Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a concept in economics called the law of diminishing marginal returns. The classic example is a factory — you add more workers to a fixed amount of machinery, and eventually each new worker adds less output than the one before. Luna: Right, the first few workers are super productive, but by the time the floor is crowded, they're just getting in each other's way. Lucas: Exactly. And I think that same dynamic plays out constantly in office politics. We have a tendency to double down on something that worked once — a certain relationship, a certain skill, a certain strategy — and we keep pouring energy into it, even when the returns have clearly flattened. Luna: So you're saying that more effort doesn't always mean more influence? Lucas: Right. In fact, after a certain point, more effort can mean negative returns — you start annoying people, burning yourself out, or missing bigger opportunities because you're over-invested in one area. Let me give you a concrete case. Luna: I'm listening. Lucas: I was talking to a marketing manager at a mid-sized tech company — let's call her Priya. She was responsible for launching a new product line, and she had this one stakeholder, the head of sales, who was notoriously difficult. He'd shoot down her ideas, miss meetings, and demand last-minute changes. Luna: Classic office politics sandbag. Lucas: Exactly. Priya decided the only way to win him over was to invest heavily in that relationship. She started having weekly one-on-ones with him, prepping detailed decks for his feedback, even joining his team's offsites. She was spending probably 80 percent of her political capital on this one person. Luna: That sounds exhausting. And did it work? Lucas: At first, yes. The first few conversations built some trust. He started showing up to her meetings. But around week six, she noticed that those one-on-ones were producing less and less. He'd cancel, or he'd give vague feedback. Meanwhile, she was neglecting other stakeholders — the product team, the CFO's office, the customer support lead — who could have been much bigger allies. Luna: So she hit the diminishing returns inflection point and didn't see it. Lucas: Exactly. She was so focused on the one difficult relationship that she missed the fact that her effort to influence ratio had peaked. And honestly, this is a trap I think a lot of us fall into — we assume that if a little bit of something works, a lot more will work even better. Luna: There's a parallel in skill development too, right? Like, you spend your first year learning Excel and you get huge productivity gains. But by year five, mastering pivot table animations might only save you thirty seconds a month. Lucas: That's a great example. And the same goes for networking. The first few coffees with someone in a new department can open doors. The twentieth coffee with the same person — assuming you're not working on a joint project — probably has a much smaller return. Luna: So how do you recognize when you've crossed that line? Lucas: I think the most practical thing is to keep a rough mental ledger of your effort versus the outcome. Not a spreadsheet — just a periodic check-in. Ask yourself: 'Is this relationship or project still giving me a good return on the time I'm putting in?' If you feel like you're grinding without seeing new results, you've probably passed the peak. Luna: And what do you do then? Just abandon the relationship? Lucas: Not necessarily. You don't cut ties — you just recalibrate. Priya, for example, scaled back her one-on-ones with the sales head to once a month and started investing that reclaimed time in the CFO's office. Within two weeks, she had a champion for her budget request. She didn't lose the sales head — she just stopped over-investing in diminishing returns. Luna: So the principle is: diversify your political investments, just like you'd diversify a portfolio. Lucas: Exactly. And the framing matters — you're not giving up on someone, you're rebalancing. The law of diminishing marginal returns doesn't mean you stop investing. It means you stop over-investing in one area when another area would give you a higher marginal return. Luna: I think this also applies to how you present yourself. If you're known as 'the person who always volunteers for extra work,' that reputation gets you some initial goodwill. But after a while, people just expect it, and the political benefit drops off. Lucas: Absolutely. The halo effect can wear thin. So the trick is to be strategic about where you deploy your effort. And that brings me to a simple framework I use: the 80-20 audit. Luna: Go on. Lucas: List your top five work relationships and top five projects. Give each a rough score for effort — say one to ten — and a score for the influence or outcome you're getting from it. Then look for the ones where effort is high but outcome is medium or low. Those are your diminishing returns candidates. Luna: And then you reallocate the high-effort, low-outcome time to something with higher potential marginal return. Lucas: Exactly. And I want to be clear — the goal isn't to be transactional. It's to be intentional. Office politics is ultimately about influence, and influence requires energy. If you're spending all your energy on a single point, you're not going to have any left for the other points that matter. Luna: So the next time I find myself spending a third coffee prepping a stakeholder who already seems checked out, I should ask: is this really the best use of my political energy? Lucas: Right. And if today's conversation gave you a useful lens for thinking about that, I'll mention — the way we keep this show ad-free and focused on practical advice is through listener support. If you found value in this episode, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it genuinely helps us keep the lights on and the advice specific. Every contribution goes straight into making these episodes better. Lucas: So back to the audit framework. Once you identify those diminishing returns areas, the next step is to test a reallocation. Pick one relationship where you've been over-investing, and cut your effort by half for two weeks. Use that time to build a bridge to someone you've been neglecting. Luna: And see if the world ends. Spoiler: it usually doesn't. Lucas: Exactly. And you might find that the person you were over-investing in actually respects you more when you're not always available. There's a subtle power dynamic there. Luna: Scarcity principle in action. So the law of diminishing marginal returns isn't just about efficiency — it's also a political tactic. Lucas: Exactly. By being slightly less available, you change the perception of your time's value. And that can actually increase the return on the effort you do invest. Luna: I think the hardest part is the self-awareness. It's easy to keep doing what's comfortable, even if it's not effective. Lucas: That's why the audit is so useful — it forces you to look at the data of your own behavior. And the best time to do it is right now, not when you're already burned out. Luna: So, to sum up: the law of diminishing marginal returns is real in office politics. Don't be the person who keeps adding workers to a crowded factory floor. Lucas: Exactly. Diversify your political investments, audit your effort regularly, and be willing to rebalance. The goal isn't to work harder — it's to work smarter on the relationships and projects that give you the highest marginal return.