Latest / My Sister's A Therapist- Mental Health, Wellness, and Healing with Humor / Irresponsible Diagnoses: It's A Wonderful Life
Transcript
- 0:01My sister's a therapist and I tell jokes.
- 0:05We both want to help all kinds of folks.
- 0:09Hello and welcome to My Sister's a Therapist.
- 0:12This is a podcast program that is made by myself, a stand up
- 0:17comedian, Virginia Jones from Portland, OR and my sister in
- 0:22Austin, TX who is a therapist. Hello, I'm Laura Ryan.
- 0:25I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, but my main
- 0:28credit is sister to bit Bandit, Virginia Jones.
- 0:31OK bit. Bandit.
- 0:32All right. Comedy is a funny old thing.
- 0:35If it's done correctly. It's something that people don't
- 0:37talk about when they're starting.
- 0:39Comedy is the upsy downsiness of it.
- 0:41A month ago I was performing in a 700 person theater.
- 0:46This week here in a toilet. This week I was in an unheated
- 0:49garage in Vancouver. Any small business operation,
- 0:53you got the highs and then you get way down to the low.
- 0:56Welcome to the holiday season. I hope that everyone is doing
- 0:59OK. Laura, why don't you welcome us
- 1:02to Zach's Corner. And Zach, please know that you
- 1:05do not need to generate material for Zach's Corner.
- 1:08It can be a come as it may type situation.
- 1:11Please don't add to your stress with coming up with content for
- 1:14us. It's always a delight when I get
- 1:16it. It's enjoyable but not required
- 1:19to be a fan of My Sister's A Therapist podcast.
- 1:22Also, listener while you're here.
- 1:24Tell the person to your left. Tell the person to your right.
- 1:26Tell the person above you. Tell the person below you.
- 1:28You love this podcast. Tell the person at the grocery.
- 1:31Store. Tell the person sharing a lift
- 1:32with you, which doesn't happen anymore.
- 1:34Tell the person on the. Other end of the hot dog that
- 1:36you're eating. Tell the person at your 6:00 AM
- 1:41yoga class that you love a show called My Sister's a Therapist.
- 1:45From Zacks corner today it's a very single man.
- 1:48I can't wait. Let's tip you're our boyfriends
- 1:51cringes. So we have Garfield here looking
- 1:55at picture of Garfield with a circle and a cross through it
- 1:59like the not smoking and it says huh I wonder who that's.
- 2:04It's been said that the pun is the lowest form of humor, but I
- 2:07think in the modern age we are at a new low which is trying to
- 2:11explain memes or comic strips. That's the.
- 2:14New Lowest, he said. I finished the boyfriend's
- 2:17episode. I listened to it first and I was
- 2:19in the air when this made the Zack's corner.
- 2:23Thankfully, I did not hear it until now.
- 2:25To avoid the plane engine screech sound effect, there's
- 2:28your Zach's Corner for today. Thank you, Zach.
- 2:31Thank you, Zach. Laura on this podcast, we take
- 2:34turns guiding the ship. For each episode, we pick topics
- 2:38and research them. This week, I have the rare
- 2:40pleasure of knowing what we're talking about.
- 2:42Because Laura wanted to do a very special holiday.
- 2:45Irresponsible diagnosis. It's a wonderful life.
- 2:48What is wrong with these people? This is one of my all time
- 2:51favorite movies. It's a classic.
- 2:53It's in the top 10 holiday movies list.
- 2:55I can't imagine anyone not loving this.
- 2:57First of all, Jimmy Stewart, come on.
- 3:00Donna Reed, Come on. Jimmy Stewart just twitching.
- 3:03And a mumbling Who's the Hugh Grant before Hugh Grant?
- 3:06I think he's a lot better than Hugh Grant.
- 3:08But they're doing very much the same bit.
- 3:10I'm a hot guy who doesn't know I'm hot, and I'm just stumbling,
- 3:14bumbling, messing with my hair, blinking and winking.
- 3:17Basically. They both look like an
- 3:19assortment of facial tics in a hot way.
- 3:22That sounds sounds really on historyhit.com, I've discovered.
- 3:27On December 20th, 1946, the film received a charity preview
- 3:31screening in the Globe Theatre, one day before its official
- 3:33premiere. The New York Times described it
- 3:36as a quaint and engaging modern parable, but concluded the
- 3:39weakness of this picture is the sentimentality of it.
- 3:42What? That's the best part of this
- 3:44picture, you dumbbell? Audiences weren't so keen
- 3:48either, landing with the $525,000 shortfall after decades
- 3:52in the shadows. It was a clerical error causing
- 3:54in a lapse in the film's copyright in the 1970s that
- 3:58brought about its rise to iconic status.
- 4:00The 19 O 9 Copyright Act stipulated that creative works
- 4:04were protected for 28 years, after which the copyright holder
- 4:07needed to renew the copyright. In 1974, after the film's
- 4:10copyright holder forgot to file for a renewal, the film entered
- 4:14the public domain. So with no royalties to pay,
- 4:16television channels screened it again and again during each
- 4:19Christmas period. In 1990, Its Wonderful Life
- 4:22became 1 of 25 films selected for preservation in the United
- 4:25States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress.
- 4:28It's interesting because we talk about things becoming popular
- 4:32sometimes because someone prominent has promoted them or
- 4:36they wind up on a. Special list, but this became
- 4:38popular just through repeat exposure.
- 4:41I think some things are like that, like there's a song you'll
- 4:43hear and the first time you hear everything is kind of wack.
- 4:46And then over time it sounds great.
- 4:48Frank Capra was particularly taken aback by its newfound
- 4:51success, saying quote, I'm like a parent who's kid grows up to
- 4:55be president. Upon rewatch there's so many
- 4:59little tradition sayings and especially Christmassy stuff
- 5:03that comes out of this movie. One of them is the house warming
- 5:06gift of salt, bread and wine. In my last job one of my Co
- 5:11workers managed to buy a house. Why?
- 5:13Because he was rich and another Co worker said I'm going to
- 5:16bring him salt bread and wine. And I said great, what for?
