Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Could Julian Sayin Actually End Up Starting This Year For The Buckeyes?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:04here as always with Tom or Tom. How's it going, Oh, Tony,
- 0:11I'm delighted to inform you that we have both apparently survived the eclipse and
- 0:19not all of the eclipse. The traffic apocalypse that we were all promised largely
- 0:24failed to materialize. So Tony glad to see we have both made it through
- 0:30this once in a lifetime extremely cool event, alive and not still stuck in
- 0:36traffic. It was extremely cool, and I have not talked to We have
- 0:39not talked since since you ventured out into the countryside and so traffic was not
- 0:46too bad. You did not just get back. I went through, and
- 0:52I decided the last thing in the world I want to do is drive towards
- 0:55a bunch of people where like a million people live. So I went to
- 0:58basically directly from where I live and took a bunch of put it this way.
- 1:03I drove the entire way from here to there and did not have one
- 1:10traffic light in the fifty or so minutes. So that gives you a paints
- 1:14a picture for how my trip was visited. The lovely town of Fredericktown,
- 1:19the home of the Fredericktown Freddy's, one of the great Ohio High school mascots.
- 1:23Lovely little town. Their library put on a very nice event. It
- 1:26was a wonderful, wonderful day. And I thought it was fascinating that all
- 1:32the people who went, like my daughter was texting with all of her friends,
- 1:34and all of her friends who went said this was the most amazing thing
- 1:38I've ever seen. And all of her friends who stayed home and had,
- 1:42you know, ninety nine percent eclipse but not the totality, said like,
- 1:47eah, it was a little underwhelming. It's like, yeah, well,
- 1:49turns out the scientists were right. You did need to drive a little Yeah,
- 1:53And there's quite a bit of difference between the ninety seven percent and the
- 1:57whole totality. Texting with my mom and my sister up in northwest Ohio and
- 2:04the God's Country of Henry County, they got to see it. My brother
- 2:08and his wife took their kids to the Harden County Fairgrounds. I only had
- 2:12to go out on my patio, so that was pretty cool. I did
- 2:16not get out in time to get glasses, so that's why my eyes are
- 2:23bandaged right now. If you're listening to the podcast. Now, I went
- 2:27out a couple of times. I had like the plate thing, and the
- 2:29neighbors saw me. He was like, you want some glasses, and like
- 2:31I had to come out five times doing this before you actually offered out some
- 2:35glasses. You know, what kind of neighbor are you? And so I
- 2:38got some glasses and it was very cool. And then of course you get
- 2:40to the totality part and you just take the glasses off and you're looking at
- 2:44something that's pretty crazy and you can see I don't know as a Jupiter off
- 2:47to the side there as well. So yeah, I was it was a
- 2:52good experience. It's something that I've talked before. I did get to experience
- 2:55back in the nineties when I was on a field trip or whatever. So
- 2:58this is pretty cool, Like you would agree, I would agree. Yes,
- 3:02we were looking up, Oh, when's the next time this happened in
- 3:05the US, and it's like, oh, twenty years from now in Montana
- 3:08and the Dakotas. So I guess we'll pencil that into the schedule for September
- 3:15twenty forty four or whatever. For Grandpa. Tom did have the Oh lord,
- 3:23my kids could have kids by that point conversation as we were talking about
- 3:28that, and it was like, I am not emotionally ready for that it,
- 3:31you know, watching it, and it kind of the story that astronauts
- 3:37will tell when they are in space and you view the Earth from not the
- 3:42Earth, and it gives you this new kind of respect for humanity and everything.
- 3:46And I think that the eclipse is kind of that way. But then
- 3:50it goes away and you're like, Okay, I need to get back on
- 3:52the internet and tell people I hate them. How long do you think it
- 3:57took between the we are all one mankind moment to the first time someone flipped
- 4:03the bird to someone who cut them off in traffic on the way out of
- 4:06the parking lot of wherever that is. I'm gonna guess the good vibes lasted.
- 4:12You know, the eclipse itself was not fully over by the time someone
- 4:16was flying the bird in the parking lot somewhere like there are parts of Mexico
- 4:21and southwest US. I got like four minutes of totality. I think we
- 4:25got about two minutes here. I don't know. I would probably put to
- 4:30the totality time as like minus one point forty as lasting longer than the amount
- 4:34of humanity, the totality of humanity following the eclipse. But yeah, also
- 4:41just a really cool thing. And I would ever recommend that you go ahead,
- 4:46should try to catch it the next time if you were able to do
- 4:48it this time. But just if it's happened in my neighborhood's stay out.
