Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 【Deep】Apple 2026 Buffett Value Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. This is the place where we take
- 0:03that fire hose information. You've given us all the
- 0:05articles, the deep research, the financial models and we just, we
- 0:09filter out all the noise and we deliver the concentrated
- 0:12insights that you really need. We are your shortcut to being
- 0:16well informed, diving deep into the structure and the mechanics
- 0:21of the world's most fascinating businesses.
- 0:24And today, wow, we are tackling a behemoth.
- 0:27We really are. Perhaps the most admired company
- 0:30on the planet, Apple Inc, Yeah, trading under the ticker AAPL.
- 0:34And our mission today is what's highly specific, and it runs
- 0:37directly into the core tension of value investing.
- 0:39OK. We are going to analyze Apple, a
- 0:41business that I mean everyone acknowledges is high quality,
- 0:44but we're doing it through the rigorous lens of Warren
- 0:47Buffett's framework for elite fiscal year 2025.
- 0:49South The ultimate question here is, is the best company in the
- 0:52world actually worth buying at this price?
- 0:55We're examining the structural strengths, what we're calling
- 0:58the fortress against all these rising legal and competitive
- 1:01risks, which we've termed the regulatory siege and the whole
- 1:06exercise. It really culminates in
- 1:08addressing that unavoidable problem of the price.
- 1:11You've got it. And we'll spend a good amount of
- 1:13time admiring this business because frankly it is a master
- 1:16class and durable competitive advantage.
- 1:19But we have to be dispassionate about the price the market is
- 1:21asking us to pay for that quality.
- 1:23And our source material is solid for this. 10 It's robust.
- 1:27We have comprehensive value analysis, strategic equity
- 1:30research covering the full FY20 25 results and a really detailed
- 1:35breakdown of all the global antitrust developments, hitting
- 1:38them in the EU, in Japan and right here in the US.
- 1:42OK, before we unpack this giant, just a quick but necessary
- 1:45context setting. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:48on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 1:51or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 1:55purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 1:58Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:01decisions. And if you want to listen to our
- 2:03full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced content,
- 2:07welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to us on
- 2:11Apple and Spotify podcasts channels.
- 2:14Deep value investing. And as we track the temperature
- 2:16of the market based on some of the financial metrics we'll talk
- 2:19about today, you know, metrics that define bubbles and crashes,
- 2:22remember, you can search and download the iOS app Buffett
- 2:25Indicator right from the Apple App Store.
- 2:28It's a great tool to keep tabs on valuation sentiment as we
- 2:31move through this. OK, let's unpack this business.
- 2:34We have to start at the beginning, the qualitative
- 2:36assessment. These are the Four Gonna Go
- 2:38filters that Buffett uses to determine if a business is even
- 2:42worth looking at. And if a company doesn't pass
- 2:44these 4 gates, the valuation exercises, well, it's basically
- 2:48irrelevant. It is.
- 2:49So does Apple qualify as a wonderful business?
- 2:52The first filter is simple enough simplicity and
- 2:55predictability. We call this the elementary
- 2:57school test. Can we actually understand what
- 3:00the business does and can we confidently predict its
- 3:03competitive position, say, 10 years from now?
- 3:06Apple passes this with, I mean, perfect scores.
- 3:10The core business is remarkably easy to articulate.
- 3:14It really is. They design premium consumer
- 3:16electronics, the iPhone, the Mac, the iPad, and they sell
- 3:20these incredibly high margin related services.
- 3:22It's the high quality gadget plus the extraordinarily sticky
- 3:27ecosystem built around it. And the genius, as the analysis
- 3:30points out, is the stability within an unstable industry.
- 3:33Yes, the business model has remained fundamentally unchanged
- 3:36for what, well over a decade now?
- 3:38They are not chasing every single fad.
- 3:40They are the standard bearer for premium digital living.
- 3:43And that's the crucial distinction for Gate 1.
- 3:46Buffett's rule is to shun businesses that could face
- 3:48obsolescence in 10 years. Sure, you know, think back to a
- 3:50company like Kodak. Oh sure, their core business,
- 3:53chemistry and film was just destroyed by digital biography.
- 3:56Technology was their enemy. But Apple is the complete
- 3:59opposite of that. Absolutely.
- 4:01Apple is a beneficiary of technology change, not a victim
- 4:04of it. They constantly refresh their
- 4:06products with proprietary innovations, like those custom M
- 4:09series ships in the sophisticated sensor systems.
- 4:12The prediction isn't that the iPhone will look the same in 10
- 4:15years, right? The prediction is that Apple
- 4:17will still be selling the cutting edge device and the
- 4:19cutting edge services that define the premium end of the
- 4:21market. We can confidently make that
- 4:24prediction. Gate 1, Clear pass.
- 4:27Now for the foundation of the fortress, the durable
- 4:30competitive Moat, the consensus here is unanimous.
- 4:34Apple doesn't just have a Moat, it has a wide self reinforcing
- 4:38and you could argue widening Moat protected by layers that
- 4:41just reinforce one another. So what are the core pillars
- 4:45protecting this Kingdom? OK, there are three real heavy
- 4:48hitters that provide genuine structural competitive
- 4:51advantage. The first one is basically non
- 4:54replicable intangible assets, specifically brand power.
- 4:57Just the brand itself. Apple's brand is world class,
- 5:01valued by some estimates at what, $263 billion?
- 5:05And that brand provides something absolutely priceless,
- 5:09substantial pricing power. And we saw specific proof of
- 5:12that elasticity or maybe inelasticity.
- 5:15Back in 2022. We did.
- 5:17Apple hiked iPhone prices by about 5% and customer demand it
- 5:21barely even registered the change.
