Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Will Big Ten Commissioner Tony Petitti Punish Michigan For Sign-Stealing Scandal?
Transcript
- 0:03Hey guys, welcome to a very special live episode of Buckeye Weekly. I'm
- 0:08Tom Orr, joined by Kevin Noon, Tony Gerdaman's going to be hopping on
- 0:11in just a couple minutes. Real life has intervened for a moment, so
- 0:15we will get the official start. Don't worry, you'll get your power pause
- 0:17in a few minutes. But as of right now, we just want to
- 0:20let you know first of all, if you're interested in supporting us, you
- 0:24can find us at buckeyehuddle dot com. That's where we all write and post
- 0:28on the message board and post our podcasts and all that good stuff. Really
- 0:32fat and fantastic community. A crystal ball came in on a five star cornerback
- 0:37for Ohio State today, so if you want to read about that, I'm
- 0:40going to guess Mark Givler. We'll have something on that a little later on
- 0:42today at buckey huddle dot com, especially on the huddle board presented by Jeff
- 0:46Ruby. That is for all of our insiders. You can get access there
- 0:50all at bucke huddle dot com. Also, Tony's wife wants us to remind
- 0:55you to hit the thumbs up button on this and make sure you like the
- 0:57show. That will help other folks find this show through whatever YouTube does.
- 1:02So Okay, So while wile rating for Tony, I just want to I
- 1:04mean, I'm assuming people have all seen this and you know why we're here
- 1:07this morning. But here we go. Report from Pete Thamil that came out
- 1:12in the wee hours of the morning, A vast majority of the Big Ten
- 1:18coaches expressed their frustrations with the ongoing sigence stealing investigation at Michigan in a video
- 1:23call with Commissioner Tony Pettiti on Wednesday, sources told ESPN. The call,
- 1:26which took ninety minutes, included nearly an hour without Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh,
- 1:30who hung up after the regularly scheduled Big Ten business to allow the conference as
- 1:34coaches to speak freely about the NCAA's investigation into Michigan. According to five sources
- 1:40familiar with the call, a chorus of voices encouraged Petiti to take action against
- 1:45Michigan in a call that was described as both intense and emotional. Quote collectively,
- 1:49the coaches want the Big Ten to act right now, said a source
- 1:52familiar with the call. What are we waiting on we know what happened now,
- 1:57Kevin. I think there are several questions that sort of arise from that.
- 2:01Number One is what can the conference do? Because we know that the
- 2:06nc DOUBLEA cannot act on this within the span of this season. So if
- 2:10anything is going to happen this season, it would have to come from the
- 2:15Big Ten because the NCAA's bylaws require it to issue a notice of allegations and
- 2:20then the school gets ninety days to respond. So by the time you get
- 2:22through that ninety days, you know, even if and when that notice of
- 2:24allegation is issued and that has not happened yet, Michigan would then have ninety
- 2:29days to respond. So that would get you way past this year's college football
- 2:31playoff. So if something is going to happen this year, it would have
- 2:37to come from the Big Ten office, and I guess you know we can
- 2:42get through. I have a bunch of things polled, so I went through
- 2:45a bunch of PDFs this morning to find what exactly are the Big Ten's rules
- 2:47on all of this. So I guess let's start with that. Do you
- 2:51have those ready? I do have them ready, all right? Call by
- 2:54the bylaw Number that's the easiest way for me to get all right, man,
- 2:59welcome to the exciting podcast you're going to watch all day. I'll try
- 3:02and crack some jokes to keep this from being too dry. All right,
- 3:07how about ten point two Authority of the Commissioner. That seems like a good
- 3:09place to start. So the Big ten Commissioner Tony Pettiti has exclusive authority to
- 3:15determine whether offensive actions have occurred. The Commissioner shall have the exclusive authority to
- 3:20determine whether an offensive action as contemplated an agreement ten point oh one above has
- 3:25been committed by anyone referenced in Agreement ten point one above. Basically, have
- 3:30you done anything to cheat, or lie or steal? In making this determination,
- 3:35the Commissioner may consider any evidence he or she deems relevant. The Commissioner
- 3:38may accept any information provided by any source, but except as outlined in ten
- 3:43point three point one below, we'll get there has no formal obligation to do
- 3:46so. Authority to take disciplinary action In the event the Commissioner determines that an
- 3:51offensive action has occurred, the Commissioner shall have the authority to pose any disciplinary
- 3:57action in response to the offensive action. Subject the provisions of Agreement ten point
- 4:00three point three point one below. All right, next up, factors that
- 4:06may be considered. I promise this is going to get more interesting. I
- 4:10was going to say we should probably take them in little bite sized pieces and
- 4:13kind of do that. Just just so. I had to take a couple
- 4:16of law classes in JA school, and let me tell you, I liked
- 4:19I liked that class so much I had to take it twice because it was
- 4:21a little dry. See, I liked I liked journalism law class. I
- 4:25got a good I think I got an a journalism law I like that one.
- 4:28I gotta be the second time. I got an f the first time
- 4:30because I'd stopped going because I hated it. Well, it was. It
- 4:34is an important class. You do have to you do have to pass it
- 4:36in order to get your degree. There's a reason for it. But I
- 4:40mean, I get you know, the big takeaway there is, you know,
- 4:44first first thing, can Tony Pettiti do anything about this? And the
- 4:48answer spelled out pretty clearly there is if he wants to, Yes, wee
- 4:55remember who the commissioner works for. The commissioner is there at the pleasure of
- 5:00the university presidents and chancellors, the athletic departments, et cetera, et cetera,
- 5:04et cetera. So if they don't like the direction that things are going,
- 5:10they'll just put somebody else in that position. And of course you know
- 5:14that that comes up everything of people trying to wait out the clock and everything
- 5:17else. But what you know, what is being said by coaches and then
- 5:23followed up. You know, allegedly there's an AD call that's supposed to be
- 5:26today. I don't you know, I don't know that one for a fact
- 5:29that you know, Twitter has all sorts of things on it, But you
- 5:31know this, there's there's going to be a lot of pressure on petit.
- 5:35If thirteen of the member institutions are clamoring for something to happen, something kind
- 5:42of needs to happen. I mean, let's let's not forget that Kevin Warren
- 5:46right off the bat and his tenure got a big old COVID sandwich and had
- 5:49to deal with stuff, and that wasn't probably dealt with the way that a
- 5:55lot of the rank and file would have liked to have seen. You know,
- 5:58I'm not going to relitigate all of that stuff, but yeah, I
- 6:01mean this is I woke up to a text message from Tom saying let's go
- 6:05live at ten. I'm like, what the hell is he talking about.
- 6:09I mean, I didn't think that Pete Damia was going to be burning the
- 6:12midnight oil with something dropping around midnight. Yeah, he was quite literally burning
- 6:16the midnight oil. And there was a tweet this morning from Adam Brittenberg,
- 6:19who is from ESPN. He is pretty plugged in with the Big Ten.
- 6:24He's kind of their Big Ten ESPN reporter and he's now the senior writer for
- 6:27college football for ESPN, but he's been covering the Big Ten for years and
- 6:30years. He says news from Pete last night. Pressure is rising on first
- 6:33year commissioner Tony Petitti is one source told me this morning quote he is going
- 6:36to have to act or he will lose the coaches and ads. And you
- 6:42know, we're going to get into what kind of actions he could potentially take
- 6:48in a little bit, but you know, some of it could come down
- 6:51to Okay, Pete Thamill said at one point, quote vast majority of the
- 6:57Big ten quote coaches were upset about this, and it could come down to
- 7:00how vast the vastness is because you will have to once you get past a
- 7:04certain level of punishments. Tony Petit has carte blanche to do whatever he wants
- 7:10to up to a certain point. And then once you get past that certain
- 7:13point, then you get into Okay, the Big Ten has to have other
- 7:17you know, the other members, essentially the Big Ten executive Committee has to
- 7:23jump in and approve something beyond just the sort of standard level punishments. Speaking
- 7:28of standard level punishments, we're joined now by Tony Gardaman if fuck I huddle
- 7:30dot com. Tony, how's it going? No, Tom, No,
- 7:40Kevin please introduce me now joining us, the one, the famous Tony German.
- 7:48Thank you, Kevin. I'm doing fantastic. Thank you for asking.
- 7:53I apologize for being I apologize for being late. I'm good. One of
- 7:59the downsides to working from home is that you your schedule exists on everybody else's
- 8:03time frame. So I'm here now, so I'm ready to go. Are
- 8:07we talking about the what are we still talking about this giant Michigan cheating scandal?
- 8:13And I think it's important to move beyond the calling it sign stealing and
- 8:16just going to cheating at this point, based on everything that is being reported,
- 8:20because the thing is when we call it sign stealing, the immediate response
- 8:24for Michigan fans is sign stealing is legal. So if you just move to
- 8:28cheating, cheating is not legal, and then that kind of eliminates some of
- 8:33the silly responses. I want to know part of the if it should be
- 8:39a unanimous thing, a vast majority who who on that call is like nope,
- 8:43nope, I'm good with it. I'm good with it. I'm fine
- 8:46if Connor Stallions wants to come on and hang out on our sideline with his
- 8:52recording ray bands and everything else, come on down. I'm good with it.
- 8:56I mean, who who? Honestly, I mean I almost feel like
- 8:58we're in that nineteen seventy three Tiebreaker documentary where it's gonna come down to an
- 9:03ad vote or something like that, and you have to sit there and count
- 9:07how many votes you have in your pocket. I don't know who's standing with
- 9:09Jim Harbaugh on this one, except for Sam Web and the dude from m
- 9:15GO blog and Satan. Kevin always great at keeping us right on the rails,
- 9:24right on task. All right, let's Kevin, Kevin. I could
- 9:28go, I could go, Kevin. We are going to punish you by
- 9:31going back to the legal documents that Tony joined us a little late. But
- 9:35Tony I pulled up all of the authority of the Commissioner and factors that MA
- 9:39can be considered, and all this stuff from the Big ten Sportsmanship guidelines.
- 9:43Just so everyone's on the same page. We're not all going well, I
- 9:46saw going on Twitter say like, no, no, We're going to go
- 9:50right to the source. So here we go straight to the source. Are
- 9:52we going to ten? Two? Three? Now? Ten two? Three?
- 9:54Factors that may be considered? Man, good luck keeping yourself from just
- 10:00jumping up and dancing around the room as I read through this one. Factors
- 10:01that may be considered when deppied to deciding upon disciplinary action. Tony gincase you
- 10:05joined us late, and we know you did. We've already established that Tony
- 10:09Petitti has the authority to take action in this matter. In deciding whether to
- 10:13impose disciplinary action. Factors to be considered by the Commissioner may include, but
- 10:16shall not be limited to, with the following, the general nature or severity
- 10:20of the offensive action. That feels like one of the things that may have
- 10:22gotten ratcheted up a little bit last night on that conference call. According to
- 10:28the reporting for Pete Tamil, any injury or damage that results directly from the
- 10:31offensive action. This would be great if I was a law talking guy and
- 10:35could tell you whether injury or damage would include you know, hey, we
- 10:37didn't make the Big Ten, you know Big Ten championship game, or you
- 10:41know, had suffered a you know, a worse seed in the college football
- 10:46playoff, or you know that that's the Ohio State side Penn State. You
- 10:48know, hey, Penn State. You know, has hell has this materially
- 10:52injured James Franklin in terms of reputation or salary or whatever. I don't know
- 10:58if that is is covered there, but would be interesting to know. The
- 11:03manner in which the offensive action fits within the context of the rules of the
- 11:07game for the sport at issue seems relevant. Any action taken or imposed in
- 11:11accordance with the applicable rules of the game. EG. Action is taken by
- 11:15game officials, the response of and or any action taken by the evolved member
- 11:18institutions, the response of end or any action taken by any other entity that
- 11:22may have jurisdiction over the offensive action, EG. Law enforcement, any prior
- 11:26offensive actions as contemplated within this policy. I mean doubt they don't all apply,
- 11:35but certainly I would say at least two to three of those seem like
- 11:39those are pretty directly applicable in this situation. I don't think you need all
- 11:43of them to apply. Do you like this? No, these are individual
- 11:46things. It's not a you know, if this, then this. It's
- 11:52like if it's one of these, then there's something that can be done.
- 11:56And one of the things that has annoyed me about is the idea that when
- 12:01the coaches go talk to Pete Thammel, Michigan fans think that, well,
- 12:07why don't the coaches put their name out there? Why don't Why are they
- 12:09being anonymous about it? And that's something that I've been saying about, like
- 12:11complaining about nil. But the coaches aren't being anonymous when they're talking to Tony
- 12:16Pettiti. Like it's computer screen to computer screen, it's phone to phone,
- 12:20it's things like that. So like there's no anonymity when you're talking to the
- 12:24commissioner. The anonymity I'd be fine if they went out in public and said
- 12:30stuff, but it's not going to change anybody's minds because Michigan fans are entrenched
- 12:35that this is no big deal, and they can find one coach or three
- 12:41coaches that say it, but if there's thirteen that say it is a big
- 12:43deal, they don't. It doesn't factor with their thought process. So even
- 12:50if they put names to it, you would just have responses like you keep
- 12:54crying, cope harder, cry harder, all of those things. That's what
- 12:58we get it from. That's what the coaches would get on social media or
- 13:03wherever. Because I can't even look at my mentions. I started tweeting at
- 13:07like seven o'clock this morning, and I've been running around until now and I
- 13:11don't even want to. I don't even want to go near my Twitter right
- 13:13now. I have and it's because I know what all of the responses are
- 13:18going to be. Engagement, equally funny. Well that's why I hit and
- 13:24run. I just tweet and run. Well that's that's the way to do
- 13:28it. That's the way to do it, and and turn off the mentions
- 13:31and everything else. I mean, only one of us up here on here
- 13:35had an image that got like sixty billion views, and it's one of us
- 13:39that's not monetizing it. And it's you know, I do like the fact
- 13:43that Tony is tweeting right now, like you know the hero in every movie
- 13:46where he you know, throws the grenade and then just turns and coolly walks
- 13:50away as everything blows up behind him. That's that's Tony on Twitter right now.
- 13:54So here it would jump on it. Uh, Kevin the joker,
- 14:00Kevin, It's time for another exciting graphic. Here we go ten point three
- 14:03procedural elements. Get your foam fingers out. We are going to be doing
- 14:07some more law talking. Commissioner's discretion, timeliness, and due process. The
- 14:11Commissioner has the discretion to pursue or choose not to pursue, an investigation as
- 14:16to whether an offensive action has occurred. In the event the Commissioner decides to
- 14:20pursue such an investigation, the Commissioner shall commence the investigation as expeditiously that means
- 14:24fast Kevin as possible, upond notification that such an offensive action may have occurred.
