Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Preparing Clients for Their Deposition: Recommendations from Both Sides of the Table
Transcript
- 0:03Well, all welcome to preparing clients for deposition
- 0:07recommendations from both sides of the table.
- 0:12I am Neda Thigafi, vice chair of BHBA's litigation
- 0:17section. I am delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:21Alexis Gamliel, Susan Gutierrez, and Mithili
- 0:25Sivarajah. Mithili Sivarajah is senior counsel
- 0:29at Tech Law, Employment and Civil Rights, where
- 0:32she represents employees in cases involving discrimination,
- 0:36harassment, retaliation, whistleblower claims,
- 0:40defamation, wage and hour violations, and wrongful
- 0:43termination. With more than 17 years of experience
- 0:48exclusively on the plaintiff's side, Nathalie
- 0:51has devoted her entire legal career to advocating
- 0:54for workers' rights and advancing social justice
- 0:58in the workplace. Thank you, Mithili, for being
- 1:00here with us today. Alexis Gamliel is the founder
- 1:05and principal trial attorney of Gamliel Law,
- 1:08an elite litigation firm focusing on employment
- 1:12matters as well as personal injury and wrongful
- 1:15death cases. She is equipped with deep litigation
- 1:19experience. She dedicates her craft to the fight
- 1:23for justice for California consumers and employees.
- 1:28In her employment practice, Alexis handles a
- 1:31diverse array of discrimination, harassment,
- 1:34retaliation, and wrongful termination matters.
- 1:37She is currently serving as the financial secretary
- 1:40for CAOC, and will be the driver for the upcoming
- 1:452026 year. Thank you, Alexis, for joining us.
- 1:49And last but not least, Sudin El -Bichiris is
- 1:53a partner in the litigation department and co
- 1:56-head of the firm's math, sports, and product
- 1:58liability group. As a commercial litigator and
- 2:02trial attorney, Susan stuck with high stakes
- 2:05matters and complex disputes across industry.
- 2:09She has scied multiple high profile cases to
- 2:12verdict in state and federal courts throughout
- 2:15the country. Susan also has significant experience
- 2:18coordinating or managing large complex action
- 2:22from the Pleadance Age through discovery and
- 2:25trial including false jurisdictional matters
- 2:28involved in multiple parties, council, and political.
- 2:32Thank you Susan for joining us. And now let's
- 2:35get started. Thank you so much. I'll be kicking
- 2:38off and nice to see everybody and hope this is
- 2:41a productive session talking about depositions.
- 2:43I'll principally be talking about depositions
- 2:46from the defense side, though I think many of
- 2:48the rules are applicable regardless of which
- 2:50side of the aisle you are on. So this is sort
- 2:57of a roadmap for where I'll be speaking about
- 2:59looking at deposition basics, sort of the purpose
- 3:02and matters, what governs depositions, going
- 3:05to setting the scene. This is where we'll talk
- 3:06about some do's and don'ts and tips and tricks
- 3:09if you want to call it that with respect to preparation.
- 3:12Then moving into what I call safe harbors, which
- 3:15are themes that you want your witness to elicit
- 3:17during the deposition and also that helps provide
- 3:19comfort for witnesses when they're particularly
- 3:22facing difficult cross -examination in a deposition.
- 3:25Next is reviewing of documents. There are different
- 3:28schools of thought with respect to preparing
- 3:30witnesses with documents or without that we'll
- 3:33talk about. And then finally something that our
- 3:35practice group refers to as the memory spectrum,
- 3:38which is, as you'll see there, the anti I don't
- 3:40recall because the I don't recall testimony when
- 3:43given in especially Syrian fashion is devastating
- 3:47or can be devastating to a defense side deposition.
- 3:53So starting with Depositions, the purpose and
- 3:55why it matters. Depositions are really where
- 3:57stories harden or crystallize into evidence.
- 4:01In California civil cases, this is often, depositions
- 4:04are often where you get your first real look
- 4:06at how witnesses hold up under questioning. So
- 4:09today we'll walk through how to prepare both
- 4:11legally and psychologically so that you and the
- 4:13witness are ready when the record button starts.
- 4:18Depositions are governed by California Code of
- 4:20Procedure, sections 2025 .10 to 620. And as I
- 4:25just mentioned, they are what creates the record
- 4:26that shapes potential settlement and trial. It's
- 4:29important to know that no matter where the goalposts
- 4:31are at the end of the day, depositions are going
- 4:33to help get you there or impede your ability
- 4:36to get there in the most practical sense. Many
- 4:39cases do not ultimately make it all the way to
- 4:41trial and to a verdict. Ninety -nine percent
- 4:43of cases, don't quote me on that exact statistics,
- 4:46but the vast majority of cases settle before
- 4:49trial. And oftentimes the depositional record
- 4:52plays the key part in effectuating the settlement.
- 4:57The importance of preparation really can't be
- 5:00overstated. It creates potential for lasting
- 5:03damage in transcript form or a potential sword
- 5:06to be used going forward to create your record.
- 5:08It can be used for impeachment at trial, can
- 5:11be used for creating your summary judgment record,
- 5:13and again, for shaping potential settlement.
- 5:17The ultimate goal, what you keep in mind in preparing
- 5:19witnesses, is teaching how to tell the truth,
- 5:21which is the basic Rule of depositions always
- 5:24tell the truth but to do so in a manner that
- 5:26is calm precise and from the defense side usually
- 5:29something brief You really don't want witnesses
- 5:31going off on the long ramblings or tangents that
- 5:33will expose them to further questioning All right,
- 5:37so setting the scene preparation and tricks What
- 5:41I usually do is start with a brief a brief case
- 5:43overview and highlights of case themes. What
- 5:46is this case about witnesses? sometimes are brought
- 5:50in in their own unique capacity and they need
- 5:52to get somewhat of a bigger picture in order
- 5:54to understand where they fit within the case.
- 5:57So I like to start with what this case is about,
- 5:59what brings us here today, as well as some of
- 6:02the defensive themes that we're bringing across
- 6:03to bring the witness into the fold a bit more
- 6:06as that helps testimony during deposition. That
- 6:09starts with also explaining where the witness
- 6:10fits into the case. So you are the ultimate decision
- 6:13maker on a particular dispute. Therefore, your
- 6:16testimony is going to be really key in establishing
- 6:18what went on with the deal, what were the negotiations,
- 6:22et cetera, or perhaps it's a lower level employee.
- 6:25You were not the key decision maker. You don't
- 6:27need to carry that particular water, but you
- 6:29do need to understand and be able to explain
- 6:31in a calm and reasonable and abbreviated manner
- 6:35what it is that you do, where your knowledge
- 6:37is, where your knowledge isn't in a way that
- 6:39doesn't sound like you're making excuses. really
- 6:43pinpointing the witness to where they fit within
- 6:44the case and where they don't, because witnesses
- 6:46will have certain water to carry, but it's usually
- 6:48not the entire case. And so really giving them
- 6:51comfort as to where they fit into the puzzle
- 6:53helps set the scene. I then transition into talking
- 6:56about logistics. Many times, witnesses that I've
- 6:59encountered have not been deposed before or have
- 7:02not been deposed for a long time. And so to settle
- 7:05their nerves, I talk about some of the easy things,
- 7:06which are the logistics. Where will the deposition
- 7:09be? How long is it expected to be? Is it by Zoom?
- 7:12Is it in person? And then further elaboration
- 7:16on what those look like. Who is expected to be
- 7:18there? Essentially try to create a visual in
- 7:21the witness' mind about what to expect when the
- 7:24lights go on. That transition into substance,
- 7:28which is where we'll talk about what are the
- 7:30goals of the other side here. The goal may be
- 7:32to establish that you as the ultimate decision
- 7:34maker did not take into account XYZ reasons in
- 7:39rendering your decision. or that you did take
- 7:41into account something that is supposedly nefarious
- 7:43or unreasonable. So understanding where the other
- 7:46side is going to try to come from is part of
- 7:49the preparation. Of course, our goals and our
- 7:52tactics. One note here that our practice group
- 7:54does that is a bit unusual in comparison to what
- 7:58I've seen many depositions do is our team will
- 8:01often use direct examination after the questioning
- 8:04is concluded. And the reason for that is that
- 8:08Many of these many cases that I do in complex
- 8:10commercial litigation last years and years and
- 8:13years. Witnesses may no longer be at the company.
