Latest / Film And Whiskey / Meet Me in St. Louis / Hancock's President's Reserve
Transcript
- 0:00In 1944 director Vincente Minnelli and star.
- 0:03Judy Garland gave the world a refreshingly Charming picture of
- 0:07a family desperate to stay in St.
- 0:09Louis in 2021, we repeat ourselves Ad nauseam.
- 0:13As We Sip another Buffalo, Trace product, that's hard to find the
- 0:17film is meet me in st. Louis, the whiskey is Hancock's
- 0:21presidents reserve and we'll review them both.
- 0:24This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:46Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast, where each week, we
- 0:48review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:51I'm Bob book, I'm Reggie and this week, we are looking at the
- 0:551944 Technicolor, MGM Musical. Meet me in st.
- 1:00Louis Brad. I think I've built this one up
- 1:03for you a little bit because I've been telling you this is
- 1:05one of my favorite movies ever and I'm opening myself up here a
- 1:10little bit. I'm being vulnerable.
- 1:11I feel like every time I bring a movie to you, that I really
- 1:15truly cherish. Its I mean, it's hard.
- 1:18It really is man, because I'm like, I don't know where you're
- 1:19going to land on these things. And, you know, I've been burned
- 1:23one too many times my friend. So I am entering today
- 1:26cautiously optimistic about this movie.
- 1:29Now, this is the second film, we've done with Judy.
- 1:32Garland, after The Wizard of Oz, this is the second Vincente
- 1:35Minnelli movie, we've done after An American in Paris way back in
- 1:38season one. I'm really anxious to see what
- 1:42you think, but also to kind of, you know, jog our memories a
- 1:45little bit and compare, and contrast to those other two
- 1:48films that we've done, that are kind of related to this one.
- 1:51Yeah, I mean, on one hand, you have the Judy G Masterpiece
- 1:55Wizard of Oz which in our opinion is pretty bad.
- 2:00Movie. And then you have an American in
- 2:03Paris, which is one of the, it's just such a pleasant film.
- 2:06Oh yeah, like like am an American in Paris, it's just
- 2:10nice and it makes me happy and I like that about it.
- 2:13Yeah. And I think at least for me Brad
- 2:15this movie has that going forward as well and it's not
- 2:18just that it's like an off Shucks, you know, simpler times
- 2:22kind of movie. But what I really love about
- 2:24this film and we'll get into it as we talk about it is that it's
- 2:28just the story of a family. Mele over the course of a year
- 2:32and nothing terribly exciting goes on in their lives, except
- 2:35for the fact that they might have to move away.
- 2:38They invest so much time and so much energy in making you
- 2:42believe that these people on screen really are a family and
- 2:45really care about each other. That you really do get caught up
- 2:49in, you know, the, the crushes that the girls have and the
- 2:53Mischief of the younger kids and then the idea that they might
- 2:55have to move away, I love that. This is a low.
- 3:00Steaks movie because in so many ways, I think it does resemble
- 3:04real life that way and it's just so near and dear to my heart.
- 3:08Yeah, there's a lot going on for it and I'm excited to get into
- 3:11it. But before I start, you know,
- 3:13postulating on why this movie is going to be cast into the fiery.
- 3:17Furnace at the end of the season.
- 3:18I think. I think we should get into Brad.
- 3:20Explains you bastard. All right.
- 3:26Well let's let's hear it from the horse's mouth here.
- 3:29And horse is generous term for what I think of you right now.
- 3:33So Brad we know, this is your first time watching the film
- 3:36meet me in st. Louis.
- 3:38And so it's time for Brad explains where Brad breaks down
- 3:41the plot of the movie that he is just seen often for the first
- 3:43time Brad. As we all know, there's a 60
- 3:45second limit on. Brad explains this season.
- 3:48Do you think you can summarize the plot of this movie in under
- 3:51one minute? I think I have a chance to doing
- 3:54it. The film meet me in st.
- 3:57Louis is about a family. Known as this is going to be
- 4:01hard to remember, everybody The Smiths and the Smiths are led by
- 4:07their father, who is a lawyer, and their mother, who is a
- 4:10homemaker I assume and it really just kind of Chronicles.
- 4:14I mean Bobby already said it, it Chronicles their life for a
- 4:17year. The main character of the movie
- 4:20is Esther Smith. The second oldest daughter of
- 4:24the four daughters and we really just see her kind of I don't
- 4:29know she falls in love with the neighbor.
- 4:32Boy, Johnny true it. She kind of encourages.
- 4:35Her older sister on a love affair of her own with a guy
- 4:40named, Warren who lives out in New York, then he goes to
- 4:43Princeton 10 seconds. Yeah, they find out, they're
- 4:46moving to New York, everybody's pissed.
- 4:48Judy Garland sings some Christmas song, The End boom
- 4:54nailed it. My favorite thing about that.
- 4:56Brad explains was that Some Christmas song is the all-time
- 5:01classic, Have Yourself, a Merry Little Christmas.
- 5:04Like, I love how you talked about it, like it's a song that
- 5:07is instantly forgettable and that no one's ever heard.
- 5:09You're the guy some song about Christmas Bob?
- 5:12I'm not gonna lie under the 10 second gun.
- 5:14I did, genuinely did not remember what something she's
- 5:17saying? You knew it wasn't White
- 5:19Christmas. And so like after that it's like
- 5:21well in Giles forgetting some Christmas.
- 5:24Yeah, exactly. All right.
- 5:26Place Up on the Rooftop maybe. Yeah.
- 5:29All right, so you have explained the plot of this movie, I'm
- 5:32gonna let you kind of dictate where we go here today.
- 5:35If you want to start talking about like overall impressions
- 5:37of the movie we can go there. If you want to talk about
- 5:39Minelli as a director we can go there.
- 5:41We could jump right into performances if you'd like so.
- 5:44I mean, what's the most kind of burning thing on your mind when
- 5:47it comes to this movie? Honestly?
- 5:49Bob, for me, I think the reason this family works is because of
- 5:542D, the youngest daughter. Nice.
- 5:56Her character the way it's written.
- 5:58And The way she delivers the lines the way her acting
- 6:02performance is just phenomenal. It's a great performance by a
- 6:06child actor. Yeah.
- 6:07So this was Margaret O'Brien, who was really, really famous in
- 6:10Hollywood. At the time, she was kind of,
- 6:11you know, the new Shirley Temple because Shirley Temple had
- 6:15become a teenager at this point and Margaret O'Brien kind of
- 6:18filled that void of the Shirley Temple role in the early 1940s.
- 6:22This is probably her most well-remembered role at this
- 6:25point and you're right. Brad.
- 6:27I mean it's not just that she Turn on like the little kid
- 6:30charm cause she does that really well, but her ability especially
- 6:33to cry on cue. Like there's, you know, the Have
- 6:36Yourself a Merry Little Christmas scene which we'll talk
- 6:38about is is actually a very sad scene in the context of the
- 6:42movie and it Sparks this little girl to cry and cry because she
- 6:46doesn't want to move to New York City.
- 6:47And she basically goes outside and destroys a bunch of snowmen
- 6:50that she's built because she knows that she can't take them
- 6:53with her. And it's, I mean it's a
- 6:55heartbreaking scene and Bubba, I don't you, I thought you said
- 6:58we're going to talk About the scene later.
