Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Identifying Far-Right Fashion" with Bellingcat Researchers
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled Identifying
- 0:07Far -Right Fashion. This week we were joined
- 0:10by my colleagues Michael Colburn and Juri van
- 0:12der Waard. We discussed the meanings behind some
- 0:15far -right symbols, why merchandise is such an
- 0:17attractive element to far -right groups, big
- 0:20and small, and how investigating these financial
- 0:22structures can give you an insight into their
- 0:25secretive internal structures. You can find links
- 0:28to all the resources mentioned in the talk in
- 0:30the podcast description. This talk was hosted
- 0:32by me, Charlotte Mar, on Thursday the 23rd of
- 0:35October 2025 in the BellyCat Discord server.
- 0:50Hello and welcome to this week's Stage Talk.
- 0:53Today we're diving into the fashion of fascists.
- 0:56Exploring why creating the latest garb with their
- 0:59messaging or symbol on it is important to far
- 1:02-right groups. Well, you've got to look fabulous
- 1:04while spreading hate, right? Speaking to this
- 1:08is Bellingcat researchers Michael Coburn and
- 1:10Eurovan Devide. Michael is known around these
- 1:13parts as somewhat of a far -right guru. He's
- 1:15spent years mapping out transnational networks
- 1:18and building research into these extremist organisational
- 1:21structures, identifying those driving the movements
- 1:24forwards. Yuri has worked on a wide variety of
- 1:28topics, but his focus on human rights abuses
- 1:30in Africa have led him into the world of groups
- 1:32like Wagner and Rusevich, Russian paramilitary
- 1:35groups associated with far -right ideologies.
- 1:38In his latest article, he identified the man
- 1:40helping to sell Rusevich merchandise from key
- 1:43chains to sticker packs that depict Alexei Miltryakov,
- 1:47an infamous Russian neo -Nazi, and a figure Bellingcat
- 1:50revealed last year may have committed a war crime.
- 1:53Michael and Yuri will unpack why merch is important
- 1:55to these groups and how you can identify a far
- 1:58right tee versus an ordinary logo. As we talk,
- 2:01please make sure to add your questions in the
- 2:03chat box via the message bubble icon in the top
- 2:05right corner of your screen. And as I just mentioned,
- 2:08this is being audio recorded. So please note
- 2:11within your question, if you do not want me to
- 2:13read your username out. Okay, Michael, it's your
- 2:17time to shine. I will shut up. And I believe
- 2:20we're starting with you. Thanks, Charlie. Yes,
- 2:23thanks Charlie and thanks everyone for taking
- 2:25the time to to come to this I have ten minutes
- 2:29I could talk for much Much longer than that,
- 2:33but I will be disciplined and keep myself to
- 2:36ten minutes talking about this so Far -right
- 2:40fashion those words. Well, first of all far -right
- 2:44fashion. It is a thing What I'll mostly be talking
- 2:49the brief presentation are is this phenomenon
- 2:53of specific brands that are worn by far -right
- 2:59and neo -Nazis, but also a bit of symbolism that
- 3:02they use, but also some of the more mainstream
- 3:03brands that they co -opt. It's more of a European
- 3:07phenomenon than it is in the United States or
- 3:12in the so -called English -speaking world that's
- 3:14starting to change. So just wanted to say that
- 3:16for a bit of context before diving in. The why
- 3:19of far -right fashion, I've mentioned it exists,
- 3:22but why does it exist? Well, the number one reason
- 3:26to mention, but maybe actually not the most important
- 3:30reason, is money. Selling clothes, selling merch,
- 3:36selling anything can be a source of revenue for
- 3:41the far -right. That being said, however, a lot
- 3:44of the kinds of brands that I look into and I
- 3:48research, they are even some of the ones that
- 3:51I may not mention by name in a few minutes, but
- 3:53you'll see some pictures of these are small brands
- 3:56are not going to be bringing in a lot of money.
- 3:59These are brands that are bringing in usually
- 4:02tens of thousands of dollars or euros, particularly,
- 4:06or anything like that. They might be bringing
- 4:09in maybe a few thousand, maybe not even that,
- 4:13but they see it as part of It's not it wouldn't
- 4:16be the only revenue stream odds are if you're
- 4:19running or if you're running one of these far
- 4:23-right fashion brands There are you have other
- 4:26revenue streams like hosting events concerts
- 4:29things like that and also For example getting
- 4:34your own members to give you money to for for
- 4:37your propaganda Thinking of a specific group
- 4:40in the United States with that one and also another
- 4:42reason related to money why far -right fashion
- 4:46is a thing or why, I guess, entrepreneurs want
- 4:49to be far -right entrepreneurs get into starting
- 4:53up a fashion brand. Well, it's a bit of status
- 4:55on the far -right. It can give them a bit more
- 4:57profile within a movement, make people within
- 5:00a movement see, oh, such -and -such is doing
- 5:02good things for quote -unquote us. He's making
- 5:05cool stuff. It's usually going to be a he, I'll
- 5:07mention that. And it gives them a bit of status
- 5:10as well. However, I would argue the more important
- 5:15reason, essentially the more central reason as
- 5:21to the why of far -right fashion is that it's
- 5:23about identity. Particularly in the times that
- 5:26we live in, fashion is... more than ever a fundamental
- 5:32component of identity building, consolidating
- 5:36identities, both as an individual and in a group.
- 5:39And that's certainly the case across the board.
- 5:42We're not just talking about the far right here.
- 5:45What I would argue is more important for the
- 5:48far right, the kinds of folks who are behind
- 5:51some of these brands, it is one, yes, money,
- 5:54but it is really more about trying to build a
- 5:57culture. It's about trying to not to build an
- 6:00identity that is, that keeps, keeps the old garden
- 6:04or keeps people excited or group identity. It's
- 6:08also something that they deliberately do to try
- 6:11to, well, bring the youth in. And especially
- 6:13given that fashion for youth is even an even
- 6:18greater part of identity formation. This is why
- 6:22they do it. It's a strategy. And this is a quote
- 6:26from somebody who's affiliated with a far right
- 6:30fashion brand. This is an exact quote from theirs
- 6:33about the strategy behind fashion, quite literally
- 6:37being something to look good, to attract more
- 6:40of the youth. They are that transparent about
- 6:44it. Moving on quickly, more about the why. One
- 6:49of the reasons why, to answer that question,
- 6:52why. Not just why, but the... Answering the question
- 6:57of how the far -right not just uses fashion,
- 7:01but what it communicates with using fashion.
