Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / U.S. Immigration Enforcement Making Sense of Immigration in 2025
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to U .S. Immigration Enforcement, Making
- 0:05Sense of Immigration in 2025. I'm Samantha Seves,
- 0:09and I am one of the membership committee chairs
- 0:11of the BHBA's Barister Section. I am delighted
- 0:14to introduce our speaker today, Nancy Cantor.
- 0:18Nancy is an accomplished litigator with deep
- 0:20expertise in federal immigration law. As a senior
- 0:23litigation counsel at the U .S. Department of
- 0:26Justice, she advised senior leadership at the
- 0:28Department of Justice, the Department of Homeland
- 0:31Security, the State Department, and Department
- 0:33of Health and Human Services on complex immigration
- 0:37policy and regulatory matters. She has led litigation
- 0:40strategies in high -profile cases nationwide,
- 0:44including challenges to immigration regulations
- 0:46and constitutional claims, and has argued numerous
- 0:49appeals before the Federal Circuit Courts. With
- 0:52this extensive background, Ms. Cantor brings
- 0:54unique insight into the intersection of immigration,
- 0:58administrative law, and constitutional issues.
- 1:01Now, let's get started. Thank you so much. I'm
- 1:05so excited to be here. You know, obviously, as
- 1:08we just talked about, I spent 15 years with the
- 1:11government as an immigration attorney. The bulk
- 1:13of that time was with the Department of Justice
- 1:15Office of Immigration Litigation, but I also
- 1:18spent two years with USCIS kind of sandwiched
- 1:22in between those 15 years with the Department
- 1:24of Justice. During my practice with the government,
- 1:27I did a very large volume of cases in the courts
- 1:31of appeals, handling primarily petitions for
- 1:33review, but also did class actions regarding
- 1:36unaccompanied minors and visa delay processing
- 1:39and APA challenges. Work closely with agency
- 1:43counsel to develop new policies. to kind of inform
- 1:48how the government approached immigration policies
- 1:50and changes in administration. And obviously
- 1:53immigration has been a very hot topic for so
- 1:56many years and I think never more so than now.
- 2:00I frequently almost daily get questions from
- 2:03friends, colleagues, my family members on what's
- 2:06going on with the news. Why is this happening?
- 2:08I don't understand. I mean we could spend probably
- 2:12a whole week discussing immigration issues and
- 2:15not even scratch the surface of what's happening
- 2:18in the news today. I think the goal of this session
- 2:21today is to give you all some context as to why
- 2:27we are kind of facing the issues that we are
- 2:29facing today. A high level overview of immigration
- 2:33law, what policies and practices have led us
- 2:37to the situation we find ourselves in today.
- 2:41And the goal is for you all to be able to better
- 2:43identify kind of the issues your clients or family
- 2:46members may be facing. but also to provide some
- 2:51insight and issue spotting and abilities to understand
- 2:54why we are where we are today. I think one of
- 2:57the big issues that we hear most common with
- 3:00immigration is why don't folks just come here
- 3:02legally? And as an immigrant myself, who my family
- 3:06immigrated to the United States in the 1980s
- 3:08and early 1990s, I know many that have benefited
- 3:11from legal immigration. I think what many folks
- 3:14don't understand today individuals who aren't
- 3:18deeply entrenched in the immigration system is
- 3:21just how increasingly difficult it has been to
- 3:24legally immigrate to the United States unless
- 3:27you have an immediate family member who is present
- 3:30in the United States. I want to start with the
- 3:33key sources of immigration law. There's Title
- 3:358 of the US Code. This is where the statutes
- 3:38governing immigration and nationality are found.
- 3:41There are also accompanying regulations which
- 3:44clarify and implement the statutes that are found
- 3:47in Title 8. Then there's also the federal criminal
- 3:50law, criminal code, which is Title 18 of the
- 3:54U .S. Code. Now you all may hear the phrase permigration,
- 3:58and permigration is kind of a cute shortcut for
- 4:00the interplay between criminal law on the immigrant
- 4:03population and how criminal conduct can impact
- 4:07an individual's immigration status. Then to further
- 4:12kind of heighten and complicate matters, there
- 4:14is state law. There are so many matters of state
- 4:17law that influence immigration status. For example,
- 4:21for children seeking derivative citizenship,
- 4:23you can get into very many questions about custodial
- 4:26parents, divorce, marriage. All of those issues
- 4:30are determined by state law, but how state law
- 4:33is written and interpreted, including state criminal
- 4:37laws. can really have a significant and profound
- 4:40impact on an individual's immigration status.
- 4:43And then finally, there's the impact of foreign
- 4:45laws. There are, of course, I think one of the
- 4:49big issues that have popped up recently are principles
- 4:52like refoulement, non -refoulement, which is
- 4:55the principle of international law that prohibits
- 4:58states from returning individuals to a country
- 5:00where they fear real risk of persecution. But
- 5:03just like state laws impact your federal immigration
- 5:07status, foreign laws on foreign laws and how
- 5:10foreign law treats divorces, marriage custody
- 5:13can also have a significant impact on an individual's
- 5:17immigration status. So these are the primary
- 5:20sources of immigration law. Of course, there
- 5:23is also court opinions and treatises, et cetera,
- 5:28secondary sources as well that impact immigration
- 5:31law. For a brief overview of the main agencies
- 5:36involved, I have here four. It seems very clear
- 5:41cut and simple, but I think one thing that we've
- 5:44seen in the last few months is that it's not
- 5:47that simple and that the far reach, because immigration
- 5:50is a federal issue, it can very quickly implicate
- 5:54so many aspects of the federal system. The primary
- 5:58agencies, of course, the big one that everyone
- 6:01knows about is the Department of Homeland Security.
- 6:04Within the Department of Homeland Security, there
- 6:06are so many sub -agencies. There is ICE, there
- 6:10is, and then within ICE, there are sub -agencies
- 6:13as well. There's CBP, there's USCIS. I like to
- 6:17think of DHS as a enforcement slash benefits
- 6:20agency. They conduct removal border enforcement,
- 6:23but USCIS aspect of it does the benefits. They
- 6:26do the LPR status. They do asylum, et cetera.
- 6:36The Department of Justice also has a big involvement
- 6:40and role in immigration. Within that, there are
- 6:43sub -agencies, the Executive Office of Immigration
- 6:45Review, which houses immigration judges and the
- 6:48Board of Immigration Appeals. There's the Civil
- 6:51Division Office of Immigration Litigation that
- 6:54handles a large handles the petitions for review,
- 6:59as well as, you know, cases that are filed in
- 7:01the federal district courts. There's also the
- 7:03US attorney's offices that handle a large number
- 7:06of immigration cases that are filed within their
- 7:08individual districts. And then there's the FBI.
- 7:12We regularly part of the Department of Justice
- 7:14coordinated with the FBI. as part of investigations,
- 7:19but also because the FBI holds kind of, you know,
- 7:22all of the background and biographical information,
- 7:25biometrical information about individuals. And
- 7:28then there's also the Department of State. The
- 7:31Department of State largely gets involved with
- 7:34immigration for individuals who are abroad. So
- 7:37for individuals seeking to come to the United
- 7:40States from outside of the United States, they
- 7:43would deal with the office of Consular Affairs
- 7:45and refugees seeking to come to the United States.
- 7:50work with the Bureau of Population Refugees and
- 7:53Migration. And then finally, there's the Department
- 7:56of Labor, which does all of the labor certifications,
- 7:59prevailing wage determinations for determining
- 8:02the number of foreign workers that can come to
- 8:05the United States that won't have an adverse
- 8:07impact on U .S. workers. Those are, I think,
- 8:11the most common federal agencies that are involved
- 8:14when you think about immigration. But because
- 8:17immigration is a federal matter, there's always
- 8:20the possibility that other agencies will be involved.
