Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Rethinking Health Care in America
Transcript
- 0:01A big thank you to Autodesk, the sponsor of Engineering Influence at this year's convention.
- 0:06Autodesk partners with the AEC industry and its leaders to shape a more connected,
- 0:12data-driven future, empowering engineers to work more intelligently and to make
- 0:17confident decisions to drive meaningful impact.
- 0:20This enables firms to evolve, stay competitive, and deliver stronger business
- 0:25outcomes, all while designing a better world. So thank you again to Autodesk.
- 0:34Good afternoon and welcome to the Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 0:38My name is Diana O'Lear and I'm the Senior Director of Market Intelligence for
- 0:41the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:44We are coming to you live from ACEC's Annual Convention and Legislative Summit
- 0:48here in Washington, D.C.
- 0:50And today I am joined by Mark Van Elden of the Life Health Trust and Dr.
- 0:54Brian Hill of HIP Nation.
- 0:56Thank you so much for being here today. Thanks for having us. Yeah, happy to be here.
- 1:00So we're coming to you fresh live off of the general session stage from talking
- 1:04about the healthcare crisis, the cost crisis, and access crisis affecting our
- 1:09employers and employees alike.
- 1:12And so I'm here just to ask a couple questions from our healthcare experts and
- 1:16share with you what's going on in their world today. So let's get started.
- 1:19Employers are facing year-after-year increases in healthcare spending that many
- 1:23now view as unsustainable.
- 1:25Help us understand the scale of the problem. How severe has this become and
- 1:30what does the real price of health care for a typical family look today?
- 1:34Yeah, it's a real problem for the country. The economy, economic activity is
- 1:40being stifled because of this.
- 1:42In 2005, the cost of health care for a family of four was about $12,000 a year.
- 1:46Last year, it was nearly $36,000.
- 1:49So it's tripled over 20 years.
- 1:51And if we don't do anything at the same rate of growth in another 20 years,
- 1:55we'll be over $100,000 a year to provide healthcare for a family of four.
- 2:00And we just can't afford that as a country.
- 2:02And so employers in the US pay the majority of health insurance premiums for
- 2:07their employees. So they're the ones that are really paying the most for this traumatic increase.
- 2:13And it goes directly to the bottom line in that most employers are covering
- 2:18in about 75% of the health insurance premiums. Actually, ACAC firms cover on
- 2:23average a little bit more than that.
- 2:25They offer really rich benefits to their employees.
- 2:28And it goes straight to net income if these costs go up at 20%, 30%, 40% annually.
- 2:34And it impedes their ability to hire new employees, open new offices,
- 2:38and their employees are not as healthy as they could be. So it's a real problem
- 2:43for the country and the economy. Yeah, Dr. Hill.
- 2:46Yeah, no, and I agree with Mark. I mean, sadly, this is just not getting any better.
- 2:49We're on a trajectory of increasing cost. And really, the question becomes twofold.
- 2:54I mean, one, you know, where are we going to be tomorrow, to your point?
- 2:58We are going to have an unsustainable expenditure where while we say that the
- 3:01employers are paying for this, in the end, this really just comes out of the employees' pockets.
- 3:07The employer only has so much money to allocate to an employer.
- 3:11And if they're spending more and more money on their health benefits,
- 3:14then what we're going to see is that the income growth for the employees is
- 3:17just not going to be there.
- 3:19So one, we're just taking so much money out of the employees' pockets.
- 3:21The second piece is we're just getting so little in return.
- 3:24Now, there's an expense that comes not only financially from these rising costs
- 3:28in health care, but the question becomes we're losing the quality of care that
- 3:32we're actually being able to deliver to the members, to our society.
- 3:36People are getting sicker. Yeah. Costs are going up as we get more and more unhealthy.
- 3:40And the question really becomes, how do we, one, drive down cost,
- 3:44but then, two, also impact the quality of care that people are receiving? Right.
- 3:47All right. Before we jump into cost drivers, I want to kind of set the stage.
- 3:52How do you two know each other?
- 3:54How did we get together? How did this happen? Yeah. Well, it's a sort of a personal story for me.
- 4:00Last year, I tried to schedule a wellness visit with a primary care doctor.
- 4:05And I called around to about six different offices and no one could see me for six months.
