Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E059: Multi-Jurisdiction Custody with Tetra Trust CEO, Didier Lavallee
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 0:07excrement ever assembled in the history of.
- 0:11Gutless. 1974198792972. 1000 and whatever we're.
- 0:18Going to call this. It's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK, I say when we sell.
- 0:33Welcome back everybody. It's a little bit of a early
- 0:35week podcast before the big Nashville conference.
- 0:39We're joined by DDA Lavelle, CEO of Tetra Trust, which we're
- 0:43excited to talk about some really interesting things we're
- 0:46doing with them, but also his background and what Tetra Trust
- 0:49is doing in Canada, which is pretty exciting.
- 0:53DD and I could connected back in consensus and you know, for
- 0:57building this industry for a while, I had no idea kind of
- 1:01Canadians status from Canada, status from custody, the
- 1:05regulatory environment and how much it's sought after across
- 1:07the globe, frankly, for assets and security.
- 1:10So, DDA, welcome to the podcast. Thanks guys.
- 1:14I appreciate you having me. Awesome.
- 1:18Well, I figured in part of the notes we maybe just start with
- 1:20your background. I think what I've historically
- 1:23seen in this space, it's really fascinating, is some of the best
- 1:26builders, if not the best builders come from a traditional
- 1:29professional background, whether it's like big tech, I think of
- 1:31Mike Belshie and Google or your background at UBS and the Royal
- 1:35Bank of Canada. And just curious kind of like
- 1:38how your journey there and how you got there and then went to
- 1:42Bitcoin and ultimately founding and building Tetra.
- 1:45Super fascinating. I think it will, you know,
- 1:47really shed a lot of light on what.
- 1:48We're doing here. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:53You know, when you look at at the background, you know, I
- 1:56would probably qualify myself as a, you know, call it a stock
- 1:59market junkie to start, if I may use that terminology.
- 2:04Always very curious, always very interested in companies.
- 2:08My father was an entrepreneur and and really the stock market
- 2:11gave me the opportunity to, you know, evaluate just companies
- 2:16after companies. So I started in equity research,
- 2:20did that for a little bit of time, and then eventually went
- 2:24to work at UBS across essentially Canada and then
- 2:27eventually to RBC for where I spent about a decade.
- 2:32I was focused on equities for about 12 years.
- 2:36So really equity research, equity trading, equity sales.
- 2:40On the institutional side. You know, one of the piece that
- 2:43was always interesting for me, specifically on the
- 2:46institutional sales side, was to spend time with leaders of
- 2:49businesses. So, you know, CE OS and CF OS to
- 2:52roadshows, worried about their business, learned what investors
- 2:56thought was was relevant and important.
- 3:00You know, I had a little bit of an event at 35I, you know, I had
- 3:03my daughter, she was born in Manhattan.
- 3:06And I looked at, you know, all the skill set that I had
- 3:10accumulating being on an equity desk, and I basically said it's
- 3:14time for a pivot. And RBC gave me this great
- 3:17opportunity to essentially, you know, pivot into another piece
- 3:20of their business. And I moved into, you know,
- 3:23essentially asset servicing and treasury management, move from
- 3:27equities to foreign exchange, essentially managed foreign
- 3:32exchange trading desks, learn, you know, kind of the trading
- 3:37business, the first line of defense, the capital and risk
- 3:41management, the PNL management excetera really quickly then,
- 3:47you know, my career really started accelerated from there.
- 3:49I was given an opportunity to essentially build an automated
- 3:53foreign exchange execution system and and to help with that
- 3:56roll out, build a team which which was fantastic experience.
- 4:00And then my last role before Tetra was essentially a head of
- 4:03Canadian custody product where RBC had about four trillion in
- 4:09assets. You know, when you think about
- 4:12the transition between Trad 5 to digital assets, I mean, for me
- 4:19it came with a little bit of frustration and, you know, being
- 4:24supposedly a change agent within a large organization, but having
- 4:29very little capacity to actually change anything.
- 4:33More specifically, you know, if you look at, you know,
- 4:36technology that's 50 or 60 years old, that is basically what the
- 4:41banking systems are built on today.
- 4:43You know, the lack of capacity to integrate with, you know,
- 4:46just basic things like API. People take for granted that the
- 4:50banking system works really well, but when you look under
- 4:53the hood, it's a bunch of manual steps and really, really old
- 4:57systems. So having the opportunity to
- 5:00build essentially on blockchain technology, you know, modernize
- 5:05financial infrastructure and, and really leave, you know,
- 5:10legacy infrastructure, I think for the future.
- 5:13And you know, my, my, my kids are a big part of my narrative.
- 5:17Was really excited for me and you know, almost a no brainer in
- 5:20terms of opportunity. At Onramp, we believe that
- 5:23Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 5:27The hard part is securing it, right.
- 5:30There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 5:32exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 5:35arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 5:37concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 5:40solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 5:44ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 5:46possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 5:50your family is protected as well.
- 5:52On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 5:55whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 5:58to your existing self custody set up.
- 6:01For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 6:05Yeah, that that's fascinating. I guess where in that story did
- 6:09like Bitcoin and blockchain kind of like fall in?
- 6:13Was it you know, post COVID in the 2020 or where?
- 6:15Where does that like insert the bug?
- 6:19Yeah, I know, absolutely. I mean, I actually, it was out
- 6:22of curiosity that I came across Bitcoin.
- 6:25I, I, I read Digital Gold, which is now appropriate in 2024, but
- 6:30essentially the book that Nathaniel Popper published in,
- 6:34in 2016. So I read it, you know, around
- 6:37the 2016 time frame and you know, being a public market
- 6:40investor, just making a lot of sense to me to even put a
- 6:45fractional amount of, yeah, let's say our, our allocation
- 6:49into investments into Bitcoin. And at the time, living in New
- 6:53York, I mean, I had access to a basically Coinbase wallet.
- 6:56I think if I remember correctly, I bought some Bitcoin, Litecoin
- 7:00and Ethereum and, and just basically sat on it.
- 7:03I remember the reaction from some of my counterparties on a
- 7:07trading floor is essentially, you know, you're, you're kind of
- 7:09nuts. Why would you do this?
- 7:11It's a scam, this and that. But I just really, it kind of
- 7:15really resonated with me. The technology, you know, the
- 7:19aspect of the store of value remittances and, and you know,
- 7:24payments, you know, potential use cases.
- 7:29I'll be honest, it kind of sad dormant there for for a long
- 7:32time. It wasn't until, you know, I was
- 7:36asked to take a look at Tetra and what I could do that I
- 7:40really kind of refreshed, you know, my outlook on digital
- 7:44assets and you know, essentially all the possibilities that came.
- 7:48But it also came at a point where my frustration around
- 7:52financial technology was also very high.
- 7:55So I think it was a perfect match.
- 7:57You know, the timing, the, the inception of me being interested
- 8:01in digital asset happened much earlier in my career are before
- 8:06Tetra. I would say, you know, 4-5 years
- 8:09before. But the match came at a point
- 8:13where personally, I was ready for change but also, you know,
- 8:17felt incapable of delivering change, you know, in my, in my
- 8:22current capacity at a big financial institution.
- 8:26Yeah, that's, that's so interesting to hear.
- 8:30I had a similar sort of experience of, of I was working
- 8:35at Bain as a management consultant and in 2014 I I got
- 8:39pulled into put helping put together our perspective on on
- 8:46digital transformation for banks, you know, like our our
- 8:50firm wide perspective on it. And you know, obviously it's led
- 8:53by the partner. And then as a lower level
- 8:55analyst, I was, I was putting stuff together, but the thing
- 8:58that that quickly became off limits was you weren't allowed
- 9:04to recommend updating from mainframe computers.
- 9:08So that was you, you know, we, we were developing our digital
- 9:11transformation playbook for banks, but you weren't allowed
- 9:13to suggest that you should maybe consider updating from mainframe
- 9:17computers because it was, it was mission critical infrastructure
- 9:20that you couldn't, you couldn't mess with.
- 9:23And that was a, one of the points that one of the
- 9:27ingredients, I think that helped me be interested in
- 9:30cryptocurrency. When I also read Digital Gold by
- 9:34Nathaniel Popper. And it's a little too bad he
- 9:36doesn't focus more on Bitcoin in that book, 'cause I also went
- 9:39down that altcoin path at that time.
- 9:42But it's, it's interesting hearing similar sort of you were
- 9:47aware of these data points as they became, you know, part of
- 9:51your professional life about how the old, the legacy system is,
- 9:55is not up to the challenge of a digital future.
- 9:59And you know, digital native infrastructure is, is really the
- 10:03way to go and, and you're, you're building that now.
- 10:07Yeah, no, absolutely. I mean, one of the things I
- 10:10would I would maybe point out there as well as, you know, you
- 10:14take for granted, right in the US, you know, you have AJP
- 10:17Morgan account or Bank of America, you use Venmo to
- 10:20transfer value to, to your friends.
- 10:23I mean, in Canada, the infrastructure is slightly
- 10:25different, but at the end of the day, it's a handful of massive
- 10:28actors that are providing getting, you know, banking
- 10:30services and then, you know, allow you to interact on, on
- 10:34this, interact on various platforms.
- 10:36Actually the, you know the, let's say the exchange of value
- 10:40in Canada is done on the system like on called Interact that is
- 10:44owned by the big 5 banks. The you know, the points of the
- 10:49data. I don't think I would have
- 10:50gotten there if I didn't work in asset servicing and treasury
- 10:54management. When you start, you know,
- 10:57looking at transferring value all over the planet and the
- 11:00steps involved in moving cash, you know, the different
- 11:04custodian, custodian access to central banks.
- 11:08I mean, you start drawing a map of complexity that just, you
- 11:12know, I think would blow anybody's mind.
- 11:14But to be fair, most people don't really fully understand it
- 11:18unless you're trying to sell or send money, sorry,
- 11:21internationally to loved ones or to family members or for
- 11:25whatever reason you might have not, you know, seen those
- 11:29issues. But those issues are real.
