Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP306: Tech Stacks & Roadmaps - An Ecommerce Leader's Playbook, With University of Law Head of Ecommerce, Edward Scott-Finnigan
Transcript
- 0:00Unification of martech infrastructure is is incredibly
- 0:04important. We have our core site, we have
- 0:07multiple sites for our sister products that all feed into each
- 0:10other. We have the CRM, we have all our
- 0:13social media channels and those extend into student specific
- 0:18chat boards that are very important to us.
- 0:23You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:26and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:29and re platform specialist James Get and call Rogers.
- 0:31Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:33industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:36practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:41This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:43Got a, a, a slightly different episode today.
- 0:46We're talking to a highly experienced e-commerce person,
- 0:50someone I've known for many years, but we're looking at the,
- 0:52the insights and learnings from somebody who's been from an
- 0:55agency to client side, back to agency and then back to client
- 0:58side e-commerce. So lots of different
- 0:59perspectives on, on delivering good E good e-commerce
- 1:02strategies. So a warm welcome to Edward
- 1:04Scott Finnegan, who's the head of e-commerce at University law.
- 1:06Hey, Edward. Hi, James, How are you doing?
- 1:09Yeah, thanks for Joy agreeing to come on.
- 1:13And for those of you you listen, Edward's been one of our longest
- 1:16term podcast supporters. I'm delighted that we've got him
- 1:18on to talk about his e-commerce, Jenny.
- 1:20Well, so yeah, thank you for being such an avid listener and
- 1:23support of the podcast. And we, we were talking about
- 1:27this one. We just before we start
- 1:28recording, Edward and I worked together on a project while back
- 1:32with a brand called Synproof where Edward was agency side, I
- 1:36was consulting and Synproof was the client.
- 1:38And I my ability to understand timelines in my life is so bad.
- 1:43There was actually only, I think you said it's only five years
- 1:45ago, wasn't it? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:47It's it's crazy how that time has flown by.
- 1:49But I think if you allow me to lament a bit, being the youngest
- 1:54of three, one of the things my brother said to me is once you
- 1:59hit 30, it just all starts disappearing.
- 2:01And I think even like now at the ripe old age of 47, yeah,
- 2:06they're just those five 5-6 years have just disappeared.
- 2:09But Audrey James, it's, it's interesting because I can go
- 2:12back to that project and it feels like yesterday.
- 2:15Yeah, I think that's thing. So can I like I almost have no
- 2:18memory until I'm reminded of something, then it all comes.
- 2:21I'm loving back. So let's let's let's give our
- 2:25audience A flavour for who you are and what you do.
- 2:28So do you want to do you want to talk us through your e-commerce
- 2:30story? Like where, where you, where
- 2:32you've been, how you come to and and then what's brought you back
- 2:35to being client side rather than an agency work?
- 2:39Yeah, cool. So as I said to you, I, I don't
- 2:43want to sort of make this podcast about 7 hours long.
- 2:46Nobody wants that. But I, I very much fumble my way
- 2:50into e-commerce. You know, I grew up in Suffolk
- 2:54and which right in the middle of nowhere and at that time
- 2:58probably didn't appreciate the beauty that I lived in.
- 3:03But you know, it was an hour and a half any direction to get to
- 3:06any civilisation. But I was very technology
- 3:09focused and ended up working for a systems integrator that was
- 3:14big in government, utilities and telcos.
- 3:18And I was at the time sort of supporting BDMI was knocking
- 3:24down doors, but learning my craft at that point.
- 3:27And you and I can both remember those times when there were only
- 3:31four channels on the TV and not everyone had Internet at home.
- 3:36But Amazon was still only selling books.
- 3:39But we worked on this fascinating project with O2,
- 3:43which was one of our big clients.
- 3:45So I was up and down from Suffolk to Leeds quite often.
- 3:49But they they were having your pay as you go phones.
- 3:53Everyone was having to go to the cigarette counter at the local
- 3:56supermarket and having to top up the prepaid cards and one of the
- 4:01clever bods, O2 and our technical director at the time
- 4:05said, why don't we do this online?
- 4:08And I can keep that was the key point where I was like, OK,
- 4:12e-commerce. That's actually something that
- 4:14can can actually work. And it was a phenomenal project
- 4:17to be involved in. But even, you know, just to
- 4:19think now that people used to go, go to droves to the
- 4:22supermarket to actually top up a prepaid card to then dial A
- 4:28specific code into your prepaid mobile phone to actually get
- 4:33credit. I mean, what, what foreign idea
- 4:36is that right now? But it was, you know, how can we
- 4:38digitise that journey? And I think what the interesting
- 4:42thing from that perspective and that key project and what made
- 4:45me a bit of a tech nerd was I had true insight and overview of
- 4:50what went on behind the scenes. So we were a systems integrator.
- 4:55So for us, even though websites were quite new at that time, the
- 5:00back end development was the big, big part of it.
- 5:02And it was fascinating sort of seeing, you know, just the
- 5:05impact of 1 system to another, to another, to another and how
- 5:09how that relates. And that's where my e-commerce
- 5:12journey began. And that e-commerce journey has
- 5:17seen me move from the UK to Germany, work for what is
- 5:21probably the biggest music retailer actually they can say
- 5:27in the world. I mean, when I was working for
- 5:29them, they were in hundreds of millions.
- 5:31Now they're into the billions. And that's a company called
- 5:33Music House Tommen. I headed up their international
- 5:36e-commerce division. And I don't again, I don't want
- 5:42to carry on through my entire CV career.
- 5:44I hope I'm not applying for another job here, but I think
- 5:48one of the things that I've always enjoyed is, is the
- 5:51project side. And what got me into agency was
- 5:55it kind of saw me. I saw it as an absolute dream.
- 5:59I can have all these wonderful projects.
- 6:01I can work on it all the time. And to some degree that's true.
- 6:07But my personal approach is I have a very custodial approach
- 6:11on, on any of the projects or any of the digital properties
- 6:13that I've worked with. There are, sorry to be cheesy,
- 6:16they are my babies. I care about them.