- 5:23That's right, the analysis suggests Apple could probably
- 5:25sustain a 10% price increase across its products and retain
- 5:29the vast majority, I mean maybe 95%, of its high end users.
- 5:34This is the definition of truly inelastic demand.
- 5:37When your customers actively seek out your product believing
- 5:40there is no adequate substitute, you have a wide Moat.
- 5:44You can effectively print profits just by managing price
- 5:47tiers and ensuring your brand stays synonymous with premium
- 5:50quality and user experience. So that's the first pillar, the
- 5:532nd, and this is maybe the most powerful for long term
- 5:56prediction is the customer lock in or the switching costs.
- 5:59We are talking about the Apple ecosystem, iMessage, iCloud, the
- 6:04seamless handoff between the Watch, the Airpods, the Mac.
- 6:09Breaking that interconnectivity is just it's cognitively and
- 6:13financially painful. And the demographic data here is
- 6:15critically important for the Longview, the source notes a
- 6:18staggering statistic. This one blew me away. 88% of US
- 6:22teens own an iPhone. Just think of that.
- 6:25It's like a generational demographic bomb.
- 6:27These users are conditioned from a young age to live inside the
- 6:30Apple digital sphere. Trying to switch to a competitor
- 6:34means disrupting your social networks, you know, the iMessage
- 6:37status, and losing all that seamless functionality.
- 6:39And that inertia, it translates directly into the financial
- 6:42results. Absolutely.
- 6:44Retention rates for iPhone users are consistently above 90%.
- 6:47Once Apple hooks a customer, the probability of keeping them is
- 6:50just extraordinarily high year after year.
- 6:53The Moat not only keep competitors out, it keeps
- 6:55customers locked in. OK.
- 6:56So Pillar 3 is a classic, but I think it's often a misunderstood
- 7:00operational mode. Cost advantages through scale.
- 7:04Apple doesn't really compete on price, but they are ruthlessly
- 7:08efficient financial machine because of their sheer size.
- 7:11And this is really embodied by their operating model, the
- 7:14negative cash conversion cycle. It's it's financial wizardry.
- 7:20They effectively use supplier financing.
- 7:22Just look at the balance sheet. In FY20 25, they held about $70
- 7:26billion in accounts payable. That's money owed to suppliers,
- 7:31but only 6 billion in inventory. Can you just elaborate quickly
- 7:34on what that negative cycle means for the listener?
- 7:36Certainly it means Apple sells the product faster than it pays
- 7:40the manufacturer for the components.
- 7:41They collect cash from you, the customer, almost instantly.
- 7:44They hold that cash and they only pay their suppliers 60 or
- 7:4790 days later. So they're investing their
- 7:49suppliers money. They are essentially investing
- 7:51their suppliers money, earning interest on the float.
- 7:54This structural working capital advantage is a powerful self
- 7:58funded operational mode that is extremely difficult for any
- 8:01smaller competitor to replicate. And we see the proof of all
- 8:05these modes, the brand power, the lock in the scale and their
- 8:08margins. The gross margin is consistently
- 8:10high. And what's really impressive is
- 8:12that it's expanding. It's moved from that 38 to 40%
- 8:16range in the mid twenty 10s up to about 47% now.
- 8:19That expansion, even with global inflationary pressures and
- 8:23supply chain volatility, is the ultimate confirmation of their
- 8:27resilience and pricing power. It shows they are truly
- 8:30operating from a position of strength.
- 8:33So Gate 2A wide and widening pass.
- 8:36OK, moving to gate 3, management quality and capital allocation.
- 8:40Warren Buffett demands managers who act like owners, right?
- 8:44Prioritizing per share value over just building an empire.
- 8:47And Apple. Management under Tim Cook scores
- 8:49exceptionally high here. I mean, their track record of
- 8:51capital allocation is arguably among the top three in corporate
- 8:54history. It's famous the Buffett himself
- 8:56praised the Cook, saying nobody but Steve Jobs could have
- 8:59created Apple, but nobody but Tim could have run it this well.
- 9:03That says a lot. It says everything about Cook's
- 9:05mastery of operations and finance.
- 9:07And the centerpiece of this owner mentality, which is so
- 9:10crucial for maximizing per share value, is the buyback machine.
- 9:14The scale is just, it's staggering.
- 9:17In the past five years alone, Apple has repurchased over $340
- 9:21billion worth of its own shares. Let's put that into perspective
- 9:24for you. This relentless buyback program
- 9:27has reduced the total share count from 16.4 billion back in
- 9:312014 down to about 14.8 billion in 2025, and they authorized
- 9:37another $90 billion program just this fiscal year.
- 9:41This continuous reduction in the equity base is the purest form
- 9:44of optimizing intrinsic value per share.
- 9:46It's a disciplined commitment to returning excess capital when
- 9:50internal opportunities just aren't sufficiently high
- 9:52returning. But the critique you always hear
- 9:54about buybacks centers on whether management is
- 9:56sacrificing R&D or future growth for, you know, these short term
- 9:59stock bumps. Is Apple starving the business?
- 10:02Not at all. Far from it.
- 10:03The sources confirm that management successfully balances
- 10:06these massive shareholder returns with substantial, very
- 10:08targeted internal investment. R&D in FY20 25 was 34 1/2
- 10:13billion dollars. That's a huge number.
- 10:15It's about 8% of sales, and that's where the cutting edge M
- 10:18series chips, the Vision headset technology, the massive AI push
- 10:22and all that speculative future growth is being funded.
- 10:25So we see rational capital allocation in action.
- 10:29They generate massive cash flow, they deploy the necessary
- 10:32capital for high return R&D and then they return the enormous
- 10:36excess in a very shareholder friendly way.
