Latest / Eye Spy: The Intelligence History Podcast / Spycraft from Elizabeth I to the Restoration
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to EyeSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 0:08I'm your host, Krystel von Kumberg.
- 0:12Every few weeks, I'm going to be interviewing historians, practitioners and scholars in
- 0:16the field of intelligence to explore some aspect of the past and what it can tell us
- 0:21about the present and future of intelligence studies.
- 0:35Professor Nadine Akkerman is a renowned scholar in early modern literature and culture at
- 0:39Leiden University, a fellow of the Royal Historical Society and an award-winning author, having
- 0:46written a series of books including Invisible Agents, Women and Espionage in 17th Century
- 0:52Britain, Elizabeth Stewart, Queen of Hearts, and The Politics of Female Households, Ladies
- 0:58and Waiting Across Early Modern Europe.
- 1:00Dr. Pete Langman is an editor, academic and occasional rock and roll guitarist who holds
- 1:06a PhD on Francis Bacon.
- 1:08His work has ranged from a collection of dark and witty short stories in his book Black
- 1:12Box, to slender threads A Young Person's Guide to Parkinson's Disease, and Killing
- 1:18Beauties based on the true story of two female spies in 17th Century London, and much, much
- 1:24more.
- 1:25I'm here today to discuss their book Spycraft, Tricks and Tools of the Dangerous Trade from
- 1:31Elizabeth I to the Restoration.
- 1:34Welcome to iSpy, the Intelligence History Podcast.
- 1:38So what initially inspired you to write Spycraft together, and could you talk a little about
- 1:43how your research developed over time, and any specific methods you used when envisioning
- 1:49your research objectives?
- 1:51As she said, I've written a book on women spies before called Invisible Agents, Women
- 2:00and Espionage in 17th Century Britain, and I was doing a lot of festivals because this
- 2:07book suddenly became quite popular, so I was going to literary festivals and people said
- 2:12how wonderful that you sort of uncovered all these women.
- 2:16But we're also really interested in how did they do it?
- 2:19How did they mix their invisible inks?
- 2:23And I think after that we were watching a series called Gunpowder, a 2017 series with
- 2:32Kit Harrington in the lead, and we saw that the spy techniques were rather awkwardly portrayed.
- 2:39So we thought perhaps this is something that would sort of really catch people's imaginations,
- 2:46and so we started considering a new book.
- 2:50What happened with the programme is that we were watching it and we were doing the normal
- 2:53historian thing of shouting at the TV screen as we were watching it, and then we saw one
- 2:58particular scene where Cecil was exposing invisible ink on a piece of blank paper.
- 3:04We thought that's just daft, no one would ever do that, and that turned into a long
- 3:07extended Twitter conversation with a few other researchers that we know.
- 3:12And before we knew it, we'd started working on a sample chapter.
- 3:15And we tested the waters whether we could really write together as well.
- 3:21So we published a chapter about archival theory in Oxford Handbook edited by Enroute Press
- 3:27called Alison Wiggins, and we thought if we can have so much fun with archival theory,
- 3:33then just imagine how much fun we could have writing a book about spycraft, which is probably
- 3:38sexier than archival theory to most people.
- 3:43So we thought we would just go ahead and write a book together.
- 3:49And how the research developed over time, we thought we were quite clever in picking
- 3:55kind of well-known plots, like the Gunpowder plot and the Babington plot.
- 4:00And we thought these plots are so well known that we can really focus on the materiality
- 4:06and we don't have to explain that much about the political context anymore.
- 4:11We won't have to do any interpretation.
- 4:13And we don't have to do any interpretation or rewriting of the plots themselves.
- 4:19But the thing was, by focusing on materiality, the plots also started to shift.
- 4:25So they became more nuanced and things changed.
- 4:29So in the end, it perhaps became a bit more academic, more than we expected.
- 4:35Yes, it took a bit of a life of its own in that respect.
- 4:39Stemming from that, how did you decide on what tricks and tools to really focus on?
- 4:44And how did archival research pave the way?