- 8:15I've had witnesses pass away. Memories fade over
- 8:18time. And as you pass the deposition and gear
- 8:22towards trial three, five years down the line,
- 8:26you never know what's going to happen with a
- 8:27witness either in their entirety or with their
- 8:30memory. And so it is helpful to have a brief,
- 8:33not a full blown direct examination. but a brief
- 8:3615 to 20 minute in the can direct examination
- 8:39that helps solidify your witness's story, even
- 8:43within a deposition being taken by the other
- 8:44side. We go over ground rules. These are many
- 8:48that all of us have had experience with, but
- 8:51they bear repeating, listening carefully, underscoring
- 8:54that this is not a conversation. And it's amazing
- 8:58how difficult this is, easier said than done.
- 9:00because many times witnesses get stuck into thinking,
- 9:03oh, this is just this is easy. I can answer without
- 9:05taking a beat. No. The next guideline is always
- 9:07take a beat no matter how simple the question.
- 9:10I say this even in response to, you know, what
- 9:12is your name and current job title? You build
- 9:14muscle memory by allowing yourself a moment to
- 9:17just take a breath. Of course, it allows the
- 9:20attorney the opportunity to object. And it's
- 9:22just building that muscle memory by taking taking
- 9:24a moment. The other is asking for clarification.
- 9:28Some witnesses think that they should understand
- 9:30what's being asked and that there's something
- 9:31embarrassing if they need to ask for clarification.
- 9:34But I always underscore, if you don't understand
- 9:36something or you need something repeated, do
- 9:38so because this record is being created and it's
- 9:40going to be evidence in this case. So anytime
- 9:42you don't understand a question or you don't
- 9:44understand a word, something seems off about
- 9:46the question. We can't proceed without your answer.
- 9:49So there's no harm in asking, you know, I really,
- 9:51I'm stuck on the word, you know, I'm stuck on
- 9:54the word X. Can you explain to me what you mean?
- 9:56Or I'm really not following the question or I
- 9:59lost track. That seems like it's two questions.
- 10:01There's a number of different ways to ask for
- 10:03clarification. Importantly, answering only the
- 10:06question asked. Again, this is to the point that
- 10:08this is not a conversation. This can be incredibly
- 10:11difficult, can be incredibly difficult for first
- 10:13time witnesses, but it involves A lot of training
- 10:18with mock cross -examination. We do mock examinations
- 10:23of all the witnesses before they're in composition.
- 10:25Remembering your safe harbors. This is something
- 10:27we'll talk about in a little bit. A safe harbor
- 10:29is a theme or a go -to that can be used in response
- 10:32to pretty much any question. The idea is to train
- 10:35the witness to hear the question, to understand
- 10:37the general topic that's being asked about. And
- 10:40if they falter in their memory or they get nervous
- 10:42or they're not sure what to say, they have sort
- 10:44of a go -to series of answers that can be used
- 10:48as safe harbors. The last ground rule that I
- 10:52always make sure to go over is the no jekyll
- 10:53and hide personalities. One thing jurors hate,
- 10:57and whether they're watching a deposition by
- 10:58video or watching it in the courtroom, is when
- 11:00a witness appears one way when being asked questions
- 11:02by their lawyer, they answer just concisely yes,
- 11:07no. versus when they're under cross -examination
- 11:10and they provide long -winded answers or they're
- 11:14combative or their personality just gets more
- 11:17aggressive. And so it doesn't matter at that
- 11:19point the substance of what they're saying because
- 11:21jurors are also assessing the overall credibility
- 11:23of the witness. So we really try to emphasize
- 11:25the importance of being neutral and uniform in
- 11:29giving answers across the board. Okay, so talking
- 11:35about safe harbors, what are they? Safe harbors
- 11:39are an easy to remember tagline or theme that
- 11:41can be used throughout the deposition. A safe
- 11:44harbor is meant to be very short. It's not supposed
- 11:45to be a paragraph long. It's not supposed to
- 11:48be highly argumentative. They're usually single
- 11:51phrases or one sentence, things that can be used
- 11:53in a pinch or in response to particularly aggressive
- 11:56lines of questioning. Their purpose is to reinforce
- 11:59greater case themes. Some examples are, with
- 12:03respect to a negotiation, we made the decision
- 12:05for three reasons. B and C. We made that decision
- 12:10for three reasons and repeating that over and
- 12:12over again. Or there was no culture of collusion,
- 12:16there was a culture of compliance. I do a lot
- 12:20of products liability cases that involve pharmaceutical
- 12:22drugs and so drug X was safe and effective for
- 12:26its intended use. Another one is at X company
- 12:30we're about science, not speculation. Those are
- 12:33just a few examples of safe harbors that we've
- 12:35used in prior cases that really underscore themes
- 12:37and they can be responsive to many questions.
- 12:40That's the important part too. They shouldn't
- 12:41be complete non -sequiturs. They have to make
- 12:43sense within the question and that can be used
- 12:45across different question types. When are they
- 12:48used? They're used when the witness hears certain
- 12:51buzzwords or topics. So in some of my examples,
- 12:55whether the drug was dangerous. Well, that's
- 12:58a cue for, no, the drug was safe and effective.
- 13:00or for the decision maker, what were the reasons
- 13:04that you ultimately decided to go forward with
- 13:06the deal? There were three reasons that we went
- 13:08forward with the deal. Being there at the ready
- 13:10or implications of collusive conduct. No, there
- 13:14was no, you know, whatever you want to call it,
- 13:16culture of collusion. There was a culture rather
- 13:18of compliance. They're useful when the witness
- 13:21freezes or loses confidence as can happen under,
- 13:24you know, extensive examination or over the passage
- 13:27of time. And then there's, of course, if the
- 13:29question clearly calls for it, in the example
- 13:31of, what were the reasons you made decision X?
- 13:33That's an easy one to say there were three reasons.
- 13:36And you really give the witness that as homework.
- 13:38We say when you're just driving to work, when
- 13:40you're in the shower, practice these out loud.
- 13:42Actually practice them to yourself and get comfortable
- 13:46with them. It's not enough just to know the safe
- 13:47harbors, but to actually practice them throughout
- 13:50your day. Why are they useful? How can safe harbors
- 13:53be used? The principal reason is to give the
- 13:56witnesses confidence. In addition to telling
- 13:58the truth, the ability to go into a deposition
- 14:00feeling comfortable and confident is paramount.
- 14:04And having a safety blanket or a safe harbor
- 14:06really aids in that effort. The other benefit
- 14:09is that it helps insert case themes into substantive
- 14:11answers. So later when, let's say, a jury is
- 14:15hearing the deposition testimony or is, let's
- 14:19just stick with deposition testimony. They're
- 14:22hearing themes that they may have heard referenced
- 14:24in opening statement and that they'll hear again
- 14:26in closing argument. This creates the impression
- 14:29that this is a uniform, consistent theme rather
- 14:32than something that was just concocted by the
- 14:34lawyers, but rather that it's something that
- 14:35the witnesses have adopted as the evidence bears
- 14:38out. Another benefit is that safe harbors can
- 14:42cut off certain lines of questioning. I've seen
- 14:45where the witness consistently provides their
- 14:47safe harbor answer and the examiner eventually
- 14:50moves on. Not because it isn't responsive, but
- 14:52because the invocation of the safe harbor is
- 14:55detrimental to the other side in a manner that
- 14:57they would say, okay, just forget it. I'm going
- 14:58to move on with my questioning. The next is reviewing
- 15:05documents. And it says, yes, show the witness
- 15:07documents. So stepping back, one... common method,
- 15:12and I've seen this time and time again in preparation,
- 15:15is not to show a witness documents. There's a
- 15:18belief that somehow for the witness to get to
- 15:20the deposition and to say, in response to the
- 15:23inevitable question, you know, did you prepare
- 15:24for the deposition? Yes. Did you review documents?
- 15:28There's this misconception that you want the
- 15:30witness to say no to that, as if there is something
- 15:32sacrosanct in being able to say no. Our approach
- 15:35is to do the opposite, is to show the witness,
- 15:39is depending on what type of witness it is, for
- 15:41instance, a 30b6, you have an obligation to educate
- 15:44the witness. But even if it's not a 30b6 witness,
- 15:47showing the witness's documents is not taboo.