- 10:38It's highly disciplined and it avoids that typical pitfall of
- 10:42CEO's who chase acquisitions purely for size.
- 10:45That whole empire for building mentality.
- 10:47Gate 3. Exceptional pass.
- 10:50Right. Finally, gate 4, industry
- 10:52structure and capital intensity. Is Apple stuck in some brutally
- 10:55competitive capital heavy industry that demands constant
- 10:59massive reinvestment? The answer is clearly no.
- 11:01While the broader tech world is competitive, Apple has executed
- 11:04this brilliant strategy of self insulation right.
- 11:07It dominates the high end segment, acting almost like a
- 11:09duopoly. You know, iOS versus Android,
- 11:12But it maintains a premium positioning that Shields it from
- 11:14the brutal commodity price wars that define the low end of the
- 11:18smartphone market. And the capital intensity
- 11:20required to maintain this dominance is surprisingly low
- 11:23for a company that sells physical products.
- 11:25Why is that? Because they brilliantly
- 11:27outsource all the heavy lifting. They design the products, but
- 11:30their suppliers handle the massive factory investments, the
- 11:34complex machinery and the massive CapEx that manufacturing
- 11:37typically requires. And that structural advantage,
- 11:40it shows up clearly in the. It does, yes.
- 11:43In FY20, 25 capital expenditures, that's the money
- 11:47they had to sink into long term assets was only 12.7 billion.
- 11:51That's just 3% of revenue. And crucially, that CapEx figure
- 11:55is roughly equal to depreciation, which was 11.7
- 11:58billion. For our listeners, why is that
- 12:01relationship between CapEx and depreciation so important?
- 12:04Well, when CapEx essentially equals depreciation, it's just a
- 12:07capital light profile. It means the company doesn't
- 12:10need to sink huge growing amounts of cash just to maintain
- 12:13its asset base. Right, just to stand still.
- 12:15Exactly. It suggests that most of the
- 12:17CapEx is routine maintenance, not necessary for radical
- 12:20growth. Apple can effectively grow
- 12:22without tying up massive amounts of cash in factories or
- 12:25machinery, which reinforces its cash generation capabilities.
- 12:29So a clean sweep. Apple passes all four
- 12:32qualitative gates. It is, by every single measure,
- 12:35a wonderful business. It is.
- 12:37Now let's prove that the financial engine is just as
- 12:40robust as the reputation suggests.
- 12:42We move now from the qualitative filters to the hard data
- 12:45validation. This section is all about
- 12:48proving that the profits are real and backed by cash,
- 12:51starting with Buffett's true measure of profitability, owner
- 12:54earnings. Owner earnings or OE is what we
- 12:56estimate the true cash profits of the business are, the cash
- 12:59the company can distribute to owners after maintaining its
- 13:02competitive position. We're using the trailing 12
- 13:05months, the TTM for FY20 25. Let's break down the calculation
- 13:09slowly for clarity. We start with net income, which
- 13:12was a massive $112 billion. Right.
- 13:15To that we add back the non cash expenses that look like losses
- 13:19but weren't actual cash outflows, depreciation and
- 13:22amortization that's 11.7 billion and stock based compensation
- 13:27which is 12.9 billion. OK, we then subtract what the
- 13:31business must spend to maintain its status quo.
- 13:35And that includes maintenance capital expenditures, which we
- 13:37estimate is roughly equal to DNA at 11.7 billion.
- 13:42And we conservatively subtract another 10 million for
- 13:45normalized working capital use, acknowledging that, you know,
- 13:48normalizing year over year working capital changes can be
- 13:51complex. When you net all that out, the
- 13:53normalized owner earnings are estimated at around 115 billion.
- 13:57But to be conservative for our valuation models, we carry
- 13:59forward a rounded figure of about 1, $100 billion for the
- 14:02year. And what's crucial is that this
- 14:04conservative OE estimate aligns almost perfectly with the
- 14:07reported free cash flow. It does.
- 14:10It was 98.8 billion for our listeners.
- 14:14That cash conversion rate is a critical metric, right?
- 14:16Because it confirms that the net income we see on paper is
- 14:19actually money in the bank, not just accounting magic.
- 14:22Exactly. Operating cash flow and FY20 25
- 14:26was 111.5 billion, nearly identical to the net income of
- 14:31112 billion. That is a 99.5% cash conversion
- 14:36of earnings. That's incredible.
- 14:38Most companies show lower cash flow than net income because of
- 14:40aggressive accruals, meaning they recognize revenue before
- 14:44the customer has even paid the cash.
- 14:46Apple shows no such weakness. Their profits are real and they
- 14:49are liquid. There are absolutely no signs of
- 14:52earnings manipulation whatsoever.
- 14:54Let's talk about operational efficiency.
- 14:56The return on assets ROA is an exceptionally high 31.2%.
- 15:01Most well run mature companies would struggle to break into the
- 15:04low double digits. They're generating 31 cents of
- 15:06profit for every dollar of assets used and.
- 15:09Then we get to the elephant in the room, the triple digit
- 15:11return on equity ROA of 152%. That number is so, so high.
- 15:16It just demands scrutiny. Is it dangerous leverage?
- 15:21That's the question. The Roe relies heavily on a
- 15:24massive equity multiplier of 4.87, which typically signals
- 15:28high debt leverage. So isn't that high leverage
- 15:30dangerous? Or is there something
- 15:32structurally unique about Apple's debt profile that kind
- 15:34of Shields them from the typical risks?
- 15:37That's a fantastic question and it is the key insight.
- 15:40We decompose the Roe using the DuPont analysis.
