Latest / Politics with Paul / Redistricting Part 2: Can We Ensure Fair Districts in Elections? | Politics with Paul #97
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home from nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today is the second of a two parter about redistricting.
- 0:14And today, specifically about the question, can we ensure fair districts?
- 0:20We all want fair districts when it comes to elections, theoretically at least.
- 0:26But is that a realistic goal?
- 0:28At the very least, it is very difficult to do and for a lot of reasons that we may not
- 0:33realize or want to admit.
- 0:36Figuring out how to make elections the fairest they can be is not an easy task.
- 0:41And last week, we explored a lot of the finer details of how new districts are made.
- 0:47And now this week, we are going to talk about how those details can make drawing up fair maps
- 0:53more complicated, some of the proposals for making redistricting fairer, and whether it is
- 0:59even possible to ensure completely fair districts.
- 1:03So let's go back to something we talked about last week, some of the criteria that you often
- 1:09see when it comes to redistricting.
- 1:12And there's quite a few of them, but there's seven that you commonly see.
- 1:17Those being equal population where maps must have close to the same number of people per
- 1:22district.
- 1:22You can't really make it the exact same number of people, but there might be a few percentage
- 1:28points off from each other depending on state laws.
- 1:32You have to have racial minority representation in the sense that districts must not
- 1:36deliberately discriminate against voters of color.
- 1:38Now, again, the recent Louisiana versus Calais ruling does make that a little bit more
- 1:46complicated, but you still can't deliberately try to discriminate against voters of color.
- 1:53The third common criteria you see is contiguity, where districts must be physically
- 1:58connected whenever possible.
- 1:59Sometimes it's a little bit more difficult when you have parts like in coastal states that are
- 2:05separated.
- 2:06And so some of the stipulations for what is contiguous there can be a little bit different.
- 2:12Their maps must also respect political boundaries in the sense that they must limit
- 2:17the division of existing political borders such as those of cities and counties across these
- 2:23districts whenever it's possible.
- 2:26Districts have to be compact where maps must limit how geographically expansive districts
- 2:32are.
- 2:33They must also preserve communities of interest where these distinct groups like social,
- 2:40cultural, economic, historical, they must be preserved whenever they possibly can.
- 2:46And also they must not lead to partisan outcomes where they are heavily designed and
- 2:52deliberately so to favor one party or another.
- 2:55Now, not every state uses all of those criteria and even when they do use those criteria, they
- 3:04do not always define it the same exact way or even say it is absolutely necessary.
- 3:09Sometimes it's really just a matter of preference but not legally considered binding
- 3:16where like, we'd like to have you consider this specific
- 3:20criteria, but you don't absolutely need to do it.
- 3:23This kind of seems to defeat the purpose of having it in law, but that's how some states do
- 3:29it with some
- 3:30of these criteria.
- 3:31And so because these criteria are a lot different, remember the US constitution does
- 3:39not prescribe a lot when it comes to redistricting for how you make these new
- 3:47district lines.
- 3:48There's there's very little that the US constitution says and it delegates a lot of
- 3:52that power to the states through the tenth amendment because the tenth amendment says any
- 3:57power is not expressly given to the US government, the federal government, are given
- 4:01to the states.
- 4:02And so that leads to a lot of issues withholding these state legislatures to account
- 4:08on these criteria.
- 4:09It's kind of that double edged sword of states' rights.
- 4:12On one hand, federal government can't be super overbearing, but also state governments can go
- 4:19about their business the way they see fit to some extent.
- 4:23So when you see a redistricting process and say, that has to be illegal.
- 4:29There's no way that that could possibly be a fair map.
- 4:33According to those states' laws, it may technically not be.
- 4:37Now, the map can certainly be unethical or underhanded or according to another state's
- 4:45laws, it may be considered illegal.
- 4:47But in that particular state, it might not be because all these states have different ways
- 4:51that they do it and different criteria that must be followed.
- 4:54Then when they have the same criteria, they don't always define it the same way.
- 4:58For example, if we have to have districts that are compact, what truly makes a district
- 5:03compact?
- 5:04Does it have to be as squared off as possible?
- 5:07How much can it, you know, kind of squiggle off to the side where it has like these little
- 5:13tendrils for lack of a better term?
- 5:16Or what's truly equal population?
- 5:18How much should it should populations across these populations differ?
- 5:22Yeah.
- 5:22They must be relatively the same, but can they only differ by 1% or 2% or up to 10%?
- 5:31What are reasonable communities of interest?
- 5:34Because these communities of interest can be all sorts of different things.
- 5:37They can be economic and historical and cultural and social and even political.
- 5:45So which of these groups should be preserved?
- 5:50And if you do preserve them, do they start having too much power compared to other
- 5:56communities of interest?
- 5:57And then that gets into a whole other kind of debate that you have there depending on what
- 6:02those communities of interest you are talking about are.
- 6:06How do you try to draw a map that isn't partisanally biased in a state where the
- 6:11electorate is already lopsided towards one party.
- 6:14And we're actually gonna talk about that kind of scenario in just a bit.
- 6:19But you see how some of these things can be very difficult to make states adhere to.
- 6:26It's very easy to say, oh, well, you know, we should have fair districts.
- 6:29But what exactly entails fair districts?
- 6:31Well, they should be compact.
- 6:32Okay.
- 6:33How exactly do you make them compact?
- 6:35Especially when some states are more densely populated than other states are, or some states
- 6:43can vary widely in terms of whether they are densely populated in some areas and then
- 6:50sparsely populated in some areas.
- 6:52Because when you look at when you look at The United States in general and you look at how
- 6:56different areas vote for party, you'll see a ton of red and relatively little blue.