- 15:51It helps the witness get confident in what their
- 15:55answers are and also to remember things. There's
- 15:58nothing wrong in having one's memory refreshed
- 16:01by showing documents. It makes the deposition
- 16:03seem much, much more credible and your witness
- 16:05seem much more prepared and confident. You really
- 16:07don't want the witness seeing documents for the
- 16:10first time in the deposition, feeling blindsided
- 16:14because that takes away from their confidence
- 16:15and makes them think, oh, what's coming next?
- 16:17What haven't I seen before? And you might be
- 16:20thinking, well, that's fine. I just talk to them
- 16:22about the documents. I'll be physically holding
- 16:24the document and say, you know, I want you to
- 16:26assume that there's an email that says XYZ. That's
- 16:30one way to go about it, but there's something
- 16:32that's really beneficial I've seen in preparing
- 16:34many witnesses for deposition where they actually
- 16:36get to lay eyes on their own words or the words
- 16:38of others on emails that they've received. It
- 16:41helps paint a picture in a way that simply being
- 16:42told it orally doesn't convey. Why the different
- 16:47approach? In a difference to building confidence,
- 16:49it creates a much better usable record when they
- 16:54provide substantive answers that shows that the
- 16:57witness knows what they're talking about and
- 16:58believes in what they're saying. So when they
- 17:00get to trial, it's not as if they have some sort
- 17:03of amnesia or they're saying, oh, well, that's
- 17:05what the document says. Having a witness say,
- 17:08I see the words on the page over and over is
- 17:10not effective. It erodes credibility. It also
- 17:14helps prevent witness amnesia. The witness amnesia
- 17:17is we've all seen witnesses say, I don't recall.
- 17:20I don't specifically recall. I don't recall.
- 17:22First of all, no person really talks like that
- 17:24in normal life. We say, I don't remember. So
- 17:28that's a nuance that I always tell witnesses.
- 17:30Talk a word to a normal human being. If you don't
- 17:33remember something, say you don't remember. But
- 17:35I've also had the situation where another firm
- 17:38handled the deposition aspect before we were
- 17:40brought into the case and were stuck with the
- 17:42record as it existed. And it's a deposition that
- 17:44by the time of trial gets spliced up into...
- 17:4730 minutes of a witness saying, I don't recall,
- 17:50I don't recall, I don't recall. It's devastating.
- 17:52And it can be prevented by showing the witness
- 17:55documents and actually engaging in a substantive
- 17:57discussion about what they say, what they mean.
- 18:01Those conversations are protected by privilege.
- 18:03There's really no downside into saying essentially,
- 18:07yes, this witness prepared. You all know the
- 18:09witness prepared. There's no harm in saying,
- 18:12yes, I saw the documents. In order for the documents
- 18:15that you show the witness to be producible or
- 18:20to be told about, there has to be a very series
- 18:23of specific lines of questioning before you get
- 18:25to that stage. You can't just simply ask in a
- 18:27vacuum, tell me all the documents you looked
- 18:29at in preparation. You can invoke work product
- 18:31protection for that. What you have to do is the
- 18:34other side has to show a document and establish
- 18:37whether it was one that in preparation was used
- 18:39specifically to refresh recollection. It may
- 18:41be that your witness doesn't need their memory
- 18:44refreshed. They may see a document and say, oh
- 18:46yeah, I remember this. And they didn't need the
- 18:48document to refresh their recollection, in which
- 18:50case there's no disclosure necessary. But even
- 18:52if there is, our team's approach overall is,
- 18:55so what? Embrace the fact that the witness looked
- 18:58at documents, embrace the fact that there are
- 19:00documents because it allows for an overall better
- 19:03evidentiary record. Finally, and I apologize
- 19:09for breezing through these, is the memory spectrum
- 19:12and I can spend a bit of time on this. This is
- 19:14the anti I don't recall. You might notice that
- 19:16I'm on a bit of a kick with this because so many
- 19:19times throughout the years I have seen deponents
- 19:21say I don't recall, I don't recall over and over
- 19:23and over again. And from the defensive side there
- 19:26seems to be this mentality that that's somehow
- 19:28winning the deposition. If you can get out there
- 19:31with as little substantive answers as possible,
- 19:33oh great, their summary judgment record didn't
- 19:34get any better. Hurrah. But you've got to think
- 19:36beyond summary judgment. You've got to think
- 19:38to potential trial. And even with summary judgment
- 19:41in mind, you can manage the memory spectrum in
- 19:43a way that doesn't create a tribal issue of fact.
- 19:46So we talk about explaining where you are on
- 19:50the spectrum. On one end of the spectrum is something
- 19:54you literally know nothing about, or you are
- 19:56truly a black box. I know nothing. Period I couldn't
- 20:00tell you where I was. I couldn't tell you if
- 20:02I had ever been there You know, I was essentially
- 20:04blackout at that point. That's one end of the
- 20:07spectrum The other end of the spectrum is where
- 20:10the witness has an absolutely crystal clear perfect
- 20:13memory. I remember where I was I remember exactly
- 20:16what I said It is as if I were there just moments
- 20:19ago a hundred percent crystal clear memory Memory
- 20:23really doesn't work that way Usually, witnesses
- 20:26fall somewhere in the middle of the spectrum.
- 20:29They have a general recollection of what happened.
- 20:32And what we say in those instances is, give where
- 20:34you are on the spectrum. This is where it's okay
- 20:36to provide a bit of color, a bit of detail. So
- 20:39I don't remember that specific meeting, but I
- 20:43know that when I attended meetings like this,
- 20:45the practice was to create minutes and then leave
- 20:49it at that. You've created a much more credible
- 20:51answer than I don't recall. When was the meeting?
- 20:53I don't recall. What was talked about? I don't
- 20:55recall. Who was there? I don't recall. Were there
- 20:59minutes prepared? I don't recall versus when
- 21:02was the meeting? I really don't remember. I want
- 21:05to say it was around Thanksgiving, but I couldn't
- 21:07tell you for certain. What I do know is that
- 21:10those were the types of meetings I would usually
- 21:12attend. I just can't remember if I was at this
- 21:14one specifically. That's a much more credible,
- 21:18believable answer than your Syria, I don't recall
- 21:20answers. Another way of an explanation for something
- 21:25on the memory spectrum is where you really lack
- 21:28memory. You can say, I really don't remember.
- 21:34I'm struggling to remember where I was. I do
- 21:37believe that there were minutes prepared, but
- 21:38I really couldn't tell you for certain. That's
- 21:41essentially saying I don't remember, but it's
- 21:43saying it in a way that provides more color and
- 21:45more depth to your answer. Again, thinking about
- 21:47a way that the jury is going to... Intake this
- 21:50sort of answer and judging your witnesses credibility
- 21:52So I think with that I may be done and I'm happy
- 21:57to jump in and chime in with others as we go
- 22:00along the presentation and Happy to field any
- 22:02Q &A as they come up Thank you so much Susan,
- 22:09I believe I am next I will give it a moment for
- 22:12my PowerPoint presentation to pop up on the screen
- 22:16But that was a very eye -opening window into
- 22:20the defense perspective on preparing your clients
- 22:22for deposition. So thanks so much for that. I'm
- 22:25just going to go ahead and share my screen here.
- 22:30Let's see. Okay. All right. So my name is Alexis
- 22:38Gamliel. Based on the introduction, I hope that
- 22:40you all understand I am a plaintiff's attorney.
- 22:43I represent individuals in personal injury and
- 22:45employment actions, specifically within the employment
- 22:48arena where I represent women in sexual harassment
- 22:51and gender discrimination cases, as well as a
- 22:54variety of individuals in whistleblower matters
- 22:56and all sorts of other employment cases, I believe
- 23:00similar to Mithalee, whom we'll hear from soon.
- 23:03So I'm here to provide the plaintiff's respect.
- 23:05I think like Susan, I will reiterate that much
- 23:09of this will translate across both sides of the
- 23:12aisle. So hopefully, no matter which side you
- 23:14represent, you'll be able to take away some actionable
- 23:16insight from the presentation today. And I also
- 23:21want to say thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 23:23Association for having me. And we'll just dive
- 23:26right in. So there are really two components
- 23:29the way I see it to preparing for a plaintiff's
- 23:31deposition in a case like this. Typically, we
- 23:36will talk about preparing our clients, but we
- 23:39also need to talk about preparing ourselves.
