Latest / Carbon Weekly News / What 300 Carbon Buyers Want, and How CDR Gets Debt | CWN EP8
Transcript
- speaker-0: Everyone is always saying okay we have so demand constraint but are we now demand constraint or supply constraint? speaker-1: But I would say that we are still demand constrained by and large. The fact that we had 3x where we were when we last ran this, we still need to 2x that to be into the range where like CDR is gonna be at. speaker-3: We take organic waste and we put it really deep underground. Like three to five Empire State Buildings underground is really, really deep underground. Honestly, I think the punchline is track record of deliveries, right? Plus offtake. I think it's those two things. speaker-2: We're coming for ya though, I'll say. Mom back is gonna we're gonna try to see if we can beat you on the registry. speaker-0: We are live with another episode of CWN and look at Dan's amazing new setup. I'm beyond excited. He's now finally taking it seriously and he is calling from his new setup. Same place, just 180 degrees flip there. speaker-2: That's right. Same same spot, but new me, new new setup. So I'm a podcaster officially. You've you've converted me. Exactly. Back in the spotlight. I remember what it felt like back when I was on stage, but now I feel it again. speaker-0: But only one light up now. You had probably a couple more. Maybe you can add like one light every episode and at a certain point of view, it will feel like Oprah again. Amazing cool. And Bistubai for New York Climate Week. I think there's always an interesting week. I was definitely, I was done. After that week, don't know how you felt. speaker-2: It was exhausting. it always feels the same way, right? But showing up and having that number of back to back things, you always start the week off and you've got all this energy. Like, I can do anything. We can meet all over the city. you're in uptown? Yeah, I'll come to uptown. And you know, when you've traversed New York seventeen times and then somebody then again asks you to go to the other side of the town, yeah. I was I was totally exhausted by the end of the week. I only stayed for four days, but Ready to get out of there. speaker-0: So for me, the change is always Monday and Tuesday, I still take the manual bicycle. And then Wednesday ongoing, it's only going to be electric bicycles. You know, like I have all the energy still in the first days. just like, no, it doesn't matter if I go up down. just, even the one meeting I had in Dumbo, was like, over the bridge manual bike. I was just fine. And then Wednesday I was like, This is 10 minute by bicycle. I'm European. Well, it doesn't matter. Electric bicycle. So that's always my, my, I would say gauge. speaker-2: Yeah, I I started the week on the electric bikes and then realized that I wanted to I wanted to get a little bit more active. which then in the middle of the week, by the time I tried a manual bike, I was already in that declining moment. And so anyway, it was a it was the bad switch. And then I went all electric the rest of the week. So speaker-0: Yeah, but it's expensive. But let's not talk about that. Cool. But I think this episode, we have two things that I think are quite important to the market overall. And on one hand, it's more from the financial perspective. And the other one is more from getting into the heads and minds of buyers of carbon credits. And I think the first one, is around how can we get more debt financing and so on into the market. And you probably know all about financing way more than I do, but this is going to be really important to scan up the market, right? speaker-2: Absolutely. No, we've been fortunate to get debt financing first, debt like financing from the World Bank through an outcome bond. And then secondly, Brazil has pretty amazing access to debt facilities through the development bank in Brazil, BNDS. And those have been huge in helping to scale projects because the cost of capital is so much lower than what you would get from equity capital, that either through a fund or You know, venture let alone, you know, not a lot of these projects are being done with venture capital, yeah, return on capital requirements. And that's insane. unless you've got a really short delivery schedule for a carbon type, right? But even those projects are quickly trying to figure out how we can get to more working capital facilities or something like that. So I think capital is a huge constraint across the market and debt is a massive unlock. We start to look more like infrastructure projects, the more and more we can leverage debt. And I think that that will mean that the market is succeeding. So it's great to see another debt deal being done. speaker-0: Yeah, and actually two deals, right? We have the one with Inplanet and Enhanced Rockwathering also in Brazil. And then we have one with Walter Dieb, which is also super interesting. And we're really excited to have Julia from Walter Dieb on the episode later. speaker-2: Yeah, exactly. No, it's it both very different projects, but again, just seeing debt flowing to a range of different developers and project types is really exciting at this point in the market. speaker-0: And the second one is more about the other perspective. What are these alleged buyers actually buying and how are they buying? And this is around a BCG report that they are, I think also presented during New Year climate week where they actually interviewed 300 corporate carbon credit buyers on how they, for instance, look at quality, how much they pay, what's is needed to unlock more buying and purchasing and so on. So this obviously I think is the first time ever that we have this kind of 300 buyers inside. I went to my mind like I'm not sure. Maybe you know. speaker-2: I've never seen anything like that. I think the best we've gotten in the past is some intermediary who says, We just ran an RFP and sorry to tell you, but you lost. And you say, why did I lose? And they say, your credits were too expensive. And you say, Okay, can you give me a little bit of a gauge of how I did or what why that was the case? And you you get this. Little breadcrumb trail of, well, there were a few other proposals and this was the qual, and this is how they thought about pricing and quality and co-benefits. Never have I seen a report like this that is so eye-opening to understand what are buyers really looking for? What are they expecting in terms of pricing? What are their budgets? You know, people always talk about share of wallet in in the commercial world, and we just have really no idea about what budgets exist and how those stack up and As a result of that, am I doing well or horribly as a supplier in terms of the share of wallet across the market? So I think this is a really helpful report, whether you're a buyer or an investor, to to start to shed some light onto this space. speaker-0: Amazing. And I, I would say as an intermediary, I would love to give you more detail, often also we are also not getting anything, you know, it's like, sorry. you didn't win this RFP. and I was like, okay. So can you tell me why? I mean, we had a lot of meetings, a lot of put up, put a lot of time in, yeah, maybe in half a year we can give you feedback when everything is done. And then half a year later you. you asking, that's just like, yeah, was too expensive. I was like, thanks for the feedback. So it's speaker-2: Right. speaker-0: always the case, but there are, there are very different feedbacks. Sometimes it's literally no feedbacks or we can't provide feedback because too many people were part of the RFP. Sometimes it's, it's