Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / IPF vs. IFS: The Difference Between the Two Within an Attachment Repair Lens
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love you, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:11That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:22This is I Love you. Keep going.
- 0:23It is Thursday, March 19th, 2026.
- 0:26It's 7, 35 PM Pacific Daylight Time and I thought I'd talk
- 0:34about IPF Ideal Parent Figure Protocol versus IFS internal
- 0:39family systems, but actually more broadly the different
- 0:45approaches and the effects on attachment conditioning.
- 0:50Ideal Parent Figure Protocol is really narrowly focused on
- 0:55developing secure attachment and what secure attachment of course
- 1:00allows for is the setting up of the social network.
- 1:04It would then supports primary exploration and the different
- 1:09things that happen to you in childhood that affect your
- 1:14attachment conditioning also dramatically affect your
- 1:18capacity to explore. And, and I think that that's one
- 1:22of the main differences between psychotherapy based approaches.
- 1:31I think one of the other central differences between a meditation
- 1:34based approach to working with attachment conditioning and
- 1:39psychotherapy approach is that we have a completely different
- 1:43point of view on the activity of self.
- 1:49Whereas we think the activity of self is a reactive witnessing
- 1:55function to the actual activity of the body mind.
- 2:00The self in psychotherapy tends to be upfront and a lot of the
- 2:04interventions are meant to work with the the structure of self
- 2:09and to understand the the activities of self.
- 2:13Whereas in the particular in the Buddhist meditation tradition,
- 2:17it really is the deconstructing of self and working directly
- 2:21with what is thought of as the unconscious.
- 2:25In Western psychology. When we talk about, let's say
- 2:39there's 3 pillars in, in the, the attachment repair response
- 2:44that was developed by Dan Brown and his group and actually using
- 2:49a, a, a psychotherapy model in his version of that ideal parent
- 2:55figure was a protocol that you used as the primary means of
- 3:01change. And that's the first pillar.
- 3:04The second pillar and the three pillars approach was the
- 3:08development of mentalizing an emotional regulation.
- 3:12You can do that in the, the, the, the, the psychotherapy
- 3:18setting. And then what we would be
- 3:22talking about here is a difference of stance.
- 3:25If you have an expert stance in the therapist and the patient is
- 3:32then coming to an expert for advice on how to change or
- 3:38function in the world, it sets up a different kind of hierarchy
- 3:42than if you have a mentoring approach where there's, there's
- 3:48no hierarchy really in the mentoring approach and the
- 3:52mentoring approach, you're both on the same level and you're and
- 3:56the, the mentor is going with you as you explore the things
- 4:00that matter to you and are able to reflect back to you what the
- 4:06experience of that is. One of the things that allows
- 4:10for transfer transference in a psychotherapy sense is that the
- 4:17therapist withholds information and withholds relating from the
- 4:24the client so that the client can then project onto the
- 4:29psychotherapist the early conditioning of childhood and
- 4:34that it can then be examined in that way and in the approach
- 4:39that we use. That's not invited.
- 4:43In fact, what's encouraged is for facilitators to reveal
- 4:48themselves and have a an actual relationship where the power
- 4:54dynamic is more in line with a a relationship outside of that
- 5:02frame. Is that all making sense so far
- 5:09in exploring the dynamics of the body mind in from that
- 5:13meditative Buddhist understanding is the sense
- 5:19activity reacts to the gathering of senses and creates the
- 5:25experience of reality. So it's sufficient to actually
- 5:27to understand the descriptions of the experience of reality
- 5:32that the person is having and and not rely on the transference
- 5:38and counter transference that arises in more conventional
- 5:43psychotherapy or psychoanalytic frame.
- 5:49You might even call it a a process of daytime dreaming.
- 5:54Often in the psychoanalytic end of things, dreaming is something
- 5:58that that's, or dream analysis is something that's encouraged
- 6:02or free association, which is akin to the process of the
- 6:07visualization of ideal parent figure.
- 6:12In One of the challenges in developing a practice of ideal
- 6:18parent figure is relying on the level of mentalizing that the
- 6:26the person coming to do the work is capable of because that, that
- 6:33there's a certain level of mentalizing that's necessary and
- 6:37able to, to enable the process to unfold.
- 6:42And so we do see a usefulness for IFS work, which is to, for
- 6:51people that really aren't able to mentalize at a level where
- 6:55they can engage in ideal parent figure protocol, they can use
- 6:59the, the structure of IFS to develop a framework for basic
- 7:04mentalizing. So really it, it's a kind of
- 7:08out-of-the-box mentalizing system which you learn and then
- 7:12you identify different aspects of your thinking and feeling
- 7:19process that maps onto the structure in IFS.
- 7:27And that actually can begin the elemental mentalizing process
- 7:34where you're actually tracking the things that are happening,
- 7:36you're identifying what the experiences are and then you're
- 7:39categorizing them. But we think that it can also be
- 7:47restricting in the sense that you're not imagining your native
- 7:55structure, personality structure so much as applying a
- 7:59pre-existing structure. And also it can eventually be
- 8:03limiting because it does tend to reify aspects of your
- 8:08personality into these frames. Whereas if when you're using
- 8:14ideal parent for your protocol, it's really mapping on to the
- 8:18native structure of your personality without imposing a,
- 8:22a, a, a kind of prefabricated structure.
- 8:28And also it doesn't reify aspects into a particular part.
- 8:341 of the things that I think is, is limiting, particularly when
- 8:38you come into trying to develop an understanding between primary
- 8:44and secondary exploration, is how when you in some sense fix
- 8:57experiences into a particular shape, when you want to move
- 9:04into a place of spontaneity and, and responsiveness to the things
- 9:08that happened in the present moment, they tend to clump into
- 9:11these ideas about what's happening based on that the, the
- 9:18structures of IFS is that is that making sense?
