Latest / The BlackSheep Podcast: Presented by HM Magazine / Tooth & Nail Records Tournament
Transcript
- 0:30Today we have Eric mcclanahand with us. I'm super stoked for this episode because
- 0:35this is gonna be a little different than what we've done before. You know,
- 0:38for those who have listened to our episodes, our fantasy draft episodes before,
- 0:42you know, we'll do these like fantasy things where we'll pick like a
- 0:45team of like our favorite artists or whatever. But this is gonna be a
- 0:49little different. This is actually a tournament, which Culin and I we've done
- 0:52a tournament. Remember we did our two thousands medal core tournament back Dan Coke.
- 0:56That was a fun episode. This is even more. This is big
- 1:00time. This is sixty four teams. This is the actual like NC double
- 1:03a tourney kind of tournament. But this is going to be a tournament of
- 1:10the best tooth and nail bands. Okay, best tooth and nail bands.
- 1:15But the thing is we're actually not picking the teams. This has already been
- 1:19decided for us. So this is what's going to really throw it for a
- 1:23loop. So our friend Eric McClanahan, over the last couple months has been
- 1:29doing these really really cool tournaments that have been somewhat centered around like the Christian
- 1:34music industry. You know, a couple months ago you did like the big
- 1:37CCM one that blew up, and then now you just did this Tooth and
- 1:40Nail one, and you've been doing some other ones as well. But as
- 1:42soon as I found out you were doing the Tooth and Nail one, I
- 1:46reached out and I was like, we need to talk about this because obviously
- 1:49that's the scene of music that Cullen and I cover, And so it just
- 1:53felt like the dumbest thing ever if we weren't getting you on the podcast to
- 1:57talk about this tournament. But this has been a tournament that's going on,
- 2:00has gone on for the last couple of weeks, and people thousands of people
- 2:04have voted in and have gone round by round voting their favorite Tooth and Nail
- 2:09artists through, and we're really excited to just kind of talk and recap.
- 2:14So what we're gonna do is just literally go match up by matchup. So
- 2:17we'll start in the first round matchups and then second, third, and so
- 2:22forth, and we're just going to talk about kind of the matchups, like
- 2:25was this do we think the people chose right? Did you know? Did
- 2:29was this an upset that was worth the upset? Was was the team that
- 2:31we thought would go all the way through the tournament getting through the tournament.
- 2:35So anyway, we're just gonna talk and kind of recap matchup by matchup.
- 2:38But with that said, are there any other things that we need to mention
- 2:42culin well to add a little bit of pretext. Mason and I we muted
- 2:46Eric on Twitter. Yes, solely for the idea that we didn't want to
- 2:50know, you know, who was matched up against who, so we could
- 2:53so we could talk about this fresh. Yeah, right, well, and
- 2:57especially we did not want to know who the champion is. So as we're
- 3:00recording right now, the champion has been declared. The polls have closed,
- 3:05all right, So if you have you've been in line, get out of
- 3:07line because the polls have closed and there has been a champion declared. But
- 3:13the thing is, we don't know who it is yet. So what we're
- 3:15gonna do is once we get to the championship round, we're actually all gonna
- 3:19look on Twitter and see who the champion is. So we're just really really
- 3:23stoked about that. Um So, Eric, tell us about yourself, man,
- 3:28how did you get involved in doing these in the first place? Because
- 3:30they're they're brilliant. Clearly you are a a like an encyclopedia of of Christian
- 3:38music and alternative music. So, uh, what got you involved in these?
- 3:43And what do you do for for life? Like what do you do
- 3:46in your in your spare time and stuff? Well, what got me started
- 3:50on these was, you know, I've you followed me for a while.
- 3:53You know, I've a tweet in music that's kind of been my main thing
- 3:58for for quite a while. A couple of my like choose one of these
- 4:02albums. Tweets kind of took off and I kept getting more Christian music followers,
- 4:09people who are interested in that, and somebody suggested around March that I
- 4:13do a Christian music tournament and I was like, Okay, that sounds cool.
- 4:16People would be into it. So I did that and uh it,
- 4:21it got a lot of traction and people are like, okay, talked about
- 4:27it. I think relevant even picked up on it, Like there was some
- 4:30big, big names in the Christian industry that, not to mention, the
- 4:33bands themselves were reaching out to you. So yeah, that's a pretty cool
- 4:38deal, man. Yeah it was. It was. I did not expect
- 4:42that at all. It turned into something I was not prepared for but uh
- 4:46it was fun. Uh did that, did a couple other tournaments since then,
- 4:51Music's just kind of always been my main hobby. You know, I
- 4:56like sports and stuff like that, but music has always kind of been the
- 5:00the thing that I spend my free time thinking about. So yeah, that's
- 5:04kind of my start. Our goal here is to make you the Nate Silver
- 5:09of Christian music. Hopefully we can hopefully we can get you there. Appreciate
- 5:18and Eric, you are one of the few people, I think Collins one
- 5:23of these other folks, but there are very few people that I know who
- 5:26are as knowledgeable about the Christian music industry as you are. And there are
- 5:30some very niche bands that you've talked about in the you know before that you
- 5:35know, we've talked about, and you've talked about on Twitter and stuff where
- 5:39I'm like, wow, I literally thought that I was the only other person
- 5:42in the world that remembers that Christian band. It's pretty impressive. Well,
- 5:47I appreciate that. It's it's been pretty cool to see also that I'm not
- 5:50the only one who remembers some of those very small, niche bands who played
- 5:56one music festival. Ever. Yeahn't that weird? Fun though, I will
- 6:00say, though, Eric, you are by far the most knowledgeable person I
- 6:05know on it. So I know Mason was trying to give me a little
- 6:09credit, but I don't deserve any of that. You are like on the
- 6:12next level. Man. I appreciate that. But you guys, you guys
- 6:15know a lot too. My buddy Josh Baylog, he's the real encyclopedia of
- 6:19Christian music. Everybody should follow him on Twitter too. I feel like this
- 6:24is like one of those things where it's like, um, it's like every
- 6:27therapist has a therapist, and we're just trying to like find whose therapist is,
- 6:31like the Kingpin therapist. You know, somebody knows it all right to
- 6:36find that person. All right? Should we get going through talking through these
- 6:42matchups? Let's do it. I'm super stoked. Well, I think we
- 6:46should maybe start like top left and then we'll just kind of I don't know
- 6:51what's that. It's so western eyed of you. I think we should go.
- 6:55I think we should go right right left? Should we go right left?
- 6:58All right? Well, right, we'll start. Should we go top
- 7:00right or bottom right? Let's go top right? All right? You want
- 7:03the top? All right? Great? Yeah? So all right? So
- 7:06the first matchup, the one and sixteen matchup is Germy Camp at number one,
- 7:13and then Seventh Day Slumber at number sixteen, and we right out of
- 7:19the gate already get a massive upset, a sixteen seed beating a number one
- 7:25seed. Seventh Day Slumber barely squeaks by the number one seed, Germy Camp.
- 7:30I honestly was not expecting this. These are like two artists that I'm
- 7:33like, not all that interested in, but the fact that Seventh Day Slumber
- 7:39was able to beat out Germany Camp is pretty impressive. Who, like,
- 7:42did you guys think that that would happen at all? I did not think
- 7:45that would happen. It actually makes me angry because I went to a Seventh
- 7:48Day Slumber show one time and they played like three songs and they just preached
- 7:54the rest of the time, and it pissed me off. So I didn't
- 7:59expect it. It kind of pissed me off too, because as a bracketmaker,
- 8:03you don't want to see a sixteen takedown one. That was a major
- 8:07failure on my part there, I think. But well, speaking of which,
- 8:09did you did you kind of rank these based off of like Spotify plays
- 8:13or just like perceived popularity or what. I used a lot of Spotify numbers,
- 8:18looked up the streaming numbers for every artist that had a chance of making
- 8:24it, and I just generally know when kind of who's done well my other
- 8:28tournaments and stuff. I used to allow that for seeding. And actually I
- 8:31talked to someone who an anonymous source who will say knows a whole lot about
- 8:39the bands in this tournament and got some pointers there too. Wow, and
- 8:43the anonymous source we're already working with the cartel or what Jesus Well. One
- 8:50of the things that's interesting about Dreaming Camp is he probably is, at least
- 8:54like album sales wise, maybe the biggest tooth nail artists sales. Possibly he's
- 9:03got four or five gold albums. Yeah, like like this is not like
- 9:07a number one seed that like just happened to get a number one seed.
- 9:09Like this is arguably maybe the at least popularity wise, probably the most popular
- 9:15tooth and nail artist. Now here's what's going to be interesting. We'll see
- 9:18this this run through. I think the rest of the tournament, there are
- 9:22going to be artists who are technically on tooth and nail, but a lot
- 9:24of tooth and nail fans aren't necessarily fans of those bands, right right,
- 9:30they just happen to be on Tooth and Nail. I think, honestly,
- 9:33I think like Thousand Foot Crutch is sort of in that vein of the like
- 9:37the average Tooth and Nail fan wasn't particularly interested in in TFK, but TFK
- 9:43was just a big band outside of Tooth and Nail. So I think we're
- 9:46gonna see that through line throughout this entire tournament. But this is one example
- 9:52of that of Jeremy Camp being technically a Tooth and Nail artist, but people
- 9:56really like who all the Tooth and Nail fans aren't like, particularly Jeremy Camp
- 10:01fans, right All Jeremy Camp fans are outside of the Tooth and Nail world.
- 10:03That said, I would love to know how many albums, other albums
- 10:09that we love that Jeremy Camp essentially bankrolled. That's true, inevitably true,
- 10:18It is very true. Yeah, there are so many. Yeah, I
- 10:20bet there's a few artists on here that even artists that we don't really like,
- 10:24but they have made Tooth and Nail a lot of money where they you
- 10:26know, they Tooth and Nail use that money to fund some other bands that
- 10:31weren't going to be as profitable. But anyway, well, number one seed
- 10:35goes down and so seventh they slumber moves on. Who are they going to
- 10:39compete against? It is between kJ five two at the eighth seed and Falling
- 10:45Up as the nine seed, and again barely squeaking by Falling Up beats kJ
- 10:52five two. Any surprises here? What are your thoughts about this matchup?
- 10:58I thought I thought it would be a close one, of course, you
- 11:01know, maybe being the Falling Up fanboy that I am, I was,
- 11:05I was hoping. I was hoping it would be a favorable matchup for them.
- 11:07But I mean, people like kJ five two is interacted with my tweets
- 11:11and stuff, so I was like, he could easily get ahold of this
- 11:15and retweet it and wined up. But he never never responded to people tagging
- 11:22him in it and stuff. So wow, he's too busy pastoring, I
- 11:26guess. So yeah, I don't really. I liked Falling Up way more
- 11:31than kJ five two, although I don't really have an affinity for either one
- 11:35of these artists, but I do think Falling Up is genuinely a much better
- 11:39artist, just like artistically I'm an agreement. So yeah, anyway, I
- 11:45guess like no surprises there. It wasn't eight versus nine matchup, so it
- 11:48should have been close, and it was close, which you know, and
- 11:50like actual NCABI tournament game, like you want to see a good eight nine
- 11:54matchup. So that worked out well, all right, So falling Up is
- 11:58going to be matched up against seven Day Slumber. We're gonna get back to
- 12:01that once we get to the second round. But next matchup, Disciple versus
- 12:07Joy Electric. This is one that, like I was just talking about this
- 12:11whole like through line of tooth and Nail artists that weren't really all that loved
- 12:16by tooth and Nail fans, this is one that actually surprises me. Joy
- 12:20Electric is beloved by older tooth and Nail fans, and the fact that it
- 12:26was as far of a or it was as much of a win by Disciple
- 12:31really surprised me. I would have thought Joy Electric at the very least would
- 12:35have put up more of a fight, but ultimately Disciple kind of handed it
- 12:39to him. I think I think this one is because Disciple had that one
- 12:43album that actually went pretty hard, so hard that somebody even busted their eye
- 12:52open too. This is very true. Mason has a very fun story he
- 12:54could probably share real quickly here. Yeah, So Cullen and I when O,
- 12:58gosh, this is like what fifteen years ago now, Culin. It
- 13:01was like one of the first years that you and I were friends, and
- 13:03we went down to Prooking's because Disciple it was like Disciple Project eighty six.
- 13:09There was another kind of big band for Chi Children eighteen three. That's right.
- 13:13So those three bands were playing and h during Disciple, I was we
- 13:18were right up front and it's one of those uh that they were on a
- 13:22stage that was sort of probably like chest high, and I was headbanging along.
- 13:26I think it was even to like that big song called game On I
- 13:28Love that one. And I was headbanging and I hit my head on one
- 13:33of those monitors that was right on the stage right there. And initially,
- 13:37like I was like, oh, like I hit my head and I didn't
- 13:41really think much of it. But then I started feeling like a lot of
- 13:43like liquid like going down my face, and I'm like, this feels more
- 13:46than just sweat, and I like wipe my hand and I just see like
- 13:50red everywhere on my hand. I'm like, oh, shit, and so
- 13:54I go over immediately they like, these people see my like head bleeding,
- 13:58and so they give me a towel really quick. I guess there was like
- 14:01a nurse in the back. So I go to this nurse and she looks
- 14:05at it and she's like, oh, you for sure needs stitches, and
- 14:07so I have to call my mom. The funny story about this and me
- 14:11calling my mom is before I left my mom. So it was Cullin and
- 14:16a couple of our friends and we're going to be staying in this town that
- 14:20was about forty five minutes away from where we grew up, and all of
- 14:24them were older than me. Colin was a couple years older than me,
- 14:26and the rest of the guys were older than me. And my mom told
- 14:28me, she was like, all right, Mason, I trust these guys.
- 14:31I totally trust them. But if you happen to find yourself in a
- 14:35situation where there's alcohol and you feel uncomfortable. Because I was like seventh or
- 14:39eighth grade at this point, I was really young, and she was like,
- 14:43if you find yourself in a situation where you feel really uncomfortable, where
- 14:46there's alcohol, just know you can call me right away and we will be
- 14:50the bad cops about this, and we will will get you and take you
- 14:54out of that situation. So she gets this call at like what is it
- 14:58ten o'clock at night when I busted my head open, and she's immediately thinking,
- 15:01oh shit, Colin took out a bunch of alcohol and they're all drinking
- 15:05now, and sure enough that's not the case. I was like, mom,
- 15:09I broke my head open. She was like what. I'm like,
- 15:11yeah, I like my eyebrow, like I hit my head on this thing
- 15:15and my eyebrows bleeding, and I'm being told that I need stitches. So
- 15:18the nurse I grabs the phone and she was like, yeah, I'm a
- 15:20nurse and he really needs stitches. So Colin takes me to the emergency room.
- 15:24I get my stitches and we come back because we thought maybe the show
- 15:28is still going on by the time that I get done with my stitches.
- 15:31We come back and they were like tearing down everything. The merch table is
- 15:35starting to get torn down, and the band was right there, Disciple and
- 15:37they were like, um, you guys are a little late for this show,
- 15:41and we're like no, no, no. We were there and then
- 15:43like this happened at the point to my stitches and they're like what and they're
- 15:46like, did that happen at our show? And we're like, yeah,
- 15:48that happened at your show, and so then they gave me a free CD.
- 15:50So it was pretty cool. It was probably the most metal moment at
- 15:54any Disciple show, so that's true. It's true, all right. So
- 16:00Disciple is going on to the second round. The next matchup, so who
- 16:04they'll go against is either between Hawk Nelson and Bibo Norman, so A four.
- 16:11I find this one hilarious. This is really really funny and very convincingly
- 16:17Hawk Nelson wins, which does not surprise me at all. I don't think
- 16:19there's any surprise here. Honestly, I forgot that Bibo Norman was even on
- 16:23Tooth and Nail, like for what a couple albums. Yeah, I forgot
- 16:29that too, to be honest, until I was researching this. That was
- 16:33a hilarious matchup. But Hawk Nelson moves on and they'll be going against Disciple.
- 16:40Yeah. I was pretty surprised that even Bibo Norman would even make this
- 16:44tournament. But he must streaming numbers must be really big or what. Well,
- 16:48I put him in because um, I wanted some of the more mainstream
- 16:52CCM followers of mine to have a little bit more interest in it than they
- 16:57would have more variety. Yeah, if you know, somebody else had had
- 17:02been in that spot. So but apparently there weren't many people who were interested
- 17:07in him being there. That is true, just true, all right.
- 17:11So the next matchup, and I honestly I don't even know one of these
- 17:15artists. Project eighty six versus ten seventh? What is this Seventh Time Down?
- 17:22Well, seventh Time Down. I don't think I've ever heard this artist
- 17:26in my life who is Seventh Time Down. They are kind of like a
- 17:32I've not listened to a whole other stuff. From what I gather, they're
- 17:34kind of like a rock worship kind of kind of like Seventh Day Slumbers,
- 17:38more worship full stuff. But one of their songs has like two hundred million
- 17:44streams or something like that. So what years were they on Tooth and Nail?
- 17:48Um, It's it's been recent. I think like they're they're they're big
- 17:52song. I think came out like twenty nineteen or something like that. Really,
- 17:55yeah, I am completely unfamiliar, but I think partly because there's such
- 18:00a new artist to Tooth and Nail, and Project eighty six is such a
- 18:04storied artist on tooth and Nail. Yeah, they just absolutely demolished them ninety
- 18:11percent to ten percent. That's uh, there's a there's no gonna there's not
- 18:15gonna be a recount for this one. Let's put it that one. Definitely
- 18:18not Florida anyway, any thoughts around Project eighty six. Eighty six just absolutely
- 18:23dominating right away. I suppose we'll come back around, we can share some
- 18:26more stories with Project eighty six. But yeah, yeah, this isn't a
- 18:30surprise to me. I don't know eric was a surprise to you at all.
