Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Hindrances of Enlightenment
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the deepening, your practice podcast
- 0:03with George Haas, deepening. Your practice is recorded at the
- 0:07against this dream, Buddhist Meditation Society in Los
- 0:10Angeles. California for more information,
- 0:13visit our website at www.medicare.gov dot-org.
- 0:18That's www.a me. TT a gr, oup dot-org.
- 0:32So welcome. And we've been in the chapter on
- 1:19purification of mind. Purification of Mind means that
- 1:25the mind is not subject to the hindrances that you're able to
- 1:28place your attention where you want to put it in, keep it there
- 1:32without them scooping you out of the meditation and the in the
- 1:40previous conversation we were talking about Carnot, the
- 1:44samadhi which is the Pali word for momentary concentration
- 1:48meditation. It's the way one way of Of
- 1:53getting into meditation is to get into an inside practice
- 1:58first. And one way to get into
- 2:00meditation, practice is to come in through concentration first
- 2:05and then go into Insight, practice.
- 2:08Karnataka, samadhi means momentary concentration.
- 2:12So actually when you're noting, so it's also kind of a, you
- 2:16could call it a noting practice. Noting is where, you know where
- 2:20your attention is. You soak.
- 2:22And have the experience of the sensing.
- 2:27This is different than finding an object of meditation to
- 2:30concentrate on in maintaining awareness of the object of
- 2:33meditation. So in momentary concentration,
- 2:37Insight practice. The at your attention is just
- 2:41moving from meditation event to meditation event.
- 2:45You're highly concentrated in the moment of noting that
- 2:50particular sensory phenomenon And then in between it is not so
- 2:54concentrated, very different way of approaching it.
- 2:58Then developing was continuous one pointed concentration and
- 3:02then moving from there into Insight practice Mahaffey is
- 3:09making the case for this as being equivalent to or just as
- 3:14good as and because this is in some sense.
- 3:21Historic this the document itself it's been translated as I
- 3:27would guess, 40 plus years old Without looking at the date,
- 3:34maybe we should. It doesn't say right here.
- 3:55Was teaching and dominant in the middle half of the 20th century
- 4:01and died in the 80s. So at that time, the idea that
- 4:08Karnataka samadhi or momentary concentration inside practice,
- 4:12could be considered as equivalent to a echo, got to
- 4:16base one pointedness, concentration first.
- 4:19Meditation was extremely controversial.
- 4:22And so, in some sense this manual is making the case for
- 4:27noting practice when it was not the dominant form of meditation
- 4:32in the intervening. Ting time.
- 4:34Of course, noting practice has not only become an accepted way
- 4:39of practicing but it's probably the dominant way of practicing
- 4:42in the west. So, totally absent of the
- 4:46difficulty that was faced by people advocating this because
- 4:51of the the change in cultural acceptance.
- 4:56So, We talked about attachment last week, but we're in some
- 5:03sense talking about the hindrances that come and corrupt
- 5:08the mind. So, this chapter purification of
- 5:11Mind, purification of Mind means that an absence of the
- 5:15hindrances and he's describing in these passages our way of
- 5:19working at with the hindrances as they arise.
- 5:22And this sub chapter is called non inversion and eversion.
- 5:28Non a version is a cause of Liberation for Noble ones.
- 5:31Noble ones, gain Liberation from the cycle of suffering by
- 5:35developing it a version is a hindrance to Liberation.
- 5:40When present it hinders a noble ones.
- 5:42Realization of non aversion on the path of Liberation.
- 5:46For this region of version is called a hindrance to Liberation
- 5:51one of the the Three poisons, craving aversion and
- 5:57unconsciousness, greed, hatred and delusion.
- 6:06The absence of a version or frustration associated with the
- 6:10noting mind it inside practice is called non aversion.
- 6:14This quality allows one to continue noting without
- 6:16frustration, when unpleasant objects unbearable, pain or
- 6:20other difficulties, arise during practice until One attains
- 6:24Nevada, and is released from the cycle of suffering.
- 6:32One of the things that was unique about the Burmese style
- 6:38and Maja see in particular, is the belief that householders
- 6:42could gain Liberation in many of the monastic Traditions.
- 6:47It's only male monastics who can get liberated.
- 6:51Everybody else cannot, but Maha see firmly believed and
- 6:58advocated for the liberation of householders, which Was actually
- 7:01one of the reasons why I found him to be an attractive teacher.
- 7:07I have not really ever had much of a colon for the monastic
- 7:11life. And I remember early on, in my
- 7:17developing of papasa not talking to a monastic, who advised me
- 7:23that I was much too functional to consider a monastic life that
- 7:28actually monasteries are for people who can't make it in the
- 7:31outside world. And if you have any chance of
- 7:34making it in the outside world, you should not go to a
- 7:37monastery, which I thought was pretty funny, but the Idea of
- 7:45Liberation was very appealing to me, maybe you will have an idea
- 7:48of what Nirvana is or what Liberation is, what freedom is
- 7:54and what can be useful in a kind of dialogue around.
- 7:59This is to compare what you think it is to what it might be
- 8:04so that you're at least in the ballpark of what it is.
- 8:07Because certainly my original conception of what a Liberation
- 8:11might be was not really related. Add two to what it is.
- 8:18I wanted to have a stress-free problem-free existence where I
- 8:24got everything that I wanted, that was what I thought
- 8:27Liberation was. But this turned out not to be
- 8:31the case necessarily. One way to describe Liberation
- 8:39would be to be able to come and go from the experience of self
- 8:42whenever you wanted to come and go from the experience of the
- 8:45world. Whenever you wanted to touch to
- 8:48be able to touch into the source is how my teacher shins, and the
- 8:53describe that come, and go from cessation into a fully manifest
- 8:58itself whenever you want. So a version is the not wanting
- 9:07of things when you have the experience of something.
- 9:11You may notice. the arising of the idea that you would like
- 9:19something else instead of what's happening or a version arises
- 9:23and you would not like what's happening We're going to do some
- 9:32meditation tonight, which is a triple noting of see.