more extensive, but I wish I could give you a lot of feedback sometimes, but also can't. That's the reason these kind of reports. are amazing and very important. speaker-2: I mean, in the past, what we've seen is, you know, two interesting reports to look at, right? Microsoft has come out with these quality criteria requirements where they've said, okay, for a high quality project, this is what we're expecting to see. And they're really great at saying here's what a supplier has to do in order for us to consider an offtake. There's a part of this new report that sheds light on, okay, what does quality mean? How do people think about the different characteristics of a project? And then on the other hand, we've seen Frontier publish some interesting reports where they have actually said, We've got a price target and a total capacity that we see some of these solutions scaling to. So if you're a supplier and you think you can bring us something that has the potential to get to that kind of a price target, we're wanna we wanna talk to you. Right. And that that also is extremely helpful because it gives us a good gauge of what's our North Star. speaker-0: Like my frontier prices, in my opinion, it's just not representative because sometimes projects come to us and say like, Hey, we can offer like a frontier kind of price. I was like, yeah, sorry, but this will not fly with our customers to be honest. speaker-2: Yeah, I was thinking more their long term pricing guidance, not the deals that they're actually willing to do today. But when you look at, for example, when they raised this billion dollars recently, we should get them on the pod, by the way, to to talk about that from the new tranche of money that they raised a few months ago. But, you know, what they do in that report is they say enhanced rock weathering needs to get under two hundred dollars, even though we know they're signing deals that are in the three hundred, four hundred range, even, right? So they they give some guidance for what they think it's ultimately going to need to land at. And then they're paying a bit of the catalytic capital pricing up front to be able to try to help the projects achieve that price target. But again, it's just it's one of the only spots where we've actually heard from a buyer, here's where we want to see the pricing land for this kind of a credit. speaker-0: Yeah, and super exciting. mean, we're not done with this now because we're super delighted to have Bio from BCG who was actually an author of that report on the show and we can dig a little bit deeper into it. Bio, amazing to have you on the show. Dan already, as he mentioned before, watched your presentation during your climate week. So he's already the expert. But I just read the report before and I saw it last week already. And obviously it was super interesting to get into the heads of 300 different buyers out there. already said, is fantastic because really often you don't get any feedback on RFPs or something like that. Especially as a project developer like Dan. So that's the reason we're, I think we're happy to have you here and also go a little bit deeper into it. So no worries. Can you start a little bit with like a intro about yourself and then we take a little deeper. speaker-1: Yeah, absolutely. So thanks for the invite as well. It's really great to be here. So by Wallaby, I'm a partner at the Boston Consulting Group and based out of the London office. I work across our climate and energy practice areas and I've done climate and energy related work for the last 15 years, give or take. at BCG, I'm one of the leaders on the carbon management topic, which covers decarbonization, but also things like carbon removals, carbon markets, and so on. I've been fortunate to do a lot of cool work since I've been here. the carbon market is an extremely, I'd say, data rich place. And maybe the background for this work that we're talking about today really started like three years ago and when we did the first sort of quantitative assessment of carbon market buyers, right? And we really wanted to understand how the people very different types of attributes of a credit and what are they willing to pay for it. this time around we were like, okay, the market the market has shifted a little bit towards carbon dioxide removals. And we really want to get deep into that and see how people are thinking about it. Also given all of the noise and the the shifts that have happened in the market over the last couple of years. So Good to be sharing this with you. I'm glad you already found it useful at the sessions we've had and happy to dig into into a bit more detail on this one. speaker-2: Yeah, we're really excited to to chat with you about it. I think that, you know, obviously for a supplier, I think there's always this angst of how is the market going to view my product and what does a buyer really care about? And we were saying before you joined that, you know, there have been some hints at that if you look to reports like Microsoft's high quality criteria report where they are pretty clear as to what they need to see for a project to hit a certain level of of least minimum threshold of quality and also how they view quality beyond that minimum threshold. But in a lot of ways, I I thought that maybe starting off with like the first chart that was in your the the appendix, you know, as you guys started to look at quality, maybe you can talk a little bit about what, what, how did you frame this question of of what is quality to you? What what is inclusive of that term quality when we think about carbon dioxide removal? speaker-1: Yeah, this thanks for that question. This was one that we debated quite a bit before we landed on this kind of eight things that we we ended up testing. I think some of the elements here are fairly well known. So things like, you know, registry credibility, the quality of the GHD measurements, you know, sometimes this is all lumped together as MRV, you know, always top of mind. There was a question about things like permanence. Do you include that? I think you answer is always yes, even though it's a contested, I would say, term. in in many cases still. Then outside of those, we wanted to look at some other things that pop up quite a lot. So co-benefits, revenue sharing is quite integral to the story that is told around, for example, nature-based credits or land, land use linked credits. So those made the list. And then we wanted to touch on some of the things that we know from a buyer perspective can become important. So the overlap with your value chain, for example, is what we were trying to test with location. so do people care? are we going for, you know, the the credit the credits that meet our criteria anywhere in the world, or do we also want to overlay that overlap and how strongly do we have that desire? And then something to test the friction of playing in this market. So the procurement simplicity element of that. So those are the things we checked. Beyond the dimensions we checked, you could also say like, well, what do we call it? Because something like GHD measurement we could have called MRV as well. But we wanted to be slightly precise in the definitions so that we put the buyers in the right mindframe as they as they do this. The big one we did not explicitly test is price, which, as you would find as we go deeper into this, it's an indicator of quality, but not quite in the same kind of way that people tend to think about it. and so we tested the price question quite aggressively and quite extensively throughout the survey, but we just didn't define it explicitly