- 15:43Roe equals Net margin times asset turnover times equity
- 15:47multiplier. Apple's high Roe is a function
- 15:50of its excellent Net margin, 26.9% amplified by that massive
- 15:54equity multiplier. But the multiplier is not risky
- 15:57debt. But this multiplier is not risky
- 15:59debt. Leverage.
- 16:00It's the result of the buyback machine.
- 16:02Precisely. The multiplier is artificially
- 16:04inflated because decades of massive share buybacks have
- 16:07intentionally shrunk the shareholder equity base.
- 16:10They're using debt, which is incredibly cheap for Apple, to
- 16:13fund the repurchase of equity. They aren't using debt to fund
- 16:16risky acquisitions or massive capital expenditures.
- 16:19They're just optimizing the capital structure for
- 16:21shareholders. And this leads to the most, I
- 16:23mean mind boggling efficiency metric return on capital
- 16:26employed RSCE. When we strip out all that
- 16:29excess cash Apple holds to see the pure operating operational
- 16:33efficiency, the return on capital employed approaches a
- 16:36staggering 276%. For context, a truly successful
- 16:42capital heavy industrial giant, one that manages assets
- 16:45brilliantly, might hit a 15% ROCE.
- 16:49Apple is achieving returns nearly 18 times that benchmark.
- 16:53That number just underscores the pure financial power of their
- 16:56asset light outsourced manufacturing model.
- 16:59It's truly elite, unmatched performance.
- 17:02It's proof of the operational genius behind the fortress.
- 17:05It'll question the efficiency. Story continues With their
- 17:07ability to reinvest even at this massive scale, the number
- 17:10suggests they still have a long runway for high return
- 17:13investment, partly because their reinvestment needs are so
- 17:16modest. We can quantify that through the
- 17:18exceptional capital efficiency ratio.
- 17:20This metric looks at the accumulative owner earnings
- 17:23generated compared to the growth capital expenditures required to
- 17:26generate them. Over the last decade, Apple
- 17:29yielded a ratio of approximately 3434.
- 17:32And remember, the benchmark for a capital light high return
- 17:35business to be called exceptional is greater than 10.
- 17:40So a ratio of 34 means that for every single dollar they
- 17:43reinvested to grow the business, they generated $34 in operating
- 17:47profits over time. Yes, that is the definition of a
- 17:50machine that compounds capital at extremely high rates.
- 17:53And where does that reinvestment runway extend now?
- 17:56Well, first, marked expansion into emerging markets,
- 17:59converting the remaining Android users to the ecosystem.
- 18:02Second and more importantly is that high margin expansion in
- 18:06the services segment. Services growth is intrinsically
- 18:09high return because it requires R&D investment, not factory
- 18:12CapEx. But the critical factor driving
- 18:15revenue growth isn't unit volume, which is, you know, it's
- 18:17pretty mature. It's still their phenomenal
- 18:19pricing power. Absolutely.
- 18:21Revenue growth has been driven primarily by rising average
- 18:24selling prices ASPs. The iPhone ASP is steadily
- 18:28moving toward that $1050 mark. They consistently raise the
- 18:32price floors without seeing any meaningful dip in demand.
- 18:35It's the ultimate test of the Moat.
- 18:37The customer just accepts those price hikes without meaningful
- 18:40defection. It suggests that their customer
- 18:42base has nearly inelastic demand for Apple products.
- 18:46They will pay the premium. They'll pay it because the
- 18:48product fulfills their need for quality, for status, and for
- 18:52that ecosystem integration. Finally, we examine the
- 18:54Foundation balance sheet integrity, which earns Apple the
- 18:58Sortress rating. They are unique among mega cap
- 19:00companies in being net cash positive, meaning they have more
- 19:04cash than total debt. Correct.
- 19:06They ended FY20 25 with $132.4 billion in cash and marketable
- 19:12securities versus 99.3 billion in total debt.
- 19:16That leaves them with a $33.1 billion net cash surplus.
- 19:20So in a global economic downturn, Apple has this massive
- 19:23strategic war chest and no immediate solvency concerns.
- 19:27None. And the debt they do carry is
- 19:30miniscule relative to their cash generation.
- 19:33Their debt to EBIT ratio is tiny, around 0.75 X.
- 19:38They could pay off all their debt in under nine months of
- 19:40earnings. Interest coverage is estimated
- 19:42at well over 50 times, making debt risk essentially
- 19:45negligible, and their operational efficiency continues
- 19:49to impress. On the working capital side,
- 19:51inventory is minimal at 5.7 billion, representing just about
- 19:555 days of sales. Which minimizes obsolescence
- 19:58risk in a fast moving hardware environment.
- 20:00It does, and fitting the classic value investor preference
- 20:04goodwill is negligible. This means they generated their
- 20:07own $263 billion brand value internally rather than buying it
- 20:12through overpriced value destroying acquisitions.
- 20:15OK, so to summarize the first two sections, Apple is a
- 20:18wonderful business with an expanding Moat, exceptional
- 20:20capital allocation, perfect cash conversion, and an unrivaled
- 20:24balance sheet. The fortress is structurally
- 20:26flawless. It is, but even the best
- 20:28fortress can be breached by a determined, coordinated siege.
- 20:32That's right, let's pivot to the primary risk facing Apple's $4
- 20:36trillion valuation, the regulatory assault.
- 20:40And here's where the tension really ratchets up.
- 20:43The primary external risk isn't a new smartphone competitor.
- 20:47It is the global regulatory assault targeting the Apple tax
- 20:51and the walled garden structure that generates their highest
- 20:54margin revenue services. The services segment is now a
- 20:57juggernaut. Revenue hit 109.16 billion in
- 21:02FY20 25, accounting for over 26% of total sales.
- 21:06And the margins are the key because the gross margin for
- 21:09services is estimated at around 75%.
