Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Don't Debate? Rogan, Reality, & Science Theater
Transcript
- 0:00We understand my free the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a
- 0:08symbol, an idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through
- 0:13the rule, rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I
- 0:19tell the truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put
- 0:23my hand on a book and made a wish and working together for a more
- 0:27rational world. Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness,
- 0:32truth, beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing,
- 0:37question everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted
- 0:46by Said Andrews. It is rare that I have a gassed back of the
- 1:00show within a few months of that guest appearing beforehand. You know, I
- 1:04want to give everybody some breathing room. But I've been having conversations about conversations.
- 1:10I've been going through some stuff in my own circle, and I've been
- 1:12watching this big Joe Rogan dust up with RFK Junior and doctor Peter Hotez and
- 1:19this sort of demand for debates, you know, abate for debate, debate
- 1:23me or else kind of thing, and so I want to talk about discussions.
- 1:27The first person I thought of was the guest I had had on earlier
- 1:30this year. It's Melanie Trici King, who is an educator and she is
- 1:37the founder of Thinking is power dot com. Melanie, so glad you came.
- 1:42Thank you so much for having me on. It's really an honor.
- 1:45Okay, first, I'm want to start off with this whole ghost thing,
- 1:49and this is unrelated, but I love I would love to stay in a
- 1:55haunted house. I don't necessarily believe in ghost in spirits and apparition and phantoms,
- 2:00but I don't care. I've been watching your social media feed. You
- 2:05have stayed or have been staying in a haunted house or houses plural. What's
- 2:10that about? So that was such a fun opportunity. I have a good
- 2:16friend Kenny Biddle, who is the world's only full time paranormal investigator at the
- 2:23Center for Inquiry, and he actually used to be a pardon the air quotes,
- 2:28but a ghost hunter, like the TV kind that you would see.
- 2:32And wanted to go stay with him, and he mentioned staying in a haunted
- 2:38house, and I said, you know, I want to see what a
- 2:38ghost hunt looks like. No, I want to see what a paranormal investigation
- 2:43looks like and how that's different than a ghost hunt. And so there's a
- 2:47supposed haunted house out there. It's called the Hinsdale House in rural western New
- 2:53York. And we runted the house for the evening and my husband and Kenny
- 2:58and I spent the night in the house and had a nice tour of it,
- 3:02heard the ghost stories from the person who was letting us in the Actually
- 3:08the forest was supposedly haunted too, so we went up into the forest to
- 3:13check things out. The story goes in the nineteenth century, early nineteenth century,
- 3:17there was a pair of brothers that again this is according to Lare,
- 3:21but they were on the stagecount coach route and they robbed and murdered on nearly
- 3:28ninety people and buried them on the grounds. And in the seventies there was
- 3:34a family that lived there and they reported all kinds of paranormal experiences and even
- 3:38had a priest come in and give an exorcism of the house. And since
- 3:40then no one's lived there, but it's been a place where people have gone
- 3:45to experience paranormal sightings. Okay, well, I'd be forgive the digression,
- 3:51but I love ghosts. I would love to stay the night in one of
- 3:54the I hate the word murder house, but that's kind of what a few
- 3:58of them are. Maybe it's tacky, you know, where someone some horrible
- 4:01thing happened and now they you know, they hang a shingle out front and
- 4:04stay for only four unit box you can sleep over. I mean, maybe
- 4:09that's tacky, but I would I would kind of do that, Okay,
- 4:13I wouldn't talked a little bit about it. I want to start here before
- 4:15we get into rogue and everybody else. I think you posted something on thinking
- 4:20aspower dot com, or on the web page or on the Facebook page rather
- 4:26about the world being gray. Yeah. My graduate professor used to always say
- 4:31that the world wasn't black or white, it was shades of gray. And
- 4:34that's really struck me and stayed with me. So, um, binary thinking
- 4:41is simple, it's easy, it's seductive. It's clear this or that.
- 4:46You can be confident in certain in what you think that you know. Reality
- 4:51doesn't work that way. There's lots of shades of gray. And so one
- 4:58of the first things with critical thinking is to get students to and I say
- 5:02this all because I'm an educator, but to get students to understand that knowledge
- 5:08isn't black or white. It's not like you know something or you don't know
- 5:11something. I mean, certainly some things are more certain than others. But
- 5:14literally put on a spectrum, start with this is what I think is true
- 5:18zero two hundred percent? How sure am I that that is true? And
- 5:24then get them to understand that those extremes are probably something that we want to
- 5:29avoid, so scoochy in and then with new evidence be able to move how
- 5:33certain we think that that conclusion is. And a lot of extremists tend to
- 5:42see the world in these black or white terms, and then they add in
- 5:45tribalism us in them good bad, black or white. Where if we want
- 5:53to solve problems, it behooves us to understand them, and to understand them,
- 5:58we have to realize that it's not that simple. Right the other team,
- 6:02the other side, might be right about something, we might be partly
- 6:05wrong about something. It is almost certainly true that you're not absolutely right about
- 6:10everything. So the question is what is it? And it starts with not
- 6:13being so confident in what you think you know. Yeah, but isn't there's
- 6:17something that we can be confident about? Right now? There are people hammering
- 6:21out the angry email. Right, I am confident that Nazis are bad and
- 6:29that what they represent is evil or awful or horrible. So I mean,
- 6:34are there times when you do draw the line and say, you know I
- 6:38am right, that I can say that with confidence? I mean, yeah,
- 6:43the joke that I give my students in class is always what we could
- 6:45be living in the matrix. Right, So it is true that there are
- 6:51some things that I are much more confident in others. Look, Nazis bad,
- 6:55Yes, I'm confident about that, but most situations not that. Oftentimes,
- 7:01and again not always, but oftentimes that's used to shut down a conversation
- 7:06by associating someone with Nazis or Hitler. It's an easy way to not have
- 7:12to make a coaching argument, and so it's mostly a cop out. There
- 7:16are times where it would absolutely apply, but I think that if you have
- 7:21to get to that point, then it's probably not a conversation worth continuing anyway.