- 18:33Uh. No, I actually had seventh time down as the sixteen seed
- 18:37until talking with the source, and I was talked into them being higher.
- 18:45So I didn't really expect a lot from them. I bet you you probably
- 18:48get a lot of hate for how you seedd uh these artists. I always
- 18:56do this one, um, this one. I actually think that I've had
- 19:00least less height about this one out of any of the three so far.
- 19:06Yeah, I mean, like I don't disagree so much with some of the
- 19:08seeding. I mean there's like a few where I'm like I would have like,
- 19:11maybe that put that one a little higher or lower or whatever. But
- 19:15for the most part, I do generally agree with your seeding, so I
- 19:18think you're pretty good on that. All right, So next one is cutless
- 19:23versus nine lashes. Cutlass easily wins against nine lashes. I feel I know
- 19:30what cutlass sounds like, is nine lashes kind of a cutlass sea sounding man
- 19:33too, right, I'm not really familiar with them. Yeah, I think
- 19:37they're a little bit heavier. I've not listened to a whole lot. Yeah,
- 19:40just maybe skillet type disciple. Right, It is remarkable how many of
- 19:47those artists are on tooth and nail And again, like these are artists that
- 19:52are they happen to be on tooth and nail, but they're not beloved by
- 19:55tooth and nail fans really, right, Like Seventh Day Slumber is one of
- 19:59those cut list I feel like maybe a little bit more than others, but
- 20:02nine Lashes, this Seventh Time Down band, Like, there are a lot
- 20:07of these bands that have that kind of like sort of a butt rock sound.
- 20:11I don't know how else to like describe it, but they have a
- 20:14butt rock sound and literally you could be any band with a butt rock sound,
- 20:18even on Tooth and Nail, and you will become a massive band.
- 20:22It's unbelievable how successful those bands end up becoming. Yeah, they've clearly done
- 20:30pretty well with switching from pure album sales to streaming as far as signing these
- 20:37kinds of bands because they're streaming. Numbers are ridiculous for these kinds of bands.
- 20:42Well, that's our friend Jeremy Schaeffer, who has his own recording studio.
- 20:47He says a lot of a lot of the bands that come in and
- 20:51work with him are like that active rock kind of sound, and he says,
- 20:55you would be surprised at how many more album sales they will have compared
- 20:59to anything the Earth Owns does, which is his band, or or anything
- 21:03in that realm. It's just it's just so much more palatable to the general
- 21:06audience. And those guys who wear like the clean Hands dirty or dirty dirty
- 21:11Hands, clean money shirts or whatever. You know. Yeah, it's it's
- 21:15it's directed towards them. But that is a larger proportion of the population than
- 21:19I think what we often give it credit for. So Cutlass defeats nine Lashes,
- 21:26and we'll face up against Project eighty six in the second round. Next
- 21:30one Plink Eye versus Manifest. I saw this maybe a couple of years ago.
- 21:36I remember Manifest being like this white Canadian rapper guy, and maybe I
- 21:41listened to a song or two back when he first got signed to Tooth and
- 21:45Nail, but I looked him up like having just totally he was off my
- 21:49radar for probably like ten years at least, and then looked him up one
- 21:53day because I was like, oh, that's an artist. I remember like,
- 21:56this is probably one of those rappers that you know, did like a
- 22:00Tooth and Nail album or two and then like called it quits and probably has
- 22:04maybe a few hundred monthly listeners on Spotify. How wrong could I event he
- 22:11is massive on Spotify. I had no idea that he got as big as
- 22:15he did. But also Plink Eye again is one of those bands that even
- 22:18though they might not be big and streaming streaming numbers, they are beloved,
- 22:22especially by older Tooth and Nail fans, And so this is a tough matchup
- 22:26against Manifest, and ultimately plink I actually pretty handily wins, but I still
- 22:33cannot believe how big manifests got after I totally forgot about him. Yeah,
- 22:38he did a bunch of stuff with like Toby Mack and stuff like that.
- 22:41Right, is that what is that where he kind of got his start if
- 22:44I remember right? It likely. I do know he had one song that
- 22:48was big that I didn't even know. It was kind of like a pump
- 22:52up type song, but I remember hearing that maybe in like the late early
- 22:56two tens or late two thousands or something, but I remember that song being
- 23:00pretty big, and even on Spotify. I think it's one of his bigger
- 23:03songs. But I just cannot but I mean, he's got several hundreds of
- 23:07thousands of monthly listeners. I mean he he's still probably make an entire career
- 23:11just out of music. Yeah, yeah, it has to be. I
- 23:14think it was. I think when I was researching it, he had a
- 23:18let's see, nine hundred and six thousand monthly listeners, almost a million monthly
- 23:22listeners. Yeah, almost for this guy who you would totally think that would
- 23:26have fizzled out immediately. But yeah, he's made it that, he's made
- 23:30it. That's more monthly listeners and like your than like your one hit wonders
- 23:34from the nineties, right, Yeah, let's see, Yeah some of them.
- 23:38Yeah, certainly, he probably had about the third most monthly listeners of
- 23:45any arts done here. I bet Manifest has more monthly listeners. I bet
- 23:48Manifest has twice as many monthly listeners as Rusted Route. Yeah probably all right.
- 23:57Plank guy, though, ultimately prevails. Even though we've been talking about
- 24:00the NFS, I do really like plank I actually a lot. They were
- 24:04one of those bands that had such a quintessential eighty like late nineties sound that
- 24:10fits so perfectly in Tooth and Nail. And again they were beloved. I
- 24:12mean people loved plank I, big following, huge following. Still listening to
- 24:18them today, a lot of people do. So they would honestly, they
- 24:21would be if if Furnace Best brought them back, they would be au they
- 24:26would be a headliner on that one kind of emo indie stage. I bet
- 24:29Colin I guarantee it. Yeah. Maybe maybe not quite a headliner, but
- 24:33they'd be. Uh, they'd be. They'd be towards the top of the
- 24:37list for sure. I mean, they are that beloved. But anyway,
- 24:40plank I ultimately prevails. Who are they going to be matched up against?
- 24:45Well, because either gonna be Oc super Tones or Citizens. This does feel
- 24:49like kind of a one of those matchups where it's just totally outmatched. Uh
- 24:55Oc super Tunes Again, such a beloved band in the Tooth and Nail world,
- 25:00and Citizens is just so new that it's hard to like build up that
- 25:03cult following that you really need for a tournament like this. But Citizens,
- 25:07aren't they kind of more I don't and I haven't really listened to that much.
- 25:11Are they kind of more of one of those worshipee kind of artists?
- 25:14Yeah, they came out of the Mars Hill uh kind of worship band.
- 25:18Uh. So they're like King's Kleidoscope then, yeah, I think they don't
- 25:22quote me on that. I think I think they came from I know they
- 25:26were. They were, you know, in that same kind of scene with
- 25:29King's Collis Scope. So maybe I just assumed they came from. Okay,
- 25:32maybe not. But nonetheless they're one of those bands that, again, they
- 25:36just are I think probably too new, and especially these worship bands or mostly
- 25:41worship bands that were a part of Tooth and Nail. They might have done
- 25:45well saleswise, but the fan base is going to is going to be more
- 25:49passionate about a band like OC super Tones, and certainly that was the case.
- 25:53So OC super Tones moves on and they will be competing against plink Eye
- 25:59in the next round. All right. So that's one region. Now we
- 26:03move on to the next region. Do we want to go bottom right,
- 26:06Cullen or where do we want to go here? Yeah? We might as
- 26:08well, all right, So now we're on the bottom right region. Number
- 26:12one seed versus number sixteen seed under Oath versus O Sleeper. This is one
- 26:18where I thought O Sleeper was probably this is where I would have disagreed with
- 26:22some of your seeding here. O Sleeper still probably has a like maybe one
- 26:26hundred thousand or more monthly listeners, and they're also beloved by tooth and nail
- 26:32bands. I thought they would be higher than a sixteen seed, not to
- 26:37say that they should be higher than maybe like a thirteen seed or something,
- 26:40But I was really shocked when I saw this matchup, and I honestly thought
- 26:45that this could be closer than maybe, you know, as much as under
- 26:49Oath is so beloved, like there are a lot of O Sleeper fans out
- 26:52there, and I thought it might be a little bit closer for a one
- 26:55versus sixteen matchup, but ultimately under Oath prevails and I didn't. I didn't
- 27:00fill out of bracket, but I would have had under earthcoing to the championships,
- 27:04so this would have this would have for sure been a pick for under
- 27:07Oath for me, even though I really like Oh Sleeper. Any thoughts on
- 27:10this one, I would agree with you, Mason. Yeah, I am
- 27:14kind of surprised that they were sixteen seed, but looking at the rest of
- 27:17the seedings here, it does make sense because there's a lot of bands kind
- 27:21of in that same realm as own Sleeper. Um, you know, if
- 27:25you're talking like hasa Day or Silent Plant or Fit for a King, Like,
- 27:27they're all kind of in that same I would say echelon, but they're
- 27:33so close you got to see them somewhere. So I get this sixteen seed.
- 27:37That's yeah, I think you can make a case for them up to
- 27:40about thirteen. Um, I definitely probably should have had them at least fifteen
- 27:45or fourteen. But before seating becoming the Archetypes. One of those fans that
- 27:51I felt like I had a lot of fans of who were, you know,
- 27:56followers of mine on Twitter, so I kind of gave them the benefit
- 27:59of the doubt there. Then once I released the bracket, I realized,
- 28:00oh, I got a lot of those Sleeper fans here too, So yeah,
- 28:03that was a that was a miss seed on my part. Anytime we've
- 28:07talked to Jason and Seth from becoming the archetype, they really put themselves really
- 28:12below in that echelon of those metal those metal bands on Solid State, and
- 28:18I guarantee that they would have put O Sleeper higher than them, just knowing
- 28:25they're also they're also annoyingly humble. Wow, that's true. That's true.
- 28:30But anyway, I honestly it was a tough matchup for me because I really
- 28:34do like Oh Sleepers. You know, Under Oath is one of my favorite
- 28:37bands of all time, and so obviously I was gonna pick them, but
- 28:40for a one versus sixteen seed, I wish it would have been an easier
- 28:42choice for me, But ultimately I picked Under Oath. And it's tough to
- 28:47see O Sleeper, you know, they I feel like they are a band
- 28:49that at least deserves to be in the second round, and so it's tough
- 28:52that they got such a hard matchup right away. But anyway, I would
- 28:55go as so far as to say it everything in this section of the bracket
- 28:59is there's no easy there's no easy ones in this section of the bracket.
- 29:03They're all gonna be difficult. And I'm just realizing this. This part of
- 29:07the bracket is almost all, if not all, exclusively Solid State bands,
- 29:11right, yeah, this is yeah solid State posts post nineties or at least
- 29:15are released something in the in the two thousands or tens on solid State right
- 29:19sure, yeah? What how did you kind of was there thought going on
- 29:23in these regions? Like how how did you kind of figure regions stuff out?
- 29:29Like? Because there clearly are themes in each one of these regions.
- 29:32Yeah. Yeah. The top left is uh is nineties artis who released stuff
- 29:37in the nineties. Um, I wanted there. The main reason that I
- 29:42separated them into categories is because the numbers and stuff of the nineties artists are
- 29:48just not comparable with right, with the newer artists, So I decided to
- 29:53make a region for that. So I just decided to also do one for
- 29:59for EC And then on the bottom left is the two thousands and tens tooth
- 30:04and nail Um and then on the bottom right solid state. So you have
- 30:11the b EC at the top right crackt. But was oc super Tones a
- 30:15BEC band? H Yep they were, Oh I didn't realize that, Okay,
- 30:19huh? And yeah, Hawk Nelson was later on with their more worshiping
- 30:25stuff that would make interesting and Disciple was too. Yeah some some of them.
- 30:30You know, we're back and forth between a couple of the the Um
- 30:34labels. So just kind of what whatever I had extra room for for man,
- 30:41that's kind of where U where slotted the minute. I think it makes
- 30:45perfect sense, man, all right, So under Oath moves on, probably
- 30:51expected to at least the second round, so second matchup in that region.
- 30:56He's the Day versus Silent Planet then is a tough one for a lot of
- 31:00people. But say He's the Day. I thought this was gonna be really
- 31:04really close. He's the Day pretty convincingly one. I don't remember if I
- 31:08voted He's the Day or Silent Planet. I love both bands a lot,
- 31:11and this was probably in the first round one of the harder picks for me,
- 31:17but I ended up again. I don't know who it was, but
- 31:21obviously Hasta Day pretty convincingly one. Any thoughts around this one this one makes
- 31:26perfect sense to me as well. Um, yeah, like Silent Planet's big
- 31:32now, they've had some killer, killer albums and they have a kind of
- 31:34that cult falling, but so does Hasta Day, and they've just been around
- 31:37a little longer, so I think it makes sense. Yeah, I wasn't,
- 31:41honestly, I wasn't real sure which which way that one would go.
- 31:45Just I don't I don't have a spirm of a grasp on the modern metal
- 31:48course scene as I did in the you know, in the two thousands,
- 31:53So I kind of wasn't sure what kind of numbers Silent Planet, which you're
- 31:56full, but sure, Well, hast to Day we'll be at Furnace Fests
- 32:01year. Also, Eric, are you gonna be at Fernace Festus year?
- 32:05I don't think I'm gonna make it this year. Oh I got to meet
- 32:09you guys there last year. Um, and I was there the year before.
- 32:14Um, it's just a lot going on. Shoot. Yeah, well,
- 32:19no hast To Day reunion for you. No, we'll see in twenty
- 32:23right hopefully. All right, cool, we'll try to make sure that that
- 32:29actually happened. So all right, So hast to Day versus under Oath,
- 32:31that's gonna be a fun matchup. Next one Fit for a King versus Acidities
- 32:37Burned. Again. Here's one of these things where it's like as Cities Burned
- 32:40really has a cult following among tooth and nail people. I mean they they
- 32:45they were right in that same era that Under Oath was getting big, and
- 32:50Acidities Burned was such a such a beloved band at that time, and uh,
- 32:55Fit for a King their numbers are big, they're huge, but they
- 33:00don't have quite the cult following that Acidities Burn does, and Acidities Burned pretty
- 33:06convincingly beats Fit for a King as a twelve seed over a five seed,
- 33:10which I think might surprise some people, But honestly, Acidies Burn really does
- 33:15have that cult following. Honestly, I'm one of those people we've we've interviewed
- 33:19Fit for a King. They're great, wonderful, but Acidities Burn is one
- 33:22of my favorite bands of all time. Yeah. Same. You compare the
- 33:25streaming numbers Fit for a King monthly listeners nine hundred and sixty four thousand,
- 33:31two sides Burns thirty nine thousand, it's hard to believe that that might be.
- 33:39I would be really curious to see in these matchups. What is the
- 33:45biggest disparity between streaming numbers, and especially if there's an upset with one of
- 33:52those, that would be this might be one of the biggest ones. That's
- 33:57incredible. It's it's hard to believe that acids burn has that few of streaming
- 34:01numbers, and I can I think of them as like in that two thousands
- 34:07era of especially Solid State. I think of them as one of the bigger
- 34:12bands, and it is really hard to believe that they just weren't able to
- 34:15like make it over that hump in a lot of you know, in comparison
- 34:20to some of those other Solid State bands. It's really hard to believe.
- 34:23Yeah, but I think there's another like instance in which you can look at
- 34:28the Spotify numbers and it's it's one of those that will lie to you.
- 34:30It's a number that will lie to you, right, because I do think
- 34:35that they're that they're probably worth more than thirty nine thousand streams. Maybe more
- 34:38people are listening on CD or on vinyl or right something else, maybe on
- 34:45MP three players or iPods. I don't know, but I can't believe that
- 34:49they have such few. There are several that really surprised me. Like having
- 34:54under ten thousand strength Plank Eyes studies like are both under ten thousand monthly listeners.
- 35:00Wow, yeah, that blows my mind. But here's the thing.
- 35:02Each one of those people, if let's say, if like Stave Saker or
- 35:06plank I went on tour right now, each one of those people would for
- 35:08sure go and buy a ticket. So, like, you know that you
- 35:12have roughly ten thousand tickets, you know, in comparison to a band like
- 35:15Fit for a King, who has almost a million monthly listeners, I guarantee
- 35:17you that most of those million people would not buy a ticket right now to
- 35:22see ye Fit for a King. Well, and we see that. We
- 35:24see that with our downloads on the podcast too. I mean we'll have on
- 35:28like the guitars from skid Row and that one does half as good as when
- 35:34we have Derek Webbon for instance. It's just it's like what it's surprises,
- 35:37It makes sense. But yeah, that there is something about like kind of
- 35:42that cult following thing that happens. It's really interesting. Yeah, I mean
- 35:46Stave Sacre is probably one of our bigger episodes I would say maybe like top
- 35:50ten or so, you know, and we've had Fit for a king on
- 35:54and I bet, I bet they have more monthly listener you know, Stave
- 35:58Sakers had more downloads in Fit for a King From and there's a lot of
- 36:04other factors to that, but it is it does say that, you know,
- 36:07if if a band is willing to share an episode, uh share our
- 36:10episode, though, you can tell what bands have the cult following. I
- 36:15mean, it's just it's clear as day, all right, So that is
- 36:21uh, sorry, We're I'm twelve. Now we're onto demon Hunter versus Demon
- 36:27Hunter versus He is Legend. Obviously, I know what you would pick,
- 36:31Cullen, Yeah, this one, this one's so like mean to But actually
- 36:37I was really surprised that Demon Hunter was this low. Demon Hunter is one
- 36:39of those bands that has actually like pretty good streaming numbers and has a very
- 36:45dedicated tooth and nail following, and so that I was really shocked by the
- 36:52fact that they were a number four seed. I'm not like the biggest Demon
- 36:54Hunter fan, so I wouldn't have like put them probably really any higher,
- 36:58but just personally, but it was shocking that they were at number four.