- 23:41So when it comes to this first component of client
- 23:44preparation, I'm going to be talking about the
- 23:47different tools, insight, and inspiration that
- 23:50you can equip your clients with, specifically
- 23:53as it relates to the tools, similar to what Susan
- 23:56was talking about with the safe harbors, giving
- 24:00actionable things that your clients can rely
- 24:03on. insight as it relates to the process to give
- 24:07clients that comfort for the framework so they
- 24:09know what to expect. And finally, inspiration
- 24:12to make sure that they have the confidence that
- 24:15they need to sustain several hours of deposition.
- 24:19In the employment context, we don't have that
- 24:21seven -hour time limit that exists in the personal
- 24:24injury space. you know, just setting the stage
- 24:28and setting expectations as far as the timeline,
- 24:31who will be there, and all those kinds of things
- 24:34that will give your client some confidence going
- 24:36forward. So for those first time deponents, your
- 24:43preparation is going to look a little different.
- 24:45We'll go very basic and talk about what the framework
- 24:49is, who will be there, who is going to be typing
- 24:52down the questions and answers and all of the
- 24:55colloquy that is stated in the deposition. And
- 24:58then the ramp up, which is getting into the more
- 25:01nuanced case specific facts and topics that will
- 25:04be addressed during the deposition. So. When
- 25:11it comes to preparing clients for deposition
- 25:13and really any case that I'm working on, I focus
- 25:16on having a trial -ready approach. And that includes
- 25:20looking to the finish line of where this case
- 25:22is going to end up. As you mentioned, Susan,
- 25:26we want to make sure that we are not only focused
- 25:29on the deposition testimony, for example, for
- 25:32things like a motion for summary judgment, or
- 25:34in my case, opposing a motion for summary judgment
- 25:37in many instances, but also on what that finish
- 25:40line looks like and how is this going to play
- 25:42out to a jury? How are we going to assemble all
- 25:46of the evidence that we need to defeat motions
- 25:48that come up, to proactively file motions as
- 25:51needed? and things like that. So from that lens,
- 25:55when I'm preparing clients for deposition, I
- 25:58first start with the very basics when it comes
- 26:00to especially preparing a plaintiff for deposition.
- 26:03These are not individuals who have sat for deposition
- 26:06before in most instances. So we're not talking
- 26:09about persons most qualified to testify on certain
- 26:12matters or company officers who may sit for deposition
- 26:15across a wide variety of topics or cases. But
- 26:19in most of my cases, my plaintiffs and my clients
- 26:22are addressing this for the first time. They
- 26:26are completely unaware in most instances of the
- 26:31format other than what they've seen maybe in
- 26:34suits on TV or in movies and things like that.
- 26:36So we really have to go very bare bones. So I
- 26:41explained to them a deposition is an under oath
- 26:44question and answer session that holds the same
- 26:46force and effect as if you were to testify in
- 26:49a court of law. And I impress upon them the importance
- 26:52of all of that. But at the same time, giving
- 26:55them that comfort of while it's not a conversation,
- 26:58it is of critical importance to your case. And
- 27:01in most instances, this is the one and only time
- 27:04that the defense attorneys or the defense attorney
- 27:07will have the opportunity to talk to you about
- 27:09your experience and the facts that form the basis
- 27:12of the case. So along those lines, I explained
- 27:16the format, the who, what, where, when, and why.
- 27:19So when it comes to the who, going down to this
- 27:22third bullet point here, parties and counsel.
- 27:26are those individuals who are permitted to be
- 27:28at the deposition. And as I mentioned at the
- 27:31beginning of this, in many instances, I handle
- 27:33sexual harassment cases. So I have to have very
- 27:36difficult and candid, frank conversations with
- 27:39my clients about it may be that the person who
- 27:43engaged in this sexually harassing conduct will
- 27:46be at the deposition if they're a party in the
- 27:48case. So that requires a very delicate, emotionally
- 27:51charged conversation oftentimes. And You know,
- 27:56there are instances where you can file a motion
- 27:58for a protective order to exclude certain individuals
- 28:01from depositions. The Code of Civil Procedure
- 28:06citation is there for you. We can talk a little
- 28:09bit. There could be a whole entire session, MCLE
- 28:13session on that area of law. Again, going back
- 28:17to the basics and priming the client for here's
- 28:20what to expect. It gives you that confidence
- 28:22when you walk in the room and you know who will
- 28:25be there, what the process is going to be like.
- 28:27And this might seem elementary, but truly on
- 28:30the plaintiff's side, it's very important to
- 28:32give your clients that confidence so that they
- 28:34can focus on what the case is really about, not
- 28:37about the feeling of uncertainty as far as the
- 28:41process goes. So when it comes to the what, giving
- 28:46your client a rough outline of what you expect
- 28:51the substance to be in the deposition. For example,
- 28:54if it's in a personal injury case, we're going
- 28:56to talk about the incident itself, your injuries
- 28:59and treatment, and then your general damages,
- 29:02just to give a high level understanding. And
- 29:05then also addressing that at the beginning, the...
- 29:08The defense attorney will likely go through what
- 29:10we call the admonitions. You'll be hearing the
- 29:12ground rules, much of which we'll go over in
- 29:15the preparation session. And finally, as it goes
- 29:20to the mindset of your client, we want to reassure
- 29:24our clients that we will be there with them every
- 29:26step of the way. Even though this is their first
- 29:28time, this is by no means our first time we've
- 29:31been here. We've done this many, many times.
- 29:33And so giving your client that reassurance really
- 29:36does help. So, going through the mechanics, and
- 29:47forgive me, this little picture here is just
- 29:49to paint the picture that really we do want to
- 29:52be trial ready. This is a photograph of me from
- 29:54my very first trial. I always go back to these
- 29:56memories because it's very important to understand
- 29:59where we're ending and how the deposition testimony
- 30:02plays into that full picture of the case. So,
- 30:05when it comes to the mechanics. As we all know,
- 30:10many depositions are still being done via Zoom
- 30:13or through other remote proceedings. Many depositions
- 30:16now, I'm finding I personally prefer an in -person
- 30:20deposition, especially when I'm taking a deposition
- 30:23because I can ascertain many more of the non
- 30:27-verbal cues that these witnesses have. But no
- 30:31matter whether your deposition is going forward
- 30:33in person or through a remote platform, Do you
- 30:37want to do your preparation meeting? I believe
- 30:39in whatever format the deposition will be. So
- 30:44that way you can prepare your client, especially
- 30:47when it comes to, you know, making sure that
- 30:50somebody, that your client is in a private place,
- 30:54that they're going to feel comfortable to be
- 30:56candid. Oftentimes we're we're probing into delicate
- 30:59matters, especially in the sexual harassment
- 31:02arena and in other case types as well. You want
- 31:05to make sure you have that privacy and also make
- 31:09sure that your client is in a space where their
- 31:13presentation is not going to be compromised.
- 31:16And we'll get into that in a moment. But no matter
- 31:20how the deposition will be proceeding, do your
- 31:24prep in the same way so that you can plan ahead.
- 31:29the process. So I also explained to my client
- 31:32that they will raise their right hand, they will
- 31:34flutter, swear to tell the truth. You will have,
- 31:38I will have as your attorney, an opportunity
- 31:40to object to certain questions. We'll want to
- 31:42explain to them the mechanics of that. That doesn't
- 31:44mean you don't have to answer the question. You
- 31:47do have to answer unless I instruct you not to
- 31:49answer. Sometimes clients, especially those who
- 31:53are doing this for the first time, they don't
- 31:55always no to anticipate those objections. And
- 32:00more often than not, you want to let your client's
- 32:02testimony flow very seamlessly. So I do my best
- 32:05to not get in the way of my client. Of course,
- 32:08in order to preserve those objections for trial,
- 32:11you want to lodge those objections in a judicious
- 32:14manner. But again, having that trial ready mindset.
- 32:18If I could just interject quickly from the defense
- 32:21side, one of the things, Alexis, that you said
- 32:23reminded me of We also prepare and when we're
- 32:26doing the the mock -cross examination, we also
- 32:29do insert having an attorney practice objections
- 32:32and we will go through with the witness what
- 32:37objections are cues for. So if the witness seems
- 32:40like they're they're relatively savvy and can
- 32:43follow along, we will say, for instance, if I
- 32:46object and say ask the answered, that's a cue
- 32:48that you've pretty much just answered the question
- 32:50already and they don't like the answer that they're
- 32:52being given. or objection vague. You do have
- 32:56to keep your objections succinct, but if you're
- 32:57saying something like objection vague, that's
- 33:00a cue that, to me as the lawyer, there's something
- 33:02hinky with the question. Yeah, I think that's
- 33:06a wonderful point. And on that note, especially
- 33:09in employment cases, when we're not talking about
- 33:12a moment in time, we're talking about conduct
- 33:15across years, there can often be instances where
- 33:18a question is vague as to time. I find that that...
