Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Law & Order(s): Best Practices for Drafting, Formatting, and Getting Your Orders Entered in Bankruptcy Court with Hon. Sheri Bluebond, J. Scott Bovitz
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, everyone. Good afternoon. Welcome
- 0:06to Law and Orders, Best Practices for Drafting,
- 0:10Formatting, and Getting Your Orders Entered in
- 0:12Bankruptcy Court. I'm Alla Policastro, CLE advisor
- 0:15for the Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today
- 0:17I am delighted to introduce our speakers, Judge
- 0:20Sherry Blubond and Jay Scott -Bovitz. Judge Blue
- 0:24Bond was appointed to the bench in 2001 as a
- 0:27federal bankruptcy court judge for the United
- 0:29States Bankruptcy Court, Central District of
- 0:31California. Prior to taking the bench, she was
- 0:34a partner in the law firm of Irel Manila, where
- 0:37she co -chaired the creditors rights and insolvency
- 0:39groups specializing in bankruptcy debtor creditor
- 0:42relations and business litigation. She's a graduate
- 0:45of UCLA Law School, where she earned numerous
- 0:47American jurisprudence awards and graduated first
- 0:50in her class. Judge Blue Bond is a fellow of
- 0:53the American Bankruptcy College and a member
- 0:55of the American Bankruptcy Institute. At various
- 0:58times, she has served in leadership roles in
- 1:00a multitude of professional and philanthropic
- 1:03organizations focused on bankruptcy and finance
- 1:06on the one hand and child welfare on the other.
- 1:09And our next speaker, J. Scott Bovitz, is a certified
- 1:12bankruptcy law specialist and partner at Bovitz
- 1:15and Spitzer. Mr. Bovitz has dedicated 45 years
- 1:19of his career to federal practice in bankruptcy
- 1:21court. In that time, Mr. Bovitz has been selected
- 1:24as a Southern California super lawyer in bankruptcy
- 1:27and creditor debtor rights every year since the
- 1:30program arrived in California. He is a prolific
- 1:34author and speaker on topics related to his bankruptcy
- 1:37expertise, frequently being sought to share his
- 1:40insights at bar associations, conferences, and
- 1:42law schools across the country. Mr. Boves has
- 1:45also served as an adjunct professor at multiple
- 1:48law schools, and is one of the most sought after
- 1:51bankruptcy mediators through the United States
- 1:54Bankruptcy Courts Mediation Program. We cannot
- 1:57wait to hear what they have to share with us
- 1:59today. And now I'm turning it over to them. How
- 2:02much? Rin, could we have slide three? Judge,
- 2:08I'm going to talk about this rebus in a second.
- 2:10We can let people look at it. But I'm not sure
- 2:13that you know, but for a long time, I was a few
- 2:16floors below you when I was at Shea and Gould.
- 2:19And we both were right across from the mall there
- 2:23in Century City. So we have kind of parallel
- 2:25paths on this. But the thing that I I'm always
- 2:30most impressed about is that you are a creative
- 2:33person somehow you've got fell into the law instead
- 2:35of painting or something and You would occasionally
- 2:39as a game host Recurring game host for the calibrated
- 2:42bankruptcy forum You would require people to
- 2:45do puzzles and do other things to win prizes.
- 2:47So what is this? Well Actually, let me just clarify
- 2:52that statement a little bit. We have contestants
- 2:55compete to win a game, but then the answer to
- 3:01each game would have been related to the topic
- 3:04that a judge would discuss, a case that a judge
- 3:07would be discussing. So it's always an educational
- 3:09game show. And frankly, there were prizes, but
- 3:11generally everybody got the same prize just for
- 3:13playing, participation prizes. So hopefully now
- 3:16that you've all had a chance to look at this
- 3:18on the screen, you've figured out what this common
- 3:20bankruptcy phrase is that I've illustrated this
- 3:23way, but I'm going to give it away for those
- 3:25of you who haven't. It's violin less in, so that's
- 3:29viola, lay, and that's a bun. But you're changing
- 3:33the B to SH, so shun, viola, shun. And then in
- 3:37Latin, eggs are ova, so. violation ova and that's
- 3:40a dish and a charge so violation of a discharge
- 3:44and then ink minus the k is in skunk where you
- 3:48change the sk to j in junk Junk and then that's
- 3:52a none but the none is SH so that's injunction
- 3:55so violation of a discharge injunction I have
- 3:58to say this was a very hard game the panelists
- 4:01would have to answer to match to turn over squares
- 4:04and then they'd see part of the puzzle and I'm
- 4:06not sure but perhaps once they saw the entire
- 4:08puzzle they still had no idea what it meant so
- 4:10that might have been a little bit too hard but
- 4:12but you've been very flattering to me Scott what
- 4:14you haven't mentioned is Well, you're very artistic
- 4:16in your own right. You have a Bovitz dot com.
- 4:19You have what about 700 songs that you have composed?
- 4:23Seven hundred and seventy one. OK, well, there
- 4:25you go. In all different genres that can be licensed
- 4:28in some instances for no cost to be used as background
- 4:31material for your various different video performances
- 4:34and anything else. The American Bar Association.
- 4:38The American Bar Association uses the background
- 4:41music, one of my songs, in the Bad Boys of Bankruptcy
- 4:44podcast, which kind of thing. Rhian, could you
- 4:47bring up slide five? Before we leave that, one
- 4:50other thing. I'm not sure you mentioned that
- 4:51Scott Boves is also a fellow of the American
- 4:53College of Bankruptcy. Anyway, thank you. Next
- 4:56slide. The way this program came about is every
- 4:59time I'm in Judge Blubon's court, she's instructing
- 5:03us on some aspect of procedure or practice. And
- 5:06the one area where we seem to muck it up, the
- 5:09blocking and tackling that we just don't do a
- 5:12good job is in preparing orders for the court.
- 5:17So I was thinking, Judge, you know, is it really
- 5:21a bigger problem? You know, what, do you have
- 5:23a couple of draft orders a day so you spend 15
- 5:26minutes, no big deal? Is that the way it works?
- 5:30Rene, you can drop that slide. Yeah, not quite.
- 5:33There's actually several steps. Several people
- 5:35along the way can be annoyed by an order that
- 5:37doesn't work right. There's three different people
- 5:39that touch orders when they come to us. And I'm
- 5:42assuming you're doing this through the lodged
- 5:43order upload program, our loop program. If you're
- 5:46lodging hard copy at the filing window, that's
- 5:49the old fashioned way. And then we've got to
- 5:50deal with, you know, marking it up and scanning
- 5:53it and everything else. Hold on a second. Hold
- 5:55on a second. We could send in a draft order to
- 5:59the clerk who would do something with it, we
- 6:02don't know. You're gonna explain that. Or we
- 6:04have an electronic system, LUE, because everything
- 6:07in the government has abbreviations, right? LOU,
- 6:11where we do something. We're gonna go into those
- 6:12details, but go ahead. Yeah, so when an order
- 6:15comes in through LUE, my courtroom deputy looks
- 6:17at it, and she'll kick it if it's messed up in
- 6:20certain ways that we'll talk about later. my
- 6:24law clerk will then review it to make sure that
- 6:26substantively it's okay. And then I look at it.
- 6:29And so I don't even know all the ways, although
- 6:31we're gonna talk about it and I've found out
- 6:33some of the ways that you can annoy the two of
- 6:35them. But when I get the order, I'm actually
- 6:39sitting at the computer and fixing the things
- 6:41that don't work for me. So yeah, I don't just
- 6:44get one or two orders a day. I get somewhere
- 6:46between... you know, 8, 10, 12, whatever orders
- 6:49a day. And some of them are more annoying than
- 6:52others. And we're going to talk about the things
- 6:53that you can do to keep from annoying the judge.
- 6:56Because last thing you want to do is have a judge
- 6:59cursing under their breath at you based on the
- 7:01way you've lodged what could have been or should
- 7:03have been a very simple order. But instead, you've
- 7:06turned it into something that makes me gale.
- 7:09So yes, we're going to try to help you avoid
- 7:11that. Please mark that moment. That's the first
- 7:14time that you've seen a judge actually do the
- 7:16lion's roar there So one of the ways that the
- 7:22Central District of California has done something
- 7:24that that other courts mock us for is we have
- 7:28standardized forms for the most common motions
- 7:31and orders and these are available in the Central
- 7:34District of California website right central
- 7:36the bankruptcy court not the district court and
- 7:39We got a boatload and we've got different search.
