Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-How have you changed as a gamer
Transcript
- 0:00So before we start the recording, remind me what the sequences here? We
- 0:05do? We do? Are we doing? Nope, that's the that's the
- 0:09that's the new show, Stave. Do I have to guess a number?
- 0:12No new show? Okay, so we're gonna have like a chat about some
- 0:17topic. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, and then there's like an interview.
- 0:20No new show, stave. Okay, are we talking about a movie?
- 0:24No, that's movie show, stave. Are we playing a game post?
- 0:30No spir report it's the sexiest show on the five g FO D network.
- 0:36Oh, hashtag channel. This is hashtag channel, a podcast about Discord
- 0:43with Ben and Steve. Well, actually a hashtag means it's a channel.
- 0:54All right, it's Steve. So this short topic before we go into the
- 0:58main topic was inspired from something someone wrote on the Discord, but not about
- 1:03this month's topic. And I don't think it's really a long enough topic for
- 1:07a full episode, but I think it's an interesting distinction. Had you had
- 1:11a chat with Scott undulation Hill, didn't you? Indeed? And he wrote
- 1:15someone wrote like, what is your worst thing at the Did you find yourself
- 1:19trapped amidst his undulations? No, Although he does have an interesting pair of
- 1:23sunglasses. Should we take turn sipping our tea? Yeah? So anyway,
- 1:30so he wrote that he thought winging at the table was worse than AP.
- 1:40Why did the British call it winging? What else would you call it?
- 1:44Whining? We call it winging. It's just a different word. Do you
- 1:48use like both interchangeably or do you always say winging? I would say winging
- 1:52usually, but you know, we understand what whining means more American, like
- 1:56the G is silent for us. Yeah, okay, So what is what
- 1:59is more annoying? Wing? And he said he told the winging was far
- 2:02more annoying than APY. Stage take it away. I think he's right.
- 2:07I think it blows my fucking mind, by the way, But carry on.
- 2:09I mean, I I can understand both sides of it. AP is
- 2:13super annoying, but whining, winging, whatever you want to call it,
- 2:17Like, having experienced it in a few games this past weekend, it just
- 2:23like it ruins your whole experience and there's almost like nothing that you can do
- 2:27about it. I think, with like the AP, you can, you
- 2:30know, gently or not so gently, encourage people to hurry up with their
- 2:34turn, and it really annoys me as well when people suffer from this.
- 2:38But like whining ruins the mood ap is simply just annoying, and it maybe
- 2:44has more potential to be correctable than the whining does, because what are you
- 2:46gonna do about someone who's whining? Just you essentially have to be like parental
- 2:51and tell them stop whining. Grow up. You're like ruining my good time.
- 2:54So I disagree, And the reason is is not because I think you're
- 3:00wrong necessarily. Oh it's an opinion, isn't it. Well, But you
- 3:02can agree or disagree with opinions, and you can also say I think your
- 3:06opinion is wrong. I think that's that's that's the thing that your your opinion
- 3:09is wrong. Yes, you can say I prefer raspberries to strawberries. Your
- 3:13opinion is wrong, Okay, great, Yeah, no, strawberries is better
- 3:16than raspberries. Fuck yourself subjective anyway, So coffee is better than tea by
- 3:21the way, your mind anyway? This I agree on cookies. Do you
- 3:25mean cookies are better than cake? Biscuits are better than cake? Yeah,
- 3:29cook cookies as we call them, Well, the subset of biscuits called cookies
- 3:32are also very good better than cake. Yeah, so anyway, the point
- 3:37is it's about it's about kind of what you assume that these things are right.
- 3:40And I guess why ap annoys me much more than winging, and I
- 3:45find more intolerable than winging is because fundamentally, winging is a reaction to a
- 3:51game state, right, and sometimes you can just feel in some ways it's
- 3:55an endorsement that the game has had some effect. It is. It is
- 4:00some it is it is evidence that someone cares about what is happening. Whereas
- 4:05a p to me is taking a finite resource of mine, the most important
- 4:14finite resource that I have, which is time, and having zero concern for
- 4:20the fact that I'm going to die one day. It is complete. You
- 4:24could be using that time for self gratification well, exactly, of various kinds.
- 4:28It's completely self obsessed, it is. And the thing is, like,
- 4:31so is whining though self obsessed, yes, but the point is with
- 4:34whining, the point is not only the game state. It's also like we
- 4:38saw numerous instances in which people were whining, and over time we've seen this
- 4:43about like the game itself, and the whining becomes protracted because once someone has
- 4:47decided they're not having a good time. They want to make sure no one
- 4:50else does either, So no, see see not necessarily consciously, but that
- 4:56was the impact. That may be the impact. So thing is by saying
- 5:00I think that AP is worse than winging, it doesn't mean that I think
- 5:03winging is fine. And I'm not saying that neither. Neither do I think
- 5:06AP is. I'm not defending winging. But the point is with AP is
- 5:10that, Okay, I'm willing to concede that you never have AP. No,
- 5:14I never do so, so you never have AP. No, I
- 5:16don't know. I sweated out like a dog, exactly like sort of this
- 5:20is what you see what I'm trying to say, if you ever see me,
- 5:24We're talking about two different possible reactions to a game, and you never
- 5:26have AP, right, exactly exactly. I never have AP. So the
- 5:31point is right. The point is that I understand. I understand that AP
- 5:39can sometimes be born out of insecurity, that you don't want to look stupid
- 5:43in front of others, so you want to make sure that the thing you're
- 5:45doing is correct. But the point is with AP, often, and I
- 5:49think mostly it's borne out of a desire for victory over the magic circle.
- 5:58You are willing to disped the magic circle, by the way, monopolizing everybody
- 6:04else's time to ecount an extra couple of points. I think it's I think
- 6:11winging so excessive. Winging of course completely unacceptable, but I don't think it
- 6:15has that selfish dimension that analysis paralysis. I think it's self indulgent, but
- 6:21I don't think it's selfish in the same way. Well, I mean,
- 6:26I don't know. This could be splitting hairs. I think your point is
- 6:30valid. I think that winging is something that is far more under your control
- 6:34often than AP. I mean, certainly, there are varieties of AP that
- 6:38are, as you describe it, simply trying to optimize every single point out
- 6:42of the game at the expense of everybody else's a good time. But there
- 6:46are occasions when AP is simply a result of like not having any idea what
- 6:48to do, trying to figure it out, and being like blocked bas so,
- 6:53and that is much harder to control, even if you don't mean to
- 6:57be wasting people's time. The whining is something that everybody can totally control and
- 7:01when it when it surfaces, it's simply like people who do it choose not
- 7:05to including myself sometimes well, I've seen you, I've seen you wings at
- 7:09a board game. Two. Sure, I mean everyone's guilty of it.
- 7:11So I so on one sense, I think you're right. But on the
- 7:16so so there are some people. So occasionally it's happened to everybody that you
- 7:21get to your turn comes around and you're like, fuck, I'm really not
- 7:27sure of which past take here, and so it takes some time to process.
- 7:31I all, it almost never happens to me, It almost never happens
- 7:36to you. Playing with Karthik is wonderful because it almost never happens to him,
- 7:43and the man's a genius. He just he sees the path through the
- 7:46game. But often the thing is this is true, But actually often most
- 7:49of the reason I see for analysis paralysis is not. It is because people
- 7:55aren't fulfilling their role at the table. There's one person that we know who
- 8:00is terrible AP and usually you know the Simpsons where they go into Homer's head
- 8:05and it's just the clashing symbols. So this one person mentioning no names,
- 8:11but when they do AP, it's because the minute they take their fingers off
- 8:16the piece on the board until it comes around to their next turn. It's
- 8:20just the monkey with clashing symbols in their head. And I consider it part
- 8:24of your role around the table in between your turn, plan your bloody turn
- 8:28if you can, if the game is the type of game where you can.
