Latest / Falcon Forward / Specialized vs Generalist: The Insurance Producer Debate
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: Welcome to Falcon Forward. My name's Peter Brecht. I'm here with our president Mike Tangy on another beautiful Wednesday here. It's July, San Diego. July in San Diego is it's my favorite. I I've kind of decided it's like my favorite month. June gloom's gone. It's actually feels summer, you know, and it's, you know, got the AC run and all that stuff. So hope everyone is doing well out there this week. Mike, thanks for taking the time to to come on. I'm excited for our topic today. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, likewise, Peter, thank you for organizing and yeah, lots of fun stuff going on and I'm also eager to debate our our topic at hand. Peter Brecht: Yeah. So our topic today is should a producer, a new producer in the insurance industry specialize in commercial or should they be more of a generalist where they're going maybe after commercial and personal lines? So Mike Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: is sitting on the side of I would, you know, having a producer do both commercial and personal. I'm sitting on the side of I think a a a producer should specialize in one niche and go after it. So I'm not sure which side we should start with here, Mike, but either way I'm excited. and then at the end we can kind of I guess figure out where we stand. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. All sh Sure. So I'll I'll kick off on it of so I'm from the camp of sell everything, right? You have a you're a new person, you're hustling, you're talking to lots of different people across the lots of different things. And if someone you know falls under the hey, this is something we can provide, whether that be in obviously our agency focuses on commercial lines and personal lines, and helpful for people to know that we're about a three-quarters split with commercial lines, P and C revenue, and then twenty five. percent comes from personal lines which is mainly in the high net worth customer segment of personal lines and so you know if you're a new person out there hustling and come across an opportunity we can deliver on those types of opportunities that you find so why not focus on both get both over to you, Peter. Peter Brecht: Yeah. so like your you know, your opening position on it. I mean, yes, we can do both. my kind of premise for all this is if I go back and look at my own kind of growth here. So started with Falcon West three years ago. Actually, I'm I'm going into year four right now, which is great. So but if I look back on the history of like where I was, came in really to be a generalist. That that was kind of the goal. and then very quickly realized with you know getting our energy practice with oil and gas in motion that didn't matter if I worked 50, 60, 70 hours a week, it was gonna take everything I had to get good at one particular niche. Right. So and I will tell you that a lot of that came from, you know, focusing on something that I never knew anything about, right? So how do you put, you know, oil to me, oil and gas was just car terms, right? Put gas in my car, put oil in my car, it runs. Now I gotta go talk to people that are actually doing the work. And so I realized that in order to sell this product, to do really well, to understand my client, the environment they're in, all that, I had to become a niche producer. I had to understand everything start to finish. and that's why ultimately I'm I'm a believer in in the niche side, right? Is is you gotta get good at one thing. and then naturally later on, you know, you can kind of acclimate and sell things easier. I can tell you now, three years in, I can have a conversation with somebody in personal lines and actually Maybe I don't have the the sales script down, right? Like I'm I don't know how to sell it so much, but I could tell them from a risk perspective, like, hey, you're you're underinsured here or you know, you miss this, you know, having those conversations easier. It might not be the smoothest sale in the world. That's not ever been my intention as a salesperson either way. I've just a good advisor that way now. But I can tell Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: you niche first and then, you know, you'll you'll do a lot better long term. Mike Tanghe: so it interesting, and I do see from a new perspective when you haven't a lot of things thrown at you, a lot to learn. if you look at our producers who let's say been working here for five years or longer, so we would consider that an established producer, that their mix mirrors the the agencies overall. So they're about 75% commercial lines, 25% personal. but for these producers, like it's a substantial revenue that is a little bit different, you know, commercial lines is gonna be a lot more intensive as far as your involvement as a producer. and then personal lines a little bit less. you can, you know, it's a little bit more, it's not an automatic renewal basis, but it's a lot more streamlined renewal, and then there's isn't those, you know, questions throughout the year, or to a much lesser degree those questions throughout the year related to claims or contract reviews or all those types of things. that we're doing