as a dimension of quality because we do recognize that it's not a linear. question and it does vary a lot by credit type. speaker-2: Yeah, I I mean I'd have a bunch of questions on on this piece because I think quality for for Momback as a supplier, for example, you know, doing reforestation projects in Brazil. I would say our thinking, our hypothesis when we started was that co-benefits would be extremely important in the in the in the quality picture of these projects, right? The ability to say, hey, I'm Restoring biodiversity, I've got water benefits, I've got you know, native forest, that that's that in and of itself, the the species mix seems like it really matters. And we hear that a decent amount from buyers that, you know, you're here's how we see you versus other native species projects. I would imagine that some of this is just compressed because you're looking across so many different, you know, removals here is everything that is a removal. So maybe some of that gets lost a little bit in here. But one of the other thoughts that that we had in looking at this was does that mean that co benefits actually ought to start be being thought of as something that is not a quality metric for a carbon credit, but actually its own separate thing? I mean, what yeah, what do you think we should be taking away from from this finding? speaker-1: Yeah, a couple of framings to that. It's and this is one that's come up quite a lot. And it was one of the most surprising results for me as well. having set this up, I didn't expect it to show up where it showed up. and so we talked quite a lot about like what is this telling us, right? one thing about the methodology. So we've asked people to force rank, right? So it's a max diff where we said, you know, between this and this, what will you pick? Right. Like if that's what the only thing left to to choose from, what will you pick? Right. And so there's a methodological element to that. and what this tells us in a way is like, look, by the time you get to an argument around the quality of your co-benefits, you probably have already met a very high bar. That's one way to look at this data. Right? It means that people are already confident about your You know, the registry you're using, the the sure that the carbon removal is happening, like, you know, they they think you've got a f appropriate safeguards in terms of like keeping the forest standing, etc. Then we're having a quote question about like who's giving me more co-benefits than the other. that is one way to read that. The other way you can read it is to say, look, many people want to make carbon claims. And if you don't have you know that covered. then you know, it does it really matter if you have the co-benefits or not. And maybe slightly linked to that, it's also, which is a an alternate explanation we've also tested in interviews, is like, well, if you don't have the co-benefits, you can't assure the permanence. Something like that. You can't, if you don't have some of the more social elements of this already sorted out. How can I trust any of the other things? Like how do I know the forest is gonna stay standing? How do I know that the, you know, the project will keep going for as a as long as you've promised, et cetera? So I wouldn't just take it as like, you know, co-benefits are not important to sit at the bottom. It's more like you know, there are other things that buyers will want to be assured of first. Once you sort those out, then they become important. Now, one solution could be to say, look, this is a separate thing by itself. These are carbon credits. They're not biodiversity credits, et cetera, which I think is what you were saying. And say like let's think about them as something else. but I don't think we need to think that. I think that's probably a more aggressive step step than is required by what the data is saying. speaker-2: I was gonna say maybe a w a way of rephrasing that is so some of this is just table stakes, right? And so if I'm gonna get into the procurement cycle of a buyer, co-benefits may actually be the thing that wins the deal because everybody is gonna have to have all these other things in order to get there. And then I'm looking at projects that are sort of being decided based on co-benefits and price. and then the other one is you said, which I think is really important. And consistent with how we think about this as well is community benefit sharing, biodiversity, these are all things that reduce reversal risk, reduce sort of assure the delivery certainty. And so they actually back up the GHG measurements and permanence of the credits in many ways. And so that's, you know, if you were to ask which one do you care about more? Yeah, I really need permanence. And of course, I'd like co-benefits, but co-benefits are going to be necessary for some of the other elements of the stack. speaker-0: I also, I was actually surprised a little bit by a registry credibility. Yeah. Why? Just because it feels like the registry not always is like an indicator of quality to me, but obviously, and this is just, this is an assumption, but I'm not sure you later we see you tested about, or you asked different kinds of buyer types in what we also see like. buy on types that maybe are less sophisticated in the RFPs. sometimes see how many percent of your credits others this and this registry. And that's literally a question for quality. So maybe it's just for us in the bubble, it's a little bit like. Registry is maybe not always credibility, but, this is just, it, it brought me down a little bit. And it's like, yo, we have to think outside of the bubble. speaker-1: That's another surprising one, I would say. so when we ran the survey a couple of years back, it didn't rank that high. but if you think about all the work that the the the industry has been doing since then, like with the likes of ICBCM looking at you know program level, looking at project level, I think that what what that has done is to kind of re-establish the the fact that look, if If you've got a program that's gone through this rigorous checks and they've created a methodology for these credits, that's a great way to start in terms of like deciding what credits you want to buy. and so we think that the fact that it's risen again to the top might be a reflection of all the work that we've done to basically reinforce what registries are meant to do and the minimum standards that they they they need to have. The other thing you have to think about is like one question we asked that the survey was so much data, right? Like we had to choose what we show, what we don't show. But one question that we tested was like, how confident do you feel that your internal teams are able to get assured along these dimensions, right? and there are a couple of things that people don't feel very confident about. And then they feel I have to rely on something to make a buy-in decision. And the registry is how they do that and the methodologies, right? So things like permanence or how well the revenue sharing is going, like they they don't know how to validate that by themselves internally, or the G HD measurements, right? So they then they default to using a regulator in a way as a way of like solving the fact that they can't deal with that for themselves. By and large, I think this is a good thing. We need a market that is easier for people to join. So yeah. speaker-0: I think so too. I am, I think it's definitely the work of things like ICBC. I mean, we see that, for instance, we, we are quite active in the German speaking area, like Germany, Austria and Switzerland. And I think