- 4:51If it's happening in my county, just stay out. We don't want you
- 4:55there. I don't think it's gonna happen in your neighborhood again until I believe
- 4:59twenty ninety nine, which you know, with the science and technology improving the
- 5:05way it is, you know, I don't know, maybe, but demographically,
- 5:11you know, statistically looking at it from an actual, real perspective,
- 5:15that may not be your problem, and that may not be my problem either.
- 5:18So Tom, let's move on with the show and what may be the
- 5:21most outstanding segue ever. Yesterday we saw the sun have its black stripe removed
- 5:30during the eclipse, and also that same day, Ohio State freshman quarterback Julian
- 5:36say it had his black stripe removed. Any coincidence, I'm going to say
- 5:45it was faded by the heavens, Tony that that was going to be the
- 5:48day that Julian san Really, honestly, it was faded by the fact that,
- 5:54of course Tony who had Julian Say in the black stripe draft? Well,
- 5:57of course it was me, So of course at that point it was
- 5:59faded that he was going to be the next person to lose his black stripe.
- 6:02Only two freshmen Tony have lost their black stripes this spring. You'll never
- 6:05guess who had both of them in the black stripe draft. And what pick
- 6:10did you get him with? Like six or something like that. I think
- 6:13it was five or six. I can I will look. Believe me,
- 6:15I will take as much time as we need to make sure that this is
- 6:19documented properly. Yeah, I had Jeremiah Smith with pick one, Julian Saying
- 6:26with pick five. So, and who do I have at two and three?
- 6:31Somebody good? I hope you have Aaron Scott who has looked good in
- 6:35our viewing opportunities, Edward Houston, who think we've heard good things about.
- 6:41And I had Bryce West at four. That was right before we found out
- 6:44that Bryce West was not going to play the spring. So so you're telling
- 6:47me there's a chance, No, that's not what I'm telling you. In
- 6:50fact, but it's going to be difficult for me to overcome you getting the
- 6:55the first two in there. And I think Julian's saying losing it at this
- 7:02point at that point, because that was a high pick for you, and
- 7:08quarterbacks shouldn't be losing them that early. But I think we're realizing that Julian's
- 7:12saying is not your typical freshman quarterback. In fact, he's the first Ohio
- 7:16State freshman quarterback to lose the black stripe in spring ball. And I was
- 7:21like, gosh, I wonder if he's the first one ever. So I'm
- 7:24going back to trying to find on the internet, like Irban Meyers quarterbacks at
- 7:30Florida, Like I'm googling all these different ways Tim Tebow black stripe, and
- 7:33I eventually found like something about Percy Harvin losing his black stripe in August of
- 7:39two thousand and six and him being mentioned. It's mentioned in passing that he
- 7:42was the first freshman Like okay, check check Tim Tebow off the list.
- 7:46He didn't lose in the spring, and back then not everybody was really enrolling
- 7:49in the spring. But this losing it at this point, and as I
- 7:56said, the first true freshman quarterback to lose it in the spring is pretty
- 8:01impressive. And this is just further confirmation of what we've been hearing and then
- 8:05got to see a week and a half ago. And we'll get to sea
- 8:09on Friday again. And and so this is it's not nothing, it's not
- 8:15everything. It doesn't mean he's starting, it doesn't mean he's going to be
- 8:18an all time great. What he has done is incredibly rare. In fact,
- 8:22nobody els done it before him, So it means something tom right.
- 8:28In fact, I look it up yesterday. I no Ohio State quarterback will
- 8:31once again lose a black stripe in the spring until two thousand and forty four.
- 8:35And that's going to happen in the Dakotas, which is crazy. I
- 8:37mean, I don't even want to try to figure out why that's going to
- 8:41happen. But this is this is one of the things where you go back
- 8:46over the years and you know, the first guy to lose his black stripe,
- 8:50sometimes that guy turns into a superstar. Sometimes that guy has injuries or
- 8:54just doesn't pan out for whatever reason. So this is not, you know,
- 8:58absolutely one hundre percent guarantee of future success. What it is is further
- 9:03information that sort of corroborates the things that we've been hearing, the things that
- 9:07we've been reporting, the things that we've been seeing. It's just a little
- 9:11more, you know, throw one more thing on the pile. If you're
- 9:13weighing, you know, Julian saying good or bad. It's one more thing
- 9:16on the good side of the scale that you know tells you Okay. Not
- 9:22only does he have the physical tools, because you can sort of see that
- 9:24while you're watching that, the black stripe is a lot of the other stuff.