- 7:06They do so in several key ways. They do this
- 7:09thing called, we would call it game playing.
- 7:12Plausible deniability is another way to think
- 7:14about it. Basically having a shirt with symbols
- 7:20on it and a slogan. That is, maybe it doesn't
- 7:22have to look that extreme, but maybe only a few
- 7:26of us nerds recognize the hateful ideology behind
- 7:31the symbol or what's even being alluded to or
- 7:34referenced in the symbol. They try to claim some,
- 7:38basically play games and play this plausible
- 7:41deniability game. It's like, oh, well, it's just
- 7:43an ancient Slavic sun symbol. It's nothing more
- 7:46than that. And they do that so that... for lack
- 7:50of a better way to put it, to take a bit of the
- 7:52heat off themselves and to sort of, you know,
- 7:56get more, relatively more into the mainstream.
- 7:59That relates to this phenomenon of double speak,
- 8:01which refers to in studying the far right where
- 8:04there is a front stage, how the far right presents
- 8:07itself to a much more public audience and the
- 8:10backstage and with the game playing, these kinds
- 8:14of people can stand on the front stage and say,
- 8:16oh, there's nothing extreme about this symbol
- 8:18or this slogan. But in the backstage, the proverbial
- 8:22backstage with all their bodies, they all use
- 8:25and relate and under relate to and understand
- 8:28that symbol. Or that said, those sets of symbols
- 8:32references the same way. And also it functions
- 8:35as a sort of secret handshake. Now you might
- 8:38not know what the specific brand is that might
- 8:41be on a shirt, maybe without even a symbol on
- 8:44it. You might not know what some of those symbols
- 8:47being referenced are. But the other guys, they
- 8:51do. It's a matter of, same with a lot of subcultures.
- 8:55It's a way of recognizing who is, quote unquote,
- 8:58one of us, who's friend and who's foe. And that's
- 9:02something that further helps build and then solidify
- 9:06identity. And to quote one of the academic articles,
- 9:09which I think has been or will be, I'm giving
- 9:13everybody a reading list. It's not very long.
- 9:16This is a quote from one of the articles. The
- 9:18whole approach of far -right fashion is inculcating
- 9:21this deliberately produced style of confusion
- 9:23where, for example, people spend two days on
- 9:28blue sky in the internet trying to figure out
- 9:30whether somebody's tattoo is a Nazi symbol or
- 9:33not, or whether they knew it was a symbol or
- 9:35not, or et cetera, et cetera. If you don't know
- 9:37what I'm referring to, you're in luck. Related
- 9:42to this, another key component of far -right
- 9:44fashion is basically being Nazis without quote
- 9:48unquote, looking like Nazis. I think a lot of
- 9:50us in our countries and our societies, no matter
- 9:54how old or young we are, because of movies, because
- 9:56of popular culture, we often have an image of
- 9:59what somebody on the far right or what a neo
- 10:02-Nazi looks like. We all think they might look
- 10:04like the character in American history acts,
- 10:09skinhead with Doc Martens and white laces and
- 10:12the kinds of people do still exist. But most
- 10:14of the contemporary far -right extremists, they
- 10:18play a more clever game than that. They always
- 10:21deliberately try to be a bit more subtle than
- 10:24that within boundaries. Sometimes they're more
- 10:26subtle, sometimes they're not. And as you'll
- 10:29see, they use some lesser known symbols as well,
- 10:32symbols people won't know. Just checking for
- 10:34time here. All right. I'm just going to have
- 10:37all these up on the screen here. So I won't go
- 10:41into detail on all of these right now, but Essentially,
- 10:44there are larger Far -right fashion brands. I'm
- 10:47only going to name some of these larger ones.
- 10:49Some of them, maybe you've heard of Thor Steiner
- 10:51is one of them. European Brotherhood is another.
- 10:54However, there are smaller, more local or national
- 10:57brands that exist only in some countries or in
- 11:02some parts of Europe, particularly, or some regions.
- 11:06But there are also, there's also long been of
- 11:11the far right co -opting mainstream brands like
- 11:13Fred Perry. I don't know if you can see the polo
- 11:17shirt that I'm wearing. There's a reason why
- 11:19I'm deliberately wearing it today. There are
- 11:21some mainstream brands that have often been associated
- 11:24with football casual subcultures or other subcultures
- 11:28for decades that the far right has co -opted.
- 11:32Some of them they've co -opted for a long time.
- 11:34But the key thing to keep in mind with these
- 11:36co -opted brands is that they're often associated
- 11:39with other subcultures or no subcultures at all.
- 11:42Like for example, not to get into too much detail,
- 11:45but those, like the brands that I have up there,
- 11:48Fred Perry, Lyle and Scott and New Balance, those
- 11:53are the same kind, a lot of the same kinds of
- 11:55brands that left -wing or anti -fascist communities
- 11:59wear as well in some countries. But sometimes
- 12:02they are wearing the same brands, maybe not always
- 12:04the same colors, but the same brands. And within
- 12:08the sort of corpus of far -right brands, there
- 12:10are some that are maybe less explicit or barely
- 12:13or not at all, where sometimes it might even
- 12:16be hard to use the terminology far -right to
- 12:18describe them. However, sometimes there are varying
- 12:21degrees of subtlety or lack of subtlety even
- 12:24within a particular brand's product range. And
- 12:28then there are some brands that are much, much
- 12:30more overt and much less subtle. And lastly,
- 12:34this is probably not surprising given that we
- 12:37are talking about the far right. The vast majority
- 12:39of this clothing is for men. There are far right
- 12:43brands who produce clothes for women. They are
- 12:46just awful. I won't editorialize too much to
- 12:50be on that. And this is my last slide. I'm just
- 12:53going to slide over here, no pun intended. Turn
- 12:56on my laser pointer with a few minutes without
- 12:58going over too much. If you're watching this
- 13:03live, you can see what's on the screen. I'll
- 13:07just try to quickly verbally explain some of
- 13:10these. Up here on the top left is a shirt from
- 13:13European Brotherhood, their brand, their initials
- 13:16in a sort of sun cross or almost Celtic cross
- 13:19type symbol. This might look pretty subtle, but
- 13:22the coordinates that are on the shirt are the
- 13:28coordinates for Vellelsberg Castle in Germany.
