Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Buy and Hold Is a Trap?
Transcript
- 0:00All right, here's a thought. It might even get us kicked out
- 0:02of a traditional finance seminar.
- 0:04Oh, I like where this is going. You know the absolute golden
- 0:07rule of investing? The one everyone from your
- 0:09grandfather to your bank manager you know swears by?
- 0:12Buy and hold forever. It's the first commandment of
- 0:14the market for sure, right? But what if?
- 0:17What if that commandment is actually a trap?
- 0:20It's a provocative idea. I mean, it goes against
- 0:23everything we're taught totally. But if you look at the actual
- 0:25mechanics of how money moves, not what people say but what
- 0:31they do, questioning buy and hold is probably the first step
- 0:35to actually keeping your wealth. That's exactly what we're
- 0:37digging into today. We're looking at some really
- 0:39challenging insights from a source called Mr. Brain that
- 0:43just completely dismantles this almost religious devotion to
- 0:47holding stocks forever. We're going to look at why never
- 0:50sell is, well, a dangerous myth, why dollar cost averaging can
- 0:54sometimes be financial suicide, and why the financial elites
- 0:58preach patients while they are frantically hitting the sell
- 1:01button. And this isn't just about trying
- 1:04to time the market, which, you know, we all know is hard.
- 1:07This is about understanding the incentives of the food chain,
- 1:09right? We need to talk about why the
- 1:11experts go silent right when you should be selling the
- 1:14psychological tricks that keep us all trapped and losing
- 1:17positions. And and ultimately we we need to
- 1:20build a framework for knowing when did you say enough is
- 1:23enough and walk away. But before we get to the exit
- 1:25strategy, you need a thermometer.
- 1:27You really do. You need to know if the room is
- 1:29on fire before you run for the door.
- 1:31That's a great way to put it. Knowing when the market is
- 1:33overheating is just crucial for these decisions.
- 1:37So to track total market temperature, welcome to search
- 1:41and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 1:46It's a great tool. It really helps keep you
- 1:48grounded when everyone else is getting, you know, euphoric.
- 1:51Absolutely. And for our listeners tuning in
- 1:53who want that bilingual edge, hit a Apple Store, Apple Store
- 1:59Joe Buffett indicator. So let's get into the meat of
- 2:03this Why is buy and hold the only message we ever seem to
- 2:07hear? Yeah, let's start with what the
- 2:09source calls a conspiracy of silence.
- 2:12It sounds a bit ominous. It does.
- 2:14It argues the financial industry is essentially this closed
- 2:19ecosystem and interest community.
- 2:22But that sounds a little polite to me.
- 2:23It's more like a feeding through, isn't it?
- 2:25I'd call it the financial food chain.
- 2:27You've got the investment banks, the mutual funds, the exchanges,
- 2:30the brokerages. They all look different, but
- 2:33they all eat the same thing. Fees, fees, management fees,
- 2:37trading commissions, you name it.
- 2:39And most of those fees are based on assets under management AUM,
- 2:43right? Their entire business model
- 2:45relies on your money staying inside the casino.
- 2:48OK, hold on. Let me play devil's advocate for
- 2:50a second. Is this really a conspiracy or
- 2:53is it just that these funds, you know, believe in their product?
- 2:56I mean, telling people to stay invested is generally good
- 2:59advice historically, isn't it? It is.
- 3:01It feels a bit cynical to say they just want our fees.
- 3:03It is cynical, but look at the incentives.
- 3:06What happens if a big fund manager goes on TV and says look
- 3:09the market is way overheated, everyone should sell and just
- 3:12sit in cash for six months? What happens to his business?
- 3:15His investors pull their money out instantly.
- 3:19And he loses his management fee. He starves.
- 3:22The whole industry can't survive a mass exit to cash, so that
- 3:27narrative, the long term holding story, it isn't just investment
- 3:30advice. It's a survival mechanism for
- 3:32them. Exactly, they need the table
- 3:34full of chips just to keep the game running.
- 3:36So even if they know a crash is coming, they can't.
- 3:38They can't really tell you to leave.