- 21:11This segment contributes nearly 40% of Apple's entire gross
- 21:15profit dollar generation. Wow.
- 21:17It's the highest quality, most recurring revenue stream they
- 21:19possess. And that high margin stream
- 21:21comes directly from the Apple tax, the 15 to 30% Commission
- 21:25Apple takes on digital goods and in app purchases.
- 21:28This mechanism originated from Steve Jobs core principle of
- 21:31close control over the App Store, initially framed as
- 21:34ensuring quality and security. But over 15 years, regulators
- 21:38argue that structure has evolved from a quality guarantee into a
- 21:42dual monopoly, controlling both the mechanism of application
- 21:45distribution and the necessary payment processing.
- 21:48Right. This is what fostered the
- 21:49immense stickiness in those massive profits and now it's
- 21:53being challenged globally. And that fight begins with the
- 21:55European Union and the Digital Markets Act, or DMA.
- 21:59This law is specifically designed to curb the power of
- 22:03tech giants deemed gatekeepers with market caps over €50
- 22:07billion and large user bases. And the requirements are
- 22:10surgically aimed at dismantling the fortress walls.
- 22:13The DMA demands 3 core changes. First, allowing third party app
- 22:17stores. Second, allowing third party
- 22:19payment channels. And 3rd, allowing web-based app
- 22:23downloads without going through the App Store at all.
- 22:25Which is huge. These requirements fundamentally
- 22:27dismantle Apple's ability to maintain a closed ecosystem.
- 22:30Apple was forced to comply and lower commissions, down to 17%
- 22:34for general apps and 10% for small enterprises.
- 22:37In the EU market. That already bites into the high
- 22:39margin revenue structure. But Apple's compliance was
- 22:42immediately met with controversy because they didn't just lower
- 22:45the fee, they introduced the highly contentious Core
- 22:48Technology Fee, or CTF. And the CTF charges developers
- 22:52€50 cents per user per year, but only after an app exceeds
- 22:571,000,000 annual installs. The backlash year was
- 23:00instantaneous and severe because this fee is a prohibitive
- 23:04nonprofit contingent charge. Let's illustrate the impact.
- 23:08A popular free app that generates no revenue but has 100
- 23:12million annual installs, which is easily achievable for popular
- 23:15social media or utility tools, would suddenly face a €50
- 23:19million CTF fee. 50 million. Regardless of whether it
- 23:23generated a single euro of sales.
- 23:25Correct. This fee is seen by developers
- 23:27as a de facto mechanism to maintain monopoly profits.
- 23:30By crippling the free to use business model.
- 23:33It prevents developers from migrating to 3rd party stores
- 23:35even with lower commissions, because the CTF threatens to
- 23:38bankrupt any application that succeeds on scale rather than
- 23:41transactional revenue. And the EU has shown it's
- 23:44serious. In April 2025, they imposed a
- 23:46massive €500 million fine on Apple for anti scaring
- 23:50practices, ruling that Apple illegally prevented developers
- 23:53like Spotify from directing users to cheaper external
- 23:57payment options and that five. €100 million penalty is a strong
- 24:00indicator. It tells us that regulators are
- 24:03willing to impose massive financial pain to ensure
- 24:06compliance, and they view Apple's initial compliance moves
- 24:10like the CTF with intense suspicion.
- 24:13And the regulatory siege is far from localized.
- 24:16We're seeing fronts open up all across Asia and crucially, in
- 24:19Apple's home market, the US. Japan is following the EU's
- 24:22playbook with its own mobile Software Competition Law, which
- 24:26was enacted to the end of 2025. It also mandates the opening of
- 24:30third party app stores and external payments.
- 24:32What's fascinating is how Apple has tried to adapt its pricing
- 24:35strategy in Japan versus the EU. Well, in Japan, Apple's
- 24:38concession is the lowest official rate globally, a 5%
- 24:42core technology fee for 3rd party stores or web apps.
- 24:45But in this is key. This fee is levied against
- 24:47revenue, not installs. Which makes it much less
- 24:50onerous. Much less many developers are
- 24:53reportedly finding that 5% fee to be far more reasonable as it
- 24:56fairly covers Apple's Technical Support and distribution
- 24:59infrastructure costs, unlike the controversial €50 cent per
- 25:03install fee in Europe. And Japan means business.
- 25:06The penalty for non compliance can be severe, up to 20 to 30%
- 25:10of their Japanese revenue, which is an enormous stick.
- 25:13It is This pressure is why Epic Games, the source notes, is
- 25:18finally able to bring Fortnite back to iOS in Japan using a
- 25:21third party store which demonstrates a true breach in
- 25:24the walls. And meanwhile, the US Department
- 25:26of Justice antitrust suit continues.
- 25:28That suit survived Apple's motion to dismiss back in June
- 25:312025 and alleges Apple maintains an illegal monopoly by
- 25:35suppressing competition in five key areas, including messaging,
- 25:39smartwatches and super apps. In the ongoing legal battle with
- 25:42Epic Games here in the US continues to put pressure on the
- 25:45Apple tax. Federal judges ruled that Apple
- 25:48flagrantly violated earlier orders by continuing to charge a
- 25:5127% Commission on external payments.
- 25:53So what happened with that? The latest ruling in December
- 25:562025, upheld the violation finding, but will allow Apple to
- 26:00charge a reasonable Commission a rate based on its actual cost of
- 26:03processing, security and distribution, not the historical
- 26:0727% rate. This ruling pushes the fight
- 26:10into this protracted legal mediation to determine that
- 26:13precise, justifiable rate, effectively putting the entire
- 26:17App Store Commission structure on trial.
