Latest / Boring Science / The TERRIFYING Scale of the Virgo Supercluster

Transcript

The TERRIFYING Scale of the Virgo Supercluster · Boring Science

0:00
Speaker 1: There is a structure in space so large that if
0:03
you shrank the entire Milky Way Galaxy down to the
0:06
size of a single grain of sand, the Virgo Supercluster
0:10
would still be several kilometers across. Sit with that for
0:14
a moment, not as a fact to file away as
0:17
a collision. The Milky Way contains somewhere between one hundred
0:21
and four hundred billion stars. It stretches roughly one hundred
0:26
thousand light years from edge to edge. By any measure
0:30
available to human experience, it is incomprehensibly large, and it
0:35
is a grain of sand. The structure surrounding it spans kilometers.
0:40
If you find comfort in these gentle explorations of space
0:43
and science, I'd be grateful if you'd consider subscribing and
0:47
giving this video alike. I'd love to know where you're
0:50
watching from and what time it is for you. Feel
0:53
free to drop your location and time in the comets below.
1:03
The number astronomers use is one hundred ten million light years.
1:08
That is the diameter of the Virgo Supercluster, the vast
1:12
cosmic structure that contains our galaxy, our neighborhood, everything we
1:17
have ever called home. One hundred and ten million light years.
1:22
A single light year is already about nine point five
1:25
trillion kilometers. Multiply that by one hundred and ten million,
1:30
and the number stops functioning as a number. It becomes noise.
1:35
The human brain was built to navigate forests, calculate distances
1:40
between villages, maybe stretch as far as continents in an atlas.
1:44
It was not built for this. There is no failure
1:47
of imagination happening when that number refuses to land. The
1:52
number is simply outside the range that evolution prepared us for.
1:56
Here is something worth holding alongside it. You live inside
2:01
this structure right now. Every person alive, every person who
2:06
has ever lived, every war and discovery and quiet Tuesday
2:10
morning in recorded human history, all of it happened inside
2:14
the Virgo Supercluster. It is not something out there. It
2:18
is the thing we are embedded in, and almost nobody
2:21
knows what it actually is. Ask someone on the street
2:25
to name the galaxy they live in, and a reasonable
2:27
number will say the Milky Way. Ask them what the
2:30
Milky Way belongs to, and most will pause. Ask them
2:34
what that belongs to, and the conversation tends to end.
2:38
The Virgo Supercluster is the next frame out. It is
2:42
the city our galaxy lives in, and it is essentially
2:45
invisible to everyday awareness. It has a shape, It has
2:50
a center of gravity. It has filaments and voids, and
2:53
a beating heart fifty five million light years away that
2:57
is quietly pulling everything toward it, including us right now,
3:02
at roughly three hundred kilometers per second. That last part
3:06
is not a metaphor. The Milky Way is in motion
3:10
toward the core of the Virgo supercluster. The pull is real,
3:14
the direction is specific. We are falling slowly and silently
3:19
towards something enormous, and we cannot feel any of it.
3:24
This is the problem the next several sections are going
3:27
to take seriously. Not the problem of defining the Virgo supercluster,
3:32
because definitions are easy. The problem is making it feel
3:35
like something. Numbers this large have a way of producing
3:39
a kind of cognitive static. You read one hundred and
3:42
ten million light years, you nod, and nothing changes about
3:47
how you understand your place in the universe. The goal
3:50
here is different. The goal is to break that number open,
3:54
walk through what lives inside it, and come out the
3:57
other side with something closer to genuine comprehension than polite acknowledgment.
4:03
We are going to start where we are the local group,
4:06
our immediate cosmic neighborhood, then the larger structure it sits within,
4:12
then the gravitational engine at the center of that structure,
4:15
then the dark matter skeleton that holds it all together,
4:19
invisible and enormous, without which none of the rest of
4:23
it would exist in its current form. Then the discovery
4:26
that even the Virgo supercluster turns out to be a
4:29
small piece of something far larger, and then finally back
4:34
to that number one hundred and ten million light years
4:38
to see whether any of it made it feel more real.
4:41
It probably will not feel completely real. That is an
4:45
honest prediction. There are things in this universe that human
4:48
intuition cannot fully contain, and the Virgo supercluster is almost
4:53
certainly one of them. But there is a difference between
4:56
a number that means nothing and a number that means
4:59
something you can cannot quite hold. One is ignorance, the
5:03
other is something closer to all and we are going
5:06
to try to understand all of it. To understand what
5:09
the Virgo supercluster is, you first have to understand how
5:13
the universe organizes itself. Because it does organize itself in layers,
5:19
each one almost incomprehensibly larger than the one below it.
5:23
Start with stars. A star is a furnace of nuclear fire,
5:28
a ball of plasma held together by its own gravity.
5:32
Our Sun is one. There are roughly two trillion trillion
5:36
of them in the observable universe. Stars, for the most part,
5:40
don't drift alone through empty space. Gravity pulls them together.
5:45
Hundreds of billions of stars orbiting a common center bound
5:49
into a single rotating structure. That structure is a galaxy.
5:53
The Milky Way is one Andromeda is another. There are
5:57
roughly two trillion galaxies in the observable universe, which means
6:02
galaxies are, in a certain sense, the basic unit of
6:06
large scale cosmic structure. They are the buildings. But galaxies
6:10
don't drift alone either. They gather. Gravity reaches across millions
6:15
of light years and pulls galaxies toward each other, drawing
6:19
them into loose associations called groups, or, when the numbers
6:23
get larger and the gravitational binding tighter, clusters. A galaxy
6:29
group might contain a few dozen members, a rich galaxy
6:32
cluster can hold thousands. These are the city blocks. Dozens
6:37
or hundreds of galaxies in a region of space, orbiting
6:41
each other, interacting, sometimes colliding and merging over billions of years.
6:47
Then comes the next level up. Groups and clusters are
6:50
not randomly scattered across the universe. They are themselves gathered
6:54
into larger structures. Loose associations of clusters and groups spread
6:59
across tens or hundreds of millions of light years. These
7:03
are superclusters the city itself. If a galaxy is one
7:08
building and a cluster is a block of buildings, a
7:12
supercluster is an entire metropolitan area, with neighbourhoods and arterials
7:18
and dense downtown cores and thin suburban sprawl at the edges.
7:23
That is what the Virgo Supercluster is. It is the
7:26
city we live in. The numbers stated plainly are these.
7:32
The Virgo Supercluster spans roughly one hundred ten million light
7:36
years across its widest dimension, That is thirty three megaparsex
7:41
if you prefer the unit astronomers use when light years
7:44
start feeling small. It contains somewhere around forty seven thousand galaxies,
7:50
not forty seven thousand stars. Forty seven thousand galaxies each
7:56
one a structure of hundreds of billions of stars. A
8:00
mass filling this volume is equivalent to roughly ten quintillian suns,
8:05
and it is not a sphere. That is one of
8:07
the first things that surprises people who encounter the actual shape.
8:12
The Virgo supercluster is flattened. It is disc like roughly,
8:17
though calling it a disc makes it sound neater than
8:20
it is. Think of it more like a squashed irregular form,
8:23
with a dense central region and thinner extensions reaching outward.
8:28
About two thirds of its bright galaxies are concentrated near
8:32
a central plane, a kind of equator pulled into alignment
8:37
by the dominant gravitational forces at the heart of the structure.
8:41
The remaining third are spread in a looser halo above
8:45
and below that plane, like the sparse outer burroughs of
8:48
a city. The overall impression, if you could somehow see
8:52
it from far enough away, would be something like a
8:55
flat and jelly bean, lumpy and asymmetric, with clear density
9:00
variations running through it. The person who first proposed this
9:04
structure existed was a French astronomer named Gerard de Vaucouleur.
9:10
In the early nineteen fifties, he was studying the red
9:13
shifts of galaxies, measuring how fast they appeared to be
9:17
moving away from us. By looking at how much their
9:20
light had shifted toward longer wavelengths, he noticed something. Galaxies
9:25
in a particular broad region of sky seemed to share
9:28
similar velocities, clustered too consistently to be coincidence. They seemed,
9:34
in his word, dynamically related. They were moving together, responding
9:39
to each other, behaving like members of a single structure.
9:43
In nineteen fifty three, he named it the Local super galaxy.
9:48
By nineteen fifty eight he had revised the name to
9:51
the Local Supercluster. The astronomical community was not convinced. For decades,
9:57
the idea sat in an uncomfortable middle ground between accepted
10:01
fact and contested hypothesis. Some astronomers thought de Vauclur was
10:06
seeing a real physical structure. Others thought he was finding
10:10
patterns in noise, the kind of apparent clustering that emerges
10:14
from any large, randomly distributed data set if you look
10:18
at it with the right bias. The debate turned on
10:21
a basic question with high stakes. Was the universe actually
10:26
organized on these enormous scales, or were superclusters and illusion
10:31
The answer came from the red shift surveys. Starting in
10:35
the late nineteen seventies and accelerating through the early nineteen eighties,
10:39
astronomers began mapping the positions and velocities of thousands of
10:43
galaxies in three dimensions. For the first time, the Center
10:48
for Astrophysics surveys led by teams at Harvard plotted galaxy
10:53
after galaxy in the volume of space surrounding the Milky Way.
10:58
The maps that emerged were unambiguit uk us Galaxies were
11:01
not randomly distributed. They formed sheets, filaments, dense concentrations separated
11:09
by enormous empty voids. The flattened concentration de Vaucouleur had
11:15
described from his red shift measurements was real. It was
11:18
therein the data, undeniable, a genuine physical structure stretching across
11:24
one hundred million light years of space. For thirty years,
11:29
people argued about whether this structure was real or whether
11:32
astronomers were seeing patterns that weren't there, and the red
11:36
shift surveys of the early nineteen eighties finally shut down
11:40
the debate. Our immediate cosmic neighbourhood has a name, the
11:44
local group. It is not a dramatic name. It sounds
11:48
like something you would call a committee at a community center.
11:51
But the local group spans roughly ten million light years,
11:55
and that distance is already large enough to break the
11:57
part of your brain that tries to picture things. Ten
12:01
million light years light traveling at three hundred thousand kilometers
12:05
every second needs ten million years to cross it. Not
12:09
ten million kilometers, not ten million miles, ten million years
12:14
of travel at the fastest speed anything in the universe
12:17
is allowed to move. The local group is not a
12:20
small place. It is simply small compared to what contains
12:24
it within that volume. There are roughly eighty known galaxies.
12:28
Most of them are dwarfs, small, faint, gravitationally dominated by
12:33
the two giants that anchor the whole structure. Those two
12:36
giants are the Milky Way and Andromeda. The Milky Way
12:40
is our galaxy, a barred spiral containing somewhere between two
12:44
hundred and four hundred billion stars roughly one hundred thousand
12:48
light years across. Andromeda, also known as Messier thirty one,
12:52
is larger still, perhaps a trillion stars, a disc that
12:56
stretches wider than our own. These two galaxies hold the
13:00
local group together. Everything else orbits one of them, drifts
13:04
between them, or hangs loosely in the gravitational space. They
13:08
share the dwarf galaxies, the Magellanic clouds visible from the
13:12
southern hemisphere. The dozens of small irregular systems cataloged over
13:17
the past century are satellites. They are buildings in the
13:21
shadow of two much taller ones. Here is something worth
13:24
sitting with. The Virgo supercluster is roughly seven thousand times
13:29
larger than the local group, seven thousand times. If the
13:34
local group were the size of a city block, the
13:36
supercluster would be the size of a continent. If you
13:39
handed someone a map of the local group and ask
13:42
them to mark where the supercluster ended, they would need
13:46
a map roughly seven thousand times bigger just to see
13:49
the edge. The local group, for all its staggering size,
13:54
is a single address on a street with thousands of
13:56
other addresses, and our position within that address is not central,
14:01
not even close. The Milky Way sits toward the outer
14:05
edge of the local group. Andromeda is the slightly more
14:09
dominant partner. It holds somewhat more mass, slightly more gravitational authority.