like three years ago, there were a lot of like local standards or they just, I don't know. did their project against some kind of ISO standard and so on. And companies were like, okay, that's fine. I don't trust the registries out there anyways. So it doesn't matter if it runs under one of the biggest standards or registries. And now we see it more and more that it's basically a requirement. Like maybe from next year on we see it more and that it needs to be ICVCM or at least it's the standards or the registry runs, underneath already be ICBCM approved. And then the methodologies, only slowly see it trickling in, but we see at least that some companies say like, you're not allowed to use any kind of methodologies that already didn't make the CCP or like ICBCM. So I also think and hope that at a certain point that yeah, it would give the. more assurance to companies because it will just make it easier also then to present it to the board and say like, look, these are the quality, credit and assurance we were able to stick to. So I think it's an important thing for sure. also found it interesting on the right where it's basically a good, almost be a split between removal and avoidance. then one theme that Dan and I also talked a lot about in the other episodes already is that enhanced rock. rock-mathering is still a little bit disputed almost on the credibility side. And I think it's funny that we just talked about it in some episodes before and now this comes up again then. speaker-1: Yeah, indeed. I mean, and if you again, if you go back three years, like there was an active debate then, avoidance is low quality, removals are high quality, and you could almost boil down the conversation to that. To some extent, I would say like you know, the the removal credits are very high on additionality in general, and that that makes that make that makes up for A large part of the explanation for why the shape of the of this responses look the way they do. I think the thing with enhanced rock weathering and cook stoves, they might be at the bottom there, but like there are different issues, right? Like I think with enhanced rock weathering, it's more the the science is not straightforward. It's straightforward and not straightforward at the same time, right? In the sense that we know that rocks weather, right? And that they would eventually remove CDR. we we know it's slightly more complicated to explain how much CD has happened over a short time frame, which is what credits are sold over. but we do expect that that's something that would improve with time, right? There's a bit of bio education to go into that. there's a bit of the science maturing, you know, the measurements maturing, etc. I mean, I think the the intensity of measurements we're having to do on enhanced rock weathering to prove. the drawdown over short periods of time, for example, shows off again on the costs, on the cost side, which is one of the things we looked at. whereas with cook stoves, again, this is another area where there's a very high social impact from the deployment of of cook stoves. But the carbon measurement is a bit more tricky, I would say. And a lot of work again has happened more recently to try and address that. It does require you to have confidence in a set of counterfactuals, right, to get to the carbon. removal and I think people just if it's not if you need to believe more things than the other thing, people kind of just say, well, this feels slightly less credible. And that I think shows up in the in the results that you you get from something like this. speaker-0: Yeah, I guess because we're short on time, was just because we jumped in so quickly and obviously we're really excited. But I was just wondering, is there like one thing in the whole report or like in the whole outcomes where you're like, damn, I would have never expected this. it changed your view on the market a little bit. speaker-1: Yeah. So the exercise that we did when we effectively said to people, so we were very curious about willingness to pay. Right. And you would expect that a willingness to pay curve will, you know, well, this was surprising as well. You're showing a portfolio price. So the fact that we had three X where we were when we last ran this, that was surprising. I have to put that out there. We still need to two X that to be into the range where like CDR is gonna be happy, but That's a shift. And that's a shift that doesn't show up from the straightforward market data, right? Like if you look at average prices retired on on the on the data channels, you don't see this, right? So it's more of a of a leading indicator to what's to come. But this was pretty cool. This was pretty cool to see. but what I was going to do on the willingness to pay is that we basically found that. For some credit types, people are not looking for the cheapest one possible. They anchor in their minds, especially around the avoidance type credits. I think it's the next the next one on. is that people expect that a credible credit for you know nature-based avoidance or red plus credits, or super superpolitan credits, which is the second category there. They have an expectation for what's a good price. for it and it's not the cheapest price possible. So that was surprising and that was a very interesting outcome for us because what it does for project developers is say, look, don't feel like you need to compete at the very lowest price. Like there your your buyers know what the state should cost if you're doing it properly. Right. so that's one of the surprising results that I would definitely flag. speaker-2: Bayo, I was I was interested to follow up on that point because I think we often think about this market from a supplier's viewpoint as okay, I've got to do everything possible to reduce price, reduce, reduce, reduce, knowing that I've got compliance markets in the future, I've got Asian markets that may come online, I've got Corsia, I've got all these other things. And if I can reduce my price at some point. Or it at at multiple points, all of a sudden, okay, now I'm at this price point. I've unlocked this new piece of demand. And the more I can reduce that while still maintaining quality, perhaps I can expand. How do you think about that kind of supply-demand curve here? Because you looked a little bit at budgets, but and and in one of the other charts, again, you also showed all right, the average bid for a reforestation project may be in the twenties and thirties, but there's also some willingness to pay even up to $70 in the premium. from a premium buyer. How how do you think about that though, in terms of what you found in in the in the interviews? How how do how much demand gets unlocked as we come down price or is it does it not quite work like that? speaker-1: It does, and that quite a lot does, provided that you can meet the quality bar that is required to deliver that credit. So I think that proviso is is the thing that is required anytime you talk about this. It's like, can you meet the bar? If you can meet the bar, every dollar that you can reduce the price is gonna give you more market share. But people are quite sensitive to look, we have spoken to seven other developers that do this. And they can't get below a certain price. And we've looked, I mean, it's quite bilateral these days. You're in the conversations, right? Like we've looked at what they're doing and their cost stack, et cetera. How are you able to like come to this at half the price? Right. Well, if you can credibly show that you're gonna win the RFP, right? You're gonna win the tenders. And that's what we're ultimately