- 37:02But this is a tough matchup for He is Legend and ultimately demon Hunter wins
- 37:08pretty convincingly. Yeah, I find this one kind of unfortunate because if you
- 37:14think about like like he his legend for instance, had songs on like video
- 37:20games and stuff like that, and and in movies even and for some reason
- 37:27like their popularity even though like they had that cult following just like demon Hunter
- 37:30does. Um, their popularity never really took off quite the same way as
- 37:36Demon Hunter. But demon Hunter doesn't really have a song that like everyone knows
- 37:39either, So right, it's it's it's a goofy one to me, it
- 37:44is, what do you think about that? Um, I'm streaming as far
- 37:49as all these bands in this region, uh streaming wise, there were five
- 37:53the top five seeds as significantly more streams than any of the ones underneath.
- 38:00Um, so I'm not surprised that demon Hunter, who has five times the
- 38:07strings of his legend one. And I feel like kind of his legend has
- 38:10that. You know, I'm I'm Hollywood's a really beloved album. But yeah,
- 38:16I think demon Hunter. One thing I learned through someone I follow on
- 38:21Twitter who tweeted, you know, quote tweet with the song that made you
- 38:24a fan of metal, and I think second to Living Sacrifice was demon Hunters
- 38:30with number of people who SITS, so I think they're they're a gateway band
- 38:35for a lot of people that I could see that, which is interesting to
- 38:37me because they're not really that accessible through a lot of most people, you
- 38:42know, but you know, the United States military beloves them, so there's
- 38:47a there's a multi billion dollar funding for the defense they've got, They've got
- 38:54a lot of backing that. Actually that actually reminds me of something I've thought
- 39:00through, is what's cool about these tournaments that you've been doing, Eric,
- 39:05is there have been enough people engaging in it where I think you could actually
- 39:09make legitimate conclusions about what, like you know about what's happening in these tournaments.
- 39:17You know, it would be one thing if like five people were voting
- 39:21and that's it, But you have several thousand people and I don't remember what
- 39:27like the whole like kind of standard for like making sociological conclusions is. But
- 39:31you're getting enough people where it's probably you're starting to get really close to making
- 39:36some conclusions sociologically about some of these bands, which is really interesting because you
- 39:40just have so much engagement with these with these tournaments. So that's really cool,
- 39:45is that like you could probably like, like, if somebody were to
- 39:49do a PhD on tooth and nail history, they could probably actually cite this
- 39:52as a legitimate source because of how many people are engaging in it. That
- 39:58would be pretty awesome. Well, I'm glad people were into it. So
- 40:01demon Hunter beats out. He is legend. Really unfortunate pick for just an
- 40:07unfortunate draw, for he is legend. I really like he is legend much
- 40:10more than demon Hunter, but it is what it is. This next one
- 40:15that people were bushed with you about this one, this one, this one
- 40:19feels like you definitely hand your you had your hand in this, uh this
- 40:23selection, but Norman Jean versus the Cherry Yet people were so mad at you
- 40:30for this. This was awesome and it actually ended up Actually I wasn't surprised.
- 40:37Actually, I really thought that wherever the Chariot was gonna be on this,
- 40:42I don't think they were gonna make it out of the first round,
- 40:45likely unless they got it like a really easy draw versus like some band like
- 40:50I don't know, Likethold or something. But I really was not thinking that
- 40:55the Chariot was going to get out of the first round anyway, Even though
- 40:59they're my favorite band of all time. But the fact that you put them
- 41:01against Norma Jean, Oh you did it dirty, Eric, Yeah, I'm
- 41:09sure you had a hand in that, right. I thought it would be
- 41:12fun. Um most people did not, but I think Norma Jane had to
- 41:20be the six um, so I was. I was figuring the chariot anywhere
- 41:24between nine and you know, twelve or so, so I was like,
- 41:30yeah, i'd be kind of This is also, again a seating thing where
- 41:32I was really surprised that Norma Jean was this low in terms of obviously streaming
- 41:37numbers. Norma Jeane isn't going to be quite as big as like a Fit
- 41:39for a King or whatever. But Norma Jean is kind of like kind of
- 41:45this perfect mix of a band where they're just big enough where they do have
- 41:49pretty decent streaming numbers, like I bet they're probably over two hundred thousand monthly
- 41:52listeners two hundred and nine thousand, yeah, and they're also like each one
- 41:57of those people are probably going to buy an album them or actually go to
- 42:00one of their shows, Like they have pretty large shows for the most part
- 42:05if they play a big enough city. And I was a little surprised then
- 42:08that they would be a number six seed, you know, in comparison to
- 42:12like other number six seeds like Copeland, Like Copeland is not going to be
- 42:15drawing the same people at a crowd as Norma Geene is. Or who else
- 42:20did you have as a sixteed Project eighty six? Maybe slick Shoes, probably
- 42:24not. But anyway, there were some other six seeds where I'm like,
- 42:28Norma Jeene seems to be a way better six seed than all the other six
- 42:30seeds, which to me was like, maybe they should have been a little
- 42:34higher. I could see Norma Jeene being like a number three seed maybe,
- 42:37But anyway that I was a little surprised how low they actually were on that
- 42:42it didn't feel right putting them there. But like I said, the top
- 42:45fives streaming numbers were so much more than the next the next set, and
- 42:53you know, really all I have to go buys is that and just a
- 42:57general impression of people. And it was also kind of hard to compare the
- 43:01the newer the newer bands like Fit for a King with somebody like Norma Jeene,
- 43:06because like I said, I uh, ashamedly, I'm not as into
- 43:12the medical we're seen as I used to be, so I don't really have
- 43:15a feel for how dedicated the fans of a band like Fit for a King
- 43:19are. Sure, Yeah, I mean I understand the case for them to
- 43:24be higher, but like um, the Devil wors Product, August Burns read
- 43:29under Oath all uh have you know, way more streams and probably um that
- 43:37makes sense, and especially if this region is going to be like more of
- 43:39a solid state region, I get from like a streaming standpoint to have them
- 43:44a little lower. But I do think, like Norma Jean in comparison to
- 43:47some of these other ones, like they're they deserve to be higher. If
- 43:52if it was completely intermixed, I think they would have been higher. But
- 43:54anyway, that's that's my only gripe with that one. Honestly, I think
- 43:59I probably voted for the Chariot just because they're my favorite band, but also,
- 44:01like I would say, Norma Jean might be like a top five favorite
- 44:05artist of all time for me, So like you know, this is like
- 44:07really like you know, trying to choose your favorite child type of thing.
- 44:10I'm surprised it was such a such a wide margin of difference. I wasn't
- 44:16expecting it to be seventy thirty. You know, I was expecting it to
- 44:19be closer to like a fifty fifty draw, so kind of a kind of
- 44:22an impressive one to me, I don't know. All right, So Norma
- 44:28Jean moves on and they will be competing against either August Burns Rad or Wolves
- 44:32at the Gate. August Burns RAD number three. That makes sense to me
- 44:37that, I mean, they are such a big band in that world.
- 44:39It wasn't interesting that Wolves at the Gate even got into this. But you
- 44:42know, Wolves at the Gate does have pretty good streaming numbers, and so
- 44:45we've interviewed them once and great, great, great folks. But yeah,
- 44:52I feel like August Burns Rad versus Wolves at the Gate that seems like kind
- 44:57of a countessential matchup of like what I would expect a three versus fourteen with
- 45:00these two bands. And also August Burns read wins in as what I would
- 45:06consider as much of a convincing fashion as it should be with Wolves at the
- 45:08Gate. So yeah, this feels like a very quintessential. This is exactly
- 45:14how you would expect this matchup to go. Yep, yeah, Wolves at
- 45:17the Gate. Um they had they had the streaming numbers worth worth being there.
- 45:22But also I know, like my friends who write for Jesus Freak hide
- 45:25Out and stuff are a real big fans of them. So I knew that
- 45:29I had some some wolves at the gate devotees, yeah, involved in this,
- 45:36So that's kind of why I put them in there. There's some of
- 45:37the more vocal fans on online from what I've seen too, h so they've
- 45:44definitely got that cult like following starting to starting to boil up. Also,
- 45:47speaking of Jesus Freak hide Out, we need to get those folks on this
- 45:51podcast calling that's a great point. I don't know, we haven't even thought
- 45:53about that. We should do that. They're all great guys. You Eric,
- 45:58you could you connect them with us and we'll make that happen. That
- 46:00would be my whole like gateway into all of this was mostly because of Jesus
- 46:06Free Cude Out. So that would be it'd be it would be an honor
- 46:08for both Colin and I'm all right. So August Burns Red versus Norma Jean
- 46:13in the second round. What a hell of a matchup right there, all
- 46:15right? So next one in this region, Living Sacrifice Number seventh Seed versus
- 46:21Dead Poetic, This one surprised the hell out of me. This does not
- 46:25surprise me who wins? But I yeah, this this also feels like this
- 46:30is so close because Dead Poetic still is actually has really great streaming numbers honestly,
- 46:37which which surprises that surprises me so so much. I would it is
- 46:42shocking that I do think like Dead Poetic with their streaming numbers. I think
- 46:46it really signifies, or at least it tells the story that they could have
- 46:51been so much bigger had they not quit so early. But versus Living Sacrifice,
- 46:57I mean Living Sacrifice. If Colin, if we got Live Sacrifice on
- 47:00and they actually shared the episode, it'd probably be one of our biggest I
- 47:02mean, that's how dedicated this fan base is. So it was actually pretty
- 47:07close. Fifty four percent Living Sacrifice versus forty six percent Dead Poetic. It
- 47:10was pretty close. But yeah, this was a pretty tough matchup. And
- 47:16uh, I don't remember who I voted. I mean maybe I voted Dead
- 47:19Poetic, but uh, this was something else. Yeah, the next round,
- 47:22the next round will will make that even more interesting there, so I'm
- 47:28excited to talking about that. I was just gonna say Living Sacrifice the Dead
- 47:30Poetics one that was one of the toughest ones for me, because they're both
- 47:34probably top twenty five bands all time. I wow, Yeah, like you
- 47:38said, I think did Poetic they were on the verge of being I mean
- 47:44they really had the same sound as Thursday, and you know, Thursday really
- 47:49blew up in that world. And Thursday still has a very dedicated following.
- 47:52We interviewed their their drummer a while back, and he's great, and Thursday
- 47:57is so big and to me, like that sound at that time was so
- 48:00big, and it's just it's hard to believe that it Like they could they
- 48:05could have been big, but you know, for a variety of reasons,
- 48:07just didn't make it. Yeah, all right, So Living Sacrifice moves on
- 48:12last un or last matchup of this region, the Devil Wears product versus Becoming
- 48:17the Archetype. I this, I think I don't remember who I voted for
- 48:25on this. Honestly, Becoming the Archetype has a very underrated fan base,
- 48:34let's just put it that way. Like, I think they do have a
- 48:37cult following, and I don't think people really recognize how big their cult following
- 48:39actually is. But obviously Double Wars product is so big in this world.
- 48:46And I've got another point to make in a second, but I'll let you
- 48:49guys say a thing about this matchup. But anyway, I thought this was
- 48:52just a tough matchup for becoming the Archetype, very tough. I think that
- 48:58Devil worst product. It's not it's not present they win. Becoming the archetype
- 49:02is just such a um they're such like an outlier in this group because they're
- 49:08they're doing something very different than any of these other bands. Um So I
- 49:13think anyone that they get put up against, they probably don't win in this
- 49:16in this whole section, this whole region, I should say, but I
- 49:21think that they probably deserve to win. So I don't know. It's a
- 49:23tough one. Yeah, they're a great band, and they're one of the
- 49:28I think what Brandon Ebel would refer to as a cred band. They may
- 49:31not have, you know, the yeah, the massive number of fans that
- 49:37a lot of the other the other bands do, but they're clearly an incredible
- 49:42band. And it was down as far as putting who in the tournament,
- 49:46it was it was down between Becoming the Archetype, O Sleeper and Phineas for
- 49:52the last three spots for me and uh Phineas had the best streaming numbers of
- 49:57the three, but I wouldn't. I thought became arch type deserves to be
- 50:00there so well. In their new album, they put on vinyl and it
- 50:04sold out immediately, which again tells you it's it's hard for a lot of
- 50:07tooth and nail bands to sell vinyl right now unless they're like a really dedicated
- 50:13you know, have a dedicated cult following and clearly becoming the archetype. Does
- 50:16I mean they literally sold out that vinyl really really quickly. They had to
- 50:22do a repress already. Yeah, exactly, yeah, yeah, never exactly.
- 50:28One thing. I'll just mention about this bracket because it was the solid
- 50:30state bracket or the solid State region in this bracket. I because Colin,
- 50:37we did the two thousands Metalcore episode the tournament a few months ago, and
- 50:42I think we had sixteen teams in that if I remember right, and it's
- 50:45all the best like two thousands metalcore bands. I bet a third to half
- 50:52of those bands were tooth and nail bands that are in this bracket right now.
- 50:57In one region you have like five, six, maybe even seven bands
- 51:02that are also literally considered some of the best two thousands metalcore bands, regardless
- 51:08of it's Christian or not. That like, this is an incredibly competitive bracket
- 51:14in terms of the style and scene of music that it's in, and so
- 51:17it was really cutthroat and it's but it's still as a testament of how dominant
- 51:22a Christian label was in a particular genre of music. It still blows my
- 51:27mind that that was a thing that happened historically in Christian music. I just
- 51:32it's still I can't believe it that a bunch of metalcore bands, a Christian
- 51:37metalcore bands, dominated the non Christian music scene in that scene for a good
- 51:44ten years. It's unbelievable to me. It's got to be the only time
- 51:47in recent history that Christians have kind of, you know, led the way
- 51:52in a subset of music. Yeah. And the irony of it is that
- 51:55it's the most Unchristian sounding music poet, Yeah, which is that to me
- 52:00is the hilarious thing about it. That's probably why it was so attractive.
- 52:05And then once it became kind of like the standard of the norm or the
- 52:08expected from Christian alternative, um, well, then all of a sudden it's
- 52:14no longer no longer the hip thing you know is something else? All right?
- 52:20Should we move on to top left, top left? Yeah, that's
- 52:23right, nineties tooth and Nail, solid state bands, all right, this
- 52:27one, this one's I'm excited for this one, all right? So number
- 52:30one seed undoubtedly like this totally makes sense. Mx p X versus number sixteen,
- 52:37number sixteen seed strong Arm pretty dominating one versus sixteen. Right here,
- 52:44MxPx pretty much dominates strong Arm, although strong Arm does have a pretty dedicated
- 52:50following. But it is hard to beat mx PX and something like this.
- 52:54This is pretty pretty h pretty typical. I wasn't overly surprised this one.
- 53:00Yeah, he XPX made the final four of the big CCM tournament. I
- 53:05did with bands of all genres and labels, so I pretty much expected them
- 53:10to do really well, understandably. So all right, so mx PX moves
- 53:16on to second round. Uh. Next one, Goady Hook versus stretch Armstrong
- 53:22eight verses nine seed. Uh. This is one that, again like two
- 53:25nineties bands that I didn't really grew up listening to. Uh, Colin,
- 53:30you're more of a you like Gody Hook, Right, I did like Gody
- 53:32Hook. I had all the Gody Hook albums. Yeah, definitely listened a
- 53:36lot of Goady Hook dig dig It dig It It's which is sort of surprising
- 53:40me because like, you're not typically like, that's not your typical genre of
- 53:44music right now, That's that's not my go too. I'm not a I'm
- 53:46not like a huge punk fan by any means, but I don't know they
- 53:50had they had a little something extra special. I felt like that, right,
- 53:53Yeah, it drew me to it. Yeah, and Goady Hook wins
- 53:58pretty convincingly. I mean fifty nine verses. I thought, yeah, I
- 54:04thought stretch Armstrong would win because when likes best, you would think it's the
- 54:07Rolling Stones, right exact lins for March, you know, a mile long
- 54:14and things like that. If we're talking about cult followings, um, Stretch
- 54:19Armstrong is by far. They're They're in like the Mount Rushmore on this list
- 54:23of terms of like cult followings because they're cult is so small they're called is
- 54:28just too small exactly, Yeah, all right. Next one Star Flyer fifty
- 54:32nine versus Extol. This is for especially for culin. This is a of
- 54:38a stating matchup. This is almost as bad as normal Gene versus the Chariot,
- 54:43But I am shocked on it. This is one of the ones where
- 54:46I really I could have seen either one of these artists winning. What I'm
- 54:52shocked by is how much star Flyer fifty nine one this eighty percent to twenty
- 54:59percent sent for Xtel. Extel I think really does have a cult following.
- 55:02I mean, there are a lot of metal artists that we talked to,
- 55:05especially those who grew up in the tooth and nail solid state world, that
- 55:08they talk about Extol religiously as a huge influence on them. So I thought
- 55:14Extel had at least put up a fight. They need to put up a
- 55:16fight. Yeah, that that blows my mind, especially since like like just
- 55:21like listening to the Furnace Fest folks um who were trying to you know,
- 55:28get the ear of the promo of the organizers, the one artist that they
- 55:32just continually continuously pounded for was Extol, and star Flower fifty nine is nowhere
- 55:43to be heard, except I did say we should get star Fliwer fit nine
- 55:45there as well. But you know, that's that's that that blows my mind
- 55:51that it was that big of a disparity, because I mean, they're legendary,
- 55:59not just the Christian world, but like elsewhere as well. Yeah,
- 56:01I mean they really we were just talking about like influential Christian artists in particular
- 56:07genres. I mean, Starfler was really early in that shoegaze era in the
- 56:12nineties. I mean, I wouldn't say that they were the originators of shoegaze.