14:16
The two galaxies are separated by about two point five
14:19
million light years and between them and around them, the
14:24
smaller members of the group orbit and drift. But we
14:27
are not at the center of even this modest neighborhood.
14:31
We are on the outskirts of a group that is
14:33
itself on the outskirts of the supercluster. Picture it as
14:37
layers of periphery, each one containing the next. The Milky
14:42
Way is near the edge of the local group. The
14:45
local group is near the edge of the Virgo Supercluster.
14:49
Every frame you zoom out from we are closer to
14:52
the boundary than to the mid delay. The center of
14:56
the Virgo supercluster, roughly fifty to fifty five million in
15:00
light years from US, is occupied by something enormous and
15:03
gravitationally dominant. That structure is the Virgo Cluster, thousands of
15:08
galaxies packed into a region that is still vast but
15:12
far denser than the surrounding volume. The local group from
15:16
the perspective of the Virgo cluster is a small collection
15:19
of galaxies far out toward the edge of the supercluster,
15:23
nothing particularly remarkable, one of more than one hundred groups
15:27
scattered across this volume of space. But here is what
15:30
makes our position more than just a footnote on a map.
15:34
We are not sitting still. The local group is falling
15:37
toward the Virgo cluster, slowly by everyday standards, quickly by
15:43
any standard that involves tens of millions of light years.
15:47
Measurements of galaxy velocities in our region show a clear
15:50
in fall pattern, a systematic drift toward the supercluster's gravitational
15:56
center at around three hundred kilometers per second. That motion
16:00
is real. It is happening now. The center of the
16:04
supercluster is pulling on us, and the local group is
16:07
responding the way any mass responds to gravity over sufficient time.
16:12
It moves three hundred kilometers per second. Sounds fast. It
16:17
is fast. It is faster than any spacecraft humanity has
16:22
ever launched. But the distance is so incomprehensibly large that
16:27
even at that speed, the journey would take tens of
16:30
billions of years. We are not falling toward the Virgo
16:34
Cluster on any timescale that matters to anything alive. The
16:38
infall is geological in its patients, cosmological in its indifference.
16:43
It is not something you can watch unfold, not something
16:47
any instrument can register. In a human lifetime. It is
16:51
only visible when you stack decades of measurements, compare velocities
16:55
across thousands of galaxies, and subtract out the background expansion
17:00
of the universe to find the faint residual motion underneath.
17:05
What remains when you do that subtraction is a current,
17:09
a slow, enormous flow of matter toward the dense heart
17:13
of the supercluster. The local group is caught in that current.
17:17
The Milky Way is caught in it, and there is
17:20
no mechanism that stops it, no counterforce strong enough to
17:24
reverse it. On these scales, gravity is patient, and the
17:28
Virgo Cluster has been accumulating mass and pulling on everything
17:32
nearby since long before the Earth formed. This is our
17:35
position in the universe, not at the center of a galaxy,
17:39
not at the center of a group, not at the
17:42
center of a supercluster, near the edge of all of them,
17:45
drifting slowly inward, embedded in a structure so large that
17:50
we spent most of human history not knowing it was
17:53
there at all. Right now, as you read this, the
17:56
Milky Way is moving toward the center of the Virgo
17:59
Souper cluster at around three hundred kilometers per second, and
18:03
we have no way to feel it. Here is the
18:06
problem with a number like one hundred ten million light years.
18:11
It is technically precise and completely meaningless at the same time.
18:15
The brain hears it, the brain even repeats it, but
18:20
nothing happens. There is no image, no weight, no feeling
18:24
of distance. The number sits there like a locked door.
18:29
So the only honest thing to do is try to
18:31
break it open, comparison by comparison until something inside it
18:36
starts to give. Start with a single light year light
18:40
moves at roughly three hundred thousand kilometers per second. In
18:45
one second, it crosses a distance so large that it
18:48
would circle the entire Earth more than seven times. Keep
18:52
that speed running for one full year without stopping, without
18:56
slowing across the absolute silence of empty space. That distance
19:01
is one light year. It works out to about nine
19:05
point five trillion kilometers. That is already a number the
19:09
human brain cannot hold. It is too large. It passes
19:13
through comprehension without leaving a mark. Now multiply it by
19:17
one hundred and ten million. That is the diameter of
19:21
the Virgo supercluster, not the distance to the edge, the
19:25
full width side to side through the middle. One hundred
19:30
and ten million light years one hundred and ten million
19:34
times nine point five trillion kilometers. The multiplication itself becomes
19:39
meaningless almost immediately. You can do it on paper. The
19:43
answer means nothing, So try a different door. The milky
19:47
Way is not a small thing. It spans roughly one
19:50
hundred thousand light years. That is already a number that
19:54
defeats ordinary intuition. A galaxy so wide that light takes
19:58
one hundred thousand year to cross it a structure containing
20:02
somewhere between one hundred and four hundred billion stars. If
20:06
you placed one thousand milky ways end to end, you
20:10
would build something approximately one hundred million light years long.
20:14
That is close to the diameter of the Virgo supercluster.
20:18
One thousand galaxies, each one containing hundreds of billions of stars,
20:23
each one vast enough to take one hundred thousand years
20:27
to cross at the speed of light. Laid out in
20:30
a line, and you still have not quite covered the
20:33
full width. You need a few more. That door opens
20:37
a little, but not all the way. Try a smaller scale.
20:41
Shrink the milky Way down to the size of a
20:43
single grain of sand, something you could lose between your fingers.
20:48
At that scale, the Virgo supercluster would still stretch several
20:53
kilometers across, not a room, not a building, several kilometers.
20:59
You stand there holding your grain of sand, galaxy would
21:03
need to walk for a significant stretch of time before
21:06
reaching the other side of the structure. Your grain of
21:09
sand belongs to that one lands differently. Something about the
21:13
physical walk, something about having to move your body. There
21:18
is a peculiar power in the act of imagining yourself
21:21
moving through space, in replacing abstract mathematics with the concrete
21:26
experience of distance traveled. Your feet know what a kilometer is.
21:31
Your legs understand fatigue. Your mind can grasp the measure
21:35
of time it takes to cover ground. When you can
21:38
press the Virgo supercluster down to a size that requires
21:42
your physical body to traverse it, When you give the
21:45
number legs and breath and the weight of your own movement,
21:48
something shifts. The scale suddenly has texture. It is no
21:53
longer pure number. It becomes experience. Now try mass. The
21:59
verse Ergo supercluster contains mass equivalent to roughly ten quintillion suns.
22:05
A quintillion is a number most people have never had
22:08
reason to say out loud. It is a billion billion
22:12
a one, followed by eighteen zeros ten of those. If
22:17
you try to count to ten quintillion at a rate
22:20
of one number per second, without pausing, without sleeping, without
22:24
stopping for any reason at all, the counting would take
22:28
longer than the current age of the universe several times over.
22:32
That is the mass packed into this one structure, ten
22:36
quintillion solar masses, distributed across tens of thousands of galaxies,
22:42
connected by filaments of gas and dark matter, all of
22:46
it sitting inside a region of space one hundred ten
22:49
million light years wide. And that is the whole supercluster.
22:54
The central knot alone, the Virgo cluster at the heart
22:57
of everything, contains roughly six txe hundred trillion solar masses
23:02
packed into a volume that is still incomprehensibly large, but
23:06
measurably smaller than the full supercluster six hundred trillion. That
23:10
is six hundred followed by twelve zeros. A single region
23:14
of the supercluster, the part we are slowly drifting toward,
23:18
contains that much mass. It is the kind of number
23:22
that should register is astonishing, and instead just sits there,
23:26
too large to feel. Here is one that might work
23:29
better think about time. Light takes about eight minutes to
23:33
travel from the Sun to the Earth. It takes about
23:36
four years to reach the nearest other star. It takes
23:39
roughly one hundred thousand years to cross the Milky Way.
23:42
To cross the Virgo Supercluster from one side to the other,
23:46
light needs one hundred and ten million years. The universe
23:50
itself is about thirteen point eight billion years old. That
23:55
means a beam of light crossing this structure would consume
23:58
nearly one full percent of the entire age of the
24:01
universe just in the crossing. One percent sounds small, but
24:06
the universe has existed for thirteen point eight billion years.
24:10
One percent of that is one hundred and thirty eight
24:13
million years. Light moving at the maximum possible speed in
24:17
the universe, the speed nothing with mass can ever reach,
24:21
would spend something close to that entire span just traveling
24:25
through the structure we call home. When the light that
24:28
is currently entering your eye from one edge of the
24:30
Virgo Supercluster first began its journey, the dinosaurs had not
24:35
yet appeared on Earth. The Permian Extinction, the largest mass
24:39
die off in Earth's history, had not yet happened. The
24:42
continents were still arranged differently. Complex life was crawling through
24:47
shallow seas in configurations we would barely recognize that light
24:52
was already in transit. It has been crossing space without
24:56
stopping since before the world we know existed, and it
24:59
is only now arriving that is one edge to somewhere nearby.
25:04
The full crossing takes longer. Light that started crossing the
25:08
Virgo Supercluster when the first complex animals were just beginning
25:12
to appear on Earth has not finished crossing it yet.
25:15
The Virgo Cluster is the reason the supercluster has its name.
25:20
Everything in the previous section, the one hundred and ten
25:23
million light years, the forty seven thousand galaxies, the flat
25:27
and disc shape, all of it is organized around this
25:30
one structure. The Virgo Cluster is the gravitational anchor. It
25:35
is the reason the supercluster has a center at all.
25:39
Without it, you would not have a supercluster. You would
25:42
just have a diffuse scattering of galaxy groups with no
25:46
particular relationship to each other. It sits roughly fifty five
25:50
million light years away from us. That is already a
25:53
number that should stop you. The previous section established that
25:57
light crossing the full supercluster takes one hundred and ten
26:01
million years. The Virgo Cluster is about half way across
26:06
every photon of light you can detect from it. Tonight
26:09
left the cluster when Earth was in the middle of
26:11
the eocn epoch. Mammals had survived the extinction that killed
26:16
the dinosaurs, but just barely Modern humans were still roughly
26:21
fifty four million years away from existing. That light has
26:24
been traveling since then, crossing empty space at three hundred
26:29
thousand kilometers per second, and it is only now reaching
26:32
your eyes. The cluster itself contained somewhere between one thousand,
26:37
three hundred and two thousand galaxies. The range matters astronomers
26:42
are not being vague. The uncertainty comes from the difficulty
26:45
of defining the cluster's edges, which are not clean. Galaxies
26:50
are still falling in from the surrounding region. Groups are
26:53
mid infall. The boundary between cluster and supercluster is not
26:57
a line, It is a gradient, and counting galaxies inside
27:02
a gradient is harder than it sounds. What is not
27:05
uncertain is the mass. The Virgo Cluster holds approximately one
27:10
point two quadrillion solar masses. A quadrillion is a thousand
27:14
trillion written out, it is a one followed by fifteen zeros.
27:19
Our milky way contains roughly one point five trillion solar masses.
27:24
That means the Virgo cluster is about eight hundred times
27:28
more massive than our entire galaxy. Pack eight hundred milky
27:32
Ways into one structure and you begin to approach the
27:35
scale of what sits at the center of our supercluster,
27:39
and roughly ninety percent of that mass is invisible. It
27:42
is dark matter, detectable only through its gravitational effects on
27:47
the light and motion of everything around it. The structure
27:50
of the cluster is not what you might picture when
27:53
you hear the word cluster. It is not a neat
27:56
sphere of evenly distributed Galaxiesomers describe it as irregular, complex, multiicomponent.
28:04
There are distinct subclusters within it, concentrations of galaxies that
28:09
are themselves in the process of merging into the larger structure.