- 7:03So it makes it look like, oh, there's a lot more voting for Republicans compared to
- 7:07Democrats.
- 7:08Well, not necessarily.
- 7:09It's because Democrats tend to be a lot more condensed in urban areas, so they look like
- 7:14they take up a lot less space.
- 7:17And Republicans look like they take up a lot more space because those rural areas are a lot
- 7:21more sparsely populated and they're a lot more spread out.
- 7:26But if you can't agree on what criteria should be used, you're going to be talking past other
- 7:33people like legislators, other reformers and activists, lobbyists, and so on when it comes
- 7:40to trying to make rules fairer for redistricting.
- 7:44Forget about political incentives.
- 7:46Even if you find people across the political aisle that genuinely want to make the
- 7:52redistricting process more fair, they may have different ideas of what criteria should be
- 7:58followed and how exactly to follow those criteria.
- 8:05And even if you do agree on what criteria to use, you have to agree on how to define it,
- 8:11which can also be tough.
- 8:12So how do you go about defining criteria?
- 8:14When you put anything into law, you'll see that it's written in what people call legalese,
- 8:21which is sometimes used in a kind of joking manner, but a lot of times it is actually
- 8:26officially called legalese because when you look at laws, they are written in a certain way
- 8:32where they're not written in a way that we would talk to each other normally.
- 8:37No normal person would talk
- 8:39to each other in those ways.
- 8:42So that's how a lot of laws are written.
- 8:45And so and the way that it's written can matter a great deal when it comes to interpretation of
- 8:51laws because a lot of lawyers get paid big bucks to make laws say whatever they want the
- 8:57laws to say and then argue that in front of courts.
- 9:00And some courts and some judges may be more amenable to certain interpretations than others
- 9:05will.
- 9:07But you also have to think about when you're making these criteria, should you make it more
- 9:11of a vague criteria or a more specific criteria?
- 9:16Talked about earlier how some criteria is used as more of a, like, preference.
- 9:25Like, we like you to do this, but you don't have to do this.
- 9:27But not only that, what exactly do they tell you to do to respect that criteria?
- 9:33Is there a very specific way that they want you to make a district more compact or more
- 9:39contiguous or respectful of trying to balance partisanship.
- 9:46If you make provisions, and not just in the case of redistricting, but in any law that you
- 9:51make, when
- 9:52you make laws too vague, it can
- 9:55become unenforceable because there's no real guidelines for how to do it.
- 10:01Or these provisions can be attacked for being wishy washy or not strong enough and so you
- 10:06won't get support for them.
- 10:08But then if you get too specific, now it can start to become inflexible and now people can
- 10:14start attacking it for the specific provisions that includes.
- 10:17They might say that the law is now too rigid or that it doesn't include these other specific
- 10:23circumstances that can be very reasonable to talk about.
- 10:31And if you are going to change redistricting laws, it's mostly going to come from amending
- 10:37state constitutions because that's where a lot of these laws are baked in.
- 10:42And if you're going to change state constitutions, means you're going to go through
- 10:45a much more grueling procedure trying to change these laws than your normal state legislative
- 10:49process where the legislature goes through its normal writing a bill, going through
- 10:55committees, going in front of the houses, and then they have both both chambers of a
- 11:00legislature have to, whether it's state governments or the federal government, have to
- 11:04agree on the exact same warning.
- 11:06They pass it on, and the state executive signs off on it.
- 11:09If it's congress, that's gonna be president.
- 11:11If it's a state government, that's gonna be that state's governor.
- 11:15And, obviously, that's even though that is a difficult process, it's not nearly as
- 11:19difficult, generally speaking, as it is to amend state constitutions because you can't
- 11:29just simply pass a law through the legislature to say, okay, state constitution is amended.
- 11:35No, it usually has to go through a process of being voted on by the voters of that state.
- 11:45And even when you don't or even if you get past the problems of how do you what criteria do you
- 11:53consider when it comes to redistricting and making new maps?
- 12:00You also sometimes have to consider the future when you're redistricting now, because
- 12:06redistricting is supposed to happen every ten years.
- 12:09But that is a lot of time for populations to change, especially these days with how
- 12:14exponentially bigger many of them are getting.
- 12:17And so what might seem like fair districts now suddenly becomes unfair, at least in some
- 12:23people's eyes, when populations expand.
- 12:26So
- 12:28two, four, six years down the road, a district might have had at the congressional level, I
- 12:35might have had like 750,000 people.
- 12:37And but then five, six years later, now it's got 800, 800, 10,000 people, and that's a
- 12:43massive difference.
- 12:46So some districts and states increase at a far higher rate than others do, and so that
- 12:52technically dilutes those districts' power because they're suddenly representing more
- 12:57people, but they still have to wait several years for redistricting to get more
- 13:01representatives in Congress.
- 13:02And for the Republican side in particularly, this is one of the justifications they use for
- 13:08saying that they should be redistricting now because they have some of
- 13:12these states have gotten so much bigger even since the last census that they'll say, Well,
- 13:19we should be able to reap those benefits now.
- 13:24It's not the only argument and it's not what every Republican state says,
- 13:30but that is one of the ones you hear for their side in particular.
- 13:35And with the increased ability to study and predict population trends, the people who are
- 13:41running redistricting processes regardless of what party they are, they may factor future
- 13:46population changes in when making new maps.
- 13:49In fact, it's pretty much guaranteed that they're going to do
- 13:51that.
- 13:53And
- 13:56both sides of an argument will have that ability and so they'll one side may say, well,
- 14:01you know, with how populations are going
- 14:03to change later, this is a fair map now.