- 7:42Sometimes you have to search three different
- 7:43places to find it. I don't know why that is,
- 7:45but you do. And so you put in the magic word
- 7:48and you eventually come up with a form of an
- 7:51order. Judge, if there's a standard form of order
- 7:54that's on the website, are we supposed to use
- 7:57that rather than some custom Bovitz version that
- 8:00has lots of good stuff in it? Well, all of our
- 8:03forms, not just the orders, but all the forms
- 8:05will say in the footer whether they're mandatory,
- 8:08or not. And if it doesn't say mandatory, you
- 8:10don't have to use that form, but it's certainly
- 8:13a good idea to look at the form and make sure
- 8:15that if you do the Bobitz version, that you've
- 8:17included everything that we wanted in there.
- 8:19Otherwise, the judge is going to have to add
- 8:21that. And if it says mandatory, it means mandatory.
- 8:24And we'll bounce it or deny it, or it won't get
- 8:27entered. If it's supposed to be mandatory, you
- 8:29don't use it. So for example, our orders on motions
- 8:33for relief from stay. Those are mandatory form
- 8:35orders. Now we've started doing, my chambers
- 8:38happens to do our own orders on motions for relief
- 8:40from stay, just because it was back during the
- 8:42subprime meltdown, we were doing 80 stay motions
- 8:45on Tuesday and 80 stay motions on Wednesday.
- 8:47And believe it or not, the time that it took
- 8:49to prepare the orders ourselves was less time
- 8:52than it took to chase 160 lawyers to get all
- 8:56of the orders lodged. OK, so we're going to talk
- 8:59about the time period. We have a window, hopefully
- 9:02within seven days, and you tell us. And we're
- 9:05going to talk about who does the order and all
- 9:07those things, those details. Sometimes, though,
- 9:09we get confused between orders and judgments.
- 9:11Marin, would you bring up slide six, please,
- 9:14the next slide, after the wizard? Okay, a judgment
- 9:19is entered what in an adversary proceeding and
- 9:22an order is entered in a contested matter or
- 9:25something else. Is that how it works judge? Basically,
- 9:27you're not going to see a judgment and something
- 9:30called judgment unless it's in an adversary proceeding.
- 9:33But if you're in an adversary proceeding the
- 9:35judgment is the thing that happens at the end
- 9:37unless you have you might have a partial judgment.
- 9:39You might have a partial summary adjudication.
- 9:41So you might have something that has the word
- 9:43judgment in it. But generally in an adversary
- 9:45the judgments at the end. But don't forget you
- 9:48can have motions in the context of an adversary.
- 9:50A motion in limiting. Motion in limiting or a
- 9:53motion for leave to amend or a discovery motion
- 9:55or you know so there will be or can be an order
- 9:59on that motion. So there can be orders. Orders
- 10:02show up in both contested matters and adversary
- 10:04proceedings. Judgments only show up in adversary
- 10:07proceedings. Sometimes you have a very special
- 10:11kind of order that we're going to mention in
- 10:13passing later. a pretrial order or maybe in some
- 10:17judges, it's pretrial stipulation with an order
- 10:20on that. I don't know. It's confusing to me.
- 10:22Should I be doing a proposed pretrial order in
- 10:26your courtroom? Yeah, this is very judge specific.
- 10:30As you just said, there's two different procedures
- 10:32described in our local rule. I think it's 7016
- 10:35-1. Either you do a pretrial stipulation with
- 10:39an order saying it's so approved or you upload
- 10:42the order itself. I'm one of those judges that
- 10:45wants the order uploaded itself. And the reason
- 10:47for that is that the pre -trial order, I'm not
- 10:50just talking about a scheduling order, the pre
- 10:52-trial order that we require in every adversary
- 10:54proceeding, or at least I require in every adversary
- 10:57proceeding, most of us do, 7016 tells you what
- 11:01has to go in there. But it's basically a list
- 11:03of everything you agree on and everything you
- 11:05disagree on. He's a chump. He won't agree on
- 11:07anything, Judge. Why am I going through this?
- 11:10to try to narrow the issues so that I know what
- 11:12I'm actually trying, have to try, have to do
- 11:15at trial. If you guys can't agree on it, that's
- 11:19one of the things we'd be talking about at the
- 11:20pre -trial conference. But two weeks before,
- 11:22and I've even sent parties to mediation to try
- 11:25to figure out what goes in the pre -trial order,
- 11:27because they were that. Hopeless. But generally,
- 11:30it's everything you agree on goes on the list
- 11:32of the things you agree on. If it's the stuff
- 11:33that you don't agree on, it goes on the list
- 11:35of the stuff you don't agree on. And the reason
- 11:37I want it uploaded instead of just file is because
- 11:40I want to be able to use the benefit of the fact
- 11:43that orders get uploaded in our loop program
- 11:46in Word so that I can modify the text. So when
- 11:49the issue of when the bankruptcy was filed shows
- 11:53up on the disputed list and I say to the parties
- 11:55at the pre -trial conference, huh? How can this
- 11:59be in dispute? It's a knowable fact. I can make
- 12:03a change. I can actually fix it. I've been there
- 12:06when you've done this. Fix it, yeah. If it's
- 12:08hopeless, I send them back to the drawing board,
- 12:10give them a new deadline. But if it's just a
- 12:11little tweak here and there, I can fix it myself.
- 12:14Okay, so we're coming in from the 10 ,000 foot
- 12:17view and we took a little side trip into the
- 12:19pre -trial thing. Rhian, could I have slide seven,
- 12:22please? Marina is our really super helpful Beverly
- 12:25Hills Bar Association person and we're so grateful
- 12:28for her. Judge, there's this central guide of
- 12:34some kind. The central guide is, it's not the
- 12:36local bankruptcy rules, it's not the federal
- 12:39rules of bankruptcy procedure, it's not the federal
- 12:42rules of civil procedure, but there's a central
- 12:45guide which we've quoted from extensively in
- 12:47our slides. What is that? Well, it's kind of
- 12:50the how. The local rules are the what you're
- 12:53supposed to do. The central guide is kind of
- 12:56the how you're supposed to do it. And the thinking
- 12:59that went into that division is that they've
- 13:02made it a little bit easier for us to do. But
- 13:04our local rules, changes to our local rules,
- 13:07technically have to be approved by the district
- 13:08court. So we don't do that every two weeks. That's
- 13:11maybe once a year, we go through that exercise.
- 13:14And it requires not only our rules committee,
- 13:17but their rules committee, their executive committee.
- 13:19So it's a big to do. We don't like to change
- 13:21that regularly. So if, for example, the US trustee
- 13:24moves and decides that you need to send their
- 13:26copies to a different address, we don't want
- 13:29to have to modify our local rules for that. So
- 13:31anything that's sort of like how, where, how
- 13:34many copies, just little more detailed stuff,
- 13:37We put in the central guide because we can change
- 13:39that whenever we want to. We don't need to get
- 13:41approval from the district court to deal with
- 13:43that. It's the mechanics, if you will. This is
- 13:47quite a change from when I started and when you
- 13:51started, where the court says, hey, we don't
- 13:54practice law. You go take care of that. We'll
- 13:56either bump it or we won't. And by doing this,
- 14:00the benefit to the court is you don't waste your
- 14:02time on as much stuff. Because if somebody will
- 14:05go onto the central district site, we'll read
- 14:08the page on the central guide about the 10 steps
- 14:11that have to happen for whatever, then it makes
- 14:14your life easier, your clerk's life easier, and
- 14:18maybe it helps the system move along. And I find
- 14:21it to be fantastic. The bankruptcy appellate
- 14:24panel in the Ninth Circuit has a kind of to -do
- 14:27thing. It's primarily authored by Susan Sprawl,
- 14:30who's the clerk of the court with the assistance
- 14:32of the various staff attorneys over there. And
- 14:35it's similar, but it's sort of a long chat. The
- 14:38central guide is discreet. So you could say,
- 14:41for example, Rin, let's bring up slide seven.
- 14:46You could have a question. I could say, who prepares
- 14:50the judgment or the order? And by gosh, on the
- 14:53central guide, it says, the order judgment may
- 14:56be prepared by the court, which is, judge, you'll
- 14:59tell them if you're going to do the order, right?
- 15:02We always discuss at the end of the hearing who's
- 15:04doing the order. I'll either say the court will
- 15:05prepare the order or I'll say so and so you'll
- 15:08prepare it. Or like yesterday at a hearing I
- 15:10said, can I get a volunteer? Who will do the
- 15:12order? And when we have an order that we want
- 15:16you to look at, we're not filing it. We're uploading
- 15:20it through the LOU system. It's called lodging,
- 15:23right? That's the magic word in connection with
- 15:26that. And when you have edited my beautiful draft
- 15:30order that somehow, I don't know, you didn't
- 15:32like it the way it is, does it always say on
- 15:34the front page, changes made by the court, some
- 15:38crazy stamp, or do you just say whatever and
- 15:40enter it? It doesn't always say that. It may
- 15:44say that if there's something I want to bring
- 15:46your attention to. Maybe the changes will even
- 15:50be in bold or underlined if it's something I
- 15:52really want to bring your attention to. But can
- 15:54we not gloss over something you just said a minute
- 15:55ago? Because this is something I encounter a
- 15:57lot, which is - Yes, I would like to not gloss
- 16:00over - And lodging. I've got it later in my notes,
- 16:02but I'm happy to do it now. When you just use
- 16:05CMACF and file something, it ends up on the docket.
