Latest / Bitcoin And | Bitcoin & Economic News / WTF is Nostr | Guest Appearance on TSPC
Transcript
- 0:02From the Bitcoin and archive.
- 0:05Here's a replay from the broader Bitcoin and stack.
- 0:09Sometimes
- 0:09that means a past episode,
- 0:11sometimes an interview,
- 0:13and sometimes a guest appearance from another show.
- 0:16The headlines may have moved on, but the Bitcoin signal, market context,
- 0:21and practical lessons
- 0:22still hold up. If it's useful,
- 0:25it belongs back in the feed.
- 0:27Here's today's selection from the Bitcoin and archive.
- 0:32There's
- 0:33a better way to do this.
- 0:39Let me
- 0:52Well, hi, folks. This is Jack Spirico with another edition of the Survival Podcast. As always, one man's view of the changing world, the changing times, and the things we can all do to live a better life if times get tough or even if they don't. Today is Thursday, 03/09/2023.
- 1:07This is episode 3,264
- 1:10of the Survival Podcast. And while we won't really talk a lot about Bitcoin today,
- 1:16we're actually gonna be talking about something called Noster. The two subjects are highly related, so I am going to also push this out onto the Bitcoin Breakout Feed. Bitcoin Breakout episode 36
- 1:27and Survival Podcast episode
- 1:303,264
- 1:31at the same time. I have a gentleman coming on. He's the host of a podcast
- 1:37called the Bitcoin End Podcast,
- 1:40and his name is David Bennett. He's a really cool guy, and he is actually the person who originally
- 1:46told me about podcasting two point zero. I didn't get on it right away or anything, but he was the first person I ever heard about it from.
- 1:53And
- 1:54he reached out to me when I said I was looking for somebody to come on and talk about Noster.
- 1:58Noster is a way of disseminating
- 2:00and sharing information.
- 2:02I'll leave it at that and we'll let David explain it deeper in just a moment. Before I bring him on, let's go ahead and hear from our two sponsors of the day. Sponsor day number one today is Start9.
- 2:14You're going to hear a little bit about Start9 and eight because you can actually run a Nostril Relay
- 2:19on your Start9 server. You can run a Bitcoin node. You can run a Bitcoin Lightning node.
- 2:24You can host your own images. You can run your own end to end
- 2:28fully encrypted
- 2:29military grade, fully encrypted chat services.
- 2:33You can act as a hub for your community, your family, etc. You can control your data. You can 100%
- 2:41control your data. Your own password management. Access your files from anywhere in the world with no third party, nobody in between
- 2:48running your own services on your own server.
- 2:52It's really not that hard. You need to get over to start9.com
- 2:55and learn more about them today. Remember, if you're an MSB member, get 9% off all purchases at start9.com.
- 3:03If you're switched on and using that Fold card,
- 3:05you can buy yourself a gift card inside the Fold app and you can use that for an even greater discount and stack the two together with Start Nine
- 3:13products.
- 3:14Next up today
- 3:17is
- 3:18who is this? Ridgewallet.com.
- 3:19I love the Ridge Wallet. I've been carrying it now for about five years. Makes my life a heck of a lot easier to keep all my ID cards,
- 3:27my credit cards, things like that. All those things that have those little RFID tags in them that people can actually steal information off of, because I don't know if you know that, but they can.
- 3:35When they're encased in titanium, not so easy to do anymore. Plus, it's a minimalist
- 3:40wallet. It just really works better. I've been doing that again five years. I've put my billfold away. I've never gone back to it ever again. I probably never will.
- 3:49And also Ridge has come up with a ton,
- 3:52I mean just a ton of really cool EDC items. You can learn more at ridge.com.
- 3:57Next up, real quick before we get started, I also wanted to let you know or kind of remind you
- 4:02about the Self Reliance Festival in Camden, Tennessee.
- 4:06I've got a post out about it today called Find Your Tribe
- 4:09telling you about how there's so much cool stuff going on up there. You really want to get to the Self Reliance Festival if there's any way that you can. Nicole Sauce and John Willis have put together a great event up there once again March 2526.
- 4:23But the big thing is if you can't get there, next best thing is a virtual pass.
- 4:28You can actually get a virtual ticket to watch all the presentations virtually as well. And you can learn all about that at survivalpodcast.com.
- 4:37It'll be the post right underneath
- 4:41the episode that you're about to hear. And with that, let's drop into the live stream with David Bennett
- 4:48and find out what the F is an oster. And we are live. Welcome folks to episode three thousand two and sixty four of the survival podcast. I believe it is
- 4:5837 or 36 of the Bitcoin breakout. I'm not sure. Don't hold me to that. This has been a discombobulated
- 5:04morning,
- 5:05and somehow our guests managed to be here on time anyway even though I didn't send them to the freaking invite
- 5:09link,
- 5:11until about two seconds before it's supposed to go live. So David, man, thanks for being with us today.
- 5:15You're welcome. Thanks for having me, Jack. I appreciate it. I'm really excited about this. We're gonna talk about Noster today,
- 5:22and this will be an unusual
- 5:24type of episode for me.
- 5:26Generally, when I hear about something new and it interests me, I learn as much as I can about it. I talk about it, then I bring somebody on to talk about it further.
- 5:33I don't know Jack
- 5:35about Noster, and I kind of did that on purpose because I feel like there's some technical stuff here.
- 5:41Instead of pretending to be ignorant, I figured I would just be ignorant for a
- 5:46a chase so that I could ask questions that truly are like, I don't get it questions,
- 5:52instead of feigning that. So this will be kind of fun for me to be completely out of my
- 5:57of my league here, in talking about this.
- 6:00But before we dig into Nostrad, can you tell us a little bit about David Bennett, man? Who's David Bennett? What was your I know you're a podcaster now, but what was, like, your professional life in the past, and what led you to to Bitcoin and and and and things related to blockchain and things like Nostrad?
- 6:16Well, the last
- 6:17job that
- 6:19I had
- 6:20was
- 6:23was the lead administrator for the Texas Tech University
- 6:26Libraries,
- 6:27three d animation studio, digital media studio,
- 6:31and I did that for ten years. And
- 6:35the thing about working for the state
- 6:38is that no matter
- 6:40what
- 6:42is going on, you always find yourself with inordinate
- 6:45amounts of time
- 6:47that you're not doing anything,
- 6:50which really sucks.
- 6:51So,
- 6:53you know, while you could it was actually partially our own fault. We built such a good studio. We had such good equipment. Our licensing was for the software was
- 7:04really good.
- 7:06It was a well oiled machine, man.
- 7:08Know, there, you know, therefore
- 7:11we find, you know, we found ourselves with lots of time.
- 7:14So I just, I ended up started
- 7:17watching stuff about regenerative agriculture.
- 7:20Okay. And
- 7:22I think I got into it through
- 7:25aquaponics.
- 7:26And then that led to, it's a rabbit hole like everything else, right? Yeah. And that led to one thing led to another and that led to Diego Footer.
- 7:35And that led to Permaculture Voices three, which is where I first met you in person.
- 7:40And then
- 7:42I started listening to you. I want to say you were still
- 7:46doing that thing with your old intern.
- 7:50Josiah?
- 7:51Yeah. I
- 7:52think.
- 7:54And then
- 7:55I started listening to you and you started beating me around the head and shoulders about Bitcoin.
- 8:00And
- 8:01we come to 2015.
- 8:03I started working in 2009 at tech
- 8:06and I did other things before that, but this is really
- 8:10the point where my life kind of shifted was at during this job.
- 8:14So I bought my first Bitcoin
- 8:16at $250
- 8:18sometime in the summer, in late summer of twenty fifteen.
- 8:22The first thing I did after that was send you 0.2 Bitcoin for your member service brigade.
- 8:27And that was the most expensive
- 8:29subscription
- 8:31I've ever bought in my entire life. Of course, at the time it was
- 8:35$50.
- 8:37Yep. Not so
- 8:39anymore.
- 8:40And once you go down the Bitcoin rabbit hole,
- 8:44everything changes
- 8:45and start realizing things. And the thing that I realized the most is just how misled
- 8:53I've been
- 8:54throughout my entire life and the further down the rabbit hole I got, I realized that my dad and my mother had been misled for their entire lives and it was probably at one point or another, my granddad probably knew the actual truth,
- 9:09but
- 9:09we find ourselves here in clown world.
- 9:12And
- 9:14it's just, it's a series of mistruths. It's a series of being misled
- 9:18about everything, about money, about food, about banking, about
- 9:22how you're too stupid to understand financial stuff.
- 9:26And it's like, it's kind of designed that way. And I get all of this
- 9:31through
- 9:32once you're down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, that's it. You're
- 9:36done for life. Everything that you left
- 9:39is sort of the only way that I can put it.
- 9:42And then everything that comes along the way,
- 9:46everything that comes down the pipe for Bitcoin
- 9:49is the only things that I'm interested in and this leads us to Noster.
- 9:53Gotcha. Gotcha.
- 9:55And then don't feel bad about paying 0.2 Bitcoin for MSD membership. It's not the one back there, but if you ever want to see, I guess as of today, about a $24,000
- 10:04shotgun, I can show you one.
- 10:06Because I bought a Yeah. A Browning Auto a five prewar
- 10:11Belgian made. It's worth about $1,500
- 10:14for, like, $600.
- 10:16Yeah. With a Bitcoin when Bitcoin was right at $600.
- 10:19And so you can look at it as I paid 600 for it. You can look at it as well right now, I paid 23,000
- 10:26something for it, or you can look at it that I paid whatever the all time high has been because I could've you know? And I don't think we should get upset over that with Bitcoin. It's just I'm now of the mind that every time I ever spent a Bitcoin, I wish I didn't.
- 10:40And every time I didn't buy a Bitcoin, I wish I did.
- 10:43So so I've I've kinda moved to where if I spend Bitcoin, I spend dollars into Bitcoin. I don't once it goes into my stack, it's forever. It's never going anywhere.
- 10:53You know, when they always talk about, you know, x amount of Bitcoin has not moved in ten years, that's me. Yeah.
- 10:59Yeah. And and to be clear, I don't actually feel bad about that point two Bitcoin at all. It is a reminder to me. Yeah. But that's all it is. It's a reminder that I have to, I really got to think,
- 11:11do I really wanna do this?
- 11:13You know? Yeah. And before
- 11:15it was like, no, you just
- 11:17buy it. You know, it's just this money that somehow or another pours out of the sky.
- 11:21Magically, don't really know
- 11:24where the well, I'm thinking about the US dollar is like, yeah, you go work for it and stuff, but it just magically appears and it's magically fungible and it's magically all this stuff.
- 11:34I
- 11:36didn't really start
- 11:37really hammering my own brain about, are you sure you want this? What
- 11:42is this thing that you buy with this value that is your time on this planet
- 11:47gonna look like in three months? You know, that's the thing and it's the big thing for people younger than us.
- 11:53A lot of these people in their twenties is the first time they ever thought about not spending money they had before.
- 11:58Yeah. Like ever in their life where they actually went, wait a minute, if I spend this, I don't have it anymore. I think that's one of many reasons the establishment hates it, but let's turn the corner to Noster because even the folks that tune into this today, they're like, More Bitcoin on the Survival Podcast.
- 12:13Look, we're talking about Noster today, and it'd be good if you involved Bitcoin with it, but what we're really talking about, from my understanding, is a platform for freedom of communications and sharing of information.
- 12:25That's about as much as I know.
- 12:28I know one other thing, and maybe we'll talk about that as we get through this today, but that's about all I know at this point. So what
- 12:36the F
- 12:37is Noster in the first place? Because when I try to use it to look stuff up and say, well tell me about Noster, most I get stuff about Nostradamus,
- 12:45and I know that's not it.
- 12:47I even tried to get chat AI to make me some copy for today, and it kept writing stuff about Nostradamus.
- 12:53Yeah. I
- 12:57have
- 12:58I have had the same problem that you may be experiencing
- 13:02with trying to figure out what the hell Noster is.
- 13:05Listened and I listened to podcasts. I purposely found podcasts.
- 13:09Yeah. You know, that's like that had somebody that's talking about Noster.
- 13:13And,
- 13:13you know, I'd listen to a one hour podcast and I would, I still am no closer to what the hell this is than I was before, you know, an hour ago.
- 13:23And that always really bugged me. So
- 13:26I had a guy that has built a client for Noster on my podcast and I'll
- 13:34email you that link at one point or another so that if you want to put it in show notes, can. And we talked extensively about it and I told him the same thing. I'm like, I gotta figure out what this is
- 13:44because
- 13:46I wanna figure out what it is during that interview.
- 13:50Like
- 13:51I didn't know anything
- 13:53because once I finally figured it out, a lot of stuff clicked and I'm kinda hoping that that's what we do here. So I just kinda want to start with what NOSTR actually stands for because That it's a would be great.
- 14:06It's
- 14:08n o s t r stands for notes
- 14:11and other stuff
- 14:13transmitted by relays.
- 14:16Okay. And
- 14:17once we get through this, I think that will make a lot more sense. It already made more sense to me right there. Right. Because I heard the relays and now that all starts to connect.
- 14:28Okay. So
- 14:29at the at the base level,
- 14:32the simplest thing that I can say what Noster is thinking of notes and other stuff is that it's a network communications
- 14:39protocol.
- 14:40It's not a computer program.
- 14:43It's not, I mean, it has to be implemented in some kind of language at one point. Sure. But let me illustrate what I mean. I asked
- 14:50on Noster,
- 14:53I go, can somebody tell me what computer language this is written in? And the answer was, it's written in English
- 15:00because it's a protocol.
- 15:03Can tell you my protocol. Wake up,
- 15:05I go drink coffee,
- 15:08I sit down with my kids, I take my kids to school.
- 15:11That's a protocol.
- 15:13And that's a Monday through Friday protocol.
- 15:16I can implement that in whatever language that I want, but essentially it's language free. It's just describing what needs to happen for other things to happen. That's the protocol. So TCP
- 15:28is a protocol
- 15:29and it gets implemented in whatever
- 15:32language is building utility
- 15:34that uses TCP IP. Yes. And and the other well known protocols are the same way. SMTP,
- 15:41FTP,
- 15:43HTTP. HTTP.