- 13:30which was a castle that the SS took over in which
- 13:34Heinrich Himmler intended to turn into a sort
- 13:36of cult -like headquarters. Very obvious what
- 13:40they're going for there. These pair of shorts
- 13:42below is from a far -right fashion brand that's
- 13:45affiliated with the active club movement. Roman
- 13:48numerals for the 14 words and neo -Nazi slogan,
- 13:51which I'm not repeating, and also stylized fasces
- 13:55up on the... center here, this sort of patch
- 14:00from a France -based far -right or neo -Nazi
- 14:04fashion brand. That style of patch is meant to
- 14:06emulate Waffen -SS imagery, and it also uses
- 14:09black, white, and red colors of the old German
- 14:13Empire flag, colors that were also used by the
- 14:16Nazis. There are historical nuances I don't have
- 14:18the time to get into here. And below, a lot of
- 14:22what you'll see with the far -right is even co
- 14:25-opting logos of other brands here. just riffing
- 14:28off the North face logo with a shirt that says
- 14:32the white race. Up here, a Canadian brand with
- 14:37what are called, again, not to get into too much,
- 14:39there's more subtlety than this, but what are
- 14:42called life and death runes that were runic symbols
- 14:45that were co -opted by the SS. This hoodie, this
- 14:49gray hoodie, it is something sold by a Serbian
- 14:53brand. And without getting into detail, it is
- 14:55referring to an anti -Bosnia or chant that is
- 14:59essentially a genocide triumphalist slogan. It's
- 15:03three words, but they've only printed the first
- 15:05two on the shirt because everybody knows seeing
- 15:08those two words in the Serbian or Balkan context
- 15:11what the next one is. This is a Thor Steiner
- 15:15shirt. Again, game playing here. A big white
- 15:18polar bearer with a slogan. It's okay to be white
- 15:21again. Ha ha. I've seen this with a great white
- 15:24shark, I think from the same brand and then Moving
- 15:26on more quickly, there's another Thor Steiner
- 15:28belt down here with runes. Runes were very much
- 15:32co -opted by the Nazis, and they're very much
- 15:35used in non -Far -right contexts as well. And
- 15:38lastly, to help lead into what Yuri is going
- 15:41to be talking about, these two brands here are
- 15:44related to stuff Yuri has written about. Up here
- 15:47is a shirt from the Hatecore brand, Fake Cross.
- 15:49And even though it is a Russian brand, it says
- 15:52Light and Proud in English. Not very subtle.
- 15:55And then this shirt here is a shirt sold by people
- 16:00affiliated with the neo -Nazi Rusich military
- 16:04unit fighting on the Russian side in Ukraine.
- 16:09It's got a kolovrat, which is another pagan symbol
- 16:11that sometimes, I don't think that often, is
- 16:14used by non -far -right or non -neo -Nazi people.
- 16:18But with these guys, it's very clear that this
- 16:21is the context that they're using it. a nice
- 16:23Odo rune, another co -opted rune of Volknut,
- 16:27another co -opted symbol that is also used in
- 16:30more mainstream context. And then in Russian,
- 16:34what it says here is, we sow death, we reap victory.
- 16:40So pretty clear what's going on here. So that
- 16:42is the end of my comments. And so I will stop
- 16:46sharing my screen. Stop sharing. Oh, thank you,
- 16:50Michael, for your insights. Um, so I'll do an
- 16:54introduction explaining, uh, one of the investigations
- 16:57that I did. Uh, it was the previous one, the
- 17:00previous investigation, uh, we did a few months
- 17:03ago. Um, and maybe after I'm done, uh, talking
- 17:06about this, I'll have some time to talk about
- 17:09the more recent article. Um, but anyway, um,
- 17:13so I will talk about the man named, uh, Raman
- 17:15Morin. I'm sorry. I'm, I'm a little bit sick.
- 17:18So if my... My voice sounds a little bit strange,
- 17:23that's why. So, Roman Morin, he, we found out,
- 17:28is the administrator of a pro -Wagner telegram
- 17:30channel called White Uncles in Africa. And he
- 17:35also sells neo -Nazi merch under the brand Hatecore,
- 17:39Hatecore with an 8. That's one of the shirts
- 17:43that Michael showed belonged to that brand. How
- 17:49did this start? I already knew of them before,
- 17:52but I started investigating them in the summer
- 17:56of 2024. It was sometime after July 25th, because
- 18:03back then a big ambush happened in Mali, where
- 18:07many Wagner mercenaries and Malian soldiers died.
- 18:12That was a really, really big event. The ambush
- 18:16was carried out by Tuareg forces and in collaboration
- 18:20with Janim, a jihadist organization. So many
- 18:25Russians died there and there were some or many
- 18:29pro -Wagner telegram channels that had the latest
- 18:32updates on what happened, but one really stood
- 18:35out and that was the White Uncles in Africa group.
- 18:39So that incident led to me taking a closer look
- 18:45at them, at the group. And I quickly noticed
- 18:49that they were rapidly growing and that they
- 18:53started selling t -shirts and merch as well.
- 18:56Some had clear neo -Nazi motifs. So it was from
- 19:03that same brand, Hatecore. They created a t -shirt
- 19:09that was specifically for this group with texts
- 19:12such as white uncles in Africa, in both English
- 19:18and Russian. So more importantly, right? They
- 19:22started sharing or they would also share lots
- 19:26of gory and graphic content and even more so
- 19:30than other channels. And that was another thing
- 19:33that sparked my interest in them. Um, cause they
- 19:37were really glorifying whatever Wagner was doing
- 19:41in Mali. And, uh, yeah, they also would share
- 19:45instructions on how to join Wagner, right? Which
- 19:48nowadays, um, kind of is disappearing at least
- 19:52in Mali, um, and becoming something else right
- 19:56under the Russian government. Right. Okay. Um,
- 20:01so yeah, it was clear that... They were sharing
- 20:04lots of footage that degrades their enemies.
- 20:07For example, decapitated corpses of presumably
- 20:13their enemies and insinuating that some of their
- 20:19Mayan partners had practiced even such things
- 20:23as cannibalism on their enemies. the Malian armed
- 20:30forces, but people from volunteer groups. Yeah.