with our commercial clients. And then also working with you typically a commercial alliance client, you we're gonna be working with anywhere from three to you know a dozen people on that team who are all handling different things as it relates to the risk management at these organizations. But I guess with that said, if you look at our producers that they typically did not do both from the beginning, Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: that it was more of a okay, they established themselves in commercial alliance and then were able to fill in on the personal lines aspect. It became kind of a almost a natural conversation. and kind of echoing Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: your point there of, you know, you feel you can have that conversation with anyone now that you've been, you know, four years Peter Brecht: Sure. Mike Tanghe: industry experience. So I can see the perspective. of you know if when you're brand new and everything you know every question is you know okay let me get back to you or you know it seems like every question is something you have to research because you don't know that answer off top of your head Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: And then just it almost more so on the process side. That's we've seen a big challenge with our new folks coming on board. And we've been working very hard to help ease that process. But it's like, okay, I got someone. Now what do I do? And then it's like you you kind of have these door series of doors that okay, you opened up that that first door, you figured out okay, how what's the code to that one, and then there's another door right behind it. And those doors could be underwriting requests, they could be carrier specific requirements as far as what they Need and it could just be getting information from clients on updates to the homes, like in California specifically, it's a very challenging market as far as the underwriting requests. It's starting to open up a bit, which is encouraging as far as what carries will write, but that doesn't mean that it's just you know, you go online and boom, you have a quote. It's now you gotta, you know, what year was this earthquake retrograde? And you know, what year did these updates and not just taking people's word for it, but tracking down invoices and receipts and all these things that we don't have to. do on a commercialized account. So I guess I can I'm warming up to a bigger perspective of you know okay maybe it doesn't make sense when you're brand new to just do everything because that could be sh i in in you know an effect shortchanging your development Peter Brecht: Well, I think there's a difference. So I'm gonna agree with you for what I'm gonna see sounds like I'm gonna agree with you, but ultimately it's gonna lead to a different conclusion, which is I think it's Mike Tanghe: Nice. Peter Brecht: important to have training. I think you need exposure to it. So understanding what personal lines is, how a personal you know, package or you know, what that structure looks like for somebody is important. I think it's I think when you take that next step and you start interacting with clients. learning how to have that conversation, really trying to, you know, learn what questions to ask. and then really having to go through all the underwriting is very difficult, right? So because that's that's really the thing you got to learn and get over. The other part of it too is going back to processes, right? So when I started, I remember this very clearly, I was talking to Brenda, client in Minnesota had called in and the lead was transferred to me. So I talked to the guy and got his first name, got his address. That's all I knew how to do, right? I mean, I knew there were other questions. I didn't know where to take it. So called Brenda. She's like, hey, you know, talk to some of the producers. I have a couple things like this is what we need. But I got I got a list of things that we needed from Bill. And then I asked Matt, got a different list. Randy gave me a different list. I think Randy sent me like a handwritten picture that he sent me. Like I it's just, it was, but it was very Randy-esque and it got the job done. He spent a lot of time with me on the phone talking me through things. I met with him in San Diego, but but really it was that's how it was. And I was like, I know there's more to this. I'd spent some time with a friend of mine kind of developing. So honestly, it went on their website and was like, what questions are they asking? I'll just go do the same thing. So Mike Tanghe: Sure. Peter Brecht: having those processes is really critical and helpful. Now, I will tell you though, that when you start getting into commercial, the biggest piece for me is the prospecting, right? So depending on who you are, having a singular focus on prospecting is massive. So if you talk to Bill. You talked to, you know, he said the number one thing that helped him and helped in turn to corner as a generalist, right? Was joining provisors and a number of these other places where he was able to go be part of a community and network. I'm not I've never been a huge network person. And it's not because networking is it's just such a long game for me, right? I'm more of the mindset of like, hey, I know