- 14:06But then
- 14:07the other side may say, well, no, you had to do it based on what you already have.
- 14:11You can't just assume that that's what's going to happen.
- 14:14And they're going to say, you're still trying to rig maps in your favor because of how you
- 14:19predict these districts to change.
- 14:22And then you also have to consider the role of courts because new maps being drawn are almost
- 14:28guaranteed to face lawsuits, especially in this very hyper partisan era of redistricting that
- 14:35we've had going on for the past year or two.
- 14:39And a big issue here is that oftentimes a state's supreme court, and that's typically the
- 14:45one who's going to be ruling on the new map, not sometimes it might be an appellate court,
- 14:49but a lot of times it's gonna be state supreme court.
- 14:52That court is going to be ideologically aligned with the legislature that is redrawing the map.
- 14:58And that becomes even more problematic when those judges are elected in partisan elections.
- 15:03Oh, yes.
- 15:03If you didn't know, some judges, not just local level judges, but state level judges for state
- 15:10supreme courts even, are
- 15:12elected in partisan elections.
- 15:15I think that's crazy, but that's a whole other topic of
- 15:19discussion.
- 15:21But because and it is not necessarily just for partisan judges.
- 15:26This can happen for nonpartisan judges too that really actually have a partisan leaning, but
- 15:31especially for these partisan judges where they are being elected in part because of their
- 15:38party identification, it becomes this issue of, well, are they consciously trying to help out
- 15:48the legislature that they're ideologically and partisanally aligned with?
- 15:52Or is it a subconscious thing?
- 15:57Or do they feel the pressure of the electorate where if they don't support the legislature's
- 16:03new map that they're afraid that led that the citizens and voters are going to let these
- 16:08judges know about it, and so they're gonna vote against these judges when they come up for
- 16:13election next time?
- 16:15That's a very real problem that can arise.
- 16:19But even nonpartisan judges can deal with that too.
- 16:21No.
- 16:22They can't explicitly state whether they are Republican or Democrat.
- 16:27But when you look at who's funding their campaigns or who's endorsing them, you'll start
- 16:33to see a pretty clear like, oh, okay.
- 16:35That one would be a Republican judge if they could run as a partisan.
- 16:39This would be a Democratic judge if they could run as a partisan.
- 16:43And you see even in political rhetoric in general where you see, oh, well, this person's
- 16:49a Trump judge.
- 16:49This one's an Obama judge.
- 16:51This one's a Biden judge.
- 16:52This one's a Bush judge.
- 16:54So
- 16:56even though, ideally, of course, you would like courts to be completely separated from those
- 17:04partisan political games,
- 17:09unfortunately, that's really not how it works most of the time.
- 17:14But even when you get past these legislators or these courts and their partisan biases and how
- 17:23they can try to gerrymander us, There's also the question of do we gerrymander ourselves to
- 17:30some extent?
- 17:32Because for as much as politicians try to divide us across districts in an unfair
- 17:37fashion, we also don't do ourselves much of a favor in that regard because of this level of
- 17:42geographic polarization that you see.
- 17:46More and more people are moving to states and districts and neighborhoods that think like
- 17:52them in partisan and ideological terms.
- 17:57You see states and districts that are getting increasingly red, increasingly blue, and more
- 18:03and more elections are basically a done deal before voting even begins because they are so
- 18:09lopsided towards either the Democratic or Republican party.
- 18:14And so when we seek out these areas that think like us, we're helping politicians create
- 18:22geographical echo chambers and making their job easier to try to gerrymander us.
- 18:28And then you have businesses that are also exploiting this by trying to cater to people
- 18:33with a particular partisan or ideological slant.
- 18:36There are moving companies that are there specifically to help out Democrats move or to
- 18:42help out Republicans moving.
- 18:46And moving to places because they think like us makes it that much easier for politicians who
- 18:52run these redistricting processes to try to gerrymander us even further.
- 18:57And we are reluctant to hold them accountable a lot of the time because we like a lot of their
- 19:03other policy views.
- 19:04We have these other policy views that are a higher priority for us.
- 19:08And then we so we suck this up where we think, okay, you know what?
- 19:12I really don't like this thing that they're doing here, but I like a lot of what this other
- 19:15stuff is going on.
- 19:16So I'm I'm going
- 19:18to vote for this person again.
- 19:21And so gerrymandering is obviously done with the intent of unfairly helping out one party
- 19:26over the other.
- 19:27But if a population in an area of a state or the whole state is so lopsided towards one
- 19:34party to begin with, how feasible is it to draw a map to give the minority party a reasonable
- 19:41chance to compete?
- 19:42If you look at a state like Wyoming now Wyoming has only got one US house rep, but they still
- 19:49have a state legislature.
- 19:51It is one of, if not the most Republican state that you'll find in terms of representation and
- 19:57in terms of the electorate and who they are registered with.
- 20:02But is there really a way to draw their map where you give Democrats in that state a
- 20:10reasonable level of competition where they actually have a voice.
- 20:15Or on the flip side, Hawaii also has little representation of congress because of their
- 20:20population, but also a state legislature, they are heavily democratic.
- 20:27Is it even possible to draw those districts in a way where the Republican party can have a
- 20:32voice in that state?
- 20:35That's a
- 20:37pretty difficult thing to accomplish, and so if you have that criteria of, well, you can't
- 20:41redraw maps to deliberately favor one party, well, if one party is so numerous in that state
- 20:50that there's really little competition to begin with, how can you draw a map to try to give
- 20:57that minority party a voice?
- 20:59So, yes, we should hold politicians accountable for how they try to gerrymander us and try to
- 21:06pit us against each other, but we also have to hold ourselves accountable with the way that we
- 21:11think about where we move and how much we like our echo chambers, whether it's geographical or
- 21:18on social media, and we wanna keep surrounding ourselves with people who think just like us.