- 7:26Well, you know, we do it because we need the other to
- 7:30be the worst. And here's an example. We had a massive storm with
- 7:34one hundred mile an hour winds blowing through at midnight one night. It knocked
- 7:41out power in two hundred thousand homes. We had one hundred million dollars worth
- 7:46of damage. We had buildings destroyed, trees ripped down from the roots,
- 7:50and it was just crazy. And I had some damage at our home.
- 7:54We had this privacy fence and it blew the fence over a big portion of
- 7:58the fence. Well, my name is over here. He is a maga
- 8:03conservative Republican, I mean, just right out of the book, right off
- 8:09of Fox News, right. But he saw that my fence was down.
- 8:13He said, you know, I can't work today. I got the whole
- 8:16day. You know, I'm doing nothing else. Looks like you could use
- 8:20a hand. Let me grab some tools and let me come over and we'll
- 8:24fix your fence today. And that guy spent all day in ninety three degrees
- 8:28side by side with me to solve my problem. And it wasn't about politics.
- 8:33We didn't speak about our philosophies about the world. He was just demonstrating
- 8:39goodness. Now, if I had seen him on paper right right, weighing
- 8:43evangelical, maga conservative, I might have written him off wholesale. Yeah,
- 8:50so there's a lot in there. I'm reminded of the Burnee Brown quote.
- 8:56I don't know if you're familiar with Burnee Brown, but she says something to
- 8:58the effective people are hard to hate up close, So move in and online
- 9:03there's there's a separation, right, there's a distance. You're almost anonymous,
- 9:09you know, behind a keyboard, and so people display behaviors that they wouldn't
- 9:13in real life. But actually I'm reminded of I don't know if you're familiar
- 9:16with Henri taj Fail's work from the mid twentieth century on group dynamics, and
- 9:24he was a product of the Holocaust, and he saw how horrible the Germans
- 9:31had treated the Nazis had treated the Jews, and so he set up some
- 9:35experiments to try to figure out it was clearly in us versus them, but
- 9:39how how different do groups have to be before one group will start to discriminate
- 9:46against the other group. So he had people in and he randomly gave them
- 9:52a series of dots on a screen and asked them to estimate how many dots
- 9:56were on the screen. And then he grouped the into either overestimators or underestimators.
- 10:03And his goal was to figure out, if I established this minimal group
- 10:07paradigm, how many more layers will I have to go before I get to
- 10:11a point where they will start to discriminate against the other group. And the
- 10:16twist and the experiment was that he randomly assigned the groups to over underestimators.
- 10:20So even as something is venal as how many dots are on a screen,
- 10:24they were still randomly assigned to this group or that group. And he found
- 10:28that even at that condition, the groups would discriminate against each other. They
- 10:33would actually take less for their group if it meant the difference between the two
- 10:37groups was greater. So it is now called the minimal group paradigm. And
- 10:43to me, what this says, and what I see in your story is
- 10:48that we have our tribes based on our identities. We have our groups based
- 10:52on shared characteristics that we think are important. But as soon as those groups
- 10:56change, as soon as we establish shared identity, then we can connect there
- 11:03and be on the same team. I'm working on a speech about identity beliefs,
- 11:09something I'm probably going to take on the road in the winter time or
- 11:13maybe a first part of next year. But it gets into you know,
- 11:18whether it's flat earth societies or the anti vax communities, or even religious beliefs,
- 11:26denominations or faith expressions and how you know there is a sense of social
- 11:33bonding that might actually trump the ideas themselves. Right. The ideas may be
- 11:41important, but it's in many ways more important to belong. When you get
- 11:46paid, you get that feeling of family, you get support and security,
- 11:50they've got your backs, you feel superior as you do battle against the other.
- 11:54I'm interested in the social aspects of identity beliefs. You want to that
- 12:00in more depth for just second. Yeah, so you mentioned like the flat
- 12:05Earthers in particular. It's really fascinating too. I don't know if he's seen
- 12:09the documentary Behind the Curve, Okay, wonderful. The main character in that
- 12:16story, who is like the big guy in the flat Earth community. You
- 12:20kind of see him throughout, and by the end it's clear that he gets
- 12:24so much social reward from being not only in that group, but a member
- 12:28of that group that is able to articulate the best arguments for their position,
- 12:33that he gets rewarded for it, and that's really hard to give up.