- 15:44All these are just nothing but protocols. Okay. We but we have to be able to interact with those protocols.
- 15:50And that's where the client comes in. Right? So
- 15:57let me before I even talk about a client, I wanna talk about the note part of notes and other stuff transmitted by relays.
- 16:07A note is like, let's say you jump on Twitter and you write a tweet
- 16:13in Nostrad that sort of what we call a note. That's
- 16:17all that is. It's just like a piece of text or
- 16:20maybe I send a link out over the protocol,
- 16:24something like that.
- 16:26That's all a note is.
- 16:28But the note is part of slightly larger thing in protocol
- 16:33called an event.
- 16:35And the event
- 16:37is really lightweight and lightweight is
- 16:40what is absolutely
- 16:42essential and why I'm so mind blown about this entire protocol in the first place. It weighs
- 16:49almost nothing as far as kilobytes or bytes or megabytes. It's like, it's very, very lightweight.
- 16:55So there's
- 16:57only six
- 16:59parts
- 17:00of
- 17:01an event that actually have to be satisfied for it to be recognized by the protocol and sent to wherever it's gonna be sent to. And that's the ID number
- 17:10of
- 17:11the actual note or the event itself. So that's like,
- 17:15I write two notes,
- 17:17one is
- 17:19one ID, the other one has completely different ID. That's how you keep them separate. Right? There's a kind,
- 17:25which is like kind one or kind two or kind three.
- 17:29Kind one is where you're just sending a simple text.
- 17:33It's just that simple. It's just like it tells the protocol, okay, you're gonna be handling
- 17:39only text. That's a kind one.
- 17:41Right?
- 17:42And then there's a pub key. Okay? Very much like Bitcoin. In fact, it's exactly like Bitcoin.
- 17:50My pub key identifies
- 17:51me.
- 17:53That's how you know it came from me because it's got my pub key in it. So it's like, oh, well this came from David.
- 18:00And then there's a timestamp
- 18:02and then there's the content.
- 18:04Okay. Like, this is going to work or hijack
- 18:08or whatever as the text.
- 18:10And then there's tags.
- 18:12There can either be zero tags like, I don't know, like a regular tag, like hashtag
- 18:18survival podcast. Okay. Something like that. But the big one the big one that makes that makes everything work is the signature.
- 18:27The signature is your private key.
- 18:30It's the exact same.
- 18:32In fact,
- 18:35it's ECDSA,
- 18:37it's Elliptic Curve. It's the way Bitcoin keys are generated. When you have a Bitcoin wallet
- 18:42and you generate a private key,
- 18:45it's done the exact same way in Noster because My the private key says I am Jack.
- 18:50And that way anybody can see it verify And
- 18:53my private key lets information be published as Jack.
- 18:58Yes. Okay.
- 18:59And that comes in
- 19:02handy later. We'll talk about it because things can get a little dicey when we start thinking about it, but that's essentially an event. If I have those six pieces of information,
- 19:11all
- 19:12of a sudden that is a valid event type for Noster.
- 19:17The protocol says, I understand what this is. Now I can do shit with it. So
- 19:23that's where we are on just the protocol,
- 19:26but none of that makes sense. And this is where I kept getting tripped up when I was trying to figure out what Noster was.
- 19:32I need a client
- 19:34to be able to interface
- 19:36with the protocol
- 19:37because the protocol by itself,
- 19:40I can't really interface with it. I need a client.
- 19:43And like Twitter is a client for the Twitter protocol.
- 19:47That's the interface.
- 19:48So that's the other thing I think I know. So you tell me if I know this right or if I'm confused.
- 19:54Yeah. Sure. So let's compare it to, like, a Twitter or a Miwi or a Facebook or anything like that. These are all proprietary
- 20:01protocols and proprietary
- 20:03applications or platforms.
- 20:05Yes. They need their language to do their thing their way,
- 20:10where Nostr is open so I could create a client to utilize it.
- 20:16And you could be on client a, and I could be on client b, and we would still be able to see each other's stuff or no?
- 20:23Yes.
- 20:25Or maybe.
- 20:27Well, let's talk about what you just said about the proprietariness
- 20:32all these
- 20:33things.
- 20:34Is that these are the walled gardens that we're talking about. Yeah, Instagram,
- 20:38face bag, Twitter,
- 20:40LinkedIn,
- 20:41YouTube,
- 20:42it's a protocol
- 20:44plus the client,
- 20:46but there's something more insidious, right?
- 20:48The ID that you use to sign in is also proprietary
- 20:53and it ain't owned by you.
- 20:55It's owned by them. So those three things we talk about, oh, it's a protocol and then there's the client. And we always leave off the fact that your identity
- 21:04to interact with those systems is also proprietary
- 21:07owned by
- 21:09Facebag,
- 21:10Twitter,
- 21:11YouTube,
- 21:12and they have control as to whether or not your ID is valid or not.
- 21:17They can kick you off at any time, they can suspend you at any time, they can black hole your ass at any time and it's all up to them because
- 21:27your ID
- 21:28is not yours,
- 21:30it's theirs.
- 21:31That's a problem. And when you get all three of those things taken together,
- 21:35that's where you get things like Doctor. Malone just disappearing off of Twitter. Absolutely.
- 21:40That's
- 21:41where you get like, you didn't use Twitter from what I understand you saying in a couple of your podcasts. Haven't you didn't use Twitter for a long time because you were just in a black hole. You're shadowbanned. Shadowbanned. I was there. You could look for me and find me, but Right. You followed me, you saw almost nothing that I published, and it was just
- 21:58it wasn't
- 21:59like, I left Facebook out of sheer anger.
- 22:02I left Twitter during that time out of completely there's no reason for me to do this. Yeah. Like, there's nothing in return, so why would I spend one second a day doing it? And, like, Elon day came and all of a sudden everybody saw me again. Yeah.
- 22:17You could just easily
- 22:19go the other way, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. And I, you know, and I remember because I was on Twitter, I started my Twitter account in 2011.
- 22:29Yeah. I didn't really start using it until,
- 22:32I don't know, 2014,
- 22:352015.
- 22:36And all that time,
- 22:39I was like, well, 2013,
- 22:42I guess is when I pretty, it was either twenty twelve, thirteen when I found you through Diego Footer.
- 22:47Yeah. And I started getting on Twitter, from, you know, let's say 2015 to, you know, up until the day I got banned
- 22:56several times,
- 22:58I never saw a thing from you. I even followed you. I
- 23:03went and searched for the survival pod and found it and followed it and I still got, I got Jack. That's what I got. Yeah, not Jack. I
- 23:13got not Jack. That's exactly Yeah, you got not Jack. Okay. So that's the problem with the open or rather the walled gardens is they own those three things, the protocol, the client that you use
- 23:24and your ID.
- 23:26Right? So
- 23:27the open gardens are stuff like
- 23:30the Fettyverse.
- 23:31Are you familiar with that at all? No. You know, have you heard of Mastodon?
- 23:35Yes.
- 23:36Okay. That's a client
- 23:38that plugs Federated. In
- 23:40Okay. Yeah. Okay.
- 23:41And they have their own protocol, but it's kinda open,
- 23:46but it's kind of boring as hell because
- 23:48of various reasons. And we're not here to talk about that, but that's one of the more open gardens.
- 23:54FTP,
- 23:55file transfer protocol, which is yet another network communication protocol is kind of, you can kind of look at that as an open garden, right? There's nobody that really controls your ID. And even if they did,
- 24:06you could just get another, you gen up another ID off of another client. So that's open, right? That's an open garden.
- 24:12And then we have Noster,
- 24:14right? And in Noster,
- 24:16the protocol is open sourced,
- 24:19okay? So anybody can copy it from the GitHub,
- 24:22anybody can make changes to it, anybody can help, you know, the original implementation
- 24:27of Noster
- 24:28by
- 24:29writing code forward if they want,
- 24:32it doesn't matter because it's free and open source software.
- 24:35And I think it's under an MIT open source software licensing,
- 24:40anybody can use it. And I think you can make money from it too if you want.
- 24:46However you wanna do it, right?
- 24:53So we come to the protocol, the protocols open
- 24:56all, and then there's the clients that come in. And that again, what we're talking about is our
- 25:02window
- 25:03into
- 25:04what's going on in the Nostril network. And without that window, it becomes very difficult to interact with it. And the more easy that user experience that the client provides, because that's what a client does. Provides you the user with an experience.
- 25:22How do I experience Nostrad the network? I do it
- 25:26through these clients. And I'll just name a couple in case people are, like, you know, wanting to know. I use Domus on iOS.
- 25:34Nostradamus.
- 25:36Okay. D a m a s? Yeah. D a m u s. Yeah. D a m u s. Yeah. That's for
- 25:42for
- 25:43Apple stuff like iOS, MacBook,
- 25:46stuff like that. If you're on Android,
- 25:48Amethyst,
- 25:50that's another one for mobile.
- 25:53And then there's all the web clients
- 25:56and there's,
- 25:57God, I mean, there's so many web clients, we'll get into that one later, but that client again provides you the nice little framed window that allows you to open the window and lean out and smell the fresh air or the stank of somebody's
- 26:13malicious crap because you get all of it. You gotta filter yourself. There's no algorithm that's gonna protect your little baby feelings.
- 26:21You're gonna see stuff
- 26:23that you don't wanna see and you have to make your choices from there on because Elon Musk can't step in and say, yeah, I'm gonna ban your
- 26:33public key from every client, from every protocol implementation,
- 26:38from blah.
- 26:40It's just not happening.
- 26:42It's just not, right?
- 26:44This all boils down
- 26:46to the key pairs.
- 26:50The key pair, like I said, is elliptic curve,
- 26:54digital signal or signature algorithm or ECDSA.
- 26:58It is
- 26:59exactly the same as if I buy a cold card wallet from CoinKite
- 27:05and it comes in the mail
- 27:06and I set it up and I go, I need a new private key. It will generate that key.
- 27:12That is my ability to sign a message
- 27:16or in the case of Bitcoin, sign a transaction that makes it valid. And let's hold there for just a second so that nobody gets upset about big giant words they don't understand. Right. If you're using, let's say, a Bitcoin wallet right now, you're doing this even though you don't know you're doing this. Yes. A wallet acts as the client for you is what he's saying,
- 27:37and so you don't have to he he's using this so that it's accurate, and then if you wanna fully understand it, you can. But
- 27:44when you have these clients,
- 27:46they're creating Think of it like your GUI, your graphic user interface,
- 27:51that you don't have to go in because you could manually code every single thing you wanted to do and send it one at a time.
- 27:58Very few people would do that, and it would suck. Somebody builds a client that automates a lot of this for you, so you don't necessarily Just
- 28:06like most people that send email every day
- 28:09or use the internet every day don't know what TCP IP is,
- 28:13or they don't know what HTTP
- 28:16is when they're using it. You're using it all the time. So you don't necessarily have to understand these definitions to use this
- 28:23tool to share information
- 28:25or to gather information,
- 28:27which probably is actually more important.
- 28:29Yeah, that's
- 28:31exactly right. So just that, you know,
- 28:35that private key aspect,
- 28:38as we go back to Noster,
- 28:40that allows me to sign my events.
- 28:43Without that key,
- 28:44I'm not sending anything.
- 28:46I mean, and if somebody has sent me a direct message
- 28:49in Nostr,
- 28:51since that's end to end encrypted,
- 28:53I need my private key to decrypt that direct message. If I don't have my private key, I can't see the direct message. So, and a direct message here is exactly like it is in Twitter, except I'm not sure if Twitter is encrypted.
- 29:07I doubt it very seriously,
- 29:09but
- 29:10the public key, can think of that as your login
- 29:14and your identity so people can find you.
- 29:17Without that public key, you can't find me on Nostr. I gotta actually give it to you. So
- 29:25here's
- 29:26the catch.
- 29:27Like
- 29:31in the thing that I sent you when I was filling out your form, I think I titled it, you know,
- 29:36WTF is an oster and how it works and sometimes how it doesn't. This
- 29:43is one of the things where
- 29:45you gotta understand something about this.
- 29:48So let's
- 29:50say Jack gives me his private key or no, I mean his public key. Sorry. Don't do that. Don't give me your private key ever, ever, ever, ever. Treat it like a Bitcoin private key. You don't wanna do that. Right. Like I emailed Jack and I say, I'm trying to find you on Noster. Can you send me your public key through email? Nobody cares. It's a public key. Sure. Right?
- 30:08But
- 30:09with that public key, not only can I find you when I'm logged in with my private keys on some client,
- 30:17right?
- 30:18You know, and I'm fully logged in as me, I can find you and I can follow your account and then I can go log out and then I can go
- 30:27log back in
- 30:29this time with your public key.
- 30:33I will never be able to sign an event, but I will see every single person that you follow,
- 30:38every person that follows you,
- 30:40every note that you sent,
- 30:43and
- 30:44every, you know, every like, every all of your followers and like, I can see everything you see exactly the way you see it except
- 30:53direct messages.
- 30:54Okay. Because that's end to end encrypted, I would have to have your private key to be able to decrypt it. But think about what that means.
- 31:04I mean, yes, you can do this in a way in like, well, you can do the same thing in Twitter,
- 31:11but this one is, I mean, this one, it just makes me, it gives me pause because I'm like, let's say I start following a whole bunch of really demented people
- 31:20that put out really demented stuff. And Jack just plugs my public key in and says, I want to see what David sees when he gets into his client. Oh my God. Yeah. I can't believe he's looking at this.
- 31:33So
- 31:34in a way that's sort of one of the things that kind of makes, you know, should make people think twice
- 31:41before,
- 31:42you know, like,
- 31:44I mean, I don't want I'm not bagging on Noster. I'm just saying that this
- 31:48is the way it is. This is warts and all. And that's a pretty big wart because it because what's different there is if you went to my Twitter account right now, you can see all my followers,
- 31:58but you don't see
- 32:01my feed from my vantage
- 32:03point. You would have to go through
- 32:06one at a time and see who those people were and what they were posting.
- 32:10Yes. So what you are saying is it would be like
- 32:14it would be like I don't wanna overstate this.
- 32:17It would be like running a screen capture video of me looking at my feed, except I'm not actually doing
- 32:23anything. Like, it's not like you would see that I was beginning to type a message and got rid of it, but everything that that came to me, you would see through my window.