- 14:30That means occurred Tony. Upon commencement of such an investigation, the Commissioner
- 14:33shall determine as expeditiously as possible whether an offensive action did occur any involved institution
- 14:39or individual at risk of disciplinary action shall be provided an opportunity which may be
- 14:45waived, to offer its or his or her position as to whether an offensive
- 14:50action occurred. The time frame within which an institution or individual shall provide it's
- 14:54or his or herror position shall be set by the Commissioner and shall be reasonable
- 14:58in light of the circumstances. Upon determination that a defensive action did occur,
- 15:01the Commissioner shall as expeditiously as possible, determine whether disciplinary action should be imposed,
- 15:07and if so, what it should be. Ten point three point two
- 15:09notice a disciplinary action. In the event that it becomes clear that an institution
- 15:13is likely to be subjected to disciplinary action, the Commissioner shall notify that institution
- 15:18or individual at the earliest reasonable opportunity. Under no circumstances shall the Commissioner comment
- 15:22publicly regarding either an investigation or disciplinary action without having first provided notice to any
- 15:28involved institution or individual. That last part, while very exciting, is also
- 15:33very important. It means until Michigan will know that there is an investigation or
- 15:41a disciplinary thing going on before the Big ten can put anything out publicly,
- 15:46So you have to know. There is sort of an order of operations here.
- 15:50Where this stuff has to happen in a certain order. The Big Ten
- 15:52must notify Michigan officially before something comes out, so you may hear grumbling from
- 15:58Michigan paeople, you know if and when this becomes official, and you know,
- 16:03the if is a very important caveat that we need to throw in all
- 16:07of this. But if this does happen, Michigan has get notified before the
- 16:11Big Ten says anything publicly about it. And this is kind of a mini
- 16:15NCAA investigation, and that the Big Ten comes with their findings and the Michigan
- 16:23has a time frame to respond a timeframe of Tony Pettiti's choosing with the NCAA,
- 16:29you get like ninety days to respond. Who knows what type of time
- 16:33frame the Big Ten would set. But also I wonder if the call last
- 16:40night with the with the coaches is to determine whether or not to start an
- 16:42investigation or get their thoughts on that, and then or get their thoughts on
- 16:48how angry all of those coaches are going to be when you don't, you
- 16:52know, start an investigation, and when you're like, well, you know,
- 16:56it's just we'd rather not rather not dig into this hole. And find
- 17:03what we might. But I think at the very least this is I'm sure
- 17:08Tony Petitti was asked to start an investigation by those coaches. And if he
- 17:14doesn't, then you're encouraging everybody else to go and spend whatever and do whatever,
- 17:22to go ahead and on site scout future opponents, all kinds of electronic
- 17:29means that you can find. Every deon Sanders is going to have spyglass apparel
- 17:33that all coaches and players are going to have. Now, so there's your
- 17:38The precedent that you're setting by not doing anything is encouraging everybody to do as
- 17:41much as they want, and then they will just point back to you said
- 17:45it was okay, Well yeah. Sometimes I mean in action means well then
- 17:52you're fine with this, you're accepting this and nothing is going on. And
- 17:56you know something that I know that we have on our docket to talk about
- 18:00out is, you know, if an investigation happens in further punishment or punishment
- 18:06ensues, does Michigan try to pick up its ball and go elsewhere. That
- 18:11seems to be a fan favorite out there, because you know everybody else has
- 18:15got moving boxes going on. I mean, why not I mean, I
- 18:18mean, I'm sure there are places where where this this level of rule infraction
- 18:23is smiled upon. Yeah, I think the Yeah, I mean first first
- 18:32of all that, Yeah, we'll get let's let's just get to the sec
- 18:34later. I don't want to. I don't want to derail everything. I
- 18:37have more exciting lost lives. I'm trying to keep people engaged, and you're
- 18:41over there, you're whatever the guy from Ferris Bueller buell Er I mean,
- 18:45and all of the I mean, honestly, as people think that I'm trolling
- 18:48Tom, I'm not trolling Tom. All this stuff is very important. It
- 18:52all sets the scene. We weren't going to give you homework come into the
- 18:56chat until you read all these bilos. I've already proven what happens in journalism
- 19:02law. If you're given freedom, you just don't do it. So,
- 19:04yeah, you've got to. We have to set all this so then we
- 19:07don't have to talk about it again. We can say, as we said
- 19:11earlier, yes, And also we want to make sure when we're talking about
- 19:15stuff. This is as much of a we are fact checking ourselves. We
- 19:18want to make sure everything we're saying is correct. So we are going directly
- 19:22to the source. This is how you do it. If you are a
- 19:25reporter and you are a journalist, you go directly to the source, You
- 19:26get the information, and then you report accordingly. You don't just make stuff
- 19:30up. Kevin, Let's go directly to ten point three point three Standard disciplinary
- 19:36action. This one's a short one, so I'm excited about This is a
- 19:38short one. Stay blessed. Ten point three point three categories of Disciplinary actions.
- 19:42Standard disciplinary action. This is the stuff that Tony Pettiti can do without
- 19:48getting any further approval. This is just if Tony Pettiti looks at it and
- 19:51goes, yeah, that's bad. Here's what he can do. Standard disciplinary
- 19:55actions shall include admonishment that means saying you did a bad thing, umand pretty
- 20:00much the same thing, finds that do not exceed ten thousand dollars, and
- 20:03suspensions for no more than two contests. Any combination of the preceding actions shall
- 20:08be considered to be a singular standard disciplinary action. Decisions by the Commissioner to
- 20:14impose a standard disciplinary action shall be final and are not subject to appeal.
- 20:18So essentially, what this means is if Tony Petitti says, and this is
- 20:22purely hypothetical. I'm not saying this is what he's going to do. If
- 20:26Tony Pettitiy looks at this and says, Okay, Jim Harbaugh, you did
- 20:32a bad thing. You are suspended for two games. Michigan has no recourse
- 20:37whatsoever, and Jim Harbaugh is just suspended for two games. Because this is
- 20:41the Big Tens sportsmanship policy that Michigan has agreed to in advance, and it
- 20:45is very clear there decisions by the Commissioner to impose a standard disciplinary action shall
- 20:49be final and are not subject to appeal. So that's the stuff that he
- 20:53can do with no recourse in terms of what Michigan could do in terms of
- 21:00you know, hey, we disagree. That is all within the commissioner's sort
- 21:06of umbrella. Next up, calm yourselves down, calm yourselves down. Next
- 21:11up, we're going to get to what does he have to go to the
- 21:14Big Ten you know, board of you know, whatever the heck it is.
- 21:18It's like the Jags or something. I don't remember. It's a This
- 21:21is why this is why I have that, This is why I have the
- 21:22slides. But okay, we have a super chat that we need to get
- 21:26to. Now, all right, let me let me jump off of this,
- 21:29right, yeah, pick that off and then let me got all sorts
- 21:33of pages to go through. There we go, Mike super Chet for Mike
- 21:36Arno. Been a pretty wild twenty four or so hours. I was at
- 21:37about a ten percent chance something was going to happen yesterday, especially after the
- 21:41president oh no tweet that was University of Michigan president tweeting out a picture of
- 21:45him with the Michigan football team a couple of weeks ago in some sort of
- 21:48generally positive words and not mentioning that the picture was from a couple of weeks
- 21:52ago, and the picture also included Connor stallions, which was a choice to
- 21:57make. Sorry to continue Mike's super chat. Last night's news brings my thoughts
- 22:03back to fifty percent ish when we were in was it Madison last week talking
- 22:11about like the Friday arrival video, We're thinking there at least I was that
- 22:15it was north of fifty that something was going to happen this season in terms
- 22:21of punishment, And then as the dripping of the news kind of slows down
- 22:27for a couple days, you're like, well, it doesn't seem like anything's
- 22:30going to happen. But it's like everything is moving so quickly in our mind,
- 22:33but it can only move so quickly because you do have to have a
- 22:37back and forth. You do have to do interviews, you do have to
- 22:40get information, gather information. What does this information mean? Take this information
- 22:44to somebody else. What do you think this information mean? What does all
- 22:47of this entail? And so there's just so much piecing all of this together,
- 22:52and they've got a ton of puzzle pieces. I think I said to
- 22:53somebody on Twitter, they're still waiting for like the corner pieces of the puzzle,
- 22:56like maybe to start bridging everything and putting everything together and have a better
- 23:02idea of what it is. But you've got the box what you know what
- 23:04you're putting together here, you know what this looks like, and you just
- 23:07need to continue to construct the puzzle. But I am am I still at
- 23:15fifty percent. I don't know, because it seems like the what you're reading
- 23:19there from the bylaws and the procedural stuff, that you're still there's still a
- 23:26if the big ten can only move so fast, and now will this ability
- 23:30of Tony p TD to hand down a nine dollars fine admonit somebody and then
- 23:38also say this is also a reprimand, by the way, so don't think
- 23:41this is just an admonishment. This is also a reprimand, so this is
- 23:45doubly bad. This is going on record exactly and then throwing a two game
- 23:52suspension. It would be interesting to see what two games those were. And
- 23:55that's the longer this goes on, the bigger those games, the suspension for
- 24:00those games would be. So I don't know if this is just one of
- 24:03these right now, we're just gonna find you. But even that is admitting
- 24:07something went wrong. That is saying you've done something wrong. And so once
- 24:11you start that ball rolling that, it's like, well, kay, but
- 24:15it was more than just a a ten thousand dollars, Fine, don't you
- 24:18think? All right, so let's get to what take what what it takes
- 24:22to get more than a ten thousand superat there, we gotta we gotta,
- 24:26we gotta clear it. I'm gonna need a cigarette after this moment's bad,
- 24:30okay, but yeah, it's uh, it's it's something. It's something I
- 24:37I've seen some things through the years of covering athletics, and if you're an
- 24:42Ohio State fan and you just you you deal in the misery business of the
- 24:47team up north. This is uh, this is your jam all right?
- 24:52Now you know what's my jam? More law talking all right? Ten point
- 24:56three point three point point to major disciplinary action disciplinary actions exceeding those listed in
- 25:04Agreement ten point three point three point one above, again, which is like
- 25:07ten thousand dollars fine and a two game suspension at the most. Anything above
- 25:12and beyond that must receive prior approval by the Joint Group Executive Committee j GEK.
- 25:21I can't wait to say, j GEK, million times. What a
- 25:23time to be alive. In any case for which prior approval is sought,
- 25:27the j GEK shall be provided in writing the involved institutions or individual position as
- 25:33listed in Agreement ten point three point one above. The jay GEK may only
- 25:37approve, deny, or lessen the proposed penalty. It shall not increase the
- 25:41proposed penalty. Further, the j GEK may not lessen the penalty to a
- 25:45lower level, a level lower than that for which its approval is required.
- 25:49Review. An action by j GEK shall include a show occur as expeditiously as
- 25:53possible, and its decisions shall be final and are not subject to approval three
- 26:00three point three point two point one interimaction. Prior to receiving approval, The
- 26:03Commissioner may impose as interim action any lesser disciplinary action any ie, any disciplinary
- 26:10action for which prior approval would not be required, which shall be in effect
- 26:14until the JAK has had the opportunity to review and act upon any proposed major
- 26:18disciplinary actions. Okay, so the second part there means Tony PETITTI could say,
- 26:23hey, you're suspended for two games and it might turn into more later.
- 26:29The other thing that's real notable there. I'm just going to read back
- 26:33the last sentence there. Review and action by JAK shall occur as expeditiously as
- 26:40possible, needs to happen fast, and its decisions shall be final and are
- 26:44not subject to appeal. Are not subject to appeal? Does that mean they
- 26:53I've heard that lawyers, we could get involved if the Big Tun chooses to
- 26:56punish Michigan. I mean, I have seen Big Ten decisions which will not
- 27:03be revisited to get revisited, but this seems pretty clear that shall not be
- 27:11subject to appeal means shall not be subject to appeal. Yeah, difference between
- 27:15the bylaws and the statement on an email basically in terms of the shall not
- 27:22be revisited subject to appeal. I do think maybe Jake k may have been
- 27:29the alias that Connor Stallion's used on the Central Michigan sideline. I wonder if
- 27:36the JAK is like the UN Security Council, where you know that Russia is
- 27:38going to vote everything down or whatever. Michigan is part of the JAK and
- 27:44they sit like in this little circle. It's like nope, nope, nope,
- 27:47nope, and they just can veto everything. I mean, it's all
- 27:52sorts of images because I had not gone to the effort to read all the
- 27:55bylaws yet. I mean, I kind of was familiar with I thought how
- 27:59the process worked through the Big Ten. But you know, Tom's research has
- 28:03brought a lot of new things to light of how this whole thing is going
- 28:06to work. And you know, I've been trying to just get an image
- 28:10of the five stages of grief in here right now, just for Michigan to
- 28:14figure out on the roadmap where they are right now at this moment, other
- 28:17than in our chat telling us how stupid we are. M Well, that's
- 28:22the first time anyone's ever said that about any of us, so somewhere in
- 28:26there, know, somewhere in here is I'm sorry, I'm scrolling to the
- 28:30actual document because I believe it or not, I did not screenshot the entire
- 28:33thing. Somewhere in here, there was a there was a thing about you
- 28:40know that you didn't you basically would be recused if you you know. So,
- 28:45if Michigan is on the j GEK, I don't think they would have
- 28:48right of refusal like the UN Security Council, so that that would probably not
- 28:56that would probably not come into come into play there. I mean Jim Harbaugh
- 29:00was, according to this Pete Damil report, was not on the call last
- 29:07night so that teams could here it is ten point three point three point two
- 29:12point two. Oh man, that's a lot of numbers. Recusal and temporary
- 29:15replacement. You're just gonna have to listen to me. Any member of j
- 29:18GEK whose institution is involved in an incident for which approval of a major disciplinary
- 29:22action is sought shall be recused and tempor temporarily replaced by an individual or individuals
- 29:29representing an institution or institutions not involved in the incident at issue. If either
- 29:34the current or incoming chair or CoA Chairs of the Faculty Representatives is or are
- 29:38to be recused. Any such member of j X shall be temporarily replaced by
- 29:41at least one member of the Faculty Representatives who most recently served as chair or
- 29:45CoA chair of the Faculty Representatives. It goes on from there, but the
- 29:49TLDR is no. If you are on the punishment committee, you don't get
- 29:53to vote no on getting any punishments. There would comment there from CBJ Buckeye
- 30:02won Adam Rittenberg just confirmed the athletic directors meeting with Patiti for later today,
- 30:07likely to get their thoughts to share the coaches thoughts on all that. Not
- 30:11that, not that the ADS don't already know what their coaches are saying,
- 30:15but this is the next happen then I assume university presidents and chancellors after the
- 30:21ads. I mean, this is seems like things are escalating, at least
- 30:26with the Big Ten. We've been wondering when the Big Ten was going to
- 30:29actually start talking about this, and you know, they don't necessarily have an
- 30:33investigation arm like the NCAA, so they would need to get that ball rolling.