- 8:22And what we've seen a lot of historically in
- 8:24the past was involvement by HHS, Health and Human
- 8:28Services. They actually have custody and control
- 8:32over unaccompanied minors. So HHS and ICE and
- 8:36DHS work together when there are unaccompanied
- 8:40minors who come into the custody of the federal
- 8:43government. And then of course there's you know,
- 8:46a lot of buzz I think recently about kind of
- 8:49the immigration concerns with tax records and
- 8:53social security records. So there's kind of no
- 8:56real limit to the number of federal agencies
- 8:58that can be involved. I would say that for most
- 9:01people though, DHS, DOJ, State Department, and
- 9:05the Department of Labor would be the ones you
- 9:07come into contact with most likely. This kind
- 9:15of, this slide kind of provides a quick overview
- 9:19of the 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant
- 9:22Responsibility Act. We called that, we refer
- 9:25to that as ARRIRA, or ARRIRA, depending on how,
- 9:28I guess, the first time you heard the abbreviation.
- 9:31But this was the last significant, last real
- 9:35comprehensive immigration legislation that Congress
- 9:37passed. And that was... quite a while ago, 1996.
- 9:42But Rivera really fundamentally restructured
- 9:44US immigration law to focus on stricter enforcement
- 9:48and harsher penalties for undocumented individuals.
- 9:52The law significantly expanded the grounds for
- 9:56deportation and limited the avenues for legal
- 9:59relief. Some of the things that the law did,
- 10:02I have a brief summary here on the slide, but
- 10:04it created reentry bars. So, for instance, it
- 10:08created a three -year bar to reentry or 10 -year
- 10:11bar or even a permanent lifetime bar on reentry
- 10:14for individuals who accrue certain periods of
- 10:17unlawful physical presence. It also created expedited
- 10:21removal, which gives immigration officials the
- 10:25power to very quickly or summarily remove individuals
- 10:28before they have the opportunity to have a hearing
- 10:31before an immigration judge. It also expanded
- 10:34deportable offenses. made it possible to deport
- 10:39individuals who are here undocumented, but also
- 10:42lawful permanent residents for a significantly
- 10:45broader range of crimes, even for past minor
- 10:48offenses. It also expanded border enforcement
- 10:54by boosting funding for border patrol agents
- 10:56and technology. One thing that it did was, Limit
- 11:01judicial discretion. As kind of these enforcement
- 11:05mechanisms came into place, ARERA also put into
- 11:08place jurisdiction stripping provisions so that
- 11:11individuals could not seek review over certain
- 11:13determinations made by the agency in the federal
- 11:16courts. It also, and I think this one is particularly
- 11:21salient or something that we think about or hear
- 11:23about a lot now, is created the 287G initiative.
- 11:27where the federal government has kind of a so
- 11:29-called cooperation with state or local governments.
- 11:32And that has evolved over the years. But the
- 11:36point I think here is to show that or to indicate
- 11:39that the last time Congress really did anything
- 11:42on immigration significant was 1996. There have
- 11:45been a number of attempts to pass immigration
- 11:49reform, none of which have been successful. Unfortunately,
- 11:54that means that our system hasn't really, our
- 11:58system hasn't really changed or advanced. I mean,
- 12:00for anyone who's been doing immigration for a
- 12:02long time, we can say that we have a number of
- 12:04ideas for what we could do or what we should
- 12:06do. But unfortunately, because Congress can't
- 12:09pass any laws, we are left to rely on one executive
- 12:13action and kind of administrative policies as
- 12:17well as the courts, right? So you have now the
- 12:20administration and the shifting administration,
- 12:24right, depending on what party is in power and
- 12:28what their politics and priorities are, as well
- 12:32as the court system to kind of shape immigration
- 12:35law. So critics of Herrera will say that the
- 12:38law led to a massive expansion of immigration
- 12:41detention system and a separation of families.
- 12:44where the intended effect of ARERA was really
- 12:47to deter undocumented immigration. Depending
- 12:52on what studies you look at, it suggests that
- 12:54maybe what would have happened or what really
- 12:57happened with ARERA was that it incentivized
- 13:00people to stay because of the aforementioned
- 13:03reentry bars. If you are going to leave and come
- 13:07back, you may find yourself subject to a permanent
- 13:09reentry bar. Thinking about kind of our hot topics
- 13:16of immigration, it was really hard to choose
- 13:19and come up with five. But if I had to, the five
- 13:24that I kind of came up with was removals, being
- 13:28kind of what is happening with individuals who
- 13:30are here and unlawfully present in the United
- 13:32States, not only in immigration courts, but also
- 13:35kind of what we're seeing, the expedited removal
- 13:38process that's happening at the border, as well
- 13:41as the more concerning removals to third countries.
- 13:44We're also seeing a lot of buzz about visa cancellations
- 13:48and with, you know, the State Department taking
- 13:50the position that a visa is a privilege, not
- 13:52a right, and that it can be canceled at any time.
- 13:55So we've seen visa cancellations en masse as
- 13:58to foreign students, the suggestion that there's
- 14:01going to be, you know, a significant impact or
- 14:04crackdown on employment visas, and then even
- 14:07more concerning just the blanket review of all
- 14:09individuals here present in the United States
- 14:11on visas. There has also been a large impact
- 14:15of the refugee admissions. This doesn't, I think,
- 14:19get quite as much press as some of the other
- 14:21topics, but the US Refugee Admissions Program
- 14:24has been effectively shut down since the early
- 14:28part of this year. That's resulted in not only
- 14:31a number of individuals being left in limbo,
- 14:34individuals who have had their refugee. refugee
- 14:39applications processed and approved, but haven't
- 14:41yet traveled to the United States. But what's
- 14:45lost in that is the significant federal funding
- 14:48that went to refugee programs, refugee resettlement
- 14:52programs and support programs within the United
- 14:55States. So that funding has been put in jeopardy
- 14:58and has been suspended. And also the individuals
- 15:01who have recently resettled into the United States
- 15:03as refugees have lost that funding and support.
- 15:06There's also, oops, sorry. Let's go back. There's
- 15:12also asylum. Asylum is kind of a big topic. I
- 15:16think what people, many folks who aren't in the
- 15:18immigration space don't realize is that there
- 15:21are over 3 million pending asylum applications
- 15:24currently and that number continues to grow.
- 15:27That backlog has grown significantly since COVID
- 15:30and it continues to grow. The problem is that
- 15:34you have individuals who are kind of in a state
- 15:36of limbo. They can get temporary work authorization,
- 15:40but individuals who have been pending for say
- 15:44four or five years who might have had a valid
- 15:47asylum claim many years ago are now in a different
- 15:51political climate where they may be facing different
- 15:53risks because they haven't obtained that asylum
- 15:55status yet. And then finally, general immigration
- 15:59enforcement. That's kind of an amorphous category,
- 16:03but I think that kind of captures the sense that
- 16:06I get from most folks asking questions these
- 16:09days is what is going on? The immigration enforcement
- 16:13that this administration has. kind of made a
- 16:18priority seems to focus a lot more on expulsion
- 16:21versus just active deterrence of entry, but expulsion
- 16:24from within. And that has increased the number
- 16:27of enforcement actions taken across the country
- 16:30impacting communities. I know here in LA, that's
- 16:34been a huge issue since, you know, for a while,
- 16:37but it has been very alarming to see that continue
- 16:41and also grow throughout the country. So, you
- 16:47know, kind of understand where we are. The US
- 16:50immigrant population is generally speaking, all
- 16:54individuals not born in the United States so
- 16:56I would include myself in that number because
- 16:58I was born abroad naturalized. The total population
- 17:01of the United States is about 340 million people,
- 17:05the immigrant population nearly I think approximately
- 17:0850 million individuals on a certain number. That
- 17:11means that it's only 15 % of the whole US population
- 17:15that is not native born citizens. So when I think
- 17:17about it, immigration is such a hot topic, but
- 17:20it's really only 15 % of our total population.
