Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 052 – Are Dominance/Submission Games in the Bedroom OK?
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the sex within marriage podcast. My name is JD and I blog over at uncovering intimacy.com. And today I am answering a question about dominance and submission games in the bedroom. And this is a question that actually came out of our one of our anonymous questions that I wanted to tackle separately because I get a lot of questions about this. And I actually posted this on the blog as a post a little bit ago, but I hadn't gone around to recording a podcast episode for it.
- 1:10So I thought I'd do that tonight as I had some free time. But before we get into that, I want to tell you about two things. The first is I just released a survey today on what do couples do when they have differing sex drives? What happens when one wants sex when the other one doesn't? How do you manage that in your marriage? What's your dynamic? And basically, how do you solve those problems? Do you solve those problems or do they just end up causing hurt? Because this is something that happens in a lot of marriages. And I get a lot of questions about this from
- 1:40both sides of it. The other thing I want to let you know about is that you have two days left to join as one of our supporters to get this exploration list free. I'm giving it out to any $5 plus supporters this month. So if you're already a supporter, there's an email going out at the end of the month. If you had thought about supporting us and wanted to check out what the supporters forum is like, frankly, it's amazing. People love it. And if you wanted to see what it's like, now's a good time to check it out.
- 2:09But for now, let's get back to the topic at hand. Now, as I said, I get a lot of questions about kind of dominance and submission play in the bedroom. Mostly everyone wants to know if it's okay and if they're the only ones doing it. I have a couple posts on bondage. You can see the links in the show notes. And we've talked about submission in terms of marriage structure. But I don't think I've ever tackled the idea of power exchange games in the bedroom before.
- 2:37And last month, I got a question from our anonymous have a question page on this topic. And rather than tackle it with all the other anonymous questions of the month, which I hope to be posted soon, I thought I'd write its own post for it and do a podcast episode for it. Because this is another question that comes up a lot. And I think people want to know more about it.
- 2:58So the question was simply, this is pretty embarrassing to ask, but I enjoy calling my husband, sir, in bed. We enjoy our submissive slash dominant roles in marriage to be played out in sex as well. He felt weird about it at first, but now loves it.
- 3:14I read your post a while ago where you mentioned that humiliation isn't good for your partner in the long term. Would you consider this to be humiliation? What about the trend to call men daddy in bed?
- 3:27And this question was pretty interesting to watch in our supporters forum. A few guys responded. First thing, they didn't get the whole daddy thing. And then my wife jumped in and said that playing with dominance can be pretty arousing.
- 3:38And then a bunch of other wives jumped in and all chiming their agreement. And I find this happens a fair bit. Everyone is silent until someone speaks up. And then a bunch of people jump in and say, Oh, yeah, we do that too. And often people don't have a name for what it is that they're doing. In fact, a known acronym in some circles is TTWD or that thing that we do, which usually refers to just like spanking or similar activities, but is sometimes extracted to include any activities that fall kind of within
- 4:08that whole BDSM umbrella. And it regularly happens that people will email me saying, Hey, we do this thing. Are we the only ones and they'll describe it and I'll tell them the name for it. And it's handy to have a name because for one, it's usually a lot shorter than that thing that we do with the description. And it's less vague, and it helps them know that they're not alone. I mean, if it has a name, then clearly enough people are doing it that they named it.
- 4:36And in this case, the wife is describing a power exchange game and even explains that for her, it's an extension of their complementarian marriage. But the truth is that this is often a turn on for those in egalitarian marriages too. And if you're a complementarian, then you might find it arousing to extend or even go more strongly into these roles in your bedroom. If you're egalitarian, you might find it arousing to play with your roles that you don't typically don't exercise.
- 5:04So I don't want this to turn into an egalitarian versus complementarian argument. But I do tend to lead more towards a hierarchical structure, though I'd argue I don't resemble what most egalitarians call complementarian at all. So it's hard to give a name to my exact stance. Personally, I'm starting to think that both complementarians and egalitarians are each on opposite but equally wrong kind of radical sides.
- 5:31But today, instead, I hope we can talk just about power exchange play, you know, also known as submission versus dominance play, or DS play. And that is you're doing it for fun for the purposes of arousal. But in order to do that, we might have to delve a bit into marriage dynamics. And I hope that the comments will focus on the play aspect.
- 5:54However, if you do want to start a fight about complementarianism versus egalitarianism, then you might want to check out three other posts that I'll post in the show notes. Because there's already been a big battle going on there for years, you are more than welcome to join it.
