Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 19 – The Stamina Episode: Corey DeAngelis melts down, ESA funding questions rise up, Denver succeeds & Don Shalvey inspires.
Transcript
- 0:02Hey, Andy.
- 0:03Hey, Jed.
- 0:03How are you?
- 0:04I'm doing terrific.
- 0:05Nice to see you again.
- 0:06Good to see you.
- 0:07I understand you like you're on the run from the law down in
- 0:10Mexico or something like that.
- 0:13It's my wife's and my anniversary and so we're down in Oaxaca,
- 0:17Mexico, a place that's been on our bucket list for a very long time.
- 0:21It started with my students in LA.
- 0:23I had a significant number of them that were from Oaxaca, and
- 0:27I still stay in contact with a lot of 'em, and they check in.
- 0:30You always said Jed, you were gonna go to Oaxaca?
- 0:33Have you been there yet?
- 0:34No, I haven't.
- 0:35No, I haven't.
- 0:36Well, now I can finally say that., I've made it.
- 0:39We're having an incredible time.
- 0:40We're balancing, you know, we're having some weeks of work, with one week at the
- 0:45beach, that will be true anniversary.
- 0:47But it's awesome to be in Oaxaca.
- 0:48I don't know.
- 0:49How familiar are you with the history of teacher unions here and all of that, Andy?
- 0:53Some, I mean, I'm familiar with that part of Mexico.
- 0:57My, cause my sister in law lived there for a while, but I'm familiar
- 1:02with the teachers unions relatively casually, except I understand that
- 1:06they make ours look like pussycats.
- 1:10Well, I can't talk for the whole country, but I will say that it was
- 1:13our second day here, we're walking around just in love with the city.
- 1:17It's just a magical place.
- 1:18And, all of a sudden there's a teacher union protest coming down,
- 1:23the main square and, it was just.
- 1:28Striking and you had to wait for probably almost 10 minutes for
- 1:33this procession to get past you.
- 1:35Of course, I was interested, I wanted to read all their slogans
- 1:38and all those kinds of things too.
- 1:40That night, we had a guy who walked us around to orient us to the city.
- 1:46His mom had been a teacher during 2006, which is when Oaxaca's union was really
- 1:54on the radar screen, I think, hearing the story from this young man's perspective,
- 1:59it really presents the teachers and moment in a very heroic light Oaxaca is one of
- 2:07the poorest states in Mexico, and the pueblos around the central city are some
- 2:12of the poorest of the poor places that you will find, and the quality of education
- 2:15in those places was just not acceptable.
- 2:18So there was a real nobility to what the teachers were trying to do, which
- 2:21was to force the central government to put a volume of resources into
- 2:26public education that would pay greater respect to these kids that were
- 2:29basically not getting an education.
- 2:31And during that time, literally, they closed down the central city of Oaxaca.
- 2:37There were like 80, 000 teachers on strike.
- 2:39The police force was only like three or 4, 000.
- 2:42But teachers literally lost their lives as people tried to
- 2:46break up these demonstrations.
- 2:47It was a major, major conflict.
- 2:51Ultimately, I think in 2006, People would say the teachers won, they prevailed,
- 2:56and they got the additional resources.
- 2:58But there's this underbelly to what they've done as well, which is around
- 3:02work rules, and the idea that if you have a job, you can pass the
- 3:07job to your own family members, or to other people of your choosing.
- 3:13That there's really no standards whatsoever for Getting a teaching job,
- 3:19just the, just the calendar and the amount of days that that kids are in class.
- 3:24These are all limited, you know, by this same force.
- 3:27And so it just makes me think that Oaxaca right now.
- 3:31puts in repose, you know, the teacher union matter in the United States as well.
- 3:37In the United States, it's over a longer time frame.
- 3:39If it wasn't for the teachers in the 30s, the 40s, the 50s, really coming together
- 3:44and becoming a force to force higher amounts of investment in public education,
- 3:49goodness knows where we would be.
- 3:50It was a totally noble undertaking.
- 3:52But then once the resources are flowing, the work rules are so
- 3:56counter to the needs of kids that it's really hard to have anything
- 4:01other than A feeling of frustration for what they're currently doing.
- 4:05Say a little more about one of the issues this time, like what's Cause I do remember
- 4:09that strike, and it was noteworthy.
- 4:11It seemed like the structure of education in many ways in Mexico is very similar
- 4:15to what you see throughout sort of Central and South America, which is, you
- 4:18know, very bifurcated and the elites.
- 4:20Are sort of operating on a different plane in terms of how they access education.
- 4:25But what are the issues now?
- 4:27Is it the same stuff still not resolved or is it new issues?
- 4:32I don't really know Andy.
- 4:33I don't wanna oversell how much I'm keyed into this.
- 4:37It seems as though these are.
- 4:38Legacy issues.
- 4:39They keep fighting in a very similar way.
- 4:42Our guest, our host, a couple of days ago was saying that kids still will
- 4:48miss dozens of days of school each year as the union just takes days off and
- 4:56occupies the central square and just reiterates what their demands are.
- 5:01One of the things that came up in this conversation is just, first of all,
- 5:04how difficult it is to be a teacher in some of these more indigenous areas.
- 5:08And yet it's very much like you find in the United States.
- 5:13Who do you think ends up going to the most difficult posts?
- 5:17The young teachers, the teachers with no experience, and as you get older
- 5:22and more seniority, what do you do?
- 5:24You gravitate toward the parts of the city that are considered most attractive.
- 5:29And of course, the more affluent Mexicans are living in those communities.
- 5:33So we find a structural way for those that need the best education
- 5:39to be most deprived of it.
- 5:40And it seems as though these seniority rights, are extremely
- 5:44important to the union.
- 5:44They're not to compromise on those things.
- 5:48They're also not willing to have higher levels of pay in the
- 5:51difficult communities or the more challenging communities to live in.
- 5:55And so, these, you know, restrictions that they insist on translate into
- 6:00the highest need kids, unfortunately being the least well served.
- 6:05Well, it's weird that that sounds a little familiar to me.
- 6:08Yeah.
- 6:08That last bit, you don't, you don't have to travel to Mexico
- 6:13if you want to experience that.
- 6:14You can, yeah, it was funny.
- 6:15Cause when I
- 6:16was explained, when I was explained, when I was explaining this with, uh,
- 6:19with our, our, our guide a couple of days ago, I didn't tell the story of senior
- 6:25teachers, uh, or teachers moving from.
- 6:28Uh, more challenging schools to more attractive ones over
- 6:32time in the context of Mexico.
- 6:34I talked about it in the context of Los Angeles and different
- 6:37schools and he's like, Oh, that's exactly how it works here.
- 6:40Except the tough places to first teach in are in the indigenous areas
- 6:45and, um, uh, and the more attractive ones closer to central Oaxaca.
- 6:49So he made the connection, not me, to the similarity between the
- 6:53Mexican context and the American one.
- 6:55Interesting.
- 6:56Anyway, I think it puts, it puts our, it puts our work in, in
- 6:59just really interesting repose.
- 7:01Sometimes I think we can see our own world, you know, by looking at
- 7:05what's happening in other countries.
- 7:07That's why I tend to write about this at Charterfolk.
- 7:08It's just, hey, um, we can see it perhaps when we look at another country
- 7:13where we've grown so used to what we see in our own, that sometimes
- 7:16it's not fresh and we can't even realize what's, what's going on.
- 7:20Yeah, I mean, I like international work and I used to do, uh, some of
- 7:25it when my kids were growing up, I didn't do much because I didn't want
- 7:28the travel that's associated with it.
- 7:30I don't want to be away from them that much.
- 7:32And now I'm starting to edge back towards some of that because
- 7:34it's, uh, it's really interesting.