- 32:33Exactly.
- 32:34So
- 32:36be it's one of those be aware things. Yeah. Right? I mean, you know, it's like, if you're like, you know, I don't know, goody two shoes and and whatever, who cares? But if you're like,
- 32:47let's say it's not even, let's not even say it's nefarious. Let's say that I log in with, I don't know, some
- 32:54Saudi Arabian activist pub keys and find out that this Saudi Arabian activist really hates her government,
- 33:01blah, blah, blah. Well,
- 33:03her government, if they know her public key can see all that crap.
- 33:07So
- 33:08understand
- 33:09that this is, we're at the very base of this protocol.
- 33:14I am absolutely certain that things will come
- 33:17up that will help the user not have that happen, but it ain't there yet.
- 33:25So that would be a good reason if unless you're like see, I'm a public facing brand. It doesn't do me any good to be on there anonymously.
- 33:32Right. It would probably make a lot of sense for the average user to not necess they just wants to
- 33:37but there's a I would say 90% of people that, let's say, use Twitter
- 33:42don't publish almost any content.
- 33:44They follow people, and they're mostly consumers. They may do a little sharing or whatnot, but mostly they're consumers.
- 33:52And and those people, even on Twitter, I kinda recommend just you don't need to necessarily be public about who you are
- 33:58because you're giving away information. There's kind of like a double edged sword. Like, if I don't do that, then I get nothing out of it. Right. Right. I'm not really on Twitter to find out that,
- 34:08you know, Coca Cola released a new formula or something. I really don't care about that. I'm there to promote myself. That's what I do. Right. But most people, that's not why they're there.
- 34:17Nope. They're there to
- 34:19consume
- 34:20and, and shitpost and
- 34:24give journalists hell about,
- 34:26well, I won't say the word because I guess this is going to YouTube. So I'm not going to say anything that's going to get you beat off, but you speak
- 34:34your mind, and that's what, know, pretty much I'm pretty sure that that's what got me kicked off of
- 34:38Twitter. Oh, I'm sure it did.
- 34:41So I think we've covered what a client is. A client is an app or a web interface that lets us look through the window and lets us connect to other people.
- 34:50So it's also decentralized communications.
- 34:53Let's talk a little bit about what it means because we throw that word around.
- 34:57And how
- 34:58does Noster meet the definition of decentralized?
- 35:02Well,
- 35:03really
- 35:04more about the relays and how, you know, the Noster protocol
- 35:09interacts with those and your private and public keys.
- 35:13It's kind of interesting.
- 35:17And this is, I guess what
- 35:20let's see here. I've I've I've you know, if I'm looking off in the distance is because I actually wrote down a wrote down some notes, like the prompts and stuff to figure out how to talk about this.
- 35:32It's decentralization.
- 35:34It's like, because I've got what does decentralized communications mean for the world.
- 35:40Let's just say, okay, I got my public key
- 35:44and
- 35:45I'm into Noster.
- 35:47How the hell do I get your note?
- 35:49Like when you send something out and I'm following your public key,
- 35:53how do I see it? And this goes back to the whole client protocol ID proprietary system, all that centralized,
- 36:00they have centralized computers at Twitter, it's fast.
- 36:04And everybody that's following, like if I'm following you and somebody else is following you on Twitter, we'll see the same messages at roughly the same time. And it's all great. Not so on Nostr
- 36:15because it's not centralized.
- 36:17Mhmm. I could like, right now, you have a StartNine
- 36:22unit. Right? Yep.
- 36:23Okay.
- 36:24When was the last time you updated the software?
- 36:29A couple weeks ago.
- 36:30Take
- 36:31a look if they have another update and like not now, but But they are updated.
- 36:37Like, I for running my Bitcoin full node, I use my node BTC
- 36:42and it's running on a Raspberry Pi
- 36:45and it's right over there.
- 36:47And
- 36:48all of a sudden, one day I updated it and lo and behold,
- 36:51they enabled
- 36:52me to have a Nostril Relay of my very own. Okay. That I can run on my Raspberry Pi.
- 36:59I can choose to do that. I don't know how to configure it. Okay. So that's the limits right now. I gotta go learn some shit before I can step
- 37:08into that and I'm not gonna do it just yet, but I can't. If I if I wanted to, and I'm thinking
- 37:13that Start Nine has a Nostril Relay, so you I think they do. I think they do, but I just haven't touched it until this interview. That was the point. Yeah.
- 37:22And I probably won't touch I probably won't be doing that for, you know, checking my own relay stuff for a services and technology god for all things TSP has spoken. Tom says
- 37:33Start Nine has a Noster Relay now. So the Okay. Got it. Okay.
- 37:38And there's there's more to come. So as you can see, this starts to get really integrated
- 37:45with Bitcoin.
- 37:46Right? But only because they're on they can live on the same platform and at the same interface. But the deal is is that
- 37:53I'm connected to, like, let's say, a Relay.
- 37:56Not a whole bunch of relays, we'll get into that yet, but one relay.
- 38:00And you're connected to that same relay.
- 38:03You can see my notes and I can see your notes,
- 38:06but I can't see the notes of somebody who's not connected to the relay and neither can you. Okay. Okay. So,
- 38:14yeah,
- 38:15again,
- 38:17this is where
- 38:18user experience
- 38:20kind of suffers.
- 38:22And for, and I I just have something to say for all the people that want what they've always had to be exactly the same on something different out of the box. Yeah. Stop it. Please stop it.
- 38:38I mean, I just,
- 38:39when did we Don't get think the Californian that moved to Idaho and said, we need a law about this. Don't do that shit.
- 38:45Yeah.
- 38:46Experience it, be part of it. Try to understand it while it's still young and fresh and
- 38:52growing.
- 38:53It's like, I don't want my children
- 38:56to be already grown up.
- 38:58I'm not gonna learn anything about my children if they're born with
- 39:03being 25 years old. Yeah. So please, please give the developers a chance, give the users a chance to get back to the developers,
- 39:13and
- 39:14together they build the thing that you eventually want, but it ain't gonna happen out of the box. And this is one of the ways that it does not happen out of the box.
- 39:23My user experience
- 39:25is completely dependent
- 39:27on the client that I use
- 39:29and the relays that my client are attached to, I can attach to more than one relay.
- 39:35If
- 39:36we are attached, like let's say, like right now, I think I've got 20 relays in my list, which is a little high.
- 39:43Lots of people are like, and the more relays,
- 39:46the more data stream that you've got. So
- 39:49you if you're connected to 30, you can heat your phone up.
- 39:53Just saying that's I mean, and I've you seen people get completely crushed on their monthly data plans because they just weren't
- 40:01understanding
- 40:02what was going on. I'm like, for each one of these relays, even if they're like 10 of the 10 of the 20 amps using,
- 40:10if a note is being sent by 10 different relays, but it's the exact same note. You're replicating it.
- 40:16You 10 times the data for one piece of information. Okay.
- 40:21So again,
- 40:22this is sort of where the UX
- 40:25suffers.
- 40:26I don't think it actually suffers. I think it's really
- 40:29interesting to watch this thing grow, but be that as it may, it is Probably a in time, I would guess clients will evolve start filtering that. Like, okay, you have this, you don't need it from these places, right? You know, or
- 40:43They already are, Jack. Okay. Right. Yeah. Yeah. So
- 40:47things things move pretty fast. So the but what I wanna really
- 40:51make clear is that,
- 40:53let's say you and I both use Domus,
- 40:56we're both on our iPhone. We're
- 40:59both connected to 20 clients.
- 41:0110 of those clients are the same
- 41:04and 10 clients for you are completely different than 10 clients from me. Okay.
- 41:08Our user experience and what we see and who we can see notes from
- 41:13will be completely different.
- 41:15Because you'll be getting notes from relays that I'm not connected to, and I'm getting notes from relays that you're not connected to. But for the 10 that we're both connected to, we're gonna get those notes.
- 41:27The deal is is that when you almost
- 41:32the
- 41:34older the relay and the best ping times and the most uptime
- 41:38tend to be the things that people really want to connect to.
- 41:42And you can find those through various tools. We'll hopefully get to that at the end, but
- 41:49chances are very good that I am connected
- 41:53to as many relays as most of the people that I follow are connected to.
- 41:58When I'm looking at it by myself, I just have my user experience,
- 42:02but your mileage may vary. And that's, again,
- 42:05that would be something where somebody might go, well,
- 42:09didn't you see John's note?
- 42:11And you say, well, no, I have no idea what the hell you're talking about.
- 42:16So there's friction.
- 42:18There could be friction there, especially if you're trying to coordinate,
- 42:21like, I don't know, a meetup or something like that, right? Okay, yeah. So there's
- 42:26enough friction there that can be kind of off putting. And again, I just ask people to be patient and understand that we're two years into this protocol. It's only two years old. Yeah, look at it, like compare it to lightning. So lightning was first proposed
- 42:41in 2015.
- 42:43And if I remember right, it was first implemented in like 2018.
- 42:47Yep.
- 42:48By
- 42:492019,
- 42:50all of the big block idiots were
- 42:53just saying how it sucked and it didn't work, and you had to run your own node and it would never work.
- 42:59And here we sit in 2023 and apps like Fountain are enabling people like me
- 43:04and yourself to receive literally thousands of transactions
- 43:10a day.
- 43:11Know, one sat or 10 sat at a shop and people streaming the stuff.
- 43:16And so that if you went back to 2019 and said, it'll do this, people would have said, shut up.
- 43:22Right? You don't know what you're talking about. So this is something that is it's a baby.
- 43:26Yeah. It is an infant.
- 43:28I mean, a newborn.
- 43:30Yeah.
- 43:31We're just,
- 43:33we're at the very edge, you know, we're at the very bleeding edge of everything that could bleed and everything that has an edge. You
- 43:40wanna experience what
- 43:42that's, what
- 43:44testing and production actually looks like,
- 43:46come on and join us because this is exactly what it looks like. Well, I also think, because I did listen to a couple,
- 43:53like working and listening to YouTube videos about an Oster in the background, What I started to understand is everybody looks at this now and says, okay, this is a replacement for Twitter.
- 44:01No, this is a protocol and the first thing people are building on it is a replacement for Twitter.
- 44:07Actually could be used to develop
- 44:09things we haven't even thought of yet on top Just of the way that when we came up with Lightning,
- 44:16was, Oh, we need a way for somebody to buy a coffee and a scone of Bitcoin and not pay a fee that's a third of the cost of the coffee and the scone.
- 44:25And now it's a way that people are sharing value at fractions of a cent at the speed of light.
- 44:32Right. Right. And so no one thought, oh, you know what? We're going to build lightning so that there can be a fountain.
- 44:39Nobody thought that. They're like, we're gonna build lightning so there can be quick, fast payments
- 44:43between individuals.
- 44:45And then
- 44:47the other things came so we could end up with maybe marketplaces
- 44:51built on top of this or maybe advertising
- 44:54platforms built on top of this. Well, exactly. And that kind of gets back to, I think the
- 45:00question that I had actually positive to you on the form was,
- 45:04again, what does decentralized communications mean for the world?
- 45:08Yeah. So I kind of wanna drill down into that.
- 45:12And you may not agree at all with
- 45:16the analogy that I'm about to use, but
- 45:19I am the guest, I get some kind of- Now you get to serve everyone.
- 45:23So you always say
- 45:25that marketing is the story that you tell
- 45:29about yourself,
- 45:31a service,
- 45:32a product,
- 45:34something
- 45:35labeled x.
- 45:37Okay?
- 45:38I look at that as
- 45:40non value communication.
- 45:42I look at that as an oster. I also look at that as the walled gardens that we just got passed.
- 45:48But I because a lot of people say, well, you know, sending value is just me communicating with you. Yeah. But there's value attached that makes it a little different.
- 45:59Yeah. So
- 46:00the marketing part I look at as an ostrich.
- 46:04Okay.
- 46:05And the question is,
- 46:07you know, or or not the question, but a sale, that transfer of belief between one entity and the other, that's a Bitcoin transaction
- 46:15or or a lightning transaction. Mhmm. So
- 46:19when you get into like, is the question about is global
- 46:23communications important for me, for you,
- 46:26like, you know,
- 46:28protests just get shut down because they turn off Twitter in China. Nobody knows where to go. Nobody knows what time it's gonna start.
- 46:35You got the MyPillow guy
- 46:37who just completely got deleted off of everything. So his ability to advertise his product in public is almost
- 46:44nil.
- 46:45Like when I announced like the daily podcast, like when I say, Hey, here's what I'm gonna talk about. Here's a link to it. And I used to throw that up on Twitter. Well, it's never gonna be up on Twitter anymore because I'm gone.
- 46:57All of the, and the boots on the ground reporting and three d print files for firearms,
- 47:02being able to send that to you over Nostrad, that's not gonna be able to be stopped.
- 47:07Some
- 47:08relays
- 47:08may decide the relay operator is just, you know, a wussy and decides that they don't want to get into freedom or whatever, but I
- 47:16got other relays that I could do. So that's the
- 47:19non value communication part. And that's important because if I don't know that my pillow guy has a pillow for
- 47:26sale, I can't buy it. Can't do a side. Or in free speech,
- 47:30it's that we always think of free speech as the right to speak.
- 47:34Yes. But it's also the right to hear.
- 47:36Yeah. Kind of the same way of explaining the thing. I have a right to speak, but if your right to hear me speak is impaired,
- 47:44then
- 47:45as much as it's hurting me, it's also hurting you.
- 47:48Because you might want to know what I have to say.
- 47:51Yeah, I might want your product. I did want your product. I bought MSB
- 47:56for 0.2 Bitcoin. I would have never been able to do that.
- 48:00I would have never been able to do that had you not been had a platform to say, hey. I got this thing.
- 48:05It costs this. I take this, and here's how you get me that that value. Well, another go out on a limb based on when you told me you found me. Uh-huh.
- 48:15I I run a website. You can get my
- 48:19stuff from my site directly,
- 48:21But odds are at that time
- 48:23in the world,
- 48:25you went to Apple Podcasts and found me. Yes. Well, because So I wasn't on Apple Podcasts back then, I wouldn't have what I have today, and that could be taken away from me at any time.
- 48:38Right.
- 48:39Yes. Exactly.
