Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Barretts of Wimpole Street (1934)
Transcript
- 0:13Hey everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan, and I didn't know you
- 0:22were recording. You frantically looked at the
- 0:24thing and I was like, did I hit record? What
- 0:26are we doing? I didn't know you had pressed it,
- 0:28so I was just like, uh, is it? Yeah, I got all
- 0:30the really juicy bits you said right before we
- 0:32started recording. Aw, man, you didn't get me
- 0:35talking about... What I thought you did. Oh,
- 0:37I did. Oh, no. Get ready for the bloopers, ladies
- 0:40and gentlemen. Bloopers. Bloopers. You know,
- 0:44the squid from Mario. Yeah. That's the one. Blooper.
- 0:48And that's probably how he would say it if he
- 0:49wasn't Chris Pratt. If Mario wasn't Chris Pratt.
- 0:52Correct, yeah. I was like, did he voice the bloopers?
- 0:54Who knows what the sequels are going to have.
- 0:56I still haven't seen Galaxy. I haven't either.
- 0:58I don't want to. I don't want to either. But
- 1:03I know I'm going to. Yeah, I'll watch it one
- 1:05day. I mean, we're both gamers. We've both played
- 1:08Smash and a bunch of Mario games, so why wouldn't
- 1:10we? I love that you threw Smash out. Well, I
- 1:13mean, look, let's be so honest about Galaxy and
- 1:15who's in it. Sure, yeah. So that's why I'm saying
- 1:18I think it's all leading to an MCU -style Super
- 1:21Smash Bros. movie. If you added up all of the
- 1:26hours I've put into Smash throughout my entire
- 1:29life, it might be two. Really? I have not played
- 1:32a lot of Smash. Oh, brother, we are not the same.
- 1:34No. We are not built of the same cloth. We are
- 1:36not. We are not. I have played so much Smash
- 1:39Bros. in my life. I've played in a couple friend
- 1:41-organized tournaments. Really? By no means am
- 1:43I, like, a competitive, like, you know. But I've
- 1:46had a lot of, like, friendly, like, tournaments
- 1:47where we've, like, made trophies and stuff for
- 1:49it. It's a ton of fun. Who's your go -to? Oh,
- 1:52depends on the game. But, like, you know, the
- 1:55generation console and everything. Yeah. Kirby,
- 1:57I really like. Okay. I also like Little Mac.
- 2:00uh in like ultimate and like the switch editions
- 2:02sure if it's not kirby and it's not little mac
- 2:05i also do pretty well with samus okay so probably
- 2:10samus across the board but i love kirby very
- 2:14nice but kirby also is like when you get into
- 2:16like competitive like actual tournaments people
- 2:18hate them you're gonna get destroyed well it's
- 2:20not that they hate him it's just more like i
- 2:21can easily defeat you as kirby No, that people
- 2:25can defeat Kirby. Oh, okay. Because almost anyone
- 2:28can destroy Kirby. Gotcha. But I just like his
- 2:30play style a lot. He's floaty. He's very floaty.
- 2:33See, two hours and you already know a ton. I've
- 2:36seen some floaty Kirby. Sounds like more than
- 2:39two hours. Does it take more than two hours to
- 2:41see Kirby float? To remember it. Maybe is what
- 2:46I would say. I like that. This is the argument
- 2:48we're having. You can always tell how we feel.
- 2:50Like what I love about episodes like this is
- 2:52in the first 10 minutes, whatever we talk about,
- 2:55I think people are like, oh, so that's how they
- 2:57feel about them. Sure. Yeah. So that's fair.
- 2:59Cause today we're talking about the Barretts
- 3:00of Wimple Street. Yeah. I like Solid Snake and
- 3:02Luigi. Thanks for asking. Today we're talking
- 3:05about the Barretts of Wimple Street. You said
- 3:07two hours. How am I supposed to know you have
- 3:09a preference? I have preferences. Okay, so Solid
- 3:11Snake makes sense because there's literally a
- 3:13giant poster of Snake behind you on the wall.
- 3:17Would you look at that? And then Luigi, not so
- 3:19much. Wow. Literally a stuffed Luigi right next
- 3:25to you. Yeah, but then Kingdom Hearts, is it
- 3:29goofy? I would rather talk about the Barretts
- 3:31of Wimple Street than Kingdom Hearts, honestly.
- 3:34That's fair. So I can't agree with it, but that's
- 3:37fair. Barrett's and Wimbledon Street is what
- 3:38we're talking about today. So this continues
- 3:40our conversation of the six, nope, seventh Academy
- 3:43Award nominations. Now, with this one, we see
- 3:47a return of some people, some people that we
- 3:49really like. We have, well, I'll let you dive
- 3:52into that. Why don't I get in nominations? Sure.
- 3:54So nominations there are not one, not three,
- 3:58two. nominations for Barrett's and Wimple Street.
- 4:00It is actress in a leading role on behalf of
- 4:03Norma Shearer. Outstanding production is our
- 4:07second, and that is on behalf of MGM Metro Golden
- 4:10Mayor. Nicely done. Proud of you. You talked
- 4:14about returning names. Yeah. Pretty much everybody
- 4:17here is a return, including the director, Sidney
- 4:19Franklin. We just saw him do Smiling Through
- 4:22last year. Loves his Norma Shearer. He does.
- 4:24And his Frederick March, because they're both
- 4:27back. Norma Shearer plays Elizabeth Barrett,
- 4:30Frederick March as Robert Browning. And then
- 4:33also returning is the great Charles Lawton. Just
- 4:37being like the worst. Just awful. He loves to
- 4:43look terrible. He does. He loves to sit in a
- 4:45makeup chair and say, just mess me up. He said,
- 4:48you know those things they're calling chops?
- 4:52Give me those, but make it look like you shaved.
- 4:55like a llama, and then just glued it sporadically
- 4:59to my cheeks. I want you to make it look like
- 5:01I put glue on my cheeks and then dove headfirst
- 5:05into a tumbleweed. Exactly. And that's what I
- 5:08want to look like. That's the look I'm going
- 5:11for. Boris Karloff. Who? He said this was the,
- 5:15give me the Edward Moulton Barrett special. And
- 5:19that's what she gave him. That's exactly what
- 5:20they gave him. You're right. It was also written
- 5:23by Ernest Vegda, Claudine West, and Donald Ogden
- 5:26Stewart. And it was based on a play by Rudolph
- 5:28Bessier. So... Based on a play. Filmed like a
- 5:35play. Yeah. Let's hop into that right after we
- 5:40talk about the... Right after these messages.
- 5:43Crest toothpaste. I wasn't going to say anything,
- 5:47but then come back and be like, wow, how great
- 5:48was that? I love listening to a podcast when
- 5:50they're like, we're going to break right after
- 5:52these messages. So let's talk about this. I'm
- 5:54like, where are the messages? Right. It's like
- 5:56they forgot to do it. Yeah, exactly. I don't
- 5:57mind, but where are the messages? But no, thanks
- 5:59for Crest for all your work on that. Thanks,
- 6:01guys. But why don't you talk to us? I have to
- 6:04be clear. Oh, yeah, not an ad. Not hashtag ad.
- 6:07Why don't you talk a little bit about the synopsis
- 6:10of the Barrett Swimple show? Norma Shear, Elizabeth
- 6:13Barrett, is... Bah, if you will. Bah, yes. Bah.
- 6:18Actually, pause. Yes. Why'd they call her Bah?
- 6:20Elizabeth, obviously. Stop. What are we doing?
- 6:24Can you call me Yah, then? I can call you whatever
- 6:26I want. Well, that's true. We're that close.
- 6:28That's right. Baby. But could anyone call me
- 6:30Yah? Yeah. And I'm just like, yeah, Yah. I read
- 6:36recently, or I heard on a podcast, that Elizabeth
- 6:38is one of the most nicknamable. names of all
- 6:43time eliza liz beth beth bethy lizzie lizzie
- 6:49sure bethy i'm l ellie no l and ellie i i totally
- 6:54understand we're literally saying a name that
- 6:58like the letters don't they're not there so like
- 7:01eliza elizabeth ba well what it's b e yeah richard
- 7:06dick i mean sure but robert i've never heard
- 7:09bob before Well, now you have, Ryan. I mean,
- 7:12she played Mooneen in the last couple movies.
- 7:14That's so true. So what we've learned is that
- 7:16Sidney Franklin is like, Norma Shearer cannot
- 7:18have a normal name. No. Is what I'm hearing.