- 9:30It's a lot of the soft factor stuff. Yeah, you've got to
- 9:31be a good player on the field, but it's also leadership, discipline,
- 9:37putting in the time in the film, study, putting in the time in
- 9:39the weight room, all that kind of soft factor stuff that ends up playing
- 9:43a big role in what kind of player you end up being as a college
- 9:48football player. So I think this is certainly more encouraging news for Julian saying
- 9:52again, I would be strongly on the side that you are there. We're
- 9:56not expecting him to be the starting quarterback this year, but it feels like,
- 10:01you know, if he's going to be of the five quarterbacks in that
- 10:03room. You know, the odds that he's one of the top three or
- 10:07you know, maybe top two a vision transfer. You know, the odds
- 10:09of that kind of feel like they're sort of slowly growing as we go through
- 10:13the spring. Yeah, and we'll get into that as well, because it
- 10:18might have to reassess our thoughts on where he fits into this offense. I
- 10:24had somebody on Twitter or on the buckehead a message board presented by Jeff Ruby
- 10:30Steakhouse, if how does he compare to quin Yours? And the thing to
- 10:35remember is Quen Yours came in like a week into camp in August, so
- 10:39there really is no comparison. I said, based on what we've seen from
- 10:43both players, I would put Julian say in a year ahead of quin yours
- 10:48at least. And the thing is Quen Yours skipped a year, so the
- 10:50math is in my favor there as well. Quin Yours, by the way,
- 10:56never had his black stripe removed, so he he he left with it.
- 11:00I don't know unless they unless they took it before he left. He's
- 11:03like, oh, where do you think you're going with that stripe? Sir?
- 11:07And then they kept it. But that's you know, that was the
- 11:11most heralded quarterback since Trell prior at Ohio State, I think in terms of
- 11:16the freshman and really just no, no significant comparison. So I went through
- 11:22and looked at where all of the Ohio State quarterbacks and the urban from from
- 11:28the Urban Meyers start. When he brought the black stripe to yesterday, when
- 11:35did the quarterbacks lose them? And of course Julians saying being the first true
- 11:39freshman quarterback to lose it in the spring, no freshman has lost it before
- 11:43him. The top three, I mean, there's one out there that Tristan
- 11:52Jeby was the third, lost it on April first of twenty twenty three.
- 11:54It was a seventh year. Come on, I mean, you should be
- 11:56losing it in April. But Justin Fields lost his on March twenty fifth.
- 12:03Will Howard lost his on March thirtieth, Tristan Jebia April first, no fooland
- 12:09and then Julian's saying April eighth. Julian Sayin loses his April eighth. You
- 12:13look at the other freshman in this group. Kyle McCord August twelfth is next,
- 12:22Then Dwayne Haskins August seventeenth, Tate Martel August nineteenth, Cardale Jones August
- 12:28twentieth, Stephen Collier August twenty first, Joe Thomas Barrett August twenty third,
- 12:37Lincoln Kenoles September twenty eighth, Devin Brown October sixth, Matthew Baldwin October seventeenth,
- 12:46Jack Miller October twenty first, same day as C. J. Stroud
- 12:48October twenty first. That was the COVID year, so they had no spring
- 12:52after the first couple of practices and then the most amazing outlier here Tom class
- 13:00of twenty fifteen lose. This is on August thirteenth, of two thoy and
- 13:05sixteen. Not good enough to play at Ohio State. Clearly that's why he
- 13:09had to leave. But you look at those numbers, anything stand out other
- 13:13than the fact that there's a lot of names there and there's only one in
- 13:18terms of the freshman that lost his stripe in April. Yeah, I think
- 13:24that's That's the thing that definitely pops out to me is you look at Joe
- 13:28Burrow, and Joe Burrow did it in I mean, so August thirteenth was
- 13:35probably about practice seven or eight maybe, I mean, that's kind of middle
- 13:41of fall camp. Right, So that's probably, I guess, in a
- 13:46sort of similar spot to where Julian Saying is. And but that was a
- 13:52year after he had rolled. Oh that was a oh he was a red
- 13:54shirt freshman. Okay, sorry, sorry, okay, sorry I missed that
- 13:58on that chart. Yeah, yeah, that's no wonder, no wonder.
