Latest / The New Paris Podcast / Episode 24: On Immigration, Islam and Identity vs Security
Transcript
- 0:06You're listening to the New Paris.
- 0:08I met today's guest three years ago at a cafe.
- 0:11He was conducting research on French Islam.
- 0:13I was writing my book on Paris that Cafe became a source of
- 0:16comfort for both of us. After the November 13th attacks,
- 0:19which killed and injured, hundreds these attacks carried
- 0:22out by French or other p and Nationals affiliated with or
- 0:25inspired by the Islamic State. Re serious questions about
- 0:29Francis. T treatment of Muslims in the
- 0:31country and policies toward integration and
- 0:33de-radicalization Andrew Aguilar.
- 0:36Then a visiting scholar at seems Poe had his own views on the
- 0:39issue today, Andrew is a PhD candidate in political science
- 0:43at Sea, all spoke and continues, his research about what's really
- 0:46at play. When we speak about French Islam
- 0:48on this episode, I speak to Andrew about immigration Mac,
- 0:51homes, new quest to restructure Islam in France, and how the
- 0:55country's Muslims feel about their place in French society.
- 1:00Andrew, thanks for being here. Great to be here.
- 1:04Can you tell me a little bit about what prompted, your
- 1:06research in the first place? Sure, thanks.
- 1:08So I started this research about five years ago.
- 1:11When I was still an undergrad at Stanford and I know my advisor
- 1:14had spoken a lot about what is the nation-state today?
- 1:17And how do we Define, what what is social solidarity?
- 1:21And he pointed me towards the French case.
- 1:23As an example of this is a state grappling right now, with issues
- 1:26of national identity, trying to integrate their migrant But in a
- 1:29much more localized in a much more contextual fashion so why
- 1:33don't you start there for your research?
- 1:35And I mean I've been now to Paris over be 30 40 times.
- 1:38I've lived here over two years so I really can't leave the
- 1:41state and I had a lot of on-the-ground experience with
- 1:45this particular subject. So it wasn't a hard sell for you
- 1:49to start investigating us. I mean, it definitely is not a
- 1:51hard to tell if if you get to go to Paris but also in that
- 1:54research seeing the different facets of Paris, not just what
- 1:58everyone knows about the The tourism section, but really
- 2:00grappling a dealing with the city struggling with identity
- 2:03issues. So that's very interesting
- 2:05because identity is probably only part of the story.
- 2:09So, in the wake of the various attacks that have been carried
- 2:11out since 2015. There's been a lot of
- 2:14finger-pointing actually at Frances ongoing struggle with
- 2:16national identity. And how sort of the Muslim
- 2:19population fits into that and especially given the country's
- 2:24strict values of lice ETA, which is the separation of church and
- 2:27state. And I for one Talking to you
- 2:29about this. I felt like this was a byproduct
- 2:32of colonization colonization that the country, you know,
- 2:35welcomes immigrants from their colonies, at a certain time.
- 2:37They come to work and then they get rejected years decades
- 2:41later. I mean, is that a fair
- 2:43assessment or is that? I mean, surely there must be
- 2:46more to it. That's only part of the story.
- 2:49So if you think about the wounded friend start identifying
- 2:52Muslim as the other, or as The Outsider, that definitely did
- 2:55begin during the colonial times France, at a very large,
- 2:58Colonial Empire. Her in Northern Africa and parts
- 3:00of the Middle East where being Muslim was a secondary status.
- 3:04But if you think about today's issues, the issues of socio
- 3:07economic integration of religious expression in not just
- 3:10in Paris but in France as a whole, it's a much more complex,
- 3:14administrative much more modern a.
- 3:16So a lot of these problems are actually recorded in society
- 3:19after the colonial period after the colonies ended.
- 3:21So I think it's a little bit of a false, no more to say that.
- 3:24It's only a colonial issue and does that mean.
- 3:28So I mean people, Look to racism to.