- 7:36I do worry though.
- 7:38Like it is a, it is a place where just like correlation causation
- 7:43and sort of monocausality and, uh, you know, errors just thrive.
- 7:47Like people go to these places, they see one thing that works.
- 7:50So like they go to the Netherlands and they see it, they've got like a
- 7:52choice system and they come back and they're like, see, you can have choice
- 7:55and a highly, you know, religious, uh, religious saturated kind of environment.
- 8:00And it's fine with absolutely no knowledge of like the history of the
- 8:03Netherlands and how they got to that point and the other aspects of the system.
- 8:07The big example of our sector, which Tim Daly recently revisited, um, uh, you know,
- 8:13it was Finland, which was like a whole industry and like thinking like one thing
- 8:18and decontextualizing and being like, this is what we should, we should do here.
- 8:21And so I think it's like, it's very valuable, but it's also, you have
- 8:24to be a skeptical, uh, you have to be a skeptical consumer of this.
- 8:29Yeah.
- 8:29And I think from a charter school perspective, you see different
- 8:32levels of receptiveness in different countries, New Zealand right now.
- 8:36Um, it's had an ebb and flow.
- 8:38It had a moment where the whole charter school experiment almost died, but
- 8:43it's been revived and it's growing and thriving in New Zealand for sure.
- 8:47Um, but like in Latin American countries where labor tends to be
- 8:50very strong, I mean, we have charter schools in Puerto Rico right now.
- 8:53But the opposition that charter schools face in Puerto Rico, it's just like, oh,
- 8:58my gosh, impossible to almost imagine when I was down in Colombia for my brother's
- 9:03illness, um, you know, I had a chance to learn about the charter schools in Bogota.
- 9:08Um, and I recently highlighted that there was a study about the
- 9:11Bogota schools that came out.
- 9:13They're doing an incredible job.
- 9:15They're doing an incredible job relative to traditional public schools, but
- 9:18the blowback that they're contending with, it's just, it makes our work
- 9:22look like, you know, child's play.
- 9:25Right.
- 9:25Well, that's Puerto Rico too.
- 9:26It's just a really entrenched, uh, set of resistance, uh, factors to reform
- 9:33and, and, uh, it's just really difficult for reformers down there in general.
- 9:38This is amazing though.
- 9:38What are we like eight minutes?
- 9:40We're eight minutes in and we haven't.
- 9:42Talked about, uh, speaking of like being skeptical and also like the,
- 9:48the teachers union's favorite people.
- 9:49We haven't talked about Cory D'Angelo.
- 9:51Yeah.
- 9:52I wanted to congratulate, first of all, thank you for what you wrote.
- 9:54I thought, because first of all, I got to tell you, I hadn't even heard of it.
- 9:58And so you brought it to my attention, but then I thought the way that you
- 10:00wrote about it was really, really smart, but you want to elaborate
- 10:04on or perhaps even for our audience that might not be keyed into it yet.
- 10:07Talk about this whole situation.
- 10:09Yeah.
- 10:10And I,
- 10:10I'd recommend, you know, as we're recording this, the 74 has a story out
- 10:14advancing the whole issue a little bit, um, which I, I would, I would commend.
- 10:18And, and, um, I mean, essentially He was a he was a self described
- 10:23school choice evangelist.
- 10:24I mean, you can certainly say he was like a very strident school choice activist,
- 10:27and he had a very particular style.
- 10:29He was extremely combative, active on social media, you know, a real shit stir,
- 10:35and, um, and he's one of these people who used like culture war for to go after,
- 10:43uh, the public schools and some of the issues he picked, we can talk about like
- 10:48whether how much of it's hypocrisy and how much of it's like, does people disagree?
- 10:52But like, um, uh, he certainly stoked a culture of fear.
- 10:56He didn't help with those, you know, people who want to see sort of a
- 10:59de escalation of the culture wars.
- 11:01He certainly didn't help with any of that.
- 11:02Um, and it's come to light that he also acted in a lot of porn
- 11:06apparently, um, website called gay hoopla, um, which I, I, I generally
- 11:13am pretty much, I do my homework.
- 11:15I go to primary sources and all that, but this one, I looked at a few screen
- 11:20grabs on social media and was like, okay, I get the, I get the idea.
- 11:23So, um, I actually gone through all this.
- 11:26Um, but you know, my initial reaction was actually like, I, this Because
- 11:31he's so combative and everything else like he seems right for a hit, you know
- 11:34There's these parts of the internet where all people do all day is argue
- 11:36and trench warfare And so I was like this could be a deep fake or just like
- 11:40a look alike I was actually a little skeptical initially But immediately like
- 11:44places where he has formal relationships like the american federation Children
- 11:48and the hoover institution took his sight off and I asked around with a few
- 11:51folks I know and and people were like, oh, yeah, there's something to this.
- 11:54This is This is real.
- 11:56Um You And, uh, and so that's kind of where we are.
- 12:00And the 74 advanced the story substantially.
- 12:04Something I hinted at in my.
- 12:06Blog posts, but I didn't have full, um, a full understanding of, so I, I only
- 12:10hinted at it was that this hit came from the right, and so it was sort of intra
- 12:15right trac side around some issues around school choice and government regulation.
- 12:21And there's some folks who think that having the government involved and
- 12:25things like ESAs and so forth, there's a real threat to liberty and, and to
- 12:29homeschooling and so forth that, you know, you, you, you know that that
- 12:31sort of faction in the school choice world has always been out there.
- 12:34And I think.
- 12:35I'm like so many issues.
- 12:36Like this is true on guns.
- 12:37People don't understand off in the full contour that like the NRA, like
- 12:41you may find them frustrating, but they've got a bunch of groups on their
- 12:43right flank that objectively make NRA look a little bit more moderate.
- 12:48Right.
- 12:48And it's the same thing as school choice.
- 12:50Got these folks out there who I remember I used to report out stuff
- 12:53on homeschools and homeschoolers.
- 12:55You, you, you would talk to people who just, they wanted, they were against There
- 13:00was efforts like let homeschool kids play sports, um, on public school sports teams.
- 13:05And they were against that.
- 13:05They're like, that's really bad because it creates entanglement.
- 13:08It's like, it's, it's, they want to hide like from the other side.
- 13:11Um, and, uh, those are the people who apparently were frustrated with some
- 13:16of the stuff Corey was doing, found some pictures and it led to stuff.
- 13:21And they, and they fed this guy.
- 13:23website that because they came out of a very sort of far right website that
- 13:27I'd never heard of before this episode.
- 13:29Um, uh, the story kind of direct
- 13:32the story dragged it into what does this mean as far as school
- 13:36choice goes within, you know, a splinter area of the choice world.
- 13:41That a lot of us are not that keyed into.
- 13:43I thought that your first post was great in that you kind of looked at
- 13:47it from the kind of social, uh, social issue perspective, which I thought
- 13:53was probably the place that will end up coming back to long term as well.
- 13:57For those of us that are interested in general interest.
- 14:01Yeah, I mean, look, you can see him like the AFT is trying to make it into
- 14:03a school choice story now and so forth.
- 14:05And that's politics.
- 14:06That's what they're going to do.
- 14:07But I don't think it's any, these are human failing stories.
- 14:09Like, like, like, look, every time a teacher's union leader gets indicted
- 14:14for fraud, I actually, I don't think that's a teacher's unions story.
- 14:18People get indicted for fraud in like a variety of sectors and situations.
- 14:21That's a human failing story.
- 14:23Um, and I think it's the same thing.
- 14:24I think it's the same thing here.
- 14:25I do think though, it does.
