Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Says I Can Handle It
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, we've spent a lot of episodes on employees who push back, who hoard, who say 'not my job.' But there's a quieter type that might be just as tricky—the person who says 'I can handle it' and genuinely means it. Luna: Oh, that's a good one. Because on the surface, that sounds like a dream employee, right? No whining, no excuses. But underneath, there's often a lot going on. Lucas: Exactly. And by the way, if episodes like this help you think through a tricky management situation, we'd love it if you'd consider supporting the show. It's what keeps Manager Mondays ad-free and in your feed. You can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Truly, every bit helps. Luna: Yeah, and we don't say that often, but it does make a difference. Okay, back to the 'I can handle it' employee. What's the real risk here? Lucas: The risk is that they're not actually handling it. They're just really good at hiding that they're not. I was talking to a friend who manages a retail operations team, and she told me about a coordinator—let's call her Maya—who never said no. Whenever there was a new project, Maya would say 'I can handle it,' and she always did. Until she didn't. Luna: What happened? Lucas: She missed a critical deadline for a store audit. Just completely dropped the ball. And when my friend followed up, Maya broke down and said she'd been juggling three times her normal workload for months. She thought asking for help would make her look weak. Luna: And that's the thing, isn't it? In many workplaces, saying 'I can't handle it' feels like an admission of failure. So people overcommit until they crash. Lucas: Right. And as a manager, you can't just wait for the crash to happen. You have to create an environment where someone like Maya feels safe saying 'I'm in over my head' before it's a crisis. That starts with how you run your one-on-ones. Luna: What do you mean? Because a standard 'how's everything going?' isn't going to cut it. Lucas: No, it won't. A question like that gets a reflexive 'fine' or 'busy, but good.' You have to ask different questions. For example, instead of 'how's your workload,' ask 'what's taking up more of your time than you expected this week?' That gets at the unexpected drags, not just the official task list. Luna: That's a nice reframe. It assumes there's something, not that everything is fine. Lucas: Exactly. Another technique is what I call the 'pre-mortem.' It's borrowed from project management, but you can use it with individuals. If they're about to take on a big task, ask them: 'If this were to go sideways, what would be the most likely reason?' That gets them thinking about risks without admitting weakness upfront. Luna: So you're getting them to talk about potential problems in a hypothetical way, not about their own limitations. Lucas: Exactly. And then you can follow up with, 'What would you need to make sure that doesn't happen?' That gives them permission to ask for resources or help without feeling like they're failing. It's a subtle but powerful shift. Luna: I love that. But what about the employee who really can handle it? The one who's actually just efficient and doesn't need help? Lucas: That's a fair question. And you don't want to overcorrect and micromanage someone who's genuinely fine. The key is to differentiate between 'handling it' and 'thriving.' Handling it means they're meeting expectations. Thriving means they're growing, they're not at risk of burnout, and they're not secretly resenting the workload. Luna: So how do you spot the difference? Lucas: Look for signs like them starting to miss small things—typos in emails, slightly delayed responses. Or maybe they're the first to leave and the first to arrive, but they seem more fatigued. Also, check in on their learning. Are they taking on stretch projects? Or are they just doing more of the same? Luna: That's a good distinction. Doing more of the same is a red flag, because it could mean they're just accumulating tasks without any growth. And that's a recipe for boredom or burnout. Lucas: Exactly. Another thing I've seen is that the 'I can handle it' employee often declines help, not because they don't need it, but because they don't trust the help. Maybe they've had bad experiences where delegating meant it wouldn't get done right. So they'd rather do it themselves. Luna: So as the manager, part of your job is to build that trust. Show them that when they delegate, you'll support them. Maybe start with a small, low-stakes task that you know will go well. Lucas: Yes, and you can also reframe delegation as a leadership skill. You can say something like, 'I know you can handle this, but part of growing into a senior role is learning to develop others. I'd like you to think about what you could hand off to someone else on the team.' That makes it about their development, not their performance. Luna: That's smart. It turns the conversation from 'you need help' to 'you have potential to lead.' Much more motivating. Lucas: And it works. I've seen managers use that approach with high performers who were resistant to letting go. Once they framed it as 'developing the team,' the employee was actually eager to delegate. They saw it as a sign that their manager believed