- 8:31And the thing is and in no game does he do it, In
- 8:35no game does he do it. And this is the point I tend to
- 8:37play games. I tend to be drawn to games in which you can plan
- 8:39your turn in between. Firstly because for me that's where the game lies,
- 8:43that's where I derive my enjoyment. And secondly, you eliminate AP because AP
- 8:48just a noise, and you know it's even worse about it. There are
- 8:50some people who just like, I don't know what is it about them in
- 8:54board games, they can just see the matrix. I wouldn't necessarily say Karthik
- 8:58is like this, but I think Terresa is kind of in this category where
- 9:01they're just like, they have a natural talent for games, yes, and
- 9:05when they win, they will often win like very big. But for the
- 9:07people who suffer from this extreme AP that like, the marginal utility of it
- 9:13seems to be very small. Absolutely all of the extra thinking and worrying they
- 9:18may still win, but like by two points or by some very small of
- 9:22course, maybe in some games that's all you need to win, but like,
- 9:24why is that worth it? And so I guess it comes down too,
- 9:28so it comes down to what you can. By the way, uli
- 9:31Uliblay also finds this to be extremely egotistical. So it comes down fundamentally,
- 9:37what do you consider the play of a game to be. Do you consider
- 9:41it to be facilitating social instruction between people or do you consider it to be
- 9:46a demonstration of your ability to master the system within the game. If you
- 9:52are someone who has the latter opinion, AP is absolutely no problem, because
- 9:54that's part of the mastering. I am someone who formally thinks, well,
- 10:00AP is such a is so deadly because it fundamentally overrides the reason why I'm
- 10:05there, which is for everyone to enjoy the game. I think it's tough
- 10:09for people to know how they should behave in a game. Obviously, you
- 10:11should try to win, but I think some people make the mistake of believing
- 10:16that who wins is actually important. And that's the dividing line I would say,
- 10:20if I have to draw a line, so of course you should try
- 10:22to win. Otherwise, like why you there. I mean, you're gonna
- 10:26end up like playing in some arbitrary way that's not gonna be fun for anybody.
- 10:30But you don't have to try to win so badly that winning becomes the
- 10:33point and you're like proud of the fact that you win, you and you
- 10:37want to like gloat about it and hold it over people's heads that you won
- 10:39and they didn't, which I think is just childish and stupid. We don't
- 10:45play any of these games enough to ever any one of us become like masters
- 10:48of them for the most part. Right, Let's just like play the game
- 10:50and enjoy the game for what it is. Like. We enjoy the game,
- 10:52enjoy the mechanisms, enjoy exploring it, enjoy being around a table with
- 10:56other people who you may or may not like, but I hope that you
- 11:00do like. Who actually wins is inconsequential ultimately, I guess. So there's
- 11:05two reasons you're saying that because you never win? Is that generally what they're
- 11:09right? Right? So the thing is, I think there's two reasons why
- 11:11I I think AP is more egregious than winging right for two reasons. One
- 11:18is just and this is absolutely true. I fucking Winget. This is what
- 11:26I was alluding to earlier. I know, And so I'm I'm more,
- 11:31of course because I'm because I'm self obsessed like everybody is, and you're tempestuous
- 11:35Bend Mattics. I'm more sympathetic because like irascible. Yeah, I'm more.
- 11:39I'm more sympathetic to those people who have reactions that you may find sort of
- 11:46weird more than sort of annoying sometimes because I see the pathway there, I
- 11:50see how they've got there. So I'm more sympathetic. And that's that's reptilian.
- 11:54It's clearly true. Yeah, I I access more of my reptilian brain
- 11:58than other people do. Right, if I were playing games like I could
- 12:03imagine a scenario in which, like, let's say we're playing Go, I
- 12:05actually don't want to play Go with you if you suck at it. If
- 12:09if my my role, my my my goal is to become better at Go.
- 12:13Sure, which is what you would probably want to do if you're playing
- 12:15Go or Chess or similar games. Therefore, you want a challenge, you
- 12:20want to play against someone who is pretty decent, and like, well,
- 12:24this often comes up when we play euro games, like someone makes a mistake
- 12:26and they ask for a take back and like I don't, I don't care,
- 12:28and I would I would say the same in a game of chess or
- 12:33go or something like that, that's not competitive because like you would prefer First
- 12:37of all, you don't want someone to like feel stupid because they made some
- 12:39dumb mistake and egare it doesn't matter. But you would also prefer to play
- 12:43against the better move, not just have some arbitrary advantage over somebody. This
- 12:48is why modern board games are great in the sense that they do offer that
- 12:52why they're great to social I don't want to say use the word product,
- 12:56it sounds so sterile, but why it's so good is a social things things
- 13:01is better than products for me in that sentence is because, as Richard Garfield
- 13:07says, they they leverage chance to kind of give everyone a fighting go at
- 13:13the game, Whereas things like tennis, go football, if you're playing,
- 13:18if you're playing so I was quite good at tennis at one point, and
- 13:22if I played against someone who was shit, none of us are enjoying it
- 13:26right, and games offer that thing. But coming back to the second reason
- 13:31why I think ap is worse than winching is because I think winging is more
- 13:35solvable than APAI. Well, I think this is like kind of kind of
- 13:41contrary to what I said before, Like I would find ap somehow more solfable
- 13:45than winging, because if someone is winging, like they can control that behavior.
- 13:48Some people seem not to be able to control the ap And for sure,
- 13:52I would rather play a game with someone who's playing the game for the
- 13:56fun of the game, Like we're trying, like we're playing against the game.
- 13:58We're trying to figure the game out, not simply trying to to defeat
- 14:01each other in the game, and and like and optimize every little thing.
- 14:05But like, the whinning just really triggers me, especially when it comes from
- 14:11the people who often end up winning anyway, which is quite a few of
- 14:13the people who also have a p But anyway, those people for whom winning
- 14:18is so important, they will like complain about the game and how they're doing.
- 14:22Oh so and so is gonna win, oh blah blah blah blah and
- 14:26uh. And this kind of whining by the people who end up winning all
- 14:28the time really does me in. And so the thing is, though,
- 14:31I think if you turn around to someone and say, hey, I mean,
- 14:35none of us have this social courage often, But if you say,
- 14:39hey, can you keep it down a bit, you know you're gonna be
- 14:41fine. It's fine. Or do what we do often, which is just
- 14:46to sit there going me me men. This is the best solution, solution.
- 14:50But I think the people with AP, you're gonna have a much harder
- 14:52time stopping them fucking AP. Yeah, it's much harder, I think,
- 14:56and so and so this is this is the point, the reason I think,
- 14:58the reason I I think AP. I think both things annoy me,
- 15:01but I'm more sympathetic to Windy because I do it, and that is a
- 15:05failure of mine. I'm not gonna say it isn't. But I just think
- 15:09winging is fixable in a way that APE is. Now. I wonder why
- 15:13Scott undulation Hill finds winging to be worse, But he tell you I can't
- 15:18remember because I was a bit hungover, but he just said, I just
- 15:20find it much worse. He seems to be a particularly mild mannered, even
- 15:24tempered, I would dare say, phlegmatic individual. Again, that may be
- 15:28it because he's a because he's a mild mannered guy who is not prone to
- 15:33him prone to that himself. He maybe doesn't see the pathways through which that's
- 15:37achieved. Expostulations of irrepressible feelings such as you ben are sometimes known for.
