Latest / Worldview Matters With David Fiorazo / Crystal Renaud Day: Shocking Number Of Women Struggle With Porn?
Transcript
- 0:00The 2027 Worldview Matters Conference will take place April 30th and May 1st at the Tundra Lodge Resort, Water Park and Conference Center in Green Bay, Wisconsin.
- 0:10Speakers include Andy Woods, Brandon Holthouse, Nathan Jones, Matthew Mayer,
- 0:18Hadia Miramati Falco, Pete Garcia, Brian Thomas, Steve Smotherman, J.B. Hickson, Mark Henry, Brianna Claussen, Alex Newman, Mark and Amber Archer.
- 0:35To register, go to davidfiorazzo.com or worldviewmattersconference.com.
- 0:46Welcome to Worldview Matters.
- 0:48Discussing controversial issues.
- 0:51Discerning current events.
- 0:53Defending biblical Christianity.
- 0:56No topic.
- 0:57Off limits.
- 0:59And now, here's your host, David Fiorazzo.
- 1:03Welcome, friends, family in Christ.
- 1:05We appreciate you guys so very much.
- 1:06You know, we just recorded our 600th episode of Worldview Matters.
- 1:12We had Ray Comfort for number 600.
- 1:14We had Ken Ham for number 500.
- 1:16I can go back.
- 1:17But in all of those podcasts, we have never...
- 1:22talked about the topic we're going to touch on today because of a brand new book.
- 1:26And I want to introduce Crystal Renaud Day.
- 1:30She's the CEO and founder of Living on Purpose.
- 1:34It's a women's telehealth counseling and coaching practice.
- 1:37And she's also the founder of and executive director of She Recovery.
- 1:42The website is sherecovery.com.
- 1:46It's a virtual recovery community for women facing pornography and other unwanted sexual behaviors.
- 1:53For nearly two decades, she and her team have helped thousands of women in more than 70 countries find healing through counseling, coaching, education, and recovery support.
- 2:07Such an important topic.
- 2:08That's why I'm so blessed to have Crystal on today.
- 2:11Welcome, sister.
- 2:12So good to see you.
- 2:12Thanks for your time.
- 2:15You too.
- 2:15Thanks for having me on.
- 2:16I appreciate it.
- 2:17And thank you for the brand new book.
- 2:19Congrats on the book.
- 2:21What drives women to pornography?
- 2:24So before we dive in and answer that question and get into some of the topics you cover through the chapters in your book, I want to mention your first book.
- 2:31You've been at this a while, and a lot of churches don't even touch on men in pornography.
- 2:39They don't touch on the topic at all, let alone—
- 2:43women because people we don't think that's a problem because you don't hear a lot of women struggling with this but back in 2011 you wrote a book called dirty girls come clean and you gave voice to a struggle that had gone largely unaddressed can you touch on that and what led you to this work that you're doing
- 3:05Ultimately, this work is stemmed and rooted from my own story.
- 3:09I was exposed to pornography at the age of just 10 years old.
- 3:12And that carried me through my adolescence with an addiction to pornography, other unwanted expressions of that.
- 3:21And it wasn't until I was 19 years old.
- 3:24that I met another female who told me her story that was similar to my own.
- 3:29And it was the first time I even knew women struggled with pornography in any kind of way.
- 3:34And so for a while, I was happy to have been in recovery early in my life.
- 3:40But I know I was perfectly fine with that being the end of it.
- 3:44Thanks, Jesus.
- 3:45Got me through it.
- 3:46But really felt like God was saying that, Crystal, you have a story to tell.
- 3:51You've been through something that many women have gone through, and I want you to help them get through it.
- 3:58And that's ultimately what led to blogging and eventually writing the book.
- 4:03Very interesting.
- 4:04So you were 10 years old.
- 4:08You know, when I'm old enough to remember, my first exposure was a Playboy magazine.
- 4:13That was just, you had to have it in your hand.
- 4:15And then came the internet years later.
- 4:18So how did that come about, your first exposure to pornography?
- 4:24Similarly, I am now 41.