- 17:24And then when you break it down even further,
- 17:27of that 15%, that's broken down to approximately
- 17:3249 % of the US immigrant population is naturalized.
- 17:3724 % hold lawful permanent residence status.
- 17:4123 % consists of unauthorized immigrants, and
- 17:45then 4 % have long -term non -immigrant residents.
- 17:48So those are individuals here on long -term not
- 17:51immigrant visa status. If you look at the pie
- 17:55chart, I think it's interesting to see. Again,
- 18:00this is only 15 % of the US population that we're
- 18:02talking about. And one thing to note is that
- 18:06this These percentages don't tend to shift significantly
- 18:10over decades because people move in and out of
- 18:13these status, right? So you may have unauthorized
- 18:16immigrants who move into lawful permanent residence
- 18:18status, lawful permanent residence status, individuals
- 18:21moving into naturalized citizen status, and so
- 18:25on and so forth. So the actual percentages do
- 18:28not tend to shift significantly based on turnover
- 18:31and change in status. I think once we understand
- 18:35the population of individuals, the question that
- 18:38everyone has is how do you become a lawful permanent
- 18:41resident or a long -term citizen or a long -term
- 18:44immigrant? Generally speaking, if you are outside
- 18:48of the United States and you want to come to
- 18:50the US, you need to seek a visa. There are two
- 18:53types of visas, non -immigrant and immigrant
- 18:55visas. A non -immigrant visa is intended for
- 18:59individuals who want to come on a temporary basis
- 19:01for a specific purpose. That can be anything
- 19:04from tourism a few months or even a few days
- 19:07or weeks to business, temporary work or study.
- 19:10So it could be somebody who wants to come and
- 19:13visit a family member for a week or somebody
- 19:15who wants to come and enter into a long course
- 19:17of study. If you are present in the United States
- 19:21on a non -immigrant visa, you are restricted
- 19:24to the activity or reason for which you are admitted.
- 19:27So if you are here on a student visa, you need
- 19:29to stay in that student visa status and continue
- 19:34to comply with the conditions on that status.
- 19:37There may be restrictions on your ability to
- 19:39work and It becomes dicey, I think, for individuals
- 19:44who think that it's very easy to move from one
- 19:47status to another. I know one common question
- 19:52that I got from individuals. who had au pairs
- 19:56was they would have au pairs and their au pairs
- 19:58would want to stay. And obviously the au pairs
- 20:00were here on a very specific type of visa. And
- 20:03once their two -year au pair agreement came to
- 20:07an end, it was often very difficult, if not impossible,
- 20:11to find another visa status for which they could
- 20:14stay in the United States. Then there is also
- 20:19immigrant visas for permanent residency. An immigrant
- 20:23visa is what it sounds like. The individual plans
- 20:26to come and live permanently in the United States
- 20:29and the holders of the visa once admitted are
- 20:32lawful permit residents or green card holders.
- 20:35This type of visa typically involves sponsorship
- 20:38by a relative or employer, although some individuals,
- 20:42increasing the small number it feels like, may
- 20:45be able to petition for this on their own behalf.
- 20:49So again, this is a summary of different kinds
- 20:54of immigrant visas. The most common type is the
- 20:57family -sponsored visa. This is for individuals
- 21:00who are sponsored by family members who are already
- 21:02here in the United States. We'll talk more about
- 21:05this later, but the goal of the family -sponsored
- 21:08visa is family reunification. There is also the
- 21:15employers. employer sponsored visa. This is where
- 21:18your job can sponsor you to come to the U .S.
- 21:21Many of these are non -immigrant visas, but there
- 21:24are also some options for conversion to permanent
- 21:26visas or permanent immigrant visas. Then there's
- 21:30the diversity visa lottery. The diversity visa
- 21:33is exactly what it sounds like. It is a lottery.
- 21:36there is a 0 .2 chance of being selected, and
- 21:40it excludes the top origin countries for legal
- 21:43immigrants. So there is a very, very small number
- 21:46of successful diversity visa applicants. And
- 21:50then there are refugees, and there is a 0 .1
- 21:55% chance of being selected as a refugee. I think
- 22:00that the US immigration system kind of has its
- 22:04focus and goals, namely, you know, family sponsored
- 22:09is to foster family reunification, employer sponsored,
- 22:14which is to kind of promote growth in the US
- 22:17economy. And then diversity and refugee is to
- 22:21promote diversity and, you know, humanitarian
- 22:23aspects. So these are kind of the overarching
- 22:26goals, I think, of USCIS and the Department of
- 22:32State who are the agencies who are responsible
- 22:35for kind of facilitating these visas. So this
- 22:42chart contains a breakdown of green card holders
- 22:46or individuals with lawful permanent residence
- 22:48status. And lawful permanent residence status
- 22:51is the status that you have before you can naturalize
- 22:54and become a US citizen. As the pie chart shows,
- 22:5947 % of LPRs or green card holders are those
- 23:04who come because of immediate relatives, and
- 23:08that is a spouse, a child to get may, I can't
- 23:13remember off the top of my head, maybe a parent.
- 23:16And then there are non -immediate family sponsors,
- 23:19which is 17%. So that would be like your brother,
- 23:22your sister, the more attenuated your family
- 23:24relationship, there would be employment base,
- 23:28which is the same amount, 17%, and then a much,
- 23:31much smaller amount in terms of individuals who
- 23:34are admitted as refugees or asylees, and then
- 23:37diversity visas. So I think this all sounds great,
- 23:44right? Like, that's great. These are laudable
- 23:45goals for the United States. We want to foster
- 23:48family reunification. We want to foster diversity,
- 23:50humanitarian concerns. But remember that only
- 23:5415 % of the US population is not native born.
- 23:57And a large significant percentage of that is
- 24:00already naturalized citizens. What does this
- 24:02all mean in terms of the numbers? In terms of
- 24:05the numbers, when we look at it, There is actually
- 24:08a very limited number of available visas every
- 24:12year that are given. There is a cap. It's not
- 24:16unlimited. So when we're talking about family
- 24:20sponsored visas, that includes immediate relatives.
- 24:23There is no cap on that. However, there is a
- 24:25cap if you're not an immediate relative. So brothers,
- 24:28sisters, aunts, uncles. All of those individuals
- 24:31are subject to different caps. And that number
- 24:33fluctuates from 260 ,000 to 480 ,000 a year.