- 7:00Talk about the song later, it's worth like a motherfuckin tight
- 7:03now, salmon. Oh okay.
- 7:04Okay. Gotcha anyway.
- 7:07She sells it really, really well, the end.
- 7:10Oh wow, that came so much faster than I was hoping for Bob.
- 7:15I think that her performance gives like credibility to the
- 7:20entire movie, because a lot of the movie it borders on the line
- 7:25of Being Cheesy and her, Like impishness and her likability to
- 7:32talk about like killing people and it's just so weirdly Darkly
- 7:38funny in the middle of this you know somewhat schmooze e love
- 7:44drama just kind of light-hearted teen rom-com.
- 7:49Yeah that I don't know why but that performance just grounded
- 7:53the entire movie for me and made me go.
- 7:56Oh, I actually like I like all of the Actors better because of
- 8:002D, I think that's like the highest compliment you can give
- 8:03an actor in an ensemble like this.
- 8:05And I totally agree with you, you know, she she says the kind
- 8:08of things that little kids say when they don't quite understand
- 8:11the consequences of what they're saying, like I have a
- 8:13four-year-old son right now and you know he doesn't understand
- 8:16the concept of death and so he's trying to ask questions to
- 8:20understand what like what death is and what happens when people
- 8:23die and things like that? But I mean, you know, he's just
- 8:25like so what happens if somebody kills this person and what Just
- 8:29look asks these various kind of socially inappropriate questions
- 8:33but it's because he doesn't know any better.
- 8:34And this little girl 2D in the movie, you know, she's
- 8:37constantly talking about how her doll has a, you know, for fatal
- 8:42diseases and we're going to give her the nicest funeral in this
- 8:45old shoebox, I've already picked it out and like the whole movie
- 8:48she's talking about stuff like that and it just makes me
- 8:51chuckle because that's exactly how kids that age are.
- 8:55Yeah, and the other thing that kids just constantly We have
- 8:59done since the 40s is domestic terrorism in the middle of
- 9:04streets during Halloween and like we see 2D like rise to the
- 9:08occasion in the midst of that. There's an extended sequence in
- 9:11the middle of this movie and I've, you know, to break the
- 9:14movie down a little bit more. It's broken up into four
- 9:17chapters. Basically tells the story of
- 9:19four seasons over the course of a year 1903.
- 9:22Leading up to the World's Fair, which is opening in St.
- 9:25Louis in 1904, and in the, the Sequence.
- 9:29It's a really extended Halloween seen with the two youngest
- 9:33daughters, and if you've ever seen some of those old pictures
- 9:36of how kids dressed up for Halloween, 100 years ago, this
- 9:39is, this does a really good job of replicating that like,
- 9:42they're very scary looking children.
- 9:45And apparently the custom at the time was to just burn Furniture
- 9:49in the middle of the street and go around and hit your neighbors
- 9:52in the face, with a sack of flour, and tell them that you
- 9:54hate them. And this was just acceptable
- 9:56behavior. And I just like, I I texted you
- 9:59that Brad. I was like, oh apparently just
- 10:01domestic terrorism was cool a hundred years ago.
- 10:03Yeah. It's just kind of.
- 10:05It was the thing to do like, like, nowadays parents are
- 10:09worried about that one poison candy bar out of like the 10
- 10:12million candy bars that get handed out back then.
- 10:15Man, you had Furniture, like, stolen off of your porch and
- 10:19burnt. Yeah, in the street.
- 10:21Yeah, so we pretty much have it. Lucky nowadays, you know, one of
- 10:24the things that I, when I was doing research on the movie,
- 10:27apparently, the production, Would you know, they had the
- 10:29sensors at the time they sent this movie off to the sensors
- 10:32and they sent it back with a note saying, you can't say that
- 10:35the kids are stealing Furniture to burn in the street, like they
- 10:38can burn it in the street, but you can imply that they stole
- 10:42it. So like, we were there getting
- 10:44really, really particular about what crimes were okay for
- 10:47children to commit. Well, honestly, that probably
- 10:50led to one of the funniest lines of the movie when I think it's
- 10:54the oldest daughter Rose, but it might have been Judy G but they
- 10:58get Off the phone and they're like, oh mrs.
- 11:01Such and such, you know, their neighbors.
- 11:02Like I pulled the hammock off and set it on the front porch.
- 11:05Can you tell him to just put it back when they're done?
- 11:08Like like everybody knows that these kids are going to be
- 11:11stealing stuff off of people's? Porches.
- 11:13I kind of love that though. You know what I mean?
- 11:15It's like, oh, it's brilliant. It's like the children version
- 11:18of The Purge once a year. Yeah, they're just gonna come
- 11:20hit me with flour and then we're good for the rest of the year.
- 11:24Yeah, we're good. All right, Brad.
- 11:26So talk a little bit about this. Movie as a quote-unquote MGM
- 11:31musical, right? And I think that, for those of
- 11:33you who have seen old musicals made by the studio, MGM, you
- 11:37have an image in mind of what that means.
- 11:38It's, you know, your Gene Kelly singing in the rain and American
- 11:41in Paris, this movie. I think really kind of stands
- 11:45alone in that, it is a musical. But it only has I think five
- 11:50original songs in it and the the songs really arise out of the
- 11:55plot more than, you know, someone gets on stage and
- 11:57performs a tap. Dance number like you would see
- 12:00in a lot of musicals at the time.
- 12:01And I think that really kind of made me think for a while about
- 12:04what makes a movie musical a musical.
- 12:08And this is a question that has come up a bunch, you know, the
- 12:11most recent version of a star is born with Lady Gaga.
- 12:15That really brought the question up again, to because all the
- 12:17songs sung in that movie are being performed by people who
- 12:21are playing performers, so it's not that they're like singing in
- 12:26their everyday life. Like the characters are Just
- 12:29they don't just break into song in this movie they do.
- 12:32And yet, I think some people might be tempted to not call
- 12:35this a musical because there are so few songs in it.
- 12:39So I don't know man. When I, when I ask you like,
- 12:41what would make a movie musical a movie musical?
- 12:45What would your criteria be? I think for me this might sound
- 12:50weird but like so diegetic sounds in film are like when
- 12:55music comes from the radio and like the Characters in the movie
- 13:00can hear the noise. Yeah.
- 13:01Right. And so, I think that when, when
- 13:05the music that the characters are dancing to is non-diegetic,
- 13:11that's a pretty clear marker for me of whether or not something
- 13:16is a musical, does that. So like that makes sense when
- 13:19you're watching like West Side Story and somebody breaks into
- 13:22song is that diegetic like do we know if the characters in that
- 13:26world? No, they're Or like to them or
- 13:30they just talking and we were just hearing it as song.
- 13:33I guess, I guess any time that a normal human being wouldn't be
- 13:37breaking out into song. That that's what makes it, a
- 13:40music. Yeah, I kind of agree with that.
- 13:41And so, I think this one has definitely qualify as a musical.
- 13:45Yeah, it does. I mean, there's a part of me
- 13:47that like, the song, when the, the wife, their mom starts
- 13:52playing the song on the piano and the dad starts singing.