- 7:21Norma is too close to normal. Let's just go nuts
- 7:24with her character names. We're going abnormal
- 7:25in this one. Paranorma. Paranorma. I'm so sorry
- 7:31I interrupted. Oh, you're good. You're right
- 7:33that I've heard Ba now because they say Ba at
- 7:36least 60 times in this movie. Yeah. Oh, he's
- 7:40going to me? Okay, so you have Bah Barrett, and
- 7:43she is the oldest of this wealthy family, and
- 7:46her father is very strict, very abusive, verbally
- 7:50abusive. It's kind of hinted that there's probably
- 7:53some physical abuse going on as well. And she
- 7:57is an invalid. She is stuck in bed at the beginning
- 8:00of this movie. They never say what her ailment
- 8:03was, I don't think. She has been in contact.
- 8:07She's a poet and she's been in contact with another
- 8:09writer, Frederick March, and they finally meet
- 8:13in person and she falls in love. But her father
- 8:15is strictly against any of his children falling
- 8:20in love and moving on with their lives. And that's
- 8:23essentially the plot where, you know, as the
- 8:27movie progresses, we learn why. And it's kind
- 8:30of like a third act twist in a big way. But this
- 8:34is 110 minutes of exactly what I just told you
- 8:37guys. So I want to call back when we did our
- 8:42Skippy episode. I told you that I thought that
- 8:45the... I can think of many reasons we're calling
- 8:48back to that. I told you that there was a moment
- 8:51where I thought that the movie was kind of a
- 8:54one -scene play of them in the dining room. right
- 8:58yeah that's what you had anticipated right i
- 9:00had anticipated that was happening because that
- 9:02was like kind of the opening shot and that was
- 9:04the majority of like i think it was like 15 minutes
- 9:06of a conversation and i was like wow wouldn't
- 9:08that be interesting if that happened well unfortunately
- 9:10sydney franklin heard me and he said well wouldn't
- 9:12it be interesting if the majority of this movie
- 9:14was norma sheer in her like kind of bed not really
- 9:18it was more a lounge chair in her lounge chair
- 9:21in her bedroom for and i'm not exaggerating I
- 9:25think 85 % of this movie, that bedroom is the
- 9:30main setting. It is. It's wild. And it's just
- 9:33people coming in and out of the room, while Norma
- 9:36Shearer is, I would say, for maybe 80 % of that
- 9:3985 % in the room, laying in that resting chair.
- 9:43And it is tough. This was a tough watch, because
- 9:48you alluded to it a little bit earlier, but you
- 9:51and I... just cannot vibe with the movies that
- 9:54are based on plays that are filmed like plays
- 9:57kills me where they just put a camera in one
- 10:00spot and say sure go for it and this is that
- 10:04and you know i liked smiling through i thought
- 10:06smiling through had some really like i i cited
- 10:09that transition scene of um When he's recalling
- 10:13what happened in the past and the camera moves
- 10:14past them to a whole different cast behind them
- 10:17on the other side of the river. Like, I thought
- 10:18that was genius. Even the crane shot, like, coming
- 10:21below the statue of the horse. Totally. Like,
- 10:24it didn't take much, you know, but there was
- 10:27some... Camera movement happening. I was about
- 10:31to say trickery, but you're right, because the
- 10:33camera moved, and it doesn't really move here.
- 10:35That's all I'm asking for. And unfortunately,
- 10:37at the time, I said, I'm not sure if this was
- 10:39Sidney Franklin or if it was the director that
- 10:41took over partially for him. It kind of seems
- 10:43now with this that it was the director that took
- 10:45over partially for him, because there's nothing
- 10:47that inspired in this. I wonder if it's the cinematographer,
- 10:50because we did praise League Arms for Smiling
- 10:53Through, and this is a different cinematographer
- 10:56here. Yeah. And there's just nothing going on.
- 10:59If you're watching these films to praise the
- 11:03cinematography and be like, well, how did they
- 11:05operate the cameras back then? They hit record.
- 11:08They sure did. That's it. They hit record. They
- 11:11made sure that most people were in the frame.
- 11:13And if not, they did their best to get in frame.
- 11:16I couldn't get into this. And part of it is the
- 11:20way that it's staged. Part of it is the very
- 11:23boring, like, scenery. If you're going to have
- 11:26to be in one place, you better make that place
- 11:27pretty interesting, and it's just not. And the
- 11:30other part is it just feels extremely overacted.
- 11:33This is a little bit of my problem with Charles
- 11:34Lawton now. I thought that he over -enunciated
- 11:38his performance in The Private Lives of Henry
- 11:40VIII. I think he over -announces his performance
- 11:43in this, too. I hear you on that twist, and we'll
- 11:46talk about it, but it... doesn't really explain
- 11:49to me why he is the way he is. It explains why
- 11:51he would have some motivation. But his character
- 11:54itself is just, I am the villain. And I need
- 11:57to play the villain, so I will be playing the
- 11:59villain as hard as I need to. So I just couldn't
- 12:03get into this. I think Nora Shearer does a pretty
- 12:05good job. There's nothing wrong with Nora Shearer
- 12:08in this. It's just she is confined to one location
- 12:12for the majority of the movie. Outside of maybe
- 12:16the last 20, 25 minutes, she has an opportunity
- 12:19to move her legs a little bit. Right. But outside
- 12:22of that, not really. I liked her and Frederick
- 12:25March. I think they're good. They're not incredible.
- 12:27They're completely fine together in this. Yeah.
- 12:30I liked them a little bit better in Smiling Through,
- 12:32so maybe it's more the material that they work
- 12:34with or their characters. But I thought they
- 12:37were good. I agree with you. Norma Shearer is
- 12:39absolutely breathtaking to watch. Always. Always.
- 12:43and frederick march i think does a pretty good
- 12:45job i really liked how charismatic he was in
- 12:46this yeah i think he has a lot of like charm
- 12:49because otherwise this is a film that takes place
- 12:51in 1845 in london so it could have just been
- 12:55like um i don't want to say little women in a
- 12:58derogatory way but it could have just been like
- 13:00a historical like period piece of like the way
- 13:02they talk to each other but he has a little bit
- 13:05more of like a 1930s like charm to him in this
- 13:08role sure and that that was welcomed so i was
- 13:11it was picking up a little bit when he walks
- 13:13in and has a conversation with her but then charles
- 13:16lawton to me is kind of the movie like norma
- 13:19sheer really is the movie like the majority of
- 13:21the time she's on screen yeah but charles lawton
- 13:23is like trying to command a presence with this
- 13:26yeah and for me i won't get into the behind the
- 13:30scenes stuff just yet but it just feels like
- 13:33i need you to look at me unless like i'm going
- 13:36to do justice to this character And that's kind
- 13:38of my vibe with Private Lives of Henry VIII.
- 13:41And I picked up on the same thing here. So it
- 13:43might just be like, I'm not a Charles Lawton
- 13:45guy. But that stood out to me. Interesting. I
- 13:49feel like just based on the movies that we've
- 13:51watched, Charles Lawton and... I have a lot of
- 13:54respect for him willing to kind of put himself
- 13:56out there. Sure. And play these roles that. You
- 14:00can't say he's a bad actor. Right. In the time
- 14:02of like glitz and glamour, he's not afraid to
- 14:05be the guy that's like ripping apart chickens
- 14:07on set, you know, or wearing these crazy chops,
- 14:11the facial hair and all of that. And really playing
- 14:15like kind of despicable characters as well. Absolutely.
- 14:18aren't as you don't have that love for these
- 14:21characters the way you do like the universal
- 14:22monsters who are grotesque but kind of in a fun
- 14:25way so i i give him a lot of credit my my big
- 14:29issue with this movie this is a like a real people
- 14:33This is a story based on real life events. And
- 14:36this is not something I was familiar with. And
- 14:39every bit of info I read about these real people.
- 14:43The important thing here is the relationship
- 14:45between Robert and Elizabeth. Bah. I don't think
- 14:50that that is presented in a very enticing or
- 14:54interesting way. Their relationship in this movie.
- 14:58And that's so much of the movie. Is their courtship.
- 15:03That's true. I mean, the real allure of it is
- 15:05that he's not a Barrett. Right. And he is her
- 15:09way out of the house. Yeah. Apparently, like
- 15:12there are beautiful love notes that were handed
- 15:16back and forth between the couple in real life.
- 15:18And some of them are like printed and framed
- 15:20and put in museums and things because they both
- 15:23are poets and writers. It doesn't really play
- 15:26a huge part in this. Like they discuss their
- 15:28poetry and things like that. And that's kind
- 15:30of what brings them together and has them romance.
- 15:32I think he reads one poem that she wrote. Yeah.