- 16:11I don't spend all my day reading through my dockets
- 16:13to see if there's anything there. But if you
- 16:16want the judge to look at an order and sign an
- 16:19order and get it entered, you need to lodge it,
- 16:22which is our new lodged order upload program.
- 16:25Or please don't do this, but you can hard copy
- 16:27at the counter. Now, if we have this procedure
- 16:32called the notice of lodgement, and I know I'm
- 16:33getting ahead of myself a little bit here, and
- 16:35we'll see one later, but the notice of lodgement
- 16:38gets filed and it tells the parties that you
- 16:42have lodged the order, but it isn't the lodging
- 16:45of the order. You still have to lodge the order.
- 16:48In fact, if you file a notice of lodgement and
- 16:50then don't lodge the order, you're lying. But
- 16:53the benefit of that is you can use our automatic
- 16:56electronic service to send a copy of the proposed
- 16:59form of order to the other parties. That's how
- 17:02the parties know that you're asking me to sign
- 17:04an order that looks like that. And we have preserved
- 17:07for the record what it was you asked for so that
- 17:10if anybody ever wants to see what changes I made
- 17:12compared to the what you filed, you've got both
- 17:15documents will exist there. And in terms of,
- 17:18you know, there is a box I can check when I'm
- 17:20approving it. that will put a little box in the
- 17:22upper right hand corner that says changes made
- 17:24by the court. If I'm making just formatting changes,
- 17:27little, nothing, somethings or others, I won't
- 17:29check that box. If I've changed a continued hearing
- 17:32date from the one you asked for, I'm going to
- 17:34definitely check that date with the hope that
- 17:36you'll notice. I might even put the date in bold.
- 17:38Or if I've deleted something I think you really
- 17:40wanted and I didn't like it, I'm probably going
- 17:43to check that box. But if it's something that's
- 17:45no biggie, I probably won't. So I hope we have
- 17:49some. young lawyers who don't do this all the
- 17:51time, as well as some grizzled veterans. But
- 17:54with respect to the young lawyers, it's very
- 17:56confusing when you start out, hey, Pacer, what's
- 17:58that? You get to look at a docket. You get to
- 18:01pull a document down and pay for it. And then
- 18:04you've got CMECF, which is some sort of magic
- 18:08thing where I'm designated to be a clerk of the
- 18:11court for just that moment to be able to actually
- 18:14upload something into the electronic file. And
- 18:17it shows up on the docket. unless some clerk
- 18:20in quality control decides that I'm a buffoon
- 18:23and I did something in the wrong case, in which
- 18:25case it might disappear. And then a whole separate
- 18:28process for orders, LOU, which is putting up
- 18:33a Word document for you to edit. And if we're
- 18:36really lucky, you edit it and then you authorize
- 18:40below my number signs that are at the bottom,
- 18:43which we'll talk about, you're going to authorize
- 18:45it to be entered. Then I never, I don't do that.
- 18:48It gets entered by the clerk over there. Your
- 18:52team enters it. Now it shows up on the docket
- 18:55so somebody in Virginia can go to PACER and see
- 18:59that an order was entered. So we know there's
- 19:02a motion. There's a hearing date yesterday. You
- 19:05may or may not put something on the docket to
- 19:07remind yourself that you granted the motion or
- 19:09you denied the motion or you set a new date.
- 19:12Sometimes that's there a lot and that's very
- 19:14helpful. We call those hearing helds. They'll
- 19:18be a docket. Some judges put more than that.
- 19:22Judge Clarkson, for example, will essentially
- 19:26put a minute order in there, but that's not the
- 19:28order. That's just an entry on the docket. So
- 19:31it's a little confusing. Rhian, could you bring
- 19:33up slide eight, please? By the way, this is an
- 19:36eight -hour program. I hope everybody knows that.
- 19:38At this rate, it will be. No, we're covering
- 19:41a lot of stuff later, so we'll be able to do
- 19:43that. OK. So we had talked about on slide eight,
- 19:48your proposed pretrial order and adversary proceedings,
- 19:52sometimes in contested matters where you're treating
- 19:54them like an adversary proceeding, which you
- 19:56can, maybe a complicated homestead case or something,
- 20:00you're going to require a set of stipulated facts
- 20:03and disputed facts that will guide you, Judge,
- 20:06during your trial, right? And so the question
- 20:09you ask that you, when we were preparing for
- 20:11this, is that fact really at issue, Counselor?
- 20:14And, you know, you give that look, and of course,
- 20:17Counselor says, no, no, no, I guess we really
- 20:18don't debate when the petition was filed. And
- 20:22it goes to the, you know, to the stipulated facts
- 20:25in this. Now, if I'm going to have a pretrial
- 20:28order, that's one of two times that we would
- 20:33like to upload it before the pretrial conference.
- 20:37Right, Judge? And then there's the other one
- 20:39about first days. Would you talk about that?
- 20:41First days you want me to talk about? No, talk
- 20:43about why do we do that? We do it because you
- 20:45can edit them, right? Go ahead. And I have a
- 20:48chance to read it, too, ahead of time, too. As
- 20:50opposed to a pretrial order, again, the concept
- 20:53is we're trying to figure out what the dispute
- 20:55is really about, as opposed to another kind of
- 20:58order where I'm memorializing what I actually
- 21:01did at the hearing. That's something that we
- 21:03don't really know what I did until after the
- 21:05hearing, for the most part. We're about to get
- 21:07to special case number two. But for special case
- 21:10number one, I want to see the pre -trial beforehand
- 21:13because I want to see if I understand what you're
- 21:15saying, what the dispute's about, and whether
- 21:17you've covered really what is at issue. And sometimes
- 21:20I'll read an issue and say, What do you, you
- 21:23know, they have the disputed issue of fact is
- 21:26whether, you know, defendant defrauded plaintiff
- 21:28by saying X on such and such a date. Okay, but
- 21:31what's the issue? Is it whether he actually said
- 21:34it or not? Whether he said it on that date or
- 21:37whether it was true or not? So I'm gonna wanna
- 21:39read through it and figure out the questions
- 21:41that I have for the practitioners. to in order
- 21:45to make the pretrial order actually say what
- 21:47it needs to say. So I need to see it before the
- 21:49hearing so I can prepare for the hearing. The
- 21:50other one was first day orders and first day
- 21:53orders. We're talking about a collection of motions
- 21:55that are commonly filed in the beginning of a
- 21:58Chapter 11 case, maybe especially an operating
- 22:00case. There's a lot of stuff that needs to be
- 22:02done right away. Permission to use cash collateral.
- 22:06You got lettuce rotting on the dock. You got
- 22:09employees who need to be paid. And so, Judge,
- 22:12you're saying with respect to that, Okay, please
- 22:14show me the proposed orders. Does that mean we
- 22:17file them as proposed orders on CMECF? Does that
- 22:21mean we LOU them up to you? It's kind of up to
- 22:25you in the sense that the faster you want it,
- 22:28the more likely, you know, it's a good idea to
- 22:30have uploaded it. You for sure want, if you want
- 22:32me to enter something right at the hearing. It
- 22:35needs to have been uploaded for me to approve
- 22:37it then and there. And you need to have sent
- 22:39it to the other side. You could be, if you're
- 22:40physically in court instead of on Zoom, you could
- 22:42hand out copies before the hearing if they're
- 22:44there. You could have emailed them to parties
- 22:46ahead of time. But if you want something entered
- 22:48at the hearing, you got to make sure, one, that
- 22:50everybody's seen it, and number two, that it's
- 22:53available for me to act on. I don't really care.
- 22:56I mean, you're the one who needs to pay your
- 22:58employees and you're the one who needs to, you
- 23:00know, what. So if I'm happy to say lodge the
- 23:02order after the hearing, but if you want me to
- 23:04act on it immediately, then it's going to need
- 23:07to be there. But I won't let you in on a little
- 23:09secret. Well, maybe you're going to say something,
- 23:12Scott. I was going to say, wow, I can get you
- 23:14to sign an order on the bench. That's really
- 23:17important. if there's a reason for us to do it.