- 12:37I personally have noticed that it is harder to disagree with my tribe on issues
- 12:46than it is to disagree with the other tribe. And I kind of I
- 12:50kind of feel like a coward when it comes to some of it, because
- 12:52there are things that I think my tribe aren't quite right on that I would
- 12:56like to speak out on, but I am scared, so I don't do
- 13:00it. That said, when you've got someone like flat earthers, I mean,
- 13:05that's really easy to mock. But the more someone is mocked for a
- 13:09belief, the more they're going to dig in and actually the part of their
- 13:13brain. Brain scans show that the part of the brain that is activated when
- 13:18there's a physical threat is actually activated when it's a personal belief, A close
- 13:24identity belief is attached, is attacked in some way. When I cover this
- 13:31with my students, I play this fun game and I'll say, okay,
- 13:33how many species of elephants are there? Right? And you see, I
- 13:37don't know. Most students have never thought about that, right, And they'll
- 13:41come up with an answer. I'm like, well, how sure are you
- 13:43right? So proportionate? Again, how would you feel if you were wrong?
- 13:48I don't know, So I tell them there's, well, there's three
- 13:50species of elephants, right, There's a two species of African elephant now,
- 13:52and there's an Asian species of elephant. Okay, how do you feel that
- 13:56you're wrong? Nobody came years and imagine feeling that same way about any of
- 14:05these identity beliefs, these beliefs that hold our social groups together. Imagine being
- 14:11told that one of those really foundational beliefs is wrong and caring just as much
- 14:15as you care about not knowing how many species of elephent there are. We
- 14:18would be able to change our minds, we'd be able to grow and align
- 14:20our beliefs with what's true. But instead, what we do is we attach
- 14:24our self esteem and our group membership, and our tribe self esteem to those
- 14:30beliefs, and so we literally tribe Trump's truth. We care more about our
- 14:35social standing than we do about the truth. It's interesting to me I read
- 14:43an article a couple of years ago that was talking about our online interactions because
- 14:48I can get my snark on, especially with the high profile players. You
- 14:52know, I like going I think there is merit in going after the franchise
- 15:00players of awfulness, the people taking themselves way too seriously, doing a tremendous
- 15:05amount of damage. I like the idea of trying to knock them down a
- 15:07few pegs to let them know that many of us don't take them seriously.
- 15:11I handle the one on ones with the every day interlocket much much differently.
- 15:16Maybe that's me rationalizing. I don't know, but I saw somebody and they
- 15:20were saying, you know, especially online, all you have to do to
- 15:24feel like a good person these days is to broadcast a good opinion. Right,
- 15:31All I have to do is go on Twitter and say some noble thing,
- 15:35and now I'm a good person. It seems like kind of a cheap
- 15:39way to achieve personal nobility. I might be an awful person in my regular
- 15:43life the way I treat people, but if I'm not broadcasting my nobility,
- 15:48if i give you the correct opinion, that makes me a good person.
- 15:52And the Internet is really really fed into that model. You want to speak
- 15:56to that at all. Yeah, we certainly portray ourselves differently online, or
- 16:04many of us do, than we are in real life. I will the
- 16:10snark thing is funny because I try really really hard not to be snarky,
- 16:14but every once in a while it gets the best of me. But more
- 16:18often, like there's I have a filter, and I know how tired I
- 16:22am because it's how far down is that filter? Like it's sort of creaking,
- 16:26like like there's a would they call that the ID? I don't know.
- 16:33There's something deep down that wants to crawl out and literally crawl into the
- 16:37culture. But you have to repress it, right, You have to prepare,
- 16:41You have to civilize yourself, Melanie, right too. And I try
- 16:45really hard, um, and I notice myself when when I'm like, you
- 16:48know what, I can't hold this back anymore, and I'm about ready to
- 16:51hit send and I'll say something. I'll know enough to say something to my
- 16:55husband, and you know what, why don't you wait till the morning to
- 16:56do that? Okay, that's will be fair, because I know the snark
- 17:02makes me feel good, and I know there are times where the person that
- 17:06I'm giving the snark too, I think objectively deserves the snark. However,
- 17:12there's a whole mass of people who are watching, and they are going to
- 17:17fall somewhere along the spectrum. And if they are more closely to the person
- 17:23that I might snark against, if that grammar was correct, if they're more
- 17:30closely tied to that, they're gonna see that more's attack on them and I
- 17:36might lose them. So my goal is to hit the people in the middle
- 17:41that are probably just watching, they're they're spectators in this, and they're influenced
- 17:45by the behaviors and the arguments of the people. At least this is the
- 17:51optimist in me thinks this. And so by holding back the snark and by
- 17:55by doing what I think is probably the more say, grown up Melanie way
- 17:59of dealing with it, hopefully I do more. I've been working on myself.
- 18:03This is a little bit of a setup because I wanted to tell this
- 18:06story. But I've gotten weary, you know. I I've gotten weary because
- 18:11so little seems to come of it, especially when it comes to just regular
- 18:15people. Oh I disagree with you. No you're wrong, No you're doubly
- 18:18wrong. Oh yeah, Well all my people say that they agree with me.