- 24:38When we talk about that 17 % of employment base,
- 24:42that's 140 ,000 a year. Refugees and asylees,
- 24:46that number is set by statute every year, every
- 24:50fiscal year. And it has been, for the last few
- 24:53years, 125 ,000. And then diversity visas, that's
- 24:57$55 ,000. So when we're talking about the 0 .1
- 25:00% chance, that's why that number is so low. Because
- 25:05you can have millions of people applying for
- 25:08refugee, asylum, diversity visas, but there is
- 25:13a cap on the number of individuals who can obtain
- 25:15that. I wanted to kind of give you all a little
- 25:20bit of context. It is a personal story. In the
- 25:24late 80s, early 90s, my family came to the United
- 25:30States, and we all naturalized, I believe, in
- 25:32the late 80s. In the 1990s, after my immediate
- 25:37family naturalized, my mother successfully petitioned
- 25:40her parents to come to the United States, but
- 25:42also for her two married brothers who had their
- 25:44own families to come to the United States. So
- 25:47they are not immediate relatives, right? Immediate
- 25:49relatives includes only your spouse, children,
- 25:53and I guess parents as well. But she was able
- 25:57to within, if I remember correctly, she was able
- 26:01to within about five years, I know for sure less
- 26:04than 10 years, petition successfully for both
- 26:07of her adult married brothers to come to United
- 26:10States. I haven't gotten kind of into the weeds
- 26:13with how visas are doled out, but essentially
- 26:17if you are outside of the United States, and
- 26:20you want to come, you need the family member
- 26:23within the United States has to petition USCIS
- 26:26so that you can come. That petition right now
- 26:30can take many, many years to file. I have personally
- 26:33seen cases where that petition has been sitting
- 26:35for six years, seven years, eight years. It is
- 26:38only after that petition has been approved that
- 26:42you can then seek a visa from the Department
- 26:45of State. In recent years, I've seen USCIS update
- 26:50their website to say that they will only prioritize
- 26:53adjudication of applications when an immigrant
- 26:56visa is available or will soon be available,
- 26:59which is to say that USCIS will say, hey, we
- 27:02understand that you want to petition for a non
- 27:04-immediate. family member not immediate relative
- 27:07family member to come to the United States but
- 27:10there is no visa available so we're not going
- 27:12to adjudicate this we are going to put it in
- 27:14the back of the line and we are going to adjudicate
- 27:16others where there may be visas available. Now
- 27:20that means your application or your visa application
- 27:24for your family member abroad can literally sit
- 27:26right now for decades and I say decades because
- 27:30If we are looking at the visa bulletin, so the
- 27:34State Department publishes monthly a bulletin
- 27:36that lists priority dates. So this is the priority
- 27:40date for F4s, brothers and sisters of adult US
- 27:44citizens. If it is a family -sponsored visa,
- 27:47F4, we look at the bottom left. The priority
- 27:50date is the date, the cutoff date by which you
- 27:54had to have an approved application. So we're
- 27:59looking at right now, if your priority, okay,
- 28:03if you're, we're looking at now, if you're an
- 28:05F4 category brother or sister of a US citizen,
- 28:08like my uncles, you must, sorry, you must have
- 28:10filed your application before September 8th,
- 28:132008, or 17 years prior. And unless you filed
- 28:18your application 17 years prior, there's no visa
- 28:21available for you. And that's literally in order
- 28:23for you to move forward and seek a visa interview
- 28:27at the consulate. and that number is even more
- 28:30even more dire if you're from India because you're
- 28:32looking at a December 1st 2006 date. If you're
- 28:36from Mexico you're looking at an April 30th 2001
- 28:39date and that's again a reminder that is to move
- 28:43forward to get a visa to even get an interview
- 28:47at a consulate abroad so I think it's hard for
- 28:51folks to understand when asked, why don't you
- 28:53just come here legally? It's really, really difficult
- 28:56to come here legally. I know my mother did it
- 28:59for both of my uncles by herself. We did not
- 29:02have the help of a lawyer. She spent a lot of
- 29:04time going to the INS building in downtown Los
- 29:07Angeles and did all of the paperwork by herself
- 29:09and was able to successfully petition for them
- 29:13to come to the US within five or so years. That's
- 29:17simply not possible today. This is a very superficial
- 29:22and high level look at legal immigration, but
- 29:26it's really intended to kind of help folks understand
- 29:29why it is so difficult. And a lot of that is
- 29:32because of, you know, the, a lot of that is a
- 29:37rear, a rear really changed the immigration landscape.
- 29:40The focus was on deterrence. And as each administration
- 29:45has come in, that deterrence aspect has been
- 29:49increasingly emphasized without any significant
- 29:53focus or reformation in terms of increasing or
- 29:56encouraging legal immigration. All right. There's
- 30:01one question. How does the percentage of increased
- 30:04legal or legal residents here in the US since
- 30:06the Biden administration compared to the previous
- 30:09administration percentage? So I don't know the
- 30:14percentages off the top of my head. I will be
- 30:18honest, most of these, most of the numbers on
- 30:21immigrant population take a while to generate
- 30:24or a while to calculate. So I would say if we're
- 30:27looking at the current numbers, we'd be getting
- 30:29numbers for maybe 2020, 2023. So anything now
- 30:34would be largely hearsay. I can say from what
- 30:39I've, what initial reports seem to indicate is
- 30:42that there are, there is less kind of border,
- 30:48there are less individuals seeking border entry
- 30:51right now for I think obvious reasons. And that
- 30:55legal immigration has been stalled. in part because
- 31:02of, you know, immigration policies that have
- 31:04slowed it down. There's a lot of background stuff
- 31:07that goes into immigration, but you know, for
- 31:11instance, as kind of the federal workforce has
- 31:15shifted its personnel, there's been less individuals.
- 31:20Anecdotally, I would guess there are less individuals
- 31:22kind of working to adjudicate say naturalization
- 31:25applications and LPR applications because they're
- 31:27working on other things. There is also a likelihood
- 31:32that visa applications have been stalled because
- 31:35individuals, because there was kind of a lull
- 31:38in processing of visa applications while the
- 31:40State Department undertook a review of what they
- 31:43were going to do in terms of like reshifting
- 31:45priorities or new focuses. I would imagine that
- 31:50the number of individuals Obtaining naturalization
- 31:54is going to slow down significantly because government
- 31:56recently put out new guidelines for determining
- 31:59good moral character. So that's gonna require
- 32:03kind of new training and involvement. So I can't
- 32:06really speak to specific percentages, but I think
- 32:08it's pretty safe to say that everything's kind
- 32:10of at a lull. It's definitely at a standstill.
- 32:13I know that the refugee admission program has
- 32:15been pretty much suspended. since January. So
- 32:20with the exception of the South Africans, the
- 32:25Afrikaners who have been admitted, I don't believe
- 32:27that the US RIP program is kind of working right
- 32:30now, including for individuals who have been
- 32:32granted that status and are waiting abroad to
- 32:34enter. So now that we've kind of talked about
- 32:40the legal immigration side, I want to speak to
- 32:44the key challenges for undocumented individuals
- 32:48who are here in the United States. One of the
- 32:50questions, of course, is why didn't you come
- 32:52here legally? But then the flip side is once
- 32:54you're here, if you are here in the United States
- 32:57unlawfully, what can you do? And unfortunately,
- 33:00there's a large number, a significant number
- 33:03of legal hurdles. There are limited pathways
- 33:07to U .S. citizenship and certainly today there's
- 33:11a very high risk of being placed in proceedings.
- 33:14Individuals can file for asylum but you know
- 33:17they can be summarily removed depending on how
- 33:19they're apprehended and kind of what's happening
- 33:22in the city wherever that you are. In the meantime,
- 33:25whatever status you are, there is very limited
- 33:28access to public benefits or even work authorization.
- 33:32And then in addition to the legal hurdles, there's
- 33:34also a significant number of procedural hurdles.
- 33:37It is complicated and a very lengthy immigration
- 33:41process to apply for status or to seek asylum.
- 33:46Once you are put in proceedings, you have...
- 33:51You have a right to counsel, but that's counsel
- 33:53at your own expense. The government doesn't have
- 33:55to provide you with counsel. So it's expensive,
- 33:58it's difficult. A lot of times individuals who
- 34:02are seeking asylum are... need information from
- 34:06the country that they were persecuted in. So
- 34:09that's obviously another hurdle. And then you
- 34:12have the situation where individuals who may
- 34:14have been present in the United States temporarily
- 34:16under one status may find suddenly that their
- 34:19status is terminated and that's just a policy
- 34:22shift by administration. It's kind of talking
- 34:29big picture about asylum applications and delays.