- 9:23I don't wanna, I don't, I'm not trying to slam anything or to,
- 9:27to suggest that you should do one thing or another.
- 9:31And I, I do know that and people who are facilitating with us
- 9:36have reported that IFS is really useful in the beginning for
- 9:40people that don't mentalize well enough, but that at a certain
- 9:44point it becomes limiting to the movement into spontaneous
- 9:49exploration. So there, there's a pathway.
- 9:56It also can be too direct in trauma reprocessing.
- 10:03One of the things about ideal parent figure protocol that's
- 10:09different from quite a lot of the modalities that are used to
- 10:12work with trauma is that it's an indirect trauma reprocessing
- 10:16system. Oh, no, Vanderhardt, who is, you
- 10:20know, an expert in dissociation, admonished quite forcefully at
- 10:28we were in London with Danny was presenting a a paper that
- 10:34Medigroup had participated in. We, the Medigroup people, were
- 10:39the control group because we were using mentalizing,
- 10:44mentalizing and emotional regulation and psychoeducation
- 10:47in how secure functioning is supposed to go.
- 10:51And his group was using a different form of mentalizing,
- 10:57emotional regulation and psychoeducation, and also the
- 11:00ideal parent figures. So we contrasted how the the two
- 11:03cohorts responded to that. And Odo Vanderhardt said that if
- 11:11you're disorganized, direct trauma reprocessing can be
- 11:16harmful to you. That that if you're dissociative
- 11:21and they take you into the original traumatic event, you
- 11:24can go into dissociative state. So that the integration
- 11:28integration process that they're that you're looking to achieve
- 11:32by titrating the trauma doesn't really happen because it's
- 11:35simply dissociated, but it can also further disorganize
- 11:41disorganized attachment systems. And so he, he was quite forceful
- 11:44in suggesting that you, you don't do that.
- 11:47But, but because most of the psychotherapy and, and systems
- 11:55engaged in working with trauma aren't screening for attachment
- 12:00conditioning and aren't screening for disorganized
- 12:03people. And in fact, most of the people
- 12:07that have trauma are going to be in the disorganized category
- 12:11anyway. It's a, it's a, it's a risk, a
- 12:15high risk with a, a low return. Whereas if you use an indirect
- 12:23trauma reprocessing system, which is that you never actually
- 12:26go into the traumatic events themselves, you go around them.
- 12:32One of the things that's important, of course, is
- 12:35particularly if the traumatic events are happening within the
- 12:38family, which is one of the things that causes the
- 12:40disorganization. What you understand, I hope,
- 12:47about the attachment system is that when it goes off it, it
- 12:51actually is causing you to seek proximity and protection from
- 12:56somebody. And so you have a hierarchy of
- 12:59people that you have an attachment relationship to.
- 13:03And when something frightens you or something appears to be
- 13:07harmful or dangerous, the attachment system activates and
- 13:10you're compelled to seek physical proximity and
- 13:13protection from somebody. But if that person is also the
- 13:17person that's triggering the event, right?
- 13:20If they're frightening to you or they feel dangerous for you, it
- 13:25activates your system. Then you're seeking proximity to
- 13:28the person that you perceive is harming you, which causes the
- 13:33fight or flight mechanism to activate and cancel the
- 13:38attachment signaling, and then you're without comfort in that
- 13:44way. And so in the indirect travel
- 13:46reprocessing, the first part of it is the offering of protection
- 13:50and comforting this with a safe parental figure.
- 13:57And then once there's a sufficient level of that, then
- 14:01we go to before it happens and have the ideal parent figures
- 14:06intervene and prevent it from happening.
- 14:09Why is that important? One of the things, and I'm going
- 14:13to use the the Buddhist bottling for this, we have the capacity
- 14:20to sense and we encounter objects that can be sensed by
- 14:24those capacities. So touching, seeing, hearing,
- 14:27tasting, smelling. In Buddhism we have this concept
- 14:31of mind, which is the thing, the the activity that selects what
- 14:36you focus on. This is different from the West
- 14:39and the Aristotelian model of it.
- 14:44The mind does a sort of uniform survey of everything that's in
- 14:48front of you and creates an internal working model, which is
- 14:52largely accurate, and then you based your responses to the
- 14:57world based on that internal working model.
- 15:01About 300 years after that, Epicuria said that if you were
- 15:05in a strong emotional state, it might distort somewhat your
- 15:09perception and might cause you to create a slightly distorted
- 15:15working model of what's actually happening.
- 15:17But it is for the most part reliable.
- 15:24And in the Buddhist frame, we do a highly curated selection of
- 15:28mind moments in the environment, which is based on the things
- 15:31that we prefer. We leave out the stuff that we
- 15:34don't want and we create a conceptual reality based on that
- 15:39highly curated selection of things that happened.
- 15:42So I would ask you, which feels like a better model?
- 15:48I've never had the sense that I could accurately perceive things
- 15:52that I have so often created these scenarios about what
- 15:57actually is happening that aren't so relatable to other
- 16:00people's experience that this, when I heard this, it was a just
- 16:05a no brainer. I'm curating my perception of
- 16:09reality. We react to every moment, we
- 16:14react to every moment, and we construct the meaning of every
- 16:18moment based on our conditioning as the Buddhist right, the
- 16:24capacity to sense meets, the object can be sensed.
- 16:26When there's contact, consciousness of that sensing
- 16:29experience arises. It's evaluated for urgency,
- 16:32doesn't need immediate attention.
- 16:34Does it not matter if we ever get to it?
- 16:36Is there time or something pleasant?
- 16:38And then it's compared to the perceptual database.