- 9:37Hear feel. So first, there's the noting for
- 9:39sensory Clarity. What is the actual sensing
- 9:42experiences? It activating visual auditory
- 9:46feeling experience in the body. First Foundation, I'm a Rupa
- 9:54thinking and sensing In the second Foundation of
- 9:59mindfulness, we have what's known as vague nor feeling tones
- 10:04Veda is related to the quality of the sensing experience.
- 10:08I like to think of it, it Geez neurobiological terms a kind of
- 10:20processing speed that is associated with sensing
- 10:25experience unpleasant experience.
- 10:31These are all English translations of poly words and
- 10:35the popular translations, which were largely using were really
- 10:41done in England, in the end of the 19th century.
- 10:50And they've, they've tended to hold pretty firm with that, but
- 10:55I often find them not to be particularly descriptive of what
- 10:59actually is happening. So unpleasant is that the term?
- 11:05It's popularly used. But I really think of it.
- 11:08More as urgent needs urgent attention, and if you look at it
- 11:13from that neurobiological aspect processing speeds are different,
- 11:19Pending on the, the way that the sensing experience is
- 11:23interpreted if it needs urgent attention, it takes less and
- 11:28less intensity of sensation less duration of society of the
- 11:32sensation in order for it to be moved to the front of the queue.
- 11:36So, unpleasant material is always superseding, all over all
- 11:40other experience, and it's faster.
- 11:42So it's we're sort of evolutionarily wired to respond
- 11:48to Door urgent material faster than other sensing experiences.
- 11:56The bandwidth of Consciousness is extremely narrow.
- 11:59And so almost everything that you experience sensorially is
- 12:05categorized as neutral and almost none of it makes its way
- 12:10into consciousness. You have the capacity to sense
- 12:16you have the object that can be sensed and when they meet a
- 12:19consciousness of that sensing experience arises, which
- 12:22awareness knows. But the bandwidth of
- 12:25Consciousness is so narrow. Almost everything doesn't make
- 12:30it into Consciousness. It's all unconscious processing.
- 12:36Using the numbers that were developed by a group of French
- 12:39neuro scientists. The body mind has the capacity
- 12:42to sin. That a rate of 11 million bits
- 12:45per second. So quite a chunk of data, but
- 12:50the conscious mind only has the capacity to process 16 bits per
- 12:55second. So in any given second of
- 12:59experience, you're getting 16 pieces out of 11 million
- 13:04possibilities. So when I say almost everything
- 13:07is a neutral experience that you never have awareness of, that's
- 13:11the vast majority of sensing Do you think that it would be
- 13:17useful say to know what, the parts per million of adrenaline
- 13:22was in the in the bloodstream? And then to have the conscious
- 13:26ability to adjust that. So that it's always optimal.
- 13:29Maybe a lot of the information that the body mind is able to
- 13:33detect is in something that would be useful consciously
- 13:36anyway. Have you seen the photographs of
- 13:39the Tibetan Monks that are able to take their automatic system
- 13:45of Eating the temperature of the body and manually controlling
- 13:49it. There's a famous photograph of
- 13:52monks sitting in the snow with a ring of melted, snow around them
- 13:56because they jacked up their body temperature, hot enough
- 14:00that they can melt snow. Um, would you spend 30 years of
- 14:07your life? Melting snow manually with body
- 14:11temperature? I haven't found that to be
- 14:15something so compelling, but maybe if I lived in a cave, be
- 14:25more urgent. My God side effect to the side
- 14:32effect to that level of study. Control.
- 14:37You've been practicing. Where are you?
- 14:44Just for a second? Uh-huh.
- 15:05How is that partitioned off? like, if my neck hurts, That's
- 15:12we would consider that Sensei like a big chunk of that.
- 15:1516-bit. Yeah, could be.
- 15:20But it's a good question about 10 million of the B is in visual
- 15:24processing, external visual processing.
- 15:27So that whole back, third of the brain processes visual input and
- 15:31forms it into the picture of the world that you're currently
- 15:34seeing. About a million bits is the
- 15:41sensing of the body and then there's 100,000 to tasting,
- 15:47smelling 100,000 spelling 100,000 hearing, so maybe this
- 15:54is why people who can't see. The brain is plastic.
- 16:06So for people who have no sight that that back third of the
- 16:10brain begins to have this others sensory input, So, 16 bits.
- 16:22I like to think of it as the printer.
- 16:27If we're using a computer metaphor to describe this
- 16:31everything is processed, and then when everything is
- 16:33processed, all of the decisions are made, the decision is sent
- 16:37over to the printer, so you could get the readout on What is
- 16:41the evolutionary purpose than of this Consciousness and it really
- 16:46acts as a veto function? That at the last the last
- 16:52millisecond just before you're about to take an action, it
- 16:56flashes into conscious mind and you have the choice of not doing
- 16:59it, that would be the purpose of it.
- 17:04So it doesn't initiate it. You don't initiate anything from
- 17:07Consciousness. You don't organize anything from
- 17:10Consciousness. All you do is at the last
- 17:13possible second realize that this is a dumb idea to stop
- 17:17doing it. Have you ever found yourself two
- 17:21words into a sentence that you realize if you complete it would
- 17:24be a complete disaster and so you just stop and then
- 17:28immediately deflect. But you were going to say So, 16
- 17:37bits, 150 micro 650,000 microseconds is the processing
- 17:43for unpleasant experience. Most everything is neutral so it
- 17:47never gets into Consciousness. Then pleasant experience
- 17:50requires twice the intensity plus five hundred thousand
- 17:56microseconds. So it's more than three times
- 17:59the length of the sensing experience in order for it to
- 18:03come into Justice. So that we are totally oriented
- 18:08around danger, Dangerous material, and we have pleasant
- 18:14experiences. If there's time, if we have
- 18:17enough time for it. So it's easy to get stuck on a
- 18:21really negative Jag of thinking and a feeling of being and isn't
- 18:26that the positive experiences aren't there?