gonna need for for compliance markets. And when buyers with slightly less willingness to pay need to join the market and do this. So I think a focus on like reducing the costs as much as possible is still required. Like that cost of discipline is just again, this is a voluntary action that people are taking right now. So that cost of discipline is just so critical. But it's it shouldn't come at the expense of like delivering the qualities that that that are required. I think is the key message to take from this. And I think you would see like with the credits that have the very high credibility from the chapter we looked at before. The demand curve behaves exactly as you would expect it to do, in the sense that, you know, you just the highest willingness to pay at the lowest price, right? Which is exactly what because like the likelihood that people are confused about the the quality of those things is very low. Like when they're buying that, they just sort of know how to adjudge quality and did you just want it for the lowest price that they can get it for, right? so we we've saw this pattern of like the market. I mean it's likely to things attention, like all of the time. Where I think that's probably the final chart that we we ended the the article with, which is like for the fairly sophisticated buyers with like higher higher target prices, they could buy more expensive stuff than what they buy today. but they're buying what they can find that meets the quality bar, and they have a very well calibrated sense of like. What that should cost, right? So they're not paid anymore for it. So they could probably do more. But the part that unlocks a lot of demand, which is what you were touching on there, Dan, is like the other part of the market that is not as sophisticated or doesn't have as big a budget, they're extremely price sensitive. And they already find what they're having to deal with today too expensive. And so that just makes it a little bit difficult for them to unlock even more demand. It makes it more difficult for more people to join. So I think if you target only the high end of the market, you're gonna leave out most of the people that will join this market, you know, over the next over the next, I'll say, you know, three, four years as we as we get into twenty thirty and people start having to deliver on some of the promises they made. speaker-2: So we just have to be a little bit cheaper than our competitors and be able to explain why we're cheaper and then we'll win these RFPs. All right, I'll I'll work on that with the team. speaker-0: That's fantastic. All right. And just a quick to end this. Everyone is always saying, okay, we're so demand constrained, but are we now demand constrained or supply constrained? I'm not like, what, what, what do we see? speaker-1: Yeah, if we have to if we have to put pick one, I would say that we are still demand constrained by and large, right? because look this there there are a few buyers in the market who can find the thing that they want to buy at the volumes that they want to buy. those budgets are fairly large, but in terms of like if I think about global impact and where we need this market to go, we are still effectively like significantly demand constrained. So we need more people in the market buying with higher budgets than they than they do today. because I think that's the thing that actually more credibly unlocks for, you know, investors, et cetera, signal that tells them to then, you know, back the developers who want to go ahead and go build these projects, right? So we are largely demand constrained and in a narrow sliver we are supply constrained. speaker-0: So basically we just need to stick on to that trajectory from your first report to this report with the portfolio prices basically increasing. then in what is it? Four years, the next report would come out and then we had like hundreds of dollars on average. And there may be, there's no early days buyers. They all went one down and then we could. speaker-1: That would be that would be a delightful outcome for everyone, I would say. challenging to to say that that's necessarily going to happen. But you know, if you get to a world where the portfolio prices are that high, it removes some of the concerns that people have around look, is this just a cheap way out? does this replace like action in your value chain, et cetera. Because you're on you're in the same ballpark as what it takes to to do primary decarbonisation and value chain. So at that point, you know, it's people choosing to have impact in the way that is most easy for them to access, in the way that's most consistent with what the companies want to do, et cetera. but yeah, let's let's see where we get, where we run this again. speaker-2: Well, we'll be excited to have you back on the podcast in a few years' time to share that good news with us. speaker-1: Sure. Thank you. speaker-0: Thanks, all speaker-2: Thanks B. speaker-0: right. That was fantastic to see the buyer perspective, 300 buyers and what they're actually doing. Now we're going to jump to the other side, right? speaker-2: Yeah, jump in to talk to a supplier who's been super successful in getting buyers around the, you know, crowding in around the table and then leveraging that buyer demand to be able to raise debt financing, which is something that you know, Momback has also had the privilege of doing. It's really hard, having been through the process. We just know just how hard it is. and so it'll be really interesting to hear from from Julia on how they've been able to manage and and wrangle this thing. speaker-0: Julia, fantastic to have you. And Dan and I just before already chatted a little bit about the announcement you had, the debt financing, which is like $35 million or up to $35 million from Mediobanker for your project. And we were just really curious. First of all, welcome, obviously. Very curious to hear a little bit more about it. But obviously, if you could tell us a little bit what Vaulted Deep is actually doing because I think it's quite the, I don't know, for me at least, maybe from the European side, because we don't have it that much on our side, a special project, right? But also a project is actually delivering a lot of durable and tons of CDR already. We tell us a little bit about that and then we can get into the debt financing, which I think is super interesting and the market needs way more. speaker-3: Yeah, awesome. I'm so stoked to be here. It's good to see you both. it's exciting. exciting that we're kind of, I think, developing like the carbon markets together and sort of each making our own our own progress in our own way. So I'm excited. And if we have time, I I want to hear also about your guys' deals because I know there's exciting ones too. but yeah, I mean, so for vaulted, just real quick for folks who don't know, what we do is we take organic waste and we put it really deep underground. So we're sort of a waste management solution that I think is better for the environment, right? So we take all different types of organic waste. Think biosolids, which is human waste, post-waste water treatment facility. We take paper sludge from paper mills, we take agricultural waste, food waste, whole wide variety of stuff that, you know, today is going to a landfill, getting incinerated, or just getting spread on the land to get rid of it. and where it's going today isn't so great, you know. Obviously for the climate, because it has all this organic carbon in it that then decomposes and contributes to climate change, but also not so great, oftentimes, for those local