Latest / Circana Unpacked / #11 - Seasonal Selectivity: How Intentional Shoppers Are Shaping Holiday 2026
Transcript
- 0:04Hello and welcome to Circana Unpacked, a podcast in which we open
- 0:07up and sort through insights that are driving market trends across CPG,
- 0:11manufacturing, retail, foodservice, and media industries. I'm Lynn Pietrak
- 0:15with Circana's newsroom.
- 0:21In this series, our thought leaders, including Circana experts
- 0:25and industry partners, regularly delve into opportunities and disruptions that
- 0:29affect businesses both in the short-term and long-term future. Today,
- 0:32it's beginning to look a lot like the holidays, and we're jumping into it
- 0:36with our projections for the festive season with our own Keira Barrett, our Global
- 0:40Head of Thought Leadership. So welcome. Thank you. A little
- 0:44bit more background on you so our listeners get to know you. Keira leads
- 0:48Circana's global thought leadership strategy and works with the world's largest
- 0:51retailers, consumer packaged goods manufacturers, and industry organizations to navigate
- 0:56disruption, unlock growth, and anticipate what's next for consumers and commerce.
- 1:00Her work spans the most critical issues shaping the industry today, including AI
- 1:04and agentic commerce, retail media, consumer spending, loyalty innovation,
- 1:08and the future of retail, all of which dovetail into the peak holiday season.
- 1:12Prior to Circana, she was managing director at Accenture, where she led the North
- 1:17American consumer goods, retail, and travel growth strategy practice.
- 1:20And before Accenture, she worked on brand management at Procter& Gamble. So we
- 1:24are going to get right into unwrapping trends. What do you think? I love it.
- 1:28And thank you so much for having me. Looking forward to it. Me too.
- 1:30It's just this is like, I just love this time of year. I'm just kind
- 1:34of like a holiday geek. And so anything related to the season,
- 1:39I just, I just love jumping into it. But if there's anything about the decade
- 1:43that we know, it's macroeconomic uncertainty. We're probably
- 1:46going to be so sick of saying it by the end of it. But heading
- 1:49into this season, what are consumers doing? How are they balancing their
- 1:53need to watch their budgets And they still want to celebrate. Does it look different
- 1:57this year? It's such a good question. So, you know, I think about what the
- 2:00families are doing. So picture a family at the kitchen table. They've got their notebook
- 2:04or calculator or phone. They're working out what they're going to do for the holidays,
- 2:08what it's going to look like. And I will tell you what we're hearing from
- 2:11consumers is no one is asking, of course, whether or not to celebrate if they
- 2:15celebrate holidays. Right. And that's really the story of 2026. It's about
- 2:19selectivity, not restraint. Shoppers are still saying yes,
- 2:23they want to do it. They're just much more deliberate with those yeses and
- 2:27being much more focused about what they're spending their money on. In our
- 2:30recent holiday surveys, about half are saying that they're going to spend less because
- 2:35of their economic situation and its uncertainty. But almost as many
- 2:38say that they're going to buy more gifts to lift up the people that they
- 2:42love. So both things are true, right? And often in the same household,
- 2:46we're seeing these trends kind of come to life, not just for holiday, but also
- 2:50earlier in the year. And we're seeing people in order to fund that really changing
- 2:53their habits to pay for it. So that selectivity is coming through even
- 2:57earlier in the year and saying, you know what, I'm not going to do that
- 3:00trip. I'm— because I want to have a nice holiday. And that resilience,
- 3:04boy, we talked about the consumer resilience for years and it is true.
- 3:07They're resilient. And I think they've been resilient for so long.
- 3:10Perhaps that's shaping this whole intentionality because they're
- 3:14getting good at being resilient. Yeah. And listen, you know,
- 3:17we've talked a lot about areas that are growing in the market.
- 3:21So what are the categories that are still finding that dollar and unit growth?
- 3:24And they're typically anchored in more joyful categories,
- 3:27which go very hand in hand with the holidays, right? Toys and beauty
- 3:31and fragrance and things like that. And so it is about finding joy where they
- 3:35can, but it comes much now more with a plan. And it's every day we
- 3:40see that in our other research too, right? Everyday elevation of enjoyment.