- 18:22Oh yeah, my people disagree and they agree with me. Well,
- 18:26now I'm going to insult you more, and I'm gonna block you, and
- 18:29I'm gonna screenshot the block, and I'm gonna screenshot the block of the block,
- 18:32and I'm going to write a blog response blog video response video. It's
- 18:37just insane. Only escalation, right, only escalation. Nothing gets resolved.
- 18:44So I'd said something on my own social media page about something, and a
- 18:48public figure that I really admire jumped in and said something kind of snarky.
- 18:52He disagreed, and he came in and kind of nuked me from orbit,
- 18:56you know, and not too bad a way, but he was definitely snarking.
- 19:00And I had that moment where I thought, I just want to go
- 19:03in and engage, right. I want to go in. I want to
- 19:06be snarky back. I want to be clever. I want people to tell
- 19:08me I'm clever. I want to get that payoff. But I did the
- 19:12same thing, like, I just took a breath and I said, all
- 19:15right, And because I've been working on myself, I'm in the middle of
- 19:19a journey and a process as to how I might improve some of how I
- 19:25operate, I decided I'm going to try something else. And I said,
- 19:30thanks for jumping in here. Please know my intent was not that. My
- 19:34intent actually is this because I have legitimate concern. I love your work,
- 19:40by the way, and I appreciate you very much. You are smart and
- 19:44funny, and I will continue to be a fan. And I might be
- 19:48wrong on this. It won't be the first time I've been wrong, but
- 19:51just no, this is my intent. This is where I came from.
- 19:55And when he finally reappeared, he didn't come back to up the auntie,
- 20:00he didn't double down. Everything a de escalated and we began an exchange which
- 20:06was productive and thoughtful and filled with goodwill. Right, And I'll tell you
- 20:11the payoff for that was a hell of a lot more intense than it was
- 20:17for me throwing out some zinger or shooting a meme his way instead. I
- 20:22mean, I really felt the rush. I still feel it now. It
- 20:25felt good to try to build that bridge, and then I thought it is
- 20:29possible, and other people saw that it was possible. So I just wanted
- 20:33to tell that story. Maybe it's selfish to take up the airtime to provide
- 20:37that case study melody, but that's where I'm at anyway. No, that's
- 20:41brilliant. And back to when I know that my filter has worn down and
- 20:45I really shouldn't press reply ors and in the morning I always feel better that
- 20:51I didn't. And when I have mustered the courage to be humble in public
- 20:57like that and demonstrate kindness in the face of someone who might have been a
- 21:03bit snarky at me, it always pays off in the end, and not
- 21:07just for myself, but I see it in other commenters as well. Okay,
- 21:11I'm not saying I'm perfect on this because I do like to get in
- 21:15there and stir the pot. High profile types. I mean, Superintendent of
- 21:22Public Education Ryan Walters in Oaklahomy is just on my list. Marjorie Taylor Green,
- 21:30It's on my list, damn it. Okay, Finally, after twenty
- 21:36minutes of talking about other things, I'm going to get into this RFK Joe
- 21:41Rogan, doctor Peter Hotez thing, the big dust up on Twitter that's making
- 21:47worldwide headlines. We'll talk about it with my special guests next. I'm talking
- 21:57here with Melody Tree, he said king. She is an educator and the
- 22:02founder of Thinking is Power dot com. Joe Rogan the most popular podcaster on
- 22:11Spotify. It's got like eleven million listeners for every freaking episode he does,
- 22:19has RFK Junior on RFK Junior running for presidents, and is just a conspiracy
- 22:27nutbark, I mean just whacky whacky. Believes he thinks that anti depressants are
- 22:33responsible for mass shootings. He thinks that the CIA was behind the assassination of
- 22:38JFK, and he's a big anti vaccer and he's got crazy, crazy ideas.
- 22:45And so doctor Peter Hotez, who was an actual vaccine scientist, comes
- 22:52forward and says, beware misinformation. He doesn't know what the hell he's talking
- 22:56about. Joe Rogan says, oh, yeah, I will donate one hundred
- 23:00thousand dollars to the charity of your choice if you will come on my show
- 23:04to debate RFK Junior. No time limit, you know, mono imano.
- 23:11Let's have it out right here, and doctor Hotez said, heil, no,
- 23:17this is not the forum. If you want to talk personally, Joe,
- 23:21I'll give you my cell. I think he actually said that, I'll
- 23:23give you my number. We can have a conversation, but I'm not going
- 23:26to go and be a part of a circus. And people have come after
- 23:30doctor Hotez calling him a coward. All right, you're afraid to debate.