- 3:30And, you know, I know a lot of Americans who really shouldn't
- 3:34be speaking about racism especially at a time like this
- 3:37but will always say, oh the French are so racist, I've
- 3:41experienced or witnessed or observed, lots of examples of
- 3:45racism in the country. But is that really what's at
- 3:49play with the feeling of the sentiment toward the Muslim
- 3:52population? I think it's a little different
- 3:54if you have to acknowledge the francophone context and the the
- 3:57political expression here in Fans, I mean, Americans, and
- 4:01Anglo-Saxon culture fell off a loop in the British here,
- 4:03everybody will say were Multicultural.
- 4:05Everybody would say, yes. We're so tolerant of everything,
- 4:07but look at recent electoral patterns in both the UK.
- 4:10And in America, the far right is thriving in these countries, so
- 4:14approaching the issue as putting my head in the ground Americans
- 4:17and British. I'm not going to acknowledge the
- 4:19races in my Society until much later.
- 4:21That is a symptom of just how we Express in verses in France, the
- 4:25far right has been a part of the mainstream political dialogue
- 4:27since the 80s. So of course, of course.
- 4:29It's very easy for Americans to say, oh look at how racist they
- 4:33are. And in addition to that, I've
- 4:35also done numerous interviews. Now, with many local and
- 4:38government officials with Muslim Association leaders and I think
- 4:41it's a bit of an overstatement to just say the French state is
- 4:43racist. There are plenty of people on
- 4:45the ground today. Act of actively trying to solve
- 4:49these key integration issues and and they're doing it in a way
- 4:52that's actually very respectful of, of the particularities of
- 4:56Muslim, migrants and their children.
- 4:57So it's just again, an overcast. Eric duration to say the issue
- 5:01is, the state is racist. So in your opinion it's not just
- 5:05about France saying, oh we don't like we're what it means to be
- 5:09French where that's headed that it now involves all sorts of
- 5:13different religions and backgrounds for you use the word
- 5:16administrative. So concretely.
- 5:18What does that? How does that put?
- 5:20You know, what is that? How does that look like?
- 5:22Sure thinks, so everybody lives their life on a day-to-day
- 5:25basis, rather, and they livid at varying levels.
- 5:27They live at, at the national level You go get your passport,
- 5:30they live it at the local level when you have to get a trashcan
- 5:32removed and so when I use the term Administration, I use the
- 5:36term to really quiet to qualify the notion of State people,
- 5:39live, different state experiences and all of these
- 5:42levels are sometimes art in theory.
- 5:44Training unit, two universally approach.
- 5:47This issue in a coherent way, in reality, local level, National
- 5:51level. And all of the vectors will
- 5:52think about Security Police, economic Vector, such as trade
- 5:57unions and associations are All acting in different ways.
- 6:00So my research does really focus on how is that integration
- 6:03experience lived at these multiple levels and what are
- 6:07some of your findings? I mean, the anybody who works in
- 6:10a large organization can relate to this, but it's I wouldn't say
- 6:14the word mess, but I would say it's a lot of conflicting points
- 6:17of view when the national state might say, we are going to
- 6:20separate church and state and we're going to make sure that
- 6:23the there's no we're not going to impede on religious
- 6:27expression, but at the local level, People who deal with
- 6:30these issues on a day-to-day basis.
- 6:31Realize, that's not a viable option or there needs to be
- 6:34qualifiers around when we enact certain things.
- 6:36So my research really focuses on those gray areas when it's much
- 6:40more of a local level call. So, can you give me an example
- 6:43like, in school? For example, you know, that must
- 6:47be an issue because of the veil and the national level policy to
- 6:51not show any religious affiliation.
- 6:53So has that been respected on a local level.
- 6:57The entire history of the Jail in France is one wrapped in
- 7:01identity politics, but also it's much.
- 7:03It's really wrapped in what do schools, what are they able to
- 7:07teach one and then two? How do they enforce the national
- 7:11identity? If they choose to do it and
- 7:13given, I mean the traditional academic approach of the French
- 7:16state is very centralized, very organized, every official of
- 7:19expressing the view of the state in reality.
