Latest / NEURO MOTION LAB / Mini season NML Episode 7- Overthinking- When Analysis Blocks Action
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to Neuro Motion Lab, where we explore the fascinating
- 0:14intersection of neuroscience and athletic performance.
- 0:17I'm Fabio Gida, Physical Therapist, trainer, mental
- 0:21performance coach and I'm passionate about helping
- 0:24athletes like you to reach your full potential.
- 0:39Hello, hello, hello, and welcome to Neuromotion Lab podcast.
- 0:44The space where the mind and the body work together to obtain the
- 0:48best results. My name is Fabian Gida and today
- 0:53we're going to talk about something that affects athletes,
- 0:56professionals, artists and high performance people in
- 1:00practically all areas of life. It is something that is often
- 1:07confused with intelligence, with preparation or with
- 1:11responsibility. But when it becomes excessive,
- 1:15it's transformed into a one of the most frequencies causes of
- 1:20paralysis in human performance. Today we're talking about the
- 1:25phenomenon of thinking too much, of overthinking, or putting more
- 1:34directly when analysis ends up blocking action.
- 1:40We live in a culture of that enormously value of thoughts,
- 1:45analyzing, planning, anticipating, evaluating
- 1:49scenarios, all of that is fundamental for decision making.
- 1:54The human brain evolved precisely for that, to simulate
- 1:59the future for disease risk and find solution before the
- 2:06problems occur. But there is a point where this
- 2:10mechanism, which was originally designed to protect us, start to
- 2:16play against us. Because a moment comes when
- 2:20thinking more no longer produce clarity.
- 2:23It's produced noise. And when the mental noise exceed
- 2:28a certainly threshold, the system lost its fluidity and a
- 2:34very particular sensation appears, knowing exactly what we
- 2:39must to done, but not being able to do it.
- 2:46To understand this we have to look into the architecture of
- 2:50the brain. One of the most important
- 2:53structures in this process is the prefrontal cortex,
- 2:56especially the dorsal lateral region.
- 2:59This area of brain is responsible for planning,
- 3:03decision making, evaluate consequence and cognitive
- 3:07control. It is in a sense the director of
- 3:11the brain. Thanks to it, we can imagine the
- 3:15future, compare possible scenarios and evaluate risk.
- 3:19But the prefrontal cortexes have two fundamental corrected
- 3:22exists. It's a metabolic and expensive.
- 3:25It's consumes a lot of energy and its processing speed is
- 3:30relatively slow compared to other system of the brain that
- 3:34operate automatically. When a person start to analyze
- 3:38too many variables at the same time, prefrontal activity
- 3:42increase significantly. The systems try to reduce and
- 3:46certainly by reviewing the available information over and
- 3:53over, looking for signals to allow for the correct decision.
- 3:59The problem is that in most real situations our 7D never
- 4:04disappear completely. There is always a margin of
- 4:08doubts and when the brain tries to eliminate the dot before
- 4:13acting, it's entered in a cognitive fit but cycle known as
- 4:18paralysis by analysis. While the prefrontal cortex
- 4:23tried to control the situation, other structures being to be
- 4:27affected, the busser gangler, which are responsible for
- 4:31automation of motor and behavioral patterns start to
- 4:35receive contradictory signals. This instructors works as a
- 4:42action selected system. They're filtered multiple motor
- 4:47options and facilitates the execution of most appropriate on
- 4:51each moment. But when the prefrontal quarters
- 4:55in terms excessively, the automatic process is
- 5:00interrupted. What once was a fluid pattern
- 5:05now becomes fragmented, movements lose rhythm,
- 5:09coordination is alterated and feeling of clumsiness appears
- 5:16that often confuse the person it is of.
- 5:20If a musician were playing a piece perfectly learned on the
- 5:25piano and suddenly someone sat next to them and start to
- 5:30talking, hey now think consciously about your every
- 5:33finger that you are going to move.
- 5:36What was when fluid music become a slow and forced sequence of
- 5:41movements? A useful analogy is to imagine
- 5:46the brain works like an orchestra, the basaglenga and
- 5:50the cerebellum carrying the rhythm of the music, allowing
- 5:53the execution to be natural and coordinated.
- 5:56The prefrontal quarters plays the role of the conductor who
- 6:01organized the piece before the concert start.
- 6:04But if the conductor were prefrontal cortex decide to
- 6:08interrupt the music every two seconds to correct each
- 6:12individual musician, the orchestral loss continued to be
- 6:16the music. The music stopped flowing.
- 6:20Something very similar happened with the cerebellum.
- 6:23For a long time it was thought that the cerebellum only
- 6:27participate in motor coordination, but today we know
- 6:31it's also plays a fundamental role in prediction and timing of
- 6:36action. The surveillance anticipate the
- 6:39censorious consequence of the movement before the movement
- 6:43occurs. It is a sort of rapid simulation
- 6:46system that adjusts the body in real time when prefrontal
- 6:51activity becomes dominant. What predictive circuits lose
- 6:55efficient? The result is a loss of
- 6:58synchrony between intention and execution.