- 15:35A lot of the times that her poems are read in
- 15:38this movie, it's all of the other characters
- 15:40going, well, that's lovely, my dear. Well, what
- 15:42does it mean? i don't know i just think it sounds
- 15:45nice yeah so it's i don't know well and he's
- 15:47the first one to really understand her yeah right
- 15:50like understand what it all means so i think
- 15:51it's the feeling seen and feeling like represented
- 15:54sure like she actually has someone who understands
- 15:57her so i i understood that i agree with you i
- 16:00feel like when you try and rationalize why they're
- 16:03together it's more i want to leave this house
- 16:06and he understands my poetry yeah And regardless
- 16:09of like the why they get together, I just don't
- 16:12think that their chemistry in this, like you
- 16:15said, it's fine. But because it's so much of
- 16:18this long movie, I didn't care very much. You
- 16:22know, I would watch. a movie because Norma Shearer
- 16:26is in it. I would watch a movie that Frederick
- 16:28March is leading because, I mean, I liked him
- 16:31fine in Smiling Through, loved him in Dr. Jekyll
- 16:33and Mr. Hyde. And Charles Lawton, it's certainly
- 16:35appealing to watch a movie that he's leading
- 16:37as well. So when you have something that all
- 16:40three of them are in, it feels like a little
- 16:42mini Grand Hotel in like, you know, we're putting
- 16:45all these actors in one movie. Isn't that incredible?
- 16:48And to me, it just has to be source material
- 16:50because I feel like they're doing about as best
- 16:53as they can. But it's just not interesting. All
- 16:57three of these characters are Oscar winners.
- 17:01Mm -hmm. Yeah, that's wild. So in theory, it
- 17:05should be this expertly crafted showcase of these
- 17:10performances. Star -studded cast. Exactly. But
- 17:12instead, it feels like a misfire to me. Yeah,
- 17:16and I think a lot of it is the presentation of
- 17:20the story. And boy, like I said. It's just a
- 17:24stage play. That's it. It's a stage play, and
- 17:27the concept is just a very overbearing father
- 17:31and how he traps his children at home. We should
- 17:34talk about his children. There is a scene pretty
- 17:38early on in the movie where Elizabeth is bedside
- 17:42or bedridden. Thank you. She's bedridden, and
- 17:45her siblings start visiting her. And her sister
- 17:50comes in. And then another sister comes in. And
- 17:52then a brother comes in. And I'm not exaggerating.
- 17:55This continues to happen until there are roughly
- 17:5815 people in the room. Yeah. And then their father
- 18:01walks in. And they're all just like blindsided
- 18:03by his appearance. And I would like to beg the
- 18:06question. And this answer is not provided in
- 18:09the movie. How many children does Charles Lawton
- 18:12have in this movie? I don't think he has that
- 18:15many. I don't think those were all. children
- 18:17well there are like you know cousins who will
- 18:20come and visit and like call them uncle and everything
- 18:22but certainly what's the appearance that's given
- 18:26is that these people who are in her room live
- 18:29there and it's not just like hey i'm your sister
- 18:31and this is my husband and i'm your brother and
- 18:33this is my wife like it is what's up sis and
- 18:37we're all wearing suits right uh and it's like
- 18:40at one point 15 people yeah totally and it's
- 18:44it's wild to me that when charles lawton does
- 18:47show up in the room this army is just like oh
- 18:51no it's him it's like guys he's one man you could
- 18:55take him yeah and he's looking a little scruffy
- 18:57you could probably handle this how often is he
- 19:00like looming on the stairs and you could just
- 19:02push him right just end it just goodbye charles
- 19:06that's what i'd say oh uh another notable return
- 19:10marino sullivan true but i was going to say so
- 19:14una o 'connor returns in this she was from cavalcade
- 19:17not to say you know oh it's the return of una
- 19:20o 'connor but she's uh i thought she was good
- 19:23in this uh and she's another person the whole
- 19:25reason i thought of her who could also push him
- 19:27down the stairs for sure yeah she she was kind
- 19:30of an interesting character to me not so much
- 19:32for her her role in this but more so that she's
- 19:37almost portraying like a stereotype She's just
- 19:41like Mrs. Potts. Yeah. Like, her accent and everything.
- 19:45Well, and that's her, that's almost Cavalcade
- 19:47as well. Yeah. When we are introduced to her,
- 19:49she has a similar position within the house.
- 19:52Yeah, yeah. I did enjoy her performance a lot.
- 19:55Like I said, though, Marino Sullivan does return,
- 19:57and we just saw her in The Thin Man. So that's
- 19:59just to further emphasize, like, the powerhouse
- 20:02of a cast this is. I do think that you were criticizing
- 20:07Charles Lawton a little bit just for your own
- 20:10personal enjoyment of him. I do think that when
- 20:13he was on screen, like that's when I was most
- 20:15engaged in this. Because otherwise it was just
- 20:18this romance that I didn't really care about.
- 20:21So when he shows up, I'm like, okay, here's where
- 20:24we're getting like some conflict, some context
- 20:26as to why this movie is even in existence, I
- 20:31guess. But yeah, he's a little over the top.
- 20:34He's not my favorite performance. Norma Shearer,
- 20:36worthy of being nominated. She's the highlight
- 20:39to me. I agree. It's such a hard movie to talk
- 20:42about because nothing really happens. No, and
- 20:44honestly, it's so funny because I think you and
- 20:46I are flipped. I think we both feel the same
- 20:48way about the movie. But in terms of the things
- 20:51we didn't like, I think we're flipped. Because
- 20:53to me, the romance between Frederick March and
- 20:55Norma Shearer... I was more interested in, okay,
- 20:58where could this go? Is it going to get her out
- 21:00of the house? And whenever Charles Lawton showed
- 21:02up, up until the third act, and even then, I
- 21:04don't really excuse it, it feels more like, hey,
- 21:08this is something that could really be good to
- 21:09me. What do you think, Dad? He's like, hmm, no,
- 21:11and then leaves. And he's just keeping her down.
- 21:15And he thinks, I guess, that he's helping her,
- 21:18but I just don't see that. Like, in his mind,
- 21:20he's like, well, have I not done everything for
- 21:22you? What have you done? Like I'm at home and
- 21:25I'm trapped here and you're telling me I can't
- 21:28ever leave. Even when the doctors suggest that
- 21:30like I go to Paris or Italy when I can. And you're
- 21:34telling me that I can't. So it is kind of remarkable
- 21:38that this movie is an hour and 50 minutes long.
- 21:41Just 10 minutes shy of two hours. And yet you
- 21:44and I were sitting here worried about if we could
- 21:46spend 60 minutes talking about it. Right, yeah.
- 21:49Because just nothing really happens in this movie.
- 21:51No. There's a lot of like, well, but there's
- 21:54this scene where this happens. It's like, yeah,
- 21:55that happens a couple times. Because again, she's
- 21:58just bedridden. The scene that I probably liked
- 22:00the most, or at least was the most notable, was
- 22:03when she feels just a little bit better. So she
- 22:05runs down the stairs to go to Robert Browning,
- 22:08Frederick March. She wants to show how she can
- 22:11do all of this. And unfortunately proves her
- 22:14father, right? Because he's telling her like,
- 22:16she can't be doing all this. And she says, well,
- 22:18I'm going to go back up the stairs. And he's
- 22:19like, you can't do that on your own. She's like,
- 22:21watch me. And she does, but about maybe halfway,
- 22:23maybe even a quarter. Yeah. She starts like falling
- 22:25a little bit. So he goes to catch her, picks
- 22:28her up and then takes her, like carries her to
- 22:30her bedroom. And unfortunately that's one of
- 22:33the most notable scenes because he's proven right.
- 22:35And that's the last thing he needed. So I, Look,
- 22:40there's a whole other side of this that people
- 22:41are picking up on as well. And one of those is
- 22:43that, like, there's a little bit of an incestuous
- 22:46nature. And this was written into the character.
- 22:48It's a big thing. It's something that they had
- 22:50to cut a lot of. Right. So they had to cut a
- 22:53lot out of it. And yet. Maybe you can pinpoint
- 22:56where I don't like Lawton as much. Even with
- 23:00that being cut and toned down, Lawton famously
- 23:03said at the time when they talked about cutting
- 23:05that, that they couldn't censor the, quote, gleam
- 23:09in his eye. So he was saying, well, you can,
- 23:12hey, you can cut those lines out, but you can't
- 23:14cut that out of my performance because it's still
- 23:16in my eye. Listen, which is great, honestly.