- 56:15I wouldn't even say that they were like the most like popular artists in
- 56:20that nineties shoegaze world, but they were in it and that that at least
- 56:23counts for something as a Tooth and Nail artist, especially when Tooth and Nail
- 56:28first started as a label. It's pretty impressive what they were able to do
- 56:31very early on. Yeah, granted they are a massive band, you know,
- 56:37have that cult following and everything, but the fact that they beat Extel
- 56:39that much just shocks me. Yeah, I feel like the Starfler fifty nine
- 56:45fan base just keeps getting stronger and bigger for no you know, explicable reason
- 56:52really, because because he just keeps making better and better music everything than the
- 56:59last. And its sense. Yeah, he's one artist. Yeah, all
- 57:04right, So star Flyer moves on next one Zao versus Danielson family. This
- 57:10was one again, like Zayo, I would just expecting to win, but
- 57:15I thought maybe Danielson family would at least put up a little bit of fight
- 57:17because since but maybe maybe their followers are like not on Twitter, like I
- 57:22could see their followers like not having any social media, Like they don't even
- 57:24have smartphones, like these are Danielson family fans are like the people who still
- 57:29have flip phones. And uh so I feel like this is a little unfair.
- 57:32Even though I think Zayo would have won regardless, I think it's a
- 57:35little unfair to Danielson family given the nature of who their kind of fans are.
- 57:39I was gonna say that I'm surprised Danilson Family band put up twenty three
- 57:45like that. That that's a pretty good fight against Zao. Does suphi On
- 57:49Stevens like repost you to even get to the twenty three percent? Is that
- 57:52what happened there? Eric, No, that didn't happen. I didn't know
- 57:58what they would do because I mean, like pitch for always praised their albums
- 58:00and things like that. But which is hilarious, that is so that is
- 58:05so funny to me. Hey, we've we've had him on Dan Smith on
- 58:08and he's great he's wonderful. Oh he was. He was a blast.
- 58:12He was a blast. But it's it's hilarious that they would even put up
- 58:15this much of a fight versus Zo. Honestly, I was. I would
- 58:19have thought maybe Zao would have been like a well I see blindside on here.
- 58:22Uh. I could have seen them as like a two or three seed.
- 58:25But again, like I'm just being nick picky there. But all right,
- 58:28so Zeo wins pretty convincingly over Danielson family. They will be competing against
- 58:34Star Flyer fifty nine. That is a hell of a nineties matchup right there.
- 58:37That is that is two very different genres and two very different cult followings
- 58:42that are absolutely going to despise each other. I love that, all right.
- 58:45So next one Slick Shoes versus Bleach. Honestly, I didn't really listen
- 58:50to either one of these bands so much. The only reason why I picked
- 58:53Bleach honestly was Steel Roots had a like they had this song from Bleach that
- 59:00was and I still I can never find it. I've literally looked through every
- 59:04song on Bleach on Spotify. They had a song that Steel Roots used that
- 59:09I to this day, I remember thinking to myself that is one of the
- 59:13coolest, catchiest things I've ever heard and never was able to actually find it
- 59:17because you know, during the stew Roots era, like it was like you
- 59:21had pure volume and that was it. Like this was even before you could
- 59:22search songs on YouTube. So I still have not found this song. So
- 59:28if anybody out there happens to be listening and also knew of Bleach song that
- 59:32was being used on Steer Roots for like some sort of like commercial or like
- 59:37kind of like next programming kind of thing, let me know. Yeah,
- 59:39it was bumping music and it was I know exactly what you're talking about.
- 59:45But I've never been able to find it either. And I'm almost wondering if
- 59:47it was like a one off thing that they did for maybe totally I don't
- 59:52know it totally could I can't believe that Bleach one. I can't believe they
- 59:55won. Really, do you like Slick Shoes that much more? No,
- 1:00:00I don't have like a strong affinity for either of these bands, but the
- 1:00:02fact that's I mean slick Shoes. I hear Slick Shoes mentioned all the time
- 1:00:07from from the community. I don't ever hear Bleach discussed almost ever. And
- 1:00:14so that's that's where I'm surprised that there was enough support for Bleach to come
- 1:00:17out and win that one. I actually get a lot of comments about Bleach,
- 1:00:22and that's that's weird. I'm not really surprised that they won. I
- 1:00:27didn't know how much a residual effect MxPx fans would have on slick shoes,
- 1:00:30so I kind of gave them a little bit of a higher seat based on
- 1:00:35that. That makes sense, all right, So Bleach moves on and we'll
- 1:00:39be competing against either the Juliana Theory or ninety Pounds, and Juliana Theory pretty
- 1:00:46convincingly wins here seventy nine to twenty one percent. It's pretty big. I
- 1:00:53really do like Giuliana Theory much more than ninety Pounds as much as ninety Pound
- 1:00:59was, like was one of those early punk tooth and nail bands. I
- 1:01:02think Juliana Theory just had like such an interesting indie alternative sound at that time,
- 1:01:08and I'm really glad that they won. I'll just put it that way.
- 1:01:10I am too. I think ninety Pounds was there. They were they
- 1:01:15were a part of that early nineties punk sound that wasn't very refined, and
- 1:01:21I think that kind of hurts a long run. Yeah, that's kind of
- 1:01:24where I'm at too. I think the Juliana theory are just more in mab
- 1:01:28wheelhouse of what I enjoy. Yeah, for sure. Man, all right,
- 1:01:32so Juliana theory we'll be coveting against Bleach in the next round. We
- 1:01:37will move on to the next matchup, which is Stave Sacre versus Dogwood.
- 1:01:42This was tough because I've both I love Josh from Dogwood and I also love
- 1:01:49Mark from Stave Sacre. And ultimately I think it was just because I like
- 1:01:53Stave Sacre's music more than Dogwood. I ended up voting Stave Sacre. But
- 1:02:00would I just have a soft spot soft spot in my heart for Josh and
- 1:02:04Dogwood And anyway, two bands I love, and it's hard to pick one
- 1:02:08over the other. Yeah, I liked them both for for completely different reasons,
- 1:02:15Like if I want to listen to Dogwood, I'm in like a like
- 1:02:16a happy, go lucky mood. If I want to listen to Stave Sacre,
- 1:02:20I want to think. So it's like two opposite ends of the coin.
- 1:02:25And I wouldn't have been able to like pick one of these, but
- 1:02:30I probably would have ended up with Stave Sacre and then just because I listened
- 1:02:32to them more often, Staves Acre or the band that made me aware of
- 1:02:37Tooth and Nail records, So I've got oh really wow. Yeah, I
- 1:02:42used to listen to Christian rock gotten it when I first got the internet,
- 1:02:45and uh, keep Waiting came on. I was like, oh, yeah,
- 1:02:49that's a jam. But how long did it take for that? I
- 1:02:51was just about to say, how long did dial up take for that to
- 1:02:53be buffer? Oh? Yeah it was. It was the old day,
- 1:02:57so it was. It took a while. So that was my version of
- 1:03:00streaming. I would request whatever song I wanted to hear in it eventually you
- 1:03:04know, come around. All right, So Staves Saker wins pretty convincingly over
- 1:03:08Dogwood. Uh that's a tough matchup though, for for Dogwood. All right,
- 1:03:13last one in this region, blind Side versus the Huntington's Uh this one
- 1:03:20percent for me blind Side. I'm also like not surprised at all how much
- 1:03:24blind Side won buy. Uh. You know what's really funny about this one,
- 1:03:28just the personal anecdote. Blind Side is on my mountin Rushmore of bands
- 1:03:31I would I would die for them, but I never had a blind side
- 1:03:36poster in my room. I had a Huntington's poster in my room. What,
- 1:03:39yeah, No, you didn't, I totally did. No you didn't,
- 1:03:44I totally did. Do you still have that poster? I don't know
- 1:03:46if I do. It's probably like a bookmark in some books somewhere in my
- 1:03:52in my closet. Year But yeah, I got even I didn't even know
- 1:03:57you even knew of them, not not much like less listen to them,
- 1:04:00like I didn't even know that you knew of them. I had gone to
- 1:04:03youth group with my sister one time when she used to go to a place
- 1:04:06called U Turn in Watertowne and they like they would like give out free CDs,
- 1:04:13so like I got free CDs all the time. The Huntington's was one.
- 1:04:16Um Godie Hook was one. Further seems forever was one. Let me
- 1:04:21think who else? There was a Mean Without You album or it was actually
- 1:04:26like a like a three three CD or three song CD for some reason,
- 1:04:30I don't know what that was. Maybe it's just like a sampler or some
- 1:04:32kind and then like casting crowns and stuff like that, but like it was,
- 1:04:35it was. I loved going to youth group with my sister, because
- 1:04:40I would get free music. I would just screw off the rest of the
- 1:04:43time and then just try to like go grab the music in the back and
- 1:04:45then head out as soon as I could. Um. But yeah, the
- 1:04:50the Huntington's not not very not very cool. Well let's just put it this
- 1:04:55way. You have not staged out of to the Huntington's, but you have
- 1:04:59to Blindside. That's true. That's true. Yes, all right, so
- 1:05:04Blindside moves on. They will They will match up against Stave Sacre here in
- 1:05:09the next round, all right, last region before we get into the second
- 1:05:13round. First matchup, Amberlin versus Spoken. I cannot believe Spoken was number
- 1:05:18sixteen. Spoken has like a good amount of Spotify listeners, right, yeah,
- 1:05:24one twenty one thousand? I think, Yeah, why why sixteen seed
- 1:05:28for Spoken? What uh are you? Are you saying they should have been
- 1:05:31higher? Or I think they should have been way higher? A lot of
- 1:05:35a lot of the other bands in that region have um similar numbers. Yeah,
- 1:05:42I even had to leave some out with like sent By Ravens had almost
- 1:05:45one hundred thousand. What that? Yes, that blows my mind too,
- 1:05:48right, Like that's a band they had like what maybe one maybe two albums
- 1:05:53on ye two albums, I thinks all they had, um so, I
- 1:05:58mean there was Secret and Whisper was the one that I kind of had that
- 1:06:00could have went there. Uh yeah, Spoken went They got there because of
- 1:06:04the streaming numbers. But like I couldn't put them ahead of you know,
- 1:06:08bands like Further Things Forever or right, you know, who have less streaming
- 1:06:13numbers. Yeah, but Spoken Spoken is one of those bands. Again,
- 1:06:16they they're kind of in that like they weren't. I wouldn't say they were
- 1:06:20exactly butt rock, but they kind of they flirted with it. They were
- 1:06:28they were exactly like Collide Skillet Collide era Skillet, Yes, yes, And
- 1:06:33and they got big because of that era. And again it's one of those
- 1:06:36bands where had they been on any other label, I don't know if they
- 1:06:40would have gotten super big, but the fact that they'd had that sound allowed
- 1:06:43them a lot of success clearly. Yeah, they kept going for a long
- 1:06:48time too, which I'm true. Yeah, Number I cannot stand Spoken.
- 1:06:55They played at at Life Light one time and um My, but that I
- 1:07:00was with like pulled me over there, He's like, you gotta see these
- 1:07:03guys. I was like, these guys suck. I'm out. I think
- 1:07:06they were from like Kansas or something. But they had that one music video
- 1:07:11for it was the song was called Promise and it was like in a tractor
- 1:07:16and like a cornfield and like that was the whole like music video. And
- 1:07:19I was like, South Dakota even though they're from Kansas. I liked a
- 1:07:28lot of their early stuff. They put their first one of their first albums
- 1:07:31before Too the Nails. It was like a new metal worship album, which
- 1:07:34it was in ninety nine. Was kind of yeah, it was pretty unique.
- 1:07:41I thought, imagine like Brian head Welch, like playing like good good
- 1:07:45Father or something. All right, all right, So next matchup, further
- 1:07:50Seems Forever versus Family Fours five, eight versus nineteen. I'm actually shocked that
- 1:07:55both of these both of these artists are this low. Now. I now,
- 1:08:00granted, I get that Further Seems Forever has probably way less streaming numbers
- 1:08:04than Family Force five, but honestly, we all know that further Seems Forever
- 1:08:10has a huge cult following in the tooth and Nail world. I'm shocked that
- 1:08:15they aren't like a three or four seed at least. And then also,
- 1:08:17like Family Force five, I feel like was really like I think they were
- 1:08:21actually kind of underrated in that Tooth and Nail seed, Like I wasn't a
- 1:08:26big fan, but I could see a lot of people loving them, and
- 1:08:30so the fact that they are a nine seed really actually surprises me. Both
- 1:08:32of these So anyway, this is a tough matchup and at the end of
- 1:08:38the day, fortunately further seems Forever wins out. Also, did I forget
- 1:08:42to mention that Amberlin wins won the last round? Yeah, we didn't say
- 1:08:45that, but I think, yeah, sorry, Amberlin won the last round
- 1:08:47against Spoken, now you know. But further seems Forever versus Family Force five,
- 1:08:51I'm really shocked by that, honestly, that that would even be the
- 1:08:55matchup. But further seems Forever kind of barely squeak it out here. Furthers
- 1:09:01things. Forever have not done well in my polls, and that's kind of
- 1:09:04contributed to them being an eight. I feel like it's starting to look like
- 1:09:09they have more vocal fans than actual number of fans who follow at least follow
- 1:09:17me on Twitter because a couple of other tournaments, I was I see it
- 1:09:24them higher than I should have, and they got like blown out by sanct
- 1:09:26Disreal. Um, so that kind of no furthers things forever is who I'm
- 1:09:35talking about, got blown Oh sorry, yeah yeah yeah, so that's where
- 1:09:42they're they're on eight. I just like that this one was like sad boys
- 1:09:45versus party boys. That's true. That that makes me chuckle a little bit.
- 1:09:49It's like it's like Casha versus Phoebe Bridgers or something. Yeah, that's
- 1:09:58good. That's good analogy. All right, So further Seems Forever moves on.
- 1:10:02Fortunately, I really like further Seems Forever a lot, So I'm really
- 1:10:08glad that they ended up moving on. Although, like I said before,
- 1:10:10I do think Family Force five was actually really influential in the krunk course scene.
- 1:10:15Now, granted, that's like being influential in a genre that like isn't
- 1:10:18particularly all that great. It's like, you know, it's like nickel Back
- 1:10:23being like, oh, we're the butt rock band. It's like, okay,
- 1:10:25great, like you're a big band, but like you're the butt rock
- 1:10:28band. So granted, Family Force fives in that world, but you know,
- 1:10:32it was something it's at least like a Christian band like influencing something I
- 1:10:36guess. So yeah, but Family Force five moves on next one, Emery
- 1:10:42versus icon Here for Hire. I'm not like, I haven't really listened to
- 1:10:46icon for Hire really at all. I kind of like, again, they
- 1:10:49to me feel like one of those like butt rock bands that got really big
- 1:10:53just because of that sound. But I wasn't honestly expecting Emory to win this
- 1:11:00handedly versus them. Honestly, I think Emory is following is just so strong
- 1:11:05and it maintains its strength for a multitude of reasons. But I get that,
- 1:11:11and I expected Emory to win. But by almost like ninety percent to
- 1:11:16ten percent essentially, that's pretty impressive. It's just hard to make sense of
- 1:11:21a bandwidth six hundred and eighty seven thousand monthly listeners getting eleven percent of the
- 1:11:27vote against a band with is that one of the seventh You make that kind
- 1:11:35of sound and you will get that many listeners. I'm telling you, go,
- 1:11:39I'm starting but rock band, guys, let's do it. You wonder
- 1:11:43why people do it that our country. Do one of those two bands and
- 1:11:45you will find but rock country. There we go. But it is that
- 1:11:51that's got to be What was the other one that on the other side of
- 1:11:54the bracket that we were talking about that was like, oh, Acid He's
- 1:11:58burn over Fit for a King was probably one of the bigger, like monthly
- 1:12:00listener kind of upsets. This has gotta be one of the bigger ones too,
- 1:12:05right, Yeah, Emory had oh so almost almost two hundred thousand,
- 1:12:14okay, but still like not quite as big as the Acid He's burned over
- 1:12:17Fit for a King, But still that's a pretty significant upset over a band
- 1:12:21that has six hundred thousand monthly listeners, especially eighty nine to eleven. Yeah,
- 1:12:28it is, Yeah, especially that big that that that's pretty significant.
- 1:12:30But all right, well, Emory moves on and uh, they will be
- 1:12:34matching up either against the Almost versus Showbread, which this was a tough one
- 1:12:40for me. I really like both of them, very mad. I like
- 1:12:45both bands equally, and honestly, the fact that Showbread was that low was
- 1:12:48a little surprising because again they I think they have really a dedicated Salt following
- 1:12:53in the Salt or in the tooth and Nail world. But at the end
- 1:12:57of the day, that almost beats him out and thoughts around that that matchup
- 1:13:00that's interesting. I think it's the Glessbie factor. I think he just carries
- 1:13:04you know. Yeah, maybe that was another one of the big streaming disparity.
- 1:13:11Show Showbird less than nine thousand monthly listeners. That blew my what less
- 1:13:15than nine thousand? Really that little I wouldn't have that. So the almost
- 1:13:19one hundred and ninety seven thousand less than nine thousand, that's got to be
- 1:13:23one of the least on the entire list. The Almost has almost two hundred
- 1:13:27thousand monthly listeners. Yeah, that that first single I had was like a
- 1:13:30top ten modern rock mainstream hit. I mean I used to see it on
- 1:13:33like MTV and of course like Showbred's now on that, But I thought like
- 1:13:38Showbred would have like some sort of carry over with dedication from their fan base.