- 5:19And she was like, well, that's the traditional house warming
- 5:22gift and it's from Eastern European and Jewish cultures.
- 5:24It happens in a wonderful life. And Donna Reed says the bread is
- 5:28so your house may never know hunger.
- 5:29Salt is so life may always have flavor and joy and prosperity
- 5:33may reign. Forever is the wine and we just
- 5:35pick it up and roll with it because we found about it in the
- 5:37movie. This is another irresponsible
- 5:40diagnosis. So I have irresponsibly
- 5:42diagnosed some of the characters.
- 5:44Not all, obviously there's a huge cast of characters, but I
- 5:46picked a few. So we're going to start with our
- 5:48friend George Bailey and I have done a double diagnosis of him.
- 5:53We're going to start with intermittent explosive disorder.
- 5:56Yeah. He's an angry guy and angry.
- 5:59Guy and it occurred to me watching this film, this would
- 6:02not be the hero in a film today. No, I'm going to start with the
- 6:06interior, the Hatch family home. So this is Mary's home.
- 6:10This is the scene where he's been at a party and his mother
- 6:14says Mary's home. Why don't you go visit her?
- 6:16Wink, wink. Right, and he's trying to
- 6:18pretend that he doesn't want to visit her, but for some reason
- 6:21that's very unclear to me, he suddenly becomes aggressively
- 6:25angry and rude to her. He's being called out on his BS.
- 6:28If she said, oh, George Bailey, what a weird coincidence that
- 6:31you're here, he probably would have been fine.
- 6:33But she said, oh, yeah, your mom said you were coming.
- 6:35And he was like, whoa. And he feels put on the spot
- 6:38because, one, she's gone to college and he feels that she's
- 6:41one, up on him. Two, he knows that she has a
- 6:43boyfriend. They get a phone call from his
- 6:46friend Sam Wainwright. They're talking on the phone, so
- 6:49as Mary listens, she turns to look at George, her lips almost
- 6:52on his lips, whispering. He says it's a chance of a
- 6:55lifetime. So Sam is talking about this
- 6:57money opportunity. George can't stand it any
- 7:00longer. He drops the phone with a crash.
- 7:02He grabs Mary by the shoulders and shakes her.
- 7:05Mary begins to cry. George says fiercely.
- 7:08Now you listen to me. I don't want any plastics.
- 7:11I don't want any ground floors, and I don't want to get married
- 7:14ever to anyone. You understand that?
- 7:16I want to do what I want to do. And your and your.
- 7:21And he pulls her to him in a fierce embrace.
- 7:24The two, meant for each other, find themselves in tearful
- 7:27ecstasy. George says oh, Mary, Mary.
- 7:30And Mary says, oh, George, George, George.
- 7:33Yuck. Yuck, yuck.
- 7:35Yes, the correct thing for Mary to say is why are you touching
- 7:39me? His speech is later echoed in
- 7:41Lloyd Gobbler's speech And say anything where he says I don't
- 7:44want to sell anything, buy anything or process anything as
- 7:46a career. I don't want to sell anything
- 7:48bought or processed, or buy anything sold or processed or
- 7:50processed anything sold, bought or processed.
- 7:52And I don't mind him saying that.
- 7:54You don't have to say it like she's somehow at fault.
- 7:57What did this woman do? She's just minding her own
- 7:59business. Sam Wainwright is calling her
- 8:01and telling her about this plastics factory he's opening.
- 8:04It was his toxic masculinity got in the way.
- 8:07I think he felt Sam Wainwright was outdoing him and showing
- 8:11that he was pitiful because he's not a multi millionaire and in.
- 8:15Financial way, Sam is beating him, but that's the core of the
- 8:19movie is that money isn't everything.
- 8:20Unfortunately, money is everything.
- 8:22We all live in Pottersville because there were not enough
- 8:25George Bailey's around. To save us.
- 8:28Yes, and Mary, let's face it, is just following the path that she
- 8:32has been given. She's carried a torch for George
- 8:35Bailey since she was small, I think.
- 8:37She was like 5 years old. Right.
- 8:38And whispered into his bad ear, I'll love you till the day that
- 8:42I die, which is adorable. But he doesn't want to be
- 8:44trapped. He wants to be free.
- 8:46I want to be free. I want to do what I want to do.
- 8:48This is the one explosive anger scene that I kind of understand.
- 8:52Uncle Billy has effed the whole business up.
- 8:56He has $8000. He stops to crow at the bad guy,
- 9:02Potter about Harry's success, George's brother in the war, and
- 9:07somehow puts the money into a newspaper and hands it to
- 9:10Potter, who then doesn't mention, oh, you gave me $8000?
- 9:13Oh, this is your money. I think he's shoving the
- 9:16newspaper and he forgets that he has put the money inside the
- 9:19newspaper to take to the bank. He's lost the money.
- 9:22This is at the end of the film. George's in trouble.
- 9:24He's going to go to jail. The business is lost, The family
- 9:27is lost. Everything is lost.
- 9:29And George says, listen to me. Do you have any secret hiding
- 9:31place here in the house someplace?
- 9:33You could have put it someplace to hide the money.
- 9:34And Uncle Billy says I've been over the whole house, even in
- 9:37rooms that have been locked ever since I lost Laura.
- 9:39And that's the only mention he has of his Laura, his dead wife.
- 9:43Uncle Billy starts sobbing hysterically.
- 9:45George grabs him by the lapels and shakes him.
- 9:47Listen to me, listen to me think, think.
- 9:49I can't think anymore. George, I can't think.
- 9:51Anymore, it hurts, and then George jerks him to his feet and
- 9:55shakes him. Uncle Billy stands before him
- 9:57like a first criminal, all his pockets hanging out empty.
- 10:00Then as George is screaming maniacally, he says, where's
- 10:03that money, you stupid, silly old fool?
- 10:06Where's the money? Do you realize what this means?
- 10:08It means bankruptcy and scandal in prison.
- 10:11He throws Uncle Billy down into the the chair, still shouting at
- 10:14him. That's what it means.
- 10:16One of us is going to jail. Well, it's not going to be me.
- 10:19George turns his head for the door, kicking viciously at a
- 10:22wastebasket on the floor as he goes.