- 18:28It's just that urgent stuff. Always supersedes everything
- 18:33else. We have a negativity bias that's
- 18:36it. Yeah.
- 18:39Is it more important that you lolly gag in the grass?
- 18:43When the sun is shining warmly? Or that you're aware that
- 18:46there's a saber-toothed tiger crouching at the edge of the
- 18:50woods ready to eat you So we have that by so it's all about
- 18:55protecting the body. So, craving a version
- 19:04unconsciousness, the three poisons.
- 19:08The next one that he talks about is brightness and sloth and
- 19:11torpor. Observing light is a cause of
- 19:14Liberation for the noble ones, Noble ones, gain Liberation from
- 19:18the cycle of suffering by developing by developing it
- 19:22sloth and torpor are hindrances to Liberation and present.
- 19:26It hinders the observation of light.
- 19:28For this reason, sloth and torpor are called hindrances to
- 19:33Aberration. Contemplation of Sunlight,
- 19:37Moonlight Starlight and light that arises in meditation is
- 19:42called observing light. It can become it, can overcome
- 19:47fatigue or sleepiness, contemplation of bright light,
- 19:51overcomes, dullness and sleepiness, then one can
- 19:54continue practicing inside. Well, this practice with this
- 19:58practice, one, obtains Nirvana and is therefore a liberated
- 20:02from the cycle of suffering. Hence, the car The contemplation
- 20:06of light is called is the cause of Liberation for Noble ones.
- 20:13When we talk about the cessation of suffering or the cycle of
- 20:17suffering, we're referring to the four path model of
- 20:19liberation. In the Tera vaada sense of this.
- 20:27The first path is called stream and tree and it said that you're
- 20:30reincarnated seven more times. If you get to stream entry in
- 20:37Tera vaada Buddhism, Liberation is to is defined as the
- 20:41eradication of the ten Fetters and it's divided into a for path
- 20:45model of the eradication of the ten feathers.
- 20:52The first is the eradication of belief in a continuous ongoing
- 20:59sense of self. You see that there isn't that
- 21:03the second is the eradication of belief that religious ceremony
- 21:08will lead to Liberation. It's often coupled with the
- 21:14belief, in God eradicated, In This Moment In traditional A lot
- 21:21of Buddhism a belief in God is a hindrance to Liberation.
- 21:29It said that you cannot be liberated if you have that
- 21:32belief. And the third aspect is the
- 21:37eradication of the hindrance of Dowd.
- 21:41Doubt that this path will lead to Liberation and it makes
- 21:45sense. That, that would be eradicated
- 21:47if you've been liberated since, you know that the path leads to
- 21:51Liberation. So doubting that in the
- 21:55hindrance of Doubt is not a doubt about other things.
- 21:59Many things can be doubted in still be good, still have a
- 22:04liberated mind, it's that the doubt about the path leading to
- 22:09Liberation is Eradicated. How do they Define God about?
- 22:15No God. I'm gonna go with a metaphysical
- 22:21being like a separate entity. Yeah.
- 22:28So there's one really do you really have a choice anymore
- 22:34soon, whether or not you'll keep going on the back, actually, the
- 22:39turning point is much earlier than that.
- 22:43In traditional Tera vaada Buddhism, the 16 stages of
- 22:47Insider 16 stages of Enlightenment.
- 22:50The turning point is considered the fifth stage which is
- 22:54dissolution If you in a lot of the commentaries, when you read
- 23:03them and you come to the fourth stage, which is arising and
- 23:07passing, so awareness of the in permanent nature of all sensing
- 23:12experience. It's your there's always a
- 23:16warning that says you don't, if you don't want to have to
- 23:20continue practicing for the rest of your life, you should stop
- 23:22now. What is that?
- 23:25That line of demarcation. So it's between arising and
- 23:28passing and dissolution. So, the 4th and the 5th stage In
- 23:33dissolution, the arising and passing become.
- 23:37So you become so concentrated on the arising and passing that the
- 23:45perception of the barrier between inside and outside
- 23:50dissolves, and you're no longer able to form a sense of
- 23:55continuous self, you could not for instance, be able to detect
- 23:59the chair from the body, the clothing from the body.
- 24:03It's just It's a complete flow of sensing experience with
- 24:06nothing fixated. And so that perception of the
- 24:12whole, the whole fixated sense of self completely goes and
- 24:19because it goes and you've seen it, you can't unsee it.
- 24:24And then go back to a belief in the solid continuous experience
- 24:29of self, which is why it said to.
- 24:33And then of course, how do you, how do you tolerate that without
- 24:37practice? I mean, how do you we
- 25:02Well, the dissolution experience is often mistaken for stream
- 25:08entry, so there's there can be some confusion around around
- 25:12that when you reform the body in coming out of dissolution, you
- 25:20go, you drop into its own as the knowledge of the miseries, you
- 25:25have often a very strong fear reaction to they're actually
- 25:30being nobody. And nothing solid.
- 25:34The second one is called Misery and it's related to
- 25:38impermanence. Nothing is permanent.
- 25:40Nothing is lasting? Nothing can be counted on in.
- 25:43And so you come into this place of deep sadness that that
- 25:47everything will be lost, including your life.
- 25:50And then that puts you into these again, are these English
- 25:55translations of poly words. Discussed is the last one and
- 25:59they, they have never resonated very well.
- 26:02With me, I tend to think of dukkha as unsatisfactoriness,
- 26:07that makes more sense to me, but as you familiarize yourself with
- 26:11it, you can choose what you like.
- 26:14There are three levels of dukkha or unsatisfactoriness.
- 26:17The first is old age sickness and death.
- 26:19When you lose the ability to contact the body, the perception
- 26:24of solidness goes. And you come into this really,
- 26:31this deeply-held integrated sense that this is going to go.
- 26:38The second level of dukkha or unsatisfactoriness is getting
- 26:42what you want and losing it, not getting what you want and having
- 26:46to put up with things that you don't want.