- 13:55Yeah. And that like if the entire
- 13:57musical was A full of things like that.
- 14:00I don't know if I'd call it a musical.
- 14:01I cuz that's just them them acting how like, they would act
- 14:06in normal real life. Like, you know, they might be a
- 14:09musical family, she just plays a song and then changes the key
- 14:12because every housewife just knows how to change the key in a
- 14:15song to make it fit her husband's, you know, vocal
- 14:19pallets. Yeah.
- 14:20And they just move on from there.
- 14:23But in the end I think you have other parts of the movie where
- 14:28you Like Judy, Garland singing at different points of the movie
- 14:33and like, sure her character could have chosen to sing in
- 14:36that moment. But a lot of times it's just
- 14:39Judy Garland singing because she's, you know, one of the best
- 14:42singers ever to live. Yeah, Brad.
- 14:44I don't even know how I'm going to get off this topic because
- 14:48first of all, I have an unrequited forever crush on.
- 14:54Like I have just always loved Judy Garland, I think she is.
- 14:58I think She is my favorite actor/actress, ever.
- 15:03In the history of movies, Gene Kelly at one point called her
- 15:06the most entertaining person I ever met.
- 15:09And like, first for somebody like Gene Kelly to say that is,
- 15:12you know, really high, praise obviously.
- 15:13But watching this movie. She's So electric.
- 15:17You cannot take your eyes off of her and for her to make this
- 15:21movie at age 22, and to do the kind of things that she's doing
- 15:24from an acting standpoint. That's a thing.
- 15:27Like I just, I don't feel like She gets enough credit as an
- 15:31actress and way back a few months ago.
- 15:34Brad, we did our patreon bonus episode where our patrons asked
- 15:38us questions. And I talked about this in that
- 15:40episode that she has. This moment in this movie where
- 15:44she has a crush on this next door, neighbor, John Truitt.
- 15:47She has kind of convinced him to come inside and help her turn
- 15:49off all the lights in the house. It's very, you know, it's filled
- 15:51with this kind of tension. Are they gonna kiss and him
- 15:54being, you know, a teenage boy, just shakes her hand.
- 15:58And and then walks off and says, well, goodnight, Esther.
- 16:01And she has this moment where she goes.
- 16:03Good night neighbor and she just looks down at her hand and it is
- 16:07just it's pitch, perfect. But the dramatic stuff in this
- 16:12movie to like bread, I mean I don't know why I assume you
- 16:15don't love Judy Garland as much as I do.
- 16:18But I think that even though she's one of the most famous and
- 16:22iconic people ever in movies, we still undervalue her.
- 16:26I'm just going to make like your Hackles raised here for a
- 16:29second. Bob, I love Judy Garland,
- 16:33singing voice. I don't enjoy her, just talking
- 16:37voice, I don't know what it is, but it just annoys me.
- 16:43Like, it's not, it's not quite like nails on chalkboard like
- 16:46it's not, you know, the worst voice I've ever heard in my life
- 16:48but there is something about it throughout the entire thing
- 16:50where I was like, man. I just feel, I think I don't
- 16:54care for Judy Garland, a ton because I feel like her voice
- 16:56sounds fake compared to Buddy else's voice interesting and I
- 17:01don't know where that comes from.
- 17:03I think it's something that I've thought about with Wizard of Oz
- 17:06before but with Wizard of Oz, that's something I grew up
- 17:09watching so I guess I didn't really think about it a ton when
- 17:12we watched it but this time through it was like I don't know
- 17:1530 or 40 minutes into the movie and I was like man I just don't
- 17:19know what it is about Judy Garland but her voice just look
- 17:24it's not my favorite. I'm so sad but you know setting
- 17:27aside your distaste The way she sounds like, you know, talk
- 17:31about the performance, though. I mean, I assume that you can at
- 17:34least agree with me that she's a better actress than people give
- 17:37her credit for. Oh, bro.
- 17:39She's the best actress in the movie.
- 17:41Yeah. Like, like Far and Away her
- 17:44performance. Obviously, I think, I think 2D
- 17:47as a child actress, does a phenomenal job.
- 17:51But the way that Judy interacts with all the other characters in
- 17:55her like and usually this word has a negative connotation.
- 17:58Notation, but I'll use it in a positive way here, the way that
- 18:02she softly, manipulates people around her and it's always with
- 18:06a pure heart is just, I don't know.
- 18:09It's almost like adorable. You know what I mean?
- 18:11Oh, absolutely. That's a perfect word for it.
- 18:13Brad, and Brad. I think we should talk about the
- 18:15rest of the cast, though, because I could go on, and on
- 18:17talking about Judy Garland in this movie and we'll probably
- 18:20bring her up more and more as we talked about how Minelli uses
- 18:24her in this movie. But I do want to touch on some
- 18:26other people in the cast because I think pretty To formally top
- 18:29to bottom. I love everybody in this movie.
- 18:32And once again, you know, Minelli stocked, this cast, with
- 18:36really seasoned character actors and one of the greatest Feats
- 18:40that I think this movie pulls off, is that.
- 18:43They so convincingly play a family.
- 18:47Like, I think, you know, by the Midway point of the movie, I was
- 18:50just bought into the idea that like, this is a family system.
- 18:53And this is, you know, how the dad operates, and here's the
- 18:55mom, who's really in charge and very quietly, leave Is this
- 18:59family where she needs to lead them.
- 19:00And here's the oldest daughter and everyone really seemed like
- 19:04at least on screen. They liked each other that they
- 19:07cared about each other that they were looking out for each other.
- 19:10I honestly think this is one of the more convincing on-screen
- 19:13families I've ever seen. Yeah, Bob I'm right there with
- 19:17you. I feel like when you watch this
- 19:19family, you can see the quirks and The Oddities of each
- 19:23individual character, that makes them endearing.
- 19:26And then, you can also see why the Characters in the movie,
- 19:30love them, hate them frustrated by them are encouraged by them
- 19:34like you just yeah. Bob it just feels like a real
- 19:37family that you know especially like at the end of the movie
- 19:41when you know, Judy Garland is engaged to John Truitt.
- 19:48And yet she still tells John like, well, no, I need to go to
- 19:51New York with my family will find a way to make it work.
- 19:54And then moments later. She's consoling, her little
- 19:57sister and like, Guarantee you're like, no, like we will be
- 20:00okay as long as we all stick together and I think the reason
- 20:05why their family Dynamic works so well is not just because it
- 20:08rings true but because the audience wants it to rest
- 20:13through. Yes.
- 20:14Like we all want to belong to a family like the Smiths.
- 20:18Well and that's the reason that the happy ending of this movie
- 20:21works. So well, it's because, you know,
- 20:24they don't move to New York, they stay in St.
- 20:25Louis, they decide, you know, the dad.
- 20:27Finally it Dawns on him. This is our home.
- 20:29This is where we want our family to be raised.
- 20:32You did think it was a fine opportunity, didn't you?
- 20:34New York? Hasn't got a copyright on
- 20:36opportunity, why st. Louis is headed for a boom.
- 20:39That'll make your head swim. This is a great town.
- 20:42The trouble with you people is you don't appreciate it because
- 20:44it's right here under your noses.