- 30:37So it is interesting to see all of this happening now, and of
- 30:40course once this meeting happens, there will be more reports out from that about
- 30:45the vast majority of athletic directors did not like it or whatever. And the
- 30:48athletic directors have to speak on this more than just football, because they wouldn't
- 30:52want this happening in any of their sports. They wouldn't want cheating to deal
- 30:55with cheating in any of their sports. And so I don't expect if they're
- 31:00going to be too many athletic directors that are saying, yeah, I work
- 31:03fine with it. You know, let's everybody does it. It's just it's
- 31:07just sports, you know, Yes, I I'll be interested to see what
- 31:11happens there. And then, as I said, what the next meeting is,
- 31:14I assume it would be presidents and chancellors. That does feel like where
- 31:18it would potentially be headed. And you know, I would assume that you
- 31:22are correct that if the football coaches are annoyed by this, and it seems
- 31:26from all of the reporting that they are, that their bosses are probably also
- 31:30annoyed by this, because you know all the stuff that this impact. You
- 31:34can remember, this is not just the football game, the score on the
- 31:40field. Let's just we're just gonna use Penn State here as an example.
- 31:44I don't know where Penn State stands. Based on James Franklin's public statements in
- 31:48the interview a week or so ago, I have a sense he's not a
- 31:51big fan of it. But if you are Penn State and you were fundraising
- 31:53to renovate your stadium, it feels like, hey, if you had a
- 31:59big win over Mission again, people get excited and people maybe get the check
- 32:00books out. That's the kind of stuff athletic directors care about, you know,
- 32:04Above and beyond just the competitive piece of this, there are financial implications
- 32:08to this as well. I'm sure Michigan has done better in fundraising the last
- 32:12couple of years after beating Ohio State a couple times, winning the Big Ten
- 32:14a couple of times than they did during the you know, late Starage Brady
- 32:19Hoke era for example. So this, you know, this is the kind
- 32:22of thing that it'll impact a lot of different areas. But you know the
- 32:28fact that you know, follow the money. What's what's the number, what's
- 32:30the number one rule? Follow the money. If this is something that has
- 32:32probably materially hurt fundraising at places, that's going to tick people off even if
- 32:37they're not necessarily ticked off just by the on field stuff, and every indication
- 32:42is they are ticked off by the on field stuff. Super chat from Red
- 32:46John m will sue a big ten bands right now, more evidence over off
- 32:52season. Maybe opponents get helmet Mike's next season Bawlban and wins vacated hashtag justice
- 32:59for Jim Kevin. Will you please punch up the major disciplinary action slide again?
- 33:04Yeah? Let me take this. I mean we had to read our
- 33:06super chat. Let me yeah, sure, yeah, yeah yeah. Ten
- 33:07point ten I got the name you. You did a really good job of
- 33:12naming these so I can find them. Ten point three point three point two
- 33:16Major disciplinary action. Disciplinary actions exceeding those listed in the Agreement ten point three
- 33:21point three point one above must receive prior approval by the Joint Group Executive Committee
- 33:25JAK. In any case for which prior approval is sought, the JAX shall
- 33:29be provided in writing the involved institutions or individual's position as described in Agreement ten
- 33:34point three point one above. The j K may only approve, deny,
- 33:37or lessen the proposed penalty. It shall not increase the proposed penalty. Further,
- 33:42the JAK may not lessen the penalty to a lower level lower than that
- 33:45for which its approval is required. Review and action by jay K listen closely
- 33:51shall occur as expeditiously as possible, listen even more closely, and its decisions
- 33:54shall be final and are not subject to appeal. Michigan. Michigan signed the
- 34:01terms and conditions when they join the conference, right, so you agree to
- 34:06the terms and conditions. The terms and conditions say shall not be subject to
- 34:09appeal, which again I do not have a law degree. But shall not
- 34:15be subject to appeal seems pretty black and white to me. You join the
- 34:21Shriners, you know you have to drive in the parades in the little cars
- 34:23with the hats on. I mean, you know what the rules are when
- 34:25you sign up for the organization. You can't come back out and be like,
- 34:30we didn't know. I mean you you you had team of lawyers and
- 34:35everything else, and you probably you know, as a founding member of the
- 34:37conference, helped shape a lot of the bylaws and everything else. And then
- 34:42now you can't sit there and say they're not convenient to us. Our cheating
- 34:46plans are way more complicated than anything you could ever figure out with any of
- 34:51this. So yeah, I mean, you can sit there and throw bluster
- 34:54every I mean, Michigan fans can throw bluster all they want that we're going
- 34:58we're going to sue you back into the Stone Age, but that doesn't change
- 35:00anything. You signed up for the organization and you're stuck. You're stuck at
- 35:06that point. Well, I do think obviously, obviously Shriners understand the cars
- 35:12thing, because that's basically why you join, so that you can drive the
- 35:15fund cars during the parade. I'm not sure what else they do there,
- 35:17but that's one of the top things. Of course. Todd Doyle says they
- 35:22can suspend Jim the offensive coordinator defensive coordinator with pay until it's resolved. They
- 35:27can suspend I mean, they can do anything, it sounds like, and
- 35:30we don't know what they're going to do. We're just saying that by their
- 35:35rules that every member agreed to, they seem to have a pretty broad swath
- 35:42of options available to them. And there is nothing there listed as but you
- 35:47can't do this. This is you know, this is but this is a
- 35:51bridge too far. There is okay, you can do these things, including
- 35:53a up to two game suspension, as we mentioned earlier, without approval from
- 35:59the jay GABA. But there's nothing there that says you can't say you have
- 36:05to forfeit all your games and you're ineligible for the Big Ten championship game.
- 36:08They could say that that's a possibility. They the Big Ten, I don't
- 36:15think, would have authority over the College Football Playoff. The College Football Playoff
- 36:20would be able to make a decision on their own. But if the Big
- 36:22Ten says you're suspended, then you know, the College Football Playoff, if
- 36:29Michigan loses a game, would probably look at that as a thank you very
- 36:32much. Now we don't have to make a decision. We can just say,
- 36:35well, they lost, so now it's not our problem. We don't
- 36:37know what the Big the College Football Playoff is going to do. They i
- 36:40did not go through their bylaws. We'll get to that if it comes to
- 36:44that. But this is the more immediate stuff based on the reporting from last
- 36:47night. And you know, there's there's a lot of people that you know
- 36:51states, you know, they're not going to do anything to you know,
- 36:53get rid of the Ohio State Michigan game this year. I don't think anyone's
- 36:57expecting that but if you're spending whoever I mean, just to use the last
- 37:02person's example, Harbaugh and the offensive coordinator Searon Moore and the defensive coordinator Jesse
- 37:10Minter, whatever, you're suspending those three guys, you're still playing the game.
- 37:15I don't think there's any reason to think that the Ohoused Michigan game is
- 37:19not going to happen this year. But you could suspend them from being eligible
- 37:22for the postseason, for the Big Ten championship game. You can you can
- 37:25wipe that out. You can say, pending this investigation, ineligible for there,
- 37:31we're gonna suspend x y z x y Z coaches. Those are the
- 37:36things that you're gonna have there. I would think from the jack if it
- 37:39gets to that point and then you know, I think as more stuff comes
- 37:45out, then then you could sit there and see where the n C two
- 37:47A goes with a notice of allegations and everything else, and that that's where
- 37:52record books get altered and things of that nature. But I think that things
- 37:54that could come out of the Big Ten office are suspensions and ineligibility for Indianapolis
- 38:01if Michigan were to get to that point. Yeah, you can't punish the
- 38:06other schools and take those games away and take those gates away and the TV
- 38:10revenue because of something that Michigan has done. So you play the games or
- 38:15whatever happens there happens there. But if they want to punish, they can
- 38:19find their way to punishment. Can I Can I discuss the turn on Wednesday
- 38:27when like everybody at ESPN turned on Michigan, and well, that's pretty interesting,
- 38:32and it comes out the day after the College Football Playoff Committee says,
- 38:38until there these are just allegations, until there's more proof, we're not going
- 38:42to do anything about it. And then you had Stephen A. Smith,
- 38:45Paul fine Bomb, Peter Burns, one of the basketball people. Obviously Pete
- 38:51Damill is working, you know, working for ESPN, but like he's been
- 38:54on this well before anybody else. But like the talking heads basically all started
- 39:00to come out against Michigan at this point. And I made a mention on
- 39:05Twitter that it's like they just realized ESPN just realized they're no longer a Big
- 39:09ten partner. And I do wonder what kind of impact that's going to have
- 39:14with the College Football Playoff Committee when they're being inundated with the talking kids just
- 39:20confirming to the ether through their viewers that Michigan is cheating. I did find
- 39:25it interesting that then Tim Brando tweeted out last night and he's a Fox employee,
- 39:30basically kind of in defense of Michigan, and I wonder if we're starting
- 39:36to see the onset of the ESPN versus Fox thing, and also how much
- 39:42of this is ESPN and the SEC seeing the potential for the Big Ten getting
- 39:49two programs in the playoffs and not wanting to have that happen again. And
- 39:52so is it time to now go all in on Michigan and just make it
- 39:58make people aware that this isn't Some people don't like what's happening there. Yeah,
- 40:05I mean, it feels like there's been a lot that's come out since
- 40:09the initial thing where I mean I didn't even watch the Paul Findbaum. I
- 40:14haven't watched the old Paul Finebaum or the new Paul Finebaum, but there was
- 40:19you know, he was cited in some of the initial Michigan response to this,
- 40:22you know, from like blogs, not from like the school, but
- 40:24just reporters or blogs or whatever saying like, look, Paul Finebaum doesn't think
- 40:28it's a big deal. I mean, a lot of stuff has come out
- 40:30between then and now, and I think this story has changed, and you
- 40:36know, sometimes we're privy to stuff that hasn't come out yet, and you
- 40:38know that that is probably you know, you're hearing it from people who would
- 40:45know if there was some smoke there, and it feels like there's more stuff
- 40:49still to come out. You wonder if some of that has gotten around to
- 40:54some of the folks in Bristol that could be part of it. There's just
- 40:59there's a lot, a lot of different possibilities there. But you know,
- 41:02I mean there was we talked about this earlier and I don't remember if actually
- 41:06threw this, and no, I didn't throw it in this show title.
- 41:07But okay, So the idea that Michigan, if they get, you know,
- 41:14some kind of punishment that hurts them this year, that Michigan is going
- 41:17to jump to the sec like this is the kind of thing you would expect
- 41:21to see from an egg Twitter account with zero followers, and instead I saw
- 41:24it from one of, if not the most prominent Michigan media folks in the
- 41:30middle of the night. And I will typically sort of give a little grace
- 41:36to middle of the night tweets because sometimes there's some inspiration behind them. But
- 41:39this is also I've seen this reported in the middle of the day too,
- 41:42so it's not just a you know, divinely inspired tweet in the middle of
- 41:46the night. It is something that's actually a thought and it's well, Michigan
- 41:51will just jump to the SEC if this happens. Tony, I want you
- 41:55to pick a number between one and seventeen, and that will be that will
- 41:59be the reason number that this is the dumbest idea I have ever heard in
- 42:04my entire life. Pick a number between one and seventeen. Seventeen seventeen.
- 42:09Hey, you know how the Big Ten people were annoyed at the fact that
- 42:15maybe their signs got stolen and maybe that, you know, affected competitions on
- 42:19the field. Did any SEC team show up on Connor Stallion's list, apparently
- 42:25allegedly were. Have there been any rumors about other SEC teams who Michigan never
- 42:32actually played, who might have been spied upon, who might have had some
- 42:37of their signals? Maybe we don't know, but at least rumors that some
- 42:42of that might have gotten pub pushed along. Any of this sounding at all
- 42:47familiar to you, Tony, yeah. Well, and you also have Tennessee
- 42:52fans who believe that Michigan spying is what got Anton Hooker hurt, and you
- 42:58know it cost them a chance at the playoffs. And having an opponent having
- 43:01advanced information on what you're going to do put your quarterback in the more more
- 43:07danger than not. So, yes, Tom, that would be one.
- 43:12Where would the media rights fall? What number is that for you? Tom?
- 43:15Well, that's that's number three. And these are just in a random
- 43:19order, but the numbers a type of super right. Sure does super time
- 43:23for Mike Arino. Isn't Michigan locked into the Big Ten until twenty thirty with
- 43:27a new TV contract similar to ACC teams? Why yes, Mike, they
- 43:30sure are. The Big Ten just signed a new TV deal that went into
- 43:32effect this year. Seven year deal. It ends after the twenty twenty nine
- 43:37twenty thirty academic year. So here's what happens. The Michigan has signed over
- 43:43their grant of rights as part of that deal. What your grant of right
- 43:45means is you have taken your TV rights and you have given them to your
- 43:51conference. And this is just a way that it just is. You know,
- 43:53look at us, We're all handcuffed together. No one can leave.
- 43:57We're all in this together. Every Big Ten member signs it. So every
- 44:00Big Ten member their TV rights go to the conference, and then the Conference
- 44:02distributes them. So if Michigan decided they wanted to take their ball and go
- 44:07home tomorrow because they were so mad right now, then they can go.
- 44:13They can do that, They can go to the SEC, but the rights
- 44:15for all of their home games in their new SEC home all go to the
- 44:20Big Ten. So that feels like that's probably not super viable financially. Yeah,
- 44:31I mean, I it's it's insane, and it's again it's it's a
- 44:36it's a reactionary statement, and it's like, well, I'm gonna go over
- 44:39and go play in that yard instead without really thinking things through. And I'd
- 44:45say that cooler heads, you know, and thoughts would prevail, but we
- 44:49know in the middle of crisis that that generally takes a little bit of time
- 44:52and everything else. But that is just you know, there's zero percent chance
- 44:55of that happening, just as much as the talk of you know, we're
- 45:00gonna we're gonna sue the conference and everything else. I mean, you signed
- 45:04the by law, you signed the deal. To be in the league.
- 45:06You've probably helped shape the bylaws. You're you're, you're, You're in it.
- 45:10Buddy, You're in it, buddy. Super chat from Mellow number seven.
- 45:14Yeah, being the number one team in America is considered being down bad
- 45:16thumbs down, eyes rolled, typical Michigan fans that drink that flint tapwater.
- 45:23You know, Mellow, Mellow number seven is not having it with all of
- 45:28our all of our visitors in the chat right now. But there's you know,
- 45:32what a time to be alive, What a time to be alive and
- 45:35Mika Hannah saying that Mellow is savage with a lot a lot of emojis there.