who I can go out and call, I know who I can go help. I'm a little more targeted in that approach. Mike Tanghe: Yep. Peter Brecht: and so having a very streamlined process, knowing who you are. and then being able to approach and go after those particular clients with an understanding is massive. It's it's no surprise to me that, you know, we, you know, a couple of our first clients that we got through the oil and gas side were on the engineering, more the engineering production professional line side because that kind of lines up with how Falcon West, like we have a lot of clients in that space already. Mike Tanghe: Yep. Peter Brecht: but now that we've kind of established ourselves, we have great carrier relationships, we're starting to kind of expand that out into oil-field services. lot guys that you know boots on the ground, which is great. And then you look too now like got Devin and Macy. Those guys both work construction. They've done welding. They know all that stuff. So we're able to kind of speak to Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: that more. So leaning into that more, I think is critical. and I think it's just a very different conversation you have to have with people. Right. and and really too the other part of it is that you as a new producer You have to, I think this is the hardest thing is you almost have to fake it till you make it. And I hate saying that because we just want to be experts and really good at what we do. But I had to defer so often to I don't know the answer, I'll find out. That is such a humbling thing to say, especially if you say it twenty, thirty times a day, right? I say it less often now, I still say it, but having to defer on a to your team and not knowing those answers can really crush you. So if you can study one thing, get really good at it, you know, learning general liability, learning, then we get into, you know. control a well, operators extra expense, you know, all these like different things that are so important. it gets and and and then knowing the markets too, right? So that's why I'm such a huge proponent of it. And there's some other things we can talk about, but those are some of the items that I want to highlight as why I'm an advocate and and really pushing someone to not just niche like even in the beginning, but really just continue that. Like you might get referrals Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: and stuff like that. Just my thought process is look, if it doesn't meet your minimum account or something that you really want to work with, like refer it out to somebody, find a solution Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: for your client, you know, but but don't even take that count account on. You you need to be true to yourself and and keep that going the right direction. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. And so very good points. I like your verbal judo of agreeing and then coming up to a different conclusion. very politically correct, tactful correct. but it does bring up it in so I'll I'll give two An agreement and then kind of a counterpoint too as well. and I guess the the end result of that is that you gotta figure out what's works good for you. But from a strictly monetary standpoint and kind of getting up to success faster, I agree that. hundred percent focused. This is my wheelhouse. If it's not in the wheelhouse, you gotta have obviously have a a way to softly hand those off. And you know it's not like you're telling a client, no, I won't talk to you. but it's like, hey, Peter Brecht: Course. Mike Tanghe: here's what I focus on. I'm gonna bring in the expert that that will take care of your home insurance or the expert that will take care of this business that's not oil and gas if if that that's the focus on it. and you know, yes, it may feel like in the short term that my gosh, I just gave up revenue, opportunity and I need revenue opportunity, but to your point of to become that master of that space, I I I think holds a lot of validity to it. So now the counterpoint to it, the counterpoint to my own point is also you gotta figure out, and this is the beauty of insurance, is you have to figure out what works good for you. so like I very and just even this week, I'm gonna have three in-person meetings this week with personal lines clients. that, Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: you know, one of them's paying half a million dollars a year. So I mean it's as big as are some of our larger commercial lines clients. But I very much enjoy those in-person meetings. I mean, these are wildly successful people that if you measure purely by by money standards. and so I enjoy those types of meetings in kind of the problem Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: solving that goes with that. could I have you know replaced that so if could I brought someone else in and had them take Take care of it? No, for sure. And then could I have then used that time to write more commercialized clouts that are you know 3x, 4x, 5x that size? Also, also true. but it kind of comes down to hey, this is something that I actually I I really like on it. But I guess where what I've realized is it's a bit I'm not necessarily setting our our new producers up for the best level of success or their