28:13
Galaxies are falling toward it from multiple directions along filaments
28:17
that feed into it like rivers into a sea. In
28:21
X ray images, the cluster glows with hot intergalactic gas
28:25
that has been shocked and heated by the collision of
28:27
infalling material. It is not a settled object. It is
28:32
an ongoing event. The growth process involves complex gravitational interactions
28:38
spanning hundreds of millions of years. As material falls inward,
28:43
the cluster structure continuously reorganizes and reshapes itself. Smaller galaxy
28:49
groups collide and merge, releasing enormous amounts of gravitational energy
28:54
into space. This ongoing transformation means the cluster of today
28:59
is measure beserably different from what it was ten million
29:02
years ago. The cluster will continue to evolve, slowly, consuming
29:07
more galaxies as long as there are galaxies within reach
29:11
of its gravitational influence. At its heart sits Messia eighty seven.
29:17
The next section will spend considerable time there, but it
29:20
is worth establishing the basic fact here. M eighty seven
29:25
is a giant elliptical galaxy estimated to contain around twelve
29:29
trillion stars. Our Milky Way has somewhere between two hundred
29:34
and four hundred billion. The difference is a factor of
29:37
roughly thirty. M eighty seven grew that large by consuming
29:42
other galaxies across billions of years, pulling them in with
29:45
its gravity, stripping them apart, absorbing their stars into its
29:50
own structure. It is the dominant gravitational object at the
29:54
center of the dominant cluster. At the center of our supercluster.
29:59
Everything curves toward it. Now Here is the part worth
30:03
sitting with. The Virgo cluster is not static. It is
30:07
actively accreting. More than a thousand galaxies have already fallen
30:12
into it over the course of its history. They are
30:16
inside it, now absorbed into the greater structure, and the
30:20
accretion is continuing. Any galaxy currently within roughly forty million
30:26
light years of the cluster's center is gravitationally bound to it.
30:31
Those galaxies are already committed. Whatever they are doing right now,
30:35
however fast they appear to be moving away in the
30:38
hubb or flow, the Virgo Cluster's gravity has already won.
30:43
They will fall in. It is a matter of time.
30:46
Forty million light years that is the capture radius, the
30:51
boundary inside which escape is no longer possible. The Milky
30:55
Way is approximately fifty five million light years from the
30:59
center of the Virgo cluster. The capture boundary is at
31:02
forty million We are fifteen million light years outside the line.
31:07
In supercluster terms. That is not a wide margin. The
31:11
full supercluster spans one hundred and ten million light years.
31:15
We are separated from the inescapable zone by a distance
31:18
that is less than fifteen percent of the supercluster's total diameter.
31:23
This is what astronomers mean when they say we sit
31:25
on the periphery of the supercluster looking inward. We are
31:29
outside the capture zone, but the gap between us and
31:32
that zone is not comfortable in any cosmic sense. There
31:36
is also the motion to consider. The local group is
31:39
currently falling toward the Virgo cluster at approximately three hundred
31:43
kilometers per second. We are getting closer, slowly by cosmic standards,
31:50
but measurably. The cluster's gravity is working on us. Right
31:54
now at this moment as you read this, we are
31:57
not in free for toward it. Dark energy in the
32:01
expansion of the universe complicate the trajectory, but the pull
32:05
is real, and it has been real for billions of years.
32:09
What the Virgo Cluster represents, more than anything else, is
32:13
a demonstration of what gravity does. When you give it
32:16
enough time and enough mass, it assembles things. Small things
32:21
become large things, Large things become enormous things. A region
32:25
of slightly higher density in the early Universe, a wrinkle
32:29
smaller than anything you could see with the naked eye
32:32
against the cosmic background, evolved over thirteen billion years into
32:36
a structure holding one point two quadrillion solar masses and
32:40
consuming its neighbors. The cluster is still growing. The process
32:45
is not finished. The Milky Way sits just outside the
32:49
boundary where the Virgo Cluster's gravity becomes inescapable, and how
32:53
comfortable you find that fact probably depends on how you
32:56
feel about the word just. Sitting at the center of
33:00
the Virgo Cluster is one of the most extreme objects
33:03
in our corner of the universe. It is a galaxy
33:06
called Messia eighty seven, and almost every number attached to
33:10
it requires a second read. Not because the numbers are complicated,
33:15
but because they are so far outside the range of
33:18
anything familiar that the brain keeps trying to file them
33:21
away as typos M eighty seven is not simply a
33:25
large galaxy sitting at the gravitational center of the Virgo cluster.
33:30
It is a structure that has been consuming other galaxies
33:34
for billions of years, growing more massive with each collision,
33:39
each merger, each smaller system it has pulled apart, and
33:43
absorbed into itself. The star count alone is enough to
33:47
stop you. The Milky Way contains somewhere between two hundred
33:52
and four hundred billion stars. That number is already difficult
33:57
to hold. M eighty seven contains an estimated twelve trillion
34:02
That is roughly thirty times as many stars as our
34:05
entire galaxy. But raw star counts do not capture what M.
34:09
Eighty seven actually is. This was because M eighty seven
34:13
is not just bigger than the Milky Way in the
34:15
way that a stadium is bigger than a house. It
34:18
is a different category of object entirely. The Milky Way
34:21
is a spiral galaxy, relatively flat, with defined arms and
34:26
a disk STRUCTUREM eighty seven is an elliptical galaxy, a vast,
34:31
roughly spherical cloud of stars sprawling outward in every direction,
34:35
with no arms, no disk, no particular shape beyond sheer
34:40
accumulated mass. Elliptical galaxies like M eighty seven are generally
34:44
understood to be the end product of repeated galactic mergers.
34:48
They are what you get after enough collisions have destroyed
34:51
the original structure and left behind something enormous and featureless.
34:56
At the center of M. Eighty seven, sits, something that
34:59
may makes the galaxy itself feel like a backdrop. There
35:03
is a supermassive black hole there. Its mass is measured
35:07
at approximately six point five billion times the mass of
35:11
our Sun. For comparison, the black hole at the center
35:15
of the Milky Way, known as Sagittarius a star, has
35:19
a mass of roughly four million solar masses. The black
35:23
hole inside eight seven is more than a thousand times
35:27
more massive than our own. It is one of the
35:29
most massive black holes ever measured anywhere in the observable universe,
35:35
and in twenty nineteen it became the first black hole
35:38
ever directly photographed. That image is worth pausing on the
35:43
event horizon telescope that is not a single telescope, but
35:48
a coordinated network of radio observatories spread across multiple contiments,
35:54
operating together as a single earth sized instrument turned its
35:58
collective gaze toward eight seven and produced an image of
36:03
the shadow of that black hole surrounded by a ring
36:05
of glowing gas. The photograph showed an asymmetric orange ring
36:11
brighter on one side than the other due to the
36:14
rotation of the material around it. It was blurry by
36:17
some standards. It was the most important astronomical photograph in decades.
36:23
That object, the dark center of that orange ring is
36:27
the supermassive black hole sitting at the heart of the
36:30
dominant galaxy at the center of our supercluster. It is
36:34
roughly fifty five million light years away, and we photographed it.
36:39
The black hole does not sit quietly. M eighty seven
36:43
has what astronomers call an active galactic nucleus, meaning the
36:48
black hole is actively consuming surrounding material and releasing extraordinary
36:53
amounts of energy in the process. The infalling gas forms
36:57
a superheated disc from the poles of that DISM eighty
37:01
seven launches jets of plasma outward into space. These jets
37:05
travel at a significant fraction of the speed of light.
37:09
One of them extends for roughly five thousand light years
37:12
and is bright enough to have been observed for over
37:15
a century. Karl Yansky detected the radio emissions from M
37:19
eighty seven in the early twentieth century without fully understanding
37:23
what he was looking at. The jet is not subtle.
37:26
It is one of the most energetic continuous structures in
37:29
the known universe, blasting through the surrounding gas of the
37:33
Virgo cluster and depositing enormous amounts of energy into the
37:37
cluster environment. That energy output affects the temperature and behavior
37:43
of gas throughout the cluster. That MEANSM eighty seven's black
37:47
hole is not just a local feature, but something that
37:50
actively shapes the environment of the entire structure surrounding it.
37:54
The sheer size of M eighty seven extends far beyond
37:57
its visible core. The galaxy has a few stellar halo
38:01
that reaches outward for hundreds of thousands of light years,
38:05
filled with stars stripped from smaller galaxies during past merges.
38:10
Some of the material at the edges of M eighty
38:12
seven was almost certainly part of independent galaxies at some
38:17
earlier pointing cosmic history, galaxies that wandered too close and
38:21
were dismantled over time their stars scattered into the halo.
38:26
This process is still ongoing. M eighty seven is still
38:29
the gravitational dominant presence in the Virgo cluster, still pulling
38:34
in material, still growing. One of the clearest ways to
38:37
see how DIFFERENTM. Eighty seven is from the Milky Way
38:41
is not through the star counts or the black hole mass,
38:45
but through globular clusters. Globular clusters are dense ancient spherical
38:51
groupings of stars, typically containing hundreds of thousands of stars
38:56
bound tightly together. Most large galaxies host upon population of
39:00
them in a halo around their center. They are among
39:04
the oldest structures in the universe, some of them nearly
39:07
as old as the universe itself. The Milky Way has
39:11
approximately one hundred and fifty known globular clusters orbiting it.
39:16
When astronomers surveyed the region around M eighty seven, they
39:20
found something of a different order. M eighty seven is
39:24
surrounded by a halo of approximately fifteen thousand globular clusters.
39:29
Some of those clusters were likely captured along with the
39:32
galaxies that M eighty seven absolute rebover billions of years.
39:38
The number is not slightly larger than the Milky Ways count.
39:42
It is one hundred times larger. The Milky Way has
39:45
roughly one hundred and fifty globular clusters orbiting it. M
39:49
eighty seven has around fifteen thousand. That tells you about
39:53
as much as you need to know about the difference
39:56
between these two galaxies. If you could step back far
40:00
far enough to see the entire Virgo supercluster at once,
40:03
the first thing you would notice is that it does
40:06
not look like a cloud. It does not look like
40:09
a sphere or a blob or any of the rounded
40:12
shapes that the word cluster might suggest. What you would
40:16
actually see is a web thin strands of galaxies stretching
40:20
across enormous distances, connecting denser knots trailing off into near emptiness,
40:27
sheets of galaxies arranged in flat planes, like the surface
40:31
of a soap bubble, and between those strands and sheets
40:35
vast regions of almost nothing. The structure looks less like
40:39
a storm and more like the skeleton of one all
40:42
framework and void, with the actual material pinned to the
40:46
edges of the gaps. This is not unique to the
40:49
Virgo Supercluster. It is the signature of how gravity has
40:53
worked on matter across the entire history of the universe.
40:57
But the Virgo Supercluster is close enough to study in detail,
41:01
and what astronomers have found in its architecture is something
41:05
that took decades to fully appreciate. The universe does not
41:09
fill itself evenly. It builds highways, and then it builds nothing.
41:15
Start with the galaxies themselves. Two thirds of the bright
41:19
galaxies in the Virgo Supercluster are not scattered randomly across
41:23
its full volume. They are concentrated near a central plane,
41:27
a flattened disk running through the structure like the equatorial
41:31
belt of some enormous slow spinning system. The remaining third
41:35
spread outward into a looser halo, distributed more spherically around
41:40
the central concentration, but still not evenly, still clumped and
41:45
streaked rather than smooth. If you mapped only the bright
41:49
galaxies and drew their positions in three dimensions, the result
41:53
would look almost like a flattened lens with faint spray
41:56
around it. This is the overall shape, but inside that
42:00
shape the detail is stranger. There are two primary filaments
42:04
threading through the supercluster, and they behave like rivers. One
42:09
of them runs from the region near the URSA major group,
42:12
passing through the IC three hundred and forty two group
42:16
and continuing through them eighty one group, a chain of
42:19
galaxy concentrations loosely strung along a common axis, separated by
42:25
tens of millions of light years, but connected by their
42:28
shared trajectory toward the gravitational center. The second filament runs
42:33
in a different direction, entirely linking the Sculptor group into
42:38
the broader network and eventually connecting toward the Virgo cluster itself.