- 45:42It is good to know that the if this was happening that at at
- 45:45Ohio State, that Michigan fans wouldn't be interested and it's wouldn't be interested in
- 45:50watching people talk about it, wouldn't be interested in talking about it or reading
- 45:52about it. Everybody. What's all the fuss about, everybody? It's just
- 45:57it's just a hamburger. It's just a hamburger. What are we talking about
- 46:00here? I did see someone in the chat saying that Michigan fans weren't worried
- 46:04about Urban Meyer and Zack Smith in twenty eighteen, they were just worried about
- 46:07getting better to beat Ohio State. Who here is old enough to remember the
- 46:12year of our Lord twenty eighteen? Any show of hands? Yeah, yeah,
- 46:15yeah, yeah, I know. T GAK is all over that well
- 46:21and in time. As you have mentioned many times, we're all old enough
- 46:24to remember when Michigan folks thought online courses was cheating. Yes, that was,
- 46:34and you know what, Listen what happened in twenty twenty. That was
- 46:37in twenty nineteen, What happened in twenty twenty COVID? What did schools have
- 46:42to do in twenty twenty online classes? What happened in twenty twenty one Michigan
- 46:46hired carran Stallions. I mean, do I need to connect the dots for
- 46:49you, Tony? This has been one long straight line from online classes.
- 46:53It's like the meme with the dominoes where you're tipping the dominoes over and it
- 46:57starts with a little one and it's like, you know, wuhan whatever,
- 47:04wuhan whatever you want to believe about how that all started, and then the
- 47:08end is and Tony Petiti got yelled at by a bunch of Big Ten coaches
- 47:12last night on the phone. I mean, do I have to draw a
- 47:15line for you, mad I would have loved to have been on that call,
- 47:20just to be able to listen to that call, Red John. This
- 47:22is a little bit of a deep cut. This is from the two thousand
- 47:25and seventeen Oklahoma game when college game day was on campus for Ohio State.
- 47:31Ohio State recused themselves from Micah Parsons because of a picture Micah Parsons was taken
- 47:36up on the platform during college game Day by an Ohio State person, you
- 47:43know, tour guide or whatever it was, and that was considered a violation
- 47:46in Ohio State said, you know what, We're just not gonna yet.
- 47:50They sort of withdrew from the Micah Parsons recruitment and he went on to be
- 47:53pretty darn good at Penn State and pretty darn good at with the Dallas Cowboys
- 47:59right now, right, yes, all right, you can tell he's a
- 48:01big NFL player because I know where he's playing. Yes, Can we just
- 48:07address the whole sign stealing thing that everybody has sign Steelers, the Michigan people
- 48:16that are just latching onto the fact that it's just side sign stealing. It's
- 48:20on the sidelines. Everybody does it. And I saw somebody responded to one
- 48:24of my tweets this morning with one of the screenshots from the Athletic Thing saying
- 48:30thirty three of the fifty coaches have sign stealers on their staff. This is
- 48:37in game stuff that they're talking about, and that's what everybody, well not
- 48:43everybody does it, many people, many many programs do it. They're trying
- 48:45to decipher signs while the game is going on. This is not what Michigan
- 48:51has reportedly done. Kind of. Stallion's just sent people out to get video,
- 48:53to acquire things electronically and has been an integral part of that, pros
- 49:00says allegedly reportedly, that's vastly different than what we're talking about in term what
- 49:07other programs do, and they're not sending people out. This is the first
- 49:10time we've ever seen anything on this scope, arguably possibly the biggest possible cheating
- 49:15scandal in college football recent history, in terms of modern day history. So
- 49:22this is not sign stealing. This is traveling funding a network. So we
- 49:30call it a vast networks, the vastest, if you will, of ways
- 49:37to gain an advantage that are against the rules. Again, against the rules.
- 49:42And I know they're Mischigan fans who are saying and Michigan bloggers who have
- 49:45said, but the NCAA wanted to get rid of one of those rules about
- 49:49advanced scouting in person. Yeah, but they didn't. It's still one of
- 49:52the rules. And that's not the only rule that is being violated. There's
- 49:54also the violation of recording signals on site things like that. No, there's
- 50:02no rule in particular rule about sunglasses that have recording, but there are electronic
- 50:10things that you can't record electronically, and there's no like the number of Yeah,
- 50:16but it doesn't say this or it doesn't say that, or you can.
- 50:21The new one is the NCAA allows third party scouting, and that's what
- 50:27counter Stallion's was funding, was third party scouting, except those third parties have
- 50:30to be licensed and approved by the the NCAA and conferences and things like that.
- 50:37I don't think a D three coach former D three coach doing it for
- 50:42five hundred bucks necessarily licensed, especially when he's not going to give his name.
- 50:45And I mean, if we want to talk about anonymity and how that's
- 50:49terrible, then is that okay, is it okay to be anonymous in all
- 50:53of this? So I just the just to not that it's gonna change anything,
- 51:00because as I've said, like Jim Harbaugh can come out and say,
- 51:02yeah, we did it, we stole signs, we had this elaborate scheme,
- 51:07and you're still gonna have a segment of Michigan fans saying it's just Jim,
- 51:13you don't know ball that everybody does it. You don't really gain an
- 51:15advantage from stealing signs. Well, I mean, imagine if this was like
- 51:20the NFL. And I know the rules are different in the NFL in terms
- 51:23of advanced scouting and things like that, but you deflate some footballs and I
- 51:29mean that was like on TV more than Swift and Kelsey or are on TV
- 51:35right now. Imagine if this was going on in the National Football League and
- 51:37just the outrage and this the wall to wall media coverage we're we're just kind
- 51:43of getting to the tip of the iceberg right now that ESPN and ESPN outside
- 51:49of its actual reporters, its personalities are talking about it. Pete Amimal has
- 51:52done a great job throughout I've known Pete Beck since his Yahoo days, just
- 51:57imagine just the groundswell that will be there. And I throw this out to
- 52:00Tom at t GEK, what are the odds that we're going to have to
- 52:05stop on our way to Rutgers to do an emergency show. I'm putting it
- 52:08in about fifty to fifty. We thought that last week this is the Big
- 52:13Ten has blessed us with back to back road trips to drive to Madison,
- 52:16Wisconsin and then Scataway, New Jersey, which are not close together and not
- 52:21close to Columbus, back to back weeks. So and last Friday I was
- 52:25messaging these guys like, hey, we need to kind of have a plan,
- 52:30like just in case something major happens that we might just have to pull
- 52:34off the road and talk to the good folks on YouTube dot com for a
- 52:37while because and we didn't have to do it last week. Stuff has continued
- 52:40to sort of come out, and you know the fact that there was a
- 52:45coaches call last night, and now according to Adam Rittenberg from ESPN, there's
- 52:49going to be an ad call later on today and I just I want to
- 52:52read his tweet just so we're providing all the context here. Adam Rittenberg,
- 52:58Big Ten Athletic directors have a call with Commissioner Tony Pettiti for later today,
- 53:01per source, likely more follow up on Michigan situation. So you know,
- 53:07we don't know for a fact that that's it, but it seems like that
- 53:10would be a logical conclusion to draw. We know, the Big Tennis dropping
- 53:15their twenty twenty four schedule later, So maybe it's that. I don't know
- 53:17who's to say, but it's probably it's probably about the Michigan situation. And
- 53:24so yeah, they I don't know that I'm expecting something that soon. Probably,
- 53:31I mean, it feels like this is gonna be one of these like
- 53:34you need to according to this stuff we read earlier. And we're coming up
- 53:37on the top of the hour, which means I get to read the law
- 53:38stuff again soon. Yay. As we welcome in new people, Uh,
- 53:44smoke them if you got them, smoke them if you got them kids.
- 53:46We're going to smoke in the whole pack. There's a lot of there's a
- 53:49lot of PDFs to go through. But you know, according to the stuff
- 53:52we read, you know, there could be an immediate you know, an
- 53:58immediate suspension of two games, but then to do anything more than that,
- 54:02you need to have, you know, the reasonable amount of time to allow
- 54:06Michigan to respond and all that kind of stuff. So I'm kind of going
- 54:10back and forth between do they put that out, you know, is there
- 54:14some sort of immediate action taken on Friday this week and you know, for
- 54:19this weekend's game, or do you wait, you get through this weekend,
- 54:22you do some of the back and forth response kind of process, and then
- 54:27you drop it all at once whatever they're going to do. And I don't
- 54:30you know, I don't know that they're going to do anything that not doing
- 54:34anything is a possibility here. I don't want to act like, oh,
- 54:37we know exactly what he's going to do. There are no punishments prescribed in
- 54:40there, you know, in terms of this particular rule breaking, there are
- 54:45limits on what he can do by himself. There's no limits on what he
- 54:47could do with the jay gek. Well, if you're jumping on, I'm
- 54:52wondering, what's a jack? Oh, friends, you just wait, we
- 54:53will go through it all, don't you worry. But you know, so
- 54:58you could do nothing. You could do something or in conjunction with you know,
- 55:05in a little bit of a longer process, you could do more than
- 55:07something. So we and we don't know what he's going to choose to do
- 55:12because we don't know Tony Pettiti at all. I mean that the Michigan people
- 55:16are saying, well, he's a TV guy, so he's going to make
- 55:19this based on TV decisions. He's also a former Major League baseball guy,
- 55:22and when he was on the Major League Baseball something or other committee he what
- 55:30was it, gek M gek, Yes, the Major League Baseball something or
- 55:34other he was part of. He was part of the committee that like nuked
- 55:37the Houston Astros for signs stealing. So you can look at the TV thing
- 55:43and say, okay, well he's going to make a TV decision, or
- 55:45you can do the like, hey, he was involved in a kind of
- 55:47similar situation and it didn't go great for the team involved. So you can
- 55:52kind of read whatever Tea leaves you want to on this one. Well,
- 55:55why are we not talking about this being Ryan Day's fault? I mean,
- 55:59Robert Hour wants to know if it is all Ryan Day's fault. Asking for
- 56:02a friend information. Yeah, glass One's butterfly wants us to catch her up.
- 56:08Don't worry, we'll get there. We'll we'll get there four minutes,
- 56:12will be at the top of the hour with with a ninth reset and everything
- 56:15else. This is not We'll probably take you right up to the Ryan Day
- 56:20radio show on uh on the Ohio State Sports Radio Network. The Jeffrey Barski
- 56:28thing. What would what would you guys do if you had the power?
- 56:30I think obviously you still need all of the information. And the thing there
- 56:35is you can have some of the information, but that doesn't tell you who
- 56:38all was involved. So you need to get everything to figure out, as
- 56:42they say, how deep it went, and then that's when you know all
- 56:45of the punishments that you would lay down. But if if this goes back
- 56:50to Gimm Harbaugh and then clearly there you I think you can get that information
- 56:58before the season is over because you just have to talk to people and if
- 57:01they're lying, can you catch them in lies? And if they're not lying
- 57:04and Jim Harbaugh's you have no proof that Jim Harbaugh has knowledge of this,
- 57:07then you have no proof that he has knowledge of it. But what proof
- 57:10do you have that other people had knowledge of it? Your your coordinator is
- 57:14clearly the coordinators. Why are you Why are you so emphatically trusting counter stallions,
- 57:22and then what was the the the conversations you had with him and that
- 57:28that got him hired, or what did he tell you? How did he
- 57:31acquire these this knowledge? And did you even ask? Because if you don't
- 57:36ask, then that's because you don't truly want to know. And if you're
- 57:39if you're going to hire somebody like wow, you're really good at this,
- 57:42how do you do it? And he says I can't tell you, then
- 57:45either you're like, well I can't hire you or okay, or yes,
- 57:49I will hire you. So there there's levels to this that you have to
- 57:52figure out what they knew, what they willingly didn't want to know, because
- 57:58that's also not great. But in terms of the two game suspension, I
- 58:04don't I don't expect anything to happen this week. So if you are going
- 58:07to suspend Jim Harbaugh for two games, you might want to do it the
- 58:12those the two weeks before Ohio State and then imagine he returns for the Ohio
- 58:17State game and just the approval, the roar of approval that he would have
- 58:22from the crowd. It's like, you know, Maximus in the arena as
- 58:28the conquering hero and I don't know that Tony Pettiti or the Big ten want
- 58:31that either well, I mean no, probably not, And I mean either
- 58:38way, that game is going to be a circus. I mean that game
- 58:43is going to be a two thousand and six level, you know, on
- 58:46field, off field, everything about it circus. I cannot wait for that
- 58:52game. I don't know what is going to happen between now and then Thanksgiving
- 58:55dinner and just go right up Harbor at that point. Honestly, we might
- 59:00need to in the hotel reservation. Yeah and there, Sorry Tony, No,
- 59:04because no, which is to go and we're gonna have to go up
- 59:07there and have a marathon show. It's not the Turkey, it's the four
- 59:15fifty inch TVs that I plan on buying for one hundred and eighty dollars total.
- 59:20So I do want to get through there. I have been if you
- 59:24have seen me like looking to the side and like smiling a bunch that the
- 59:28comment section has just been just perfect. What I mean, what is more
- 59:36fun than Ohios dated to Michigan people just going back and forth at each other's
- 59:38throats just for an hour straight. I do want to punch this one up
- 59:43real quick. From Ninja Rob. He is a Michigan fan based on the
- 59:47you know, preponderance of his his his messages. Sign steeling it he got
- 59:55he got auto corrected here, but sign stealing really helped us with ECU toilet
- 1:00:00emoji. So who wants to point out the funny thing about that? Well,
- 1:00:08yeah, the funny thing about that is they didn't necessarily have TCU signs.
- 1:00:14They didn't advance scout the horn frogs, and some would argue that's why
- 1:00:20they didn't win and struggled as much as they did in that game, and
- 1:00:23in fact ended up losing in that game, surprisingly as a considerable favorite.
- 1:00:29Maybe it's unrelated. Everybody and their uncle came in and said, hey,
- 1:00:34guess what Michigan steals signs. You might want to check yourself before you wreck
- 1:00:37yourself. So they had all sorts of things in place, they knew going
- 1:00:44in, and they they had plans for all of it, and you know,
- 1:00:49and you're going out there. It's like the scene in Animal House where
- 1:00:52they steal the carbon copy of the test, but the other house put the
- 1:00:58fake one in there and they all failed. I mean, it's that's exactly
- 1:01:01what it is. I'm I'm sorry, I got to jump off. I
- 1:01:04got to get on Photoshop right now and start doing some things. Super chat
- 1:01:08from David Greenshield. Will this be the biggest game in the history of the
- 1:01:13rivalry? And I always, I always thought two thousand and six would be
- 1:01:19impossible to top number one versus number two. BeO Schambeckler passes away the day
- 1:01:24before the game. I mean, just the the emotions, the storylines in
- 1:01:30that stadium on that day were. I mean, I never thought you'd match
- 1:01:36it. And you've had so many great ones when you go back through the
- 1:01:39seventies and the Ten Year War, and you know, the nineteen sixty nine
- 1:01:43game up in ann Arbor Bo's first game, you have the you know,
- 1:01:46the twenty sixteen game, you have last year's game. I mean, there
- 1:01:50have been some great, great, you know, top four, top three
- 1:01:53kind of games. I don't think I don't know if it's the biggest,
- 1:01:58but I don't think we've ever seen anything like what this could be in a
- 1:02:02couple of weeks. Kevin, I mean I don't disagree. I mean I
- 1:02:08think that certainly when it comes to off the field things, Yes, the
- 1:02:15tragic passing of Bosham Beckler around six was was a huge one. I think
- 1:02:20that the uh, you know, the first trestle game, you know,
- 1:02:24after you know, three three hundred and ten days after he delivered his comments.