- 4:26So this is 30 years ago, just about that.
- 4:29I was exposed to that pornography.
- 4:31And it was a magazine left out by my teenage brother who also shouldn't have had it either.
- 4:38And it was left out one afternoon when I came home from school.
- 4:41And that was the end of it for me.
- 4:44That was like the best and worst day of my life.
- 4:47So talk to us about, you said it was nine years before you met another woman who you heard also had that problem, that struggle or that addiction.
- 4:58Nine years.
- 5:00So you must have felt like you were struggling with this secret sin, this addiction that you couldn't tell anyone about.
- 5:07Talk to us about those nine years.
- 5:09That's very interesting.
- 5:11Yeah, so I had heard conversations, maybe a sermon or two, but mostly it was just guys talking about porn.
- 5:20You see it in sitcoms where it's made light of and it's men talking about pornography.
- 5:25So what happens with that is that's a messaging that a young woman receives, right?
- 5:30That this is a man's struggle.
- 5:32This is something that only men do.
- 5:35And so if you're living with a struggle that you believe is...
- 5:39isolated to you as a woman, then that just compounds that shame, the shame you're already experiencing.
- 5:45Because as a young believer, I also was like, had a lot of shame about knowing what I was doing with sinful.
- 5:52But then to add on the fact that I didn't think women struggled in this way, because of the messaging that I was receiving, that that shame was only compounded and exponentially worse.
- 6:03Wow.
- 6:05This is really so good that we're talking about this.
- 6:07I'm so thankful for your book.
- 6:09Over on the Amazon page, and friends, this just came out a couple days ago, weeks ago, nearly 40% of online pornography is consumed by women.
- 6:20Here now we're into the internet age, Crystal, and young people today, wow, they're dealing with stuff that maybe you and I didn't have to deal with growing up.
- 6:29You've got it at the convenience of your phone and gadgets that are right in front of you.
- 6:36Parents have a hard time keeping up with what their kids are doing, but talk to us about that 40% problem.
- 6:42number because that is really high for a lot of people to understand.
- 6:4740% is it?
- 6:48Did I hear that right?
- 6:5040% of online porn consumed by women.
- 6:54Yes.
- 6:55And that's from the horse's mouth.
- 6:57Really?
- 6:57That is the information we get directly from a website called Pornhub, largest porn site in the world.
- 7:03They love to release their annual statistics to brag about what, you know, who's coming to their site and how often and what they're looking up.
- 7:11But they break it down by gender.
- 7:13And so they said that about 39% to 20, 25 was the number of women.
- 7:20And that's registered accounts, which is something to think about, too.
- 7:24We did a survey ourselves asking women about their porn experiences.
- 7:28We actually asked them, have you ever created an account on a site like Pornhub?
- 7:3386% said no.
- 7:35And so there's something to be considered there where maybe it's actually more than 39% worldwide.
- 7:41Maybe it's actually more women than that.
- 7:43We just don't have the accounts to prove it.
- 7:46So let's talk about a few other numbers.
- 7:47I'm a stat guy.
- 7:48I like research and surveys, and it gives you a better idea.
- 7:51But like you said, the numbers might not be fully accurate.
- 7:55But this, out of the notes on your book, it says nearly 60% were first exposed before the age of 13.
- 8:04Well, you were exposed at 10 years old when you're a teenager, so nearly 60%.
- 8:11And then here's another one, Crystal, and you can respond to either one of these.
- 8:15In a study a few years ago, 93% of women had never attended a recovery meeting, meaning they struggled with pornography, but maybe they didn't know how to go about finding a cure, a solution, or getting help.
- 8:30I'm sure that's probably consistent with the church not wanting to go and talk to a pastor or open up or share.
- 8:37Talk to us a little bit about that or whatever you'd like.
- 8:39Yeah.
- 8:40I think it's interesting to look at those numbers, especially the exposure numbers, because we might think that pornography or these sexual behaviors are something that begins in adulthood.
- 8:50It's something that we make a conscious choice to enter into or seek out.
- 8:55But in reality, you're talking 60% of those we surveyed were exposed to porn or were shown porn or saw porn before the age of 13.