- 26:49That's the second level. How have you had the experience
- 26:53of really wanting something and getting it and then it not
- 26:56lasting. Have you really wanted to get
- 27:01something and then not been able to get it?
- 27:05And have you had the indignity of having to put up with stuff
- 27:09that you don't want? That seems like all there is.
- 27:21And then, the third level, is this subtle ongoing irritation
- 27:26that nothing is actually how you would have it if you were
- 27:29actually in charge of anything. So it's a kind of two-pronged
- 27:33thing. Nothing is the way.
- 27:35You would have it and you have to face up to not being in
- 27:38charge of anything. So when you come out of
- 27:43dissolution, if you're thinking that you've had the Liberation
- 27:46experience and you end up in the knowledge of the miseries, that
- 27:49would be an indication that you've not had stream entry,
- 27:52what you've had is dissolution. In stream entry going to
- 27:58cessation the cessation of awareness and when you come out
- 28:01you watch the experience of self and World reform and in seeing
- 28:07through your direct experience that happen.
- 28:09It eradicates any. Any belief you may have had that
- 28:17there was something solid, something permanent something,
- 28:20intrinsic happening. You see self and World form out
- 28:27of this, the capacity to sense. But you have the direct
- 28:31experience of sensing without fixating anything.
- 28:38This may not be making sense but we make things solid by
- 28:42attaching to them and if you don't attach to them it's just a
- 28:47flow of of sensing experience. There's no language.
- 28:51There's no objects. There's Just Energy, just
- 28:55movement. So, you fixate the world.
- 29:07When you come out of the cessation experience, you watch
- 29:11the process of the Mind reforming, the solid sense of
- 29:15everything. And you have the experience of
- 29:17it, not being formed and then being formed and you see in the
- 29:21formation of the experience of your own self and the experience
- 29:26of the world, any distortions that you might put into it.
- 29:31So that if you don't hold yourself as this gorgeous
- 29:34wonderful deserving of love, being you watch the imperfection
- 29:43at judgment, that Association of less than that attached to the
- 29:49experience of who you are. But because you've seen that and
- 29:53had the experience of yourself without any of that, when it
- 29:57reattaches, you recognize it as empty.
- 30:01See that it's a conditioned response.
- 30:03Not something that's actually there, which is very freeing
- 30:09version and attachment. Or they are they distant cousins
- 30:13or they're closely related, are they in the same Spectrum?
- 30:20Whether as a hindrance, you mean?
- 30:22Yeah. It is the group of hindrances.
- 30:27Yes. So it's pretty much the same.
- 30:31But yeah, it is something that prevents this this question
- 30:37before this process that you just described could this be
- 30:43during the course of one, long sit or this is the period of a
- 30:46couple of years or My parents have, it is pretty
- 30:50serendipitous. It's hard to predict how it will
- 30:54happen. I've met many people say coming
- 30:57into the meditation center having, had this experience with
- 31:01no practice and no knowledge at all of any of this stuff,
- 31:06wondering, what the hell happened to them?
- 31:10That's called being struck, enlightened pretty ordinary,
- 31:15it's not really, it's just, well, the dissolution piece, but
- 31:20they could have had the actual experience of cessation and
- 31:25watch that whole thing happening.
- 31:26Just think that they're crazy. Or come and look for an
- 31:32explanation. There's a book by the, the
- 31:35former head of the Los Angeles, Zen Center that described her
- 31:40doing the dishes and having the experience of cessation and
- 31:43coming out of it and not being able to reform a sense of self
- 31:49and it being disastrous in its sense because not being able to
- 31:53reform his sense of self. When she couldn't be the wife
- 31:56that she had been, she couldn't be the mother.
- 31:57She had been, she couldn't be the employee.
- 32:00She'd been And they took her around to Western Psychiatric
- 32:05facilities and the she was told that she was having a
- 32:09depersonalization event and that that she would eventually
- 32:14recollect but it didn't resolve and then she went to her
- 32:21religious institutions work which were Christian and they
- 32:24didn't really have much in the way of health.
- 32:27And just by accident she was driving down, Crenshaw passed
- 32:30The Los Angeles, Zen Center, and she parked her car and went in
- 32:34and sat in front of the Abbot and describe this experience.
- 32:38And he said, oh yes, you've had stream entry and this is what
- 32:41you do. So that, you know, in that
- 32:45context, you just began to practice, send their later,
- 32:49became the head of the center that's described in Sunrise at
- 32:55called santori, you know? These are different Maps.
- 33:02The Tara, bottom map is one map. The Zen map is a different map
- 33:06and they describe the process of this happening, but is the same
- 33:12That's a good question. If you practice in the terabyte
- 33:19away, due to have a tendency then to have the big cessation
- 33:23event and if you practice in the Zen way of practicing, do you
- 33:26have the walking through Mist experience that drenches you
- 33:30eventually and you end up enlightened, is it the kind of
- 33:35practice that reveals a kind of insight?
- 33:38And then how do you know which map to use?
- 33:42These are all questions. I like this map that I'm
- 33:46describing to you because it's but my experience has been, I
- 33:50didn't have to translate anything, it's just kind of the
- 33:53way that it happened for me. But then you have to you're not
- 33:57me and your conditioning is not mine.
- 34:00So you have to examine for yourself.
- 34:03What is a good way to go? There are lots of different
- 34:06Maps. I tend to like this one and I
- 34:10talked about it because it's so similar to what my my practice
- 34:15has been like again a good question.
- 34:23I haven't been in two places to know.
- 34:30This is John practice. Is that part of the this map or
- 34:34is it part of a nom de Prix? De a lot of the day, probably
- 34:40predate. This certainly, the Buddha of
- 34:44good Jonna was very Adept at reaching the 8th jhana and
- 34:49discovered in being able to do that.
- 34:51That was not Liberation as he was thinking.
- 34:57And so he continued practicing in a different way than that.
- 35:06And really we're talking about these two paths.
- 35:09One is to develop Jonna and go from Jonna him to inside
- 35:12practice. And one is to develop momentary
- 35:16concentration through Insight practice.