- 48:40So what I like the the thing about it is is what decentralized communications means to the world is that we had answered one problem of the the ability to communicate value to each other, real monetary value through Bitcoin,
- 48:54but now we've got
- 48:55all the non value stuff. So let me give you an example of, I ran an experiment when I was first on Noster because
- 49:03we were able to put lightning invoices directly into the notes.
- 49:07So
- 49:08what I did is I took it like my wife
- 49:11knits.
- 49:12Now she's actually starting to spin her own yard, but that's another story. Get it? Sorry.
- 49:17Bad jokes. I love bad jokes.
- 49:20So I took a picture of one of the hats that she knitted
- 49:24and then I generated a I gend up a 100 Satoshi lightning invoice,
- 49:30like just a
- 49:31regular old fashioned Lightning invoice.
- 49:34I put both of those into a single note.
- 49:38And then at the very top, I said, I'm running an experiment. Somebody please pay me a 100 sats to buy this hat.
- 49:45No, you're not actually getting the hat.
- 49:47And then in the lightning invoice,
- 49:49give me your address.
- 49:52And within seconds that hat was bought.
- 49:55The lightning invoice was paid, my wallet of Satoshi flashed it. And then the first thing back was there's no room in the memo
- 50:03of this lightning invoice when I'm paying it to put in my full address.
- 50:08The idea was is I don't want their address in public. I want their address to be between me and you or, you know, me and that person. So the but the point I'm trying to make is that in a single event on Nostr, I was able to advertise the thing and have a payment structure all in one place.
- 50:26Didn't have yet to sell the damn thing.
- 50:29It makes me think of my discussion with the dude that wants to make a Zola into fuel and biochar and stuff like that.
- 50:36Another thing he wanted to do was create something very similar to this with advertising
- 50:42and sales, but that I could literally do the same thing and at the same time be running an affiliate program
- 50:48that you see the thing I'm trying to sell and I don't have anybody following me that'll buy it, but you relay
- 50:54it, not the right word for this because it means something else, you share it, somebody acts on it, I get payment, and a piece goes to you. Like, that doesn't exist yet, but it could. It it will. It not that could. Has to eventually
- 51:08exist because if you can do that, somebody will.
- 51:12Yes.
- 51:13And that's the whole thing. But
- 51:16I just wanted to get to that because that was a section of these notes that I was writing to myself for the show that I was like,
- 51:23I
- 51:24found it fascinating that it would have worked if there was a way that I could keep the address private within the Lightning Network.
- 51:31Yeah.
- 51:32Or some other way. It doesn't matter as long as the user experience is like,
- 51:36I like that hat. Oh, look. Here's how I pay for that hat. Boom. It's done. Oh, and all the last thing, enter my, you know, my address
- 51:44shipping address. Yeah. If you can make that experience basically a one two punch Yeah.
- 51:51You're gonna have a lot less friction on sales. You also need inventory control in there because if it's a one off item, you don't want 20 payments on it. Yeah. It
- 52:00Exactly. Except that with with that lightning invoice Oh, once it's paid, you can't pay to it anymore. Whoever paid it first. Oh, so I can Whoever gets to it 20,
- 52:10and when I say 20 and you're sold out, it's not on me. You're out. Like Absolutely.
- 52:16It fails.
- 52:17Yes. And unlike Twitter, I can I can send the exact same note many times, except that it wouldn't be the exact same note because the lightning invoice would be different And every
- 52:27you you said expiries too? So, like, if you say this is good for twenty four hours
- 52:31Yep. You said that I put that a number of seconds on your invoice to twenty four hours, whatever that comes to in seconds.
- 52:37And if you're doing a deal and maybe it's not a limited inventory but limited time,
- 52:41that string of invoices expires or like a master invoice type thing where anybody can use it and it creates new ones because they're building that too.
- 52:50Right, exactly. So the point being
- 52:52is that we've got non value communication
- 52:56at the same time that we have value communication and they just fucking collided. Sorry, I didn't mean to actually say No, can say that here.
- 53:03We're really passionate about what No. That
- 53:07It changes the world,
- 53:09and it starts to take a lot of things that I've talked about
- 53:12building on Lightning and kinda taking it to another level. Like, I don't know you've heard me talk about, like, I think we need a traffic app. We need a ways that
- 53:20lets users
- 53:21not only share information and wrap the cops out,
- 53:24but, you know, David rats out the cops. I'm hooking along at ninety.
- 53:29I see the little whoopy lights, and I slow down,
- 53:32and I don't get a ticket, and I go, here's a buck.
- 53:35Right? Yes. And then I verify that that asshole's still there, and maybe the next payment
- 53:40hits you for 90% and me for 10 as a verifier.
- 53:44Right? Yep. Like Yep. I don't know if you need an Oscar to do that, but as you're saying this, I'm seeing how, like, it could all play together and make it tighter.
- 53:53And then a lot of this thing about the relays, like, you were building a client or an app
- 53:58and it was for a specific purpose, you wouldn't worry about all the rest of the Nostroverse.
- 54:03You'd only worry about the users who had tied in with that app.
- 54:07They might not even know they could just like people don't know they're using TCIP.
- 54:11Right? Maybe wouldn't even know they're using Nostr. Like it's an app powered by Nostr. It means nothing to somebody. Like, when somebody buys a computer that says powered by a Pentium, whatever, they don't know what the hell that means.
- 54:21Right. Right. But as as exciting as that is, the sober let let's get back to like, let's sober up a little bit. Yeah. Because we're not there. Yeah. Because like the the whole thing is is that remember, this is all based around public private key pairs. Yeah. And you're responsible for them. Yeah. So here's the here's the bad thing. Okay. Is that
- 54:42for every client that you wanna log into, you gotta give it your public
- 54:47and your private key. Do you trust that client?
- 54:50Are you sure? How
- 54:51do you know if you can trust How do know if they're about-
- 54:54And
- 54:56here's one of the things that I use
- 54:58is especially for web clients, okay?
- 55:01Which is mostly where I'm using,
- 55:04you know, like snort. Social, again, we'll get into all that. But when I'm on the web and I want to try out 12 different clients of which there are many more than that,
- 55:14I'm not gonna enter my private key into all of them. That's
- 55:18stupid. And it's it's Sounds stupid.
- 55:20It's bad. So are you familiar with Alby, a l b y? Yeah.
- 55:25Okay. Alby extension
- 55:27almost immediately
- 55:29after
- 55:30Nostrad got big,
- 55:32Nostrad really came into the frame about mid December
- 55:35last year.
- 55:37Almost immediately Albie had a solution in their Albie wallet with their web extension that it will handle your public private key pair. And it will auto sign you in. If it senses that it's a Nostra client,
- 55:48it'll give
- 55:51you
- 55:53a pop up that says, Albie Wallet is asking you,
- 55:58do you wanna sign in with your public key?
- 56:01Confirm.
- 56:01I like that. Because I only have one person I'm trusting then. Yeah. Yep. Only once been around a while. I use Albee. Right now, if you're watching this video and you're just thinking, man, Jack brought us this great dude. I wish I could give Jack some money. If you're using Albee, you can give me money right now. There's right up in your browser, if you're using Albee, you can do it. I did not know they were already tied together.
- 56:21That things are are moving
- 56:23moving so quickly that we can't really see them. They're moving kind of at the speed of light.
- 56:28So that's my suggestion
- 56:30is that you that's the way that you handle your public private key pairs. Also make sure that you've got backups of your private key
- 56:37and
- 56:39the tale of woe from a man named BTC Gandalf,
- 56:43who we used to, you know, back in the day, we would post our public keys so that other people could follow us. And BTC Gandalf posted his private key. No. Don't do that. Sign the message with his private key,
- 56:56and it's never coming back because guess what? In Noster, you can't delete notes.
- 57:00Once it's there, it's there forever. Ever.
- 57:04So
- 57:05that was For that Trump and tweet that you left out for three seconds and deleted and nobody screenshotted it, now it's gone, that doesn't happen.
- 57:13That does not happen. Bar, Donald Trump, etcetera should not use Nostr.
- 57:18Exactly.
- 57:20It's
- 57:25like a hardcore hike,
- 57:27like the one you took.
- 57:29Yeah. Do you really wanna do this?
- 57:32Once That's you're point where you're committed. Once you're out in the shit, you get a broken leg. You
- 57:38better be able to set that thing yourself
- 57:40because that's where we're at. We're out in the middle of the Appalachians, man. It's just like, there's nobody around, nobody to help us just like Bitcoin. Right? So
- 57:50his account is completely compromised forever. So, but luckily enough,
- 57:55we rely on the social layer. He spins up another set of private public key pairs. He's already got a list of like, he can go back to his original compromised account and refollow
- 58:06all those people and send them a message that says, Hey, I screwed up. I put my private key in. And now it's become like a matter of a joke to sign in as BTC Gandalf and just post weird stuff.
- 58:19So that's the bad thing. Right? So I was just thinking the good part is the account just terminates, but it doesn't because now anybody can put whatever they want on there. It's forever. It's like a Bitcoin wallet address. If I give you a bit a one time Bitcoin wallet address and say, Jack,
- 58:36you know, it's like, I don't know.
- 58:37Sent you
- 58:39back some of the confre that you sent me or something like that. And
- 58:43I go, here's your one time wallet address, you know, Onchain BTC transaction.
- 58:48Yeah, you're gonna pay a fee. Here's the wallet address. Don't use it again.
- 58:52I can't stop you from you giving me more money on that same address. No. You can't. I can put anything I want on there. Yeah. It is forever.
- 59:00Forever, forever, forever, because that's the way Bitcoin works and it's exactly the way Nostril works. And that's really important to understand that your private keys, your public key pair,
- 59:12this isn't something that you can just email customer support at 1800
- 59:18and get fixed. It ain't getting fixed.
- 59:21It's never gonna get I want that number now. What? 1800
- 59:25use that as my customer service.
- 59:28If you need No customer service 800
- 59:32area codes left
- 59:34that use the word cry harder. Because I would I would vanity,
- 59:39pay for that and own that number
- 59:41and just put a recording on it, and I would use that. And I would pay
- 59:46the 6¢ per minute inbound, limited to one minute to call just to let people call it when they were bitching at me. That
- 59:53yeah.
- 59:54So it sounds like we can't get rid of stuff.
- 59:58Yeah. But what about third parties? So uncensorable
- 1:00:01supposed to be nonsensible. Could nostril be stopped? Let's say the the the powers that that that wanna be decided we hate this.
- 1:00:10Mhmm. And we build all this wonderful stuff we're talking about. It's five years later. It's mature
- 1:00:16like lightning is now. We got all these people building on top of it.
- 1:00:22Could someone
- 1:00:24use vulnerabilities
- 1:00:25and shut down these relays or
- 1:00:28somehow attack
- 1:00:29the networks and shut it down? Yeah.
- 1:00:32You can attack the network most definitely.
- 1:00:35So let's just back up and remember that this is a protocol.
- 1:00:39The Nostril thing is a protocol. It's implemented in almost every computer language that you can imagine already. Rust, Go,
- 1:00:47C plus plus C plus C,
- 1:00:49F,
- 1:00:50whatever.
- 1:00:51Whatever you pick your poison, I guarantee you that there's already an implementation of the Nostril Protocol
- 1:00:58in that.
- 1:01:01And the thing about it is, is that the lightning or the Nostril Protocol is very lightweight.
- 1:01:07That's why
- 1:01:08MyNodeBTC
- 1:01:10and Start9 and Umbral have all pushed the ability for you to run a relay because
- 1:01:16running the relay is one thing and it's easy, it's cheap, it's super simple.
- 1:01:21Collecting the data and holding the data for further use is up to you and however many terabytes of a hard drive you want, but that's a separate issue. Okay. So
- 1:01:31once that protocol, now the protocol's been out in the wild and I can run it on a Raspberry Pi four, good luck. Yeah. Yeah. Good luck. Now, surely
- 1:01:40somebody in your audience is probably a kick ass network,
- 1:01:44you know, guy that understands
- 1:01:46networks at the protocol layer at TCP IP and says, well,
- 1:01:50he's not right. I will take that. I reserve the right to be wrong. But as far as I can tell from everything else that the hell that I've seen,
- 1:01:59because it's so lightweight and because almost any idiot can run one,
- 1:02:04again, good luck.
- 1:02:05More power to you. Test the system easily attack a relay.
- 1:02:10Yep. You can attack the relays. It's kind of the same thing with Bitcoin. Right? Like Whack a mole. You you could go after one miner
- 1:02:19somehow, I would imagine. You could figure out a way,
- 1:02:22but good luck shutting down the network. Now the other side of that is a Bitcoin miner is very incentivized
- 1:02:29to keep mining.
- 1:02:31Yes.
- 1:02:32And a Bitcoin miner has a whole lot of horsepower just even in one mining rig,
- 1:02:39and so it takes a lot of
- 1:02:42if you had enough computing power to attack the Bitcoin network successfully,
- 1:02:47then the
- 1:02:48smartest thing for you to do would be participate in the network. That's kind of what keeps it defensible,
- 1:02:53that it's so expensive to do that, Hey, I want it. Want the Bitcoin. Right?
- 1:03:02And you're talking you have to put, like, multiple nations together to do this or something. And then Oh, yeah. All the other shit you should be doing. Yes. Where this isn't it's the the power is anybody can do it, but the weakness, I guess, would be then that there's not a lot of horsepower behind it.
- 1:03:18Right. Yeah. That's like it's still whack a mole to the infinity, like, way easier to set up a relay than probably a lightning node. Yeah.
- 1:03:27Well, that one, I don't know. I got a Lightning node. I set that up through my node BTC.
- 1:03:33And I I turned on the Nostril Relay,
- 1:03:36and I was like,
- 1:03:38what do I do? Because there was no interface. I I was thinking that when I clicked it after it was on my node, that
- 1:03:46there would be like a window that came up and it's like, nope, you gotta interface with this
- 1:03:51command line interface
- 1:03:52as far as I can tell.
- 1:03:54That's where it is right now. Again,
- 1:03:57I don't need all this stuff out of the box. There is some assembly required.
- 1:04:01And
- 1:04:03given how much I want to be able to do this is exactly how much I will go have to learn to do it, but be that as it may, if I've got at least two relays
- 1:04:12running the Nostril protocol,
- 1:04:14I got a network. I need two.