- 3:40They can't, and that leads to the darker side of this whole
- 3:42equation, the liquidity trap. The source makes a really brutal
- 3:46point here. Never sell is a sermon preached
- 3:50to retail investors. The sheep to make sure there's
- 3:53someone to buy when the smart money needs to get out.
- 3:56This part this part really stuck with me.
- 3:57The source brought up a story about Warren Buffett that I
- 3:59honestly had never heard before. It's about his exit from
- 4:02PetroChina back in 2007. Oh, this is a classic heist
- 4:06movie moment in finance. It illustrates the problem
- 4:08perfectly. OK, so Buffett wanted to sell
- 4:11his massive stake in PetroChina. He knew the price was too high,
- 4:15but he had a huge problem. He was just too big.
- 4:18If he hits cell on his computer, the market sees that huge volume
- 4:22and. It panics, yes.
- 4:24Instantly the price crashes and he completely destroys his own
- 4:27exit, right? He needed to get out before the
- 4:29market even knew he was leaving. So you know what he did?
- 4:33What? He used?
- 4:34Snail mail. Snail mail no.
- 4:35In 2007, yes. He physically mailed his
- 4:39disclosure documents to the Hong Kong exchange.
- 4:42He knew that the mail would take a few days to get from the US to
- 4:45Hong Kong. Wow, that is.
- 4:47Devious. It's brilliant.
- 4:49He used that physical time lag to buy himself a window while
- 4:52those letters were sitting in a mailbag somewhere over the
- 4:54acific he was aggressively selling his stock.
- 4:57Oh my God, by the time the letter finally arrived and the
- 4:59public found out Buffett is selling, it was already gone.
- 5:02So while all the retail investors were reading reports
- 5:05about holding for the long term, Buffett was using the Postal
- 5:09Service to front. Run them.
- 5:11It highlights the harsh reality of liquidity.
- 5:13You can't sell if there's no one to buy.
- 5:16If the elites want to escape, they need the public to be
- 5:18buying. And the buy and hold story keeps
- 5:20them buying. It ensures the liquidity is
- 5:22there for them. That makes me feel a little less
- 5:25like a disciplined investor and a little more like the bag
- 5:28holder. But surely the analysts, the
- 5:31pundits on TV, someone sees a crash coming.
- 5:34Why doesn't anyone warn us? Well, this brings us to the
- 5:37asymmetry of reputation. Imagine you're a famous analyst,
- 5:41right? OK, if you predict a boom, you
- 5:43say the markets going to the moon and you're wrong.
- 5:46What happens? People lose money, but everyone
- 5:48was optimistic. It's forgivable.
- 5:50Exactly. Optimism is socially acceptable,
- 5:52but what if you predict a crash if you're the bear?
- 5:56You're the party pooper. It's worse than that.
- 5:59If you predict a crash and you're wrong, you are mocked.
- 6:03I mean, look at how people treated Buffett when he
- 6:05avoidedthe.com bubble or Bitcoin.
- 6:08They called him a dinosaur. They laughed at him.
- 6:10That's true. Now here's the kicker.
- 6:12If you predict a crash, and you're right, you get blamed for
- 6:18ruining the party, you become the villain who talked down the
- 6:21market. So you literally can't win.
- 6:23You can't. So the rational choice for a
- 6:25public figure for their career is to stay optimistically vague.
- 6:30You hear things like Howard Marks saying nobody knows.
- 6:34It's just safer for your reputation to be wrong with the
- 6:36crowd than to be right all by yourself.
- 6:38That is a fascinating psychological trap for the
- 6:40experts. But let's look at our own
- 6:42psychology. Because even if I know all this,
- 6:45even if I know the game is rigged, I still find it
- 6:47incredibly hard to hit that sell button.
- 6:49That is because your own brain is fighting you.
- 6:51We have to talk about loss aversion.
- 6:53The idea that we hate losing way more than we love winning.
- 6:56Much more. And here's the trick our brains
- 6:59play. As long as you don't sell, that
- 7:01loss feels fake, right? It's just a paper loss.
- 7:05You can look at the screen and just say, oh, it'll come back.