- 23:21And yeah, if it's on the other hand, if it's
- 23:23just you're doing that all the time, I might
- 23:24find that annoying. Once upon a time, we used
- 23:26to talk about, remember walking through an order
- 23:29when it was really urgent? There is no such thing
- 23:31anymore because there's nowhere for you to walk.
- 23:33You could, if there's something that you wanted
- 23:35to do a walkthrough for and it's that urgent,
- 23:38I could approve it and then you can wait on the
- 23:4010th floor and they can get it entered and print
- 23:43you a copy. But I guess that's the closest thing
- 23:46to walking through an order. But the secret I
- 23:49was going to let you in on is one of the reasons,
- 23:52and this may not be the only, but there's two
- 23:54reasons that we probably, other than these special
- 23:57cases, don't want you uploading the orders ahead
- 24:00of the hearing. One is we literally have a queue
- 24:03of all the orders that have been uploaded. And
- 24:06the longer it gets, the harder it is to find
- 24:08the one we need to find. So we don't need extra
- 24:10orders in there that aren't what we actually
- 24:12ordered. So I may deny your motion. I don't need
- 24:15your order granting the motion sitting in my
- 24:18queue. It just means somebody is going to have
- 24:19to look at it, look back, see what I actually
- 24:21did, and tell me to delete that order. So it
- 24:24clogs the queue. The other reason that some judges,
- 24:27I personally don't care, but some judges may
- 24:29not want you blogging it, uploading it ahead
- 24:32of time. They keep statistics and we look at
- 24:35our own statistics on how many days from the
- 24:38time an order is uploaded till it's reviewed
- 24:40or checked in by the by the court and deputy,
- 24:43reviewed by the law clerk, and then approved
- 24:45by me and entered. And we keep track of judge
- 24:49average, division average, district average.
- 24:52Some judges are very competitive. You upload
- 24:54that order early, I'm not going to sign it. And
- 24:56it's going to screw up my statistics. It's going
- 24:59to mess up my averages by having an order that's
- 25:01there for 21 days instead of the ones that are
- 25:04there for a day or two. Because we turn those
- 25:06orders around if they're ready to be entered.
- 25:09So we'd rather have an average of 1 .42 days
- 25:12than an average of 10 days. And nobody's looking
- 25:16over our shoulder, really. It's all internally
- 25:18the competitiveness. But some people care about
- 25:22that. You know, in the olden days, going way
- 25:25back into the 80s, every now and then an order
- 25:27would get uploaded and it'd get signed. Sometimes
- 25:30you'd have a grant and a deny order issued in
- 25:33the same case because it was a mess. And it's
- 25:37not because judges or clerks were incompetent.
- 25:39It's just the bunch of law. Let's look at slide
- 25:43nine, Wren. Judge, there's something else called
- 25:47findings of fact and conclusions of law. I sometimes
- 25:51I see an order or a proposed order that has not
- 25:55only motion granted, but it has a bunch of other
- 25:58stuff in it. Is that the way to do it? Well,
- 26:03it's not the best way to do it. Frankly, I draft
- 26:06my own orders that way sometimes. But you are
- 26:10supposed to make findings. Findings of fact and
- 26:13conclusions of law. They can be done orally.
- 26:15And the easy way to do it is to have the order
- 26:18say, for the reason set forth on the record at
- 26:21the time of appearing, it's hereby ordered as
- 26:24follows. I mean, that's the easy way to do it.
- 26:26Now, if I know that the matter is likely to be
- 26:29appealed, I don't want to make sure that it's
- 26:32convenient for the district court of the bankruptcy
- 26:34appellate panel to know why I did what I did.
- 26:37I may want to do findings. It's better for them
- 26:40to be in a separate document. And we generally
- 26:44do that after a trial. There'll be findings,
- 26:46the fact, and conclusions of law, and then the
- 26:48judgment or the memorandum. Or we often will
- 26:51do that at confirmation, findings, the fact,
- 26:53and conclusions of law in one document, confirmation
- 26:55order in another. And that's actually the better
- 26:58way to do it. Because let's see, I made a note
- 27:01of the section here. FRCP rules 52 and 58. the
- 27:06judgment may not be considered effective and
- 27:10the appeals period may not start to run if you
- 27:13have combined them and until there's like a drop
- 27:17dead date of 150 days so there you it doesn't
- 27:21invalidate the order the order is still good
- 27:23but there is an argument that you have given
- 27:26the opposing side who lost maybe up to 150 days
- 27:30to appeal if you don't put them in separate documents.
- 27:33That's for the grizzled veterans who found themselves
- 27:36stuck in this program. They just want to hear
- 27:37your tips to connect with that. Rene, would you
- 27:40bring up slide 11, please? I'm just going to
- 27:43skip a slide, go to slide 11. Okay. This, you
- 27:46know, the federal rules of civil procedure apply
- 27:48most of the time and mostly through the federal
- 27:51rules of bankruptcy procedure, right? And here's
- 27:54one that applies 52A3 that says, hey, You, Judge,
- 27:59are not required to state findings or conclusions
- 28:01when ruling on a motion unless the rules provide
- 28:04otherwise somewhere or any other motion. So this
- 28:07is different than an adversary proceeding trial
- 28:10for non -dischargeability or fraudulent transfer
- 28:13where you're going to enter a judgment and you're
- 28:15going to make some findings and conclusions on
- 28:17the record or otherwise. But do you do findings
- 28:20and conclusions? I think the answer is yes, because
- 28:23when you come out with your tentative ruling,
- 28:25you're telling us where you're going to go and
- 28:27ultimately what you do. Go ahead. Yeah, I was
- 28:29going to say there is a judge who is now retired
- 28:32who I never appeared in front of this judge.
- 28:34But rumor has it that he would listen very politely
- 28:37to all of your argument and then say motion granted,
- 28:40motion denied and just leave the bench. I would
- 28:42never do that. First of all, I don't want the
- 28:45parties being confused, and I have this fantasy
- 28:48that if I present my reasoning well enough that
- 28:51it reduces the likelihood that the losing party
- 28:53will appeal. But it also gives the appellate
- 28:56court no idea whatsoever why you did what you
- 28:59did. And now it's true that the appellate court
- 29:01can sustain the ruling on any ground, even if
- 29:04it's not the ground you used. But what if they
- 29:06don't think of the ground you used? And you are
- 29:08actually right, but it didn't occur to them.
- 29:10So I always explain the findings that I'm making
- 29:13and the conclusions that I'm making, or why I
- 29:15don't need any findings, because this is all
- 29:17a matter of law. I want the parties to know why
- 29:20I did what I did, and I want the appellate court
- 29:22to know why I did what I did. to preserve that
- 29:27information and have it. In fact, Judge, this
- 29:29sort of goes to the drafting of the order. Okay,
- 29:32maybe you don't have all the findings of fact
- 29:34and conclusions of law in it, but when you are
- 29:37going back to review and analyze or interpret
- 29:40your order or something else, you want to make
- 29:42sure you can pick up the order and understand
- 29:44what you did, right? That's your personal preference.
- 29:47So if the order simply says, motion docket number
- 29:5011, you know, granted, that doesn't tell you
- 29:54anything. You got to go back and read something
- 29:56else. You want more precision in the order and
- 29:59maybe a little bit of the why. Am I right on
- 30:02that? Not really. No, I mean, I have preserved.
- 30:07I not only have the tentative ruling that lives
- 30:09forever in the system, it won't live on the record
- 30:13unless I read it into the record or attach it
- 30:16to an order, but it lives on so that I can find
- 30:20it in our systems. Of course, I guess I should
- 30:22break the news that at some point in the next
- 30:23couple of years, there'll be a new, instead of
- 30:26CME -CF, there's going to be a new CMM. Yeah.
- 30:29And who knows? And then we're going to have to
- 30:31change our calendaring system and we will have
- 30:33an uploader, a lodged order upload program too,
- 30:36but maybe I won't have the historical tentatives.
- 30:39I don't know, but what I will have every time
- 30:41I have, I still like paper. So as I'm having
- 30:44hearings, I take notes and I note what I did
- 30:47and it's on a copy of the tentative ruling and
- 30:50we scan those and save those. So I have at least
- 30:53two different ways to figure out that the handwritten
- 30:55notes are better because it not only has the
- 30:57tentative ruling, it has what I actually did
- 30:59notes. And then that is given back to me when
- 31:02I look at the proposed form of order. So especially
- 31:05in routine matters, I don't want anything more
- 31:07than, you know, here's the, this hearing came
- 31:09on for calendar and here's who was there or appearances
- 31:11were as noted in the record. And for the reason
- 31:13set forth on the record at the time of hearing
- 31:15and other good cause appearing there for it's
- 31:17hereby ordered, boom, boom, boom, boom. I don't
- 31:19necessarily, I don't need that in the order.