- 16:41And if there's a previously experienced event that has a
- 16:46meaning, that has meaning, of course that is matched to the
- 16:51pattern of the present moment experience that that whole
- 16:53meaning thread attaches to it. That whole meaning thread, of
- 16:58course, includes how you might respond to the conditions of the
- 17:03present moment and what you might expect to happen.
- 17:08And if you are in an early family situation where there's
- 17:12no real escape from danger, as an adult now, you could easily
- 17:17make a reality where there's no escape.
- 17:20And so the second part of the trauma reprocessing work is to
- 17:26have the ideal parent figures intervene on the child's behalf
- 17:29and prevent the traumatic event from happening so that we
- 17:35develop this expectation that we can respond to the the present
- 17:40moment now and act in a different way and anticipate a
- 17:44different result. I think the statistic is that
- 17:49somebody who. Is raped is 9 times more likely
- 17:58to be raped a second time than somebody who hasn't been raped?
- 18:02Because the defense the the resistance doesn't happen.
- 18:09There's a kind of passivity that settles in on people that have
- 18:13had a lot of trauma in response to the perception that a
- 18:17traumatic event could happen again.
- 18:21Is that making sense? It's a terrible statistic.
- 18:28So we work at the ideal parent figures responding and
- 18:33protecting us so that we can develop an expectation of
- 18:36protection and we can develop agency to respond.
- 18:41And then the third aspect is the desire for an ideal outcome.
- 18:49If you're a child and you grow up in a household where where
- 18:52there's violence or some kind of harm that that's directed at you
- 18:57from your caregivers, we might divide it into two aspects.
- 19:01One would be sort of a hapless, overwhelmed caregiver response
- 19:06and one would be a sadistic response where there was some
- 19:09pleasure gained by the the the perpetrators of the traumatic
- 19:14event. But in that hapless experience
- 19:19for the child, there is often a desire for a different kind of
- 19:25outcome. So we work with understanding
- 19:28what what actually was the desire of the child in
- 19:32relationship to caregivers. And it's reasonable to
- 19:38understand that as the child longed to be loved and seen and
- 19:44appreciated and to have an effect on on their caregivers,
- 19:48even if the caregivers were out of control at certain times and
- 19:53caused harm certain times. Is that making sense?
- 20:02We have a popular culture around trauma that that that's grown up
- 20:06and particularly in the way that we have media now and social
- 20:11media now that there's a a. I I would say a lowering of the
- 20:19bar of what actually is traumatic and what isn't
- 20:21traumatic and and we tend to keep a pretty high bar in in
- 20:29this work, mentalizing training we do through the the use of
- 20:37meditation. So what we want to begin to do
- 20:42is understand how we navigate life as children.
- 20:50Of course, we mainly observe how the adults that we are
- 20:55encountering in our lives as children operate the world.
- 21:00And when you grow up in family systems, people largely use the
- 21:05same tools. We as children, of course, learn
- 21:08the tools for emotional regulation.
- 21:10We learn the tools for conflict negotiation in our family
- 21:15systems. We understand the nature of
- 21:18power dynamics. Children are very sensitive to
- 21:21power dynamics and can recognize who has power.
- 21:26They we're very moral creatures. We have a high sensitivity to a
- 21:30sense of fairness and a sense of justice, and we learn the, the,
- 21:38the, the, the way that those things are supposed to operate
- 21:42in our family systems. And we adopt the way that we
- 21:49adopt what happens in our family system as our understanding of
- 21:53how the world operates. When's your first
- 22:00autobiographical memory? 456789234 so bat range.
- 22:12So 456 is the most common. You've already learned all of
- 22:22this by the time your autobiographical memory starts,
- 22:25right? Just by observing what's
- 22:27happened. And so you come into the world
- 22:30with an understanding of how these things operate and
- 22:33remember that you have a child's brain, not the brain that you
- 22:37have now. And so you, you, you observe
- 22:42whether things are going the way that they're going.
- 22:45And in childhood, there's this understanding that the whole
- 22:49world is like that because of the the nature of how children
- 22:53perceive things. Do you remember when you went
- 23:00out into the world and recognized that the way that
- 23:03your family system operates is different than the way other
- 23:06people's family systems operate? How old were you then?
- 23:14Did you? How old were you when you
- 23:16started to realize that you have a particular way of valuing
- 23:19things? Did you, did you go go back home
- 23:24when you recognized that it was different and attempt to have a
- 23:27dialogue with your caregiver so that you could make sense of how
- 23:31your family system operated was different than the way somebody
- 23:36else's family system operated in which was better and what would,
- 23:40what you could expect in terms of navigating this is the
- 23:44beginning of learning to resolve conflict with someone else.
- 23:50All of these things are important in adult
- 23:54relationships. Do you?
- 23:58When was the first time that you recognize that you have this
- 24:02narrative that follows you, this internal monologue or dialogue
- 24:09or you might call it or narrative, I like to call it a
- 24:12narrative. What's your narrative?
- 24:15When did you recognize that you had a narrative and did you ever
- 24:20stop to question the validity of the narrative that you use?
- 24:23Or is it just a narrative? Is it just true?
- 24:27Is it is your understanding of yourself and your understanding
- 24:34of the world, the way of the world?
- 24:38In Buddhism of course in the Sati Pattana Suta, in the in the
- 24:44refrain of the Sati Pattana Suta, it says mindfulness of
- 24:48inside, mindfulness of outside and mindfulness of inside and
- 24:51outside. So mindfulness of inside is
- 24:54yourself experience as it arises based on conditions.
- 25:00Outside is other people, the world and Buddhism is other
- 25:03people, not not the landscape. And then the sensitivity to the
- 25:09interaction between yourself and others.
- 25:12This is an essential piece in how we're able to relate to
- 25:20other people. Can you mentalize in real time
- 25:27the constructions of the representations of self and
- 25:31world, and the interaction between self and world as it
- 25:35unfolds, so that you can be responsive in a way that's
- 25:40reflective of the conditions of the present moment?
