Latest / Interfaiths / Crossroads of the Medieval Mediterranean Islam and Christianity
Transcript
- 0:00Indeed, God is beautiful and he loves beauty.
- 0:04That is a quote that hits you right at the very
- 0:07beginning of the material we're diving into today.
- 0:10It really does. It's a hadith, a saying attributed
- 0:12to the Prophet Muhammad. And honestly, it feels
- 0:16less like a strict religious instruction and
- 0:19more like, well, a universal key. It kind of
- 0:21unlocks this entire conversation we are about
- 0:24to have. Yeah, I completely agree. It sets the
- 0:26stakes immediately. Because when you hear that
- 0:29The idea that God actually is beauty. it fundamentally
- 0:32changes how you approach the physical world around
- 0:35you. Right, because making something beautiful
- 0:36isn't just, you know, interior decoration at
- 0:39that point. Exactly. It's an act of worship.
- 0:40It's an act of reaching out to the divine. And
- 0:43today we're going to see how that very specific
- 0:46drive for beauty actually managed to bridge one
- 0:49of the most hostile divides in human history.
- 0:52And hostile is definitely the operating word
- 0:54there. Because when most of us think about the
- 0:56history of the Mediterranean, specifically the
- 0:58Middle Ages, let's say from the 10th to the 16th
- 1:00century, We have a very specific, almost like
- 1:03a Hollywood movie playing in our heads. Oh, for
- 1:06sure. Lots of chainmail and dramatic speeches.
- 1:08Right. We see the Crusades. We see the Reconquista
- 1:11in Spain. We picture these glorious, bloody naval
- 1:16battles. Basically, we see a massive clash of
- 1:19civilizations. We are so conditioned to view
- 1:21the medieval relationship between Islam and Christianity
- 1:24as this perpetual binary state of war. Us versus
- 1:28them. Cross versus Crescent. Fortress Europe
- 1:31against the Islamic East. And look, I am not
- 1:34going to sit here and say, The wars didn't happen.
- 1:36Right. I mean, the violence was very real. It
- 1:38was absolutely real. But if you only look at
- 1:39the battlefields, you completely miss the actual
- 1:42texture of life. You miss the story of how people
- 1:45actually lived, how they traded, and how they
- 1:47created things together. And that is exactly
- 1:49the mission of this deep dive. We're digging
- 1:51into a really fascinating, incredibly dense collection
- 1:54of research titled The Medieval Mediterranean
- 1:57Between Islam and Christianity, Cross -Pollinations
- 2:00in Art, Architecture, and Material Culture. It's
- 2:03edited by... Sammy Luigi de Josa, and Nicolaus
- 2:06Frazidis. And let me tell you, this is not about
- 2:08how sultans fought kings. No, it really isn't.
- 2:10This is about how a bowl, a carpet, a bottle
- 2:14of oil, or even a stone column moved between
- 2:16these two supposedly separate worlds. It is about
- 2:19a concept the editors call the aesthetic space.
- 2:23I love that term, aesthetic space. It sounds
- 2:25almost sci -fi, but it is actually very grounded.
- 2:28Let's unpack this immediately before we even
- 2:30get into the physical objects. What does aesthetic
- 2:32space actually mean? mean in this context so
- 2:35think about it this way dogma you know religious
- 2:38rules strict theology political allegiance all
- 2:41of that creates borders right it creates walls
- 2:44it very clearly defines who is in and who is
- 2:47out but beauty art material refinement That creates
- 2:52what scholars in the source material call effective
- 2:54proximity. Effective proximity, meaning it brings
- 2:57people closer emotionally. Exactly. The core
- 3:00argument here is that the appreciation of beauty
- 3:02allowed these two rival faiths to intermingle
- 3:05in ways that politics just never would have permitted.
- 3:07Like a Christian could look at an Islamic textile
- 3:09and admire the weave, the color, the sheer luxury
- 3:12of it without necessarily converting to Islam
- 3:15or feeling like a traitor. Yeah. The aesthetic
- 3:17space is essentially this zone where judgment
- 3:20is suspended in favor of admiration. So beauty
- 3:23transcends all the heavy baggage. It's like a
- 3:26demilitarized zone for the eyes. That is a perfect
- 3:29analogy. A demilitarized zone for the eyes. And
- 3:33to see this zone in action, the researchers use
- 3:36a methodology called Microhistory. Microhistory.
- 3:39That sounds like we're taking a microscope to
- 3:41the historical timeline. We basically are. Instead
- 3:43of macrohistory, which deals with the grand rise
- 3:46and fall of empires and these broad, sweeping
- 3:49generalizations, we are looking at the story
- 3:51of specific, tangible objects. We're tracing
- 3:55individual choices. Like tracking a single package
- 3:58across the world, but in the 12th century. Precisely.
- 4:00We're asking questions like, why did a priest
- 4:02in Italy want a book that looked like it came
- 4:04from Cairo? Or why did a Muslim soldier... and
- 4:06built his own tomb using stones that had hardcore
- 4:09Christian theology carved right into them. That
- 4:11is wild. Right. When you zoom in that close,
- 4:14the hard borders on the map just start to dissolve.
- 4:17I feel like we are conditioned to think of these
- 4:19medieval borders as rigid iron curtains. You're
- 4:23on this side, you're safe, you cross the line,
- 4:26you are deep in enemy territory. But the medieval
- 4:29Mediterranean was just not like that. It was
- 4:31a fluid network. It was a sea of connectivity.