- 11:32And, you know, you see it with fractional reserves in the USI
- 11:35mean, I don't have to talk to you guys about this.
- 11:37You know, we saw it really well in in 2023 with some of the bank
- 11:41failures. And it's happened historically a
- 11:43few times as well. So, you know, those data points
- 11:47just got, I would say more intense, Jesse, as my knowledge
- 11:51of the financial infrastructure also got deeper and deeper.
- 11:55And we try to, as part of the narrative at Tetra, educate
- 11:59people on basic concept of financial systems, right?
- 12:03Not necessarily going too deep, but how money moves, you know,
- 12:06why it's inefficient, why blockchain technology can help,
- 12:11you know, the role that Bitcoin can play into that.
- 12:15So there's an education part of of what we do as well that can
- 12:20help people understand better how risky it is currently to,
- 12:26you know, maintain the current financial infrastructure that as
- 12:30it stands. Yeah, that that makes a lot of
- 12:33sense in understanding that landscape because I think that
- 12:36really is like prerequisite almost to changing it, right?
- 12:40It's like if we know the existing model and how it's
- 12:42inefficient and then we have this new technology, then how
- 12:45can you map it to like basically fill the gap in those
- 12:49inefficiencies? But taking a step back, yeah,
- 12:53I'm curious, So you had the time at RBC and was working through
- 12:57building there and then looked at Tetra, founded in 2019.
- 13:04What was that relationship with Tetra in Canada from 19 to 2022?
- 13:09And was there a component of just like how you referenced
- 13:13this idea that you had Bitcoin sitting at Coinbase dormant?
- 13:16I think most people globally are now are starting to realize
- 13:18like, wait, maybe it doesn't make sense for me to send all my
- 13:20Bitcoin to San Francisco. I need other solutions.
- 13:23And curious if that was part of Tetra's founding story or where
- 13:27the foundation of Tetra started and ultimately how you were
- 13:30pulled in in 2022 to leave the firm?
- 13:35Yeah. So you know, really the Tetra
- 13:37inception came out of the Quadriga failure in Canada.
- 13:41So Quadriga CX, you know when Quadriga happened, you really
- 13:46had two marketplaces in Canada to purchase and sell digital
- 13:51assets. It was Quadriga and it was Coin
- 13:54Square and you know it. It highlighted the need to have
- 13:59proper qualified custody or third party custodian,
- 14:03essentially behind the crypto trading platforms and what
- 14:07retail users would be using. It also started a journey around
- 14:13educating local regulators around, you know, what a digital
- 14:18asset custodian framework would look like at a trust level.
- 14:22NYDFS was ahead of Canada definitely.
- 14:25I mean, because I think they issued their first license in
- 14:272015 to to Paxos and then Gemini got one that few months later,
- 14:33but it took until July 2021 for the Canadian regulators to
- 14:37essentially issue a license to, to Tetra.
- 14:40So from 19 to 21, essentially there was a lot of work that was
- 14:45done behind the scenes trying to educate the regulators as to why
- 14:50this was necessary. And it also came at a time where
- 14:53there was a lot of work being done by our regulators in Canada
- 14:58around, well, how do we prevent Puerto Rico from happening
- 15:00again? What kind of checks and balances
- 15:04do we need? And you know, it's, it's
- 15:07obviously custody has an important part of it because the
- 15:10guy was basically holding the keys and disappeared with all
- 15:14the clients assets, right. So that's really the inception
- 15:17story of Tetra. It came out of a failure and
- 15:22essentially the necessity of having proper qualified custody
- 15:26in country, locally regulated. And as you, you know, you're
- 15:31probably aware, you know, the financial system or
- 15:35infrastructure in Canada, you know, is, is I would argue well
- 15:39governed, right? Like we went through the great
- 15:42financial crisis relatively unscathed.
- 15:46You know, we have a very conservative framework up here.
- 15:49You know, there's only a handful of that entities.
- 15:51They have, you know, pretty, pretty strong capital controls.
- 15:56So having the opportunity to create a similar framework for
- 16:00digital assets I think has resonated really, really well
- 16:04across the globe just because of the, you know, perceived safety
- 16:11that the Canadian financial infrastructure brings and the
- 16:15control around governance etcetera for its its financial
- 16:19institutions. And Didier, Marty here jumped in
- 16:27late, had a call that ran quite a bit longer than expected.
- 16:32So sorry for being a bit tardy. But with that in mind, like what
- 16:35are when you're looking to right the wrongs of Quadriga and start
- 16:40from Ground Zero building up in terms of providing the market
- 16:44with quality custody solutions? What are like the number one,
- 16:48two and three things in the checklist that you need to be
- 16:51wary of providing this type of service to the market?
- 16:54Is it more social governance before you even get the
- 16:57technical? Does it start from a technical
- 16:59base? What are the assurances that you
- 17:02guys look to provide the market to right the wrongs that were
- 17:07created by Quadriga? Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:09And by the way, nice hat. Love Prince St.
- 17:12Pizza. Yeah, you know, I would say you
- 17:18definitely have to start with, for us it starts with key
- 17:23management and key control, right.
- 17:25Who has access to the keys? How are they governed and
- 17:28control, you know, backups, segregation of roles and
- 17:33responsibilities and and really educating as well, Marty across
- 17:38across the board, right. Again, going back to let's say
- 17:41day one, you start a conversation with a regulator,
- 17:44they have no concept of what digital assets are.
- 17:47And anyways, most of them and they don't know how it's going
- 17:50to fit in, right. They have a vision of, you know,
- 17:53let's say equities depositories like DTCC or you know, CBS up in
- 17:59Canada and entities that control, you know, virtual
- 18:02certificates for equities. But they don't have a concept,
- 18:06you know, digital asset, you know, key management, wallet
- 18:10infrastructure, etcetera. So it, it really starts with,
- 18:16OK, what's the proper governance framework to ensure that we know
- 18:20where the keys are at all times. We know that there's no single
- 18:24individual that can leave with those keys.
- 18:28We understand there's proper governance and oversight.
- 18:31So Tetra, when it started on day one, Tetra had a board of
- 18:36directors, all very experienced and you know financial
- 18:39institutions, financial infrastructure, a lot of our
- 18:43board members have gone on and build great businesses over
- 18:46their career to the right of governance and oversight from
- 18:50various committees, right? We have audit committees, we
- 18:53have governance committees, etcetera.
- 18:56So providing that right, that right infrastructure, it also
- 19:00goes with transparency in my view, right?
- 19:04You know, to your point, Michael, around sending all your
- 19:06Bitcoin to San Francisco. I mean, we do a lot of work with
- 19:10a lot of platform globally's and globally.
- 19:13And at times when you start asking questions around key and
- 19:17key management, you know, you will get answers like, well, you
- 19:21know, we don't share our secret or here's our shock.
- 19:25Don't worry, our auditors have reviewed our process.
- 19:29That's not very comforting, specifically from an industry
- 19:32that, you know, typically would say don't just trust verify,
- 19:37right? So the transparency, the
- 19:41governance, I think are fundamental points.
- 19:43And then Marty, I think what probably makes Canada a little
- 19:47bit different than other markets as well as some of the capital
- 19:51metrics and capital requirements around running a trust
- 19:54structure. So we have very clearly defined
- 19:58capital metrics at Tetra that we need to meet.
- 20:01There's a lot of capital behind the entity to essentially, you
- 20:05know, we're going to call it protect and airport the assets.
- 20:09But there's a certain level of maturity inside that you need to
- 20:12have to offer in this space, which again, I think is, is is
- 20:16pretty good and you know, helps prevent, you know, the kind of
- 20:20failures that you might have seen in other jurisdictions just
- 20:23because of how the entities are, are positioned towards the
- 20:28regulators. It's fascinating because I think
- 20:33most people forget about Quadriga in 2018 and like
- 20:38knowing Tetra stem from that or the the reason for its
- 20:41existence. It would imagine you guys were
- 20:44OK in 2022, but there was a lot of firms that in 2022 went belly
- 20:47up because they didn't have that framework to build from the
- 20:50ground up. They were the first version.
- 20:52They were the Quadriga of that vintage.
- 20:54So it's just fascinating to see that like circle kind of go
- 20:57around in different markets. And I know when we chatted that
- 21:01there was regulatory bodies all over the world, frankly reaching
- 21:04out to you guys, trying to understand either your custody
- 21:07model or some of the oversight that Canada had to, you know,
- 21:12thinking about like whether it's UAE or some of the Caymans to
- 21:17have a better framework and how they should think about digital
- 21:19assets. It's curious like how that
- 21:21that's gone. Yeah.
- 21:25I mean, I think it's, it's fascinating, but what also
- 21:27humbling, right, to get to get outreach from various
- 21:30jurisdictions, you know, around the custodial framework, the
- 21:34governance, you know what I would call our terms and
- 21:37conditions with our primary regulators, but also how we work
- 21:42with, you know, the rest of the industry in, in governing the
- 21:45system, the framework. I think there's been obviously a
- 21:50lot of jurisdictions over the last, you know, two years, 2 1/2
- 21:56years that are really dug into digital assets that want to
- 22:00create frameworks that aren't sure where to start, You know,
- 22:04having a failure, I think I'll always helps, you know, push you
- 22:07forward pretty quickly. I mean, you know, just look at
- 22:10what's happening in India in the last week or so.
- 22:13And I'm sure there's going to be some regulatory impact that's
- 22:16going to come out of that. You know, they, they want to
- 22:20hear, you know, essentially from the regulatory landscape.
- 22:24They want to hear from the market participants.
- 22:27They want to understand essentially what's the barrier
- 22:30to entry or how high the barrier is.
- 22:33I mean, you know, a Tetra, we like to think about our specific
- 22:38license. It's just, you know, not only
- 22:41setting the standard in the marketplace, but also, you know,
- 22:45almost like a little bit of a starting place, right?