- 15:43Indeed, So anyway, that was an interesting little fifteen minute chat stay,
- 15:45wasn't it? So that was that fifteen minutes? Yeah? Do we time
- 15:48flies? Doesn't it? Tempus fugit stay exactly? So can we all agree
- 15:54then on that I was right? I mean, I don't want you to
- 15:58fly into a rage after altogether too much consultation with the greatest minds in the
- 16:03world of topics we present this is so I want you in this main topic
- 16:18to reach back into your reservoirs of nostalgia. You're going to reach around into
- 16:25my reservoirs and nostalgia. Really get your nostalgia. I tug it until it's
- 16:30splurred, like a fistful of nostalgia. Yeah, and then just flick it
- 16:34at the listener's ears, so their ears are like dripping like off their It's
- 16:40like drip it. It's like we're like podcast orangutans in like exactly that they
- 16:45are visiting exactly. So the topic of this one, so I just want
- 16:49to say, as a disclaimer before we go into this I've edited people's comments
- 16:52down because this is the kind of question that elicits very long answers wonderfully.
- 16:59On our discord, every topic seems to elicit very long answer. This is
- 17:02true, and some of the comments are absolutely wonderful, but I've edited them
- 17:04down just simply because I wanted to get to the the crux of what they
- 17:08were trying to say, and also that you know, for practical show purposes,
- 17:12I can't be reading three page essays. But they were wonderful, and
- 17:15if you ever feel like writing something of that length, excuse me, please
- 17:21do. But the question is, Steve, how have you changed as a
- 17:23gamer? That's the question. That's the question. How have you changed?
- 17:29How have you developed? Have you evolved for your taste? I obviously didn't
- 17:30look at this beforehand. This is this is authentic raw Live. Steve here,
- 17:37how have I changed as a gamer? I don't know. I think
- 17:40someone like I don't know that I can be objective about that. So so,
- 17:44okay, do you have a prepared answer. I'll get to me in
- 17:47a minute. I'll just help you. I'll guide you through this. Have
- 17:49the kind of games that are in your central wheelhouse of enjoyment? Shifted.
- 18:00Well. When I was a little kid, I played whatever board game I
- 18:03could get my hands on, and then all the sort of Parker Brothers and
- 18:07Milton Bradley favorites. Particularly I remember fondly thunder Road, the original Screaming Eagles,
- 18:15and Mystery Match. And I've mentioned before mouse Trap, although that was
- 18:18more about like building all the plastic shit than actually playing it. Guess who,
- 18:22I think, although I think the way it was designed, you could
- 18:26just you know, is it a man or a woman? And then half
- 18:26the things go down. Yeah. Later, when I joined the board Game
- 18:33Club, I think I think actually the bridge for me to get into that
- 18:37was Magic the Gathering, And I really don't remember how I discovered the Gathering
- 18:41at all, but I was a mega Magic player, and when I started
- 18:45going to the board game meet up, I became like a mega Empire Builder
- 18:48player. So maybe this is one way in which I've changed now that you've
- 18:52so kindly been the Virgil to my Dante and guiding me through the purgatory of
- 18:57this question. I used to play the same games over and over again,
- 19:03right, far more often than I do now. I would say every week.
- 19:07It was like either Magic and or a Train Game, History of the
- 19:11World many many times, so much Iron Dragon, so many times, Settlers
- 19:17of Catan, Carcassone, Dominion, just over and over and over again,
- 19:21the same game, never getting sick of it. Today, I'm lucky if
- 19:23I play the same game twice. I mean the way I buy games,
- 19:26I'm lucky I play at once. That I would say, this is actually,
- 19:30I don't know if this seems like a trivial answer to the question.
- 19:32This is the major difference in the way I play games now to the before
- 19:37in the nineties, I would say, like the proper beginning of my entry
- 19:40into the hobby, so as have evolved it it's your fault. No,
- 19:42I agreed entirely, so as I evolved as a game. But because the
- 19:45thing is the difference between me and you are experienced younger, I mean you're
- 19:49much younger. That are looking two years younger than me, sexier, two
- 19:52years younger than me for like a month. Yeah, So the thing is
- 19:56right, I feel so potent. You have different eras. So you have
- 20:02your teenage era, then you have this era. My gaming career is essentially
- 20:07one long era from when I moved to Berlin, right, And so I
- 20:11guess that through line is more parent to me because I don't have a big
- 20:15gap in the middle, and so I started off with games that appealed to
- 20:19me. I played loads of D and D in that gap, right,
- 20:22And I didn't do nothing in that gap. I when I was in grad
- 20:26school, I played board games with my fellow grad students. I just I
- 20:30had no money and I didn't I didn't buy a lot of board games,
- 20:33so I just played what I had, and that was literally Dominion, History
- 20:37of the World. I had Twilight what's it? What's it called, Imperium,
- 20:44Twilet Imperium third edition, which was jank as fuck. I didn't like
- 20:47it. And I had Carcassone. I had Settlers, I had Tigris and
- 20:49Euphrates, and you know the train games. I just I didn't play them
- 20:56often. Though I now play games every week, right, sometimes more than
- 20:59once a week. Back then it might have been once a month. So
- 21:02the through line is much more tenuous, right, But it's there, and
- 21:06like loads of D and D. Actually we had a long running D and
- 21:08D campaign in my grad school years. But it's not like it's a little
- 21:14bit discontinuous. For sure, I would say dramatically change when I came to
- 21:18Berlin, dramatically, I was like, suddenly, as I expected, in
- 21:22like the motherland or shall I say fatherland of board games, and I was
- 21:26able to go to Essen and Berlin, Bret spiel Khan and Rudy's were like
- 21:30every week it's something new, and I had never been exposed to this cult
- 21:34of the new before and so I guess with me, I naturally so when
- 21:38you first get into the hobby, and I got into I'd done other gaming
- 21:44things in the past, but never really into it. Whereas when you first
- 21:48get into the hobby, you obviously climb into the hobby through games the little
- 21:53lighter, but also I naturally had an entrance into the hobby through games that
- 21:59appealed to who I am Mousey essentially. So it was very social deduction,
- 22:03a very sort of interactory games, games that lived above the table very much
- 22:10not necessarily mechanically dependent in that way. And then I discovered midweight Euros and
- 22:17then I was just like, Oh, this is what games are about.
- 22:19And what's really funny is I think you go through that phase and I still
- 22:23think midweight Euros are my wheelhouse essentially. But what's interesting is you end up
- 22:27becoming disillusioned with that, and I think with the modern and I'm unsure whether
- 22:34my disillusionment with midweight eurogames is because of the development in modern game design that
- 22:41they seem very overwrought and sort of frankly poorly designed in many cases, or
- 22:48it's just that, you know, you naturally sort of climb out of something
- 22:53that you've been into and move into a different genre. So I went through
- 22:57a phase of being into small games no thanks skull king those sorts of things,
- 23:03arbore eat them. And then I went through a phase which is now
- 23:07rising up again, which was coin games and more more complex, more challenging,
- 23:15rules wise games, and I will never be I don't think I will
- 23:18ever be a devotee to that sort of genre because I just I hate reading
- 23:22fucking rules. Essentially, I think we've gone in the opposite direction a little
- 23:26bit. The game group I played in the nineties was full of like middle
- 23:30aged men playing war games. I didn't play loads of them, but I
- 23:34played enough of them, like Circus Maximus and Titan and these, like a
- 23:38lot of these old fashioned games that just are very heavy, have lots of
- 23:41rules. Nobody wants to play them anymore. Fortunately I didn't have to ever
- 23:45teach any one of them. I didn't have to learn anyone of them.