- 21:25Politicians gerrymander us, but we also gerrymander ourselves to some extent.
- 21:32And so with all these problems in mind, and there
- 21:35are many more problems that we just don't have time to get to, but putting those aside for a
- 21:42moment, how do we fix the redistricting process?
- 21:45Because there are a bunch of ideas that people have had for some time about how to either
- 21:51directly or indirectly fix the redistricting process.
- 21:54It might not be explicitly changing how to redistrict, but it might be a different kind of
- 22:02reform that by default makes redistricting more fair, or at least in theory it does.
- 22:09But even if one idea has objective merit, you'd have to incentivize the powers that be to
- 22:16support it, and that's a
- 22:17part that a lot of reformers miss even if they think they've addressed it.
- 22:22No matter how persuasive you think you are, you are not going to
- 22:26win these kinds of reform battles simply by having a better argument.
- 22:30Some people are not going to be moved by arguments.
- 22:32They are going to be moved by whether you give them a good reason to support your change.
- 22:39And so, not only that, you also have to get regular citizens and voters to support these
- 22:45ideas too.
- 22:46So then you have to spend time on educating these voters on what all these reforms mean.
- 22:52And you have to respond to opponents' arguments about your reforms, whether they are legitimate
- 22:57arguments or not, because you will always have a weak spot in your argument.
- 23:01It does not matter what policy you support.
- 23:03There's always going to be a line of attack that somebody can find.
- 23:06Might not always be a legitimate line of attack that they're finding, but there's always going
- 23:10to be something they can do to try to take your idea down.
- 23:15And you also just have to plainly get these people to care.
- 23:19A lot of them don't care about politics or they're very apprehensive about getting
- 23:23involved in politics.
- 23:24So, they throw their hands up and say, I don't want to get involved.
- 23:29And even if they want to care, they have a lot of other stuff that is going on in their lives
- 23:34that take up their
- 23:35bandwidth.
- 23:37And we can't care about everything that's going on.
- 23:41And sometimes that's
- 23:43a thing that's very hard for those of us involved in politics for a living to
- 23:46appreciate.
- 23:47Yeah.
- 23:47We're not normal.
- 23:49Those of
- 23:49us who get as involved in politics like this.
- 23:56Regular people do not follow and pay attention nearly to the same degree,
- 24:04not just because they don't care.
- 24:05Yes, some people don't care, but some of them just don't have the capacity to be able to care
- 24:11as much as they would like.
- 24:13And even if they do care, even if they do care about politics and they do get involved, you
- 24:18still have to get them to prioritize these reforms over some of their other primary
- 24:23interests because they can't devote all their caring and energy to every single thing that
- 24:30needs to be changed in politics.
- 24:33So, with those things in mind, we're
- 24:35going look at three ideas that are relevant to the redistricting and gerrymandering discussion
- 24:40and how we can think about some of the ways that the powers that be might be incentivized
- 24:47to support these reforms.
- 24:49And remember, I'm not arguing that we should have these reforms necessarily, and they're all
- 24:55going to have flaws to some extent, but these are
- 24:58things you have to think about when it comes to wanting these reforms.
- 25:04And so these three are making more independent commissions in The States for those who are
- 25:14actually redrawing the districts, expanding the US House and proportional representation.
- 25:22And so let's talk about independent commissions first.
- 25:27It's quite clear that you cannot trust partisan legislators.
- 25:31That's a pretty inarguable point.
- 25:33They're going to maybe not necessarily brazenly redraw maps to suit them and suit their
- 25:42parties, but there's going to
- 25:43be something they do to try to tweak things in their favor even if it's subconscious, even if
- 25:49it's not necessarily deliberately intended.
- 25:54And it's it's especially the case in these legislatures that are heavily lopsided towards
- 25:58one party or the other, and we're seeing more states that have that kind of political
- 26:04reality.
- 26:07Now some states, as we discussed in the last episode, do use separate commissions apart from
- 26:12the legislature to redraw district lines.
- 26:15Most states use their state legislatures to redraw these districts, but you do have some
- 26:20that use either a separate commission or they have a separate commission work in tandem with
- 26:26the state legislature.
- 26:29Independent commissions, if they were done quote unquote right, would clearly be better
- 26:34for fair maps, whether they fully drive redistricting or work with a state legislature.
- 26:40But how do you make one that's the best it can be?
- 26:44That's a bit harder to answer.
- 26:48And saying we need to create independent commissions is a much more complicated task
- 26:52than it is sometimes made out to be.
- 26:54Oh, well, you know, we should just have a separate commission that's redrawing the maps
- 26:58for these instead of these legislators.
- 27:01Yeah, they'd be better than the legislators doing it because the legislators have an
- 27:04incentive to redraw maps in an unfair way.
- 27:08But what actually makes a commission independent?
- 27:14We can say it's
- 27:15an independent commission, but is it really all the independent?
- 27:18Is it still susceptible to pressure from the legislature?
- 27:21Are these people who could run for the legislature later?
- 27:24Even if the commission is separate from the legislature, that doesn't necessarily guarantee
- 27:30independence.
- 27:32And so some of these things that you need to consider when it comes to independent
- 27:36commissions is do they work in tandem with the legislature or are they the sole driver of
- 27:41redistricting?
- 27:42Are they really independent?
- 27:44What is the partisan makeup of this commission?
- 27:46Do you have an equal number of Republicans and Democrats?
- 27:50That's probably what you'd wanna do if
- 27:51you really wanna make it fair.