- 4:11And one doctor actually had a three-month wait list.
- 4:15And so I chose that one. It was 10 o'clock in the morning. I finally get my
- 4:18appointment and I get there at 9.55.
- 4:20I fill out a stack of paperwork, about 15 pages. I wait for 20 minutes in a crowded waiting room.
- 4:26Finally get taken back to the real waiting room, which is in the doctor's.
- 4:33Examiner, an assistant or a nurse, weighed me, measured me, asked me a bunch
- 4:38of questions, like those 15 pages that I filled out and I hadn't done that.
- 4:43And then I waited for another 45 minutes.
- 4:46Finally, the doctor comes in. She was super rushed.
- 4:49She went straight to her computer, logged into the computer,
- 4:53started asking me a bunch of questions from the computer screen,
- 4:57barely even asked me about myself. I think she was in there for less than six or seven minutes.
- 5:03Told me I needed to watch my weight because I have a BMI that's one point in
- 5:08the overweight category.
- 5:09On the podcast, you can't see this, but I don't think weight has been an issue.
- 5:15And again, just sort of being a
- 5:17doctor by the numbers. And then she said I needed to get my lab work done.
- 5:21I'd been fasting all day. It was now nearly 11.30. I was starving.
- 5:25And she said, well, we can't do it today. We don't have any opening.
- 5:28So you have to come back next week to do that.
- 5:30Well, a couple of weeks later, after I had done the visit, which was one of
- 5:35the worst experiences I've ever had, I got two bills over on the kitchen counter
- 5:40waiting for me, over $700 for a wellness visit and for the lab work. out.
- 5:45And I, as the president of the trust, I just felt like the system is broken.
- 5:52The reason that the wellness visit, which should have been covered at zero cost,
- 5:56wasn't is because we had talked about, well, she had talked about some other
- 6:01things that weren't strictly wellness related.
- 6:04And again, it was just a system designed to maximize billing and revenue with
- 6:09the provider instead of actually making sure I was well.
- 6:12And so I was just absolutely my wit's end. And I thought to myself,
- 6:16you know, how many of the trust members and ACC firms are going through this on a daily basis?
- 6:21And I really made it a personal mission to do two things. One,
- 6:25I wanted to find a better doctor for myself and to find a way to make ACC member
- 6:30firms have a better experience as well.
- 6:33So I actually just started looking around and found a direct primary care provider
- 6:38close to where I live. and I signed up as a subscription. I signed up for myself
- 6:42personally and my family.
- 6:44And had an incredible experience where I got in the same day,
- 6:47spent an hour and a half with the doctor, got lab work done same day.
- 6:51It was just an incredible experience where the doctor actually got to know me.
- 6:54And I left there and I was like, I've got to try and find a way to get this
- 6:57to as many of the trust members as possible.
- 7:00And through that direct primary care provider, they knew Dr.
- 7:04Hill in Atlanta with another, he's a direct primary care provider.
- 7:08They put us in touch. And then when we rolled out the pilot program,
- 7:12we chose Houston, Dallas, Atlanta, and we've got a group in California as well.
- 7:18And Hip Nation is the provider and Dr. Hill is the founder of that.
- 7:22We've got a couple of groups in Atlanta doing it. It's been great so far.
- 7:26Dr. Hill, why don't you tell us about this new program? No, that's great. Thank you.
- 7:30And I think most of us would actually go through Mark's experience and say the same thing.
- 7:36And it's not an abnormal, unfortunate, you know, kind of experience for people.
- 7:39And- We've sort of gotten used to it. We've gotten used to it.
- 7:42I mean, it's almost like, you know, the frog in the pod, right?
- 7:43We've just kind of accepted that that's the norm.
- 7:46And we sit and take a look. And even if that were covered by the trust,
- 7:50did you get $700 of healthcare value out of that visit? Absolutely not. Not at all.
- 7:55Right? It was a meaningless interaction. And we wonder why people take a look
- 8:00and we'll talk about primary care in a second, but they take a look at primary
- 8:03care and go, it really doesn't have any value to me.
- 8:05The only time I'm going to see primary care is when I'm sick because nobody
- 8:09there is trying to help keep me well. If I can get in. If I can get in. Yeah. Right.
- 8:13Because nobody in that experience was there to make you well.