- 4:34As we go through these sources today, I want
- 4:37you to really try to imagine a world where a
- 4:39Christian church is decorated with Islamic bowls
- 4:42and the holiest Christian relics are wrapped
- 4:45in Muslim silks. OK, it sounds like we need to
- 4:48completely reorient our mental maps for this.
- 4:51So let's just jump right into the first segment.
- 4:53Let's talk about this aesthetic space and the
- 4:55flow of objects, because you mentioned bowls
- 4:57in churches just now. And that sounds, well,
- 4:59to a modern ear, it sounds like someone made
- 5:01a huge mistake. It really does, doesn't it? But
- 5:03it was surprisingly common. We are looking at
- 5:05research. here by Maria Bourne -Poudaki, specifically
- 5:07focusing on Venetian Crete. Okay, Crete. Right.
- 5:11Now keep in mind, Crete is this massive island,
- 5:14strategically smack in the middle of all the
- 5:16major trade routes. It's a Venetian colony at
- 5:18this time, so it is Catholic ruled, but the local
- 5:21population is largely Greek Orthodox. And on
- 5:24top of all that, it's trading constantly with
- 5:27the Islamic world. So it's the ultimate crossroads,
- 5:29a total melting pot. A total melting pot. And
- 5:33in the late medieval period, Bourne -Poudaki
- 5:35found... something fascinating in the local church
- 5:37architecture. They call them immured bacini.
- 5:40Immured bacini. Okay, I have to be honest, that
- 5:42sounds like a delicious pasta dish, but I know
- 5:44it's not. What exactly are we looking at? No
- 5:47pasta involved, unfortunately. Amir just means
- 5:49embedded in a wall. And Bacini refers to ceramic
- 5:52bowls. Got it. So picture a Christian church,
- 5:54could be Orthodox or Catholic. It has the stone
- 5:56facade, very solemn, very sturdy. But embedded
- 5:59right into the exterior walls, high up where
- 6:02everyone can see them, are these incredibly colorful,
- 6:04glazed ceramic bowls. And here's the kicker.
- 6:08Many of them are Islamic ceramics. Wait, so they're
- 6:11taking bowls like... literal dinnerware made
- 6:14by Muslims, often featuring Islamic styles and
- 6:17patterns, and they are cementing them into the
- 6:20holy walls of a Christian church. That is exactly
- 6:22what they are doing. That is crazy. We have to
- 6:25ask the obvious question then. Why? Why on earth
- 6:28would you put the supposed enemy's dinner plates
- 6:30on your literal house of worship? Was it some
- 6:33kind of power statement like we conquered you
- 6:36so we are taking your bowls as trophies? Or was
- 6:39it some progressive, hey, we're all the same
- 6:41message? It's a great question, but the research
- 6:44suggests it wasn't really theological synchronization.
- 6:46They definitely weren't trying to say Islam and
- 6:49Christianity are one. And it wasn't necessarily
- 6:51a triumphalist conquest thing either. It was
- 6:54far more practical than that. And it goes right
- 6:56back to that concept of the aesthetic space.
- 6:58Practical is what way? It was about the glazed
- 7:01versus plain aesthetics. See, local pottery in
- 7:04Crete or mainland Greece at the time was often
- 7:06unglazed. It was plain terracotta. Like a standard
- 7:09flower pot. Exactly. It was functional, matte,
- 7:11and usually just brown or dull red. But these
- 7:14Islamic bowls coming from Mamluk Egypt or later
- 7:17coming from Spain, they were glazed. They were
- 7:20incredibly shiny. They had vivid colors, deep
- 7:23blues, bright greens, and lusterware that just
- 7:26caught the Mediterranean sun perfectly. Oh. So
- 7:30it was about the bling. It was about catching
- 7:32the light. In a way, yes. It was entirely about
- 7:35visibility and status. If you are building a
- 7:38church, you want it to be beautiful. You want
- 7:40it to shine. You want it to reflect the light
- 7:42of God literally and metaphorically. These Islamic
- 7:46bowls provided color and reflection that local
- 7:49Greek materials simply could not match at the
- 7:51time. That is so interesting. Right. Because
- 7:54when that bowl crossed the sea, it lost its specific
- 7:56religious identity. People stopped seeing this
- 7:59as a Muslim bull, and it gained a completely
- 8:00new identity. This is a beautiful, expensive,
- 8:03exotic object that reflects the sun. It's like
- 8:06the object gets laundered of its ideology just
- 8:08by moving geographically. The Islamicness of
- 8:10the bull evaporates, and only the beautifulness
- 8:12remains. That's a really great way to put it.
- 8:15The aesthetic quality completely neutralizes
- 8:17the political origin. And Bourn -Poudaki's research
- 8:20really highlights Crete's role here. It wasn't
- 8:22just a Venetian outpost, it was a massive hub
- 8:25connecting Mamluk Egypt, Muslim Spain and the
- 8:29rest of Europe. These bowls are physical, cemented
- 8:32proof of a trade network that frankly did not
- 8:35care about religious wars. They cared about supply
- 8:37and demand. If the Mamluks make the shiniest
- 8:40bowls, the Christians are absolutely going to
- 8:43buy them for their churches. And I assume this
- 8:44intense trade wasn't limited to just ceramics.