- 35:21We're all householders and so it may be more economical to do
- 35:26inside. Practice leading to develop
- 35:29concentration. Certainly, that would be the
- 35:31case that Maha see is making. But also in my experience
- 35:38teaching here at against the stream, offering basic Insight,
- 35:42practices that people didn't have enough concentration to do
- 35:48them. So that there was a base level
- 35:52of concentration, that was needed in order to even do the
- 35:55inside technique, well enough to be able to have the momentary
- 36:00concentration, that's required for that, that way of
- 36:04practicing. And and I know that culturally
- 36:08here, the dominant way of practicing is an open awareness
- 36:14way of practicing and that doesn't necessarily produce the
- 36:17level of concentration in the short periods that people
- 36:21practice, that, that would likely make this kind of noting
- 36:25practice or a real possibility. So I began to teach just a basic
- 36:31breath counting, practice to develop just a A basic level of
- 36:37concentration. So that you would be able to do
- 36:40the technique well enough that you would begin to get the fruit
- 36:43of insight practice from it. And, you know, it's really 10
- 36:48minutes of concentration practice.
- 36:52Every other day for 3 months is enough to develop that level of
- 36:57concentration where then you can move into the direct.
- 37:02Inside path. But I found that it as a teacher
- 37:09that without that minimum amount of concentration, practice
- 37:14people. Weren't able to have momentary
- 37:18concentration that the hindrances that we've been
- 37:21talking about what, in fact, that the effort from moment
- 37:26momentary concentration, and the fruits of insight practice would
- 37:31not, then arrived and people became Frustrated in their
- 37:36practice because they weren't getting the prescribed thing out
- 37:40of it. But then with that minimum level
- 37:44of developing concentration, the fruits of insight began to flow
- 37:48easily from practice. So you really also have to
- 37:52figure out where your capacity for concentration is and also
- 37:57paying attention to the purification of mind that in the
- 38:02moment that you're concentrating moment in.
- 38:04That moment is the Mind free of endurance is free of the
- 38:10distraction. But you want to do is to get
- 38:14into a rhythm of the noting practice that Bridges it
- 38:19Bridges. Each of these individual moments
- 38:22of noting into a kind of concentrated mind that's similar
- 38:26to having developed access concentration or Jonna But doing
- 38:31it by this momentary concentrations that.
- 38:34So, you begin the noting practice and then you may notice
- 38:37two or three or five minutes into practice.
- 38:40Suddenly, it seems that the mind has become concentrated where is
- 38:43it may have as you began the practice seemed scattered.
- 38:48But you know, we're householders.
- 38:50So we're coming in at the end of the day, we the sloth and torpor
- 38:54pieces. Usually an issue, we're sitting
- 38:56down where we going to practice. It's 8:00 at night and we're
- 39:00sleepy. The mind is agitated and won't
- 39:05settle. So that coming into that
- 39:07momentary concentration were not able in that moment to purify.
- 39:13The mind that is to say to make the Mind free of hindrances.
- 39:16So they can actually be in the meditative experience.
- 39:19So, you'll notice with me, I'm often offering a concentration
- 39:25period prior to doing the Insight, practice to gather the
- 39:29mind and then pushing into the Practice, which is a kind of
- 39:35hybrid of the division between the two.
- 39:39I'm not asking you to go into access concentration or to Jonna
- 39:42first. I'm just asking you to collect
- 39:46the mind and then go into the noting practice.
- 39:54Is that thing that you talk to you about in the beginning about
- 39:57focusing on like as a solution to tiredness is that related to
- 40:02what you were just saying. Yeah, but you're just imagine
- 40:04the sun. No, you look at the light.
- 40:09Have to be naturally. It doesn't a lot of people do
- 40:12with candles that, you know, have you heard of that, they
- 40:15light a candle and they focus on the light of the candle or any
- 40:19of those. I'm an old son all the time.
- 40:28Kind of person. I live here because I want 365
- 40:32days of sun. I'm willing to see the quarter
- 40:34day a year but anything beyond that.
- 40:38Throws me into what I call California, seasonal affect
- 40:42disorder, 10 minutes of overcast and you know I need
- 40:46antidepressants. I have bright lights that I have
- 40:53on my desk for days like the last week or so it's but it's
- 40:57been too great for me. So I have a bright light that
- 41:00just blasts me with life, I call it my happy light.
- 41:06So it does. It does energize you to have
- 41:09that. It's just a physiological
- 41:11response to it, huh? So If, for instance, at the end
- 41:18of my day, I decide to sit down and meditate and I met with
- 41:26either fatigue or lack of concentration, is it?
- 41:33I tend to Bear down and do the best I can with what I have
- 41:37available. Do you recommend that or do you
- 41:40recommend? Just I would not doing it at all
- 41:44and just coming back to it or making the Lite-Brite See this,
- 41:50this is way too dark for me. How is it for you?
- 41:53This is the way the room is. I like it really bright.
- 41:59Well, maybe one bulb is out and that's why it's not quite
- 42:02enough. I'm always jacking the light all
- 42:07the way up because it energizes things.
- 42:12This is to Moody. So we're going to do some triple
- 42:27noting practice. So first noting for sensory
- 42:31Clarity. So is it a visual experience and
- 42:37auditory experience? Or is it a feeling experience in
- 42:39the body? See, hear feel are the labels.
- 42:46Then we're going to note for Vaden of feeling tones and
- 42:50feeling tones. Second Foundation refers to the
- 42:54quality of the sensing experience.
- 42:58Is it Pleasant unpleasant or neutral?
- 43:00Most, I think most sensing experience tends to fall in the
- 43:04neutral category if it's visual or auditory.
- 43:09And the body is often a mix of pleasant neutral and unpleasant
- 43:14experience. So you may have a pain that
- 43:16would be experienced the sensing aspect of it as unpleasant, you
- 43:21may have say the feeling of the breath.