- 23:47I never owned any of them. Just I played whatever people brought, and
- 23:49you know, sometimes it was some giant hex map that they spread over a
- 23:52table, and I just I worked my way through it as best I could.
- 23:55I was never very good at it, and often it was, you
- 23:59know, some train game, and I ended up gravitating more in that direction,
- 24:02and I kind of moved away from the heavier war games, so I
- 24:06never became like a proper full on wargamer in that sense. But I've always
- 24:10been up for a much longer complex board game in any genre, like History
- 24:15of the World, one of my favorites. It always took all day to
- 24:18play, and if you play the original version, it probably still would.
- 24:21And this type of game among the gamers I hang out with now it's just
- 24:26not it's just not gonna happen. People don't want to play games that take
- 24:29that long anymore, which is fine. I think the one to three hour
- 24:33midweight euro games are great, and I'm perfectly happy to have landed there.
- 24:37It's fun to occasionally play a heavier game like like Vimar or a coin game.
- 24:40I think any card driven game is great. I love this for me,
- 24:45like you know, new discovery of a game. So so I think
- 24:48the reason the reason that I that I really like eurogames in a way that
- 24:52I don't like other heavier genres, And I think why I'm so annoyed by
- 24:56the modern propensity for eurogames to be complex, no, no, complicated rather
- 25:04than complex, is that the beauty of eurogames is they're self propelling machines.
- 25:11You learn the rules, start the engine, and it goes and you don't
- 25:15need to stop the engine, look in the rule book, start the engine
- 25:18again, and then go wargames. That's built into wargames right that you look
- 25:22at the way wargames rules are written. It's implied in that you're constantly referencing
- 25:29things right, And some people love that. I don't, And so I
- 25:33love that idea that a game is just a self propelling machine that once you
- 25:37start it, it goes to the end. I think having to refer to
- 25:41rules is a bit annoying. I guess a lot of wargamers, well some
- 25:45of them will have to do this, some of them will not. I
- 25:48don't mind in general, a game that takes all data play, because I
- 25:52think it's interesting to see a game unfolding over that long period of time and
- 25:57sort of moving back and forth over who who's in the lead and who isn't.
- 26:02So the length that never bothered me. I suppose having like loads and
- 26:04loads of heavy rules. I mean, I can totally understand how that's annoying.
- 26:08I wonder if to some extent this is not a cultural thing, Like
- 26:12I just didn't end up hanging out with a lot of war gamers. In
- 26:15the mid two thousands, when I lived in Princeton, I would go to
- 26:18the Princeton University Board Gaming Club. I don't know if I ever mentioned it
- 26:22to you. I didn't go a lot because everyone there was a dickhead.
- 26:25But I was always into games, Like I never stopped being into games like
- 26:27the Great Lacuna in my life is only due to lack of opportunity, right,
- 26:32lack of interest, And I went where I could to play games,
- 26:36and I just didn't happen to have a lot of friends who were interested.
- 26:38And when I would go to like these groups, it was like hard to
- 26:41find people I was simpatico with. Yeah, I do remember though, bringing
- 26:45Tigris and euphrates to the Princeton University Board Game Club one night and I kicked
- 26:49all their asses, right, fuck you East Coast elitists, and so yeah,
- 26:55and I think, but just just just wrap up the point, like
- 26:57I never fell in with like the Warhammer crowd either, Like I never became
- 27:02a hardcore minis player. And if I, if I had happened to have
- 27:04friends who were into that, I might have become into that. And it
- 27:08seems like to get into war games you somehow have to end up in that
- 27:11community. And I don't. I don't know how people do it. I
- 27:14mean, maybe they play one, they find that they like it, and
- 27:15then they seek it out. I have no idea. Well where I ended
- 27:18up, I think is I think what's interesting you You become a part of
- 27:22community. You become a part of a community through sheer, bloody mindedness and
- 27:26force of will. I became part of the board game community because I really
- 27:30wanted to become part of the board game community. And you know, I
- 27:33think games are welcoming, but I'm sure other communities are as well. I'm
- 27:37sure the Jigsall puzzle community is welcoming. I'm sure the knitting community is welcoming.
- 27:41It's just it's just you get really into something and you want to do
- 27:44it enough that you end up doing something that really bothers me. Is this
- 27:47this artificial distinction that that some people seem to insist on between like euro games,
- 27:53like the board games that we play, and war games. Maybe it's
- 27:56a distinction between a game where you actually have a board or maybe some limited
- 28:00set of components versus like an unfoldable map that's unmounted and a bunch of little
- 28:04counters. I don't know, Like, to me, these are all board
- 28:07games, and it is it is possible to enjoy all of them, even
- 28:11if you have a preference for like one type. So you don't think you
- 28:15don't think general distinctions about it. Not that I think I think it's okay,
- 28:18but like they always end up being like you get into this like no
- 28:22true Scotsman situation, or you're just like begging the question about what is and
- 28:26is not a war game? Like they're not like very interesting debates to me,
- 28:29Like I was, I was chatting with a ceed hunter on the discord,
- 28:33And when I say chatting with him, I mean that he was explaining
- 28:37to me using very precise legalistic language. I was wrong about everything I was
- 28:40saying, which I always enjoy, and you know, he makes very good
- 28:44arguments. And I don't like think deeply about the shit that I post to
- 28:47our discord, as everybody like piles on to pick it apart, which which
- 28:52which is fine because it gives me a chance to talk about it now.
- 28:53And I had said, I really like what GMT is doing. I think
- 28:56they have a lot of really great games that seem to me to be overlooked
- 29:00by the rest of the hobby, and that GMT as a publisher is quite
- 29:03underrated compared to a lot of others. Like you go to Essen and they
- 29:07have like a little booth like I've seen them have sometimes like a larger presence,
- 29:11but like last year they had like a table basically and a couple of
- 29:14bookcases. And it was pointed out to me that, you know, maybe
- 29:17Essen is not like representative of all of board gaming, that wargaming in particular
- 29:22is not well represented there. I'm like, well, I don't know.
- 29:23It seems like you can get anything at Essen and and Essen. You know,
- 29:27if any place represents like the totality of board gaming, it is this
- 29:33place. And you know, if you want to see like war among wargamers,
- 29:38I think was the argument among war gamers. GMT is a big deal,
- 29:41like, no question about it. But then we have to say,
- 29:44well, wargaming itself is very niche, and therefore GMT is going to be
- 29:47very niche. Like I just don't care about any of this. All I'm
- 29:48trying to say is they make great games that get overlooked by people who only
- 29:52play mid eight euros, and they could occasionally dip into this and not have
- 29:56to feel like I play this but not that. So I think it's interesting.
- 29:59I think I think genre distinctions clearly exist. I think you can something
- 30:03they exist independently of us though, so sure they sure they just so.
- 30:08I think they do. But I think I very much subscribe to the pornography
- 30:12definition for shorthand if I was to look at it, if I was to
- 30:17look at it, you know, deeply, I think you can. I
- 30:21think you can draw general distinctions. But when you think of a war game
- 30:25where you think of a euro game, you kind of know it when you
- 30:27see it, right, I just I just don't care. I just think
- 30:30war gamers shouldn't think I don't play that ship and what I think war gamers
- 30:33shouldn't think I will never play a word. I think to some degree you're
- 30:36building a straw man here because what I've seen, which is interesting. I
- 30:41think Rodney Smith is a great example from what it played. He is someone
- 30:44who got into the hobby through through very ameerror trashy games. Right then he
- 30:49went through very eurogaming an obsession, and now he's very much into war games.
