Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Is Nissan The Right Honda Partner?, CA Dealers Push Back on Scout, Overpriced Fast Food
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] It is Monday, December 30th. A lot of people don't really know what day it is. I don't.
- 0:06But we're talking about Honda and Nissan, little updates, California suing Scout, overpriced fast food, and Kyle and I have near zero inboxes- Here I go...
- 0:14ladies and gentlemen People really wanna know That's probably the biggest news of the day. [laughs] We just figured- It's massive...
- 0:19it's funny, we didn't talk a lot last week because of Christmas and holidays and kind of- Yeah, yeah... have a little more of a fluid work schedule.
- 0:25Um, a lot of people were off, and we just realized that we both kind of, like, came into the office, air- quotes, on late last week just- [laughs]... to manage the monstrosity- It was-... of our inboxes. It was magical.
- 0:40Nobody was bothering me. No Slack messages coming in, and it was just like, yep, tick that one off, tick that one off, tick that one off, and it felt so good. I went into the weekend just like, "Ah," you know?
- 0:51How many emails did you unsubscribe from? I, see, I'm pretty good at that- Are you?... on the normal. Okay. Right? It, it was, like, legit work that had to get done, so- Well, I did- I don't know...
- 1:02a lot of unsubscribing as well. You know, I, I- I'm proud of you... kind of, the way... I, I subscribe to emails, and I absorb a lot of information just through subject lines and first, like, paragraphs. Yeah.
- 1:14On a bunch of different fronts. Some are creative fronts, some are news, some are... Right? And so I'm always like, "Oh..." And then eventually I'm like, "You know what?
- 1:21I haven't opened or cared about this thing in like two months." I haven't done it in a hot minute. It's gone, it's gone, it's gone. So I don't know.
- 1:26We still got two days left, today and tomorrow, and the end of the year. I know.
- 1:29I mean, you know what's cool is the few dealers that I have kind of like rubbed shoulders with and texted with, the end of the year is doing really good. Yeah.
- 1:39Like, people are heads down, and they are selling a lot of cars, servicing a lot of cars. So I'm excited. I think the last two days of this year are gonna be roaring- Banging... for a lot of people. Yeah, we got it.
- 1:49Yeah. We got, we got two days left, right? Everybody's on the push. Um- So good. I was just, I was just in a dealership, had to drop my vehicle off for the first time, um, at, at a, at a new dealership.
- 1:59And the service advisor actually came from a sales department in another dealership. He went from sales to service advisor, and he said he loves it. He loves it. And they're bang- That's amazing...
- 2:09they're, they're jamming over there, too. Um- I'm hear- We're hearing more of that. We heard that last week on, what, a podcast or something like that. Yeah, sales to service. And then... Yeah, so many people going...
- 2:17And then, yeah, it's... People are figuring out that service is, is a jam, you know? There's a consistency thing to service that- Yes... the sales side of the business just isn't for everyone, you know? [laughs] Right.
- 2:28Yeah. Uh- You have, you have to be willing to put in some work that doesn't feel like work all the time. Yes. And service, you're, like, always doing something product- productive. Yeah. For sure.
- 2:36This week, definitely gonna be a little bit of a, of a jittery one with, uh, New Year's right in the middle. But we've got some new content for you to listen to.
- 2:42If you're looking for a podcast or something to feed your brain with, uh, give you a little inspiration, spoke with Carol Marshall with Active Engage, talking about, uh, human connection in data-driven auto industry.
- 2:52We had a... Carol's just been a great friend for a lot of years. Oh, she's great. Yeah. And she's always, I mean, she is just a people-oriented leader, period, right? Yeah. Does a lot of data, does a lot of tech.
- 3:01So, uh, that's our Auto Collabs podcast, Auto Collabs. Um, also, big thing, NADAparties.com.
- 3:10It's not quite January, but it's about to be January, and the second that happens, all people are focused on are what they're doing at the NADA show. That's right. Or, like, the vast majority of the industry.
- 3:21During, after, lots of people in the industry are gonna be worried about it. We've got 22 parties sitting on NADAparties.com- Already... from, all the way from Wednesday to Saturday evening. So- Wednesday?...
- 3:31after you get... Even Wednesday. Okay. [laughs] People doing things on Wednesday, fam. Uh, so whatever you, whatever you, you got going on during the day, we've got you covered for the nighttime. Um, so check them out.