fastest level of success by saying, Hey, this is something I enjoy. and again it's easier for me because I did commercial lines for probably four years before I started focusing on on or not focusing, but before I started writing personal lines. So Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: to ask our new people to come in and do both, I'm realizing that's not the best method to go and they would be better served of saying Hey, we're gonna bring in, you know, this ask the questions for sure. and if there's interest in having a review of the personal lines, now we can bring in an expert that makes them look better and we'll handle that for Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: the client. So we're taking care of the client first and foremost. that producer can get paid for that opportunity, but it's not taking away from their development on their core focus. So Peter Brecht: Yeah, yeah, and I think I mean, I agree, but I and even in even with what you're saying too, so I think I would like to clarify even with personal lines, right? So I I wake up every day and I think to myself, all right, like if I had to start over again, like what would I focus on? And I think it's a great way for me to reframe like my focus for the day is like if you if today was zero, right, how am I gonna how do I wanna end my day? Where do wanna go? If I had to go into personalized production, what I've slowly over time realize because again I haven't focused on the personalized conversation a lot, but I've thought about it a lot over the past couple of weeks, especially with some producer changes internally and you know, just moving account managers into product it's so it's been great. But focusing on, you know, a niche and having a process for that. So if you're gonna do if you're gonna do home and auto and you're talking to, you know, you just happy writing a ton of clients and you want to have a 3,000 client book and, you know, don't really care about how many accounts and all that stuff and we get to really into the nitty-gritty numbers. That's fine. When you move into but but and but you have to have a s a really good process for that. You have to be able to submit, quote, know your markets, et cetera. My my preference in that case even would be to focus really on high net worth, private client where we can't have really actual conversations with people, right? So Mike Tanghe: Yes. Peter Brecht: you have to even within your niche get really good at one thing. So Mike Tanghe: Yes. Peter Brecht: It's kind of bizarre, but you know, you've got personal lines, which is is sort of your your standard market. then you have your high net worth. And then commercial, it's like you get to pick an industry, but even in that industry, you might have something that's even more granular that you you know you can really do. carrier appetites change. you know, you kind of try to it's constant. So I I don't I like in the other part too is I would really encourage anyone that's getting into a niche To think about two things. First of all, what are you, what do you find interest in, right? You have to be, you have to almost, regardless of personal lines, commercial lines, whatever it is, but you must be so obsessed and consumed with that industry that it almost becomes your identity. And I I know that sounds crazy, but it's gonna take three years of just study, belief, and just going and talking to everyone in that industry to get good at it, right? So if you look at, What I knew about oil and gas three years ago, nothing, Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: right? Fast forward to today, I've talked to, I mean, honestly, hundreds of people in the industry. I have I started a podcast about it to learn more about it. Like it's it was an all consuming obsession. And now I'm kind of setting that to the side for a second so I can take a breather. I need to remember why I started this in the first place, which was because I love insurance and I just think it's a great thing to do. and then looking at the overall organization and company as we're trying to grow. so not to get too far off track, but you have to be obsessed with it. If that's private client, you're gonna be, you know, you're gonna study from study. I I really mean that. Like you're gonna say, Randy, hey, I need to learn everything I can from you. you're gonna be calling me up and saying, Man, our website, when we're talking about clients, like it is way off. I need you to change like there's that level of specificity. you know, and I've seen I've heard people writing books about this stuff, just like to learn how to do it. It's it's amazing. So just be obsessed with it. I think you'll do really well. You don't really stop thinking about things as a producer. You really don't. It's not something where you're gonna set it aside. and I think too, Mike, like you've been doing this for for a very long time. And so I think that just comes naturally to you. Like you, you know, you're you like those one on one meetings and stuff. I'm I'm my personality is more like and you you laugh because Devin and Macy are like this when I'm calling, but I'm I'm so like I'm almost too direct, right? It's like, hey, do do you want help or not? Right. And the people that say, yeah, great. And they but But you