- 27:53But then do you include third parties and no party affiliates?
- 27:57People who are affiliated with a third party, there tends not to be many of them, but
- 28:05there are a lot of people who are completely independent who are not registered with either
- 28:09party.
- 28:10But then how many of them are really independent and how many of them are more so
- 28:14Republicans or Democrats and they just don't wanna admit it?
- 28:17And then how many people from each of these groups?
- 28:19Do we have five Democrats, Republicans, and Independents each?
- 28:23Do we have eight Republicans and Democrats and Independents each?
- 28:29What are the backgrounds of these commission members?
- 28:33So can they be previous legislators?
- 28:36Can they be current legislators?
- 28:38So yes, you don't have the full legislature decide these maps, but do legislative leaders
- 28:48like the majority leader in the state senate or the speaker of the state house, do they get to
- 28:53participate in this commission?
- 28:55Do you allow lobbyists to be on there?
- 28:58Do you allow community activists, government administrators, business people, regular
- 29:05citizens even, because even if you allow each of these individuals, then you start to think,
- 29:13well, could they have an incentive to redraw maps in a certain way?
- 29:16Like if it's somebody who wants to run for office in the future and they're involved in
- 29:21redistricting maps, well, can they try to draw a district that they would run-in a way that
- 29:29benefits them specifically?
- 29:32That's possible.
- 29:33Or if they're a lobbyist, they might already have an in with a lot of legislators that are
- 29:40already in office.
- 29:41And so if they help draw a district or districts in a certain manner, that might get
- 29:48them in well with the current legislators.
- 29:50And then so when those lobbyists run later on for office, those current legislators will
- 29:56eventually become previous legislators and they'll endorse that person running for office.
- 30:02So even if you think it's an independent commission, maybe it's not necessarily me.
- 30:06Or how about regional requirements where you say members have to come from different regions
- 30:11of a state, and then so how many regions are there?
- 30:14If, like, if we talk about Florida, if we were to make it as a separate commission for
- 30:18Florida, do we take it from Northwest Florida and North Central Florida and Northeast Florida
- 30:23and Central Florida and and the Tampa Bay area and Miami area and the Keys?
- 30:29And that's a also can get very nitty gritty.
- 30:35Can commission members run for office in the future, or do they have to sit in time out
- 30:40basically for a few years where, okay, you're on the commission, now you have to wait four
- 30:45years, six years to run for that office.
- 30:49All these things you have to think about.
- 30:51And then, even if you make the best independent commission that you could possibly ever make,
- 30:58How do you incentivize this change?
- 31:00How do you incentivize the powers that be to support this change?
- 31:04Because most states have their state legislatures run the show.
- 31:08Are they really going to want to relinquish some level of power to a different body?
- 31:17They probably are gonna be a lot less amenable to that.
- 31:22And not only that, even if they agree to change redistricting laws now, if or citizens pass a
- 31:31ballot initiative, that legislature may later on try to repeal that change.
- 31:37You saw something similar in California where they have a redistricting commission and now
- 31:42the legislature repealed that and then tried to make their own maps that they have instituted.
- 31:49Would a change take effect immediately in redistricting or would it be delayed?
- 31:54If you delayed it where you said, Okay, we're installing an independent commission now, but
- 32:01it's not going take effect for like six years, well, the current legislature may be more
- 32:06amenable to it because it would be later legislators that are stripped of redistricting
- 32:11power.
- 32:13Or if they really still are just all they care about is whether their party controls the
- 32:18redistricting process or not, they still might not support it.
- 32:22So, not to say that it's
- 32:25not doable because there are some states that allow a separate commission to redistrict their
- 32:31maps, but it's very difficult to change something that's been instilled for so long
- 32:40within the purview of the state legislature.
- 32:43So that's independent commissions.
- 32:44What about expanding the US House?
- 32:46In episode 60 of this podcast, I actually covered this idea for reform.
- 32:52The US House is limited by law to four thirty five members since 1929.
- 32:58So to increase this limit would mean having to repeal this law.
- 33:02Now that would not actually require an amendment to the US Constitution because the US
- 33:06Constitution did not originally set a specific number of seats in the US house in the first
- 33:12place.
- 33:12Really, the main stipulation they just
- 33:15said is that populations represented by the US house must be relatively equal.
- 33:22And right now, that average number of residents per congressional district is 760,000 plus
- 33:30people.
- 33:31Those are huge.
- 33:32And back when these districts were first made in the very early years of this country's
- 33:41republic,
- 33:45the average was more around like 30,000 people.
- 33:51And in the context of redistricting,
- 33:54the idea for expanding the US House is that these smaller districts are harder to
- 34:00gerrymander because if you're including more representatives in the US house so that there
- 34:06would be more people cut up into different or divided into different districts, you would
- 34:14inherently have smaller districts, not just geographically, but you would have fewer
- 34:20citizens per district.
- 34:21So now it might be something like 500,000 people per or 400,000 people per.
- 34:27You these smaller districts, it's a lot harder to make them just snake around and make weird
- 34:31district shapes so easily, and they would inherently be more compact and contiguous.
- 34:36But, again, how do you actually enforce compactness and contiguity?
- 34:43But
- 34:44oh, and oh, sorry.
- 34:45Also, it would likely lead to more US Representatives of color, not necessarily a
- 34:50higher percentage of the US house or of state legislatures, but there were the number of
- 34:58legislators for racial minorities would increase inherently because of smaller
- 35:03districts.
- 35:03So you'd have more districts that are majority minority, or you just have more people that can
- 35:11actually run for office that are racial minorities in general.
- 35:17But if we did expand the US house, how would we exactly determine the number of seats?