- 3:43Plan, plan your little journey all the way across New Orleans.
- 3:46And, uh, if you haven't signed up for the wait list of our party, do so, because we have a feeling we'll be able to scrub a couple people out that don't respond on the last minute. Yep.
- 3:55And also, if you are on the current list, just know we're gonna be calling you the week before to make sure you're gonna be there, 'cause that thing is already sold out, and we wanna make sure we get max capacity out.
- 4:04Yeah, and if you don't respond, unfortunately you're not gonna be able to get in. We're, we're at max capacity. But make sure you're on the wait list because we will- Because... try our best to get you in. Just because.
- 4:14All right. There's been a lot of drama. Actually, it's really strategically over the holidays drama. But Honda CEO, uh, Toshihiro M- Miya- What is it, Mibi? I don't know. Mibi? You go for it. Toshi- Mibe?
- 4:27Toshihiro- Toshihiro Mibe... Mibe. Toshihiro Mibe. There you go. We're good with that. I'm good with that.
- 4:31He faced an awkward press moment when asked, here's the question: "Why would Nissan, why will Nissan make a good business partner?" And he said, "That's a difficult one." [laughs] Ugh, trying to explain- Oh...
- 4:43the rationale. I feel so bad for him. Oh, no The comment highlights the broader skepticism and questions surrounding the partnership.
- 4:48Basically, H- Honda, solid hybrid lineup, struggles with EV development after parting ways with GM.
- 4:54Meanwhile, Nissan, a lot of financial instability, declining EV market share, despite its history as an early leader with the Leaf. You know something about that, Kyle.
- 5:03Um, Nissan's robust m- manufacturing network, supply chain could potentially align with Honda's hybrid expertise. Now, Nissan's shares went up about 60% when they were talking about, like, "Hey- Great... we're gonna..."
- 5:17[laughs] Who wants to be with Honda? Like, me too. Wow. Um, actually, shares sliding a little bit after, as it's developed a little bit more. All the excitement is coming down.
- 5:25Both companies do face uphill battles for sure. Any meaningful results from a merger might take three to five years. Oh, at least. For sure. Here's an analyst, Julie Boot.
- 5:35Um, [smacks lips] she says, "Ideally, it would've been a healthy and financially sound company-" [laughs] "... rather than Nissan." So, uh, we've obviously had, we had Brian Binstock.
- 5:45If you haven't seen it, we had Brian Binstock make some comments on this right before we left for the break. And, uh, this is something that obviously everyone's watching. There's more at play than just- Yeah...
- 5:55like a failing- I think, I mean, there's two major things at play. One is purchasing power. We know that. The other one is political, uh, you know, that kind of impacts to this.
- 6:04And so I think there's kinda some unspoken stuff probably happening outside of the boundaries of just the partnership. Mm-hmm.
- 6:11Um, but, you know, it-Either, either way, when you look at two global brands that are, are clearly doing fine when it comes to just, like, the entirety of where they push vehicles into- Mm-hmm...
- 6:25you're gonna get just, like, support from being bigger, I think. Yeah. Um, so I'm, I'm sure there's stro- some strategic maneuvering that we're not aware of, and I agree, um, with the estimation of three to five years.
- 6:40Like, those are, those are two front runners that have been competitors for a quite some time, so seeing the strategic alignments happen over a, a longer timeline instead of initially is probably gonna be where, where this all draws out.
- 6:53Yeah. Without that. Well, we'll see. I think everybody's in the, like, we're just in it for the ride, uh, Honda dealers- We'll see... Nissan dealers. Like, there's really not much anyone can do but pay attention. Yep.
- 7:03Yes. Hey, good morning, everyone on live stream. Hey, Kate Mairs, good to see you on the- Good morning... live stream this morning. Good morning, merry Christmas, pre-happy New Year.
- 7:11Um, man, all the, all the, all the interesting stories happening, like, while everyone's on, on vacation and break. California New Car Dealers Association, they are pushing back- Psh...
- 7:20against Volkswagen Group and Scout Motors, accusing them of violating state law by taking direct to consumer refundable deposits for their upcoming Scout models. Oh, boy. So money is changing hands now.
- 7:33California's amended vehicle code, effective January 1st, 2024, prohibits automakers or their affiliates from direct-to-consumer sales if they already have a franchise dealership network in the state.