- 6:18I want them to be the best. And I think what I've learnt
- 6:21from agency side is, yeah, it's exciting to get to work with
- 6:26these companies, to build relationships, to network, to
- 6:28see the vision, be a key part of that journey.
- 6:32But it's almost I, I, I, I put it in these terms.
- 6:36I'm a bit of a car guy, but imagine building your perfect
- 6:39car and the moment you're handed the keys, someone takes them
- 6:43off, you gets in the car and drives off.
- 6:45And, and I think that to me has always left me.
- 6:49You know, you have that, that launch excitement, that project
- 6:52go live excitement, which is awesome.
- 6:54But then for me personally, there was a little bit of a, you
- 6:59know, but, but I want to join that.
- 7:01I want to keep going. I want to see where it can go.
- 7:03And I think that's where my growth mindset is not being fed
- 7:07because I'm always like, OK, now is the next part.
- 7:10We've got the foundation. Let's let's build, let's grow.
- 7:13Let's see where this rocket can go.
- 7:15And, and I think that's what brought me back to client side.
- 7:20You know, I've done consulting and again, similar story, but
- 7:26being client side allows me to grab onto a brand to build a
- 7:30future to sort of see where, where things could go.
- 7:33And I think I've learnt important lessons from both
- 7:37sides of the coin. But I think I'm I'm at my
- 7:41happiest client side. Yeah, I find this really
- 7:44interesting because I've, yeah, I've been a consultant for 16
- 7:47years. I was previously agency side and
- 7:49client side before that. And the the mindsets are
- 7:52different and the cadence of work is very different.
- 7:54You're right. And actually one of the hardest
- 7:56things I've found as an independent is because I get
- 7:58very emotionally vested in the projects I work in because I
- 8:02care. I might be able to be flippant
- 8:05when things go wrong because that's just the way you have to
- 8:08destigmatize the challenges we face with technology and people.
- 8:10Where I generally care and I will do my utmost to make sure a
- 8:13project's successful. And if there's any issues, I, I
- 8:16kind of take it personally as well, but I've had to teach
- 8:18myself to disconnect at the end of projects because it is quite
- 8:22an intense thing, isn't it? When you're whether it's a re
- 8:24platforming or it's a large launch of something else,
- 8:28there's a real emotional build up as you hit launch period.
- 8:32And I, and I think, but one of the things that is invaluable
- 8:36and a lesson that I've learned from being a consultant or being
- 8:40agents inside, whilst the emotion is important and it's
- 8:45invaluable, being sort of outside that in the early doors
- 8:50gives you a real good understanding of, of being able
- 8:54to pinpoint what is the reason, What is the real reason?
- 8:57What is the purpose of this project.
- 8:59Usually you're fed, Oh, because we want to hit X revenue goal in
- 9:03five years or we want to move into this new market because
- 9:07it's the age-old, if we have 1% of their GDP, suddenly we'll all
- 9:11be billionaires. But I think, you know, being
- 9:14agency and consultant, you can sit there and you can take
- 9:17yourself out of the noise and go.
- 9:19It's very, you can quickly come to the real purpose behind any
- 9:23of these projects, whatever it may be.
- 9:25And I think it's a key lesson that I wouldn't, I wouldn't have
- 9:28been able to evolve if I'd been purely client side the whole
- 9:31time. What do Mattel, Victoria,
- 9:35Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 9:40They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 9:44Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 9:47the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 9:51converting check out on the planet Shopify powering the
- 9:56future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at shopify.com.
- 10:00Slash enterprise, yeah, that was one of the key question I had
- 10:04for you is, is because I've spoke to lots of people have
- 10:07been in different roles, people have been in the same type of
- 10:10role all their lives. And I guess my yeah, my that
- 10:13that chance of me, the the thing that I perceive of benefits,
- 10:17having worked with so many different people, not being not
- 10:20working full time in one organization is as well.
- 10:23Whilst I might be emotionally invested in projects because I
- 10:26want to be successful, I have that ability to just step out
- 10:28and be objective about agree. Why you doing this and why do
- 10:32you do things like this? And this is really the right way
- 10:34of doing it. I think it's very hard when
- 10:36you're embroiled in the day-to-day into the politics and
- 10:39the ways of work it to be able to step back in and challenge it
- 10:43so objectively and say, OK, great, you do things like that,
- 10:46but that's not actually an optimal way and and there are
- 10:48more efficient ways of doing it. Do you have you got some
- 10:51specific areas where you when you've come back to clients on
- 10:54the university law, where those skills you've developed in an
- 10:57agency world have already like come home to roost?
- 11:00Absolutely. I think so University of Law,
- 11:04we've, you can tie back our, our origins to like over 150 years,
- 11:11you know, and we've been a charity, we've been a college
- 11:16where a, we're in university by name, but we're not classed as a
- 11:21university by government regulations because we have no,
- 11:27there's no beds for anyone to sleep in and there's certain
- 11:30areas. So we're kind of, we're
- 11:33university, but we're, it's kind of pseudo university.
- 11:36But the way we've grown is through acquisition and we've
- 11:40been transferred through, you know, differing operating
- 11:45parties. So I was, I think education for
- 11:49me was, you know, I, I came to University law as a consultant
- 11:54and I was very upfront that I've got no idea about education.
- 11:59I've never sat in this side. But I think what the way I've
- 12:04been able to model the University of Law and its output
- 12:08is, I say it's kind of like a brand manufacturer, you know,
- 12:12the, the systems that I say the transfer of data, yes, you can
- 12:16call, you know, the courses of product, we create those
- 12:20products, we market those products.
- 12:21I think being able to work across multiple channels,
- 12:26verticals, whatever you want to call them and understand that
- 12:29there is there is a structure that works across a lot of
- 12:33businesses irrespective of your vertical.
- 12:37And I'd say, you know, being able to 1:00 ask that avid 3
- 12:44year old question of why and be very, very forefront about why
- 12:50are we doing, what is the purpose.
- 12:52And then really, you know, when you're doing any due diligence
- 12:56consultant or agency side, the most important value you can
- 13:02have to any project is really understanding the why.
- 13:05I don't want to sound all Simon Sinek.