- 30:56And I see with see with most gamers that they have a happy place.
- 31:03But I think most gamers generally will give something a go, and I
- 31:10think it's completely justified to say, oh, it's not for me, And
- 31:12I think I think the problem is we fall into We do fall into a
- 31:18trap. All of us fall into a trap of saying it's not for me,
- 31:22therefore it's not good. But at the same time, at the same
- 31:27time, I think it's also we had a discussion with people over in Portugal
- 31:33where he said the only valid thing is to say it's not for me,
- 31:37to not make a quality of judgment, just to say I didn't like this
- 31:40game, it's not for me, which is just clearly not correct. Right.
- 31:44I think you can say that things are bad, but I think to
- 31:48call a whole To condemn a whole genre is because you don't like it.
- 31:51It is clearly fucking absurd, right, I mean I don't personally believe in
- 31:56like the prior existence of concepts or anything like that, but it's like that
- 31:59interesting to me. All I'm trying to say is like totally agree, like
- 32:01things are, they could, They may or may not be for you.
- 32:05You may or may not have a happy place. I was simply making like
- 32:08the superficial statement that GMT produces a lot of great games that I think are
- 32:14generally overlooked by the mainstream of the hobby, as represented by essen, as
- 32:19represented by board game media. I understand that there's like probably a whole world
- 32:22of wargame media and cons and publishing that I'm not aware of. So this
- 32:29is by definition a sort of like darker corner. So so I think it's
- 32:32I think it's interesting if it's all about it's all about perspective, right,
- 32:37because if you're a wargamer, GMT is the towering Again, but this,
- 32:42this is the counter argument. If you're a wargamer, which is a special
- 32:45type of gamer who only cares about the thing is the thing is these historical
- 32:49conflict simulation games and wargames have such a high barrier to entry that again,
- 32:54it's this thing you have to have a real also will, real bloody mindedness
- 33:01to get into it. In a way, this is why midweight Euros are
- 33:06essentially the sort of center of the hobby, because they deliver a brilliant experience
- 33:09and they're very easy to get into, and even hardcore gamers are like,
- 33:15I can't read a fifty page. Yeah sure, I mean I'm not talking
- 33:19about Hexton counter games per se. But I think GMT publishes a lot of
- 33:22stuff that doesn't like fall into that category that a typical heavy eurogamer can certainly
- 33:28play and enjoy, whether it's Dominant Species or any coin game or any car
- 33:31driven game. I mean, they publish loads of them. They don't all
- 33:34have to be you know, hexagonal maps or anything like that. And this
- 33:37is why I say they they publish a lot of really great games that don't
- 33:40seem to get a lot of like coverage and attention and true underrated, but
- 33:45you have to realize, so not underrated among wargamers obviously, but like then
- 33:50what wargaming has to offer you might say is underrated by GMT, haven't means
- 33:53done. What GMT in particular haven't done in the last sort of maybe six
- 33:58or seven years, is pubably to crossover title, and they're all expensive and
- 34:02they're hard to get. Shipping is so high, especially for Europeans. When
- 34:07I got to maybe skewed living here. When I got into gaming in twenty
- 34:09twelve, Dominant Species was a thing, a big thing. Gamers talked about
- 34:15Dominant Species. It would feature in top one hundred best Games of All Time
- 34:20lists. It's just Dominant Species hasn't had a significant reprinting a few years.
- 34:24Do you think Marine was as big as Splash? No, No, it
- 34:29wasn't anyway anyway, anyway, this very but we've got to move on.
- 34:31This is not about us, Steve. It's not about you, isn't it.
- 34:35No? Is it about you? No, it's about Amberona, he
- 34:38says. I think the types of games I play have changed over time to
- 34:43fit where I'm at at my life at that point of time. The core
- 34:45reason for playing games hasn't changed much. I think I've always played them to
- 34:50have fun with family and friends. And I think this is a very astute
- 34:54point, right, because I think there is an ooer reason for playing games
- 34:59and for me it's the same thing. And all of that sort of all
- 35:04of that sort of overlay of what kind of games I like is just a
- 35:07way of facilitating that central call desire. Is that correct? Well? One
- 35:10of the problems with this question is people are going to speak from their own
- 35:15experience in ways we can't really like, agree or disagree with. It's just
- 35:19oh, I can I can tell people. I could tell people their opinions
- 35:22are wrong. I mean, you do all the time. But in this
- 35:24case, is like, has gaming changed for you? Like it has or
- 35:27it hasn't. I don't know. I mean, what are we gonna say
- 35:29about it? In this case? What I can speak to is this mention
- 35:34of family and friends. I think that board gaming has a massive like family
- 35:38element to it, especially in Germany, where families play all kinds of board
- 35:44games, and I think that like part of the history of German board gaming
- 35:46is that they're made for families. Like she feels, yrs is aimed directly
- 35:50at families, I guess, And when I think about it, it was
- 35:53never the case for me. I don't think I've ever played a game with
- 35:57a single member of my family, right, No, my parents, maybe
- 36:00my brother when I was growing up, but I don't even remember it,
- 36:02so it couldn't have made that much of an impression on me. I think
- 36:05I think we probably he and I did for a time, but like since
- 36:09I was like eight years old, not at all. It's just not a
- 36:13thing for me to play orgames with my family. I now play them occasionally
- 36:15with my wife, and I expect in the future if I have a family,
- 36:20it will be different. But I think I did grow up having it
- 36:22as like a family thing. I think me and you were similar, and
- 36:23I think that's probably why we've become friends, is that we seek our family
- 36:28and our friendships not in our family, right and so and so part of
- 36:34so I see in you, and you know this is getting this is getting
- 36:38pop psychological now, but I see in you a desire to form a group,
- 36:44a solid, regular, dependable group to play games with. Right You're
- 36:49constantly talking to me about do you think this person would be cool? Do
- 36:52you think this person would be cool? And a desire to really have something
- 36:55fixed and dependable. This is clearly a desire for a proxy family. Now.
- 37:00You're much more open minded, I would say about this than I am,
- 37:04maybe much more tolerant of people's idiosyncrasies. So I think I think you
- 37:08especially see games as an as not just about playing games, as an extension
- 37:16of a relationship. And if you can find your I think you would be
- 37:21very happy if you could find the four perfect players, Me, you,
- 37:25Oui, Karthik, if we all lived in Berlin, I think you'd be
- 37:29perfectly happy to play games three times a week with those people and never play
- 37:34with anyone else. Right, I think it's a perfectly salient observation. And
- 37:38whereas me, I'm constantly I'm also searching for a proxy family, but I'm
- 37:45also searching for so you said to me on Sunday when we were leaving Ria
- 37:50Kon, I'll go in and check. I'll go and find Maeople Pete.
- 37:53You don't go because you'll end up fucking talking to people for forty five minutes.
- 37:59Right, I'm constantly on the search for wider experience, and I'm very
- 38:04conscious of having a core of people who I consider close. But I like
- 38:07having acquaintances. I guess it's less important. You're much more of an extrovert
- 38:13than I am. And you know, I think you get energy from these
- 38:16experiences. I mean, this is why you're the ideal person to do what
- 38:19you do. You want to talk to everybody? Yeah, I don't really
- 38:22So I mean for me, every one of these things that we go on,
- 38:24it's always more about the games than the people. And like through you,
- 38:29I've gradually gotten to know people, but I'm not trying to meet everyone.