- 20:46The grass is always greener in somebody else's yard and the
- 20:51movie ends triumphantly with them at the World's Fair talking
- 20:54about, I can't believe it's right here.
- 20:55It's right here in St. Louis.
- 20:57And the reason that That that happy ending works is because we
- 21:01feel as an audience that these people deserve a happy ending.
- 21:05Like you have watched them go through the trials and
- 21:08tribulations of a year. You've watched The Strain on the
- 21:12parents marriage a little bit. You've watched it Through The
- 21:14Eyes of their children and not wanting to move away there.
- 21:18And it's like, yes, I want these people to get a win at the end
- 21:22of the movie and so that ending doesn't come off as cheesy.
- 21:25It doesn't come off as overly sentimental.
- 21:28It He does feel earned. And, and really that that's the
- 21:32sign of a good director. What Minnelli Does in this
- 21:35movie, the way he carefully crafts, this family drama, he
- 21:40does it in such a way that you can tell that he genuinely cares
- 21:45about the story being told and that as you kind of weave your
- 21:50way through this year, in the life of the Smith.
- 21:52Family, like you said, you get to the end of it and you realize
- 21:57you're just really rude. Ting for this family to succeed.
- 22:01And the big thing is I don't think it's tied to the outcome
- 22:04of whether or not they go to New York because I fully believe
- 22:09that that family would be successful even if they had
- 22:11moved to New York. But the happy ending is because
- 22:17they get what they all want. They get to stay in St.
- 22:20Louis and that and that's just I don't know.
- 22:21I think Minnelli Does a masterful job weaving the story
- 22:24together throughout the movie. Well let's kind of nerd out here
- 22:27on Minelli for a couple. That's because just like Judy
- 22:30Garland, I think Minnelli is underrated when it comes to the
- 22:33discussion of great directors, because this man had a sense for
- 22:37how to compose a shot that very few people ever had.
- 22:42And there are just like, countless examples, I could get
- 22:45from this movie Brad, this is one of the most beautifully
- 22:47composed movies I've ever seen, but I think the first thing I
- 22:50want to do is kind of jog, our memory back to season one.
- 22:53When we were first talking about An American in Paris, I
- 22:56mentioned this movie. I talked about how Minnelli Does
- 22:59this great thing in some of his movies where he kind of builds a
- 23:02frame within a frame. And, you know, when you watch
- 23:05this movie and it shows the title cards were it's like
- 23:08spring and Autumn. It looks like a greeting card.
- 23:11But what Minnelli Does in many of the scenes is he kind of
- 23:14frames people inside of a window sill or something, and makes it
- 23:18look like the people in that scene or kind of in a greeting
- 23:20card. The, I think the best example is
- 23:23the first song, Judy Garland sings called the boy next door
- 23:25where she's you know, pining for John Truitt.
- 23:28And the whole song is just her looking out the window.
- 23:32And first of all again, Judy Garland, incredible performance,
- 23:35I would say the first two thirds of that song.
- 23:38Our one shot one take. But I love that he does these
- 23:43little flourishes that just make.
- 23:45It's like, he makes the most artistic possible choice at
- 23:49every point in this movie, but it never really gets
- 23:51distracting. It always feels like, yeah.
- 23:55I totally understand why he went for that and I think it
- 23:58enhances. Has the viewing experience.
- 24:00Yeah. The shot that really stood out
- 24:01to me was when 2D was that the little bonfire that the
- 24:06Hooligans had created in the middle of the street and she
- 24:10challenges them all and says, well I'll go throw.
- 24:13I'll go kill mr. Krakow for crack off or
- 24:17something. And when she walks away from the
- 24:20fire and the camera slowly like dollies in front of her, like
- 24:24the look of fear on her face with the fire burning behind her
- 24:28in the Children all like watching her leave.
- 24:30It was just a daggone. Beautiful shot, man.
- 24:33Well, and you got to remember to the size of the cameras back
- 24:36then, I mean, they were hundreds of pounds for him to move the
- 24:39camera the way he does. It took a ton of work and
- 24:42there's one really really great example from this movie.
- 24:45It's that scene where Judy Garland and John Truitt played
- 24:49by Tom Drake are going through the house turning out the lights
- 24:52and you don't notice it until someone points it out to you.
- 24:55It's one shot like the cameras in the ceiling and then it Drops
- 24:58down a little farther and it floats into another room.
- 25:01They had to like, specifically build this set to accommodate
- 25:05that camera and from what I read, like, it took a lot of
- 25:08time to choreograph that correctly, but to see somebody
- 25:12doing that, that kind of work with a camera in the 1940s.
- 25:15When it was like prohibitive to try to haul a camera up to the
- 25:19ceiling. It's just, I mean, it's just a
- 25:21sign of a director, who knows what he's doing and is trying to
- 25:24make the best decision at every point and Minelli.
- 25:28Giving a little inspiration to, in Yuri to there is that?
- 25:31That's right. Brad.
- 25:32I do want to talk about one more shot in the movie though and
- 25:35it's because, you know, sometimes you look at a shot and
- 25:37you're like, wow knocks me away with the visuals or like, wow,
- 25:40that's a great metaphor. My favorite scene in the film I
- 25:43think is that scene that you were mentioning where the
- 25:47patriarch in the matriarch of the family are singing the song
- 25:50You and I and it's right after the dad has just announced, I'm
- 25:54moving you all to New York and does not ask for input on it.
- 25:57Everyone's pissed. Everyone goes, their separate
- 25:59ways and the mom just calmly quietly, like goes over to the
- 26:04piano and starts playing the song.
- 26:07And it's this perfect marriage of music and lyrics and visuals.
- 26:11Because in the foreground of the shot, you've got mom and dad and
- 26:15they're singing. The song that goes You and I
- 26:18together forever. It's a song about marriage.
- 26:22It's a song about the commitment that is marriage and
- 26:25self-sacrifice and how we are in this thing together.
- 26:28Even when we're pissed off at each other, even when we don't
- 26:31feel like doing it, even when we disagree, we are in this
- 26:34together. And for me, it's the most
- 26:37poignant representation of what marriage looks like on screen.
- 26:42And in the background, everybody else kind of starts to shuffle
- 26:45back into frame. Like they, they've cooled off
- 26:48they're going to come. Listen to Mom and Dad sing and
- 26:50what you have is the oldest daughter Rose, and she comes and
- 26:53stands about halfway down the steps.
- 26:55And it's a visual for us as the audience, that Minnelli's.
- 26:58He's trying to do something with how he's placing people in frame
- 27:02and Rose, comes and stands there.
- 27:03And then passed her comes to tea the youngest.
- 27:06And then after her comes Agnes, the second youngest.
- 27:08And then after her comes Judy Garland, and what Minnelli's
- 27:12doing is he is showing like visually the passage of time,
- 27:17right? Like he introduces their oldest
- 27:20daughter. So that you're thinking about,
- 27:21okay, like, you know, their firstborn daughter and then you
- 27:25see this little girl come walking by and you see a little
- 27:28bit. Older girl, come walking by and
- 27:30it's like he's showing us these people that are singing to each
- 27:33other committing themselves back to each other again, have been
- 27:36doing this for years and you watch the years pass as their
- 27:40children grow up before them and then, you know, finally the
- 27:43whole family comes back together in the room and it is just the
- 27:46most eloquent way of visually depicting.