42:43
These are not coincidences of position. Galaxies in filaments are
42:47
moving along them. They are drifting, pulled by gravity, following
42:52
the path of the strand toward whichever dense concentration lies
42:56
at the far end. The filaments are not static structure,
43:00
They are currents. Think of it like a water shed.
43:04
Water on a hillside does not flow in random directions.
43:08
It follows the contours of the landscape toward the lowest points.
43:12
Galaxies do something similar, but the landscape is gravity itself,
43:17
shaped by the distribution of matter and dark matter across
43:21
hundreds of millions of light years. The filaments mark the
43:24
low channels in that gravitational terrain. Groups of galaxies that
43:28
formed in the filaments find themselves slowly accelerating along the strand,
43:33
drawn toward the massive clusters that anchor the intersections. The
43:37
Virgo cluster sits at one of those intersections, which is
43:41
precisely why it has grown so dominant. It is not
43:45
just massive. It is positioned where the floes converge between
43:49
the filaments of the voids, and the voids deserve their
43:52
own attention because it is easy to treat them as
43:55
the absence of something interesting, rather than as something interesting
43:59
in themselves. Avoid spanning thirty or forty million light years
44:04
as a place where the large scale structure of the
44:06
universe has essentially failed to form. In the early universe,
44:10
matter was distributed nearly evenly. Tiny density fluctuations. Regions slightly
44:17
more dense regions slightly less were the seeds of everything
44:21
that came after. Where the density was slightly higher, gravity
44:25
pulled more matter in, and those regions grew into filaments
44:29
and clusters. Where the density was slightly lower, matter drained
44:33
away into the surrounding over dense regions, and those regions
44:37
became voids. The voids did not stay empty by accident.
44:41
They were emptied actively, their matter flowing outward into the
44:46
surrounding structure over billions of years. They are not completely empty.
44:51
A careful survey of a large void will find occasional
44:55
isolated galaxies, small groups that never fell into a filament,
45:00
stragglers left behind by the general flow. But the contrast
45:04
between a void and a filament is stark enough to
45:07
register immediately in any map of the supercluster. Inside a filament,
45:13
you might find dozens of galaxies within a few million
45:16
light years of each other. Step into a void, and
45:20
you could travel ten twenty thirty million light years and
45:25
encounter almost nothing. The density drops by a factor that
45:29
is difficult to express simply, if a filament is a
45:33
busy street, a void is open ocean with one island
45:37
every thousand kilometers. The overall structure filaments, sheets, clusters, voids
45:45
is what astronomers call the cosmic web. The Virgo supercluster
45:50
is not some exotic exception to the general pattern of
45:54
the universe. It is a textbook example of it, close
45:58
enough to study in fine detail, large enough to contain
46:01
all of the major features. But knowing that it fits
46:04
the pattern does not make the pattern less astonishing. The
46:08
visible matter in this structure, all the stars and gas
46:11
and dust that telescopes can detect, traces out something that
46:15
looks almost designed, almost deliberate, long thin strands of galaxies
46:21
arking across tens of millions of light years, dense nodes
46:25
where strands intersect, enormous hollow regions where almost nothing has gathered.
46:32
The universe built something that looks at this scale more
46:35
like lace than like anything solid. The question of what
46:39
actually holds this structure in the arrangement we observe is
46:43
not fully answered by the galaxies alone. The visible matter
46:46
follows the pattern, but it does not set the pattern.
46:50
Something unseen is doing most of the gravitational work, and
46:54
that is a problem that belongs to the next part
46:56
of the picture. For now, the shape itself the thing
47:00
worth holding. A supercluster one hundred and ten million light
47:04
years across that is not a sphere, not a cloud,
47:08
not a uniform distribution of anything, a web of strands
47:12
and sheets built over billions of years by the slow
47:16
arithmetic of gravity, with vast silent gaps between every thread.
47:21
The voids between these filaments are real. They are not
47:24
just gaps in our maps, and they can span tens
47:27
of millions of light years with almost nothing in them.
47:31
The Virgo cluster is not the only thing pulling on us.
47:34
This took a while to figure out. For decades, the
47:37
assumption was straightforward. The Virgo cluster sits at the gravitational
47:42
center of the supercluster. Our local group sits near the edge.
47:46
The cluster pulls us slowly inward. A clean picture, a
47:50
sensible one. Then astronomers started measuring the actual velocities of
47:55
galaxies across our region of space with more precision, the
47:59
clean pure developed a problem. Everything was moving in the
48:03
wrong direction. Not wrong in the sense of random or chaotic,
48:07
but wrong in the sense that the motion did not
48:09
point where the Virgo Cluster was. Galaxies across a vast
48:13
stretch of the local universe were streaming toward a particular
48:17
point in the sky, a point in the direction of
48:20
the constellation Centaurus, roughly two hundred and fifty million light
48:24
years away. The Virgo Cluster could not account for this.
48:29
Something else was out there, something massive, and it was
48:33
pulling on everything in the neighborhood. Astronomers named it the
48:36
Great Attractor. The name sounds dramatic, and the reality earns
48:41
that drama. The Great Attractor appears to be a concentration
48:46
of mass so enormous that it is drawing not just
48:49
our local group, but effectively our entire supercluster toward it.
48:54
The infull velocity toward the Virgo cluster is roughly three
48:58
hundred kilometers per second. The streaming motion toward the Greater
49:02
Tractor runs at somewhere between six hundred and one thousand
49:05
kilometers per second. Those are not small numbers. Light travels
49:10
at three hundred thousand kilometers per second, so these are
49:14
not relativistic speeds, but for the slow gravitational choreography of
49:18
galaxy clusters drifting through space, these are remarkable velocities. Something
49:24
very large is doing the pulling. The problem is seeing
49:27
it directly. The Greater Tractor sits behind one of the
49:31
most frustrating obstacles in observational astronomy. In that direction of sky,
49:36
our line of sight passes straight through the densest part
49:40
of the Milky Way zone, disc through the concentrated dust
49:44
and gas of our galaxy's central plane. This region is
49:47
called the zone of avoidance, and it does exactly what
49:50
its name suggests. The disk of our own galaxy blocks
49:54
the view. Optical telescopes cannot penetrate it. The light from
49:59
whatever lies when that direction is absorbed or scattered before
50:02
it reaches us. For years, the Great Attractor was essentially
50:07
a gravitational rumor something inferred entirely from the motion of
50:11
other things, rather than seen directly. Radio and X ray
50:16
surveys eventually pierced the obscuring disk well enough to identify
50:20
what is likely the primary culprit. The normal cluster, a
50:24
rich concentration of galaxies sitting roughly at the position the
50:28
greater attractor was predicted to occupy, has a mass consistent
50:32
with much of the observed streaming motion. It became the
50:36
leading candidate for what astronomers had been sensing through the
50:39
motion of galaxies for years, but identifying the Normal cluster
50:44
did not entirely close the case. When researchers ran the
50:48
numbers carefully, the normal cluster alone was not quite heavy
50:52
enough to account for everything that was observed the streaming
50:56
motion suggested something more behind the normal A cluster farther
51:01
along the same general direction sits, the Shapleigh Supercluster, at
51:06
a distance of roughly six hundred fifty million light years.
51:10
The Shapleigh Supercluster is one of the largest concentrations of
51:14
matter in the nearby universe, a vast gathering of galaxy
51:19
clusters containing mass that dwarfs the Virgo supercluster by a
51:23
considerable margin. Current thinking places the Shapleigh Supercluster as a
51:28
significant contributor to the overall streaming motion, working alongside the
51:34
normal cluster region to produce the pool that shows up
51:37
in galaxy velocity measurements across our neighborhood. The greater tractor,
51:41
in other words, may not be a single thing at all.
51:45
It may be a direction, a general zone of extreme
51:48
mass density that combines several overlapping gravitational sources, each adding
51:54
its weight to the total pool. What makes this genuinely
51:57
strange is the scale involved. The Virgo cluster is fifty
52:01
five million light years away, its gravitational influence on the
52:05
local group is already difficult to absorb. The Shapleigh supercluster
52:10
is more than ten times farther, yet its gravity reaches
52:14
back across that distance and perceptibly nudges the motion of
52:17
galaxies in our region. Gravity has no speed limit in
52:21
the sense of influence. A mass concentration that formed billions
52:25
of years ago began shaping the flow field around it,
52:29
long before any astronomer existed to notice. The streaming motion
52:33
we measure today is the accumulated product of billions of
52:37
years of gravitational influence propagating outward from these massive concentrations. Then,
52:44
in two thousand eight, a team of researchers published results
52:48
suggesting something stranger still. Using data from the w MAP satellite,
52:54
they reported that galaxy clusters at distances of several billion
52:58
light years appear feared to be drifting coherently in a
53:02
particular direction, a bulk flow that could not be explained
53:06
by any known concentration of mass within the observable universe.
53:11
They called this dark flow. The implication was unsettling. If
53:16
the signal was real, something beyond the observable horizon structures
53:21
so distant that their light has never reached us and
53:25
never will. Given the expansion of the universe, might be
53:29
exerting gravitational influence on matter inside our observable bubble. The
53:35
universe we can see would be in a gravitational sense,
53:39
not the whole story. Dark flow remains contested. Later analyzes
53:44
using more sensitive CMB data have not consistently reproduced the
53:49
original signal. The debate among cosmologists has not reached a
53:53
clean resolution. Some researchers argue the original detection was a
53:58
measurement artifact. Others maintain that the signal is real and
54:03
that its explanation demands something genuinely new. The honest position
54:08
is that the question is open, but the broader picture
54:11
is not in doubt. The local group is embedded in
54:15
a gravitational landscape far more complex than a simple infall
54:19
toward the Virgo cluster. Multiple massive structures, some clearly identified,
54:24
in some only partially visible, pull on us from different
54:28
distances in different directions. The net motion we observe is
54:32
the vector sum of all of these influences, tangled together
54:36
across hundreds of millions of light years. Unpacking them requires
54:40
measuring the velocities of thousands of galaxies and running those
54:44
measurements through models that attempt to reconstruct the underlying mass distribution.
54:49
It is an extraordinary thing to do. It is also
54:52
not finished. Some researchers have raised the possibility that the
54:56
pull comes from structures so large and so distant that
55:00
they lie beyond the edge of what we can observe.
55:03
That means we may never be able to see what
55:06
is tugging on us. Everything discussed so far, the galaxies,
55:11
the clusters, the filaments, the Virgo cluster M eighty seven
55:16
represents only about ten percent of what is actually in
55:19
the Virgo supercluster. The rest is dark matter, not dark energy,
55:25
which is a separate concept entirely. Dark matter is matter,
55:30
It is mass, It is gravity. It pulls on things.
55:34
What it does not do is interact with light in
55:37
any way that telescopes can detect. It does not emit light,
55:41
It does not absorb light, it does not reflect light.
55:45
It simply sits there, invisible and exerts gravitational force on
55:50
everything around it. When astronomers calculate the total mass of
55:54
the Virgo supercluster roughly one point four eight times ten
55:58
to the fifteenth power solar massive, a number that is
56:01
almost too large to write out, only about ten percent
56:05
of that mass shows up in any telescope image ever taken.
56:09
The galaxies you see in photographs of the supercluster, all
56:13
forty seven thousand of them, every star in every one
56:16
of those galaxies, all the gas clouds and dust lanes
56:20
in glowing nebulae, that is the ten percent. The ninety
56:24
percent is somewhere else, or rather everywhere, spread through the
56:29
same space, invisible and unmeasured by any direct observation. This
56:34
is not a fringe idea. It is one of the
56:37
most well tested conclusions in modern cosmology, and the evidence
56:41
comes from multiple independent directions at once. The first serious
56:46
hints appeared in the nineteen thirties, when Swiss astronomer Fritz
56:50
Swicky measured the velocities of galaxies inside the coma cluster
56:55
and found something that did not add up. The galaxies
56:58
were moving too fast. At those speeds, the cluster should
57:02
have flown apart long ago. There was simply not enough
57:05
visible mass to hold them together. Zwicki proposed that unseen
57:10
matter was providing the extra gravity. For decades, most astronomers
57:14
dismissed the idea. Then, in the nineteen seventies, VERA. Rubin
57:19
and her colleagues measured the rotation curves of individual spiral
57:23
galaxies and found the same problem at a different scale.