- 1:02:30I think that you know, in terms of on the field sixty nine
- 1:02:34when when Michigan with bo is able to be to the defending national champions.
- 1:02:38There certainly were a lot of things there. But we live in a world
- 1:02:43now with so much information and much of it misinformation, but so much information
- 1:02:47out there at our fingertips that this is going to be unlike anything that we
- 1:02:53have ever been witnessed to. I really think that this is going to be
- 1:03:00something, and it's really going to be a great time to be a member
- 1:03:04of Buckeyehuddle dot com. I mean, get all of the lead up to
- 1:03:07the to the game, make sure you don't miss a single thing, a
- 1:03:10single room or anything there. For the price of a crummy delivery pizza,
- 1:03:15you could have a month at Buckeye Huddle to get you through the game.
- 1:03:20Give us a give us a chat, a chance, see what's going on.
- 1:03:22Go to the huddle board presented by Jeff Ruby, Steakhouse, Columbus,
- 1:03:27and be able to get all the insight from there. Mark Gibler's recruiting information,
- 1:03:30great analysis from Ross Fulton, Devin Ratliffe, Michael Pettitt, everything there,
- 1:03:37and of course Tom t Gek and myself all there on the board.
- 1:03:42You don't even have to wait for us to go on a chat. You
- 1:03:44get full access to us there at Buckeye Huddle dot com and also be sure
- 1:03:47to check out wager wire as well. Another one of our sponsors sign up
- 1:03:52for their app use code Buckeye Huddle, and that certainly would help us out
- 1:03:55as well. Thank you, k Pop. I would also ask, if
- 1:04:00you're watching now, go ahead it and hit the thumbs up on this.
- 1:04:02That always helps us and helps YouTube find this show for other people before we
- 1:04:08get to the super chat. I think this game, as you said,
- 1:04:11Tom, it's going to be vastly different than any other game because of the
- 1:04:15circumstances surrounding it. Obviously the playoff circumstances and then the cheating scandal, the
- 1:04:21gigantic, massive cheating scandal that is going on around the entire Michigan football program
- 1:04:27and everybody associated with it. The giant cheating scandal there. But I also
- 1:04:31don't think the stakes of this game, like the results of this game will
- 1:04:35be what they are. But also I think the season might not exist for
- 1:04:42Michigan after this season in terms of I could see this game being wiped away
- 1:04:47or with their season already kind of If you ask national reporters or national talking
- 1:04:55hands, they'll tell you that the season has already become tainted for Michigan.
- 1:04:59So if we should give it more weight than it deserves. But if Michigan
- 1:05:03does beat Ohio State, they're going the narrative there, and I don't know
- 1:05:08that it's entirely wrong. It is like, we don't need to cheat to
- 1:05:11win. And I would say, you didn't need to cheat to win,
- 1:05:15and you've proven that here, but that doesn't mean you didn't cheat to win
- 1:05:19every you know, for the past three years. So I think a loss
- 1:05:24for Michigan would be devastating to their storyline and to probably the Jim Harbaugh because
- 1:05:30he thought this entire thing was on the up and app the whole time.
- 1:05:34Well it does, I mean narratively, just setting aside the you know,
- 1:05:39Big Ten Championship, the College Football Playoff potential berths and all of that kind
- 1:05:44of stuff. Just narratively, if Michigan wins this year, then the narrative
- 1:05:48is exactly what everyone from the Michigan side is saying in the chat right now,
- 1:05:53which is this is all just Ohio State was scared and it didn't make
- 1:05:56any difference at all, and nothing matters, and you know it's just Ohio
- 1:06:00State is you know, a bunch of whiny cry babies. And if Michigan
- 1:06:03wins again this year, then that absolutely becomes the narrative. If Ohio State
- 1:06:09wins this year, then boy, how different to the last couple of years.
- 1:06:12Look where Hey, coincidentally, the two years that you had this guy
- 1:06:15on your staff out of the last twenty three are two of the what four
- 1:06:23times in that span that you've beaten Ohio State. Boy, what a coincidence
- 1:06:28that is? I wonder if you could draw any kind of a straight line
- 1:06:30between these two facts. There's I mean, I don't know how much that
- 1:06:34matters anywhere other than the internet, but hey, we're all on the internet
- 1:06:38a lot, so I guess that matters a lot. So super chat from
- 1:06:42the Buckeye Businessman. Michigan should be removed from the Big ten. There now
- 1:06:45at the center of the biggest basketball scandal in NCAA history, and now football
- 1:06:48they have proved that they are cheaters and always will be no room for that
- 1:06:51in the Big Ten. I mean, you know, we talked earlier about
- 1:06:55the idea that Michigan was going to take their ball and go to the SEC,
- 1:06:58and I find that implausible. I also find it pretty implausible that the
- 1:07:03Big Ten would boot Michigan over this. It that's just not how these decisions
- 1:07:09get made. These are These are decisions that get made over the span of
- 1:07:13years and decades and get made by people who probably broadly don't care that much
- 1:07:18about football or athletics at all. I mean, you think of Ohio State
- 1:07:23and Michigan as having enormous athletic departments and nine figure budgets every year, and
- 1:07:27it's like, wow, that's a lot of money on the scale of an
- 1:07:30university. It's nothing. That's a rounding error on the scale of you know
- 1:07:33what, the Ohio State University, Ohio State Medical Center, or University Michigan,
- 1:07:39University, Michigan Medalskill Center, all that stuff. Yeah. I mean,
- 1:07:44that's that's like a tiny speck in the corner of you know, of
- 1:07:47the graph in terms of like the money involved here, the number of people
- 1:07:51involved here, You're not You're not going to see you know, the Big
- 1:07:56Ten's not kicking Michigan out. Michigan is not taking their ball and going home.
- 1:08:00No, that's just that's just people being mad right now. And this
- 1:08:03is not a decision that's going to get made in the next week. It's
- 1:08:06there's going to be years for something to settle, you know, everyone to
- 1:08:10sort of calm their bodies down and settle down and not make an emotional decision
- 1:08:14that this is not a decision you make emotionally. You're not universities, despite
- 1:08:17what people might think, are not run by completely irrational idiots. I do
- 1:08:21want to agree with It's just me Tim seventy nine sering at least A Fab
- 1:08:25five was fun to watch. They're very fun to watch, but it's not
- 1:08:28fun to watch is the same Michigan Michigan game over and over and over and
- 1:08:30over again this season. But you know, the things we do for the
- 1:08:34people. You know what I'm hearing right now, hearing the law talk coming
- 1:08:40up, I think, Yes, I hope that Tom is Jones and for
- 1:08:44it. So here, you know we're about we're about seventy minutes into the
- 1:08:47show, So I think it's time to reset. For those of you who
- 1:08:49have joined us here on the later side, welcome. We are your Buckeye
- 1:08:55Huddle crew, Tom Moore, Tony Gerdaman and myself Kevin Noon. This is
- 1:08:59the big turmoil. Coaches want action. Now, what does it all mean?
- 1:09:02Show? And uh, you know, take it away, Tom,
- 1:09:06with all of your prepared slides counts for all, right, So let's start.
- 1:09:11This is all from the Big ten Sportsmanship policy. So this is all
- 1:09:15the stuff that when you're seeing Pete THEAMIL referencing, like, here's what the
- 1:09:17Commissioner can do. This is the direct document. We're not taking it from
- 1:09:20Pete theam all. I went and found here's the direct document from the Big
- 1:09:25Ten. Ten point two Authority of the Commissioner ten point two point one executive
- 1:09:30exclusive authority to determine whether offensive actions have occurred. The Commissioner shall have the
- 1:09:33exclusive authority to determine whether an offensive action is contemplated in Agreement ten point zero
- 1:09:38point ten point oh one above has been committed by anyone referenced in Agreement ten
- 1:09:43point one above. In making this determination, the Commissioner may consider any evidence
- 1:09:47that he or she deems relevant. The Commissioner may accept any information provided by
- 1:09:51any source, but, except as outlined in Agreement ten point three point one
- 1:09:55below, has no formal obligation to do so ten point two point two to
- 1:10:00take disciplinary action in the event the Commissioner determines that an offensive action has occurred,
- 1:10:03the Commissioner shall have the authority to impose any disciplinary action in response to
- 1:10:08the offensive action, subject to the provisions of Agreement ten point three point three
- 1:10:13point one below. So what does this mean the TLDR on this is just
- 1:10:17yeah, the commissioner at Tony Pettiti, and the Commissioner himself can determine whether
- 1:10:24any sort of offensive action has been committed. So whether there has been a
- 1:10:27violation, that's up to Tony Pettiti. That's not like, oh, you've
- 1:10:30got to have a whole thing, you know, you don't. This doesn't
- 1:10:33have to get run through the NCAA, This doesn't have to get run past
- 1:10:36the governor, it doesn't have to get run past Jim Harbaugh. Tony Petiti
- 1:10:42gets to make that decision. That is what that means. All right,
- 1:10:45real quick, we're going to try and blast through these a little bit faster
- 1:10:46than we did last hour, just in case we have people who are still
- 1:10:48on factors that may be considered. So this is just like, what are
- 1:10:53the violations that you could be looking for when you're deciding what kind of punishment
- 1:10:59might be in life, whether it's a violation, and what kind of punishment
- 1:11:00might be merited in deciding whether to im impose disciplinary action. Factor to be
- 1:11:06considered by the Commissioner may include, but shall not be limited to, the
- 1:11:10following A the general nature or severity of the offensive action. B Any injury
- 1:11:15or damage that results directly from the offensive action. See the manner in which
- 1:11:17the offensive action fits within the context of the rules of the game for the
- 1:11:19sport at issue. D Any action taken or imposed in accordance with the applicable
- 1:11:24rules of the game. Eg. Action taken by game officials. E.
- 1:11:28The response of and or any action taken by the involved member institutions. F.
- 1:11:31The response of, and or any action taken by any other entity that
- 1:11:35may have jurisdiction over the offensive action. Eg. Law enforcement. G.
- 1:11:41Any prior offensive actions as contemplated within this policy. I mean, real quick,
- 1:11:46anyone see anything on that list that could apply to this situation based on
- 1:11:50the information that we currently have available to us. Well. I also like
- 1:11:55the fact that it says shall not be limited too, so there could be
- 1:11:58more that comes up there, Like you know what, this should be part
- 1:12:00of that as well. Because this is an unprecedented thing. You might have
- 1:12:03some unprecedented actions that didn't fall under the the kind of things that you would
- 1:12:09think would happen when you when you start witnessing stuff that has never happened before,
- 1:12:13then maybe you might have to create some new rules or something like that.
- 1:12:16So they've they've got the ground rules that the they've laid out the ability
- 1:12:21to add rules to that as well. Which is interesting is the FBI Law
- 1:12:28Enforcement. I'm just asking for a friend, uh comment in the chat for
- 1:12:33Michael Ensminger. These guys are dork blue non responsive but okay, not necessarily
- 1:12:40inaccurate, but non responsive ten point three inn procedural elements ten point three point
- 1:12:45one. I don't know why anyone thinks were dorks. We're reading through extremely
- 1:12:48dense legal terminology right now. Only one of us is reading through it,
- 1:12:55dork, where do you get off? Or ten point three point When commissioner's
- 1:13:00discretion, timeliness and due process, the commissioner has the discretion to pursue or
- 1:13:03choose not to pursue, an investigation as to whether an offensive action has occurred.
- 1:13:08In the event the Commissioner decides to pursue such an investigation, the Commissioner
- 1:13:11shall commend investigation as expeditiously as possible upon notification that such an offensive action may
- 1:13:16have occurred. Upon commencement of such an investigation, the commissill determine as expeditiously
- 1:13:20as possible whether an offensive action did occur. Any involved institution or individual at
- 1:13:26risk of disciplinary action shall be provided with an opportunity, which may be waived,
- 1:13:30to offer its or his or her position as to whether offensive action occurred.
- 1:13:34The frame within which institution or vill shall provide it or his or her
- 1:13:39position shall be set by the Commissioner and shall be reasonable in light of the
- 1:13:42circumstances. Upon determination that a defensive action did occur, the Commissioner shall,
- 1:13:45as expeditiously as possible, determine whether disciplinary action should be imposed, and if
- 1:13:50so, what it should be. Ten point three point two Notice of disciplinary
- 1:13:55action. This is an important one because this is here's what the first step
- 1:13:58is if any of this is going to happen. In the event it becomes
- 1:14:00clear that an institution is likely to be subjected to disciplinary action, the Commissioner
- 1:14:04shall notify that institution or individual at the earliest reasonable opportunity. Under no circumstances
- 1:14:11shall the Commissioner comment publicly regarding either an investigation or disciplinary action without having first
- 1:14:15provided notice to any involved institution or individual. That's an important one because that
- 1:14:23tells you, you know, if you hear the Big Ten is actively investigating,
- 1:14:26or Tony Petiti starts talking about it, that means, you know,
- 1:14:29if Tony Petiti is talking about it, that means they have sent it to
- 1:14:32the cent to Michigan in notice of you know that they're investigating that. That
- 1:14:38is, you know, likely the first that you know, the next big
- 1:14:41step if something is going to happen, and we're still saying if something is
- 1:14:45going to happen, would be the Big Ten notifies Michigan that there's going to
- 1:14:47be an investigation. If they do that, that's you know, that's step
- 1:14:51one. Then the ball is rolling. And then you know, there's a
- 1:14:56lot of at the discretion of the Commissioner in that in terms of violations,
- 1:15:00in terms of timetables, you know that he has to give them a reasonable
- 1:15:03amount of time. Well, what's a reasonable amount of time? Well,
- 1:15:05it sounds like that's up to the commissioner. I do think it's interesting that
- 1:15:12he can't talk about it once. Once this is late, once this is
- 1:15:15given to Michigan, he can release a statement or do whatever. And you're
- 1:15:19not gonna hide, not going to totally hide under the fact that can't talk
- 1:15:25about an ongoing investigation. Now, it may just be there's an investigation ongoing,
- 1:15:29or there have been some notice sense of Michigan. I can't talk about
- 1:15:31it beyond that. But once, if this happens, there will be conversation
- 1:15:36about it. So that is interesting to me. Boy, there are a
- 1:15:42lot of Michigan fans in the chat. I'm assuming they're also hitting the thumbs
- 1:15:45up. Yeah, I'm sure. I think we'll get to the end of
- 1:15:48this and it'll be like, oh, you have like eight thousand reactions,
- 1:15:51but four thousand of our thumbs down. I think that we probably made our
- 1:15:57way to one of their boards or something. I think that just makes it
- 1:16:00more important for Ohio State fans and penn State fans and Michigan State fans and
- 1:16:04whoever is in here. Truth and justice, Yes, all right, So
- 1:16:12let's move on ten point three point three standard disciplinary action. Standard disciplinary actions
- 1:16:19shall include admonishment, reprimand finds that do not exceed ten thousand dollars, and
- 1:16:24suspension from no more than two contests. Any combination of the preceding actions shall
- 1:16:28be considered to be a singular standard disciplinary action. Decisions by the Commissioner to
- 1:16:30impose a standard disciplinary action shall be final and are not subject to approval.