- 26:20So OK, we have the EU establishing the precedent of
- 26:23dismantling the walled garden, Japan establishing A relatively
- 26:26fair pricing reference point with that 5% revenue based fee,
- 26:29and the US pushing for a cost justified reasonable Commission.
- 26:33What is the ultimate strategic implication of this coordinated
- 26:36global siege? It's the global domino effect.
- 26:38Every compliance move made in the EU or Japan sets a reference
- 26:41point for regulators. Everywhere else, Korea, the UK,
- 26:44Turkey, Brazil, regulators talk to each other and they look for
- 26:48the lowest common denominator in terms of concession.
- 26:50So the worst case scenario for Apple's valuation is a
- 26:52convergence. Exactly.
- 26:54If a unified global compliance standard emerges, say mandatory
- 26:59third party access everywhere, combined with a 5 to 10%
- 27:03Commission cap on all digital goods, the profitability of the
- 27:07$100 billion services segment will suffer A devastating blow.
- 27:11Just walk us through that math. If the gross margin on that $100
- 27:15billion segment drops from 75% down to say 50% due to fee
- 27:20reductions in competition, Apple loses $25 billion in annual
- 27:25gross profit. That is a massive hit to the
- 27:27quality of their earnings. And Apple's defense, according
- 27:31to the sources, involves what technical upgrades, right?
- 27:33Boosting the security and compatibility arguments for iOS
- 27:37and business transformation. Shifting revenue towards their
- 27:39proprietary subscriptions like Apple Music and iCloud, which
- 27:43are slightly harder for regulators to classify as
- 27:45monopoly price gouging. But this regulatory siege really
- 27:48is the single biggest operational threat to Apple's
- 27:51financial model today. Make no mistake, it threatens
- 27:53the core high margin mode that justifies the company's current
- 27:57premium valuation. So if that core cash cow is
- 28:00under siege, Apple has to be aggressively planting seeds for
- 28:03massive future growth to justify the market price.
- 28:06They do. Let's look at where they are
- 28:08pivoting their enormous R&D. Resources The overarching theme
- 28:11for FY20 25 is strategic recalibration.
- 28:16The era of explosive iPhone growth is over, replaced by a
- 28:19defensive necessity to find new multibillion dollar categories,
- 28:24primarily in AI and the speculative hardware bats.
- 28:27The revenue snapshot confirms this shift.
- 28:29Total net sales reached 416 billion, a moderate 6.43% year
- 28:35over year increase. The iPhone still accounts for
- 28:38over half the business at 209 billion, but services is now
- 28:41over 109 billion, 26% of the total pie.
- 28:45And the iPhone maturity is clear.
- 28:46Growth is moderate and driven almost entirely by average
- 28:49selling price that ASP of 1050, not unit volume.
- 28:52The replacement cycle is lengthened significantly. 70% of
- 28:55buyers now hold their phones for two years or more it.
- 28:57Just shows that the device is technologically satiated for
- 29:00many users. It is.
- 29:01Interestingly, the Max segment saw a strong recovery, growing
- 29:04over 12% at 33 billion. That's the M series custom
- 29:09silicon transition story. The performance gains are
- 29:12compelling users who bought early M1 Max to upgrade to M4 or
- 29:16M5 architecture. And this leads to a crucial
- 29:19strategic insight, what the source is called the hand me
- 29:21down economy. Apple is implicitly encouraging
- 29:25device longevity partly because a four year old iPhone, now
- 29:28handed down to a secondary market user in an emerging
- 29:31economy, still generates that high margin recurring services
- 29:35revenue. So the mode continues to widen
- 29:37through services, even if the primary sales engine for new
- 29:40hardware slows down. Precisely now to the future AI.
- 29:44Apple adopted a very distinct strategy with Apple Intelligence
- 29:47AIA Hybrid Privacy first approach that directly contrasts
- 29:50with its competitors. They run lightweight models
- 29:53locally on the A&M series chips for instant utility and only
- 29:56offload the most complex queries to their custom private cloud
- 29:59compute or PCC servers. The core selling point is
- 30:03privacy. Apple is telling the world we
- 30:06can deliver sophisticated AI without harvesting your personal
- 30:10data to train our models. Can you elaborate quickly on
- 30:12PCC? Is that essentially Apple
- 30:14proving they don't look at your data while processing the heavy
- 30:18AI lifting? That's exactly the public
- 30:19relations message and the technical architecture.
- 30:22CC uses secure proprietary hardware built by ALE to ensure
- 30:27that requests sent off device are processed without ALE or
- 30:31anyone else being able to access the underlying user data.
- 30:35It's a costly but essential move to maintain trust, particularly
- 30:38in privacy conscious markets like the EU.
- 30:40And initial adoption suggests success, at least for utility
- 30:43features. 88% of compatible iPhones adopted iOS 18.
- 30:47Feeders like notification summaries saw high engagement
- 30:50because they solved the pain point of information overload
- 30:53without requiring users to fundamentally change how they
- 30:55interact with the phone. However, a functional feature
- 30:58gap remains between Apple and key competitors, particularly
- 31:01regarding real time multimodal interaction.
- 31:04The sources specifically contrast Apple's static visual
- 31:07intelligence with Google's approach.
- 31:09Right. Take Google's Gemini Live that
- 31:12offers real time video stream analysis with a conversational
- 31:15overlay. You point your phone camera at a
- 31:17damaged bicycle part and Gemini can tell you what the part is,
- 31:21where to buy a replacement, and give you step by step repair
- 31:24instructions, all in real time. That level of proactive
- 31:28assistance is powerful. And similarly, Samsung's Live
- 31:31Translate offers real time on device translation in over 30
- 31:35languages, eliminating language barriers instantly.