- 43:27That would be neutral. The experience of temperature
- 43:31might be neutral but then you might notice that a breeze is
- 43:35blowing and it's a pleasant experience Across the Skin.
- 43:41And then the third aspect is going to be whether you're
- 43:44craving something different than what is your aversive to what is
- 43:49or you get caught up in unconsciousness.
- 43:53Most of the time we get caught up in an Consciousness, we end
- 43:56up in thinking and so it's useful to note the thinking and
- 44:00then come back to the see hear feel aspect.
- 44:04We're doing noting practice. So we know what where our
- 44:09attention is, we soak in and have the sensing experience of
- 44:12it and then it's helpful to generate an auditory label of
- 44:17which aspect of sensing you're dealing with So, auditory
- 44:22thinking for most people is inside the head between the ears
- 44:25are actually at the ears. So you generate the word, see if
- 44:33it's visual experience. So visual experience of Eyes Are
- 44:36Open, which sometimes you do, because you're falling asleep,
- 44:39but that's more energy, more light that would be one aspect
- 44:44of experience and insight space to Second aspect would be
- 44:49internal visual thinking so most people have a blank screen which
- 44:54is there. And then when you have imagery
- 44:59associated with thinking, Acted on to the screen.
- 45:03Some people also have a sense of the light coming through the
- 45:07eyelids. That's a different thing than
- 45:10the mental screen, and it's actually more related to
- 45:14exterior site. You have a visual aspect of the
- 45:19outline of the body and its current position.
- 45:23Kind of proprioceptive sense of how the body is laid out.
- 45:29You have the body's location in its current environment.
- 45:32Most people would report this as a sort of the view looking out.
- 45:37If you close your eyes, you can detect it.
- 45:41Some people have what's called, otoscope Ian, which is there
- 45:44actually outside of the body, looking at the body.
- 45:46But most people would report this view of just looking
- 45:50straight out into the environment, as a way of
- 45:53locating, the body in the current environment, you'll have
- 45:57an image reaction to a local sensation in the body.
- 46:00Say, if I were to ask you to examine the pressure on your
- 46:05left foot, you might then notice also there's an image of the
- 46:09left foot appearing in the mind. And and then there's an image
- 46:12reaction to exterior sound. So you hear something?
- 46:16And there's a visual aspect of that that would all be see
- 46:19experience. So you would know that your
- 46:22attention was in see experiencing soak into the
- 46:25sensing experience and then you would generate the word.
- 46:28See, In auditory experience, there's exterior sound which is
- 46:35the soundscape around you. There's the Clear Talk of the
- 46:38mind so you hear the voice inside your head.
- 46:43And you know what, the words mean that to the Clear Talk of
- 46:46the mind? Some people are able to detect,
- 46:49a subtle vibratory activity, in the same location.
- 46:52So, somewhere inside the head between the years are at the
- 46:55ears. And actually what you notice if
- 46:58you focus on that, is the cognition of what the Clear Talk
- 47:01will be precedes, the Clear Talk so that you know what the Clear
- 47:05Talk is going to be before it happens and then you can watch
- 47:09that. If your attention is drawn to
- 47:14auditory experience, you soak in, you know, that that's where
- 47:18it is and soak in. And then generate the word here
- 47:22in auditory thinking space, there's no need to label the
- 47:28labeling. And then if your attention is
- 47:32drawn to some sensation in the body.
- 47:35So, gravity temperature respiration circulation,
- 47:38digestion. The efforting to hold the
- 47:40posture or emotional experience in the body, then you would
- 47:46bring your. You would know that your
- 47:48attention was there soaked into the sensing experience of that
- 47:52and then you would generate the label feel in order to
- 47:55rethinking space that clear terms of the basic techniques
- 48:00Wake of see hear feel. We'll do that for a little bit
- 48:04and then we'll add to that Vada or feeling tones.
- 48:08The second foundation. So double noting noting first
- 48:12for sensory Clarity. And then whether you find the
- 48:14experience of sensing Pleasant unpleasant or neutral, And then
- 48:20we'll do that for a little bit and then we'll do we'll add the
- 48:23triple noting which is whether you're craving something
- 48:27different, whether you're aversive to what is whether you
- 48:30get caught up in the thinking or you come into Equanimity with
- 48:33the experience of the present moment.
- 48:36In which case you would label that I like to use wanting for
- 48:39craving. Not wanting for a version
- 48:42thinking for unconsciousness, and peace, or Equanimity, just
- 48:48because I like short words as the label charged earlier today.
- 48:57Sometimes I forget what exactly the purposes of exploring this.
- 49:02Well, you want to begin to tease apart?
- 49:05Art the sensing experience that formed things into the solid
- 49:10experience. The self, the send the
- 49:13experience of self because you and you also want to take up the
- 49:1716 bits. The more of the 16 bits, you
- 49:21take up the less room there is for the creation of its sense of
- 49:25self so it's a it's a way into the experience of not self.
- 49:32Away into the experience of just sensing without fixating
- 49:36anything. So this would be a way of moving
- 49:40through the first five stages of insight.
- 49:44We could also add a fourth fourth noting, which would be to
- 49:49note, whether the sense of self is there or not?
- 49:52As you're doing it, but I think three is enough, right?
- 50:00Don't fret over this just do the best you can.
- 50:04If you find that the see hear feel single noting is good
- 50:07enough, just say they're adding the second note is good enough
- 50:10and you can do it easily enough than add the third node.
- 50:15Is that okay? I will.
- 50:30You know, once you get into a role of the triple noting I
- 50:32really find it, one of the most fun.
- 50:42And then just adding the self-inquiry also, it is great
- 50:46fun. So we're going to do some
- 51:22depositors them inside practice, you're going to want to position
- 51:25the body in a posture that you can hold still without having to
- 51:28move. And this is accomplished by
- 51:31finding a way to balance the body.
- 51:33So you use the least amount of muscle power.