- 7:46Tesla is exempt, and it has, as it has never operated through franchisees. Dealers are arguing Scout's model excludes VW's 50 franchisees, cutting them out of Scout's EV sales opportunities.
- 7:59Scout is insisting it's independent from VW, despite having leadership that was shared at one point.
- 8:03Um, the California New Car Dealers Association is evaluating legal action if Scout and VW do not comply with the law, saying, quote, "VW has chosen to launch the Scout brand in a matter, in a manner that is brazenly unlawful."
- 8:17We aren't a part of that company that owns 100% of us. We're totally not a part of that. And that we- That is- [laughs] And that we took the leadership from and placed him over here. Nothing to do- Literally 100%, Paul.
- 8:30100% is owned- None of your dollars have gone into any of this... none of that has gone into it. Um- And I know you've been begging for pickup truck for years, dealers. [laughs] Just saying there's a market for it.
- 8:42We're gonna throw this other thing over here and not call it yours. It's tough. Thank you very much. It's tough to get past that one. Um, yeah, this one's tough to get past. I, I'm, I'm, uh, surprised, honestly.
- 8:51I mean, we know a few of the people, uh, you know, over at, um, CNCDA. Uh, and, and obviously they are pushing back. Saw some of the LinkedIn posts about how they're responding, what the communication pattern is here.
- 9:04I think it's bold to come from California first, uh, because you wouldn't expect that, especially- Mm-hmm... when dealing with a net new brand, when they've already given so much to Tesla.
- 9:13Like, there's some grounds for a net new company- Yeah... coming in and doing this type of thing. So they must feel like there's a really strong leg to stand in. Obviously- Mm-hmm...
- 9:23there's recent, um, vehicle code that gives them a lot of leverage because it's a very recent ruling. Yep. Um, so interesting to see what happens here.
- 9:33I, I s- I think that Scout is gonna have some reckoning across states.
- 9:37And any time you see California come out with something like this this early, you're gonna see other states just fall right in line, doo, doo, doo, doo, doo. And we'll see what happens.
- 9:47You know, there's, I feel like there's so much opportunity to leverage the dealer network, to deliver these vehicles, to show them off, to test drive them. Like, I know it's complicated, but man, to bypass it like that,
- 10:01I, I just, I won't- And here's the thing. Like, as dealers, VW dealers are some of the, from what I have experienced, they're typically, like, they swing more savvy. They swing more customer-centric.
- 10:16They have alr- like, VW owners are already a lot more loyal. They're loyal. So why wouldn't you leverage all that brand loyalty? I don't get it.
- 10:24I mean, I, I just don't get it because, you know, Daniel Govara was on the show and we said, "Scout Motors," and he goes, "Who?" Who? [laughs] Right?
- 10:32Scout has a massive lift, just speaking from a brand build perspective and what you need to build a consumer brand from the ground up. Nobody- I mean, such a small percentage of people remember the old Scout vehicles.
- 10:44Right. Right? It's just not that iconic. They're trying to bring it back and make it iconic, and I think they just have a much, much bigger lift to get that to be someone's, like, prime choice, top of mind.
- 10:54However, like you said, you siphon from the V- VW brand, right? Scout from VW, right? A VW, a brand. Yep. All of a sudden, all the VW owners look and say, "Oh." Right? But they, they can't, they can't do that.
- 11:08[laughs] Yeah. They can't do that. It's even harder when all you're really building is a Land Rivian. A Land Rivian. [laughs] That's so good. [laughs] That's pretty much what it is. I mean, the cars are gorgeous.
- 11:18They are gorgeous. They are straight up- But it's just a Land Rivian... Land Rivian. Oh my gosh. [laughs] Okay. Speaking of gorgeous- I don't have any- Segway. Just stop it. Oh, that was a bad joke. It's good.
- 11:28Bad joke on a Monday. I think it was a good joke. You laughed. It worked, it worked. Yeah. A recent study has named Shake Shack and Five Guys as amo- America's most overpriced fast food chains- Makes me hungry...
- 11:37marketing bait. Over, [laughs] with their premium pricing for burgers and fries. Is it really worth it?
- 11:42Uh, a company called Preply analyzed 57,000 Google reviews, highlighting Shake Shack as the most overpriced, not just expensive, overpriced chain, followed by Five Guys and Sugar Factory.
- 11:54Key terms like expensive and not worth the money dominated a lot of cus- customer feedback.