- 27:52A lifelong Union between people and like, every time I see that
- 27:56seen it chokes me up, because Again like the subtext is these
- 28:00people who are just really mad at each other recommitting
- 28:03themselves to you know, to self sacrifice for each other.
- 28:06But it's also this really great beautiful representation of what
- 28:10it looks like to do that over the course of a Lifetime.
- 28:13Well, and and really the only thing that could have made that
- 28:16scene, like slightly more powerful is if they had all done
- 28:20it over a glass of whisky and Bob, I really think I do know
- 28:24your Segway is getting cut off. I like, I literally, I went In
- 28:28on my analysis and I was like, Brad.
- 28:31I'm gonna blow this dude away with my analysis of this scene
- 28:34and you just immediately. Go to the whiskey segue.
- 28:38How dare you sir? Yeah, I'm really intrusive
- 28:41whiskey, bro. You Brad acknowledge acknowledge
- 28:46my analysis. Yeah, it was great, man, killing
- 28:50it. Let's do it Brett.
- 29:37Alright so today we are checking out Hancock's presidents
- 29:40Reserve, Brad. This is a Single Barrel Bourbon
- 29:43that comes from the Buffalo, Trace Corporation, our
- 29:46favorites. This is from their Mash bill.
- 29:49Number two recipe, which is rumored to be a high recipe.
- 29:53The Rye is somewhere between 15 and 20% of the mash bill, but as
- 29:56with most things at Buffalo Trace, they don't disclose the
- 29:59mash bill. But we know that this is related
- 30:01to Brands like Eh, Taylor and Blanton's, they both come from
- 30:05this Mash bill. Now, eh Taylor we both really
- 30:08liked Blanton's, we have been hit or miss on depending on
- 30:10which expression Hancock's is an interesting one, because this is
- 30:14the lowest proof offering from that Mash bill at it's only
- 30:18comes in at I believe 88.9 proof or only you know, forty four and
- 30:23a half essentially alcohol by volume.
- 30:26So I'm really interested to see what this is like Brad because
- 30:29the blames that we tried which is again A Single Barrel.
- 30:31So it could I've been off was so so harsh at only what was it?
- 30:36Like 103 proof so maybe this will be a more pleasant drinking
- 30:41experience. Have you had any exposure to
- 30:43Hancock's before? Now aside from it, being a
- 30:47Buffalo, Trace expression. And we all know how I feel about
- 30:52my exposure to the Buffalo. Trace brand?
- 30:55No, no. I haven't Bob.
- 30:57All right Brad. So, let's get into it.
- 30:58What are you picking up your on the nose?
- 31:00It's just not very Powerful in any way, which, you know, whisky
- 31:05doesn't have to be powerful to get a great score for me,
- 31:09there's like some soft spices going on here, a little bit of
- 31:11cinnamon, a little bit of a baking spice that kind of mix
- 31:16nicely with like a fresh Apple Lee.
- 31:19Add an a, I don't know some something of a nice fresh scent
- 31:24but you know, it's just kind of nice and generically sweet.
- 31:27I'll give it a seven and a half out of ten on the nose.
- 31:29Yeah, I think honestly Brad if you wanted to just You know,
- 31:32Define Pleasant and inoffensive. This is pretty much it.
- 31:37There's nothing in here that I would change.
- 31:39I still wouldn't call it a perfect nose, but this is kind
- 31:42of like the epitome of a very pleasant drinkable.
- 31:46You know, when you, when, you know something, you know, if
- 31:48it's going to be drinkable or not.
- 31:50And this one is, it has all your classic bourbon notes, which are
- 31:53like you said tone down a little bit, the baking spices are toned
- 31:56down. The alcohol is toned down.
- 31:58You get some nice oak on this and then you're right.
- 32:01Brad for me. It's red too.
- 32:02Just Apple all the way. And I really like that the fruit
- 32:05mingles really well with the oak.
- 32:07We know that some Buffalo Trace products, Brad and I found way
- 32:11over oaked. So I'm looking forward to this
- 32:14because I think maybe at the proof point.
- 32:16You know, watering it down a bit, will really help to
- 32:19mitigate that. I like this knows a lot, but
- 32:21just like you Brad, it's nothing to write home about.
- 32:25I'll give it a seven and a half on the nose.
- 32:27Yeah. And as I get into tasting this,
- 32:29there's just not a lot going on here.
- 32:32I think. Feel like there's some sweetness
- 32:34going on. That Apple note is continuing
- 32:37on. For me it gets decently okey and
- 32:41a little bit spicy and it's not it's not really working for me.
- 32:46A ton its pleasant on the palate but not great.
- 32:51I'll give it a 6 out of 10. Oh yeah I'm not really enjoying
- 32:54this on the taste Brad and it really did seem to flip a switch
- 32:58towards the back is very drastic front of Mount.
- 33:01You know front of your tongue. In front of your palate to the
- 33:03back of the palette, on the front of your palate.
- 33:06It's very thin. But like you said, very
- 33:08pleasantly, sweet. Lots of apple juice here.
- 33:10I wouldn't even call it apple cider.
- 33:12It's just like sugary nectar kind of on the front of the
- 33:17palate and then as soon as you kick it to the back of your
- 33:19mouth, you're right, really okey.
- 33:21Lots of smoke after you swallow on the finish and it does kind
- 33:25of it. Borders on going bitter and a
- 33:28little bit sour on the end and that's incredibly disappointing.
- 33:32Because there was a lot of Promise up front and you know,
- 33:36we've both been saying this already.
- 33:37It's thin. It's watered down, I get that.
- 33:39But even at a lower proof point, I was like, oh this is gonna be
- 33:42a really nice easy sipper. It's not, it packs a punch but
- 33:45not in a way that I like because it just really hits you with
- 33:49Oak. I'm only going to give this a 6
- 33:52out of 10 on the taste. Yeah.
- 33:54And and with the Finish once again, it's kind of generically
- 33:59sweet. There's a little bit of vanilla
- 34:02Tiny bit of maybe caramel for me but it has a short to medium
- 34:09Kentucky hug and it really finishes with a little bit of a
- 34:13rise spiciness that I kind of like I'll give it a seven and a
- 34:17half on the Finish. It's decent, but not, not
- 34:20overwhelmingly good. Yeah, for me, it's like, if you
- 34:22could pinpoint all of the probably eight or nine different
- 34:25flavors going on in the back end and then pick the two least
- 34:28Pleasant, those are the ones that kind of carry through to
- 34:31the Finish. It's really a heavy Char and
- 34:33kind of campfire smoke for me. And then it's this really bitter
- 34:37kind of grain tastes like it's not quite straight Rye grain,
- 34:43but I think the presence of that much Oak makes this really go
- 34:46bitter for me on the back end. There's not a lot.
- 34:49Like he said, there's not a Kentucky hug, there's not a lot
- 34:51of chest burn again. It's only 88 proof.
- 34:53So I wasn't expecting much there but even when it just comes to
- 34:56the flavors that are left behind on the palate, Brad, I think.
- 34:59I can only give this like a five and a half on the Finish.
- 35:02It brings us into our balance score.
- 35:05It's a nice little poor. There's little pops of flavor
- 35:09here and there but nothing really stands out.