- 8:15That was not a conversation, even though it was your annual wellness exam.
- 8:18How much of that was actually about,
- 8:20wellness. And it's sort of the free market working that people are seeing no value in primary care.
- 8:25So they're going to urgent care and emergency rooms because they can actually
- 8:28get in into those. We've seen a massive increase in utilization of urgent cares.
- 8:33And yeah, it's one of those cost drivers.
- 8:37So it's a transactional process. And so what we believe and really take a look
- 8:42at in Hip Nation, and there's a movement, fortunately, going around the United
- 8:46States, is that primary care doctors are going, that's not the primary care doctor I want to be.
- 8:51And I would suspect that your primary care doctor there, that's probably not
- 8:54who she wanted to be when she thought she was going to be a doctor.
- 8:57Right, right. Right. But that's how she gets paid.
- 9:00It's what the system tells her to do.
- 9:02And so doctors are miserable, burnt out, and they just don't feel like they're
- 9:06actually fulfilled, which is why, one, we have a primary care shortage in America.
- 9:10It's not a great job description to be that kind of doctor. Right.
- 9:13And two, we see a lack of health in our society because that foundational piece
- 9:17of primary care is just empty. It's a hollow.
- 9:21And so the way we stepped in to try to go, how can we solve this medically for people?
- 9:27And the finances follow suit, is that we have physicians that have walked away
- 9:32from, we call that fee-for-service primary care,
- 9:35running people through assembly line medicine, following a dogma set of questions
- 9:40to ask somebody to make sure we're doing their proper annual wellness exam.
- 9:44Right. We go walk away from that. Stop seeing 25 people a day.
- 9:48Stop being run by an insurance company and literally just set up a practice
- 9:53where you direct contract without any insurance in the middle,
- 9:58with society, whether it's with employer groups and people like the ACC Health
- 10:02Trust or local businesses, and just pay on a monthly membership model.
- 10:07And because I get rid of all of the insurance costs, the administrative burden
- 10:13of coding and billing, we've all been in the offices where you look around and
- 10:16you have all these doors and all these people scurrying around the back.
- 10:19None of them have anything to do with providing medical care.
- 10:22And every single one of them had to do with dealing with the industry of healthcare.
- 10:25Well, and talk about how many primary care doctors are now employed by massive
- 10:29systems, because that's just how healthcare is now delivered.
- 10:34Yeah, it is the majority. And we're seeing that move rapidly.
- 10:37And we've seen that kind of change over the past decade, where there's been
- 10:40a rapid move of primary care, running their own practice, setting up in their
- 10:44own shop, and being bought up by hospital systems.
- 10:48And really, for the hospitals, and this is just another conversation,
- 10:50right, it is a way for them to capture downstream revenue.
- 10:54You know, the primary care doctors become a referral piece for the hospital
- 10:57systems, trying to get, kind of say, butts in the bed. Hospitals get paid by
- 11:01having people use their services. You know, hospitals are the highest cost center for health care.
- 11:05So they're trying to capture a segment of primary care in order to get people
- 11:08to utilize their services.
- 11:10And really what's been lost in the middle, right, is the primary care doctor
- 11:14literally being focused on taking care of the patient.
- 11:18And we're trying to get that relationship back again by completely separating
- 11:23from that system, working directly with employers and individuals and going,
- 11:28let's work outside of the insurance industry. Let us just take care of you.
- 11:32And the beautiful thing that happens out of that is people get healthier,
- 11:35they get well, and costs go down because healthy people become less expensive
- 11:40people for health insurance plans for an employer group.
- 11:43All right. Thank you for that. Let's get to our second question.
- 11:46When we talk about rising costs, who or what is actually driving them and what
- 11:50are the biggest cost drivers employers should understand?
- 11:54Yeah. So it's a complicated problem. I said this earlier, but pretty much everyone's
- 12:01to blame, doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical
- 12:03companies, health insurance companies, employers, employees.
- 12:07And then regulatory as well.
- 12:09We have a patchwork of insurance regulations state by state,
- 12:14you have government interventions through Medicare, Medicaid, Pricare.
- 12:18It's such an enormous problem that's now one-fifth of the U.S. economy.
- 12:22And there's so much spending going on.
- 12:26And there's a lot of fraud, waste, and abuse as well that is very hard to quantify.