- 1:04:18So again, we go back to whack a mole and again,
- 1:04:22the notes that are being sent like the, I hate to say it, but like your tweet being sent,
- 1:04:28if it's just nothing but text,
- 1:04:31like a lightning invoice or instructions on what to do somewhere,
- 1:04:36those notes are so small.
- 1:04:39It's possible
- 1:04:40to broadcast and relay that through repeater stations on AM radio.
- 1:04:45Good luck.
- 1:04:47I mean, good luck. And of course that boils down to, well, how tenacious do we want to be?
- 1:04:53Am I really going to go do that? Well, I might.
- 1:04:56Won't Nobody will just approve that you can do it. That's what's going That's to
- 1:05:00one of those, you and me won't do it, but there'll be two dudes in a garage smoking dope going, you know, we should do.
- 1:05:08Yeah. I mean,
- 1:05:10Right? I mean, that's that's gonna happen.
- 1:05:12Yeah. It it exactly.
- 1:05:14So but here's the thing is that from a protocol standpoint,
- 1:05:18good luck.
- 1:05:19Now from a social layer network,
- 1:05:23things get a little weird,
- 1:05:24like spam attacks that never ever, ever lit up and we've had them. We got one right now, it's called the hell thread,
- 1:05:32where somebody wrote a note that had like 150
- 1:05:35or two fifty public keys in it that said something nasty.
- 1:05:41And now that like my notifications,
- 1:05:43like my messages to me and my notifications on Domus,
- 1:05:47a 100% unusable
- 1:05:49because there is nasty stuff all in this thread. It's bad, bad, bad. Before that, there was the
- 1:05:57dick pic fiasco of January
- 1:06:012023
- 1:06:02where global the global feed for, like, the all your relays are,
- 1:06:07getting all the messages and just shoving them into your your interface. Yeah. Was just nothing but these dick pics. Same one too, not a whole bunch of different ones, just the same one from
- 1:06:17500 different pub keys. So even the dude that wanted them is like, yo, man.
- 1:06:23The same Do something
- 1:06:25different. But the point is, is that that really screwed things up. It caused questions to be asked like, how can we stop this? Yeah.
- 1:06:34Paid relays.
- 1:06:35We already have them. Like eden. Noster.
- 1:06:39Something is like one of the paid relays.
- 1:06:41I have six paid relays and it cleaned up my feed.
- 1:06:45The
- 1:06:46solution. The market's always a solution.
- 1:06:48The market
- 1:06:49will provide. If
- 1:06:51you place value in something, somebody will return that value with a product, a service, what have you. So I like that. So there'll eventually be an opportunity to have, like, relay operators. In fact, it sounds like it already is. Relay operators are making money by providing relays
- 1:07:07that are clean.
- 1:07:08Some of them are making good what you
- 1:07:11want. Right? So
- 1:07:13somebody might have a different version of clean.
- 1:07:17And the beauty of this is there's room for everybody in that pool.
- 1:07:21Right. I like that. Now ISPs
- 1:07:25blocking relay IPs.
- 1:07:28Well, since it's so ultra cheap to spin up a relay and,
- 1:07:32you know,
- 1:07:33again,
- 1:07:34whack a mole, good luck brother. I mean, it's like, I like your marksmanship better be spot on because it's just, you're gonna be killing. It's like, I don't know, being overrun with 10,000,000
- 1:07:45squirrels jumping around trees and you're trying to kill them all and they keep breeding. See, that's the point is that in mid December, there was 20 relays that I knew about that I could attach to. Now there's five twenty eight.
- 1:07:57That's what
- 1:07:59one full, like maybe one full quarter of the I
- 1:08:04mean, that's almost exponential growth. Well, see people constantly. I'm a nostril, I'm a nostril, I'm a nostril on Twitter. That's kind of fun watching one platform.
- 1:08:13But you use itself to build another
- 1:08:16series of clients. Right? Basically,
- 1:08:19one client being used
- 1:08:21to sift people into all these different clients, but all of the connection. It's
- 1:08:25it's interesting.
- 1:08:29Yeah. So I don't
- 1:08:31know how it really could be stopped, especially long term, because now you've got all these propeller heads, and I say that in a very
- 1:08:38A flattering? Way. Right? Right? A very flattering way. Right?
- 1:08:42I don't mean it as an insult, but are all working on all this stuff because
- 1:08:46way back in the very early days of the Internet
- 1:08:50and I got into marketing online,
- 1:08:53I what
- 1:08:54you would call flat out a black hat SEO person. I I used every hole
- 1:09:01in Google's algorithm. I did I did crazy shit. I would use ColdFusion or PHP
- 1:09:06and take something that people shop for locally.
- 1:09:10And took The US Postal database
- 1:09:12and made one website selling one thing, put a page for 65,000
- 1:09:16cities across the country,
- 1:09:18and all the states, and even in some cases regions,
- 1:09:22and then took and pulled in snippets of information from bunches of other places. So every time that page loaded,
- 1:09:30the core content would stay the same, but there was no duplicate content
- 1:09:34Right. Because the majority of the content on the page was different every time.
- 1:09:39So the Alabama page looked different than the Texas page even though they were the same.
- 1:09:44And so I made a lot of money doing shit like that, selling, like, cable service, phone service, stuff like that that people look for locally.
- 1:09:50Yeah. And it doesn't work anymore. Well, the reason it doesn't work
- 1:09:55is because we exploited it.
- 1:09:57And I don't mean when I say me, just me. I mean, there were I wasn't the only one doing this. We had,
- 1:10:02private forums that we shared information on how to do all this stuff.
- 1:10:05Right. And
- 1:10:07Google's a better search engine because we exploited it.
- 1:10:10Uh-huh. Right? And I think and the people that are doing this shit are way more advanced than me and my contemporaries back in, you know, 1999.
- 1:10:19You know, right? Way more advanced than we were. We were just playing it like, Oh, I can do that. Holy shit. Let me see what I can do.
- 1:10:25You know? Right. Right. And that, you know, that was like you had this interest in it. It giving you something back. Yeah. So what
- 1:10:33I
- 1:10:34one of the things that I've you know, the the only real thing that kinda every once in a while worries me about Bitcoin is the same thing that worries me about
- 1:10:42Noster is to kill it, apathy.
- 1:10:46You know, there's so many people there's like, you know, there's so many,
- 1:10:51what, there's so many social medias yet when, you know, yet one more thing to log into and then blah, So blah,
- 1:10:59there's that. And then the market being saturated,
- 1:11:02but
- 1:11:03then again,
- 1:11:04is it really saturated?
- 1:11:06Mean, I
- 1:11:08I mean, you were talking about
- 1:11:10what It
- 1:11:12is correct. You made the correct statement that it just so happens that the first thing that we latched onto was recreating the Twitter environment
- 1:11:19as clients in Noster. Yep. That was probably
- 1:11:24I don't wanna say it was done. It makes sense. It was easy. It was easy. And we that's what was
- 1:11:32central on people's minds is like, because
- 1:11:35this goes okay. This goes back to my I put in in my
- 1:11:41regular
- 1:11:42your your form.
- 1:11:44This was my second Bitcoin moment, Nostr. Okay.
- 1:11:48This is because this is important. Right? So
- 1:11:51I got deplatformed
- 1:11:53from Twitter, not once, not twice, but five times. Okay.
- 1:11:57The last time that I got deplatformed,
- 1:11:59it was because
- 1:12:00I put in a new piece of information in my bio that was my old Bitcoin hackers mastodon it or Fetiverse address. And
- 1:12:09they linked that back to my original account that got banned
- 1:12:13a year ago and said, you're trying to evade suspension.
- 1:12:16Was thirty seconds after I hit save on my bio. I get an email, you're done.
- 1:12:22Yeah. Okay. So
- 1:12:26at that point,
- 1:12:28like I get kicked off somewhere mid November
- 1:12:32within a week that really drove me to figure out the Nostril thing.
- 1:12:36And then I'm like, oh, this is why. And this is why it comes up like this. I find my first client, I generate the key pair. I start, I
- 1:12:46I don't know what this is. So I start following people. I get followed by people. I send some messages. I do other stuff. I send DMs.
- 1:12:55I get a couple of DMs
- 1:12:57and then I
- 1:12:58go,
- 1:12:59well, wait a minute, what's this other client?
- 1:13:03So I think one of the first ones that I was playing around with like Snort or something,
- 1:13:08and then I went over to Astral. Ninja, warning on Astral. Ninja, do not use.
- 1:13:13It
- 1:13:14will leak your private keys, which is why I don't like putting private keys into all these clients. So warning,
- 1:13:20but at the time I was using it.
- 1:13:23Then I went over to another one and I can't remember any of these names. Right? Iris. To is another one and there was another one.
- 1:13:30But when I went to so I'm on this one client that I get kinda used to and I do all these things, and then I move to another client, completely different user interface,
- 1:13:40except for what?
- 1:13:42All of the people that I followed
- 1:13:44on the other client was there.
- 1:13:47Okay. All of the people that followed me were still following me on this new client because it's all part of my public key. All of the DMs
- 1:13:57I sent and received, they're all there.
- 1:14:00Everything
- 1:14:01was there.
- 1:14:02Sure. And that's when I realized this is exactly like Bitcoin.
- 1:14:07No matter what you do to me, no matter what relays get rid of me, no matter what client blacklists my IP.
- 1:14:14Yeah. You're not getting rid of my public key. You can't erase it. Try
- 1:14:19to erase a grain of sand on the beach. You can't destroy the mass any more than you can destroy
- 1:14:26once you pull up that public key, once you gen that thing up and that private key, it's there forever because it was already there
- 1:14:34forever. We
- 1:14:35just uncovered it. So that was just does person make their like, get a pub key? Like, so people do this all the time with Bitcoin and they don't know they've done it. They get a wallet.
- 1:14:46Yeah. Right? They they generate a wallet. It generates immediately a public
- 1:14:51key and a private key, and then you have multiple addresses
- 1:14:55that are all secured by that
- 1:14:57wallet, and they didn't really do it. Right. Like if you go get one of these clients, does that make one for you and then give it to you? Yes. Or do you have okay. Alright. And but So I I'm I'm listening to this today, and I'm like, I'm willing to give this crazy shit a shot. I'm sitting out here in the audience.
- 1:15:13And what do I freaking
- 1:15:16do? Because I still don't know what I do. Yeah. Like, one of my favorite one of my favorite,
- 1:15:22clients
- 1:15:22I'm gonna hold on for a second. Let me get over
- 1:15:26I'm gonna take this and
- 1:15:28go over to
- 1:15:30something that you're not you're not seeing.
- 1:15:32Nostril
- 1:15:33if you want to.
- 1:15:35With the health thread that's going on right now. Okay. I don't I don't wanna subject your audience to that because I can I can stomach a lot of crap,
- 1:15:44but I I We're good? I don't wanna do that to your audience. We're good. Nostragram.co.
- 1:15:49I can go over
- 1:15:51it's actually my favorite client for the web.
- 1:15:54Another one is like snort.social.
- 1:15:57Snort.social.
- 1:16:03Go over there. Okay.
- 1:16:05So I can go to settings,
- 1:16:09and I can go
- 1:16:11to,
- 1:16:14yeah. I can go over to settings when you're for when you're not logged in, you can go to settings and it will say, do you wanna do you wanna make a key pair?
- 1:16:22Why? Yes. I do. And then you hit okay,
- 1:16:25and it gives you a
- 1:16:28it gives you a private key and it gives you a public key.
- 1:16:31Write that shit down.
- 1:16:33Write
- 1:16:35it down somewhere like even, you know, like just give a thought, however you wanna do it, but you gotta keep your private key.
- 1:16:42Once private
- 1:16:43public key pair is generated, it doesn't matter what client generated it. You can go to any client and use it.
- 1:16:51But that whole, remember the Albie wallet we were talking about? Yeah.
- 1:16:55Albie wallet will generate you a key pair inside the wallet.
- 1:16:59I like that because then I'm never doing it with somebody else's stuff. Exactly. Now how how does that well, let's say I'm using the one we just had up I don't remember what you said it was now. Nostragram.co.
- 1:17:09Nostragram. I'm using Nostragram. I go there. I have all of you. I've already generated my key. I'll be somehow interacting with Nostragram.
- 1:17:18How does all be keep Nostragram from gaining access to
- 1:17:22that information that I've generated there?
- 1:17:26I wish I could tell you, but I'm at the the at the limit of how that communication
- 1:17:32on the back end works between Albie and the clients. But I can tell you this.
- 1:17:37I've been using the Albie extension
- 1:17:40and I have not had
- 1:17:42any issues that I am aware of. Okay. Whether I, and I've had the extension live well before I got into Noster. Yeah. And I had, have not had any issues that I am aware of. That doesn't mean that there's not issues. I'm just, if there is
- 1:17:57I good luck. I I I don't know about them. So Yeah. I got you. Okay.
- 1:18:03Where where were we?
- 1:18:05We we we were talking about what a person does.
- 1:18:09Oh, yeah. Okay. So we we you know, that whole thing about the whole Twitter clone kind of thing,
- 1:18:16there's a telegram clone. That's the astral ninja one.
- 1:18:20It
- 1:18:21looks completely different. And this leads me to the fact that
- 1:18:26honestly,
- 1:18:26this doesn't have to be this way.
- 1:18:29Even Jack Dorsey, you know, the guy that started Twitter, right? He's got like a 1 BTC,
- 1:18:36bounty out on somebody that will use Nostr to build a GitHub
- 1:18:40replacement.
- 1:18:41GitHub is owned by like Microsoft now or somebody like that. So there's complete, it's completely compromised and God forbid, that's where the Bitcoin repository
- 1:18:50right now lives. Although we have copies, so that's good.
- 1:18:54But he's got, I mean, that's a lot of money,
- 1:18:57right? For somebody, you know, especially for somebody using Nostril, which is from what I understand, easy to work with, it's lightweight and all that kind of stuff to build a GitHub, to rebuild GitHub in it. It's $20 a day and it's probably $250
- 1:19:11in two years.
- 1:19:12Right. So I mean, yeah. Exactly.
- 1:19:15So that's a lot of money on the line, but again, we're copying what we already have.