- 22:47We're now three years in operation.
- 22:49There's no other entities in Canada been able to essentially
- 22:53land the license that we have, even though there's been, you
- 22:56know, what we're told over 12 applicants.
- 23:00You know, we are consistently evolving the standard.
- 23:02And I think one of the things that I can point to is, for
- 23:05example, proof of reserves. When we started, you know, in
- 23:102021, one of the requirements that we had worked with the
- 23:14regulator on was essentially to do proof of reserves twice a
- 23:18year. So before 2022, before FTX 4,
- 23:24you know, people started releasing their wallet addresses
- 23:27and basically validating everything that was, you know,
- 23:32in the vaults or on the platforms on chain.
- 23:35Tetra was already doing those audits.
- 23:37Now, as you guys are probably very familiar with a proof of
- 23:41reserve isn't perfect and you know, the very nature that it's
- 23:44a snapshot of the specific point in time, right?
- 23:48So there's all sorts of things that can happen around that
- 23:51snapshot. And I think you've seen some
- 23:53global exchanges essentially, you know, move assets in for the
- 23:57proof of reserves and then out and then the activity is
- 23:59validated on changing. People can see that that
- 24:02happened. But one of the things we work on
- 24:05is essentially, well, how do you make that framework better,
- 24:07right? What's better than proof of
- 24:09reserves, let's say biannually is be able to do it more
- 24:13frequently, being able to do it ad hoc, being able to basically
- 24:18you know, have the regulators go on chain themselves and verify
- 24:21the information that we are providing essentially given also
- 24:26them the tools to go and verify themselves.
- 24:29Again, going back to that phrase, don't trust verify.
- 24:33And so you know, we've been able to develop a lot of framework in
- 24:38Canada based on the initial requirements and then push those
- 24:41those frameworks forward. And I think it's helped a lot of
- 24:45jurisdictions essentially evolve their landscape.
- 24:49We're actually in in talks with a couple of jurisdictions where
- 24:52they would like Tetra to come in and and basically operate as an
- 24:55entity, you know, apply educate on the framework, potentially do
- 25:00a key deployment locally, which which is all very interesting.
- 25:05I think you're also going to see a lot more custody in country in
- 25:11the very near future. It is a trend that we are
- 25:15starting to see. I mean, I think Germany's there,
- 25:18UAE's there, Australia's talking about it, Singapore, Hong Kong,
- 25:24Japan, all jurisdictions. They're essentially talking
- 25:27about, you know, making sure that key ownership and, and key
- 25:31control is in country with a locally registered entity.
- 25:36And I think this is a trend that you're going to see happen more
- 25:38and more. And it makes sense, right?
- 25:40If you have a failure in another jurisdiction, well, it it, you
- 25:45don't want to try to go recover your assets in that jurisdiction
- 25:49if you're a player in another country.
- 25:51I mean, there's all sorts of reasons why jurisdictional risk
- 25:54is suboptimal from a, from a key management perspective, from an
- 25:58asset recovery perspective. So that's certainly one of the
- 26:01trends that we've seen and a lot of players have reached out or a
- 26:04lot of jurisdictions have reached out to basically get our
- 26:07sense on that front. That makes a ton of sense.
- 26:12I mean, we talk about eliminating trusted third
- 26:15parties at the individual level with decentralized exchanges,
- 26:18but if you're a nation state that's going to wade into the
- 26:22waters of Bitcoin, it makes a lot of sense that you would want
- 26:26the keys that secure your Bitcoin held within your
- 26:29borders. I mean, it's been beaten to a
- 26:32dead horse over the last two years, but you just look at what
- 26:34happened to Russia's treasury assets.
- 26:37Whether you agree with Russia's war in Ukraine or not is
- 26:41external to the effect of being able to freeze assets and sell
- 26:47them off without any repercussion on behalf of the
- 26:51person that owns those assets. So it makes sense.
- 26:53And there is one thing I wanted to circle back on as it pertains
- 26:58to proof of reserves, because there is this ongoing
- 27:01conversation about proof of reserves.
- 27:03Can you even do it correctly? Doesn't even make sense.
- 27:07And I do think there's like a spectrum of a proof of reserve
- 27:10system from pretty poor and doesn't give you a lot of
- 27:14assurances to gives you way more assurances and something I've
- 27:18really never heard anybody talk about.
- 27:20But I'd be interested Didier to see if you guys think about
- 27:23this. But within a proof of reserve
- 27:25system. Do you guys basic calculate coin
- 27:31days of the coins that have been hold held in cold storage in
- 27:35particular wallets and and market that as proof of reserve
- 27:38saying like we've had 1000 Bitcoin that have been in this
- 27:41wallet for X amount of days? Because I think that's one of
- 27:45the big knocks on proof of reserves is that somebody who is
- 27:48marketing proof of reserves could easily move some Bitcoin
- 27:52into a wallet like a day, a week, a month before they do the
- 27:56proof of reserve audit and then quickly move it out after.
- 27:58But I think there's some metrics that could be added to proof of
- 28:01reserve. So it would really solidify the
- 28:04legitimacy of a company trying to do proof of reserves.
- 28:07And one of those metrics is coin days within the wallets that
- 28:11you're doing reserves for. Yeah, that's, that's a really
- 28:17good point. I mean, coin days is certainly
- 28:19one of the data points that we are looking to do.
- 28:23The one thing I would say, Marty, is because we have a fair
- 28:26amount of crypto trading platforms on our balance or on
- 28:30our balances, there's a certain transactional aspect to, you
- 28:36know, what we hold. And what I mean by that is
- 28:38there's a lot of in and out, you know, I would say on a daily
- 28:41basis. Additionally, if you look at the
- 28:43ETF business, there's also some transactional nature obviously
- 28:48around subscriptions and redemptions.
- 28:50That means that there's, there's in and out.
- 28:52So you can do a percentage basis, right.
- 28:54You can say, well, let's say 70%, eighty percent, 90%,
- 28:58whatever the number is been there for a certain amount of
- 29:01time. The one thing though that we're
- 29:04really focused on is essentially providing the tools to the
- 29:08various regulators, you know, so they can do their own oversight.
- 29:13So we've been working, you know, our, our partner on this front
- 29:16is Elliptic. We've been working with, you
- 29:19know, various on chain analytics tool.
- 29:23We have our own actually UI that people can sign on to and can
- 29:29they verify the information, the wallets, you know, the addresses
- 29:32themselves. But ultimately what we'd like to
- 29:35do is to make sure that the regulators can go in at any
- 29:38point in time and verify the information because that's
- 29:41really the only way you can get comfort around proof of
- 29:46reserves. In my opinion is don't come
- 29:49through me have the tools to essentially or through Tetra
- 29:54have the tools to essentially go verify yourself whenever you
- 29:58feel that, you know, you need to audit the system.
- 30:01So we are looking to evolve from a, you know, I would say a
- 30:08certain periodic report that we're providing to the to the
- 30:12various regulatory bodies with data sets.
- 30:14Like let's say, you know, the amount of days that, you know,
- 30:17the coins have been in the storage to essentially creating
- 30:21tools to allow people to validate the information
- 30:24themselves. And you might say, well, Diddy,
- 30:26if they sign into your front end, then you can control your
- 30:29front end. OK, fair.
- 30:31But at the end of the day, we're also educating them as to, you
- 30:34know, how to work with the various on chain tools to be
- 30:38able to verify themselves, right?
- 30:39I mean, anybody that understands, you know, this
- 30:43technology, even at a minimum level understands that the, you
- 30:46know, one of the value add is that you can track anything on
- 30:49chain. So, you know, don't use Tetris
- 30:53UI. You can go, you know, to block
- 30:55explore and verify yourself. So we, we are, we are adding
- 31:00data points, but also we are, we are working on creating tools
- 31:05that will allow people to sell verify.
- 31:09Yeah. And I think products falling
- 31:11into that mapping to bitcoins protocol I think are natural,
- 31:14right. Whether it's like multi
- 31:15institution custody from an individual perspective or even
- 31:18at the fund level where we've talked to some fiduciaries that
- 31:22from a fund level the legal or the fiduciary from a moving
- 31:26assets. But like pensions in particular
- 31:28will ask for a wallet that's segregated for their assets.
- 31:32And while that doesn't protect them from a legal perspective,
- 31:36it does provide this quasi proof of reserves that their assets
- 31:40are sitting there, which is, which almost operates like a
- 31:45quasi alarm bell. Because you can imagine if you
- 31:47have that set up, whether it's from a private client or an
- 31:50institutional, from a, from a fund perspective, if assets are
- 31:53moving, that shouldn't be moving now you're like, wait, what's
- 31:57going on? And if that happens enough or
- 31:59just once, that can already send a signal versus what we had to
- 32:02wait for, you know, multiple years in the FTX situation.
- 32:07But going back DDA to the the reference point on keys and and
- 32:12this notion of sovereigns and in countries wanting to hold keys,
- 32:16it's kind of interesting because it maps to a lot of education
- 32:20that we we all talk about here. I think everybody here would say
- 32:23it's not necessarily the hardest to figure out custody.
- 32:25It's hard to figure out custody either at size or scale or from
- 32:29an institutional perspective. And it would make sense as the
- 32:33market gets educated, they want to bring those keys in the same
- 32:35way that when Amazon first started, you know, Amazon W
- 32:39housed majority, if not all of the data.
- 32:41And then as data privacy and all the things associated that got
- 32:45more prevalent and understood you wanted to house that data in
- 32:48different countries, different continents.
- 32:51I'm curious, as you've seen the market get educated post 2022,
- 32:55what are some of the learnings that have either been
- 32:58prerequisites or requirements from the industry?
- 33:00Have you, how have you seen them get more educated and what
- 33:03they're requiring? An example, I guess I think if
- 33:07it's like the UAE and my understanding of like ADGM
- 33:10requiring anybody that's holding cryptographic material via
- 33:12licensed custodian, that's kind of I think probably a little too
- 33:17far just given that what we know about, you know, multi sig in
- 33:19the notion that single entity doesn't have unilateral control.