- 8:47I mean, if they're embedding bowls and walls
- 8:49for the shine, what else are they trading for
- 8:51the sake of luxury? Textiles. And this is a huge
- 8:53one. We have a fascinating chapter by Anna Cabrera
- 8:55Lafuente that looks at Andalusi textiles. Now,
- 8:59Andalusi refers to Al -Andalus, which is Muslim
- 9:02Spain. Okay, Muslim Spain. High quality stuff,
- 9:04I imagine. I feel like Andalusi's silk was probably
- 9:07the Italian leather of the 13th century. It was
- 9:09the absolute gold standard. Literally, they were
- 9:11often woven with actual gold thread. But La Fuente
- 9:15points out a massive misconception in the history
- 9:18of all this. For a very long time, historians
- 9:21and museum curators would find these high -quality
- 9:23silks in European churches and just automatically
- 9:26assume, oh, it's nice, it must be from Muslim
- 9:29Spain. They labeled everything Andalusi. So they
- 9:33were giving the brand name to everything, regardless
- 9:35of whether it was actually from there or not,
- 9:37like calling every tissue a Kleenex. Exactly
- 9:40like that. It just became a generic term for
- 9:42high quality. But new research using carbon dating
- 9:44and deep technical analysis of the weave itself
- 9:47shows it is a much more complex web. These textiles
- 9:51were moving along pilgrimage routes, not just
- 9:53standard trade lines. But here is the most striking
- 9:56part of her research, and this really challenges
- 9:58that clash of civilizations narrative we talked
- 10:00about. These textiles were often used to wrap
- 10:03Christian relics. Relics? Wait, we're talking
- 10:05about the bones of saints, pieces of the true
- 10:07cross, like the holiest of the holy objects.
- 10:09The absolute holiest objects in Christianity.
- 10:12Take the San Isidoro Church in Leon, Spain, for
- 10:15example. You have these ornate reliquaries containing
- 10:18the physical remains of saints' objects that
- 10:20believers thought could literally channel divine
- 10:22power, and they are swathed in silks woven by
- 10:26Muslim artisans. Wow. And here is the detail
- 10:29that really gets me. These silks are often covered
- 10:31in Arabic calligraphy. That seems, I mean, it
- 10:34seems wildly contradictory. Did the Christians
- 10:37know? Could they read the Arabic? Sometimes yes,
- 10:39sometimes no, but often it just didn't matter.
- 10:42Again, enter the aesthetic space. The sheer quality
- 10:44of the fabric, the undeniable luxury of it, is
- 10:47what signaled reverence. You don't wrap a revered
- 10:49saint in cheap burlap. You wrap them in the absolute
- 10:52finest silk available on the market. And if the
- 10:55finest silk comes from a Muslim workshop in Granada
- 10:58or Baghdad, then that is exactly what you use.
- 11:01The sanctity of the relic required the highest
- 11:04aesthetic honor, completely regardless of who
- 11:06wove the cloth or what language was written on
- 11:08it. So the material quality completely trom -
- 11:11the religious origin it implies that being holy
- 11:14has a specific look and that look was entirely
- 11:17shared across the mediterranean that is the key
- 11:19takeaway here it challenges the whole conquest
- 11:22narrative it wasn't just we beat them and took
- 11:24their stuff it suggests a deeply shared culture
- 11:27of luxury A Christian king and a Muslim sultan
- 11:31shared the exact same taste. They both agreed
- 11:34on what power and holiness look like. And that
- 11:37look was very often Islamic in origin. The visual
- 11:40language of power in the medieval Mediterranean
- 11:42was, in many ways, an Islamic visual language.
- 11:46That connects perfectly to the next segment of
- 11:48the research. Because it's not just about pretty
- 11:50objects or luxury goods for the rich. It is about
- 11:52deeply shared knowledge. It's about the literal
- 11:55stuff you need to actually practice your religion
- 11:57on a daily basis. And this brings us to a story
- 11:59that I honestly found mind -blowing when I was
- 12:01reading the sources. The balsam of Mataria. Ah,
- 12:04yes. Hani Hamza's research. This is an absolute
- 12:07classic example of pragmatism beating dogma.
- 12:10This is where the rubber meets the road, or rather
- 12:12where the oil meets the forehead. So, set the
- 12:15scene for us. What exactly is this balsam, and
- 12:18why is it so incredibly important? So, we are
- 12:21talking about a specific type of plant, a balsam
- 12:23tree, that produced a very specific resin or
- 12:26oil. In the Christian tradition, specifically
- 12:29the Coptic and other Eastern churches, this oil
- 12:31was absolutely essential. It was used to make
- 12:34chrism, which is the holy anointing oil. Okay.
- 12:36You need chrism for baptism. You need it for
- 12:39the ordination of new priests. You need it to
- 12:41consecrate new churches. Basically, without this
- 12:44specific oil, legally speaking, within the church,
- 12:47you cannot perform the sacraments. The entire
- 12:49mechanism of Christian salvation literally grinds
- 12:52to a halt without it. OK, so incredibly high
- 12:55stakes. This isn't just nice perfume. This is
- 12:57the literal fuel for the religious engine. Very
- 13:00high stakes. But here is the massive catch. By
- 13:03the medieval period, this specific plant only
- 13:06grew effectively in one single garden in the
- 13:08entire world. Let me guess. Not in Rome. Yeah,
- 13:12no. And not in Constantinople. Not in Rome, not
- 13:14in Constantinople. It grew in Mataria, which
- 13:16was a suburb of Cairo down in Egypt. Which was
- 13:19under? Mamluk rule. Muslim rule. So the Christian
- 13:22church, in order to perform its most sacred fundamental
- 13:25rites, was entirely dependent on a supply chain
- 13:29that was totally controlled by the Muslim sultan.