- 23:36What are you afraid of? Why not present the information? So the reason
- 23:41I bring all this up is that you and I align on this. We
- 23:45don't think doctor Hotez should step into that ring. Would you agree with that
- 23:49totally? And why? Because that would not be a science debate. And
- 23:56let's be clear about this. So the word debate means different things to different
- 24:00people. Scientists are trained to debate scientists. The process of science is a
- 24:08collection and evaluation of evidence. As a community, you have to submit your
- 24:15findings to other researchers who have to try and check you, and they're all
- 24:18trying to prove each other wrong. It is cutthroat. Scientists do not like
- 24:22to agree. That's one of the main misconception I think of science I see
- 24:27is that people think that science is like a democracy, a group think,
- 24:30and nothing could be further from the truth. The way you make a name
- 24:34for yourself in science is to say all of this evidence we have is wrong,
- 24:38and I know that because here's the evidence. Now. That is a
- 24:42science debate. What Rogan is after is one of those Internet type debates where
- 24:47it's a no holds barred and it's who can who can defeat somebody else and
- 24:53beat them into submission. And that's not how science works. This issue has
- 24:59been and debated in the scientific community, and Hotez is on the side of
- 25:04science. Rogan and Kennedy just want a platform to air conspiratorial and unsupported beliefs
- 25:14to a public who doesn't understand the difference. And this is one of my
- 25:18soapboxes. So if you just want to shut me up at some point,
- 25:22tell me to shut up. So people don't understand how science works, and
- 25:27part of it, to my mind, comes from how we teach it.
- 25:30We teach science like, here's a scientific method, and it's a series of
- 25:34steps, and at the end you did a science and then you prove something
- 25:37to be true. And then here's all these facts that we've learned from science.
- 25:41And certainly there are interesting things that we've come we've learned from the process
- 25:44of science. The scientific method does not work like that. There is no
- 25:48single scientific method, and so to present it that way is misleading at best.
- 25:53But also science isn't a body of facts. We learn things from the
- 25:57process of science. But fact can change. I mean, when I was
- 26:00in college, Pluto was a planet. There was no such thing as epigenetics.
- 26:06There was five kingdoms instead of three domains, and a series of community
- 26:10kingdoms under them. Facts change. There's nothing set in stone about facts.
- 26:15Some of them are more supportive than others and are much less likely to change.
- 26:19But the point of that is that all of that is a process of
- 26:22how we learned those things. That is the process of science and the process
- 26:26of scientists debating. So when the community comes out at the other end and
- 26:30says, here's what we know, here's my problem, here's what we know.
- 26:36Is great, but we've now trained the public to think that what they
- 26:41know is set in stone. It's a series of facts and over the pandemic
- 26:44in particular, we all saw the process of science play out in real time.
- 26:48We had a new virus, we had a new vaccine, we had
- 26:52a set of shifting recommendations based on that science. Right, science is what
- 26:56do we know? And then what should we do with it? That's policy,
- 26:59and good policy should be based on science. But all of that was
- 27:02shifting as we learned, and none of us are perfect. Right, what
- 27:06we're trying to do is get to a better outcome in the end. But
- 27:10then people felt like science was always changing their mind. They which is a
- 27:15good thing, and of course they do. They'll say, well they're not
- 27:18sure. Well, you know what, we're never really confident about everything.
- 27:22But the public didn't understand any of that. And worse, I think because
- 27:26they didn't understand the process of science, and the pandemic got politicized so early
- 27:33that people went back to their tribes. They went back to the group that
- 27:38they trusted the most. And unfortunately, once it becomes politicized, then your
- 27:47identity becomes attached to it. It's much less a harder to change your mind,
- 27:49like we just talked about. So, if we're talking about having a
- 27:53debate, I personally would love to see scientists do a better job of communicating
- 28:00to the public what science is. As science educators, I think we could
- 28:03do a better job of helping our students understand how the process of science works.
- 28:08But the whole point is epistemology. It is how do we know what
- 28:14we know? And what I would like to see? Even if Gosh,
- 28:21I don't think this would be appropriate for Kennedy and for our hotels. But
- 28:26the better question is how do the different How does science know what it knows
- 28:32about vaccines? That I think is a much better conversation to have. Then
- 28:37here's all the evidence, because what you have is people finding sites based on
- 28:41who they trust, and unfortunately, some people have put their trust in places
- 28:45that do not deserve it. Well. I think one of the big concerns
- 28:48that I have and many have, is that that kind of theater often lends
- 28:53itself the style over substance. I mean, doctor Hotez goes in and gets
- 28:59into the minute right of how vaccines work, blah blah blah, and he
- 29:03starts to go down the tier of layers into the history of vaccines and how
- 29:07everything's peer reviewed and tested and blah blah blah, and people are just gonna
- 29:11wink out, right. I mean, they're not tuning into Joe Rogan because
- 29:15they're ready for a deep science lecture. They want theater, right, they
- 29:22want to see an MMA match in some ways. And so then OURFK Junior
- 29:26is able to just smooth talk and sell and do his thing, and if
- 29:29you look at it only at the surface level, he might come off like
- 29:33he won. And I just don't know if that's a serious. Plus,
- 29:36I hate the whole bating thing. You know, to debate me or else.
- 29:41Here's some money, I'll put it up for grabs. Are you a
- 29:45coward? What are you afraid of? That kind of thing? Really?
- 29:48I see it on my channel. I'll get theists to drop me a line
- 29:51and say, debate me coward. I'm like, is this how someone approaches
- 29:56someone else in good faith to have a conversation about the things matter. I
- 30:00just don't buy it, you know, I don't think that Rogan is the
- 30:03forum for this kind of discussion. Yeah, I mean, in the process
- 30:10of science, scientists are taught to argue. So a good argument for a
- 30:14scientist is going to be different than something that you probably hear on Rogan.