- 13:08I don't want to sound all cheesy and LinkedIn title, but there is
- 13:12a purpose behind everything that is not written in the
- 13:15requirements document. And I think that that I, I
- 13:19wouldn't have that questioning ability.
- 13:21I wouldn't have that understanding.
- 13:22I wouldn't be, you know, really to get down to the nitty gritty
- 13:25because as he rightly said, it's once you understand, if I put it
- 13:29to a recent project and there was discussion on our main site
- 13:35about should we move to, you know, headless front end, But
- 13:41you know, why what, what is it? And I'll, I'll save you the
- 13:45laborious meeting feedback, but it came back to what is the real
- 13:50requirement here? It's actually autonomy to do
- 13:52what the teams need to do within the main site.
- 13:55It it was nothing about it was just suggested.
- 13:57Well, for us to achieve this autonomy, we have to absolutely
- 14:01move from an on Prem solution to a highly technically functional
- 14:10cloud front end. And, and, and it was just like,
- 14:14no, that that's, that's not the why.
- 14:16It's that we can deliver that autonomy for a lot less hassle,
- 14:19a lot less budget and a lot less time frame.
- 14:23But if you looked at the requirements document, anyone
- 14:26would just look at it and go word for word.
- 14:29Yeah, no, no, they need the headless front end without an
- 14:30absolute. It's so interesting.
- 14:34Yeah, it is. And it's, this is one of the
- 14:36things I love about doing like discovery sessions of really
- 14:38probing into what's driving the decision, what the commercial
- 14:42driver for it. Is it about saving money?
- 14:44Is it about operational efficiency?
- 14:46Is it about greatest speed to mark?
- 14:48What are all those drivers of success?
- 14:50And and what, what does success look because you have to come
- 14:53back to us and what does success look?
- 14:54All right, because you could take in that use case.
- 14:56I've been in a project where people talked about wanting to
- 14:58move to like headless CMSS and to unpick one or two challenges.
- 15:03But what's the benefit to the business?
- 15:05Or could you actually, can you actually live with a slightly
- 15:08slower process because the cost of moving is going to give you
- 15:12very little impact to, to, to have those benefits?
- 15:14But it leaves you on to the question actually, because
- 15:18you've got what always struck me about when, when we worked
- 15:21together, that project when you were agency side was was that
- 15:23you have a strong technical knowledge and understanding.
- 15:26So you're not just on the commercial side.
- 15:28You really like to get into the detail about what the how the
- 15:30technology works for, how it's going to deliver on, on business
- 15:33needs. I'd love to, I'd love to hear
- 15:36your perspective. Now you're backing clients side,
- 15:38you're running an e-commerce operation.
- 15:41The technology landscapes changed massively in the last
- 15:43five years. Business challenges are pretty
- 15:46tough right now. So from a tech leadership point
- 15:49of view, what current challenges do you think heads of e-commerce
- 15:52have when looking at their technology stack?
- 15:57It's interesting because I could go to a real deep layered onion
- 16:01of different verticals. But if I stand back a bit and
- 16:06I'd say I'm going to pinch one of your sayings and that's
- 16:12technology evangelism, I think confusion is probably the key
- 16:18moniker. I think you're right right now.
- 16:21We had a torrid time last year and I said we, the commerce
- 16:25community, and we were warned that 2025 was going to be even
- 16:30more challenging. And it was interesting in the
- 16:32beginning of the year, IMRG, we're forecasting massively
- 16:36down. But oddly, it looks like we're a
- 16:40couple of percent up year on year, but it was a pretty awful
- 16:44year last year. And I think, you know, the, the,
- 16:48the true leaders last year, beauty fashion, they're having a
- 16:52real hard time right now. So I could get really specific,
- 16:56but I think one of the key it is confusion.
- 17:00It is, it is looking to the shiny thing, it's looking
- 17:04towards. You know what?
- 17:08There's not one solution that's going to fix all.
- 17:11You know, if you don't have a strategy in in place, then I'm
- 17:16sorry to say you're probably already losing.
- 17:19But it's understanding that long term strategy and it's being
- 17:21able to react, but that it's very hard at the moment when
- 17:26you're being presented lots of flashy options.
- 17:30Dare I say that 2 letters that everybody's, we're an
- 17:34interesting bell curve at the moment.
- 17:35I think every product manager in the world has gone bonkers in
- 17:38the last three months and said we've got to include AI within
- 17:43our product. And if we don't, you know, it's
- 17:45we're losing. But I think it's an interesting
- 17:48discussion because it's, if we go back to the naughties, we
- 17:52were talking about personalisation.
- 17:56We're now in 2025, the back end of 2025, we're still talking
- 18:00about personalisation. I think AI is incredibly
- 18:03important, but it's just being LED as a solution for all now.
- 18:07And I think that's that distraction from your strategy,
- 18:10that shining new thing. And I'm not beating up anyone in
- 18:14the e-commerce field. People are really struggling now
- 18:17and they're finding it harder than ever.
- 18:19And you know, if you're, if you look at LinkedIn, you could be
- 18:23swayed by your opinion hourly on what the right route to do.
- 18:28And I think there's a lot of people out there who are
- 18:30confused right now. And I think there's, you know,
- 18:33with your sessions with Paul, when you're talking about the
- 18:35landscape and you're talking about the amount of re
- 18:38platforms, you know, if I go back to the old name of inside
- 18:43commerce, you know, it shows that there used to be a lot more
- 18:46re platforms happening. There's not so many at the
- 18:49moment. And I think that adds that's
- 18:51it's proof that there's confusion.
- 18:53People are very are having a torrid time.
- 18:56I'm not saying it's disastrous, but it is challenging.
- 19:00The old methods aren't working as good as they used to.
- 19:03We can't just throw more money at the wall and expect it to
- 19:06rebound like things used to. But I think that confusion of
- 19:12what directions are going, what technology to use, the belief in
- 19:17this platform will solve everything.
- 19:20And, you know, again, going back to one of your key monikers,
- 19:24that technical evangelism of this platform will solve all
- 19:29your woes. If you join us, everything will
- 19:31be better. You know, when you look up the
- 19:35chain of command, it's very easy to see why senior execs or
- 19:39company owners might go, actually, yeah, I see all my
- 19:42peers on that platform or using this system or whatever.