- 20:37So why do I talk about that? Well, all of that
- 20:42was shared kind of jokingly by these people,
- 20:45right? By white uncles in Africa. And it seemed
- 20:48to me that it was partly intended to attract
- 20:51men to join their cause or at least become supporters.
- 20:54And when I spoke to Maureen, he personally confirmed
- 20:59to me that he joined Wagner after he had seen
- 21:02a video of torture, killing, burning and decapitation
- 21:07of a Syrian deserter by Wagner fighters in Syria
- 21:12many years ago. So he said that he is in favor
- 21:16of justice and that's what attracted him to Wagner.
- 21:21So, yeah, sharing that kind of footage may also
- 21:25constitute the war crime of outrages upon personal
- 21:31dignity, according to some experts I spoke to.
- 21:35And there is also an article by the AP that said
- 21:39that the ICC was investigating such cases and
- 21:43also cases of disseminating this type of material.
- 21:47And in particular, they mentioned this group
- 21:51white uncles in Africa in their article. But
- 21:54the rest of the presentation, I will focus a
- 21:58bit more on hatecore because through that brand,
- 22:02I was able to establish who Moirin was. And it's
- 22:07also an interesting way to see how they operate
- 22:10and how this, let's say, propaganda works. So
- 22:15I started this investigation with the goal of
- 22:18finding out who was behind white uncles in Africa,
- 22:21right? But really what helped me crack this case
- 22:24was that the person behind white uncles in Africa,
- 22:29Raman Morin, was also selling neo -Nazi merch
- 22:32from his brand, Hatecore. So actually when I
- 22:35came across Hatecore, I first knocked on the
- 22:38door of Michael to ask his opinion on it, but
- 22:40it was pretty obvious even to me. that it was
- 22:43a neo -Nazi brand because of some of the shirts
- 22:47that they were selling, the motifs on them, like
- 22:50the Black Sun or the Kolovrat, things like that.
- 22:56So Hatecore is a grassroots project that Morin
- 22:59started more than a decade ago for fun, according
- 23:02to what he said himself. Because when I spoke
- 23:05to him during the write -up reply phase... He
- 23:07said that for him, it wasn't really about the
- 23:10money, but you know, it was some kind of hobby.
- 23:14He liked to do it and his customers and friends
- 23:17also liked it. So there was a lot of information
- 23:20out there from that decade long history of the
- 23:24brand. Some of it he had tried to hide, but a
- 23:28lot of it was still out there and kind of hidden
- 23:31in plain sight. White uncles in Africa... kind
- 23:35of pretended that the founder of hatecore and
- 23:38the admin of white uncles were two different
- 23:40people, right? Or they kind of insinuated that,
- 23:44but they also dropped some breadcrumbs every
- 23:47now and then, and that allowed us to connect
- 23:52the dots, right? So they would share... promotional
- 23:57images of their t -shirts and say things like,
- 24:00the owner of Hatecore is a good friend and a
- 24:03former Wagner fighter. Oftentimes the person
- 24:07in these promotional images was the same guy.
- 24:10So I was able to tell that because of his build,
- 24:14right? And most importantly, the tattoos. In
- 24:19some pictures, they would blur the tattoos, right?
- 24:22But you could still analyze it because of where
- 24:25the tattoos were located on the body, like on
- 24:28the same arm, forearm, hand, right? In most recent
- 24:33images, he had blurred his tattoos and he was
- 24:36generally speaking more secretive. But I found
- 24:42other social media where Hatecore was promoting
- 24:45their products and they were... or are active
- 24:49on Telegram, but most importantly on VK and YouTube.
- 24:54VK is kind of the Russian Facebook. So the latter
- 24:58two social media platforms were very important
- 25:01for me because they contained history that went
- 25:04back years and years. In the case of YouTube,
- 25:09almost like 10 years. VK was still active when
- 25:13I started. investigating it it is still active
- 25:17today but they removed lots of pictures but back
- 25:21then the history would go back really years and
- 25:23years all the way back to i think 2016 the youtube
- 25:27channel had died down but it was still online
- 25:30right so they hadn't uploaded anything new since
- 25:342016 but at least they didn't remove the old
- 25:38videos So that was important for me because I
- 25:42was able to find old pictures of the man I later
- 25:47learned to be Ramon Morin. The pictures there,
- 25:55they weren't censored. So you could clearly see
- 25:58some of the dews that he had back then, and you
- 26:01could clearly see his face. Morin had also left
- 26:05his personal email address. Uh, in the YouTube
- 26:09contact details and true that I found his real
- 26:12name because he had also used it to register
- 26:15as an individual entrepreneur at the Russian
- 26:18tax offices, right? So if you want to sell stuff,
- 26:21um, and pay taxes, then you need to register
- 26:25and he used that same, uh, email address. Now
- 26:30I tried to confirm that Maureen was the person
- 26:33I was seeing in old pictures and videos, right?
- 26:37So that took me a while because Morin in newer
- 26:40stuff would also use aliases, nicknames, but
- 26:46most commonly he would go by Andrei Maskov. So
- 26:50I had to confirm that his different personas
- 26:53were really him. I had to connect that also to
- 26:57him, like his physical appearance, his face.
- 27:00I was finally able to confirm that Morin was
- 27:04Moscow's, the admin of hatecore and not just
- 27:07an associate by finding his parents' social media
- 27:10profiles, where they were using their real names
- 27:14and they would also tag Morin. So I was able
- 27:17to confirm that. And then at that point, I wanted
- 27:21to connect him to white uncles in Africa, right?
- 27:25So I already had the hunch that the admin of
- 27:30or one of the admins of white uncles in Africa
- 27:32and Maureen, that they were the same people,
- 27:39the same person. But yeah, I had to prove that
- 27:43somehow. Luckily Maureen slipped up a couple
- 27:47of times. So on the white uncles page, they would
- 27:51share an image of a man with someone called Alexei
- 27:58Molchakov. Charlie spoke about Alexei Molchakov.
- 28:02He is the current commander of the neo -Nazi
- 28:06paramilitary group Rusich. So you might know
- 28:11Molchakov because he is quite infamous and the
- 28:15group is infamous as well. And both he and the
- 28:18group are under international, mostly Western
- 28:23sanctions for stuff they did. not only in Ukraine,
- 28:28but they were also in Syria, in the Central African
- 28:32Republic and Libya, and there they were acting
- 28:37as part of Wagner. So Ruzic is very controversial,
- 28:43as I said, and one of their former commanders,
- 28:47Jan Petrovski, is currently in jail in Finland
- 28:50for war crimes committed in Ukraine in 2014.