- 51:36The muscles getting tired and achy over time the car and you
- 51:39to move. So a process of trial and error
- 51:42finding a useful posture, remembering it, finding it
- 51:47again. The next time you sit down
- 51:49refining it re remembering it and in this way over time
- 51:52training the procedural memory just to settle the body in
- 51:57Always a good idea to do a quick inventory of the body's part of
- 52:01the settling in process. So, starting at the top of the
- 52:03head, relax the scalp, the brow, the eyes, The face.
- 52:12But the draw goes slack relaxing the tongue.
- 52:16Straighten the spine balancing the head.
- 52:20Relax, the shoulders. Just at the arms.
- 52:24Hang down. Arranging the hands,
- 52:25comfortably. If you're sitting in a chair,
- 52:34plant your feet to have a good solid base.
- 52:37And if you're sitting on a cushion arrange, the legs that
- 52:39would be comfortable for the period of sitting.
- 52:42Just let the breath go in and out is it will no effort to
- 52:46control it. We'll use a little bit of breath
- 52:56counting as a way of concentrating, the mind.
- 53:02Counting from 1 to 5 on both the out-breath and the in breath.
- 53:07So breathing out, count one breathing in count one beating
- 53:12out count to breathing in count two.
- 53:15Breathing out, count, three, breathing in count.
- 53:17Three breathing, out, count for breathing in count.
- 53:21For breathing out, count, five breathing in count.
- 53:25Five. And then begin the count again
- 53:29at 1. So, the sensing experience
- 53:50itself could be pleasant unpleasant or neutral, and you
- 53:52could want it or not, want it get caught up in thinking or be
- 53:56at peace with it. Because they're different
- 53:59functions. First is the quality of what it
- 54:03is. Actually what is it?
- 54:04What is actually the experience of sensing and what does that
- 54:07feel like Pleasant unpleasant or neutral?
- 54:10And then the Mind reaction to that, Which is something
- 54:16entirely different. so, for instance, sometimes the sound of
- 54:22the train, there was a quality to the sensing of the which I
- 54:28found unpleasant, but the But I was fine.
- 54:36Was it bothered by particularly? I have thoughts.
- 54:43The hearing of the thought was neutral, my didn't mind the
- 54:47content of the thought so much. But it caused a anger reaction
- 54:51in the body, which was unpleasant and I didn't want.
- 54:55So, you know, you really can get quite nuanced in, you're picking
- 55:00a part of what's actually happening.
- 55:03There everything is interactive with everything else so the
- 55:06visual aspect Auto fan creates auditory which creates feeling
- 55:09in the body and it just bounces along. and so, if you really
- 55:14free up, your your awareness to Just Bounce with that sensing
- 55:19Bowl, it's just moving all the time, for instance, In
- 55:27breathing, there's because my chest is congested, but I feel
- 55:32the air in here. It's unpleasant and the
- 55:35sensations in the throat or unpleasant, but the sensation of
- 55:37the coolness of the air coming in his Pleasant.
- 55:41And then sometimes, if I'm breathing through my nose, the
- 55:44sensation of breathing through my nose is neutral So we're
- 55:49actually is your attention in the moment of sensing.
- 55:53What are you actually soaking into?
- 55:56Are you then able to hold that whole experience?
- 55:59Would you could if you had a wide awareness and then
- 56:02averaging it or what is it actually that's happening.
- 56:05And then what is the Mind reaction to that in terms of
- 56:10craving something different? The sensation my body is
- 56:16actually not very comfortable right now.
- 56:20So all a lot of the sensations are unpleasant, but visual
- 56:24experience is Happened to be really kind of vivid tonight.
- 56:29The sensing of visual experiences perfectly neutral
- 56:32for me. I don't really have any version
- 56:36or any craving in the sensing experience, but I find the
- 56:40imagery fascinating. So sometimes there's a wanting
- 56:44for more imagery arises in response even though the sensing
- 56:48experiences completely neutral. Is that making sense?
- 56:55So you're actually pulling apart different aspects of the
- 56:58experience, every experience is made up of all of those aspects
- 57:02were really just trying to piece them apart.
- 57:06If we can piece them apart and hold the threads individually,
- 57:09then we can watch how they come together and form the experience
- 57:12that we're having and we can see how those qualities are in it.
- 57:17In. As a gross example.
- 57:21Do you ever find that you don't want to go someplace and then
- 57:24when you get there, you have a good time.
- 57:28So then what you're noticing is that the feeling response to
- 57:32going is not wanting? I don't want the feeling
- 57:36response, it's not that I don't want to being there and having
- 57:39fun. And so it's can be often that
- 57:43because you don't have good Clarity that they feeling the
- 57:47sensing experience of going becomes overwhelming and so you
- 57:51don't go, but if you could pull it apart and see that, oh, I do
- 57:55want to go, but there's this sensing experience that that I
- 57:59don't want, that is preventing me from going.
- 58:03Then you can push through that part in go.
- 58:06But if you didn't know that actually the part that you
- 58:09didn't like was the physical Sensation experience of going
- 58:13not a going there or being there, you might limit yourself,
- 58:17is that good enough metaphor for it?
- 58:22So they're going. Oh yeah this this old body
- 58:24doesn't want to go because it doesn't feel good or this young
- 58:26body doesn't go depending on where you are.
- 58:31I often find that my body is is a painful place to be in and it
- 58:38and I can limit what I do as a way of trying to avoid that.
- 58:45But where I can try and come and Equanimity with it and just go
- 58:47anyway. I don't consciously, but if I
- 58:57become unconscious and the body mind is recoiling from it, I can
- 59:02it can totally distort my behavior.
- 59:12Oh me, one of the things that also comes to mind is when I do
- 59:16this exercise or inside actually.
- 59:21It's a study also are arising and passing.
- 59:24Does that make sense? Sure.
- 59:27And he asks, any sensing aspect can be viewed from that, that
- 59:32would be the fourth noting. You would add the three marks,
- 59:38the three marks of characteristics of existence as
- 59:41the 4th note, is this a selfing experiences?