- 14:01Joe Burrow was such a bust. Uh. It took it took a full
- 14:05year to lose it. It's it's pretty amazing to me that he's lost it
- 14:11already. I you know, we had heard good things, but you look
- 14:16at that list. There's a lot of really talented players in that There's multiple
- 14:20first round draft picks on that list, and you know, the only ones
- 14:24who've lost it are two graduate seniors too, who've been in college so long
- 14:28that they're ready to basically be coaches just about. And justin Fields, who
- 14:33was, you know, a top five national player who also had already played
- 14:37a year, So he came in a little more ready than a lot of
- 14:41other people to do that as a true freshman who had not spent that much
- 14:46time at Ohio State. And Julian Saying went through his whole recruiting process,
- 14:50committed to Alabama, was going to be a member of the Crimson Tide,
- 14:54enrolled at Alabama and then left a week later, and then just sort of
- 14:58got thrown into this new spot with bunch of people. He knew, he
- 15:01knew these people from recruiting, but he didn't, you know, he had
- 15:05not had fifteen visits to Ohio State and knew the internet ins and outs of
- 15:09all the you know, the whole process, and you know, you got
- 15:13an early look at the playbook like none of that stuff. So for him
- 15:18to be this early in and of itself is remarkable. For him to be
- 15:22this early given all the other stuff. I just said, when you look
- 15:26at all the other guys who you know, JT. Barrett had access to
- 15:31the you know, the playbook and made a bunch of visits, and Jack
- 15:35Beller, C. J. Stroud, all of those guys, Con mccorr,
- 15:39Dwayne Haskins, all of those guys had all these other benefits, and
- 15:43still Julian Sayin's losing it before them. That's pretty intriguing to me. So
- 15:50I put that list out on Twitter and people were like, yeah, but
- 15:54he enrolled in, Julian saying enrolled in spring, So it's different it's like,
- 15:58well actually, well well actually ten of the thirteen freshmen on that list
- 16:02enrolled in the spring. The only guys who didn't enroll in the spring were
- 16:04Dwayne Haskins, Lincoln keen Holes, and Joe Burrow. So like this is
- 16:11this is typical to enroll in spring and is atypical to be doing what he
- 16:15is doing. This may then beg the question is Ryan Day more lenient with
- 16:22the black stripe when it comes to than Urban Meyer was. And you know,
- 16:27if you go back you look at all these years and their dates.
- 16:30I don't know and quarterbacks specifically that there's any any trend that way, because
- 16:36when you look at you on Lincoln keen Holes and Devin Brown losing THEIRS in
- 16:41September and October, and Jack Miller c just John of course that was COVID,
- 16:45But yeah, Dwayne Haskins loses his in August as an early as a
- 16:52late enrollly, as an on time enrollly, So that's pretty quick. You
- 16:56know, Tate Martel lost his in August, Cardill Jones lost his August,
- 17:00even Kllier or J. T. Barrett, they all lost THEIRS before.
- 17:03Guys like Lincoln Keyholes, Devin Brown. Matthew Baldwin was an Urban sinnee,
- 17:10but Ryan Day was the quarterbacks coach who was involved in that decision. So
- 17:15is there any thought that maybe maybe that Ryan Day is just an easier greater,
- 17:21Maybe he's like the substitute who is not the stickler that the old teacher
- 17:26was. Is there any possibility there? I mean, I think what I
- 17:30would do before I before I tried to psychoanalyze those two guys and what they
- 17:36you know, what they really think they're doing with the Black strike, I
- 17:38would take a moment and look at the quarterback play and production under Ryan Day
- 17:42as compared to the quarterback play in production under Urban Meyer, and go,
- 17:47yeah, whatever Ryan Day's doing is fine. I think, you know,
- 17:51I think everyone viewed Kyle McCorry last year as this is this unmitigated disaster,
- 17:56and it's like that's probably at least average to slightly above average Urban Meyer quarterback
- 18:00play. So I think I would immediately leaned toward I think Ryan Day knows
- 18:06what he's doing with the quarterbacks, so I think it's fine. But also
- 18:10you go through Take Martel August nineteenth, Cardil Jones August twentieth, Stephen Collier
- 18:15August twenty first. J. T. Barrett, August twenty third, Like
- 18:18this is like, okay, it's all happening the same basic day, it's
- 18:22all happening at the exact same point of camp. And those guys had very
- 18:26different careers in you know, very different shapes of very different careers, and
- 18:30a lot of them were complete non factors for multiple years after they lost those
- 18:37stripes. So yeah, I don't you know, I don't think I look
- 18:40at that and go, you know, boy, back in back in Urban
- 18:42Meyer's day, they really they ran everything like the Navy seals, and you
- 18:45really had to earn it, and you weren't you know, you weren't ready
- 18:48to lose your black stripe until you were ready to lead the troops into battle.
- 18:53And like, there's a lot of guys on there who lost that black
- 18:56stripe at really almost the exact same point point of camp and then didn't play
- 19:00for multiple years after that. So no, I don't put a lot of
- 19:03stock into that. And I also had people saying, well, you know,
- 19:07you look at the Joe Burrow thing or some of these guys, like,
- 19:11well, they they had more guys to fight through, you know,
- 19:15on the depth chart and it's like that has nothing to do with it.