- 34:33Asylum is something that is a big, it's near
- 34:37and dear to my heart. It's near and dear to my
- 34:41heart. It was a large focus of my practice at
- 34:43the Department of Justice during the last few
- 34:46years. But there is a backlog I mentioned earlier
- 34:51of more than 3 million pending asylum applications
- 34:54in the United States. You have 1 .4 of those
- 34:58that are pending with USCIS as affirmative asylum
- 35:00applications. These are applications that have
- 35:03been filed when individuals come to United States
- 35:06and they're filed immediately with USCIS and
- 35:10that individual has not been put into removal
- 35:12proceedings yet. I've seen delays anywhere from
- 35:16three years to over eight years in processing
- 35:18these applications. Then you have defensive asylum
- 35:22applications, which is asylum applications that
- 35:26are filed in removal proceedings after you've
- 35:29been placed in a removal proceeding before an
- 35:31immigration judge. And there are over 1 .5 of
- 35:34those pending in immigration court. So we're
- 35:36talking about three million asylum applications.
- 35:42And then over here, I have a blurb under the...
- 35:45give you kind of an understanding of the removal
- 35:47process. There are over 3 .7 million open removal
- 35:50cases as of January 31st, 2025 of this year.
- 35:54So more than half of the individuals in removal
- 35:57proceedings, or slightly, sorry, slightly less
- 36:00than half of the individuals in removal proceedings
- 36:02are seeking defensive asylum. And then you have
- 36:05individuals in proceedings seeking all kinds
- 36:07of other types of relief. Of course, the big
- 36:10issue with asylum is delays. There are varying
- 36:13delays depending on jurisdiction and immigration
- 36:17court, you're going to have some jurisdictions,
- 36:20some asylum processing offices where you have
- 36:23just a significant population and the delay is
- 36:25going to be significantly larger than at other
- 36:31asylum offices. I think one of the things that
- 36:35is often lost is that in addition to kind of
- 36:39the processing delay based on just the volume
- 36:40of applications is that removal proceedings can
- 36:43take a really long time. One court has reported
- 36:48an average of 2 ,119 days until an individual's
- 36:52removal proceedings can be adjudicated. And then
- 36:55you have kind of overarching with asylum policy
- 36:58changes is by administration how an individual
- 37:02seeks or applies for asylum becomes different,
- 37:05right? There was the Remain in Mexico program.
- 37:07There was a CBP -1 program. There was this is
- 37:10all suspended now. So individuals are getting
- 37:12conflicting information as to how they can actually
- 37:15seek an asylum in the United States. So that's
- 37:19all just kind of increased the difficulty of
- 37:22seeking asylum, not to mention the difficulty
- 37:24in actually obtaining a decision on an asylum
- 37:27application. For individuals who are out of status,
- 37:34and that refers to anybody who's here kind of
- 37:37without status, without a lawful visa, without
- 37:40permanent residency basis, individuals who are
- 37:45here unlawfully are subject to removal proceedings
- 37:47if they're apprehended by DHS. So there's a estimated
- 37:51undocumented immigrant population of 11 .7 million
- 37:56as of July, 2023. So that goes back to just the
- 38:00numbers are so hard to estimate that like they're
- 38:02always at least a year behind in terms of actually
- 38:04giving us an estimate. And there's a rough estimate
- 38:08of say right now 2 million individuals in immigration
- 38:10court proceedings. So for folks who are immersed
- 38:14in immigration and the removal world, there's
- 38:18something we called we call regular removal proceedings,
- 38:21which are under 8 USC 1229A. That is, you know,
- 38:26an individual is put into removal proceedings.
- 38:29They appear before an immigration judge. They
- 38:32have the right to appeal to the board of immigration
- 38:35appeals. And then they have a right to go to
- 38:39the court of appeals. This process can take very
- 38:42many years. I had cases at the Department of
- 38:46Justice that were filed in the court of appeals
- 38:50maybe four or five years ago that continued to
- 38:53sit in the court of appeals and then you have
- 38:55you know kind of the four or five maybe six or
- 38:57seven years depending on the complexity of the
- 38:59case and which immigration court the individual
- 39:01came from where they've been pending for even
- 39:05many more years so you can easily have an individual
- 39:08who's been in regular removal the regular removal
- 39:11proceeding for over a decade but then there's
- 39:14expedited removal which is you know, the process
- 39:19that was created in ARERA in 1996. That is where
- 39:23an immigration officer can essentially, without
- 39:27presenting the individual before an immigration
- 39:29judge, summarily order the individual removed.
- 39:33We'll talk more about exedata removal, but it
- 39:36is a summary removal process. It has historically
- 39:40been used to quickly remove certain non -citizens
- 39:43without a hearing before an immigration judge.
- 39:45you still have, individuals still have the right
- 39:48to seek asylum. So there is an initial screening
- 39:51process. And if they show either a credible fear
- 39:54or reasonable fear, they are then put into regular
- 39:57removal proceedings. The catch is though, right?
- 40:01There's an emphasis on summary or expedited,
- 40:03which means it's very quick. So if an asylum
- 40:06officer at the border says you have not shown
- 40:08a credible fear, the review of that negative
- 40:11determination is very limited. individuals may
- 40:15only bring a lawsuit challenging, generally speaking,
- 40:19an expedited removal order if they are already
- 40:22a lawful permanent resident or if they've someone
- 40:24who've been granted refugee or asylum status
- 40:27or who is wrongfully subjected to expedited removal.
- 40:30And, you know, I think the difficulty there is
- 40:33what does wrongfully subjected to expedited removal
- 40:35mean? Changes in administration policy and interpretation
- 40:38can really influence that. And that's a lot of
- 40:40what we're seeing at the border right now. The
- 40:43use of expedited removal historically has ebbed
- 40:47and flowed a lot. So looking at this chart, I
- 40:51started at DOJ, and it's not Mars, but I started
- 40:55the Department of Justice in 2010. And it was
- 40:58a good, I think, four or five years before I
- 41:01even encountered a case that involved an expedited
- 41:03removal order. It was just not something that
- 41:06we saw very much of. It didn't happen very often.
- 41:09And when it did, there was limited there was
- 41:11limited review in the courts, so we didn't see
- 41:14a lot of it. I will say that one of the silver
- 41:18linings over the last few years has been that
- 41:21courts have been increasingly exercising jurisdiction
- 41:24over these types of cases, both in the district
- 41:26courts and the appellate courts. But one of the
- 41:29issues that we are seeing in expedited removal
- 41:32is that because it is so summary and it is so
- 41:35quick and there is generally not review available,
- 41:39it becomes very difficult for individuals to
- 41:42challenge when they are subject to expedited
- 41:44removal and then subsequently removed. One of
- 41:47the things that we're seeing in the context of
- 41:50expedited removal now is that it should really
- 41:52only apply to individuals who are present in
- 41:54the US for less than two years. It's hard to
- 41:58prove that you've been present in the United
- 41:59States for more than two years, right? Like,
- 42:01I certainly don't carry around paperwork showing
- 42:03that I've been in the United States for more
- 42:05than two years. So, you know, ICE is putting
- 42:09the burden on individuals to prove that. Traditionally,
- 42:14or the traditional advice I think most people
- 42:17give their clients is that you don't have to
- 42:19answer or, you know, there's a privilege against
- 42:21self -incrimination advice. Don't say anything.
- 42:24You don't need to say anything. You don't need
- 42:26to answer these questions. But if ICE is going
- 42:28to put the burden on you, burden on an individual
- 42:31to show that they have been present in the United
- 42:33States for more than two years, then suddenly
- 42:35folks do have to answer. One of the pieces of
- 42:39advice I've seen floating around is suggesting
- 42:42to individuals who are here who are undocumented.