- 23:18Sure. No praise to his character. But, like,
- 23:23that's what's written into this character. And
- 23:25if the studio is going to start cutting things
- 23:27or the production office is going to start cutting
- 23:29things, it's nice that he has that much faith
- 23:33in his acting ability that he, you know, or his
- 23:36pride in his acting that he's able to portray
- 23:39this very weird and gross concept just through
- 23:44a look on his face. Like, true. Way to go, Charles.
- 23:47You grossed me out in this. Even after they cut
- 23:50all the gross stuff. And that's the point, I
- 23:52suppose. And that's true. I can't hold his character's
- 23:56intentions against him. And he's just trying
- 23:58to do right by the character. But still, it's
- 24:00kind of a weird thing to read when I'm already
- 24:02not a big fan of Lawton. So you're right. It's
- 24:04a good call. But that was something that he famously
- 24:06said and that they did try to tone down from
- 24:08the performance. So my understanding is in the
- 24:10play, it was a little bit more written and intentional.
- 24:14Yeah. And I was reading, too, that sexual...
- 24:19uh aggression he has towards his children like
- 24:21that wasn't real that was something that was
- 24:24added just as like shock value yeah just for
- 24:27the story overall it's like historically that
- 24:29there's no evidence of that you know i'm so glad
- 24:32you said shock value because i think that's my
- 24:33issue with the movie i i think that charles lawton's
- 24:36character just feels like i'm supposed to be
- 24:39this very loud Well, he's actually kind of quiet,
- 24:43but this like such a pronounced villain. Yeah.
- 24:46And I need to just keep you here. And even with
- 24:49the realization of like why he's doing what he's
- 24:51doing, to me, it doesn't really explain or like
- 24:54fully excuse it. So to me, it just feels like
- 24:58we had to like go above and beyond to show a
- 25:03villain in this. And Charles Lawton is up for
- 25:06the part, but it's just such a showy. performance
- 25:09and not in a good way yeah so i couldn't rock
- 25:12with it the other thing that's interesting about
- 25:14this is that lawton was only three years older
- 25:16than sheer here so they're very close in age
- 25:20and yet you know looking rough yeah well the
- 25:23makeup is very good in this i suppose is what
- 25:25you can say uh it's not something that you notice
- 25:28when you're watching but when i looked it up
- 25:30afterwards like oh that's interesting That it's
- 25:32like father and daughter. Yeah. Because you buy
- 25:34it with Norma Shearer. I mean, she looks like
- 25:36she could be like anywhere between 18 to like
- 25:3935. Right. Like, it's just hard to tell. The
- 25:41other thing, too, is that, and this is kind of
- 25:46what I want to talk to you about, not most, but
- 25:48I was excited to talk to you about. You mentioned
- 25:50Sidney Franklin directed this. He remade this
- 25:52in 1957. Oh, yeah. I did see this. And not only
- 25:55was it a remake, it was shot for shot, word for
- 25:59word. What shot? You know, the one shot for shot.
- 26:03Jeez. It was shot for shot, word for word, same
- 26:06movie by the same director. And that begs the
- 26:10question, why? Did he feel like this wasn't,
- 26:13like, it didn't get its, like, true recognition
- 26:16at the time? And if he did, why wouldn't he bring
- 26:19back some of the people? Like, because I think
- 26:21Norma Shearer was still, like, doing work in
- 26:231957. Oh, I guess she can't play that young of
- 26:25a role. Sure. you know bring some people back
- 26:28into it because otherwise it feels like if it's
- 26:30word for word shot for shot same director it
- 26:33feels like well it didn't take that first time
- 26:35maybe it will this time and i don't know that's
- 26:38a weird thing for me because it's it's it's apparent
- 26:41that this movie was not received as well as they
- 26:43wanted it to be to a point where lawton was like
- 26:46disappointed that he wasn't nominated for best
- 26:47actor he thought this was like an oscar -worthy
- 26:49performance his words. So he was disappointed
- 26:53that he wasn't nominated for this. So there was
- 26:56a clear like, you know, disappointment with at
- 26:59least on Lawton's side, but clearly also with
- 27:01Franklin, if he wanted to revisit the story again,
- 27:04a story he didn't write, but a story he adapted
- 27:06and thought he could do again. So I don't know.
- 27:09It's a weird situation. I'm looking at the 1957
- 27:12version right now, and there's not enough ratings.
- 27:16It's been seen by 272 members on Letterboxd,
- 27:19so not much at all. Yikes. It's not enough to
- 27:21actually see a number, but most people are giving
- 27:25it like three and a half to four stars. Which,
- 27:28no spoiler, is higher than I would have rated
- 27:29this. Yeah. This has an average 3 .3 on Letterboxd.
- 27:35Okay. And, wow, even this has like three to four
- 27:38and a half. I don't get it. Guys, what are we
- 27:40doing? What are we doing? This is a big issue
- 27:42I have. I've been thinking a lot about studios
- 27:45and what they're putting out during this time
- 27:48period. We've seen some heavy hitters this year
- 27:50alone from Columbia Pictures, which is kind of
- 27:53like the underdog studio. There have been a lot
- 27:57of Warner Brothers pictures that I really enjoy.
- 28:00Paramount puts out a lot of things that I can
- 28:03get behind. Even RKO. We haven't seen a lot of
- 28:07them, but like outside of the Academy, they're
- 28:09doing the Universal Monsters and all of that.
- 28:12They did All Quiet on the Western front. MGM,
- 28:14however, unless they're doing like these glitzy
- 28:18musicals, I don't know if I enjoy half of the
- 28:22things MGM puts out. And the bummer is that because
- 28:25of the contracts in the studio system at the
- 28:27time, if you have an actor or an actress that
- 28:29you really enjoy and they are in contract with
- 28:32a studio that you don't really enjoy. They're
- 28:35kind of locked into just productions that you
- 28:37can't get behind. And that's how I feel about
- 28:39Norma Shearer. It's no secret that I love Norma
- 28:43Shearer. But beyond the divorcee, I've never
- 28:45really fully vibed with any of her movies that
- 28:49we've sat down and watched. I would say the closest
- 28:51we've gotten is Smiling Through. Yeah, but...
- 28:54Which we're like kind of halfway through. You
- 28:55enjoyed that a lot more than I did. That's true.
- 28:57Yeah, that's a good point. You know, there's
- 29:00a real chance here too that like people just
- 29:03wanted to go and see plays. People just wanted
- 29:05to go to their local theater and see these plays
- 29:08from these large stars. You can't do that. So
- 29:12instead, what you can do is we can film a movie
- 29:15that is based on this play that people do want
- 29:17to go see, starring these actors that everyone
- 29:19knows and have given incredible performances
- 29:21before doing those roles. So maybe there was
- 29:25a time where, and there are people who really
- 29:28do just want to see the filmed aspect of this,
- 29:32and they're rating it that highly. Because to
- 29:34me, I mean, I'm not saying there's bad performances
- 29:37here. Even Charles Lawton, who I'm not fully
- 29:39vibing with, it's not a bad performance. I think
- 29:42it's a little one note, but it's not bad. But
- 29:44the subject matter is just so uninteresting.
- 29:48And it's two hours, just about two hours. That's
- 29:51the killer for me. That really destroys it. Yeah.
- 29:54And when I was watching this, this movie might
- 29:56as well have been three. You know, I just told
- 29:58you I'd rewatched the, and I'm not trying to
- 30:00be that guy who's like, be like Toy Story. But
- 30:02I just watched the Toy Story trilogy one through
- 30:04three. And the thing I just told Taylor was like,
- 30:07those movies are 45 minutes. They're not. They're
- 30:10like 90. But they feel like 45 minutes because
- 30:12they introduced the plot very early on. And the
- 30:16entire movie is that plot. Sure. There's no like
- 30:18side story, this and that. Like it all kind of
- 30:20blends in. And those movies feel like 45 minutes.
- 30:24Like they are quick. I think the length of your
- 30:27movie doesn't really matter if the pacing is
- 30:29good. Right. And the pacing here is just so not
- 30:33important. Yeah, we've complained a lot about
- 30:35third acts recently for a lot of these films.
- 30:38This is one that the middle is the biggest problem.
- 30:41Yeah, that's the thing. Like, the most exciting
- 30:43part of this movie is, in fact, the third act.
- 30:47And really kind of the finale, I guess. For a
- 30:51movie that's an hour and 50 minutes, like...
- 30:53That is a cinema sin to have to sit through that
- 30:56much movie just to get to a point where you go,
- 30:59okay, I'll pay attention now. Not that I was
- 31:02paying attention this whole time, but I was like,
- 31:05why? Why am I watching this? Leading forward.
