Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Ports, Policy & Trade: Inside America's Maritime Industry
Transcript
- 0:06Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 0:10Today's show is brought to you by The Market Edge, a new podcast series that
- 0:14was created by the American Council of Engineering Companies national members
- 0:18that are participating in the Market Intelligence Committee.
- 0:21Each episode will feature an industry expert addressing member-specific questions
- 0:26with a focus on market trends,
- 0:29economic insights, and actionable strategies aimed at empowering engineering
- 0:32firms to drive their growth, adapt to change, and maintain their competitiveness.
- 0:36So today we have with us the National Association of Waterfront Employers,
- 0:40or NAWE, President Carl Bensel, and we will also be talking about ports policy and trade.
- 0:47So Carl, thank you so much for being with us today.
- 0:50Dana, nice to meet you. It's nice to meet you as well. So I want to tell our
- 0:54listeners a little bit about Carl.
- 0:56So he was nominated by President Trump to the Federal Maritime Commission,
- 1:00FMC, in 2019, serving a term through June 2024.
- 1:05In December, he became president of the National Association of Waterfront Employers
- 1:09and executive director of the National Maritime Safety Association,
- 1:13leading advocacy and safety initiatives in the industry.
- 1:17Previously, Bensel headed federal advocacy at DCI Group and founded a consulting
- 1:22firm focused on regulatory and legislative issues.
- 1:25He served for a decade as Senate committee staff, helping craft landmark legislation
- 1:30like the Maritime Security Act of 1996 and the Maritime Transportation Act of
- 1:342002, earning awards from the U.S. Coast Guard and Maritime Security Council.
- 1:39And finally, Benzel holds a JD from the University of Alabama and an LLM from
- 1:43Tulane's Admirality Law Institute and a BA from St.
- 1:47Lawrence University. So I'm going to just jump right into our questions here.
- 1:51So those that aren't familiar, Carl, can you tell us more about NAWE and what
- 1:56their mission is? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:58Now these member companies are primarily marine terminal operators,
- 2:03so we're the companies that work at ports.
- 2:06Sometimes people get them mixed up. They conflate everything to be a port,
- 2:10but actually there are businesses that are operating at those ports.
- 2:14And so we represent companies that are marine terminal operators processing cargo through U.S.
- 2:22Ports. So our member companies handle about over 90 percent of our containerized cargo,
- 2:29a majority of the brake bulk oversized cargo that comes in and out,
- 2:33and also most all of the passenger services in the United States.
- 2:39So I'm glad you said that because that's where our connection is.
- 2:42We have a lot of marine terminal operators and other waterfront-related employers
- 2:46as clients for our engineering firms.
- 2:48So I'm curious for them, what are the key trends that are impacting what there
- 2:54are clients and your members most right now?
- 2:56Yeah, sure. No, no. Engineering companies are required for what we do.
- 3:01It's very complex. It's a huge, huge industry.
- 3:05As I say, it's the nation's supply chain. Really, sometimes they talk about
- 3:09semiconductors and other elements that are commodities brought in through our
- 3:15services, but we really service the nation.
- 3:19And so without great engineering, we can't do it.
- 3:23Technology has gotten so sophisticated that we've been able to handle increases every year.
- 3:33It really is a growth industry as the world has internationalized in its production
- 3:41of goods and commodities and food and health care products.
- 3:47So we're also sort of confined geographically. Our member companies are operating
- 3:53the same places that they've operated for hundreds of years.
- 3:57If you go to a port, it was first a port, and there was a small town,
- 4:02and then there was a city, and then there was a large city, and then there was
- 4:06urban sprawl surrounding our complexes.
- 4:09So how to get cargo through what are now very densely packed urban environments
- 4:15is the big challenge that we face as an industry.
- 4:20Well, I appreciate the plug for engineers. You should come work for us.
- 4:26So what are maybe current policies, if we could drill down into some specific
- 4:31trends? There's a lot going on coming out of the White House right now.
- 4:34Are there any trends specifically that are impacting your members and the ports
- 4:37and the surrounding real estate that you work within?
- 4:40Yeah, I think we've had, with this administration, some very positive steps
- 4:46and some very challenging steps in the trade environment area.
- 4:50And so we're trying to balance those. I think the big thing,
- 4:55President Trump announced an executive order to revitalize the maritime industrial base,
- 5:01which includes my member companies, were probably the largest U.S.-based entity
- 5:07servicing maritime transport in the United States.
- 5:11It used to be U.S. carriers, but we just don't have very many of them left.