- 1:13:42But clearly I was. That's one of the biggest surprises in streaming numbers
- 1:13:45for me was Showbred's such small numbers. Wow. But I mean they're playing
- 1:13:50at Furnace Fest again this year and people go, I mean they played a
- 1:13:55couple of years ago, people go all out for Showbred. H Colin,
- 1:13:58What's are you much more of a Showbred fan than the Almost? I I'm
- 1:14:03not a fan of the show of the Almost at all. Really, all
- 1:14:08I mean the first album I love, and I probably love it more than
- 1:14:11any other Showbred album, But as an artist as a whole, I probably
- 1:14:15am a Showbred fan. And I forget who I ended up voting for on
- 1:14:19this one, but it was pretty close. But I can't believe that there
- 1:14:24was that much of a disparity between streaming numbers. Yeah, that's a pretty
- 1:14:30significant one, all right. So the almost moves on, though they prevail.
- 1:14:33Next one, Copeland versus King's Kaleidoscope. Again, like, it's hard
- 1:14:39to believe that some of these worship bands got so big on Tooth and Nail,
- 1:14:42but King's Kalidoscope was one of them, even though they said they ut
- 1:14:45for it every now and then. But Copeland, to me, Copeland is
- 1:14:49one of those bands that is severely underrated in the Tooth and Nail world.
- 1:14:55As an indie emo band, I think they they influence that world, and
- 1:15:00they were a part of that indie emo world for for a while, and
- 1:15:04I think they I think more people know about them than they realize. And
- 1:15:09I think the Further Seems Forever is kind of in that same vein too,
- 1:15:12But I I can't believe that Copeland didn't get as big as they should have.
- 1:15:17They are one of the bands on this where it feels like they were
- 1:15:20severely underrated. Yeah, they're great songwriters. Um, I would I would
- 1:15:27have voted for against Glascope here. Um really yeah, they're They're one of
- 1:15:30the few kind of like worship artists that I actually do listen to every once
- 1:15:35in a while. I I can't believe you like them more than Copeland,
- 1:15:39though I love Copeland. I think incredible. I think Copeland, I think
- 1:15:45their problem with with not being nearly as big as they should as they're they're
- 1:15:48two emo for the Pitchfork crowd, but too you know, into artsy for
- 1:15:54the emo crowd. I think, yeah, yeah, they were in that
- 1:15:58kind of weird world. But you know, they really the album a couple
- 1:16:00of years ago that was one of my favorite albums was that twenty eighteen,
- 1:16:04twenty nineteen or something. But I think Aaron Marsh is an incredible songwriter.
- 1:16:10I think he's an incredible artist, and I think Copeland is just severely underrated.
- 1:16:15This is one of your favorite bands on this next one? Uh so
- 1:16:21obviously again Copeland moves on. It was fairly close, but Copeland moves on
- 1:16:27all right. Thousand Foot Crush versus FM SAC This almost feels like a Chariot
- 1:16:30versus Norman Jeane kind of matchup. But like for like my like least favorites
- 1:16:35for for nine year old Mason. Yes, this is If you would have
- 1:16:42asked me this question almost twenty years ago, this would have been the hardest
- 1:16:46pick for me. But the biggest thing was it was twenty years ago.
- 1:16:55Honestly, though, it's hard to believe that thousand foot Crush has the following
- 1:17:00that they do. I mean, how many how many monthly listeners do they
- 1:17:02have? Eric probably coal million, three point four million, three point four
- 1:17:06million for Tooth and for thousand for Crunch call up? And how much how
- 1:17:12much does a FM static have eight hundred and four thousand. FM static has
- 1:17:18almost nine hundred thousand monthly listeners FM static correct, And this is both These
- 1:17:26are both Trevor mccannon bands. This Yeah, he is by far the most
- 1:17:30listened to Tooth and Nail artist ever and it's not even close. And it
- 1:17:36blows my mind how popular he was. But neither one of these bands I
- 1:17:43think are like they have like the dedicated Tooth and Nail following. They were
- 1:17:45big outside of Tooth and Nail. Yeah. Wow. TFK have the most
- 1:17:50monthly listeners of any band in the tournament, more than We're than Jeremy Camp
- 1:17:57and yeah, Jeremy Camp's got one point seven minut and yet you had two.
- 1:18:01You had a thousand foot crutch at number three. That's interesting. I
- 1:18:05had him at two, but after talking to someone I was I was talked
- 1:18:11down, but I felt like I couldn't move him very far down, so
- 1:18:14I just moved him from two to three. Wow. So the band that
- 1:18:18has the most Spotify listeners currently is number three in the tournament. That is,
- 1:18:24that's something else, but something else. They ended up actually dominating FM
- 1:18:29static. H. You know what would be interesting is to hear Trevor's opinion
- 1:18:33on this. If he if he had to vote between the two, would
- 1:18:36he vote TFK over FM Static? What do you what do you think you
- 1:18:41would say? Eric? I think it's say TFK because um Static is probably
- 1:18:46only as popular as I are because of his FROMK. Yeah. Probably,
- 1:18:53Yeah, that's true. All right, Well, TFK ends up prevailing and
- 1:18:57they will be facing off Copeland in the next round, all right, last
- 1:19:00one of the second round, second to last. Yeah, May versus the
- 1:19:05Classic Crime. These are two bands that were somewhat similar in sound. Classic
- 1:19:12Crime is a little heavier, but yeah, yeah, yeah, I mean
- 1:19:15this is a tough This is a tough matchup. I love me, so
- 1:19:18I ended up voting for me. Any thoughts on this matchup, I probably
- 1:19:24personally would have gone Classic Crime. Really is it? McDonald Rayton? Yeah,
- 1:19:29Matt, Matt McDonald, Matt, Yeah. I I really dig Matt
- 1:19:32McDonald's voice, and I think he's actually probably the most talented singer other than
- 1:19:38Krystal need Scott on this entire list, Wow, even more so than Mark
- 1:19:45Creme as well. Yeah that's true and markin you really like Mark from Steve.
- 1:19:49I do like Mark as well, But I think that I think that
- 1:19:51Matt McDonald's a better singer all around than Wow. Interesting all right, Yeah,
- 1:19:58I like the Classic Crime, but Mayer five band for me, so,
- 1:20:00oh hey, there you go. What's your what's your May album?
- 1:20:08The ever Glow? Of course? Yeah? Yeah, for sure, I
- 1:20:10mean classic and And honestly, if it weren't for ever Glow, probably Classic
- 1:20:15Cry might move on. But Everglow is such a especially among Tooth and Nail
- 1:20:18fans during that era, as one of them I mean Overglow, like Define
- 1:20:24the Great Line, some of those other albums from that mid two thousands era
- 1:20:28are considered some of the classic tooth and Nail albums, and so obviously I
- 1:20:32think May, just by that alone, probably ends up moving on. Yeah,
- 1:20:36I've noticed, I've noticed from my tweets that the ever Glow is one
- 1:20:40of the most like beloved albums of like that scene, easy, totally,
- 1:20:45totally. Well, May moves on probably because of the ever Glow, and
- 1:20:48they will be matching up against either Me Without You or The Fold. Here's
- 1:20:54what's funny, though, Colin, You're about to your shit's about to uh
- 1:20:57is it shit? Shit's bricked or whatever what's called it called? Sure,
- 1:21:01your mind's about to be blown. Let's put my ship's about to be bricked?
- 1:21:06Me without You versus the Fold? How many more monthly listeners does the
- 1:21:12Fold have then Me Without You? Eric, you probably found this out?
- 1:21:15Oh can I guess? Can I guess? I'm gonna say it's nine and
- 1:21:19a half times more that many? Okay, not quite that, not quite
- 1:21:25the Fold. The Fold have three hundred and thirty nine thousand monthly listeners to
- 1:21:29make without use one hundred and fifty four thousand. I didn't know me without
- 1:21:32you was that high. Actually, yeah, I want, I want to
- 1:21:34guess. Yeah, it is pretty dedicated. But The Fold is a band
- 1:21:40that here's what's funny. Out of almost most of these bands, the Fold
- 1:21:45is a band that got all of those listeners after they left the Tooth and
- 1:21:49Nail world and they started doing what was what's the like like power Ranger.
- 1:21:56It wasn't powering like Legos. It's Legos. Yeah. They made all these
- 1:22:00songs for Legos and got huge because they were making songs for Legos. Yeah,
- 1:22:05that Legos crowd, Man, you gotta, you gotta, you gotta
- 1:22:09get in their pockets. It's unbelievable. So the fact that they even got
- 1:22:13to number twelve almost probably exclude Honestly, if if it weren't for the Legos
- 1:22:17thing, do you think they would have even been in the tournament? Eric,
- 1:22:20No, probably not. Yeah. I mean it's just like streaming numbers
- 1:22:24alone because of Legos. But if you look at the streaming numbers of their
- 1:22:27Tooth and Nail albums, I think they had like two or three. There's
- 1:22:30there's no way they would probably even been in the in the tournament. But
- 1:22:34the fact that they were a tooth and nail band at one point and they
- 1:22:38got huge because of legos put them up there. But honestly, unless you
- 1:22:42had a bunch of like ten year olds voting on this Twitter poll, uh,
- 1:22:45me without you, I think was undoubtedly gonna win. And so Me
- 1:22:49without you very handedly wins this matchup against the fold rightfully. So well there
- 1:22:55you go, Eric, You you know now that you need to go out
- 1:22:57and try to find that that ten year old demograph to get them, get
- 1:23:00them engaged. All right, So we're now moving on to round two.
- 1:23:08It's gonna be a lot shorter now fortunately. All right. So because we're
- 1:23:11already at an hour and a half of recording, I knew this was gonna
- 1:23:13take a while because that's what happens, all right. So we're gonna go
- 1:23:15back up top right, Seventh Day Slumber, who ended up upsetting Germy Camp
- 1:23:21versus Falling Up? Eric, what did you think of this matchup? It
- 1:23:28was just another one where I was hoping following up would would get the get
- 1:23:31the wind, but after Seventhday Slumber, Big jere mccamp, I didn't really
- 1:23:34expect it. But yeah, yeah, so falling Up ends up beating Seventh
- 1:23:40Day Slumber in a pretty close one. It was a nail biter, but
- 1:23:43they end up beating them again. I think it's one of those things where
- 1:23:46it doesn't make sense to me how Seventhday Slumber ends up beating Germany Camp but
- 1:23:50then doesn't end up beating fallowing up. That doesn't make sense. Let's ask
- 1:23:54this question, why is Seventhday Slumber putting up a fight here? Because I
- 1:23:59I simply don't understand this one. That's a good question. They have like
- 1:24:02eighty six thousand monthly listeners, but yeah, I don't. I don't really
- 1:24:06I can't explain how they would beat Jeremy Camp at all. Am I missing
- 1:24:13something with with like the like their live shows or something like that that maybe
- 1:24:17like didn't resonate with me but resonate with someone else, Or because like their
- 1:24:20songs, I mean, their songs are just okay at the very best.
- 1:24:25Yeah, maybe it's where they're just a real, like, you know,
- 1:24:27outspoken, Christian testimony driven kind of band, kind of like probably Skillet fans
- 1:24:32or probably yeah, Seventh Day Slumber fans. Yeah, when when Skillet fans
- 1:24:36want to chill out for a little bit, they go listen to some Seventhday
- 1:24:40Slumber and yeah, say, you know what, whatever, let's move on.
- 1:24:43Yeah, yeah, I think you're probably right. I think that Falling
- 1:24:45Up is significantly a better artist all the way around the board. Yeah,
- 1:24:50catch here, more energetic, more creative, more creative. Yeah, totally.
- 1:24:57Well that that was not too much of a surprise to me. I
- 1:25:00don't think it's probably a surprised to you guys either. Uh, next one,
- 1:25:03Mace, all right, So next one, Disciple versus Hawk Nelson.
- 1:25:10This does feel like it should be a really close one, right it does.
- 1:25:13Yeah. I feel like the fan bases are just as dedicated. They
- 1:25:17probably have somewhat similar kind of size of fan bases this one. I think
- 1:25:25I probably voted for Hawk Nelson, but I really had no idea where this
- 1:25:29one was going. Any thoughts on this one? Disciples singer followed me on
- 1:25:34Twitter, right as odd relationship, that's right, So he was he was
- 1:25:39ready to pounce. So yeah, him and the Disciple Twitter. We're both
- 1:25:45retweeting every round, so that helped him out quite a bit. I'm sure
- 1:25:50nice. Well Disciple ends up winning, and so they're gonna be matching up
- 1:25:55against Falling Up in the Sweet sixteen. Next one, Project eighty six versus
- 1:26:00Cutlass, again a matchup that feels like it should be close. Given the
- 1:26:04fact that Cutlass is huge and Project eighty six probably doesn't have quite as big
- 1:26:10of a fan base but has a very dedicated one, it felt like this
- 1:26:13one should be really close. I knew that Cutlass was popular because my uncle,
- 1:26:20who was like the leader of our local promise keepers, that was like
- 1:26:26his favorite band. And I was like, yeah, that's so not cool,
- 1:26:30man. But I didn't think that Project eighty six is gonna win this
- 1:26:33big. I mean pretty pretty much sixty five percent to thirty five percent over
- 1:26:39Cutlass. Yeah, which you can. I think it's that theme of Cutlass
- 1:26:44probably was one of those bands that, even though they were on Tooth and
- 1:26:46Nail, their fan base was outside of the Tooth and Nail world. Yeah,
- 1:26:51and I do think that affects this draft. Yeah. Yeah, they
- 1:26:56had a gold record. It was their worship album, So that kind of
- 1:26:59tells you kind of the crowd that they were. What was that big song,
- 1:27:01Strong Tower? I feel like worship to that all the time in youth
- 1:27:04group. Well we got we got ghosted by gut lists. Remember that Mason
- 1:27:10did we Oh that's oh, that's right, we did get ghosted by them.
- 1:27:13That's right, all right, Well glad Project eighty six moved on,
- 1:27:16all right? So Project eighty six moves on plank I versus the super Tones?
- 1:27:21Who are they? Who's going to match up against Project eighty six?
- 1:27:27This one I felt like should have been closer, but pretty convincingly that was
- 1:27:30the super Tones wins. The Ska is strong, I was gonna say.
- 1:27:34I clearly the fact that they're like the only SKA band on here, I
- 1:27:40think only helps them because so many people have such a strong connection with that
- 1:27:46SKA phenomenon that there was. That it's just it's just they're they're they're gonna
- 1:27:54move on because they are so much different than everyone else. Right, It
- 1:27:59is interesting that we have like, you know, third fourth waves of emo
- 1:28:01now and we have yet to have a second wave of SKA that I know
- 1:28:06of. Yeah, that is that is true. Was scats so weird that
- 1:28:12it's just it's too weird to like have another wave of it? I tweeted
- 1:28:16out the other day. I said, clearly people are ready for a SKA
- 1:28:19revival because the skall bands just dominate in my tournaments. Yeah, somebody sent
- 1:28:25me like a Brooklyn Vegan article saying, you know, twenty ska bands are
- 1:28:29out now, but it's like, for some reason it's not becoming a thing
- 1:28:31again. It doesn't seem like it's so weird because five Iron one your CCM
- 1:28:36one. Right. Yeah, yeah, I was gonna say, people are
- 1:28:39tweeting me asking me to do tournaments with a no ska band rule because they
- 1:28:44feel like it's it's unfair to everybody else, which is ridiculous considering it's a
- 1:28:49genre that hasn't been popular in twenty five years. I feel like that's weird.
- 1:28:54This is one that has to be a victim to nostalgia like that,
- 1:29:00Like that that's the only reason I could imagine people and like really wanting to
- 1:29:03listen to ska is because of nostalgia. Very well likely, I it's just
- 1:29:11I never really understood it, and especially especially the super Tones version of Scott
- 1:29:15right. I mean, like five are in friends that you have like very
- 1:29:18like pointed like political messages and things like that, and and like you know,
- 1:29:23existential questioning and all that stuff, But like with super Tones, you
- 1:29:26don't really have that. So that's where I think it's got to be just
- 1:29:30nostalgia. It must be. It's a really it's really bizarre. But also
- 1:29:34again like super Tones were one of outside of maybe mx p X, they
- 1:29:39were one of those early bands that were on tooth and nail. They were
- 1:29:43probably funny and everybody else's albums. Yeah, true, true, I mean
- 1:29:45they were that big at that time. It was it's really interesting how big
- 1:29:49they got. But all right, well, super Tones end up prevailing over
- 1:29:53Plank Guy. Goodbye, plank Guy. Did you get my little like a
- 1:29:57good eye Plank Guy? That was U wonderful? Great? All right,
- 1:30:01So under Oath versus Haste the Day, this one was pretty handidly. But
- 1:30:06again I thought maybe there would be a little bit more of a fight from
- 1:30:12Haste to Day. Yeah, I'm not surprised that there wasn't. When you're
- 1:30:15going against under Oath, I mean it is. I mean, that's the
- 1:30:19juggernaut in the room, so that's that is true. But I thought maybe
- 1:30:25a little bit more of a fight, Like I thought, maybe like sixty
- 1:30:27five thirty five kind of thing, but nope, eighty one nineteen unbelievable.
- 1:30:32Yeah, I would have thought a little more fight from Haste to Day.