- 11:59Uh, back in March, a viral receipt for $22 for a cheeseburger- bacon cheeseburger, soda, and fries obviously led to a lot of, uh, widespread backlash for Five Guys, with one post asking, "What is the right amount these days?"
- 12:14[laughs] Um, Shake Shack has raised prices twice in 2024, uh, 3% in March, 1.5% in October, citing inflation pressures. Um, w-Still, Shake Shack, they're making money.
- 12:27Strong Q3 earnings, 14% s- uh, revenue surge, 17 new locations. CEO Robin Lynch said, "We're proud of the results. As we grow total re- to- grew total revenue with positive traffic." Listen- So people still showing up...
- 12:40well, the question is, like, what is overpriced? Because if people show up, like the person who bought the $22 burger, fries, and soda, I guarantee you- Enjoyed every bit of it...
- 12:48I guarantee you when they walk out the front door of that Sh- of, of that Five Guys, they could, within eyesight, see a McDonald's and a Burger King. Absolutely. Right?
- 12:57And if you wanna pay $12, you can go to McDonald's or Burger King. That's right. But if you want- Yep... if you want, I mean, it's just- Well, I think that's the juxtaposition here...
- 13:05good brand building, it's good quality food. Like- Yeah... we- we're- like, a lot of people still rem- remember going and getting a Big Mac meal for 5.89. Shoot, I remember- Right?...
- 13:12two, two, two cheeseburger meals for 2.99. We were just telling my kids- Absolutely... Mom and I used to eat at McDonald's for six bucks total. Easy. And that's just not a reality. Like- No...
- 13:21Chick-fil-A, we come out of Chick-fil-A, and I'm like, "And they took my wallet, too." Oh [laughs]. It's crazy, right? [laughs] Uh- It's a second mortgage showing up...
- 13:30but, like, personal, I've never seen a Shake Shack not busy. Not s- You ever been to a Shake Shack- Never... and it's like, "Where did all the people go?" Nah, it doesn't happen. Never. Right? Never. Yeah.
- 13:41Actually, the- Yeah, so- It's funny, like, when that Shake Shack picture come up, Nathan, can you put that back up? This specific Shake Shack model, it, it conjured, it conjured a, a feeling [laughs]
- 13:54for me because I don't know if you remember, you and I had- were dealing with one of the most toughest, the toughest business- Tough, yeah... turn- like, forks in the road.
- 14:02I mean, it was, it was a year and a half ago, so we figured it out. But we were, like, in there, we're like, "What are we gonna do about this?" [laughs] Yeah. In a Shake Shack that looked just like that.
- 14:11And that burger was stellar. Oh- It was great... I would've paid $50 for that burger in that moment. [laughs] Perfect timing. Big five- Perfect... that, I wasn't buying a burger, I was buying solace.
- 14:21[laughs] And I, yeah, solace. And I'll say, every time I go into a Five Guys and that, that, the fries are just, like, a just overflowing, and you're like- Yes... "How? This is not a small.
- 14:32This is a double extra large"- Oh, they do that right... everywhere else. Yeah. Right? I put the whole thing...
- 14:36And, and by the way, I think it's worth, since we're just commentating at this point, I think it's worth mentioning- [laughs]...
- 14:40that if you're ever in the airport, Atlanta Airport, I, I can't remember, is it B terminal or C terminal? There's a Five Guys. I think it's C terminal. There's a, there's a Five Guys.
- 14:49And the staff there is always entertaining. They're always great.
- 14:53They're, they're- We've been there several times, and different people- And when we say entertaining, like, it's not just the entertainment like you would expect it... good service entertaining. Yeah. It's [laughs]
- 15:01amazing. Good service entertaining. So if, if you ever do that, go to that Sh- Five Guys. Make sure you tell them we sent you, to which they'll have probably some entertaining response because- Yep...
- 15:09they're upbeat, they're energetic, the food's always good, and that's just a little airport recommendations from Paul and Cal- Little rec-o... at the beginning of the year. [laughs] Little travel rec-o.
- 15:17At the end of the year, actually. You can start off 2025 right, go to Five Guys in the Atlanta Airport terminal C. That's right. Tell them we sent you. Look, whatever you're doing, close out the year strong.
- 15:25We have two days until it's 2025. We'll see you tomorrow morning. [upbeat music]