Latest / Comeback Project: Human strength, healing & change / Why Your Burnt Cookies Are Actually a Win: Embracing Culinary Failure | Comeback Project
Transcript
- I burned three batches of cookies last night and ate them anyway, standing alone in my kitchen at midnight. It was the most honest thing I’ve done all week. Let me tell you exactly how that happened. I had this vision in my head. You know the one. It’s that glossy, Pinterest-perfect image where everything looks effortless. Golden edges, soft centers, a sprinkle of sea salt that catches the light just right. I wanted to make something beautiful. Something that said, 'Look, Yasmin. Look what I can do.' So I went to the store. I bought the good vanilla beans. The expensive chocolate chips. The butter that costs more than my hourly wage, which is ironic because I’m talking about financial stress while buying luxury ingredients. But here’s the thing about these visions. They don’t account for reality. Reality is a distracted mind. Reality is a phone buzzing with an email from your boss while the oven timer is counting down. Reality is trying to remember if you already added the baking soda or if you’re guessing. I followed the recipe. Or at least, I thought I did. But when I opened the oven door, there wasn’t golden perfection. There was smoke. Not a little wisp, but a thick, gray cloud that triggered the alarm. And then, silence. Just the hum of the refrigerator and the sound of my own heart beating a little too fast. I looked at those blackened discs on the tray. They weren’t just burnt. They were ruined. And in that moment, I felt a surge of shame so sharp it almost physical. It wasn’t just about cookies. It was about the gap between who I am and who I think I should be. We live in a culture that glorifies the final product but erases the process. We scroll through feeds of people who seem to have mastered life. They bake sourdough on day one. They paint watercolors without spilling a drop. They write novels in a weekend. It makes us feel like failures before we’ve even started our own mornings. But let’s breathe into that for a second. That image you see? It’s a highlight reel. It’s not the whole story. Behind every perfect loaf of bread is a dozen dense bricks. Behind every stunning painting are crumpled pieces of paper thrown in the trash. We are taught that if it doesn’t look perfect immediately, it’s wrong. It’s bad. It’s a sign that we aren’t good at this, whatever 'this' is. Maybe it’s cooking. Maybe it’s parenting. Maybe it’s starting a new job or learning a language. We equate competence with immediate success. If I try it and it tastes bad, I must be incompetent. If I try it and it looks ugly, I must be unskilled. This is a lie. A dangerous, exhausting lie. Competence isn’t about never failing. It’s about what you do after the failure happens. It’s about the willingness to stand in the wreckage of your expectations and decide what comes next. When we refuse to accept that things might taste bad, we rob ourselves of the joy of discovery. We stop trying new things because we’re terrified of looking foolish. And in doing so, we keep our lives small, safe, and incredibly boring. So, what did I do with those burnt cookies? Did I throw them out? Did I call a friend and cry about my culinary inadequacy? No. I sat at my counter. I picked up one of the charred circles. It was hard as a rock. I took a bite. It tasted like ash and regret. And then... I took another bite. Why? Because I was hungry. And because I realized that throwing them away would have been an act of violence against myself. It would have been saying, 'This mistake is too big to exist.' Instead, I ate them. All three batches. It wasn’t enjoyable. It was actually quite unpleasant. But it was mine. I made a mess. I tried something new. And I accepted the result. That is resilience. Resilience isn’t bouncing back to being happy and fine. Resilience is sitting in the discomfort of 'it didn’t work' and staying there until you figure out what you need. It’s acknowledging that you are still worthy of nourishment, even when your efforts fail. You don’t have to be fixed to be whole. You don’t have to have the perfect recipe to deserve a meal. This applies to so much more than food. Think about the conversations you’ve had that went poorly. The emails you sent that sounded too harsh. The projects you launched that flopped. We tend to want to delete those moments. We want to scrub them from existence. But they are part of your story. They are evidence that you showed up. You attempted. You engaged with the world. And sometimes, the world says, 'That didn’t go well.' And that’s okay. It’s not the end. It’s just data. It’s information. It’s not a verdict on your soul. There is a specific kind of bravery required to try something new and accept that it might be terrible. Most people never get past the fear. They stay in the realm of 'I’ll try it someday.' They curate their lives to avoid any possibility of embarrassment. They only cook recipes they’ve made ten times. They only wear clothes they know fit perfectly. They only speak in meetings when they have the absolute right answer. This is a survival strategy. It keeps us safe. But it also keeps us stuck. To try a new recipe is to admit vulnerability. It’s to say, 'I don’t know if I can do this yet.' It’s to trust that even if I fail, I will survive. I will still be able to eat. I will still be loved. I will still be enough. This bravery is quiet. It doesn’t come with applause. No one claps when you burn the cookies. No one sends you a trophy for eating them. But there is a deep, internal satisfaction in knowing you didn’t run away. You faced the awkwardness. You faced the imperfection. You stayed. And in that staying, you built a muscle. You built the ability to handle disappointment. You learned that your worth is not tied to the outcome of your actions. It’s tied to your presence. Your willingness to participate in your own life. Even when it’s messy. Especially when it’s messy. This is the antidote to perfectionism. Perfectionism tells you that if you can’t do it right, don’t do it at all. Courage whispers, 'Do it badly. Do it imperfectly. Just do it.' Because doing it badly is infinitely better than not doing it at all. It’s the difference between a blank canvas and a painted one. One has potential. The other has texture. It has history. It has life. After I finished those cookies, I cleaned up the kitchen. I scraped the black bits off the tray. I washed the bowls. I put the good vanilla beans back in the cupboard. And I smiled. Not because I liked the taste, but because I felt lighter. The pressure was off. I had tried. I had failed. I had eaten the failure. And the sun came up the next morning. Nothing catastrophic had happened. My life hadn’t ended. In fact, I felt more connected to myself than I had in weeks. I stopped pretending to be someone I’m not. I allowed myself to be a beginner again. Beginners are funny. They make mistakes. They ask stupid questions. They use the wrong tools. But they are also full of wonder. They are curious. They are open. When we let go of the need to be experts, we rediscover the joy of play. We start experimenting. We try weird flavor combinations. We cook without measuring. We laugh when things go wrong. We stop taking ourselves so seriously. This episode is a reminder to give yourself permission to be a novice. To allow yourself to be bad at things. To let your first attempts be ugly. Let them taste bad. Let them look strange. Let them be awkward. And then, let yourself enjoy the process anyway. Because the process is where the magic happens. The outcome is just a bonus. If you can find joy in the trying, you will never be defeated by the result. You will always be moving forward. Always growing. Always becoming. So tonight, if you’re feeling stuck, if you’re feeling like you’re falling short, remember the burnt cookies. Remember that you can eat them. Remember that you are still sweet, even when you’re a little charred on the outside. You are still worthy. You are still loved. And you are still here. Keep going. Breathe into that. What does resilience look like on a Tuesday? It looks like eating the burnt cookie and deciding to try again tomorrow. Thank you for spending this time with me. Be gentle with yourself today. You’re doing better than you think. Until next time, I’m Yasmin Mayo. Take care.