- 35:12I'll give it a six and a half on balance.
- 35:14It moves from each part to the next decently.
- 35:18Really, the flavor palate is where this really struggles?
- 35:23Yeah, I'm gonna give it a six. If I took value into
- 35:26consideration, I'd probably give it a lower score, but that's why
- 35:29we have a value category unto itself.
- 35:31If you told me, This was a twenty dollar whiskey, I'd be
- 35:34like yeah that makes a lot of sense.
- 35:36This this drinks, you know the funny thing is I just bought a
- 35:39bottle of Benchmark the other day which was the very first one
- 35:42we ever tried on this show. I wanted to see how it held up.
- 35:45This is way way better than Benchmark but it's still at a
- 35:47proof point and it's still so simple and not complex that I
- 35:52would not be surprised if this was only 20 or $25 and that
- 35:55doesn't say much for it. I'm only going to give it a 6 on
- 35:58balance and that's where things get weird Brad because now it's
- 36:02For the value category and MSRP on.
- 36:05This is $50. You will not find it anywhere.
- 36:08Anywhere anywhere for $50. It is going for ridiculous.
- 36:13Prices on the secondary Market. I when I just type the name of
- 36:16this product into Google. The second result on Marketplace
- 36:20was 235 dollars for a bottle of this.
- 36:24I would say that you are lucky. If you can get a bottle of this
- 36:27for $100, like usually the markup on this is at least
- 36:30double what they asked for it. And that is absolutely
- 36:35ridiculous. And I will say this of it Brad.
- 36:38I truly hated the sample of Blanton's that we got.
- 36:42When it just comes to the regular blatant single barrel.
- 36:45And I would still say that I would, I would find paying
- 36:49double the cost for that Blanton's.
- 36:51More justifiable than paying $100 for this, this is 25
- 36:56dollar. Whiskey, that is, commanding a
- 36:58over $100 on the market. Yeah, you know, Bob with With us
- 37:03watching, such a pleasant movie in Meet Me in st.
- 37:08Louis, I feel that today is the day.
- 37:11The the one day I will give a reprieve to the Buffalo Trace
- 37:16company, what? And and just say, you know what?
- 37:21Let it be man, I'm fine. I'm gonna give it a 2 out of 10
- 37:27on Bali. Yeah, but I'm not going to rant
- 37:29about it. If you need to hear my rants,
- 37:31there are plenty of epi. Uh, so d'z go check them out.
- 37:33I don't even know what they are. You can hear my rants on Buffalo
- 37:36Trace, but today it's a 2 out of 10 on value.
- 37:39I also gave it a 2 out of 10 and I feel like that is being
- 37:42generous. If you've ever seen this bottle
- 37:44on the Shelf, it is the most kind of what's the word blase
- 37:49nondescript bottle. It has a really ugly kind of
- 37:53gold. Foil sticker slapped on it.
- 37:55It looks like it looks like fifteen dollar Whiskey on the
- 37:58shelf and I'm really glad we got to try this.
- 38:01This sample was given Us by our friend, Tyler @tk, bourbon on
- 38:05Instagram, he lives locally to me, I would never have been able
- 38:09to try this otherwise because it is so rare and hard to find.
- 38:12And I'm really glad that I got to try it as a sample for this
- 38:15show because Brad, I would not recommend buying this and I
- 38:19really don't recommend trying it, like it's okay, but even a
- 38:23poor of this at a whiskey bar is going to cost you like, I don't
- 38:26know, 15 bucks. Probably, there's no way that a
- 38:30poor of this is worth $15. Yeah.
- 38:32Yeah. Bob, you're trying to suck me in
- 38:35to talk and crap about Buffalo Trace and I'm not going to do it
- 38:38today. I'll do it.
- 38:39I'll do it for the both of us. Man.
- 38:41Do it, man, go. Yeah, you go for it.
- 38:43You got this. Bob, I'm coming out to a twenty
- 38:45seven out of fifty. Brad, where you at?
- 38:48I'm at a twenty nine point five out of 50, really taking Mercy
- 38:51on this one. I see.
- 38:52Now, I, I mean, you know what, this is the first whiskey in a
- 38:56while, Bob now that I'm thinking about it, I don't know the last
- 39:00whiskey, that you and I both came out.
- 39:02Under a 30 out of 50 on know, it's been a minute and we've had
- 39:06some bad Whiskey's on this show. Now I will say, like I don't
- 39:09think this is a bad whiskey if this was priced at the price of
- 39:13regular Buffalo Trace. Well, you know what it's
- 39:15supposed to be and was 25 bucks. I'd say like, yeah, maybe this
- 39:19would be a good entry level bourbon for some people.
- 39:22It's just, it's never going to be worth.
- 39:24What? It's commanding out there on the
- 39:25secondary Market. Bob you do it?
- 39:29Push me here, do it. Screw Buffalo, Trace him.
- 39:32Why the hell do they put this whiskey out?
- 39:35And they expect people to pay freaking top dollar for it and
- 39:39they try to drive it drive it up because they only release a
- 39:43little bit of it and I make the mystery because they barely put
- 39:46any information about it, you have to go to sazeracs website,
- 39:49to find any, you know, information about this, stupid
- 39:51freaking bourbon. That's garbage.
- 39:54Like, what are they doing? I hate that the whistle.
- 39:59And now I'm going to turn the whiskey Community for a second,
- 40:01I hate that. Whiskey Community.
- 40:03Buys their she like stopped buying Buffalo.
- 40:07Trace they put out stuff in such a just just uh manner that I
- 40:13just as a company they're garbage.
- 40:16Let the hate flow through you brat.
- 40:20We are coming out to an average of a 28 point 25 out of 50 or a
- 40:2556 and a half out of 100. I do not recommend Bradley, I
- 40:28can tell you do it, here's the here's the thing.
- 40:31Bob, if they put this Out. Even at like, let's just say $35
- 40:35and they made it widely available and everybody could
- 40:38try it and go. Yeah.
- 40:39You know, it's not quite 35 dollar whiskey.
- 40:41But okay. That's not the biggest, you
- 40:44know, dent in my wallet. I'd be fine with it, but they
- 40:48put it out at $50 a bottle. They barely release any of it.
- 40:51They MIT just don't buy this. Just don't I'm actually feeling
- 40:58really good now because no matter what you were thinking
- 41:01about meet me in st. Louis Before this.
- 41:03I know now that you will like that movie way more than you
- 41:08like this whiskey. So Brad, what do you say?
- 41:11We hop back into talking about meet me in st.
- 41:12Louis, I would love to do that. Robert.
- 41:55All right, that was Hancock's president's Reserve.
- 41:57We are getting back into talking about meet me in st.
- 42:00Louis and Brad, you've informed me off.
- 42:02Are that you have a new segment to introduce to the film.
- 42:05And whiskey podcast, I await this with bated breath, my
- 42:09friend. Yeah.
- 42:11So last week, we debuted a new segment called.
- 42:14Why the hell is he in this movie this week?
- 42:17We're debuting the new segment that I am going to call director
- 42:22Swap and Bob as you were talking about the End of this movie that
- 42:26this movie kind of inspires hope in any viewer.