- 33:21That is often one of the ones that comes up most
- 33:24frequently. So I do recommend that my clients,
- 33:28first of all, as you mentioned before, we want
- 33:31to make sure that they understand any question
- 33:33that they're being asked and to ask for clarification
- 33:36as needed. That especially is true when it comes
- 33:38to the timeframe of a question. We want to make
- 33:41sure that our clients are equipped with the tools
- 33:45that they need to speak up for themselves and
- 33:48if they hear a question and they're not sure
- 33:50about which time frame is being addressed, that
- 33:53they should speak up and ask for that point of
- 33:56clarification. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Okay.
- 34:01Another thing that I think is important that
- 34:03we explain to our clients is when we are on the
- 34:06record, when we are off the record, making sure
- 34:08that they have an understanding that the court
- 34:11reporter who's there is taking down everything
- 34:14that anybody says and that anything that occurs
- 34:17on the record will go into that transcript. And
- 34:21that they're being videotaped more often than
- 34:24not, a plaintiff's deposition in a case, whether
- 34:27it's a personal injury case or an employment
- 34:29case, is videotaped. Sometimes they're not. When
- 34:33I'm taking depositions, I always videotape them.
- 34:36Again, having that trial -ready mindset is very
- 34:39important to me. To zoom out to where what is
- 34:44going to happen with all of this? I advise my
- 34:46clients Afterwards, you're going to receive the
- 34:49transcript in the format of a booklet whether
- 34:51you know in in the old days before at least the
- 34:55last several years, you know, the clients would
- 34:58receive a hard copy booklet. Now, of course,
- 35:00we get those electronically and it's really easy
- 35:03to mark as read, you know, or sign and just kind
- 35:07of let things go. But we need to make sure that
- 35:09our clients understand the importance and the
- 35:11gravity of their deposition testimony being boiled
- 35:15down into a booklet. and that they have the opportunity
- 35:19to read, review, and sign that transcript. And
- 35:21when they do sign, it holds the same force and
- 35:25effect as if they were to testify in a court
- 35:27of law that the testimony is under penalty of
- 35:29perjury. Of course, as we often hear in the admonitions,
- 35:34our clients do have the right to make changes
- 35:37or corrections afterwards. But the important
- 35:40thing is that those changes or corrections can
- 35:44be commented upon at trial. So we want to make
- 35:47sure that we get that testimony right the first
- 35:48time. So emphasizing to our clients the importance
- 35:51of that even though they will be advised more
- 35:54likely than not at the beginning of their deposition
- 35:57by the attorney on the other side that they have
- 36:00that ability to make those changes that we want
- 36:03to make sure that the testimony as it's given
- 36:06on the day that it's given is accurate. and that
- 36:10if they're not sure of something that they give
- 36:13themselves some wiggle room in the words that
- 36:15they use. So when it comes to preparing clients
- 36:23for deposition, there really are, in my view,
- 36:27two rules at the top of the food chain here.
- 36:31Number one, always tell the truth. There are
- 36:33a lot of things as lawyers that we can fix and
- 36:36that we can massage later on if we need to, but
- 36:39you cannot fix a lie. So we need to make sure
- 36:43that they understand the importance of this.
- 36:46And the second thing is to answer only the question
- 36:48that's being asked. First of all, it's important
- 36:51because we want to be very focused with the answer.
- 36:54But second of all, I think it really helps for
- 36:56a more efficient deposition. And I think the
- 37:00attorney defending the deposition appreciates
- 37:03it, but also the attorney on the other side because
- 37:06we're staying responsive and staying on top of
- 37:09the answer. The other key points that I like
- 37:12to emphasize with my clients are That there's
- 37:15really a twofold purpose to a deposition. It's
- 37:18both what you say and how you say it So it's
- 37:22a combination of substance and presentation What
- 37:25that means is not only are we focusing on getting
- 37:28out the facts that are critical in the case?
- 37:31related to the causes of action at issue, but
- 37:33and and also our clients damages, but in addition
- 37:36to that it's how the client relays that message.
- 37:40And like Susan, you said, it's about credibility,
- 37:44right? And you have to have that mindset going
- 37:50in. Now, these can be somewhat delicate conversations,
- 37:52again, that we have with our clients. You want
- 37:54to show up as if you're going to a job interview.
- 37:57You also want to be comfortable and feel like
- 38:00yourself and be yourself in that deposition.
- 38:02But with the understanding, that eventually later
- 38:05on, these deposition clips could be used in,
- 38:08let's say, mediation. They could be used at trial
- 38:11and a variety of other things. So your audience
- 38:14is not just the attorney on the other side. It's
- 38:16also perhaps the insurance carrier, you know,
- 38:19when that deposition transcript and video gets
- 38:21shared. It's also the jurors eventually. So you
- 38:25have to prepare not only for the audience that
- 38:27you're facing that day, but also down the line.
- 38:30In order to not put too much pressure on our
- 38:34clients and make sure that, but at the same time
- 38:37having that concept in mind of who will see it,
- 38:41we just wanna advise our clients, show up, put
- 38:45your best foot forward, be comfortable, be yourself,
- 38:48at the same time you wanna have a polished presence
- 38:51and appearance. And it's not only about attire,
- 38:55it's about being articulate, being trustworthy
- 38:57in your message. and making sure to answer the
- 39:01question. And if you're nervous, we need to work
- 39:05through that and figure out how to calm those
- 39:10nerves. And sometimes the preparation can be
- 39:12a much longer meeting. Sometimes it can be many
- 39:15meetings broken up into hour long increments
- 39:18or half hour long increments. It really does
- 39:21depend on your client and how your client focuses
- 39:24best. Really what weighs into this decision as
- 39:29to how to break up the preparation, I think,
- 39:31is the trauma and the emotional weight. And it
- 39:36depends in large part upon the case type. So
- 39:38you need to get to know your client well in advance
- 39:40of the deposition. If the first time that you're
- 39:43really sitting down and getting to know your
- 39:44client is the deposition prep meeting, then you're
- 39:48already behind. You have to get to know your
- 39:51client and do it... you know periodically set
- 39:54yourself reminders to just have meetings to check
- 39:57in. You don't always have to have a specific
- 40:00purpose in mind in terms of like getting information
- 40:04or or meeting in advance of a hearing or some
- 40:08thing like that. You can do it for no apparent
- 40:11reason and there will always be a reason that
- 40:13unveils itself. And part of that is bonding with
- 40:16your client on the plaintiff side. It's really
- 40:18important that we have that unbreakable bond
- 40:21because we are going through the fire together.
- 40:25And so that's just a little bit about... the
- 40:29purpose, and Susan, I saw you unmute, so feel
- 40:32free to... Yeah, I did. With reference to dressing,
- 40:35on the defensive side, it's something that is
- 40:37also very important, and especially when you
- 40:40are dealing with an executive, a high -level
- 40:43executive, for instance, and if the deposition
- 40:46is by Zoom, as most are, at least in my practice
- 40:49currently, thinking of things like the background
- 40:53of the Zoom is incredibly important. You know,
- 40:56what is, you know, jurors are looking at at everything.
- 40:59So for an executive, you don't want to have something
- 41:01that looks like they're in a high -rise building
- 41:03of some fancy schmancy office. So we really try
- 41:06to watch little accoutrement that may be in the
- 41:09background. Are there awards? Are there family
- 41:11photos? What is in the background there? As well
- 41:13as what they're dressed like. Many people have
- 41:16an aversion to high -level company executives.
- 41:19And so in that instance, we often suggest to
- 41:22the witness that if it's a man or somebody that
- 41:24wears suits, wear a jacket, wear a button up,
- 41:27but don't wear a tie. Don't become excessively
- 41:30formal to the point that you are distancing yourself
- 41:33from the average jury or showing a respect in
- 41:36the same way that you would appear to a courtroom,
- 41:37but don't overdress in a way that emphasizes,
- 41:40you know, what may be a significant financial
- 41:43divide between you and the people seeing this
- 41:45video. It's a very good point. Along those lines,
- 41:51in addition to attire, presentation is also demeanor,
- 41:54right? And so we want our clients to be forthright.