- 1:19:20Right?
- 1:19:21So
- 1:19:22it'll take somebody else to go, I wanna create something
- 1:19:27from nothing that nobody's ever seen. I don't even know what it is.
- 1:19:31It's gonna be possible because what can you create with communications
- 1:19:36of non value that are married with communications of value?
- 1:19:41There's not really a
- 1:19:43box that you're in. Adam Curry, get on this shit. You're gonna know. Right? You know? Yeah. I don't think Adam understands it just yet. Listened
- 1:19:52to No Agenda and podcasting
- 1:19:55two point zero, and they're kind of bagging on it right now. And I'm like, I know where you're at in this journey and that's okay. If I can be of service,
- 1:20:04call what, you know, don't call one-eight hundred CRY HARDER, call one-eight hundred I'll try to help. Don't know.
- 1:20:12So
- 1:20:13but here's, like, an idea that I had. Do you use any kind of, like, a application
- 1:20:19for note taking?
- 1:20:21I use notes. I use the most boring one there is. Right. I use it it seamlessly integrates between my MacBooks
- 1:20:27and my phone. And I I use it for boring shit, like the three things I'm gonna get done today or,
- 1:20:33I'll put my grocery list on it, and I'll tell my wife, if you wanna add shit to the list before I get to the store, just open it and add it. It'll be there when I get there. That's all I do with notes. I'm not I'm not meticulous with time management. I just am not. Okay. And I and I'm not either, but I've found a couple of of applications
- 1:20:52that that are really helping me along.
- 1:20:55Can I
- 1:20:56this one I do wanna show you because it kinda makes sense to show you? So it's present. Yep.
- 1:21:03Where am I at? And I would share the tab that you're gonna pull up.
- 1:21:06You should say present, and it should say share screen.
- 1:21:09Yeah. And then when you hit that, you should see
- 1:21:13Got it. Tab.
- 1:21:16Okay. And I'll add it for you. Okay. There you go. Alright. This is the notes that I'm working on today or working off of for today. This is what's called a canvas.
- 1:21:25But the whole thing
- 1:21:27is this is a note taking thing called Obsidian.
- 1:21:31Jesus, you are organized. It looks like a plan to build an atomic bomb or something.
- 1:21:36But if I go paper clip on on the screen here for if you can't see it, folks. Yeah.
- 1:21:42But if I go over to something that I've been working on, you know, for a while,
- 1:21:48let's see, regenerative agriculture books, soil loaders manual.
- 1:21:53This is a write up I did for soil loaders manual. And you say, hey, look,
- 1:21:59I kind of
- 1:22:01want that. And this is also what's called a note in Obsidian. Has nothing, absolutely nothing to do, but it's got all this information like I
- 1:22:10can backlink to the author and I've got a whole page for him. And it's not because I built this all, it just started coming up as I started keeping notes. Okay. And you want it. What if I can turn this into a note that Nostrad understands and send it directly to your Obsidian app and you pay me for it.
- 1:22:29I rent it because I've got a lightning, you know, a lightning node. So I'd probably give you a 100,000 steps to have it for two days. Right. Or, you know, it's like, you want all the links that all the news stories that I covered in,
- 1:22:44you know, yesterday's episode, episode six eighty five of Bitcoin and podcast, and here's all the links that I use. And you go, you know, I heard something
- 1:22:53and maybe you can even do a blind request where I don't know who the hell wants it, but I just get this request inside Obsidian and
- 1:23:00it's powered by Noster and
- 1:23:03it's a request and there's like an invoice that if I accept it will give me a 100 sats and they get all of these things. This is a terrible example because who gives a shit about what I'm showing you now. Just insert anything that you want that you think is a value that is information that I can put in an application like this,
- 1:23:23replace that. And then all of a sudden it's like, oh yeah, I would, you know, I think I want that whole,
- 1:23:28you know, that whole canvas that he's sharing with Jack right now.
- 1:23:32Let's go see where that is,
- 1:23:36Noster and it's the TSP Noster Canvas. And if you want this,
- 1:23:40you can have it and I'll pay that.
- 1:23:44I accept the invoice and it gets paid and sent to my Lightning. And then all of a sudden this entire file
- 1:23:50gets shot out as a note
- 1:23:52over Noster and it comes right into your application.
- 1:23:56It could be like that. So this brings up something else, though. So
- 1:24:01as you're talking about how light everything is, I start thinking about what actually gets the most traction being shared today, and it's videos, it's images, it's it's much heavier
- 1:24:11files.
- 1:24:12Very. So if I'm on Nostra right now, can I share videos or that it has to be hosted somewhere else? How does that work?
- 1:24:19It depends on the client.
- 1:24:22You can go ahead and stop sharing this if you want. It depends on the client. Some clients there's like
- 1:24:28Noster,
- 1:24:29it's one of the reasons why I like Noster.
- 1:24:31And by the way, the gentleman that built Noster,
- 1:24:35John
- 1:24:36Leggett,
- 1:24:37he was the guest on one of my previous podcasts and he talks all about Noster Graham. We talk all about Noster and we, you know, I'll give you that later. But
- 1:24:48in nostragram.co,
- 1:24:51you can just put videos and images directly into your note.
- 1:24:55Somebody's gotta host that.
- 1:24:57Right now, it's John.
- 1:24:59So it hurt it's it's painful for him. Right? Gotcha. And what I normally do is I rely on like, I use a lot of snort.social
- 1:25:08as well, and I rely on a third party, which is always bad, but it
- 1:25:13is what it is. We're building this stuff. We gotta figure it out. I use, MGUR to host either a video or rather like a small GIF or a small video or a picture, and I put the link in. Most
- 1:25:26I'll put the link into the note. Most clients will render that link as a picture that you can see, which is kinda cool. Alright. So the other thing is is that that is a concern
- 1:25:38because this is massive amounts of data. We're talking you get like a couple of million users doing this, you're talking about petabytes.
- 1:25:45Right? How do we solve it? I don't know. We'll figure it out.
- 1:25:49You know, we're not stupid. You know, we the
- 1:25:52human condition is that which finds problems and then burns them down with a flamethrower. That's what we do. And we need to figure out, like, how to deal with things that don't need to be there forever. So this is a tweet that I sent today
- 1:26:06promoting this livestream.
- 1:26:09Right? And and this livestream will be hosted on various video websites.
- 1:26:13It'd be great if there was a Nostril equivalent,
- 1:26:16but, you know, it'll be on some very uncensorable
- 1:26:19sites in addition to YouTube and whatever. This tweet and that image that I uploaded because Twitter was being bitchy today and it wouldn't bring the thumbnail in from the post,
- 1:26:30I don't really care if that thumbnail's not there
- 1:26:32as soon as we're done. Right. Right? Because there'll be a new thing that is the permanent podcast. Right? And there's tons of stuff. You know, I'll share a meme or something like that, and I don't really care if that meme's there three weeks later.
- 1:26:46It and and but Noster's, like, forever. So I actually think the third party of some of the pieces
- 1:26:53in some ways make sense. You know? Throw the video on D tube or whatever. You know? Or I can't think of the one everybody else is using now.
- 1:27:03It's one where all the crazies are. Like, the complete like, even I'm like, woah. That dude's got some he ain't got a tin hat. That dude's got a steel hat, man. He's got
- 1:27:12I can't think of what it's called now, it's it's one of those kind of like BuzzTube
- 1:27:16or so. I don't know.
- 1:27:18Okay. Okay. Well,
- 1:27:20yeah.
- 1:27:21But okay. Okay. So like the the the weightiness of of ancillary files, that's a thing. Yeah. That's a thing. So there's been talk already in, you know, people that are developing Nostrils,
- 1:27:35they get it clearly,
- 1:27:37and they're trying to figure it out. So questions are becoming,
- 1:27:40do we really need exactly what you're saying? Do we really need to keep this forever? And you kind of can't delete a note. Yeah. You kind of can,
- 1:27:49but
- 1:27:50you kind of can't.
- 1:27:51And again, user experience snafu causes friction. We're not sure we're building it. We're trying, we're testing, we're testing in production, we're, you know, as Adam Curry says, we're running with scissors. That's what we're doing. We're
- 1:28:04running with scissors.
- 1:28:06We'll figure it out. And I don't think that it's impossible to never not delete a note. Maybe we can overwrite the note with like a zero bit data or something like that, where it's just blank. It's still there. It's just ain't nothing in it. But like the video
- 1:28:23file falling off after thirty days,
- 1:28:26why not? Unless
- 1:28:27I could pay,
- 1:28:29we'll get into Last thing that we should probably end up with Zaps, but I could pay a relay.
- 1:28:35Like I put the note, and I get the six kinds of information that it needs to be a functional part of the protocol. And I give it, you know, upload
- 1:28:44it, upload the video that I'm gonna attach to it. And then I attach to that an invoice of
- 1:28:51a 100,000 sets. Yeah. And that gives me a timer.
- 1:28:55And if I want more time
- 1:28:57and again,
- 1:28:58we have to measure that against the user experience.
- 1:29:02How wonky will that be? Well, we won't know until somebody actually builds the damn thing, and then we'll figure out if it sucks as a user experience. If it does, we'll figure it out from there. This whole out of the In the real world, the strong live and the and the weak die. And that's okay. Like, failure is okay.
- 1:29:19Yes. How many versions of email were there?
- 1:29:23Oh god. Right? How many Right. Yeah. There I don't know if most people in the office probably don't know this. Government, when email came up, thought people would pay the government
- 1:29:31for government email.
- 1:29:33I don't remember that. Even have a .gov.
- 1:29:36I meant, like, they they literally thought you would pay, a nickel an email.
- 1:29:40Yeah. Like and and they really thought people would do it, they actually built it, and then, like,
- 1:29:45nobody used it. And they're like, well, we'll use it internally. And they're like, well, that makes no sense. We'll be paying ourselves.
- 1:29:51Right? You know what?
- 1:29:53Know, Adam Back came up with a Hashcash
- 1:29:56to do the exact same thing, but that was a spam prevention thing. Yeah. There's no reason why something like that doesn't work here.
- 1:30:03I can choose.
- 1:30:04See that's the thing is like, I can choose to have a public relay.
- 1:30:08Might have to put up with dick pics. Okay, I can choose to have a private relay. How much do I wanna pay for it?
- 1:30:15What
- 1:30:16services does it provide?
- 1:30:18Does it provide good services? Well, then I'll probably pay for it. Does it just suck and do nothing? I don't really wanna pay for it. But
- 1:30:27again, this is the wanting everything out of the box to work exactly the way that you're used to the ease of which the convenience of which you've become accustomed, stop it.
- 1:30:38Is there any possible way that we could do something the hard way for freaking once? Yeah. I mean, I know we don't always have to, but
- 1:30:48is that what what
- 1:30:50what does that journey entail?
- 1:30:52What gifts does it give us on the other side of learning
- 1:30:56because we went through something hard? Yeah.
- 1:30:59Yeah. I mean, look at blogging. Right? Before WordPress, blogging was hard. Yeah. Blogging was hard. Blogging was hard. Now blogging is easy. And now literally anything you wanna blog to do, there's a plug in, and that plug in will either throw a little advertisement in there or you can pay for it, or it's a freemium. Like, you get the base layer, and they'll give you that for free because it's software is printing money. Once you've done it, it's done.
- 1:31:23Right. But you want all the expanded features, like all in one SEO plug in for WordPress.
- 1:31:29It's free, but do you want everything, or do you want to be able to just put in your basic tags that only change how things display on a search engine? It's up to you. Do you want analysis? Like, you pay for the pieces you want, or you buy a Tesla. You buy a Tesla. The Tesla you buy
- 1:31:45that won't go 3.2,
- 1:31:48zero to 60,
- 1:31:49could.
- 1:31:50All you gotta do is pay for it, and they'll they'll they'll flick a button,
- 1:31:54and the the the the what everything that's needed is already there,
- 1:31:58and you pay for what you want. And I think this will be
- 1:32:02it might be the most extensive example of that ever as it matures.
- 1:32:07Yeah. Because why would it be? Yeah. A complete sandbox that actually does stuff. Yeah. You know, my kids play,
- 1:32:14you know, like a Minecraft. It's a sandbox.
- 1:32:17You can't get anything out of it. I mean, spatial
- 1:32:21recognition,
- 1:32:23know, building skills,
- 1:32:25interfacing with a computer.
- 1:32:27Yeah, that, but everything that is in Minecraft is in Minecraft. It's in the sandbox. It remains there forever in a day. This
- 1:32:35one's out in the wild, walking around, reaching for things and breaking shit.
- 1:32:38This is different.
- 1:32:44This is about the Simpsons episode we talked about with Nicole and, John the other day where Homer goes back in time and sneezes on a dinosaur.
- 1:32:52When he comes forward, like, everything's jacked up. Right? Yes.
- 1:32:57Yeah.
- 1:32:58And then he just keeps running the toaster time machine until it comes back to normal, and it's, almost normal. And he settles for it. Right? He settles for it. Settles for normal. So, yeah, let's end with Zaps. I keep seeing people, I got Zaps. I got a bunch of Sats today on Nostr or whatever. How does that work? Okay. This is this answers the question of how is Bitcoin integrated directly with Nostr. It is not. Okay.
- 1:33:23Kind of.
- 1:33:24The Bitcoin the Bitcoin may
- 1:33:27sorry.
- 1:33:28The Bitcoin main chain transactions,
- 1:33:31Nostr doesn't see it. Nostr doesn't understand it. Okay. Maybe one of these days, somebody will build something for the protocol that will. I don't know. But right now, uh-uh. However, Zaps,
- 1:33:41that's a remember we were talking about event of kind one.
- 1:33:45Okay.
- 1:33:46And that's like sort of just text and the protocol says, oh, I'm gonna be sending a text event. So I know how to format it for relay and there you go.
- 1:33:55Zaps is a different kind of event that the protocol understands.
- 1:34:01Mostly you interact with that.
- 1:34:05Most of the time that you're in well, all the time that I'm interacting with it, I'm interacting with
- 1:34:10Zaps through a client and the client is relaying the information to the protocol.