- 31:07Right. So it's such a bummer. I keep looking
- 31:11at the time and I'm like, 34 minutes. That's
- 31:15also how I felt watching this movie. Stretch.
- 31:17Yeah. I was like, are we done? I'm like, well,
- 31:20can we talk about this scene? Can we talk about
- 31:21that scene? And there's nothing really worth
- 31:23talking about until you get to the end. I will
- 31:26say, like, Maureen O'Sullivan, her character,
- 31:28Henrietta, the younger sister, like, she has
- 31:32a side plot here as well where she's fallen in
- 31:34love with another gentleman. Is she the one or
- 31:38is this the cousin who has the lisp? The cousin
- 31:40who has the lisp. The speech impediment. Isn't
- 31:42that... Yeah, that is a woman. I feel like there
- 31:45was a guy, too, that also had a speech impediment.
- 31:47She's like, we're very proud to see you. Right.
- 31:49Yeah. No, it was definitely the daughter. Okay,
- 31:52yeah, that was her sister. Well, let me look.
- 31:54I'm pretty sure that was her sister. Maureen
- 31:56O'Sullivan was the sister? I'm pretty sure. Yes,
- 31:59Henrietta Barrett. Yes. She has the side plot,
- 32:02which I actually think is more interesting than
- 32:04Nora Shearer and Frederick March. All that being
- 32:07said, her performance is good, but it's still
- 32:10just not enough for me to be drawn into it. So
- 32:13no matter what you try and pull from this, where
- 32:15you're like, oh, well, let's talk about this.
- 32:17It's like, it's not really worth talking about.
- 32:20Well, I would hate to correct you this quickly,
- 32:22but I do have something that I think we're going
- 32:24to talk about a good bit that you have not mentioned
- 32:26yet. Is this our second canine star? Of the podcast?
- 32:32It sure is. In the very beginning of this, it
- 32:35does something that I love, which is it shows
- 32:38the actor and then says the name. I love it,
- 32:40too. Love this aspect. And it goes through the
- 32:42list. It says Norma Shearer as Elizabeth Barrett.
- 32:44Frederick March as Robert Browning. Charles Lawton
- 32:47as Edward Moulton Barrett. And then Maureen O'Sullivan
- 32:50as Henrietta Barrett. And at the very end, it
- 32:53says Anne Flush as himself. Yeah. And Flush is
- 32:56a cocker spaniel. And Flush. is the star of this
- 33:01movie. Flush is good. I don't want to be Homer
- 33:03Simpson with, like, whenever Poochie's not on
- 33:05screen, everyone should be asking, where's Poochie?
- 33:08Yeah. That was me. Like, whenever, like, a scene
- 33:10was happening and Flush wasn't there, I was like,
- 33:14we need to get Flush back on screen. Yeah. A
- 33:16highlight in this, for sure, is when Flush is
- 33:19sitting on Norma's lap and she's petting him
- 33:22and she starts crying and little Flush was sleeping
- 33:25and then he looks up like, why do you cry, Norma?
- 33:28And I'm just like... why do i cry flush i do
- 33:32think flush not a joke was giving one of the
- 33:35better performances in this yeah flush was great
- 33:37like really good there's a one of the opening
- 33:39scenes is flush running up the stairs and then
- 33:41going to her door and then scratching on the
- 33:43door and waiting very politely great sitting
- 33:45down and then just like trotting in yeah there's
- 33:47even a weird tense scene I don't know if you
- 33:50caught on to this, a scene where like Charles
- 33:52Lawton is so mad and he looks at the door and
- 33:55like it's flush and flush kind of looks at him
- 33:57and then just like very confidently like trots
- 34:00over to like her bed and jumps on where I was
- 34:02like, do they have beef? Like, well, they do.
- 34:05They certainly do. The first time you see Charles
- 34:09Lawton come into the room and the entire army
- 34:12of the family is in there. The bear battalion,
- 34:15if you will. Very nice. I like that. Flush, like,
- 34:18hops off the bed and gets into his little doggy
- 34:20bed because he's like, oh, no. I'm not supposed
- 34:22to be here? Yeah. Yeah. So, fantastic performance.
- 34:26I love these dogs in these movies. So, great
- 34:28year for dogs. Great year for dogs. I'm trying
- 34:32to remember the name. Asta? Asta, yeah. That
- 34:35was the character. Correct. I don't remember
- 34:37the dogs. I don't. I gotta look. Did you write
- 34:40it down? I did look. Of course. Top billing.
- 34:47Skippy. You can't write that. So Skippy performed
- 34:51Asta. And in this case, Flush played himself,
- 34:56which that's when you know you're a star. Listen.
- 34:59When they're like, you are Flush. Yes. We have
- 35:01the George, what's his name? Arliss? No, no,
- 35:05no, no. Eastone? George Eastone. We have the
- 35:08George Eastone Award coming for our annual Once
- 35:11Upon a Time at the Oscars podcast. I think we
- 35:13also need to do. uh please don't shoot my co
- 35:16-star oh that's that's a good one that's a good
- 35:20name i'm gonna write that down please don't shoot
- 35:24my co -star award goes to yeah i think we should
- 35:27also have that because there have been some great
- 35:29animal actors yeah throughout every year and
- 35:32this one being one of the strongest years well
- 35:34it also just helps that like and this is how
- 35:36you feel about norma sheer so i don't feel so
- 35:38bad half the reason that flesh is just so cute
- 35:41Like, I cannot get over how cute Flesh is. There
- 35:43are scenes where performances are happening and
- 35:46Flesh is like, I'm just going to catch a quick
- 35:49nap here if you don't mind. Just falls asleep
- 35:51right under her lap. And I was just glued to
- 35:56the screen whenever Flesh was on. And, you know,
- 35:59with something like Asta, like in Thin Man, that
- 36:02is central to the performance of that movie.
- 36:05And I don't think it's as central here. But it
- 36:08needed it. It desperately needed something like
- 36:10that to keep you more invested. And again, I
- 36:13think it shows the kind -hearted nature of someone
- 36:15like Elizabeth Barrett. Sure. So you see a little
- 36:19bit more of that. And flesh is central to the
- 36:22story because at the very end, spoilers for this
- 36:25movie, The Bears of Wimple Street, she ends up
- 36:29running off with Robert Browning. Right. And
- 36:31they're leaving despite her father's wishes.
- 36:34I kind of like this moment from Maureen Sullivan
- 36:36a good bit. This might be my second favorite
- 36:38moment where the family finds a letter and they
- 36:42all, the battalion runs in and all 45 of them
- 36:46run into the room and say, well, what's going
- 36:48on? And the sister with a lisp is crying and
- 36:53says, she left me this letter. And then she left
- 36:55this letter for dad or father is what they call
- 36:58him. And they're all like, well, who's going
- 37:01to give it to her? And Marino's like, me. Oh,
- 37:04it's me. Give me the ball right now. And when
- 37:08he walks in, she has such like a you did this
- 37:11to yourself look on her face. Very smug. And
- 37:14the performance is giving him the note, just
- 37:15like, revel in this. Because I know I'm going
- 37:19to. Yeah. And he, of course, is livid. And he
- 37:24runs to the window to look for her. And he's
- 37:27like, find her dog. Bring me the dog. Or rather,
- 37:30find the dog, take it to the local shelter, and
- 37:33eradicate it. Right. Annihilate it. Destroy it.
- 37:37Yeah, I think he says destroy. I think you're
- 37:39right, destroy it. Which I'm just like... And
- 37:40they're like, she actually took... I think this
- 37:43is Maureen O'Sullivan, too, where she's like,
- 37:45well, she took him, so you can't. And he's just
- 37:48like... I think the closing shot is how mad he
- 37:50is. Closing shot of that scene. Yes. We then
- 37:53move on to the wedding. Oh, you're right. And
- 37:55then the wedding comes. That's right. Closing
- 37:57shot of, is of Flush. So, you're right. Again,
- 38:01the beef between them is so funny. Yeah. Because
- 38:04he says to destroy the dog, and she's like, you
- 38:06can't. They took him with them. And he has this
- 38:10absolute look of like, he's going to scream,
- 38:13like shout Khan from Star Trek. Yeah. And the
- 38:16camera fades into Flush sitting at the wedding
- 38:20by the door. Yeah. Almost as a security guard.
- 38:23Like, no one else is coming into this chapel.
- 38:27That shot of Charles Lawton looking so mad, cutting
- 38:30to Flush, incredible. I love that Flush shows
- 38:35up because the year prior, Flush saw Smiling
- 38:39Through and was like, no, no, no, I saw what
- 38:41happened at Moonene's wedding. I'm not letting
- 38:44anything like that happen again. The last time
- 38:46you two got married, things did not go well.