- 10:24Uncle Billy remains sobbing at a table, head in his arms.
- 10:28That's not okay. We've got emotional abuse, we've
- 10:31got physical abuse, we've got a transference to an object, which
- 10:34is a great tough guy move. I remember when I was married,
- 10:37that was one of the issues. My husband kicked a trash can in
- 10:41the door and we went to therapy and he said, well, what's wrong
- 10:44with kicking a trash can? And I said it's incredibly
- 10:46aggressive and it creates an environment that's really
- 10:49hostile and feels really threatening.
- 10:51Donna Reed butter won't melt in her mouth.
- 10:53She didn't do anything wrong this whole movie.
- 10:55She does do one thing wrong and that is carrying this man right.
- 11:00That was her first mistake and it wasn't great.
- 11:04I agree. This is an incredibly tense
- 11:06situation. He doesn't have to be happy, but
- 11:09he's screaming at a man who everybody knows that Uncle
- 11:13Billy's a couple sandwiches. Short of a picnic, he shouldn't
- 11:16have been given the opportunity to hold money.
- 11:19Why are we letting Uncle Billy do that?
- 11:20The only. Reason Uncle Billy has a job is
- 11:23that it's a family business. After this, George goes back to
- 11:26the family home and he decides, you know what?
- 11:28I haven't had enough screaming at an old man.
- 11:31I think I'm going to go scream at a bunch of.
- 11:32Children and my wife get up. He comes home, complaints about
- 11:35the house. Gosh, it's just this old house.
- 11:37I don't know why we don't all have pneumonia.
- 11:39This drafty old barn might as well be living in a
- 11:41refrigerator. Why do we have to live here in
- 11:43the 1st place and stay around this measly, crummy town?
- 11:45George, what's wrong? Wrong.
- 11:48Everything's wrong. You call this a happy family.
- 11:50Why do we have to have all these kids?
- 11:51Answer Because you're Catholic and you're not doing this thing
- 11:55to not have. Kids bro.
- 11:57Who got her pregnant? Did she get herself pregnant?
- 12:00I feel like you did that. That would be pretty tricky of
- 12:02her if she had. She would be a snake.
- 12:05Keith coming in Dad, how do you spell frankincense?
- 12:08George? I don't know.
- 12:09Ask your mother. He snatches the phone from Mary.
- 12:12Hello. And he tears into.
- 12:14This is Welch. Yeah, I'm Zuzu's father.
- 12:17He's named after a ginger cookie.
- 12:19What kind of a teacher are you, anyway?
- 12:20What do you mean sending her home like that half naked?
- 12:23You realize she'll probably end up with pneumonia on the cat of
- 12:25you. Well, why are you sending her to
- 12:26school half naked? And the answer is that she's
- 12:28going to exotic dancer school. And she's.
- 12:30She was. Well, her name is Zuzu, after
- 12:32all. It's kind of exotic.
- 12:34Zuzu was trying to hold on to her flowers, so she didn't quite
- 12:38close her coat properly. I don't think the flower, I
- 12:41don't think that she was half naked.
- 12:43I feel like that a little bit much.
- 12:45So then Mary, shocked, says George.
- 12:48She puts a restraining hand on his arm and he shakes it off.
- 12:51She cannot know that George's tirade against Mrs. Welch is
- 12:54really a tirade against the world, against life itself,
- 12:57against God. Over the phone, we hear Mrs.
- 12:59Welch's voice sputtering with protest.
- 13:02George, is this the sort of thing we pay taxes for?
- 13:05To have teachers like you? Silly, stupid, careless people
- 13:08who send our kids home without any clothes on?
- 13:10You know, maybe my kids aren't the best dressed kids.
- 13:13Maybe they don't have any decent some clothes.
- 13:15Mary succeeds in wrestling the phone from George's hand.
- 13:17George. Oh, that's stupid.
- 13:19Mary speaks quickly into the phone.
- 13:21Hello. Missus Welch, I want to
- 13:23apologize. And then we hear Missus Welch's
- 13:26voice. Now who do you think you are?
- 13:28George hears this and grabs the receiver from Mary.
- 13:30George to Mary, wait a minute on the phone.
- 13:33Hello, who's this? Oh Mr. Welch.
- 13:35OK, that's fine. Mr. Welch gives me a chance to
- 13:37tell you what I really think of your wife.
- 13:39Mary once more tries to take the phone from him.
- 13:41George says. Mary George raving at her.
- 13:44Will you get out and let me handle this?
- 13:46Into the phone shouting hello, hello what?
- 13:49OK, OK Mr. Welch, anytime you think you're man enough.
- 13:52Hello. And then Pete says Daddy, how do
- 13:55you spell Hallelujah? George shouts at his child.
- 13:58How should I know? What do you think I am a
- 14:00dictionary? He yells at Tommy noisily
- 14:03playing with his vacuum cleaner. George says Tommy stop that,
- 14:07stop it, Janie's still practicing the piano.
- 14:10George savagely says, Janie, haven't you learned that silly
- 14:13tune you've played? Said it over and over.
- 14:15Now stop it. Stop it.
- 14:16One of George's pressure points is education, spelling and being
- 14:22asked to know stuff. Potter is right about one thing.
- 14:25He's the smartest man in that town.
- 14:26George's. He is surrounded by people who
- 14:29don't understand how his savings and loan works.
- 14:31He should have gone to school. He should have been able to have
- 14:34the life he wanted, but he was born into or took on this
- 14:37responsibility. He carries a lot of resentment
- 14:40for it. When someone asks him how to
- 14:41spell something or how to do something, he is very angry.
- 14:45Then he goes on a tirade. The room has become ominously
- 14:49quiet, the only sound being George's labor breathing.
- 14:51George goes over to a corner of the room where his workshop is
- 14:53set up. A drawing table, models of
- 14:56modern buildings, etcetera, savagely kicks over the models,
- 14:59picks up some books and hurls them into the corner.
- 15:00The three children are crying. George, I'm sorry.
- 15:03Mary, Janie, I'm sorry. I didn't mean you.
- 15:06Go on and practice, Pete. I owe you an apology, too.