- 12:34So when you put it all together, everyone's to blame, which makes it a really,
- 12:38really tough problem to solve.
- 12:40Understood. Dr. Hill? Incentives. Incentives are a big problem.
- 12:44And maybe I'll throw a bunch of people under the bus here because I never mind doing that.
- 12:50So the insurance industry. The insurance industry makes money generally on something
- 12:55called medical loss ratio. We'll get a little nerdy here. Okay.
- 12:58So on a majority of the insurance companies' health insurance plans,
- 13:03the insurance company is allowed
- 13:04to make anywhere from 15% to 20% based on health insurance premium.
- 13:09If a company is making a percentage on a premium and the premium is reflective
- 13:13of healthcare costs, what is their goal with regards to healthcare costs, have them go up.
- 13:19Because the more expensive healthcare is, the more money that they have to put
- 13:22into premium, and the more the premium is, the greater return that is for an
- 13:27insurance company. Right.
- 13:28Yeah, I would actually push back a little bit on that. We'll fight a little bit on these.
- 13:33I go to depend on interest a little bit. So, out of that 15% that they take,
- 13:38so 5% is usually a commission to a broker.
- 13:41Okay. 2% of that is taxes and fees to state and regulatory companies.
- 13:47You know, overseers and the rest is for administration, which is still a big chunk.
- 13:52I mean, but back to the medical loss ratio, one of the things the Affordable
- 13:56Care Act did is sort of capped that loss ratio. It had to be 85% large groups
- 14:01and 80% of the small groups.
- 14:03And so what happened? Well, a lot of health insurance companies vertically integrated.
- 14:07I mean, most people don't realize that the number one employer of physicians
- 14:11in the United States is a health insurance company.
- 14:13So what happened is they said, well, if you pay doctors that you own,
- 14:16that sort of counts towards the spending.
- 14:19And so we've seen a shift. Like if you actually look at profitability on loss
- 14:23ratio, if you just look at that pure model, profitability is generally less than 1%.
- 14:28But if you own the doctors and you own the pharmaceutical benefit manager,
- 14:32then now you see the other side of the profit center. So vertical integration
- 14:36has definitely been a factor in the rising costs as well.
- 14:41But then on the other side the providers are vertically integrating you know
- 14:44they're buying up the physicians as well so it's sort of like,
- 14:47there's been a lot of consolidation and there's some legislation out there like
- 14:51the breakup big medicine act that's that's really looking at this it's very interesting to see
- 14:56that senator warren and josh hawley they're they're teaming up on something
- 14:59that's a very interesting pair so we're watching that closely and very curious
- 15:03to see what the outcome of that is but yeah that's my my defense of.
- 15:07The insurance it's just that there's Health insurance, if you're just a pure
- 15:10health insurance company, it's actually extremely unprofitable.
- 15:14But that's why you saw a lot of the big health insurance companies consolidate
- 15:19and buy more of the delivery of care because the delivery is where a lot of the profit is.
- 15:24So I want to talk about a couple of things that we didn't get a chance to when
- 15:27we were in GLP ones. Well, let's go there in one second. I want to talk about
- 15:31prescription drugs and the rising costs and the trend, the utilization rates.
- 15:36I attended an event recently and it was Politico hosted it.
- 15:40And Mark Cuban was there and he was talking about his cost class drug.
- 15:43And the reason I bring it up is because you're talking about the middleman.
- 15:46It seems like this middleman keeps capturing a lot of this revenue and profit
- 15:50and it's driving up costs for everybody else.
- 15:52And so, do you know anything about his program? What's he doing?
- 15:55Can you talk to it? Yeah. So, you know, what Mark Cuban is doing,
- 16:00I think he's definitely on the right track there.
- 16:03The fact is we have a system where, you know, I think pharmaceutical benefit
- 16:07managers definitely play a role.
- 16:12And some of the formulary decisions that insurance companies make are probably
- 16:18not as transparent as they should be.
- 16:21But at the end of the day, as much as pharmaceutical benefit managers have questions
- 16:27around the value they're bringing.
- 16:30A certain drug that is maybe $1,000 a month in England is still $30,000 a month here.
- 16:37Wow. And the pharmaceutical benefit manager isn't really to blame for that as
- 16:44much as the manufacturer is.