- 28:54So in that picture, they said that the white
- 28:57uncle's admin, the guy whose face they had blurred,
- 29:00was meeting with Molchakov to donate some equipment,
- 29:04right? And around the same time, Ruzic also promoted
- 29:07hatecore and white uncles in Africa gear on their
- 29:11own channel. So they were kind of doing each
- 29:13other a favor, right? Um, all right. So, uh,
- 29:16the admin, Spoiler, Maureen, right, appeared
- 29:19in that picture with Melchikov. I had a hunch
- 29:22it was him because of some of the clothes he
- 29:24was wearing and particularly his gray blue New
- 29:28Balance sneakers that he had worn in several
- 29:31different pictures. Um, so yeah. Uh, I still
- 29:36had to prove that, but then around New Year's,
- 29:39um, they shared another image and video of the
- 29:43admin, again, Maureen. And Maureen was congratulating
- 29:48the subscribers, right? Like wishing them a Happy
- 29:51New Year. And Maureen wore a mask, shades and
- 29:55a hatecore baseball cap to hide his identity.
- 29:58Um, but yeah, in the video, they forgot to blur
- 30:02certain keyframes where you could see his tattoo
- 30:06on the back of his hand and here on the side
- 30:10of his left hand between his pinky and his wrist,
- 30:15where you could figure out what was written there.
- 30:22It was the VDV. VDV is the Russian Airborne Forces,
- 30:28like that unit or that part of the of the Russian
- 30:34military, right? And on that other hand, he had
- 30:37a hate -core tattoo. So that was really good
- 30:40for us because both tattoos matched with tattoos
- 30:43from older pictures where he didn't hide his
- 30:46face, right? And where you could see also the
- 30:49same tattoos, the hate -core tattoo and the za
- 30:53vedeve tattoo. So after finding that, we still
- 30:57had to confirm that he was a former Wagner fighter.
- 31:02So for that, We contacted Candice Rondeau and
- 31:06Ben Dalton from the New America Project Foundation,
- 31:09I should say. And they have access to a bunch
- 31:13of internal Wagner documents from, I think, 2021
- 31:19and before. And then there, they found that someone
- 31:23with the same full name and birthday appeared
- 31:27in their records. I had only given his name.
- 31:31in his date of birth, but then they provided
- 31:36me with his passport number and some other details.
- 31:39So I cross -referenced and yeah, I found out
- 31:44that that was the same guy. So at that stage,
- 31:50I had enough to contact Moiding himself to ask
- 31:53him a few questions and to lay out what we found
- 31:56about him. And that's when he admitted that he
- 32:02was indeed the hate core admin. First, he didn't
- 32:06really want to admit that he was also the admin
- 32:08of white uncles in Africa. But I explained how
- 32:13I knew it was him. And then he confirmed as well.
- 32:17And yeah, well, he confirmed almost everything.
- 32:20He confirmed he served in Libya, but he said
- 32:23that he couldn't talk about ongoing things, right?
- 32:27I suspect he might have been active in Mali as
- 32:31well, but that's one of the things he wouldn't
- 32:34tell. So he denies being a neo -Nazi, interestingly.
- 32:39So I asked about the black sun symbol he tattooed
- 32:42on his elbow, and that was heavily featured in
- 32:46some of the clothes he sells. But he said that
- 32:50was just an Asian pagan symbol. So I noticed
- 32:54that Maureen deleted some images from his Telegram
- 32:57profile, but he kind of doesn't care anymore.
- 33:01Sometimes nowadays you see posts by him where,
- 33:05for example, he is selling a certificate that
- 33:08he got with a medal from the Russian government.
- 33:13It was a medal for Odvago, which means like medal
- 33:16for courage. And the certificate had his complete
- 33:21name there. So I guess nowadays he doesn't care
- 33:25too much. But he removed a bunch of other things
- 33:28from his profile, like stuff where he was kind
- 33:32of insinuating that he was active in Mali. I
- 33:35wasn't able to confirm whether he was the one
- 33:38taking those pictures or if it was someone else.
- 33:42But yeah, so a few things remain unclear. Months
- 33:47after I published... The AP came out with the
- 33:50aforementioned article and also Jeune Afrique
- 33:54published an article about White Uncle's premium
- 33:57Telegram channel where they were selling the
- 34:00more graphic content. And after the latter came
- 34:04out, Telegram banned the premium channel. So
- 34:08I guess that's good, but the open channel is
- 34:10still active and hatecore is still active as
- 34:14well. Do you mind if I cut in here Yuri, just
- 34:17because of time and perhaps we can explore the
- 34:21second article within the questions. I actually
- 34:23have a question based on what you were just talking
- 34:25about and thank you so much for going through
- 34:28your research and Michael also beforehand going
- 34:31through some of the reasons why these merchandise
- 34:35exist and what they look like. When it comes
- 34:38to investigating groups like this, do these financial
- 34:42offerings, these merchandise structures, are
- 34:45they a good way in to discover organizational
- 34:49hierarchies and people who are potentially quite
- 34:52centrally involved in the organization? So in
- 34:55Morin's case, you kind of eventually found out
- 34:59that he was the admin for the White Uncles in
- 35:01Africa. But in the Rusich case with Romanov,
- 35:05he denies being anything other than just a salesman.
- 35:10How often is it that the person who's behind
- 35:13the merchandise sales is so entrenched within
- 35:16the organization? Is it often quite a good way
- 35:18in to these hierarchies of these secretive organizations?
- 35:23I think it's difficult to tell because I worked
- 35:26on two articles like that. Like this one in the
- 35:30Aromanov one that we published a few days ago.