- 35:24We talked about this in that previous episode, but would you hard cap or raise the hard cap of
- 35:30legislators of US House Representatives?
- 35:33So now it's instead of four thirty five, would it be 500?
- 35:37Would it be 600, 700, 800, more people?
- 35:41Or would it be based on an average number of citizens like it used to be?
- 35:44So how many average citizens do you want per district?
- 35:47Would it be 600,000, 550 ks, 500 ks, even fewer people?
- 35:55And then again, how do you incentivize the powers that be to change this?
- 36:00These are politicians, so they need an incentive to support something.
- 36:07So if we talk about the because this would actually have to be a change to federal law
- 36:13because even though the states drive a lot of the redistricting, if you're actually changing
- 36:20the number of representatives in the US House, Congress actually needs to pass that law
- 36:25instead.
- 36:26So if you're trying to incentivize members of Congress to support that, well, is the current
- 36:33majority party in Congress going to support adding more US House members?
- 36:38They might not because the current rules got them in power in the first place,
- 36:43so they might be fine to just stay put.
- 36:47But does that necessarily mean that
- 36:49the current minority power in Congress will support it?
- 36:53Might not because they may think they have a really good chance of taking back the US House
- 36:57under the current rules the next time around, likely in a midterm.
- 37:01Midterms are almost always against the current sitting president and his party.
- 37:07And very often, that party is or the president's party is the one who controls
- 37:14congress.
- 37:16Not all the time, but a lot
- 37:17of times it happens, or at least the current majority party in congress gets punished.
- 37:24But then
- 37:25what if the US house and the US senate are split between the parties?
- 37:28Now you need both chambers to agree on this exact same wording of the bill.
- 37:33I mean, you need to do that anyways, but it's gonna be harder to do that if the US House is
- 37:37Republican and the US Senate is Democrat and vice versa.
- 37:40Even though this is controlling US House representatives and how many there would be
- 37:45there, because it's a federal law, the US Senate would still have to agree on the exact
- 37:52wording of a bill that would change that number of US House Representatives.
- 37:57And even if you get past the partisanship, smaller states might be harder to get on board
- 38:02with expanding the US House because some would argue that a larger US House would reduce the
- 38:08power of small states in presidential elections.
- 38:11You think back to that small versus large state debate at the US constitutional convention
- 38:16where there was a lot of fighting about how to make the legislative body in the US House,
- 38:25where big states wanted it based on population and small states wanted an equal share and
- 38:30that's how we eventually came to the compromise where the US House is based on population and
- 38:35the US Senate gives two senators to every state no matter their size.
- 38:41Now, smaller states would get more representatives if we expanded the US House by
- 38:46default, but the larger states would get even more as well and they would probably increase
- 38:51even more in their representation.
- 38:53So state A that's small might have one representative and then a bigger state might
- 38:59have 15 right now.
- 39:04Depending on how you expand that US House, maybe the smaller state now has four or five
- 39:11representatives, but that bigger state may have just jumped up to like 30 or 35, 40
- 39:17representatives.
- 39:18So now they're dwarfing that smaller state even further.
- 39:22Again, it depends on how exactly you change the number of representatives in the US House and
- 39:27if you make it a moving target.
- 39:30So smaller states may not be on board with this change and you would have to get those smaller
- 39:38states in both the US House and the US Senate to support these bills.
- 39:42And that might become a bipartisan issue where it's Republicans and Democrats banding together
- 39:49based on whether they are in a smaller or bigger state to either support or oppose a bill
- 39:55that would expand the US House.
- 39:59And then
- 39:59lastly, proportional representation.
- 40:03So this is a, at least for America,
- 40:07this is a pretty unique concept, but a lot of other democracies in the world use proportional
- 40:13representation in some fashion.
- 40:15And what proportional representation does is it elects representatives in districts based on
- 40:19how much the vote went to each party.
- 40:22So if a party wins 30% of the votes in a district, they get 30% of
- 40:27the seats.
- 40:28Now depending on
- 40:29how many seats there are, it might have to be rounded down, rounded up, so maybe the party
- 40:33won 34% of the seats in that district, but because of how many seats there are, maybe they
- 40:38only get 30% of the seats.
- 40:41And the current system in the vast majority of US elections, of what level of government
- 40:48you're talking about, They are winner take all single member districts.
- 40:52It's whoever gets the most votes wins that district.
- 40:57You do have a few states that or relatively few states that have at least one chamber that uses
- 41:03multi member districts where two, three, or even more people are in that district for that
- 41:10chamber, but that's pretty uncommon to see.
- 41:15Proportional representation though wouldn't inherently use more multi member districts
- 41:20because seats in the district are awarded based on how much of the vote each party has won.
- 41:25Now, not every single proportional representation system works the exact same way,
- 41:30but in any case, it does become a lot more difficult to gerrymander proportional
- 41:34representation system maps because of just how the maps have to be drawn to give seats to
- 41:42different districts.
- 41:44And so even if you carve them try to carve them in a certain way, you're still going by
- 41:49proportional representation where it's just purely based on how much turnout the respective
- 41:56parties have been able to make happen.
- 42:00And so how do you incentivize this change?
- 42:02This one out of these three may be the most difficult to actually make happen.
- 42:08When a party has a chokehold on a district or a state's representation, proportional
- 42:13representation would inherently cut into that power by giving more voice to the minority
- 42:20party.
- 42:21So a place that Republicans just have a stranglehold on, Democrats would then
- 42:26inherently get more power.
- 42:28If it was a place that Democrats had a stranglehold on.
- 42:31Now Republicans are getting a
- 42:32little bit more power because even though that one party is the majority in there by a country
- 42:39mile, the proportional representation system is going to make
- 42:44it so that at least a couple of those seats start to go towards that minority party now.