- 15:09I'm sorry. What do you want to know, Pete?
- 15:11Holding back tears. Nothing, Daddy.
- 15:13Pete has learned his lesson. Don't ask questions or daddy
- 15:17will scream and throw books around the house.
- 15:19That's so aggressive and creepy. So here are some of the features
- 15:23of Intermittent explosive Disorder.
- 15:25Recurrent behavioral outbursts representing a failure to
- 15:28control aggressive impulses as manifested by verbal aggression,
- 15:32Temper tantrums, tirades, verbal arguments or fights.
- 15:36All of the above. Or physical aggression towards
- 15:38property, animals, or other individuals.
- 15:41This says it's occurring twice weekly.
- 15:43I don't know if it's happening that often.
- 15:45For him. The physical aggression does not
- 15:47result in damage or destruction of property.
- 15:48Actually, probably does. Probably.
- 15:51Does imperial outburst involve damage or destruction of
- 15:54property and or physical assault involving both injury against
- 15:57animals or other individuals? The magnitude of aggressiveness
- 16:00expressed during the recurrent outburst is grossly out of
- 16:04proportion to the provocation of any precipitating psychosocial
- 16:07stressors. 1 might argue there's a lot of stressors.
- 16:11He's clearly projecting. What he's stressed out about is
- 16:13the loss of his home, family and liberty.
- 16:17And that's a huge problem. Big deal.
- 16:19Yeah. He's not really upset that his
- 16:21kid doesn't know how to spell that his other kids practicing
- 16:24piano or that Zuzu had to carry a flower on her way home from
- 16:29school. He's finding reasons to be
- 16:30angry. Scott did point out upon
- 16:32watching this film that Zuzu's pedals is the name of a band.
- 16:36We didn't know what came from the pedals he puts in his pocket
- 16:39when he's lying to his child about pacing them back onto the
- 16:42flower. I think that's probably another
- 16:44part of intermittent explosive disorder lying to your children,
- 16:47the part that I want to impress upon you.
- 16:50The recurrent aggressive outbursts are not premeditated,
- 16:53they are impulsive or anger based and are not committed to
- 16:56achieve some tangible objective. He's doing them without a plan
- 17:00and he's doing them really to blow off steam their.
- 17:03Family is very lucky that they don't have a dog because that
- 17:06dog would have got kicked. If he kicked a dog, I don't know
- 17:08if this would be the Christmas miracle that we all enjoy.
- 17:12Maybe there's a lost dog kicking scene that's been edited out to
- 17:15a modern audience. His outbursts are terrifying.
- 17:19I think at the time, that's just sometimes what would happen to
- 17:22daddies. Daddies would drink, Daddies
- 17:24would yell because we were all in the chokehold of the
- 17:27patriarchy. It's just something you had to
- 17:28deal with. I think that that's a very
- 17:30common scene. Because I was raised in the
- 17:32family that I was raised in at the time that I was first
- 17:36exposed to this movie, that didn't seem strange because
- 17:39that's what was happening in our house.
- 17:41George Bailey is anger issues. He may have intermittent
- 17:43explosive disorder. I think he he has chronic
- 17:46hotness the whole movie he's just uncomfortably hot.
- 17:48Amen. His.
- 17:49Coats too thick? Something's too thick, but he
- 17:53also has issues with depression. The thing I want to clarify is
- 17:58that he has depression, but it's not general depression, it's
- 18:01just based on the experience he's he's having right now.
- 18:05The first time George Bailey's on the bridge, he does pray and
- 18:08he says, dear Father in heaven, I'm not a praying man.
- 18:10But if you're up there and you can hear me, show me the way.
- 18:12I'm at the end of my rope. Show me the way.
- 18:14Yeah, no, me. That's been dealt with in the
- 18:17Christmas episode of Black Mirror, where the way they
- 18:20punish criminals is they get blanked out.
- 18:23You're not visible and not audible.
- 18:25Jon Hamm has committed a crime so heinous that no one on earth
- 18:29can see him or interact with him.
- 18:31That messes with George Bailey not being known and not being
- 18:34recognized. It's very hard because he spent
- 18:36a life building these relationships.
- 18:38Adjustment disorder with depression.
- 18:40These symptoms or behaviors are clinically significant, as
- 18:42evidenced by one or more of the following.
- 18:44Mark Distress that is out of proportion with the severity or
- 18:47intensity of the stressor, taking into account the external
- 18:50contacts and cultural factors that might influence symptoms,
- 18:52severity and presentation. Significant impairment in
- 18:55social, occupational or other important areas of functioning.
- 18:58The stress disturbance does not meet the criteria for another
- 19:01mental disorder and is merely an exacerbation or pre-existing
- 19:04mental disorder. The symptoms do not represent
- 19:06normal bereavement. So what I hear you saying is
- 19:09George Bailey is depressed with good reason, is not a free
- 19:13floating unattached depression. He's depressed because his life
- 19:16is depressing. Because he has low mood, he's
- 19:19tearful, he feels hopeless, but it's not a general part of who
- 19:23he. Is he's a pretty positive guy.
- 19:26That's why people are attracted to him, right?
- 19:28He's extremely upstanding. He's a very generous person.
- 19:31He's got a generous spirit. It does seem odd to me that
- 19:34every time he's about to leave town, something terrible happens
- 19:38with the family business. What are the?
- 19:39Odds. Does he have a hero's combo?
- 19:43I think he's very codependent. For me the line was when he's
- 19:47leaving on his honeymoon and they decide to save the building
- 19:51and loan lose all the money for the honeymoon.
- 19:53They end up in some rainy, rotten old house.
- 19:56She puts a cheery face on it, but that's depressing.
- 19:59That's rough as hell. Terrible events keep happening.
- 20:02The first one is he's planning on going on his European Tour.
- 20:06He is having a good time with Mary in a hydrangea Bush, but
- 20:11his father has a fatal stroke and so.
- 20:12He has to take over the business and he gives up his travel
- 20:15plans. The next thing is he wants to go
- 20:18to college, but he needs his brother Harry to come and take
- 20:21over the business and Harry's not going to.