- 35:35And in those two cases, it appears to be the
- 35:38case, right? But maybe Michael has more information
- 35:42about that because he has been doing this for
- 35:44longer. Right. The short answer to your question,
- 35:48Charlie, is yes. I really think that when I think
- 35:53about some of the different brands that I've
- 35:56personally spent a lot of time researching or
- 35:58investigating, or that I'm familiar with, even
- 36:00to the point of going into their shops, or just
- 36:06being familiar with smaller ones. In a lot of
- 36:09cases, finding out, and sometimes it's not at
- 36:12all hard because they literally don't hide it,
- 36:14but figuring out who's behind one of these brands
- 36:18can often really be somebody who already has
- 36:23particular status within a movement or within
- 36:27a sort of far -right cultural sphere. In other
- 36:30words, they're not usually a nobody. They usually
- 36:34have, even if not a formal affiliation. they
- 36:38will have some connections with some specific
- 36:43parts of the far right or with other groups within
- 36:47it. And so in short, yeah, if one wants to figure
- 36:52out a bit more about a particular country's scene,
- 36:58even if it's very small, if they've got one of
- 37:02these kinds of brands, look into that and it
- 37:05might be able to be a window into understanding
- 37:10a bit more about the context and the broader
- 37:13network. You mentioned how the white uncles in
- 37:17Africa, the main Telegram account could close
- 37:20down. I've been thinking about consequences.
- 37:24Very Charlie, just one small correction. The
- 37:27main Telegram channel is still up, but the premium
- 37:30one where people had to pay to view the query
- 37:34content, that one is... That one was taken down.
- 37:37I wanted to ask about the consequences of reporting
- 37:40on merchandise that's associated with far right
- 37:43groups. Has that been any cases that you're aware
- 37:47of where... you've found products online or other
- 37:51organizations have found products online reported
- 37:53about those products and those products have
- 37:55been taken off for sale. For example, I know
- 37:59a couple of years ago, we covered some merchandise
- 38:03being sold on Amazon that was then taken down.
- 38:06Is there any consequences for these kinds of
- 38:09sellers? Is there any rules or regulations that
- 38:13prevent what can be sold on t -shirts, for example,
- 38:16or on... merchandise in general. Sure. I go first
- 38:21and then you, Michael. I think you're trying
- 38:24to speak, but I cannot hear you. Go ahead. Yeah.
- 38:31So just quickly in my case, right, I reached
- 38:34out to ozone .ru, which is kind of like the Russian
- 38:38Amazon. They didn't do anything. Telegram. didn't
- 38:44do anything until Joan Afrique did the other
- 38:47article about the premium channel. I'm trying
- 38:53to think, VK, it's still there. Other social
- 38:59media, I think it was mostly also because they
- 39:02are in Russia, right? In Russia's, I think most
- 39:06platforms are kind of closing their eyes for
- 39:08this kind of stuff. even though it's like, as
- 39:12far as I understand, against their laws. In my
- 39:17case, I have seen and I'm familiar with where
- 39:21some of these brands, they still will sell their
- 39:27products on a website, but they're prevented
- 39:31from using particular payment processors. So
- 39:34kind of related quite a lot to Colina's work
- 39:38where making it difficult for them to process
- 39:41payments, even if it's from a small group of
- 39:43like -minded people, that puts a dent in the
- 39:47kinds of things that they want to do. Then there
- 39:51can be some cases where if there's media coverage
- 39:54about a particular product or set of products
- 39:58that generates a negative reaction, they sometimes
- 40:02have stopped selling it or they've been told
- 40:05you can't sell this anymore. The example I'm
- 40:08aware of is from Serbia. The example of the shirt
- 40:13that I, the hoodie that I had in my presentation,
- 40:16the one that I'm just not saying, saying the
- 40:20chant, but you know, genocide triumphalist slogan,
- 40:24two thirds of it. And even in Serbia, even for
- 40:29the Serbian stays, the whichever departments,
- 40:33Stepped in and said that violates a law you cannot
- 40:35sell a shirt and they took it down. So there
- 40:38can be short -term Maybe not always hugely damaging
- 40:43consequences for particular kinds of media coverage.
- 40:46But so when this kind of coverage adds up Yeah,
- 40:50it makes it it can put a bit of a dent in in
- 40:54in what they're trying to do Bishop says in the
- 40:57chat, I think the only rules at least in North
- 40:59America, as long as the brand is not overtly
- 41:01spreading hate speech throughout its brand is
- 41:04okay. Whether or not the community circles the
- 41:06way it spread hate, that isn't necessarily put
- 41:07upon the brand itself. So there's a guess based
- 41:10on my understanding of law in North America.
- 41:12Interesting to see if any reporting has been
- 41:14done on social media advertisements. For example,
- 41:17a lot of these brands have profiles for the brands
- 41:21as well on social media. It would be interesting
- 41:23to see if any of them have done any promotions.
- 41:25uh, and whether those are, uh, taken down by
- 41:29the likes of X or Instagram, for example, um,
- 41:33all of those, that's where often merchandise
- 41:35is advertised. Just pitching, investigating ideas.
- 41:42This is kind of related, particularly on Instagram.
- 41:45And I'm not the only person who's observed this
- 41:48over the past year or more, but a lot more, more
- 41:51of these kinds of groups operate. It's not like
- 41:56Telegram, but they can operate. In other words,
- 42:00what I'm getting at, they can post a lot more
- 42:03content that I don't remember seeing on Instagram
- 42:06before 2024, especially before 2025. There's
- 42:11a lot more far right organizing, broach selling,
- 42:17propagandizing on Instagram than I think a lot
- 42:20of people are aware of. Absolutely. And if you're
- 42:25interested in monitoring some of these things,
- 42:27we do have a space within here called hashtag
- 42:30far right monitoring where I know Michael spends
- 42:33a lot of his time. So please do check that out
- 42:35channel out. And if you have any questions, by
- 42:37the way, please get them in. We've got about
- 42:3915 minutes left. What are some organizations
- 42:44that are consistently monitoring far right activities,
- 42:48particularly far right merchandise or fashion
- 42:52or symbol use that other people within this survey
- 42:56or listening to this podcast might want to check
- 42:58out. What are the organizations that you monitor
- 43:02that you think do great reporting? For me, there's
- 43:08several. In terms of a resource, one of the probably
- 43:14the better resources right now in terms of hate
- 43:20symbols is the Right now, I always mix up their
- 43:24name. The Global Project Against Hate and Extremism,
- 43:28GPAHE, they have developed a pretty wide ranging
- 43:35database of symbols. We are actually, myself,
- 43:39are actually working on a sort of smaller glossary
- 43:42or encyclopedia of symbols, almost like a visual
- 43:46dictionary of some of the symbols that I've talked
- 43:48about, a lot of which incorporates photos that
- 43:51I've taken of graffiti and stickers and street
- 43:54art and fashion over the past decade. So eventually
- 43:58some more of our work will become reasonable.