- 1:30:34Fans clearly, not that even the Haste to Day fans were like, nope,
- 1:30:40under Oath. That's kind of the problem with this with the solid State
- 1:30:45section the Solid State region, is that the bands are so similar that you're
- 1:30:48not going to get massive or like like super super close fights. I don't
- 1:30:56think just because if you were a hast to Day fan, you were also
- 1:30:59you're also on the Oth fans. But when you're going to guess under Oath,
- 1:31:01under Oath is gonna win out every single time because everyone knows ten under
- 1:31:04Oath songs by heart, right, yeah, versus like if you're a Star
- 1:31:09Flyer fan over Extol fan, Like, those are two very different fan bases.
- 1:31:12It's very different. Yea, right, all right? Well, under
- 1:31:15Oath very convincingly moves on to the Sweet sixteen Acidities Burn versus demon Hunter again
- 1:31:23a very like big matchup in terms of Spotify numbers, but demon Hunter ends
- 1:31:27up prevailing. Apparently Mega Corps is very strong within the Christian world. Like
- 1:31:34I said, I've learned that, you know, demon Hunter is a gateway
- 1:31:40band for a lot of people, So yeah, people get attached to those
- 1:31:43kinds of artists might also be a gateway to some very interesting politics that I
- 1:31:47think should probably be done with possibly, so uh that the oh and I'm
- 1:31:55just realizing now you actually have the reason the regions labeled. It was like,
- 1:31:59oh my earlier I was like, oh, why did you have that
- 1:32:01region that way or whatever? And I'm like, just no, noticing this.
- 1:32:05All right, So demon Hunter moves on. Now. Norma Jeane versus
- 1:32:10August Burns Read probably one of the more difficult Round of thirty two matchups right
- 1:32:16here. I probably voted for Norma Jean. But my goodness is this is
- 1:32:21going to be way closer than I think people realize because August Burns Read is
- 1:32:26probably what an like a million monthly listeners, yeah, close to him,
- 1:32:30and then Norma Jean is at just under two hundred thousand. So just August
- 1:32:34Burns Read has four times more monthly listeners on Spotify and yet pretty much makes
- 1:32:40it a two point game at the end of the day. Yeah, that's
- 1:32:45pretty impressive, very impressive. And again I think that really shows that Norma
- 1:32:50Jean just album for album, people are dedicated and love Norma Jean. I
- 1:32:56do think like, if you know Norma Jean has played Furnace Fest last year,
- 1:33:00they'll play again this year. Uh, if August Burns read happened to
- 1:33:02be at Furnace Fest, I think they would probably have equal sized crowds.
- 1:33:06Let's put it that way. That's an interesting thought. I don't know.
- 1:33:12I think I think outside of like the Christian world, UM, August Burns
- 1:33:15Red definitely pulls a lot more respect and um probably fandom as well. So
- 1:33:23I don't know if they I think they have a bigger fandom outside the Christian
- 1:33:26world. I don't know if they have more respect. I bet, like
- 1:33:29I bet outlets like Metal Sucks probably likes Norma Gine more than August Burton's Red.
- 1:33:33Metal Sucks hates Normagine why outside of Bless the Martyr they hate Norma Gene.
- 1:33:40Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's in fact, in fact, just
- 1:33:45about just about every single uh Christian adjacent artist Metal Sucks hates, right.
- 1:33:51But I would say out of all of the metal core even out even Norma
- 1:33:56gin or under oh sorry, I would say Norma Jean might be the most
- 1:34:00artsy metalcore artists I've ever heard, even in the outside of the life.
- 1:34:04They're so artsy. I can't imagine that an outlet like Metal Sucks would hate
- 1:34:08Normagene given how artsy they actually are, and it's not like they have like
- 1:34:13it's not like they have success that seems unbridled. Like they have success that
- 1:34:18has been very hard earned, and the very little success that they do have
- 1:34:23they have worked their asses off for because they're damn good artists. I can't
- 1:34:27imagine any outlet being like anti Norma Gene. Yeah, they have a lot
- 1:34:30of hate, and I think it would surprise you. Interesting. Well yeah,
- 1:34:35all right, well August Burns Red barely ends up beating out Normagene.
- 1:34:40Norma Gene ends up going out in the second round. I feel like they
- 1:34:42should have at least deserved a sweet sixteen bid, but here they are out
- 1:34:45in the round of thirty two. Next one, Living Sacrifice versus Devil Horse
- 1:34:51Product. This is our first extremely close one. Yeah. Wow, again
- 1:34:58it tells you everything you need to know about Living Sacrifices fandom. Yeah,
- 1:35:04this was another one. What's the monthly listener difference here? Because this is
- 1:35:10a massive one, I think, Yeah, that's what I was about to
- 1:35:12say. Uh, the Divorce Product has almost one point two million monthly listeners
- 1:35:17to Living Sacrifices twenty thousand difference, So this has to be this has to
- 1:35:26be a cred thing, like this has to be like this thing where like
- 1:35:30you have to pay your respects to the ogs. Otherwise that's sixty times larger.
- 1:35:36Yeah, that's so crazy. Yeah, I was surprised. I was
- 1:35:41real surprised by this. Pleasantly. It's like you literally got all twenty thousand
- 1:35:46monthly listeners from Living Sacrifice and got them to vote for Living Sacrifice. Well,
- 1:35:50what else is almost this is interesting is that they barely squeaked out of
- 1:35:55the first round only to barely barely squeak out of the second round. Like
- 1:35:59that's doesn't there's sort of like a well they're not there are seven seats and
- 1:36:03they're not a Cinderella. But like the fact that they're like winning these like
- 1:36:06close matchups, it's pretty impressive. Yeah. Yeah, but they win fifty
- 1:36:13point four, not fifty four, fifty point four over forty nine point six.
- 1:36:18So I mean that's like a matter of maybe a hundred votes. Yeah,
- 1:36:24I mean that is close. Yeah, that is so close. That's
- 1:36:27unbelievable. But Living Sacrifice beating out Devil War's product, that is a upset.
- 1:36:33That is one hundred percent and upset. Yeah, and again just shows
- 1:36:38you how dedicated the Living Sacrifice fandom is all right? Uh? Top left
- 1:36:44now to mx p X versus Goady Hook, and MxPx wins pretty handedly over
- 1:36:51Goody Gody Hook, which makes sense because I think if you're one of those
- 1:36:56people that liked if you're a punk fan and that like nineties era for Tooth
- 1:37:00and Nail, even if you liked Godie Hook Moore, you realize that like
- 1:37:05mx PX was on another level. Yeah, they're more influential. They give
- 1:37:10you cred as a Christian Christian kid, you know, yeah, yeah,
- 1:37:15I mean mx p X saved Brandon Ebel's uh you know, he took that
- 1:37:18like one hundred thousand dollars loan from his grandpa. Brandon Ebel would probably be
- 1:37:23in jail now if it weren't for mx p X, yeah, because he'd
- 1:37:26probably or that or he would be filing for bankruptcy. Yeah. It's similar
- 1:37:31to the under oath verse haste the day situation. You know, how can
- 1:37:35you how can you vote for for you know, artists that's obviously lesser.
- 1:37:44You know, mx p X another big band that will be uh at Furnace
- 1:37:47Fest calling you got a pizza ready? I'll get my pizza ready. Very
- 1:37:51wonderful. All right, next one, who will MxPx be going against star
- 1:37:56Flyer fifty nine or Zao the this is an entire Oh my god, this
- 1:38:01is such a difficult matchup. Yeah, but surprisingly this actually shocked me.
- 1:38:08Star Flyer wins pretty convincingly over Zao. Yeah, that surprises me a lot
- 1:38:14as well. Star Flyer apparently just does really really well against real heavy bands.
- 1:38:19What eric was Star Flyer in your CCM bracket? No, they weren't.
- 1:38:25Okay, they were if it were up to my own preferences, they
- 1:38:28definitely would have been been there. But had they been, it would been
- 1:38:31really curious. Even though they're significantly smaller than a lot of other CCM bands,
- 1:38:38if they were in that bracket, it feels like, at the very
- 1:38:41least, clearly there's enough votes that probably would have got them through maybe the
- 1:38:45second round, even in the CCM bracket. And this is this is an
- 1:38:47impressive how well they're going through this bracket right now? Yeah, I'm going
- 1:38:51to put them in the in the next one. I'm gonna do that big
- 1:38:54CCM one every year. Cool? Yeah, how much to see what it
- 1:38:58is? That's gonna be interesting to see how much it changes. Yeah,
- 1:39:00yeah, that's great. All right, So Star Flyer ends up beating zaout.
- 1:39:04I don't know who I ended up voting for here. I like both
- 1:39:08bands pretty much equally, but I can't believe that there was this much of
- 1:39:12a discrepancy between the two. Sixty one percent versus thirty nine percent for Zo
- 1:39:16Yeah, pretty impressive, all right, So sorry, Star Flyer will be
- 1:39:21against mx PX in the next round. Pretty tough matchup for star Flyer,
- 1:39:26all right. Next one, Bleach versus the Juliana Theory. This is again
- 1:39:32and now that this was a really really close one. And also it feels
- 1:39:36like both this is the fan bases for both of these bands are the same
- 1:39:42fan bases that I could be wrong. I wasn't around in the nineties for
- 1:39:45Tooth and Nail to know this, but it feels like that Bleach actually didn't
- 1:39:50come on too Tooth and Nail until the two thousand's, But I think most
- 1:39:54people think of them as a nineties band, So yeah, they were a
- 1:39:59forefront and interesting, so I'm not sure that they would have been completely in
- 1:40:02the same same crowd. But Bleach barely wins over Juliana Theory, which I
- 1:40:10don't know. Again, I don't know who I ended up voting, probably
- 1:40:13Juliana Theory on this one, but oh my goodness, I cannot believe that
- 1:40:18it was that close. It's pretty pretty impressive. So bleach over Juliana Theory.
- 1:40:24Who will they be going against? Either Stave Sacre or Blindside? I
- 1:40:28love you, Mark Solomon, but honestly, let's be honest. Blindside is
- 1:40:33unbelievable band and deserves to be going on and very much so. They won
- 1:40:40sixty eight percent versus thirty two percent over Stave Sacre, So Stave Sacre doesn't
- 1:40:44get out of the second round. But any thoughts around Blindside beating save Sacre
- 1:40:47other than it seems like that was pretty predictable. I guess maybe I don't
- 1:40:51know, pretty predictable. I hate to see I hate to see Stave Sacre
- 1:40:55go but yeah it makes sense. Yeah, two bands that I love,
- 1:40:59hate to see either one go out, but deserves it. Yep, it
- 1:41:02makes sense. It makes sense by Blindside goes on. All right? So
- 1:41:08that is uh, the second to last region, last region of the second
- 1:41:12round Amberlin, because remember they ended up being spoken Amberlin versus further seems forever
- 1:41:19I I like both bands a lot, almost equally. I do think if
- 1:41:25I remember right, I do believe I voted for Further Seems Forever on this
- 1:41:30one, but this does feel like you're really outmatched for a further Season Forever
- 1:41:34because Amberlin is so big and not just so big, but they also have
- 1:41:38a pretty dedicated fan base. Yeah. Yeah, that's another one, probably
- 1:41:43two top twenty bands for me, so I hate to see either one go.
- 1:41:47Great great band Amberlin, I mean both both bands have like put out
- 1:41:51consistently great albums. It's really hard. I mean, it just so happens
- 1:41:56that Amberlin kind of struck gold with a couple other songs, ended up getting
- 1:42:00really big, and even outside of the Christian music world. I knew lots
- 1:42:03of people who knew Amberlin, ye, outside of the Christian music world,
- 1:42:08other than like really weirdly weird like emo snobs. I guarantee you nobody knows
- 1:42:13who Further Scenes Forever is, but a lot of people who know who Amberlin
- 1:42:16is. Eric, real quick, did you did you vote on these yourself
- 1:42:19as well? I didn't? Was that hard? Yeah? I try to
- 1:42:25stay I try to stay unbiased. You know, they're they're obvious ones that
- 1:42:29people are going to know I'm pulling for, but yeah, I don't usually
- 1:42:33vote on them. I bet Amberlin versus Further Seams Forever is also a big
- 1:42:40spotified discrepancy because Further Seams Forever wasn't maybe like thirty thousand yea monthly listeners.
- 1:42:45I bet Amberlin's Amberlin's gotta be over a million. Yeah, Further Things Forever's
- 1:42:49forty seven thousand, Amberlin is one point one three million. Yeah, so
- 1:42:56almost, like what is that fIF like a fifty times big different. I
- 1:43:00mean that's pretty pretty significant. So Amberlin, I think, just like is
- 1:43:02going to win in that regard. All right, So next one, who's
- 1:43:05amber Ln going to be facing against? In the Sweet sixteen? Emory or
- 1:43:10the Almost two bands that actually, out of all these matchups, I think
- 1:43:15these are two bands that are like best friends with each other. Aaron Gillespie
- 1:43:18is super good friends with Emory, so it's kind of funny that those two
- 1:43:23ended up matching up against each other. But again, Emory pretty convincingly wins
- 1:43:30over the Almost. Again it shows you like how dedicated Emory fans are,
- 1:43:33even though I think Almost probably has I think you said almost has more Monthly
- 1:43:39listeners than Emory, right, Yeah, they almost has about twenty thousand more
- 1:43:43monthly listeners, not a huge gap, not that much. Okay, so
- 1:43:45it's pretty close, but still Emory wins pretty convincingly. Clin obviously you're probably
- 1:43:50rooting for Emory here. Yeah, definitely room for Emory. Did did Matt
- 1:43:55Carter reach out at all on this? No? I never, I never.
- 1:44:00H We need to bug him about that then, yeah, totally he
- 1:44:03would. He would absolutely love to throw that in Aaron's face. Yeah,
- 1:44:09y'all have to let him know about it. We will fell gladly let Aaron
- 1:44:13know that. You know, not only is he getting beat out by Emory,
- 1:44:15but he's also the uh he's the fill in for Daniel Davidson. All
- 1:44:20right, So moving on Copeland versus TFK, here is probably a big Spotify
- 1:44:29discrepancy here, right. Copeland's got what like maybe one hundred thousand followers,
- 1:44:33one hundred nineteen thousand, one hundred and nineteen thousand, so just over one
- 1:44:39hundred thousand monthly listeners and TFK, you said, is three million, three
- 1:44:43three million million, So what what is that? Over a third? Almost
- 1:44:46like a thirty thirty times difference. Uh, And Copeland, given the fact
- 1:44:50that it's a thirty times difference, actually keeps it fairly close. Close.
- 1:44:56Yeah, pretty close. That's pretty impressive. But TFK ends up pulling out
- 1:45:00fifty eight percent to forty two percent. That's pretty impressive for Copelyn. Honestly,
- 1:45:03that's a great showing. That is Again, it goes to show that
- 1:45:10a band like Copeland versus TFK, it shows that, like there is a
- 1:45:14dedicated tooth and nail fan base and they have their favorite artists, and TFK,
- 1:45:18even though they might be massive, still does not have quite the poll
- 1:45:23that some of these smaller artists do just because of who the fan base is.
- 1:45:27It's really interesting. Yeah, all right, so Copeland or sorry,
- 1:45:30TFK ends up moving on to the Sweet sixteen May versus Me Without You.
- 1:45:36I'm probably one of the biggest Me Without You fans out there, even though
- 1:45:41I love me, I love love love me. We're going to be interviewing
- 1:45:45them sometime in the summer for Furnace Fest. Very excited for that. But
- 1:45:49you can't vote against Me Without You. I mean I feel like I think
- 1:45:54even Zach, who is the guitarist for May, even like it. When
- 1:45:59it was this matchup He was like, it's got to be me without you.
- 1:46:01Like, if you're voting for us over me without your you're a bunch
- 1:46:04of dumblasses. And that's a guy who's coming from the band May. So
- 1:46:10that makes sense. Yeah, great band. Um, the Spotify listeners are
- 1:46:15fair probably fairly similar, right, Uh yeah maybe without us one hundred and
- 1:46:18fifty four thousand, May is eighty thousand. Okay, yeah, so similar
- 1:46:25similar ish, But Me without You again is such such a dedicated fan base.
- 1:46:29I mean it's one of they were one of those bands where those one
- 1:46:31hundred and fifty thousand people that are listening are going to be buying tickets and
- 1:46:35and and also getting albums and everything. I mean, they're they're that dedicated.
- 1:46:41So all right, that rounds out the round of thirty two. Uh,
- 1:46:45now we're going to Sweet sixteen and we have oh boy, here we
- 1:46:50go, all right, falling Up versus Disciple. I feel like falling Up
- 1:46:59is a better or artist, but Disciple does have such a significant larger fan
- 1:47:03base. Yeah that it makes sense. Disciple ends up winning here, but
- 1:47:09falling Up they made it pretty far given the fact, like what they have
- 1:47:14like twenty three thousand monthly listeners. Uh sorry, they have sixty two thousand
- 1:47:21that much? Okay, Well, the fact that they're even under one hundred
- 1:47:25thousand monthly listeners and made it into the Sweet sixteen that's pretty impressive for a
- 1:47:29band. So I'm fairly impressed by how far Falling Up made it. But
- 1:47:33at some point you do realize, like the Disciple fan base is just going
- 1:47:39to yeah, make this, especially with them retweeting it. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:47:44I don't doubt that's right. Yeah, that I forgot that the lead
- 1:47:45singer was involved in all this. So all right, Well, Disciple ends
- 1:47:49up winning, not by that much, but they end up winning pretty decidedly.
- 1:47:54All right, So who will they be competing against? Project eighty six
- 1:47:59or the OC super Tones Again, you know, these feel like two very
- 1:48:03different fan bases. The Project eighty six fan base does not feel like at
- 1:48:08all the OC super Tunes fan base. So it's like two different fan bases
- 1:48:12compete against each other, and it's a pretty tight one here, Yeah it
- 1:48:16is. You know, I think I would like to know if you were
- 1:48:19to take the song spy Hunter out of Project eighty six is discography, do
- 1:48:27they make it past the second round? Yeah? Well, Eric, look,
- 1:48:31at spy Hunters plays. Is it the Is it their most played song
- 1:48:34on Spotify? It's gotta be right, it's actually not their play their most
- 1:48:40played song is I Believe It's Evil from um the albums or something? Yeah?