- 19:46That is our goal. That's what we'll use where it
- 19:49might not be and you might, you might actually not see that
- 19:53immediate impact when you go live.
- 19:56It might take you another 12 to 18 months to propagate that kind
- 19:59of revenue expectation you were looking for and can how can you
- 20:03survive within that period long winded way.
- 20:08But to answer your question, but I do think one of the the the
- 20:12key challenges right now is confusion on which route to go.
- 20:16Because those those tried and tested methods are proving not
- 20:20to work as they once did. Yeah, the, the biggest change
- 20:25for me is the, as much as I hate the terminology sometimes
- 20:29because it gets, it gets misused, but composability in
- 20:34commerce is completely the right strategic direction because it's
- 20:37about building flexibility into ecosystems so that you're not
- 20:43wedded one system to another, so that if you need to change one
- 20:46part of the stack, you don't have to redevelop everything,
- 20:49every interface, every API that that to me is that's the
- 20:53evolution we're in now, right? Where some are further ahead on
- 20:57that. They've gone for a big
- 20:58investment and they've like literally done a big lift and
- 21:01shift and they've rebuilt entire systems, landscapes versus
- 21:04others who have bought into one part of it.
- 21:08Maybe they put in a, a Shopify or a big commerce, whatever it
- 21:10might be a centre. You pick your platform that's
- 21:12got a good open API and they're in phase one of their evolution.
- 21:16But, but yeah, the, the point you make is really salient,
- 21:19which is that when you move in your core e-commerce platform,
- 21:24you will fix some problems, you will introduce some benefits and
- 21:27improvements and, and often agility.
- 21:29But you will definitely find compromises and you'll
- 21:31definitely find unforeseen issues that even the smartest
- 21:35agencies, consultants, ecom leads don't know about.
- 21:39Because every project is unique. And I've every project I've been
- 21:42on, there will be an unknown unknown that hits in at some
- 21:45point. And the impact of it is small,
- 21:48medium, high, depending on where in the in the like operational
- 21:52processes it sits. You're absolutely right.
- 21:55And I, and I think that I've always said, I don't know if
- 22:01you've had this or like, if, if I have to explain to my mum what
- 22:04I do, she just smiles at me. And, and when I say e-commerce,
- 22:09it's interesting now because e-commerce is such a very title
- 22:14and it means many things to many different people.
- 22:16But I think one of the ways I've been able to translate my role
- 22:21is that I'm all about shifting pain.
- 22:24And I think it's key to what we do is once you grow another
- 22:28area, once you fix an area in one, a problem in or challenge
- 22:32in one area, you are shifting that pain onto another system
- 22:36onto another department. And I think that's why I've
- 22:39always said that the three pillars of what I believe
- 22:42e-commerce is about is technical, commercial and
- 22:45operational. And if you look that it imagine
- 22:49a Venn diagram and then you're seeing that revolving circle.
- 22:53If you are growing, if you are, you are putting pain onto those,
- 22:57each of those three areas and you look at the key systems that
- 22:59revolve around those areas. And I think that's what makes me
- 23:03quite excited. It's OK.
- 23:06I understand is if I do something good here, I'm going
- 23:10to have to impact in these areas.
- 23:11I'm going to have to budget for these areas, whether that be
- 23:14people, process systems and it's a it's a revolving circle.
- 23:18And I think that's helped me immensely when looking at like
- 23:24launching in different countries because like, OK, you know, you
- 23:28really have to look at that knock on impact.
- 23:30And as simple as I can put it is how much pain am I going to give
- 23:35to the next person once I make this change?
- 23:39Yeah, I like that. It's always, that's always a
- 23:41good one, isn't it? What problems am I going to
- 23:44cause and how do I manage around that?
- 23:46But how do you, I have interest, how do you make sense of the
- 23:50tech? This you, you touched on AI just
- 23:52a minute ago and we're going to come back to it in a minute
- 23:55about your adoption of the university law.
- 23:57But like tech they, I mean, God, the fragmentation of the tech
- 24:00space is insane. Like the number of thousands of
- 24:02thousands of technology options of e-commerce platforms,
- 24:05specialist apps, like all in one platforms.
- 24:08There's so much out there. And I know you listen to the
- 24:11podcast. So thank, thank you for doing
- 24:13that. And there will be, there are
- 24:14lots of other amazing podcasts out there.
- 24:16But how do you make sense? Like what are your go to sources
- 24:18of information that you think are credible and give you
- 24:21practical advice on what texts good for what?
- 24:24I think the network is is above all and I think, I think I, like
- 24:31many people, have made the mistake of when you get into
- 24:35LinkedIn, it's all a vanity bubble of how many connections
- 24:38you can get. And then you realise why am I,
- 24:41why is this person in my feed and why am I trying to?
- 24:44It's another inspirational leadership quote that how much
- 24:48is that giving to me? So I have done the sifting of
- 24:53who I follow on LinkedIn to see real guidance.
- 24:57I do find white papers quite a challenge because they're,
- 25:01they're coming out thick and fast.
- 25:02You can have three or four in your inbox in a day.
- 25:05And when you look at that white paper, it can be 20-30 pages
- 25:09long. I can say, I can say ebooks are
- 25:11no, no, not ebooks. You know, any, any of the, the
- 25:14big sort of books that are, are produced are they look great.
- 25:19But then to find the time to sit down and really, you know,
- 25:24really invest in that that content personally, I find quite
- 25:28challenging. So This is why I really do tune
- 25:32into a lot of e-commerce podcast.
- 25:34I think Chloe does an amazing job.
- 25:38She has nicknamed me the what was it?
- 25:42She called me again, the podcast connoisseur.
- 25:48But I, I just think they're, they're, they're invaluable.
- 25:50The information, what I find very good about yourselves,
- 25:54Chloe, is it's real world people talking about real world
- 25:58solutions. It's not a forced demo that's
- 26:02being sponsored and has some commercial expectations at the
- 26:06end of it. It's really this is some of the
- 26:10is it the the chat from Matalan? I I think you've had him on
- 26:14twice. He like both of those sessions
- 26:18were just this is real pain within my industry being bled
- 26:24out and actually this is our problem.