- 16:46Okay. So, again, the PBM, pharmaceutical benefit manager, There's probably some
- 16:51role there for them to improve, but it really is the manufacturer demanding
- 16:57extremely high prices for drugs in this country.
- 17:00And it's very unfair to Americans that of the trillion dollars of pharmaceutical
- 17:06expense annually worldwide, we account for $670 billion of it,
- 17:11even though we're only 20% of the total prescriptions and 4% of the world's population.
- 17:15So there needs to be a rebalancing that across the way that the pricing is in
- 17:20industrialized countries. And I would like to see the U.S.
- 17:25Do a little bit more about that. Okay. Thoughts?
- 17:29I would throw out there that we certainly write more prescriptions than anybody
- 17:32else in the world. We wrote 3.5 billion prescriptions in America last year.
- 17:36That's up 35% over the past decade.
- 17:39What we're seeing, though, as a result of that, still rising chronic disease.
- 17:43So, it's really not solving the problem. It's not helping.
- 17:46And a big part of the problem that I see out of this is that we're,
- 17:49as a healthcare system, failing miserably and actually trying to step in and
- 17:53inhibit the process of preventable chronic diseases.
- 17:58And we should be focusing on deprescribing as opposed to prescribing.
- 18:01Yeah. I actually remember listening to a speech of one of the FDA commissioners about 10 years ago.
- 18:09He was saying that if you feel really bad all the time and you're on eight,
- 18:13nine different medications, you need to get those coordinated because we don't
- 18:19study how nine different drugs interact with each other.
- 18:22At best, maybe two. And once you start adding...
- 18:25I mean, there are people on nine drugs a day. I mean, it is incredible.
- 18:29And so we have a real prescribing issue that I think it's because we have fragmented
- 18:34care, not enough primary care doctors involved in the process.
- 18:39And multiple specialists prescribing that one thing for that illness without
- 18:42looking at the whole picture.
- 18:44I think probably the problem also ties into the fact that a primary care doctor,
- 18:47when that's your annual wellness exam that you just explained earlier,
- 18:51none of that was actually sitting down and going, hey, Mark,
- 18:54how do we sit down and really look at maintaining your health, your wellness?
- 18:58How do we try to make sure you exercise better, eat better? I know you're overweight. Yeah, exactly.
- 19:04But how do we actually keep you well so that we don't need to be prescribing you bad as since.
- 19:09When primary care doctors, to your point, are spending seven minutes with the
- 19:12patient, most of the time they're spending putting records into an electronic medical record.
- 19:17They're really just prescribing rather than actually engaging and treating.
- 19:21Another thing about the electronic medical record, I mean, doctors are spending
- 19:24on average about three and a half hours per day just in an electronic medical
- 19:27record. But take prescribing.
- 19:30How many times has a doctor prescribed electronically? It's to that CVS on the wrong street.
- 19:35Now they have to go back in and send you another one. You know,
- 19:37the days You just get a pad and take it wherever you want and get the best price.
- 19:40And, you know, it's just we've come a long way under the guise of efficiency.
- 19:43And yet, it's sort of made it a lot harder for people. So, I always thought
- 19:48that was something we didn't talk enough about. Yeah.
- 19:51I couldn't agree more. All right, I'm going to go to our last question,
- 19:54GLP-1s. There's a lot of attention on them right now, both for diabetes and
- 19:58weight loss and, of course, other health benefits.
- 20:01How should employers think about coverage, cost, side effects,
- 20:04and long-term implications?
- 20:06So I'll give you the sort of the administrative overview and then Dr.
- 20:12Gil can talk to the medical side of things. So a couple of years ago,
- 20:16GLP-1s were coming and we had utilization.
- 20:20First of all, the trust and most health insurance plans don't cover it for weight
- 20:24loss unless it's sort of required from a regulatory standpoint.
- 20:27But they do cover it for type 2 diabetes. And what we're seeing is that those
- 20:32two things do overlap, that a lot of people with type 2 diabetes are also overweight.
- 20:36In the last year, it became the number one drug, increasing costs by tens of millions of dollars.
- 20:42A couple of things we've noticed from the data early on. First of all.
- 20:45Most people that start GLP-1s after three months stop taking them.
- 20:49So that to me was a very interesting statistic.