- 42:44to carry evidence that they have been in the
- 42:48United States for more than two years. That includes
- 42:50rent agreements, letters from friends, family,
- 42:54their employer, their pastor, any number of things.
- 42:57As you can probably guess, the proof is kind
- 43:01of subject to the reviewer of the proof, the
- 43:04ICE officer, the DHS officer who's looking at
- 43:06that. So it has become a very, I think, increasingly
- 43:10difficult area for folks who are practicing in
- 43:12the immigration space because changes in administration
- 43:16policy so heavily influence what is happening
- 43:19in this particular aspect of removal. So a very
- 43:25quick and kind of comprehensive or a big picture
- 43:28overview of the removal system and what happens
- 43:32to individuals is that undocumented individuals
- 43:35can be detained or apprehended by DHS and The
- 43:38top one takes you through the regular removal
- 43:41proceedings. You can go to removal proceedings
- 43:44for an immigration judge. And again, one court
- 43:46said it could take over 2 ,000 days to get a
- 43:48decision. You can go to the Board of Appeals
- 43:51and appeal that decision. It'll take a couple
- 43:53of years. And then you have the right to appeal
- 43:56to this, sorry, you can go to the Board of Immigration
- 43:59Appeals to appeal that decision. And then after
- 44:02that, where it can take a couple of years at
- 44:04the BIA, you can go to the Court of Appeals.
- 44:08And that can also take a couple of years. The
- 44:13regular removal proceeding process is slow. It
- 44:16is expensive. It's very difficult for individuals.
- 44:19But at least there is kind of a mapped out process.
- 44:22And it does take a long time, during which time
- 44:25individuals are typically not, you know, historically
- 44:27not going to be removed. Then you have to illustrate
- 44:31just how the summary removal or expedited removal
- 44:34process works is DHS removal proceedings. That's
- 44:38kind of a big kind of umbrella term that, you
- 44:41know, the government uses for expedited removal,
- 44:44all different kinds of expedited removal. There
- 44:48is very limited review for the circuit court
- 44:50of appeals. There is no like three years or four
- 44:54years where you sit before an immigration judge,
- 44:56and then multiple years where you sit before
- 44:58a board of immigration appeals, and then even
- 45:00more years where you sit in the circuit court
- 45:01of appeals. One thing that we've seen in the
- 45:06Court of Appeals as well is that certainly in
- 45:12the last two democratic administrations, the
- 45:15Second Circuit and the Ninth Circuit kind of
- 45:17developed their own processes for putting cases
- 45:20on. putting cases kind of in an abeyance or mooting
- 45:23out cases or putting them in kind of a judicial
- 45:26administrative closure posture. Basically, the
- 45:29court was saying, look, you're not really going
- 45:30to remove these individuals. So let's just close
- 45:33this case. So the case is closed. It's administratively
- 45:36closed in the Court of Appeals. The individuals
- 45:39have The government at the time agreed that they
- 45:43were not going to pursue removal of those individuals.
- 45:48This administration is aggressively reopening
- 45:51all of those cases that were previously administratively
- 45:54closed. So all of those individuals who have
- 45:57cases pending in the court of appeals that were
- 46:00judicial admin closed are now being repursued
- 46:04for removal. We talked a lot about the immigration
- 46:13courts and the Circuit Court of Appeals. There
- 46:16is a, if you're a lawyer, which I know we all
- 46:20are, the U .S. District Courts have a significant
- 46:24role in immigration policy as well. I would say
- 46:28that, you know, historically the Historically,
- 46:33the role of the district courts was certainly
- 46:36from my perspective at the Department of Justice
- 46:38was administrative APA challenges, administrative
- 46:41procedure act challenges. We saw a lot of challenges
- 46:44to agency decisions, rules and policies, how
- 46:47those were promulgated, whether or not they comply
- 46:51with APA rulemaking requirements, constitutional
- 46:54challenges. class actions, we have significant
- 46:58number, or the government handles a significant
- 47:00number of class actions against unaccompanied
- 47:03minors, certain groups of visa applicants, certain
- 47:05groups of refugees, all that. That is kind of,
- 47:09you know, traditional big, big government type
- 47:13source of immigration litigation. In the last
- 47:17four or five years, mandamus cases, bottom left
- 47:20cases have also become an increasingly big component
- 47:25of the government's immigration litigation. Mandamus
- 47:29actions deal with all of those delays in adjudication.
- 47:33So when you have individuals who've been sitting
- 47:35on their who have had application asylum applications
- 47:38that have been sitting for three years or five
- 47:40years or seven years, they might sue and say,
- 47:43hey, the government needs to make a decision
- 47:45on my application. So that number has spiked
- 47:48traditionally. I can't remember off the top of
- 47:51my head, but it was something like before COVID
- 47:55and the big delays that came with asylum and
- 47:58visa adjudications, there would be maybe like
- 48:02a thousand mandamus cases a year across the country.
- 48:07In 2022, I believe it was over 10 ,000. So that
- 48:12was a significant source of increased district
- 48:14court litigation in the immigration context.
- 48:18And what we are seeing today, is an increasing
- 48:21number of habeas challenges. And that is for
- 48:23all of the individuals who are detained. And
- 48:26it is literally, you're not lawfully detaining
- 48:29me. I need to not be detained or not be removed
- 48:32or not be moved to this other space. And the
- 48:35federal district courts are the quickest way
- 48:39to get review of those decisions. And I think
- 48:43that you know, as we progress through this administration,
- 48:48that the availability of equal access to justice
- 48:51fees and Section 1983 and FTCA claims will become
- 48:56a source of litigation. Not necessarily, some
- 49:00of it will come to whether or not, you know,
- 49:03non -undocumented individuals are eligible for
- 49:07this, but the government is detaining a lot of
- 49:10people, including lawful permanent residents,
- 49:13including US citizens. That will certainly give
- 49:16rise to 1983 and FTCA claims and determining
- 49:20what the damages are in that context. Going back
- 49:25to the big issues in immigration law that we
- 49:28talked about earlier, I hope this goal today
- 49:33was really to give you an understanding of the
- 49:37shift in immigration policy in terms of this
- 49:40administration. What I have seen is that the
- 49:43focus has been on, yes, everyone says the focus
- 49:47has been an increased focus on enforcement, but
- 49:50enforcement isn't. kind of specific enough. The
- 49:53focus is really on expulsion, not deterrence.
- 49:56You know, during the first administration, the
- 49:58first Trump administration, there's a lot of
- 50:00talk on like the border wall and the travel ban.
- 50:02But now it feels like an expulsion, right? There
- 50:05is kind of the the immigration raids that are
- 50:09happening, there is talk, every once in a while
- 50:12you get talks of denaturalization, and that is
- 50:14really kind of a moving people from the United
- 50:17States out, aggressively deporting them, not
- 50:19even to necessarily their home country of origin,
- 50:23but to a third country that will take these individuals.
- 50:30That effort is really also going to impact how
- 50:33the government deals with kind of the existing
- 50:36asylum backlog and the existing visa backlog.