- 20:22He's gotten married. He's going to go work for his
- 20:25father in law's business. Yeah, that's why he doesn't go
- 20:27the second time. The third time he's going to go
- 20:29on a honeymoon and there's a run on the bank.
- 20:32He loses $2000 to all these ingrates who don't know how
- 20:35building and loans work. He's depressed because his life
- 20:38hasn't worked out. He had goals and dreams and he
- 20:41didn't get to do any of them except for Mary.
- 20:43Mary. That was never his goal.
- 20:44He said. He didn't want to be married.
- 20:46He's depressed I think because he's given his whole life to
- 20:50other people, basically making everyone else happy, and then he
- 20:53finds himself, because of the incompetence of his uncle, in a
- 20:57terrible situation. When George is on the bridge and
- 21:01Clarence tries to save him, Clarence jumps in because he
- 21:04knows George will fish him out of the water.
- 21:06He understands what motivates George Bailey.
- 21:08He knows that George Bailey is codependent AF.
- 21:11Right, there's a real life story in Seneca Falls, not Bedford
- 21:14Falls. I think Bedford Falls was based
- 21:16on Seneca Falls. Right.
- 21:17This kid, Antonio, he is 19 years old, it's 1917 and he
- 21:22heard a young woman screaming for help.
- 21:25He rushed into canal and managed to bring her close enough to
- 21:27shore where another man helped pull her to the bank, but he
- 21:30drowned. The source is wonderful.
- 21:32lifemuseum.com. The original newspaper story
- 21:35mentioned the name of Ruth Dunham, but it did not mention
- 21:38her rescuer, calling him an Italian whose first name was
- 21:41Tony. There was a lot of racism
- 21:43against Itels. I'm realizing there was a part
- 21:47that I never understood before where Mr. Potter is screaming,
- 21:50you can have your garlic eaters. And I didn't realize, oh, that's
- 21:54an Italian slur. That's.
- 21:56That's really racist. That's real.
- 21:58Because I just thought, is he saying that the people which
- 22:01surrounds him with a really bad breath, I didn't understand that
- 22:05that was some sort of racial thing.
- 22:07Speaking of Mr. Potter, Henry F Potter, I'm going to say that
- 22:11Henry F Potter has narcissistic personality disorder and here
- 22:15are some quotes to support them. George Bailey says to Mr.
- 22:18Potter, Mr. Potter, what makes you such a hard sculled
- 22:21character? You have no family, no children.
- 22:23You can't begin to spend all the money you've got, Potter says.
- 22:26So I suppose I should give it to miserable failures like you and
- 22:29that idiot brother of yours. Suspend for me, Peter Bailey
- 22:32says. Oh, he's a sick man.
- 22:34This is before he has a stroke. Frustrated and sick.
- 22:37Sick in his mind. Sick in his soul, if he has one.
- 22:40Hates everybody that has anything that he can't have.
- 22:43Hates us mostly I guess. He's a Scrooge Mcduck.
- 22:46The only way he feels good about himself is lording his money
- 22:50over others, and he has more money than he could spend in a
- 22:52lifetime. Who does that remind you of?
- 22:54Every billionaire that's ruining our country.
- 22:56I found myself a lot during this movie feeling like wow, this was
- 23:0180 years ago and absolutely nothing has changed.
- 23:04Things have changed, Laura, but for the worse.
- 23:06Working people cannot have homes now.
- 23:09They couldn't then either. I think that was the whole point
- 23:11Bailey made, this whole opportunity for these people
- 23:15where he created this building alone that made absolutely no
- 23:18money at all and it was basically a social safety net we
- 23:21don't have in our society now. Nobody is extending this
- 23:26charitable service of loaning money to people who are just
- 23:30getting by so that they can buy a home.
- 23:32Like George Bailey says, let a man work and then come home,
- 23:35have a little plot of land, 2 bedrooms and a bath.
- 23:38Yeah. It's not much, no.
- 23:41So here's another quote from Potter.
- 23:43George. Now, that's just what I like so
- 23:45much about you, George. I'm an old man and most people
- 23:48hate me, but I don't like them either.
- 23:50So that makes it all even. You know just as well as I do
- 23:53that I run practically everything in this town but the
- 23:56Bailey building alone. You know also that for a number
- 23:59of years I've been trying to get control of it or kill it, but I
- 24:01haven't been able to do it. You've been stopping me.
- 24:04In fact, you've beaten me, George, As anyone in this county
- 24:07can tell you, that takes some doing.
- 24:09Take during the Depression, for instance.
- 24:11You and I were the only ones who kept our heads.
- 24:13You saved the building alone, and I saved the rest.
- 24:16George said yes. Well, most people say you stole
- 24:19all the rest, and then Potter says the envious ones say that.
- 24:23George the Suckers. You once called me a warped,
- 24:26frustrated old man. So that's the scene where he's
- 24:28offering him a job, right? And now I'm reading the scene at
- 24:31the end where George Bailey is asking him for money and the
- 24:33job, by the way, it would be like $300,000 in today's money,
- 24:37An insane amount of money. You once called me a warped,
- 24:39frustrated old man. What are you, a warped,
- 24:41frustrated young man? Oh, that's a real burn.
- 24:44Score one for Potter, a miserable little clerk crawling
- 24:47in here on your hands and knees and begging for help.
- 24:49No security, no stocks, no bonds, nothing but a miserable
- 24:53little $500 equity in a life insurance policy.
- 24:55You're worth more dead than alive.
- 24:57Why do you go to the riffraff you love so much, ask them, and
- 24:59let you have 8000? You know why?
- 25:01Because they'd run you out of town on a rail, which is not
- 25:03what happens. But to Potter, he feels spurned
- 25:07because he offered George Bailey a great job in exchange for his
- 25:10soul. Same thing happened in Flash
- 25:12Gordon, by the way. Ming the Merciless says, I see
- 25:14something in you, kid. Let me give you the earth to
- 25:17rule over. And Flash Gordon says he doesn't
- 25:19want. That George Bailey have that in
- 25:21common. Mr. Potter is miserable and he's
- 25:24making other people miserable, and that's how he likes it.