- 9:06Before you have any language for it, understanding of it,
- 9:09Many of those women didn't even know, it didn't have the sex talk yet.
- 9:13And suddenly they're being inundated with something that is really a counterfeit to what we actually know the good design of sex to be.
- 9:21And so it changes your sexual palette, your appetite, how you see humanity, how you see others, how you see, you don't see them as image bearers of God, you see them as a commodity.
- 9:31And so it really changes all of that in the mind and in the heart.
- 9:36But then if you think about,
- 9:38those women who are feeling stuck in it, that 93% who didn't go to a support group, that to me is obviously really sad.
- 9:45I've been offering support groups for 20 years, but I'm just one person, which means there just isn't either the opportunity to find, to have a small group, to go to a small group, to go to a support group, or they are still too afraid and too full of shame to go.
- 10:00So why do you think, and I know you read about this in the book, why do you think that women's stories or experiences about pornography have gone largely unheard or unshared for so long?
- 10:12I think in general, especially if you're looking at it from the church view, from a Christian view, unfortunately, a lot of Christian teaching is that women aren't sexual beings.
- 10:22Like we are too pleased, we aren't to be pleasured.
- 10:26And so I think that's a part of it, is that kind of that belief that women aren't visual, aren't necessarily interested sexually, and maybe are the ones who are the tempter, not the temptee.
- 10:40And so I think that some of that language, some of that narrative is added to that, which is to me, it's kind of ridiculous because, you know, we are made in the image of God.
- 10:51And if man is sexual, so is woman because of that.
- 10:55And you can look at how we were made and how our bodies are designed and how it isn't just for procreation.
- 11:00It's for pleasure for both.
- 11:09That's kept women's issues and struggles overlooked because you aren't, if you can't even admit that they are sexual, then how do you admit that they have, they may have sexual brokenness too.
- 11:22I'm so glad you read about this.
- 11:24The subtitle of your book, which I didn't mention, says why women struggle sexually and how to heal.
- 11:31There's the important part, Crystal.
- 11:34Thank you for covering that as well.
- 11:36You came up with the SCARS model, a practical framework for long term change.
- 11:42S-C-A-R-S. Talk to us a little bit about that.
- 11:46Yeah, the SCARS model was actually something that was devised in the first book, 30 Girls Come Clean.
- 11:52And it is, it's an acronym, spells the word SCARS.
- 11:55I was as prayerful, you know, writing that book originally, figuring out, you know, how does this all fit together?
- 12:00How do these steps that have come together, work together?
- 12:03And I was reminded of Thomas in scripture where he is, you know,
- 12:08doubting and questioning even Christ's scars.
- 12:12But what I think is really important is that scars in and of themselves aren't a bad thing.
- 12:17Scars tell a story.
- 12:19It means we have a wounding, but it also means that we have been healed.
- 12:23And so it begins with surrender.
- 12:25That's the S is to surrender.
- 12:27It is to say you've become powerless, much like a 12-step program.
- 12:31But not just surrendering to the powerlessness of your struggle, but surrendering to why you reach forward in the first place and coming to understanding of what that might look like.
- 12:41And also surrendering to the one who can truly save you, which is the Lord.
- 12:45And then we go into confession, which is...
- 12:48to be known, to actually share your story with someone, someone who is safe to hear your story.
- 12:52It can be a counselor, it can be a friend, it can be a family member, a church staff member, but being able to bring your story from isolation and darkness into light is that second step.
- 13:03And then accountability is third.
- 13:06That is what it sounds like.
- 13:07It's being accountable, not just to your behavior, not just to have you looked at porn today, but how is your heart doing?
- 13:14being accountable to your own healing.
- 13:17Are you doing the hard work that it takes to recover and to heal?
- 13:21And then responsibility is again, kind of restitution, making amends for how your behavior has affected others and taking responsibility for your own healing.
- 13:31But also understanding that many women, our own survey found that 46% of these women were sexually abused.
- 13:39And so while we may not be responsible for what happened to us, we are responsible to heal.