- 7:07Right. I haven't actually lost any
- 7:08money until I sell. I've definitely said that to
- 7:11myself. We all have.
- 7:12But the moment you sell, the pain becomes real.
- 7:15You have to admit failure. So never sell becomes this
- 7:21psychological shield. It protects your ego from
- 7:24admitting you made a mistake. It also feels like there's a bit
- 7:27of an identity crisis involved, like if I buy a stock because I
- 7:30think I'm smart and then it drops 30%.
- 7:33Then you have cognitive dissonance.
- 7:35The reality which is you're losing money conflicts with
- 7:37yourself image which is I am a smart investor.
- 7:41So you rationalize, you pivot, you say, oh, I'm not a trader,
- 7:43I'm a long term investor. You just rebrand being trapped
- 7:46as having a strategy. Oh, that hits a little too close
- 7:49to home. I think we've all done that.
- 7:50I believe in the long term vision of the company usually
- 7:53just means I am down 40% and I'm scared to exit.
- 7:57And the Internet has basically weaponized this.
- 8:01Just look at the whole diamond hands culture.
- 8:03The memes HODL. It's tribalism.
- 8:07In these online communities, selling is framed as a moral
- 8:10failing. It's a betrayal of the tribe.
- 8:13If you sell, you have paper hands.
- 8:15You're weak. It's peer pressure, but for
- 8:18finance. Precisely, it feels safer to
- 8:20lose money with your friends than to make a rational exit
- 8:23alone and risk being kicked out of the group.
- 8:26So we have the industry working against us, and our own brains
- 8:29are working against us. But I want to go back to the
- 8:31logic of buy and hold, because surely over a long enough
- 8:35timeline, the market always goes up.
- 8:37The source calls this the linear history fallacy.
- 8:40This is one of the most dangerous assumptions we make.
- 8:43We assume the stock market is like physics, You know, gravity
- 8:45pulls it down and elasticity brings it back up.
- 8:48But the market isn't physics. It's a political and social
- 8:51construct. And those can break.
- 8:53The source used a pretty chilling example to illustrate
- 8:56this, the Shanghai Stock Exchange.
- 8:58Right pictures Shanghai in the 1940s.
- 9:01It was the Wall Street of the East.
- 9:03Bustling, massive wealth, huge companies.
- 9:07If you were a buy and hold investor there, you felt
- 9:09invincible. And then 1949 happens.
- 9:11The regime change, the exchange closed and it didn't just close
- 9:15for a week, it stayed closed for over 40 years.
- 9:18Oh, so if you held for? Forever.
- 9:20You went to 0. The paper became worthless.
- 9:22When the exchange finally reopened decades later, it was a
- 9:25completely new board. Your old equity was gone.
- 9:28Wow, that's a stark reminder. We get so used to the stability
- 9:33of something like the S and T500 that we forget regimes change,
- 9:36currencies fail and markets can actually just disappear.
- 9:40Exactly. Assuming it always comes back
- 9:42shows a kind of lack of respect for history.
- 9:45Survival is not guaranteed. OK, so we've dismantled the
- 9:47myth. Buy and hold can be a trap.
- 9:50The pros are selling while telling us to hold.
- 9:52Our brains are tricking us. So what do we actually do?
- 9:55We can't just panic sell everything.
- 9:58No, panic is just as bad as blind faith.
- 10:01The source outlines what it calls a rational selling
- 10:04framework. It's basically a synthesis of
- 10:07the actual behavior of guys like Buffett, Munger and Lynch.
- 10:12It's a decision tree. Let's break this down.
- 10:13It starts with a simple question.
- 10:15Has the core logic changed? This is the fundamental check.
- 10:20Why did you buy the stock in the 1st place?
- 10:22Didn't have a Moat? Was the management brilliant?
- 10:25If the Moat dries up, say a competitor releases a better
- 10:28technology, or if the management turns out to be corrupt, you
- 10:33sell. Immediately, so no waiting for
- 10:35it to bounce back. No, hoping hope is not a
- 10:37strategy. If the thesis breaks, the
- 10:39investment breaks, you're done. OK.
- 10:40That's clear. Step 2 deals with the price.