- 25:27He also has that grandiosity. He's talking about the suckers,
- 25:30right? He thinks everyone's beneath
- 25:32him. He thinks he's the best person
- 25:34in the room. He's the smartest person in the
- 25:35room. He's the richest person in the
- 25:37room. I also think he's a sociopath.
- 25:39We don't have to go that far. I think he has a sociopath
- 25:41because even a businessman who was not interested in
- 25:45maintaining your business, he would have had some sort of
- 25:48scruples about stealing money. Like he's stole that money from
- 25:52Bill Bailey. Yeah, but I think any decent
- 25:55narcissist would do the same because it's about operating my
- 25:57own self-interest. And I suppose because Bill had
- 26:00been shoving his face in the fact that Harry's a war hero, he
- 26:03felt justified. Oh, I'll just keep this life
- 26:06changing amount of money, this life destroying amount of money.
- 26:08Because he's always looking out for numeral.
- 26:11You know the only reason he offered him that job is because
- 26:14he had his own self-interest in mind.
- 26:16Because he was told by his employee the only reason why
- 26:20there wasn't a Pottersville is because of George.
- 26:22If you want to hear more about personality disorders, you can
- 26:25listen to our Crunchy Nutty Cluster Bees episode.
- 26:28But here's some of the highlights of narcissistic
- 26:30personality disorder. A grandiose sense of self
- 26:32importance. Preoccupied with fantasies of
- 26:35unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal
- 26:38love. I don't think he's worried about
- 26:39ideal love, but he definitely wants success.
- 26:41Belief in himself being special, requiring excessive admiration.
- 26:45I think this is the big one. Interpersonally exploitative,
- 26:49Takes advantage of others in order to achieve his own ends.
- 26:52Lacks empathy, obviously sense of entitlement.
- 26:55Envious of others. I think he is very envious.
- 26:58He's envious of your whole family, how they hang together,
- 27:02they love each other. He doesn't have any of that.
- 27:04Right. And also the community loves
- 27:06them. I think he wants that adoration
- 27:09and he's not ever going to get it because he's a garbage human.
- 27:11Arrogant, haughty behaviors or attitudes.
- 27:14He's got all of the above. Let's talk about Uncle Billy.
- 27:17He clearly has ADHD. Inattentive type.
- 27:21He's got string on the fingers that he can't remember what the
- 27:24strings are for. He misses George's wedding.
- 27:26He forgets to finish things. He has a bird for a pet.
- 27:31His wife is dead. Sometimes is.
- 27:33That because of his ADHD. Who knows?
- 27:36Maybe he left the stone. On You don't know how Laura
- 27:39died. Well, aren't you going to make a
- 27:40deposit? Sure, I am.
- 27:42Well, then it's usually customary to bring the money
- 27:44with you. Oh, shucks.
- 27:46Uncle Billy searches through every pocket he has, looks
- 27:48bewildered. I know.
- 27:49I had to tell her knowing the old man's vagaries points to one
- 27:52of the numerous strings tied around his fingers.
- 27:53I should have my head examined $8000.
- 27:55It's got to be somewhere. So ADHD.
- 27:58Inattentive Poor listening skills check.
- 28:00Loses and or misplaces items needed to complete activities or
- 28:04tasks, Check. Big check.
- 28:06Sidetracked by external or unimportant stimuli Inattentive.
- 28:10Forgets daily activities check. Has a bird check.
- 28:13Diminished attention span. Avoids or is disinclined to
- 28:17begin activities requiring concentration.
- 28:20Fails to focus on details. He's a sweetheart.
- 28:22He's a kind man, he's kind of a fun guy, but he is unemployable
- 28:26in money matters. I don't know what Bill possibly
- 28:29could do for the firm. He is there as a personality
- 28:32hire. I think he could be a
- 28:34professional juggler, potentially out front of the
- 28:36building and loan. Perhaps so.
- 28:38He's got crippling ADHD. He cannot win for losing.
- 28:42Let's talk about Donna Reed for a SEC, because I want to give a
- 28:45couple flowers. This is from the article The
- 28:47Problem with It's a Wonderful Life.
- 28:49Would Donna Reed's character really have lost her sight
- 28:52without Jimmy Stewart? Because she read?
- 28:55Too many books, Laura. She's got her nose buried in a
- 28:59book because she's an old maid and that's the worst thing that
- 29:04could happen to a woman, you hear me?
- 29:05The worst thing on earth. She's got to have a job.
- 29:09She has to work. And she didn't have children.
- 29:11My God, what purpose could she possibly have?
- 29:14I don't know. Clearly none.
- 29:16It is one of the climaxes of the film.
- 29:18George Bailey realizes with misery and terror that had he
- 29:20never been born, Mary would now be not only single but, gasp, A
- 29:25librarian. It concludes, therefore, that
- 29:28his life was meaningful if only because he saved people from
- 29:32death, ruin, and the sheer misery of a single woman who is
- 29:35perpetually in circulation. Or, as Joanne Brokaw puts it,
- 29:39thank God George saved her from a life of independence and
- 29:42learned. It's a very sweet idea that
- 29:45people are created for each other and that there was one man
- 29:48in the world for Mary Hatch. If there was no George Bailey,
- 29:51she would not have fallen in love with George Bailey.
- 29:53She would have fallen in love with Sam or one of the other.
- 29:55People, it's ridiculous. And I also feel like she's, I
- 29:59want to say codependent, but I don't think she is.
- 30:01I think she's a woman of her time.
- 30:03I think she knows my husband is going completely off the rails
- 30:06and there's nothing I can do about it really, because what am
- 30:09I going to do? I can't buy a house, I can't get
- 30:12credit, I have no opportunities. She's going to figure it out.
- 30:15And I I feel like to me, she's actually the real hero of this
- 30:19film because she's the one who holds the family together.
- 30:21She's the one who goes out in the streets with the basket and
- 30:24gets the money. He's just standing around with
- 30:26his punched lip and his drunkenness and his frazzled
- 30:29hair, smiling because his wife handled everything.
- 30:32There's a scene where it says Mary worked every night getting
- 30:36the house into some kind of a shape.