- 7:21It's a lot more complex where prior to the the law Banning us
- 7:25and say ostentatious religious symbols in 2004 schools.
- 7:29The authority to basically say what was a religious symbol or
- 7:32not? What they actually prosecute
- 7:35students who did wear religious fail and it was done more for
- 7:37the public order after the uniformity of 2004.
- 7:40Saying, every school must now enforce the Banning of religious
- 7:44symbols, in accordance with the law of separation of church and
- 7:46state. It became a lot more uniform.
- 7:49But still, you still have pocket cases of where teachers and I've
- 7:51spoken to a few of them were teachers.
- 7:53And administrators won't actually take action because
- 7:56they know it'll rile up a hornet's nest of other issues.
- 7:59Issues in the bottle you. So it's basically like they're
- 8:03deciding whether it's worth the battle.
- 8:06Yeah. I mean think about our own lives
- 8:07and there's always laws that we have to deal with and there's
- 8:10directives and these are more directives that aren't legally
- 8:13binding per se and then you take it and then you think well that
- 8:16won't work in my context so I will or will not do it
- 8:19interesting. This sort of leads us to a more
- 8:23timely conversation. You recently responded to a
- 8:26Washington Post article about Mac homes new On French Islam
- 8:30and your letter to the, to the opinion section effectively.
- 8:34Analyzed that this is this strategy, which you will tell us
- 8:38about has been in place for a long time.
- 8:41Or it's been attempted numerous times and you're feeling is that
- 8:44this is not a good idea. So can you tell us what this,
- 8:47what Mak homes policy is and why is it risky business?
- 8:51So my Crohn's policy right now is to basically recast Islam in
- 8:55France, and make that a French variant of Islam or French
- 8:58Islam. This is not the first time, this
- 9:00phrase has been used Sarkozy actually beat him to it in 2002
- 9:03and 2003 calling for the formation of a French Islam free
- 9:07of foreign influences and one that is loyal to the value of
- 9:10the French Republic. The problem with that is this,
- 9:13his attempt is. Now the fifth time that the
- 9:15state has tried to create a French variant of Islam, and
- 9:18he's going to run into several problems that I'm, I find that I
- 9:21see in my research on a day-to-day basis.
- 9:23One associational politics with the major Muslim associations
- 9:27often result in a very competitive.
- 9:29And very distrustful situation where each one is effectively
- 9:33funded or controlled by their states of origin.
- 9:35So there's a de facto Moroccan Association, a defective
- 9:38Tunisian Association. A de facto Muslim Brotherhood of
- 9:42related affiliation and they've tried putting them all together
- 9:44in the same room and it usually doesn't end well for for the
- 9:47ultimate result just given the political backstabbing and the
- 9:50Electoral the last initiative involved elections and that
- 9:53didn't go well because no one trusted the those elections.
- 9:56So that's just 1. And then 2 which Pivot toward my
- 9:59current research Focus today. This is his attempt, his attempt
- 10:03to create a French. Islam is done in the name of
- 10:05security. So let's let's move away any
- 10:08kind of coded language here. He's doing it for D
- 10:11radicalization, to a, to create a French Islam to prevent
- 10:14radical French citizens from enacting future terrorist
- 10:18attacks. And I think this is this is much
- 10:21more of a contemporary Focus which in the other prior
- 10:24initiative radicalization and security were not the primary
- 10:27aim. However, if I Correctly in your
- 10:30your response to the opinion section.
- 10:32You said that this assumes that all Muslims are susceptible and
- 10:39are the only people susceptible basically to radicalization.
- 10:42I mean, that, that sends quite a nasty message.
- 10:45Exactly. When a lot of Muslims that I've
- 10:47interviewed on the ground who are involved in these dire
- 10:50radicalization strategies and local level initiatives to
- 10:53improve integration, they all say they're French today.
- 10:55So again singling out a large chunk.
- 10:59Chunk of the population today saying, these are the people we
- 11:01need to monitor. Effectively for radicalization,
- 11:04is disconcerting to to Muslims who are French today.
- 11:08Who have French citizenship, who pay French taxes, and who work?