- 13:46We were responsible to find that healing.
- 13:49But we also need to relinquish some responsibility because many who experience abuse also carry a lot of guilt and shame and self-blame for those types of things.
- 13:58So we have to relinquish that responsibility as well.
- 14:01And then that last step is to share, is to use your story.
- 14:05It's to allow God to take what happened and redeem it.
- 14:09I'm not saying you all have to go on a talk show and do it, but there's going to be women in your life eventually that are going to need you to hear your story and God will lead you to those right women.
- 14:21So you just went through part four in your book, Scars, right?
- 14:25And there's part five, and then there's much more information here.
- 14:31But I love, I'm going back through the table of contents.
- 14:33I'm looking at this.
- 14:35What if we're asking the wrong question, chapter one?
- 14:39Talk to us a little bit about that, because I think if it's not talked about, maybe we are asking the wrong question.
- 14:45Yeah, I think there's two ways to interpret the wrong question.
- 14:48The wrong question, as far as how I've been doing this work for so long, has been do women even struggle with porn?
- 14:55That's the wrong question.
- 14:56We know now that they do, and the right question is to ask why.
- 15:01And of course, figuring out what drives you, what drives her to pornography.
- 15:05But the other wrong question is, what's wrong with me?
- 15:09Or why can't I stop?
- 15:11The real question is, why do you reach for it in the first place?
- 15:15And how do you heal?
- 15:17Okay, now I know you get into these in depth in the book, but you talk about five primary drivers that commonly underlie women's pornography use.
- 15:28And this is the book title, What Drives Women to Porn?
- 15:31Again, friends, each of these is a chapter.
- 15:34But can you just touch on briefly each one of them?
- 15:38Yes.
- 15:38So we, really it's, it's been well informed by our survey that we did, well informed by the women that I have worked with for two decades, but also informed by my own experience and my own stories, own story.
- 15:50And so we found basically five drivers of female porn use, which really we could also translate into men's experiences as well.
- 15:58But you can, you have emotional reasons.
- 16:01You have emotions.
- 16:02relational drivers, you have identity drivers, you have traumatic drivers, and you have spiritual drivers.
- 16:10And it's not that one woman has one of these, she could actually have a combination of all five going on that are keeping her going back to pornography or other acting out behaviors again and again and again as part of that addiction cycle.
- 16:25So let's talk about what we touched on briefly, and that is women have a hard time maybe approaching a pastor or a brother or a sister in Christ when the church should be a safe place.
- 16:38We should be able to share our struggles.
- 16:40I think a lot of people don't.
- 16:43So as far as women in pornography, why do you think it's so hard for women to get help at church?
- 16:51I don't think they see their experience presented to them.
- 16:55Like going back to my conversation about you're, you're not hearing the right sermons.
- 16:59You're hearing it from a very male centric perspective.
- 17:03And so if she's not seeing her experience being shown as, as a safe place to take it, like, cause if she, if she doesn't know that, that, you know, she, she isn't alone in the struggle, I think it was like 69% of our ladies thought they were alone too.
- 17:16So it's,
- 17:18if she doesn't see her experience presented in front of her as a path to help, then she's going to continue to kind of, you know, isolate, enter back into herself, experience that shame and that isolation.
- 17:31And honestly, again, I'll just say this truthfully, like when you're in addiction, there's some selfishness going on.
- 17:37There's a little bit of like, I hate this thing, but I also know that it's doing something for me.
- 17:42And so it's easy to make excuses for why you can't get help.
- 17:47And sometimes that excuse is the lack of general awareness in your church or in your culture where it's not the path to recovery, the path to healing is not evident.
- 18:01Okay, so let's go back to the very beginning of the book.
- 18:05And I want to ask you, I mean, the title, What Drives Women to Porn?
- 18:10You dedicated the book to your dad.
- 18:14Tell us about that, Crystal.
- 18:16Yeah, I lost my dad last year.
- 18:18Sorry.
- 18:21He passed away suddenly in June of last year.