- 25:46Or do you not mentalize fast enough and so you're simply
- 25:51reacting and unable to evaluate whether the constructions of
- 25:56reality that you've made are reflective or reactive?
- 26:01Simply respond. Is that making sense?
- 26:07Is that voice in your head? Is it kind to you?
- 26:11Is it encouraging to you? Does IT support you as you
- 26:14attempt to pursue the things that matter to you, or is it
- 26:18harsh or berating or difficult? Does it, does it actually lend
- 26:27to you moving toward the things that matter or does it actually
- 26:33provide an excuse not to pursue the things that matter to you?
- 26:42This is one of the, the, this is really the discussion of primary
- 26:47versus secondary exploration. In primary exploration, we're
- 26:54pursuing the things that matter to us, the things that we derive
- 26:59meaning from. And the the better we are able
- 27:03to organize our lives in such a way that that a greater part of
- 27:07each day is spent in those activities, the more meaningful
- 27:12our sense of life is, the the richer that quality of
- 27:18exploration is, the the richer the sense of meaningfulness that
- 27:22we find enlivens the relationships that we have.
- 27:26Because we can come back to the relationship and express in an
- 27:31exuberant way the things that we're discovering.
- 27:34And because we've gathered around us people that are
- 27:37interested in and who delight in US, they're delighted to have
- 27:42the experience the, the, the telling of what you've
- 27:46discovered. And you have the experience,
- 27:48that of being this delightful person who's engaged in
- 27:52interesting things that are discovering things that matter
- 27:57to the people around you. How's that?
- 28:01So if you're lucky, I guess, baby, if you have good fortune,
- 28:09this would be a complex discussion in Buddhism of karma
- 28:13over multiple lifetimes. And you have enough in the way
- 28:18of resources that you don't have to dedicate much time to the
- 28:21gathering of resources. You can spend more and more time
- 28:25on primary exploration, but if you don't, then you're going to
- 28:30have to balance the gathering of time, energy, and resources.
- 28:34But have you ever noticed that people who are very successful
- 28:38at gathering a lot of resources and have an abundance of
- 28:42resources don't that magically reorient toward pursuing things
- 28:48that have meaning? They actually pursue the things
- 28:53that distract themselves from pursuing things that are
- 28:57meaning, meaningful. They gather tokens of success,
- 29:03but often find that empty. They rather than being
- 29:09completely open and generous and engaging, they tend to move into
- 29:14a kind of withholding, a kind of hoarding of that resource.
- 29:22So in in examining this, this and in the attachment work that
- 29:35focuses on repairing the insecure, disorganized
- 29:41attachment conditioning that came out of the family system
- 29:46that modeled the kind of relationships that you can have
- 29:50into relationships that are actually going to be supporting,
- 29:53encouraging of you manifesting your authentic self, this
- 30:01becoming who you are. That's the whole point of all of
- 30:05this, to become who you are so that you're free to do this.
- 30:12And then what we begin to examine in that the distance
- 30:16between that and how a lot of us adapt to the, the kind of
- 30:21conditioning that we have is that relationship to
- 30:26exploration. How do we think of ourselves?
- 30:29What do we think we're capable of?
- 30:31What are what are the things that matter to us?
- 30:33And how can we free up our restricted way of relating to
- 30:40ourselves so that we can actually pursue that?
- 30:45That's that's the work. And so we notice that the
- 30:51attachment system is toggled to the exploration system.
- 30:57When the attachment system activates, the exploration
- 31:00system deactivates. And so if you're in a situation
- 31:05where the attachment system is constantly activated, you're not
- 31:09really free to solve much in the way of problems.
- 31:22What is it that allows that that attachment system to shut down
- 31:27and the activation of the exploration system, a sense of
- 31:35safety, a sense of being seen and known, and a sense of
- 31:40encouragement to to explore some marks.
- 31:45What's what's essential in order for that to happen?
- 31:49You have to be willing to tell people who you are so that they
- 31:52can see you authentically. What we all want from the very
- 31:57beginning is to be able to express ourselves authentically,
- 32:01to see that somebody understands that who we are and then that
- 32:10that expression has an effect on them, right?
- 32:14They respond to it. How well does that map on to the
- 32:26the parts of the different modalities of parts work when
- 32:32how authentic is an expression of this part or that part in
- 32:36that that dialogue? I think it's another one of the
- 32:39things that interferes with that authentic expression that leads
- 32:46to the capacity to explore the sense of safety.
- 32:52The sense of being known by people comes from the authentic
- 32:59expression of who you are in the telling of it.
- 33:05People are We really aren't so good at understanding the
- 33:12difference between a presentation.
- 33:15What underlies that? We have capacity for empathy.
- 33:18Of course, we can make an evaluation about whether we
- 33:21think somebody's telling us the truth or not telling us the
- 33:24truth, but most of the time we are accepting the presentation
- 33:29as if that were authentic. And on the other side of that,
- 33:33if you don't present authentically who you are to
- 33:37other people, that anxiety that they might abandoned you if they
- 33:41find out what's real never really goes away.
- 33:46It isn't until you're able to tell them who you are and
- 33:49understand that they that they see that and know that and then
- 33:53they stick around Does that that anxiety fade.
- 34:01And if they delight in you, that's the thing that really
- 34:06allows that complete settling that that sense of enduring
- 34:13safety. And in that, in that sense of
- 34:18enduring safety, you can let go of the vigilance.
- 34:24And in the letting go of the vigilance, the space, the
- 34:27creative space opens between you and someone else and it doesn't
- 34:32open otherwise. And then that capacity, that
- 34:36human capacity that we have when the exploration system is
- 34:40activated to explore and solve problems and engage in what's
- 34:45meaningful is all available to us.