- 14:28Have one like sort of like subtle lesson that's not unique to school choice,
- 14:32but it's around like edu celebrities Like I think people like it was
- 14:36striking to me how that the media never vetted this guy and that's like Yeah,
- 14:41the bottom has fallen out of media.
- 14:42It's a it's a tough business right now But it seems surprising that there
- 14:46hadn't been like a little more vetting.
- 14:48Um, uh, Of something like this and and that struck me and then also like people's
- 14:55willingness to fall in love with like these combative Types, you know, and yeah,
- 15:01like you shouldn't fall in love with the ideas, fall in love with your North star.
- 15:06But like we see this in politics too.
- 15:08If you, if you fall in love with people, you're inevitably like, Some of them
- 15:11will will disappoint in various ways.
- 15:13Maybe not quite as dramatic as this but in in various in various ways
- 15:18Well, I was going to bring up Uh, cory's last major piece with you.
- 15:22Anyway, um, which was his analysis of the arizona voucher program and
- 15:28um, and he basically, um, and also like Matt labner went after me
- 15:33too because i've been highlighting
- 15:35A question before he got I want to talk about it.
- 15:38Did
- 15:39you ever meet this guy?
- 15:40You
- 15:41Never did.
- 15:42Never did.
- 15:42Yeah.
- 15:43I didn't either.
- 15:43I did have, I had several people who, uh, encouraged me to, to meet with
- 15:50them and, and, and those kind, and I wasn't like strongly resistant.
- 15:53It just wasn't a priority of mine.
- 15:55And so it, it never really, never really happened.
- 15:58Um, part of it was, I just had like kind of that intuitive sense too.
- 16:02It's just this, he's a figure that's just very, uh, incendiary and, and
- 16:07I'm not, and I don't know enough.
- 16:09to like, like welcome them onto the charter folk platform
- 16:12or something like that.
- 16:13Um, and without that level of knowledge, I just kept what
- 16:16turned out to be a distance.
- 16:19Yeah, no, I never met him either.
- 16:20And, and like, it sounds like your instinct may have been like
- 16:23something about him always seemed off.
- 16:25I never, I wrote about this in the, in the blog post.
- 16:27I never, I didn't like, I didn't think anything like this, but
- 16:30like something just didn't.
- 16:32And there was a, and there was a, um, a podcast he did recently
- 16:34with Nick Gillespie of reason.
- 16:36And like, um, and.
- 16:39Like the beginning of it is almost like painful with the host Gillespie
- 16:43trying to like get this guy like just off of sort of script and message and
- 16:48performative talking points and, and that podcast at the time kind of like,
- 16:52it just kind of underscored for me, like something just wasn't, didn't sit right.
- 16:56It was like, it was like a performance or, or, or a shtick,
- 16:58which again, I think maybe should have made people a little more.
- 17:01Skeptical and I do hope there's some reporting on like
- 17:04when did people know this?
- 17:06And like, you know, like how much were people willing to because this guy did
- 17:11trade in some pretty anti lgbt themes not and again as I said earlier, right
- 17:16or Not everything like he he he took some positions on some culture war issues
- 17:21that like plenty of gay people Would take or plenty of transgender people so
- 17:24it's not like across the board, but he definitely traded in some pretty divisive
- 17:28You stuff around like the context and, and climate he was creating and some
- 17:32of the things he said, this sort of, they're coming for your kids kind of vibe.
- 17:36And yeah, um, and there should be some accountability for that.
- 17:39When did, when, when, when did people, when did people know about this?
- 17:42And so I'm hoping this gets reported out a little bit more.
- 17:45Yeah, to want to, on the one hand, I want to just keep the focus
- 17:48there and don't let it, um, become a story that it's actually not.
- 17:54At the same time, and this is what I wanted to ask you about this
- 17:57Arizona story, I think it's important that we deeply trust the people
- 18:03that are doing the analysis here.
- 18:05This is, this is basic economics.
- 18:07This, this, this is adding and subtracting.
- 18:10Um, and ultimately you can get to the bottom of the answer of whether or
- 18:14not, uh, the choice system in Arizona is bankrupting the state or not.
- 18:19Um, and my first response was, well, I should probably trust his analysis.
- 18:24I have no reason to distrust it.
- 18:26It made me want to reach out to Matt Ladner and just say, Hey, do
- 18:29I fundamentally have this wrong?
- 18:31Is in fact the Arizona choice, um, system economically sustainable.
- 18:36But then when I see these other compromises that Corey has made
- 18:40in other areas of his life, it makes me go back and look at his
- 18:45piece that he wrote about Arizona.
- 18:47And wonder whether he was willing to cut corners or misrepresents,
- 18:50you know, in that context as well.
- 18:52Do you have any similar, I don't know.
- 18:55I mean, look, he may not.
- 18:56Yeah,
- 18:56he may not have been playing straight pool as it turns out.
- 18:58But, like, I feel like on the Arizona thing, it's more.
- 19:02I think everybody has an agenda here.
- 19:05And so you should be skeptical.
- 19:06The choice people have an agenda and saying, Hey, there's nothing to see here.
- 19:10And this is not.
- 19:11And some of the points they raise are correct.
- 19:13So like in Arizona, the way things work to access some of these funds
- 19:17under like ESAs, you have to forego other tax credits so that there's
- 19:21going to be costs and savings.
- 19:23Um, they're not all wrong, but they have an interest in saying much as we've
- 19:27discussed with the musical chairs, they may have all, they have an interest in
- 19:29saying, Hey, there's nothing to see here.
- 19:31Don't worry.
- 19:32Oh, right.
- 19:32On the other hand, like the governor Hobbes and and the Democrats have an
- 19:39interest in like hyping this as much as they possibly can and coming up
- 19:43with like the most robust assumptions to get to the biggest numbers to
- 19:46scare the bejesus out of everybody.
- 19:48And I think the answer at this point is we don't quite know what
- 19:51we can be sure of is you've got two fairly powerful forces here.
- 19:56A cost structure that that is going to be an issue, um, and a very, very
- 20:01popular program and that and we've essentially created entitlement.
- 20:06Uh, that's very popular.
- 20:07And those two things are are in collision with one another.
- 20:11I think it's just too soon to tell exactly how it's going to play out, how people
- 20:14are going to take their options and how they're going to think about that.
- 20:18And are, you know, is it all going to be or the bulk of it be people
- 20:21who aren't publicly involved?
- 20:22Previous public school participants or will people that
- 20:24will there be more movement?
- 20:25And we won't know that for a little bit as to we see the behavior stuff
- 20:29on this I think anyone who's followed school choice for a while Should be like
- 20:32chasing the behavior stuff on this always plays out in like unpredictable ways.
- 20:36And so Um, I just think it's too early for like some of the grand pronouncements.
- 20:41We're hearing from from all sides Um, I said, I say that with a huge
- 20:46caveat is I haven't read, um, Cory D'Angelo's his stuff on this, but
- 20:50I have read the stuff from the state and some of the other things.
- 20:53And so, um, uh, I, and I, I take it all with a, with a grain of salt.
- 20:57I just think it's too soon and people are still largely arguing from their
- 21:02priors and there's a lot of, there's, there's a lot of agendas on all sides.
- 21:06Yeah.
- 21:06Okay.
- 21:07Well, I'm not saying it's not an
- 21:08issue.
- 21:09I'm also not saying that, like, this idea that it's, you know, gonna
- 21:12absolutely decimate these budgets.
- 21:14It could play.
- 21:15It could play out in some different in some different ways.
- 21:16We're gonna see this in some other states.
- 21:18We're also gonna see this jet, as you know, is a huge natural experiment.
- 21:21In some places, you've got some degree of means testing.
- 21:23In some places you don't.
- 21:25Um, in some places you have it.
- 21:26Yeah.