- 4:47Well, spying fundamentally is about communication, whether in generally secret communication,
- 4:52communication or information.
- 4:54And so obviously, we were limited in the amount of work we could do on eavesdropping because
- 4:59it's so ephemeral.
- 5:00But you can work on when the information that is gathered is transported.
- 5:04And the only way it can be transported fundamentally is in a person or in a letter.
- 5:10So what we looked at first was how you actually deal with that, how you deal with it as a
- 5:15spy, what you're doing as a counter spy.
- 5:17How you deal with it with the problems of opening a letter, of closing a letter, of
- 5:21stopping your opponents knowing what you're doing.
- 5:24And then from then on, everything just kind of evolves so that we ended up with first
- 5:28you have to forge your letter.
- 5:30And then if you know that your letter is going to be forged, you think how else can you protect
- 5:34the information?
- 5:35Well, maybe you do ciphers and codes.
- 5:37Then maybe you start disguising the fact that you're using ciphers and codes.
- 5:40And then if necessary, you make it so that you can't even see that there's a message
- 5:44there.
- 5:45And then if necessary, just kill your opponent.
- 5:47Yeah, everything else fails.
- 5:49So having murder and assassination as the final chapter is of course a bit of a joke.
- 5:56But we thought just one chapter advice to deal with the problem that has arisen in the
- 6:03previous chapter.
- 6:06The interdisciplinary approach embedded in this book is truly unique.
- 6:11The ways material culture and sensory history are infused with intelligence history is masterful.
- 6:18And I found one of the most fascinating aspects of the book is the collection of different
- 6:22objects such as book gun, a frog pouch and a poison ring.
- 6:28And you mentioned how the early modern view of everyday objects was really different from
- 6:32how we see them today.
- 6:34And so I'm wondering what implications does this have for understanding early espionage
- 6:39techniques?
- 6:40Yeah, so we opened the book with a trompe l'oreal, a kind of painting that deceives
- 6:46the eye.
- 6:47And it's a necessary board, which looks like a 3D scene full of letters and ceiling wax
- 6:56and pen knives and other writings, writing bits, writing implements.
- 7:05And then suddenly you see a comb as well, and people have always thought, OK, that is
- 7:10presumably then a fanatist object or even or just symbolizing fanatism.
- 7:18And we've sort of found through the use of secondary literature that combs were actually
- 7:24used to score the paper to have kind of lines on the paper that you could then sort of use
- 7:31as kind of ruler.
- 7:34So there are so many objects that we no longer recognize as for what they were used for in
- 7:41the period.
- 7:42It's effectively the same in language.
- 7:44They're faux-zami.
- 7:45They're things that you see and you think, I know what that means, but actually it meant
- 7:49something completely different then.
- 7:51And it's very, very easy to get caught up in what we think things should mean and what
- 7:55we think.
- 7:56It's the same with words.
- 7:57What we think words meant they don't mean or they didn't mean what they mean now.
- 8:00So you have to be very careful always in every particular way that you're investigating anything
- 8:04in this period to make sure that you have an idea of what people then thought of these
- 8:09things and how they translated and interpreted objects.
- 8:12And sometimes it's very easy to get them wrong.
- 8:14But when you get them right, it quite often exposes things that you really didn't expect
- 8:18to be exposed.
- 8:20And it was also a period of superstition and where everything was still in flux.
- 8:28So you have certain spy techniques that obviously didn't work, but they believed that they did.
- 8:35So for instance, using a bit of unicorn horn to detect poisons, which is of course won't
- 8:43work, but even the biggest spy chiefs such as St. Francis Wolcingham absolutely believed
- 8:50that they did.
- 8:52So it's just looking at objects in a different manner.
- 8:57We do of course suffer from the same problems now where people think that certain things
- 9:01will protect them from X, Y and Z, that you can cure cancer by positive thought and all
- 9:05this kind of nonsense.
- 9:06And you have to be, none of this has gone away.