- 42:51But it's also the fact that this system would be very unpopular with Republicans and
- 42:56Democrats alike, at least in a lot of places, because it would inherently lead to more
- 43:00competition, not just from the other major party, but now third parties and nonparty
- 43:06affiliates are now going to have a lot more of an impact and they're going to get a lot more
- 43:12representation in Congress or in the state legislatures.
- 43:16Now, how much more competition?
- 43:18That's not as clear as some people may say it is and it's not necessarily gonna suddenly be
- 43:23like, oh, wow.
- 43:24There's legitimately a third party that is now competing with Republicans and Democrats.
- 43:28That's necessarily gonna happen right away, but there are considerably large percentage of
- 43:35Americans that identify as independents.
- 43:40They often don't vote that way and that's for a wide variety of reasons,
- 43:43but you are going to have a much different looking US house and state legislatures if you
- 43:54implemented proportional representation.
- 43:59Now, regardless of whatever reforms you support,
- 44:05talk about all those differences in how we define criteria for redistricting, all that
- 44:11stuff.
- 44:11Let's just forget about that for a moment.
- 44:14Can we ensure fair districts?
- 44:17In fact, what even is a fair district?
- 44:20Like many words in politics, the definition of quote unquote fair seems obvious in the
- 44:26abstract, but in practice, it's not nearly so straightforward.
- 44:30And sometimes it's a matter of genuine disagreement, like what criteria should be
- 44:35followed when we are redistricting maps.
- 44:39Like how do
- 44:40you make a compact district or how do you make an independent redistricting commission?
- 44:48Those can be genuine disagreements.
- 44:50Yes, sometimes they are more a matter of partisanship, but sometimes those are genuine
- 44:54disagreements.
- 44:55But sometimes it really is just a matter of political biases and incentives.
- 45:01When Democrats draw maps, a lot of times Republicans think that they're unfair.
- 45:05When Republicans draw maps, a lot of times Democrats think they're unfair.
- 45:10And you notice how parties often change their tune on policies like you know, first expanding
- 45:16beyond redistricting, like the filibuster in the Senate when their party takes charge or
- 45:22they lose power.
- 45:23In the case of the filibuster, you saw how Republicans, when they took power front back
- 45:30from Democrats, Democrats used to poo poo the filibuster because they were the majority, and
- 45:37they kept getting blocked by Republicans filibustering.
- 45:42And Republicans were saying how much the filibuster matter.
- 45:45Now that the power has flipped, now suddenly, you hear more Republicans talk about how the
- 45:52filibuster is terrible and needs to be erased.
- 45:55And now Democrats are suddenly more amenable to the filibuster.
- 46:00And you get that kind of thing when it comes to fair district maps depending on who drew it.
- 46:05Oh, well, now all of a sudden, they think it's unfair.
- 46:08Even if you had an independent commission redraw a map, and we we were able to agree that
- 46:14they were independent.
- 46:15Well, if they draw a map that just happens to support Democrats more, now Republicans are
- 46:22gonna say, well, this is not really an independent commission, or if that independent
- 46:25commission drew a map that was more amenable to Republicans, now Democrats are saying, oh, this
- 46:29is not really an independent commission.
- 46:32This is politics we're talking about.
- 46:34There people are going to find a way to say something is unfair when they don't benefit
- 46:38from it even if it's not anything that's meant to be underhanded.
- 46:44Theoretically, we all want fair districts, theoretically.
- 46:49But when we're the ones in power or the party that we support is in power, how much do we
- 46:54really care about fairness?
- 46:56It's like freedom of speech.
- 46:58How much do we really care about freedom of speech when it's somebody who's not us?
- 47:02We can hoot and holler all we want about somebody that we think similarly to when we
- 47:09think that their freedom of speech is being infringed upon, whether it actually is being
- 47:13infringed upon.
- 47:15But it's a whole other thing when it's people we don't agree with that are having their
- 47:21freedom of speech infringed upon.
- 47:23And it's a similar case when we're talking about redistricting and making fair districts
- 47:29and fair elections when we're not the
- 47:33ones who are benefiting from it, but somebody can argue it's fair.
- 47:39Are we really going to support that policy and say, You know, I wish my party was benefiting
- 47:49but from this is the way to go about things.
- 47:53We don't necessarily see that a whole lot, at least not from people who have a platform.
- 47:59And some gerrymandering is obvious, some isn't, but some of it is.
- 48:05And even when some gerrymandering is clear cuts, how to make elections the fairest they
- 48:11can be is not an easy task because of all these reasons that we gave.
- 48:15But even if we enacted any of these reforms, we expanded the US House, we made every state use
- 48:22an independent redistricting commission, we implemented proportional representation, Can
- 48:27you ever have 100% fair districts?
- 48:32No.
- 48:34There is always something wrong or that can at
- 48:36least be made better whenever humans are involved in the process.
- 48:39It's always going to be iterative.
- 48:42It's always going
- 48:43to require more and more tinkering.
- 48:46There are always trade offs for policies, but the goal does not need
- 48:52to be a 100% fairness in districts, nor should it be because you're gonna be pulling your hair
- 48:57out when you're finding something that's wrong.
- 49:02And when you have so many people involved in the process of elections, there's always gonna
- 49:09be somebody who's trying to be underhanded about it.
- 49:13Now people try to extrapolate that and try to say, oh, well, see, elections have a lot of
- 49:18problems with their security, but really it's isolated incidents.
- 49:22And both Republicans and Democrats have used those arguments.
- 49:29But you may have also heard me say that the goal should not be a 100% fair districts.