- 1:48:47Yeah, rival factions. That surprises me. I think spy hunter might
- 1:48:53be the most perfect song created in the entire like to the Nail discography,
- 1:49:00more than a Brian's side song, more than a blind side. So I
- 1:49:02think it's I think it's a perfect song. It's very It's a damn good
- 1:49:06song, that guitar riff. Yeah, And I'm not like the biggest Project
- 1:49:11eighty six fan by any means, but that song is is it? It
- 1:49:15draws in so many different kinds of fans, whether you're punk fan, rock
- 1:49:20fan, a heavy metal fan like it. It draws in everyone. It's
- 1:49:27catchy, it's got a great risk. I'm I'm surprised that that's that they're
- 1:49:31most listened to. First of all, that's their fourth most listen to.
- 1:49:38Yeah, what something's wrong there? Cullen? Who were we talking to somebody
- 1:49:43recently that were they were talking about how, um what was the band?
- 1:49:47Oh? Lincoln Park was opening for Project eighty six or maybe some other conversation.
- 1:49:53It wasn't. It wasn't. But at one point, Lincoln Park,
- 1:49:58very very early on even for uh, what's their that first album, uh,
- 1:50:03Hybrid the Hybrid Theory. Yea, yeah, before Hybrid Theory came out,
- 1:50:08they like literally months before h it was like Pod and Project eighty six.
- 1:50:15Oh you know who it was. I was talking with Seth Headcocks about
- 1:50:17this, uh, and he was like, oh, yeah, like they
- 1:50:20were on this like big tour and it was it was Project eighty six,
- 1:50:25Pod and Lincoln Park right before they released Hybrid Theory, and then Hybrid Theory
- 1:50:30came out, and it was like they got off the tour and then ended
- 1:50:34up, you know, doing their own tour because Hybrid Theory just became the
- 1:50:38biggest thing in the world at the time. But it's weird to think like
- 1:50:42Project eighty six and even Pod were in that world at one point. It's
- 1:50:45unbelievable that it is hard to believe. All right, So Project eighty six
- 1:50:50ends up losing to OC Supertones though, which is hard to like. Again,
- 1:50:58there's something about the whole like SKA World, right, yeah, yeah,
- 1:51:02something about that Ska World. It will it will take you over.
- 1:51:05So all right, well, uh, oci Supertones move on and they will
- 1:51:10be competing against Disciple here in the is that Elite eight? So now we
- 1:51:15move on to under Oath versus Demon Hunter. Honestly, I thought this would
- 1:51:20be closer again. I thought Demon Hunter has such a dedicated fan base.
- 1:51:25But under Oath ends up prevailing here. Yeah, that surprises me a lot,
- 1:51:32a lot a lot. You thought Demon Hunter would actually be under Oath
- 1:51:36here? No, I thought on Earth would win. I thought this was
- 1:51:39going to be like a nail biter down to the last. Yeah, it
- 1:51:44ended up being way more. It's hard to believe how many people were really
- 1:51:47that big of Under Oath fans. It's it's it's hard to believe that scene
- 1:51:51was so centered around under Oath at one point. Yeah, unbelievable. All
- 1:51:58right, well, so under Oath moves on beats Demon Hunter. They will
- 1:52:02move on to the Elite eight. Now, August Burns read versus Living Sacrifice.
- 1:52:09This one I thought would actually be closer, given how Living Sacrifice literally
- 1:52:13had just barely beaten devil Ware as product, I thought this would also be
- 1:52:17very close. But it turns out it wasn't that big. That much of
- 1:52:21a close game. August burn Dreads pretty win like wins out pretty handedly.
- 1:52:28Yeah, I think you have two pioneers of of of genres that that we're
- 1:52:31defining for the whole, for the whole like scene overall, it doesn't surprise
- 1:52:39me that August burn Read wins here. Uh, probably just because of the
- 1:52:43demographic that's on Twitter compared to um Living Sacrifice. But it is impressive.
- 1:52:50It is impressive that that they won by six, by sixty one to thirty
- 1:52:54nine. That's I mean, this is this is a big another big like
- 1:52:57Spotify discrepancy, right, So the fact that August burns Read wins it's like
- 1:53:02not that surprising, but also it's like Living Sacrifice moving into this position in
- 1:53:09the Sweet sixteen is pretty impressive, So props to them. All right.
- 1:53:15So August burns Read ends up moving on to the Elite eight, all right,
- 1:53:19moving up to the Elite eight or the Sweet sixteen bracket in the top
- 1:53:26left, all right. Mx p X versus Star Flyer. Oh, Cullen,
- 1:53:31I know where you're going with this, but yeah, this is uh,
- 1:53:35I still can't believe how much more x mx PX is winning here.
- 1:53:41I can, I mean, I it's dominating. If you listen to like
- 1:53:45the people we've had on the podcast who are all in the scene, almost
- 1:53:48all of them. MxPx is by far the most discussed band as like an
- 1:53:56influential band to them. So I get why m xpx's winning star Fly forty
- 1:54:01nine is a multitudes more talented and better, but it is what it is,
- 1:54:06you know, unbelievable. Eric any thoughts on that, I wouldn't have
- 1:54:11been surprised if MxPx hadn't won by even more just because really how well.
- 1:54:16Yeah, they always do so well in in in my tournament, So yeah,
- 1:54:20I wouldn't have been surprised if it. Clearly they're like they're one of
- 1:54:25those bands that has not only a a like they have popularity, but they're
- 1:54:30also like super dedicated fan base, which makes sense why they're headlining that one
- 1:54:34night of Furnace Vests. I mean, that will be I'll probably be one
- 1:54:38of the bigger furnace Fest shows, if not the biggest furnace I think,
- 1:54:42especially the fact that they haven't played for so long together, it's going to
- 1:54:45be pretty big. Yeah. Yeah, so I can't imagine how much Furnace
- 1:54:48Fests had to had to pay for them. To show that's actually that would
- 1:54:51be interesting is to like how these bands compare into how much these bands to
- 1:55:00get paid in order to play. That would not just like how many tickets
- 1:55:03are they selling, but how much they are requiring venues to pay for them.
- 1:55:09That would be interesting. I wish there was a resource. I bet,
- 1:55:13I bet, I bet that actually is probably a better act, like
- 1:55:15a more accurate measurement than Spotify listeners prob. Yeah. All right, So
- 1:55:21MxPx moves on. Next one Bleach, which somehow made it into the Sweet
- 1:55:27sixteen versus Blindside again pretty convincingly Blindside or Bleach. I don't think anybody's really
- 1:55:34supplies by surprised by this, even probably Bleach fans are probably not surprised by
- 1:55:39this. Yeah yeah, I mean Blindside's juggernaut here. Um again, it's
- 1:55:44one of those things too. It's just it's a better band versus not as
- 1:55:47a good band. Right, I mean, here's something, the fact that
- 1:55:51Blindside's gotten this far. Here's something, Eric Blindside only had what one album
- 1:55:57that was actually solid state? Right? They had two um thought trust your
- 1:56:02Mind and then they're self titled. Yes, yep, okay, so they
- 1:56:06had two out but but they're big albums that what like made them famous were
- 1:56:11not tooth and nail albums. That was interesting. Yeah, so what how
- 1:56:15when you ended up making this bracket, how did you determine what actually qualifies
- 1:56:20as a tooth and nail band? Did you go into if they just released
- 1:56:24an album off of Tooth and Nail, then they're a tooth and Nail band
- 1:56:28or did they have to have tooth and nail albums that made them big?
- 1:56:30They had to have released two at least two albums on one of the Tooth
- 1:56:34and Nail labels. Okay, so like Pod technically is a tooth and nail
- 1:56:40band because they had like an EP on Tooth and Nail, they would have
- 1:56:43been a huge I don't know how far they would have gotten, but they
- 1:56:45would have been a huge seed on this but they only released like an EP.
- 1:56:49Yeah, but and they weren't big. They didn't even get big off
- 1:56:54of Tooth and Nail. So that's like, that's the other thing that's really
- 1:56:57interesting. Yeah, it would have felt weird having like Pod as a one
- 1:57:00seed and making it to the B four based on releasing the EP on the
- 1:57:04label that the tournament placed on. Right, totally well, and ends up
- 1:57:09being Blindside versus MxPx. I'm very excited for that matchup next. All right,
- 1:57:13last last little region before we move on to the lead eight Amberlin versus
- 1:57:19Emery. Yeah, that's a tough one again. Like I feel like these
- 1:57:24are like two bands that like probably know each other pretty well, so this
- 1:57:28is a this is a good matchup. But Amberlin ends up winning pretty handily
- 1:57:31here too, sixty four to thirty six. Yeah, a much bigger string
- 1:57:36of just better songs by Amberlin. It makes sense. I would have still
- 1:57:41voted for Emery, but right, and I probably did too if I remember
- 1:57:45right, But this is Ah, it's pretty impressive that Emery even got this
- 1:57:49far with what was it, two hundred two hundred thousand monthly listeners or whatever
- 1:57:54it is. It's pretty impressive. Again, Amberlin's probably close to a million,
- 1:57:59if not over a million, and so you know, Emory is really
- 1:58:01fighting against just a massive fan base at this point. Yeah, and Amberland,
- 1:58:06even though I think they really got big outside of the Tooth and Nail
- 1:58:10world, they still were sizeable in the tooth and Nail world, Like they
- 1:58:13had a large tooth and Nail fan base, and so it makes sense ultimately
- 1:58:17that they would beat Emory. They've got a lot like crossover appeal between not
- 1:58:23just like Christian and mainstream, but like they also you know, they have
- 1:58:27the Tooth and Nail crowd, they also have like the switch Foot crowd.
- 1:58:30You know would also be switch Food fan or Amberlin fans. Yeah, they
- 1:58:35rode that rail so nicely. Where they're they're kind of drawing from again,
- 1:58:39multiple multiple different fan bases or or genre fans, I should say, where
- 1:58:45they're they're poppy enough, they're hard rock enough, they're um anthemic enough where
- 1:58:53they can they can just pull from everywhere. That's that is a sound that
- 1:58:57is difficult to accomplish, and they did it just about better than anyone.
- 1:59:00Yeah, they're they're pretty incredible. I mean, they are one of those
- 1:59:02bands where if I ever mentioned like Tooth and Nail to people, if they
- 1:59:08don't know who under Oath is, probably in the next band that I mentioned
- 1:59:11of people my age is Amberlin because of how much they were able to go
- 1:59:15outside that mainstream world. So yeah, makes sense that Amberlin ends up winning
- 1:59:19here against Emory. But sad to see Emory go. But here we are,
- 1:59:25all right, So who is Amberlin? Gonna be matched up against.
- 1:59:27It's gonna be either TFK or Me Without You. And I felt like this
- 1:59:32was one of you know, you know, stay in line, if you
- 1:59:35can stay in line kind of thing. Me without You barely beats TFK,
- 1:59:41which again I can't believe because TFK to me, does not have the fan
- 1:59:45base within the Tooth and Nail world, but clearly they have enough where they
- 1:59:50can pull off enough votes against Me Without You. But there's a massive Spotify
- 1:59:56difference here too, right, because Me without Us like what one hundred and
- 1:59:59fifty thousand monthly listeners and tfk's at three something three million. Again a massive,
- 2:00:04a massive difference here between the two bands, but Me without You one
- 2:00:10hundred and fifty thousand. Those people decided to vote. I guess the TFK
- 2:00:14fans threw up the rock fists while Me Without You fans started throwing roses at
- 2:00:18them. This this does feel like the most like Joe Biden versus Trump,
- 2:00:23kind of like actual demographic, does it not? Like out of all the
- 2:00:30like matchups between all these bands, like Me without You being the Biden vote
- 2:00:34and Trump being the TFK vote, like that that totally makes sense here.
- 2:00:41Yeah, I'm surprised, Uh surprise, TFK didn't have a steal the vote
- 2:00:44or steal steal the was it steal the vote, steal the steal the election
- 2:00:47thing. I'm sure they stormed the I'm sure they stormed at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
- 2:00:58They're they're putting another crack that liberty bill. That's right, all right?
- 2:01:02So mean with how you ends up winning, I'm glad me without you
- 2:01:08wins here. I mean TFK was honestly one of the first tooth and nail
- 2:01:12bands I ever listened to, So I think even though I like very quickly
- 2:01:15fell out of love with them, uh TFK, Like, I wouldn't probably
- 2:01:19be here without TFK, So I've at least got to like pay my respect.
- 2:01:25But at the end of the day, like me without you such a
- 2:01:28much better band, I mean, we fortunately the fans voted in that direction.
- 2:01:32Yeah, all right, So that finishes up the Sweet sixteen. A
- 2:01:36couple more match matchups here, all right, Disciple versus the OC super Tones.
- 2:01:45Again, I have no idea where this is going. These are two
- 2:01:46bands that I'm not, like, don't have a huge affinity for, but
- 2:01:50ends up that OC super Tones ends up beating out not like that big but
- 2:01:57you know they handed it to a disciple. It's pretty impressive. SKA rules
- 2:02:01the day still, yeah, pretty sure. Disciple retweeted that realm too.
- 2:02:08Yeah, I mean Disciple, did I guarantee you, Like, does OC
- 2:02:12Supertones even have a Twitter account? Probably not even have tweete. I think
- 2:02:15it got hacked and they haven't gotten it back in several years. Okay,
- 2:02:17so they got hacked and OC Supertones a still won in this fucking shit.
- 2:02:21So this is like unbelievable to me that OC Supertones are able to win over
- 2:02:26a Disciple crowd that literally retweets to vote for us, and OC Supertones are
- 2:02:32coming out, the fans are coming out in droves. Uh my goodness.
- 2:02:36These are the people that you tell them the stay in line, They will
- 2:02:42stay in line. Yeah, that's funny. Rain or Shine Disciple does feel
- 2:02:50like the kind of band that is like, you know what, don't worry
- 2:02:54about like mail in voting, but OC Supertones mail in voting, stay in
- 2:02:59line. I don't give a shiite, Like what's that? What's that why
- 2:03:08people are mailing voting? Like that's probably disciples whole thing to this whole thing.
- 2:03:12But anyway, OC Supertones winning and out again. So they're in the
- 2:03:15final four. Now we're moving on to under Oath versus a BR. This
- 2:03:20is the matchup I feel like we had to have had in the solid state
- 2:03:26category, and uh, under Oath again very convincingly wins over ABR fans that
- 2:03:34are probably pretty close in Spotify numbers and probably dedicated fan bases, and yet
- 2:03:40under Oath wins pretty convincingly. I thought that this would be really close and
- 2:03:44ends up not being all that close at all. Yeah, yeah, it
- 2:03:48would be close, surprising to me, surprising. I would never have guessed.
- 2:03:56I mean, I think eight like I could have seen it go either
- 2:03:59way. I think under Oath probably was going to take the edge, and
- 2:04:02certainly I ended up voting for under Oath. But the fact that they won
- 2:04:08that much, sixty eight percent over thirty two percent, that's pretty impressive.
- 2:04:13So here we are under Oath over a BR All right, So they're moving
- 2:04:16on to the final four with the OC super Tones. What a great matchup,
- 2:04:23all right? Elite eight for the other round or the other side of
- 2:04:28the bracket. MX p X versus blind Side, Colin, I know where
- 2:04:31you're going with this, But Eric, if you could have voted MxPx or
- 2:04:35over Blindside. Where are you gonna go with this? Blind Side easy?
- 2:04:41Okay, Blindside over m XPX for you? Okay, great? So you
- 2:04:44I think we're all three in agreement here, but mx PX wins pretty convincingly
- 2:04:49over Blindside. How are we all three um in the minority here? Just?
- 2:04:55Uh, that doesn't make sense to me either. But again, I
- 2:05:00think, like we weren't probably the biggest like pop punk punk fans, but
- 2:05:03clearly that's a huge that that MxPx world. You don't fuck with them?
- 2:05:09Yeah? Yeah, so that's like that's like the battle between pop punk and
- 2:05:13more like hardcore punk, right, because like I mean, like Blindside's early
- 2:05:17stuff is more hardcore punk. So yeah, yeah, I mean totally.
- 2:05:20I mean it's like, you know who gonna vote for, like have Heart
- 2:05:24or follow a Boy? Yeah right, Like, of course, of course
- 2:05:30follow a Boy's gonna get more votes. But the fact that Blindside made it
- 2:05:32this far Elite eight pretty impressive. I would have loved to seen them in
- 2:05:36the final four. I feel like they at least deserve that, But the
- 2:05:41fact that they're in the same region as mx PX, like it's gonna be
- 2:05:45really hard to beat any MxPx team, Like, let's be honest. I
- 2:05:49do know that some people told me they were just going to vote based on
- 2:05:55the output with a tooth and nail label, which would have hurt blind Side
- 2:05:59here considering they all had two totally two albums, I don't I don't know
- 2:06:02that it would have been enough for him to overtake m XPX, but it
- 2:06:05probably would have been close. MxPx only did they have three or four?
- 2:06:09They probably four maybe five? Ye tisane albums four Yeah, so yeah,
- 2:06:15I mean, yeah, I'll put that makes sense. But still like those
- 2:06:18first three albums, God, it's just tough. But yeah, Blindside over
- 2:06:24mx it just it's just tough. But MxPx prevails, all right. Next
- 2:06:29one the closest vote, Yeah yeah, this this literally I remember h Lindsay
- 2:06:38Ficus, which who we've interviewed. Uh, she was literally like tweeting out,
- 2:06:43if you're in line, you stay in line, Amberlin versus me without
- 2:06:47you. And even though there was a pretty big Spotify difference here, me
- 2:06:55without you prevails fifty point two over fifty nine or forty nine point eight.