- 38:49Exactly. That's good. Yeah, I... I think that
- 38:52that's the first moment you see Charles Lawton
- 38:54kind of look defeated, which is cool that it's
- 38:57done by the dog. The Maureen O'Sullivan performance
- 39:00is great, how she is so smug with the, here's
- 39:03the letter. I don't like that she breaks in between
- 39:06that and the, well, they took the dog with them.
- 39:08And she's like, oh, father, please forgive her.
- 39:12We're past that, girl. Move on. The one scene
- 39:16that I think is... Probably the most talked about
- 39:19scene in the movie is when, I want to say his
- 39:23name. I got to get better at saying the character
- 39:25names. Robert Browning? When Edward sits down
- 39:28with Ba and finally reveals like why he is the
- 39:32way he is. This is when you get the full on like,
- 39:35look, you were born from love. But after that,
- 39:40I was just getting wild. I was like a sex addict,
- 39:44he basically says to his daughter. It feels like
- 39:48it comes out of left field. It does. It's so
- 39:51bizarre. And again, this is something that I
- 39:52read was like not a trait of the real Edward
- 39:58Moulton Barrett. So it's just like, whoa, what
- 40:01are we doing here? That's your daughter, bro.
- 40:03Yeah. And he does have a moment where he's like,
- 40:06look, I know that this was all pretty awful to
- 40:09hear, but. And then he like puts a move on her.
- 40:13And it's really gross. It's really detestable.
- 40:16But I think that this is the moment of the film
- 40:20that most people will be like, yeah, I watched
- 40:22this and that was crazy. Yeah. It almost feels
- 40:25like who did Promising Young Woman and Saltburn?
- 40:29Who's that? Emerald Fennell. Yes. This is when
- 40:32it takes like an Emerald Fennell turn. The, how
- 40:35did Tina Fey put it? The surprisingly violent
- 40:38sexual left turn. Yeah, that's 100 % what this
- 40:42feels like. Just in here for shock value. Especially
- 40:46when you learn that, okay, well this isn't historically
- 40:48accurate either. So, I don't know. This hit and
- 40:52my jaw dropped a little bit because I was surprised
- 40:54I was seeing this in 1934. And then when I read
- 40:57deeper into it, my jaw hit again because I'm
- 40:59like, whose idea was this? Do we think this is
- 41:02more interesting if it's an unofficial sequel
- 41:05to Private Lives of Henry VIII? Like a descendant,
- 41:10like Henry's kid finally grows up and eventually
- 41:13we get... He's like, hey, look, this is just
- 41:15the way I've looked at relationships because
- 41:17of my father and everything. He just flew through
- 41:18women. Yeah, could be. And now I just want to
- 41:21keep everyone... Like, it almost feels like a
- 41:23Shyamalan twist. Yeah, yeah. Where it's like,
- 41:26he didn't see that coming, did you? It's like,
- 41:27well, no, but like... That doesn't mean I wanted
- 41:29to see it. Exactly. Yeah, it's pretty bizarre.
- 41:33And... I don't know what this movie is selling.
- 41:36And the fact that it has 3 .3, I'm like, guys.
- 41:40To me, I think that a lot of the heavy carrying
- 41:42of that is the, not performances, but the actors.
- 41:46Yeah. Yeah, that's got to be it. I mean, you
- 41:49had Cedric Gibbons doing the set design here.
- 41:51And like you said, this one set that we get,
- 41:53it's not really doing anything for me. No, I
- 41:56mean, it's completely fine. And I will tell you
- 41:59that I guess I'm influenced because I want that
- 42:00like laying chair that she has that she's in
- 42:03for the majority of the movie. It does look cozy.
- 42:05I would like that. But unfortunately, as we determined
- 42:08in our Disraeli episode, any movie that is predominantly
- 42:11featuring someone in a play -like movie or based
- 42:15on a play, resting in a chair, Being sickly,
- 42:19wrapped in a blanket for the majority of the
- 42:21movie isn't going to get a lot of love from us.
- 42:23No, there's got to be something that differentiates
- 42:26it from a play and a movie. And to me, the performances
- 42:30that Marino Sullivan and Norma Shearer and Frederick
- 42:34March are giving aren't one of, well, this is
- 42:37my movie. Charles Lawton's doing it a little
- 42:39bit, but not to a George Arliss level. It's just
- 42:41a very loud performance. It doesn't commit the
- 42:46sin. The actors don't commit the sin of George
- 42:48Arliss in Disraeli, but the filmmaking of this
- 42:51does. Yeah. Yeah. And it's going to be something
- 42:54I'm going to be so happy that we do away with.
- 42:57The one praise I do have for movies like this
- 43:00is... Outside of flesh. What? Outside of flesh.
- 43:05What is that? What are you saying? The dog. Oh,
- 43:07flush. I thought you were saying flesh. Yikes.
- 43:10I was like... No. Excuse me? Outside of the dog
- 43:14named Flush. Yes. Thank you for the clarification.
- 43:17Uh -huh. Man. Oh, when you have this type of
- 43:23like, okay, set the camera up and just let things
- 43:25go. Like at least you're getting, okay, let the
- 43:27actors act, which is something that I do think
- 43:30is missing from like modern films. Sure. Especially
- 43:32working on a set and you see where some actors
- 43:36are getting to say one line at a time. And then
- 43:39the camera flips and they're like, all right,
- 43:40let's get the turnaround. Here's your one line.
- 43:43So it allows the actors to do a form of acting
- 43:47that I think is kind of faded away from a lot
- 43:50of modern productions. So I do enjoy seeing that
- 43:54a little bit. But I'm also like, look, I could
- 43:58just go see the play. I wouldn't. But I could.
- 44:01Yeah, it's not a performance, but it's like,
- 44:03I can't remember if it's taken two. I think it's
- 44:05taken three. There's a segment of Liam Neeson
- 44:08climbing a fence. Oh. And it's like roughly 40
- 44:12cuts. Right. Of like a bam, bam, bam, bam, bam,
- 44:15him climbing one fence. Yeah. It's a similar
- 44:18thing of like, we just can't linger on one thing.
- 44:20Yeah. I'm with you. And it's nice to be able
- 44:23to get like some performances like that. But
- 44:25again, if the story is uninteresting. right and
- 44:28we're not changing our location we got to do
- 44:30something different i think it's rare that a
- 44:32movie that is just a hey film the play does well
- 44:36and this is not the example of that no it's not
- 44:39um sorry go ahead well we're about to get into
- 44:42ratings but i do want to ask there there is a
- 44:45trend of blank on blank street and it's rare
- 44:50that the street really matters in that This is
- 44:55an example of that. Do we care that this takes
- 44:57place on Wimple Street? Not at all. Is there
- 44:58some historical relevance to Wimple Street? I
- 45:01was kind of waiting for them to run into like
- 45:02another family of the Barretts and be like, well,
- 45:05no, we're the Barretts of Wimple Street. Right.
- 45:07But I was also kind of waiting. I guess I would
- 45:10prefer them not doing this over like the last
- 45:12line being like, I did my best to protect my
- 45:16family. The Barretts of Wimple Street. Yeah,
- 45:19like throw something in there. Or like there's
- 45:20like some guy who's like, you know, at his funeral
- 45:23and he's like, you know, we don't talk about
- 45:25the Barretts of Wimple Street or something. But
- 45:28no, it's never talked about. There's no clarification.
- 45:30Yeah. Maybe it's because like this was a real
- 45:33thing and it did happen on Wimple Street. I suppose.
- 45:36But apparently, was it a real thing? I mean,
- 45:39like they existed. Yeah, like all of this was
- 45:42real. The details like there was an overbearing
- 45:45father who wasn't allowing this. Was he was he
- 45:49actually a sex addict? Yeah. Was he making passes
- 45:51on his daughter? According to what I read? No.
- 45:55Yeah. But I don't know. Written by Edward Barrett.
- 45:59I just wonder if it's one of those trends of
- 46:02kind of like the once upon a time at blank where
- 46:06we got our show name. You know, there's there's
- 46:09Mexico. There's Hollywood. There's in the West.
- 46:12Those make more sense because those things actually
- 46:14take place there. Right. Is this one of those
- 46:16trends of like Nightmare on Elm Street? Does
- 46:19Elm Street really matter in that? More so than
- 46:22this, it does. I would argue way more than this.
- 46:24It's just one of those movie title trends, I
- 46:28guess, that I always think is interesting. Yeah.