- 6:13So let's start with what is power exchange play. And playing with dominance and submission is a type of power exchange play. That is one person is giving up power and the other is taking it. Our lives are full of power exchange dynamics, you know, children and parents have a power exchange dynamic, with the parent having control over the children, employee, employers and employees have a power exchange dynamic. So do government officials and the population, police and the citizens, officers and enlisted.
- 6:42Enlisted. These are all voluntary, consensual exchanges of power that everyone is more or less okay with. What sometimes upset people is that when you move that into marriage, and sometimes even more when you move it into the bedroom, because even though it's still a consensual, voluntary exchange of power between two adults, it's now about sex. And that makes a lot of people nervous. And while it's good that our society is moving to be more cognizant about improper uses of power,
- 7:12we unfortunately sometimes swing too far, and look at any type of power exchange as bad, even when it's for our benefit, and when we enjoy it. And this has had an interesting effect on making power exchange a very taboo thing.
- 7:28The whole equality slash feminine movement has caused this dynamic where you're not allowed to want to be submissive as a woman. Housewives are now often looked down on for choosing to stay at home. People who choose whether due to belief or just personal preference to live in a complementarian marriage are demonized and told that they're being abusive or being abused.
- 7:48In fact, I've had to prune my follow list on social media because this war between egalitarianism and complementarianism is so toxic from both sides that neither side is reflecting Christ, especially the Christians.
- 8:03And my point is that this has created a culture where power exchange has the potential to be considered, yeah, really taboo. It's going against the grain, against what most of society, both Christian and secular, because frankly, sometimes it's hard to tell the difference in these arguments.
- 8:18Tells us this is right. And a lot of people find that really arousing, especially the rebels out there.
- 8:29And so this brings us to this question of, is submission humiliation? And this is where I think people get hung up because of this whole feminist movement, particularly the later stages, there has been this growing push for women to be completely independent, not beholden, submitting, or under.
- 8:48Anyone or anyone or anything. And if that's the case, then yeah, I could see that why you would think that submission would equal humiliation.
- 8:57I would imagine some of those in egalitarian marriages feel the same way, particularly those who claim having dominance over something is abusing it.
- 9:04But in a complementarian view, submission isn't humiliating at all. It's a willing submission for your own benefit. If anything, it's a position of power.
- 9:15It first requires that you understand that your will is yours to do with as you like, and you have the right to give control over it if you desire.
- 9:24And I see this in our relationship with God. We don't submit because we have no choice. At least, I don't believe that we do.
- 9:32I believe that it's that choice, it's that gift of free will from God that allows for our submission to Him.
- 9:39In fact, it's about the only thing that we can do that can be seen as remotely good, and that is simply to respond to that call from God to submit.
- 9:49And that choice alone is what we claim to have done to make us Christians. After all, it's simply a choice to continue to submit, to do as our Master wishes. Why? Because it's good for us.
- 10:05Now, is that humiliating? It's humbling, to be sure, but that's not quite the same, though the words have the same root and can sound similar.
- 10:13You know, humiliation is about shame being made to be seen as worthless, as undervalued, but God holds us in very high value. That's why He wants our submission, I think.
- 10:26You know, if we were worthless, then God would have no need or desire for us. There would be no value in us submitting to Him.
- 10:33And we know this because when we do submit, He doesn't use us selfishly. Quite the opposite, actually.
- 10:38The more we give up the control, the more we submit and allow Him to work through us, the better our lives get.
- 10:46As we learn to trust and lean on Him, our earthly life tends to improve.
- 10:51And I'm not talking about prosperity gospel here, which I think has a drop of truth in an ocean of deception,
- 10:56but rather that allowing ourselves to be ruled, to be molded into something more Christ-like has some real benefits.
- 11:03You know, we learn how to handle relationships as well as material things better.
- 11:08We learn better time management, how to have healthy boundaries.
- 11:12And yes, these things might lead you to more wealth and prosperity, but that's not guaranteed.
- 11:17What is guaranteed is that you will be led to a better life, which will look different for every person.
- 11:23But no one willingly submits to God and follows His guidance, ever looks back and says,
- 11:29I wish I hadn't done that.
- 11:31You know, a lot of people grow up in the faith, feel forced to submit to the rules and regret that,
- 11:36but not if they've made that choice to make it their own.