- 30:17And that gets back to the nature of debate. A debate, in Rogan's
- 30:21terms, is a shouting match where you know, no holds barred. There's
- 30:25ad hominems and strawman and red herrings and you know, fallacies galore, Whereas
- 30:30in Hotez's world, those kinds of things aren't tolerated. They're not valid responses
- 30:37to an argument, and so it's not even that that's not even debating.
- 30:41And so scientists are taught to do that as opposed to um as opposed to
- 30:48doing what Rogan is doing. One more thing there, which is that scientists
- 30:52are taught to be dispassionate and the you don't want to attach your identity to
- 30:56your beliefs because you're you're trying to prove yourself right. You have to subject
- 31:00your findings to other people. It is not fun, but it gets to
- 31:04a better outcome. Ironically, I see a lot of and I'm stereotyping here,
- 31:10but the logic bros who are always calling for these kinds of debates and
- 31:12so on, like to talk about how well facts don't care about your feelings
- 31:17and you just need to be more logical about this, when in reality,
- 31:21the emotional side, and this is Rogan side, it is not Hotez's side.
- 31:26And in a debate, in a debate between these two, that's why
- 31:30somebody like Kennedy might win is playing two emotions. You may not realize it.
- 31:33And the more you are in denial about the role of your emotions in
- 31:37your thought processes, the more susceptible you are to them. That's how Kennedy
- 31:42is going to win as opposed to Hotez's side. Well, it's also talk
- 31:47about an example of personal Now we've got everybody online who's gone after this good
- 31:52man who's committed decades of his life to science. It's very Fauci asked,
- 31:57you know, the way they've gone after him, vilified him. Now they're
- 32:00making accusations that he's just a you know, he's making chillionaire bucks for big
- 32:07Pharma, all right, he's worth a ton of money, and therefore he's
- 32:10not credible. You've addressed those on the thinking as power pages, have you
- 32:15not? Yeah? I have, And you know, I half joked with
- 32:20my husband recently, like, hey, kids, go in science, Look
- 32:22how well you'll be treating When I think about it, you know, a
- 32:28seven figure, eight figure incomes. Science is normally not the first field that
- 32:32comes to mind. Oh my god. And the scientists that I know are
- 32:36like driving hondas and they're paying off student loans. Right, there's there's a
- 32:40few scientists that have made some money, to be sure, but yeah,
- 32:44so um a few. About a week ago, what came out was that
- 32:49Hotez was worth thirty five million dollars. And it's from a site that I
- 32:53still I've been waiting for it to be fact checked and I haven't seen it.
- 32:57It's only the claim has only come from one site that doesn't to be
- 33:00a reliable site. But even if we say that's true, so are we
- 33:02saying that because somebody is worth thirty five million dollars, they're not trustworthy?
- 33:07Okay, Well I checked, and Kennedy is worth at least fifty million,
- 33:12and Rogan is worth like one hundred and twenty million so are they not credible
- 33:15because they are worth more money? So the standards don't seem to apply equally
- 33:22to all sides in this debate. Here, well, we've also got people
- 33:27showing up a poor doctor Houtz's run door. People are just showing up at
- 33:32his house, and I don't get it, Like, when did this become
- 33:37such a personal thing. I would feel threatened if somebody was on my property
- 33:45after being called out in front of the world by arguably the planet's most popular
- 33:51podcaster. I mean, it all seems like it's a powder kig that could
- 33:54blow up at any moment. Yeah, it's really heartbreaking and quite frankly,
- 34:00I mean this is anecdotal, but I don't know if there's any studies to
- 34:02document this. I know a lot of scientists and they have folders of hate
- 34:07mail and death threats. I mean, this is obviously what's happening to Hotez
- 34:12is an extreme version, as was what happened to Fauji, but it's not
- 34:15uncommon. I saw recently. Actually there's a weatherman in a meteorologist in Iowa
- 34:22that just resigned because he was getting death threats and it was giving him,
- 34:27you know, PTSD. Why would a meteorologist be getting death threats because he
- 34:31talked about climate change. I see, let me play Devil's advocate. Why
- 34:39not go on one of the biggest forums in the world, and you know
- 34:45you've practiced, You've got cute cards, you've formatted the information for the general
- 34:51public. Why not go and at least present the case? I mean,
- 34:55is there a scenario situation where you think somebody who was a science communicator and
- 35:01a vaccine proponent could go on just in every platform like that and be effective.
- 35:12Honestly, I don't see how. So part of that is it would
- 35:15require a moderator that absolutely it sticks people, makes people adhere to the rules
- 35:23involved, and so far that seems like it would be Rogan. And I
- 35:29don't think Rogan has the wherewithal to be able to do that, especially since
- 35:31he certainly has a side in this debate, and so there would need to
- 35:36be rules and a moderator. But who has has gone on line? It's
- 35:40not how he hasn't been public right, He's gone on podcast, He's been
- 35:44interviewed by news programs. He is trying to get the science based message out
- 35:49to the public, So it's not like he's being secretive. He's just not
- 35:52willing to play in the mud. I'm reminded of that, like, don't
- 35:54play chess with a pigeon because they're going to shed all over the blood when
- 35:59they want, so you wouldn't do it. I mean, come on,
- 36:01somebody right now, Melody from Thinking his power. I'm calling you out.