- 31:38Another massive utility feature that drives adoption.
- 31:41Yes, the criticism of Apple Intelligence is that Siri, even
- 31:44with its latest Linwood LLM update, often punts complex real
- 31:49time queries to third parties like ChatGPT and this creates
- 31:52platform risk because the user is conditioned to leave Apple's
- 31:55need of environment to get complex answers.
- 31:58Apple is not yet the native real time agent of the future, and
- 32:01the $275 valuation is pricing in the assumption that they will
- 32:04rapidly close this feature gap. And this challenge is why their
- 32:07hardware road map is pivoting so sharply beyond the mature iPhone
- 32:10slab. The first big swing, the Vision
- 32:12Pro, has been, well, challenging.
- 32:14Sales in 2025 are estimated to be under 1,000,000 units.
- 32:18Hanford significantly by the $3500 price point and the 1.4 LB
- 32:23weight. It was a product designed for
- 32:25fidelity, maximum resolution and immersion over form factor and
- 32:28comfort. Right.
- 32:29The early enthusiasts market was strong, but the mass consumer
- 32:33market rejected the compromise on weight and price.
- 32:36This forced the strategic pivot away from heavy, isolating AR.
- 32:40Apple has paused work on a cheaper headset, the rumored
- 32:43Visionaire, and is reallocating resources toward a more
- 32:46consumable form smart glasses project N50, aiming for late
- 32:512026 or 2027. This is a recognition that the
- 32:55market prefers lightweight utility glasses that can provide
- 32:57quick contextual AI feedback and notification support over heavy
- 33:01AR immersion. They are chasing the mass
- 33:03consumer market, recognizing that the primary utility of AR
- 33:06may be enhancing the experience away from the computer, not
- 33:09bringing the computer closer to your face.
- 33:11And beyond AR, they are making a bold move into the home with
- 33:14Project J595, often described as the Pixar Lamp home robot,
- 33:18following the cancellation of the Apple Car project.
- 33:20This is a major speculative pivot budgeted for high R&D
- 33:24send. The robot is rumored to be $1000
- 33:27Tabletop Smart Home Command center with an iPad like display
- 33:31mounted on a robotic arm. The arm allows the screen to
- 33:35follow the user around a room, tracking their voice and
- 33:37providing constant interaction. It's an attempt to create a more
- 33:40alive and proactive interface than the static competitors like
- 33:44the Echo Show or Nest Hub. It is, and it's important to the
- 33:47valuation because the smart home market is massive but fragmented
- 33:51and dominated by low margin devices from Amazon and Google.
- 33:55Apple needs to invent a premium and differentiated category,
- 33:58$1000 smart home anchor that can hook customers into yet another
- 34:02high margin service subscription layer.
- 34:04It's high risk, high reward. And finally, the purely
- 34:08defensive hardware move, the foldable iPhone Project V68,
- 34:12targeting a 2026 release with a clamshell design.
- 34:15Yeah. This is not an innovation play,
- 34:17it's an insurance policy. It's meant to prevent high end
- 34:20users who seek novelty and cutting edge design from
- 34:23defecting to established foldable Android devices,
- 34:25particularly Samsung. They can't afford to lose those
- 34:28highest spending customers. Exactly.
- 34:30Not even to niche competitors. These new hardware categories,
- 34:34smart glasses, robotics, and foldables are the essential
- 34:38growth optionality. The market is currently pricing
- 34:40in to the $275 stock price. Which brings us to the final and
- 34:45most challenging section, connecting all this quality and
- 34:48inherent risk back to the current price tag.
- 34:51So now we revisit the intrinsic value framework.
- 34:54Apple passed every single qualitative gate.
- 34:57They are an exceptional fortress like business generating $100
- 35:00billion in annual owner earnings.
- 35:03The question is, what is an exceptional business worth to a
- 35:06discipline value investor? We use our normalized owner
- 35:09earnings of $100 billion and a standard 10% discount rate.
- 35:13OK, let's run the three scenarios to bracket the true
- 35:16intrinsic value or Ivy per share.
- 35:18Scenario A The rock bottom baseline No growth if Apple
- 35:22earned 100 billion forever with 0% growth, a highly conservative
- 35:26assumption for a business of this quality.
- 35:28Discounted to 10%, the total value is $1 trillion.
- 35:31Dividing that by the 14.8 billion shares gives us an
- 35:35intrinsic value per share of approximately $67.
- 35:38That's the absolute worst case floor value based on current
- 35:42earnings. Scenario B.
- 35:44The base case modest 3% GDP growth, assuming Apple grows
- 35:49modestly at the rate of global GDP for perpetuity, which is a
- 35:52very reasonable expectation given its global reach and
- 35:55pricing power. Using the Gordon growth formula,
- 35:58100 billion growing at 3%, discounted at 10% gives us
- 36:02approximately 1.47 trillion. That translates to an intrinsic
- 36:06value per share of roughly $100. This is our solid base
- 36:09expectation of value for a long term owner.
- 36:12And scenario C, the optimistic case, let's be generous and
- 36:15assume Apple can grow robustly, say at 6% annually for the next
- 36:19decade, fueled by services and new hardware, and then slow to
- 36:233% perpetual growth. Using that two stage discounted
- 36:26cash flow or DCF model, the total value comes out to about
- 36:291.84 trillion. That puts the intrinsic value
- 36:32per share at around 125 dollars. OK.
- 36:35So the realistic disciplined range of intrinsic value based
- 36:39on conservative to highly optimistic assumptions is 67 to
- 36:44$125 per share. And this is where the price
- 36:47problem becomes unavoidable. Apple's current market price is
- 36:51approximately $275 per share, implying a market capitalization
- 36:55about four point O $7 trillion. The gap is immense.