57:28
Stars at the outer edges of galaxies were orbiting too fast.
57:32
The visible mass of the galaxy could not account for it.
57:35
Something invisible was adding gravity at the edges. The flat
57:39
rotation curves that Reuben documented became one of the clearest
57:43
pieces of evidence that dark matter was real and that
57:47
it extended well beyond the visible boundaries of galaxies. The
57:51
evidence kept piling up. When astronomers mapped how light from
57:56
distant objects bends as it passes through galaxy clusters, a
58:00
phenomenon called gravitational lensing, they could calculate how much mass
58:05
was doing the bending. The number was consistently far higher
58:09
than the mass of all the visible galaxies and gas
58:12
in the cluster combined, the extra mass had to be
58:16
there somewhere, in a form that telescopes could not see.
58:20
Then came the large scale structure arguments. Cosmologists running simulations
58:26
of how the universe evolved from the hot, nearly uniform
58:30
state after the Big Bang found that ordinary matter alone
58:34
could not produce the structures we observe. Galaxies, clusters, filaments, superclusters.
58:41
None of it forms fast enough without something else. Dark
58:45
matter clumps differently than ordinary matter because it does not
58:49
interact with radiation. While the early universe was a dense,
58:53
hot plasma of particles and light, all jostling and colliding,
58:58
dark matter was already beginning to gather quietly into halos,
59:02
building the gravitational scaffolding that ordinary matter would later collapse into.
59:07
Without that head start, the universe should look almost smooth today. Instead,
59:13
it looks like a web. Dark matter is why, within
59:17
the Virgo supercluster, specifically, that web is what defines the
59:21
shape of everything. The filaments are not random, The sheets
59:26
of galaxies are not random. The concentration of galaxies in
59:30
the Virgo cluster, rather than scattered evenly across the supercluster's
59:35
volume is not random. All of it traces the underlying
59:39
dark matter skeleton, which formed first and poured ordinary matter
59:43
into the patterns we observe. Galaxies drift toward the densest
59:47
nodes of the dark matter web, gas collects along its filaments,
59:52
cools formed stars, and lights up what was already there. Structurally,
59:57
in this sense, every galaxy photograph ever taken is really
1:00:01
a map of dark matter. The glowing points are just
1:00:04
the places where the dark matter density was high enough
1:00:08
and the conditions right enough for ordinary matter to ignite.
1:00:12
The Virgo Cluster itself sits at one of the deepest
1:00:15
wells in the local dark matter distribution. Its gravitational pull
1:00:19
on surrounding galaxies, the infowl we discussed the thousands of
1:00:24
galaxies that have already been captured, is almost entirely a
1:00:28
dark matter phenomenon. The visible mass of the cluster is
1:00:32
enormous on its own terms, but the dark matter halo
1:00:35
surrounding it extends far beyond the visible galaxies and accounts
1:00:40
for roughly ten times as much mass as everything that
1:00:43
lights up. What you see when you look at a
1:00:45
photograph of the Virgo Cluster is a small bright signal
1:00:49
riding on top of a vast, invisible structure that outweighs
1:00:53
it by an order of magnitude. This creates a strange
1:00:56
picture of what the Virgo supercluster actually is. Strip Away
1:01:00
the dark matter and the supercluster would not exist as
1:01:03
a recognizable structure. The galaxies would not be concentrated where
1:01:08
they are, the filaments would not run the way they do.
1:01:11
The clusters would not have formed at all, at least
1:01:14
not in the time the universe has had available the
1:01:17
entire architecture. Everything described in the previous sections, all the
1:01:22
structure and motion and gravitational dynamics, is downstream of something
1:01:27
we cannot see. The filamentary skeleton of dark matter came first,
1:01:32
the galaxies followed. The supercluster is, in the deepest sense,
1:01:37
a dark matter object that happens to have galaxies growing
1:01:40
inside it. We have never directly detected a dark matter particle.
1:01:45
Every attempt to catch one in a laboratory detector has
1:01:48
come up empty. So far. Experiments buried deep underground, shielded
1:01:53
from everything else, have been running for decades waiting for
1:01:56
a dark matter particle to bump into an ordinary atom.
1:02:00
Nothing confirmed yet. The evidence that dark matter exists is overwhelming.
1:02:05
The evidence for what it actually is remains frustratingly incomplete.
1:02:10
The galaxies are real, but they are the small bright
1:02:12
things attached to a vast invisible structure, and the invisible
1:02:16
structure is what actually holds everything in place. The Virgo
1:02:20
supercluster is not a permanent feature of the universe. That
1:02:24
fact sits uncomfortably alongside everything else in this story because
1:02:29
the scale of the structure makes permanence feel like it
1:02:32
should be guaranteed. Something one hundred ten million light years
1:02:36
across should not be fragile, but it is, and the
1:02:40
force undoing it has been at work since the beginning.
1:02:44
Start with what happens first. In roughly five billion years,
1:02:48
the Milky Way and Andromeda will collide. They are already
1:02:51
moving toward each other, closing the gap at about one
1:02:54
hundred and ten kilometers per second. When two galaxies merge,
1:02:58
it is not a collision in the way two cars collide.
1:03:02
The stars inside each galaxy are so far apart that
1:03:05
almost none of them will actually strike another star. What
1:03:09
happens instead is slower and stranger. The two galaxies will
1:03:13
pass through each other, distort each other's shapes, swing around,
1:03:17
pass through again, and over hundreds of millions of years,
1:03:21
gradually spiral into a single combined structure. Astronomers have a
1:03:26
name for what comes out the other side. They call
1:03:29
it Milkomeda. It will be a large elliptical galaxy, rounder
1:03:34
and less structured than either of the spirals that produced it,
1:03:37
and it will contain the stars of both. The night
1:03:40
sky viewed from any surviving planet during that merger will
1:03:45
look nothing like what we see now. The Milky Way
1:03:48
band will warp, Andromeda will fill enormous stretches of sky.
1:03:53
Then slowly the two will become one. Milkomeda will still
1:03:57
be part of the local group. The merger changes the
1:04:01
dominant member, but not the group's membership or its trajectory.
1:04:05
The local group, now organized around a single giant merged galaxy,
1:04:10
will continue its slow fall toward the Virgo cluster that
1:04:14
in four has been happening for billions of years already,
1:04:17
and will not stop because the Milky Way and Andromeda
1:04:21
decided to combine. Gravity does not pause for mergers. But
1:04:25
here is where the story turns, because while gravity is
1:04:29
pulling the local group inward, something else is pushing everything outward.
1:04:34
Dark energy, the force responsible for the accelerating expansion of
1:04:39
the universe, does not care about the gravitational hierarchy. It
1:04:44
acts on all scales simultaneously. At small scales, gravity wins easily.
1:04:50
The Earth stays bound to the Sun. The Sun stays
1:04:53
bound to the Milky Way. Galaxy clusters hold themselves together
1:04:58
against the expansion because the gravity inside them is strong
1:05:02
enough to overpower it. But superclusters are a different situation. Entirely,
1:05:07
the Virgo supercluster is not gravitationally bound. That is a
1:05:12
precise statement with enormous consequences. A gravitationally bound system is
1:05:17
one where the collective gravity of all its members is
1:05:20
strong enough to hold the group together against the expansion
1:05:24
of space. Galaxy clusters pass this test. The Virgo cluster
1:05:29
itself is bound. Those thousands of galaxies are locked together
1:05:33
and will not be pulled apart. The local group is bound,
1:05:37
but the supercluster as a whole, the full one hundred
1:05:40
and ten million light year structure, containing all of its
1:05:43
clusters in groups and filaments, does not have enough internal
1:05:47
gravity to hold itself together over the long run. Dark
1:05:51
energy is winning at this scale. What that means, played
1:05:54
out over tens of billions of years, is a gradual dissolution.
1:05:59
The outer regions go first, the galaxies and group sitting
1:06:04
in the looser periphery of the supercluster. The ones not
1:06:07
tightly locked into dense clusters will find that the expansion
1:06:11
of space slowly overcomes the weak gravitational threads connecting them
1:06:16
to the rest of the structure. They will drift outward,
1:06:20
not violently. There is no explosion, no sudden break. It
1:06:24
is more like a crowd slowly dispersing after an event ends.
1:06:29
One person leaves, then another, Then the edge is thin out,
1:06:33
and eventually what was a gathering is just scattered individuals
1:06:36
moving in different directions. The tightly bound clusters survive this.
1:06:42
The Virgo cluster will remain intact. The local group once
1:06:46
it has merged into Milkomeda and eventually fallen closer to
1:06:50
the cluster may be drawn in and absorbed. What survives
1:06:54
in the very long run is not the supercluster, but
1:06:57
its gravitational cause. The dense, tightly packed clusters that gravity
1:07:02
has held together strongly enough to resist the expansion. Everything
1:07:08
between them will have drifted away. This is worth sitting
1:07:11
with for a moment. The structure we have been describing,
1:07:15
the filaments, the sheets, the vast, interconnected web of groups
1:07:20
and clusters spanning one hundred ten million light years is
1:07:24
a temporary arrangement. It formed because the early universe had
1:07:28
density variations, small lumps in the distribution of matter and gravity.
1:07:33
Spent billions of years amplifying those lumps into the structures
1:07:37
we see today. But the expansion of the universe was
1:07:40
always running in the other direction, and at supercluster scales,
1:07:44
expansion is winning. What exists now is the peak, the
1:07:49
moment of maximum structure at this scale. From here, the
1:07:53
supercluster does not grow more organized. It begins slowly to
1:07:57
come apart. There is a version of this that sounds
1:08:00
like loss. A structure assembles itself over thirteen billion years,
1:08:06
and then dark energy spends the next one hundred billion
1:08:09
years quietly dismantling it. The galaxies that formed in the
1:08:13
outer filaments, that spent their entire existence as part of
1:08:17
this supercluster, will drift out into regions of space increasingly
1:08:22
empty of neighbors. The filaments will thin, the sheets will fade.
1:08:28
The cosmic web, at least locally, will unravel, but the
1:08:33
time scales involved strip the word loss of most of
1:08:36
its meaning. The complete dissociation of the supercluster happens over
1:08:40
stretches of time so long that the Sun will have died,
1:08:44
the Milky Way will have merged with Andromeda, and the
1:08:47
stars formed in that merger will themselves have aged and faded. Life,
1:08:53
if it still exists anywhere, will be operating on a
1:08:56
fundamentally different set of physics problems than we are. The
1:09:00
supercluster dissolving is not an event anyone will experience. It
1:09:04
is a slow reversion to the mean of an expanding universe.
1:09:08
What we are looking at from our vantage point near
1:09:11
the edge is a structure in the process of being
1:09:14
assembled and then slowly torn apart by the same expanding
1:09:19
universe that created the conditions for it to form. In
1:09:22
twenty fourteen, a team of astronomers published a paper that
1:09:26
quietly moved the Virgo supercluster I leveled down in the hierarchy.
1:09:31
No dramatic announcement, no press conference that made the evening news.
1:09:37
A paper in the journal Nature, authored by R. Brent
1:09:41
Tulley in his colleagues, and inside it was a map
1:09:44
that changed our cosmic address. The Virgo Supercluster, one hundred
1:09:50
ten million light years across, containing tens of thousands of galaxies,
1:09:55
the structure that had anchored our sense of place in
1:09:58
the universe for sixty years. It was not the top
1:10:01
of the ladder. It was a branch, a single lobe
1:10:05
of something vastly larger that nobody had fully seen before.