- 26:26This is what we tried. It worked for X amount of time.
- 26:29We came back to the drawing board, We tried again, different
- 26:33approach. And I think those are the sort
- 26:36of sources that I I really gravitate to because they're
- 26:41speaking my language. It's almost like I don't care
- 26:45about the systems used. I don't care.
- 26:48I actually want to see what is the problem and how you how you
- 26:51look to how the what is the It's like see if my mate mate says to
- 26:56me, oh, I just drove this new Audi.
- 26:58I respect his opinion more than I do of the big, you know, car
- 27:03reviews because he can give me a real world view of what it's
- 27:07like actually sitting in the traffic going to Exeter in the
- 27:10morning rather than hooning it around a track or around the
- 27:14Italian mountains. Because that's not the life
- 27:17unfortunately I live. And I think similarly, when I
- 27:20can hear from real world use cases and I think it's something
- 27:24that you and Chloe do incredibly well.
- 27:30Of course there is across the pond I do have an interest in.
- 27:35I think it's one of the interesting things I've never
- 27:38launched within the US and it's one of my, I've done APAC, I've
- 27:45done Europe, but never hit the US market.
- 27:48And I think, you know, the likes of Rick Watson and Vinny O'Brien
- 27:52are incredible resources just because I'm a bit of an
- 27:56e-commerce geek and I like to know what's going on over the
- 27:59pond. And Vinny comes very much from
- 28:02a, an eBay and marketplace background, but they're sort of
- 28:06news hot topics that are going on, who's buying who, who's
- 28:11investing and who, which is a general interest of mine.
- 28:16But I'd say my main sources are you, the people that you bring
- 28:20in, and also Chloe and the guests that she has on.
- 28:23Yeah, there's nothing like hearing of how people have done
- 28:26something and what the bits I love is like what was the
- 28:29challenge and what went wrong? How how did you handle it?
- 28:31Because we all know it. Like when you work with
- 28:33technology and people, it's it's flawed.
- 28:35We're all flawed and and nothing's perfect.
- 28:37And that's great. And trying to pretend
- 28:39everything's perfect is not sensible or or productive.
- 28:42But Conor Lee's room's the next question, which is let's flip to
- 28:46to your current role. Like university typically have
- 28:49old legacy tech stacks and how are you've come in?
- 28:53You're you're heading up E com at a time when there's like
- 28:56great modernisation of technology happening and the
- 28:58pace of change is is exponential.
- 29:01How are you tackling modernisation?
- 29:03Because you're going into a legacy stack and just going
- 29:05right, we're going to RIP all up is just not feasible or
- 29:07practical. We both know it.
- 29:08It takes a much more nuanced approach.
- 29:12And I think so, you know, the University of Law with nearly
- 29:17like 2000 people across several campuses.
- 29:21We have a lot of sister companies as well that operate
- 29:25under our banner. And we are behest to a big
- 29:29holding company as well, which adds its own pressures.
- 29:33But you're right. I, I think if you look at
- 29:36martech on its own, then I'd say when I joined, you know, the,
- 29:43we'd signed up Adobe commerce. It was the first step to
- 29:50dismantling that sort of big monolith and and taking sort of
- 29:55moving to a more of a cloud infrastructure for martech
- 29:58systems alone outside of the university, you know, main
- 30:04monolith architecture. And again, as I said earlier, if
- 30:06you think of us as a brand manufacturer in the way we've
- 30:09grown and through acquisition, you know, again, you're
- 30:13absolutely right, lots of legacy systems, but you think just the
- 30:16systems to, because you know, even though I said that we're
- 30:20not classed as a traditional university, we do have to report
- 30:24back to the government. We do have to report on how
- 30:27students are doing, where they are at any one time, especially
- 30:31if they're on national visa sponsorship.
- 30:34So if you think of those systems and our own internal IT team,
- 30:38which is substantial, but you know, it's whether it's ERP,
- 30:44student information, the actual platforms that students access
- 30:49for library for actually taking the course, for engaging on the
- 30:53online campus for to actually gaining access to the specific
- 30:59rooms that they have to within each campus that we have.
- 31:02It is I'm, I'm fortunate that I don't have responsibility for
- 31:07all that, but there there is a process of decoupling us from,
- 31:12you know, the whole martech infrastructure, which is slow,
- 31:15but I think slow on purpose. I'm, I'm, yeah, I, I think it's,
- 31:22you know, with the amount of data that we're funding from
- 31:25anyone point, if you think of the engagement points that a
- 31:30student might have, whether we meet them at a show or they come
- 31:33to a webinar or they go onto the site, or whether they come back
- 31:37to another more personal webinar, it's a one to one or
- 31:40it's a phone call. You know, when you're looking to
- 31:43take a master's degree, it's, you know, it's not like you're
- 31:47deciding to well, I'll spend that money tomorrow.
- 31:50And then, you know, it's all the, it's how you gain access to
- 31:54the application fortunately within the e-commerce and what,
- 31:57what I'm responsible for, which is probably about four, 5% of
- 32:01the university's overall product catalog.
- 32:07There's the, it's a much simplified journey, but still
- 32:10the, the multiple touch points are there.
- 32:12So I think right now, if I, if I give you an example, yes, we're,
- 32:17we're, we're looking at connecting that entire R tech
- 32:20infrastructure. But right now one of the biggest
- 32:23projects that we're undertaking in the university with is
- 32:26deploying a new ERP. And, and we're trying to do that
- 32:30within, in under 2 years, which is in itself optimistic.
- 32:37But I think we're, the plan go live date is February next year.