- 1:16:35So that means that subject to appeal. Sorry, So that means that if
- 1:16:40Tony Patiti looks at the situation right now and says and looks at all the
- 1:16:44available evidence, and Michigan has responded, and he looks at that and says,
- 1:16:47Okay, something bad happened here. I would like to suspend any you
- 1:16:53know, whoever he wants to, Jim Harbaugh, one of the coordinators,
- 1:16:56whatever, he can suspend them from no more than two contests two games,
- 1:17:00without anyone else approving, without any say so from anyone else, without any
- 1:17:04you know, having new go to a higher level, and Michigan cannot appeal
- 1:17:08that they are is a standard discipline reaction shall be final, not subject to
- 1:17:14appeal. That's you know, that's you know, pretty pretty black and white.
- 1:17:17They're not a lot of gray area there. Let's hit that super chet
- 1:17:20real quick. I'm assuming it is fish Nurse. I want a Connor Stallion's
- 1:17:26action figure. I do too, with you know, with removable glasses.
- 1:17:31You can sit there and hit a button and his Michigan gear turns into Central
- 1:17:35Michigan Gear. And uh, actually it doesn't say anything on the placard with
- 1:17:41the card because we don't know what name he's going by at any given time.
- 1:17:45But you can also scan the QR code to get the full Michigan manifesto,
- 1:17:49which is just an added bonus. Now you do have to purchase the
- 1:17:53action figure. You can't just get it from the back of the package.
- 1:17:55You're gonna have to purchase it, open it up, which also is this
- 1:17:59the next figure you want to open up or you want to keep it in
- 1:18:00the box. That's the tricky part. You want my suggestion by two,
- 1:18:04play with one, collect the other, put it on the shelf. And
- 1:18:08I heard there were going to be three different ones because each one he was
- 1:18:11going to have a different set of signs. So you want to make sure
- 1:18:14that you get the right ones. And then you also got to get the
- 1:18:16one where he's got the costume from Hath from Empire. I think that is
- 1:18:20a notable one as well, so somebody out there collectibles. He also has
- 1:18:27the one where it has like the little rockets that come out of his back,
- 1:18:30but those are a choking hazard, so you don't want to you don't
- 1:18:31want to open that one. Well, a lot of Michigan action figures are
- 1:18:35choking hazards. Oh t gek oh. All right, let's hit the next
- 1:18:45couple of super chats. Kevin David Greenshield says, give me the first few
- 1:18:49questions you would ask the stallion where would you get those fantastic sunglasses? Hmmm
- 1:18:58mm hmm. Well, I mean, I mean it's the question like if
- 1:19:02you're a truthfully gonna get truthful answers, you're you're gonna want to know who
- 1:19:09did anybody tell you to do this? Who did you tell? Because I
- 1:19:12completely imagine this starting out his plan. Now, yeah, who would know?
- 1:19:17I see this being his Like he's a very eager dude. I think
- 1:19:23we can admit that being a volunteer coming from California to Michigan for games or
- 1:19:29whatever. Whenever he was doing it at camps or whatever. Eager dude loved,
- 1:19:32loved the university, loved the football program. So I can see him
- 1:19:36going above and beyond to come up with this plan and then saying, you
- 1:19:43know, I would believe that. I do believe that that. I don't
- 1:19:45believe that he was brought in to do this. I believe he was doing
- 1:19:47this and then got in because of it. Then, but then in terms
- 1:19:51of who did you tell about this? How much did people know what you
- 1:19:55were doing, how you were getting it, and that sort of thing,
- 1:19:57I think that's really what we want to know. That's really what the gist
- 1:20:00of how deep it went, who was all? Who is all going to
- 1:20:03be punished for this? And that answers the rogue staffer, which again,
- 1:20:11you can be a rogue staffer, but then when you're next to the coaches
- 1:20:15during games and they're giving you such trust and all of that, and hey,
- 1:20:20it's just sign stealing, But what do the coaches know about how those
- 1:20:25signs were stolen and the lanks that went that were taken to get that stuff?
- 1:20:30That information? Just you know, who else knew about this entire thing?
- 1:20:33And that's that's that'd be my question. If I knew I was going
- 1:20:36to get a a true answer. All right, all right, Corey Heart,
- 1:20:43let's punch up the next super Jet. Mike Ferguson says, because the
- 1:20:45next show feature everyone wearing sunglasses at night, I mean, I don't have
- 1:20:49any around here. It's also eleven twenty in the morning and it's sunny outside,
- 1:20:54so it doesn't work. I can't read anything because I now have my
- 1:20:57glasses off. But yeah, well I saw Mike Ferguson, uh super chat
- 1:21:01there, and I was happy to oblige with a pair of Beater sunglasses that,
- 1:21:05for some reason, was sitting on my computer desk. All right,
- 1:21:10Next up, Daniel says, you have to exchange your team's signs for purchase.
- 1:21:15I mean, we really have an idea here, t Gek about these
- 1:21:19action figures. I mean, we're gonna have to cut the person who suggested
- 1:21:23it in on the deal. But I'm going to go get a three D
- 1:21:27printer and we're gonna start working on this one right now. I mean,
- 1:21:30Portanoy can have his shirts or whatever where he misspells cologne, we can have
- 1:21:33the action figures. Ninja rob Sharing, Hail to the Victors, Valiant,
- 1:21:42Hail Go Blue, Thank you for the superchat Rob. I've always appreciate that,
- 1:21:46Kurt says, I'm minister to sports. Today Zach is dropping something else
- 1:21:49new and big. I have a feeling I know what that is. We
- 1:21:53have different editorial standards here. There's big, big news that has been hidden
- 1:21:57all the tea Blue Wolverine says, go Blue. I think we're caught up
- 1:22:06one more thing, and I think it's the one that is the most important.
- 1:22:10Ten point three point three point two. Ye, your disciplinary action.
- 1:22:15Hit that ten point three point three point two air horn. It's time to
- 1:22:18talk about major disciplinary action, disciplinary actions exceeding those listed in Agreement ten point
- 1:22:24three point three point one above. That was the minor thing that Tony Petiti
- 1:22:28can do on his own. And you remember we talked about that a couple
- 1:22:30of minutes ago. Must receive prior approval by the Joint Group Executive Committee k
- 1:22:34In any case for which prior approval is sought, the JAK shall be provided
- 1:22:39in writing the involved institutions or individual's position as described in Agreement ten point three
- 1:22:43point one above. The JAX may only approve, deny, or lessen the
- 1:22:46proposed penalty. It shall not increase the proposed penalty. Further, the JAK
- 1:22:50may not lessen the penalty to a level lower than that for which its approval
- 1:22:55is required, so they could not say, like, actually, no,
- 1:22:57this is just a one game suspension. Would have to at least get you
- 1:23:00allowed Tony Petiti to do what he could do by himself. Review an action
- 1:23:05by JAAK shall occur as expeditiously as possible, and its decisions shall be final
- 1:23:11and are not subject to appeal. That is an important line. We will
- 1:23:15read that line to you again in a minute, because there's been a lot
- 1:23:17of discussion about what Michigan's recourse could be if the Big ten died something it
- 1:23:24didn't agree with. Ten point three point three point two point one interim action
- 1:23:28Prior to receiving approval, The Commissioner may impose as interim action any lesser disciplinary
- 1:23:32action, i e. Any disciplinary action for which prior approval would not be
- 1:23:35required, which shall be in effect until the JAYAK has had the opportunity to
- 1:23:39review and act upon any proposed major disciplinary actions. So that just means that
- 1:23:47that just means that Tony Petiti could put in a two game suspension for someone,
- 1:23:53multiple someone's whatever, and while they sort out is there something bigger coming
- 1:23:59down a line, So that's that's a possibility as well. Just to read
- 1:24:03that last sentence of that first paragraph for you one more time, because this
- 1:24:08is an important one. Review and action by JAX shall occur as expeditiously as
- 1:24:13possible. It's to happen fast, and its decisions shall be final and are
- 1:24:16not subject to appeal. So that means, uh, Michigan has signed a
- 1:24:21sportsmanship policy, which means they can't appeal the decision. So you know,
- 1:24:26I was under the impression that they might try and follow file some sort of
- 1:24:30legal action. They might still try to file some sort of legal action.
- 1:24:34That is you know, sometimes the legal terminology is real dense and it's like,
- 1:24:40well what does that mean? What is you know? You can you
- 1:24:43can do this real talmutic parsing of like what does this mean? Like shall
- 1:24:47not be appealed? It cannot be appealed? Like that's real straightforward, that
- 1:24:50is extremely straightforward. You signed a thing that says this is the deal and
- 1:24:56so whatever the conference says can't be appealed. Like that's real, real straightforward.
- 1:25:02Yeah, real quick, before we get into the super chat, Joe
- 1:25:06saying in the chat that Chris k eats drive fruit loops for breakfast. Look,
- 1:25:12let's we can have our fun and stuff, but please don't insult a
- 1:25:15Michigan man by saying he does not have milk with his breakfast. Okay,
- 1:25:18let's not go to these links. We're trying to stay friendly in this.
- 1:25:21We've had to ban a couple of people. We don't want to ban any
- 1:25:25more people, So please easy up on the milk stuff. Will Zerk says
- 1:25:30this just in Michigan blames OSU for the hiring of OSU spy Connor sign whisperer
- 1:25:34Stallion. I mean, listen, if this is all like a false flag
- 1:25:41operation, I mean well done. That is that is like a wheels within
- 1:25:45wheels, eight dimensional chess kind of thing. I suspect that's not what's going
- 1:25:50to be the ultimately end up being the explanation here. But you know,
- 1:25:54listen, if you if you play the game that well, that's uh,
- 1:25:58you gotta you gotta kind of take your hat. Have we noticed that there's
- 1:26:01no longer the conversation about the crime itself. It's not about the signs stealing,
- 1:26:08it's not about any of that. It's oh, Ryan Day turned them
- 1:26:14in oh, Ryan Day's brother turned them in. Oh, you guys are
- 1:26:16soft. I mean, there's there's no disputing the Connor stallions. There's no
- 1:26:23disputing you know. Let's let's let me find it here in the images the
- 1:26:28picture. Let me got to drop the super chat off here really quick.
- 1:26:32There's no there's there's not a lot of disputing any of these other things.
- 1:26:35It's all now about trying to go and attack the messenger or whatever. So
- 1:26:41it's it's it's kind of amazing how we have have progressed here at this point,
- 1:26:46and everybody trying to talk about the fact that they're not getting a fair
- 1:26:53shake, and nobody talking about the fact that, oh gee, they've kind
- 1:26:57of been caught red handed. At this point, the what was a super
- 1:27:03chat up there after? Real quick hard comments started, Yeah, yeah,
- 1:27:10we'd read it, but yeah, just to get back to Will's er super
- 1:27:12chat, thanks super chat. I do think if this all is proven to
- 1:27:16be true, that Ohio State is to blame for all of this. It's
- 1:27:20the the Jim Harbaugh saying they're going to beat Ohio State or die trying,
- 1:27:25like losing to Ohio State. If the cheating started in twenty twenty one.
- 1:27:30I mean, the math, the timeline all fit. So I do think
- 1:27:35ultimately this is all Ohio State's fault it, you know, I think it's
- 1:27:43interesting that the beat Ohio State or die trying might be might become beat Ohio
- 1:27:49State and or die trying like that that might not be an either or situation
- 1:27:55depending on how all of this shakes out. And again, let's let's repeat
- 1:27:59all of the things that we've said before. Remains to see what can be
- 1:28:02proven, because Tony Petiti is not going to like just take well, this
- 1:28:06guy on Twitter said, like there's actually a you know, you have to
- 1:28:10consider the actual evidence. What can be what has been presented to him,
- 1:28:14what has been proven, has more than has been presented publicly been presented to
- 1:28:19him, or has less than what has been presented publicly been presented to him?
- 1:28:23Both of those are possibilities. And what you know of the stuff that
- 1:28:28you has been sort of rumored but not reported yet, what can you prove
- 1:28:31of that, if anything? Because there's you know there, I think everyone
- 1:28:35has sort of been waiting for another shoe to drop, a potentially significant shoe
- 1:28:42and it hasn't happened yet. And does that mean that there is insufficient proof
- 1:28:45to prove it or does that mean that it just hasn't been you know that
- 1:28:48it hasn't been brought out yet, but it might get brought out, you
- 1:28:53know, if Tony Paiti doesn't act on it. We don't know. This
- 1:28:56is all speculation at this point. We have, you know, a lot
- 1:28:59of information now about what Tony Pettiti can and can't do, how he's making
- 1:29:01the decision, Who makes the decision if it's a more serious punishment, What
- 1:29:04can the Michigan do if there is a significant punishment levied? We have a
- 1:29:09lot more information about that. We don't have a lot of information about Tony
- 1:29:13Pettiti himself. We know, like like I said earlier, we know he's
- 1:29:16a TV guy, so he's you know, is he going to risk damaging
- 1:29:19the Ohouse date at Michigan broadcast or you know, devaluing the Big Ten Championship
- 1:29:24game? Or is he the former MLB executive who helped nuke the Houston Astros
- 1:29:29for their sign stealing thing? He is both of those people. You know
- 1:29:32that this is the there are two wolves inside of you, and you know
- 1:29:35which of those wolves is going to win. There's so many things We don't
- 1:29:40know that, you know. I'm sure the comments right now are going by
- 1:29:45like a you know, like a speed run. But I'm sure people are
- 1:29:49asking what do we think the punishment's going to be. And I will be
- 1:29:53the first to raise my hand and say, I don't know. Will there
- 1:29:56be a punishment? I don't know it. Will it be a serious I
- 1:30:00don't know. They could do nothing. They could force Michigan to vacate games
- 1:30:06or suspend you know, Jim Harbaugh and the coordinators, or they could ban
- 1:30:11them from the Big Ten championship game. About the only thing that I could
- 1:30:15would be like shocked, shocked if they did would be like say, Okay,
- 1:30:19you don't get to play any more games this year. Like that doesn't
- 1:30:23seem real likely. They're not going to take the Ohio State Michigan game,
- 1:30:26the Michigan Penn State game off the calendar. That doesn't that that's not gonna
- 1:30:30happen. There's a lot of there's a lot of leeway in terms of the
- 1:30:34conference rules that we just read, the sportsmanship policy that we just read.