- 13:31Precisely. And the Mamluks absolutely knew it.
- 13:34They controlled the production of a substance
- 13:36vital for Christian salvation. Now, if you stick
- 13:40to the traditional clash of civilizations script,
- 13:43you would think, oh, the sultan would just burn
- 13:45the garden to the ground or cut off the supply
- 13:47to cripple the Christian faith. Right. Strike
- 13:49a massive blow against the enemy. But they didn't
- 13:51do that at all. They monetized it. They absolutely
- 13:53monetized it. And they used it as a brilliant
- 13:56diplomatic tool. It became a legend. The balsam
- 13:59of Mataria was famous throughout Europe and the
- 14:01Middle East. And what is really fascinating is
- 14:04the blend of lore surrounding this garden. The
- 14:06Christians believed the garden was. Right. So
- 14:15for Christians, this is deeply sanctified ground.
- 14:18It's a major holy site. Exactly. But the Mamluks,
- 14:21the Muslim rulers, were the caretakers of this
- 14:24Christian holy site. They actively maintained
- 14:27the garden. They organized the harvesting of
- 14:29the oil. Hani Hamza's research shows that this
- 14:32wasn't just a simple commodity being traded.
- 14:34It was heavy diplomacy. Sultans would gift small,
- 14:38precious vials of this oil to European kings
- 14:41or even directly to the pope. Wow. It shows such
- 14:44a complex, layered relationship. It's like the
- 14:47sultan is saying, you are my enemy. technically,
- 14:49but I control the literal keys to your religious
- 14:52rituals and I am going to use that leverage to
- 14:54keep you talking to me. But I'm also going to
- 14:56protect the site because it's valuable to me
- 14:58too. It is the... ultimate frenemy situation.
- 15:01I hate you, but I desperately need your holy
- 15:04oil. I hate you, but I really like your diplomatic
- 15:06gold. It proves that the economic and ritual
- 15:08ties were so much stronger than the ideological
- 15:10divide. And it goes even deeper than just trade
- 15:13and ritual. It goes to the very look of knowledge
- 15:15itself. We have another incredible case study
- 15:18here by Alison Oka about book bindings. Now,
- 15:21this is something that actually affects us even
- 15:23today when we think about books. Being a massive
- 15:26book lover, this one really resonated with me.
- 15:28Because we all think of the classic old scholarly
- 15:31book. You picture dark leather, gold tooling,
- 15:34maybe a protective flap on the edge. It just
- 15:36screams old world Europe to us. Right. If you
- 15:40picture a quintessential Renaissance book sitting
- 15:42in a beautiful library in Florence or Venice,
- 15:45you are actually picturing something that looks
- 15:47very, very Islamic. Really? Still? Yes. Because
- 15:50before this period. European books, what we call
- 15:53Gothic books, were extremely heavy. They had
- 15:56thick wooden boards for covers. They were clunky.
- 15:58They had big heavy metal clasps to keep them
- 16:01shut. They were basically meant to sit on a heavy
- 16:04wooden lectern and just stay there. Like a chained
- 16:06library book. Exactly. But in the Islamic world,
- 16:09specifically the Mamluk and Ottoman empires,
- 16:12they had developed an entirely different, much
- 16:14more advanced technology for books. They used
- 16:16pasteboards, which are layers of paper glued
- 16:18together instead of thick wood. It was so much
- 16:20lighter. They used incredibly fine leather. They
- 16:24pioneered gold tooling, which is stamping intricate
- 16:27gold geometric patterns directly into the leather.
- 16:30And they used the envelope flap that folds over
- 16:33the front to protect the pages. And the Italians
- 16:36saw this and just said, We want that. Exactly.
- 16:38As the Italian humanists started reviving classical
- 16:41knowledge, you know, translating Plato and Aristotle,
- 16:43they wanted a completely new look for this new
- 16:46wave of learning. They did not want the clunky,
- 16:49heavy Gothic style that was heavily associated
- 16:51with what they saw as the Dark Ages. They wanted
- 16:53sophistication. And to them, the high culture
- 16:56of the East, the Islamic world, visually represented
- 16:59that intellectual sophistication. That is so
- 17:02interesting. So the physical vehicle for the
- 17:03European Renaissance, the actual physical book
- 17:05itself, was technologically and aesthetically
- 17:08an Islamic import. The container of the knowledge
- 17:10was Islamic, even if the text inside was Latin
- 17:13or Greek. Allison Ota traces exactly how these
- 17:16specific bookbinding techniques migrated across
- 17:18the sea from Cairo and Istanbul straight into
- 17:21Venice. It's just another amazing example of
- 17:24how the aesthetic... the cool factor, if you
- 17:27will, completely overrode any religious prejudice.
- 17:30To be modern, to be seen as a true intellectual
- 17:32in Renaissance Italy, meant holding a book that
- 17:35looked like it came straight out of the Sultan's
- 17:36personal library. I love that so much. It's literally
- 17:39like buying the latest tech today. It's entirely
- 17:41about the design language. You want the sleekest,
- 17:44most advanced design completely regardless of
- 17:47where it was invented or who manufactured it.
- 17:49It really is. And sometimes this intense mixing
- 17:51of design languages creates something that is
- 17:54truly baffling to historians, a hybrid object
- 17:56that completely defies simple categorization.
- 17:59Which perfectly brings us to segment three, the
- 18:02hybrid object. When three hands touch one artifact,
- 18:05we're looking at a very specific artifact found
- 18:07at Mount Athos, specifically at St. Paul's Monastery.