- 32:41So it might be actually 28 months instead of 24 months, but
- 32:47that's actually resolving over 60 disparate systems into two
- 32:52platforms. And and that is a huge, a huge
- 32:58process to be involved with. And it's, it's becoming, it's
- 33:03even how we how we. So a lot of the systems that,
- 33:08for example, when a student books on the e-commerce side
- 33:12that is then I'm not calling it an absolute dumb client, but
- 33:17then we do that hand off to those internal systems that will
- 33:20look at OK, how do we prove this person's identity, especially if
- 33:25they're international? How do we we have an online
- 33:28enrolment form? And again, that pain process and
- 33:33how that gets updated and how we're going to better that whole
- 33:37process was taking over 60 systems into two is being a
- 33:42fascinating news. And I'm just, yeah, it I can
- 33:45stick in my e-commerce bubble and be very happy playing in the
- 33:48martech space. But when you move into this
- 33:50larger infrastructure, I can only just sit back and admire
- 33:54and sort of have that classic Wow face because it becomes
- 33:59incredibly sophisticated. Yeah, that's really, I mean,
- 34:04it's the ERP, but it's the fundamental decisions.
- 34:07And it to be honest, 24 months to 28 is good for an ERP
- 34:10because, oh, it's phenomenal. I've seen projects shift by 18
- 34:14months. I've even seen somebody walk
- 34:16away for a project after after 12 months because they feel like
- 34:20it's not going to. But.
- 34:23Now looking at the more the more modern parts of the tech stack
- 34:26and you touched upon AI earlier and then right, the industry's
- 34:29obsessed and there's a lot of evangelism out there about how
- 34:32if you don't become an AI driven business in the next few months,
- 34:35you're going to be obsolete, which is utter nonsense.
- 34:38So not looking at what other vendors are doing with AI that
- 34:41you might be investing in in their platforms, but what is
- 34:44your approach to adoption of AI internally is in tools you might
- 34:47use in your team for like productivity and efficiency?
- 34:51So there's two sides of this really, isn't there?
- 34:52There's, I mean, look, I find AI fascinating.
- 34:56I really do. I think I've gone from being
- 35:01fearful to being, I guess it, it, if I, I would say I honestly
- 35:08use AI maybe 4-4 out of five days a week.
- 35:14And that can come from very different reasoning.
- 35:18So if I look at how we're using it, we had, we're a Microsoft
- 35:23company. So we get copilot out the box,
- 35:26which is effectively an older version of ChatGPT.
- 35:30So that that's great for I've got to say when, when you're
- 35:34facing a ridiculous inbox after a week away and you can just use
- 35:38copilot to identify those quick answer emails.
- 35:41And and also if how you can use it to summarise long chains, I
- 35:48cannot tell you, you know, we're still live in a world where
- 35:50everybody wants to CC everyone else.
- 35:53And then once you get, you get it copied in on a 20 stage
- 35:58e-mail. I'm pleased to summarise this
- 36:01for me. It's fantastic.
- 36:02So I think for convenience, for catching up, I think, you know,
- 36:07I personally use ChatGPT paid version, which again, if I'm
- 36:13looking at AI as a supporting tool to help me do research, to
- 36:21help me even build like job descriptions.
- 36:24I've used it for SEO text. I've helped it produce new
- 36:29product page content. And I think I've actually, I'm
- 36:34doing presentation next week with Adobe and being able to
- 36:41create a presentation quite quickly, build a structure and
- 36:48but more importantly, not rely on our internal design team to
- 36:54make me some silly images, you know, or, or just edit some
- 36:59basic images that are good enough for a PowerPoint
- 37:01presentation. And is, is a major win.
- 37:05I, I don't, I think, I think people are getting confused at
- 37:08the moment because they're saying, oh, it's just going to
- 37:10take away all of this work. I think if that's a company's
- 37:16way of thinking, they're going to fail pretty quickly.
- 37:18And they, I read some statement, I think it was Brent is saying
- 37:23like, and one of these big AI companies that I actually do
- 37:26training with, they're saying like 87% of all AI initiatives
- 37:30currently fail. And I think because they're
- 37:32trying to do adoption at mass, they're trying, they are
- 37:35drinking the kool-aid. They're saying, OK, I can just
- 37:38replace an entire operation. No, it can support and speed up
- 37:44and probably supplement again. If I don't have to tie up
- 37:48someone within our design team to make me a graphic, I can
- 37:52actually do a basic graphic that my small brain can actually
- 37:55conjure up in my mind. That's good enough for me, but I
- 37:59don't have to then go into a process of booking that in and
- 38:01taking an hour of someone's time.
- 38:04I think that's fantastic. And I think those those general
- 38:10tasks to help me work quicker and not rely as much on other
- 38:15agencies. Great.
- 38:16But then if we look at the flip side, we've been using AI for
- 38:20quite some time and we've used AI within, you know, to replace,
- 38:28you know, purpose built integrations.
- 38:31So for example, the way our finance team look at daily
- 38:35reports, we have a bot that actually looks at a bot, a daily
- 38:41reconciliation export that can actually pick and map those
- 38:47details from a customer and apply it to our finance system.
- 38:51So rather than having to pay people to sit there and copy and
- 38:55paste out of a daily reconciliation sheet, we just
- 38:58have bots running it. And also we haven't had to then
- 39:01build some, you know, very expensive and labouring
- 39:06integration for such a simple process.
- 39:09So that for me, I, I see those sort of things invaluable and I
- 39:14think there's going to be better.
- 39:15But I still think AI in itself is very has to be seen as a
- 39:20supporting matrix. It is there to help you.
- 39:25But again, I saw something the other day they were saying the,
- 39:30I don't know if it's a LinkedIn naysayer, but there is they,
- 39:34they evaluated people using AI in like, I don't know if it was
- 39:38FTSE 100 or the, OR the big U.S. companies, but they're saying
- 39:43even though people felt they were more productive, it was
- 39:47actually slowing them down because they were having to
- 39:50review the output of AI in much more granularity because they
- 39:55knew they couldn't trust the output without human
- 39:58intervention. And I think, you know, again, we
- 40:01are the world of product marketeers and platforms that
- 40:05their job is to sell you a service.