- 3:43We kind of see that enjoyment means different things. It could mean gift giving to
- 3:47others. It could mean the way we are enjoying spending time together to celebrate the
- 3:51holidays too. So are we kind of seeing that in gatherings as well as gift
- 3:54giving? Absolutely. And what we're seeing actually in some of
- 3:57the research that we just did was that
- 4:02if we compare versus a year ago where people are willing,
- 4:05especially as they think about hosting holidays, I think that's a good corollary, right?
- 4:09Like we want to bring people together. Typically that's more expensive,
- 4:13you know, having the parties, having the food, et cetera. And what people are
- 4:16telling us is actually as they look at that space and creating those
- 4:20holidays for their families and friends, they are more willing to
- 4:24outsource part of that experience. So whether they— a part
- 4:28of their meal is going to be bought from somewhere else or all of it
- 4:32is going to be catered or purchased elsewhere, those numbers went up this
- 4:36year, which typically also means that they're going to spend a little bit more,
- 4:38right? Because they're not making it themselves. But I think people are
- 4:42trying to balance the enjoyment of the season versus the
- 4:45mental load of doing a full celebration and willing
- 4:49to pay for that convenience because recognize it's worth it. And you
- 4:53could see the balance literally on the table because there might be some store-bought
- 4:57pies and there might be home baking. Exactly. Or, hey, you know what?
- 5:00I'm going to do the cheese board from the grocery store because then
- 5:04it's beautiful and they made it all nice and I can just put it out
- 5:07and it looks like I did it right and I get the credit. So I
- 5:10think that that's a part of it as well. And we talked too about the
- 5:12moments, what joy looks like that consumers are focusing on experiences
- 5:16and moments and gifts. And so how does that play into the emotional relevance
- 5:20with moments? I think joy has gotten maybe
- 5:24a bit smaller and a bit closer in, right? It looks less like
- 5:27that big trip or that big experience and more like, hey, what if I
- 5:31host an intimate dinner party with my friends and make it really cool and
- 5:35fun? You know, in finding that balance, like most people,
- 5:38as we're starting to look at some of even the data for trip miles
- 5:42driven and things like that are kind of trending toward maybe skipping the
- 5:46overnight trip and hosting things at home. So I don't want to
- 5:49go and travel for the holidays. I'm going to just keep it tight at my
- 5:53home. And then, as I mentioned, more of them are ordering parts of their meal
- 5:56in a way that allows for them to really be in the moment, right?
- 6:00Because planning those things does take a lot of time and energy
- 6:03away from the celebration. And in a world that you're— to your point of the
- 6:07macroeconomic environment, in a world where maybe things are a little bit more stressful,
- 6:11trying to maximize that convenience is a gift to yourself,
- 6:15right? And so, you know, thinking about that as, hey, I want to free my
- 6:19time up so I can just be with my friends and family. And I also
- 6:22think when we think about Joy, people are leaning much more
- 6:25in. And this is true for all the mini holidays throughout the year and what
- 6:29we've seen. They're leaning into wanting things that are
- 6:33like mean something or that last. And I don't mean last like
- 6:37only of good quality, but like the fragrance, like why fragrances
- 6:42are so big in the holiday season is because of that like
- 6:45emotional connection and, hey, remember me when you put this on, or, hey,
- 6:49I know you're gonna have this trip, next year, so I bought you a jacket
- 6:53for that, you know, so that you can remember me when you're on it.
- 6:56Those types of connections or, or even experiences. People are spending
- 7:00more on tickets and movie— going to movies is popping.