- 19:17The depth chart has nothing to do with the black stripe. It's how you
- 19:18individually are performing, has nothing to do with the fact that there is no
- 19:23established starter at Ohio State right now, a quarterback that's not even in the
- 19:26picture. Whereas well, Joe Burrow had J. T. Barrett and Cardile
- 19:30Jones ahead of him, and of course he you know, took him.
- 19:33While it's like that has nothing to do with anything. It's what you're doing,
- 19:37essentially in a vacuum, but also surrounded by all these other other people
- 19:41and how you are playing in that situation. So that's not a factor either.
- 19:51When you look at where Julian's saying is in terms of the other true
- 19:55freshmen that have lost their black stripe in those teen years since since urban Meyer
- 20:02got here and started this, there have only been eight true freshman at Ohio
- 20:08State who have lost their black stripes earlier than Julian saying, which is pretty
- 20:15crazy, and this is a pretty good list. It was. I'll give
- 20:18them to you an order and March twenty first, Jeremiah Smith first, the
- 20:23earliest ever practiced for Colonel Tate. March twenty fifth, practice five, Austin
- 20:30Mack March thirty first, Marvin Harrison Junior April sixth, same day as Jack
- 20:36Sawyer, Willie Cartford April seventh, same day as Jelanie Thurman, Kay Stokes
- 20:41April eighth. In twenty twenty two, and then five years to the day
- 20:47that Julian Saying lost his Garrett Wilson lost his same practice number, same day,
- 20:55all that good stuff. So you know, like I said, eight
- 20:59guys in the thirteen years of the Black Stripe got their black stripe off earlier
- 21:06than Julian said. And I have Kai Stokes listed as going earlier as well
- 21:08because it was the eleventh practice, even though it was the same April eighth,
- 21:12semantics, whatever. But that that also is pretty incredible when you consider
- 21:21not just the quarterbacks that have come through Ohio State, but all of the
- 21:25players since twenty twelve that have come through Ohio State, and only eight guys
- 21:30lost their black stripes faster than Julians saying. That's pretty remarkable. And I
- 21:36think it's even more remarkable when you consider he's a quarterback. And there are
- 21:40nine names on this list, including Garrett Wilson, who's tied with him.
- 21:42Four of the four of the other eight names, five of the other nine
- 21:47names, sorry, are wide receivers. And I think there's something to that
- 21:52where you know, number one Brian Hartline and has been bringing in, you
- 21:56know, really really elite level wide receiver process and you know Austin mac was
- 22:02pre Brian Hartline, but you know four of the five are Brian Hartline level
- 22:06wide receivers or ERA wide receivers. So that's you know, that's one thing
- 22:08that I think factors into that. And also there's just there's you know,
- 22:12if you can run your routes and you can block, and you can you
- 22:18know, do the do the stuff that Brian Hartlin is looking for you to
- 22:21do, you can lose that stripe relatively early. We tend to have wide
- 22:25receivers towards the top of our boards because we know that this is sort of
- 22:27the pattern quarterbacks are not. You know, there's a lot more that goes
- 22:33into all of the you know, you're running the offense. There's a lot
- 22:37more playbook study, there's a lot more everything that goes into being a quarterback
- 22:42at Ohio State and losing your black stripe. So to do it at a
- 22:45position where other guys haven't done it. You know, it's five wide receivers,
- 22:49one defensive end, one tight end, two safeties, and now Julian's
- 22:53saying that's impressive that you know, if you look at the offensive line,
- 23:00like, we never expect offensive linemen to lose their black stripes early because there's
- 23:03so much physical development that goes into that position that you almost expect it to
- 23:07take the better part of a year. For half of the guys in the
- 23:11class. There's a you know, there's a certain positional specialty where it just
- 23:19takes so much more. It feels like to lose it at certain spots,
- 23:23so to lose it at quarterback, to be the first guy to lose it
- 23:26at quarterback and also be in the com you know, in not only just
- 23:30positionally. The names on that list Jeremiah Smith, Colonel Tate Austin Mack,
- 23:33Marvin Harrison, Junior, Jack Sawyer, Lik Hartford played at as a true
- 23:37freshman some last season at that deep safety spot. Jolannie Thurman. Obviously,
- 23:41there's a lot of a lot of optimism about and he probably would have played
- 23:45more last year if Kate Stover wasn't there. Garrett Wilson, I mean those
- 23:48are some very very talented names. The one that kind of jumps out is
- 23:52Kai Stokes, who lost to Stripe and then now has already transferred, which
- 23:55is kind of a kind of a weird thing. But you know, the
- 23:59hit rate at the top of that list is high enough that it feels that
- 24:03it feels like that's pretty significant. So then do we reevaluate our thoughts on
- 24:11Julian Saying's role in the quarterback competition this year? I think with five quarterbacks
- 24:19it's with Saying. Now, I think it's safe to say he is.