- 59:44This one arising and passing experiences this and
- 59:47unsatisfactoriness experience? And then what you may notice is
- 59:54that you're so consumed with piecing, this stuff out that
- 59:58there's no experience of self. Because there's no bandwidth for
- 1:00:02it. You're just in the flow of
- 1:00:05sensing experience, which moves you out of that fixated
- 1:00:09experience of self, just in 240, which is moving in the direction
- 1:00:15of dissolution. Which story you told somebody?
- 1:00:27Yeah. Indeed.
- 1:00:29You're in a state of unfixed dated flow.
- 1:00:32It's not it's not a great place to be in terms of functioning in
- 1:00:36the world and actually Freedom would be to come from that state
- 1:00:40into totally fixated and functional and then we don't
- 1:00:43need totally fixated in functional dropping back into
- 1:00:46that flow. Remember the ability to come and
- 1:00:50go from that? It's really the variation
- 1:00:53ability to come from totally fixated brilliant manifestation
- 1:00:56of capable self and then drop into cessation but you don't
- 1:01:00need it anymore with no clinging, no version between one
- 1:01:06State or the other. Not ever spacing out.
- 1:01:17Good enough. This is deepening our practice.
- 1:01:22So I'm always advocating. Deepening your practice and the
- 1:01:25main way I think that or the one useful way to do that is to go
- 1:01:29on Retreat. We have one long residential
- 1:01:33Retreat, left this year at 80s, which is the one that I'm
- 1:01:37teaching up in Montecito. At La Casa de Maria from the
- 1:01:4126th of December until the 6th of January.
- 1:01:44I think it's 11 nights. I teach a metaphor personal
- 1:01:50style Retreat. So the first five days will be
- 1:01:52pure meta and then we'll go and do pure Insight.
- 1:01:56The, I find that doing the the first five days of meta, really
- 1:02:01calms. The body-mind down really
- 1:02:04centers that really concentrates it and then we're free to shoot
- 1:02:07off into the pasta. You can come for the first six
- 1:02:11nights which would be pretty much all mentioned the last five
- 1:02:15nights. All the possum at that makes
- 1:02:17More sense to. But if you haven't been on a
- 1:02:20retreat this year really consider coming, it's good to
- 1:02:22have at least one recruit a year under your belt Dave Smith and
- 1:02:29Charles seen have a retreat scheduled at for New Year's
- 1:02:33weekend or New Year's weekend. I think about speed if he's
- 1:02:39fully recovered by that or recovered enough to do it and
- 1:02:43then in January, Mary San cabbage and Joanna, Harbor are
- 1:02:47doing a woman's only retreat at Joshua Tree.
- 1:02:53But if you want to do a long, I like ten day or so, Retreats the
- 1:02:57best a little bit longer. If you think about a week-long
- 1:03:00retreat or a weekend retreat, you arrive.
- 1:03:04It takes you a day or two to settle in and then you get into
- 1:03:07it and then the retreat is over. If you go ten days, it's like
- 1:03:13having three more sitting dazed added in.
- 1:03:16So you really get, you know, you have an 11:00 night Retreat,
- 1:03:21you'll have tents Eating days which is quite a bit different
- 1:03:25than having a week-long retreat in having five sitting days.
- 1:03:28It's twice as twice as many sitting days without having to
- 1:03:32stay twice as long. Anyway, take a look at that.
- 1:03:37There's a bunch of flowers out there for other classes that are
- 1:03:40coming. Take a look at those setting up
- 1:03:43your daily practice, I do a thing called morning meditation
- 1:03:46at 7:30, which is a live conference call in and then
- 1:03:50there's a 25-minute. Guided meditation are some
- 1:03:52flyers on the bulletin board for that.
- 1:03:56I know that it not everybody great at getting up at 7:30 and
- 1:04:00meditating for half hour on the phone.
- 1:04:02So if you use one of the Flyers, it'll give you a month.
- 1:04:05Access for free. And then we do have a thirty
- 1:04:09five dollar a month asked for that.
- 1:04:15I'm also a big advocate of meditation centers.
- 1:04:18The inside path can often be challenging and it's useful to
- 1:04:22have friends that support you in your practice.
- 1:04:26If you ever tried to get a friend who doesn't actually
- 1:04:28meditate to help support you in your meditation practice.
- 1:04:31Usually, you see the limitations of that right away?
- 1:04:34Why would you even do that as? Usually?
- 1:04:36The response you get rather than some kind of support, so where
- 1:04:42can you come to meet people all? Also have a meditation practice,
- 1:04:45Meditation Center. If we don't have a meditation
- 1:04:48center, you can't come and meet people who support you in your
- 1:04:51practice and make it easier. We can't have a meditation
- 1:04:54center if you don't practice, Donna.
- 1:04:56When you come to The Meditation, Center, Donna, is the Pali word
- 1:04:59for generosity? We really do need you to be
- 1:05:03generous, each time you come to, the lights can stay on the
- 1:05:06doors. Can stay open the rent.
- 1:05:09In this space went up fifteen hundred dollars a month.
- 1:05:13Two months ago. Needing to raise quite a bit
- 1:05:16more money to keep this space. So we've crunched the numbers.
- 1:05:21$15 is a good amount. We think to keep the doors open
- 1:05:26in the lights on but you really should be practicing generosity
- 1:05:30at a level that's meaningful to you.
- 1:05:33So if $15 is an insignificant amount of money than give more
- 1:05:39so that it has meaning if $15 is a good amount of give that if
- 1:05:42it's too much. Give it the level that you can
- 1:05:45give if you if you're not resource at the moment and you
- 1:05:49just want to come, please come, we're very happy as a community
- 1:05:54to support the place for you, if that's what you need.
- 1:06:00We take cash and cards out there at the desk, if you would also
- 1:06:03be so kind as to put the chairs back in the cushions away,
- 1:06:07that's also appreciated before you next time.
- 1:06:09Thank you. We take cash and cards out there
- 1:06:02at the desk, if you would also be so kind as to put the chairs
- 1:06:05back in the cushions away, that's also appreciated before
- 1:06:08you next time. Thank you.