- 11:12And, I mean, what I mean, this didn't really come up as a major
- 11:18talking point in Mac homes. Campaign, do you think that this
- 11:21sort of, he sort of being directed to come up with a
- 11:25policy like this? I mean, was it what are you?
- 11:29Doing in terms of from a political perspective, how this
- 11:32is emerging? I mean, if you think about just
- 11:33the rhetorical value of French Islam, there is a very high
- 11:36rhetorical value, which is why members of both parties have
- 11:39used this language since the late 1980s.
- 11:41The the idea of creating a French variant of a religion
- 11:44effectively which contradicts also the entirety of the French
- 11:48separation of church and state, which I'm not even going to
- 11:50touch that today. But also if you think about,
- 11:52it's a very preliminary approach in my opinion, it's one rooted
- 11:57in not having practical. Experience on the ground,
- 12:00knowing what these issues are but politically, as I've
- 12:04mentioned earlier itself. And so I think it's coming more
- 12:06from his need to sell right now in the trendy subject is
- 12:10radicalization. It is Islam, it is security.
- 12:14But at the same time, he may have less experience on the
- 12:17ground, but his predecessors did.
- 12:19And yet they still went in this direction and they again, I
- 12:23think it's the appeal of the one who can finally.
- 12:26Say, I've created the French Islam.
- 12:28I've integrated the Muslims of the Republic.
- 12:30I vinc reincorporated those lost territories in the words of
- 12:34Sarkozy. So, it mean, it's a viable
- 12:36political goal and you can't deny that.
- 12:39And what are his thoughts on immigration as a whole, because
- 12:42the article you responded to did touch On that as well.
- 12:44It's not even just about creating French Aslam, but but
- 12:47sort of who gets to stay and who, who doesn't?
- 12:50Yes. Over microns really touching
- 12:51Asylum policies right now which he's the first men France in
- 12:55comparison to other Western European states have had a very
- 12:58receptive policy of Asylum for Asylum.
- 13:01Seekers and he's seeking to reduce the period where people
- 13:05can apply for Asylum and be eligible.
- 13:06And so that's really causing people to question.
- 13:10Where does he stand on immigration?
- 13:11Is he really closer to the far right than we thought?
- 13:14A lot on the left and we can remember mccrone was a coalition
- 13:17government. So we've angering the people on
- 13:19the left, and he's also promising to go after immigrants
- 13:23who don't have papers. So thinking about really
- 13:25enforcing immigration laws, which in the modern EU context.
- 13:29It's really, it's a little perplexing because European
- 13:34States get effectively gave up their immigration policy when
- 13:36they agreed to the Schengen policy in the 90s.
- 13:39So, really reasserting the the national, and then the era,
- 13:42where the supranational is much more, It's stronger in
- 13:45Immigration. So this is where a lot of anger
- 13:47is, is emerging. Certainly we've seen that, if
- 13:50anybody is on Twitter, following, you know, leading
- 13:54French voices in the media. There are other all sort of,
- 13:57there's a lot of dialogue about this decision and including this
- 14:01policy on French Islam. Now, on the other hand, there
- 14:05does, there's a, there's a whole set of the population that feels
- 14:08that France, badly needs reforms on all levels, whether it's
- 14:11locally on in labor, and Employment Innovation all these
- 14:15things or on on a broader level like these policies.
- 14:19So I mean isn't it just bound to be painful?
- 14:22No matter what he does. Definitely but mccrone and macro
- 14:26has a very unique time and opportunity right now where he
- 14:29has a mandate he was elected and then he swept out both houses of
- 14:34the French government so he effectively has the popular
- 14:36mandate to say. This is what I want to do.
- 14:40The risk is let's say any of his actions.
- 14:43Fail or I mean he's going to run up against a lot of strong
- 14:46opponents in both the his economic reforms immigration
- 14:49reform, you name it, he's going to face tough challenges if he
- 14:53doesn't succeed. I do personally worried that
- 14:55that will lead to the emergence of the far right?