- 46:30No, it seems like they could have found a better
- 46:32name. But again, why would Sidney Franklin remake
- 46:35it with the same name, with the same shots, or
- 46:38sorry, same shot, and the same words? It doesn't
- 46:41make sense. You know, my favorite thing that
- 46:43we can take away from this movie in this episode
- 46:46is when you texted me and said, what movie are
- 46:50we covering? The Barretts of the Wimpy Kid or
- 46:52something like that? That was good. I laughed
- 46:54pretty hard at that. I'm glad that this movie
- 46:56could bring us some joy in that sense. I do also
- 46:59want to call out when we talk about movies that
- 47:01are filmed that are based on plays. uh how you
- 47:04can do that and i think you know a good example
- 47:06this isn't always done this way fences is a good
- 47:10example denzel washington uh this is not my double
- 47:12feature but in 2016 denzel washington uh filmed
- 47:15and uh directed well starred and directed in
- 47:18the movie fences and that was based on a play
- 47:20so there are ways to do it to where it's not
- 47:22just one camera set up and you can be artistic
- 47:24with it and i would welcome that and i know that
- 47:27like you know some of this is well you are grading
- 47:29a movie from 1934 in 2026 with things that we
- 47:33have not done at that point or you know we've
- 47:37learned from our experiences sure true but at
- 47:40the same time we are seeing other films like
- 47:42experimenting with this and there are different
- 47:45ways different kinds of directors back then so
- 47:48maybe that's why maybe it's a cinematographer
- 47:51issue maybe like it is just a source material
- 47:53issue but there is something that stops this
- 47:56film from being interesting and especially for
- 47:58how long it is it needs something other than
- 48:01just flush on screen flush f -l -u -s -h that's
- 48:07the one can you imagine if i was like there's
- 48:09flesh on screen four stars well there it is folks
- 48:13yeah so i literally almost just looking for this
- 48:16movie typed in here comes the barretts of wimple
- 48:18street interesting i was combining a couple things
- 48:21here comes the barretts of wimple street so let's
- 48:23get into ratings uh spoiler alert i gave it two
- 48:27stars um same i'd probably give it lower on a
- 48:30rewatch I think I would too. Yeah. This is not
- 48:33a movie that I think over time I'll remember
- 48:35it a bit differently. I might not go below two
- 48:38because of the dog whose name sounds different
- 48:41when I say it. Yes. I love that dog in this movie.
- 48:45It's a good dog. So two stars feels like the
- 48:48best I can do for it. Yeah. It's boring. I don't
- 48:50mean to Pawn Stars it, but, like, best I can
- 48:53do is two stars. Right. Let me call my incestuous
- 48:57father guy and see if he can tell me a bit more
- 48:59about this character than you can. Yeah, maybe.
- 49:01But, yeah, no, this is not what you want. I'll
- 49:05say that. And it comes in a year that I think
- 49:07has been kind of off and on. Yeah. We've had
- 49:11a peak in Thin Man. And I think for what's to
- 49:14come, we'll have another peak. But we're at a
- 49:16weird spot. Because we liked Here Comes the Navy.
- 49:19Fine. And your face tells me that we didn't.
- 49:23No, we did. Oh, you did. Okay, yeah. You were
- 49:25like, who? Me? Yeah, we've enjoyed some of these.
- 49:29I do think this is kind of like a down note.
- 49:33And I think this is like we're taking the wrong
- 49:34lessons from things like Little Women. And we're
- 49:37like, oh, we love period piece dramas based on
- 49:39plays or novels, don't we? I'm like, you got
- 49:42to have a reason for it. Yeah, yeah. And performances
- 49:45only get you so far. People must have been flocking
- 49:48to the theater for the names. Well, that's the
- 49:51point, is that with Letterboxd reviews, that's
- 49:55not Rotten Tomatoes. That's not we looked at
- 49:57all the past reviews and said what it was. These
- 49:59are current reviews. Yeah. Or at least more recent.
- 50:03And that's why I don't understand why it's as
- 50:05high as it is. Let us know. Let us know how we
- 50:08got it wrong. Yeah. I'll argue. I will. Yeah.
- 50:13How about double features? So for double features,
- 50:16it was a difficult one, but I settled on a movie
- 50:20by actually someone who's in the news a good
- 50:23bit, Destin Daniel Cretton. He's doing the new
- 50:26Spider -Man Brand New Day. He did Short Term
- 50:2912. He did Shang -Chi and the Golden— Ten Rings?
- 50:34The Ten Rings. And when he did Short Term 12,
- 50:36that was one of his first films that he did with
- 50:39Brie Larson. And then he made another film with
- 50:41Brie Larson in 2017 called The Glass Castle.
- 50:44And that is my double feature recommendation.
- 50:46The Glass Castle is based on a novel. And the
- 50:49idea is that a family is on the run from, I think,
- 50:54tax evasion or from the law. And they are living,
- 50:57traveling place to place, living off the grid.
- 51:00And as she's older, she reflects on the lifestyle
- 51:04that she lived and how her father was overbearing
- 51:07and tried to give him the best life possible
- 51:08and dreaming of glass castles when that was never
- 51:12a reality for them. And the idea is that Brie
- 51:15Larson's character reflects a little bit of Norma
- 51:17Shear here in like living under the thumb of
- 51:20her father. And while it was joyful at the time,
- 51:22she can reflect back and look at how he didn't
- 51:25set her up for success. And the tension between
- 51:27the daughter and the father, I thought there
- 51:30was a lot of. connection there woody harrelson
- 51:32her father is not giving the same kind of despicable
- 51:36performance as he is in as charles lawton is
- 51:39in barrett's wimple street but i thought that
- 51:42connection of the two of them made for a very
- 51:44good double feature nice i can't say i loved
- 51:46the glass castle but i also can't say i love
- 51:49barrett's wimple street so there you go there's
- 51:51a double feature for double feature of things
- 51:52you don't love my love to knock those out for
- 51:56you my favorite good double feature it sounds
- 51:59interesting enough to check out. I was waiting
- 52:01for you to try and, I saw you think of the word
- 52:03good in your head and you were like, no. Different
- 52:06word. Well, when you describe it as, eh. Yeah.
- 52:09You know, you gotta. That was a tough one because
- 52:11we saw it in theaters and Taylor was like, I
- 52:13loved this novel so we have to see the movie.
- 52:15And then we watched the movie and I was like.
- 52:17I think she felt the same way, too. She was like,
- 52:19the novel's way better. But still. That's always
- 52:21a bummer. Yeah. So I went with the trope I was
- 52:24just talking about of the blank on blank street.
- 52:27And I also went with something that has kind
- 52:29of weird relationship stuff in it and a dad who's
- 52:34not a great dad, but maybe tries with good intentions.
- 52:38He's not doing the best, but whatever. I'm going
- 52:42with Sweeney Todd and the Demon Barber of Fleet
- 52:43Street. Listen, he loves his Joanna, and he's
- 52:50trying to get vengeance, and things don't really
- 52:53go great. Do you think this movie needed murder?
- 52:55It almost got it with Flush. You know? He's a
- 52:59pretty awful dad, and I think he was willing
- 53:01to make a couple meat pies out of the pup. Yeah.
- 53:04And that bums me out. Yeah, meat pies out of
- 53:06the pup is just the sentence I did not think
- 53:08was going to be said this morning. Well, you
- 53:10know. You've got to be ready for everything on
- 53:12this show, I guess. Yeah, I sure do. Demon Barber
- 53:15of Fleet Street. Good call. Yeah, man. It's more
- 53:17interesting than Wimple Street. I completely
- 53:19agree. Or those Barretts. Yeah. Oh, Mr. Todd.
- 53:23That's all I'm hearing now. I really like Sweeney
- 53:26Todd. I think it's great. No, I own a Tim Burton
- 53:29collection. I was just going through my physical
- 53:31media the other day. I told you it was yesterday.
- 53:33I was building out my new shelves and everything.
- 53:35And I saw that I have a Tim Burton collection.
- 53:38And I was like, oh, I'm glad I have this because
- 53:39it gives me Pee Wee Herman's or Pee Wee's Big
- 53:42Adventure. And I was like, oh, I have that on
- 53:44Criterion. I was like, yeah, but I love Mars
- 53:45Attacks. I'm like, I have that in Steelbook.
- 53:47And the more I thought about it, I was like,
- 53:48do I need this? Do I need this collection? And
- 53:51Tim Burton for me is a hit or miss. That is close
- 53:54to a 50 -50 for me, director. I think Charlie
- 53:58and the Chocolate Factory is in there. And I
- 53:59almost kind of want to just throw that disc into
- 54:01the sun. But Sweeney Todd's in there. And until
- 54:04I find a really cool edition of Sweeney Todd,
- 54:06I think I'm going to keep the Tim Burton collection
- 54:08because of that. Yeah. It's a great call out.
