Latest / Kublai Khan and the Mongol Rule of China — Fexingo History / Kublai Khan's Paper Money and the Inflation Crisis of Yuan China
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've covered a lot of ground on Kublai Khan — his wars, his capital, his Buddhist patronage. But there's one thing that underpinned everything else: money. And I mean literally the paper in people's pockets. Luna: Paper money? In the 13th century? That always sounds so ahead of its time. Lucas: It really was. The Yuan dynasty under Kublai introduced the first nationwide paper currency in world history — the chao. But it wasn't just a clever innovation. It was also a weapon, a gamble, and eventually a disaster. Lucas: Now, paper money wasn't new to China. The Song dynasty had used jiaozi and huizi — private promissory notes that became quasi-official. But those were regional, limited, and backed by silver or silk reserves. Kublai's chao was different: it was the only legal tender across the entire empire. Luna: So you had to use it, whether you liked it or not? Lucas: Exactly. Kublai decreed that all taxes, all debts, all transactions — even foreign trade — had to be conducted in chao. Refuse it, and you could be executed. The state printed it, spent it, and forced everyone to accept it at face value. And at first, it worked brilliantly. Lucas: Marco Polo, who saw it in action in Dadu — that's modern Beijing — was astonished. He wrote that Kublai 'has more treasure than all the kings in the world.' The chao he saw was made from mulberry bark, stamped with red seals, and declared legal tender by imperial decree. Luna: But if it's just paper, what kept it valuable? Lucas: In theory, the state's promise — and the fact that you could exchange chao for silver at government treasuries. But the key was that the government collected taxes in chao, creating demand. For a while, the system was stable. Kublai's finance minister, Ahmad Fanakati, a Muslim from Central Asia, managed it tightly. Lucas: Ahmad was ruthless. He centralized tax collection, cracked down on private hoarding of silver, and expanded the money supply to fund Kublai's ambitions. But that's where the trouble started. Because Kublai's ambitions were endless. Luna: The invasions, you mean? Lucas: Right. The failed invasions of Japan in 1274 and 1281 cost a fortune — building fleets, paying soldiers, provisioning armies that never saw a real battle. Then there was the invasion of Vietnam, the invasion of Burma, the invasion of Java. Each one required more chao. Lucas: The government just kept printing. By the 1280s, the chao began to depreciate. Prices rose. The state tried to prop it up by banning the use of silver and gold — anyone caught using metal currency could be punished. But you can't outlaw economics. Luna: So they doubled down on force. Lucas: They did. And it made things worse. Merchants started hoarding goods, not accepting chao at face value. There were riots in the markets of Dadu. Ahmad Fanakati was assassinated in 1282, partly because of the resentment his policies caused. But the printing press didn't stop. Lucas: By the 1290s, inflation was out of control. The government tried issuing new denominations, even new series of chao, but people had lost faith. The Pax Mongolica — that era of safe trade across Eurasia — actually made things worse, because it exposed the yuan to foreign silver, which the state couldn't control. Luna: It sounds like the whole system was built on a kind of faith that eventually shattered. Lucas: Exactly. And when the faith broke, the dynasty's fiscal foundation cracked. The later Yuan emperors couldn't pay their armies, couldn't fund their bureaucracy. The chao became virtually worthless. By the time the Ming dynasty took over in 1368, they abandoned paper money almost entirely for centuries. Lucas: You know, it's a strange parallel. Kublai's paper money was a marvel of state power — but it also showed the limits of that power. You can decree that paper is treasure, but you can't decree that people believe it. Luna: Speaking of belief — and I know this is a bit off track — it reminds me of how much this show relies on listeners who believe in supporting the work we do. If you've been enjoying these deep dives into Mongol history, a couple of dollars a month genuinely keeps them going. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good point. We keep the show ad-free, and that's only possible because of listener support. If you've gotten something out of these episodes — maybe a new understanding of Kublai or the Yuan — you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a small amount makes a real difference. Luna: And we really appreciate it. Now, back to the chao — Lucas, you mentioned that the Pax Mongolica actually fed the inflation. Can you explain that? Lucas: Sure. The Mongol Empire created a unified trade network from China to Persia. Silver from Europe and the Islamic world flowed into Yuan markets. But the state couldn't control that inflow. Merchants would bring silver, exchange it for chao at official rates, then use the chao to buy silk or porcelain. The government was essentially printing money to buy silver, which expanded the money supply further. Lucas: And there's another layer: the traditional Mongol tax system was based on the tamgha, a commercial tax levied on trade. But in China, the Mongols inherited a sophisticated fiscal apparatus from the Song, which relied on land taxes and monopolies on salt and tea. Mixing these systems was messy. Luna: So you had Mongol tribal instincts competing with Chinese bureaucracy. Lucas: Exactly. And Kublai, for all his brilliance, never fully reconciled them. He trusted foreign administrators like Ahmad Fanakati — Persians, Uyghurs, Central Asians — more than his Chinese subjects. That bred resentment, and when the currency collapsed, it gave the Chinese elite a reason to rally against Mongol rule. Lucas: One more detail: the chao itself was beautiful. Marco Polo described it: 'All these pieces of paper are issued with as much solemnity and authority as if they were of pure gold or silver.' They bore the imperial seal, warnings against counterfeiting, and even had a face value printed on them. But beauty doesn't stop inflation. Luna: Were there any attempts to reform it? Lucas: Yes, several. After Ahmad's death, the court tried to stabilize the chao by limiting new issues, but the damage was done. In the 1290s, a minister named Sangha — a Tibetan Buddhist — tried to introduce a new chao backed by silk, but it failed. By the 1330s, the government was printing chao so recklessly that it took thousands of chao to buy a single sack of rice. Lucas: There's a famous story: a scholar-official named Zhao Ruyu wrote that people in Dadu 'used chao as wallpaper' because it was cheaper than buying real paper. That's the kind of hyperinflation that destroys empires. Luna: So the paper empire literally dissolved into paper. Lucas: That's a perfect way to put it. Kublai's chao was a bold experiment — state-issued fiat currency centuries before the West attempted it. But it also showed the danger of putting too much faith in state power without the economic discipline to back it up. The Yuan learned the hard way that money is ultimately a social contract, not a decree. Luna: It's fascinating how a seemingly dry topic like currency can reveal so much about a dynasty's strengths and weaknesses. Lucas: Absolutely. And it's a reminder that even the most powerful empire can be undone by the very innovations that made it great. Next time, we'll look at another aspect of Yuan rule — maybe the role of the Muslim astronomers who brought Persian science to China.