1:10:09
They called it lania KaiA. The name comes from Hawaiian
1:10:13
meaning immeasurable heaven, and the people who chose it were
1:10:16
not being poetic, They were being accurate. Lania KaiA spans
1:10:21
roughly five hundred and twenty million light years. It contains
1:10:25
around one hundred thousand galaxies. Its mass is approximately ten
1:10:30
to the power of seventeen solar masses. If you stacked
1:10:33
that number out in suns, you would run out of
1:10:36
ways to describe it before you got close. The Virgo Supercluster,
1:10:41
for all its scale, accounts for only a fraction of
1:10:44
what lanier KaiA actually is. To understand why this discovery
1:10:48
was possible in twenty fourteen and not earlier, you have
1:10:52
to understand what Tully's team did differently. Previous maps of
1:10:55
the large scale universe were built on positions you measure
1:10:59
a game. Galaxies redshift, you calculate its distance, You plot
1:11:04
it on a map. Do that for enough galaxies, and
1:11:07
patterns emerge, clusters, filaments, voids. That approach built everything we
1:11:13
knew about the Virgo supercluster. It was good science, but
1:11:17
it had a blind spot. It could tell you where
1:11:20
galaxies were, it could not easily tell you which way
1:11:23
they were falling. Tully's team mapped velocities, not just how
1:11:27
fast galaxies were moving away from us due to cosmic expansion,
1:11:32
but how fast they were moving relative to that expansion.
1:11:35
Their peculiar velocities the component of motion driven by local
1:11:40
gravity rather than the universe's overall stretching. If you can
1:11:44
measure that for hundreds of thousands of galaxies, something remarkable
1:11:49
becomes visible. You can see the flow. Galaxies are like
1:11:53
water running downhill. They drift toward gravitational concentrations. Map enough
1:11:59
of those drift vectors and you can trace the basins,
1:12:03
the regions of space where everything is flowing toward a
1:12:06
common point, where one basin ends and another begins. That
1:12:10
is a boundary. That boundary defines a supercluster. This was
1:12:15
the conceptual shift. A supercluster is not just a dense
1:12:19
region of galaxies. It is a gravitational watershed. Everything within
1:12:24
it is flowing inward toward a common attractor, and nothing
1:12:28
crosses the ridge line into the next basin. By that definition,
1:12:32
the Virgo Supercluster was not its own watershed. It was
1:12:36
a tributary. All of its galaxies, including our own Milky Way,
1:12:40
are flowing not just toward the Virgo Cluster, but towards
1:12:44
something deeper inside Lanikaea. That's something is the greater attractor,
1:12:49
the mysterious gravitational concentration that astronomers had been puzzling over
1:12:54
for decades, partially hidden behind the plane of our own galaxy.
1:12:58
It sits near the center of Lanikaea, in the region
1:13:01
of the Norma cluster, and it is the point toward
1:13:04
which the entire flow of our supercluse tear ultimately drains.
1:13:10
Lania Kaya is not just the Virgo Supercluster scaled up.
1:13:14
It is a different kind of object. It contains the
1:13:17
Virgo Supercluster as one component, but also the Hydra Centaurus Supercluster,
1:13:23
the Normal Supercluster, the pavo Inda Supercluster, and several other
1:13:28
large concentrations of galaxies that were previously considered separate structures,
1:13:34
all of them, it turns out, a part of the
1:13:36
same gravitational basin. All of them are flowing toward the
1:13:40
same attractor. The boundaries that astronomers had drawn between them
1:13:44
were real in a positional sense, they were not real
1:13:47
in a dynamical one. The numbers require a moment. The
1:13:51
Virgo supercluster is one hundred and ten million light years across,
1:13:56
Lania KaiA is five hundred and twenty million light years across.
1:13:59
That is not a modest expansion of the neighborhood. It
1:14:02
is nearly five times the diameter, which means roughly one
1:14:06
hundred times the volume. Lanier Kia contains about one hundred
1:14:10
thousand galaxies. To the Virgo superclusters forty seven thousand, its
1:14:15
mass is one hundred times greater. Every measure of it
1:14:18
is overwhelming. In a different direction. Here is something worth
1:14:23
sitting with the greater tractor. That object at the heart
1:14:27
of Lanier KaiA, toward which we are all slowly falling,
1:14:31
was discovered because astronomers noticed an unexplained tug on galaxies
1:14:35
throughout our region of space. For years, they could not
1:14:39
identify the source clearly because the milky way's own disc
1:14:43
blocked the view. They knew something massive was there, they
1:14:47
couldn't see it directly, And when Tully's team mapped the
1:14:51
flow patterns across hundreds of thousands of galaxies, the shape
1:14:56
of that hidden center finally came into focus, not as
1:15:00
a visible object, as a pattern in motion. The attractor
1:15:05
revealed itself through what everything around it was doing. That
1:15:09
is an almost strange way to discover the center of
1:15:12
your home, not by looking at it, but by watching
1:15:15
which way everything falls. Lania kaya is almost certainly not
1:15:20
gravitationally bound in the way a galaxy cluster is the
1:15:23
same dark energy pulling apart. The Virgo supercluster at its
1:15:27
periphery is doing the same thing at lania Kaia's scale,
1:15:31
only more so. What Tully's team identified is a structure
1:15:35
defined by present day flow patterns, not a permanent gravitational cage.
1:15:40
Over billions of years, as cosmic expansion continues to accelerate,
1:15:46
the flow will weaken, the water shared boundaries will dissolve,
1:15:50
and lanikaere as a coherent structure, will fade. What we
1:15:54
are mapping now is real, but temporary, in the way
1:15:58
that all things that superclusters gales are temporary. None of
1:16:01
this was apparent in twenty thirteen. In twenty thirteen, the
1:16:06
Virgo Supercluster was the answer to the question of what
1:16:09
our largest local structure was called. One year later, it
1:16:14
was a lobe, a single tendril flowing into something five
1:16:18
times its size, anchored to a gravitational center that had
1:16:22
been partially hidden from us the entire time. Every time
1:16:26
the map gets redrawn, we end up living somewhere slightly smaller.
1:16:30
Our galaxy shrank when we measured it against others. Our
1:16:34
supercluster shrank when we found Lania Kea and Lania KaiA.
1:16:38
Itself is embedded in a larger structure called the piscey
1:16:42
Setu supercluster complex, which suggests the hierarchy may not end
1:16:47
bear either. The Virgo supercluster is not unusual. That is
1:16:51
perhaps the strangest thing about it. After everything, the one
1:16:56
hundred ten million light years, the forty seven thousand galaxy,
1:17:00
the gravitational pull of eighty seven, the dark matter skeleton
1:17:05
holding it all together, the Virgo supercluster is by cosmic
1:17:09
standards ordinary. The observable universe contains roughly ten million structures
1:17:15
like it. Ten million each one spanning hundreds of millions
1:17:19
of light years, each one containing tens of thousands of galaxies,
1:17:24
each one anchored by its own massive central cluster, threaded
1:17:28
by its own filaments, carved out by its own voids.
1:17:33
The Virgo supercluster is not a landmark. It is a
1:17:36
data point. To understand what that means, you have to
1:17:40
zoom out past Lania KaiA, entirely past the five hundred
1:17:44
and twenty million light years of that larger structure, past
1:17:47
everything we have covered so far. At the scale where
1:17:51
individual superclusters become visible as objects, the universe reveals its
1:17:56
true architecture. It is not a uniform fog of galaxies.
1:18:00
It is not a random scatter. It is a web.
1:18:04
Astronomers call it the cosmic web, and it is the
1:18:07
largest confirmed organizational structure in existence. Superclusters form the nodes
1:18:13
connecting them of filaments, enormous strands of galaxies and dark matters,
1:18:18
stretching across hundreds of millions of light years, sometimes more.
1:18:23
Between the filaments of voids, vast mostly empty regions where
1:18:27
almost nothing lives. The filaments themselves are staggering objects. A
1:18:32
typical filament runs somewhere between fifty and five hundred million
1:18:36
light years in length and maybe one or two megaparsecs thick.
1:18:41
They are not solid structures. They are rivers of galaxies,
1:18:45
loosely aligned, drifting toward the denser concentrations at their ends.
1:18:50
The Virgo supercluster sits at one such node. The filaments
1:18:54
feeding into it are part of a network that connects
1:18:57
to other superclusters, other nodes, other gravitational anchors spread across
1:19:03
the observable cosmos. Then there are the walls. If filaments
1:19:07
are rivers, walls are something closer to continents. In two
1:19:11
thousand three, astronomers mapping the Sloane Digital Sky Survey identified
1:19:17
an enormous concentration of galaxies stretching nearly one point four
1:19:22
billion light years across. They called it the Sloane Great War.
1:19:26
At the time, it was the largest known structure in
1:19:29
the universe. It held that title for about a decade.
1:19:33
Then a team examining gamma ray burst distributions identified something else,
1:19:38
the Hercules Corona Borealis Great Wall, roughly ten billion light
1:19:43
years across. To call that a war is almost a
1:19:47
category error. It spans nearly ten percent of the diameter
1:19:51
of the entire observable universe. It is so large that
1:19:55
some cosmologists debate whether it qualifies as a coherent structure
1:19:59
at all, or whether it is simply a statistical density enhancement.
1:20:05
So enormous it blurs the line between structure and background.
1:20:09
This is where the definitions start to strain. There is
1:20:12
a principle in cosmology called the cosmological principle. It holds
1:20:17
that on large enough scales, the universe is roughly the
1:20:20
same everywhere, homogeneous and isotropic, the same in every direction,
1:20:27
the same in every region. The cosmic microwave background supports this.
1:20:32
The after glow of the Big Bang is almost perfectly uniform,
1:20:36
with tiny temperature fluctuations of only about one part in
1:20:40
one hundred thousand. Those fluctuations grew into everything we see,
1:20:45
but at scales above roughly three hundred million light years,
1:20:49
the lumps and filaments should average out, the universe should
1:20:53
look smooth. Structures like the Hercules, Corona Borealis Great Wall
1:20:59
are so large they push against this expectation. They are
1:21:03
either a genuine challenge to the cosmological pre enciple, or
1:21:08
they are a reminder that our maps and our statistics
1:21:11
have limits. Below that smoothing scale. Though the web is
1:21:15
real and it is everywhere. Every supercluster we can identify
1:21:19
sits within it. Every filament connects to something larger. Every
1:21:24
void is bounded by walls that contain galaxies drifting along
1:21:28
the edges. The structure repeats. It is not identical everywhere,
1:21:33
but the pattern nodes, filaments, voids shows up across the
1:21:39
entire observable universe with something close to regularity. Run a
1:21:44
simulation of how the universe should have evolved from those
1:21:47
tiny early fluctuations, applying known physics and the measured amounts
1:21:52
of dark matter and dark energy, and you get a
1:21:55
cosmic web that looks almost exactly like the one we observe.
1:22:00
Yeb is not a surprise. It was predicted. It emerged
1:22:04
from conditions set in the first fraction of a second
1:22:07
after the Big Bang, encoded in the physics of how
1:22:10
matter clumps under gravity when dark matter provides the scaffold.
1:22:15
There are about ten million superclusters in the observable universe.
1:22:19
The observable universe itself spans roughly ninety three billion light
1:22:24
years in diameter. Inside that volume, there are an estimated
1:22:28
two trillion galaxies two trillion, the Virgo supercluster holds perhaps
1:22:34
forty seven thousand of them. That is not even close
1:22:37
to a rounding error. Pull back to the scale where
1:22:40
all ten million superclusters are simultaneously visible, and the Virgo
1:22:45
supercluster is simply one bright spot among millions in a
1:22:49
glowing web, indistinguishable, unremarkable, a predictable feature at a predictable location,
1:22:57
in a pattern that repeats across the cosmos. Striking about
1:23:00
this is not the size. The size stopped being graspable
1:23:04
several sections ago. What is striking is the regularity. The
1:23:09
universe at its largest scale is doing something almost mechanical.