- 54:10I love Sweeney Todd. It's good. Solid one. Yeah,
- 54:13that's the Barretts of Wimple Street. If you
- 54:16have thoughts, shoot us an email at outaopodcast
- 54:18at gmail .com. I'm going to take a couple minutes
- 54:21to hype something up that we've got going on.
- 54:24I'll see you later, buddy. Bye. That's exactly
- 54:26what's going to be happening in a, well, would
- 54:29have happened a couple days ago. So this is the
- 54:31last episode of June. We'll be finishing up the
- 54:341934 7th Academy Awards moving into the first
- 54:38half of July. And there are four movies we'll
- 54:41be covering. And it wasn't until early in this
- 54:44year that I realized, oh, one of these movies
- 54:47is Almost Lost Media. What are we going to do?
- 54:51Almost Lost Media, meaning the only way to see
- 54:53it, is how? It is playing at the—or they have
- 54:57the only copy, surviving copy, at the UCLA TV
- 55:00and Film Archive in Los Angeles, California.
- 55:04And I was like, well, what do we do? We've already
- 55:06done a Lost Media episode with The Patriot back
- 55:08in the second year of the show. You know, I don't
- 55:12want to just read up on it and just do our best
- 55:15that way. So I did the completely financially
- 55:18irresponsible thing, and I—as you're listening
- 55:22to this— I am in Los Angeles and I have seen
- 55:26The White Parade, which will be the last film
- 55:28we cover on or for the 7th Academy Awards. So
- 55:32this is just me hyping up what we have coming
- 55:35out in these first two weeks. We have a couple
- 55:37of interviews lined up. One, with the return
- 55:41of Antonia Carlotta, and she's going to be talking
- 55:43with us about the last Lemley -produced Best
- 55:47Picture nominee, Imitation of Life. That will
- 55:50be July 8th. I'm really excited to speak with
- 55:52her again. Yeah, that's going to be great. And
- 55:53catch up and just be like, hey, how you doing?
- 55:54I'm back, by the way. Yeah. Welcome back, Ryan.
- 55:57But also, I'm really excited to fly out to California
- 56:01and check out the White Parade and just have
- 56:03that experience of... Not only going to UCLA,
- 56:07we're both going to be speaking with two of the
- 56:11folks at UCLA that are in charge of preservation
- 56:14and curation. We talk a lot about goals in this
- 56:19podcast, like OffPod. And one of the goals that
- 56:22we had was just pushing the agenda of preservation
- 56:25and film restoration. And there is really no
- 56:28better source to get that information than from
- 56:30the UCLA. We just covered a few months ago the
- 56:34front page. And we watched on that Criterion
- 56:37disc the efforts that go into both the Howard
- 56:39Hawks Library and UCLA and how far they go to
- 56:43restoration. So I think I'm really looking forward
- 56:47to that conversation. I think that's going to
- 56:48be a huge thing. I mean, East Lynn we talked
- 56:50about as well. I believe that copy is at UCLA
- 56:54as well. I believe there are versions you can
- 56:56watch online, but the last 10 minutes are exclusive
- 56:59to the UCLA print that they have. And the fact
- 57:02that it exists online is... It's not supposed
- 57:06to be. Correct, yeah. So there is that. But yeah,
- 57:09I'm just really excited for what we have moving
- 57:10forward with the interviews, finishing up the
- 57:137th Academy Awards, and just the opportunity
- 57:15to go and see a film. This is the furthest I
- 57:18have ever traveled for a movie, and hopefully
- 57:21the furthest I'll ever have to travel for a movie.
- 57:25We'll see. Yeah, we'll see. Who's to say? But...
- 57:28There's another thing that you're missing out
- 57:30on here. And that's that you will be boots on
- 57:33the ground at the Academy Museum. Yes. Yeah.
- 57:35So I'll be doing that as well. Or I will have
- 57:37done that by now. It was great. Thanks, guys.
- 57:40We're asking. Yeah. Just overall, this trip,
- 57:42I'm really excited about. And that's why we've
- 57:44been kind of teasing, like, pay attention to
- 57:46the socials. Those are all listed in the show
- 57:48notes, the Instagram, the TikTok. And just now's
- 57:52a good time, I think, to... Share with your friends
- 57:55and with your families. Hey, check out this podcast.
- 57:58Yeah, they go through and they talk about these
- 58:00movies themselves, but they're also making a
- 58:03little bit of an effort to do more than just
- 58:05watch and review. Exactly. We're trying to, again,
- 58:10push the agenda of preservation and restoration.
- 58:13And if it's not physical media, like collecting,
- 58:16then it's at least to have it out there for people
- 58:18to collect and also just to share with family
- 58:21members. I mean, you know, I can't say that it
- 58:25wasn't. semi -emotional and therapeutic yesterday
- 58:28going through all of my physical media and i've
- 58:30had stacks of like eight to ten stacks of movies
- 58:33that i've just been sitting on top of my shelves
- 58:36and not stored uh or alphabetized because i haven't
- 58:39had the space for them and i you know took time
- 58:41out of my day yesterday to like literally the
- 58:43entire day outside of running errands was just
- 58:45building these large shelves and i did that and
- 58:49then immediately started storing these and like
- 58:51The idea of taking things and alphabetizing them
- 58:53and putting them. Do I want criterions? Criterions.
- 58:55Do I just want to alphabetize all the way through?
- 58:57And then I found some duplicates that I had.
- 59:00And then I was like, cool, I can trade these
- 59:02in. And oh, I'm missing this. Now I need to put
- 59:04it in my diary so I know what to look for. And
- 59:06I need to re -update my register on blu -ray
- 59:09.com. It's very therapeutic. And I've really
- 59:12enjoyed doing that. So the only way we can do
- 59:15that is if these movies are available for purchase.
- 59:17And at least to obtain them. And some of them
- 59:21aren't. White Parade is a perfect example where
- 59:23there is a DVD, but it's only at UCLA. And that
- 59:26wouldn't have been available if they didn't have
- 59:28the belief in restoration and preservation that
- 59:31they do. So huge opportunity. I'm so glad you
- 59:34have the chance to do that. I wish I could go
- 59:36with you. It'll be just the first trip that you
- 59:39take. And I'll join you on the next one. And
- 59:42I've been to the Academy Museum before. I'm still
- 59:44extremely jealous that you're going without me.
- 59:46So I'm vicariously living through you. And I
- 59:50can't wait to see the updates on socials. I do
- 59:52hope I get some pictures outside of socials.
- 59:54Oh, yeah, yeah. You'll get all the ones of me,
- 59:56like, doing the scary movie face in front of,
- 59:58like, the ruby slippers. Just like, look where
- 1:00:00I am. Okay, I'm glad you clarified, because I
- 1:00:04did think for a second you were talking about
- 1:00:05the YouTube, like, pog. Like, when you say scary
- 1:00:07movie, like, just you pointing. I'll do that,
- 1:00:11too. Why not? I know you will. There's some things
- 1:00:13I'm waiting for you to see for you to be like.
- 1:00:15So we'll get there. But that's super cool. Make
- 1:00:17sure you follow Once More Time at the Oscars
- 1:00:19on Instagram and check us out. Follow on Patreon
- 1:00:23for any specific episodes that come out of it
- 1:00:26that is additional content maybe of your experience
- 1:00:29overall. For sure. Maybe we'll release two episodes,
- 1:00:33one for the White Parade and then just also a
- 1:00:35recap of your trip. Maybe that'll be one. Yeah,
- 1:00:37that'd be a fun little bonus episode. We'll see.
- 1:00:38I like that. Yeah, but stay tuned for all of
- 1:00:41that. Really looking forward to it. Wish me a
- 1:00:45happy flight home, I guess. Because, yep, I should
- 1:00:48be boarding in a few hours if you're listening
- 1:00:51to this live. I just thought about having that
- 1:00:55relaxed, carefree attitude about, like, figuring
- 1:00:58out when I'm going to fly. I know this is, like,
- 1:01:00in two weeks for you or in a week and a half.
- 1:01:02But the idea of you thinking that right now,
- 1:01:04like, I wonder when my flight is. You should
- 1:01:06be on it right now. Yeah. But that's it for the
- 1:01:10Barretts of Wimple Street, which is, you know.
- 1:01:13Most interesting thing we can do for it is talk
- 1:01:15about going to California. Exactly. So, as always,
- 1:01:18I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the
- 1:01:21movies.