- 11:40Now, God is perfect and all-loving and all-knowing, so of course our submission to Him yields nothing but goodness.
- 11:46You know, submitting to sinful, broken humans is obviously more problematic.
- 11:51Yet, that doesn't stop God from telling us to do it.
- 11:55You know, numerous times in the Bible we find verses telling us to submit to humans.
- 11:59You know, we have Romans 13 verses 1-2 tells us,
- 12:03Let every soul be subject to the governing authorities.
- 12:061 Peter 2 verses 13-21 starts with,
- 12:09Therefore submit yourselves to every governance of man for the Lord's sake,
- 12:13whether to the king as supreme or to governors as to those who are sent by him
- 12:19for the punishment of evildoers and the praise of those who do good,
- 12:24for it is the will of God.
- 12:25And it continues.
- 12:28We have,
- 12:29Likewise, you younger people, submit yourselves to your elders.
- 12:31In 1 Peter 5,
- 12:33We have,
- 12:34Fathers, do not provoke your children to wrath,
- 12:36but bring them up in the training and admonition of the Lord.
- 12:39You know,
- 12:39Bond servants, be obedient to those who are your masters.
- 12:42In Ephesians 6.
- 12:43We have,
- 12:44Children, obey your parents.
- 12:45It's also in Ephesians 6.
- 12:46We have,
- 12:47Slaves, obey your masters.
- 12:49In Colossians.
- 12:50We have,
- 12:51A reminder to be subject to the rulers and authorities.
- 12:54In Titus 3.
- 12:56So God,
- 12:57Knowing how broken and sinful we are,
- 12:59Knowing that we are so bad,
- 13:01We need a savior because nothing else could redeem us.
- 13:04You know,
- 13:04He still chose to command us to submit to humans.
- 13:08And of course,
- 13:08It's generally in situations where that person is supposed to care for us.
- 13:12Be they a government official, a parent, or fellow believer,
- 13:15But even more so when they're your spouse.
- 13:18So then how can it be humiliating to willingly submit to them?
- 13:22Based on what I see in the Bible,
- 13:24Choosing to submit to your husband for the purpose of sexual pleasure
- 13:27Is in no way seen as humiliating or sinful.
- 13:31But some will still feel humiliated.
- 13:33Some have dealt with abuses of power,
- 13:35Or perhaps have an incorrect view of submission,
- 13:38One that's focused more on an abusive model.
- 13:40Some may believe that humans can't be trusted with this sort of power.
- 13:43Some may simply be so in love with the idea of absolute personal freedom
- 13:47That they may not be willing to submit to anyone or anything.
- 13:51And I'm not saying that they all need to learn to submit in the bedroom.
- 13:54What I'm saying is that we all need to learn to submit at one time or another.
- 13:59At the very least to God.
- 14:00But according to the Bible,
- 14:01As I read it,
- 14:03We need to be willing to give that submission to others as well,
- 14:06When appropriate.
- 14:07Which may be all of the time.
- 14:10Philippians 2 verse 3 says,
- 14:12Let nothing be done through selfish ambition or conceit,
- 14:15But in loneliness of mind,
- 14:17Let each esteem others better than himself.
- 14:20So, no, I don't consider submission to be humiliation at all.
- 14:25So what about calling your husband, sir, in bed?
- 14:28Some people like to mark this power exchange by using titles.
- 14:32And for me, here's where you can get into a gray area,
- 14:35Depending on the reason.
- 14:36Because titles have been used two ways that I can think of.
- 14:39The first is as a sign of respect.
- 14:42And the second is a sign of humiliation or dehumanization or disassociation.
- 14:47And the way I see it,
- 14:48If you want to mark that power exchange by using titles as a sign of respect,
- 14:52Endearment,
- 14:52Or simply to make it clear that this is power exchange playtime,
- 14:55And it separates it from normal time,
- 14:57Then I don't see a reason not to.
- 14:59But if you're using it to make yourself an object,
- 15:02Less human in some way,
- 15:04Or it's a mechanism for humiliation or disassociation,
- 15:08You know, distancing the relational aspect of your interaction,
- 15:10Then I think you need to be careful.
- 15:13As well, I think it depends on people's association for the words.
- 15:16For some, using titles like sir, lord, master, my king, etc.
- 15:20Is sexy and arousing.
- 15:22But for others, it might seem blasphemous and a turn-off.
- 15:26Some Christians grow up believing some titles should only be used by God.