- 31:21But sometimes I want to, again, make sure the
- 31:24parties know and I want to make sure the appellate
- 31:26court knows. Do I need to say who was in the
- 31:28hearing at the hearing? I don't know that you
- 31:31do. I mean, I remember once upon a time we always
- 31:34did. Now I see more often appearances of whereas
- 31:37noted in the record and. I guess the only time
- 31:40I would say do it is if there's somebody who
- 31:42might claim later that I wasn't there and I didn't
- 31:45know and I'm not bound and I've been my due process
- 31:47rights were violated. Maybe it's helpful to have
- 31:50there right there in the order so and so was
- 31:52there at the hearing. But other than that, I'm
- 31:54not aware if there may be a reason, but I'm not
- 31:56aware of any reason why appearances were as noted
- 31:59in the record isn't sufficient. Should I say
- 32:01it was opposed? You know, the checklist in our
- 32:05standard form say the motion was not opposed.
- 32:07The motion was opposed. If there's a written
- 32:10opposition, sometimes it might be you could you
- 32:13could say the objection was overruled or the
- 32:15opposition was overruled. But I mean, I think
- 32:16that. or what I generally do when I draft something,
- 32:20I'll say, you know, the court having reviewed
- 32:21and considered the motion and all papers filed
- 32:24in opposition there too, and the replies and
- 32:25all supporting, I mean, I may say that, but the
- 32:29court's gonna, the appellate court's gonna presume
- 32:31I read all that. And if I didn't, and I still
- 32:35granted the motion, okay, well, if it's an error,
- 32:38it's an error, and if the appellate court wants
- 32:40to fix it, they can fix it, but. I don't know
- 32:43that there's any magic to whether the order says
- 32:45that or not. Okay, let's look, Rin, at slide
- 32:4712. Judge, I want to talk about preserving your
- 32:50tentative. You mentioned that. Okay, so if you
- 32:54did a tentative and you often do, you know, something
- 32:57that's thick with information, not in every case,
- 33:01but you have the stuff that we can all read and
- 33:04understand before we come to the hearing. Why
- 33:07don't I just say, in every order that I say my
- 33:09motion was granted or whatever, for the reasons
- 33:14set forth in Exhibit A, you don't have 11 page
- 33:19tentatives usually, but why don't I just do that?
- 33:22And I can upload a Word file and attach a PDF
- 33:26to go with it. That would be my PDF. Isn't that
- 33:29a good practice? You can. I don't know that it's
- 33:32necessary in every case. And the one caution
- 33:34that I would have and the one objection the court
- 33:36might have is one of the reasons there was a
- 33:40major cost savings when we went from, remember
- 33:44like stipulations in order used to be a combined
- 33:46document. And now we have a separate standalone
- 33:49order. The orders are shorter. And we actually
- 33:53have some people that we have to mail things
- 33:55to. Not everybody gets electronic copies of things.
- 33:59So there's people who get hard copy mailing and
- 34:02the government has to pay postage for that. So
- 34:05we tend to try to avoid long exhibits. That's
- 34:08why there is a rule about only 10 pages of an
- 34:11exhibit is because we don't want to pay the postage
- 34:14costs. And we saved our district alone saved
- 34:16millions of dollars when we went to please don't.
- 34:19Put long things on your orders. Same thing with
- 34:22like a settlement agreement. If you've approved
- 34:23the settlement agreement or the plan confirmation,
- 34:25instead of having it attached as exhibit, it
- 34:28better to have it refer back to exhibit eight
- 34:30of the motion or the plan filed such and such
- 34:33a date, docket number, whatever, so that we don't
- 34:35have massive mailing costs when we're sending
- 34:37that out. Yeah, there's there's sometimes when
- 34:39you're going to want to have that, we're going
- 34:41to want to have that. And so we're going to cause
- 34:43you grief by doing that. But I thought an example
- 34:46on slide 12 that was real nice. Here it is. This
- 34:50is a quote, deny request for relief under section
- 34:52362 D2 due to existence of equity, but grant
- 34:56motion under 362 D1 without a waiver of rule
- 34:594001 A3 as movement lacks adequate protection.
- 35:03That's a quote from an actual order. Wow, that's
- 35:06just simple. It tells you exactly what you were
- 35:08thinking. It tells you what the conclusions were.
- 35:11It gives that. Now this is a language, a custom
- 35:15language, right? Not our standard form for relief
- 35:17from the automatic stay. But is this kind of
- 35:20a good model? Yes, except for Emotions for Relief
- 35:25Mistake, because there's mandatory form orders.
- 35:27And there'll be a box that I check for granting
- 35:29D1. There'll be a box I check for denying or
- 35:32I won't check the box for D2. And then I'll either
- 35:34check the box or don't check the box for waiving
- 35:36the $4 ,000 A3. I'm with you. I'm just talking
- 35:39about the kind of the flow of an order. OK, you
- 35:42refer to emotion by a docket number. Then you
- 35:46say, you know, review the things and then you
- 35:49have a little bit of a ruling, OK, that you go
- 35:51in here and then put at the end. So ordered,
- 35:54I guess we still need to say so ordered at the
- 35:56end. No, you don't need to say it is so ordered
- 35:58at the end. Sometimes it's just sometimes it's
- 36:00there for like, well, I don't know how to like
- 36:03symmetry or just sometimes you end with with
- 36:06something where you just want to draw an underline
- 36:10and an apostrophe at the end, not apostrophe,
- 36:12an exclamation point at the end. That's kind
- 36:14of what it is, but I can't, it's no, it's absolutely
- 36:16not required. Let me go back to the question
- 36:18though, should you just like lift and copy something
- 36:20like this? If I were drafting the order, I would
- 36:23say the court having, you know, the motion came
- 36:25on for hearing, the court having found that there
- 36:28is no equity or that there's an adequate equity
- 36:30cushion, you know, or that there's no reasonable
- 36:33likelihood of reorganization within a reasonable
- 36:35period and other good cause appearing there for,
- 36:39it's hereby ordered that It's granted under this
- 36:41section, denied under that section. I usually
- 36:44don't combine the reason with what I'm actually
- 36:48doing. I usually put the reasons up before that
- 36:51it is so ordered and the actually what I'm ordering
- 36:54after that. Wren, let's bring up slide 13. Judge,
- 37:00you spent a lot of time and attention on preserving
- 37:04exhibits. exhibits from contested matters, exhibits
- 37:07from trial. In the olden days, we had notebooks,
- 37:11and they had exhibit tabs. And gosh darn it,
- 37:14I guess they sat around if there was an appeal
- 37:16and some rolling cart in your jury room that
- 37:19you don't use, waiting for someone to tell you
- 37:21that the appeal is over. Connected with that
- 37:23book. We do use the jury room. My staff eats
- 37:25lunch there, and they use the bathroom. So the
- 37:27jury room does get used. But how do you preserve
- 37:30these exhibits? Do you do electronic trials?
- 37:34What's your thought on preserving exhibits in
- 37:37connection with this? Do you stick them somehow
- 37:39to an order? Oh, hey, because of this great contract,
- 37:44exhibit one, attaches a PDF to an order. Is that
- 37:48what I do? Yeah, this is a whole program in itself.
- 37:51And there is a working group right now in the
- 37:53Ninth Circuit working on the best way to do this.
- 37:55But in the meantime, this is what I do. I do
- 37:58have the parties, I think it's important to bring
- 38:00an exhibit book if you've got a witness, unless
- 38:02everything is all electronic and the witness
- 38:04has a screen there too. And sometimes I do Zoom
- 38:07trials, so that's the way. But, and I do have
- 38:09the parties exchange exhibits electronically,
- 38:12and I have them email exhibits to me to a special
- 38:15email address. Now, none of that's on the record
- 38:17yet, but then we all have them electronically.
- 38:20And then after it's over, The exhibits that are
- 38:22admitted, and I suppose if there was a big dispute
- 38:24about whether something should be admitted or
- 38:26not, I have the courtroom deputy upload those
- 38:31to the docket so they're actually docketed. But
- 38:34different judges do it differently. But it is
- 38:36a good idea to have the electronic copy preserved.
- 38:40And if there's not... that many, they could be
- 38:43just one clump of exhibits. If they're lengthy
- 38:47and they may need to be separate ones, there
- 38:49are different ways to do it. But like I said,
- 38:51that's a project in flux and hopefully we'll
- 38:54come up with a great system for doing it. We're
- 38:56kind of doing it on an ad hoc basis now. Everybody's
- 38:59doing their own thing. So ask the judge. Beverly
- 39:01Hills Bar Association will do a program next
- 39:04year on what every judge is doing to preserve
- 39:06exhibits, paper and otherwise. That's an excellent
- 39:08thing to discuss at the pre -trial conferences.