- 21:26These different kinds of programs that can interact with one
- 21:29another in some places you don't.
- 21:30I think it's going to be like the one problem is the way
- 21:34some of these are set up.
- 21:35We're going to be able to evaluate some of the descriptive and behavioral
- 21:39aspects, but we're going to really struggle to evaluate some of the outcomes.
- 21:42And so.
- 21:44it will, which in education means it will forever be a somewhat political
- 21:49debate based on people's priors.
- 21:50We won't get, at least in the near term, we're not going to get some
- 21:53of the evidence that might be really satisfying to help figure out and,
- 21:57and, and, you know, validate or falsify various claims people are making, but we
- 22:01will, we will be able to, that's real.
- 22:03And we'll, in a few years, we'll have a really good sense of what's going on.
- 22:07Well, I just wonder, is this something that bellwether is going to wade into?
- 22:10Are you going to host a debate?
- 22:11Or are you, can you get to the bottom of the economics here such that, you
- 22:15know, those of us that really wonder, you know, have a greater sense of confidence
- 22:19in the numbers as, as they truly are.
- 22:23I want to host a debate on this.
- 22:24So I shouldn't, I haven't had a chance to tell them.
- 22:26So I'm getting out in front, but like, I would like our school finance
- 22:29lead is Jen, she's, she used to run the budget office in Texas.
- 22:33She's just very deep.
- 22:35She's been involved in a number of the States where you've seen like substantial
- 22:37finance reform the last few years.
- 22:39She's.
- 22:39Just outstanding on this.
- 22:41Um, I would like to see her and Ladner have a debate about it And I would love
- 22:45to host that debate and so like i'm gonna be great Yeah, i'm previewing
- 22:49that here which uh, if they're listening will be a shock to both of them because
- 22:52I haven't raised it That's the debate.
- 22:54I actually want to see to start to shed Uh to start to shed some some
- 22:59light on this Uh, they're both serious people and I think also would if
- 23:03given the opportunity to talk through this with some caveats I think you'd
- 23:06get to a real nuance discussion.
- 23:08I don't think it would be like a food fight kind of debate.
- 23:10I think it would be very thoughtful.
- 23:12Well, I think that, um, it would be good to get to the bottom of these things
- 23:16and to have, like, some general ideas.
- 23:18If you're in a place like Arizona and your ESA and voucher credit is going
- 23:23to be 7, 500 a kid, and the state is spending 12, 000, And that you can now
- 23:29just start to have some rules of thumb about, okay, how many kids need to leave
- 23:35the public school system funded at 12, 000 to take the 7, 500 option, um, uh,
- 23:41in order to pay for the new kids that had previously had their entire private
- 23:45education paid for by their parents.
- 23:46It seems like this is just simple, simple algebra here.
- 23:49Well, if they're using tax credits, their savings in the case, Arizona,
- 23:54that's where it gets a little tricky.
- 23:56And then also, as you know, the schools, we talk about this, like, it's 1 to 1.
- 24:00It's not the schools have fixed costs and overhangs and so forth.
- 24:03And so, um, It all ends up being messier than you hear in the public debate.
- 24:09Well, the, and the other thing too is, well, you could, you could, you could,
- 24:13cause I, I'll, I still think that there's an algebra answer here to what is the
- 24:18overall effect on the state budget?
- 24:20Just the state budget.
- 24:21Are they spending more in aggregate on, on education?
- 24:24Yes or no.
- 24:25But then.
- 24:26Then there's the second thing, which is okay.
- 24:28Who would be benefiting?
- 24:29Are there very many, um, families that would voluntarily give up essentially
- 24:34a 12, 000 voucher to say it stay in the public school system to take to
- 24:38get 7500 for, uh, for a private school?
- 24:41What families are really going to be doing that?
- 24:44It would seem intuitive that it's going to be people at the higher end of the ladder
- 24:48that are going to be benefiting from that.
- 24:50And, you know, that should be another part of the understanding here.
- 24:54I saw a study.
- 24:55I haven't had a chance to look at it from Pennsylvania.
- 24:57Um, and I haven't had a chance to get into any depth.
- 24:59So I can't in any way, you know, comment on on the methods or
- 25:04anything else or how robust it is.
- 25:05But it's it indicated that the demographics there were
- 25:08more, uh, more diverse and surprising than you might think.
- 25:11Again, I want to so much.
- 25:12Dig into that and see what's behind that.
- 25:15But it was, it was interesting.
- 25:16The headline, it was interesting enough that I put it in my
- 25:18pile of things I want to read.
- 25:21All sorts
- 25:21of stuff
- 25:21to
- 25:22dig into.
- 25:22I'm, I'm, I'm glad you guys are diving into it.
- 25:24I think it's a, it's a really, we want to,
- 25:25we'd actually like to do a big evaluation project on it.
- 25:28We're talking with a, with a partner right now about trying to think about what are
- 25:31creative ways to answer this question.
- 25:33I know there's some other folks, I know Doug Harris at New
- 25:36Orleans is thinking about this.
- 25:37Yeah.
- 25:37A few quotes from Big Winter.
- 25:39Because it's going to take some creative approaches to get at it.
- 25:44Um, but it's, but it's important.
- 25:46I think we want to, it's going to be one of those things where like, um, uh,
- 25:52uh, Jay green used to do this a lot.
- 25:54Like where you just have to be the first person across the barbed
- 25:56wire with methods, ideal world, what you'd want, but are the best
- 26:01to be able to do in the context.
- 26:03Yeah.
- 26:03And just be like, what, what can we know?
- 26:05And there's going to be a ton of caveats.
- 26:07But I think we need some work like that, uh, here.
- 26:12Well, I think there are these macroeconomic issues that we
- 26:16should be looking at more.
- 26:17I don't know if you saw the post that I sent last weekend with the
- 26:20chart of the century in there.
- 26:22And, uh, the chart of the century basically showed how, uh, Well, first of
- 26:26all, hospital stays have had inflation rates at just unbelievable levels.
- 26:30Just below that is the cost of, of higher ed.
- 26:34Um, and one of the others that's just been way out of control in
- 26:37relative, relative to other parts of the economy has been that housing
- 26:40costs, especially housing purchases.
- 26:42Meanwhile, elsewhere in the economy, Like, the cost of a TV monitor has fallen
- 26:46off a cliff, technology costs have just dropped, um, phone costs have just, you
- 26:50know, dropped, and, um, and so it just puts in, in repose, like, you know,
- 26:55the parts of the economy that are least regulated are the ones where you tend to
- 26:58see a lot of the price drops and a lot of the economy that is most regulated.
- 27:04As the, the worst inflation.
- 27:05And as it so turns out, you would've,
- 27:09that Jed that's like surprising know, and as it turns out, lowers prices.
- 27:15That's like, that's biblical
- 27:18. But, but what?
- 27:19But as it turns out, you know, our world, you know, I look at, you can say at the
- 27:23chart of the century and say, why are you writing about that at charter folk?
- 27:26It doesn't have anything in there about K 12 specifically.
- 27:28Nothing about charter schools, but the, the, the adjacencies
- 27:30to our work, higher ed.
- 27:32And housing, given that we attend schools based upon the place where
- 27:35we live, you know, these parts of the economy are are really having
- 27:39a profound effect on on our work.
- 27:42And, you know, the way that that tuition costs got out of control in our country
- 27:46is, I mean, I know there's a lot of argument here, but it's inarguable.
- 27:51The guaranteed student loans for everyone.
- 27:54For everyone, regardless, you know, your, your income level just allowed higher
- 27:58ed to basically raise their rates to a level that, you know, is whatever they
- 28:04could coax their students into borrowing.
- 28:05And that's how inflation just got completely out of hand.