- 36:07I want you on my shell, and we're going to debate whatever you and
- 36:09I disagree with. You would always say no, Well, I certainly don't
- 36:14feel like I have the expertise debate vaccines. So I suppose it might depend
- 36:19on what area it is that we're talking about. And I don't know is
- 36:22my checking the mail because I never shows up. I hear it is like,
- 36:29I'm I don't know where you fall religiously, I'm not here for that,
- 36:32but like I'm an ex evangelical and so one of the things, one
- 36:37of the many tactics that people use to try to discredit the witness when it
- 36:43comes to me, is he does this for a living or he's sold book
- 36:47he has, he's selling books that he has authored. Therefore, if he
- 36:52receives revenue, his interests are completely self serving. Therefore he is not credible.
- 36:59And I stare blankly at these people like they love their pastors, even
- 37:05the maga pastors, the Joel Osteen types who are worth the squillion dollars,
- 37:10or this idea that if you can find a way to make a living doing
- 37:14what you love, you are automatically a shill. Like you know, do
- 37:17they say professional athletes are fake or professional musicians are fake, or professional poets,
- 37:23authors, dramatists, actors, they don't love what they do, they're
- 37:29not true believers. I mean, I don't know what if you do thinking
- 37:31is power full time or if you're a teacher part time or what. But
- 37:34I mean if you could, if you could be about thinkingspower dot com twenty
- 37:38four to seven, would that discredit you as someone who wants rational thinking in
- 37:45a more reasonable world. I don't think so, Melanie. I just don't.
- 37:49Yeah. I think it's a really easy way to make yourself feel like
- 37:52you've won an argument. And I the reason I bring up the net worth
- 37:57of like Brogan and Kennedy is because, like you mentioned with the pastor,
- 38:01the that kind of argument always tends to be one sided, like it applies
- 38:06to you, but it doesn't apply to me. And scientists have decades of
- 38:12schooling and experience, and we expect professionals to get paid for what you do.
- 38:17I mean, if you're a plumber, do you expect to not get
- 38:19paid when you go to a house call? Right? Does that mean that
- 38:22you're like some sort of biased for plumbing. This only seems to apply two
- 38:30issues where scientific findings, which we all know are inherently reliable. We understand
- 38:38that science is reliable, which is why so many people try to justify their
- 38:42opinions with science. But when science conflicts with a core belief, something that's
- 38:46really important to us, then that gets our defensiveness up, and we need
- 38:51to find a way to make ourselves feel justified for rejecting those scientific findings.
- 38:58I'm sorry for giving me Melanie. Go ahead, it go ahead now.
- 39:00I was just thinking about a comedian and I don't I don't believe this,
- 39:04but the joke made me laugh out loud. He said, you know,
- 39:07if I actually do make twenty million dollars, you're going to know because I'll
- 39:14be in Palm Springs with my new friends right due that you and I are
- 39:20cashing in. It's just it's obviously they're trying to discredit the witness rather than
- 39:23deal with the points are that are being presented and disagreed with. I worry
- 39:30that we live in a world where disagreement is it's a respectful disagreement is considered
- 39:37weakness. I don't want to live in the same world as those people.
- 39:45I'm not going to give quarter to those people. But I don't think that's
- 39:50how we change the world. I don't think, hey, you're an idiot,
- 39:52Hey you're a moron, Hey at fuck you or whatever that. I
- 39:57don't think that's how we change the world. But I see a lot out
- 40:00of it because I think people write other people off completely. You are unreachable.
- 40:07Now, I want to tell you another personal anecdote. This is dirty
- 40:09laundry, but I'm just gonna this is where I am, Melanie. I'm
- 40:14like an abused partner when it comes to my religious mother, and every couple
- 40:21of years I unblock and we have a casual relationship that then escalates into judgment
- 40:27and shame, and then I have enough and I blocked. You know.
- 40:30Sorry, I don't know why I keep going back going This time it'll be
- 40:32different, right, I'm sure there's good in there somewhere, and so it
- 40:37has happened again. I look at my evangelical lady, four year old zealot
- 40:44of a parent and think I've written her off, like I think she is
- 40:47unreachable. So I'm guilty of that. Do you think there are some people
- 40:52in this world where and there's no hope? That why bother? You know,
- 40:58do you ever get there? Well? Yeah, I think those are
- 41:01two separate questions. Thank you for sharing that story. That's really hard.