- 9:10We really have this idea sometimes that in the 21st century we think of things objectively
- 9:14and we're accurate and we're correct and right with everything, but actually we're not.
- 9:18Everything's in a state of flux.
- 9:19Knowledge is in a state of flux continually.
- 9:22And it certainly was back then, perhaps more so than it is now.
- 9:24But then that may just be from our perspective.
- 9:29So I think what we were trying to say with the comb, for instance, that you have to look
- 9:34at the kind of smallest details sometimes and even when you are doing archival research
- 9:40as well.
- 9:41Absolutely.
- 9:42And talking about imagery and different perspectives, I'm curious about your book cover.
- 9:48And within the narrative, it's mentioned that the 17th century Italian book of emblems,
- 9:53Iconologia by Cesare Rippa, included a sketch of a spy with his tools, which is described
- 9:59in your book as a man in a noble habit, hiding most of his face with his hat, his cloak woven
- 10:05with eyes, ears and tongues.
- 10:08So what does this image of a spy suggest about the perceptions of just spies in general in
- 10:13early modern Europe?
- 10:15Yes, this specific edition, this 17th century edition of Iconologia had the spear for the
- 10:23first time, a kind of emblem of the spy.
- 10:26And we use that for the book's cover.
- 10:28So you can see it there.
- 10:30But people might also have seen a certain design which compares to it in the rainbow
- 10:36portrait, that famous portrait of Elizabeth I, attributed to either Marcus Heeris or Isaac
- 10:43Oliver.
- 10:44We don't really know, but you can also see the kind of sensory equipment of spies, eyes
- 10:51and ears and the kind of main counsellors of the Queen, Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester,
- 10:59for instance, referred to himself as the Queen's eyes.
- 11:02And he drew a little emoticon under his letters saying, I am your majesty's eyes.
- 11:10Another one, the courtier and the later Lord Chancellor, Christopher Hatton, referred to
- 11:15her eyelids.
- 11:17So observing things are very important, but I think the main thing in this emblem that
- 11:24really stands out are the tongues.
- 11:26Yes, I mean the tongues, what they symbolise apart from chattering tongues and loose tongues
- 11:31and loose talk, is the importance of the patronage system, certainly in the late Elizabethan
- 11:36era, whereby the idea of a complete systematised professional secret service just didn't exist.
- 11:46All of the different spymasters had their own bunch of spies and they didn't talk to
- 11:51each other, they didn't share information because they were in competition.
- 11:53They were all in competition with each other to impress the Queen because the Queen was
- 11:57where they got their power from.
- 11:59So there wasn't this one particular way of doing things, everyone was, it was kind of
- 12:05a bit of a free fall.
- 12:07Yes, so the tongues sort of symbolised that you always had to flatter your patron, so
- 12:14the spies had to flatter their own patron and those patrons had to flatter the Queen,
- 12:20so everyone, they were all kind of competing with each other, such as Pete said.
- 12:27So in that emblem we see that the spy also has a dog, so this could be perhaps the spy's
- 12:35assistant, we thought.
- 12:38He carries several things, several tools, such as a lamp and the cloak is a kind of
- 12:46disguise, literally and metaphorically.
- 12:49Yes, so the lamp of course also has references to intellectual knowledge as well, and shining
- 12:55a lamp upon knowledge, which was quite a common emblem at the time too, so all of these things
- 13:00were wrapped in and around each other.
- 13:04And then you also asked whether it reflected the contemporary societal views about secrecy
- 13:10and deceit and perhaps the moral ambiguities of espionage.
- 13:18Yes and no, I think.
- 13:19We see on the emblem that this particular spy is wearing a kind of noble habit and dressing
- 13:27up, pretending to be probably of a higher status, though he definitely also had the
- 13:33gentleman spy.
- 13:35We can see the master code breaker of Elizabeth the First, Thomas Filippas, coming from a
- 13:41proper family as well as kind of Francis Bacon, but in this period the word spy came with
- 13:48a trunk full of negative connotations and this perhaps understandable because as a spy
- 13:54you had to lie, you had to cheat, you had to skulk in the shadows.