know, everyone's got their own style. So what I'm saying there is if you're a networking guy and you know that, or you know, you're the kind of person who wants to be in your community book club and that's who you're prospecting to, that's fine. but but you gotta know who you are and you gotta know how you like to talk to people, how you wanna reach people, because it's gotta feel natural. At the end of the day, if it's not who you are and it's not how you were kind of raised. for lack of a better thought process there. But if it's not who you know, you're not gonna do well. You're you're gonna be going against yourself all the time and it's not gonna be fun. So Mike Tanghe: Yeah, no great great points that be true to yourself. add a couple things to that of and I'm glad you brought up the focusing on the personal lines in the high network segment 'cause we have two producers that solely do that right now and do a fantastic job. We're about to bring on our third producer, that is gonna be solely focused on that personal lines and it that gets back to your point of, you know, what do you enjoy, what do you want to do? and Yeah, this person will be wildly successful because they they have those that interest, that attributes. The thing that I would also add that I would tell to anyone who's thinking about the industry, and it doesn't matter whatever industry you're in, yes, you need to find like what your passion is. the thing I would add to that for someone is look to see are there other people who have that same passion who are having success. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: so in other words, is there a pathway? If and so if other people are doing it, then that great. That means that I can also do that because there's some things that I I talk with some younger people and here's stuff that they're doing and I was like wow like that's cool I'm glad that's your passion but I don't know that there's necessarily a a means to make money in that that level of passion again that's not not the most important thing it's not everything out there but there is especially if you know you want to get married and you know have a family you know there's certain level of responsibilities and so you're you're you're almost setting yourself up for failure if you're gonna do something that doesn't necessarily have that pathway or it's just gonna be a lot more high risk on it. So I always tell people, you know, like, okay, that's like you sounds like a cool job. It's this new company. Like are there other people doing and I learned that the hard way. I one of my jobs right out of college is with a company that was really cool and we raised a bunch of money and we had really cool offices. But at the end of the day when we would start talking to people and clients, there wasn't we had nothing to sell. on it. And so again, didn't last there very long, thankfully, nor did the company last very long. But I guess that kind of proved to my point of like, wow, like this all sounded great, but there wasn't this pathway of in insurance, thankfully, 100% has that. There's a lot of people that are very successful in the insurance industry. And then it's okay, what's my interest, what's my niche, and then full on pursuing that. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Well, you might remember when I started, I had like I knew I knew so many of the independent coffee shops here in California and I was like, Mike, I'm gonna Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: write these coffee shops and you're like, Yeah, no, like let's let's not worry about that right now. Let's you know. So it's it's funny. You can almost steer someone away from something because you know that hey, there first of all, there's no markets, there's no whatever. that's fine, but it's it's funny. So I'm still very passionate about coffee. I just don't write a whole lot of coffee shops. I think I have maybe two two t two total. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Right. They're f fun to go enjoy, be a consumer Adam. But yeah, it's yeah, so a great great example there though. Peter Brecht: Very funny, yeah. gosh, I had another thought that popped in my mind and I lost it. So I'm a little bummed. hopefully not e everyone else isn't too disappointed on that. But yeah, Mike Tanghe: Ha ha. Peter Brecht: so so where does I mean so where do we st like what's the let's talk Falcon West going forward? Like we're we've got some growth Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: plans, we've got some things we're always working on, obviously. I know you guys hear about it every week. like from the from my from where I'm at, you know, I'm constantly looking at process, right? So our our ops team we're we're we're really focusing on you know how are we getting all that through because you know Mike and I we actually went to an event yesterday an Oracle event so it was our AI you know one other AI just trying to get questions not that you know we might not have anything Oracle related but there's always good questions we can learn and one thing that I kind of figured out with insurance is you know we we we're taking in data right we're taking data in we're processing data we're presenting that data to underwriters, we're presenting it to clients, we're