- 24:25I mean he is above Aaron Nolan. We've seen that all practiced long.
- 24:30He has lost his black Stripe eron Nolan still has his, So we're not
- 24:33speaking out of school here on that one. He's chasing people right now.
- 24:38I'm not I'm not ready to say he's going to start this year, but
- 24:45I would be less surprised now if he did at some point. I don't
- 24:49think it happens in September, And as I've said before, I think it
- 24:53requires other people to lose the job or get injured. I don't I think
- 25:00he's going to overtake anybody. I think this this would be a result of
- 25:03something's happening to somebody else. But I'm not going to be shocked if he
- 25:11starts a game because we've seen, you know, we saw Kyle mc courtz
- 25:14start a game in twenty twenty one. We saw Lincoln Kentoles almost start a
- 25:18game in the Cotton Bowl. Like things happen and they've got five quarterbacks.
- 25:22Now he's moving up the I don't even know if he's moving up really is
- 25:26he. We don't know if he's ahead of Lincoln Kentles at this point.
- 25:29I think that's the next competition for him. That's the next checkpoint. But
- 25:33what are your current expectations as now compared to where they were February? Well,
- 25:41compared to February, I think they've certainly moved up. I don't know
- 25:44that, you know, in terms of like starting day one, I think
- 25:48it's gone from zero percent to one percent or something. It's not I'm certainly
- 25:53not expecting him to be the day one starter right now. We'll see,
- 25:57We're going to get to watch practice on Friday, We're going to get to
- 26:00watch the spring game on Saturday. That's going to be a lot more information
- 26:03just between those two days than we have for pretty much the whole rest of
- 26:07the spring in terms of what we've seen. So I reserve the right to
- 26:11change my mind on that in a week, but I don't think I'm expecting
- 26:15a Day one start. I think the odds that he is in the top
- 26:21three before, you know, before the start of the season, have gone
- 26:25up significantly. The odds that he's in the top two before the start of
- 26:27the season, they're up. They're certainly up that. I don't think it's,
- 26:32you know, eighty percent likely he's this to back up for Game one
- 26:36or anything like that, but I think it's certainly within the realm of possibility.
- 26:38And some of that also has to do with, Okay, does someone
- 26:41hit the transfer portal, does someone get hurt? Does someone just not pan
- 26:45out, you know, for whatever reason, as we're seeing these guys with
- 26:48more reps, does it just not happen for someone. It's certainly possible.
- 26:52This is just all of the things that led me to think there was basically
- 26:56no chance back in February. The level of talent everywhere else on this team,
- 27:02the fact that you don't need the quarterback to be the hero who pulls
- 27:07games out for you, and you're willing to take a high, higher risk,
- 27:10higher reward kind of quarterback position. All that stuff I think is still
- 27:14true. They don't need the quarterback to be you know, a plus plus.
- 27:18They need the quarterback to be you know, safe, solid, not
- 27:22make mistakes. Typically you expect a freshman to make mistakes. With the talent
- 27:30that Ohio State has, You're looking to reduce your variance this year because you
- 27:33are just gonna be able to out talent just about everyone in the country.
- 27:37So I think you know you're not. This is not the type of season.
- 27:41This isn't the type of roster where you're going to be willing to maybe
- 27:45take as big of a you know, high upside, high you know,
- 27:49low floor kind of risk, which is what a true freshman quarterback just about
- 27:55always is. I didn't expect to be talk talking about this for thirty minutes,
- 28:00But now I also have a hypothetical. What if Julian Saying had enrolled
- 28:07at Ohio State last year and he's competing against Devin Brown and Colm Accord and
- 28:15things aren't necessarily going great in the middle of the season, or if it,
- 28:21I think would the chances of him starting last year with Devin Brown being
- 28:26much less experienced kym m accord again, he was fine, but would would
- 28:37they have seen the limitations of kylem accord and seeing somebody like well, if
- 28:41we can get Julian saying going in these next three games, heading into like
- 28:47a Michigan or something like that, that can really get us over the top.
- 28:52Do you think the chances are starting last year would have been better than
- 28:56this year if everything is equal in terms of what he's doing right now.