- 33:23But just curious how you think about what you've seen in the
- 33:25market and how they're the markets getting more educated,
- 33:27the requirements that they're asking?
- 33:32Yeah, I, you know what, I probably have a lot to say.
- 33:35I'm going to try to be concise. There's what I would qualify as
- 33:40bot tick ticking exercises, right?
- 33:43So and then things that actually help you protect your clients
- 33:50or, you know, your assets. Now what I mean by bot tick
- 33:53ticking exercises is, you know, third party custody is now a
- 33:59requirement I would say in the majority of the markets globally
- 34:04that take digital assets pretty seriously.
- 34:07You know, to us, some of the only markets that are really
- 34:10not, don't have a framework right play right now would
- 34:13include places like Australia, but they're certainly working on
- 34:16one. So you have to work with a third
- 34:19party qualified custodian. And now every country has a
- 34:23definition of what a qualified custodian looks like.
- 34:26You know, let's take the US and Canada as an example, right?
- 34:29So both through the NYDFS or through, you know, various
- 34:33states in the US, you have the concept of, you know, being able
- 34:38to get trust licenses or, you know, some organizations like
- 34:42Anchorage have secured banking licenses.
- 34:45In Canada. Right now there's only US and
- 34:47it's through a provincial trust. So the equivalent of, you know,
- 34:49essentially NYDFS would be the Loan and Trust Corporation Act.
- 34:54Now you essentially have the box to tick when you want to become
- 35:00a qualified custodian. So you know, you need a certain
- 35:04amount of capital, you need to certain kinds of audits.
- 35:07So financial audits, you know, you need your sock.
- 35:10Canada is a little bit more. I would advance in the NYNYDFS
- 35:16framework where there's, you know, concept like proof of
- 35:18reserves, penetration testing, you know, so there's added
- 35:22layers of, you know, kind of audits and securities that are
- 35:26that are put forward. So that's one way to look at it.
- 35:29So all parties involved in the regulated framework to provide
- 35:34all qualified custody essentially go through this
- 35:36exercise and say, do I have financial audits, audited
- 35:41financials? Do I have a do I have a sock
- 35:44type 2? No, OK, I got to go get a sock
- 35:46two type 2. Do I have a board or directors?
- 35:48No, I got to go get a board, right.
- 35:50And they go through that exercise and then they take the
- 35:52blocks. Now that provides some control
- 35:55and some governance. And obviously Tetra is a
- 35:57qualified, Odeon is one of those entities.
- 36:00And we have to do all those things every year.
- 36:03Now, there's also steps that, you know, the platforms can take
- 36:06themselves when engaging with the consumer.
- 36:10And one of the things we've seen is, you know is custody, what I
- 36:14would call custody diversification.
- 36:16So essentially not just having all your assets in one
- 36:19custodian, but essentially spreading your assets around or
- 36:23creating redundancy in your infrastructure.
- 36:27I would say that's quickly becoming best practice in Canada
- 36:33and we're seeing it in the US as well.
- 36:36There is no regulatory bodies to my knowledge right now and
- 36:40globally that I've made that a point for any trading platforms.
- 36:47But I do believe that over time you might see requirements where
- 36:50you can't have 100% of your assets in one specific place.
- 36:55You need to have let's say two or three custodians behind.
- 36:59So you can kind of refer to maybe like a two or three versus
- 37:03your key control. That being said, the assets that
- 37:07you have on those platforms, you are taking, you know,
- 37:10essentially single counterparty risk on those assets, right?
- 37:14So if you, let's say have 50% of custodian A and 50% of custodian
- 37:20BI mean 100% of that 50% of your assets is exposed to that, you
- 37:25know, single entity or single player.
- 37:28So you know, the, and this is where I think it's kind of a
- 37:31good leeway into the conversation with with on ramp
- 37:34and between on ramp and, and Tetra is essentially, you know,
- 37:38the capacity to spread your counterparty risk across
- 37:42multiple regulated entities, but that no single entity is
- 37:46essentially, you know, offering you're not getting counterparty
- 37:52risk to no single entity. I think that's a very valuable
- 37:56proposition. I think this is something that
- 37:59you are likely to see more and more of, you know, you're,
- 38:04you're really thinking about segregating your risk across
- 38:09various counterparties and that no single entity is responsible
- 38:15for, you know, specific failures or specific risk.
- 38:21I think it's a novel concept. I think it makes a lot of sense.
- 38:24And I think it's something that we're already seeing, you know,
- 38:27in terms of a trend that's that's starting to to evolve in
- 38:31the custodial landscape. From you're, you're the closest
- 38:38to it. I think of minors as being the
- 38:39most sophisticated with this concept and the best that they
- 38:43do. And it's it's the cousin of what
- 38:45Saylor does is literally just spread it across exchanges into
- 38:47your point hope that 1/5 or 1/3 of their assets go away of a
- 38:51single custodian, which just reminds me of FDIC.
- 38:54It's like, wait, you know how people spread it around?
- 38:56It's like that doesn't sound like a solution for protecting
- 38:58your wealth. It was more of a like question
- 39:04mark or like not question, but just thought of like the the
- 39:07notion of spreading risk at the mining level I think is the
- 39:11closest to sophisticated. But that's still the best that
- 39:15they by nature of understanding Bitcoin have to build these
- 39:18facilities. But then the best that they have
- 39:19is literally to just spread it across multiple entities.
- 39:23Well, that and it's also from a legal perspective too.
- 39:28That's what I think multi institution, multi SIG.
- 39:30And I know sitting on the board of a Canadian mining company
- 39:34myself, like we had to pick specific custody providers based
- 39:40on whether or not they're SoC 2 compliant and their governance
- 39:44structures that they have in place.
- 39:45And so that alone limits the number of people that are in
- 39:50custody with at least as a publicly traded company in
- 39:54Canada. And so I think the more multi
- 39:58CIG, multi institution solutions that come to market with
- 40:02qualified custodians that are sock 2 compliant and have proper
- 40:05audits and governance structures in place, like it's going to
- 40:08make way more sense for these minors to consolidate their
- 40:12holdings into these multi institution multi Cigs.
- 40:16And then if you want to diversify from there, maybe you
- 40:18go to a single provider and just maybe you have two or three
- 40:22different quorums of institutions.
- 40:26Controlling keys around different addresses that you
- 40:28control that maybe that's the the trend of what is considered
- 40:33diversification of treasury assets, treasury Bitcoin in the
- 40:38future. Yeah.
- 40:42It goes back to what Didier was was saying about, you know, if,
- 40:45if you, if you're splitting your assets between two custodians,
- 40:49you're currently, you currently have 100% risk with 50% of your
- 40:52stack in two different situations, but 100% risk with
- 40:58that portion because you're trusting a single custodian.
- 41:01And Marty, I think to your point, like multi institution
- 41:05custody is new and it's still emerging, right?
- 41:10We've only been working on it for a few years, but it's, it's
- 41:13been possible with Bitcoin for 10 years.
- 41:16And as we progress with building out that the kind of regulatory
- 41:25check boxes that are that, that folks, you know, who, who have a
- 41:31board of a board of managers have to check those boxes, then
- 41:39you know, we multi institution custody is, is on a fast track
- 41:43to become a, a, a superior option to that current model of
- 41:47split your eggs into multiple baskets.
- 41:49But you're risking it all with a single custodian.
- 41:52You know, you're, you're 50% is risked 100% with a single
- 41:55custodian. And you know, the moving from
- 41:59that model to a fault tolerant model where Marty, to your
- 42:02point, maybe you have multiple quorums where you, you're
- 42:06risking 50% of your stack with, in a 2O3 multi institution multi
- 42:11sig setup where there's fault tolerance inherently built into
- 42:14that. So, so you're not, you know, if
- 42:17one of those custodians goes down, you, you still have the
- 42:21ability to hold to, to recover 100% of those assets.
- 42:27That that's, that's just a step function better in terms of, of
- 42:31assurances to the end client that their Bitcoin will be safe
- 42:37for the long haul because of fault tolerance.
- 42:40That's it's not possible when you're splitting up your stack
- 42:43into trusting all of it, 100% of that portion with a single
- 42:48person, single custodian. Yeah.
- 42:50And I mean, Jesse, you've referenced clients, but I could
- 42:53certainly see a case where particularly in public markets
- 42:57like in the best interest of shareholders, it is demanded
- 43:01that you put your Bitcoin in a setup like this.
- 43:04So that's what it all. It's just.
- 43:06A function of time until this, this model proves itself out and
- 43:11checks enough of those regulatory boxes such that there
- 43:14becomes, I think you're right, demand from shareholders that
- 43:19that'll be a sea change moment where this model becomes so
- 43:26objectively better in terms of assurances to shareholders that
- 43:30it becomes demanded from the bottom up as well as as you
- 43:34know, sought out from the top down from, you know, decision
- 43:38makers in the organization. Yeah, this is a product of
- 43:42exactly that. For outside of, you know, a
- 43:44partner group, it becomes really hard to self custody the asset
- 43:47because you're you're managing capital on behalf of others and
- 43:50the alternative was leaving it on a single custodian.
- 43:52And we all know, you know that Bitcoin has additional
- 43:56assurances and security profile. You don't necessarily have to do
- 43:59it. I think what Jesse said is
- 44:02really important that what's happening here, it could have
- 44:05been done for 10 years. It's just more of an education
- 44:08coupled with the need want the price.
- 44:11As the price appreciates, then naturally counterparty risk
- 44:14becomes greater because amount of Bitcoin, whether an
- 44:16individual's leaving on an entity or the entity's housing,
- 44:20you want to like remove yourself potentially from losing that
- 44:22asset or moving that asset. And the, the real if call it
- 44:26anything innovative is more of the legal framework wrapped
- 44:31around the, the whole holding the agency of that key and then
- 44:37the requirement to move the asset.
- 44:39And so Didier, this kind of ties back to our conversation.