environments, because you know, those traditional options can have some environmental impacts, right? You can have air quality impacts with incinerators, you can have water and soil quality impacts. You know, a lot of those wastes have PFAS, which is a forever chemical that's linked to cancer. you can have nitrate contamination issues. landfills of odor, methane, leachate, right? So in our sort of traditional waste management infrastructure, oftentimes where we put organic waste can cause really serious in local environmental contamination and local community health consequences. So we're trying to both fix that and actually, you know, provide a better home for organic waste by putting it really deep underground to permanently dispose of it, which means no PFAS in your drinking water and no odor and no methane and no nitrate contamination. but then of course, that also is a great way to really durably remove carbon because all the organic waste has that organic carbon. So we put it thousands of feet underground. Like, sorry, I'm American, so I I think in Empire State Buildings, like three to five Empire State Buildings underground. This is really, really deep underground. we used a proprietary, you know, pressurized injection technology to do it. Actually, that technology was developed in the oil and gas sector. My co-founder Omar really developed that with his company Advantech and commercialized that mostly in oil field waste. And then we took it and applied it to organics. So yeah, waste management, carbon removal, sort of all in one, two operating sites, one with our partner in Los Angeles and one in Hutchinson, Kansas, taking all sorts of different organic waste. speaker-2: What's been the secret to allowing you guys to move so quickly from getting this idea going to now delivering tons of carbon? Like I remember when I met you five years ago, you were doing a very different thing at that time. And it sounds like you've taken something that is hard technology, not not software, something that is very hardware-based that people weren't doing before, brought it into a new space, gotten financing, started projects, built methodologies, and delivered. carbon. I mean, you guys are the leading supplier of carbon removal on the isometric registry. So what's what's been the secret to success in getting projects going so quickly? speaker-3: didn't know that. That's that's cool that we're we're at top an isometric. but I mean really the reason why we've been able to be so you know, been able to scale so quickly is because you know we're incredibly lucky that we were able to spin off of my co-founder's company. My co-founder did a decade plus of work before I ever showed up. and really, you know, commercializing that core technology, I think you know, a key here is this is not. A new technology. It's a hard-to-do technology. So it's used. Very few companies do it in the oil and gas sector. And what it is is a slurry injection technology, which sounds very niche, but it's, you know, most geologic injection is a pure gas or a pure liquid. This is a solid-laden liquid, right? So it's a slurry, it has both solids and liquids in it. That's fairly hard to be able to inject deep into the subsurface. It's easy to plug your well. Right. And so it's easy to plug your formation. And so really very few companies do it in the oil and gas sector. They do it for oil field waste, all that like oily rocky water when you drill for oil and gas. but my co-founder, you know, his father was one of the inventors of that, you know, tr technology in the 80s out of the Clean Water Act, which is amazing. And then he really like commercialized it and grew it with his company. AdvanTech Waste Management Services. And so when I showed up, like there was a mature technology that had already been proven. And that was, you know, obviously, in and of itself, so fantastic. But then what's more is, you know, the that company, Advantec, mostly had oil field waste injection sites. That was sort of their you know bread and butter. but they had one site in the city of Los Angeles, which is the first site in the entire world to do deep well injection of organics. They're really pioneers, the first site in the entire world to think about how do we Take organic waste and dispose of it differently and put it really deep underground. So they take 20% of the city of Los Angeles' biosolids every year. They put them 8,000 plus feet underground where it's permanently stored. It's an amazing site. It's co-located right there at the wastewater treatment facility. And, you know, when I met him, he was like, this is great waste management, right? It's like, it's right there on site. You know, you're not trucking it into the Central Valley, you know, to get rid of it. because when you're in a city like Los Angeles, you have to transport your waste, you know, quite far away. landfills in the middle of Los Angeles. and so he's like, and it's right there on site, you know, and and it's you know really protective. The whole point is like protect groundwater, right? So you're not spreading it on land and and having PFAS contamination issues with land application. so he's like, This is really good waste management. And I looked at it and I was coming. Dan, you mentioned earlier, like I was a venture capitalist for a couple of years, and I was looking at all these different carbon removal technologies. And I was really interested in how do you get like the most efficient carbon removal. and I thought about it and I was like, it was really our first conversation was really like a light bulb moment where was like, that's great waste management. That is amazing durable carbon removal, right? It's like the waste, the carbon's aggregated for you through like huge legacy infrastructure like. Our sewage systems, right? Like a lot of people did a lot of work to like aggregate that carbon. And then, you know, it's and then it's a waste, right? And so people will pay you to dispose of it, right? So there's a nice secondary revenue stream. and then, you know, when you put it really deep underground, it's obviously permanent, permanently stored, trapped there under, you know, thousands of feet of rock with a cap rock layer. So you've got the permanence piece. And it's really measurable, right? It's sort of a closed loop system. You're putting it underground. You can measure exactly how much carbon is in that waste. Where did it go? And so I loved it from a carbon removal standpoint. And I said, wow, for this thing to like really scale, I think what we should do. And this was Omar and I together, let's take this sort of traditional technology, let's spin it off into its new company. So we spun vaulted off of Advantec. We they already had a site, the Kansas site that was like, not doing a ton of operations, but was permitted. And so we were able to take that site and like really ramp up ops. And then we work with them on the Los Angeles site to do the carbon credit piece. so that's a very long-winded way of answering your question, which is like the reason we were able to scale so quickly is because decade of work from someone else and and they had already proven it in waste, but we realized we needed carbon as a you know revenue stream to really monetize the good, you know, work they're doing on on on removing carbon and fighting climate change. You monetize that, you can really then, you know, press play and scale up and really yeah get more sites online faster. Sort of the thesis of the company. speaker-2: Yeah, no, that's awesome. And what what's been the secret now that has let you guys get access to debt? Because