- 30:38OK. She's out there with a baby on
- 30:40one arm and a paintbrush in the other, and what's he doing
- 30:44working at a building and loan making no money?
- 30:47Complaining that the knob keeps coming off the banister.
- 30:50Glue it down. Fix it bro, your hands broke,
- 30:54you don't have access to wood glue.
- 30:56I want to give Mary her flowers because like you said, she
- 30:59didn't do anything wrong. And what does she get in her
- 31:01payment for that? A man screaming and getting
- 31:03drunk and running their car into a tree.
- 31:05I also want to make a shout out to Annie.
- 31:07She doesn't have a last name because she's a person of color
- 31:11who works for the Bailey family. She gets sexually harassed,
- 31:14slapped by one of her employers, which is not OK.
- 31:19And then at the end, they treat her like she's real dumb, which
- 31:22I think is not fair. But she says in the end, she'd
- 31:24been saving money for her divorce, but then she'd never
- 31:27gotten married. And I thought, you know what,
- 31:29Annie? You're probably the smartest
- 31:31person in this room, Violet. Bick She spends the whole movie
- 31:35dating men, chasing men, being boy crazy and in the end she's
- 31:39broke and she needs a loan from George Bailey to move to New
- 31:42York and. Onto the lake with him.
- 31:44She could have been his wife. That's not who she is and he
- 31:47knew that. She wants to be taken out to
- 31:49dinner, have a fancy time. She's not going to get dirt on
- 31:52her fingernails or single handedly transform a battered
- 31:57down house. She's more of a fancy lady that
- 31:59she spent her whole life in service of men.
- 32:02It got her nothing. Nobody married her.
- 32:05Nobody will give her money. And then the alternative
- 32:08universe, she ended up being a drunk stripper, which is not
- 32:12great. Drunk angry stripper.
- 32:14I did not realize until watching it this time that that was a
- 32:18strip club. It was the strip club of its
- 32:19time, the Diamond Dance Hall Girl.
- 32:21It's what happens in Sweet Charity.
- 32:24That's what Shirley MacLaine does.
- 32:26It's in the Pat Benatar video. If those women had actually
- 32:31taken their clothes off on stage, people would have died of
- 32:33shock. You could handle a girl, you
- 32:35could dance with her for money. And so that was the progenitor.
- 32:38I mean, there were cabarets and stuff going on in Paris.
- 32:41Although Buffalo gals. That was a very racist sounding
- 32:44song as I was listening to it this time well as.
- 32:47Well, what it really was is these are the dancing girls that
- 32:50would tour with Buffalo Bill's Wild West show.
- 32:52OK good. I thought it was some native.
- 32:54Inviting thing it is, Yes. I was wondering about that as
- 32:56well. It's like the Calamity Jane.
- 32:58The original song Buffalo Gals was from a minstrel performer,
- 33:02John Hodges. OK, that's why as lovely fan
- 33:07when you come out tonight spelled cum so there is a
- 33:11questionable. There may be it may be
- 33:13prostitutes also, but it. Seems like they might be
- 33:16prostitutes who are people of color.
- 33:18Violet gets screwed every way to Sunday, and what is her major
- 33:23malfunction? Just.
- 33:24Wanting nice dresses, she's. Looking for male attention.
- 33:28And I mean I would just say she's probably somewhere in the
- 33:31cluster B Histrionic. Histrionic.
- 33:34So fun trivia fact, I didn't realize until this watching in
- 33:37the movie that the opening of the ballroom floor was being
- 33:40done specifically at George because one of the kids is mad
- 33:44at him. The kid who opens the ballroom
- 33:46floor is Alfalfa from our gang. Oh wow.
- 33:50Hey, Virginia has a special connection.
- 33:53Special connection to that artwork.
- 33:54To our gang, he's mad because he's trying to get things moving
- 33:59with Mary. Somebody was C blocked.
- 34:01Virginia, what are your final thoughts on this wonderful film?
- 34:05It's a Wonderful Life. My final thoughts are despite
- 34:08the anti Italian sentiment and George's wild rages, it's still
- 34:15a very sweet and heart warming film.
- 34:17I think the core message is good.
- 34:19Should George have abandoned his family business and gone and did
- 34:24what he wanted to do? On the one hand, yeah it would
- 34:27destroy the town, but in almost every iteration the town gets
- 34:30destroyed anyway. I think that's this frustration
- 34:32at the end. The core of it is that he has
- 34:34sacrificed again and again and again and he just can't pull
- 34:39this business out of the swamp. To feel that you have given
- 34:42everything for this business and it's led to nothing is hard.
- 34:46Do you think George should have just taken his own life?
- 34:48Probably. It's adorable.
- 34:50Donna Reed. If she'd had any sense, she
- 34:52would have gone out with Alfalfa or the guy who gets super rich.
- 34:56Sam's not a bad guy. He does this really annoying
- 34:59donkey thing I really don't enjoy.
- 35:01Maybe she could have talked him out of that.
- 35:03George is the complicated character.
- 35:05He is not all positivity, but he has worked most of his life to
- 35:10improve the lives of others, which is not a bad message.
- 35:13What do you think? My final thoughts are watching
- 35:16it from a psychological perspective.
- 35:18This time was a little bit different.
- 35:20I think I've also grown incredibly intolerant of men's
- 35:24shenanigans. Reference our boyfriend's cringe
- 35:28episode. I think I wasn't so bothered by
- 35:31his screaming before. If I had been Mary in that
- 35:34moment with the phone call, this man's yelling at me, trying to
- 35:38kiss me, that would have been it for me.
- 35:40And. That's going to be a no for me.
- 35:41Done. Sorry dog, that's not it.
- 35:43I don't want that to be a feature of any relationship that
- 35:47I enter into. Intermittent Explosive Disorder
- 35:49is not for me. My take away is that Mary is the
- 35:52hero of this film. Quietly laboring behind the
- 35:55scenes, right, and sacrificing her honeymoon.
- 35:58She had a moment where I think she really could have pressed
- 36:01it. She makes the decision to stand
- 36:03by Herman and his family business, and that's what she
- 36:06does. And I do like the idea that
- 36:09Martini and his family pretty much owe everything to George
- 36:13and what the building and loan did for them.