- 44:42It was fascinating because this relationship here was a
- 44:46confluence of multiple things. We were having this discussion
- 44:48and you, you being so close to the industry, it's seen this
- 44:51tailwind of requirement of multiple custodians being, you
- 44:56know, participating in the custody of you know, an entity's
- 45:00assets from diversification or risk, along with what we were
- 45:04building with multi institution with ourselves on ramp coin
- 45:07cover and Bitco. And we've all been seeing this
- 45:11natural sophistication or sophisticated requirement or ask
- 45:15from investors of having multi jurisdictional key.
- 45:18So not only key segregated from different institutions, but also
- 45:22key sitting at different sovereign levels.
- 45:25And so part of this first initial relationship we're
- 45:28announcing that will come out either I believe Tuesday of this
- 45:32week before the conference, which would the 23rd when this
- 45:35podcast will be released is the first multi institution, multi
- 45:39jurisdictional quorum between Bitco, Tetra and coin cover in
- 45:44the UK. That will come with all the
- 45:46assurances that we brought on with insurance and transaction
- 45:49protection. Bitco's qualified custody key
- 45:51signing, which is little known, but that key that protects the
- 45:54honor multi institution vault is the same key that participates
- 45:57in the two ETFs that are housed that's offline cold storage.
- 46:01And then Tetra will also be participating in this, which
- 46:04we're insanely excited to bring to market because we think as
- 46:07Jesse said, it's a step function improvement on a lot of the
- 46:10custodial situations that have existed and going narrow just
- 46:14for treasuries. We see that growing adoption.
- 46:16You can imagine as fiduciaries or capital managers are coming
- 46:19in, it's a step function improvement on leaving all the
- 46:22Bitcoin on a single custodian. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 46:26keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 46:28sitting on an exchange. Worried about hackers?
- 46:31Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 46:33with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 46:36device in your desk drawer? Gain Peace of Mind with Onramp
- 46:40and our multi institution custody solution.
- 46:43Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 46:46sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 46:50a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 46:55unilaterally. Instead, only you have control
- 46:58over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 47:02You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 47:04with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 47:08sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 47:10going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 47:14exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 47:18in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 47:21you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 47:24custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 47:28eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 47:31attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 47:35financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 47:37Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 47:41warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 47:44and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 47:47asset, secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 47:52Well, I was going to say, you know, it is very exciting and
- 47:54and you can see, I mean, you guys are obviously partners with
- 47:57Big Bow. I mean Mike and Mike Belshie's
- 47:59been talking about it for some while, right.
- 48:01I mean they now are registered, you know, if I remember
- 48:05correctly, it's you know, in Germany and and in Singapore.
- 48:09So you can basically, you know, start having different exposure
- 48:13in terms of geographies, you know, from your key management
- 48:17perspective. Now the problem you know, and
- 48:19and some knock about bit go at all, but I think you've brought
- 48:23it. We've we've talked about this.
- 48:24It's still a single entity exposure, right?
- 48:27So you can get geography exposure, you know, from
- 48:30different regulatory frameworks and different jurisdictions, but
- 48:35you still get a, you know, single entity exposure, which
- 48:38you know, may or may not be sub optimal depending on how you're
- 48:41looking at it. So being able to bring multiple
- 48:44jurisdictions regulated frameworks to the table.
- 48:47And you know, I, I think we could all argue that the UK, the
- 48:50US and Canada to some degree are good financial framework from a
- 48:54governance, you know, perspective in addition to
- 48:59minimizing single counterparty risk.
- 49:02I think it's not only really interesting, I think it's market
- 49:04leading and and you know, hopefully we'll bring a lot of
- 49:07attention. Yes, absolutely.
- 49:12And you know, I think in the Bitcoin community there's been
- 49:15talk for quite some time about how multi jurisdictional multi
- 49:19sig is, is going to be the future.
- 49:21So it's best in class. It's what everyone should strive
- 49:23for, but it hasn't been possible before now unless you set it up
- 49:29for yourself, right. So, you know, a lot of the time
- 49:32when people have been on on Bitcoin Twitter, when people
- 49:36talk about multi jurisdiction, multi sig, what they really mean
- 49:40is like flying to another country and setting up some sort
- 49:44of safe deposit box or, or, you know, burying it on foreign soil
- 49:52to have a key there. And then doing that in multiple,
- 49:56multiple countries such that they have a multi jurisdictional
- 50:00multi sig set up that they self custody set up that they've set
- 50:04up for themselves. But outside of that, there has
- 50:08not been any solution to date where you can have multi
- 50:12jurisdiction custody of your Bitcoin short of of having to go
- 50:19fly to that country and set it up for yourself.
- 50:21And this product is this partnership with Tetra in
- 50:27conjunction with our existing partnership with Bitco and Coin
- 50:30cover creates that first ever product where you have a key in
- 50:35in the US that's the Bitco key. That is, as Michael pointed out,
- 50:40the same sort of protection and security that is used for a
- 50:47couple of the ETFs that are using Bitco as their custodian.
- 50:51That's one key, that's the US key, then the the Canadian Tetra
- 50:55key and then the UK based coin cover key.
- 50:58And through that, that coordination, that partnership,
- 51:02you have a turn key best in class security, multi
- 51:06jurisdictional multi institution, multi sig setup.
- 51:11Whereas you know before that been completely untenable to to
- 51:14reach that level of excellence and and completeness by doing it
- 51:18yourself. Yeah.
- 51:22And maybe I would just add like a little bit of a history lesson
- 51:26here if I may, But part of the reason why you want multiple
- 51:29jurisdictional exposure or multi jurisdictional exposure is just
- 51:34look at gold. Look at, you know, the Gold
- 51:37Reserve Act of 1934. Look at when Roosevelt
- 51:41essentially for all intent and purpose outlawed self custody of
- 51:46gold and you know, required all Americans to basically start
- 51:52putting the custody of gold with the US Fed.
- 51:56Now I still know if today that, you know, there's a lot of
- 51:58Americans that hold their gold in Canada because Canada does
- 52:02not have that framework. So unless you're holding it, you
- 52:05know, under your mattress or you know personally, then you know,
- 52:08there is no way for you to do so with an institutional in the US.
- 52:13Just just take gold, replace it by Bitcoin.
- 52:17Now, can we say a scenario or can we see a scenario in a few
- 52:21years time where, you know, one specific jurisdiction government
- 52:28steps in basically says we are outlawing self custody of
- 52:32Bitcoin, all Bitcoin. Now it needs to be custody
- 52:35through the local central bank for whatever reason, right?
- 52:39It's not that far fetched. So actually it's happened in the
- 52:41past and could happen again. So minimizing your exposure,
- 52:46you're minimizing your exposure to a specific government.
- 52:50You know, changes in government happen all the time.
- 52:52I mean, you know, in the US you're, you're seeing hopefully
- 52:55or maybe a change of guard in, in the next little while, but
- 52:59that will also probably bring some change in narrative around,
- 53:03you know, digital assets, Bitcoin, Bitcoin support,
- 53:06etcetera at the government level.
- 53:07So being mindful of jurisdictional risk is
- 53:10incredibly important and quite frankly currently not enough
- 53:14part in the narrative for people that are holding large amounts
- 53:18of digital assets. Yeah, this has been a framework
- 53:21that we've talked about for a long time on this podcast and
- 53:24Marty, since like and I since like 2022.
- 53:26I think when some of these ideas were coming about.
- 53:28It's like nobody talked about the distribution of the keys in
- 53:32the same way they talk about distribution in the hash rate.
- 53:34And it sounds hyperbolic. What I like to say like the
- 53:36difference between gold and Bitcoin is effectively multi
- 53:39sake for that exact reason, DDA that you pointed out 'cause I, I
- 53:42sometimes hesitate to bring it out 'cause it sounds
- 53:44conspiratorial or whatever, but it's just this notion that once
- 53:47enough gold centralizes, it's just not a good thing for
- 53:49anybody. And so the notion of being able
- 53:51to distribute the asset is what makes this asset so redundant
- 53:54and resilient. And you get the transparency and
- 53:56all the things. And then the beauty of self
- 53:58custody is you could take the delivery of it at any point as
- 54:01that like fell safer alarm bell. So it's really, it's really an
- 54:05amazing kind of technology all around to approve assurances.
- 54:10I'm curious on your side, you mentioned some of the trends
- 54:14you've seen from we don't have to call out a country, but just
- 54:16the interest in Canadians regulatory, Canada's regulatory
- 54:19body for housing some assets from high net worths to wealth
- 54:22managers. How you see that coupled with
- 54:25also financial institutions participating in a setup like
- 54:30this, if you do at all, where maybe they do not step in to be,
- 54:35you know, build or buy custody, but they may either leverage a
- 54:38solution like this or hold one of the keys.
- 54:41I have thoughts and I've seen some stuff, but just curious if
- 54:43you thought about it from that landscape, that lens.
- 54:48Yeah, I have. And I, I would say it's probably
- 54:51safe to say that Tetra, you know, has pretty advanced
- 54:54conversation with a lot of FIS in Canada, you know, around
- 54:58digital assets, right. So to your point, like should
- 55:01they build, should they, you know, utilize a vehicle like
- 55:04Tetra, what's the framework? How do regulators think about
- 55:08it? You know, we're actively in
- 55:10contact with the regulators, even with government.
- 55:12So I was, you know, in Ottawa last week talking to the
- 55:16ministers of finance, you know, the various kind of government
- 55:21entities around digital assets, custody, why custody matters,
- 55:26etcetera. I can, I can say transparently
- 55:31because I, it, it's public information.
- 55:33I mean, my, my previous employer, they were working on a
- 55:36cold storage, you know, solution that essentially, you know, got
- 55:41shelled for various reasons. You know, one, you know, the
- 55:45operational nature of it, obviously it's, it's relatively
- 55:48complex. There's none of that native
- 55:50expertise in house, you know, it doesn't didn't really scale
- 55:55right, didn't really make a lot of sense.