- 18:24Um, and it's, you know, um, I, and I miss him a great deal, but, uh, I dedicated the book to him, um, in part because, uh, he was a champion for me in this work.
- 18:38Even if he didn't understand it, even if he didn't even want to hear about it, um, he was still a champion for it because he, he laid a foundation for me to be able to go back to school, to get the training that I needed to, um, um, to, um, to, um, to, um,
- 18:51And live with them for much longer than anybody should live with their parents.
- 18:56But it was encouraging and allowed me to pursue the calling that God had on my life.
- 19:02Hmm.
- 19:03Sounds like a wonderful man.
- 19:05Well, thank God we get to see them again.
- 19:07You know, just personally, two years ago, I lost my mom.
- 19:11That was probably, if not the hardest year in my life, one of them, one of the top.
- 19:16So I'm sorry to hear what you're going through, but thank God for the hope we have in Christ.
- 19:21So this is going by very, very fast, Crystal.
- 19:25You were really the first person writing about this specifically for women.
- 19:31So what has changed in the 20 years plus since you started writing about it?
- 19:37I mean, I know there's more awareness now, maybe.
- 19:39But what's changed?
- 19:40Because, my goodness, you would think...
- 19:4350 years ago or 25 years ago, there'd be a book or articles or something on this, but you were kind of like a groundbreaker.
- 19:50Go ahead.
- 19:52Yeah, so the very first group I ever led was in 2007, so almost 20 years ago, and there was nothing, nothing available on the shelves, whether it was Christian or secular, on female pornography use.
- 20:09At the time, there were two books, both by the same author, Marnie Faree, who is now retired.
- 20:15I call her the grandmother of female sex addiction recovery.
- 20:21Um, but, uh, but her books were largely rooted in sex addiction, where it was a lot of women's stories and experiences and even her own of having, um, numerous affairs and being more, more promiscuous where it wasn't necessarily pornography or pornography related behaviors, but more of that more external relationship looking, uh, struggle.
- 20:42And so as I was, you know,
- 20:44Leading this group, it was helpful, but it wasn't exactly our experiences.
- 20:49And so I ended up writing Dirty Girls Come Clean.
- 20:52Since then, yes, Dirty Girls Come Clean created awareness.
- 20:58She Recovery, my organization, created awareness.
- 21:00And awareness is good, but we needed more than awareness.
- 21:05We need to actually heal, right?
- 21:07And that's in part why I went back to school and I got my counseling degree.
- 21:12But there's the need for...
- 21:16And we've seen it where there's more women who are telling their stories.
- 21:19So you can go on Amazon, you can find other women writing about their stories like Jessica Harris or Joyce Garka.
- 21:25And they have written their experiences down and paths to healing as well.
- 21:29And that's something that hasn't happened or has happened in the last 15 years.
- 21:33And I, I will humbly say likely because of what I was able to lay the foundation for, but I also give a lot of credit to Marnie for kind of opening the gates on it.
- 21:43But certainly now there is more awareness, but there still is precious few resources in terms of spaces for women to heal in community.
- 21:53Yeah, I think just the numbers that we talked about earlier in the podcast that are coming out now, not a lot of people have heard anything close to that.
- 22:02And I'll go to your Amazon page again.
- 22:04Nearly 40% of online porn consumed by women.
- 22:09We have a hard time wrapping our heads around that only because we haven't heard anything.
- 22:14truthful reporting or testimonies or information on women and pornography.
- 22:21So, boy, it's going by fast.
- 22:23A couple more questions for you, Crystal.
- 22:27Why...
- 22:28Women struggle for years, but they pray, they try to go to church, they try to seek accountability, they keep trying harder.
- 22:36But why do you think some, and maybe most, I don't know, and I think this is relatable to men and pornography too, why do you think the struggle continues?
- 22:47Because they're not getting to the root of it.
- 22:49They're not getting to the reasons why they're reaching for it in the first place.
- 22:54There's a big difference between sobriety and healing, which is what I talk about a lot in the book.
- 23:00You can be sober from alcohol and drugs and sex and porn, but still be very unhealthy emotionally.