- 7:03And so I think we're starting to really see that come to life. And it's
- 7:07not that these categories are competing against one another,
- 7:10but it's how do we become a part of what people are trying to build
- 7:14for their lives? That is so well put. And I think there's a creativity to
- 7:18it as well, because there was a time when, okay, we'll just go get a
- 7:21gift card, but now there's meaning behind the gift card. What, what experience
- 7:26can I get out of this? Because it just, that was maybe easy to
- 7:29do, but there's meaning behind those experiences and giving those
- 7:33to other people. And I also think as we think about channels, right? So where
- 7:37people are finding things like, of course
- 7:40there's a big growth in e-commerce and social, et cetera, but there's still a
- 7:44lot of value in just the shopping experience itself to
- 7:48put yourself in the mindset of holiday. And, you know,
- 7:51I'll tell you that I, you know, haven't done a lot of shopping yet,
- 7:53but I can't wait to get in that holiday spirit. Yeah, it's been a little
- 7:57too warm here, but, but it's— but it is. It's— you get the little hot
- 8:00chocolate, you walk around the mall, and I could just come home with maybe one
- 8:03bag and one thing ticked off the list. So— and we're seeing—
- 8:07you mentioned a few sectors, but we're seeing this play off across different categories
- 8:10and different industries. Right. And are there some— you mentioned some areas
- 8:14that are doing them. What are some things that are going to be popping that
- 8:17some of the research told you? I think a couple things are important.
- 8:20The first is just the way that I'm thinking about the wallet and
- 8:24what people are doing with it. Like, the wallet's a little bit smaller,
- 8:27you know. In general, people are saying they're going to be— their budget is
- 8:31down, but they also are recognizing that things are going to
- 8:35cost more. So there's a bit of a, I'm not going to likely get as
- 8:38much for my money this year, so I need to be more
- 8:42careful and thoughtful about where I'm spending it, as we had talked about
- 8:45before. So they're telling us they're still planning on spending in the same
- 8:49categories, that hasn't changed, but less in each one. And especially
- 8:54in technology, beauty, and home, they're pulling back. The winners are the
- 8:57ones that are really driving some of that emotional attachment,
- 9:01so, or connection. So think about people are passionate
- 9:05about or where they're big fans. So when we think about gaming as an
- 9:09example, you know, we've got a huge game launch in Grand Theft Auto,
- 9:13that could be a big gifting moment or the holiday or toys.
- 9:17We expect that people are saying that they're going to continue to
- 9:21invest in that as a gift-giving moment, which is the same for most
- 9:25of the holidays. But where we're seeing— where we believe there will be big pickups
- 9:29will be in things like continued in squishies and LEGO and Pokémon
- 9:33and some of those big franchises that have really been successful
- 9:36throughout the year. They're aging up in toys too, right? Exactly.
- 9:40Exactly. And then I think there is this theme about gifts that,
- 9:44you know, say maybe a little bit more about who you are. So think
- 9:48about jewelry, fragrance, you know, some of those traditional categories,
- 9:52but also apparel, footwear where, you know, it gives people
- 9:56a bit of their own style, lifestyle, and those typically
- 10:00do well. I was at a dinner the other night and everyone was going on
- 10:03about the mahjong gifts that they're going to be giving for other people. Super anecdotal,
- 10:06but that really ties into they want to host parties.
- 10:10So that ties into it. They want a certain game. When we're talking to our
- 10:14gift experts and our industry experts on their gifting big
- 10:18buys, you know, a lot of the trends of people wanting to
- 10:22unplug and be more analog or be more nostalgic and
- 10:26host more things connected at home versus, you know,
- 10:29and create those environments for those connections, those are also
- 10:33the categories that are going to be big. So in your point of toys for
- 10:35sure and gaming, but also in small appliances,
- 10:39Right? Where, hey, I'm going to use this slushie maker or ice cream maker because
- 10:43I'm going to host a party or bread maker. So we're anticipating those to be
- 10:47big wins as well. And I love that you can get these, you can discover
- 10:50these through scrolling through any kind of e-commerce. We want to do
- 10:54the grandma hobbies and do all the fun things at home, but we're finding out
- 10:57about them and talking about it and sometimes purchasing them. So what
- 11:02findings from this year's intentions report maybe surprised you a little
- 11:06bit, Kira? You know, I kind of anticipated people feeling
- 11:11worse about the economy just given what we've been tracking.