- 36:59The current price is more than double the most optimistic
- 37:02intrinsic value estimate we could responsibly derive.
- 37:05Why is the market willing to pay such an extreme premium?
- 37:08Well, the market is no longer pricing Apple as a traditional
- 37:11hardware company. It is pricing it as the world's
- 37:14most successful subscription service distributor, whose
- 37:17hardware sales are merely the necessary upfront cost to
- 37:20acquire a perpetually recurring high margin customer.
- 37:24This perspective grants at a growth premium usually reserved
- 37:26for pure software platforms. To truly understand the market's
- 37:30psychological expectation, we perform a reverse DCF.
- 37:34We ask what sustained annual growth rate would Apple need to
- 37:37deliver for the next decade Florida State to justify today's
- 37:414 point O $7 trillion valuation? The calculation is well, it's
- 37:46staggering. To justify the $275 market
- 37:50price, the company would need to compound its owner earnings at
- 37:53approximately 15% annually for the next decade. 15%.
- 37:58And 3% thereafter. That is the price of corporate
- 38:01perfection and 0 risk. We are talking about inventing
- 38:04the equivalent of 2 full-sized Amazons in 10 years purely to
- 38:08justify today's price. A 15% sustained growth rate
- 38:12would require Apple to roughly quadruple its profits in 10
- 38:16years, reaching annual revenues near 1.5 to $2 trillion.
- 38:21That requires near flawless execution in AI, the massive
- 38:25success of high risk ventures like smart glasses and robotics,
- 38:28and the assumption that the $100 billion services segment will
- 38:31emerge from the global regulatory siege virtually
- 38:33unscathed. And that staggering expectation
- 38:36forces us to apply the final critical step, the margin of
- 38:39safety. Buffett demands a safety margin.
- 38:42For a quality business like Apple, we would apply a minimum
- 38:4525% margin of safety MOS to even the optimistic IV of $125.00.
- 38:52That yields A desirable buy price of approximately $94.
- 38:56Given that the stock is trading at 275, the conclusion by
- 39:00discipline Value investing standards is unavoidable.
- 39:02Apple is a wonderful company, but it is demonstrably not at a
- 39:06wonderful price. The stock at 275 is
- 39:09significantly overvalued. It offers 0 margin of safety and
- 39:13is trading at more than twice the most generous intrinsic
- 39:15value estimate. So what's the final
- 39:17recommendation for listener, whether they are a prospective
- 39:20or current owner? The recommendation is hold, not
- 39:23buy. If you currently own Apple, you
- 39:25maintain your position due to the undeniable business quality,
- 39:28but for a new investor, you must wait for a better entry point,
- 39:31perhaps under 150, or ideally under the disciplined margin of
- 39:35safety threshold of $100 to ensure a high probability of
- 39:40acceptable forward returns. The price of perfection leaves
- 39:43absolutely no room for error or unexpected regulatory
- 39:46turbulence. This has been a truly
- 39:48fascinating deep dive, meticulously showing us the
- 39:51tension between structural quality and market expectation.
- 39:55Apple passed every single quality test.
- 39:57The Moat is widening, management is exceptional, and the cash
- 40:01flow engine is robust. It did.
- 40:03It failed only the final critical test.
- 40:05The price is simply too high for a new investor.
- 40:07If you are an investor who currently holds Apple, there are
- 40:10key metrics you must monitor going forward to gauge if the
- 40:13Moat is holding. 1st, watch the trend of services revenue
- 40:16growth. You want to see high single to
- 40:18low double digits. If services growth dips below
- 40:218%, it signals that the regulatory siege or general
- 40:25market maturity is having a greater than expected impact.
- 40:28Second, watch the gross margin. It must hold the 40% plus level,
- 40:32ideally staying near that current 47%.
- 40:36If the margin erodes, Apple is losing pricing power to either
- 40:39competitors or regulation. And most critically, the global
- 40:43regulatory environment remains the biggest external risk.
- 40:46Any significant new penalty or unified global standard will hit
- 40:50profits directly. Absolutely.
- 40:52The biggest long term threat is the convergence of global
- 40:54regulation, the EU, Japan and the US DOJ, leading to a unified
- 40:59global standard that significantly erodes the high
- 41:01margin Service Commission structure.
- 41:04Any unified global fee structure settling definitively under 10%
- 41:08will be a major cause for RE evaluation of the entire
- 41:10business model and its valuation.
- 41:12Before we sign off based on everything we discussed today,
- 41:15we want to leave you with one critical tension to Mull over.
- 41:18The current 4 plus trillion dollar valuation relies entirely
- 41:21on the future success of unproven ventures like robotics
- 41:24and smart glasses and flawless AI execution, right?
- 41:27While simultaneously assuming the $100 billion high margin
- 41:30services mode will not be significantly breached by global
- 41:33regulators. Which assumption, the flawless
- 41:35growth into entirely new markets or the permanent integrity of
- 41:39the existing high margin Moat is more likely to break first?
- 41:44That's what you should be thinking about as an owner of
- 41:46Apple stock today. Thank you for joining us for the
- 41:48Deep Dive. And remember, if you want to
- 41:50track total market temperature based on the financial metrics
- 41:53we discussed today, search and download the iOS App Buffett
- 41:57Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 41:59One final time, our necessary disclosure disclaimer.
- 42:03All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 42:06may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 42:09The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 42:13constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 42:16before making investment decisions.
- 42:18If you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 42:21or access more advanced content, welcome to join Deep Value Club
- 42:24membership or subscribe to us on Apple and Spotify podcast
- 42:27channels. Deep Value Investing.
- 42:29We'll see you next time on the Deep Dive.