- 5:16But this effort to grow the maritime industrial base and to have more resources
- 5:23is something that we're working closely with the administration on.
- 5:27On the other hand, the challenge has been the tariffs in trade and balancing
- 5:33some of the trade policy,
- 5:35which has been incredibly difficult, both with respect to commodities coming in, Trade sanctions,
- 5:43for instance, on Chinese-built ships and Chinese flag vessels that have established
- 5:52market dominance, according to the United States government.
- 5:55And also, more recently, potential USTR actions on cargo handling equipment,
- 6:01the equipment that we'll need to be able to produce the type of traffic flows
- 6:07that we need for our customers and the U.S. public.
- 6:11Essentially. So balancing those demands has really been a challenge.
- 6:16But we've seen a very dynamic and volatile trade environment that goes up and
- 6:23down depending on a trade announcement.
- 6:26So how to balance that out. And also, in general, the market has been always expansive, growing.
- 6:35And so how do we get the type of engineering and production of our facilities
- 6:44to ensure that we can continue to handle the growth?
- 6:50We saw what happened during the pandemic when shipping congestion occurred,
- 6:56and that was inflation and really was caused by problems getting ships into U.S.
- 7:03Ports and commodities through ports when we saw incredible surges of cargo in
- 7:09the early part of the pandemic.
- 7:11So there's two things I want to drill down further into that point.
- 7:14One is let's talk about ship-to-shore cranes because you brought up the executive
- 7:18order and the means of maritime.
- 7:22What are they for those that aren't sure? And how are the imports being impacted
- 7:27by the potential restraint of not being allowed to use cranes imported from China?
- 7:32So the Chinese have had a conscious decision as a government to try to dominate
- 7:42international trade and maritime shipping.
- 7:44That includes the production of ship-to-shore cranes.
- 7:48Those are the cranes that we use to take cargo from very large containerized
- 7:55vessels that continue to expand in size.
- 7:59Largest container ships coming into the port of LA Long Beach can carry as much
- 8:04cargo that the first truckload of cargo that was disembarked from a vessel would
- 8:11be entering Las Vegas before the last cargo container got off that ship.
- 8:17So the magnitude and size of shipping now is astronomical.
- 8:25And so ship-to-shore cranes have also changed over that time frame.
- 8:30The Chinese market for ship-to-shore cranes, those manufactured in China,
- 8:36is 96% of the world's output of SDS cranes.
- 8:40So it's complete market domination by Chinese government controlled companies.
- 8:47The U.S. government has indicated that they do not want us to purchase a U.S.
- 8:53STS equipment anymore. So we're wrestling with how to get to a point where almost
- 9:00all of our market is or would be excluded from being used in the future.
- 9:06And that's every crane that we use to take cargo off ships and put them on shore.
- 9:13Yeah, we'll have to connect later on to see if there are any more developments
- 9:17about the orders that were made in advance of this executive order being put out.
- 9:21I'd be very curious to see if those allow to come through or what's going to
- 9:26happen there in your industry.
- 9:27Next, I wanted to talk about import volumes. So everyone thought,
- 9:31oh, they'd be down because of the tariffs hitting. But now it looks like they're at all time highs.
- 9:36Import levels are just booming, unseasonally so even.
- 9:39So do you think this is still a pull forward effect in anticipation of future Chinese tariffs?
- 9:44Is it economic growth? Is it something else? What do you think?
- 9:48You know, I think it's a little bit of everything as usual.
- 9:53But yes, there's some pull forward to accommodate lower tariffs.
- 9:59So we've had two, we'll be in our fifth or sixth month of suspension of extremely
- 10:07high tariffs, for instance, for China.
- 10:10And it's been volatile, to say the least.
- 10:14But some of that is being driven because shippers, retailers,
- 10:18manufacturers are trying to take advantage of the fluctuating trade policy.
- 10:25And so we've seen the preliminary
- 10:29assessment we have three or four months ago when the 145% tariffs went into
- 10:35effect on Chinese cargo was we lost 30 to 40% of cargo to certain terminals
- 10:42that handle a lot of Chinese cargo, for instance,
- 10:46which was very similar to what we saw during the pandemic when Chinese manufacturing closed.
- 10:52And then the announcement went into,
- 10:55It came into effect that there would be a three-month suspension of that, and we saw the reverse,
- 11:03a 30% or 40% increase at those same terminals and even more so record highs.
- 11:11So it's gone up and down with fluctuation.
- 11:15And it's a little difficult for the industry to adjust because it takes four
- 11:20to five weeks before anything can respond to a proclamation or a statement because
- 11:29of the time delay in actually getting cargo moving.