- 10:43Is the valuation extreme? This is where we avoid the
- 10:45bubble trap. Even a great company can be a
- 10:47bad investment if you pay too much for it, right?
- 10:50The source suggests using the PEG ratio price to earnings
- 10:53growth. Can you unpack that for us?
- 10:55What are we looking for there? Sure.
- 10:56You're essentially asking how much am I paying for future
- 10:59growth? If the PE ratio is really high
- 11:03but the growth is low, that PEG number shoots up.
- 11:07If the PEG is widely over, say, 2, or if the valuation has just
- 11:11completely disconnected from reality, you are walking on very
- 11:14thin ice. So if the chart looks like a
- 11:16vertical line, it might be time to trim.
- 11:18You trim or you sell the lock in profits.
- 11:20Like the source says, money is only real when you sell.
- 11:23Until then, it's just digital ink.
- 11:26You don't want to be the person who rides a winner all the way
- 11:28up and then all the way back down again.
- 11:30And the final point in the framework is my favorite because
- 11:32it feels the most empowering opportunity cost.
- 11:35The switch. This is the huge mindset shift.
- 11:38We tend to get married to our stocks totally, but investing is
- 11:41a comparison game. You should always be asking
- 11:43yourself, is my money working as hard as it possibly can right
- 11:46now? So if I'm holding stock A and
- 11:48it's doing OK, but over here stock B is cheaper, safer and
- 11:53growing faster? Than selling stock A to buy
- 11:55stock B isn't giving up. It's an upgrade.
- 11:58You are optimizing your capital. I love that.
- 12:01The Never Sell crowd views selling as a failure, but a
- 12:05rational investor views her selling as a tool to move
- 12:08capital to a better home. Selling isn't an ending, it's a
- 12:11transition. Exactly.
- 12:13It puts you back in the driver's seat.
- 12:14To wrap this all up, the source ends with a metaphor that I
- 12:17think just perfectly captures this whole philosophy.
- 12:20It references the sci-fi novel The Three Body Problem.
- 12:23Yes, specifically the story of the Starship Blue Space.
- 12:27It's a pretty grim but powerful analogy.
- 12:32For those who haven't read it, the ship is trapped in deep
- 12:34space and it's facing a battle they can't possibly win with
- 12:37normal tactics. Right.
- 12:38So to survive, the crew has to make this horrifying choice.
- 12:42They have to drain the atmosphere from the ship to
- 12:44prepare for a high G battle in a vacuum.
- 12:47They essentially have to shed their earthly environment, the
- 12:50very air they breathe, to survive the void.
- 12:52And the connection to investing is?
- 12:54The market is a dark forest. It can be hostile, and to
- 12:58survive it, you sometimes have to shed your earthly morality.
- 13:01You have to shed the media narratives, the tribal loyalty
- 13:04to a subreddit, the fear of judgement from your peers.
- 13:07You had to become a cold, rational actor.
- 13:10That gives me chills. It's about stripping away all
- 13:12the noise and just doing what is necessary to survive.
- 13:14The ultimate right of any investor is the right to exit.
- 13:18It's your vote. You vote with your feet.
- 13:21Don't let a slogan like Diamond Hands take that vote away from
- 13:23you. That is a powerful place to
- 13:25leave it. Remember, the sell button is
- 13:27there for a reason. Use it when the logic dictates.
- 13:30Stay rational. Now, before we sign off, we do
- 13:33need to cover the important legal and community details.
- 13:36Yes, listen closely. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 13:39on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 13:43or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 13:46purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 13:50Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 13:52decisions. And if you want to listen to our
- 13:54full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced content,
- 13:58welcome to join the Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to
- 14:02us on Apple, Spotify Podcasts Channel, Deep Value Investing,
- 14:06and luluvc.com. And for our global friends,
- 14:11Shusha Hora is see what turns are in ducks.
- 14:33And queen with a coin. Shanghai ubei utmo shanghu.
- 14:42Shambhui fuso san chuo tahiye shindo koken shanghu Jiang ku
- 14:49Shan Chao Kong taho. Thanks for joining us on this
- 14:52deep dive. We'll see you next time.