- 1:30:39In terms of what he can do, there are not really any guardrails there.
- 1:30:43He could do just about anything. He wants to and because Tony Pekti
- 1:30:46is new to the job, we don't have this like track record of him
- 1:30:50that oh man, you know you hear about judges being like hanging judges,
- 1:30:55like, oh, this is on crime, yeah, tough on crime.
- 1:30:58Like we don't have any kind text on this because this is a new guy
- 1:31:00who hasn't had to deal with this. Welcome to the show, kid.
- 1:31:04Hope you enjoy your hope you enjoy your new office next to the highway in
- 1:31:08uh in Rosemont and all the fogo to show you can eat. I got
- 1:31:12a couple of super chats and the comment that's not a super chat that I
- 1:31:15want to put up after But Mike ferguson Michigan fans eat their cereal with Brondo,
- 1:31:20Is that like fago, that's from It's from the videocracy. Yeah,
- 1:31:27it's got it's got the what the whatever the plants need? Yeah it is
- 1:31:32Yeah, it's our mediocracy. Yes. Uh. Blue Wolverine says, allegations
- 1:31:36only at this point, I mean yeah, I mean we've we've sort of
- 1:31:41addressed that what is provable, what is not? I mean it is you're
- 1:31:44getting to the point where there's a little more proof than there was a week
- 1:31:49ago, and there's a lot more proof than there was two weeks ago,
- 1:31:51and it all feels like it's trending a certain way. But you know,
- 1:31:56we have been We have on every single show that we've done, talked about
- 1:31:59like you gotta be patient, you gotta let stuff play out. You don't
- 1:32:01want to get out ahead of things. We're trying to make sure we're doing
- 1:32:04that here. But I mean, it feels like the likelihood that, like
- 1:32:10none of this happened and no rules were broken, that feels pretty like that
- 1:32:15likelihood feels pretty low to me right now. You can also have a bunch
- 1:32:18of denials and the allegations become proof because of the overwhelming evidence even if nobody
- 1:32:26admits to anything. And again, they don't really have the court of law
- 1:32:30aspect the ponderance or the you know, it's not an illegal thing that they
- 1:32:34need to come to. They just have to come to something that follows their
- 1:32:38bylaws that they've already set up. So whatever they feel like doing, they
- 1:32:43can pretty much do. Mike Schaffer with the great walkall reference here, you
- 1:32:48cheated, you lose, good day, sir. Also the dead Sham Beckler's
- 1:32:55avatar is tremendous. I know, I know Mike Schaeffer is moving up my
- 1:32:59hot eleven of of Buckeye Huddle YouTube channel posters right there, super chat will
- 1:33:03zerk Tony Pettitti is Ryan Day's That would be big. Now, I can't
- 1:33:10confirm that. I'm Kevin. If you guys can, yeah, I don't
- 1:33:14know how. I don't know how much he's talked about Nil, so I'm
- 1:33:15not sure if that's true or not. I do wonder how how many degrees
- 1:33:20of separation will it take for somebody to draw a conclusion. Has Tony PETTITTI
- 1:33:27ever been to New Hampshire? I think that's something we need to know.
- 1:33:30I graduate to see his New Hampshire. So I'm in on it. We're
- 1:33:35talking people only, it's not okay. Can we see Tony Pettitti's Google timeline
- 1:33:43or Apple timeline of his travel or the the pushpins and all of the states
- 1:33:46that he's been to, because I'm interested what has happened? Was was he
- 1:33:50in ever in New Hampshire? Was in Massachusetts when Ryan Day was at Boston
- 1:33:55College? Was he in the San Francisco area when Ryan Day was with the
- 1:33:59four nine Ers? Was he near Philadelphia or New Jersey when Ryan Day was
- 1:34:03with the Philadelphia Eagles. Has he been in Ohio at any point since twenty
- 1:34:09seventeen, because if he has, you don't even have to be related at
- 1:34:13that point. Something there is hinky. The TV did go to Harvard Law.
- 1:34:17That's in Massachusetts, that is which is New Hampshire adjacent. And you
- 1:34:23don't go there just to go there. You go there for a reason,
- 1:34:25and that reason is to build a conspiracy that will eventually take down the University
- 1:34:31of Michigan football program. Boy, I think we've put it all together,
- 1:34:36so hopefully more thumbs up from the Michigan fans. I can feel him coming
- 1:34:43in already. Dave k says, you m fan super fan illegally spies ohsu
- 1:34:48super Fan were stupid cowboy hat and cape? So are we? Are we
- 1:34:54asking Tony Petiti to take action on two different matters here? I don't,
- 1:34:57I mean, but the action is not Well, that's a debate. I'm
- 1:35:03not I'm not a judge. I'm not here to I'm not the least commissioner,
- 1:35:08Tony. That's not my call to make what a sophie's choice that would
- 1:35:11be. You know what it's kind of both in half. That would be
- 1:35:15a Solomon's choice, not a Sophie's choice. But Dave k says, you
- 1:35:20think Day was the loudest voice on the call? Do we want to let's
- 1:35:25let's read just for people who may be joining us late, just the first
- 1:35:29couple of paragraphs of this Pete Damil story, just to put some contact to
- 1:35:31what we're talking about. A vast majority of Big Ten coaches expressed their frustrations
- 1:35:35with the ongoing sign stealing investigation in at Michigan in a video call with Commissioner
- 1:35:40Tony Petiti on Wednesday, sources told ESPN. The call, which took ninety
- 1:35:44minutes, included nearly an hour without Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh, who hung up
- 1:35:46after the regularly scheduled Big Ten business to allow the conference's coaches to speak freely
- 1:35:49about the NCAA's investigation into Michigan. According to five sources familiar with the call,
- 1:35:55a chorus of voices encourage Petiti to take action against Michigan in a call
- 1:35:59that was described as both intense and emotional. I don't I don't know whose
- 1:36:06voice is louder. I don't think anybody's voice needs to be loudest because you're
- 1:36:11just having a conversation. You're not shouting over each other, You're taking time,
- 1:36:15you're going one at a time, and you're giving your thoughts. I
- 1:36:18don't know that anybody needs to get loud, But what you do is you
- 1:36:21convey how this how having signals already in hand and knowing what is going to
- 1:36:29happen impacts your team, what it has cost your program, what it has
- 1:36:32cost your players, the opportunities that has cost them, draft positions that it
- 1:36:36may have cost them, grief that has cost them from social media, stuff
- 1:36:42like that. And it's not just the Ohio State side saying things like or
- 1:36:45that that would be having those kinds of conversations. So it's just conveying that.
- 1:36:49I think you don't necessarily need to get angry. You just you're happy
- 1:36:53that you actually have a commissioner who is listening to you. And that is
- 1:36:57a change, I think for Big ten coaches of late. So you talk
- 1:37:01to him, you tell them what has got your feelings, your thoughts,
- 1:37:03and yes, some of it's going to get emotional, because I mean,
- 1:37:09these are tense dudes. But you know when I'd be shocked if Friday was
- 1:37:13the loudest. Oh not at all, although Tom Allen has a very loud
- 1:37:16speaking voice, but he wants you to love each other, So that doesn't
- 1:37:21sound like the tone of the call overall. PG Fleck was probably clapping a
- 1:37:27lot or whatever. You know. There was one thing that I think there's
- 1:37:34been a lot of conversation about, like this doesn't give you a big advantage,
- 1:37:36Like this is this is not a big deal. Here's why coaches are
- 1:37:43talking about this as a big deal, and you know this is the big
- 1:37:45ten call. This is also the report in the Athletic on Wednesday. All
- 1:37:50these days are blending together. The report and the Athletic on Wednesday that they
- 1:37:55surveyed fifty college football coaches nationally, and I think it was two rated this
- 1:38:00as a one or or two in terms of severity on a one to five
- 1:38:02scale. Like virtually everyone said like this is at least medium severity, and
- 1:38:08the vast majority said four or five out of five in terms of severity of
- 1:38:11the scale. So those are head coached, you know, those are coaches
- 1:38:14college football coaches who have some sense of how college football works. I wanted
- 1:38:18to go back and look at trying to put just an objective measure on what
- 1:38:23kind of an advantage this might have provided, and it seemed like the two
- 1:38:28games, based on the scouting that has come out this year, in terms
- 1:38:31of like who Michigan was spending a lot of time looking at, it was
- 1:38:34mostly the prime the better teams on the schedule. So I don't think there's
- 1:38:39been any indication that Michigan like sought out to scout a Bowling Green game,
- 1:38:43because they really weren't that worried about Bowling Green. So I went back to
- 1:38:45the last year's game. Last year's games as scouted on end go blog,
- 1:38:50which is a you know, probably the biggest Michigan site, they do a
- 1:38:54segment after every game, well most games where they do. It's called a
- 1:39:00pawn Further Review, and they go through and scout play by play and they'll
- 1:39:02rate players and say, this guy did this well, this guy did this
- 1:39:05poorly, this you know, here's why this works, Here's why this didn't.
- 1:39:09And they have a segment on there at the bottom called RPS, which
- 1:39:12is Rock Paper scissors, and that's basically, hey, your play call was
- 1:39:16so good that it blew up the other team's play call or the other team
- 1:39:20made a play call that was so good that you had no chance of stopping
- 1:39:23it. So, you know, on average, you would expect these to
- 1:39:26be about even. You know, would come out about even, unless your
- 1:39:30coaching staff is so much smarter than the other coaching staff and the other coaching
- 1:39:32staff is so stupid that you know. So that's that's sort of the explanation
- 1:39:36for this over the years. The Penn State game last year, Michigan had
- 1:39:43twenty one plus plays and three minus plays. They were plus eighteen in rock
- 1:39:47paper Scissors in the twenty twenty two Michigan Penn State game. This was after
- 1:39:54Connor Stallions was on the staff, before any of this had come out publicly,
- 1:39:58So plus eighteen you would expect, you know, this is essentially on
- 1:40:00average, you would expect to be flipping a coin and having it come out
- 1:40:03about even, right, So plus eighteen is significant. The Ohio State game,
- 1:40:10they were plus plus twenty four minus twelve, so they were plus twelve.
- 1:40:14The notes on that one was property of the Baltimore Ravens NFL Club LLC.
- 1:40:18That would be the Michigan defensive coordinator Jesse Minter being off the Baltimore Ravens
- 1:40:24tree from John Harball. So Michigan came out a total of plus thirty ahead
- 1:40:30on Penn State and Ohio State last year, as judged by a Michigan blogger
- 1:40:34at the time before any of this had come out. So this is as
- 1:40:38objective a measure as you could possibly you know, you can't say, oh,
- 1:40:42you're skewing the numbers like these are the numbers from a Michigan guy.
- 1:40:45You would assume assume that this would help you more on the defensive side of
- 1:40:49baaldon the offensive side of the ball, because defense is a little more reactive
- 1:40:51than offense. Offense, you're gonna run Whi're gonna run defense, You're reacting
- 1:40:56to what the offense is doing. So that you know, you would expect
- 1:41:00that to be the side of the ball. And they did have a pretty
- 1:41:02significant advantage against both Penn State and Ohio State in those measures last year.
- 1:41:10Super cheating. Yeah, So say a ton of petiting does nothing, and
- 1:41:14once the investigation clues everything turns out to be true, would the coaches and
- 1:41:16ads ever forgive Patiti? No? That's that is interesting because coaches can't hold
- 1:41:24grudges against commissioners, and that goes with any conference that you'll find. But
- 1:41:30I think one thing that Petiti can do is do nothing and let this play
- 1:41:33out. And then it's like, well, Nancy has handed down their punishment
- 1:41:38and we agree with it. And look, yeah they may have Michigan may
- 1:41:42have won the Big Ten championship in twenty twenty three and gone to the playoffs,
- 1:41:45but NANCAA has removed that. So all things are fixed, and you
- 1:41:47know, now my hands are clean of it, and everything is fine,
- 1:41:51and it won't be fine for the opposing coaches. But you know, that's
- 1:41:58so often coaches administered raiders will just rightly wrongly let the process play out.
- 1:42:05And it's not not wrongly letting the process play out, but they will hide
- 1:42:10behind it. They will wait for it. Like I say, wrongly in
- 1:42:13hiding behind it is when the player is in trouble with the law and the
- 1:42:15coaches are like, we're gonna let the process play out, knowing that they've
- 1:42:19got a guy that did something wrong, and it's like, yeah, but
- 1:42:21we've got a big game, so or just gonna let the process play out
- 1:42:26and then suspend them against Eastern Michigan something like that. That's that's the waiting
- 1:42:30for the process. That is like that's the wink and the nod of college
- 1:42:34sports. This is a little a lot different than that. So the weight
- 1:42:39the immensity of the gigantic, enormous cheating scandal going on right now. You
- 1:42:45can understand taking your time and getting all of the information right, but there's
- 1:42:47so much information that if you've got a certain amount of information that reaches a
- 1:42:54point like if you're filling a cup with the allegations and the information, how
- 1:42:59much of that cup do you need to be full before you're like, well,
- 1:43:01we need to act. The Big Ten needs to act. You don't
- 1:43:03need the entire cup full. If you've got a twenty four ounce cup or
- 1:43:08a twenty four ounce mug, is it eight ounces? You know? Is
- 1:43:10it twelve? Where does that cup need to be for you to be like,
- 1:43:12geez, this cup is no longer half empty. It's half full.