- 38:31It's like one person at a time I can sort of like handle to
- 38:36bring into my own magic circle. So you know, one year it was
- 38:39famed board game designer Isaac Shalev, and then eventually Karthik and then Uli.
- 38:44In a way, you're like the advance guard. You sort of like go
- 38:47out into the field and just accumulate all the people, and I sort of
- 38:51like curate the collection exactly. Anyway, So Mina says, originally I played
- 38:57Magic the gatherings. A tournament player, not a great one, not a
- 39:00bad one, a pro tour player without great success. If you're playing on
- 39:04the pro to or for Magic, that suggests you're a very good magic play.
- 39:07Can anybody just opt to do that? I have no idea, but
- 39:10I mean to consistently play. I assume if you're if you were me and
- 39:14I could play at a pro to or event, I assume I get chucked
- 39:17out on the first round. Yes, yeah, me too. Later on,
- 39:20I get back to gaming when a friend of mine introduced me to Carcassant.
- 39:22However, I got fed up with heavy eeur of games where the complexity
- 39:25is in the rules and game mastery. I found myself not to be interested
- 39:30anymore in games with a challenge lizing rules and complexity for the sake of itself.
- 39:34Nowadays, I tend to look for rules lighter games with more player interaction.
- 39:37I'm rediscovering classics, and I've rejuvenated my taste for Ameri trash games.
- 39:43So I found this fascinating because when I got into the hobby, after I
- 39:47went through the phase of doing social deductiony stuff, I was a meritrash gamer
- 39:55fantasy flight games, dissent, the sort of very AMERI dice rolling games.
- 40:00And then I got into Euros and they dominated my sort of gaming for eight
- 40:06years or something, and suddenly I found a desire to play ameritrash games again.
- 40:12And it is for one reason me no thunder Road. Thunder Road.
- 40:17I've seen me so what I've seen now, And this may be bullshit,
- 40:22right, this may be just me totally fucking the cart before the horse or
- 40:28whatever. But what I see in thunder Road, So my problem with ameritrash
- 40:34was always is they're not self propelling machines that you're constantly having to look at
- 40:38the rule books for little fiddly things and edge cases, whereas thunder Road seemed
- 40:43to have taken that ethos of Eurogames, that self propelling machine idea, and
- 40:47transposed it into the best glorious things that you get of ameritrash games. It
- 40:53really is the mattic. It really feels like you're doing what you're supposed to
- 40:58be doing. And the reason I picked this comment is I'm very excited to
- 41:01explore, hopefully what is a new dawn for the ameritrash genre going on in
- 41:07the future. Steve Well, I think Restoration Games is certainly giving you Christ
- 41:10for your mill there. Yeah. Well, I'm gonna also put a pre
- 41:14order because I'm a stam Kunda for what at s bretx Filga cheft for what?
- 41:19For the fuck yourself, damn Kunda, you aren't so for what's it
- 41:24called? It's not undaunted, untapped or something, it's killed. No,
- 41:30it's it's a skirmish combat game. And I showed it to you. They're
- 41:34releasing an expansion with Shakespeare and Hamlet and Prospero. Oh yeah, no idea.
- 41:38And so I pre ordered that, and that's gonna be I'm gonna try
- 41:43that. And that's another Restoration Games product, and hopefully it's going to be
- 41:45another one of these wonderful simple amritrash game. Yeah. I mean, on
- 41:49this topic, I don't mind playing a long, complex game like I'm here
- 41:52for Weimar, right, we keep talking about it. I'm here for Pendragon
- 41:54and coin games are quite long and it can be quite involved when it's worth
- 41:59it. And I to this person's point, maybe to your point, on
- 42:01occasion, big heavy, complex or complicated, which is the pejorative one in
- 42:07this formulation complicated, a big complicated euro games. I am also tiring of
- 42:13them because they aren't worth it. They do seem complicated for the for the
- 42:16sake of being complicated, and it's like the game, the game isn't even
- 42:20to win the game. It's just like to figure out how to even play
- 42:22the game. Whereas a game like Viymar that might very well take twelve hours,
- 42:25it doesn't feel that way to me. It doesn't feel complicated. Although
- 42:30it may be big or deep or I don't know what the correct word is
- 42:35here, but there aren't like so many different rules, interactions and exceptions and
- 42:38combos I have to think about, and so much happens on every turn.
- 42:43I actually like, I have to just stay pay attention where I'm going to
- 42:45like accidentally cheat. I'm getting really tired of that. Mabe. Maybe in
- 42:50like the euro space totally like Midway Class, you know me, I'm like
- 42:54mister classic board game. I'm totally in agreement here, and like the bigger
- 42:59and more sensive and more uh unnecessarily baroque euro games like economic euro games I'm
- 43:07not into. And you know the ones I'm always talking about that I like
- 43:09the best splotter. They're not like this at all. These are exactly what
- 43:13I like. They're they're hard to play, hard to win, hard to
- 43:15play, I should say they're hard, they're hard to win, they're hard
- 43:17to be good at, but rules wise, completely ruthless and efficient. Y
- 43:22right, yeah, I mean I I could play Antiquity right now and I
- 43:24basically know how to play it. Put any Vita al aserta game. I
- 43:28hate to pick on him, it just comes to mind. I don't know
- 43:30how to play any of them, even the ones I have played before,
- 43:32Like, I will not remember how to play them. I will have to
- 43:36constantly be referring to the rule book. But once I've sat down to a
- 43:38splatter game and I've played it like one round, I'll know what I'm doing.
- 43:43Vymar, big heavy game, we knew what we were doing pretty quickly,
- 43:45I would say. So, I'm still here for those games that are
- 43:49that are worth that kind of investment, but not for the ones that aren't.
- 43:52So now, Lules, apparently experience is meant to change, meant to
- 43:58change you. I always say that I feel the same person that you were
- 44:00ten years ago. You've wasted ten years of your life. I don't he
- 44:04coined that phrase. He says that he always in trouble. Then he always
- 44:07says it. I don't think he coined that price. And for me,
- 44:10the same applies to gaming. If years of being exposed to games have not
- 44:13changed your approach to the hobby, what have you actually done? So this
- 44:16is really interesting. It's interesting. It is personal growth, meant to be
- 44:20part of your well. This is the pinterface with the hobby. This is
- 44:22the point, right, It's an interesting way of phrasing it, because I
- 44:24think a lot of people talk about their gaming career in those terms, because
- 44:30what that implies is promotion, It implies forward momentum, It implies a gross
- 44:37Do you think that's bollocks? Yeah? Let me let me respond to this
- 44:43with maybe a controversial statement. So I sometimes joke about everyone on our discord
- 44:45being a dickhead. Right, we are included among the discards, right.