- 41:57They have nothing to hide. And so the demeanor,
- 42:01we have to also prepare them so that they're
- 42:03comfortable asking or answering questions and
- 42:05not having that nervous energy. Responsiveness,
- 42:10we've discussed. Also, it's okay to ask for clarification.
- 42:15And of course, we want to make sure that our
- 42:17clients have audible responses. We don't want
- 42:20to trip them up in the middle of the deposition
- 42:22where the defense lawyer is asking them, is that
- 42:24a yes? And all of those things are very easily
- 42:27avoidable. And so we're going to take a step
- 42:32back and rewind and talk about our preparation
- 42:35before we prep our clients. Referring to this
- 42:40behind the scenes of the attorney of the client
- 42:43prep is the attorney prep. So along the lines
- 42:46of reviewing documents in employment cases and
- 42:49personal injury cases, you have your discovery
- 42:51responses, medical records as applicable. For
- 42:54example, that would certainly apply in personal
- 42:56injury cases, but equally in disability discrimination
- 43:00cases or failure to reasonably accommodate cases.
- 43:04Incident reports, investigation reports, witness
- 43:07statements, policies and procedures. payroll
- 43:09records, personnel file. There's a wealth of
- 43:12documentary evidence that can be relevant in
- 43:15cases like this. So you have to look at the universe
- 43:17of the documents that exists in your particular
- 43:19case. And don't only look at the documents you've
- 43:22produced on behalf of your client as the plaintiff,
- 43:25but also on the other side, the documents that
- 43:28the defense has produced, because we want to
- 43:30anticipate the defenses review what the key contentions
- 43:34are in the matter. And then, of course, the complaint
- 43:37in a case like like those that I handle, in many
- 43:42employment cases, the attorneys will go through
- 43:45the complaint because they want to make sure
- 43:47that this is not just the attorney talking in
- 43:49a pleading, that it matches and mirrors what
- 43:52the plaintiff's experience is. And of course,
- 43:55we want to make sure that the plaintiff is fresh
- 43:57on that information. The timeline. Many times,
- 44:03this will not come from documents produced in
- 44:07the case. That would be something that you, as
- 44:09the attorney, would prepare. And sometimes, as
- 44:12I mentioned at the beginning of this, There are
- 44:15cases that span years of conduct. So you want
- 44:18to make sure that you have those key dates locked
- 44:20in. Again, to give your client the confidence
- 44:23that they know what happened when. They lived
- 44:26it, but it may have been several years ago that
- 44:28they lived the experience. So it's a good and
- 44:31helpful tool to create for your client and discuss.
- 44:37And that concludes my presentation, but happy
- 44:40to answer any questions at the end. And thank
- 44:43you for the opportunity to speak to you. All
- 44:47right. I will have the next tech up in just a
- 44:49moment. Thank you. All right. So I'm Mike Lisa
- 44:54Raja. I do employment, pretty much employment.
- 44:59Most of my cases are employment cases, some civil
- 45:02rights cases representing plaintiffs. I'll wait
- 45:07for the slides, but I'll comment on some of the
- 45:09stuff while we wait. I'm going to rush through
- 45:12some of them since we're running behind. Could
- 45:28you flip the slides on rotating for me? Next.
- 45:41OK, so we're going to. go past this because I
- 45:44think everyone's talked about this, essentially
- 45:46credibility is one of the most important things.
- 45:49So, and I think for prep, you really do want
- 45:52to prepare your witness so that they have the
- 45:56confidence and clarity, not just on the liability
- 45:59side, but also on the damages. Obviously depends
- 46:02on the witness, but for plaintiffs, they need
- 46:04to understand it's not just about the... the
- 46:07chronology and the timeline and the theme, but
- 46:09also how to promote their damages. Next slide.
- 46:17It's working. Okay. Um, this is just roadmap
- 46:21of what I had planned. We'll go over the planning,
- 46:26admonition, some difficult scenarios, technical
- 46:28issues, um, mock Q and A and some takeaways.
- 46:33So for me, I look at it in three phases. I think
- 46:37prep for deposition starts from the moment a
- 46:40client walks in for me. So I'm thinking about
- 46:44timeline, key documents, and the written discovery.
- 46:48So the moment written discovery documents start
- 46:51coming in, I start marking up. These are key
- 46:54documents. And I don't wait for the actual notice
- 46:57to come in. We want to get the clients really
- 47:01prepped because a lot of times there is a lot
- 47:03to... cover and by the time the deposition notice
- 47:06comes in, it's too late to give the time to really
- 47:10prepare somebody and then reassure them that
- 47:13they're okay, meaning someone who's never been.
- 47:17Um, in a deposition, you're going to have all
- 47:20the nerves and emotional issues as Alexis, um,
- 47:25talked about earlier. So chronology is one of
- 47:28the key things I drive home to plaintiffs is
- 47:32need to know the facts. Cause there's, I think
- 47:35Susan referenced the, I don't recall response
- 47:37is not going to cut it for plaintiffs, right?
- 47:39If you cut yourself out as a, as a do not recall
- 47:42witness on a key. point in your chronology, you're
- 47:47taking yourself out as a witness, right? So it
- 47:50is critical that, especially for the material
- 47:53events in the chronology, that they know that
- 47:56sacrosanct, because if you say, I don't remember,
- 47:59and a defense witness comes in and knows a different
- 48:01version of the fact, that testimony is going
- 48:04to stick. Damages is another item that I think
- 48:10needs to be worked on from the get -go. So you
- 48:13can't wait for the deposition notice to come
- 48:15in to work on damages. There are some clients,
- 48:20harassment cases, disability cases. It's very
- 48:24tenuous for them to even talk about it. So you're
- 48:29going to need to break it up. And it's not going
- 48:32to be one session, two sessions, three sessions.
- 48:34It might be multiple sessions, starting with
- 48:36written discovery responses. So when the form
- 48:39logs, all those damages questions come up, I
- 48:43spend a lot of time with the clients to say,
- 48:46okay, now remember, this is going to come up
- 48:48again in your deposition. So let's make sure,
- 48:52not just like saying sleeplessness, headache,
- 48:54whatever. actually will have descriptions of
- 48:57what that means, how you've gotten treatment,
- 49:00all of that needs to be specified. Okay, and
- 49:04then some of the other things, depot notice,
- 49:06chronology, key documents, and then if they've
- 49:08had any prior or concurrent lawsuits, obviously
- 49:11need to cover that because that's going to come
- 49:14up. Um, and then the next thing, which I've had
- 49:17some clients talk about how my questionings on
- 49:20the mock Q and A's are harder than defense counsels.
- 49:23And I tell folks that I'm going to make it hard
- 49:27because I'm a hard grader. So I want to, I do
- 49:31both things, friendly defense counsel, uh, approach
- 49:35to questioning and then aggressive defense counsel
- 49:38approach to questioning. So you play both parts
- 49:40to see because, and I, and I'll tell you that.
- 49:44I find the most dangerous are the friendly opposing
- 49:47counsel witnesses because you build the rapport
- 49:50and then soon enough you have clients, you know,
- 49:54speaking, opening the Pandora's box, answering
- 49:57questions way beyond the scope of the question
- 49:59that's answered. So I believe that mock questioning
- 50:02and kind of managing the emotions, the anxiety,
- 50:05all of that is really important. And the actual
- 50:08doing, like the mock Q &A, doing multiple sessions
- 50:12with different approaches, different questions.
- 50:15So sometimes I just say... Damages, we're just
- 50:18going to do damages. We're not going to talk
- 50:19about anything else except damages. Sometimes
- 50:22we're just going to talk about just this one
- 50:25aspect, performance deficiencies. We're not going
- 50:27to talk about anything else, just that. Just
- 50:30to sort of get them into like here are the phases
- 50:34of the questioning that might happen. And then
- 50:39I also tell folks that even during the deposition,
- 50:42I'm a hard grader because as Susan and Alexis
- 50:45have echoed, it is really important to get the
- 50:48transcript accurate as possible while you're
- 50:51doing the deposition. I have only had a handful
- 50:55of clients. in all my years who have actually
- 50:59corrected a transcript. Because I make sure,
- 51:01and I'm our grader, if they miss something or
- 51:04speak out of turn, you go back and correct it
- 51:08right on the record during the tenure of the
- 51:12deposition. Let's go to the next slide. I'm not
- 51:17going to go over these. I think these are already
- 51:19talked about, but I think one of the most important
- 51:22things, like with all the admonitions, the important
- 51:26thing is answer the question in the shortest
- 51:31and most accurate way. I mean, most accurate
- 51:35and shortest possible answer. If you get anything
- 51:37else, just remember that because your credibility
- 51:40is the most important thing. And then these are
- 51:44all kind of... Secondary, understand the questions.
