58:03architectural expert. your status as an attorney
- 58:07still provides obligations that you're gonna
- 58:09have to comply with. And I think there's one
- 58:14more question, and I think this is more of a
- 58:18looking for a confirmation. If there is a contractual
- 58:22obligation to keep something confidential, what
- 58:26happens if the expert is testifying and is cross
- 58:30-examined? And same question for trial testimony.
- 58:34And then the person is looking to confirm that
- 58:38there's no confidentiality once the expert's
- 58:40report is submitted to the opposing counsel and
- 58:43the other side. Sunny? You're the confidentiality
- 58:48guru today. Why don't you take that one? Yeah,
- 58:50well, I think there's two different ones. One
- 58:53of them is relatively easy. Once the expert report
- 58:57is turned over to the other side, there's no
- 58:59more expectation of confidentiality. You are
- 59:01a testifying expert and whatever has been provided
- 59:04to that expert is now discoverable. That's the
- 59:08easy part. The other one has to do with the confidentiality
- 59:14requirements when dealing with a witness, but
- 59:17this applies to any witness who's testifying
- 59:20who is subject to a confidentiality agreement.
- 59:22You're going to have to go look at the terms
- 59:23of the confidentiality agreement and probably
- 59:27bring some kind of a motion before the court
- 59:29to get permission to go beyond that confidentiality
- 59:36agreement. But you should start with, this is
- 59:39confidential and I can't disclose it. Last question.
- 59:44So let's talk about the fine line between the
- 59:49expert becoming an advocate. So if you have an
- 59:51expert witness who in the course of doing his
- 59:55or her work identifies different areas of discovery
- 1:00:00that will be helpful if pursued, is there a distinction
- 1:00:06that can be drawn? that keeps the expert from
- 1:00:10switching over to advocate. For example, if the
- 1:00:13expert says to the handling attorney, here are
- 1:00:17the opinions I've developed so far. I see you
- 1:00:19haven't taken these eight depositions and propounded
- 1:00:22this discovery. That would be very helpful for
- 1:00:24my analysis versus I'd like you to go out and
- 1:00:30do this discovery because let's say I need this
- 1:00:33discovery to complete my analysis. So two different
- 1:00:39ways of saying the same thing. But what's your
- 1:00:43thought on whether that blurs the line between
- 1:00:46expert witness and advocate that's driving the
- 1:00:50case? Yes, it does blur the line, and sometimes
- 1:00:56it can't be avoided. But generally speaking,
- 1:01:01and there's another line that we haven't addressed
- 1:01:03in this presentation, but there's a distinction
- 1:01:06between what the expert can say and opine about
- 1:01:12and what the expert can't say and opine about.
- 1:01:17If I don't know things, it can't be subject to
- 1:01:22my expert opinion. Whether I can't imagine or
- 1:01:27I can't assume that I'm going to be able to answer
- 1:01:29questions about which I don't actually have information
- 1:01:32to offer the expert opinion. And if I go out
- 1:01:36and proactively say to the attorney who's retaining
- 1:01:39me as the expert, hey, I need you to figure out
- 1:01:42X, Y, and Z and answer these questions for me,
- 1:01:45I think I've probably gone over the line in terms
- 1:01:48of establishing what I'm supposed to be doing
- 1:01:50as an expert. And I would agree with that. And
- 1:01:54I'd be concerned that once the expert is starting
- 1:01:57to discuss who to depose, that you may be getting
- 1:02:02into having to turn over the work product of
- 1:02:07what you're asking in that deposition and how
- 1:02:09much of that came from the expert and how much
- 1:02:11of it didn't. And I just would want to stay away
- 1:02:15from that. The expert should be relying only
- 1:02:17on things that are happening, not things that
- 1:02:19could happen in the future. OK. Well, at this
- 1:02:24point, it's 5 o 'clock. We don't have any other
- 1:02:28questions in the chat. And so I think we'll conclude
- 1:02:32our presentation. Thank you, everybody, for joining
- 1:02:35us. Thank you, Joel. Thank you, Adam. Thank you,
- 1:02:38Beverly Hills Bar Association for hosting the
- 1:02:42seminar. Everybody, please keep an eye out. The
- 1:02:47ethics and legal malpractice law section will
- 1:02:51be pretty active this year. And so we'll have
- 1:02:53a lot of programming coming up for you. And with
- 1:02:56that, thank you very much for your time and your
- 1:02:58attention. We'll see you at the next presentation.
- 1:03:01Bye, all. Bye.