obviously debt has been this you know, amazing goal for a lot of companies in the carbon space as we think about the capital stack that you need to do projects. You know, we've we've seen like Momback did a World Bank outcome bond to bring in some debt like financing. We have development banks who've started to provide debt. We saw JP Morgan give chestnut. a deadline for a reforestation project in the US. So there's been a few examples of this now in the market, but yours feels unique as well. And and every one of these, especially with some commercial banks in play, really cool to see. So what was it that made that happen? And then tell us a little bit about the actual deal itself. speaker-3: Yeah. Honestly, I think the punchline is track record of deliveries, right? Plus offtake. I think it's those two things. you know, I think we're we're fortunate to have Frontier as a major off taker. They were our first customer and then they signed with us in 2024, sort of our major off take that we're delivering against now, you know, which went from 2024 to 2028. And so that's an amazing off take for us because. you know, not only is it sort of a locked in, you know, locked in off take with great counterparties that are really credit worthy, right? I'm sure folks know, but that's like Stripe and Shopify and Google and like really underwritable counterparty on the off take. but they're also just so smart on carbon removal that they also wrote a really bankable off take, right? So that sort of the off take piece I think was super key. and that's obviously like Frontier's main theory, right? Of like theory of change is like, let's go and sign these off takes with suppliers so that they can be financeable, so that we can get the tons, right? And so it's really like I think their their theory working and sort of evidence of it. so I think it's the off take. And then on the other side, it's like, yeah, the you know, the bank really has to believe that you can deliver, right? It's for us, we get paid on delivery. and so for there I think it's just the the track record, right? And saying, like, okay, we've been operating commercially, we do thirty to fifty trucks a day, every single day, you know, and and just sort of putting those numbers on the board. I shouldn't use sports references. I don't know what I'm talking about, but assuming that's the right sports reference. Those numbers on the board. but speaker-2: In Brazil, everybody only talks about sports reference related to soccer. And if in the US, a lot of sports references are baseball or football, but mostly baseball, right? Knock it out of the park, you know, are touch the base. there are all these things that you start to realize like a Brazilian has no concept of any baseball reference. So, you know, unless you're saying like, score an amazing goal, which we never talk about, you know, or kick the ball really far and hard. You just speaker-0: It's simply like you've read in Germany, let's be honest. speaker-3: my gosh. It's so hard. And you know, when I say like numbers on the board, do I know what sport that is? Not quite sure. Maybe it's multiple sports. I don't know. Baseball. Great. speaker-2: Again, baseball, yeah. People used to physically put numbers on a board that was at the edge of the park. So but anyway, back to your back to your story. You were saying putting numbers on the board, this is what so how does the deal work? You this is a backed by off takes, you're getting capital up front to be able to deploy into the projects. Is that covering you still have to use some of your own equity? Is that or like how how's the financing being leveraged by the by your team? speaker-3: Yeah. Yeah. So you can almost think about it a little bit like receivables financing. So it's at TopCo, it's not like dedicated project finance, which was amazing. Maybe as you just said, let's do that receivables financing, you know, for any credit that goes into that off take. And then we can use it really flexibly. You know, for us, we're trying to build a bunch of, you know, a bunch more projects across the country. So we're mostly using it for project finance. But the nice thing is You know, we can we can use it flexibly. We can use it across different projects. We can use it you know, for CapEx or OpEx or you anything we need. So mostly, mostly to go build out our next couple of sites, you know, which are getting going now, which is exciting. but yeah, I think, you know, for us kind of that flexibility is really key. CFP was the arranger and they did just like this amazing job of figuring out like, okay, how do we structure this? It was relatively new. and so, you know, getting really creative on the structure and then really like saying, Okay, how do we like bring in insurance? Right, like RTO is there on the insurance front, and then also bringing in the bank as well. Mediobanka was the the bank that ultimately, you know, was the capital provider. And they did a lot of work to sort of get Mediobanka up the, you know, learning curve on carbon and carbon wool and what does this mean? Get comfortable and layer insurance. So I honestly think it took It just took a minute with a lot of creativity to go figure out like, okay, how do we put these puzzle pieces together to make it bankable? speaker-0: I think it's super interesting from another perspective because we had Robert Höglund here before and he said for the different project types, he was like, it's actually only Biochar that is delivering. And then I checked and basically it's Biochar and VoltaDeep. speaker-2: But speaker-0: That is delivering which I find like those fantastic and I'm actually so surprised that there is I was surprised that there aren't a lot of like other vaulted deeps out there, but you basically explained now why this is the case also, right? You have quite like a like a USP there and that obviously is fantastic for you, but I'm also wondering At the moment, you're mostly in the US, right? And obviously I sit in Europe. I work with a lot of European companies. This is something like, first of all, that you can also bring to other areas. think probably there's also regulation that you have to look at. know Germany is really strict with their waste and so on. But there's one thing that I'm wondering. And then also, just for me, because I'm not the expert in that project type, In what kind of direction on pricing do we, what can we get at a certain point? I'm just curious because obviously I'm always trying to compare all the durable methods with each other. would be really curious about that. speaker-3: Yeah. Yeah. on intern okay, so on international a hundred percent. I think this is something, you know, that can be global. for us when we think about sites like, you know, expansion, and and this is in the US or globally, we kind of look at like three main things, right? Like, Where is there good geology, right? Where is there the geology we like, which really has the containment we need, right? We only pick geology. It's a big part of what we do. Like we've mapped the whole subsurface of the US to go figure out where is there geology with really good containment? And that usually looks like a basin structure. So there's sort of like a basin, you know, couple thousand, you know, three to five thousand feet underground, which can really absorb the waste. So it's usually like a sandstone or like a pretty porous rock that has that absorption capacity. and then you know, also a caprock layer, right? So a layer on top of it, usually like a shale or something really non-porous that is not gonna let the waste come back up, right? And so then you're