- 51:48If you don't understand, make sure you understand.
- 51:51It's okay to ask the question to be rephrased
- 51:54and don't feel like you're stupid for asking
- 51:58that because I know a lot of clients who may
- 52:02not be as educated. have some psychological barriers
- 52:06too, right? They might not be speaking the language.
- 52:09If you have translators, there's like another
- 52:12barrier, right? You have to wait for the translation
- 52:15to happen before the next thing happens. So,
- 52:19talking over each other. That is... I mean, I
- 52:23think goes without saying, but I have had depositions
- 52:27when the court reporter has had to like break
- 52:29it up. And then I've had to have spats with the
- 52:32court reporter, but I always say like, Hey, just
- 52:35pause and like take a deep breath. And if I find
- 52:39that the client is too anxious and it's just
- 52:42kind of not like not going well, I take them
- 52:45out. I'm like, okay, we need to take a break.
- 52:48Let's go for a walk. You know, there's something
- 52:51awry here. Let's see. Let's see. Handling difficult...
- 52:55Okay. Emotional topics and crying. This happens
- 53:00a lot in many of our cases, sexual harassment,
- 53:06harassment disability cases. And I have encountered
- 53:11many clients, especially those who have had disabilities,
- 53:16who want to... push on, right? Like they don't
- 53:18want to take a break. So it's not one way or
- 53:21another, like, hey, keep going or not keep going.
- 53:25I check in with them beforehand. I will say shoehorn
- 53:30into this is stamina. I have had some clients,
- 53:33especially after like the lunch break, like,
- 53:36I want to finish this. I don't want to come back
- 53:38for another day. I want to finish this. I had
- 53:40a client fall asleep on the record. So Because
- 53:44she wanted, she didn't want to take another day
- 53:46off and she literally fell asleep during questioning.
- 53:49It was like, you know, like an hour or two after,
- 53:52and it was, it was live deposition. So after
- 53:54that, if, even if it says like, I'm going to
- 53:57push through, if I see like, they're kind of
- 54:00phasing out and it's, I, I, I've taken them out
- 54:04and said, Hey, this is not a marathon, right?
- 54:07Like if you're tired and you can't answer the
- 54:09question, Hey, am I, am I? What's the question?
- 54:15Am I able to proceed with the deposition? Prepare
- 54:19to provide your best testimony. If you can't
- 54:21say yes unequivocally, then you can proceed.
- 54:26Privilege, embarrassing questions. We need to
- 54:32address those. before we get in there for sure.
- 54:36So I call these skeletons in the closet. So even
- 54:39when a new client comes in and I'm about to take
- 54:41the case, I talk about this. If there are skeletons
- 54:44in your closet, something from the past, like
- 54:46we have coins, especially in abuse, sexual harassment
- 54:49cases. past abuse, where they don't want to talk
- 54:53about, you know, family members, anything like
- 54:55that. We need to know that as soon as possible
- 54:58because you don't want that coming up in depositions
- 55:02or we need to know how to address them. And that
- 55:07goes to the instruction not to answer. So we
- 55:13go over if there are. pieces that we are not
- 55:17going to go into to address it. Maybe move for
- 55:20a protective order so you're not in that position.
- 55:23Okay, then we have multiple defendant issues.
- 55:26You just need to... I, when there are multiple
- 55:29defendants and there are multiple defendants
- 55:31questioning at the same time, I make sure that
- 55:34they allocate time. So especially if you're in
- 55:37federal court and you're in the seven hour limit,
- 55:39well, you're not in the seven hour limit if you
- 55:41have multiple folks, but you do want to make
- 55:44sure that the time is allocated because the client
- 55:48is going to get tired. Okay. I'm not going to
- 55:53go through these. The technical readiness is
- 55:56something important to go through with your client
- 55:58because if you're not savvy with it, you're going
- 56:02to have issues with that. Same thing, managing
- 56:06exhibits and documents. I think Susan talked
- 56:10about it. Make sure you go through it beforehand.
- 56:14All witnesses, even if you've seen it, if you
- 56:17see it again in deposition, don't say you've
- 56:19seen it without reading it. Make sure you actually
- 56:22read it and take the time to do it. Um, don't
- 56:25worry about, um, taking, you know, taking up
- 56:28time or taking too much time, anything like that.
- 56:31Okay. Next line. I'm not going to go over this
- 56:36because this is small, but obviously objecting
- 56:39to the notice if there are issues beforehand,
- 56:43especially if there are notice for production
- 56:46of records. You don't want to wait until the
- 56:49actual deposition to make the objections. You
- 56:52want to do it before. And then protective orders.
- 56:58I've had to do this for location of deposition
- 57:01when my clients have moved away out of town and
- 57:04the other side has wanted the deponent in person.
- 57:12So that's the only other thing I would say about
- 57:16this. And then Alexis talked about this. The
- 57:20way I've handled... depositions where the defendant
- 57:32is a party who was also the harasser, for instance,
- 57:35where the plaintiff is really doesn't want the
- 57:38person there. addressed it as, when the question
- 57:42is asked, are you able to provide your best testimony
- 57:46today to say, no, I'm not, because this person
- 57:49is here and they cause me emotional distress
- 57:52or whatever it is, and have addressed it that
- 57:55way. Most of the time I address it before with
- 58:00defense counsel, so we don't need to deal with
- 58:02it when we're in the room. But if there isn't
- 58:04an agreement, then we address it that way at
- 58:07the deposition. And if I could just chime in
- 58:09on this point too, another way to address this
- 58:12proactively is to reach out to your opposing
- 58:15counsel and have that candid conversation of
- 58:18who do you intend to have at the deposition.
- 58:21it will work on the right case and you'll know
- 58:24the dynamics between the parties and council
- 58:27as well, but just another tool to have in your
- 58:29arsenal. Yeah. Cool. Yeah. And then there's talked
- 58:34about this mock Q &A and I do these pretty vigorously
- 58:40to test out which how the witness does and then
- 58:46so that they feel assured. Sometimes they're
- 58:49more not assured. And then when they get to the
- 58:53depositions like, oh, I'm glad I'm prepared because
- 58:56now this is a lot easier. And then, yeah, so
- 59:01we debrief afterward. Yeah. And then the only
- 59:06other thing I would say is for post deposition
- 59:08follow -up, I like to do all the housekeeping
- 59:10things right there and then as much as possible.
- 59:14So if we need to do continued deposition, put
- 59:17it on the record. If there are any documents
- 59:19that still need to be produced, put it on the
- 59:21record so there isn't any sort of ambiguity.
- 59:25And you know, I had a deposition go on for two
- 59:28and a half years because of just documents not
- 59:32being produced. So it was one. plane of deposition
- 59:35that went on and on, like we had five depositions.
- 59:38So try to nip it in the butt so that it doesn't
- 59:41drag. All right. So I think those are most of
- 59:45what I had to say. Anything, really just need
- 59:50to prepare folks early enough. All right. Do
- 59:57we have questions? I think we have a lot of questions
- 59:59here. Great. So we do have a couple of questions
- 1:00:01in Q &A if you guys would like to address them.