- 1:43:16Well, And that that's the great question because we don't have enough context about
- 1:43:20Tony Pettiti in his current role as the Big Ten commissioner to really be able
- 1:43:25to judge how he's going to view this. I mean, again, we
- 1:43:28have his time at MLB and the astro sign stealing investigation, and it came
- 1:43:32down pretty hard on that. But that was not you know that that was
- 1:43:35something that came out after the season, So it wasn't that they you know,
- 1:43:40he didn't vacate a season or anything. Astro still have that what MLB
- 1:43:44Commissioner Rob Manford so eloquently called a hunk of metal. Great job, Rob,
- 1:43:47you're so good at your job. He'll be gotten. Dodger fan Kevin
- 1:43:51has logged on it's there's there's so much we still don't know because to repeat
- 1:44:00something we said earlier, we don't know exactly what evidence has been presented because
- 1:44:04not everything that has been a lot of these articles have been you know,
- 1:44:09presented as we were told sources, what kind of evidences you're to back all
- 1:44:14this stuff up? You get the sense that there's it's not nothing like national
- 1:44:16outlets are not running stories, you know, coming down against one of the
- 1:44:20bigger brands in the sport based on nothing. There's something there. The question
- 1:44:25is like, what is there? What can you prove? House you know
- 1:44:29what, how severe are the violations attached to what can be proven? What
- 1:44:32does Tony Petiti want to do about it? He has the leeway and the
- 1:44:36big ten on the whole has the ability to do something about it, but
- 1:44:41depending on what is presented to them, they may or may not decide to
- 1:44:44do it. And we don't have the track record from Tony Pettitti. We
- 1:44:46certainly don't have the track record from Jay Gak. We don't even know who's
- 1:44:49on the Jay Gak Committee right now to even be able to say like,
- 1:44:54oh, well, that guy's a hangin judge that you know this is it's
- 1:44:58Ohio State and Penn State and Michigan State and they're on the committee, and
- 1:45:00oh boy, are they gonna We have no idea who's on this committee right
- 1:45:03now, So all of that is kind of a question. And you know,
- 1:45:09all of the timing on all this stuff is like within a reasonable amount
- 1:45:12of time should you know, need to be done expeditiously so quickly, but
- 1:45:15not you know, not like hey it has to be done within seventy two
- 1:45:17hours or three weeks or six months. That it's all just kind of like,
- 1:45:23well, you know, use your best judgment. So there's just there's
- 1:45:27so much on here that we just don't know yet in terms of like what
- 1:45:32are you expecting. I don't know. I'm expecting to probably be doing another
- 1:45:35live show at some point whenever whatever else blows up. What about if it's
- 1:45:41an eye for an eye type of thing, and Ohio State everybody gets Michigan's
- 1:45:45calls for the next two years, two plus years. Then we'll see if
- 1:45:50actually having the calls is any kind of advantage, and then everybody would be
- 1:45:54happy with that. I think at least thirteen of the fourteen Big Ten coaches
- 1:45:57would be okay with that. It isn't that all you need. Mike Ferguson
- 1:46:02with the super Cat Connord gets the seats behind the pillars in the shoe prior
- 1:46:05to twenty twenty one. I did see somebody put his picture in the seats
- 1:46:14of twenty twenty when it was just all cardboard cutouts. So he was representing
- 1:46:17in twenty twenty as well, when no fans were allowed in Ohio Stadium or
- 1:46:20any of the stadiums. So that was great to see. Rick Guess says,
- 1:46:25again, why illegally steal signs if it offers no advantage. I've yet
- 1:46:27to see a Michigan fan answer this question. And you look at the you
- 1:46:31know that thing in the athletic that we just talked about with the survey of
- 1:46:33the fifty coaches and you look at the rock papercisors thing I just read you
- 1:46:39from MgO blog, like this self evidently is a significant advantage. And it's
- 1:46:44self evidently a significant advantage because you're doing all this work, you're breaking these
- 1:46:47rules to get that advantage. If there wasn't an advantage to be gleaned there,
- 1:46:54then you wouldn't do it. I mean the idea that people steal signs
- 1:46:59during games, like, Yeah, there's a reason you steal signs during games.
- 1:47:00It's because you then can act on those later, and that's an advantage.
- 1:47:05But generally it takes a while to gain that advantage. So you could,
- 1:47:09you know, you could fall behind by two touchdowns, three touchdowns by
- 1:47:13the time you figure out what the other team signs are, and then it
- 1:47:15might be too late. So if you have the stuff in advance, then
- 1:47:17you don't necessarily you know, you have a much better chance to figure stuff
- 1:47:21out right off the top of the game and not have to, you know,
- 1:47:25not have to spend the whole first half or whatever decoding things. And
- 1:47:28just to answer the next reply that I'm sure we'll be popping up in the
- 1:47:30comments, it's not that easy to change your signs immediately. There's a lot
- 1:47:35of stuff that goes into it. You have a lot of players, You're
- 1:47:38spending a lot of practice time to change signs during the week. That's why
- 1:47:41you can change signs between the end of the regular season, the conference championship
- 1:47:45games, and the bowl games because you have a whole month. Then you
- 1:47:48have a lot more time. You're not trying to cram this all into seven
- 1:47:50days. And TCU did And how did that game go? I mean,
- 1:47:58Michigan Michigan was I think we all expected how Michigan was playing at the end
- 1:48:00of the regular season in the Big Ten championship game. I think we all
- 1:48:04expected Michigan to just steamroll at TCU because you could tell TCU was a deeply
- 1:48:09flawed team. And you saw that ten days later against Georgia and they didn't.
- 1:48:13It was like, that's weird. And you go back and listen to
- 1:48:15shows and we are like trying to figure out, like, what the heck
- 1:48:19is going on that why can Michigan beat Ohio State? But then they lose
- 1:48:24their bowl game every year what one and seven in bowl games or something like
- 1:48:28that. It's like and we were assuming it was well, teams are adjusting
- 1:48:31to what Michigan does and you have more time to prep and he doesn't change
- 1:48:33things as much between the regular season and the bowl games. And now it's
- 1:48:36like, well, maybe there's a different explanation. Well, and you said
- 1:48:44seven days. You only get so many hours with the team, and every
- 1:48:46and every minute you are changing your signs is a minute that you're not doing
- 1:48:50your normal routine. So there is something to be said about that. So
- 1:48:56to the person who said, well the NCTWOA said that, it's only you
- 1:49:00know, a minimal advantage, First of all, how do you quantify minimal?
- 1:49:03What is your definition of minimal? But the truth of the matter is
- 1:49:06is that every minute that you are going into efforts to change your signs is
- 1:49:12a minute you're not preparing for your next opponent. So minimal to me would
- 1:49:16mean a lot more than minimal. But you know what, I'm what what
- 1:49:20am I? What do I know? I mean the NC two A and
- 1:49:24it's glacial pace. I'm sure will figure this out by twenty twenty seven and
- 1:49:28will give Grand Valley State the death penalty over it, because that's generally the
- 1:49:33way the NC two A works. I did have a Michigan fin just tell
- 1:49:38me last week that you can. It's easy to change signs. Just send
- 1:49:42the paperwork, just send the signs home with the players and they can work
- 1:49:44on it overnight. And it's like, yeah, you're totally correct. I
- 1:49:47never thought about it like that. You can just take the new signals home,
- 1:49:50learn them at home before you go to bed, and then maybe get
- 1:49:55up early and learn them again and just continue to get them into your mind
- 1:49:59terribly. So there are so many hours in a day, Connors, Well,
- 1:50:04that's that's let's talk about that with j tell. Bigger question is does
- 1:50:09Michigan have laminators on the sideline after they steal the signs? And this is
- 1:50:13something we talked about a week or so ago once Tom's photos came out and
- 1:50:17the entire world saw them. Thank you Tom for putting those on the internet
- 1:50:21for everybody to see. But that was my question. So, if this,
- 1:50:25if this isn't, if this is in game sign stealing, which,
- 1:50:30as Michigan fans tell us, is legal, we know, how does that
- 1:50:34get there? How does this image the signals? How do how do they
- 1:50:40get the diagram there? Where did those come from? Is there a laminator
- 1:50:45on the sideline? Is is the information being gotten in the first quarter,
- 1:50:47and then it's being drawn up on the sideline by Connor with the his his
- 1:50:53notebook or whatever, and then you get the piece of paper and you take
- 1:50:56it over to the laminator and then by this maybe by halftime they have this.
- 1:50:59Now, well, that actually isn't true because this was a photo early
- 1:51:02on in the game, I believe, So maybe in warmups is he getting
- 1:51:05this? No, because they don't do warm ups. They don't do signals
- 1:51:08and warm ups, so obviously they would have had gotten these earlier in the
- 1:51:13season at some point on site. And you can't get it all from ALL
- 1:51:16twenty two, then you can't get them all from TV. You can get
- 1:51:18some stuff from TV. Two angles. I mean, that's only a couple.
- 1:51:24We were told that by somebody in one of our chats. Yeah,
- 1:51:27I want to correct that that the all twenty two does not mean all twenty
- 1:51:30two angles. There are not twenty two angles that they show. The all
- 1:51:32twenty two is all twenty two players and the cameras focused on the field,
- 1:51:36not on the coaches, not on the sidelines, anything like that. So
- 1:51:41you can piece this stuff together, but you can't piece it all together.
- 1:51:44And if you don't have the entire picture, then you don't know for a
- 1:51:47fact that you've got the right picture. Now, what Michigan's counter Statutes has
- 1:51:50done is they've gone to the lengths to get the entire picture and present it
- 1:51:55and prepare their team for it. And to know this signal means this,
- 1:52:00and so I set the defense for this. It's an incredible advantage. And
- 1:52:04yeah, all teams should be changing changing their signals. You're not changing everything.
- 1:52:12You can't change everything every week. You do what you can when you
- 1:52:15know that somebody has gotten wind of things. But you can only change so
- 1:52:18much. And when somebody is so familiar with what you do, they'll eventually
- 1:52:23catch on can catch on to some changes as well, and they'll know who
- 1:52:26the live guy is and things like that. So the fact that you have
- 1:52:30to put it on and it's complete victim blaming in terms of in terms of
- 1:52:33this stuff. And I don't want to get too far down that rabbit hole,
- 1:52:38but it's like, well, you shouldn't make it so easy to deal.
- 1:52:40You shouldn't have left your car unlocked. That's basically what this is.
- 1:52:44Yeah, And I just want to hit a couple points on the picture from
- 1:52:46earlier. The two things. Number One, that was from the first drive
- 1:52:49of the game, because that was a picture of Marvin Harrison making a catch
- 1:52:53that I think was not rule to catch on the sidelines, but the first
- 1:52:56first drive of the game, so that was not something that was like,
- 1:52:59hey, after halftime came out and I had this. Number Two, we
- 1:53:01don't know for an absolute fact that those are Ohio State signs or related to
- 1:53:06Ohio State signs. Mark Givler from Buckeye hudd All reported he had been told
- 1:53:10that, you know, the Ohio State coaches believe them to be their signs,
- 1:53:14that we don't know. You know, that has not been established as
- 1:53:15an absolute fact. But the just kind of two things that are worth sort
- 1:53:20of mentioning just in terms of like one of them is, you know,
- 1:53:26if it is Ohio State signs, then boy, it would be real weird
- 1:53:29to see that on the first drive of the game. There are people on
- 1:53:31here on the chat always, you know, talking about you know, hey,
- 1:53:36they could have gotten those off of TV. I mean, yeah,
- 1:53:38they could have. But if you were getting all this great stuff off of
- 1:53:42TV and off of all twenty two, you wouldn't need to go to the
- 1:53:45games, and you'd be able to do that that would all be legal.
- 1:53:48If that was all coming legally, then sure, but you have what thirty
- 1:53:54five games and with people where you're sending people and you're have people, you
- 1:54:00know, with cameras out and all that kind of stuff. Like, if
- 1:54:03you could get all that stuff off of TV, you wouldn't need to have
- 1:54:08done the stuff that was illegal. So that sort of seems fairly self evident
- 1:54:14in terms of what you know, how much you can get off TV,
- 1:54:15and if there's an added benefit gained by doing this stuff that was done illegally.
- 1:54:19Dee Thompson says, question, why can't we just go to headsets?
- 1:54:23I mean, we have already heard that no matter what happens, this will
- 1:54:25bring change. That should this will bring change, it should have been place
- 1:54:28already. Agree, disagree. I assume we're headed there very soon. In
- 1:54:33the college game. I mean, they make changes every off season. I
- 1:54:36would guess that you're going to go to like the NFL style thing, because
- 1:54:41you know that was always sort of a cost thing that was you know,
- 1:54:44it was like, well that costs too much money or whatever. It feels
- 1:54:46like that's we're probably headed there, and the question is more like when rather
- 1:54:53than if. Well, I think the conversation with that one is a lot
- 1:54:58of coaches. Some of the coaches I don't want it like to they are
- 1:55:02scigence dealers, so this would take away an advantage. So that's why some
- 1:55:05people are against it. But yeah, I mean high schools do it.
- 1:55:10The NFL obviously does it. There's plenty of money to do it. Now
- 1:55:14the bigger conferences may have to throw some funding to the smaller conferences, or
- 1:55:17if it's just the Power five there they are on their own budgetary scale.
- 1:55:23So I wouldn't be surprised if they'll do it regardless, no matter what the
- 1:55:28rest of FBS is doing, they'll just go ahead and do it. I
- 1:55:30would expect that to happen within the next year. But again, the option
- 1:55:34to do it, and if you don't, if you can't, if you
- 1:55:36don't want to do it, you don't, then that's on you. And
- 1:55:40keep putting your little signs out there with Mickey Mouse and a transformer and a
- 1:55:44cheeseburger and a booger out there or whatever your signs have on there. I
- 1:55:48mean, I mean, we got to go to the green dot system.
- 1:55:50We have to that's where it has to go well, and when you when
- 1:55:56you have the helmet signals and the communication if one is down and then both
- 1:56:01teams have to be down. But if one chooses not to use it,
- 1:56:03then I guess you know that's on you. Who's excited to listen to the
- 1:56:09Ryan Day Radio show in four minutes. We will not be doing it here
- 1:56:12on this chat, but we probably do need to be wrapping up. Just
- 1:56:15reminding Tony what time it is here? Is that is coming up here in
- 1:56:20less than four minutes. Yeah, I'm gonna have to jump off and check
- 1:56:25that out, see if there's any new updates on Mecca Abuka, Lathan Ransom,
- 1:56:30Devin Brown situation, all of that good stuff. So definitely, gosh,
- 1:56:34it's a shame to be leaving at this point with so much more to
- 1:56:39talk about. But I have a feeling we'll be doing another one here probably
- 1:56:43pretty soon. Yeah, so I think it's coming out in day two.
- 1:56:47Stay tuned for conference dates for the Big Ten that will be dropping at four
- 1:56:55pm. We will certainly have a story over at Buckeye Huddle and we'll see
- 1:56:58kind of what comes out of that. Yeah, everybody gets to find out
- 1:57:02when they're going working, and how they're gonna get there by train. Mostly
- 1:57:06so, I want to thank you all for tuning in and tuning in.
- 1:57:09Lastly, if you want to go ahead and hit that thumbs up one more
- 1:57:11time, we would appreciate it. If you're not yet subscribed, please do
- 1:57:14so. Thank you for tuning in. Please find us at Buckeye Huddle dot
- 1:57:16com. Michigan fans or High State fans. Everybody's welcome, Georgia fans,
- 1:57:20Tennessee fans please no South Carolina fans anyway. That will do it for today.
- 1:57:25I want to thank you all tuning in and we will talk to you guys later