- 18:10And this thing sounds like a complete puzzle.
- 18:13It is a massive puzzle. This is research done
- 18:15by Nikolaos Frisidis and Pascalis Ingroudis.
- 18:19This object is, well, the best word for it is
- 18:22a survivor. It's a composite object. Describe
- 18:25it for the listener. What does it actually look
- 18:26like? So imagine a metal candlestick. The base
- 18:29of it is beautifully worked metal. It features
- 18:32a prominent double -headed eagle and various
- 18:34astrological symbols. Now this base is seljuk.
- 18:38It comes from Muslim Anatolia, probably made
- 18:40in the 12th or 13th century. Okay, so a Muslim
- 18:43-made candlestick base. Right. But attached firmly
- 18:46to the top of it is a cross, a distinctly Venetian
- 18:48Catholic cross. Okay. And the whole composite
- 18:51thing is currently sitting in a strict Orthodox
- 18:54monastery on Mount Athos, and it was used in
- 18:56Greek liturgy. That is absurd. A Muslim base,
- 18:59a Catholic top, and an Orthodox home. It is like
- 19:02the turducken of... religious artifacts that
- 19:05is well that's a very vivid image but yes yeah
- 19:08it physically embodies the micro history of the
- 19:10entire region this object isn't just one thing
- 19:13it is a literal collision of three distinct cultures
- 19:16how does that even happen practically do they
- 19:18just find a base weld across onto it and call
- 19:20it a day essentially yes but the analysis goes
- 19:24so much deeper than the physical joining the
- 19:26real question is why did they keep the base Why
- 19:29didn't the Christians just melt it down and forge
- 19:32a properly Christian base for their cross? And
- 19:35the answer lies in that symbol on the base. The
- 19:39double -headed eagle. Now wait, I know the double
- 19:42-headed eagle is a distinctly Byzantine symbol.
- 19:45It represents the Roman Empire looking both east
- 19:47and west. You still see it on flags in the region
- 19:50today. That is the Byzantine and Orthodox interpretation,
- 19:53yes. It is imperial. It represents the divine
- 19:55authority of Constantinople. But in the Seljuk
- 19:58context, the Islamic context where the base was
- 20:00originally made, the double -headed eagle was
- 20:02also a very common symbol. But there it was cosmological.
- 20:05It represented power, sure, but often in an astrological
- 20:09or talismanic sense. It was viewed as a protector
- 20:11figure. Oh, so you have a symbol that easily
- 20:14passes. in both cultures. Exactly. This is the
- 20:16absolute key to its survival. The visual overlap
- 20:20allowed the object to survive the transition
- 20:22between religions. A Christian monk looks at
- 20:25this candlestick base and sees the Byzantine
- 20:28eagle, his own imperial heritage. A Muslim artisan
- 20:32looks at the exact same base and sees a Seljuk
- 20:35cosmological symbol. because the symbol was completely
- 20:38ambiguous, or rather, because it held a shared
- 20:41yet different meaning for both TDs. The object
- 20:44could be seamlessly repurposed rather than destroyed.
- 20:46It could just pass. It is like linguistic code
- 20:49switching, but for physical objects. It speaks
- 20:51whatever visual language the viewer happens to
- 20:53speak. Perfectly said. And that ability to code
- 20:56switch visually is the only thing that saved
- 20:58it. It allowed a Seljuk object to literally hold
- 21:01up a Venetian cross on a Greek altar. It proves
- 21:04that these cultures were not hermetically sealed
- 21:06by... Speaking of things being misunderstood,
- 21:19and this is honestly my favorite story in the
- 21:21entire collection of sources we read that we
- 21:24have to talk about the marble slabs. This story.
- 21:27I mean, of all the stories we've covered, this
- 21:29one feels the most ironic. It feels like a comedy
- 21:31scriptwriter wrote it. Oh, this is the ultimate
- 21:33historical irony. This is the story of the marble
- 21:36slabs of 1166. Segment four, misunderstanding
- 21:39is preservation. Let's dive in. What exactly
- 21:42are these slabs? These are massive, incredibly
- 21:45heavy marble inscriptions. Originally, they were
- 21:48set up inside the Hagia Sophia in Constantinople
- 21:51during the height of the Byzantine era. And they
- 21:53contain the text of a very specific, incredibly
- 21:56dense theological decree. It's from a church
- 21:59council held in 1166 that was furiously debating
- 22:02the meaning of a phrase from the Gospel of John.
- 22:04My father is greater than I. My father is greater
- 22:07than I. OK, that is heavy theology. Extremely
- 22:11heavy. It is fundamentally about the nature of
- 22:13Christ. Is he totally equal to God the Father?
- 22:15Is he somehow subordinate? The council ultimately
- 22:18decided on a specific orthodox interpretation
- 22:20that Christ is equal in his divinity but inferior
- 22:23in his humanity. Now, the minute details don't
- 22:26matter as much as the fact that this text is
- 22:28hardcore, uncompromising Christian dogma. It
- 22:31is explicitly Trinitarian. It rigidly defines
- 22:34the nature of Jesus as the Son of God. Okay,
- 22:36so massive Christian text carved into marble
- 22:40on a wall in the Hagia Sophia. Standard Byzantine
- 22:43stuff. Standard. Until the year 1453, the Ottomans
- 22:46conquer Constantinople. The Hagia Sophia is converted
- 22:50into a mosque. Now, usually you would expect
- 22:52the new Islamic rulers to smash these slabs to
- 22:54dust, right? Yeah. The text completely contradicts
- 22:57Islamic theology, which views Jesus strictly
- 22:59as a mortal prophet, not the literal son of God.