- 55:57And specifically when you're looking at going beyond let's
- 56:00say a single asset in terms of support and then how do you
- 56:03scale the solution, you know, where the kind of roles and
- 56:07responsibility and risk lies. You know, there's, I would say
- 56:11different comments around the capacity for financial
- 56:15institutions to enter into this. I would say specifically in
- 56:19Canada, one of the issues that we we come up against is
- 56:22essentially that there's no federal framework for any of
- 56:26these institutions to basically touch this asset class.
- 56:31So because of the lack of framework, FIS are more likely
- 56:35to let's say look at partnering with various entities like Tetra
- 56:40then essentially do this themselves.
- 56:41But that poses, you know, the same risk we've discussed on
- 56:45this podcast for the last little while, which is essentially, you
- 56:49know, a single entity exposure, right?
- 56:52When you look at, you know, a large FI, you know, they might
- 56:55not want to just take exposure to Tetra to hold its digital
- 57:00assets. They might want to essentially
- 57:02have the opportunity to face multiple, you know, institutions
- 57:08in terms of protecting the digital assets.
- 57:12Now, I personally have a strong view on whether or not they're
- 57:15equipped to do this themselves. Having to work at at the largest
- 57:21players in the country. I would, you know, quite
- 57:24honestly say that I don't think they're equipped to handle this
- 57:27technology from a day-to-day perspective, you know, for
- 57:30various reasons. But you know, I think one of the
- 57:32obvious one, and we've talked about it then and Jesse, Jesse
- 57:36talked about it as well in the Inception story of the of why I
- 57:40joined Tetra. Essentially, the technology's
- 57:43not even there to actively monitor what's going on on
- 57:46chain, right? So for the lack of being able to
- 57:50even just plug in the systems into your current infrastructure
- 57:54means that you're unlikely to do it yourselves.
- 57:57So there are looking to partner, they are looking, you know, for
- 58:00various entities that can provide some assurances and not
- 58:05just the traditional kind of governance framework, but also,
- 58:09you know, assurances around minimizing single counterparty
- 58:13risk, minimizing jurisdictional risk, you know, minimizing
- 58:18technology risk even to some degree, right.
- 58:21You know, I think it would be unlikely to see somebody that's
- 58:25on the multi sig, you know, wanting to bag to let's just say
- 58:29one type of service and one type of technology.
- 58:33So they think about that from a risk perspective.
- 58:36I think they partner. I think they might look at, you
- 58:39know, people that can hold keys and hold assets for them, but I
- 58:43think they need a lot of assurances and multi
- 58:46jurisdictional, multi counterparty or multi
- 58:49institution and and multi tech I would say as well are probably
- 58:53all very strong selling points. And revenue, revenue, I think
- 59:02people don't recognize that every custodial solution
- 59:05effectively looks the same. So you can only charge so much
- 59:07for it. And there's a notion here where
- 59:10you, and we're experiencing it that you can actually charge for
- 59:14a product significant, you're not significantly, but with a
- 59:18greater market than 0, which is effectively existed for, you
- 59:22know, a private client and individual client or family
- 59:24office. That's a it's kind of a race.
- 59:26It's the, this notion or thesis that the market structure of
- 59:30digital assets is kind of grafted on the traditional
- 59:32market structure of compression from custody.
- 59:36And it's really kind of the opposite in our opinion, because
- 59:39when you think about it, the digital barrier asset that has
- 59:41so much room to appreciate, there's only 21 million that
- 59:44it's the one thing you should pay for if you want to get into
- 59:46the future and have that asset with the price appreciation
- 59:49exposed closure. And from our experience, you've
- 59:52probably seen a little bit of this.
- 59:53Financial institutions hesitate to jump in because they're like,
- 59:55how do I make money in this asset class?
- 59:58And when they see our model, they're effective.
- 1:00:00They're like, oh, wait, you can actually make money coupled with
- 1:00:03everything, you just share GDA. And an easy example is like
- 1:00:07additional insurances. Now you can underwrite, you can
- 1:00:09provide insurance that is an omnibus.
- 1:00:12Underwrite it and it's not saying Oh well if everything
- 1:00:15goes away like there people know that there's not enough even
- 1:00:18insurance capital to like map to mapping coin bases or insuring
- 1:00:21coin bases. Custody is, but you can change
- 1:00:25that dynamic when it's a single wallet and you can underwrite
- 1:00:30that multiple institutions have to basically fail or effectively
- 1:00:35fail on the relationship with that.
- 1:00:37It's a different relationship to underwrite.
- 1:00:40And so now you can give greater assurances to a financial
- 1:00:43institution coupled with increased revenue and all the
- 1:00:45other things you extract, you've shared.
- 1:00:47And now it makes it a lot more tenable for somebody to step in,
- 1:00:51which is just a, it's a, it's a very interesting thing that
- 1:00:54we've kind of like stumbled on as the more the conversations
- 1:00:56we've been having with institutions globally.
- 1:00:59And it's it's not really like a foreign type of relationship
- 1:01:02either with these institutions when you consider that they
- 1:01:05interface with broker dealers and clearing houses.
- 1:01:09I could see it being a very obviously not exactly the same,
- 1:01:12but a similar set up between Bitcoin custodial partners and
- 1:01:16these institutions, whether they're hedge funds, banks,
- 1:01:18whatever it may be. Yeah, that's right.
- 1:01:22And I, I think just overall, I mean, custody in Bitcoin has
- 1:01:25sort of been viewed as like a loss leader.
- 1:01:27Everybody's so, so focused on, on gaining market share in terms
- 1:01:32of exchange volume because that's where people make the
- 1:01:36upfront revenue. Every time somebody makes a
- 1:01:40trade in exchange or service gets a percentage of that,
- 1:01:46usually about 1%. And that's, you know, that's
- 1:01:48where they're making their money.
- 1:01:50And as a result of that, custody is an afterthought.
- 1:01:52It's been a commodity as Michael said, it's been sort of
- 1:01:55everybody does it the same way. You can't really charge for it
- 1:01:57because there's no value addition.
- 1:01:59There's people aren't providing value in the type of custody
- 1:02:03that they include in their exchange service typically.
- 1:02:08But with multi institution custody, this becomes much more
- 1:02:12value added form of custody because it really does increase
- 1:02:16the probability that you're going to effectively propagate
- 1:02:18those assets into the future, which is the whole point here,
- 1:02:21being able to hold on to this call option of major upside in
- 1:02:26the future. If you know, we're right about
- 1:02:28how big of a role Bitcoin can grow into in in the financial
- 1:02:34landscape and in, you know, warranty backed insurance is on
- 1:02:39on your transactions is a big part of that model.
- 1:02:43And inheritance planning is a big part of that model.
- 1:02:45These things are possible with multi institution custody as
- 1:02:49value additions that are not are not really possible with this
- 1:02:53typical exchange models. Or we just throw it in a cold
- 1:02:56storage wallet the same way that everybody else does.
- 1:02:59And you know, it's not that sexy.
- 1:03:00So let's not talk about it and let's not charge you for it.
- 1:03:04You know what, I think we really are moving to it to a different
- 1:03:07to a future where people appreciate the the value
- 1:03:12addition of multi institution custody over a typical single
- 1:03:18third party custodian model where it's kind of a black box.
- 1:03:24Yeah, I I would also add quickly, you know the partners
- 1:03:31that you select and the businesses they play in.
- 1:03:34Jesse, to your point is also is also, you know, should be
- 1:03:38considered as a criteria. And what I really mean by that
- 1:03:42is like Tetra is a pureplay test fee provider, right?
- 1:03:45Like we don't do anything else. And and you know, I think
- 1:03:49Michael, to your point, there's, there's currently a lot more
- 1:03:52value to be generated and you know, transactional businesses
- 1:03:56or etcetera. But we strongly believe that
- 1:03:58over time, you know, people will want to pay a specific price to
- 1:04:02protect their assets, you know, because that is fundamental
- 1:04:07into, you know, for Bitcoin, you know, there's entities obviously
- 1:04:12globally that played massive roles in custody, but also land
- 1:04:17margin, trade clear and settle, I mean the list goes on and on.
- 1:04:24So you basically open a lot of risks to your underlying assets
- 1:04:28when you're working with these providers.
- 1:04:30And you know, something was touched upon earlier around the
- 1:04:33segregation of, of, of assets or segregation of wallets.
- 1:04:37I mean, Texas has been segregated from day one, right?
- 1:04:40Our infrastructure has always been segregated in, in cold
- 1:04:43storage. There is no omnibus accounts
- 1:04:46that's behind what we do in none of our clients assets are are
- 1:04:49essentially sitting in an omnibus structure.
- 1:04:52And unfortunately when you commingle services, you end up
- 1:04:55having to commingle assets as well.
- 1:04:58So while, you know, you might do some review of let's say a
- 1:05:02specific custodian that will tell you that your assets are
- 1:05:04segregated and that you can also transact through their system.
- 1:05:09Then then through the transactional business, your
- 1:05:11assets end up being commingled. You know, whether it'd be for,
- 1:05:14you know, a handful of seconds or longer, you know, to clear
- 1:05:18and settle and transact. So those should also be
- 1:05:21considerations. Again, it gets to a little bit
- 1:05:23more of a technical understanding of what really
- 1:05:26happens behind the door and how assets are positioned.
- 1:05:30But you know to to the best of the clients capacity, they
- 1:05:37should consider the various institutions that custody the
- 1:05:40assets and the role they play in the ecosystem and try to purify
- 1:05:44that as much as possible. Yeah.
- 1:05:47And it's it's incredible because it reminds me a lot of when we
- 1:05:49used to compete with Block Fi and our loans were nominally a
- 1:05:52little bit higher, but we say risk adjusted, it's much
- 1:05:54cheaper. And it reminds me of what we're
- 1:05:56talking about here. And it's kind of kind of scary
- 1:05:59how coincidental this happens to be the week of maybe we can, you
- 1:06:03know, I know we have about 15 minutes left talk about the
- 1:06:05conference and all the different conversations that are going on
- 1:06:08with Treasury in the US state, the US level, everything's
- 1:06:11happening globally. It's like, imagine when you
- 1:06:14start to really move this asset gets to six figures and how, how
- 1:06:18are we going to do custody, right?