- 50:39but also is going to have an impact, I think,
- 50:42on business immigration enforcement. One of the
- 50:45things that I've started to see is aggressive
- 50:48moves towards subpoenas and records, both in
- 50:50the health care context, but also I think businesses
- 50:54are going to start getting subpoenas from ICE
- 50:56and warrants, asking them to basically allow
- 51:00either blanket searches of their premises or
- 51:02to produce documents to look for undocumented
- 51:07individuals. And then finally, we have policy
- 51:11changes. The policy changes kind of captures,
- 51:17I guess, the movement towards enforcement and
- 51:19expulsion. But also, we are looking very quickly
- 51:25to a new fiscal year where the USRAP ceiling
- 51:32is going to be set. So that number was historically
- 51:35125 ,000. I have no idea what the number is going
- 51:38to be this year. It could be zero. And I know
- 51:40the government has argued in the past that that
- 51:42number could be zero. It could be 50 ,000. It
- 51:45is just a significant decrease in the number
- 51:47that it used to be. And then there is also the
- 51:51talk of focus on civil denaturalization, review
- 51:54of visas, not only for new visas, but for individuals
- 51:59who are present in the United States on Exist
- 52:01Support. currently present in the United States
- 52:03on visas and whether or not to review those visas.
- 52:07So that kind of all falls within policy changes.
- 52:09And again, with limited resources, with the government's
- 52:14resources, kind of just the people it has, all
- 52:16of this focus takes away from the benefits side,
- 52:20right? From the adjudication of the benefits,
- 52:22from the lawful I -130s and I -45s, and kind
- 52:26of even determining, even working through the
- 52:29asylum backlog. This is just the same ARERA slide
- 52:35that I had at the beginning of the presentation.
- 52:38It's a reminder that ARERA was enacted in 1996,
- 52:43and it has been a very, very long time since
- 52:45Congress has done anything. The most recent Court
- 52:51of Appeals argument I had in the Second Circuit
- 52:53involved the judges, the panel being very, very
- 52:56upset with me for the government's position in
- 52:59that case. I said, my light went on. But I said,
- 53:07my answer to the panel was basically, that's
- 53:10the law. That's the law that Congress set. And
- 53:14I can't change that. I think immigration lawyers
- 53:17are, immigration lawyers I think are all frustrated,
- 53:21both whether they're on the government side or
- 53:23the private side right now, because immigration
- 53:24policy has been. has not been updated to reflect
- 53:28existing realities and concerns, but also it
- 53:31has been shaped so much by changes in policy
- 53:34and court decisions that aren't necessarily cohesive.
- 53:38You have courts in the Second Circuit and the
- 53:39Third Circuit and the Ninth Circuit, they're
- 53:41all kind of saying different things. You get
- 53:43circuit splits, eventually you get up to the
- 53:45Supreme Court, but that's on one issue. There
- 53:47are so many issues in immigration law and where
- 53:50an individual is and where the issue pops up,
- 53:54the outcome will differ significantly based on
- 53:57what jurisdiction you're in. So I think this
- 54:04is kind of my, when I was thinking about the
- 54:08focuses that ARERA had, the impact of ARERA on
- 54:11kind of the left -hand side. the enforcement
- 54:13focus, due process, family separation, the punitive
- 54:17environment, legislative influence, and then
- 54:19kind of where ARERA has led us to today. So you'll
- 54:23have ARERA established a foundation for prioritizing
- 54:28border security and interior enforcement. So
- 54:31you have interior enforcement, expulsion, you
- 54:33have the border wall, you have visa bans. When
- 54:37we're looking at due process, ARERA really set
- 54:40up that limited judicial review and relief. And
- 54:43so now you have kind of an increasingly, I think,
- 54:48difficult situation where the government's aggressive
- 54:51use of expedited removal process is raising serious
- 54:56concerns about what due process rights individuals
- 54:59have. There is family separation that, you know,
- 55:04Eurera definitely increased deportation that
- 55:06contributed to it and the social disruption.
- 55:08So Now you have situations where the government
- 55:13is actively encouraging individuals to self -deport.
- 55:16So you'll have family members who are parents,
- 55:20grandparents who will self -deport, but then
- 55:22what happens to their US citizen children. And
- 55:26then there's the punitive environment, right?
- 55:28The IRERA set up those kind of increasingly mandatory
- 55:32detention policies and penalties and re -entry
- 55:35bars. And I can't think of anything, I can't
- 55:39think of anything that more encapsulates a punitive
- 55:41environment that alligator acotras or the government
- 55:44sending folks to third countries that they don't
- 55:47even have any connection or relation to. And
- 55:50then there's legislative influence. You know,
- 55:53ARERA really paved the way for subsequent laws
- 55:57like Homeland Security and 9 -11. But we really
- 56:01have very little congressional action. We have
- 56:05had times where Congress has said they will kind
- 56:09of talk or, you know, try to work on a bipartisan
- 56:12bill, but those have not been successful. We
- 56:15have, and we unfortunately have a situation where
- 56:19it feels like one side of Congress has completely
- 56:22abdicated to executive power, and that executive
- 56:26power goes to everything from the president claiming
- 56:30that 212 gives the president power to not only
- 56:36prohibit the entry, but also the expulsion of
- 56:39individuals to kind of looking at bigger issues
- 56:41such as what is the president's Article II powers?
- 56:45What can the president do under Article II? And
- 56:49it does feel like that congressional silence,
- 56:54the congressional silence does feel like in many
- 56:57ways an acceptance or a concession of what Congress
- 57:03should be doing to the president. And we see
- 57:07it not only in terms of immigration enforcement,
- 57:10but also in terms of funding. The government
- 57:14is capable of using funding to really get individuals,
- 57:23businesses, corporations, and schools. We see
- 57:25that with the universities. Government funding
- 57:28is such a big deal that they can use funding
- 57:31as a tool to influence or advance their immigration
- 57:35goals and policies. So I think that one of the
- 57:44biggest issues with immigration right now is
- 57:46nobody really knows what's going on with immigration.
- 57:49It certainly seems to change on a daily basis.
- 57:52I have very many friends, very many good friends.
- 57:55who are still in the Department of Justice and
- 57:57have very many good friends who have left the
- 57:59Department of Justice and are working on the
- 58:03private immigration side. One of the biggest
- 58:05issues, I think, is a sense of how to keep up
- 58:10with the news. I'm always happy to talk about
- 58:14immigration. That's one of my favorite topics.
- 58:16And I think that there are a lot of really good
- 58:20folks paying attention, keeping track of policies
- 58:23and preparing to address the challenges as we
- 58:27face them. I think businesses have been largely
- 58:32kind of protected from some of the more unpleasant
- 58:37aspects of immigration enforcement right now.
- 58:40One thing that we are seeing is, you know, obviously
- 58:43the raids on the communities and the detention
- 58:46of individuals that is the start, I do think
- 58:51that with the new budget or bill that was passed
- 58:54in July, the increased funding that ICE is going
- 58:58to get for enforcement is going to be spent on
- 59:01kind of more large scale immigration enforcement.
- 59:04So to the extent we see, you know, kind of hospitals
- 59:07being subpoenaed for medical records, we're going
- 59:11to start seeing businesses and, I don't know,
- 59:14businesses, churches, other organizations being
- 59:17subpoenaed. I am done with my slide. So I am
- 59:25now going to look at the Q &A section and see
- 59:28kind of what questions there are. I'll start
- 59:35from that. Can you discuss how much of a financial
- 59:37incentive it is for private corporations to have
- 59:39more people detained or for longer periods of
- 59:42time? Is this a significant concern, renovation
- 59:47agenda? I'm looking at this question about financial
- 59:51incentives to have people detained. I think your
- 59:55question maybe goes to the private contractors
- 59:57who are operating many of the detention centers.
- 1:00:05There is certainly that concern. There are private
- 1:00:08groups, contracting groups, who are operating
- 1:00:11the detention centers and also suggestions as
- 1:00:14to private groups. private corporations that
- 1:00:17run like small airline fleets or airline fleets,
- 1:00:21I guess, who are contracting with ICE to run
- 1:00:23their deportation flights. I think that there
- 1:00:26are certainly companies that are taking advantage
- 1:00:33of the opportunities that they have. I do not
- 1:00:37think that that... I mean, I think it depends,
- 1:00:42right? Is this a significant concern or motivation
- 1:00:44for the agenda for lack of due process? I think
- 1:00:47for some people that could be it. It's great.