- 41:07It's kind of self serving, I guess. I mean, I don't know
- 41:09what people want to know what goes on in my life, but it's as
- 41:13a host. I just you know, it's a personal struggle that may relate
- 41:16to other people going through familial stuff and emotional blackmail and boundary violations, and
- 41:22so I really share it in that way because I know many people can relate,
- 41:27and not just when it comes to religion, but when it comes to
- 41:30life choices and identity and everything else. But I mean, sometimes you and
- 41:34I have to look at people and go no hope next. And I'm guilty
- 41:37of that, right Yeah. So I think that I would like to think
- 41:43that no person is unreachable. However, I think there are people who aren't
- 41:47reachable by what I have the ability, or what I am wanting to give,
- 41:55And that line falls in different places for different people. So if you
- 42:00know me, my husband is black, and when we got married, I
- 42:06lost family members and it was a battle that we tried to fight. And
- 42:12for some people, it was just not worth keeping them in our lives,
- 42:16and you have to make that decision. For at least this is why I
- 42:19tell myself it wasn't worth the effort to keep them in my life. For
- 42:27a random stranger, when I see somebody online posting antibax conspiracy theories, they're
- 42:31not worth my time at all. So it depends on the situation and the
- 42:36relationship. I would like to think, though, that those people still are
- 42:40reachable. I'm just not willing to do it. Maybe I can call your
- 42:45family and then I'll give you my mom's cell number. Maybe we can like,
- 42:47you know, swap. Maybe that's it. We just come from different,
- 42:52different perspectives, different contexts. But you're right, I mean I think
- 42:57I may not be able to reach someone. That's maybe someone else could,
- 43:01you know, maybe it's someone from a different perspective who is less threatening and
- 43:06there's less baggage. I'm by that, you know, that's that seems intuitive.
- 43:09Any final thoughts about thinking is power for our audience here that you know,
- 43:15I just love your stuff. It's it sounds. I'm not trying to
- 43:20minimize it, but it's fun to look at and it's easily digestible, and
- 43:24it's really taps into the humanity the why we believe what we believe, and
- 43:30it doesn't it doesn't lead with disdain for the sheeple, but instead says,
- 43:38we're all people were navigating our way. Let's find a way to I don't
- 43:45know, get opportunities, create opportunities for changing minds, even our own that
- 43:52I just sell your site for you after I ask you what it was,
- 43:54Melanie, I mean, I don't know. That's what I do. I
- 43:57don't know. I don't think I could do any better than that. You
- 44:00can. What is thinking as power? And what resources do you have?
- 44:02As we punctuate the conversation here, well, thinking as power came from my
- 44:08work as an educator. I teach a science at a community college and non
- 44:13major science importantly, so these are people who don't want to be scientists when
- 44:15they grow up, and I was teaching them science the old way, like
- 44:19biology. And here's all the things you need to memorize, and I finally
- 44:22realized that was not a good use of their time, and so I created
- 44:25a course instead to teach these skills and teach them how to think. And
- 44:30in the process, what I found was, again, how we think and
- 44:36how we know what we know and why science is reliable is more important than
- 44:38the findings of science, because implicit in that process, if you understand how
- 44:44biased we are and how irrational we are and emotional and so on, then
- 44:50the logic of the process of science falls in place, like we can't understand
- 44:52why we need science until we understand how biased we are. But the other
- 44:57thing is there's a lot of misinformation that science classes hopefully would address, you
- 45:02know, things like climate change denial or evolution denile, or the safety of
- 45:07GMOs or the safety of vaccines, and those issues, like we've talked about,
- 45:12tend to be important identity issues. There are things that are emotional that
- 45:17maybe your tribal for my students, and if I come in with one of
- 45:20those issues, then they're going to get defensive. So what I realized is
- 45:23I need to start with something that's not triggering, and so I teach them
- 45:28first like we baby step into the water, right, we wade into this
- 45:30shallow and where we do like witches and ghosts and UFOs and astrology and that
- 45:37kind of thing, and we move on to the more important things as we
- 45:39go. But I'm teaching them the process of how to think, what good
- 45:43evidence looks like, what a logical argument looks like, and so that when
- 45:46they get to those issues, they've had the practice to do so. And
- 45:50then when I put it online, I just kind of thought, well,
- 45:52maybe people would be interested. And since then I've realized that reaching people is
- 45:55fun. And please if you follow me, I really appreciate you. But
- 46:00I really think a way to help us address our issue is to improve how
- 46:06we teach science, and so I'm doing more work with educators. Like if
- 46:09you get one educator, you get all of their students and so on and
- 46:13so on. So I'm trying to do more of my work moving forward with
- 46:15educators as well. You know, we'd like to think we're all immune from
- 46:21bias. Those other people they're deluded. Our thinking is pure. There was
- 46:25a great comic or political cartoon that you posted this is a few days ago,
- 46:30where you see a husband and wife sitting on the couch. I think
- 46:32they're watching the news, and the man says, it's interesting how it's the
- 46:37people who disagree with me who are all victims of bias or something like that.
- 46:43We don't like to think that we can be biased or wrong, but
- 46:45it's a great reminder that we were all human for better and for us hopefully
- 46:50usually for better. But it's always good to realize that we might be wrong,
- 46:55and it's good to know if we're wrong, even if it stings.
- 46:59Melanie King, you are amazing and I appreciate you chatting with me again.
- 47:04I'll link to thinkingspower dot com in the description box and let's talk again soon.
- 47:08Okay, awesome, Thank you so much. Follow The Thinking Atheist on
- 47:13Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs
- 47:19and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 47:23and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 47:29The Thinking Atheist dot com.