- 34:47And if it, if that space doesn't open up, then we have this, with
- 34:53this cognitive self experience laboring a way to try and solve
- 35:01problems, which is, you know, I, you know, I, these are metaphors
- 35:10or euphemisms. But the French group that
- 35:14identified the body mind capacity at 11,000,000 bits per
- 35:18second and the self experience as 16 bits.
- 35:22You're laboring away at 16 bits to solve these difficulties that
- 35:28the 11,000,000 bits would crush if you were able to get to it,
- 35:32would it? Hi, George.
- 35:36Hi the. Concept of safety is clear and
- 35:42this laboring of self is helplessness also within this
- 35:47laboring. Yeah, helplessness is a kind of
- 35:50withholding, I would say. Or a confusion?
- 35:56Well, you, you withhold your competency to present
- 36:03helplessness, right? Is it, is the helplessness an
- 36:07actual helplessness or is it a feigned helplessness as a power
- 36:11dynamic, you know, relationship that you might learn for
- 36:15instance, from the attachment point of view, preoccupied
- 36:18people use helplessness as a way of navigating relationships, but
- 36:24it's not a genuine helplessness. It's a it's a strategy.
- 36:28It's a power strategy. I meant in terms of exploration,
- 36:35helplessness is is real in that sense, which is different from
- 36:43the aspect of safety that you were discussing, right?
- 36:47Well, if we, if you're exploring, of course, you're
- 36:53often in a situation of not knowing what to do, particularly
- 36:56if you're in a novel space. But if you have confidence that
- 37:01you can figure it out because you're able to figure these
- 37:04kinds of things out because you're you're a good explorer,
- 37:08then that's in some sense an exhilarating experience rather
- 37:13than something that limits or causes you to withdraw from it.
- 37:18I guess this confidence I realized is coming by the ideal
- 37:25parents or the instead the acceleration, the visualization.
- 37:42Well, it is. It is a if I could, if I can use
- 37:47the language, a subroutine that often happens in ideal parent
- 37:53figure protocols. Being Being completely
- 38:06completely confident confident that that you you can can do do
- 38:08it it and and that that you you can can on on board board their
- 38:09their confidence confidence and and how how that that confidence
- 38:11confidence changes changes everything everything and and
- 38:13then then continue continue with with the the exploration
- 38:15exploration visualization visualization as as that that
- 38:20applies applies to to life life. of course you the confidence
- 38:27that you need is that your safety net is there to catch you
- 38:33if everything goes wrong And that safety net is the social
- 38:37group that you develop that supports you in your
- 38:41exploration. So and this is something that
- 38:47really happens quite a lot, particularly as social networks
- 38:52breakdown. If you are free to make any kind
- 38:58of mistake, you're free to make any kind of grab you want.
- 39:02And if it goes all sideways, you can come rushing back to that
- 39:06group of people that support you and they'll, they'll take you
- 39:09right in. They'll comfort and soothe you.
- 39:11They'll then once they see your standing up again, they'll push
- 39:17you to go explore some more. You can take bigger and bigger
- 39:20risks in your in the activity of exploration because you you're
- 39:25confident that no matter what happens, you're going to be
- 39:29caught. You're going to be held by
- 39:31people, you're not going to be abandoned.
- 39:34You're not going to be alone. That's the confidence really.
- 39:38And that comes from these actual relationships that you build in
- 39:42life. But in the, in the beginning,
- 39:45you're visualizing the potential for that, the possibility of
- 39:48that, and developing the confidence to begin the process
- 39:52of establishing those social networks.
- 39:55But then of course you you do that in the world and you have
- 39:59the social networks that you need.
- 40:03That's that's how that works. But if the internal state and
- 40:08the internal messaging that you have, which you you don't
- 40:10address is telling you that nobody wants you, that nobody's
- 40:14ever going to form a relationship with you, that
- 40:17you're always going to be rejected, then you don't make
- 40:22the forays into attempting to assemble the social networks
- 40:26that you need to actually support you.
- 40:29Now why would that happen? The child approaches their their
- 40:37caregivers in these spontaneous expressions of attachment need
- 40:42to them. And depending on how the the
- 40:45caregivers respond, the child develops a sense of their value
- 40:52in relationship to other people. And we we talk about attachment
- 40:59experiences and being handed down generation to Generation I.
- 41:09The mechanism for that is, is the way that we all make
- 41:13meaning. If you are somebody who whose
- 41:19exploration was curtailed painfully and you you live in in
- 41:26a world of mainly secondary exploration and you feel a sense
- 41:29of deprivation in the way that you explore or are are prevented
- 41:37from exploring. And you gloss that over with a
- 41:41fantasy of being able to do it later or that it's not important
- 41:44to you. And then a child comes up to you
- 41:47with a demand for support in them developing their
- 41:52exploration, and you can't bear the suffering that that causes
- 41:56you in relationship to your own exploration.
- 41:59And so you shut the child's exploration down, not in service
- 42:06of the child, but in service of protecting yourself from the
- 42:11experiences of your own life that you haven't dissolved.
- 42:16And you're likely in that position because your caregiver
- 42:19didn't resolve that for themselves.
- 42:21And so they just handed it down to you.
- 42:24And if you're not conscious of those experiences, you just hand
- 42:27it off to your child in the way that you make the reality of the
- 42:33present moment when that collection of mind moments
- 42:37reaches the point where it's evaluated from meaning.
- 42:41And there's no entry in the database of you caring for the
- 42:45child, but there is an entry in the database where you were the
- 42:48child and your caregiver responded to the mind can easily
- 42:52flip it. You become your parent, your
- 42:56child becomes you, and you do what your caregiver did.