- 1:00:49They're making money. But I don't honestly think
- 1:00:53that that is the government's goal. I don't think
- 1:01:02that the government is planning to, or like the
- 1:01:05main actors in the government space who are putting
- 1:01:07into place these policies. I don't think that's
- 1:01:11what they're after. I just can't see how this
- 1:01:13is financially motivated, kind of the level of
- 1:01:16hate and animosity that we're seeing. The question
- 1:01:20that I keep looking at is, I see this as a negation
- 1:01:22of due process at the federal level. Am I missing
- 1:01:24something? I agree. It has been very difficult
- 1:01:30for anybody who has been in the immigration space
- 1:01:35for any amount of time. You know it's hard for
- 1:01:37many of my friends who are private citizens who
- 1:01:40are seeing this happen or have family members
- 1:01:42or friends who are being subjected to these administration
- 1:01:48policies because it does feel like they're taking
- 1:01:50away due process. One of the biggest concerns
- 1:01:54that I have, or we all have, is that it feels
- 1:01:59like the federal district courts are fighting
- 1:02:00the good fight. But they're not, at least on
- 1:02:04the big cases that have gone to the Supreme Court,
- 1:02:06they're not getting kind of the final decision
- 1:02:09that they need in order to really change immigration
- 1:02:14policy. Because the Supreme Court seems to kind
- 1:02:19of agree with this notion of unlimited executive
- 1:02:22power. seeing, can advocates who are warning
- 1:02:26immigrants about ISIS presence have any fear
- 1:02:28of being arrested for shielding immigrants? I
- 1:02:31think that there is a concern that I've certainly
- 1:02:37seen, I've seen some news reports indicating
- 1:02:43that the government is taking a very aggressive
- 1:02:46approach in terms of any kind of hostility or
- 1:02:52obstruction of justice, accusations against individuals
- 1:02:56who are shielding or protecting undocumented
- 1:03:00folks who are being arrested by ICE. So it is
- 1:03:06a very big concern. Does a respondent in a removal
- 1:03:11action have a right to discovery? Yes. So typically
- 1:03:16there is discovery. in district court, it depends
- 1:03:23on where you are in the immigration space. But
- 1:03:27in federal court, there's always a right to discovery.
- 1:03:31In the immigration court process, I think you
- 1:03:33do have a right to what the government produces
- 1:03:37to show that you are removable. But I think that
- 1:03:42the key issue in the immigration court space
- 1:03:46is that If you are here and documented, it is
- 1:03:49your burden to show that you have a right to
- 1:03:53relief, right? So you have the individual who
- 1:03:56is in proceedings has a burden to show either
- 1:03:59they're entitled to asylum, they're entitled
- 1:04:00to cat, et cetera. And they are not entitled
- 1:04:04to government resource. They're not entitled
- 1:04:07to appointed counsel. So they have a right to
- 1:04:09counsel, but the government doesn't have to.
- 1:04:12give them counsel. So it becomes a very difficult
- 1:04:16issue in terms of kind of how you're going to
- 1:04:19get all your documents. And that's one of those
- 1:04:21kind of procedural hurdles to removal. It feels
- 1:04:28like undocumented individuals have no due process
- 1:04:31rights today, rounded up without any cause, beaten,
- 1:04:34apprehended, incarcerated. What potential legal
- 1:04:37claims can be filed against the government to
- 1:04:39address these abuses? Well I think that you know
- 1:04:42those go to kind of grow an unusual punishment.
- 1:04:46I know that the government has at times in the
- 1:04:48past taken the work taken the position that individuals
- 1:04:51who are here undocumented have no due process
- 1:04:54rights. I don't think that's correct. They have
- 1:04:57some due process rights. They might have slightly
- 1:05:00less due process rights than a US citizen. But
- 1:05:04to the extent that the government is violating
- 1:05:06those due process rights, I think individuals,
- 1:05:09certainly LPRs or US citizens who are detained
- 1:05:12and treated poorly are going to have FDCA claims
- 1:05:16and 1983 actions. I think we start, I think that
- 1:05:21the private bar needs to start there to pursue
- 1:05:24those cases and then try to expand the detention
- 1:05:28of, trying to expand 1983 and FDCA claims from
- 1:05:33the lawful permanent residence to undocumented
- 1:05:36individuals. I'm seeing some questions about
- 1:05:49companies and green card holders. That's a tough
- 1:05:52one. I mean, the green card space is very difficult
- 1:05:55right now because I do think that the government
- 1:05:58is, I do think, I do know that there was kind
- 1:06:01of a comprehensive overview and review of the
- 1:06:05visa application process. A lot of it is, I think,
- 1:06:08just sit tight and wait and see what happens.
- 1:06:12It is changing, I think, every day. it certainly
- 1:06:16feels like it is. One thing that I would say
- 1:06:19for, unfortunately, if I'm being completely transparent,
- 1:06:24one thing I'd say is that companies, especially
- 1:06:27large companies and companies that are likely
- 1:06:31to be in the news, need to be concerned about
- 1:06:35being in a position where the government might
- 1:06:37wanna retaliate against you. So you're gonna...
- 1:06:41have to be concerned about, say, taking a position
- 1:06:45on immigration or speaking out against immigration
- 1:06:48because that could subject those companies that
- 1:06:51rely on green card holders or company -sponsored
- 1:06:54green card holders that they employ, that could
- 1:06:57result in them being subjected to enforcement.
- 1:07:02operations and that ties into the whole, are
- 1:07:05they going to be, you know, sent a DHS subpoena
- 1:07:07or are they going to get a warrant against them
- 1:07:11to search the premises for undocumented immigrants?
- 1:07:15It's just kind of not a great space right now.
- 1:07:17It's very tenuous and it does change daily. So
- 1:07:21I would really, you know, consult your immigration
- 1:07:23council, pay attention to the news. There is
- 1:07:27a lot of right now hang tight and see what happens
- 1:07:29next. Latino US citizen are being detained by
- 1:07:34ICE. What can they tell agents to avoid? I think
- 1:07:37they just need to say as loudly as possible that
- 1:07:39they are US citizens. That is my advice. I've
- 1:07:43had very many friends ask me what to do. And
- 1:07:46I've said, just say as loudly as possible that
- 1:07:49you are a US citizen. and then call your attorney.
- 1:07:52And for very close, very good friends of mine,
- 1:07:54I have said, you are welcome to call me. Their
- 1:07:58lawyer needs to file an immediate habeas action
- 1:08:02with the TRO seeking their release, because they
- 1:08:05are a US citizen and ICE does not have jurisdiction.
- 1:08:09And it could be a few days. What I've told most
- 1:08:12people is that it could be a few days in which
- 1:08:14you're detained. But they don't have a basis
- 1:08:17for detaining you. The key is you're a U .S.
- 1:08:20citizen, they're violating your rights, and they
- 1:08:23need to contact their lawyer, and their lawyer
- 1:08:24needs to get to ICE as quickly as possible, and
- 1:08:30the U .S. Attorney's Office, where the individual
- 1:08:32resides, or the Central District of California,
- 1:08:34as quickly as possible to get them released.
- 1:08:37And then after that, it becomes a question of,
- 1:08:40you know, FTCA and 1983 actions. But Just kind
- 1:08:45of say as loudly as possible, but not violently.
- 1:08:51As loudly as possible that you are a US citizen
- 1:08:53is kind of the best advice I can give. I think
- 1:09:00that is all the questions. I'm grateful for everyone
- 1:09:05who joined today and I hope you all found this
- 1:09:08interesting and helpful.