- 28:08And also the
- 28:09substitute in the aid package to take what aid they were getting and then push
- 28:13their institutional aid up the food chain.
- 28:16Um, the economic food chain, like they, it was, uh, the distorting effects.
- 28:23And we're constantly asked to pretend that this wouldn't be the case, which is like,
- 28:27it would be highly unusual if this wasn't the case because it would like, you know,
- 28:30run against everything we understand about like, how, how this stuff would, how you
- 28:35would expect this to work, um, and it was all kind of distorting sorts of effects.
- 28:40And, um, there's a guy named Art Hoffman who did a lot of work on the
- 28:43substitution issues and was sort of basically blackballed out of the.
- 28:46Uh, higher ed world.
- 28:47As a result, people said, I want to talk about it.
- 28:49Yeah.
- 28:50Well, I think that, that, I mean, there's a lot of talk now about the importance
- 28:54of voc ed and we've, we've touched upon that previously, but you know, the, the,
- 28:57under the subtext there is people are comparing the value of, of voc ed, um,
- 29:02to what the cost of, of, you know, higher ed is, but when higher ed's economics
- 29:07have been basically warped by this out of control inflation, it makes you, um, have
- 29:13a different calculation that we would.
- 29:14you know, otherwise.
- 29:16And, um, I mean, I, I didn't know until I started writing that thing,
- 29:19just poking around, like, I had never even heard of the Western governors.
- 29:24I, I, and it's the biggest university in the country, right?
- 29:28Yeah, in the history of it, it's kind of an interesting regional cooperation.
- 29:32It probably has like lessons and implications for other education issues.
- 29:35If we pause to look at it.
- 29:38Well, one of the things I didn't write about, I should have, or I should have
- 29:40included in there is when they made the Western governors universities, those,
- 29:44those are not public universities.
- 29:46Those are that they created a nonprofit.
- 29:49And, and the, and the, and the states have like supported the development of,
- 29:53it's basically a big college charter.
- 29:56Run as a nonprofit organization supported by, by states.
- 30:00Um, and that has turned out to be a recipe that has been incredibly successful.
- 30:04They gave, they gave out more than 50, 000 diplomas last year.
- 30:09Yeah.
- 30:09I mean, look, the real lesson here, we've talked about a little bit.
- 30:12We actually had a Virginia state board meeting, talked about it with
- 30:14some students recently it came up is like program, uh, and, and degree
- 30:20matter more than school at this point.
- 30:23But people still like just, you know, we're so attracted to the brand names
- 30:28and so forth, but it's like, what are you, what are you actually studying?
- 30:32And the feds have tried to put out some data on this to help people see
- 30:36that, but it hasn't really penetrated.
- 30:38Um, And look, if you want to study, um, uh, you want to go to Harvard and
- 30:44you want to study, you know, uh, you know, so, you know, critical theory
- 30:48or sociology, whatever, that's fine.
- 30:49Go for it.
- 30:50If that's your passion, people should, I should follow their passion.
- 30:53People should be aware of like.
- 30:55You know, with the R.
- 30:55O.
- 30:56I.
- 30:56And all that stuff looks like and likewise, some credential programs
- 30:59are great and some are not.
- 31:01We need to be communicating that, uh, better and helping
- 31:04his navigate that, uh, as well.
- 31:06We've done a lot of work on that, though, whether,
- 31:09well, the other piece is just the, the housing costs and during, during
- 31:13the, during covid to have seen that 88 percent of house purchases in
- 31:182022 were executed by white people.
- 31:22Right now, now.
- 31:22Down to 81%.
- 31:24Oh, we've made, we've made progress, right?
- 31:27It just shows who has the economic might, uh, to be able to Um, get to,
- 31:34uh, the house purchases that they want, uh, where they can, you know,
- 31:38and, and meanwhile, Oh, the black
- 31:40homeownership is rising and, and, and the black benefits, there
- 31:44is some good news there as well.
- 31:46And if you, you're always going to have a higher percentage of
- 31:48whites because there's just more white people in this country.
- 31:50Um, but there is some good, there is some good news there.
- 31:53There's obviously also like when you break down and you look at people
- 31:57who are descendants of slavery in America, there's like enormous
- 32:00wealth gaps that, that should require greater attention than they get.
- 32:05Well, 81 percent of purchasers are white.
- 32:0858 percent of American residents, you know, are a resident as it's
- 32:12yeah, no, no, there's a gap.
- 32:13I'm not arguing it's not a gap, but there's also stairs
- 32:15buried
- 32:16in there.
- 32:18And the strongest opponents to charter schools tend to be, you know, white
- 32:21progressives who have enough, uh, money to go and buy themselves houses in the burbs.
- 32:26So, I mean,
- 32:28These places.
- 32:28Yeah, no, that's it.
- 32:29That's, and I, and I think longterm.
- 32:32As it forces changes in either we go to higher density or do people
- 32:36move out and get more sprawl?
- 32:37What does that, what are the effects of that on, on education policy?
- 32:40I think there's like a bunch of dimensions to that.
- 32:42It's quite interesting.
- 32:44Well, you had mentioned that you'd seen a new study outta Denver,
- 32:46and I hadn't even heard of it yet.
- 32:48Tell me what, tell me what it is that you saw there.
- 32:50Oh, I think in color and the broader, you know, that's where I grew up.
- 32:53Um, yeah, yeah.
- 32:54What, what's the latest findings here?
- 32:56Yeah, and I was just out there this last weekend, um, uh, hosting a small group.
- 33:01And so, and, and, and so this was sort of front and center, um, thinking about
- 33:05this, uh, this guy named Parker Baxter.
- 33:07He's, um, at the University of Colorado, Denver, um, runs a really
- 33:10fantastic policy center there.
- 33:12He's worked in the district.
- 33:14Um, just one of these, you know, really great low key people in education.
- 33:18And, um, yeah, he did a study a couple years ago that showed some gains, but
- 33:22there was some methodological limitations.
- 33:24And it was, it was a little, and as he acknowledged, it was
- 33:26a little difficult to parse out.
- 33:28Are these like demographic changes in the city and, and, and, you know,
- 33:32enrollment changes that are driving, um, uh, are driving what looks like
- 33:36improvements or their actual improvements.
- 33:38Yeah.
- 33:38So he went back, he got student level data, the district fought him on it.
- 33:42So it's important, like it shows how the power there has shifted.
- 33:45You had Michael Bennett, Tom Bozberg, Susan Cordova, who are like, these like
- 33:49reformers who wanted to see the district in the current leadership and the district
- 33:53didn't want, like, they literally didn't want him to have access to this data,
- 33:57which is like, it's, it's, it's crazy that the sort of lack of curiosity
- 34:02about, or, or concern that somebody might make an inference somewhere.
- 34:05Um, Which we see a lot.
- 34:07It's not just there, but he got the data, um, was able to look large scale study.
- 34:12I think I don't have it in front of me, but I think I 40, 000 kids was
- 34:16able to make sure they'd been in the district for a couple of years,
- 34:18able to follow them to student level data and found really substantial
- 34:22effect sizes, differing effects by demographics and certain subpopulations.
- 34:28Um, but overall strong effects and really encouraging effects, uh, with
- 34:33with some groups of kids is a lot.
- 34:34They will drop some links to the study into media accounts
- 34:37in the, um, in the show notes.
- 34:39And I think what's like, it's 1 of these things that, like, it's these
- 34:43reforms were super controversial.
- 34:45The school board there has been highly contested and the results come in.
- 34:49On this reform approach.
- 34:51And it's like the train has kind of moved on.
- 34:53It points out a couple of things we've talked about.
- 34:55One, this idea that nothing works, which is like, yeah, exactly.
- 34:59It's another example of how something does work.