in their leadership potential. Luna: Let's talk about the manager's own behavior. I've noticed that managers who are also 'I can handle it' types tend to have that same attitude in their team. They model the behavior. Lucas: Absolutely. If you're the manager and you never admit you're overwhelmed, your team learns that that's the norm. You have to model vulnerability. In a staff meeting, you might say, 'I'm feeling stretched this week, so I'm going to push back on a few requests.' That gives others permission to do the same. Luna: It's like the old saying: 'The fish rots from the head down.' But in a positive way, if the head models healthy boundaries, the rest of the team follows. Lucas: And it doesn't have to be a big confession. It can be as simple as, 'I'm going to take a shorter lunch today to catch up,' which is normal, or 'I'm going to ask for an extension on this project.' When you do that, you're signaling that it's okay to have limits. Luna: That's a good point. But what about the employee who says 'I can handle it' and then actually does handle it, but they're doing it at the expense of their well-being? They're working nights and weekends, but they never complain. How do you address that without seeming like you're punishing their work ethic? Lucas: That's really important, and it's a bigger issue than just the immediate task. You have to look at the long-term cost. I had a colleague who was incredibly productive, but he was burning out. He'd send emails at midnight, and he was proud of that. But his health was suffering, and eventually he had to take a leave of absence. Luna: And by then it was too late to prevent it. Lucas: Right. So as a manager, part of your job is to protect your team from that. You can say, 'I appreciate your dedication, but I need you to be sustainable. I'd rather you deliver slightly less but be here in a year.' That's a hard conversation, but it's necessary. Luna: And you can also help them prioritize. Maybe they're saying 'I can handle it' to everything, but they don't realize that not everything is equally important. Lucas: Exactly. That's where you as the manager come in. You have the big picture. You can say, 'This new project is a 'C' priority. Could you put it on the back burner?' That helps them see that they don't have to handle everything at full intensity. Luna: I think there's also something about the language we use. If you say 'I can handle it,' it's a bit of a binary—you either can or you can't. But in reality, it's a spectrum. You might be able to handle it at a basic level, but not at the level of excellence you expect from yourself. Lucas: That's a good nuance. And that's why asking 'what would it take for this to be excellent?' can be a better question than 'can you handle this?' It opens the door to them acknowledging that they might need more time, more resources, or more help to meet the high standard. Luna: So we've talked about the manager's role. But what if the employee still won't open up? I've had team members who, no matter how safe I try to make it, they just won't say they're struggling. What then? Lucas: That's a tough one. At some point, you have to trust your observations over their words. If you see signs of overwork—late-night emails, missed deadlines, irritability—you have to intervene, even if they say they're fine. And you can do it in a way that doesn't challenge their competence. Luna: Like what? Lucas: You could say, 'I've noticed you've been putting in long hours lately. I'm not asking you to do that. What can I take off your plate?' That way, you're not saying 'you can't handle it.' You're saying 'I see you working hard, and I want to help.' Luna: That's a good approach. And it's more concrete than just saying 'let me know if you need help.' Lucas: Exactly. The problem with 'let me know' is it puts the burden on them to admit they can't handle it. Instead, you're taking the first step. You're saying 'I'm going to take something off your plate,' not 'do you want me to?' That can be a relief. Luna: And you can also build in a regular check-in on workload. Like, every two weeks, ask 'what's the one thing you'd like to stop doing?' That normalizes the idea that we all have tasks that could go away. Lucas: I like that. It makes it a routine part of the conversation, not a sign of weakness. And over time, the employee starts to see that you're genuinely interested in their well-being, not just their output. That builds the trust they need to be honest. Luna: So, to wrap up, the 'I can handle it' employee is often your most dedicated team member. But that's exactly why they're at risk. The manager's job is to help them see that asking for help is not a failure—it's a skill. Lucas: And it's a skill that will serve them well as they advance. Because as you move up, the work becomes less about what you can do alone and more about what you can enable others to do. The sooner they learn that, the better. So next time an employee says 'I can handle it,' maybe the best response is: 'I know you can. And I also know that a great leader knows when to share the load.' Luna: That's a great note to end on. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And to our listeners, we'd love to hear how you've handled this type of employee. Drop us a line or just reflect on it in your next one-on-one. Until next week.