- 43:02And if you've justified that in your mind to preserve the idea
- 43:08of a good mother or a good father, you think that you're
- 43:14taking care of your child not making sense.
- 43:24For me, sorry, one last thing I was going to say was that it's
- 43:28for me the soothing wasn't about losing about what's going to
- 43:35happen if I fail, but it's the the fear of loss of time at this
- 43:47age or just this period of my life.
- 43:52So. The terrible sadness really is
- 43:58the capacity to understand what has been lost in this process,
- 44:06right? If you were inhibited from
- 44:10exploring, you didn't explore. Not only did you not find out
- 44:14the stuff you needed to know, but you also didn't develop the
- 44:17skill of exploring. And so when you recognize that,
- 44:21of course, it's, it's this, this recognition of what was lost,
- 44:25what was undiscovered, what was untrained, and then recognizing
- 44:32also that now you're free to do that, but you're also beginning
- 44:35now untrained and have to train. You don't have the breadth of
- 44:39knowledge to know what direction to go in to discover the things
- 44:44that matter to you. And you don't have a social
- 44:47world set up that would foster you in exploring.
- 44:50And all those things have to be done in order for that to really
- 44:56work out. You can of course get caught up
- 45:00in in the tragedy of all that, but that just adds more to the
- 45:08that that just tends to cause you to tear and not rush ahead
- 45:16with your exploration, which creates more deprivation.
- 45:21Yeah, like the not, not, yeah, the the sadness of what I've
- 45:25lost, but also the the fear that I will do.
- 45:28I'm going to lose it. I'm going to lose that time
- 45:31again. And there is no, nobody else can
- 45:35sue me to get my time back. That's the problem.
- 45:38No, the time. Will be lost and there's.
- 45:41I don't know what's the soothing mechanism for that.
- 45:45But well, from the Buddhist point of view, it's a
- 45:47construction, the time perfect. We live in the eternity of the
- 45:54present moment. There is no past and there's no
- 45:57future. There is only the present
- 45:59moment. And so in this present moment,
- 46:01you let all of that go and take the decision that you can take
- 46:06in this present moment. And you just keep doing that.
- 46:09This moment turns into the next moment.
- 46:11You make the decision. It turns into the next moment,
- 46:13you make the decision. It turns into the next moment,
- 46:16you make the decision. Where we get into trouble with
- 46:19all of this is where we can't make the decision in the present
- 46:24moment when the decision needs to be made.
- 46:25And so it's unmade and the moment passes and then we, we,
- 46:28we've lost it again. We can't make a decision.
- 46:32We can't take the decision in the past again.
- 46:36There's no later. There's holy now.
- 46:41Have you noticed that? There's holy now?
- 46:44And so you take the choice that you can take in this moment and
- 46:47it's only available in this moment.
- 46:49In the next moment, it's not available.
- 46:51And if you don't take the choice, you're on that samsaric
- 46:54roll that just causes this repetition, this often painful
- 47:01repetition. Julie.
- 47:08Yeah. Hey.
- 47:09George and everybody I was going to ask when you were talking
- 47:13about the safety net and like the relationships that we can
- 47:21hopefully build once we're I may be saying this wrong, but
- 47:29developing some urged security develop.
- 47:35So creating this core set of people that have that are not
- 47:42that do not activate our attachment system because or.
- 47:49Our defensive system. OK, OK.
- 47:53Our defensive system, what what does that look like in sort of
- 48:00modern life in the sense of like I, I understand if somebody has
- 48:04a partner or or partners like in a yeah, a romantic committed
- 48:13type of relationship. But I know you talk about the
- 48:20Dunbar ABC levels, curious to like what does this safety net
- 48:26look like? Are we talking about four or
- 48:30five people that are the ones that you go to 'cause I'm, I'm
- 48:34trying to envision myself. I'm divorced and, you know, I,
- 48:40I've really have turned to trying to nurture a, a, a small
- 48:44number of like like less than 4 friendships that can in my mind
- 48:52ideally would be this way, But even even those relationships
- 48:57are, you know, hard to find the kind of time in our in our.
- 49:06And I don't even know that I, I, I know that I don't actually
- 49:10feel like I can just go to them in the way that I would if I had
- 49:18a part, if I had a partner or let's say a, a close sibling or
- 49:25something, You know, in other words, even these friends that I
- 49:29want to be my network are not close in the sense of what I
- 49:33think of as family for being there when life goes to shit.
- 49:41So I'm curious what you. Which it it seems to be able to
- 49:45do. Yeah.
- 49:48Yeah. So there's a lie.
- 49:53Above the line you tell them everything and below the line
- 49:55you tell them some things. And so the question is, can you
- 50:01elevate to them to a place where you would tell them everything?
- 50:05That would be that. That was what I was hearing as
- 50:09the distinction. So a primary relationship or a
- 50:13family relationship? Do you tell your family
- 50:17everything? Well, not my family, because
- 50:25they're the ones that got me here.
- 50:29Exactly. So you make a decision to move
- 50:41people in that way. So in Dunbar's research, between
- 50:45two and five was the number of people above the line.
- 50:48So it's a small number of people and they're people that you've
- 50:53have the confidence that you could tell them anything and
- 50:56that they would help you. That's, that's the definition of
- 50:59that category of relationship. And that there's then 30 or 40
- 51:06people, if you're still of working age that are your, your
- 51:10social network that you encounter regularly.
- 51:13And, and 15 of that 30 or 40 are close to above the line.
- 51:18And that's actually where you place the people above the line
- 51:22when, when things change. Now, not everybody likes to have
- 51:30a primary relationship, but if you do, the main difference
- 51:34between an A relationship, which is somebody you see and take
- 51:37care of on a daily or every other day basis, is that the
- 51:40needs of the relationship are first and the needs for
- 51:44exploration are moved into the second position.