- 49:33That doesn't make any sense.
- 49:34Why wouldn't I want a 100% fair districts besides the fact that it's just not possible?
- 49:39We should try to get as close as we can to a 100% fair districts.
- 49:43Of course, we should.
- 49:44We should be trying to make things the best they could possibly be, but we have to
- 49:49recognize that it's going to be an iterative process, And we shouldn't be discouraged when
- 49:54we don't reach that threshold of a 100% fair districts.
- 49:58It's just it's like anything else in life, especially if you played sports.
- 50:02You're always no matter how good you are at a sport, you are going to make a bad play at some
- 50:08point or you are going to make the wrong decision if you're a coach.
- 50:13It's it's the same thing for basically anything else you do in life.
- 50:17Something is going to
- 50:18be done wrong.
- 50:20Something is going to be there's always going to be room for improvement, but you don't stop
- 50:28striving to be the best you can be.
- 50:30You don't stop striving to be as perfect or close to perfect as you can possibly be.
- 50:35And it's the same thing with redrawing districts.
- 50:38But if we want more fair representation in politics, we want more fairly drawn districts.
- 50:46We want more fairly administered elections because of how these districts are drawn.
- 50:52And we have to be better at holding our officials accountable for their actions.
- 50:57Not just when it suits us, not just when it's somebody who we don't normally agree with.
- 51:02We have to be consistent in how we hold people accountable every single time.
- 51:11We have to make fair districts a legitimate priority, not one mired in partisanship, we
- 51:17can't just take the other side quote unquote to task and then be silent about our side.
- 51:22It does not work like that.
- 51:24Well, unfortunately, it does work like that a lot of times, but that's not how it should be.
- 51:27And you're not going to fix things if you just only attack the other side.
- 51:32That's not real accountability.
- 51:34Real accountability is when you apply the same standards, not only to the people you disagree
- 51:38with, but to the people you do agree with.
- 51:41And a lot of times, it's more important to hold your own side accountable than the other side.
- 51:47And we also have to make this fairness a real high level priority, even if we're not going to
- 51:54be partisan about it.
- 51:56Governments have an agenda to follow that is a mix of the most pressing issues that citizens
- 52:01care about and the biggest interests of elected officials.
- 52:04And how they follow that agenda is partly a matter of where political winds are taking
- 52:10them, what they think is going to get them elected.
- 52:13We have to start treating fair districts as a legitimately high enough priority to the point
- 52:19that those who have power over redistricting are forced to respond to us accordingly.
- 52:24They don't want to draw fair districts, then we have to threaten to remove them from office
- 52:30through voting.
- 52:33We have to be willing to put some of our other interests in policies lower on our priority
- 52:42list because there isn't enough time or incentive for federal or state governments to
- 52:47hear every single issue and give them legitimate thought.
- 52:53You are going to have to
- 52:56be willing to say, you know what?
- 52:59This policy about take your pick, whatever issue you want to be, that I really care about
- 53:08and I typically support this side and how they handle that policy, well, they are not being
- 53:14fair about how they redraw districts and I'm going to let them know about it.
- 53:20And if they want to try to redraw things in an unfair way, I'm going to
- 53:25make sure I don't vote for them at the ballot box.
- 53:27You have to actually scare them into thinking they could possibly lose election
- 53:33by trying to rig the system.
- 53:38And unfortunately, a lot of times we don't do that.
- 53:41And we see a lot of
- 53:44things not get better, not just in the case of redistricting,
- 53:47but with all sorts of other policies and polarization.
- 53:52We don't see things get better because we are not willing to put aside some of our priorities
- 53:58for something that affects everybody negatively, in this case, drawing unfair
- 54:06districts.
- 54:09It has to become a legitimate priority and something that officials feel like they're
- 54:16going to be held accountable on in order to have real sustainable change.
- 54:20That's the only way that you could actually have real sustainable change.
- 54:25Politicians need to feel like they're actually vulnerable, that they could lose any election
- 54:31they come across.
- 54:33Very idealistic, but that's what you have to do.
- 54:36And it has to be done regardless of what party they are, what ideology they subscribe to,
- 54:43whether we personally know them or not, whether they have a similar background to us, doesn't
- 54:49matter.
- 54:50The only way you're gonna actually have them be accountable is if we are actually truly willing
- 54:56to hold people accountable, hold them to the same standard regardless of who they are.
- 55:03So that is the main thing I would challenge everybody, including myself.
- 55:08Sometimes this is something I need to do as well.
- 55:13This is something that we need to be cognizant of every day and to be able to say, you know
- 55:21what?
- 55:22It's time that I actually truly
- 55:25hold people accountable,
- 55:27not just for my own priorities, but for these things that are really causing a legitimate
- 55:33crisis in America, like these redistricting wars.
- 55:38But we have to be willing to do it for everybody across the board to the same
- 55:43standard.
- 55:45And that's gonna do it for today's episode of the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 55:49As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 55:51Please like, comment, share, subscribe, YouTube, Spotify, Apple podcasts.
- 55:56Links in the show notes.
- 55:58My other works include a five day educational email course about how we can all more
- 56:03effectively mitigate polarization, my book on political independence, which you can buy on
- 56:09Amazon and several other retailers, but Amazon is is the one you could primarily get it on.
- 56:15And there's another thing that's escaping me at the moment, but my other links, my LinkedIn, my
- 56:22Facebook page, mymedium.com profile, my website, Paul Raider dot org, and my email,
- 56:29PaulRaiderWrights@Gmail.com.
- 56:32So that's where we're
- 56:33going to end things today.
- 56:34As always, thank you so much, and we'll see you next time.