- 29:00That's a really interesting question because you know, knowing now what we you know,
- 29:04knowing then what we know now, you would say yes, of course,
- 29:07because you know that it wasn't good enough last year. But that was
- 29:11also a Kyle McCord who had been in the system for a couple of years
- 29:15and was the former five star prospect, and you know, had had the
- 29:21you know, the pedigree and had a little bit of track record, and
- 29:25you had seen him in mop up duty and you thought, yeah, I
- 29:27mean he'll he'll get there eventually, and now we know it really didn't quite
- 29:32get there for him, and Devin Brown was banged up so much, and
- 29:36Lincoln Keenholes last year, coming in in the summer and coming in from such
- 29:40a small program really was not ever going to be a significant factor, you
- 29:45know, almost regardless you saw in the Cotton Bowl. You know there's talent
- 29:49there, but he just he would not have been ready to step in in
- 29:52October or something if they felt that like the team needed to change. And
- 29:56I guess I'm approaching this as twenty twenty four Julian saying goes back in time.
- 30:00This is not a Julian saying in rolls early last year kind of thing
- 30:03or anything like that. So, you know, knowing then what we know
- 30:10now, Yeah, absolutely you should give him a shot. I just it's
- 30:15it's I don't think they would have done it last year because of the track
- 30:22record of McCord. But it's just so hard to say because you know,
- 30:26he hadn't like clearly, clearly head and shoulders won that job for you know,
- 30:30the twelve months leading up to the first game, and Devin Brown was
- 30:37not overly impressive by any means during the opportunities he got to play, but
- 30:41he was so limited by injuries. I think they probably would have rolled with
- 30:48Kyle McCord. Now, if Kyle McCord's pass that was whatever three plays before
- 30:55the winning touchdown at Notre Dame, that hit the linebacker in the hands.
- 31:00If that linebacker catches that football, I think that maybe impacts this question more
- 31:06than people might want admit. And you know, it's it's crazy to think
- 31:10that that could. You know, whether one guy catches one football could impact
- 31:15who the starting quarterback is for Ohio State a month and a half later.
- 31:18But if they have a loss on their resume at that point, you might
- 31:22feel like it's a little bit of a different question. Well, and him
- 31:26not catching not intercepting that ball leads eventually to the touchdown and the confidence that
- 31:30Kyle leccurd can lead us to a game winning drive, so he can play.
- 31:34He's been in big games, he's experienced that. So you're you're you're
- 31:37going to be reticent to remove him from that situation and turn the ball give
- 31:42the ball to a true freshman. So it is interesting just a dropped pass
- 31:47and this hypothetical, but also in reality because we saw what happened last year.
- 31:52But what what one linebacker safety does determines how how a quarterback is viewed
- 31:57and and whether or not he sticks as the starter. The last thing I
- 32:01want to talk about is I planned on spending more time on this, but
- 32:06we don't necessarily need to. Kevin and I talked about this on a Big
- 32:09Me kickoff show live stream on Monday, if you want to hear more about
- 32:14it. But Dallan Hayden transferring, We'll be transferring after the spring. I
- 32:21do wonder where he moves in terms of the depth chart right now, do
- 32:23you give the freshman more reps? Tccafe more reps? Like does Dalan Hayden
- 32:29immediately go to the back of the line. Because we have seen in the
- 32:31past where guys announced they are transferring but still remain at Ohio State, whether
- 32:37it's to graduate or just to get them through spring. Kyle Trout did it
- 32:39years ago when o High State kind of needed bodies on the offensive line.
- 32:44It was announced that he's going to be transferring, but he stayed and he
- 32:47practiced. But I think the question I'm seeing from people on Twitter and things
- 32:53like that, it was Ryan Day really screwed this up. And I fight
- 32:59myself tom to like say, actually, well, actually, it's a position
- 33:04coaches that to dictate when players play. And I completely agree with the red
- 33:09shirting, not completely. I understand the red shirting last year because of the
- 33:13guys in front of him, I don't understand not the not playing against Michigan
- 33:19and Georgia as a true freshman. I don't, you know, like the
- 33:23sheer amount that he did not play. And I said this on Big and
- 33:27Me kickoff against Maryland in twenty twenty two as a freshman he had twenty six
- 33:31carries in the second half against the Terps. He had thirty carries the rest
- 33:35of his career. It's crazy. That is crazy. And you know,
- 33:40as far as what he's going to do, I don't think. I haven't
- 33:44seen anything definitive that he's not going to be practicing with the team anymore.