- 7:03In parallel something interest happen at the neurochemical
- 7:07level. The increase in sustained
- 7:11cognitive activity is associated with a higher release of
- 7:15glutamate in the prefrontal network.
- 7:18Glutamate is the main excessatory neurotransmitter of
- 7:21the brain and allows the precision of complex
- 7:25information. But when is activated is is too
- 7:30long and for a long time with periods of no regulation, the
- 7:34system enters in at a state of hyper excitation.
- 7:39This journaling mental fatigue difficult to change in a
- 7:42strategy and tendency to repeat the same thought patterns.
- 7:48At the same time, the dopamine system actively participate.
- 7:53Dopamine regulates motivation, the evaluation of value, and the
- 7:58selection of action. When the brains tries to decide
- 8:02between multiple options, dopamine helps estimate
- 8:06probabilities and possible results.
- 8:10But when the numbers of scenarios become excessive, the
- 8:14dopamine signals loss precision. The brain has stopped having
- 8:18clarity on which option is truly better, and the decision is
- 8:24delayed. The anterior singulate Cortez
- 8:28also participate. This region is involving in
- 8:32error detection and conflict monitoring.
- 8:37When the brain perceives too many options or too many
- 8:41possible consequence, this structure increase its activity.
- 8:46Trying to resolve the conflict between the alternatives.
- 8:50The system gets trapped in a sort of permanent cognitive
- 8:53vigilance, looking for signs that a decision might be
- 8:58incorrect. But overthinking is not only a
- 9:03neurobiological phenomenon, it's also has a deeper psychological
- 9:09dimension. Many people believe they think
- 9:13too much because they are very analytically, but in reality
- 9:19many times they think too much because their nervous system is
- 9:23trying to avoid an emotional experience.
- 9:28Analysis become a protection strategy in those cases.
- 9:34People have this kind of thoughts.
- 9:36If I analyze everything enough, maybe I can avoid being wrong.
- 9:41Or if I can think a bit more, maybe I can avoid failure.
- 9:47Or if I reveal all variables, maybe I can avoid feeling shame
- 9:54or losing control behind overthinking something is pretty
- 10:00human. Often appears the fear of being
- 10:03run in front of others, the fear of judgement, the fear of
- 10:08failing. When a person has lived through
- 10:11experience of intense criticism, humiliation, or public failure,
- 10:17the brain learns quickly that being run can be painful, and
- 10:23then it's a development strategy to avoid the pain.
- 10:27One of those strategies is cognitive hyper control, or what
- 10:33we talk today over thinking. The person is trying to
- 10:37anticipate everything, analyze every possibility, prepare every
- 10:43scenario. But that attempt at absolute
- 10:47control has an enormous cost, because real life always contain
- 10:53uncertainty, and when the brain tries to completely eliminate
- 10:58uncertainty before acting, it's an app paralysis itself.
- 11:04Let's imagine this scenario. Someone has to send an important
- 11:08e-mail or a delicate message. The person write the message,
- 11:13rereads it, change the phrase, reads it again, the latest award
- 11:19adds another, review the tone again and ask themselves how the
- 11:24other person will interpret it. If will sound too direct, too
- 11:29cold or too emotional, then they decide to modify it again. 10
- 11:35minute pass, then 20. The measure was already clear
- 11:39from the beginning, but the mind keeps trying to anticipate all
- 11:44possible reaction of the receiver in that moment.
- 11:48The brain is trying to completely eliminate uncertainty
- 11:53before acting. It wants to ensure the other
- 11:57person understand it exactly and as a was intended, that they're
- 12:05not misunderstanding and that is not don't generate negative
- 12:10reaction. But it is impossible to
- 12:14completely control how the other person will react.
- 12:18The analysis process can continue indefinitely.
- 12:22So something that could be resolving in 30 seconds end up
- 12:27taking half an hour and many times the person ends up sending
- 12:33a message very similar to the one they have written in the 1st
- 12:3910 seconds. This show something very
- 12:43important many times. The problem is not that we don't
- 12:49know what we do, the problem is that we want to have too much
- 12:55certainty before doing it. Many people don't actually fear
- 13:00the mistake. They fear the emotion that
- 13:05appear after the mistake, the fear of feeling shame,
- 13:09frustration or expose. So the minds try to avoid that
- 13:15emotion by keeping the system in permanent analysis.
- 13:19But this strategy has a paradoxical effect.
- 13:23The more the minds try to avoid a mistake, the further its get
- 13:29from the direct experience and the further this gets from the
- 13:34direct experience, the more it losses the capacity to
- 13:38adaptation. At this point a central concept
- 13:42for Neuro Motion Lab approach appears, the concept of
- 13:47interception. Interception is the capacity of
- 13:50the brain to perceive the internal state of the body.