- 1:06:20Like, you know, up until this, we know people have been working
- 1:06:22on it and more people are working on it.
- 1:06:24But this notion of just sending it all to Coinbase is, is not a
- 1:06:28good strategy. And I think people are even know
- 1:06:30that now. But what happens when the price
- 1:06:31double S because that's you know that that means more people are
- 1:06:35exposed, but that's more Bitcoin as well that they're
- 1:06:37accumulating just a very fascinating time to this is all
- 1:06:41going to like I think in future state look like obvious, but
- 1:06:44right now we're kind of like at the edges of this stuff.
- 1:06:48Yeah. And I mean, one thing that I
- 1:06:51would mention or to consider is, you know, as the asset prices
- 1:06:55have recovered and doubled and the ETFs and the US launched and
- 1:06:59everybody basically went to a single counterparty pretty much
- 1:07:03to do custody, their asset balances blew up, but their
- 1:07:08insurance, their governance and their framework stayed the same,
- 1:07:12right? So to your point, Mike, you
- 1:07:15ended up taking additional risk without knowingly doing so to
- 1:07:19some degree. You know, I think some of the
- 1:07:22latest figure is 340 billion or so of assets that are, you know,
- 1:07:26sitting at Coinbase, but they still only have 350 million of
- 1:07:30insurance. So the, you know, from, from
- 1:07:35insurance versus underlying asset standpoint, you know, you
- 1:07:39have increased your risk quite dramatically of, of keeping your
- 1:07:43assets essentially there. And it's certainly something
- 1:07:48that people would consider or should consider when they're
- 1:07:52thinking about custody or they thinking about, you know,
- 1:07:54locating, you know, their assets with a single counterparty.
- 1:07:59Yeah, there's a discussion of trillion dollar wallets and this
- 1:08:01is naturally obviously squint, this is just the start, but you
- 1:08:05can imagine different continents, different financial
- 1:08:07institutions, different balance sheets.
- 1:08:09And like we talked about this early and it sounded crazy and
- 1:08:12it's kind of strange to see it happening.
- 1:08:14This is good dates back to the call 2022.
- 1:08:16But the notion of Coinbase and other firms having to
- 1:08:19participate in a model like this, I believe they will have
- 1:08:23to and increasingly believe they will have to because large scale
- 1:08:26institutions either want to leg into the asset class or firms
- 1:08:29like MicroStrategy that I guess it's like roughly 20 billion
- 1:08:32price double s. Now they're 40 billion.
- 1:08:34Let's say a third of their assets are at Coinbase and they
- 1:08:37say, hey, we're going to move. Unless you adopt something like
- 1:08:39this and participate, whether it's a net new client like
- 1:08:42multiple pensions go into a State Street and asking them to
- 1:08:45participate or existing incumbents that have a singular
- 1:08:50view and kind of not Moat, but kind of a Moat.
- 1:08:55That mode is only as as strong as a click of a button.
- 1:08:59Maybe it's a little harder with Coinbase and sometimes they make
- 1:09:02it really hard where you can't pull your assets out.
- 1:09:04But the point being that if you move your assets, eventually the
- 1:09:09market has to participate. And so I personally have had
- 1:09:12this long standing view that this will be a standard in a
- 1:09:14future state when it comes to like institutions will not be
- 1:09:17able to have unilateral control over the asset.
- 1:09:20Now how quick that happens is really the question on how much
- 1:09:22the market, you know, requires or demands it, I think.
- 1:09:28I think, I think you're oh, sorry, I think you're going to
- 1:09:31see tensions. I think you're going to see
- 1:09:34pensions in large organizations starting to demand control,
- 1:09:38right? I think it's, it's the natural
- 1:09:41evolution here. I mean, you looked at those.
- 1:09:43I was looking at BlackRock over the weekend.
- 1:09:45I think there are 21 billion now, right?
- 1:09:49How long before they start asking for, you know,
- 1:09:53potentially being one of the pieces of the quorum for
- 1:09:57Coinbase, right? If it's a set up of seven of 12
- 1:10:00or 7 of 10 or or whatever the quorum is, right?
- 1:10:03How long before BlackRock says, well, actually I want one
- 1:10:07operator to be part of the quorum for any transaction?
- 1:10:10I think it, it definitely will need to happen.
- 1:10:14I think there's going to be diversification, but I think
- 1:10:16they're going to also demand to be included, you know, in the
- 1:10:21key control specifically for large organizations, pension
- 1:10:24funds, you know, sovereign wealth, etcetera.
- 1:10:27It just, it just doesn't make any sense and they're they're
- 1:10:30not going to take exposure to any single counterparty on this
- 1:10:34technology. It wouldn't pass the risk
- 1:10:36assessments. It's fascinating that
- 1:10:40MicroStrategy isn't there yet because they're a tech company.
- 1:10:43We've talked about this for years like that.
- 1:10:45It's kind of weird, right, that you would outsource.
- 1:10:48Like Michael Saylor couldn't figure out the people within his
- 1:10:50network to trust more than the institutions.
- 1:10:53He let that hold the Bitcoin because you could set up what
- 1:10:55we're talking about here within an entity as well.
- 1:10:59I mean, and this is what we talked about last week with Alex
- 1:11:01from Coin Covers. You have to hope as an
- 1:11:05individual, as an operator in the space that the institutions
- 1:11:11that have exposure to large amounts of Bitcoin recognize
- 1:11:14this before we have another Quadriga, another Mount G Ox,
- 1:11:18another Block 5 Celsius, FTX. Name the blow up throughout
- 1:11:23Bitcoin's history like that, especially as the stakes get
- 1:11:27higher because every doubling from here, I mean, if we double
- 1:11:29from here, we're adding another $1.4 trillion in market cap and
- 1:11:34the the stakes just increase exponentially as a price goes
- 1:11:38up. And so, I mean, that's part of
- 1:11:40the reason why we do this show and why the word education has
- 1:11:44been mentioned so many times throughout this conversation, is
- 1:11:46because there is like a moral obligation to make people aware
- 1:11:50of these options and get them over to them as quickly as
- 1:11:53possible to mitigate any of these potential blow UPS in the
- 1:11:57future. Because they are just going to
- 1:11:58get larger and create bigger headaches for the industry at
- 1:12:01large. This feels like a trip down
- 1:12:06memory lane because when Jesse and I were chatting and already
- 1:12:09like back in 2022 about all this stuff, the key inflection point
- 1:12:14was like seeing the the smartest people in the room weren't the
- 1:12:16smartest people. And then the existing market
- 1:12:19structure, nothing really changed.
- 1:12:20Obviously there's, so there's more regular, there's more
- 1:12:24regulatory hurdles requirements, which is naturally better for,
- 1:12:29you know, depending on the assurances required.
- 1:12:31But then the underlying tech is still the same with a single
- 1:12:34entity having unilateral control.
- 1:12:36And you can even have all the best regulations like we saw
- 1:12:38with Nevada and whatever happened with the trust charters
- 1:12:40with prime trust. But it doesn't matter from a
- 1:12:42technical perspective if you lose the assets, if you're
- 1:12:45leveraging MPC and all the other things.
- 1:12:47And so to Marty's point, the sad part is I'm pretty confident
- 1:12:51like we're still going to see orders of magnitude more hard
- 1:12:54that we saw in 2022 because the numbers are going to get bigger.
- 1:12:56And I believe it's effectively the same infrastructure because
- 1:12:58what we're doing is still so new that the market has to catch up
- 1:13:02to it. But the hope is like you go into
- 1:13:04the next, you know, 2028 ETFs are larger and this is demanded
- 1:13:09by the SEC and other requirements.
- 1:13:11And we talked to the ETF providers, they call it
- 1:13:12bulletproof. It's just the, it's again, it
- 1:13:14melt the exact quote. It's bulletproof, but it melts
- 1:13:17brains. Yeah.
- 1:13:20Yeah, Michael, to your point, I mean, you know, in, in industry
- 1:13:24and a nascent, a nascent industry, a nascent asset class
- 1:13:27only develops if you learn from the failures that happen along
- 1:13:31the way. And and so like Quadriga, Mount
- 1:13:34Gox, all these, you know, FTX, all these failures, they only
- 1:13:41help us make this asset part of the financial fabric of, of the
- 1:13:47world if we learn from them and, and take the those learnings and
- 1:13:52incorporate them into better products and better solutions.
- 1:13:55And yeah. And that's multifaceted too,
- 1:13:58because obviously at the end of the day, you you protect the end
- 1:14:03clients and the consumers. But it also, I think it's
- 1:14:06imperative because you basically show regulators that we know how
- 1:14:10to self regulate and reduce the potential for regulators to come
- 1:14:15in with overbearing regulation. Like we're able to actually self
- 1:14:18regulate and educate and move people over to this as quickly
- 1:14:21as possible. Maybe regulators look at those.
- 1:14:24They're like, yeah, these guys are actually responsible.
- 1:14:25And there's some people in that industry, despite what the
- 1:14:29public and many pundits may say, that actually know what they're
- 1:14:32talking about and do care about securing people's wealth.
- 1:14:37Yeah. And to to Michael's point, I I
- 1:14:39fear that our educational efforts will not outpace the
- 1:14:44appreciation of of of the the value held in Coinbase for
- 1:14:49example, you know like it DDA, I didn't know that stat.
- 1:14:54They have $350 million of insurance on what would you say
- 1:14:59$340 billion of digital assets that Coinbase.