- 42:30You know, I kind of talked a little bit about how like this
- 42:33is the family that like we want to be true that we want to be a
- 42:37part of and that really coalesces at the end of this
- 42:40film. It really just made me think
- 42:43about another director, really, a set of directors that are a
- 42:49little bit in a different vein of looking at the world and I'm
- 42:52just curious. Bob, if you Opt to directors and
- 42:56instead of Vincente Minnelli, what would the ending of this
- 42:59movie? Look like if it had been
- 43:01directed by the Coen Brothers by the Coen Brothers.
- 43:07Um, well, it'd be much more nihilistic.
- 43:11I don't know. I'd love to see like the No
- 43:13Country ending just just, you know, superimpose on to this
- 43:16movie where 2D actually does end up just kind of killing
- 43:20everyone. Yeah.
- 43:21In a very cold and calculated way and then just wanders off.
- 43:25Then it cuts to John Truitt and he's like, you know, I had a
- 43:29dream that that they were going to go to New York and they were
- 43:32going to live a good life and then I woke up and then that's
- 43:36the end of meet me in st. Louis, but just cut to Black the
- 43:41end. Finn.
- 43:45Oh man, this is gonna be a great segment.
- 43:47Brad director swap. I love it.
- 43:49Yeah, I'm a big fan so far. I just, I just couldn't get over
- 43:52the idea of Anton chigurh being In this movie, heads would go to
- 43:58New York, tales Mister here, call it, Judy Garland's.
- 44:02Like I need to know what I stand to lose and he's like no you
- 44:05don't call it your whole life. All right, I'm actually going to
- 44:16in the spirit of that. I'm going to resurrect a
- 44:18segment. We haven't done in a while and
- 44:20that is hot. Takes hot tea.
- 44:24Now normally hot. X is where we look on IMDb or
- 44:27Amazon Prime and we find one star reviews of the movie, we
- 44:30were reviewing that week. Brad, this is going to be the
- 44:33most unique hot takes ever because in doing research on
- 44:36this film, I found a book that was written about this movie for
- 44:39the British Film Institute. It's fantastic little book and
- 44:42there are talking about the fact that this movie had basically no
- 44:45complaints come into the studio afterwards, which is, you know
- 44:48really saying something, because people love to complain, they
- 44:50said only two complaints were received by people who had seen
- 44:54this movie. Be back in 1944.
- 44:56Wait, so what you're saying is this is a hot take from 19 1944
- 45:01where we do not excited. So one of the two complaints
- 45:05that was written into the MGM Studios was from a mr.
- 45:09AP Broadfield from Poughkeepsie, New York, and this is what he
- 45:12said, gentlemen. I witnessed the showing of your
- 45:16picture meet me in st. Louis, and enjoyed it very much.
- 45:19However, I did see a flaw in the scene in the dining room while
- 45:23having supper mr. With crunched on celery, which
- 45:26was of the Pascal variety. I do not believe that.
- 45:29Particular kind of celery was in existence in 1903.
- 45:33Thank you very much for the enjoyment of a really nice
- 45:35picture. I am very truly yours AP broad
- 45:37field, dude, that's it. This man, this man wrote a
- 45:41letter to just tell them, hey, I found it.
- 45:46Is this man would would fit right into the dce you like
- 45:50fandom like this. Dude wrote into the studio to
- 45:54say hi, I recognized the celery and it is not historically
- 45:58accurate celery. This letter is proof that
- 46:01internet trolls existed before the internet.
- 46:05You know, nothing. Nothing against mr.
- 46:07AP Broadfield. I don't know what he did in his
- 46:09day-to-day life, but the fact that the thing that has survived
- 46:12him, the longest in on Earth is a letter that he wrote just
- 46:18shown on MGM about their anachronistic.
- 46:21Use of celery is is the funniest thing I've Ever seen, dude,
- 46:26because that that's the thing that you look for in movies, man
- 46:29is like Horticultural aspects of set design and like, you know,
- 46:35choices will eat it all meant to introduce another segment that
- 46:38just called celery watch, since the bubble bubble, bubble, that
- 46:43historically, accurate celery, I don't know.
- 46:46I'm not sure this has been another episode of celery,
- 46:51watch, Brad before we get out of here today.
- 46:54I do want to talk About the song Have Yourself, a Merry Little
- 46:57Christmas and this movie does have really good songs in it.
- 46:59You know, for only having a few, the trolley song, The Judy
- 47:02Garland sings is one of the most famous musical songs and there's
- 47:06so many directions we could go, but I want to make sure we talk
- 47:09about. Have Yourself a Merry Little
- 47:10Christmas. The song was written for this
- 47:13movie. Judy Garland is the first person
- 47:15to ever sing Have Yourself. A Merry Little Christmas and I
- 47:19think that the thing people don't really realize is that
- 47:23once the song, kind of hit the ABS.
- 47:25They change the words a little bit.
- 47:27And the funny thing is, even the version that we have in this
- 47:29movie was not the original, like, the lyrics were initially
- 47:32weiwei satyr and Judy Garland was like, I am not sending this
- 47:36because initially, the something went Have Yourself a Merry
- 47:39Little Christmas, it may be your last next year we may all be
- 47:42living in the past and she said that.
- 47:45So that's the Coen Brothers. Yeah, there it is.
- 47:47It was that sausage you to God? I was like, nah, I'm not, I'm
- 47:50not saying that, but what I've really noticed is that when you
- 47:53listen to the song on the radio, Yo, now, they only made slight
- 47:56changes, but they really do change the meaning of the song.
- 47:59So, in the movie, the song goes Have Yourself a Merry Little
- 48:02Christmas, let your heart be light.
- 48:04Next year, all our troubles will be out of sight and you know if
- 48:08you've listened to on the radio, they change that to from now on
- 48:11and I really kind of hate that because I love the way that it's
- 48:14written in this movie and the closing lines of the song where,
- 48:20you know, if you're familiar with the song, it's the hang a
- 48:22shining star upon the highest bough in the V.
- 48:25It's until then we'll have to muddle through somehow and not
- 48:29only does it fit the context of the movie really well, which is
- 48:31this family, that is really sad on Christmas and trying to find
- 48:34a glimmer of hope to get them through.
- 48:37If you look at the historical context of the movie like this
- 48:40movie comes out in 1944, it's the middle of World War two.
- 48:45Most people who are married to able-bodied men.
- 48:49In America are separated from them at this point.
- 48:51Like they've been drafted into the war, they're fighting
- 48:53overseas. It's a time where people are
- 48:56going through something and Christmas Is Not What It
- 48:58normally is and I just kind of hate that.
- 49:02We took a song that I wouldn't even call it a sad song, but I
- 49:06think that there are times in life where, you know, you have
- 49:09to be okay with making the best of what you have and to have a
- 49:12Christmas song that acknowledges, like not every
- 49:15Christmas is going to be this like, idyllic Norman Rockwell
- 49:19existence and that sometimes, you know, you just have to hope
- 49:23that next year. It's ailing me now or what's
- 49:26coming up against me. Now, is going to be gone and I
- 49:29hate that we've like sanitize that and we've changed it.
- 49:32I don't know Brad, I'm sure that you noticed the lyrics being a
- 49:35little bit different in the movie than they, normally are
- 49:38what which version do you prefer?