- 13:54This function is mediated mainly by the insula, a region that
- 13:59integrates signals coming from the cardiovascular, respiratory,
- 14:04visceral, and muscle system. The insula constantly informs
- 14:12the brain about how the organ is filled when a person is trapping
- 14:18and overthinking, cognitive activity dominates the
- 14:21conscience experience and corporal perception is reduce
- 14:25it. Breathing becomes shallow,
- 14:28muscle tone increase, the autonomic nervous system learns
- 14:34tour sympathetic activation and the body begins to send signals
- 14:40of tension. Paradoxically, the more the
- 14:45minds try to control the situation, the more is
- 14:48disconnected from the signal that could help to solve it.
- 14:54In a sport, this is observed with great clarity.
- 14:59An athlete who has processed repeated a movement 1000 times
- 15:04possess an extremely refined personal memory.
- 15:08The moment listen the Bashel Ganglers and the cerebellum, but
- 15:13under pressure, when the athletes start to analyze every
- 15:17detail of the gesture, the prefrontal cordes invite a
- 15:21territory that should remain automatic.
- 15:25And then something happened that many athletes know very well.
- 15:30The movement that was always natural suddenly becomes rigid,
- 15:36slow and fragmented. But this doesn't only happen in
- 15:42the sport, my friends. It's happened when a person
- 15:45tries to speak in public and start to analyze every word
- 15:50before say it. It happened when someone must
- 15:53take an important decision and spend hours and hours reviewing
- 15:57possible scenarios without moving forward.
- 16:01It happened. When thoughts becomes an attempt
- 16:05to control the future, Well, like it's usual in this channel,
- 16:10we provide you with a practical tools to serve overthinking.
- 16:17The answer I tell you what I have is not to stop thinking.
- 16:22Thoughts is an extraordinary tool.
- 16:26The key is to restore balance between thoughts and sensation,
- 16:32that means between mind and body.
- 16:36Here are some practical tools that you can apply.
- 16:39First, conscious breathing. When a person performs a slow
- 16:44inhalation followed by prolonged exhalation, the parasympathetic
- 16:49savings system is activate and the excessive activity of the
- 16:54prefrontal cortex decrease. 3 or 4 cycles of deep breathing can
- 17:01bring reduce the state of cognitive hyperactivation. 2
- 17:07movement. When the body moves, brain
- 17:10activity is redistributed. Walking, shaking your arms,
- 17:15changing your posture, or performing rhythm movements help
- 17:20reactivate sensory motor circuit that integrate body perception
- 17:25with action. Three time limits The brain
- 17:30needs structural containment. When a person decide in advance
- 17:35how much time they are going to dedicated to analysis, they
- 17:39avoid falling into our endless cycles of thoughts. 4 Change the
- 17:46focus of attention. Instead of directing attention
- 17:50through yourself, through every detail of your own movement or
- 17:57thoughts, it's often more effective to direct attention
- 18:01toward the environment. External focus improves
- 18:06coordination and movement. Efficient. 5 Interreceptive
- 18:11check. Make a pause and ask what is
- 18:15happening in my body right now, where I feel the tension, how
- 18:21I'm breathing. This simple gesture reactivates
- 18:25the insula and return fundamental information to the
- 18:29brain. Fox is one of the most
- 18:32extraordinary capacities of the human brain.
- 18:36Thanks to it, we develop it science, technology and culture.
- 18:41But Fox was never designed to replace directed experience.
- 18:47The human brain evolved to thinks, fill and move at the
- 18:52same time. When one of the system dominates
- 18:55the other, imbalance appear. Thinking too much is often a
- 19:00sign that the system has lost confidence in its own automatic
- 19:06intelligence, that intelligence that allows the body to adapt,
- 19:11correct and learn in movement. Perhaps the true learning is not
- 19:16thinking more or thinking less. But remember that thoughts is
- 19:23only one part of the system. Clarity do not always appear
- 19:27when we analyze more. Sometimes it appear when we
- 19:32breathe, when we talk, when we walk, when we feel the body
- 19:37again. Because the brain can imagine
- 19:41thousands of possible futures. But the body always lives in the
- 19:46present, and it is in that present where the action finally
- 19:54occurs. Well, well, well, what a episode
- 19:57today, my friends, isn't it? Because when we understand this,
- 20:01something changed deeply. We stop trying to solve our
- 20:07whole life inside of our heads and we start to trust again in
- 20:13intelligence of the complete system.
- 20:18If you know someone who tends to overthinking everything, share
- 20:21this episode with them. And if you aren't subscribe it
- 20:25yet, please subscribe it to No Emotional App Podcast on
- 20:29Spotify, on Apple Podcasts and also on Amazon Help apps to, you
- 20:37know, reach more people to understand that human
- 20:41performance is not just a matter of strength or a discipline.
- 20:46It's a matter of deep regulation of the nervous system.
- 20:51In our next episode #8 we're going to address a very trendy
- 20:57and controversial topic, false self esteem.
- 21:02Why thinking positive is not enough?
- 21:07This was Narrow Motion live podcast.
- 21:10My name is Fabian Gida. And remember, the mind can
- 21:16analyze the path, but it's the body that finally takes that
- 21:21step. See you in the next episode.
- 21:25Bye. None.