- 20:53Second thing is that after people start taking GLP-1s and they stay on them,
- 20:57the healthcare costs actually increase, even when you exclude the cost of the
- 21:01GLP-1s subsequent to starting. So that's more specialist visits,
- 21:04urgent care visits, emergency room visits.
- 21:07There are a lot of, there can be some complications with them.
- 21:10But one thing we do know from what we're seeing is that they absolutely help people lose weight.
- 21:15I think what I'm more interested in long-term is, are there long-term side effects?
- 21:20What happens when you start them and stop them?
- 21:23And, you know, I also worry about the costs. I mean, there's a lot of movement on the costs right now.
- 21:29But remember, they're not covered in most cases for weight loss.
- 21:33If that were to be mandated, there would be less of incentive for the GLP-1
- 21:37producers to keep costs relatively low.
- 21:41And still, even if it's $200 a month, which is what we're seeing on TrumpRx
- 21:45or even $500 a month, that's still $6,000 a year, which is still a lot of money
- 21:51for a drug you're taking every month.
- 21:52So I'm concerned in the long run around costs of it. But Dr.
- 21:56Hill will give you the medical response.
- 21:58Yeah, I'll give you two pieces on that, I think, on the medical side.
- 22:01Certainly, I carry a lot of concern about what these drugs are going to do to our bodies long term.
- 22:06We have got some short-term data right now that we're seeing increasing.
- 22:09We call it gastroparesis, a bit of a paralysis of the GI system.
- 22:14Never a good thing when you use the word paralysis referring to our body.
- 22:18We're seeing increasing lean muscle mass loss.
- 22:20So what we're doing is that 40% of the weight loss is coming from lean muscle.
- 22:25So we're getting people skinnier, but they're getting frail.
- 22:28Skinny and frail is probably not a great combination. And then we're also seeing,
- 22:31and just had a study recently came out showing increasing risk of osteoporosis.
- 22:35So the bone density is getting weak. So we're hurting the physical structure
- 22:39of our body in order to try to help knock off weight.
- 22:43So I worry about what that looks like. And we're early in this process of GLP-1s.
- 22:47What is this going to look like if people are on these GLP-1s for a long period of time?
- 22:51It's a real mass experiment.
- 22:54There's a lot of people on them. And, you know, there may be some benefits to being trained,
- 23:01thinner than being overweight, but at a lot cost to other parts of your body
- 23:07is sort of the unknown from my standpoint.
- 23:10Yeah. And I'll throw one other piece on that. I mean, I think the other piece
- 23:13on that, if we take a look at the trajectory of our society in America,
- 23:17and we take a look over the past 20 years, we've seen a doubling of obesity,
- 23:23in America over that time frame.
- 23:24We've had about 19.3% of Americans were considered to be obese in 1990.
- 23:29We're up to 45% today.
- 23:3166% are obese and overweight, if we put that as a classification.
- 23:35I'm one of them. Two out of three. Yeah, exactly. We got GLP-1 around the corner
- 23:39for you. But if I look back and go, okay, in 1990, did we have a deficiency of GLP-1?
- 23:47No, we're doing fine. I mean, granted, 20% of people being obese is probably
- 23:51not great, but it wasn't a problem of us not having, you know, GLP-1 to treat them.
- 23:57It was a shift in society that now we have this level of obesity and we're trying
- 24:02to solve it with a band-aid of a drug, as opposed to getting back to a root cause analysis.
- 24:08You know, maybe we really need to empower medicine and people to join together
- 24:14to go, let's really, truly impact your health and your wellness.
- 24:18Let's spend time together. Let's create trust and relationships.
- 24:22Let's create accountability between a doctor and their patient to go,
- 24:26let's walk together to actually really truly help you live well through lifestyle modification.
- 24:33And that's the pathway towards long-term wellness. Because wellness,
- 24:38right, is how do I live long? How do I live well? How am I productive through my lifetime?
- 24:42And well, it doesn't come at the pen putting somebody's side, you know. Right.
- 24:47All right. Well, that's about all the time we have for today.
- 24:50Mark, Dr. Hill, thank you very much for joining me. Thanks for having us.
- 24:52Thank you. Appreciate it.
- 24:53And thank you for joining another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 24:57My name is Diana O'Lear. See you next time.