Latest / The Confessional Booth / Where Shame Comes From
Transcript
- Marie Wagner: Welcome back to the confessional booth. This is a space where we bring voice to what has been hidden, where we begin to untangle the stories that have lived quietly beneath the surface for years, sometimes decades, and where we start to understand that what we carry in our bodies is often much older than we realize. Because so much of what we call our patterns, our blocks, our fears, our inability to fully open, to fully trust, to fully receive love, intimacy, pleasure, connection, often did not begin with us. And that is what I want to talk about today. I want to talk about where shame comes from. Because if we are going to deconstruct shame, If we are going to soften its grip on the body and begin to create new pathways in the nervous system, then we first have to understand its origins. We have to understand that shame is rarely something we consciously decided to believe. It is something we learned, something we absorbed, something that was imprinted into the body before we had the language, the maturity or the nervous system. capacity to make sense of it. And this is such an important distinction, because when people experience shame, there is often this underlying belief that says, this is just who I am. This is just how I'm wired. This is my personality. And what I want to offer today is that so much of what feels inherent is actually inherited. inherited does not mean permanent. There is a quote from John Bradshaw that has stayed with so many people in this work. He said, Shame is the feeling that there is something wrong with us. And what he spent so much of his work exploring was this idea of toxic shame. Shame that moves beyond a healthy awareness of our actions and becomes fused with identity. I made a mistake, but I am the mistake. And that kind of shame rarely develops overnight. It is built slowly, quietly, repeatedly, through moments, messages, experiences, and environments that teach the body to associate being fully seen with danger. And if we are honest, Most of us learned this very early, usually first through family. Family is our first nervous system environment. Before we ever understand language, before we can rationally interpret what is happening around us, our bodies are reading signals. We are constantly scanning. Am I safe here? Am I accepted here? Am I welcome in my full expression? and children are extraordinarily perceptive. They feel tension before they understand conflict. They feel withdrawal before they understand disapproval. They feel the contraction in a parent's body before they understand why it is happening. And because a child's nervous system is wired for attachment, they almost always internalize what feels unsafe as meaning something about themselves. So if a child is expressive and they are repeatedly told they are too much, too loud, too emotional, too sensitive, too curious, too sexual, too needy, the child doesn't think, my caregiver is dysregulated. They think there must be something wrong with me. And this is how shame begins embedding itself into the physiology. Because a body starts pairing self-expression with disconnection. The moment authenticity leads to withdrawal, criticism, punishment, or even subtle emotional distancing, the nervous system learns at a very early age, expression is not safe. And what does the body do when something feels unsafe? It adapts. It contracts. It protects. Maybe that protection looks like becoming very quiet and agreeable. Maybe it looks like becoming hyper performing and perfect. Maybe it looks like disconnecting emotionally. Maybe it looks like becoming highly attuned to everyone else's needs. while abandoning your own. These are not personality flaws. These are brilliant nervous system adaptations. And so often they are shame responses. Then there is religion. And this is such a layered conversation because for many people, faith can offer profound belonging, purpose and healing. But when religion becomes fused with fear, control or moral rigidity around the body, especially around sexuality, it can become one of the strongest carriers of shame. How many people grew up receiving explicit or implicit messages that desire itself was dangerous, that curiosity was sinful, that pleasure was indulgent, that pleasure was sinful, that the body was something to overcome rather than inhabit. And what happens when a natural biological experience, arousal, attraction, pleasure, desire is repeatedly met with fear-based messaging. The nervous system becomes confused because biologically, the body experiences these sensations as natural activation. Blood flow increases, breath changes, hormones shift, there is aliveness. And then cognitively, emotionally, socially, another message arrives. This is wrong. And when those two experiences collide, natural physiological arousal and learned moral fear, the body often stores that contradiction as shame. This is where so many people become split. Part of them longs for connection, intimacy, desire, pleasure, and another part braces against it, judges it. suppresses it, fears what it means. And this is not because they are broken, it is because their nervous system learned to associate embodiment with threat. This is why people can deeply desire intimacy and simultaneously shut down when it becomes available. The body remembers what the mind may not consciously recall. Then there is culture. Our culture shapes shame in ways that are often so normalized we do not even notice them. The cultural messages around masculinity, around femininity, around what desire should look like, around who gets to express it and how. For men, shame often gets wired around vulnerability. The message becomes, do not cry, do not need, do not soften, do not falter. And so many men learn. to override their body's signals, to suppress emotional sensation, to disconnect from tenderness, to confuse performance with presence. And because suppressed emotion does not disappear, it often re-routes itself through the body into tension, into numbness, anxiety, sexual performance pressure. Hypervigilance, difficulty receiving. For women, cultural shame often lands around desirability and permission. Be desirable, but not too sexual. Be expressive, but not too much. Be open, but not too available. And this creates a different kind of nervous system fragmentation. One where women often become externally attuned. to how they are being perceived rather than internally attuned to what they are actually feeling. And this is one of the deepest ways shame disconnects us from ourselves. It pulls awareness outward into monitoring, into performance, into self-surveillance and away from embodied presence. This is something Brene Brown speaks to so beautifully when she says that shame needs secrecy, silence and judgment to survive. And I think what is so powerful about that framing is that it reminds us that shame thrives in isolation. It thrives when what was imprinted remains unnamed. Because once we begin to bring language to it, once we begin to understand where it came from, the nervous system begins to loosen its grip. Naming creates space. Understanding creates regulation. Compassion creates possibility. And then there are the early imprints that do not always come from dramatic events. Sometimes shame is not one defining moment. Sometimes it is repetition. The subtle facial expression. The withheld affection. The look of disappointment. The joke made at your expense. The silence after a vulnerable disclosure. These moments accumulate and the body records them. Neuroscience tells us that repeated experiences shape neural pathways. The brain becomes efficient at predicting what will happen next. So repeated experiences taught your body that being visible leads to rejection. Your system will anticipate rejection, even in situations where it is no longer present. This is why adult shame responses can feel irrational. You might logically know you are safe and yet your body still braces, still contracts, still prepares for judgment. That is not weakness that is imprinting. And this is also why healing shame requires more than insight. You cannot simply think your way out of a pattern your nervous system learned through repeated embodied experience. You have to create new experiences, new moments of being seen and remaining safe. New experiences of truth and connection. New moments where your body learns, I can reveal this and still belong. I can feel this and remain safe. I can be fully expressed and not lose connection. That is the deeper work. And this is why confession is so powerful. Because every time we tell the truth in a regulated space, every time we bring something hidden into compassionate witness, we offer the nervous system corrective experience. We begin teaching the body something new. So if today's conversation brings anything forward for you, I want you to sit with this question. What beliefs about yourself did you inherit before you ever had the chance to choose them? What stories about your body, your desire, your worth, your voice were handed to you? And more importantly, are they actually yours? Because awareness is the beginning of freedom. The moment you begin tracing shame back to its origin, it starts losing its authority. You begin seeing it for what it is, not truth, not identity, but conditioning and imprinting. And conditioning and imprinting can be rewritten. This is the work, not forcing yourself to become someone else, but gently, patiently teaching your body that who you have always been is safe to become. This is the confessional booth, a space where what has been hidden is finally given breath, voice, and room to move. I'll see you in the next episode. Thanks for being here.