- 44:01But in terms of a lot of the best monitoring
- 44:07of these kinds of groups, it does differ by country.
- 44:13I've worked with Expo in Sweden. Expo's first
- 44:21editor was Stieg Larsson and Expo has long done
- 44:24great work and has actually been kind of an inspiration
- 44:28for the kind of work that I've wanted to do,
- 44:30the kind of journalism that I've wanted to do.
- 44:34There are individual journalists, journalistic
- 44:40outlets who maybe focus a bit more on the far
- 44:44right from time to time. There are organizations
- 44:47that research, but they also do their own kind
- 44:49of lobbying or, you know, maybe sometimes you
- 44:54call more activism, like maybe Hope Not Hate
- 44:57in the UK is an example of that. There are also,
- 45:02of course, without getting too much into politics,
- 45:05there are, I mean, a lot of research, again,
- 45:10depending on the country, there are anti -fascist
- 45:12activists who research the far right. And sometimes,
- 45:17especially in say Germany, they produce their
- 45:18own magazines. Now, of course, if in those kinds
- 45:21of communities, uh, there's quote unquote, activist,
- 45:26a partisan element involved, but very easy to
- 45:30do as cause I spent my life doing it. And I think
- 45:33we've, a lot of us spent our lives doing it,
- 45:36reading sort of, you know, somebody's research
- 45:40on a fiery group. Maybe for them it comes from
- 45:42some partisan quote unquote act. activist perspective,
- 45:46but especially doing it using open sources and
- 45:49showing your work and being ethical about it.
- 45:52They're resources and they're sources that mainstream
- 45:55conventional journalists use. So that speaks
- 45:59to it. Yuri, do you have any that you want to
- 46:03shout out just for on this subject? No, not really.
- 46:08I think I've been focused more on just Russia.
- 46:13angle, right? And I think my interest in this
- 46:18came from somewhere else and then I kind of rolled
- 46:21into this. So I don't really have other examples
- 46:25of groups doing this on a larger scale. Yeah.
- 46:32So in short, Yuri, what you're saying is unlike
- 46:34me, you have a life outside of researching the
- 46:37FARA and good for you. That's good. Well, I'm
- 46:40I'm going to tell you one thing. I'm really tired
- 46:43of looking at these kinds of folks, right? I
- 46:46think I need a break from Bruce Hitch and Wagner
- 46:51guys, neo -Nazi Wagner guys. I really need a
- 46:55mental health break in do something else just
- 46:58for a little while. I can speak to that. I can
- 47:01understand that where for anybody who may be,
- 47:05anybody listening who maybe has an interest in
- 47:09you know, researching or monitoring or writing
- 47:12about these kinds of groups or wants to start
- 47:15doing it. One thing that I would stress to always
- 47:19keep in mind is even if at first you think you're,
- 47:24you know, you think you're going to be able to
- 47:29let like, you know, water flow off you like a
- 47:33duck's back that you can go and look at all these
- 47:35telegraph channels. constantly all the time.
- 47:39Maybe you're looking at stuff that even isn't
- 47:41explicitly violent, but maybe it's full of hateful,
- 47:45hateful, hateful rhetoric. What I've found over
- 47:48doing this kind of work for years is that when,
- 47:53when you spend time, too much time, you get sort
- 47:59of buried in their world or this world that they've
- 48:02created. You can just, you just. Yeah, even if
- 48:07it is not always explicit like if like if I opened
- 48:09on my telegram right now where I follow all from
- 48:13different accounts a lot of very not nice stuff
- 48:17Even after like nowadays even after a few minutes
- 48:21ten minutes of going through. Oh, here's what
- 48:22this group posted about recently then there's
- 48:25you just Like it's just like you feel like in
- 48:28your head you're looking or you're seeing are
- 48:31these hateful people think everybody is out to
- 48:34get them and that they you know And it can be
- 48:37hard, hard to, hard to deal with. And so it doesn't,
- 48:42this, the key thing for me, for anybody who wants
- 48:46to not have their quote unquote beat like me,
- 48:49but if they even, you know, looking at things
- 48:53on the side or maybe a specific article or investigation,
- 48:57be cognizant of the fact that you need to pace
- 49:00yourself and take mental breaks from it. Even
- 49:04when you maybe at the time don't think you need
- 49:08to, don't spend day and night, day and night,
- 49:11day and night constantly looking at this kind
- 49:14of stuff because to put it in an informal way,
- 49:16it's going to fry your brain. And it's not, you
- 49:21know, even in very small ways, it could be not
- 49:25fun looking at some of this kind of crap. If
- 49:26I can just be that blunt, looking at some of
- 49:28this kind of crap, you know, during a work day
- 49:31for me, you know, it can, it can, it can ruin
- 49:33the rest of the day because it's Even like, I'm
- 49:36not going to say that's on the level of trauma,
- 49:39but it's, it can, viewing some of this content,
- 49:43some of the language, just the hateful world
- 49:46that some of these groups and channels and whatnot
- 49:50have constructed, it can bring you down too.