1:23:13
Matter fell into the gravitational well seeded by dark matter.
1:23:18
It flowed along filaments, It pooled in clusters, It left
1:23:23
voids behind. That process happened here, and it happened in
1:23:27
ten million other locations spread across the observable universe, all
1:23:32
following the same physics, all producing versions of the same structure.
1:23:37
Our supercluster is not the result of some special set
1:23:40
of conditions. It is what happens when you leave gravity
1:23:44
running for thirteen billion years. It happened everywhere at the
1:23:49
very largest scales. Our supercluster disappears into the average one
1:23:53
node inner web, so vast and so regular that the
1:23:57
universe doesn't particularly care whether it's there. The Virgo supercluster
1:24:02
was not discovered by pointing a telescope at the sky
1:24:05
and seeing a giant structure. There is no image of it,
1:24:10
no photograph captures its shape. It was discovered the way
1:24:14
most things at cosmic scales are discovered, through numbers, patterns,
1:24:19
and a French astronomer in the nineteen fifties who notice
1:24:22
something strange in the data. Gerard de Vaucouleur was measuring
1:24:27
the velocities of galaxies. The tool for this is redshift.
1:24:32
When a galaxy moves away from us, the light it
1:24:35
emits gets stretched, the wavelengths grow longer on the spectrum,
1:24:40
they shift toward the red end. The faster the galaxy
1:24:44
is receding, the more the light stretches. Measure the stretch
1:24:48
and you know the velocity. Combine the velocity with Hubble's law,
1:24:53
the relationship between recession speed and distance, and you get
1:24:57
how far away the galaxy is. Devocolurs was running these
1:25:02
measurements on hundreds of galaxies across a wide region of sky,
1:25:06
and he noticed something that wasn't supposed to be there.
1:25:10
A large number of galaxies in one particular region of
1:25:13
sky were sharing velocities that were too similar to be coincidental.
1:25:18
They weren't just neighbours on the sky. There were neighbours
1:25:21
in three dimensional space, moving together, dynamically connected. In nineteen
1:25:27
fifty three, he called the structure the local super galaxy.
1:25:32
A few years later he renamed it the Local Supercluster.
1:25:36
The astronomy community, for the most part, was skeptical. Seeing
1:25:41
a pattern in a data set is not the same
1:25:44
as proving the pattern is real. The argument ran for
1:25:48
three decades. Critics pointed out that Devocolur was selecting which
1:25:52
galaxies to include, that the boundaries of the proposed structure
1:25:56
were fuzzy, that the signal could be noise or bias
1:25:59
in the Sun. This is how science is supposed to work.
1:26:03
An observation gets challenged, the challenger demands better data. The
1:26:08
data improves. In the late nineteen seventies and into the
1:26:12
nineteen eighties, it finally did. The Center for Astrophysics Redshift surveys,
1:26:18
built at Harvard was something different in scale from anything
1:26:21
done before. Astronomers mapped thousands of galaxies in three dimensions,
1:26:26
measuring redshifts systematically across large patches of sky, rather than
1:26:31
cherry picking individual targets. The results were not subtle. The
1:26:36
three D maps showed enormous structures, sheets of galaxies, filaments
1:26:42
connecting clusters, vast empty voids between them. The supercluster was
1:26:47
not a statistical artifact. It was a feature of the universe.
1:26:52
The debate closed. What Devoculure had seen in the nineteen
1:26:56
fifties was real, and it was larger than even he
1:26:59
had described. Here is how the mapping actually works, because
1:27:04
the process matters. You take a galaxy, you measure its spectrum,
1:27:10
the rainbow of light it emits, and you find the
1:27:13
characteristic fingerprint of hydrogen or calcium or other elements. Those
1:27:19
fingerprints appear at known wavelengths in a laboratory. In the
1:27:23
galaxy spectrum, those same fingerprints are shifted. You measure how
1:27:28
far they shifted. That gives you the galaxy's recession velocity.
1:27:33
You apply Hubble's law and convert velocity into distance. Now
1:27:38
you have three numbers, two coordinates for the galaxy's position
1:27:43
on the sky and one for how far away it is.
1:27:46
Three numbers give you a point in three dimensional space.
1:27:50
Do that for ten thousand galaxies, do it for a million,
1:27:54
then clot the points the structure appears. The Sloan Digital
1:28:00
Sky Survey pushed this to a scale that devoculurs could
1:28:04
not have imagined. Launched in the year two thousand and
1:28:08
running in phases ever since, it eventually measured redshifts for
1:28:13
millions of galaxies across a substantial fraction of the visible sky.
1:28:17
The maps it produced showed the cosmic web in extraordinary detail,
1:28:22
filaments stretching hundreds of millions of light years, enormous voids,
1:28:27
walls of galaxies billions of light years long. The Virgo
1:28:31
supercluster appeared in those maps, not as something exceptional, but
1:28:36
as one node among many in a much larger network.
1:28:39
It was the Sloane data, combined with other surveys, that
1:28:43
gave the Tully team in twenty fourteen, the raw material
1:28:47
to define laniar KaiA. But the technique has a hard limit,
1:28:51
and the limit is embarrassingly close to home. The Milky
1:28:54
Way is a disc galaxy. We sit inside the disc
1:28:58
roughly two thirds of the way out the center. When
1:29:01
we look in the direction of the disc's plane, which
1:29:04
is the bright band of the Milky Way visible in
1:29:06
the night sky. We are looking through the densest concentration
1:29:10
of stars, gas, and dust in the galaxy. This material
1:29:15
absorbs light. Galaxies behind it are invisible or nearly so.
1:29:20
Astronomers call this the zone of avoidance, which is a
1:29:23
precise name for a frustrating problem. Roughly twenty percent of
1:29:28
the sky is obscured by our own galaxy's disc Everything
1:29:32
behind that curtain is either invisible to optical telescopes or
1:29:36
severely degraded. Radio telescopes and X ray observatories can push
1:29:41
through some of it, but significant regions remain mapped only
1:29:45
poorly or not at all. The zone of avoidance falls
1:29:49
squarely across a region of sky that includes the direction
1:29:52
of the Great Attractor. This is not a coincidence of
1:29:55
bad luck. The Greater Tractor sits roughly in the plane
1:29:59
of the galaxy from our perspective, which is precisely where
1:30:02
we can see the least. The gravitational anomaly was detected
1:30:06
through its effects on the motions of galaxies around it
1:30:10
before anyone could clearly see what was causing it. Decades
1:30:14
of work with radio and near infrared surveys have partially
1:30:17
lifted the curtain. The normal cluster and related structures have
1:30:21
been identified, but the full picture of what lies behind
1:30:24
the zone of avoidance and how much mass is hidden there,
1:30:28
is still being assembled. What this means is that our
1:30:31
map of the Virgo supercluster is not finished. Forty seven
1:30:36
thousand cataloged galaxies is account of what we've been able
1:30:39
to see, not a census of what is there. The
1:30:43
structures hidden by the Milky Way's disc are real. They
1:30:47
influence the motion of everything around them, but we cannot
1:30:51
directly observe them from our current position, embedded as we
1:30:55
are in the very galaxy doing the blocking parts of
1:30:59
our our own supercluster remain hidden behind the disk of
1:31:03
the Milky Way, which is a strange thing to have
1:31:06
to say about something we live inside. Every human who
1:31:10
has ever lived has spent their entire existence inside the
1:31:13
Virgo supercluster, not metaphorically, not in some abstract cosmological sense,
1:31:21
literally inside it, Embedded in a structure one hundred ten
1:31:25
million light years across with no possibility of exit and
1:31:29
no way to feel the walls. Every person who was
1:31:33
ever born, lived and died did so inside this thing,
1:31:38
every war ever fought, every city ever built, every quiet
1:31:44
morning anyone ever sat through with a cup of coffee
1:31:47
and nowhere pressing to be. All of it happened here
1:31:51
inside the Virgo Supercluster, and almost none of those people
1:31:56
had any idea. That is a strange fact to sit with.
1:32:00
We have spent most of human history trying to understand
1:32:03
where we are. We mapped continents, We charted coast lines.
1:32:08
We tracked the movements of planets and stars, and worked
1:32:11
out the geometry of the Solar System. We discovered that
1:32:15
the Sun was a star, that the stars were distant suns,
1:32:19
that the Milky Way was a galaxy among billions. Each
1:32:22
expansion of the map was a shock. Each one reset
1:32:26
our sense of how large the context was. And even now,
1:32:30
with all of that knowledge accumulated, most people walk around
1:32:34
with the working picture of the universe that stops somewhere
1:32:38
around the Solar System. The supercluster barely registers. It does
1:32:43
not feel like anything from inside. That is the deepest
1:32:47
strangeness about living inside a structure this size. There is
1:32:51
nothing to press against. When you are inside a room.
1:32:55
You know you are inside a room because there are walls.
1:32:59
When you you are inside a city, you know roughly
1:33:02
where the city ends, because eventually the buildings thin out
1:33:06
and the fields begin. The Virgo supercluster has no edge
1:33:10
you can point to, no boundary you could cross and
1:33:14
know you had crossed it. The density of galaxies simply
1:33:18
decreases as you move outward, gradually over tens of millions
1:33:22
of light years. You could travel in any direction for
1:33:26
millions of years and never experience a threshold, never feel
1:33:30
a change. The structure that contains everything we have ever
1:33:34
known does not announce itself. Carl Sagan's pale blue dot
1:33:38
image gave a generation of people a visceral sense of
1:33:42
scale at one particular level, Earth photographed from four billion
1:33:47
miles away, reduced to a speck of light suspended in
1:33:50
a beam of sunlight. The image worked because it connected
1:33:54
something visible to something almost too large to hold. But
1:33:58
the pale blue dot is inside a solar system. The
1:34:02
solar system is inside the Milky Way. The Milky Way
1:34:06
is inside the local group. The local group is inside
1:34:09
the Virgo supercluster. The Virgo supercluster is inside Lanakare. Each
1:34:15
of those frames shrinks the dot further. Each one adds
1:34:19
another layer of context that makes the blue speck smaller,
1:34:23
more improbable, more isolated. By the time you reach the
1:34:27
supercluster level, the dot is not just pale, It is
1:34:31
essentially undetectable. It is a single atoman a building, and
1:34:36
the building is on a continent, and the consonant is
1:34:39
on a planet, and the planet is not the largest
1:34:42
thing in the room. The question worth asking is what
1:34:46
this actually does to anything. The scale is staggering. That
1:34:51
part is easy to say. But does it change what
1:34:54
happens on the dot? Does it reduce the weight of
1:34:58
any particular moment A child being born, a species going extinct,
1:35:06
a civilization collapsing or rising. Does any of that register
1:35:10
differently once you know the supercluster is out there, enormous
1:35:15
and silent, indifferent to all of it. The honest answer
1:35:19
is probably no, and probably yes. The facts of human
1:35:23
experience operate at human scales. Pain is pain at the
1:35:27
same intensity, regardless of what is behind the night sky.
1:35:32
The supercluster is not competing with any of that. It
1:35:36
is simply the context the outermost known frame, and frames
1:35:40
do not usually change what they contain. A painting is
1:35:44
the same painting in a large room as in a
1:35:46
small one. But something does shift when you genuinely try
1:35:50
to hold the scale, not the numbers, because the numbers
1:35:53
defeat you. Something else, the knowledge that this structure has
1:35:58
been here for billions of years and will continue long
1:36:01
after the Earth is gone. That everything we consider permanent,
1:36:05
every mountain range, every ocean, every civilization we are capable
1:36:10
of imagining, is temporary in a way that the Supercluster
1:36:13
is not. We are not the reference point. We are
1:36:16
the variable. The supercluster is the constant, at least on
1:36:21
the time scales that matter to anything that has ever
1:36:24
lived here. There is something almost clarifying about that. The
1:36:28
supercluster does not need us to understand it to exist.