- 11:14But I think that one of the big surprises was, of course, people feel worse,
- 11:19but they're, you know, they're recognizing the
- 11:22bump in pricing and what that means. And so they are actively
- 11:26budgeting more and being able to kind of push
- 11:30a little bit on their choices earlier in the year so that
- 11:34they can keep that hole. And I think I was anticipating maybe people being
- 11:38a bit like pulling back a little bit more than what they're maybe telling us.
- 11:42Well, and that kind of shows, so overall we're expecting flat
- 11:46to a slight elevated. What are, what are overall, are things just kind of flat?
- 11:50What does that mean for, you know, the— we're trying to project, well, it,
- 11:53it's a bit of an uncertain scenario. So we have a bit of a wide
- 11:56range of, you know, down 1%, up maybe plus 2.5%.
- 12:02And the reason we have it that way is because it really is gonna be
- 12:06dependent on a couple of the other factors we can't control. So for example,
- 12:10If gas prices go down in the near term, then maybe people
- 12:14feel a little bit more comfortable being able to, you know,
- 12:17spend a little bit more. So there's kind of these other scenarios that are going
- 12:20on, but I think fundamentally it's gonna be a pretty moderate
- 12:24at best holiday season versus, you know, versus last year.
- 12:28And that is kind of a trend we've seen over the past several years.
- 12:31But there's growth to be found, like to your point, there's growth and opportunities to
- 12:35be found. Yeah, exactly. Across quite a few segments.
- 12:38And just on your, your question on what surprised me, I think the other
- 12:42thing that was interesting in the results of the survey was when we talked
- 12:46to folks about what is it that's compelling them to buy something,
- 12:50you know, what about their experiences? So we talked about things
- 12:53like, well, is it the product or is it the brand? And especially in the
- 12:57social media environment, like why, what's going to get you to make a move
- 13:00to convert? And what we heard from folks is that people are going
- 13:04to like are much more oriented toward buying the thing versus
- 13:08buying the brand. And so talking about a hero
- 13:12SKU or having the details of a particular product is what is going
- 13:15to, you know, make people feel excited versus like a whole SKU
- 13:20or set of SKUs or a broader brand message. And so,
- 13:23you know, how do you think about that coming to life in retailers
- 13:27and the choices and brands and the choices that they're making? And do you have
- 13:31any other advice for retailers and brands right now? I mean, they're, they're, they're in
- 13:34the thick of it, right? And maybe we don't have as much time to— we
- 13:36don't have a lot of time to pivot. But if there is some advice,
- 13:39you know, right when we're in the thick of it, what would it be?
- 13:41You know, I first— I mean, let's be realistic. I think that's my
- 13:45first advice. You know, if the season actually is in that range of
- 13:49-1 to 2.5 up, you know, a good season is really going to
- 13:53mean winning bigger share of a wallet that's not growing very fast. And so that's
- 13:57a tough situation to be in, right? So what are the real moments where you
- 14:00can make that come to life? I think first and foremost is,
- 14:03you know, how do you make sure you're showing up in the places
- 14:07where consumers are in the moments that they're excited?
- 14:10Consumers told us that they've already started shopping, you know,
- 14:13shopping early. Now, there's always a bit of a tricky moment,
- 14:17right, where people say, I'm going to get everything done before,
- 14:21you know, or by Black Friday. And then the reality is everybody
- 14:25goes last in shopping. So you have to take that with a bit of a
- 14:27grain of salt. But I think really the message is making sure you're showing up
- 14:31in those moments with the right offer. And making that value
- 14:35impossible to miss because people overall are telling us
- 14:40that they are not finding as good of deals as previous years. They're not feeling
- 14:43as compelled. A 10 to 20% discount isn't
- 14:47enough to make me make a choice. I'll just wait. And so how are
- 14:51you making sure you've got the right value proposition in those right moments to compel?