- 39:11How are we going to handle exhibits? And I also
- 39:13do a trial procedures order that will explain
- 39:15what I want the parties to do with the exhibits.
- 39:17Right. A lot of judges have special rules for
- 39:21contested matters and adversary proceedings.
- 39:23Rin, let's look at slide 14, please. Rin's the
- 39:27best. A round of applause in your seats, please,
- 39:30for our Beverly Hills Bar Association right arm.
- 39:34Judge. This is just golden. Drafting a proposed
- 39:37order. Tips. Okay, we've got a couple of these
- 39:40connected with that. Prepare the order in Word.
- 39:44Judge, I'm going to use my, you know, something
- 39:48other than Word. Okay, Word Perfect 5 .1. Why
- 39:52can't you use that? Well, I could, but it's not
- 39:57the system. I don't think it'll accept it, and
- 39:58it'll get bounced. if the courtroom deputy would
- 40:01bounce that one, because they'll turn, I happen
- 40:04to have gotten special dispensation to continue
- 40:06using Word, because my law clerk has some programs,
- 40:09some things in Word, but we're all on, we're
- 40:13all, I'm sorry, we're perfect. We're all on Word
- 40:15now, and it won't work. When the courtroom deputy
- 40:19tries to call the order up to do anything to
- 40:21it, it won't open, right? So yeah, nope, doesn't
- 40:25work. OK, so now second point use 14 point font.
- 40:29Wow, that's really big. I know people from very
- 40:32large firms who think that that's just not, you
- 40:35know, not appropriate. You will going to send
- 40:36it up to you in 11 point font. Is is that something
- 40:40you care about the font size? Within within reason,
- 40:46I I think I probably prefer 12 than 14. But I
- 40:50certainly don't want read the part in parentheses
- 40:54there. There's one practitioner who shall remain
- 40:57nameless. You know who you are if you're out
- 40:58there. He likes to do the first letter of the
- 41:02order ginormous. I don't know. It's like 40 point
- 41:05font. And then it screws up the spacing for the
- 41:08rest of the order. Every order, and this person
- 41:11appears in front of me regularly, every order,
- 41:14I delete it. And sometimes they even check the
- 41:17box, change is made in the hope that he'll get
- 41:19the point. As I said, this is not an illuminated
- 41:23manuscript. It's pretentious. It looks ridiculous.
- 41:27Can I rant a little bit more on the next point?
- 41:30Just yesterday, this was the simplest order.
- 41:34It was either a schedule, it was an order on
- 41:37a stipulation to continue a hearing. I mean,
- 41:39it was a nothing, super easy. But whoever did
- 41:42this order didn't know how to use columns. I
- 41:45don't know how they were doing their lines and
- 41:47numbers on the left -hand side of their page,
- 41:49but on the first page, I tried to add date, time,
- 41:51and place underneath the caption, and it screwed
- 41:54up the numbers on the left because it wasn't
- 41:56columns, it was across each line. I had to figure
- 42:00out how to do that. Then on the second page,
- 42:02I didn't like the way the paragraphs were. They
- 42:04were spaced funny. I tried to fix it. I couldn't
- 42:07fix it without messing up the lines and numbers
- 42:10on the left hand. It would go one, two, space,
- 42:12space, space, space, three. I mean, it was, so
- 42:15please take a class, learn how to do this. And
- 42:19we're finding employee in your firm who knows
- 42:21how to do this. Don't upload garbage to me because
- 42:24if I need to try to make a change, I don't want
- 42:26to spend 20 minutes trying to figure out how
- 42:29to fix what you didn't know how to do in work.
- 42:31So, and then as long as I'm ranting, the gratuitous
- 42:34Latin phrase, that same one who uses my illuminated
- 42:36manuscript there, routinely puts a little Latin
- 42:40phrase up at the, now I guess I could tell my
- 42:43staff to take it out. I guess I could also tell
- 42:45him personally, please don't do that. But I thought
- 42:48he'd notice after I've deleted every single one
- 42:50that he does every time that he shouldn't do
- 42:52that. But yeah, it's an order of the court. I
- 42:55don't want it to say. funny things, and I don't
- 42:57want it to look silly. So anyway. Judge, I think
- 43:01your favorite point, the point that that really
- 43:04is the is the reason we're doing this is should
- 43:07I use the word proposed before the name of my
- 43:11order? That is, here's my word document proposed
- 43:15order granting motion, blah, blah, blah. Yeah,
- 43:18no. I mean, I think that was a nice thing back
- 43:20when we used to serve things by mail on each
- 43:23other as we were lodging them so that you could
- 43:26see, oh, look, this is just the proposed version.
- 43:28It's not the entered version. But even then,
- 43:31we had to cross it out and initial it. Now it's
- 43:34just one more thing for me to do. Of course,
- 43:35it's proposed. You've attached it to a notice
- 43:38of lodgement. You've uploaded it through Loo.
- 43:40If it was already entered, it wouldn't be in
- 43:43my Loo queue. Once I enter it, it disappears.
- 43:46So it just gives me that and footers. We used
- 43:49to use bluebacks. Wait, no. I put a footer. You
- 43:54can use the footer with your code number. You
- 43:58can use it on your left -hand side so you know
- 44:01what the document is in your system. but I don't
- 44:03need the name of the order in the footer because
- 44:06then if I change the name of your order then
- 44:08I got to change the footer too and by the way
- 44:10can I get a little ahead of ourselves or maybe
- 44:12it's here your title of the order doesn't need
- 44:15to be eight miles long okay it doesn't need to
- 44:18exactly match everything you're asking for it
- 44:20can be a condensed version and please don't give
- 44:22me Order granting motion for order granting whatever.
- 44:26I mean, that's just order granting extension
- 44:30of time. Anyway, it can be shorter. You don't
- 44:36need to repeat your entire argument in the caption
- 44:38in boldface font. So thank you. This is very
- 44:43therapeutic for me. I don't know if anybody's
- 44:45learning anything, but it's very therapeutic
- 44:47for me. Could we bring up slide 15? I told you,
- 44:50Judge, that this is going to be the most fun
- 44:53that you're going to have in a program for a
- 44:55long time, because it's the things that you want
- 44:57us to know that we need to pay attention to.
- 45:00And by the way, you had some input with respect
- 45:03to the format and content of orders in the central
- 45:09guide supplement. That's a kind of a funny thing.
- 45:11So the way you go to the central guide is you
- 45:13go to the court's website, search central guide,
- 45:17or just use the words order or something, and
- 45:20they'll bring up some choices. You click on them.
- 45:21We're in the next slide, please, slide 16. And
- 45:24they're all also the sections of the guide. They're
- 45:27their code. key to the local rules. So if you
- 45:30just go to the front homepage of our website,
- 45:32there's a thing on, there's a tab up at the top
- 45:34that says something like, you know, rules. And
- 45:36if you click on that, it'll have local rules,
- 45:38central guide, general orders, things like that
- 45:40too. Yeah, but that's not useful, Judge, because,
- 45:42you know, I want to know everything about an
- 45:44order. I want to know everything about this type
- 45:46of motion. I want to know about a notice of lodgement.
- 45:49The central guide will give you the 10 steps
- 45:51I need, because by the way, I'm busy and I got
- 45:53to go do something. On slide 16, some of the
- 45:56other things you had talked about, the title
- 45:58of the order, including a hearing date and, you
- 46:01know, that kind of stuff, and it's there. Let's
- 46:03look at slide 17, Wren. This is a sample from
- 46:08the court's website, which I find to be a little
- 46:10bit troubling for various reasons, but, Judge,
- 46:14okay, in the upper left -hand corner. Are we
- 46:16going to put the name of the lawyer who's lodging
- 46:19it? I guess the answer is yes, right? This doesn't
- 46:22have an email address. You'd want that on there,
- 46:24wouldn't you now? And a bar number, too. This
- 46:26is an old whatever. This is an old form from
- 46:29the court site, right? In the 80s, where we didn't
- 46:33have to use to put bar numbers on stuff, every
- 46:35now and then someone who wasn't a member of the
- 46:39bar would be filing stuff as a lawyer. And eventually
- 46:41they figured out if you put the bar number on
- 46:43there, eventually it would catch up to you. We
- 46:45have something in the middle that says the Bankruptcy
- 46:48Court, Central District of California. We have
- 46:50different divisions. And you would put that there.