- 35:01And I just think in terms of like portfolio approach stuff that like
- 35:04people like Paul Hill have been talking about just, you know, for
- 35:07a long time, um, it's important.
- 35:09And it, and the findings are really interesting and it, it should be
- 35:13getting more attention than it does.
- 35:15And I feel like, no, it's not like a broken record, but I feel like.
- 35:18In, in some other fields, you know, medicine or energy or whatever.
- 35:22You know, when you have some good news, it tends to travel a little
- 35:25bit better and, and good news just doesn't, this is an important, this,
- 35:29this study should be traveling more.
- 35:32The, the Denver Post did a story on, there was kind of a hatchet job.
- 35:35Um, like, cause there's an industry and like, no, this can't be.
- 35:38And like, it's, there's some interesting stuff in the effect sizes are, I would
- 35:42describe as unusual relative to what we usually see with these things.
- 35:46And so people should want to pay attention.
- 35:48Well, I really want to dive in.
- 35:49We've done some focus in the last two weeks at charter folk on Indianapolis.
- 35:54So we had Brandon Brown from MindTrust, right, um, and had a few charter,
- 35:59uh, he wrote a piece, Scott Bess, um, wrote just a couple days ago.
- 36:04I was out there, visited schools.
- 36:06It's been really interesting talking to Brandon.
- 36:07It isn't in his piece.
- 36:09But it's worth focusing on in Indianapolis.
- 36:12They have these innovation schools and the way their state law was done.
- 36:17They have the charter schools in Indianapolis, but then they have these,
- 36:19they're, they're basically, I call them cabins charters, all but in name.
- 36:24Uh, there's, they're run by most of them are run by separate nonprofits.
- 36:29Yeah, well, I, yeah, so, um, because there are chinos, right?
- 36:33Charters in name only.
- 36:34And then there are cabins.
- 36:35Cabins, charters, all but in name.
- 36:37And it seems as though these Indianapolis schools really are cabins.
- 36:40Um, in Denver, they went forward with something similar.
- 36:45But because they weren't precise in their state, uh, advocacy work, I think
- 36:51most would say that I think they're called innovation schools or they, I
- 36:54think they're also called innovation schools in Denver, but their, their
- 36:57autonomies are fundamentally compromised.
- 37:00So I'll be really curious to read this report and see
- 37:02how those schools are doing.
- 37:05Um, cause I think that if those schools had the additional autonomies that
- 37:08to make them cabins too, well, then I would feel a greater sense of confidence
- 37:12that the progress that's been made in Denver is going to be locked in.
- 37:15Yeah, I remember a few years ago now in Denver, a fascinating group
- 37:20of teachers wanted to take control of their school and be empowered.
- 37:23They felt that they could run it better and wanted to do this.
- 37:26And like the union bought them.
- 37:27And so it was 1 again, it was 1 of those things that like you would think
- 37:30would cause people to pause and be like, maybe something's weird in this field.
- 37:34But, you know.
- 37:36that's just like Wednesday.
- 37:37Um, uh, and so, yeah, so, uh, Indianapolis, like,
- 37:41I'm obviously a big fan.
- 37:42I should, like, I was, uh, uh, I was a founding board member of the mine
- 37:45trust with Bart Peterson and David Harrison, and it's just an amazing work
- 37:49there and, and just to like, just the slow, steady work of moving this along.
- 37:54And, and, and Indianapolis, like there's still tons of problems.
- 37:56It's not where it needs to be, but man, the progress is.
- 37:59Is substantial and should, again, everyone who thinks this is all, you know, hopeless
- 38:03and futile, um, you know, th their, their, their, their work is a compelling example.
- 38:09Can I ask you there overall, you know,
- 38:13it's, I remember read Hastings one time talking about school boards being
- 38:17like, um, motherhood and apple pie.
- 38:19You know, there's no way we're ever gonna.
- 38:21You know, be able to, um, move the public off of a ee for them.
- 38:27But when we look at these large urban school districts across the
- 38:29country, and maybe I have a tick, you know, , but I mean, when you see
- 38:33Milwaukee and Chicago and you see St.
- 38:35Louis and, and you see what, what Denver was recently and just so many
- 38:39of these cities across the country, um.
- 38:41The dysfunction of their publicly elected school boards is just so apparent.
- 38:48And then not every charter school is a good charter school.
- 38:50Not every nonprofits, a great nonprofit, but just the stability of a self
- 38:54sustaining board, a self perpetuating board just seems like a fundamentally
- 38:59stronger place from which to.
- 39:02Chief excellence for our kids.
- 39:04But you know, the conversation is always in the opposite direction.
- 39:07No, no, no, no.
- 39:08We should be taking away from these nonprofits, uh, their ability to
- 39:12be self perpetuating and force them to have elections of some kind.
- 39:16Uh, is there anything you can offer here?
- 39:21Embedded
- 39:21there.
- 39:21Like, how do you like, I just think I'm, I find the Elected appointed debate, like
- 39:31just sort of a side show in the sense that there's compelling examples on both sides.
- 39:36Everyone loves appointed boards until somebody they don't like gets appointed.
- 39:39And then they're like.
- 39:40We should like, figure a way to change the power structure, um, me and you,
- 39:45you see this in a bunch of places.
- 39:47Um, I think, and this is going to sound glib, but like, it's almost like
- 39:52sometimes you just need a palate cleanser.
- 39:55And so when a place isn't working, shifting the
- 39:57governance arrangement can help.
- 39:58It can bring in change.
- 40:00Um, but no one should romanticize any particular governance model
- 40:05because we've seen plenty of dysfunction with with all of those.
- 40:07And it is a little bit like, oh, like things really aren't working.
- 40:11Okay, well, what model do you have?
- 40:12Well, then try the other one.
- 40:14Um, and you shouldn't do like what Chicago is doing is like
- 40:16incredible overcorrection.
- 40:17They're going to this board.
- 40:18It forgets like 27 people, something like that.
- 40:21It's just.
- 40:21And that's absurd.
- 40:22And that you can, you can tell how that's going to go.
- 40:25Um, but like, I, I don't know that you can inherently say that elected school boards.
- 40:30Um, you know, these things and people can wield their power in other ways.
- 40:35And, you know, obviously Denver played out through the changes in elected school
- 40:38board, a bunch of political campaigns, but with that political pressure
- 40:41been brought to bear and other venues potentially, I do think giving parents
- 40:46choice is a counterweight against this.
- 40:48To some extent, you start to build in some dynamism that doesn't exist.
- 40:53Basic reforms that it eludes me that we don't have and that people
- 40:56aren't out there pushing for.
- 40:57School board elections are held at off peak times.
- 40:59That's by design so that special interest, the unions can kind of drive it.
- 41:03They should be held when people are voting for other offices during
- 41:06your normal primaries and general elections, like to increase turnout.
- 41:10We shouldn't be doing these crazy, you know, firehouse elections or these
- 41:13off peak or at some, you know, some random day in, in, you know, April.
- 41:18I mean, there's reforms, there's reforms we could make, but I think yeah,
- 41:20Democracy's messy, and I'm skeptical of the idea that there is any kind of a
- 41:24panacea, um, any kind of a panacea here.
- 41:28Well, I wasn't arguing for appointed over elected.
- 41:31I was arguing for self perpetuating.
- 41:34That's, that's the value of these nonprofit boards.
- 41:36And, you know, I just my years at high tech high, I know for sure that if they
- 41:41hadn't been able to get board members that are deeply committed to project
- 41:45based learning and the different things that they wanted, if they just had
- 41:48any old board member come on there or one that was elected, all the things
- 41:51that made high tech high unique or different, they would have compromised on.