- 44:51And what I've seen it as a common phenomenon among board gamers, the ones
- 44:57who are in the hobby for a really long time and have played so many
- 45:00games, like it's like impossible for us not to become jaded. And I've
- 45:04met so many board gamers who seem to basically hate boards every game. Yeah,
- 45:08they like they do it as some kind of compulsion or at least like
- 45:12this is essentially this is where all their friends are and what they're doing,
- 45:15So they continue to do it as like this, like you know, dead
- 45:19exercise. I don't know, like no game you can't bring up a game
- 45:22that you enjoy and share your joy and enthusiasm for it with them without them
- 45:27immediately like critiquing it and saying it's not that good or telling you about ten
- 45:30other games that are better, like this is what maybe this and many other
- 45:36types of hobbies, types of hobby. Yeah, does two people you eventually
- 45:40overtok hobbits? Yeah? You you just like you can't even enjoy it anymore
- 45:46because you're you're just so like inured, right, Like I don't feel this
- 45:50way about myself. If a new game comes along, that's good, I
- 45:52will genuinely love it. But I do see a lot of and I hope
- 45:57this never happens to me, a lot of super veteran game we just like
- 46:00don't seem to like games anymore. But there is this fundamental thing, right,
- 46:04it is undeniable. And this is not progress, by the way,
- 46:07No, I agree, but that there is this undeniable thing that when you
- 46:09get into something, the more you get into it, you become a connoisseur
- 46:13you become, and the less you are, the less you're surprised, and
- 46:16so the less you have when you initially get into games. I remember,
- 46:21especially, I would sit there playing games and just go, my god,
- 46:23I love this. And it was almost every game I was playing, because
- 46:27I was just being introduced to this amazing new world that I had no idea
- 46:30about but and new gamers that we meet still have this, yes, and
- 46:36it happens less. But I felt that playing Distilled, I was so impressed
- 46:40with it. I was just like, this is really good and it was
- 46:45really exciting, and and I don't want to make generalizations here, but it
- 46:50could be inevitable that everybody or most people, eventually some number of people become
- 46:54dickheads, right, and they just can't enjoy games anymore. And you know,
- 46:58progress, I don't know what progress looks like, but if you can
- 47:00hold on to some part of that enthusiasm, I think that's good. And
- 47:04Breakdown says, I've been in this heavily for ten years. I've seen lots
- 47:07of things that repeat themselves. And I'm becoming more commudgeonally. I think that's
- 47:12inevitable. I think becoming more curmudgeonally is inevitable with age. But also I
- 47:15think it's inevitable with an art form that it's inevitable with an art form that
- 47:21is heavily based on minor iteration. Right. Game design is a minor iterative
- 47:28form, and so you will see a lot of things. We played at
- 47:31Loria Kon a trick taking game that I thought was really original, not perfect,
- 47:37but really original, really interesting, and took trick taking in a direction.
- 47:43Yeah. Yeah, the Game of a Dune that we played, and
- 47:45I thought it was really fascinating. But I'm also if someone says to me,
- 47:51I've got this game it's a midweight worker placement game, I instantly don't
- 47:57think, Oh God, I've played a million midweight worker players. I just
- 48:00can't be able to play another one. I think I like midway work placement
- 48:02games. I'm probably not gonna love it. I'm probably not gonna get a
- 48:07fucking adrenaline boost, but I'm probably gonna have an hour and a half of
- 48:10a really excite, a really enjoyable time and come away. The thing is
- 48:15not everything has to be the fucking Godfather, right. I think a lot
- 48:17of these games are just like so desperate to be novel somehow that they end
- 48:21up like piling on the mechanisms, and and for the classic games that don't
- 48:24need to do that, then it's you know, you enjoy the game for
- 48:28the mechanisms because it's an enjoyable experience. It slots right into your brain.
- 48:31You can play it like you know how to play it, and then you're
- 48:36just like distinguishing based on theme, and you can enjoy a game that could
- 48:39have any theme whatsoever or no theme at all. But the theme, I
- 48:44don't know, like helps you find your way into it somehow. And the
- 48:45thing is, I've heard you use this criticism before that like, I just
- 48:50didn't find it particularly original. And it's not a criticism, it's it's not
- 48:53something that I ever look for. Like if I find it, then I
- 48:58go. This is why Splotter except exciting, because they seem to be breathtakingly
- 49:02original and everything they do. But the point is we discussed this in Lisbon.
- 49:07Right. I like familiarity. I like going to the caf I have
- 49:09been before. I like staying in the same place that I have been before.
- 49:13I like going to the same campsite that have been before. I find
- 49:15a I guess because I live a chaotic life. I find a comfort in
- 49:21familiarity and repetition. And so I would never use if someone says to me,
- 49:27oh, it's not very original, that tells me nothing as to whether
- 49:30I think it's of quality or not. Right. Yeah, I wonder if
- 49:34I deploy this argument more often with euro games, because so many of them
- 49:37seem so similar to one another. Whereas the games that I have the most
- 49:42nostalgia for, you, you could make an objectively correct argument that like History
- 49:47of the World or Iron Dragon, as compared to modern games, is either
- 49:52not that good or has or really shows its age, and you'll never convince
- 49:55me of it. So I have a question. So I have such positive
- 49:59feelings about them from my youth, I will continue to have fun with them
- 50:01playing. And I have a question with you on this, And I think
- 50:04you just kind of answered it though, because I've played Iron Dragon, but
- 50:07I came to Iron Dragon like three or four years ago. Yeah, and
- 50:10I'm gonna I didn't find it particularly prepossessing. We gotta play Damp Frost.
- 50:16So do you think that you'll love for Iron Dragon? And I don't think
- 50:22this is in any way. I don't think this is any way less worthy
- 50:27than any other any other reason for appreciating something. Do you think your appreciation
- 50:31for it is based on nostalgia. I'm sure it's a big part of it.
- 50:35I don't think I ever analyzed games the way you do until meeting you
- 50:42and getting involved in this, or I'm like I'm comparing and contrasting and thinking,
- 50:45you know, intellectually about about them in some way. If I were
- 50:50to do that, I might be able to come up with some argument as
- 50:52to why Iron Dragon, you know is or is not a good game.
- 50:55But like the thing is, my heart would never be in the argument,
- 50:58sure, because I so viscerally respond to it right that I'll never really believe
- 51:02it. But like, looking at it, well, you like draw some
- 51:07some some rail lines on a board with crayon and then it's pick up and
- 51:09deliver. It's like not actually that complicated, and it takes a really long
- 51:14time to do because of the way the game is designed, and you know,
- 51:17compared to modern like compared to Age of Steam, it's like it's like
- 51:21nothing of a train game. I'm very much a believer that qualitative criticism is
- 51:25all basically post talk justification of a visceral reaction anyway, But you know,
- 51:31it's it's far easier for me to do this with with games that I play
- 51:35now, because with my like with like recency bias, I'm more likely to
- 51:42be like I don't want to say, objective, but less steered by any
- 51:45kind of nostalgia. So Severn says, and I'm going to read the whole
- 51:51sentence, but I'm only interesting sort of part of the sentence and asking you.
- 51:54I think the more I dive into design, the larger my academic interest
- 51:58is, and it's what lead to me. Now I see an impulse in
- 52:05you. You can correct me if I'm wrong to academic size things like a
- 52:09natural impulse. Where I have an impulse to create something based on it,
- 52:14you have an impulse to sort of You're like Linnaeus. And you know,
- 52:19it's interesting that when you got into games almost one of the first things you
- 52:22did was make a geek list of sort of classic games I need to play
- 52:28building a cannon and building a cannon, and then making sure that you have,
- 52:32you know, experienced that canon. To what degree do you think you
- 52:37take an academic interest in games as a sort of as a sort of academic
- 52:45subject as much as a thing you do for lolls. I don't think a
- 52:52lot. I mean, it doesn't take long to make a geek list,
- 52:53right. It probably is true that I have an academic approach to a lot
- 52:58of things because I spent a huge part of my life as an academic.
- 53:00It is, in fact how I tend to think, and it has shaped
- 53:06my way of understanding the world and the way I approach any intellectual topic.