- 14:55And then I think we're like really understanding where
- 14:59people are looking for items in their discovery process
- 15:03as we see more and more discovery getting pushed into social media
- 15:07and into AI. And in a world where, you know, you're typing in
- 15:10your, your person that you're shopping for and their likes and dislikes,
- 15:14and you're asking a ChatGPT or a Gemini or a Claude to help you,
- 15:18if you as a brand don't show up in those moments, you are not going
- 15:22to be considered. And so how do you make sure you're there? And then
- 15:26I think the last thing is, you know, especially to protect that finish
- 15:30line, Because we know that there will be some last-minute
- 15:34shoppers, how do you make things easy? You know,
- 15:36buy online, pick up in store, partnerships with delivery aggregators,
- 15:41gift card incentives, you know, clear delivery dates
- 15:45and really making people feel confident that when they purchase with you, they're going to
- 15:48get the stuff that they need when they need it, I think will be critical.
- 15:52That's a great point. I've been out there so late that the Valentine's Day stuff
- 15:56is out. So That's like every year for
- 16:00me, Lynn. That's every year. Don't worry. But that leads us to another point,
- 16:03I guess, too, Kira, is that we see all these micro holidays doing well.
- 16:07So, you know, right on the heels of this, we've got Valentine's Day,
- 16:10we have the big game, we've got all these little March Madness. So there are
- 16:14other opportunities throughout the year to engage these consumers that are looking for
- 16:18these moments, that are looking for the joy all year round.
- 16:21Absolutely. Okay. So we like to end these podcasts with a little fun
- 16:25question. So my question to you is, have you already shop?
- 16:29Have you bought something from a brand that maybe you had
- 16:33never even heard of before for somebody? So I have to admit,
- 16:37I am behind on my holiday shopping. I'm gonna be
- 16:41real honest with you, but I will tell you that I am in that camp
- 16:45of relying on social and e-commerce to help me with my discovery. And actually
- 16:49recently I was looking for ski gear for my kids
- 16:53for the holiday as a gift because where, you know, we're kind of my— we're
- 16:57trying to move in that direction as a family. In that process,
- 17:01I was prompted for a particular set of needs
- 17:05and I got introduced to a new website that I had never seen
- 17:09before and basically went and scrolled and was looking and kind of put a basket
- 17:13together in that new world. And, you know, I think that is a trend
- 17:17that we're seeing now much more regularly with the shoppers and consumers that we're
- 17:21interacting with, meaning that discovery is going, you know, much more
- 17:25through social, much more through an agenda Now,
- 17:28I will say I still love going into certain
- 17:32stores for all of the pageantry of holidays. I celebrate Christmas,
- 17:35so I love when things are decorated, when we've
- 17:38got all of the rigmarole, as you might think. And I grew up outside
- 17:43of Chicago. I remember every year we used to go to the Walnut Room in
- 17:46Marshall Fields, for those of you that are familiar. And it was just so special
- 17:50and so unique. And then obviously, we walked around the store. It's now a Macy's,
- 17:53but you can still do that. And so I value that really.
- 17:56Good in-store environment where it's exciting and
- 18:00it allows me to create those memories too for my family.
- 18:03And so I will say that I plan on doing that
- 18:07still, even if a lot of my shopping will happen through more digital
- 18:10channels. And that brings it all back to meaning. That's what it's all about,
- 18:14right? And I tell you, I'm planning to go to the Walnut Room this year
- 18:17too. I try to get there every year. So I have to get that
- 18:21little snowman sundae and then— And then they give you the— nowadays they didn't
- 18:24do it. Before, but they give you the souvenir cup.
- 18:28Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's half the fun. That's half the fun.
- 18:32Well, thank you so much for joining us. I love talking about this
- 18:36and we're going to keep talking about holidays, you know, throughout the year, the other
- 18:39micro holidays. But it's just a treasure trove of information. So thank you.
- 18:43Absolutely. Thanks for having me. And join us next time throughout the year as we
- 18:47welcome executives and thought leaders who are going to provide a 360-degree view of today's
- 18:51ever-evolving marketplace and along the way underscore the power of collaboration
- 18:55in our shared journeys. If you have any feedback or idea for future podcasts,
- 18:59we really want to hear from you. So feel free to email us at newsroom@cirkana.com.
- 19:04Thanks for listening. Let's keep unpacking, and in this case, unwrapping what's