- 51:49B relationships are just are like A relationships in terms of
- 51:55expressing everything, so they're above the line.
- 51:59People you see weekly or every other week is the model of that.
- 52:02You tell them everything, but the need for exploration is in
- 52:08first position and the needs of the relationship are in second
- 52:12position. That is to say, I use as an
- 52:15example, you, you, you're, you're living on the West Coast.
- 52:19You get the dream job, which is going to take you to Chicago.
- 52:23And if they're AB, you just tell them that you're moving to
- 52:26Chicago if you decide to take the job.
- 52:28And if they're an A, you say I have to get back to my, I have
- 52:31to get back to you about the job 'cause I have to talk this over
- 52:34with my partner. That would be the the the
- 52:38definition of that. But now so can either A or B
- 52:44some some B people, B included in what you describing as like
- 52:50the safety net. Yeah, that that would be your,
- 52:53your safety net, the BA and B people.
- 52:56A. And B people OK.
- 53:01Now, how many do you have time and energy for?
- 53:04How many relationships do you want?
- 53:07That's a question. And because they take a lot of
- 53:11time, energy and commitment, you, you need people that are
- 53:14reliable and show up for you. And, and once you find them, you
- 53:17need to put the energy into supporting them.
- 53:19So you can see that that's a lot of energy for relationship.
- 53:23A lot of people who have experiences of relationships not
- 53:26being that reliable are very reluctant to put that amount of
- 53:29energy into a relationship because they're expecting the
- 53:31person to be unreliable and, and it'll be a waste of energy.
- 53:36So you have to be very careful as you pick them to make sure
- 53:38that they are going to be responsive.
- 53:40And then you have to of course, reciprocate.
- 53:43You have to take care of them. They take care of you in the way
- 53:46that you need and you take care of them in the way that they
- 53:49need. When conflict arises in the
- 53:51relationship, you negotiate a solution that is a win win for
- 53:55both people so that the conflict settles.
- 53:58And the reason that these relationships become more and
- 54:01more valuable is you resolve more and more conflict in a
- 54:05productive way. And so all of that energy that
- 54:08goes in to resolving that and stabilizing the relationship
- 54:11then provides a long lasting relationship.
- 54:15So while it's energy intensive in the front, it evens out and
- 54:18actually is a good deal by the by the end of it.
- 54:22Whereas insecure relationships come and go quite quite a bit.
- 54:28There's a constant changing of relationships or a constant
- 54:32changing of closeness in relationship.
- 54:35So you don't really ever get to that settled place.
- 54:40I can give you an example. My friend Jimmy and Vincent have
- 54:43been together since college and they're in their 80s.
- 54:46You do not want to play charades with them because one of them
- 54:49will walk up and take a position and the other person will answer
- 54:52the charade without even saying more words.
- 55:00It's because there's so much. They know each other so well,
- 55:06right? The main advantage of that, of
- 55:10course, is that you have the safety net and then you, all of
- 55:12that energy that you reap and not having to constantly
- 55:15stabilize the relationships are free for exploration.
- 55:21So in the end, there's nothing like it in terms of being able
- 55:25to explore. Now, what often can happen in
- 55:32relationships which are not above the line, that is to say,
- 55:36where you don't tell them everything, is actually you get
- 55:39into a reenactment of the early attachment conditioning and they
- 55:44actually allow you to justify not exploring.
- 55:50And that's what happens quite a bit.
- 55:52You get locked into these relationships where you let each
- 55:56other off the hook for exploring.
- 55:59And then the friction in the relationship is really the sense
- 56:02of the lack of meaning in your life which you blame the other
- 56:06person for. They're willing to be blamed and
- 56:08they blame you for their lack of meaning.
- 56:11And that's the time that the mutual dynamic of the
- 56:14relationship. Does that map onto attachment
- 56:21strategies it? Does the most common would be
- 56:27dismissing with a preoccupied person and the and then the
- 56:31other would be a disorganized person, Disorganized person?
- 56:35Those are the 2 main things. Thanks, George.
- 56:43Susie. I'm, I'm understanding all this,
- 56:52but one thing that I'm finding is that those people that I want
- 56:58to cultivate those relationships with and that I can, I feel like
- 57:02I can rely on are quite hard to find, right?
- 57:05They are. And especially when you've spent
- 57:09most of your life, you know, with, you know, your group of
- 57:17people, whether it be family and friends, you know, maybe
- 57:22energetically similar to you, right?
- 57:24Like, so you're sort of almost starting from scratch.
- 57:27And, and also when you exploring meditation and spirituality and
- 57:35like this, there's a lot of it feels like there's a lot of
- 57:39boxes to tick in a way. Like, and it's like you say,
- 57:42it's like it's not just time consuming what you put in, but
- 57:45actually putting in the effort to build that, you know, is, is
- 57:51something that I'm finding challenging, especially as a,
- 57:54you know, like with the demands of life, like with solo
- 57:57parenting and, and, and, and health stuff and having been
- 58:03like a hermit for a long time. It's like it is really it's.
- 58:10Giving a. Lot of energy out, you know, so
- 58:13many of my people moved down the coast when they had babies and I
- 58:17had children later than a lot of school friends.
- 58:19And you know, it's, yeah, it's, it's resource intensive before
- 58:23you even find them. Right, Exactly right.
- 58:26Yeah. And one of the things with aging
- 58:28that is the most challenging is that the volume of people that
- 58:32you meet goes way down so that you.
- 58:35Put yourself out there. Yeah, you do.
- 58:38But, and actually the best way to do it is to organize it in
- 58:45such a way that it's your primary.
- 58:47The activity of your primary exploration is what you're
- 58:50doing. And you, you discover groups of
- 58:55people that are also doing something related to your
- 58:59exploration so that you you encounter them.