- 1:34:16So
- 1:34:17in like Thomas,
- 1:34:20I have on my iPhone, I got Wallet to Satoshi,
- 1:34:24right? And Domus,
- 1:34:26you know, at the time there was way back in the day,
- 1:34:29last December
- 1:34:3117,
- 1:34:32we were still posting
- 1:34:34LN invoices generated from Wallet of Satoshi and a few other ones. We would paste them right in to the note and people would,
- 1:34:42they'd copy and they'd paste into their Wallet of Satoshi and they'd pay me. I'd go check my wallet of Satoshi and I'd say, look, they paid me.
- 1:34:51And Nostrad didn't see any of it.
- 1:34:53And then
- 1:34:54all of a sudden I was able to get a wallet of Satoshi invoice and drop it into Domus and it would render it as a button with a picture of the invoices. This is a wallet of Satoshi invoice. Okay. And I would click it and it would take me to wallet of Satoshi. So we've deleted a step
- 1:35:11and then
- 1:35:13we got the ability to put in a and I'll just go with Wallet of Satoshi. Lots of wallets can be used. Okay. But I don't wanna go over all that because I know you're probably low on time. No, we're good. I can go to Wallet of Satoshi and
- 1:35:29can get my my Wallet of Satoshi address, which is like, I think mine is tearing feet thirty one at walletofsatoshi.com
- 1:35:37or something like that. Mine is beefy Persian thirty seven.
- 1:35:42There you go. There you go. It auto generates some random crap and that's what I got, you know? And
- 1:35:48now most clients
- 1:35:50in your profile
- 1:35:51will allow you to drop that in
- 1:35:54to a specific
- 1:35:55spot that says lightning payments,
- 1:35:58and you drop in that
- 1:36:00and then at your profile that somebody else sees, all of a sudden the lightning bolt occurs in your profile
- 1:36:06and they hit that and it opens up wallet or Satoshi or whatever it is that, you know, there's ways that you can set these clients to recognize certain wallets, just figure it out. I can't hold that many hands, but
- 1:36:19I've got mine set for Wallet of Satoshi. So when I hit the little lightning bolt, Wallet of Satoshi comes up and it says, how much you want to pay Jack? And I go, I don't know, 10,000 Satoshi's. And I hit, it generates it. And I said, I just hit send. I don't even paste the invoice.
- 1:36:34Because the, well, when I hit your, actually what happens is I hit your lightning bolt, it generates me an invoice. Okay. And then then I can sit where wait a minute. No. I'm sorry. All I have to do is put in your Because wallet's extension
- 1:36:47you're using an LN URL, I guess, is what it's called. Yeah. But this isn't a zap. This is a tip. Okay.
- 1:36:54And then we somebody finally figures out,
- 1:36:57and I think it I can't remember who it was that did it. It doesn't matter. They figured out how to make an event.
- 1:37:03And now I can zap
- 1:37:05you directly to that same address. You don't have to change anything. Okay. Because it's present in
- 1:37:12your bio.
- 1:37:13If you send out like, I just did this show with David about Noster, come listen, here's the link.
- 1:37:20And then I can go and I see that note, I can specifically
- 1:37:23zap that note.
- 1:37:25Okay.
- 1:37:26And that note
- 1:37:28in clients
- 1:37:29keeps that information.
- 1:37:31So like I send out like 10 different notes, one has nothing in it, one has a picture of a dirty kitty,
- 1:37:37the other one has a really well thought out essay
- 1:37:41and chances are good. The one that I put the most proof
- 1:37:46of work into
- 1:37:47will get the most zaps. Okay. I can use it as a metric of here's what people like what I do. And here's when people don't give a shit about what I do. So how's the other end work then? So let's say that I I I dropped my BPPersian
- 1:38:02thing
- 1:38:03in there,
- 1:38:04and so then I'm somehow having to link my payment side back. Right? So it makes total sense to me that I could get paid that way.
- 1:38:13Right. Sending it inside
- 1:38:15Nostr, hitting a lightning bolt and zapping.
- 1:38:19Right. You see, I understand how you do it in Fountain because you have a wallet inside Fountain. Right. That's a custodial arrangement at that point. Right? If yeah. If it's on your phone Yeah. Like, you know, let's just take Damas. I'm not sure about Amethyst. I can't speak to it. Not an Android user. In Damas, it knows you've got wallet of Satoshi.
- 1:38:37It just knows. It's
- 1:38:40it senses that you've got these wallets on there.
- 1:38:42And there's a little bit more to it than that. I mean, like you hit thing and it will say, Hey, I detected these, here's all the wallet list I can use. I click Wallet of Satoshi and it sets it as my default wallet.
- 1:38:53Then after that, if I want to pay you, I hit a lightning bolt to ZAP you.
- 1:38:59It brings up my wallet to Satoshi. And
- 1:39:02I've got a set of like right now,
- 1:39:05general ZAP amount, I'm a cheapskate, so I'm doing 77 ZAPs,
- 1:39:09right? Or 77 SATs per ZAP. So I see your
- 1:39:13show announcement. I go, I like Jack. I hit ZAP on that note and not another one, just that note,
- 1:39:20not your tip, not your profile, that particular note. And it opens my wallet, I hit send and it senses that I want 77 sats and then you get it.
- 1:39:31And it comes up messages
- 1:39:34in
- 1:39:35or your notifications that you got zapped.
- 1:39:38And Adrian just, by the way, sent me a 100 sats.
- 1:39:42That was the direct send just to beefy person. If I wanna see if it really worked, but thank you, Adrian.
- 1:39:48Not a zap. But that's cool. I guess so then,
- 1:39:52like, I don't spend much time actually on this device.
- 1:39:56Uh-huh. I'm a desktop guy because I'm old.
- 1:39:59So am I. And I'm in my I I work here. And when I leave this office, I try to leave work alone.
- 1:40:06Like, I don't even have email on here. Uh-huh. I do have a ProtonMail account on here for emergency communications and backup communications and vacation communications. Right? Uh-huh. But I don't even I don't even run email on my phone. I walk out of my office. Screw it. I'll see you tomorrow. Right. So if I'm on a desktop,
- 1:40:24I've never tried to use there is no desktop version of Wallace Hitoshi, is there? Nope. Nope. Nope. I wish use there was. Alby?
- 1:40:33That that's where I was going. Okay. That's what I use. I when I go to snort.social,
- 1:40:39nostragram.co,
- 1:40:40iris.to,
- 1:40:42these are all enabled. I sign into all of them with with the Alby extension.
- 1:40:47Then I'm receiving SATs and I'm sending SATs from a centralized and it's the custodial wallet, but who gives a shit? Because you're not gonna keep $10,000 in there. No. That's just that's just stupid. And the whole thing of you should never use a custodial wallet. I'm like, okay. It's not binary.
- 1:41:03There's shades of gray. At what point am I uncomfortable
- 1:41:07with keeping, you know, as what amount am I uncomfortable with keeping on a custodial wallet? I will call you on the phone and I will tell you when I'm uncomfortable. Otherwise, it is none of your damn business. Yeah. Okay. I'll get real quick. Would I would I put the bills,
- 1:41:22if they were cash, in my front pocket and walk around with them? If I would do that, I'm comfortable with it in Wallace, Satoshi Blue wallet, whatever. If I wouldn't,
- 1:41:31then it's either
- 1:41:33you know, I I use for my Lightning node, I use Zeus.
- 1:41:36So I have so I do have a mobile interface to my node with the Zeus wallet,
- 1:41:43and I'm very comfortable with that even though there's some, you know, Lightning.
- 1:41:47I have some liquidity out there for my node. Right? That's still not that much money. The vast majority
- 1:41:53of my Bitcoin is held on a hardware wallet.
- 1:41:58Right? And that's that's a toll like, those are different worlds. I if you're worried about losing
- 1:42:03$50,
- 1:42:05I I I don't Yeah. I can't help you. What to say, man. How do you how do you put your socks on and go out the door if you can't handle that? Yeah. And you can always call 1800
- 1:42:15for customer There's
- 1:42:17probably people calling that right now, and who knows who they're getting.
- 1:42:20Would it be funny if somebody had that number and didn't even know it was the number they had? I could see that happening. I've I've actually wondered that myself and I have never tried calling it because I'm like, I, you know, it's funny to say, I don't wanna give it any more attention.
- 1:42:34No.
- 1:42:35But I just just to be clear in case somebody, you know, missed it, you're on a web client
- 1:42:41and
- 1:42:42like, if you're already using Albie to handle your key pairs, which you should be, there's also NOS2X,
- 1:42:48I believe.
- 1:42:49When you hit a Zap or you wanna tip somebody,
- 1:42:53that web client knows about Albie and it says, Hey, Albie, can you open up the wallet? I gotta make a transaction here. And pop ups will come up and you can hit like, you could either put in the amount there
- 1:43:05or depending on the client, you might've put in the amount you want to Zap inside the client. Then it tells Albie either way,
- 1:43:12Albie will give you the ability to say, yeah, I really do wanna send this or, oh, I made a mistake. I didn't mean to actually hit the lightning bolt button and just cancel. So
- 1:43:22that's how you do it on at least on like, you know,
- 1:43:26Windows, you know, Microsoft based, you know, based operating systems. Oh,
- 1:43:30shit. I meant 10,000 sets, not a 100. Right? Exactly. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. You get a chance to you get a chance to back out of any transaction,
- 1:43:38whether it's on like, I'm using Domus and iOS or I'm using, you know, Windows, I really shouldn't be, but I do. I I I'm
- 1:43:46gonna catch hell for that. It just works.
- 1:43:49And that's like,
- 1:43:51for me,
- 1:43:52I can send up a shit post and get like maybe 77 stats for it, or I can announce
- 1:43:58like a show. I can say, Hey, I was on Jack Spirits Coats, the Survival Podcast. If you want to hear it, here's the link that Jack sent me. And people will probably give me like one, you know, by the time it's all said and done a couple of grand in Sats.
- 1:44:11Okay.
- 1:44:16Let me be clear about this one, though.
- 1:44:19Since I put tearing like, I no longer use tearing feet 31
- 1:44:24at Wallet of Satoshi for my for Yeah. My
- 1:44:27Okay. So no, you can, it'll just go to my wallet of Satoshi because I really like the guys over at Stacker, stacker.
- 1:44:35News. It's sort of like a Reddit, it's lightning empowered,
- 1:44:39it's built by Bitcoiners out of Austin, Texas. I love these guys, I always will love these guys. I'm shilling it on air. It's unruly and probably unwelcome, but- No, it's fine. I'm
- 1:44:50able to take their wallet that they give me. I can give them that. I now give,
- 1:44:56Noster or like my client that address.
- 1:44:59And now all my Zaps go to Stacker News.
- 1:45:03If I wanted to change to somewhere, it went somewhere else, like let's say you gave me
- 1:45:09your wallet address
- 1:45:11and for some reason or another, was feeling like I'm a generous God and wanted to put your address into where, you know, into my profile for your wallet,
- 1:45:21then it's gonna go to you.
- 1:45:23Interesting.
- 1:45:24It's yeah, it's amazing.
- 1:45:26But there was another point that was probably important, but maybe it wasn't because I forgot it, but there it is.
- 1:45:35Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
- 1:45:37I think that's interesting too, though, because like if I
- 1:45:41I could do that temporarily. So if I had somebody that
- 1:45:45I found something going on in their life and I knew their
- 1:45:49place to connect to,
- 1:45:51I could share their information and you could verify when you were sending it that, like, all contributions go to this person for this day.
- 1:45:59Yeah. That's kind of interesting. Right?
- 1:46:02Yeah. Yeah. Oh, and
- 1:46:04there's a verification process for people that what that just, you know,
- 1:46:09have to have it.
- 1:46:11It verifies you that it's like extra verification, like a blue check on Twitter called NIP.
- 1:46:18Noster Improvement
- 1:46:19Possibilities is what NIP stands Okay.
- 1:46:22So it's like a zip. Yeah, exactly. It's NIP zero five
- 1:46:26and I
- 1:46:27use nosterplebs.com,
- 1:46:29but here's the deal. You have your own website, Jack.
- 1:46:32Yeah. You are an administrator of that website.
- 1:46:36You can put
- 1:46:37information
- 1:46:38from noster into your
- 1:46:41dot well known.
- 1:46:42Yeah. And it will
- 1:46:45and I don't know exactly know how to do that. There's people on Nostr you can ask on exactly how to do that.
- 1:46:51And then
- 1:46:52you can take what's generated from that and put it into your profile.
- 1:46:56And it will say this account will basically it says verified.
- 1:47:00But since I know that it,
- 1:47:03like I could, like for instance, the beef initiative,
- 1:47:05got him a private key, got him public key, got him like a nostril clubs. Did that. I had to tell people and announce I'm doing this because Slim is overseas. He ain't got time for the chip, but he needs a presence. But that's not really verified because I ain't beef initiative, right? Got you. Got you. But
- 1:47:22when you do it on your website, I'm
- 1:47:25pretty damn sure you're the only one that could actually put that information in one On site, correct.
- 1:47:30So
- 1:47:31there's another layer of, yeah, pretty sure this is Jack.
- 1:47:36Yeah. Yeah. I'm wondering if because I've been trying to get these guys on the air and I need to play with their browser more, but the impervious browser would just seem like this is a natural fit to, like, seamlessly integrate into impervious.
- 1:47:48Oh, how are you liking that? Because I'm I you know,
- 1:47:52I'm I'm
- 1:47:53so busy
- 1:47:55Yeah. That I haven't, like, actually started using it daily. I'll play with it, and then I'm like, all my shit's set up in Brave, and I go back to Brave. And I you know, need
- 1:48:06to need to play with that more because it seems like they
- 1:48:11built a browser
- 1:48:12so that it was designed for all of these things, including the thing that you and I will be talking about two years from now that has nothing to do with Nostr. Right? Like, it's designed for that is how it seems to me anyway.
- 1:48:24Yeah. Let's take a couple real quick questions, and then I'll let you go.
- 1:48:30K Bog said,
- 1:48:31so what could be the ideal application?
- 1:48:34I don't know. We kinda threw some ideas out there. I mean, maybe in a fully integrated browser,
- 1:48:39I mean, that is the ideal.
- 1:48:41Or or, you know, live garage sales.