- 33:49Is going to be practicing with the team? Have you? No? I
- 33:51assume he's going to stick with the team, but just should you be giving
- 33:55him reps that could go to somebody else? Well? And I don't I
- 34:00don't know that that's necessarily true because I believe last year when Lorenzo Styles Junior
- 34:05announced that he was transferring, he stopped practicing with Notre Dame. So you
- 34:08might see him just not practice because I don't know how much you really gain
- 34:14continuing to practice, Like what do you gain by running the ball in the
- 34:19spring game? And you're risking injury and that kind of stuff. It feels,
- 34:22I mean, it feels to me like if you've made the decision that
- 34:24you're definitely leaving and you're not leaving the door open for a Bryson Rodgers kind
- 34:30of boomerang transfer. I think if it was me, I'm I don't think
- 34:36I have a lot to gain by continuing to practice, and I guess running
- 34:38the risk of injury. But we'll see what he decides to do. You
- 34:42know, as far as whether this was mismanaged, I look at the fact
- 34:46that he had multiple years of Tony Alfred and this was decided by Tony Alfred,
- 34:52and I definitely thought there were there were plenty of times that I thought,
- 34:54I can't believe they're not giving Dalan Hayden more reps. We always were
- 34:59hearing behind the scenes that it was you know, pass blocking stuff and you
- 35:02know, just just a lot of the other factors that you know, all
- 35:06the other responsibilities of a running back. It was some of that stuff that
- 35:08was keeping him on the field. It's kind of telling to me maybe that
- 35:15you know, Tony Alfred leaves, you bring in Carlos Lochlan, you've got
- 35:19a new running backs coach. It's a fresh start. And here we are,
- 35:22what a week, not even a week into Carlos Lachlan Senor, and
- 35:25now he's already announced he's transferring. He's not waiting until after the spring game.
- 35:30That tells me that Carlos Lochlin probably presumably I'm kind of reading Tea leaves
- 35:36here, but Carlos Lachlan probably doesn't re you know, view him as a
- 35:40clear, you know, guy who's going to get a lot of reps this
- 35:45year. And I think Dollan Hayden's good enough player. He's going to go
- 35:49somewhere. I've been plenty of reports, you know, over the years he's
- 35:52got some ties to University of Tennessee, and I would not be surprised to
- 35:55see that be where he ends up and for him to have a pretty good
- 35:59career there. But the fact that it's not just one running backs coach who's
- 36:04been here his whole career and he hasn't played, and you know, maybe
- 36:07that guy just doesn't like something about his game. The fact that you've got
- 36:09someone else coming in now and almost immediately he's entering the portal. You know,
- 36:16we don't know Carlos Lochlan at all. We will get a chance to
- 36:20meet him for the first time on Wednesday, when we get a chance to
- 36:22interview him. But my reading of the tea leaves there would be that I
- 36:27don't think Carlos Laughlin was viewing Dlan Hayden as being someone who was going to
- 36:31get a ton of carries this year either. I also think when Dlan Hayden,
- 36:37when the red Shirt situation was broached to him, it was done under
- 36:42the the the fact that, well, you know, Mayan's going to go
- 36:47to the pros, Trevian Henderson's going to go to the pros, so you're
- 36:52going to be the next guy up. And then Travian Henderson does not go
- 36:55to the NFL, and quincy On Jenkins transfers am and then suddenly that open
- 37:01pathway is now You've got two guys in front of you who are not blocking
- 37:06backs, but they are blocking you, and so it became a situation where
- 37:10it might just be time for a clean break. We had a video of
- 37:15him at the interviews. He was at interviews last week and people are like,
- 37:17boy, he sure seems depressed at that time. It's like, well,
- 37:21that's kind of just his demeanor at times. He's not the most boisterous
- 37:23person. But it is interesting looking back, and it'd be interesting to talk
- 37:29to day in Lachland on Wednesday to see like when did all of this?
- 37:32When did you know? And is you know how long has this conversation been
- 37:36going on? This is this something that was decided even before Lachlan or was
- 37:40this something that you know? Is just it was the time was right and
- 37:45to to break free and move on. But we'll have more of that on
- 37:50Wednesday. We'll have what we'll be live streaming that as well, so check
- 37:52that out at YouTube dot com slash bucke Huddle. Subscribe if you have not,
- 37:57if you're watching right now when liked this video, if you would,
- 38:00we would appreciate that. And of course, as always, you can find
- 38:02us at buckeyehuddle dot com. That is the absolute best way to support us.
- 38:07Become a member there, check us out, say hello to us on
- 38:09the message board, let them know that we sent you and we'll treat you
- 38:14even better than the normals. So that will do it for this episode.
- 38:17Want to thank you all for tuning in and we will talk to you guys later