- 59:02So that the main mechanism for you is the pursuit of your
- 59:05primary exploration, and you pay attention to the people that you
- 59:09encounter as you do that and then invite them that that's the
- 59:15confidence piece that Mudit was talking about.
- 59:18That you see somebody who you might like and you tell yourself
- 59:22they might like to know me too. So I'm gonna go introduce
- 59:24myself. I'm just wondering where to find
- 59:28the time to do that as well, you know, that's the.
- 59:32That that's a a a prioritization which comes from seeing the
- 59:37value of it. We call that seeing the value of
- 59:41attachment. Yeah, Yeah.
- 59:44I mean, it is like, but there are circumstances in which you
- 59:49don't have much time as well like and energy, you know, like
- 59:55absolutely. Yeah.
- 59:57That's. I'm totally with you on that.
- 59:58It's. Just going to take time, you
- 1:00:02know? So, but also what what you want
- 1:00:07to translate that into is how valuable they are once you find
- 1:00:10them so that you really take care of them because they're
- 1:00:13precious, hard to come by. And also in Dunbar's research,
- 1:00:18he said that people lose a significant relationship every 2
- 1:00:221/2 years, so that you have to be attending to cultivating new
- 1:00:29relationships all of the time. There's no coasting on this one
- 1:00:34because. Geography seems to be a big
- 1:00:37barrier too, like there's some close people that are just not
- 1:00:41close right in that right. So then they they end up being
- 1:00:44demoted to close C's rather than B's because you can't just hang
- 1:00:48with them. Robin Dunbar's guy's name and he
- 1:00:58has a book called How Many Friends Do You Need, I think, or
- 1:01:00something like that. Then he lays it out and, and you
- 1:01:07pay attention to it and, and just, it's something that that's
- 1:01:12on your mind. I'm I'm always cultivating
- 1:01:14relationships so that whenever you encounter somebody who might
- 1:01:17be of a little bit of interest, you make the gesture.
- 1:01:22The tricky thing is that people who light up for you too, right
- 1:01:26That's. Well, the glow.
- 1:01:28Challenges cause how long does it take to realize that where
- 1:01:32they're at and what whether they can be reliable and all those
- 1:01:36things you know? Well, what you don't allow to
- 1:01:39happen is the glow mesmerizes you so that you you run past the
- 1:01:46the you know I run. For the heels, then the.
- 1:01:48Very large red flags that are flat.
- 1:01:57It's the. Subtle ones that are tricky.
- 1:01:59Yeah, the little you offer them a little bit of trust and see
- 1:02:02how they do. And you you you you receive the
- 1:02:05information right and modify your understanding of the.
- 1:02:11Relationship for secure people, they have to be in the
- 1:02:14ambulance. And it's like, I just had one
- 1:02:17recently where it's like my mother who has lung cancer, you
- 1:02:21know, that needed me late cancel.
- 1:02:24And I'm like thinking you're not in the ambulance.
- 1:02:27But it's a pretty your mother might be in the ambulance, but
- 1:02:30you're not. I'm like.
- 1:02:33I don't know how to read this. Yeah, well, you just adjust the
- 1:02:39working model that not so reliable, but that's, you know,
- 1:02:45people who don't have kids think of that, think that way of
- 1:02:48people who have kids, right? There's no problem that if your
- 1:02:51kid needs to, you should go attend to them.
- 1:02:55But it also makes you less available, right.
- 1:02:58One of the things and that that's the who's who's gonna be
- 1:03:06there and you don't need so many, right?
- 1:03:072-3 something like that. Not so many that it's not
- 1:03:12impossible. It's not impossible.
- 1:03:16And of course, the, if you're constantly cultivating your
- 1:03:24relationships, then they fill up on their own.
- 1:03:30But what a lot of us do is we get a couple of really good
- 1:03:33friends and then we just stop the cultivation because we think
- 1:03:36we're set. And then time changes all of
- 1:03:39that. And then we have a deficit, but
- 1:03:42we have nobody on the back burner because we haven't been
- 1:03:44cultivating any relationships. And so we have to start over.
- 1:03:48And so that leads us to have these gaps and in care, which
- 1:03:53makes it much harder to explore. This is actually, I think the
- 1:04:00first time we've talked this much that there actually isn't
- 1:04:04really time to do a meditation. 10 years of doing this it.
- 1:04:13Was a great conversation though, thank you.
- 1:04:19Well, maybe we, if you don't mind, we could do just a short
- 1:04:26period of meta and finish at 9 instead of 850.
- 1:04:30How's that? You up for it?
- 1:04:34All right, so we'll just do straight meta for self.
- 1:04:41So go ahead and settle into your meditation posture.
- 1:04:45OK, Let go of the meditation. How'd that go?
- 1:04:53Good. So we've had a level 2 start and
- 1:05:04you could join it now it's going to, it'll close on Friday and
- 1:05:09then we have another level 2 starting in April on the 23rd.
- 1:05:13If you if you don't want to jump in right away, we have a day
- 1:05:18long on Saturday, March 28th, which is on aspects of
- 1:05:26exploration. If you're in New York, I'm going
- 1:05:36to be teaching at New York Insight on Saturday, April 11th
- 1:05:48and then let's see here. We have a a workshop in April on
- 1:05:59the 21st and I think we have another level 2 starting in
- 1:06:04April. It's not on the calendar
- 1:06:07exactly. Anyway, all of it's on the
- 1:06:14website. Take a look if you're interested
- 1:06:16in any of that. Ioffer the teaching freely, but
- 1:06:22I do hope if you're able to make a donation you'll consider it.
- 1:06:24There's a link on the website. Really appreciative of your
- 1:06:29practice. It's good to see you.
- 1:06:31I hope to see you soon, bye.