presenting it to our account managers. and it's actually a lot of it's the same information, right? it just has to be packaged and and and shared a different way depending on who your audience is. so that's something we're we're kind of thinking about. That was that was an we that we could do a whole podcast on yesterday. but that said, like if I look at this, you know, we have new producer, Devin joined us, you know, 120 days ago. So he's been with us for four months. You know, are I guess let's just ask the question like are are we planning on having people wear multiple hats or would we prefer them to focus on a niche? Like, you Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: know, where would you stand on that? What are your thoughts? Mike Tanghe: Yeah, so I would say I have come around through your persuasive arguments on it in that and Devin and I were working on an opportunity that he did a fine job on, but again, Peter Brecht: Yeah. Sure. Mike Tanghe: the amount of time and again what I so I the error of my ways was realizing that viewing this with someone who has experience and so it's a bit more in so I needed to put myself back in that beginning shoes. and so I think the better way for the producer, better way for the client and better way for the company itself is if future opportunities come up that Devin uncovers that would be in a personal lines that he bring in another person at our company to handle that. and then that way he can stay focused on his track. and Where I guess I will strayed from our goal was we want to get him to a viable book of business as as quick as possible. And that doesn't mean just all revenue. It means here's the quickest path as you focus on the oil and gas niche. this is your proven path. Other people have done this ahead of you. it's your quickest path to success. Once he gets to that path, then he can kind of, you know, come up for air and be like, hey, I I wanna do a little bit more personal lines or with these oil and gas clients that I work with. Or but to get him to success. the fastest, I think that should be a better model for our organization going forward is we have the experts for whatever whatever it is and that could be Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: generalist PNC it could be small business PC it could be personalized and so much like if we come across an opportunity where someone says hey health insurance we bring in outside companies to do that this would just be that same concept of let's bring in our inside experts to do Peter Brecht: Yeah. I think it's great. And and yeah, I I've encourage so like even myself, like I still don't ever want to get rusty on things and you know, other things kinda take up my day. But I still love making cold calls. I still love getting kind of I still love going to meet businesses or, you know, knocking on doors every now and Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: then. Like if I can do it once a month, man, that's like the best ten ten people I'll go talk to, right? just to just because it's it's part of who you know, it's it's gotta be part of your routine. But So, you know, trying to kind of build up all that at the same time is is fun. So I just love it's funny, we did we had triline management came on with our academy. man, Mike Tanghe: Yeah, I'm eager to hear how that went earlier this week. Peter Brecht: it was great. I I I c Adam did a fantastic job sharing and and going through like LinkedIn, personal branding, and all that. I the first the first session I got to attend, hadn't heard the material, even though I'd helped him sort of like proofread it and go through it, put the all the stuff together. but I came away with with some great things and learned something about myself, which is that like my like what drives me is actually helping other people be successful, which is a really odd thing. But if you look at like my past, it's always been kind of identifying what people are good at and then helping them really sharpen that edge and just go after it, right? I want them to do as good as they can be, whether that's people I work with, my kids, my spouse, myself, right? Like I just love equipping people with it. And so you might call that a teacher. but but anyways, I'm really encouraged by just seeing all the new people coming in, just the range Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Peter Brecht: of talents and all all the great things there. So yeah, we'll we got a lot more to cover, Mike. today we've got I I know I have a couple things to do before we head off to a meeting, but anyways, this has been this has been fun. We'll have to revisit this, I think, in like let's give it six months. Maybe we have to re Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Right? Peter Brecht: review this in January, just see how we're doing. Mike Tanghe: That sounds like a sounds like a good plan. So good stuff today, Peter, thank you. Peter Brecht: All right. Hey everyone, thank you for listening to today's episode. if you have any questions, let us know. Put it in the comments, like and subscribe. the stars, if you can put five stars, four stars, whatever you feel like giving, helps us kind of get some visibility. So thanks for listening and we'll see you again next week. Mike Tanghe: Awesome.