- 15:30Personally, I think the title God should only be used when referring to God,
- 15:33But titles like Lord aren't exclusively linked to God.
- 15:37You know, Oxford Dictionary says,
- 15:39A lord is someone or something having power, authority, or influence, a master or ruler.
- 15:45It's not necessarily linked to any kind of deity or religion or anything like that.
- 15:51So I think that's one of those,
- 15:52If it bothers you, then don't do it.
- 15:54I mean, the idea is that it's supposed to be fun play.
- 15:58And if it's not fun, well, then that's kind of defeated the purpose.
- 16:02And I also wanted to say, and I forgot to write this in the blog post,
- 16:05That the Bible actually uses the term lord for people other than God as well.
- 16:11There's many people who get called lord from time to time,
- 16:14Be they king, or even Sarah calls Abraham lord.
- 16:17So there's almost a precedence there that it's okay.
- 16:21And it could be cultural, but it's clearly not a big problem.
- 16:26So what about calling your husband daddy in bed?
- 16:29And here, again, I think is where you get people answering based on how they associate the word.
- 16:34For some, calling your husband daddy is more about the position,
- 16:37Or feeling cared for, or taken care of, provided for, etc.
- 16:41In the same way, we call God father.
- 16:43He's not our biological father.
- 16:45In a sense, he's our adopted father.
- 16:47But really, we call him father because of his goodness and how he cares for us.
- 16:51And others can't get over this association that daddy equals, well, daddy.
- 16:56To them, the idea of calling their husband daddy is disgusting and incestuous.
- 17:00Some hate to call God father as well because of the association that brings due to their earthly father or lack thereof.
- 17:09In fact, there's a book written about a man having this experience called Finding the Father
- 17:13and his journey to understand what sort of father God is after growing up with a broken view of what a father should be.
- 17:21I have five children who have called me daddy since they were little kids.
- 17:26And using that term in a sexual context, just, I don't think I could make that mental shift needed.
- 17:32So for me, that's a bit of a turnoff.
- 17:35Others have the same feeling about the term of endearment, babe.
- 17:39You know, Christina called me babe just once to try it out because that's what my brother and his wife call each other.
- 17:45And frankly, they can have it.
- 17:46It is not for us.
- 17:47I am not her baby.
- 17:48I never want to be associated that way.
- 17:50And for both of us, it's just a complete turnoff.
- 17:53But I understand that for others, that association isn't the same.
- 17:57So I think it's up to you and how you process that word and what it means for you.
- 18:04And lastly, I know somebody is going to ask, you know, what if the genders are reverse?
- 18:09And to be honest, I don't know.
- 18:11I get really confused about that question, which I'm not used to feeling.
- 18:16I'm usually pretty clear on what I believe and why I believe it.
- 18:20And with this one, my only real concern, I think, is that if the genders are reversed, you know, from my experience, what happens in the bedroom tends to spill out into the rest of the marriage.
- 18:30And marriages are holistic.
- 18:32Nothing is self-contained.
- 18:34And as I've said, my personal belief is that husbands should be leading the marriage.
- 18:38And if they're usually taking a submissive position in the bedroom, then I worry about how that would affect the rest of the marriage.
- 18:46But it just might just be that this is my own personal bias based on my marriage dynamic and my experiences of talking to some couples where the dynamics like that have negatively impacted their relationship.
- 18:58But it doesn't mean it will happen as a rule.
- 19:00And there is definitely something enticing about a woman who knows what she wants and is assertive enough to state that desire.
- 19:06So I guess the best answer I have is to make your own decisions based on your dynamic and your convictions.
- 19:14As for dominance and submission games in general, I can't see a biblical or psychological reason not to engage in them other than for the reasons stated above, past abuse and associations.
- 19:26And frankly, there's a ton more to cover here on the whole topic if people are interested.
- 19:31But today, I just wanted to answer these kind of basic questions and hopefully relieve some people's minds and make them feel okay.
- 19:41So if you're interested in trying it, talk to your spouse.
- 19:45If you're not, then don't worry about it.
- 19:48Or if you aren't sure, you know, you can check out our sexploration list and it might help you have a much broader conversation about what you and your spouse like and don't like in the bedroom.
- 19:59And like I said, if you want to get one free, check out our supporters page.
- 20:04Link's in the show notes.
- 20:06That's it for now.
- 20:06Don't forget to fill out the survey.
- 20:08And hopefully I'll have the rest of the anonymous questions up soon.
- 20:12See ya.