- 14:00You need to be morally corrupt to be a spy, so spies in general were also looked down
- 14:06upon.
- 14:07And also quite a few of them were, the lower sort were recruited from prisons anyway, so
- 14:12there was a real overlap between illegal behaviour and what you did as a spy, and ultimately
- 14:18whether what you do as a spy is considered really morally bad is whether you're caught
- 14:23or not and whether the person who is in charge of you wins or not.
- 14:28So being on the winning side is always the most important thing.
- 14:31Yeah, and I think it is important to remember that the word spy is a very modern one and
- 14:37it's as slippery in this period as the people it aims to describe.
- 14:42In the medieval world certainly the lines between messengers, diplomats, spies and secretaries
- 14:48were blurred.
- 14:49They were all seen as doing the same thing.
- 14:53They were responsible for secret matters and especially with ambassadors, they caused a
- 14:58lot of problems.
- 14:59They were called honourable spies, certainly to distinguish them from a kind of lower category
- 15:06of dishonourable spies.
- 15:09So they really struggled I think with the moral nature of being a spy or the morally
- 15:15corrupt nature.
- 15:16The late 16th and early 17th centuries were key for the rise of English espionage driven
- 15:22by Catholic threats abroad and at home, fueling plots, conspiracies and counter-espionage.
- 15:29Could you provide some insight into this context and elaborate on your micro-historical analysis
- 15:34of Arthur Gregory and his role in early modern espionage?
- 15:38You mentioned that Gregory was the early modern equivalent of James Bond's gadget specialist
- 15:43Q. So why did you choose him as a vehicle for the reader to engage with spycraft?
- 15:50And would you say he's a spy in the modern sense?
- 15:53In this period you have the Protestant Queen Elizabeth I replacing her half-sister Mary
- 16:00Tudor, also known as Bloody Mary in the period, who was of course Catholic.
- 16:07So a Protestant Queen is still surrounded by a lot of Catholics in the country and also
- 16:13by threatened by countries abroad such as Spain and also France who supported her rival,
- 16:22her distant cousin, also a Catholic Mary Queen of Scots who was a claimant to the throne.
- 16:29So she and the country as such was under a lot of pressure and England in a way became
- 16:35a pressure cooker to develop in which espionage techniques were developed.
- 16:42They really had to adapt and they were falling behind Italy and Spain in particular.
- 16:52But we see that the techniques are being invented and developed by men and women such as Arthur
- 17:01Gregory and he is a bit of a hero in the book because we have his name so we have a little
- 17:07bit of personal information about him as well which is rare.
- 17:12But because we wanted to work on the spy techniques we thought it was wonderful to have a kind
- 17:20of inventor of spy techniques at the centre and he is indeed a gadget specialist.
- 17:28Not so much a spy in the kind of modern sense but more of an intelligence espionage agent.
- 17:36Yes, counter-espionage agent.
- 17:39He is sitting behind a desk so he is not in the field but he is working in his office
- 17:45or his home laboratory inventing various things and working on several techniques.
- 17:52In what ways did the Thirty Years War and English Civil War influence the development
- 17:57of more sophisticated espionage systems?
- 18:01How did this shift from individuals like Arthur Gregory to more collaborative intelligence
- 18:05units as seen in the black chamber for instance impact the long-term effectiveness and institutional
- 18:11memory of early modern spy craft techniques?
- 18:16One of the things that Arthur Gregory complained about continually was that he didn't have
- 18:20constant employment and he would be writing to Seth, he would be writing to Walsingham
- 18:23saying give me a job, give me an office, make sure that I am constantly on call so that
- 18:28when you need me we can just go to work instead of trying to find him when you actually need
- 18:32something to be opened or something to be written or counterfeited or what have you.
- 18:37When it came to the Civil War, the English Civil War and the end of the English Civil
- 18:41War especially during the interregnum, one of the things that Thurlow who was one of
- 18:47Cromwell's later spy chiefs realised is that you need continuous application of spying
- 18:54techniques, you don't want things to be ad hoc, you need everything to be continually there
- 18:58and this is what was fundamentally behind the formation of the post office in England
- 19:04at the time.