- 14:57Because effectively emerge and the re-emergence in a much
- 15:00stronger way because effectively today.
- 15:03Macron killed the left. I mean you do see a little bit
- 15:05of the parties of the horns. Honking he's and more of the far
- 15:10left is still lingering out there but he took the Bastion of
- 15:13the left. And so what is left today, and
- 15:15still in a viable option, if he were to fail, is the far right?
- 15:18So there is that risk, which sounds a little bit like what
- 15:21happened in the u.s., right? As soon as Obama the Democratic
- 15:26couldn't run, again, we were left with.
- 15:28I mean you're pretty Tall Tree options and and then the right,
- 15:32especially the optimism. You think everybody thinks about
- 15:34the optimism of 2008? Exactly.
- 15:37And he and the electorate fell, he fell short and so the
- 15:40electorate didn't go left. They went right.
- 15:42So this is a risk in France. As well.
- 15:45Back to your research, you've interviewed Muslims all over
- 15:49Paris and particularly in nearby suburbs like will be VA.
- 15:52What's the sentiment? I mean, you've gone on the
- 15:55ground numerous times. So I mentioned 2015, when you
- 15:58and I met and you were often in, you know, nearby suburbs and and
- 16:04more recently your back doing any additional research so do
- 16:07they feel like they're still treated as the other?
- 16:09Do they feel targeted unjustly. You know what?
- 16:13What are some of the Feelings that you've uncovered while
- 16:15you've been on the ground. One of the major themes that I
- 16:18think is relatively recent that started in about 2015 is this
- 16:22prevailing notion that the state feels were all going to
- 16:26radicalize within a day. And so the level of surveillance
- 16:29has increased the level of policing and we're thinking
- 16:33about policing. There's both the traditional
- 16:35concept of, you know, the policeman on the street, but
- 16:37there's also security related individuals and things like the
- 16:41school in urban policy. So there's security.
- 16:44Interpretations of urban policy. Whereas in the past that really
- 16:47wasn't the case. And so from at least from the
- 16:50perspective of a Muslim who's living in the bundle and I speak
- 16:53to a lot of the associational leaders and to local level
- 16:56politicians who might be involved in like local councils
- 16:58and things like that. They very much aware that it's
- 17:00becoming a much more heavily, watched a heavily suspicious
- 17:05State and they feel that actually helps the efforts of
- 17:09radicalization because it really feeds into these narratives.
- 17:12Also it encourages it, instead of Feeds into the Isis Narrative
- 17:15of the state doesn't trust you. Our state will that kind of that
- 17:19kind of baiting language that they do use.
- 17:22Now in previous conversations. I think you've mentioned that
- 17:26radicalization does happen quickly.
- 17:28Now at the whether it's a Muslim or somebody else I mean just in
- 17:32general we're in a time where it doesn't take months of sort of
- 17:37coercion you know it can happen over the course of what like a
- 17:41day or several days of watching certain materials on the
- 17:44Internet, right? But doesn't that mean, though,
- 17:47there has to already be a sensitivity or a susceptibility
- 17:53to, you know, outside influences.
- 17:57So if they already feel ostracized, and they feel under
- 18:00people in general, in these in these bone, you have feel like,
- 18:03they don't matter. Anyway, I mean, what how is this
- 18:06happening? I mean, is there truth to the,
- 18:09to the danger of radicalization or is it?
- 18:12Are we painting to eat? You know, sort of, to simple a
- 18:15picture. I definitely agree in that they
- 18:19are susceptible but I also think it's too easy of a picture.
- 18:21If you think about old school and I hate to use this term but
- 18:25old-school terrorism 2001, Al-Qaeda very long out long
- 18:29drawn-out plan for a major terrorist attack that took years
- 18:35those days are gone effectively and States today.
- 18:38Beginning with about, I would actually say the Paris attacks
- 18:41are one of the first but maybe more the London bombings.
- 18:44In the mid-2000s when somebody in the course of a month, could
- 18:48radicalize take Isis or radical beliefs that they want to.