- 49:54And so like I said, pace yourself with it. You
- 49:58might want to, or feel the need to take a look
- 50:01at any of that kind of stuff on a particular
- 50:03day. doesn't mean you're not doing your job or
- 50:05you're not committed to it, you just got to take
- 50:08care of yourself doing it, even if it isn't like
- 50:10the most, quote unquote, extreme kind of content
- 50:13or particularly kind of extreme visual or violent
- 50:16content. And as you said at the beginning, Michael,
- 50:19about some of the reasons behind merchandise
- 50:22being sold, it's not just a financial reason
- 50:25for these groups, but also it's a sense that
- 50:28of brotherhood of we're an army of people. or
- 50:32wearing the same kind of uniform. It might be
- 50:36a secret uniform, it might be a secret handshake,
- 50:38but it does have this, when you manage to flood
- 50:43yourself with so much content, it does have this
- 50:46ability to make you think, oh, wow, there's quite
- 50:49a lot of them. There's quite a lot of people
- 50:51within this movement that, yeah, it has its persuasive
- 50:56techniques and that can be quite gut wrenching,
- 50:59particularly if you've seen some of the more
- 51:01extreme information that they're sharing and
- 51:04thoughts and feelings that they're sharing in
- 51:06these groups. I wanted to ask about safety actually,
- 51:10if you're infiltrating some of these groups or
- 51:13if you're looking at looking down the financial
- 51:16structures of these merchandise sellers, what
- 51:20are some of the steps you can take to protect
- 51:22yourself as a researcher? I think especially
- 51:27with investigating or trying to even just find
- 51:31out information about some of these brands is
- 51:34that, you know, it can depend on the country,
- 51:36but wherever they are, sometimes they will, I
- 51:41mean, not sometimes, I think for the most part,
- 51:42they will be incorporated and depending on the
- 51:46country. That means you can very easily, you
- 51:50know, get the basic financial information, maybe
- 51:52not. So in other countries that you can find
- 51:54out. with a public registry search, you know,
- 51:59who, who the agent is behind particular like
- 52:03LLC or, you know, or, or whatever, whatever terminology
- 52:07who might be behind your brand. So one fortunate
- 52:09thing is that it, that side of things can be
- 52:15easy. Uh, on the safety side of things, what
- 52:18I can say is that this doesn't just relate to
- 52:21fashion. I found that the invest investigations
- 52:24that I've done that seem to have got some of
- 52:30these people the most upset are investigations
- 52:34where I'm reasonably certain one of the major
- 52:36impacts was human lose money. And that something
- 52:41to keep in mind for anybody who might be wanting
- 52:44to investigate the far right or other kinds of
- 52:48related actors, whether, you know, anti -vax
- 52:53type people or any anybody who kind of of that
- 52:55ilk is despite all the principles or rhetoric
- 53:00they might like the sound when if you end up
- 53:04making debts in the money that they're bringing
- 53:08in even if it's not very much they don't like
- 53:09it and that's just a safety consideration to
- 53:12keep in mind you can maybe write other articles
- 53:15that embarrass them in some way or make them
- 53:18look look silly. They won't like that either.
- 53:20But if you like, for example, when I, when I
- 53:23wrote about for belly got the, this, uh, a European
- 53:27fight night in 2023. And it was essentially because
- 53:29of my article that the venue pulled out the day
- 53:31before. And so these guys had to run around and
- 53:33find some place in the, you know, in some small
- 53:37town, an hour away from Budapest, some little
- 53:40field. And it means certain that because of that
- 53:44article and the consequences of it, that lost
- 53:48their money. And that's why at their actual event,
- 53:51I can't see what it says on the flyers, but they
- 53:54put flyers of my face, so I don't think they
- 53:57were happy. And that's something safety wise
- 54:02to keep in mind. Sorry, Yuri, did you have anything
- 54:07to add? No, not really. I think it's too... employ
- 54:14some of the same techniques that you employ on
- 54:16them yourself to see what they could potentially
- 54:20do. I think some of the far -right people aren't
- 54:26necessarily the brightest, but others, right?
- 54:29Especially if there is like a state involved,
- 54:34right? Like state -sponsored far -right groups,
- 54:38like the case of Rusage. In those cases, you
- 54:41have to be a bit... more careful, I think. So
- 54:45try to see if you can talk to yourself and try
- 54:50to take measures and get advice from people who
- 54:56know more about online safety, cybersecurity,
- 55:01but also physical security, if you're really
- 55:04worried about this. I wanted to ask one question
- 55:08from the audience just to wrap. I know we're
- 55:10on time, so I'll make it quick. Argyle's just
- 55:13asked, I've been noticing local groups here in
- 55:15the US creating their own bespoke clothing. Are
- 55:17there some more common clothing manufacturers
- 55:19these groups might be using instead of, say,
- 55:22screen printing their own? And just to add, Michael
- 55:25earlier gave us a really good reading list. I
- 55:28will be including that reading list in the description
- 55:31of this podcast so you can read up more on this
- 55:33topic yourself there. I was typing out a response
- 55:39to that, but now I don't have to type it out,
- 55:41especially in the US context, but also literally.
- 55:44I would say a lot of local dollar groups, they
- 55:47are getting relatively cheap things wholesale
- 55:52and finding some sort of friendly provider to
- 55:57do the pressing or the stitching. I wrote an
- 56:02article just over a year ago about how the brand
- 56:05affiliated with the active club movement, which
- 56:07is based in the United States. Uh, one of the
- 56:11places where they wholesale, not just wholesale
- 56:15wholesale, but where they actually get the printing
- 56:19and stitching done. So far as I can tell is in
- 56:22Bulgaria. So they were, and even in Bulgaria,
- 56:26they are probably getting those wholesale shirts
- 56:29and shorts and whatnot. They're probably getting
- 56:31even getting them even cheaper from Turkey or
- 56:34somewhere like that. Cause right on the border.
- 56:37But yeah, I think on local levels, if they're
- 56:39trying to, they're probably not taking the time
- 56:42to screen print all of these things themselves.
- 56:45I know of smaller brands like very, very small
- 56:48brands in the, in some European countries or
- 56:51cities where they, yeah, they, they've got a
- 56:56sympathetic So who runs a kind of shop or somebody
- 57:00who doesn't know what they're doing, uh, to,
- 57:03to do the, to do the work for them, like in even
- 57:07getting a graphic designer, you know, friendly
- 57:09graphic design, you're part of the quote unquote
- 57:11movement, uh, and go from there. And that's an
- 57:17investigation in itself. Um, I just wanted to
- 57:20end just by reiterating if you are going to investigate
- 57:23particularly local groups, groups that are local
- 57:26to you. Please, please be careful and take into
- 57:29consideration some of the points that we've just
- 57:31mentioned in terms of safety. Thank you, Yuri.
- 57:35Thank you, Michael, for your time today. If you
- 57:37want to continue these kinds of conversations,
- 57:39as I mentioned, hashtag far -right monitoring
- 57:42in this space is the place to be. We also have
- 57:45hashtag disinfo and propaganda as well, which
- 57:48often overlaps. In two weeks' time, we'll be
- 57:51back with another stage talk. But for now, thank
- 57:54you so much, everybody. Thank you. Bye bye. Thank
- 58:00you. Thank you for listening to the Stage Talk.
- 58:05If you'd like to catch a Stage Talk live where
- 58:08you can ask the guest questions, join the Bellingcat
- 58:11Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 58:17Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 58:20Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.