- 49:40Or what did you think of the version in this movie?
- 49:42Well, I think that like with a lot of things that that American
- 49:47culture has taken something that points to just as simple reality
- 49:51which is this world isn't perfect.
- 49:55And we've washed it clean. Like you said, we've sanitized
- 49:58it to a feel-good black. Well, it's Christmas.
- 50:02And from now on our troubles will they'll just got now
- 50:06they're gone by and like the reality.
- 50:09Is that I think the original lyrics for the song point to one
- 50:13of the most beautiful like absolute truths about this world
- 50:17and the Human Condition which is that most problems that when we
- 50:23look at them a year down the road, They're really not that
- 50:27they're much more of a anthill than a mountain right?
- 50:31That we're at a point though where it's just easier to
- 50:35pretend like no problem is a problem from the moment it
- 50:38happens and so I don't know. I just I love the way that the
- 50:42the movie presents like yep, we're sad right now.
- 50:46We're okay with that sadness and a year from now, it'll probably
- 50:50be a little bit better and and recognizing that a year from now
- 50:54it'll be a little bit. It better isn't impeding or
- 50:57changing the fact that I'm sad right now and that's okay.
- 50:59Yeah, well and I think that's the reason that this has kind of
- 51:02entered my Christmas movie rotation every year.
- 51:05Like I don't know that I would call this a Christmas movie Just
- 51:07because it has a huge Christmas scene in it, but it is important
- 51:10that the, the emotional kind of climax of this movie happens at
- 51:14Christmas time. You have this really wonderful,
- 51:17beautiful moment where Judy Garland goes to the ball and
- 51:20everything has gotten messed up. John can't go because he doesn't
- 51:23have a tuxedo. Playing Auld Lang Syne and she's
- 51:27dancing with their grandpa and they're both crying because they
- 51:29have to move away. And he sees John, enter, from
- 51:31across the room and Spins her kind of behind this tree.
- 51:34And when they come out from behind the Christmas tree, it's
- 51:36her and John, and it's just such a touching, beautiful moment
- 51:40that leads right into, like you said going home and having to
- 51:43comfort 2D, who is like in hysterics about having to move
- 51:46to New York and she goes outside and destroys all these snowman
- 51:51and she's breaking down and you finally see the dad have his
- 51:53realization. This is not what I want for my
- 51:56family and it does resolve in this really beautiful kind of
- 51:59reconciliation where everybody truly understands like the
- 52:03meaning of Christmas and it wouldn't work if you didn't have
- 52:07like the Spectre or the idea of the sad part of Christmas
- 52:11hanging over the whole thing. And like you said, Brad, it
- 52:14really does just demonstrate. If, if you want to appreciate
- 52:18what you have, like you have to acknowledge both the good and
- 52:21the bad. And I think that is why this
- 52:23movie works. Well for me because it doesn't
- 52:27shy away from the hard stuff that family families, go through
- 52:30and yet when the happy ending comes at the end of the movie,
- 52:33it doesn't just feel like attacked on Hollywood ending.
- 52:36It feels like a family that you have watched really go through
- 52:39some stuff. Come out the other side stronger
- 52:42and you know, I'm going to use my final moments in this episode
- 52:45to do Bob. I am going to disparage another
- 52:49movie. We watched because of how much
- 52:51better this movie it will please Mary.
- 52:54E Poppins is a terrible movie and when you look at Mary
- 53:01Poppins in light of meet me in st.
- 53:04Louis, I think you understand why?
- 53:07Because like, when you look at Mary Poppins, it feels like
- 53:10they're trying to create this family with these young children
- 53:13who are imaginative and inventive and and this, you know
- 53:16magical Nanny that takes them on adventures.
- 53:19But in the end, there's not a single thing about their family
- 53:22that like Rings. True Whereas like this story
- 53:27just has such a beautiful heart at the center of it that you
- 53:33can't help but fall in love with the family that every single
- 53:36character is quirky and unique and fun and interesting.
- 53:40And the way that they interact with one another, the emotions
- 53:43they draw out of each other. It just really makes for a
- 53:46beautiful movie and Mary Poppins just misses on all of those
- 53:50fronts, you know? And it's really funny.
- 53:52You bring that up though because I definitely wrote down that the
- 53:54dad and this He was giving off major mr.
- 53:57Banks phibes. Like it's the same day, you
- 53:59know, he's not dumb. He's just not observant to
- 54:01what's going on around him and I really do.
- 54:04I agree with you Brad. I think this movie is superior.
- 54:07I'm just going to go ahead and give my 10/10.
- 54:09Now, this is one of my favorite movies ever.
- 54:11It's my favorite of the MGM musicals.
- 54:14And I think when, when people hear that, you know, like I said
- 54:17before, you think about this thing in the reins of the world,
- 54:20this movie just means more to me than that.
- 54:22And I think it gets at something way deeper than that.
- 54:25And and that's why I cherish it so much for me.
- 54:28It's a 10 out of 10. I want to hear what you think
- 54:30though, Brad. Bob, I'm pretty close to you.
- 54:33I think it's a 9 out of 10 for me.
- 54:35I think it's just charming and pleasant, and fun, and
- 54:39nostalgic, and it hits you with all the fields.
- 54:43It's not a perfect musical for me.
- 54:45I really, really do love it. I think I'm going to kind of end
- 54:49with a little bit of a Bittersweet note that I'm not
- 54:53sure what it is. About content that survives the
- 54:58test of time. Like when you look at music they
- 55:01like there's there has been so much music produced out there
- 55:04and yet still 40 years later, we're listening to The Beatles
- 55:08and the stones. And so many other bands have
- 55:10just Fallen by the wayside. And I hate to say it.
- 55:13Bob, as much as I genuinely love this movie, I just have a
- 55:17feeling that, like, 40 or 50 years from now, almost.
- 55:20Nobody will have remembered meet me in st.
- 55:23Louis. Yeah.
- 55:24And that does make me sad. And I think that, you know, I am
- 55:27trying to be part of the vocal minority, because I think that
- 55:29people who have seen this movie like advocate for it very
- 55:33strongly, I wish that it cracks the afi's top 100 but you're
- 55:36right. Brad, it's not as big and
- 55:38splashy and kind of like instant gratification as Singing in the
- 55:42Rain is. But to me, it's the superior
- 55:44film and I would love to see somebody listen to this podcast
- 55:49and decide to go watch this movie as a result.
- 55:51I don't think you'll be disappointed.
- 55:53We are coming out to a nine and a half. 5 out of 10 on average,
- 55:57but we want to know what you think.
- 55:58If you've seen Meet Me In St. Louis if you're inspired to see
- 56:01it by our podcast, let us know you can find us on social media
- 56:05on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram at film whiskey, or
- 56:08you can give us a phone call. Let your voice be heard to talk
- 56:12about meet me in st. Louis, you can leave a voicemail
- 56:15by going to our website, which is anchored on FM / film whiskey
- 56:20next week. We'll be back talking about
- 56:22another surprisingly, sweet movie Cameron Crowe, Rose 2000,
- 56:26comedy, Almost Famous. We'll see you next week for that
- 56:29until then I'm Bob book. I'm Reggie and we'll see you
- 56:32next time.