1:36:32
It was assembling its filaments and drawing galaxies toward its
1:36:36
center long before there were eyes to see any of it.
1:36:39
The Virgo Cluster was pulling galaxies into itself before the
1:36:44
Earth had cooled eighty seven, was consuming smaller galaxies, while
1:36:49
single celled organisms were the most complex life this planet
1:36:52
had managed to produce. The supercluster does not require witnesses.
1:36:58
It simply is, and yet here we are inside it,
1:37:02
trying to take its measure. We built the instruments, we
1:37:06
developed the mathematics. We learned to read the red shift
1:37:09
of light and turn it into a distance, turn that
1:37:13
distance into a map, turn the map into a structure.
1:37:17
We found the filaments, we named the clusters. We identified
1:37:21
our own position within the supercluster and confirmed that we
1:37:25
are falling toward its center at three hundred kilometers per second.
1:37:29
That is not nothing. The structure may not require witnesses,
1:37:33
but it has them, improbable ones. Sitting on a pale
1:37:37
blue dot near the edge of the local group looking
1:37:41
in the scale doesn't make the dot smaller in any
1:37:44
way that matters to the things living on it, but
1:37:47
it does change what it means to ask where home is.
1:37:50
For all of the measurements and maps and redshift surveys,
1:37:54
there is a long list of things astronomers genuinely do
1:37:57
not know about the Virgo supercluster. Start with the great attractor.
1:38:02
Something is pulling on us, pulling on the entire local group,
1:38:06
pulling on the Virgo cluster itself, pulling on hundreds of
1:38:10
thousands of galaxies across an enormous volume of space. Astronomers
1:38:15
can measure the pull. They can see it in the
1:38:17
peculiar velocities of galaxy streaming in a specific direction. What
1:38:22
they cannot fully see is the thing doing the pulling.
1:38:26
The normal cluster sits in roughly the right place, and
1:38:30
for a while it seemed like the answer. Then better
1:38:33
measurements suggested the normal cluster wasn't quite massive enough behind
1:38:38
it partially obscured, something larger might lurk. The Shapleigh supercluster,
1:38:44
roughly six hundred fifty million light years away, is one candidate,
1:38:49
but even Shaply may not account for the full magnitude
1:38:52
of the streaming motion. The honest answer right now is
1:38:56
that nobody knows exactly what the Great Attractor is. And
1:39:00
part of the reason nobody knows is that our own
1:39:03
galaxy is in the way. The Milky Way's disc is
1:39:06
thick with gas and dust. In certain directions on the sky.
1:39:10
This material absorbs so much light that distant galaxies become
1:39:14
invisible to optical telescopes. This region is called the zone
1:39:19
of avoidance. It cuts a wide band across the sky,
1:39:23
and it is not a minor inconvenience. It hides a
1:39:26
significant portion of our cosmic neighborhood. The Greater Tractor sits
1:39:31
almost precisely behind it. Radio telescopes and X ray observatories
1:39:36
can peer through the disc somewhat, and researchers have used
1:39:40
these tools to identify galaxy clusters hiding in the zone,
1:39:44
but the picture remains incomplete. There are structures in our
1:39:48
own supercluster that we have not cataloged because we cannot
1:39:52
see them clearly. We live inside this thing, and pieces
1:39:56
of it are still hidden from us by our own
1:39:58
front yard. They seven thousand galaxy figure for the supercluster's
1:40:02
total population is a catalog number. It reflects what has
1:40:07
been found and measured and recorded. It is not a census.
1:40:11
Galaxies come in a vast range of sizes, and the
1:40:14
faint dwarf galaxies at the small end of that range
1:40:17
are genuinely difficult to detect at supercluster distances. Studies of
1:40:21
the local group alone keep revising the count upward as
1:40:25
new instruments pick out fainter objects that previous surveys missed.
1:40:29
The same thing is almost certainly true across the full
1:40:32
extent of the Virgo supercluster. The true number of galaxies
1:40:37
inside it is larger than forty seven thousand. How much
1:40:41
larger is an open question. Some estimates push the real
1:40:44
count considerably higher once you account for everything too dim
1:40:48
to have been cataloged. Yet then there is the boundary problem.
1:40:52
Where does the Virgo supercluster actually end. The twenty fourteen
1:40:57
lanier Kea paper drew boundaries by mapping the flow patterns
1:41:00
of galaxies, the idea being that any galaxy whose motion
1:41:04
is ultimately directed toward the same gravitational basin belongs to
1:41:09
the same supercluster. It was a genuinely clever approach, and
1:41:13
it produced a striking result, but not everyone agrees with
1:41:17
the methodology. Some astronomers argue that defining a supercluster by
1:41:22
flow convergence rather than by gravitational binding, creates boundaries that
1:41:27
are somewhat arbitrary, dependent on the precision of velocity measurements
1:41:32
and the assumptions built into the flow models. The edges
1:41:36
of lanie KaiA, and therefore the edges of the Virgo
1:41:39
supercluster within it, are not hard lines. They are regions
1:41:43
of lania KaiA, and therefore the edges of the Virgo
1:41:47
supercluster within it are not hard lines. They are regions
1:41:51
of f uncertainty, where the answer changes depending on which
1:41:55
team's method you trust. Dark matter is perhaps the deepest
1:41:59
open question. We know it is there. The gravitational evidence
1:42:04
is consistent and overwhelming, But knowing something exists and understanding
1:42:09
how it behaves in detail are different things. The filamentary
1:42:13
structure of the Virgo supercluster, the sheets and strands of
1:42:17
galaxies connecting the clusters, is thought to trace the skeleton
1:42:21
of the underlying dark matter distribution. The galaxies are, in
1:42:25
a sense just the lit portions of a much larger
1:42:29
invisible web, but that web has never been directly observed.
1:42:33
It is inferred. The models that describe how dark matter
1:42:37
clumps and flows and shapes the cosmic web are sophisticated,
1:42:41
and they match the observations well. They are still models.
1:42:45
The specific three dimensional arrangement of dark matter throughout the
1:42:49
Virgo supercluster is not something anyone has mapped. It is
1:42:54
something people have calculated. The future of the supercluster is
1:42:58
similarly uncertain in its details. The broad picture dark energy
1:43:03
eventually pulling apart the looser outer regions while the tightly
1:43:06
bound inner clusters hold together depends on the precise value
1:43:10
of the cosmological constant, the number that describes how fast
1:43:15
the universe's expansion is accelerating. That number has been measured,
1:43:20
it has also been argued over for decades, and attension
1:43:23
in the measurements remains unresolved. Different methods of measuring the
1:43:27
expansion rate produce slightly different answers, and astronomers have not
1:43:32
agreed on why. Until that tension is resolved, Precise predictions
1:43:37
about when and how structures at supercluster scales begin to
1:43:40
dissolve are difficult to make with confidence. The direction is clear,
1:43:46
the timeline is not. What makes all of this strange
1:43:49
is that the Virgo supercluster is our home. This is
1:43:53
not some distant, exotic object at the edge of the
1:43:56
observable universe. It is the structure. We are embedded in,
1:44:00
the thing that contains everything we have ever called a neighborhood,
1:44:04
and we are still filling in the map. The Greater
1:44:07
Tractor remains partly concealed. The galaxy count is provisional, the
1:44:13
boundaries are contested, The dark matter skeleton is inferred but unseen.
1:44:19
The future depends on a number still being argued over.
1:44:23
For something this close, this fundamental to our cosmic address.
1:44:27
The list of uncertainties is almost too long to take seriously,
1:44:32
and yet there it is. Every time astronomers have thought
1:44:35
they had the largest structure nailed down. The next generation
1:44:39
of surveys has handed them some inmed bigger, and there
1:44:43
is no particular reason to think that pattern has stopped.
1:44:47
After all of that, the number is still one hundred
1:44:50
ten million light years, and it still does not mean anything.
1:44:54
Your brain can actually feel. Walk through every comparison, every analogy,
1:45:00
every carefully constructed scale model, and when you arrive at
1:45:03
the end, the number sits there, unchanged, unmoved, a grain
1:45:08
of sand stretched across several kilometers light that has been
1:45:13
traveling since before complex animals existed and still has not
1:45:17
crossed the whole thing. These images land for a moment,
1:45:21
then they slip. The brain accepts them as facts and
1:45:24
refuses them as feelings. That is not a failure of attention.
1:45:29
That is just the honest limit of what human intuition
1:45:32
was built to do. But something else is true. You
1:45:36
now know things about where you are that most people
1:45:38
who have ever lived did not know. The local group
1:45:42
ten million light years of bound galaxies is still just
1:45:46
a small corner of this structure, the Virgo cluster one thousand,
1:45:50
three hundred to two thousand galaxies packed into the gravitational
1:45:54
heart of the supercluster sits roughly fifty five million light
1:45:58
years away, and it is on you right now, not metaphorically.
1:46:03
The Milky Way is falling toward it at around three
1:46:06
hundred kilometers per second. Every second the gap closes by
1:46:10
three hundred kilometers. You cannot feel it. Nothing in your
1:46:14
life changes because of it, and yet it is happening
1:46:17
constantly in the background of everything. M eighty seven is
1:46:21
out there, twelve trillion stars organized around a black hole.
1:46:26
We actually photographed. The image exists. The orange ring is real.
1:46:32
That black hole anchors the dominant galaxy in the dominant
1:46:35
cluster of the structure you live inside. And the filaments
1:46:39
connecting everything, those long invisible threads of dark matter with
1:46:43
galaxies strung along them like lights, those are real too,
1:46:48
not visible, not something you can point to from a backyard,
1:46:52
but real, structurally real, the actual skeleton of your cosmic address.
1:46:58
Here is the strange part. Knowing all of this does
1:47:01
not make the sky look crowded. It still looks exactly
1:47:05
the same, the same quiet scatter of points in the dark.
1:47:09
Oryon still has his shoulder, The Virgo constellation still sits
1:47:14
in the spring sky, unremarkable to anyone not looking for it.
1:47:19
Somewhere behind those faint stars fifty five million light years back,
1:47:23
the Virgo cluster churns enormous and indifferent. You are aimed
1:47:29
at it, moving toward it, part of a structure that
1:47:33
is simultaneously being assembled by gravity and pulled apart by
1:47:37
dark energy, two forces running in opposite directions, across scales
1:47:42
too large for any single lifetime to register, And Lanikaea
1:47:47
is above all of it. The structure that swallowed the
1:47:50
supercluster hole five hundred and twenty million light years. Our
1:47:55
supercluster is one tendril of it, one lobe reaching outward
1:47:59
from a center we cannot easily see because the Milky
1:48:03
Way's own disc is in the way. The Greater Tractor
1:48:06
sits somewhere in that direction, massive and partially hidden, tugging
1:48:11
on everything around it, including us. Some of those questions
1:48:15
are still open, Some of the map is still blank.
1:48:19
The zone of avoidance is a genuine gap in our knowledge,
1:48:22
hidden behind the plane of our own galaxy. This structure
1:48:26
is temporary, not on any timescale that matters to a
1:48:30
human life, not on any timescale that matters to human civilization,
1:48:35
but on the timescale of the universe, the supercluster is
1:48:39
a passing arrangement. Dark energy is winning at this scale.
1:48:43
The outer galaxies will eventually drift away. What looks like
1:48:47
a coherent structure today is something the universe will disassemble
1:48:52
over the next tens of billions of years. But one
1:48:55
hundred ten million light years will become a memory in
1:48:58
the geometry of an older colts. The number never got smaller.
1:49:02
It was never going to. But the structure behind it
1:49:06
is real, and our position inside it is real, and
1:49:10
the motion is real, and the dark matter holding it
1:49:13
together is real. The sky looks the same as it
1:49:17
always did. The supercluster keeps doing what it has been
1:49:20
doing since before the Earth existed, slowly assembling itself, slowly
1:49:26
being pulled apart, enormous and silent and indifferent, And we
1:49:31
are inside it, looking out