- 1:00:05So, Susan, I believe this one's directed towards
- 1:00:07you. They're asking if you can revisit a concrete
- 1:00:10example of a safe harbor. Sure. Safe harbors,
- 1:00:14the ones that I gave examples of are what I call
- 1:00:16them the one, two, three. So, two points is too
- 1:00:20few, four points is too many, so we stick with
- 1:00:22three. Usually, if you have something like a
- 1:00:24decision maker or a contract issue, you say something
- 1:00:27like, we made the decision or I made the decision
- 1:00:30for three reasons. one, two, and three, and repeating
- 1:00:33that over and over. You can have a more thematic
- 1:00:35-based safe harbor. And an instance there is
- 1:00:38there was no culture of collusion. You can go
- 1:00:41further and have them be offensive to and say
- 1:00:43there was a culture of compliance. But combating
- 1:00:46that notion of culture of collusion, you build
- 1:00:49that into the witness's answer that underscores
- 1:00:51a theme that you're going to be proffering at
- 1:00:53trial. Great. And then the next question is,
- 1:00:59I guess this could go to anybody. What guidance
- 1:01:01do you give to your clients on how to listen
- 1:01:03to your objections to glean how that might impact
- 1:01:05how they respond? We've responded to that somewhat
- 1:01:10earlier, but for instance, if the objection is
- 1:01:14asked and answered, I think I wrote in my notes
- 1:01:16like misstates testimony. That's like a cue to
- 1:01:20you as the witness, hey, listen to the question.
- 1:01:22Maybe it's been asked and answered or it misstates
- 1:01:24your testimony. So, and I think Susan, you reference,
- 1:01:29it really depends on the savviness of the witness.
- 1:01:32Some folks can, others you don't want to get
- 1:01:35into it because then that throws them off. there.
- 1:01:38I usually keep it pretty succinct with that.
- 1:01:41I think asked and answered in this state's testimony
- 1:01:43are ones that are easy for witnesses to remember.
- 1:01:46Calls for speculation is one where that's a cue.
- 1:01:48I would say that's a cue that they're trying
- 1:01:50to get you to guess at something. Of course they're
- 1:01:52entitled to an estimate, but you shouldn't be
- 1:01:53guessing flat out. So if you hear me say speculation,
- 1:01:56they're asking you potentially to guess at something.
- 1:01:58When you get a more deposition proficient witness,
- 1:02:02you can go into more nuances such as you know,
- 1:02:05vague, vague and ambiguous, or even something
- 1:02:08as, you know, convoluted as lacks foundation
- 1:02:10for a very savvy witness or a witness who's a
- 1:02:12lawyer, perhaps. Yeah. Or calls for expert opinion
- 1:02:16would be a cue to the witness to not opine on
- 1:02:22their medical condition or something like that.
- 1:02:25But really, if they can still answer the question
- 1:02:28of what their understanding was as far as their
- 1:02:30diagnosis or what the issue is, then that would
- 1:02:34be a good course of action. All right. The next
- 1:02:38question is, almost all of my clients need an
- 1:02:41interpreter. I'm thinking that at the mock depot,
- 1:02:45I start bringing in the translator because it
- 1:02:47always throws people. At the mock depots, their
- 1:02:50bosses or someone else at the company will translate,
- 1:02:52but it's not the same. as a pro translator. My
- 1:02:55clients don't have a lot of money and I try to
- 1:02:57keep Depot costs on the lower side. What are
- 1:02:59your thoughts? Yeah, I think trying to simulate
- 1:03:03the circumstances that they'll face in the deposition
- 1:03:05is the safest bet you can make and to do that
- 1:03:09within whatever cost constraints you have. And
- 1:03:12I would say that if you are not able to get a
- 1:03:14professional interpreter for cost reasons in
- 1:03:16the prep, you can simulate the time in which
- 1:03:18it will take. by having, you know, really practicing
- 1:03:21so that your informal interpreter is not allowing
- 1:03:25crosstalk and really practicing, okay, when this
- 1:03:28person is speaking, do not say anything. When
- 1:03:30they finish speaking, then is your time to answer.
- 1:03:33Really just practicing the fundamentals of having
- 1:03:37long periods where you're truly just listening
- 1:03:39before you say anything and having that beat
- 1:03:41is another way to go. All right. And then the
- 1:03:46next question, if a client wants to confer with
- 1:03:48you privately during a remote deposition, no
- 1:03:51question pending, how do you handle it? Do you
- 1:03:53go off the record and communicate via cell phone
- 1:03:55or WhatsApp? If the witness is communicating
- 1:04:00with me during deposition, that is somewhat of
- 1:04:02a problem. Jay really can't be having that, but
- 1:04:04I would take it to say that I need to ask for
- 1:04:06a break at the soonest opportunity. You don't
- 1:04:08need to give an explanation for why you need
- 1:04:10the break, since in this scenario there's no
- 1:04:12question pending. I really try to avoid having
- 1:04:14substantive conversations with witnesses while
- 1:04:17depositions are pending. Depending on the jurisdiction,
- 1:04:19they can be considered, you know, once they're
- 1:04:21under oath until the examination is complete.
- 1:04:23You really shouldn't be having those types of
- 1:04:25conferences. But many times, not many times,
- 1:04:28there are times where witnesses just feeling,
- 1:04:29you know, I'm really getting a bit tired. What
- 1:04:31do I do here? And that is a perfectly appropriate
- 1:04:35conversation to have. And of course, if you need
- 1:04:37to consider if there's any privilege at issue.
- 1:04:40But for the most part, I do try to tell witnesses,
- 1:04:41you know, once you're on, we're not going to
- 1:04:43be having substantive discussions about your
- 1:04:45testimony because you don't want to open any
- 1:04:47doors. Yeah. And while opposing counsel is not
- 1:04:51permitted to... to delve into the substance of
- 1:04:53any attorney -client communications, they can
- 1:04:56ask questions around the factual circumstances
- 1:04:58of the communication. For example, if you took
- 1:05:00a break and it was a 30 -minute break, the opposing
- 1:05:05counsel could ask your client, what did you do
- 1:05:07during that 30 -minute break? And they would
- 1:05:10have to say, I spoke with my attorney. wouldn't
- 1:05:15have to go into and wouldn't be required to go
- 1:05:18into what they discuss, certainly not, but it
- 1:05:21would, you know, you just understand that that
- 1:05:25exists, that that's a risk as well. I just want
- 1:05:30to chime in not to... polarize that too much
- 1:05:33because I do think that it's important to get
- 1:05:36the record straight. So if you have to have conversations
- 1:05:39to clarify things, I do think that it's more
- 1:05:42important to correct the record while the deposition
- 1:05:44is going on versus correcting it with the transcript.
- 1:05:48Of course. Yeah, I agree with that. Great. And
- 1:05:52the next question is, when taking time off work,
- 1:05:54To attend a deposition as a plaintiff, is it
- 1:05:57considered protective leave? Can an employer
- 1:05:59with a no -fault attendance point system require
- 1:06:01the employee to use their points or to have sufficient
- 1:06:03points? I actually don't know the answer to that
- 1:06:09question. I don't know either. All right, moving
- 1:06:12on. Will you kindly elaborate on instructions
- 1:06:16not to answer from your views and examples? Certainly
- 1:06:21the most, you know, the clearest example is if
- 1:06:23something calls for privilege information, and
- 1:06:25that may seem obvious, but in the moment the
- 1:06:27question may be a bit of a gray area as to whether
- 1:06:29privilege is implicated. And so in that circumstance,
- 1:06:31what I've done is say, I usually have real time
- 1:06:34with me, but if not, I can just be listening
- 1:06:35carefully and just say, just give me a moment
- 1:06:37before you answer or reviewing the question or
- 1:06:39I'm thinking about the question. And it can feel
- 1:06:42a little bit awkward, but I just, at this point,
- 1:06:43I'm not embarrassed by it. And I'll say, you
- 1:06:45know, if that seems to infringe on the substance
- 1:06:48of our communication, or if you can answer that
- 1:06:51without disclosing the content of attorney -client
- 1:06:53information or advice that's been rendered or
- 1:06:56requested, you may do so. Typically, the witness
- 1:06:59is unable to do so, and then they'll stand by
- 1:07:02the instruction. Another one is if there's privacy
- 1:07:05at play. I've instructed on the basis of privacy
- 1:07:09many times that plaintiff's counsel will ask
- 1:07:12the witness, you know, a random fact witness
- 1:07:13what their residential address is and I've instructed
- 1:07:16on that and it tends to result in somebody asking
- 1:07:18me if I'll accept service of a trial subpoena
- 1:07:20for 1987 purposes, which is something that will
- 1:07:23have been discussed in advance and in the preparation
- 1:07:25so that, you know, when that representation is
- 1:07:28made and the instruction is given, there's not
- 1:07:29a big kerfuffle about it. Oh, great. I believe
- 1:07:35that about wraps up Q &A. Thank you all so much
- 1:07:38for your time today. We truly appreciate you
- 1:07:40speaking on this topic to our members. Thank
- 1:07:42you very much.