- 23:01God has no partners. That is the absolute central
- 23:03tenet of Islam. Right. So technically, to the
- 23:06new rulers, this marble slab is pure blasphemy.
- 23:08But they didn't smash it. Fast forward a century
- 23:12or so. These massive slabs are moved from the
- 23:15Hagia Sophia. And where do they end up? They
- 23:18end up decorating the mausoleum, the grand tomb
- 23:21of Sultan Suleiman the Magnificent. Wait, wait,
- 23:23wait, wait. Let me process this. You're telling
- 23:25me the tomb of one of the absolute greatest Muslim
- 23:28sultans in history is decorated with huge Byzantine
- 23:32slabs proclaiming the literal divinity of Christ.
- 23:35Yes, the longest lapidary Byzantine inscription
- 23:38in existence ended up protecting the body of
- 23:41the Caliph of Islam. How? Why would they do that?
- 23:44That seems completely impossible. That is exactly
- 23:46the question the researchers asked. Forik Bilici
- 23:48and Helene Fregaki call this phenomenon misunderstanding
- 23:51as preservation. The most likely explanation
- 23:53is that the Ottoman architects simply could not
- 23:55read the Byzantine Greek theology. Or, perhaps
- 23:58more accurately, they just didn't care what the
- 24:01words actually meant. They cared deeply about
- 24:03what the words looked like. They just really
- 24:04liked the font. In a way, yes. They viewed the
- 24:07script as deeply ancient. There is this widespread
- 24:10medieval concept of talismanic power. The sheer
- 24:13otherness of the text, the fact that it was ancient,
- 24:16incomprehensible Greek, beautifully carved into
- 24:19high -quality marble, gave it a profound sense
- 24:22of magic, of lingering power. They likely saw
- 24:25it as spolia -reused material that carried the
- 24:28baraka, the divine blessing or power of the ancient
- 24:31conquered city. So they looked at it and thought,
- 24:33this looks incredibly powerful, it looks magical,
- 24:36let's put it on the sultan's tomb to protect
- 24:38him. Even though if they had bothered to translate
- 24:40it, it would be a total heresy to them. Exactly.
- 24:43The aesthetic space trumped the theology completely
- 24:45and totally. The stones were preserved and elevated
- 24:48because they were impressive artifacts of power,
- 24:51not because of the actual message they conveyed.
- 24:53The visual awe completely silenced the theological
- 24:56conflict. Now there is a story in the notes here
- 24:59about a mufti. Is this a legend or did this actually
- 25:02happen? It's a bit of both, but it's a great
- 25:05little anecdote recounted in the sources that
- 25:07illustrates the mindset. The legend goes that
- 25:10Sultan Selim II, Suleiman's successor, eventually
- 25:14noticed these weird stones and asked a mufti,
- 25:17a high -ranking religious scholar, what the Greek
- 25:20words actually said. Put yourself in that mufti's
- 25:23shoes. You probably don't know ancient Greek.
- 25:25Or if you do, you know it says something intensely
- 25:27Christian. You cannot look the sultan in the
- 25:29eye and say, hey, just so you know, your dad
- 25:32is buried under a massive monument to Christian
- 25:35dogma. Oh, my God. That is a career ending move
- 25:37or honestly a life ending move. Right. So the
- 25:40mufti thinks fast and claims they are the mysteries
- 25:42of Ali, referring to Ali, the cousin and son
- 25:44in law of the prophet Muhammad. He basically
- 25:46tells the sultan, oh, it's deep secret Islamic
- 25:48mystery, your majesty. Don't worry about it.
- 25:50He improvised. He completely. bluffed. He claimed
- 25:53the Christian text was esoteric Islamic wisdom
- 25:55just to protect the stones or, more likely, to
- 25:58protect his own neck. But it is a perfect historical
- 26:01example of how meaning is entirely malleable.
- 26:05The physical object stays exactly the same, but
- 26:08the story we tell ourselves about it changes
- 26:10to fit our current political or aesthetic needs.
- 26:13That is just, I love that so much. It perfectly
- 26:15shows that people will just bend reality to fit
- 26:18the aesthetic they want. If they want to keep
- 26:20the pretty powerful looking stones, they will
- 26:22invent a theological reason to justify keeping
- 26:24the pretty stones. And that bending of reality,
- 26:27that negotiation, brings us right into... To
- 26:29segment five, the idea of identity and architecture,
- 26:33how individual people actively use these aesthetic
- 26:36choices to define who they were. It's about blurring
- 26:39the lines. It's about how minority groups navigated
- 26:41this deeply mixed up visual world. Right. And
- 26:44we're talking about tiras again, but this time
- 26:45specifically Coptic tiras. Right. We touched
- 26:48on luxury textiles earlier, but this is a very
- 26:50specific political application of them. This
- 26:53is Arielle Winnick's research. Tiras were highly
- 26:56specific inscribed textiles, usually taking the
- 27:00form of robes of honor. In the Islamic world,
- 27:02they were officially distributed by the caliph
- 27:04himself. They had the caliph's name and titles
- 27:07prominently embroidered right onto the bands
- 27:10of the fabric. If you wore one in public, it
- 27:12meant you were in with the in crowd. You actively
- 27:15had the ruler's favor. Okay. So it's like getting
- 27:18a varsity jacket from the popular team captain.