- 36:15And I think we need to look out for our neighbors.
- 36:18I felt like this is a very socialist coded film.
- 36:20Yeah, and I like that because I am a socialist.
- 36:24That we need to lookout for each other, I believe we need to take
- 36:26care of each other, and we all do deserve A2 bedrooms and a
- 36:30bath to live in and die in in the end.
- 36:33In the alternate reality where we see Pottersville, everyone is
- 36:36so unhappy and drunk and I guess it's because they don't have
- 36:39houses. I think that if it were remade
- 36:41today, they might have turned George down a bit.
- 36:44Oh you mean like his aggressiveness?
- 36:45I also found out that Jimmy Stewart had PTSD and depression.
- 36:49I think that's part of why his character was so rich and varied
- 36:53and complicated, because I think he was those things right.
- 36:56He was just coming back from the Korean War.
- 36:59Yeah. And he wasn't sure he was ready
- 37:01to make a movie. Capra was like, Nah, Nah, you're
- 37:04good. I think that you're right.
- 37:05I think that his experiences just enriched him as an actor
- 37:09and brought a lot to the film. We all got to benefit from it.
- 37:12So I hope that this motivates a couple of us to watch It's a
- 37:15Wonderful Life, despite the fact that it didn't used to have a
- 37:18copyright on it. I had to pay $2.00 to watch it
- 37:21on Prime but that's OK. Luckily I own the DVD.
- 37:24The real Christmas spirit is caring for other people, I think
- 37:27especially in times where we are now where it's tough and we all
- 37:31want to self-care with capitalist purchases.
- 37:35Or going to the strip club or drinking alcohol just like all
- 37:39those people in the movie. I don't know if we should all be
- 37:41living in drafty old houses with 100 kids, but I do think we
- 37:44should be looking out for our neighbors and caring about
- 37:47people. Even the people that are
- 37:48different. From us and for God's sakes,
- 37:51learn how to spell frankincense. It's not that hard.
- 37:55When you're trying to approach a woman, please do not shake her
- 37:58by the shoulders and scream at her.
- 38:00Yeah, when you're experiencing basically your first courting
- 38:03event, the fact that she went in for that, there is something
- 38:07wrong with Mary. Yeah, that's there's something
- 38:09about Mary that was some problematic behavior that Mary
- 38:12tolerated, and I would not recommend that if you're dating
- 38:16at the moment, Virginia, if you don't want to cry about Frank
- 38:19Capra movies, you want instead maybe sit in a public toilet and
- 38:23watch a woman. Where would people find out
- 38:26about you? Great.
- 38:27Thank you. Great question.
- 38:28If you're local to Portland, I'm doing a ton of shows this
- 38:31holiday season during Corvallis. I will be doing a don't tell
- 38:34show. It's a secret, so I shouldn't
- 38:36tell you, but it's January 17th. You can find out all about it on
- 38:39my website woowowa.vidinia.com. You can check out my TikTok,
- 38:43Vidinia and my Instagram, which is at Vidinia.
- 38:46There's a pattern here if you can ever figure it out.
- 38:48If you're not local to Portland, but you're just starving for
- 38:51more Virginia Jones content, my album Gothic American is
- 38:54available on Apple band camp, Amazon Music.
- 38:58It's available anywhere where you can spend I think $5 to get
- 39:01it. So give yourself a little treat
- 39:03this Christmas. Let's.
- 39:04Give Virginia a couple of dollars in her stocking this
- 39:08year. Laura, where can people find you
- 39:10if they wish to do so? If you're interested in working
- 39:12with me professionally and you live in the state of Texas, you
- 39:15can find me at lauraryan.org. If you're interested in watching
- 39:20my amazing AI content and ads for our podcast, you can find me
- 39:26at I am Laura Ryan on TikTok. If you want to get in touch with
- 39:30the show like Zach. If you want your own corner, you
- 39:33can find us on Instagram at My Sisters the Therapist Instagram
- 39:37and if you want to listen to all the episodes in one place, you
- 39:40can go to mysistersatherapist.com.
- 39:42If you would like to hire us, you can check us out at Hire Us
- 39:48at my Sisters a therapist.com and we're available for all
- 39:50kinds of things. You want to sell your Bedford
- 39:53Falls sweatshirts? You can contact us.
- 39:57If you are working for some of our favorite brands, including.
- 40:02But not limited. To Kirkland, Costco brand,
- 40:05Liquid Death, Imperfect Foods, Waterloo, please write us at
- 40:10hire us at mysisters@therapist.com and we
- 40:13will promote many, many things on this podcast and we will do
- 40:16it pretty shamelessly. It has to be a vegan thing and
- 40:19not have animals in it. So if you're trying to sell your
- 40:22zebra juice, we're not going to have it.
- 40:24Your beef tallow that's that's going to be if you want to sell
- 40:27us your goose meatballs somewhere else to go.
- 40:32If you have a show idea or just a compliment, you can write us
- 40:35at Hello at mysisters@therapist.com.
- 40:38If you would like to write us a review out of your kindness of
- 40:42your heart and holiday spirit, you can review us not just on
- 40:45Apple, but also on Audible or Spotify and we will see all of
- 40:49them and we will appreciate all of them.
- 40:52Laura, Speaking of reviews, now's the time of the show where
- 40:54you sometimes read a review or a nice e-mail we got.
- 40:57Do you have one to share this week?
- 40:58I certainly do. This is an audible review from
- 41:01Shannon Brown. Free therapy and stand up in one
- 41:04place. I love my sister's therapist
- 41:07podcast. Every Thursday, I look forward
- 41:08to the latest episode. This show has become a staple in
- 41:11my podcast rotation and a reminder that we can make it,
- 41:14baby, because we're all in this together.
- 41:16Thanks, Virginia and Laura for the education and laughs.
- 41:19Thank you, Shannon. We.
- 41:20Would like to leave you with the words that Shannon Brown
- 41:22referenced, the words of our spiritual founder Billy Ray
- 41:25Valentine as we remember him through the holiday season and
- 41:28all the year. We can make it, baby.
- 41:30Me and you. Bye bye.