- 40:08So make it look more attractive. And I think that's where we are
- 40:11on the bell curve that everybody has to be flashing and talking
- 40:14about it. But once you actually get over
- 40:17the fear of using it. Because that's to believe there
- 40:20is a lot of fear out there and there are a lot of fear mongers
- 40:22on LinkedIn itself. But when you see the value and
- 40:27how it can be applied in your day-to-day, it can take a lot of
- 40:30the mundane tasks and deal with them quite quickly or it can
- 40:34speed up. But yeah, I I think it's, it's
- 40:37one to watch, but it, it's not taking all our jobs as of
- 40:41tomorrow. And that's before you even talk
- 40:45to me about Agentic. There there's an interesting
- 40:48report from from the US, I'm trying to remember which big
- 40:51consultancy did it. And it was looking at what's the
- 40:54likely impact on the US labour force in the short, medium and
- 40:58long term of AI. Because there there is all this
- 41:01paranoia about we're going to lose loads and loads of jobs and
- 41:06a is can take over and inevitably some jobs will go,
- 41:10some job roles will go. But they, they estimated short
- 41:13term, which is in the next couple of years, and the medium
- 41:16term, which is around 5 to 10 years and long term 10 years.
- 41:20Plus. There's a, there'd be a initial
- 41:23impact, maybe 6% of the workforce where job roles would
- 41:27be replaced. But actually in the long term it
- 41:29would be, I think it's around 1, less than 1% long term loss
- 41:34because of AI, because actually roles are being repurposed.
- 41:38So what what we're going to do is there's going to be people
- 41:41are going to need to learn AI skills and people are going to
- 41:44need, there's going to be more strategic roles, more thought
- 41:47laced roles and more oversilent roles rather than doing roles.
- 41:51Yeah, no, 100% agree. And I mean, that's definitely
- 41:56the conversations I have with people about is, but that the
- 41:59most important thing is you've got to have a strategy and
- 42:01approach to AI rather than just we're going to use it or not use
- 42:05it. But what why?
- 42:05What is the reason around it? And, and how are you going to
- 42:08put governance into it? Because AI tools can depend on
- 42:11how you're using consume personal data and therefore
- 42:14you've got compliance implications.
- 42:15And somebody's got to have a handle on this so that you don't
- 42:18get this Wild West where hundreds of people in the
- 42:20business are all using lots of different AI tools without any
- 42:23coordination or control. And I, and I think you're,
- 42:26you're 100% right again this morning, quite it's kind of
- 42:30poignant. We our head of AI internally,
- 42:35we're, we're looking to, we're, we're actually trialling a on I
- 42:41don't want to a closed model that does not look for any
- 42:46external references, but it is only being trained on University
- 42:50of law data. Now the, the first step of that,
- 42:54as as infantile as it might sound, is creating an
- 43:00interactive intranet. So all of our policies across
- 43:04all of our departments, everything goes into one system
- 43:09and can be, you can actually engage with it as a chat bot.
- 43:13So it's a central source of truth, but it's for all of those
- 43:17items that are purely for staff. So how many, how many billions
- 43:22have gone into complex intranets that no one ever looks at?
- 43:26But actually, if we can put it in an engaging way and I can
- 43:29actually say what is the University of Law's stature on
- 43:34maternity pay? What, what is the terms and
- 43:36conditions? How do I, how can I interpret
- 43:38these long documents about our terms and conditions?
- 43:42Actually, I can engage in a chat form and probably that evolved
- 43:46to a speech form that. And so that that again, it's,
- 43:49it's, it's early doors and it is very infertile.
- 43:53And I don't mean that in a derogatory way, but it's like,
- 43:55OK, that's actually a real good use of people's time because you
- 43:58can think of all of the content that is being put into a company
- 44:01intranet that people don't really engage with.
- 44:03So when you're on boarding new people, it's it's fantastic.
- 44:08And I think slowly but surely you'll see things like that,
- 44:12like evolve and then you could actually expand that to students
- 44:17accessing it. So OK, what are the terms and,
- 44:20and policies that are pertinent to me as a student?
- 44:23How can I access that quickly rather than go at scrolling
- 44:26through millions of sub menus? And can I actually, if you think
- 44:30of international students, how can I interpret, you know, what
- 44:34is effectively a legal document in ways that I can understand?
- 44:39And I think again, that's, that's a very good use of AI.
- 44:43The the the you could you can adopt very quickly, but
- 44:47understand the value in it. Yeah, I I think that's a nice
- 44:51way of framing the internal use. I mean, honestly, there's a lot
- 44:54of the E com business I'm working with a tool in to help
- 44:57people be more productive. And yeah, same principle as
- 45:01customer service agents that are automating inquiries and
- 45:05customers. Why wouldn't you do that
- 45:06internally? But let's kind of like a final,
- 45:09final question I've got for you, which is like the like where
- 45:12you're where you're headed, because we talked about the fact
- 45:15there's so much tech and that there are challenges in term
- 45:18determined like tech stacks and road maps.
- 45:21How do you how do you manage a road map?
- 45:22What does it look like? Like what are the areas that are
- 45:24of most importance? You, you talked about the ERP
- 45:26project logs and automation, but what are the areas where you're
- 45:30going to be really pushing on from a technology point?
- 45:33So I think as much as as cheesiest as might sound, but
- 45:38unification of Martech infrastructure is, is incredibly
- 45:43important. If you think of we have our core
- 45:46site, we have multiple core sites for our sister products
- 45:49that all feed into each other. We have the CRM, we have all our
- 45:53social media channels and if you think those extend into student
- 45:58specific chat boards that are very important to us.
- 46:03And then you think of all of those student touch points.
- 46:07Again, understanding the journey of you know, what cohort,
- 46:11whether you're undergraduate, postgraduate, whether you're a
- 46:13business professional, how do you want to engage not only in
- 46:17comms, but you know, face to face?
- 46:20Do you prefer online? Do you like our in London
- 46:24campuses? Would you like, prefer to go
- 46:25out? What it would you know, all of
- 46:27those those touch points are incredibly important to us to
- 46:30understand. OK, we have a immense amount of
- 46:34data that we can present to you, but how do we present it in the
- 46:37right way? So you're getting what you need
- 46:39to answer the questions to to make such a you remember, it's
- 46:43always a big emotional investment in everything we do,
- 46:45which is why I come back to us almost being a brand
- 46:48manufacturer. It's that same sort of
- 46:50engagement. But for me personally in the
- 46:54ecom world, you know, we went through a big re platforming
- 46:58well. So re platform, we re platformed
- 47:01the front end. We you know, I came in, we we
- 47:04were very much in a proof of concept mode.