- 2:07:03Yeah, that's that's like gotta be what like fifty votes difference, like maybe
- 2:07:09less than that. I think somebody said it was like forty votes or something.
- 2:07:12Oh my god, that's nuts. That is that that deserves a recount.
- 2:07:17I mean, Amberlin, if there was any reason for them to storm
- 2:07:20the capitol that this feels valid reasons. This is, this is so close
- 2:07:28and yet Me Without You pulls it out. Uh. This is Uh.
- 2:07:32This is a big deal for me as a Me Without You fan, although
- 2:07:36I love both bands, love both bands, but the fact that Me Without
- 2:07:40You was able to squeak this one out, it's pretty impressive. But yeah,
- 2:07:45forty votes, that's how close this came. That's impressive. Yeah,
- 2:07:49that's nuts. So here we are our final four. I'll repeat, our
- 2:07:55final four is the OC Supertones versus Under Oath, and then at x p
- 2:08:00X versus Me Without You. We're gonna go back to the other side of
- 2:08:03the brackets. So OC Supertones versus Under Oath, and we're starting to get
- 2:08:07really close matchups here and the OC Supertones barely squeak it out all over Under
- 2:08:16Oath. This to me blows my mind. Again, OC Supertones, I
- 2:08:20totally get getting to the final four. That makes sense to me. But
- 2:08:24over Under Oath to get to the championship does not make any sense to me.
- 2:08:28I thought under Oath would for sure get into the championship game, and
- 2:08:33here we are with the OC Supertones taking what I think is the upset over
- 2:08:39under Oath. I think this is a numbers thing. So there's there's only
- 2:08:43like a handful of of SKA bands that were really really big. OC Supertones
- 2:08:50were like the Christian example of that. There was a bunch of metalcore bands
- 2:08:58that got really big, under Oath just being the biggest of those. I
- 2:09:05think I think that there was just probably you're able to concentrate all your SKA
- 2:09:11fans into OC Supertones, whereas you're not necessarily able to concentrate all your metalcore
- 2:09:18fans into under Oath. I think it's like the only answer here that makes
- 2:09:20sense. What are you guys think? I mean, it's so weird to
- 2:09:26think like SCA versus metal core. I still thought under Oath would prevail here
- 2:09:33too. It's just it's mind blowing to me how dedicated the SKA world is.
- 2:09:39What's even more mind blowing is the fact that scot continues to get so
- 2:09:43it is repeatedly so popular in these at least in these brackets and yet there
- 2:09:52is hasn't been a revival. Metal core is still around. They're still great
- 2:09:56metal core bands, and those bands are still around doing their thing, and
- 2:09:58there new bands coming up. Who's the new SKA band or whatever like that
- 2:10:05that doesn't exist. It's mind blowing to me that that fan base is still
- 2:10:09that dedicated to a thing that existed twenty five years ago. Yeah to fifteen
- 2:10:13songs on an on an album that all sounds the same. Oh sorry,
- 2:10:16that was disrespectful. That's my band. Well, while I didn't like fill
- 2:10:22out a bracket on what I thought would happen, or a vote or anything
- 2:10:26I did, I predicted that the final four would be Supertones against under Oath,
- 2:10:33but I thought under Oath would have this one easy. I'm really surprised.
- 2:10:39Who who is your? Who are you in your championship game? Did
- 2:10:41you have under Oath versus Me without You or m xp X versus under Oath,
- 2:10:46xp X versus under Oath? That would make sense to me culin if
- 2:10:50you. I don't know if you've filled out a bracket or not, but
- 2:10:52who would you have had in your championship game? I probably would have had
- 2:10:56under Oath and um Jeremy camp, but Jeremy Camp was in the same so
- 2:11:05that would be in final four, Jeremy Camp versus under Oath. Yep,
- 2:11:09that's what That's what I would have had in my final four? Is that
- 2:11:11what you're asking? Or are you? And then the other note the championship
- 2:11:15game. For the championship, I would have had under Oath versus UM like
- 2:11:20me without you MxPx blind side and said me without you. I would not
- 2:11:24have said blind side, even though I want them to. I probably would
- 2:11:28have said m xp x Oh, so you would have put mxp x over
- 2:11:33in under Oath in the championship. Yeah, I would have put me without
- 2:11:37you and under Oath in the Championship I would have personally voted for I would
- 2:11:41have figured that MxPx and me without you were going to be in the final
- 2:11:43four, and I would have voted for me without you, and I think
- 2:11:46they would have had a fighting chance. And I was hoping that would be
- 2:11:50me without you versus under Oath. But Supertones end up beating ends up beating
- 2:11:54out under Oath. Let's go to the other side of the Brackett and x
- 2:12:00PX versus me without you, and I was right. Mx PX loses to
- 2:12:07me without you in a fifty two percent to forty eight percent vote. Pretty
- 2:12:13damn close game. But my goodness, I was not expecting honestly, I
- 2:12:18was just like putting my vote out there and hoping for the best that me
- 2:12:20without you would win. But Colin, I bet you're pretty happy about this
- 2:12:24that MxPx ends up losing the final fe without you. I'm very happy about
- 2:12:28that. I love Me without you, and I think that they're a far
- 2:12:31better band than MxPx. Um I am. I'm just surprised because it's not
- 2:12:37very often that a better band all around, to like a more esteemed listener,
- 2:12:45wins out. That's true. That's true, Eric, And any thoughts
- 2:12:50about this mx p X versus Me without You matchup that that's a to me,
- 2:12:54it seems like an upset. I could be wrong, but it seems
- 2:12:56to me like to be an upset. Well, this is actually a rematch
- 2:13:00of an elite eight matchup in the Big CCM tournament or MxPx one fifty six
- 2:13:07percent to wow. Oh man, So Lindsay's you know, shout out to
- 2:13:15you to like rally the troops of mean without you. My goodness, So
- 2:13:22how why do you think that? Do you think it's the nature of the
- 2:13:28bracket that MEW without you ends up winning this one versus MxPx winning the CCM
- 2:13:33one. Do you think it's just this one being a tooth and nail one
- 2:13:35versus XPX winning the CCM one, or do you think it's just like a
- 2:13:41voting thing where the me without you fans come out and droves or what?
- 2:13:46What? What? What do you think? Why? Why do you think
- 2:13:46there's that difference there? I think, um, you know, five Iron
- 2:13:50Frenzy won the CCM tournament, and my understanding is that there's a relationship between
- 2:13:56m XPX and five Iron Frenzy. So I'm pretty sure the uh Filero and
- 2:14:01Frenzy voters in the CCM tournament we're also voting for MxPx, which sure certainly,
- 2:14:05Yeah, that to make sense. Yeah, that's interesting. Well but
- 2:14:11well, why do you think, Um you said m xp X beat out
- 2:14:15me without you though in the lead eight? Yeah, why do you think
- 2:14:18m xp X be them out in the lead eight me without you in the
- 2:14:22lead eight in that bracket but not this one in the final four? Well
- 2:14:26that that's kind of what I was getting at. Like the main CECUM tournament,
- 2:14:30Firo and Frenzy was rallying all their voters where they had no put into
- 2:14:33this one. So that makes sense. Yeah, okay, well we are
- 2:14:39voters, right yeah damn libertarians? All right? So OC Supertones versus ME
- 2:14:48without You? All right, if you're watching this on YouTube, you have
- 2:14:52not been able to see the the champion. We don't know who the champion
- 2:14:56is. We're literally recording right now not knowing who the mpion is. I
- 2:15:01have it pulled up on Twitter, and I made sure not to look look
- 2:15:03at the results, but I have it pulled up on Twitter right now.
- 2:15:07Who the championship is? Uh and and who has won the Tooth and Nail
- 2:15:11champion and let me it's still like, I still have you muted, Eric,
- 2:15:18So here we go, all right, that the we're gonna I'm gonna
- 2:15:26pull this up here and we're gonna find out who ends up winning. But
- 2:15:31it is what all right, MEW without You with fifty seven percent of the
- 2:15:41vote over OC super Tones with forty three percent of the vote. No way,
- 2:15:46I'm actually kind of shocked by this. How well OC Supertones we're doing
- 2:15:50throughout the tournament. I thought that the troops would rally here. Yeah,
- 2:15:54but mew with how you ends up winning the Tooth and Nail Championship and there
- 2:16:00were over a thousand votes in the final. That is impressive. Father Josh
- 2:16:09Koulik, I don't know I say your last name, but you are the
- 2:16:11You're at least on our screenshot here, and you were asking if you're voting
- 2:16:16as my high school self or my college self. You're voting as yourself.
- 2:16:20I don't care who you are. You're voting as yourself, and Me without
- 2:16:24You ends up winning over the OC Supertones. I do think that these are
- 2:16:30two different fan bases, but I think they are fan bases that would at
- 2:16:35the very least respect one another. Like if Me without You hadn't been in
- 2:16:39this tournament, in this championship, but the OC Supertones were, I think
- 2:16:45those those ME without You fans would have voted for OC Supertones and vice versa.
- 2:16:48If the OC Supertones weren't in this championship but Me without You was,
- 2:16:52I think Me without You would have gotten the fans from the OC Supertones.
- 2:16:56Maybe I'm wrong, but that's what I'm thinking. I would never throw my
- 2:17:01head in with a SKA fan. I'm not talking about you specifically. I'm
- 2:17:07talking about in general. Well, yeah, but if you're talking about in
- 2:17:09general, I'm just saying in general, that's not what I would do.
- 2:17:13So without you fan, I get that, and I and I wouldn't either,
- 2:17:18But I like likely whoever the other band was, I would be voted
- 2:17:22for the other band over the OC super Tones, But I do see that
- 2:17:26there is a respect from each fan base for the other band. Yeah,
- 2:17:30I'd be curious to know if Under Oath ends up pulling out a victory there
- 2:17:35who wins between Me Without You and Under Oath? That is a good I
- 2:17:39think it might be closer than the OC super Tones versus Me Without You.
- 2:17:46Yeah, what what do you think, Eric, what do you think about
- 2:17:48this matchup? And what do you think about any like possible other matchups that
- 2:17:52it could have been. Yeah, I think it would have been a lot
- 2:17:54closer if it was Me Without You versus Under Oath, because you know,
- 2:17:58those those first made Without You albums were kind of heavier and actually solid state
- 2:18:05releases, So there's a little more in common there between the two that I
- 2:18:09think could have swayed some voters the other way. Yeah, as far as
- 2:18:13the result of this, I'm always surprised when skolarses anymore so. But the
- 2:18:18fact that SKA gets this far and again, this is not like five votes.
- 2:18:24I mean, this final round was a thousand votes, and they were
- 2:18:26probably collectively tens of thousands of votes in this in this tournament. The fact
- 2:18:35that SKA remains so beloved it blows my mind. I mean, even the
- 2:18:43fact that they're even commedian this much with Me Without You fifty seven to forty
- 2:18:46blows my mind. But yet here we are. But I honestly I couldn't
- 2:18:52be happier, even though The Chariot's my favorite band of all time and happens
- 2:18:54to be on you know, the Solid State Tooth and Nail World, and
- 2:18:56they got eliminated right away in the first round. I would have predicted it
- 2:19:01to be under Oath versus Me Without You, but I at least got one
- 2:19:05of them in, and Me Without You ends up winning, and I think
- 2:19:09rightfully so. I mean, MEW Without You was one of those bands that
- 2:19:13has a respect from so many different people. Even Hayley Williams from Paramore is
- 2:19:20like the biggest Me Without You fan. And you get a band that literally
- 2:19:26can play an acoustic guitar at a show and people are literally mohing. No
- 2:19:31other band in the world is like that, and I feel like Me without
- 2:19:35You for that reason alone respectfully wins the Tooth and Nail Tournament. Yeah I'm
- 2:19:45I'm gonna say ditto. Yeah, I'm happy with that. There were there
- 2:19:50were maybe five bands that I feel like had a rightful claim to be in,
- 2:19:54you know, the quintessential tooth and Nail band and Me Without You or
- 2:19:58one of them. So so Me without You under oath OC super Tones maybe
- 2:20:03was that other third band? Right, are the other couple bands that you're
- 2:20:07thinking mx PX and A Berlin think, Yeah, those those feel like the
- 2:20:11five. That feels like the five that should be at least in the final
- 2:20:15four, or if they could have been all in the final four, that
- 2:20:18makes sense. Yeah, that that seems right. It's pretty remarkable that a
- 2:20:24band of one hundred and fifty thousand monthly listeners ends up winning. And maybe
- 2:20:28it's a recency biased thing, right because Me without You just broke up.
- 2:20:31Everybody's still like heartbroken about Me Without You. Maybe it's that over the OC
- 2:20:37super Tones, But still, I really do think Me Without You is one
- 2:20:41of those bands that even outside of the Christian indie world. I think there
- 2:20:48are lots of artists who are like I wouldn't be an artist because without me
- 2:20:52without you. Yeah, that's how influential they are. And I do think
- 2:21:00as much as we hear MxPx, I do think Me without You versus under
- 2:21:05Oath, those are like two of the more influential bands that we consistently hear.
- 2:21:09MxPx is one of those two. Yeah, but those are like the
- 2:21:11two the three two or three bands that we hear consistently is influential, And
- 2:21:16so it makes sense why a band like Me without You would get this far
- 2:21:20and then end up winning it all. Yeah, yeah, well me without
- 2:21:26You wins. Whin's the whole thing. Any final conclusions about the entire tournament
- 2:21:31in general, I'm just curious, like any kind of like overarching ideas,
- 2:21:35thoughts, themes that you saw throughout it, any any ideas around that.
- 2:21:39I think it's a wonderful experiment to kind of see where there's different there's different
- 2:21:45interests and where those loyalties lie. You know, some of them just like
- 2:21:50in any bracket, but some of them just didn't make sense how they were
- 2:21:54winning by a little bit and then all of a sudden by a lot on
- 2:21:56them the very next round or not at all on the next round. Where
- 2:22:01the support uh Waynes and waxes is interesting to me. It makes you wonder
- 2:22:09where the thought process was and where those loyalty is really live. But Eric,
- 2:22:13I gotta I gotta say thank you for doing the Lord's work here,
- 2:22:15because this is this is important data. We have to have this kind of
- 2:22:18stuff. Oh it's fun. I'm enjoy doing it for the most part.
- 2:22:22For the most part, I don't you like about it? Uh, you
- 2:22:26know, there can be usually about halfway through some of the I get,
- 2:22:28you know, a little tired of all the comments. You know, this
- 2:22:33part, this bench should have been in it, this bench should have been
- 2:22:35seeing how this this. I brush it off for a while, and then
- 2:22:39about halfway through against to me a little bit, and then I regained my
- 2:22:43strength and I'm very happy with things by the time it's over. Look over
- 2:22:48at the screen shot right here and see how many uh notifications Mason has on
- 2:22:52this screen shot. Yeah, I don't even like those are twenty different arguments
- 2:22:58that Mason's like gonna go have here and just a few. I don't know
- 2:23:01how he does it, I said him, I said him. Message not
- 2:23:05longer. I said, how in the world do you do this? You
- 2:23:05have twenty times more followers than I do, and I feel like I can't
- 2:23:09keep up with things. Mason. Also, anytime we're hanging out, he
- 2:23:16spends an exclusionary amount of time on the toilet. I feel like hemorrhoids have
- 2:23:24to be a part of this whole situation, because well, we don't need
- 2:23:28to talk about that right now. You know, he's he's just, he's
- 2:23:31just he's just arguing only on the toilet. It's like his space. Well
- 2:23:37and if if, if only they knew that that's where I am doing.
- 2:23:39You know, that's how serious I'm taking the arguments from them. You know,
- 2:23:43they're they're putting like all this thought, They're like probably you know,
- 2:23:46they're like googling shit, They're putting all this research in and I'm like,
- 2:23:48I'm just saying whatever comes to mind while I'm sitting on culin max toilet.
- 2:23:56And I'm perfectly fine with people disagreeing with me, you know, I'm on
- 2:24:00with that. It's just when people are jerks about it that it's goods to
- 2:24:03me. Yeah, well, wow, we should have been jerks calling.
- 2:24:05That would have been fun. No, that's nice. Eric's gray. Hey,
- 2:24:11Eric, we're gonna bring you back on at some point. Well,
- 2:24:13well, we actually we should do like a very like niche Christian like super
- 2:24:18like underrated nobody knows about them, like Christian band thing, nobody might listen,
- 2:24:24but they would be really fun. Less than one thousand Spotify listeners,
- 2:24:28let's do. Yes, yeah, that would be. And we could title
- 2:24:31it like like you know, a thousand Spotify listener or less Christian music artist
- 2:24:37tournament or something like that. That would be. That would be a fun
- 2:24:39time. We could even put it out there and like ask bands that have
- 2:24:41less than a thousand to to give us their vouch for themselves. That'd be
- 2:24:48fun. That would be a lot of fun. But anyway, thank you
- 2:24:52so much, Eric, This has been so much fun. It's been so
- 2:24:56cool to just like see this whole thing blow up and so many people,
- 2:24:58uh be a part of this. And also, congratulations to me without you,
- 2:25:03pround of applause to me without you. Unbelievable, so great, such
- 2:25:09an incredible band and rightfully deserving of the top tooth and nail artist of all
- 2:25:13time. So yeah, here we are great, wonderful. Thank you so
- 2:25:18much, Eric, all right, Thanks for having me. Thanks man,