- 53:09And if I'm to take games seriously as intellectual topic, that's those are the
- 53:14tools I'm going to reach for. Right, that's like the most familiar for
- 53:16me. I don't know if I spend a lot of time thinking about it
- 53:21this way. I'm not sure what severin means here. I mean, I
- 53:22mean, one thing I can say I noticed is that I made this joke
- 53:27this year at Arria Con that I never want to play a board game again
- 53:30with a group of designers, right because they're the most miserable of the miserable
- 53:34cunts when it comes to games, because all they see are either like the
- 53:37flaws in the design or in the the the UI of the game, or
- 53:43maybe they they or the insecurities that they have that they didn't design. They
- 53:46can't stop thinking like designers. I'm just there for, like, you know,
- 53:50purely the fun of playing the game. And I wonder if this is
- 53:52what he's referring to, Like, the more you become a designer, the
- 53:55less you can stop like dissecting he theorized the game, right, And I've
- 54:00known other designers who've even said, like they don't really like, so I
- 54:05play the game at the level of theme, they're sort of like looking past
- 54:07that to the design and then either trying to like evaluate it or defeat it,
- 54:13you know, like breaking it down to essentially just like the computer program
- 54:16that's driving the game and forgetting about everything else. And I don't even know
- 54:21if you cannot do that, if you're like so inured to design that you
- 54:24just see it. I don't ever want to become that. But this is
- 54:28not where I where my academic interests lie for me. It's much more and
- 54:32maybe this is what you're referring to, like the history of the hobby,
- 54:37and like I don't want to like miss these classic games that have contributed like
- 54:42lore and even like actual like mechanisms to the game. Like I remember wanting
- 54:46to play Kless because I heard this is one of the earliest work replacement games
- 54:51and it's meant to be like also far nastier than you get in a typical
- 54:54contemporary work replacement game. And we did play it, and it's just very
- 54:58interesting to play that game and like understand more about where things in the hobby
- 55:01have come from and how things have evolved over time. So yeah, I
- 55:07probably look at it much more from this like historical materialist point of view,
- 55:10just as you tend to look at it from a kind of like like I
- 55:14don't just want to say art history, sexy baby and whatever bollocks you do.
- 55:19So Jerry Baker. Finally, Jerry Baker, healthcare hero and host of
- 55:24rival podcast Board Game Snops. I'm sorry we have rivals. Yeah, every
- 55:29other podcast is arriving. I don't consider anybody in our class. So the
- 55:32meandering course, I'm going to read this exactly because I think it belies his
- 55:38archer. Who is this Jerry from Bold Game Snaps? Okay, can you
- 55:42do it? In Jerry's acts? I can? The meandering course mad gaming
- 55:46laugh has allowed me enjoy various taps of games. Is the meandering course sort
- 55:52of like a river? Yeah? Through like Kentucky? Sometimes I avoid it
- 55:58though, Yeah, okay, well just accidentally, the meandering course and my
- 56:02game and laugh has allowed me enjoy various taps of games that I would not
- 56:08have appreciated earlier. In my laugh for this reason, I use the term
- 56:14grown instead of change. Also, it makes me feel superior to others,
- 56:20as if my mind has been enlightened. So he got lost in the performance.
- 56:25He wants to imply that he's been enlightened and he's cleverer than other people.
- 56:29And yes, Steve, I'll read you. The meandering course of my
- 56:32gaming life has allowed me enjoy various types of games. Yeah, it also
- 56:37makes phone. It also makes me feel superior to others, as if my
- 56:42mind has been enlightened. All right, let's move on to in an act
- 56:47of willful competition, we present our all right, Steve, suppose for the
- 56:57month's time. M there's an easy one. Oh oh exciting. So give
- 57:00me the list of candidates we have. Let me have a look at,
- 57:05Stevie. We have Ambi, Roona, minor noodles, apparently breakdown severin Jerry
- 57:12Baker. Well, it's definitely going to Jerry Baker because you have some fucking
- 57:15nerve criticizing someone for their grammar. That was our So what should people do,
- 57:25Steve? There are so many things people should do, do them in
- 57:30this order. First of all, go to iTunes or the Android play store
- 57:37or wherever you can reviews for podcasts and leave a review five stars. Uh,
- 57:42not only the rating, the written review in which you tell Ben how
- 57:45great he is. I cannot emphasize enough how badly his puny ego. Need
- 57:51it? I need it. Second, you need to go to where do
- 57:54we sell the T shirts? Some people dot com? People dot com where
- 58:00there is only one more Steve in the feed shirt remaining in the story.
- 58:02Is that right? It's one left? Yeah, yeah, I mean I
- 58:05don't know if we're gonna print them again. So Scott Hill had one yeah
- 58:08at laria com and his was the penultimate one. I think, yeah,
- 58:12I think there's only one left, and it's not guaranteed we're gonna print another
- 58:15run probably not. Probably get one of those or any of the other variety
- 58:20of five G for D products, lots of T shirts. I think there
- 58:22are other mugs, Yeah, and I'll yet mugs, bocks, flip flops.
- 58:27So whatever you want, basically you need merchwise, yeah, like we'll
- 58:30make it for you. Anything that you want, like giant fifty foot tall,
- 58:34like totalitarian state s Steve pointing his finger into the sky, Yeah,
- 58:39exactly, don't look at the tip of my finger, look at the moon
- 58:43exactly. Then what you need to do after that is you need to join
- 58:46the discord. If you're not already in there, you need to go to
- 58:49www. Dot five G for d dot com dot really need the www.
- 58:52If you type five G for D into your browser, it'll probably take you
- 58:55straight there. I will. And there's a pinpost on the top of the
- 59:00of that website if you click that, if you click the link that's in
- 59:04that post. Yeah, I still haven't figured out the best way of communicating
- 59:07this information. Just click the link in the pinpost. It'll take you to
- 59:09a permanent invite you get to join the discord. Join the discord and you'll
- 59:13be you'll be patured on this show essentially. Yeah, you'll you'll be getting
- 59:15to have your say in the greatest board gaming community on the internet today in
- 59:22date, following all of these steps, and I hope I don't leave anything
- 59:25out you haven't left so far, this is the most important one. You
- 59:29need to go to patreon dot com slash five G for D and join me
- 59:32to become a patron of this wonderful podcast series. Now, if you're listening
- 59:37to this right now, I guess you probably already are a patron. No,
- 59:42does this go out on the main feed? Yeah? It does.
- 59:43Yeah. Oh and I was using Cursey curse words. That's all right.
- 59:46Well, if you're already a patron, I want to encourage you double your
- 59:50pledge. You can afford it, and honestly, it's worth it. You'll
- 59:52never get to my pledge level. I challenge you to do it. If
- 59:55you're not a patron, why don't you become one? For five euros month,
- 1:00:00you can listen to everything that five G for D produces, and it's
- 1:00:04quite a lot. I don't actually know where Ben finds the time or the
- 1:00:07motivation, but he is. He's doing yeoman's work, Yeoman's for the board
- 1:00:12gaming community. And I think if you're enjoying, if you enjoy this show,
- 1:00:16I almost use German grammar there. If you're enjoying this show right now
- 1:00:21as I speak, then there's so much more for you to discover. And
- 1:00:24without your support, I will have to listen to Ben Winge until the end
- 1:00:29of time. Excellent. Well, with that, I just like to say
- 1:00:31thank you to everybody who commented, even if you didn't get featured in the
- 1:00:36show. It's your comments that make this show. It likes to thank the
- 1:00:38patrons because they are the ones that keep five D G for D going.
- 1:00:43If it wasn't for you, none of the shows would exist. And finally,
- 1:00:45I like to thank Steven Cyrek, who has always been fragrant and intelligent
- 1:00:51and I just left for me to say I did that, well, didn't
- 1:00:54I say goodbye Steve? Goodbye Steve. Without you, this show wouldn't exist,
- 1:01:07So really, you're to blame, So thank you for listening and oil
- 1:01:12up your ears for the next hashtag channel.