- 19:05Cromwell was very specific about it, he said we are going to form the post office so that
- 19:08we can get all the letters in one place so that we can open them all, read them all and
- 19:11find out all your horrible plots against us.
- 19:14And that was fundamentally the beginning of a bureaucratic spy regime in England and this
- 19:21followed in from the earlier work of the Alexandrine of Texas who Nadine knows much more about
- 19:28than I, in Brussels.
- 19:31Yes, Alexandrine was a kind of post mistress who in the 1630s, so quite early already in
- 19:40comparison to other countries, came up with which we would later recognise as a kind of
- 19:46cabinet noir or black chamber where you have an intelligence union in a back office of
- 19:54what we would describe nowadays as a post office where they had ten men around the table,
- 20:02each with their own sort of task, so one person would open the letter, then the other person
- 20:07would copy the letter, there was a person who would forge the seal, there was a code
- 20:12breaker on site, a translator, someone who could copy really quickly and they all worked
- 20:18together and sort of tried to learn from each other as well.
- 20:22I think in the period of Arthur Gregory, because they were rifles, they did not share the secret
- 20:27techniques with each other, so there were kind of lone wolves.
- 20:32As soon as you have a kind of black chamber, you have ten colleagues who pass on their
- 20:37secret techniques to each other, so they do not constantly have to reinvent the wheel.
- 20:43When you look at the end of the Interregnum, you see two of the main inhabitants, main
- 20:49workers in the black chamber, Samuel Moreland and Isaac Dorislaus, they are both working
- 20:55in the black chamber for Thurlow, so they are both absolutely parliamentarian.
- 20:58As soon as the restoration comes along, they just stay, they basically switch sides, but
- 21:02fundamentally they have turned into civil servants, they are no longer spies as such,
- 21:06because normally what happens obviously when you get a change in regime, all the people
- 21:10who are doing nasty stuff in the previous regime get silently dealt with, or certainly
- 21:14don't remain in position, but in this instance that's exactly what happened, so it shows
- 21:20that it's going beyond maybe party affiliation in that respect and turning into a more professionalised
- 21:25service.
- 21:26What ways might the skills and technologies of early modern spies have influenced modern
- 21:31popular culture's portrayal of espionage?
- 21:34And given the tools available, do you think early modern spies were more reliant on their
- 21:39shrewd wit and resourcefulness than their modern counterparts?
- 21:46I think the glamour of 007 bears no relation to the crittily unpleasant and dangerous business
- 21:53of espionage and counter-espionage in this period, in the 1600s and 1700s.
- 22:01Of course the Q branch is fictional in the James Bond books, but in this period people
- 22:09were designing things for use by others, and of course there are code breakers still, so
- 22:17some of the techniques remain, but I'm not sure about the portrayal thereof.
- 22:23The same problems remain, you still have to break a code, but we break it in a different
- 22:27way, we use computers now.
- 22:29Of course at this point people were designing machines to try and solve these problems,
- 22:34so Samuel Moreland designed a triple-wheeled machine which he used for deciphering and
- 22:39deciphering things, which fundamentally in that respect is the precursor of the Enigma
- 22:43machine, a multi-wheeled cipher wheel, a multi-functional cipher wheel.
- 22:49So the same kind of things are happening, but we've moved on so much in technological
- 22:53terms.
- 22:54Of course if you look at Bacon's early cipher, that fundamentally is binary notation, so
- 23:02all of these things well into one other, they overlap so much, it's sometimes difficult
- 23:07to see that they are exactly the same thing because they're so completely different, but
- 23:11the fundamentals are always the same, it's just the way we deal with them are different.
- 23:15Not that I've virtually been a modern spy so I couldn't possibly say for certain, but
- 23:18the impression that one gets is there's a lot more support staff these days than there
- 23:22was in the 16th, 17th century.