- 41:54And it would have sacked back to, you know, the miasmic
- 41:57one talk about all the time.
- 41:59So I feel like,
- 42:00yeah, well, hey, one other thing I guess I'd say about that.
- 42:08It's worth just pausing for a moment.
- 42:10Is this pressure to, like, get into board governance as a way to hamstring?
- 42:15Charters is a problem because it's hard to find good members who are committed,
- 42:21who have the skills, who have the time.
- 42:23Uh, and so to the extent people want to make it like you have to have more
- 42:27and more seats, it just makes that challenge harder and leads to problems.
- 42:31I think charter critics know that.
- 42:32So you need to be thoughtful about how do you make sure these, These
- 42:34things are publicly accountable, transparent, there's appropriate
- 42:38public input, but where that's not used as a, as a tool to hamstring them.
- 42:44Well, Minnesota is a cautionary tale for us right now.
- 42:46You probably saw how the Tribune, the Minneapolis Tribune came out
- 42:49with a big long hit piece against the state sector generally.
- 42:54But one of the things that was highlighted there is that one thing
- 42:57that makes Minnesota's charter school law different than any other state
- 43:00in the country is it's required that all school board members are elected.
- 43:05And so a lot of the most respected players in the country would never
- 43:08set up shop in Minnesota because they can never agree to a governance
- 43:13structure that was so fatally flawed.
- 43:15So governance really does matter and, um, and we have to remember what those things
- 43:20are and make good arguments for them.
- 43:23Um, yeah.
- 43:25Good week.
- 43:26We don't need to get into.
- 43:26We can throw that in the show notes.
- 43:27I have not read the article yet.
- 43:29It's on my list, but I will say people out there.
- 43:31I respect say there is some quality variance issues.
- 43:34On the other hand, Minnesota has some really fascinating authorizing methods.
- 43:38I think it's, I think it's a super interesting state.
- 43:41Um, with some really compelling examples.
- 43:43So I think it's again, it's one of these ones where there's something for
- 43:46there's something for everybody, but serious players in the charter sector.
- 43:50They have been around for a long time are certainly pro charter
- 43:52have have raised concerns that there are some quality issues.
- 43:56I'll be writing about it soon, so I'll be curious to see what one of
- 44:00these things like.
- 44:01What, you know, it gets back to these really difficult questions.
- 44:03Like how much should we be like, this is not quality.
- 44:06If it's a school, the parents like a different kind of pedagogical approach.
- 44:09This stuff's not, this stuff's not straight, straightforward.
- 44:13Sorry.
- 44:13You were going to talk about the last,
- 44:16yeah, well, the last minute, the last election or the last discussion, we were
- 44:20talking about walls and, and, you know, he coming onto the ticket and everything,
- 44:24um, we're now only six weeks out, you know, and I, I shared with you in an email
- 44:28in advance of this that, Hey, I don't.
- 44:31I don't know if I have anything different to say about this presidential
- 44:34election, but now we're only six weeks.
- 44:36Are you seeing any new trends?
- 44:37Anything?
- 44:37That's no, I think it's what
- 44:41it seems.
- 44:41It's a very, it's going to be a very close election.
- 44:44Trump probably enjoy some structural advantages relative
- 44:47to the electoral college.
- 44:48She is certainly having just a, a, a sort of wind at her back, uh, that
- 44:53any politician would, would want.
- 44:56And she's running, I think, a pretty smart campaign.
- 44:58We can talk about that.
- 44:59Um, uh, but like, but it's, it's going to be close.
- 45:04My, my gut sense is it's either going to be, he wins by a
- 45:08little or she wins comfortably.
- 45:10Um, and because we just don't quite understand what's happening with the,
- 45:13with, with, with the electorate and does that do low propensity voters that are
- 45:17hard to pull turn out for, um, for him, or is, is, is there going to be the end
- 45:22people are going to break towards her?
- 45:24Cause again, you know, it's, it's, it's a weird race.
- 45:25You think the eventual wisdom is always people like, well, you know.
- 45:28Undecide his break against the incumbent but like who's really
- 45:31the incumbent in this race.
- 45:32It's a little it's it's a complicated dynamic um one thing I do think
- 45:37is interesting and sort of I I find interesting in the sense that
- 45:40I'm one of these people who does believe education's like usually
- 45:42the last to get the memo She's like running pretty hard to the center.
- 45:47She's tossed identity politics politico this week, you know, where she's like
- 45:52she's ending sort of identity based appeals You Um, to hispanic voters and
- 45:58instead going with aspirational appeals, um, which a lot of people have been
- 46:04urging her to do except sort of the activist class that, that, that, you
- 46:08know, um, has an interest in invested interest in various things and she is.
- 46:13So she's, she's running a very smart campaign that way.
- 46:16Um, And, uh, and I think that's interesting.
- 46:20And so she's, you know, you're not hearing like no, no identity politics on her.
- 46:24She's, she's cutting against that and so forth.
- 46:26And yet like in our sector, everybody's still like luxuriates
- 46:28and that stuff all the time.
- 46:30And that just, to me, that's an interesting, that's an
- 46:32interesting disconnect.
- 46:33Um, she, I think she is closer to where the country is.
- 46:38Uh, I think she has a better, uh, thumb on that than, than perhaps like all the
- 46:41elites in our sector, uh, and that's showing up in, in how she campaigns.
- 46:45And then there's going to be some lessons there.
- 46:47And she's not she hasn't clawed back all the gap with where Biden was in
- 46:512020 with with different demographic groups, but she's doing better, um,
- 46:57uh, than he was she's making background among black and hispanic voters.
- 47:00She's doing very well among white voters.
- 47:02Like she's starting.
- 47:03You can see the glimmers of the coalition.
- 47:04She would need, uh, she would need to win
- 47:07well, we in education world often get focused on those those
- 47:11presidential elections or top of ticket matters when usually.
- 47:14What matters the most is what happens in the, in the legislature
- 47:17is what's the mix of stuff.
- 47:18And I, I just saw something, I don't know if it was in Politico or maybe
- 47:22it was in 74 about, um, Arizona.
- 47:25We were talking about Arizona earlier in the voucher program.
- 47:271 thing that's, uh, is a real possibility there is that they could have.
- 47:32A democratic governor and both chambers of the legislature controlled by Dems,
- 47:37who would then be determining the future of their ESA and voucher program.
- 47:41In a number of different states right now, there's a possibility for
- 47:43significant chamber, chamber shifts.
- 47:46And that's where actually the, you know, the education policy tire hits the road.
- 47:51Yeah.
- 47:51Well, going back to what we talked about earlier, historically, cost issues have
- 47:56been a potent argument against choice plans and So you can see that they're
- 48:02going to need a way to go after the choice stuff and you can see that being the way
- 48:07and because that's been again, that's been a that's been potent and so you can see
- 48:11that happening in Arizona and you sort of seen hops kind of casting around for a way
- 48:15to go after it while recognizing that it's very popular and so this could provide
- 48:20that that could be an avenue they go.
- 48:22The other thing I just think, look, yeah.
- 48:24The more states you have with, like, robust charter sectors and Democrats
- 48:28in the Senate, the better it is.
- 48:30Yeah.
- 48:31Because it starts to mute the opposition.
- 48:33It's like when we talk about Tim Walz, where, you know, where he's
- 48:36obviously no great fan of charters, but he's also like, look, parents are
- 48:39choosing this, this is going on, I'm not going to, like, upend their lives.
- 48:41He was kind of a responsible governor in that way.
- 48:44And like, you could, it is better the more states you have where there's actually
- 48:50a constituent interest in this, like, the better will be in terms of, like,
- 48:55restoring some sense of at least, like, equilibrium, even if we can't get to,
- 49:00like, outright support for charters in the, in the, in the Democratic caucus.