really making sure like nothing's going back up to surface, nothing's going to the groundwater, it's really permanently trapped down there. A good like shortcut for that is if there's oil and gas production. Like, not to get too esoteric, but one way to think about vaulted is like We're sort of like recreating oil, right? Like oil and gas is just like organic matter trapped under layers of sedimentary rock. and so when you like put it really deep underground, like those formations that trapped those, you know, that organic waste and made those hydrocarbons originally is like really good. So if you want to just like mentally map the world, oil any place where there's oil and gas production is like generally pretty good geology for us. and then we can also do slightly different geology. So actually our Kansas site is a network of salt caverns. So we can repurpose salt caverns. Those were actually originally leached to store like butane in the 50s. but you know, we can repurpose that sort of infrastructure as well. And and salt is this great self-healing formation that also is like really good containment. so there's a little bit of flexibility there. but but we really yeah, look for like good geology. We look for where we can get a permit. So, you know, where is there a country or a region that knows how to permit things in the subsurface? know that's relatively more comfortable with you know some some types of extraction or injection under in the US we're under class five not class six and so you know that also varies state by state some regulators are more you know open and some are less and then last but not least but I think probably the most important one is where is there waste that I mean I would say where is there waste that's actively causing an issue today, right? Where is there waste where It's going to a landfill and landfills are filling up at capacity and those landfill prices are getting crazy. obviously, Europe, do you guys have a waste issue? I mean, we have a waste issue in the US too, but Europeans are really squeezed for you know, for waste disposal capacity. and so yeah, where do you find that waste that's like going to landfills, going to incinerators? Maybe there's land app, land application sort of contamination. so I think a good example of this is actually in the Netherlands. The Netherlands has a pretty significant nitrate contamination issue because of sort of agricultural and animal production. the new government is really focused on how to lower nitrate levels because of the groundwater contamination. and so for that, like we can work with excess manure that's being sort of, you know, right now over applied on land and we could put that really deep underground. And the Netherlands actually has good deep well geology, but they also have great salt caverns, right? So like something like that could also really work. for us as we think about expansion. speaker-2: How how are you thinking about the next phase of financing? For you, is it more debt per dollar invested in a project? was the deal that you did, you know, how how good was the deal in your mind? Like I, you know, for us, for example, we had World Bank, Outcome Bond, and then the Brazil National Development Bank. The two things are are quite different from one another. And so they're also, you know, because these are first of their kind deal, like you said. You had to bring in a ton of different parties here, right? So it seems like streamlining these arrangements, both in the leading up to signing phase and then in the actual operation phase of the financing is going to be really important for us to keep scaling them. But I'm yeah, I'm just wondering what's on your wish list now for the next financing deal that you do. speaker-3: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think I really love the deal and I think things I love about it, like flexible Topka, you can use it. You know, it was also a really flexible draw and repayment schedule, not to get too detailed, but like there's a lot of things to love about it. and I think it will serve us really well for the next, you know, however long, at least, you know, year year plus. But I also think that's not necessarily like the only structure we'll look at, right? So because you know we're trying to bring online dozens of projects in the next, you know, call it five, ten years, like I think we're gonna also look at different structures as well. That might also be something like a portfolio project financing. that might look totally different. But I think there's like a lot of like creativity in front of us in in thinking about like different structures as we grow. I think off take is an amazing one. And we just have to think about as you, as you well know, like how do you match, you know, when you can get the financing and when repayments needed to sort of your cash flows when you're trying to build, you know, a pretty sizable sort of industrial project. So there's always the the tension there of how you how you kind of structure that really well so it matches sort of your your cash flow needs. speaker-0: I mean, that is quite interesting from a perspective because I think not a lot of project developers are there yet, right? It's kind of like the next stage, you know, in the beginning, everyone is like, please can I get my first big off take? And only if you had a couple and they're back, but you can think about this more, more from a project financing and scale up perspective. So, yeah. Like first of all, congrats again. It's amazing. I also saw that you are basically come remove a royalty now with the time 100. speaker-2: Yeah, that's pretty cool. speaker-0: Now that's amazing. I actually came all over my feet because there's also this one South African youngest parliament member in there. And then I went through the list and actually only then I saw you and then the day later I saw it all over LinkedIn. So congrats to that as well. I found it quite cool. To have someone from carbon removal in a list like that, I think it's good for the space. Thanks so much for coming on on CWN and share your perspective. And I hope we see way more debt financing announcement, off-takes and so on. And yeah, you leading the delivered durable carbon ranking also in the future. speaker-2: We're we're coming for you though, I'll say. Mom back is gonna we're gonna try to see if we can beat you on the registry, but it'll be a good battle back and forth. So speaker-3: I love it. We we need we need it all. And I'm so stoked to be building with you guys. I just like I don't know. I mean, that's very nice to thank you, but like I'm I'm one of those people that's like we need every, we need, we need us all to be successful. I don't think our move is gonna be successful with like one or two companies. I think we need like a bunch of companies that can deliver, that can scale so we like have a real industry and market and we can show the naysayers that it is real and we can put tons on the board. Did I use that well? Tons on the board. You heard it here first. speaker-2: You heard it here first. speaker-0: for tons on the boat. speaker-2: Well, awesome. Well, thanks for joining us, Julia. Fun to fun to chat as always. And and yeah, congrats on this deal and and mu to many more successes. speaker-3: Awesome. Thank you guys. So fun to be here with you. speaker-2: All right, thanks. speaker-3: Bye. speaker-0: If you've loved this episode, please, please, please hit the subscribe button. The more followers we have, the more guests we can get and the more coverage we will be able to provide. So thank you so much for your support.