- 47:06We learned a lot. We then moved to a Hoover front
- 47:11end, which has been a dramatic improvement for us.
- 47:15Not only is it visually moving on from a proof of concept to
- 47:19something that more represents our brand, but it's given us a
- 47:25new foundation to sort of say, OK, we are dealing with students
- 47:29now and it it's very much a singular student concept.
- 47:33But then we are also engaging very much B to B.
- 47:37And that could be from small 2, three person legal outfits in
- 47:43Exeter or it could be internal legal departments at some of the
- 47:47biggest companies across the world.
- 47:49And I think where we're going to be evolving in the future is
- 47:53very much moving into the next stage.
- 47:56Probably next year will be the beginnings of our B2B ecommerce
- 47:59operations because, yeah, it's we're trying to amalgamate a lot
- 48:04of our our disparate silos of companies that we've acquired
- 48:10over the years and they haven't yet been bought into the fold.
- 48:14But yeah, I, I think B to B is one of the biggest areas that
- 48:18we're focusing on because we can we see that demand right now for
- 48:23example, you know, just something simple as a payment
- 48:25method of OK, we define them as firm sponsored.
- 48:29So a student comes to us and said, OK, my company wants to
- 48:33pay that for me invest in my future, but they don't want to
- 48:36use a credit card. Absolutely.
- 48:38But we'd actually have to build that into our our checkout
- 48:42method. How do we check the firms real?
- 48:44How do we know they're that registered?
- 48:46How do we know you know? And also I think the future of
- 48:50our e-commerce operation is not only to simplify things for
- 48:53students, but also to feed the engine of University of Law.
- 48:58Because you might be starting as something simple right now and
- 49:02you might might be undergraduate, but we'd like to
- 49:05cultivate you, your career with you when you feel ready and also
- 49:10market to you at those particular times.
- 49:12So when you're seeing where students are in their journey,
- 49:15we and especially whether they're just rocking up to us
- 49:18and doing it at their own their own pocket or we have larger
- 49:22firms engaging with us. There's a great cultivation
- 49:26engine there for the larger organization that can work in in
- 49:29tandem with student wishes and where they want to take their
- 49:32career. So just a few small things to
- 49:35work on then. Yeah, I wanted to.
- 49:37I, I hope they'll keep me around for a while.
- 49:39But I think I think it's for someone that has never put their
- 49:43toes in education and I still don't fully understand it.
- 49:47But one of my biggest fears and probably one of my biggest
- 49:50learnings is, you know, I've worked, I've worked across a
- 49:54multitude of industries. And I think, you know, you'll
- 49:57echo this, working with a multitude of clients.
- 50:00You don't just stick with beauty.
- 50:01I've seen your portfolio and it's as diverse as any, but you
- 50:06can apply those fundamentals of e-commerce and you don't
- 50:12necessarily have to understand the concept of the brand because
- 50:16there are, there are so many tangibles that are equal from
- 50:20brand to brand to brand. And I think that's why I've been
- 50:23able to apply here. I think one of the things I'll
- 50:26leave you with this, when I joined our star marketing
- 50:29director, I said, are we seasonal?
- 50:31And he went no. And then I looked at the, the,
- 50:34the how we are and we're very much, again, if you think of us
- 50:38as a luxury brand manufacturer and we have a spring, summer and
- 50:42an autumn winter and an autumn winter is always our biggest
- 50:44intake. And you know, our Black Friday
- 50:48is clearing. So if you think of that, I, I've
- 50:51always looked at, you know, what are people doing?
- 50:54Why would they come to us? Why are we going to have our low
- 50:58points? And I think everybody's seasonal
- 51:01and I think that's, that's one of the things I just keep coming
- 51:04to the fact that we are very, there are so many commonalities
- 51:10between the brands that I've worked with that it's allowed me
- 51:13to migrate very easily. But get quickly up to date on
- 51:17the product and the wise. But the same technological
- 51:21fundamentals apply irrespective. Yeah, the importance of politely
- 51:26challenging preconceived notions, I think when you come
- 51:28in is, is is essential. I've really enjoyed it.
- 51:31And as you said, the stock chats at 3 hours on this stuff quite
- 51:34happily. But for those listening, if
- 51:37anyone, anyone who's working in ecom wants to reach out, wants
- 51:40to like check on a few more things or exchange visually, I
- 51:43know you always have yourself at ecom.
- 51:45What's the best way to contact you?
- 51:47Yeah, by LinkedIn as always. I'm not one of those guys that
- 51:51puts myself out there. I just I'm happy to chime in and
- 51:56especially if there's something I'm passionate about.
- 51:58But if you ever want to grab a coffee or just say hello,
- 52:03Linkedin's always best. Or if any of you are going to
- 52:07this big e-commerce show in a couple of weeks in London, I'll
- 52:10be there. But please, no salespeople.
- 52:15Yeah, there you go, nice and clear.
- 52:16I'll leave for those of you listening on our landing page on
- 52:19the website you can there's a link to Edward's LinkedIn
- 52:22profile as well. Edward really really glad we had
- 52:26did we set up this session, really enjoyed it and it's great
- 52:29to hear we have the next stage in your E com journey.
- 52:33I'll be excited if we can come back for a Part 2 for our B to B
- 52:36journey. Oh, interested.
- 52:37There we go. He's teasing people for the
- 52:40future. All right, well look, lovely to
- 52:42chat. As always, thanks to everybody
- 52:43for listening. Hope you've enjoyed it as much.
- 52:45So I have and have a great day Edward.
- 52:47And you, Jones, take care. You're listening to the Inside
- 52:51Commerce podcast, hosted by experienced consultants James
- 52:54Gert and Paul Rogers. Inside Commerce is your fast
- 52:57track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 52:59leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 53:02C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 53:05strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 53:07Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 53:10advice based on the experience to help fine tune your ecom
- 53:13strategy and tech stack. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 53:17out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 53:19project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 53:21episode.