- 23:09And you are still gravitating towards things that maybe aren't so good for you, but maybe are a little bit more acceptable.
- 23:16And so if you're if you don't deal with what's underneath it, you can keep trying harder and harder and harder.
- 23:22But there's going to be a propensity or you're susceptible to returning to it.
- 23:27One, because it's familiar and just because something is familiar doesn't mean that it's wanted.
- 23:32It's just familiar.
- 23:33But also there's a nervous system in your body that has learned to cope with unwanted or uncomfortable emotions.
- 23:42And it's like, hey, remember that thing that we've always done that always seemed to work, that always seemed to help?
- 23:47Let's go back to that because we know that it works.
- 23:49And your nervous system is designed for that.
- 23:52It's designed that way.
- 23:54But if you don't deal with the why and give your nervous system something else to feast on, give it a new pathway, then that is going to continue to be where you go.
- 24:05All right, Crystal, I don't want to run out of time before I ask you this question.
- 24:09I would think the majority of our viewers and listeners have possibly never heard a sermon on pornography or pornography when it relates to women.
- 24:23What would you say to people, a lot of people in our audience from across the country and many other countries, that think, well, my pastor's never talked about this.
- 24:33How can we lovingly approach a pastor and maybe share this information?
- 24:39Yeah, I don't have the exact statistic.
- 24:41I know you're a stats guy, but I don't have the right one in my head right now.
- 24:45But there's actually a fairly big reason that pastors don't talk about porn, and it's because they're using porn themselves.
- 24:52I want to say it's a I think it's at least 40 percent of pastors are using pornography, too.
- 24:57You can actually find this information from the Barna Group.
- 25:00They did a church survey and they redid it two years ago.
- 25:03And so you can look that up yourself.
- 25:06But you know,
- 25:07I think that there's some of that is involved in it just because they don't want to expose even themselves at all in talking about it.
- 25:16And there could be a lot of shame involved in that as well, obviously.
- 25:20And so I would say like, send it anonymously if you have to, but write into your church and say, Hey, we need to be talking about porn more right on the back of your connect card and your bulletin and submit that, you know it's just important that you,
- 25:35Because even if your pastor is struggling, he shouldn't be struggling alone, right?
- 25:38So we need to be, the church needs to be a safe space for even him to confess.
- 25:44But so, yeah, I think it's just really important.
- 25:47And if there is a pastor listening, maybe you have or haven't done a sermon on porn before, but maybe if you did, it was directed towards men.
- 25:56It's a very simple solution for that.
- 25:58And it's talk about it again, and then just add two words to your sermon.
- 26:02And it's, and women.
- 26:05Men and women struggle with pornography.
- 26:09And what that does is it tells the girl who's like me, who is in your congregation, who feels alone, who feels invisible, she's not alone.
- 26:17And then you see her and that there's hope for her.
- 26:20Great, great answer.
- 26:21Thank you, friends.
- 26:23Take that to heart, and we need to ask our pastors about this important topic.
- 26:28By the way, we just had George Barna on last week, so what a blessing.
- 26:34I love the stats, but some of these numbers, at least to me, the way I see things, they really jump out at you, because especially if we haven't heard a lot of information or reports on this, Crystal, congrats on the very important book that...
- 26:47Friends, it just came out.
- 26:49Please check it out.
- 26:49Crystal Renault Day on Amazon, or you can go to her website, sherecovery.com.
- 26:57The book site is WDWTP.com.
- 27:02But go to sherecovery.com.
- 27:04Thank you for your time today.
- 27:05Hopefully we can keep in touch.
- 27:07Yeah, thank you so much.
- 27:09You're most welcome, Crystal.
- 27:10Very important, friends.
- 27:11And now we can say we covered the topic because I don't know how many other topics we haven't done in 600-plus podcasts, but now we're covering these on shows that I think are really important, and these are really things people struggle with, especially young people today, with all the things that bombard our youth at younger and younger ages.
- 27:32Very important.
- 27:33God bless you, friends, and as always, keep speaking the truth about things that matter.
- 27:38We'll see you next time.
- 27:39Bye.