- 1:48:45Oh. Take take a picture of the item. I said, I've rented a garage sale, and this this hasn't sold yet. Take a picture of it. You know? Like, put it on on Noster with a lightning invoice and see if No. You can get rid of
- 1:48:57Wait. Wait. Check this out. So there's all these people flipping shit, and they go to these strip shops and stuff. Uh-huh. And they pick out the things they know will sell.
- 1:49:05They buy them, they bring them home, and they put them up for sale. And they don't leave them at thrift store because you put it up for sale. It's not there. You're screwed when you go back and somebody else wouldn't got it. But what if you can, like you walk around in a Goodwill store and they, oh, I think this is pretty cool. And then, like, you just just carry it around like you're gonna buy it. If somebody buys it, you put it in the basket.
- 1:49:24So you're selling it in real freaking time.
- 1:49:27So, like, I've got my own That's a great idea. Secret shoppers or not that's not the right word for it. My own, like because there's people out there that buy ridiculous amounts of bullshit.
- 1:49:37I think they're stupid,
- 1:49:38but they want their shit, and there's no reason they shouldn't have it. But, like, if I was out there and I'd be like, well, I got this this really cool mug. I don't know what it is. Right? It's got the the the Bitcoin Val logo on it, and it ends up in a goodwill because somebody got rid of it, and they scan that. And somebody in my audience, and let's say we discontinue that from a shop, is like, I want that thing, and I'll pay x for it. You could even have it run like a a real time eBay.
- 1:50:02Yep. Right? So, like, starting bid is
- 1:50:0710,000 sats, and it the the option runs for the next thirty minutes. That's as long as I'm gonna be here. Yep. And I'm locked the door in thirty minutes, and if nobody meets the reserve, I'm putting it back on the shelf. And if if somebody is the highest bidder, we'll close. I'll take payment, and I'll pay for it at the register. And then we need some kind of reputation management to go with that So, you know, I'm not closing you over. So you can see in my profile that I have successfully retrieved
- 1:50:30400 items
- 1:50:32and shipped them. So, like, okay. I'll buy like eBay has. Like, I'll buy from Jack. He's a power seller on
- 1:50:37Nostra
- 1:50:38Nostradamus
- 1:50:39thrift shit or whatever it is. That would be a cool app. Right? Yeah. Yeah. And the reputation could be handled like an like an event kind.
- 1:50:48Yeah. And you can also so then it goes the other way. Now I'm the collector,
- 1:50:52and I'm like, what I really need is
- 1:50:56and here's my bounty for finding it. There you go. Right? Here's my bounty. I I I can't find it online.
- 1:51:03Surely somewhere it's at somebody's garage sale, estate sale, whatever. I have an open bounty on this thing. The first person that claims it gets 500,000 sats or whatever it is, you know, at the time. Right.
- 1:51:13That's
- 1:51:14yeah. See, and that's where we're now we're creating something that doesn't exist. Exactly. We're not copying. So I think the answer to the ideal application is something that doesn't exist yet.
- 1:51:25Alright.
- 1:51:26Nick,
- 1:51:27there's blogs, and there's the potential for RSS feeds. There's a potential where file sharing is pretty wild. RSS feeds are already there. There are,
- 1:51:35whole bots
- 1:51:37that are, pub key, private key paired
- 1:51:40that all they do is monitor a single RSS feed and then blast it out over Nostril.
- 1:51:45So I could hook up my blog feed Yep. And automatically share every episode, every new item of the day post, all of that shit. Just like right now, I do that.
- 1:51:54Well, Tom did it for me because I didn't do shit. But
- 1:51:58when I make a new post on TSP,
- 1:52:01I don't know where it goes first. I think it goes to Telegram first. And it goes to my Telegram
- 1:52:07channel.
- 1:52:08My channel reposts it to my group, and one of them throws it over to our Discord.
- 1:52:14Uh-huh. And put so in one motion, I get published. It's Telegram group, Telegram channel Discord into its proper
- 1:52:21category on our Discord. Right. So you could do the same thing with Noster,
- 1:52:26right, and and and and and broadcast that way into whatever
- 1:52:30feeds you attached it to. Yeah. And blogs and file sharing. Well, we already talked about that GitHub
- 1:52:37thing that Jack wants to give somebody a you know? And we talked about the Obsidian thing, but, yeah, blogs are all this all of this all of it.
- 1:52:46Real quick on this one. Adrian says, how do you link Lightning to Amethyst if it was not covered already? Can't Zap without this. I don't know.
- 1:52:54Because I'm not an Android user, so I I can't speak to I mean, that's just, you know, unethical for me to speak to something that I don't think about.
- 1:53:02Keep keep keep bumping on. You'll figure out. So,
- 1:53:06you wanna tell people about your podcast?
- 1:53:07Oh, yeah. The Bitcoin and podcast. You can find it bitcoin and space .space.spacedot,
- 1:53:14which is terrible, but it's supposed to be about Bitcoin and other things. Right. Other things exist.
- 1:53:20I am on Fountain. I use heavily use podcasting two point zero.
- 1:53:25My name is David Bennett. I do the show. It's a Bitcoin news show almost
- 1:53:29every day. I didn't do one today because I'm meeting with you.
- 1:53:33But if you want to figure out what the hell is going on in Bitcoin, I will read you the articles.
- 1:53:38Like Guy Swan does these big log ones that are like essays and stuff. I
- 1:53:43needed somebody to tell me what the hell was going on with Jerome. What did Jerome Powell say today
- 1:53:48and how did it affect Bitcoin? It's not, I mean, I do commentary on it, but I'm reading word for word,
- 1:53:55like eight to 10
- 1:53:57articles that are relevant to Bitcoin. I try to stay as far away from shitcoiner as I can, but sometimes you gotta talk about it because it comes in. Yeah. And
- 1:54:07I give you a little market update in the middle of it. I try not to jack around too much, but I do make commentary and people have been liking it. So I've been doing it for almost getting into my fifth year.
- 1:54:21That's awesome. That's awesome. Well, you are the one that told me about podcasting two point zero. Yay. He finally recognized me. You're
- 1:54:28the reason I did it. I've said it before.
- 1:54:31I just I I I never it's like, I I I you can't talk about, like, Bitcoin, podcasting two point o, and I'm like, I told you about that. I swear to God I told you about that. I think I think he's forgot I think you forgot me. Well, when you told me about it so long ago, it kinda like, nostril. There's all this crap you had to do and stuff. Then I had Adam on, and he's like, oh, no. Just get Breeze.
- 1:54:50And it was like it already existed, but I didn't know about it. Like, the next day, told me about Fountain.
- 1:54:56Uh-huh. And then I didn't do anything with that, and we set it up using some kind of Discord bot.
- 1:55:02And Uh-huh. And then when I got on Fountain, I'm like, wait a minute.
- 1:55:07Like, then it really made sense. And I think a lot of this stuff that we're talking about today,
- 1:55:11it will be the apps
- 1:55:13that use the protocol that will open it to the masses. But that's why get involved now. Build your history now.
- 1:55:19Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Crap now because,
- 1:55:22you know, I got on Fountain in August last year,
- 1:55:26and I made the top 10 list on Fountain for the year
- 1:55:30Uh-huh. For supported shows. I think I was number seven for the year, and I'm like, well, I should've got my ass on there in January.
- 1:55:35Uh-huh. And that would've made a lot more sense. Right? You know? Yeah.
- 1:55:40You know, again, we're all running with scissors around here. You know,
- 1:55:45we're all in dangerous territory, but if you want to
- 1:55:48get an update,
- 1:55:50generally speaking, Monday through Friday,
- 1:55:52you go to Bitcoin and I will read you the news and I read it verbatim so that
- 1:55:58you can make your own decision
- 1:56:00about whether or not my commentary is valid for you. Sure. You know? But
- 1:56:06I just kind of wanna leave this off
- 1:56:09with this last thing is that
- 1:56:12where does this all lead us?
- 1:56:14You're gonna end up with 195
- 1:56:17pissed off governments.
- 1:56:19You're gonna end up with 195
- 1:56:22citizenries
- 1:56:23that are rediscovering their birthright,
- 1:56:25their future, their freedoms.
- 1:56:27And when you add Bitcoin plus the Lightning Network plus Nostr, you got a three pole chair, which is the most stable thing that you can have. We've been waiting on Noster for that last little bit,
- 1:56:40that last push over the cliff.
- 1:56:42And that last push over the cliff is probably, it's not
- 1:56:46going to be bright and cheery and filled with rainbows and
- 1:56:50you know, farting unicorns.
- 1:56:52Yeah. There may be blood and I don't wanna end it on a doomer note, but all of this is important.
- 1:56:58And when things are important, they have a tendency to have consequences.
- 1:57:03This is going to have consequences.
- 1:57:06There's no such thing as a bloodless revolution.
- 1:57:09All you get to choose is maybe how much blood and what kind.
- 1:57:12Exactly. Right. So that's where I'll leave it.
- 1:57:16This is the they said the revolution won't be televised.
- 1:57:20However, it shall be broadcasted.
- 1:57:23It will absolutely be experienced.
- 1:57:25Yep. Yep. Well, man, I've got links to all your stuff in the show notes. One thing I want to hit you with before we leave because I wasn't sure what I was looking at. I've got your Nostre pub key,
- 1:57:36and there's something that followed that that said hex. Is that supposed to be in the show notes or not?
- 1:57:41Yeah.
- 1:57:43There's two
- 1:57:45versions of the PUB key. One starts with NPUB1.
- 1:57:49That's that one. That's a
- 1:57:52type. Some clients don't like that type. They want a hex. So I had to convert NPUB one through an NPUB two hex converter. And that's the hex. So if for whatever reason it says,
- 1:58:06you put in says, I don't like it. Try the hex one. Don't include hex or NPUB in parentheses, just the numbers that come before it. Gotcha. So if you can't find them on one, you can try the other. And I've got them both in the show notes. I've got his Stacker News profile.
- 1:58:21I've got his podcast on Fountain and on Apple, Instagram, No Agenda Social, and Patreon,
- 1:58:27all in the show notes today. If you like what David had to say and you want to find out more and follow him,
- 1:58:32I got all the ways that he gave me that you can do that,
- 1:58:36locked into the show notes for you today. That'll be on the audio version of the episode. Link to get there is right down there in the video. If you're watching this, you know, anytime after we did it, it's probably already there. If you're watching it right now, not done yet. You'll have to wait. That will be live in about an hour from right now. That is 01:54PM
- 1:58:55Central Standard Time, Thursday today.
- 1:58:57David, thank you for being with us today. You're welcome, Jack. Thank you for having me. Well, I will say that I talked to David a little bit,
- 1:59:05after the episode, and I'm sure that this won't surprise anybody when I say this,
- 1:59:12but I'm less excited about what Noster is and what it does than what it will be and what it will do. That's
- 1:59:20really what
- 1:59:22I'm excited about and I take away from this. And I'm finally gonna get my butt on Nostrand. I promise you guys it may not be today or tomorrow, but by the end of the weekend. So Monday, I will have a pub key for those of you guys that are on Nostrand and wanna come and hook up with me and I'll figure it out. Think I'm going to follow his advice and use the Albee extension to integrate with whatever app I choose or whatever application or website I choose to use with Nostrad. That seemed like good advice.
- 1:59:49With that, I want to remind you guys that there are ways you can help support us and one of them is really simple.
- 1:59:55You just start your online shopping at tspaz.com.
- 1:59:58That's tspaz,
- 1:59:59tspaz.com.
- 2:00:02Item of the day today I brought around about two weeks ago.
- 2:00:05They're adjustable grow light rope hangers for
- 2:00:09seed starting systems, aquaponic systems, hydroponic systems,
- 2:00:12indoor systems where you're using grow lights, and honestly anything that you want to hang that ain't that heavy anyway,
- 2:00:18where you want to be able to change the height at which it hangs. These are pretty cool, they're a little ratchet
- 2:00:24gear shifter in them. They've got a carabiner on one side that's attached to the pulley system and then they got a carabiner on the other side just tied onto the rope. It's actually a pretty long rope so you could you can do quite a bit of elevation change.
- 2:00:38I actually, since I'm using them in my planter system,
- 2:00:41I took most of that rope and cut off the extra just so it wasn't in the way.
- 2:00:45But I added something today. My grandson went and shot a video for me just about a minute long. I actually have them installed in one of my seed starting systems now and so that you can see exactly how they work with my grow lights
- 2:00:59and why I chose to hang them the way that I did with that orientation.
- 2:01:04These things are inexpensive.
- 2:01:05The price has actually gone up a couple bucks since the first time I featured them just two weeks ago, but they're still cheap and they just work and work every time. So check them out and this is one of those ones where I'm not really concerned about the brand. There's a lot of people that make these and I give some information in another video that's in the write up. Just remember you can always support us and find the item of the day at tspaz.com.
- 2:01:29Tspaz,
- 2:01:30tspaz.com.
- 2:01:31And all my reviews are there categorized
- 2:01:34alphabetically so you can find like the permaculture stuff, the energy stuff, all of it's there. If it's in T SPAS, I own it, I use it, I bought it, and I would spend my money on it again or I wouldn't recommend it to you. Last but not least, do consider joining the members support brigade. Just go to survivalpodcast.com,
- 2:01:51click on members to learn more. If you sign up and use the discounts that are provided to members,
- 2:01:56you will get your money back several times over every year. It's a profitable thing to be a member of the MSB.
- 2:02:03Unless you pay for it with bitcoin and bitcoin quadruples in value or something like that, like David mentioned today, that can happen.
- 2:02:12But remember, if we don't use bitcoin, then bitcoin doesn't have a use, and you can always spend bitcoin
- 2:02:17without actually spending your Bitcoin by using the Strike app. And if you wanna know more about my Bitcoin tools,
- 2:02:23go to the bitcoinbreakout.com
- 2:02:25and click on tools and all of the different stuff that I use is there. With that, I will catch you guys tomorrow with an expert council q and a show for the week, and then we'll start the whole thing again on Monday.
- 2:02:36But that's been Jack Spierko with another edition of the Survival Podcast.
- 2:02:49They said you should have a house,
- 2:02:51the American
- 2:02:53way.
- 2:02:55A dollar down, a dollar a month,
- 2:02:58and you never
- 2:02:59have to pay.
- 2:03:03There's
- 2:03:03a better way to do this.
- 2:03:10Let me show you a better way.