- 11:32So there's been a delay.
- 11:34So it really has been a challenge as a result of this.
- 11:39Understandably so. I'm going to pivot us away from trade and policy a little
- 11:44bit into transit engineers are following as port planners and port designers.
- 11:49You know, what's the next big thing that port operators are looking to or investing
- 11:54in in the way of technology? So how is AI impacting your market?
- 11:57I know recently we put out our own market brief where we're tracking a lot of autonomous tech.
- 12:03There's a lot in the rail cars that, of course, are right there next to you.
- 12:07You've got a lot of the cold storage industry that's just booming because of that capability.
- 12:12What new technology can you tell us about?
- 12:15You know, it's technology. There's always a lot of discussion about automation
- 12:21and technology, and I really don't like the term automation per se.
- 12:27It does get into issues that we have in our collective bargaining process.
- 12:32So our labor unions that work with us closely, our,
- 12:37opposed, violently opposed to automation, as I believe a lot of Americans are,
- 12:43purely being outsourced as an automated economy.
- 12:47So I like to look at issues related to how we can promote efficiency at ports.
- 12:55And so actually I was in the port of Rotterdam visiting terminals there as FMC
- 13:02commissioner a couple of years ago, and I went into a fully automated terminal complex.
- 13:08And they were taking out some of the automated equipment,
- 13:13literally hundreds of millions of dollars of equipment, because it was relatively
- 13:17slow and couldn't scale up or scale back and adjust to cargo flows.
- 13:23So I think our members are looking at technology that will allow them to maximize
- 13:30the efficient production of their facilities.
- 13:34So pure automation is something I refrain from talking about too much.
- 13:42But for instance, utilizing technology that will allow efficient offloading
- 13:48of cargo onto rail units to maximize the space that we have in a yard is something
- 13:55that has been popular and helpful in producing more growth.
- 14:00What our challenge has is we
- 14:03don't have an opportunity to expand a lot of footprint around us to grow.
- 14:08So we need to make sure that the space that we have is used as productively
- 14:13as possible to handle growth.
- 14:16And so a lot of that is on efficient use of space and maximizing the ability to move cargo.
- 14:24So precision loading and unloading and spacing of cargo equipment and equipment.
- 14:31And maximizing our space is really the challenge.
- 14:35And on certain coasts, we run into lots of challenges with environmental mandates
- 14:42that require us to reduce the emissions or carbon output of our products and go to electrification.
- 14:51So we need to deal with issues that we haven't dealt with in those areas in the past.
- 14:57Not all over, but for instance, on the West Coast and the Northeast.
- 15:02That is an additional challenge that we face.
- 15:06Understood. We've been hearing a lot about mergers and acquisitions and increased
- 15:11M&A activity within your industry, specifically in the real market and beyond.
- 15:15Is there anything you can share with us about that? Is it impacting your members and how so?
- 15:21It's a concern. I am in process of composing a letter to the Surface Transportation
- 15:29Board. We're evaluating the proposal to create a transcontinental railroad.
- 15:35My members invest all the time.
- 15:39We would love to get the railroads investing in intermodal rail services from
- 15:44our port to a greater extent, but we literally spend hundreds of millions of
- 15:49dollars every year as an industry.
- 15:52Putting in intermodal railroad, on-dock railroad to our ports.
- 15:57We use the mainline railroads as the primary means of getting into the interior.
- 16:05Our ability at certain ports, their ability to really grow is to accommodate
- 16:10that service into Chicago, into Dallas, into inland destinations.
- 16:15So getting effective services from railroads to do that is critical.
- 16:23And so they are partners.
- 16:25But we are also concerned that eliminating competition sometimes takes that
- 16:33willingness for them to work aggressively for our growth and our potential growth at the port side.
- 16:41So we are looking very closely at that merger. We have some concerns.
- 16:45We're going to want to hear directly what their intentions are.
- 16:51But in my view, if we do one merger from the west to the east,
- 16:59there's going to be another merger.
- 17:01And then you're talking about two railroads competing for all of the intermodal
- 17:08cargo through our ports.
- 17:09And so we're going to look very closely at that.
- 17:13It's definitely going to be a trend worth watching. So that is about all the
- 17:16time we have for today. Carl, thank you so much for joining.
- 17:20Diana, nice to meet you. And to all the engineers that are out there,
- 17:24companies that are out there, we rely on you for our technology,
- 17:29our planning, and the development of the next generation of engineers.
- 17:33Music.