- 23:25So certainly in the turn of the 16th century, going into the early 17th, you'd find that
- 23:30very much would be individuals dealing with things, so you'd just have your Arthur Gregory
- 23:35or your Philippe working and you'd very rarely see them working together, whereas by the
- 23:40middle of the 17th century you've got the black chain where people are collaborating,
- 23:44so it turns into a much more collaborative resource, and that means that you have to
- 23:49rely, I imagine, would have to rely less on your own individual ability because you'd
- 23:53be able to call on other people much more easily.
- 23:56Focusing on a specific method, in early modern political intrigues, poison was often used
- 24:02as a covert weapon, with figures like Catherine de Medici, who were rumoured to use poison,
- 24:09perhaps reflecting broader anxieties about power and influence, particularly involving
- 24:13women.
- 24:15So how did this fear of poison as a tool of espionage relate to larger concerns about
- 24:20control and what specific role did women play in this realm?
- 24:24Very hard to prove, of course, whether someone has been poisoned, and especially if then
- 24:29some of her entourage were perfumers, who were using this kind of distillation equipment
- 24:36and people weren't really sure what that person was brewing, so accusations of poisoning
- 24:44were quickly made, and she was poisoning her gloves, so these things turn up in intelligence
- 24:51reports, and it's certainly the case that you had actual poisoners, especially in France
- 24:57and Italy.
- 24:59In Italy there was a group of women active who sold poisons to wives who wanted to get
- 25:05rid of their husbands.
- 25:07That actually happened.
- 25:09But in England you have more the fear of poison being used.
- 25:14One of the great things about poison, of course, as a user, well, as a recipient, is that it's
- 25:20very difficult to tell that it has been used.
- 25:22If you stab someone in the head, it's kind of obvious what you've done.
- 25:24If you shoot somebody to assassinate them, it's kind of obvious what's happened.
- 25:28With poison it isn't quite so obvious, and quite a few of these poisons, people didn't
- 25:34really know how they worked, so they would do a lot of experimentation.
- 25:37There were experimentations with panaceas.
- 25:40So for example, you get people who were, at one point the Pope, I think it was the Pope,
- 25:45gave one of his surgeons a couple of prisoners to experiment on, and they were given a very
- 25:50stark choice.
- 25:51They said, what are we going to do?
- 25:52We're going to do this experiment.
- 25:54We'll give you some deadly poison, and if you survive, you go free.
- 25:59If you don't, you'll just die horribly, and we'll give you a panacea, and if it works,
- 26:03great, and if it doesn't, well, tough.
- 26:05One of them died horribly, the other one didn't allegedly, but they didn't really understand
- 26:10why, so of course it makes it much more useful as a weapon of fear, as well as a necessarily
- 26:16weapon you actually have to use, because the fear of poison would actually, I'm trying
- 26:23to think, what's the word, paralyse people.
- 26:25Certainly paralyse a lot of politicians at certain periods, but they spend so much time
- 26:30trying to prevent themselves from being poisoned.
- 26:33So, in England and in the late 16th century, where you have all these spy chiefs acting
- 26:40as rifles, all trying to be the better spy chiefs, to really become that head of intelligence,
- 26:47to really get into faith with Elizabeth I, they said, I can prevent this poison plot
- 26:53from happening, and they often had invented those poison plots themselves.
- 26:58So a lot of innocent men were executed to sort of show how powerful a secret service
- 27:04could be.
- 27:05Near the end of your book, you include a section on the practical application of some of these
- 27:11spycraft methods, such as ciphers and codes, recipes for making and revealing invisible
- 27:17ink, and organic poisons.
- 27:20So how much did you personally experiment with this, and what if anything went very
- 27:25wrong or was particularly unexpected?
- 27:28Yes, we experimented a lot.
- 27:30The only thing we didn't try ourselves, obviously, were the poisons and methods of killing each
- 27:37other or other people.
- 27:40We had help with the experiments from MIT, so some of these things were done in a proper
- 27:46laboratory, other things were done in our kitchen.