- 27:20Right. Or wearing a branded hoodie from a really
- 27:22exclusive tech company. Exactly. It was a highly
- 27:25visible marker of political loyalty and status.
- 27:28But here is the fascinating twist. Coptic Christians
- 27:31living in Egypt, who were obviously living as
- 27:34a religious minority under Muslim rule, adopted
- 27:37this exact aesthetic form. They started making
- 27:39their own tiras. But they couldn't possibly wear
- 27:42the caliph's name if they were doing their own
- 27:44separate religious thing, right? That would defeat
- 27:45the purpose. Well, they kept the entire visual
- 27:48language. They kept the distinct bands of writing
- 27:51on the sleeves. They kept the exact layout and
- 27:53colors. But instead of naming the Muslim caliph,
- 27:56their inscriptions named God or Christ, or they
- 27:59use specific Coptic Christian prayers. So from
- 28:0310 feet away in the street, you look exactly
- 28:06like a loyal, wealthy subject wearing the trendy,
- 28:09officially sanctioned Islamic court fashion.
- 28:12But up close, you are actually reading a Christian
- 28:15prayer. Precisely. It is all about fitting in
- 28:18while simultaneously standing out. Winnick argues
- 28:21that these Christians were basically inscribing
- 28:23their bodies. They were actively adopting the
- 28:25dominant visual culture because, well, that's
- 28:27just what power and success look like in that
- 28:29society. But they were subtly subverting the
- 28:32text to assert their own specific minority religious
- 28:34identity. It's a brilliant survival strategy.
- 28:37You don't retreat into a cultural shell. You
- 28:40put on the camouflage of the ruling class, but
- 28:42you tweak it just enough for your own community
- 28:44to recognize. That is so incredibly smart. It
- 28:46is visual code switching again, just like the
- 28:48candlestick. And the sources show it wasn't just
- 28:50happening on their clothes. It was happening
- 28:52in their massive public buildings, too. We have
- 28:54a whole section here on Mucornis. Mucornis, yes.
- 28:57If you have ever seen pictures of the Alhambra
- 29:00in Spain or really any great medieval mosque,
- 29:03you know what Mucornis is. It's that incredibly
- 29:05complex geometric honeycomb vaulting in the domes
- 29:09and arches. It almost looks like stone stalactites
- 29:12hanging down. It is arguably the single most
- 29:15distinctive, recognizable feature. Islamic architecture.
- 29:19You see a picture of that, you immediately say
- 29:21Islam. But Richard Peer and McCleary's research
- 29:23found them inside Christian churches. Yes, inside
- 29:27Armenian churches and in other Christian buildings
- 29:30in Mosul and across Anatolia. A great example
- 29:33he uses is the Church of the Holy Apostles at
- 29:35Anani. Now, why on earth would a Christian architect
- 29:37consciously choose to use the literal brand logo
- 29:42of Islamic architecture for their church? Because
- 29:44to them, it wasn't the brand logo of Islam. It
- 29:47was just the modern style. To be contemporary
- 29:49in the 12th or 13th century, to show your congregation
- 29:53and your rivals that you were on the absolute
- 29:55cutting edge of building technology and high
- 29:58fashion, you used Muqarnas vaulting. So it wasn't
- 30:02viewed as Muslim architecture at all. It was
- 30:04just viewed as... as modern architecture. Exactly.
- 30:07We modern people are the ones projecting the
- 30:09strict religious label onto the geometry today.
- 30:12Back then, it was just the incredibly cool, structurally
- 30:16brilliant new way to hold up a roof. It shows
- 30:19that architectural forms were treated as neutral
- 30:21technology, as fashion trends, not strictly as
- 30:24loaded religious symbols. If the engineering
- 30:27works well and it looks beautiful, we are going
- 30:29to use it no matter who invented it. If it works,
- 30:31use it. That honestly seems to be the overarching
- 30:33motto of this entire era we're looking at. Which
- 30:36brings us to our final major case study in this
- 30:39segment, esoteric spolia in Cairo. And this one
- 30:43involves actual magic, doesn't it? It really
- 30:45does. This is Sami Luigi de Jus' research focusing
- 30:47on the mosque of Sultan al -Nasir Mohammed in
- 30:50Cairo. So the sultan is building a massive new
- 30:53mosque. And he goes out of his way to import
- 30:55very specific columns, ancient, often Christian
- 30:58or pre -Christian columns, from completely different
- 31:01historical sites to hold up his mosque. Right.
- 31:03Now, typically, older historians would look at
- 31:05that and say, oh, he is physically conquering
- 31:07the past. He is taking their ancient columns
- 31:09and stepping on them to show Islamic dominance,
- 31:12standard empire stuff. But De Giza argues it
- 31:15is much more nuanced than that. He connects this
- 31:17specific architectural choice to... Hermeticism.
- 31:21Hermeticism. Like Hermes, the Greek god. Yes.
- 31:24But specifically how he was viewed in the medieval
- 31:27Islamic mind. Hermes Trismegistus was a legendary
- 31:30figure often directly associated with the Quranic
- 31:33prophet Idris. He wasn't just a myth. He was
- 31:35seen as a profound sage, the ultimate source
- 31:38of ancient wisdom, early science, and yes, esoteric
- 31:41magic. So reusing these very specific ancient
- 31:43columns wasn't just cheap recycling to save stone.