- 46:54If you have something on the left and it's an
- 46:56adversary, you're going to want the adversary
- 46:58caption as well as the Chapter 7, Chapter 11,
- 47:02Chapter whatever. And then both the case numbers
- 47:05that you have there. Judge, if it's an adversary
- 47:08order, I'm uploading it in the adversary LOU,
- 47:13not in the in connection with that. Now, here
- 47:18it has a hearing date, time, and courtroom. Again,
- 47:20this is the court's exemplar. I usually put the
- 47:23calendar number. Does that help your staff find
- 47:25what it was that we're talking about? Sometimes,
- 47:29especially if it's a large case, or maybe it
- 47:32relates to a motion, and there have been several
- 47:33of those kinds of motions, or different parties
- 47:35have filed similar kinds of motions. That's unambiguous.
- 47:40We know which motion you're talking about. So
- 47:41it's a pretty good idea. Not required, but a
- 47:44pretty good idea. Wren, let's go to slide 18,
- 47:46please. I have problems. Everyone has problems,
- 47:52Judge, with some sort of special security system
- 47:55that finds anything in your brief, anything in
- 47:59your lodged orders, that somehow reads outside
- 48:02of the box. It takes you someplace else. because
- 48:05that's a classic indication of a fraud or some
- 48:09sort of problem in connection with that. So you
- 48:12basically have to have a document that has nothing
- 48:15in it. But because you want a Word document,
- 48:18you don't want something that's turned into a
- 48:21TIFF and then scanned to a flat PDF that you
- 48:24can't cut and paste from. That won't work for
- 48:26you, right? Correct. The converse is true with
- 48:30something you're filing CMECF. I mean, we kind
- 48:32of want those locked down, you know, if you're
- 48:34filing something that way, because you don't
- 48:36want somebody to be able to call up CMECF and
- 48:38just modify the document and make it say something
- 48:40different. But as far as coming in through our
- 48:42lodged order upload program, yeah, we want it
- 48:45to be word and clean. So, and I don't want, again,
- 48:50it's all about how much time does it take us
- 48:52to make it say what we want it to say? And if
- 48:54I've got to be turning off track changes and
- 48:56make sure that it's the final version, because
- 48:58sometimes when you've got the track changes going,
- 49:01you end up with something that, yeah, it just,
- 49:03I want it clean. I don't want any of that fancy
- 49:05stuff in my Word document. So for a while. Just
- 49:08a few years ago, we were talking about having
- 49:10a hyperlink to every case that's cited in a brief
- 49:14so that you can go right to that pin site and
- 49:17read the quote that I'm directing you to. I'm
- 49:20not thinking that's going to work for a while
- 49:23because we need to deal with the safety aspects
- 49:26of that, but that sure would be easy, wouldn't
- 49:28it? for the orders that it's going to be problematic.
- 49:33It's not problematic if CME -CF will accommodate
- 49:36that, because that'd be lovely. As you're reading
- 49:38a brief, you can click on the links in that.
- 49:40And you'd know better than I, because I never
- 49:42file anything, whether or not you can file something
- 49:45through CME -CF with links in it and have the
- 49:47links work. I thought you could. Can we? Sometimes.
- 49:52And sometimes no. And the only way I get rid
- 49:55of the no sometimes is to completely strip everything
- 49:57out. You flatten it. And sometimes you have to
- 50:00scan it, make it an image, and then bring it
- 50:02back to PDF. And it has nothing. And it works.
- 50:06Rin, let's look at slide 19. In the olden days,
- 50:10Judge, we used to have a stipulation classic.
- 50:15We agree that the trial date should be moved
- 50:17out. The first date available in February next
- 50:19year. And then you would approve that by signing
- 50:24something at the end. We just put it right on
- 50:27the end. That doesn't work anymore. And, in fact,
- 50:31we don't even put a signature line for you anymore
- 50:33in any order at all. Why is that, Judge? Because
- 50:37that happens electronically. The exception to
- 50:39that is if you're one of those annoying people
- 50:41who's still watching orders over the counter
- 50:42of a hard paper, then I do want a date and a
- 50:45line and a line for me to sign because I'm going
- 50:47to have to actually sign it. If it's coming in
- 50:50through our lodged order upload program, I check
- 50:52a box to say approved. The three dashes, the
- 50:55number signs or pound signs or whatever we call
- 50:58those these days. Hashtags, I guess people call
- 51:01them. The three hashtags. is where the signature
- 51:04is going to end up electronically in the document.
- 51:08And that can't go below line 21, I think it is,
- 51:10or we run out of room. But we can fix that. Yeah,
- 51:16I think I answered the question. OK. Rin, let's
- 51:19go to slide 20. So Judge, if I'm doing this electronic
- 51:23thing, I don't need to send you envelopes through
- 51:25some separate mailing to the court or something,
- 51:28right? Correct. We have a don't blue back the
- 51:31order, but I bet you half the people on here
- 51:33have never seen or even heard of bluebacks in
- 51:35the olden days. The bluebacks were stapled in
- 51:38a document so you could tell them the different
- 51:40pleadings apart, right? Right. And since we don't
- 51:43have hard copy files anymore, we only have the
- 51:45electronics. We don't we don't need that. And
- 51:47you wouldn't. What would you blue back? Because
- 51:48if you're doing, you know, you do if you're ideally
- 51:51you're doing it electronically anyway. So what
- 51:53would you do with the envelopes and the copies
- 51:55and the blue? What would you blue back? I don't
- 51:56know that it wouldn't work. Let's skip ahead
- 51:59to slide 22. Before we totally skip over stipulations,
- 52:07I do want to say one thing about stipulations.
- 52:13Some judges may feel differently about it. Again,
- 52:16don't prepare a combined stip in order. in my
- 52:20order, I kind of like the order to actually say
- 52:23what I'm doing. So that if you just have an order
- 52:25that you've uploaded that it said that step that
- 52:27we filed over there, it's approved. Then if anybody
- 52:30ever wants to know what I actually ordered, they
- 52:32not only have to look at the order, they got
- 52:34to go find the stipulation. So I generally like
- 52:36to have if you're stipulating that a claim can
- 52:38be allowed in X dollars, I like the order to
- 52:41say. Paragraph one, stipulations approved. Paragraph
- 52:45two, the claim is, objections overruled. And
- 52:47three, the claim is allowed in this dollar amount.
- 52:50I kind of like the order to speak for itself,
- 52:52so you don't have to go look at the step. Plus
- 52:55me too. We have a new trial date, but I can't
- 52:57remember what it is. But I got it in the order.
- 53:00Let's go to slide 22. We've mentioned some of
- 53:04the mandated standard form orders, or there are
- 53:06a few that are suggested. connection with that.
- 53:10Some judges have orders, Judge Rizolo has one
- 53:13that he likes for confirmation order and stuff
- 53:16like that. So obviously this is judge specific,
- 53:18but generally if you've got a standard form order,
- 53:21classic order granting relief from the automatic
- 53:25stay, you're going to use that. And it says don't
- 53:28change it, don't change it. Now sometimes that
- 53:29doesn't work for me, so I have to take my...
- 53:33Adobe after I printed up and prepared it and
- 53:37I have to X over some crazy line that just doesn't
- 53:40make any sense and I use giant X's and I bring
- 53:43it to your attention so you know that. Is that
- 53:46okay or am I you know I'm violating the rule?
- 53:48That's okay yeah the key reason for not changing
- 53:50the language is so that we thought it said what
- 53:52it always used to say and we checked that box
- 53:54and you've changed it. So if you're really upfront
- 53:57about what you're doing so that we can see you've
- 54:00made a change, that's not necessarily a criminal
- 54:03offense. And then there's always that extra other
- 54:07at the bottom. There's always a spot for that
- 54:08where you can add whatever additional text you
- 54:11need to add as well. Now, I reserve the right
- 54:13to change the language of the mandatory form,
- 54:15and I will sometimes do that. from the bench
- 54:17if I've got, because I'll have my motions for
- 54:19leave from staff, the orders in the queue when
- 54:21I'm hearing the hearings. So I may actually modify
- 54:23that in there, but that I'm allowed to do that.
- 54:26You guys are right. Judge, you're right that
- 54:29we've been covering a lot of stuff that was on
- 54:31our slide. So I'm going to shut you all the way,
- 54:34send you all the way to slide twenty seven for
- 54:36a minute. Slide twenty seven. Judge, when I upload
- 54:40a proposed order, I get a fancy form and it has
- 54:44a number on it. OK, and that Number is a document
- 54:48number. I guess that's a unique key number for
- 54:51that. Let's go to slide 28. And it looks something
- 54:55like this. Judge, do you get something like this
- 55:01in your box or it just shows up and goes, ding,
- 55:03you know, there's an order here? Neither. We
- 55:06have like a queue. We have a list of orders and
- 55:08they're by number. Well, you can sort them by
- 55:10name or by number or whatever, but they have
- 55:11a number associated with them. That's how I know
- 55:13I'm looking at the right number. So if my clerk
- 55:15is sending me something, if they give me a hard
- 55:18copy of an order, they write that number on it.