- 49:05Yeah, I'm really quite, quite interested in the changing tone in Charterland.
- 49:11Uh, I think things are getting a little bit more positive right now.
- 49:14I think there's a lot of concern about what's going to happen at the top of
- 49:16the ticket and all that kind of stuff.
- 49:17But I'm not sensing in my day to day conversations the degree of
- 49:21exhaustion and the degree of, of almost futility that people were
- 49:25feeling maybe three to four years ago.
- 49:27And I wonder if it's just a matter of Recognizing our own staying
- 49:32power and how unique staying power is in the education world.
- 49:36Um, and maybe to wrap up, we could we could talk a little bit about one who
- 49:40had as much staying power as anybody that we knew, which is Don Shelby.
- 49:45He had this event last week, and I had a chance to go there.
- 49:50It was a great thing to see so many people there.
- 49:53But, um, I think the overarching thing was, you know, Well, there were so
- 49:58many things to celebrate about Don Shelby, but it's the staying power.
- 50:01I did see Reed.
- 50:02He walked up and he was just like, you know, Don just stayed in the game
- 50:08for so long and it's the cumulative impact of staying in the game.
- 50:13I didn't make the connection with Reed in that very moment.
- 50:16Um, but a good thing I immediately was locking onto.
- 50:19Yeah.
- 50:19And the staying power of charters were, you know, well into our fourth decade now.
- 50:24And it's the staying power, um, our people, uh, and the
- 50:28broader, you know, sector itself.
- 50:29But I don't know, you knew Don as well as I did, you know, um,
- 50:33any, any new reflections on, on what, you know, his legacy is.
- 50:37Well, yeah, I was sad I couldn't be there, but I had a, I had a
- 50:40commitment elsewhere and, and, and so I was very, I was very sorry.
- 50:43I was very sorry to miss it.
- 50:44Yeah.
- 50:44I mean, look, I think part of it is, um, I also think it's
- 50:48not just staying power alone.
- 50:51Don also made some big bets early or, you know, he bet his career when he
- 50:55left the superintendency to do aspire.
- 50:57He was willing to bet his whole career.
- 50:59And so I also, I want to make sure he gets credit for the staying
- 51:02power is important, but so is the willingness to take a risk in my.
- 51:05Big fear for the sector right now.
- 51:07I'm not sure how many leaders we have.
- 51:08We're actually willing to like make those, you know, we've talked about it, the
- 51:12Howard Fuller's, the Linda Brown's, you know, people who were kind of willing to
- 51:16put all their chips in the middle of the table for something that they believed in.
- 51:19And I worry we have like, A lot of people now who see themselves as
- 51:24the future, you know, CEO or ED of this or that, or the future deputy
- 51:29assistant secretary of this or that.
- 51:31And so they're not like, and, and, and a movement that suffers from that's a move.
- 51:34It's not going to get very far.
- 51:36So I don't, I don't want to lose his bravery as well as his staying power.
- 51:40But yeah, I do think there's something.
- 51:41To that, I mean, it's the old, you know, you know, have a life showing up
- 51:44like you got to keep showing up and, and look that going back to Denver,
- 51:49like the reform critics, they got swept out of the board, you know, and
- 51:52Michael Ben and Boseberg were, you know, moving an aggressive agenda, but
- 51:56they didn't just like, um, and then Susanna, they just didn't like go home.
- 52:00They like kept showing up and they clawed back.
- 52:04Um, like you have to respect that.
- 52:06Um, and I think our folks are can be pretty fast to kind of declare
- 52:10mission accomplished or move on or say it's futile or be a little feckless.
- 52:13And, you know, Don, Don was definitely not.
- 52:16any of those things.
- 52:17He just, he was, he was very persistent, um, in a, in a
- 52:21good, in a good, uh, a good way.
- 52:25And he, he had a, he had a North Star and he stayed, he never,
- 52:28he never lost that North Star.
- 52:30The next month I'm going back to San Diego.
- 52:33They're going to have a big event for Larry Rosenstock, um, at High Tech High.
- 52:38Uh, he's not passed, uh, but his health is not good and it's a part of the reason
- 52:42why they, they want to celebrate here.
- 52:44But one of the things, and, and Don and, and, and Larry
- 52:47spent a lot of time together.
- 52:48They did refer to each other as brothers from other mothers.
- 52:50Um, but the one thing that they had, it's like, I mean, cause I can remember
- 52:54Larry in my, in my like second or third month on the job at high tech
- 52:58high, cause I was like, go get it.
- 53:00It's like, I wanted to like, you know, just go really fast and stuff.
- 53:03He's like, look, we will go fast, but people around here, we love our work.
- 53:08We love our work and we are going to continue loving our work.
- 53:12That is a non negotiable.
- 53:14And it's just that love of work, that the privilege of being
- 53:17able to work with young people.
- 53:18I mean, all you had to do with B is be with Larry in the presence of teenagers.
- 53:23And you just, you just saw them.
- 53:25And that was the thing that with, with Don too, it was like whatever setting
- 53:28he was in, whether it was with teachers or it was with funders or it was with,
- 53:33you know, other educators or parents or, or kids themselves, this guy.
- 53:37You know, he had the staying power, but it was no, it was no huge.
- 53:41He took his risks.
- 53:42He took his risks.
- 53:43Yeah.
- 53:43But it's no heavy lift.
- 53:44He loved it.
- 53:45Right.
- 53:46And he was a happy warrior.
- 53:47Yeah.
- 53:48It's, it's one thing that I think we, and, and, and it's one of the reasons why
- 53:52when I feel, you know, charter land having a little more oxygen in the room and I
- 53:56don't feel a sense of dispirited ness to the same degree that I did, you know,
- 53:59last, you know, three or four years ago.
- 54:01Makes me more optimistic because the only way we're going to sustain
- 54:05this work is if we continue to to enjoy it And if there's anything that
- 54:10that Don reminds us that he he wrote something at Charterfolk Love you.
- 54:14Love what you do and then Then three days later.
- 54:18He said Jed.
- 54:18I didn't get everything in there Can I publish again next week so
- 54:22I would never do this before same contributor two weeks love what
- 54:25you do part two Yeah, well, I think
- 54:30that's an important thing there, Jed, that ties both those, and you're right about
- 54:33Larry, and Larry has hilarious, so many hilarious stories, uh, about, like, he's
- 54:38just like, it's so much fun to be around.
- 54:40Um, uh, both those guys, though, I think one thing, they knew what they were
- 54:47for and why they're in this business.
- 54:48They weren't just about tearing down, they weren't just like against the
- 54:51unions or against the government.
- 54:52Districts are wanting to, you know, abolish this or that.
- 54:55Like they, they were builders.
- 54:57They had, they were like, here, they, they were for something.
- 54:59And I think that's a big differentiator, um, that you need like leaders in the
- 55:05sector who are actually are for something, have a positive vision in the world that
- 55:10they want to see realized almost less matters if you have an agree with that
- 55:15vision or not, but some sort of positive vision for change rather than just like
- 55:18all these things that you're setting yourself in opposition to or against.
- 55:23Well, all we got to do is keep going at it and, uh, for another 30 years
- 55:27plus and, you know, laughing all the way and we will have lived up to the
- 55:30example that Larry and Don left for us.
- 55:33But I sure enjoy our time together a lot, Andy.
- 55:35Yeah, Jed, it was great.
- 55:36I hope congratulations again on your anniversary.
- 55:38I hope you have a great rest of your trip and I'm going to look
- 55:42forward to seeing you in person soon.
- 55:45All right.
- 55:45See you for another one in a month.
- 55:47Great.
- 55:49Take care, Andy.
- 55:50See ya.