- 31:47Not at all. It was a highly deliberate attempt
- 31:49to harness that ancient wisdom, to physically
- 31:51harness Baraka, which means blessing or spiritual
- 31:55power. By incorporating these specific ancient
- 31:58stones into the very fabric of the mosque, the
- 32:01sultan was trying to tap into a continuous lineage
- 32:03of power that went back way before Islam, way
- 32:07before Christianity, to the very mythological
- 32:10roots of wisdom itself. It shows that the aesthetic
- 32:13space wasn't just about collecting pretty things.
- 32:15It was about curating powerful things. It was
- 32:18about surrounding yourself with objects that
- 32:20had a poppable esoteric charge to them. It really
- 32:23changes how you look at a historic building.
- 32:25You aren't just looking at a pile of dead rocks.
- 32:27You're looking at a carefully constructed battery
- 32:30of spiritual power, assembled from whatever potent
- 32:33parts they could find across the world. A battery
- 32:35of spiritual power. I really like that phrasing.
- 32:37That is exactly what they believed it was. So
- 32:39let's take a breath and look at everything we've
- 32:41covered. We have looked at ceramic bowls, silk
- 32:44textiles, holy oil, book bindings, a hybrid candlestick,
- 32:48misunderstood marble slabs, and magically charged
- 32:51architecture. And the one glaring common thread
- 32:54through all of it is that none of these things
- 32:56stayed in their assigned lane. None of them.
- 32:59And that perfectly brings us to the synthesis
- 33:02of this whole deep dive, the concept of the New
- 33:05Mediterranean. Let's bring it all together for
- 33:07the listener. What is the big overarching takeaway
- 33:09from all this microhistory? The big takeaway
- 33:12is that we fundamentally have to stop looking
- 33:14at maps of battles if we want to actually understand
- 33:17human history. The historians Horden and Purcell
- 33:20talk about this paradigm of fragmentation and
- 33:23connectivity. Yes, the politics of the Mediterranean
- 33:25were deeply fragmented. The religious dogmas
- 33:28were distinct and often violently opposed. But
- 33:31the connectivity, the relentless trade, the shared
- 33:34art, the unstoppable flow of beautiful objects
- 33:37was intense and constant. It's like looking at
- 33:40a huge dysfunctional family that violently argues
- 33:42at the dinner table about politics, but they
- 33:45still pass the salt and share the same food.
- 33:47Yes. That's exactly it. Islam and Christianity
- 33:50in the medieval Mediterranean were not just distant
- 33:53neighbors who occasionally waved or shot arrows
- 33:56across a tall fence. They were roommates. They
- 33:58literally shared the furniture. They wore each
- 34:00other's luxury clothes. They ate off each other's
- 34:02shiny plates. I am realizing that. It really
- 34:04humanizes the past, doesn't it? It strips away
- 34:07the grand, impersonal narrative of holy war.
- 34:10It does. It reminds us that looking closely at
- 34:12a single object, a bowl and a wall, a book on
- 34:15a desk, tells a much truer, more intimate story
- 34:18of human interaction than any royal treaty or
- 34:21grand declaration of war ever could. War is an
- 34:24event, but trade is a life. Art is a life. War
- 34:28is an event, but art is a life. That is profound.
- 34:31And I think we really need to highlight the significance
- 34:33of this research. Why does this matter for the
- 34:35field of religious studies today? It matters
- 34:37immensely because it absolutely proves that religions
- 34:40do not exist in hermetically sealed vacuums.
- 34:42They never have. We co -construct our visual
- 34:45and spiritual worlds. Christian art in this period
- 34:48looks the way it does directly because of Islamic
- 34:51art and vice versa. You cannot untangle the threads
- 34:54of one from the other without destroying the
- 34:56whole tapestry. It forces interfaith understanding.
- 35:00by showing that at our core, we've always been
- 35:02borrowing from each other to define ourselves.
- 35:04So if we look at the world today, we see a lot
- 35:06of incredibly rigid boundaries. We see a lot
- 35:09of intense us versus them rhetoric everywhere
- 35:12we look. We do. But this deep dive, to me, raises
- 35:15a really provocative final thought. Think about
- 35:18what we just learned. If a dense Byzantine theological
- 35:21decree literally defining the Trinity can end
- 35:24up lovingly protecting a Muslim sultan's tomb,
- 35:27and if a distinctly Muslim style of vaulting
- 35:29can be used to hold up the roof of a Christian
- 35:31church just because it looked cool, what modern
- 35:34boundaries that we currently think are rigid
- 35:36and permanent might actually be just as fluid?
- 35:38That is the ultimate question. If we looked at
- 35:40our own object today, You know, our phones, our
- 35:43clothes, our food, the media we consume instead
- 35:46of our angry politics. Would we see divided enemies
- 35:49or would we just see roommates sharing the same
- 35:52space? I think if we look close enough, we'd
- 35:55see a whole lot of roommates. I think so, too.
- 35:57We're far more connected by what we find beautiful
- 35:59than we are divided by what we believe. Expert
- 36:02speaker, thank you so much for guiding us through
- 36:05this material. This has been an incredible trip
- 36:07through history. It was my pleasure entirely.
- 36:10Indeed, beauty is a remarkably powerful thing.
- 36:13It truly is. Yeah. And to you, the listener,
- 36:16the next time you see a piece of art or an old
- 36:19building or even just a complex pattern on a
- 36:21rug in your house, take a second to look closer.
- 36:24Ask yourself, where did this actually come from?
- 36:27And who might have loved this exact same design
- 36:29centuries before me? You might be very surprised
- 36:32by the answer. Thanks for joining us on the Deep
- 36:35Dive. We will see you next time.