- 55:20If they're emailing me to say, Judge, look at
- 55:22this order, they write that number on it. So
- 55:23it's very important to us. But it's useful for
- 55:26you to have it, because sometimes we'll be at
- 55:29a hearing, and I'll say, well, counsel, have
- 55:31you uploaded an order? Not like you should have,
- 55:33but did you? Because maybe I'm ready to sign
- 55:35it if you did. And they'll say, you know, maybe
- 55:37the lawyer will say yes. So they'll say, OK,
- 55:40well, I can't find it. Do you have the number?
- 55:42because then I can search and see that I actually
- 55:45have. Because sometimes there's a lot in my queue.
- 55:47If I've been very diligent, my staff's been very
- 55:49diligent, maybe there isn't. But sometimes there's
- 55:51a lot in there. So it's helpful to help the judge
- 55:53locate it. And we use those numbers internally
- 55:56all the time. Let's look at slide 31. Judge,
- 56:03if I have no opposition, I file an easy motion,
- 56:06and it's a slam dunk, and you agree in connection
- 56:10with that. I can just go ahead and upload my
- 56:13order. I'm done. I don't have to go through this
- 56:15notice of lodgement process, which is kind of
- 56:17funky, right? Well, the local rules tell you
- 56:21when you have to do that. Personally, for me,
- 56:23I'd probably do a notice of lodgement all the
- 56:24time so that you don't mess up and not do it
- 56:26when you should or that you don't encounter a
- 56:29courtroom deputy who's confused about when you
- 56:31need to or not. And the advantage, again, of
- 56:33the notice of lodgement is that everybody gets
- 56:36served with it. So that if you mess something
- 56:37up or said something I didn't say, They know
- 56:40about it. So I think I was probably one of the
- 56:43people who created that process in the first
- 56:45place. I'm a big fan of the notice of large.
- 56:47And so yes, you may file. You may follow the
- 56:50local rule and omitted. But you know, but it's
- 56:55probably hard to train if you have staff and
- 56:56you're not doing it yourself. Probably hard to
- 56:58make sure your staff knows when to do it and
- 57:00when not to do it. It's probably easier to just
- 57:02say always do it. Let's look at slide 3434 Ren.
- 57:08Judge, a notice of lodgement is one of those
- 57:11downloadable forms that we have, slide 34, and
- 57:14it has one of those great easy -to -remember
- 57:16numbers, F9021 -1 .2 - .bk .notice .lodgement.
- 57:22I don't know why... That goes with the local
- 57:24rule that it relates to. That's why they're numbered
- 57:25that way. It's a good thing. I often take...
- 57:28It's two pages. It's got this first page, and
- 57:30it's got a last page, which is a service page.
- 57:33I often take this page... Then I take that LOU
- 57:36form with the number, the key number for the
- 57:39document. Then I attach my proposed order that
- 57:42I uploaded. Then I do the proof of service, which
- 57:45is really page two of this thing. Then I put
- 57:47the service list I have there in connection with
- 57:50that. And I find that that probably helps, but
- 57:54I don't know. Judges having the key number in
- 57:56there help you when I notice a lodgement, or
- 57:58you never look at the notice of lodgement. I
- 58:01don't look at the notice of lodgement. My staff
- 58:03will look to determine that there is one. So
- 58:06it might be helpful. Again, if you've got a case
- 58:09where there's a lot of orders flying around,
- 58:10different parties are lodging proposed forms
- 58:12of order, and maybe there's multiple motions
- 58:15that have similar titles, it might be helpful
- 58:18so that the courtroom deputy who is checking
- 58:21to make sure you did the notice of lodgement
- 58:23can make sure that that's the notice of lodgement
- 58:25that goes with that particular order. So it's
- 58:27not a bad idea. Yeah, not a bad idea. You're
- 58:33on mute, Scott. Oh, yep. You're supposed to read
- 58:39my lips, Rin. Let's go to slide 40, thank you.
- 58:44Judge, on the rear, we're just going to talk
- 58:46about objections for a second, okay? Objections
- 58:49to a form of an order. One more slide for me,
- 58:52slide 40, Rin, please. If I'm there and I'm opposing
- 58:57a motion and I lose because you've ruled in favor
- 59:01of the other party, And then an order comes flying
- 59:04in that I think doesn't comport to what you said,
- 59:06probably expands on your very carefully delineated
- 59:10filing. I might be able to file an objection,
- 59:14and that's a process that involves filing the
- 59:17order that was uploaded and my proposed order,
- 59:20and I do an LLU version for myself so you have
- 59:23it, but you would say, Judge, this is not a motion
- 59:28for reconsideration, right? Correct. And a key
- 59:32point is, if you don't like an order that you've
- 59:34seen lodged, call Chambers immediately. Because
- 59:37some of us will, I think the local rule still
- 59:39talks about waiting seven days or something like
- 59:41that for objections, but we don't. We'll just
- 59:43approve it. So if you have, well, I may fix it
- 59:47to make it look the way I, and frankly, I might,
- 59:49whatever your objection is, I may have the same
- 59:51objection and I may fix it and you may be fine.
- 59:53But don't trust me to do that. Call Chambers
- 59:56and say, I want to file an objection. and we'll
- 59:58give you a deadline, and then you file an objection,
- 1:00:01lodge your alternate proposed form of order,
- 1:00:03and then I'll look at the orders and figure out
- 1:00:05what I ought to do. You're on mute. This is a
- 1:00:12time when calling chambers is really important.
- 1:00:14I call chambers like right now. I saw that uploaded
- 1:00:17an hour ago, and I often say because I'm talking
- 1:00:21to voicemail usually. I'll have my proposed alternative
- 1:00:24form of order up by noon tomorrow, you know,
- 1:00:27something like that. And then I'm going to send
- 1:00:29it to you. So I'm not wait. I'm not saying I'll
- 1:00:31do it. I'll wait a week and go through that because
- 1:00:33then I have to bring a motion into rule 59 or
- 1:00:35something to to change it. And I don't want to
- 1:00:37do that. Judge, wrap this up. give us any final
- 1:00:41tips you have on orders. A lot more to say than
- 1:00:43you thought when we first started talking about
- 1:00:45this, wasn't it? Absolutely, absolutely. Well,
- 1:00:47let me tell you about, I don't know if other
- 1:00:48judges would be open to this, but I saw an interesting
- 1:00:51process yesterday or the day before that I thought
- 1:00:53was really fun. There was only one little dispute
- 1:00:55about the form of the order. The parties had
- 1:00:58met and conferred, everything else was fine,
- 1:00:59but there's one line they didn't want in or not.
- 1:01:01And they did something I've never seen done,
- 1:01:03it's not permitted under the local rules, but
- 1:01:04they did it anyway and it worked. was on the
- 1:01:06notice of lodgement. They put like a little footnote
- 1:01:08or something saying, by the way, the parties
- 1:01:10don't disagree about whether this, this part
- 1:01:12should go in or not. And then in the text of
- 1:01:14the order itself, it was like little brackets
- 1:01:16saying, this is, you know, the defendant doesn't
- 1:01:19think this goes here and plaintiff does. And
- 1:01:21so I didn't have to read all these other papers.
- 1:01:22They didn't have to call. It was so the parties
- 1:01:25were working together. Maybe you could do something
- 1:01:28like that. Although I don't know, would you get
- 1:01:30a judge who would have a problem with that? That'd
- 1:01:32be pretty rigid if a judge gave you a problem
- 1:01:34with that, but. Anyway, just a thought. If we
- 1:01:37can save you an hour a day on your order review,
- 1:01:40I mean, we're doing a good job out here. That's
- 1:01:42the bottom line is just think about, are you
- 1:01:44doing something that's going to aggravate and
- 1:01:46annoy the judge? Because if you are, that is
- 1:01:48not in your interest. So put yourself in our
- 1:01:51shoes from the court's perspective and try to
- 1:01:53make our job easy, and then we'll like you. So
- 1:01:57that's the conclusion of law and orders. Best
- 1:01:59practices for drafting, formatting, and getting
- 1:02:01orders entered in Judge Blue Bond's court. Oh,
- 1:02:04I mean, in the bankruptcy court. And we really
- 1:02:07appreciate your time, Judge. Thank you so much.
- 1:02:09You are very welcome. Thank you, Scott, for all
- 1:02:11your hard work on this program, too. And thank
- 1:02:13you, folks, for showing up and listening. Thank
- 1:02:16you very much. Wren, I think we wave and you
- 1:02:18cut us off, right?