- 1:15:03It's 1% of their assets. It's one thousandth of their
- 1:15:08assets, which is outrageous. And I mean, talk about ticking
- 1:15:13time bomb. If like if you want to, if you
- 1:15:15want to, if you were going to take a holistic assessment of
- 1:15:19like existential risk to this industry and, and you were going
- 1:15:27to, you know, find all the all the ways in which something
- 1:15:31calamitous could happen. Coinbase is is has got to be top
- 1:15:36of that list in terms of some internal failure or perhaps the
- 1:15:4161 O2 sort of scenario happening.
- 1:15:44If you have a a single third party custodian that has
- 1:15:47unilateral control over that many assets and and you know
- 1:15:51that much market share in the ETF space in particular, and
- 1:15:55that only gets worse as the price appreciates.
- 1:15:58And you know, Didi, I think you have a great point there that
- 1:16:00their systems and controls are not scaling, are not are not
- 1:16:05necessarily going to scale as the price appreciates.
- 1:16:11Yeah, I mean I, you know, I. And Marty has some.
- 1:16:13Great. Yeah, I was going to say I, I,
- 1:16:16I, I I have so much to say on this topic.
- 1:16:20Unfortunately, I have to be careful what I say publicly, but
- 1:16:25any industry that has so much concentration typically leads to
- 1:16:30a very poor outcome, right? I think there's a lot, a lot of
- 1:16:34analogy that we can say around what's being done right now by
- 1:16:40actor, like an actor like Coinbase.
- 1:16:43And you can draw parallels to like Microsoft in the 70s and
- 1:16:4980s and dumping into markets and pricing.
- 1:16:51And you know, you know, on the custody front, I can tell you,
- 1:16:54we see them being incredibly aggressive on pricing and you
- 1:16:58know, it's very hard for other entities that are pure place to,
- 1:17:02to compete on that front. You know, if you look at your
- 1:17:05own ETFs and, and this is a statistic that, you know, Brian
- 1:17:08Armstrong has said himself publicly, they have about 90% of
- 1:17:13the volume out of the ETFs in the US.
- 1:17:17So not necessarily you know, the number of entities they control
- 1:17:21versus a live ETS, but the amount of assets it's it's about
- 1:17:2690%. There are also the largest
- 1:17:28player in Canada. They've been gathering a lot of
- 1:17:32market share in Europe. I know Australia just launched a
- 1:17:36couple of ATS all custody with Coinbase.
- 1:17:39So I mean, you look at, you know, the systemic it's, it
- 1:17:43really is becoming a systemically important
- 1:17:46institution or FI or as other would want to position it as
- 1:17:51systemic risk into the system. And I think that's something
- 1:17:55very, very important to consider.
- 1:17:57And, and to to certainly we can't underestimate, I mean, the
- 1:18:01point around insurability. Unfortunately, insurance remains
- 1:18:04a very difficult piece to get in the industry.
- 1:18:09There's only certain pools that we'll give to let's say digital
- 1:18:14assets and most of them are already kind of fully allocated.
- 1:18:18But with products like on ramp is is working on with multi, you
- 1:18:25know, institution multi jurisdictional exposure, then
- 1:18:29you know, the the hope is that you will be able to bring
- 1:18:33essentially more insurability, more coverage, more underwriting
- 1:18:37into the marketplace and essentially reduce that risk.
- 1:18:41We shouldn't kid ourselves like digital assets currently as it
- 1:18:43stands has a lot of single counterparty risk.
- 1:18:47And also, I mean, we didn't touch on this and I know we're
- 1:18:50close to time, but also a lot of risk around banking obviously in
- 1:18:53banking services, which continues to be a problem in the
- 1:18:56industry. Yeah, I was just referencing
- 1:19:01Marty on TFTC has a lot of investigative journalism into
- 1:19:05Coinbase and some of their custodial efforts with Zappo and
- 1:19:12and you know the history there that I think is important for
- 1:19:14anybody to listen to. And just what DDO was
- 1:19:17referencing to the aspect of the larger Coinbase gets, the more
- 1:19:21likely that it is for something negative to happen.
- 1:19:25And it doesn't even necessarily have to be something crazy as a
- 1:19:2861O2. It's just a larger honeypot and
- 1:19:30larger honeypots naturally have larger, greater attack surface,
- 1:19:33more, more vectors or more individuals looking at them.
- 1:19:39And so I think that's an important thing.
- 1:19:40And then the only other thing to mention on that is the only way
- 1:19:43to to win in something like that is to play a different game.
- 1:19:45And that's effectively what we're talking about here is that
- 1:19:47the asset is fundamentally different and the existing
- 1:19:52models of financial services and digital assets have been grafted
- 1:19:56on the existing model, which is effectively you have a single
- 1:19:59entity that holds the asset, you have a single entity that sells
- 1:20:01the asset. And what we're introducing is a
- 1:20:04different version where you leverage the native protocol
- 1:20:07which is multi sig. Native aspects of the protocol,
- 1:20:10multi sig and you don't have to require a single entity to have
- 1:20:13unilateral control. And that changes the dynamic of
- 1:20:16custody and then also additional financial services that can be
- 1:20:20figured out. But ultimately custody is that
- 1:20:22the base layer? Because we're still, you know,
- 1:20:24we're not even at 100K yet. We all know we have so much more
- 1:20:26room to go. Yeah.
- 1:20:28And I think tying two things that were said throughout this
- 1:20:30conversation together to really get this idea proliferating
- 1:20:37through the institutions is, I mean, Michael, you used the
- 1:20:40example of Unchained offering higher interest rate loans
- 1:20:44compared to Blockfy and people didn't understand that.
- 1:20:47Well, it's like the the risk is much higher on Blockfy, so
- 1:20:51you're actually paying a much higher price if they blow up,
- 1:20:54which ultimately happened. I think similarly Didier with
- 1:20:58what you mentioned in terms of like being a pureplay custodian
- 1:21:01and trying to compete with Coinbase on fees.
- 1:21:04It's going to be very hard considering the scale and the
- 1:21:07different business lines that they have.
- 1:21:09But it's really trying to price that unknown risk for end
- 1:21:12clients where yes, they may have cheaper custody fees, but it's
- 1:21:16actually much more expensive in the long run due to this insane
- 1:21:19concentration risk that exists within Coinbase.
- 1:21:23Yeah. And we actually also, Marty, to
- 1:21:25your point like we also get there as well by jurisdictional
- 1:21:29diversification, right? So, you know, it's a huge
- 1:21:33selling point for us as, as you know, being able to say your
- 1:21:36keys are in Canada, they're secured under, you know, a
- 1:21:40Canadian regulated entity with a clear framework.
- 1:21:43It's not, you know, trust us, we have 14 shards or 12 shards,
- 1:21:48whatever the number is spread out globally.
- 1:21:50It's like, no, here's the framework, here's how they're
- 1:21:52controlled, here's the governance overlaying.
- 1:21:55You know, there's some transparency, some trust that's
- 1:21:57built over that and some verification as well.
- 1:21:59That's able to be done to some degree, but we're we're, we're
- 1:22:03competing on jurisdictional risk as well.
- 1:22:07Very good point. And I want to again, apologize
- 1:22:11for being tardy to this, to this episode, to this recording.
- 1:22:16It was a pleasure speaking with you, Didier.
- 1:22:17This is fascinating stuff. Pumped.
- 1:22:20I mean, by the time this airs, the announcement will have been
- 1:22:22made. So Congrats on really pushing
- 1:22:25this ball forward. And it's something like Michael
- 1:22:28said and Jesse, Michael and I have been talking about for
- 1:22:30years, like this is where the ball is going to end up
- 1:22:33inevitably. So the more we can push it as
- 1:22:36quickly as possible, the better in my mind, because I think this
- 1:22:39is desperately needed considering all the tailwinds
- 1:22:42that are coming our way, which is a good thing.
- 1:22:44But we we need to mitigate any unforeseen disasters in the
- 1:22:49future with with models like this.
- 1:22:52Yeah, we have an exciting panel with DDA, Mike, Belshi, Jesse
- 1:22:56and Alex talking about these concepts at the Institutional
- 1:22:59Day. Great to hash this out in here.
- 1:23:03It'll be it'll be good to hear Mike talk about, you know, the
- 1:23:05different countries, but under Beko and then this approach and
- 1:23:08the his thoughts there. Yeah.
- 1:23:11Now we're, we're very excited. We we certainly appreciate the
- 1:23:15partnership. We think this is again like just
- 1:23:18market leading in terms of the approach and you know, we think
- 1:23:21there's definitely a need for it in the marketplace.
- 1:23:25So we're we're happy to be your partners and we appreciate the
- 1:23:29opportunity and look forward to to pushing this together.
- 1:23:34Yeah, awesome. We're we're thrilled about it.
- 1:23:36You know, like I said before, I think, I think it's probably
- 1:23:40hard to really point your finger at just how significant of a
- 1:23:46milestone this is. I think in in the evolution of
- 1:23:49Bitcoin custody. But with Tetra, we now have the
- 1:23:531st instance of a true multi jurisdiction, multi institution,
- 1:23:58multi sig custody set up available for people today.
- 1:24:04It's called M. Cubed for short.
- 1:24:06Is that what we're going to go with?
- 1:24:09Yeah, at some point we need some shorter description
- 1:24:12descriptions, but it, you know, there's so much happening under
- 1:24:15the hood, it's hard to. M ^3 m ^3 custody, It's comes
- 1:24:21off the tongue much. Better.
- 1:24:22I do like that. Maybe we'll end up with that.
- 1:24:29Well, gentlemen, I look forward to seeing you all in Nashville.
- 1:24:32My flight leaves early tomorrow morning from the East Coast.
- 1:24:36We'll we'll have to all get together.
- 1:24:40Yeah, absolutely. We'll coordinate.
- 1:24:42Looking forward to seeing everybody.
- 1:24:45All right guys, have a good rest of your day.
- 1:24:49Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:24:52If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:24:54episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:24:56app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:24:58today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:25:01Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Ramp Media is
- 1:25:03for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:25:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:25:09Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:25:12to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:25:15to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:25:18advisors.