- 18:53And then go and strike. The population states are really
- 18:55struggling with, how do we prevent that today, and it's
- 18:58really hard to prevent somebody who radicalize is a, maybe 124
- 19:01were days for example, and decides to pick up a car.
- 19:04So the struggle of states are finding then are, how can we
- 19:08then prevent radicalization to be strategies but they also
- 19:11neglect the issue of if individuals.
- 19:14Are feeling ostracized. Let's look at other
- 19:15non-religious. Non structural reasons.
- 19:18So let's look at socio economic integration issue.
- 19:21So I one of the the, my more favorite initiative that in all
- 19:27of Western Europe, is Frances, recent recent push to build
- 19:29Metro lines. Connecting the Barrios to
- 19:32Central Paris. So lines believe, 15, 16 and 17,
- 19:35which they marketed. As we're going to redo the
- 19:36Metro, expand the lines. But in reality, these are
- 19:39connecting values in the past that are incredibly hard to get
- 19:42to chew the And I think doing some basic issues and basic
- 19:46research around what improves integration at that level will
- 19:49go a longer way towards de-radicalization, then strategy
- 19:53focused on D radicalization of religious Muslims, and then and
- 19:57then you avoid that vicious cycle.
- 19:59So it's really about creating opportunities creating access.
- 20:02Making them feel like they're part of this city, which is
- 20:06normal. This is a normative normal
- 20:08belief, right? The benefit of the French state
- 20:10is that they can push through the initiatives through but
- 20:13imagine can we You Lindsay being from the US?
- 20:16Could we imagine building Metro lines only for disadvantaged
- 20:20suburbs ever? And in the UK, is the same
- 20:22thing. There's no way we would build
- 20:23additional Metro to those and invest in those areas.
- 20:26So, it's, again, the benefit of having a state rooted in, we
- 20:30need to integrate, everyone. There's benefits to that, but
- 20:32then there's also the caveats of the racism.
- 20:35The, the you need to be more French, kind of rhetoric, which
- 20:39it's interesting. All of these, the this
- 20:41Improvement you're talking about Echoes.
- 20:43What a previous It was an urban strategist.
- 20:45Talked about on a previous episode, which was about those
- 20:48projects to connect even the suburbs among between each other
- 20:52and then, the suburbs to the city.
- 20:54And obviously, the Olympics is a good end goal for the city, but
- 20:58it's true. They're not, they're not
- 21:00presenting it in that kind of a framework.
- 21:02They're showing it is simply Urban and urban improvements and
- 21:07like you said, creating just better transportation, but
- 21:10effectively the results could go a long way.
- 21:12What other improvements? It's do you think need to be
- 21:14made to create a an environment that feels harmonious to a
- 21:22population, which is overwhelmingly Muslim at this
- 21:25point. So, this is actually a really
- 21:28good example of the, of the contradictions in local, level
- 21:31policy and implementation. So the government decided to
- 21:34fund these Metro lines under the auspices of, let's improve the
- 21:37metro and its really, it put money in the suburbs, but they
- 21:40also they will not put increase the money in funding
- 21:43disadvantaged School. In these neighborhoods because
- 21:45that contradicts the notion that everybody is equal.
- 21:48So this is a perfect example of the incoherence of State policy
- 21:52of different level level differing levels of
- 21:54interpretation saying one thing versus another I think what the
- 21:57state needs to do and start realizing it, there needs to be
- 21:59a much more comprehensive approach to integration policy
- 22:03that does not result in contradictions and battles in
- 22:05the courts of saying, well this policy contradicts that, but
- 22:09then the ministry of transportation is doing
- 22:11something different. In education is saying another
- 22:13thing. Thing.
- 22:14And then you have interior in the police saying something
- 22:16completely different, so really trying to figure out as a state.
- 22:19What do we want to do? And do you see any Headway being
- 22:22made on this? No, this is a one that is
- 22:26discussed one that is put in in rhetoric but it is never never
- 22:31been put in practice, just given for organizationally.
- 22:34It would be super difficult, right?