- 27:50We found that it really helps to appreciate the material constraints of certain techniques.
- 27:59And I think what really struck us was the element of time.
- 28:03Yes, especially when you're looking at ciphers and codes.
- 28:07It's the way that everyone talks about ciphers is, oh, yes, they got the cipher.
- 28:10So they decipher the letter, and then they solve the plot, and everything is fine.
- 28:15And there's no sense that any of this took any time.
- 28:18But as soon as you actually start working in these fields, as soon as you start writing
- 28:23out and actually trying to decipher, it takes ages, absolutely ages, even with the simple
- 28:28codes.
- 28:29And one of the reasons we put a lot of the cipher techniques in the appendices is that
- 28:34to explain them all is quite hard work, and actually detract from the actual narrative
- 28:40of what we're trying to get in the book part.
- 28:44But if you go to the more complicated codes, so the later ones, the auto-key ciphers, if
- 28:50you get one thing wrong, one letter wrong, every five or six letters will be wrong from
- 28:56then onwards.
- 28:57And of course, a couple of mistakes, and after you've done about 50 or 60 letters, the whole
- 29:02thing is complete gobbledygook, and you have to start again.
- 29:05And this is one of the things that we realized, certainly in the Barrington plot, there's
- 29:09this one period where Mary gets a letter from Barrington, and all the historians say, and
- 29:15then she prevaricates, she didn't know what to do, she was like, should I do this, should
- 29:19I do that, should I do the other?
- 29:20It's just total nonsense.
- 29:21She knew exactly what she wanted to do, it just took ages to decipher the letter, even
- 29:25with the keys, and then make a response, and then we cipher them so that they could actually
- 29:31send the bar.
- 29:32It takes an awful lot of time, which is why we put in part of one of the letters and said,
- 29:38just decipher it yourself.
- 29:40Decipher it and just see how long it takes, and see how difficult it is to do it without
- 29:44making a mistake.
- 29:45And even if you have the key, so here's the cipher key, and now just experiment with how
- 29:53much time it takes.
- 29:54But it's also what we're telling to experiment with invisible inks.
- 29:59So you see again how long it takes to reveal an invisible ink letter, holding it to a candle,
- 30:06how easy it is to set fire to the letter.
- 30:10And also how wonderful alum is, because you can dip your letter in water and instead of
- 30:16taking a long time, it will reveal instantly, and it dries back into invisibility again.
- 30:22So that is the only invisible ink that sort of turns invisible again.
- 30:29And we experimented with creating a message in an egg.
- 30:34We broke about 50 eggs before we got that to work.
- 30:37So it's a lot of fun.
- 30:40A lot of things can also be done with children.
- 30:43How to create a message in an egg is great for Easter, for instance.
- 30:47A lot of omelets that week.
- 30:49A lot of omelets that week, yeah.
- 30:51But it was all serious intellectual work, of course.
- 30:56So my last question is, what key ideas would you like your readers to take away from your
- 31:01book?
- 31:03I think that materiality matters.
- 31:06Pay attention to detail.
- 31:08Archival work, archival research, it's not stuffy, but it really can be very sexy and
- 31:15you can change the most well-known stories if you pay attention to detail.
- 31:20And also when we mean pay attention to detail, this means that sometimes the people who really
- 31:25are doing the work and the people who are acting in these big politically earth-shattering
- 31:31plots are quite often the little people who are really doing the business.
- 31:35So like in the bad winter plot, it's the secretaries who are fighting each other.
- 31:39It's not Walsingham and Mary, they're just kind of overseeing them.
- 31:42It's actually secretaries on the front line who are doing all the fighting.
- 31:46And that sometimes people, I think, completely forget.
- 31:49Yes, people who you sort of think of, those who are really kind of in the margin, suddenly
- 31:54come back into focus.
- 31:56So you get kind of different actors in history.
- 32:02Well, it's been such a treat to speak with you both about your book.
- 32:09Thank you very much for joining me.
- 32:11Thank you for inviting us.
- 32:12It was a pleasure.