- 22:35You would have to get everybody on the same page, remove the
- 22:38conflicting power dynamics between various Ministries,
- 22:41which every state faces. But if we're Going to work on
- 22:44this today in a very solvable way than they're going to have
- 22:47to cooperate and not just between Ministries.
- 22:50But national and local, there's a big distrust everywhere
- 22:53between local level I know better and the national level
- 22:56who just designed the theoretical strategy.
- 22:59And how would you say this Compares?
- 23:00What? France is facing?
- 23:02How would this compare to what? The u.s. seems to be struggling
- 23:06with today? Now not just with Muslims, but
- 23:09any kind of minority in the United States.
- 23:12I mean, is this It's sort of like a universal struggle that
- 23:16you know, and that all of these nation states are going through.
- 23:18Or what do you, what do you see as the big difference?
- 23:21Maybe go a little bit further. I think it is the struggle that
- 23:23nation-states face today. This is, how do you build new
- 23:26social, cohesion, when you have so much difference in a world?
- 23:31Where if you think about just, if I were to get a bit,
- 23:33theoretical the origin of democracy.
- 23:35Everybody was not meant to vote, everybody was never meant to
- 23:38participate. We are in a period today where
- 23:40everybody can participate, sand does participate of all Politics
- 23:44whether we like them or not, but then how do you create that
- 23:47cohesion to keep people together?
- 23:48And we see that in the state's it's somewhat cracking the for
- 23:51the right, and the left are now not talking to each other.
- 23:54Same in France, to a certain extent in the UK in every nation
- 23:56state. So and integration is at the
- 23:59core of these issues because that is the other ring of a
- 24:02population that has citizenship that is the same legally, right?
- 24:06But they're not seen as that. So I think this is the struggle
- 24:09that every state will is coming to grab coming to deal with and
- 24:13will We'll deal with for some time.
- 24:15So what's next for your research?
- 24:17Because you're in the the midst of your PhD where you headed, so
- 24:24I will be doing this research for probably three or four more
- 24:27years. I'm trying to defend in the
- 24:28spring of 2021, which is a long way in a short way away right
- 24:32now and actually my research encompasses both France and the
- 24:35UK were I'm taking a much more comparative approach.
- 24:37Okay, from here, I'm really hoping to do sponsor to spark
- 24:40more Dialogue, on this idea of Ready should not be the end goal
- 24:45of integration. Integration is its own basket of
- 24:48issues, but we need to start disentangling that.
- 24:50So really calling a light. They're highlighting this.
- 24:53This approach, the problems of this approach and then what we
- 24:56can do from there and can people find your research anywhere at
- 25:00this time? Or is that, is that still a work
- 25:03in? Progress is definitely a work in
- 25:04progress. I think the Washington post's.
- 25:06My letter was my first foray into much more public dialogue.
- 25:09And I'm really hoping to start writing more for a much more
- 25:12General audience because The challenges of Academia that
- 25:16we're often in Rat and in wrapped in meshed, effectively
- 25:19in our terminology but it also prevents the public from
- 25:23engaging. So I'm trying to really make
- 25:25this an issue where the public is engaged.
- 25:29Which I would love to see. I would love to see more of your
- 25:32you're thinking out in the public and certainly it would be
- 25:34great if your research gets into the hands of the administration
- 25:38and you know someone someone sees what you're talking about.
- 25:41Shirley that you know your, I'm sure you're not the only Who is
- 25:45providing some of this, very intelligent strategic feedback
- 25:48but you know, it couldn't hurt to have an outsider's
- 25:52perspective. I hope you'll come back and join
- 25:54us because surely this is an issue that we're going to keep
- 25:57coming across and maybe maybe they'll be positive advancements
- 26:00that we can talk about and if not still come back but I look
- 26:04forward to seeing where your work takes you and I hope you.
- 26:08I hope you'll join us for sure. Thanks Lindsay.
- 26:11Thanks Andrew. And until next time you can find
- 26:13All previous episodes of the new Paris on iTunes, SoundCloud and
- 26:18on world radio, Paris a bientot.