Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / The Supreme Court Of Canada Just Opened A New Door To Sue Your Ex
Transcript
- 0:34Michael Mulligan: Yes, this decision which just came out from the Supreme Court of Canada is going to have a massive impact in terms of how family law cases proceed.
- 0:43Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure that that's been fully absorbed in the uh the reporting that's occurred so far about it.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: But what the Supreme Court of Canada has done here is create a new tort.
- 0:54Michael Mulligan: And what's a tort?
- 0:55Michael Mulligan: I guess it's a dessert, but it in this context, uh it's a uh there are a list of things uh which have been established by courts to amount to like civil wrongs, things that you could sue somebody for.
- 1:07Michael Mulligan: And so common ones people may be familiar with are things like negligence, right?
- 1:11Michael Mulligan: You could sue somebody for negligence on the basis they were careless and caused you some harm.
- 1:16Michael Mulligan: Other things would include uh civil claims for things like an assault or a battery or false imprisonment, or there's even one for the intentional infliction of mental distress, right?
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: Um, or um defamation would be another example of it.
- 1:30Michael Mulligan: And many of those things have been sort of incrementally created by common law over many, many years, right?
- 1:38Michael Mulligan: And courts are generally uh reluctant to make radical policy changes, leaving those for legislative action, uh, and traditionally have made sort of minor changes over the many years to how those sort of court-created uh torts uh worked.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: Now, with that being said, the courts have uh said repeatedly, look, there is author there is capacity for courts to create a brand new tort.
- 2:06Michael Mulligan: Um, and that's what's just happened.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: Um and the this new tort, just like that list of things I mentioned, um, is a new basis upon which you could sue somebody for money.
- 2:19Michael Mulligan: Um and it's been defined uh uh either, the language they've used kind of alternates between this concept of intimate partner violence or coercive and controlling conduct.
- 2:29Michael Mulligan: Now the concept there of intimate partner violence, and who could be uh who everyone would of course be against all forms of violence, one would imagine.
- 2:39Michael Mulligan: Uh one of the challenges here is that they've it was one of these circumstances where they've defined this thing in a way that doesn't involve what most people would consider violence.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: Uh it's been defined by the Supreme Court of Canada uh to include a whole host of things that are potentially uh not clearly defined.
- 3:00Michael Mulligan: Um and the court talks about it as being things like conduct that could amount to things like emotional abuse or economic control, or uh I think one of the pieces of language they used in here was uh like litigation, like using litigation in some improper way.
- 3:18Michael Mulligan: And they described it as things which could undermine the person's ability to make meaningful choices about their life free of coercion, uh, or activity that might uh interfere with the equality of spouses, uh or uh, you know, whether somebody can be uh sort of equal and autonomous as being the things that might be affected by things like economic coercion or interfering with relationships or things of that sort.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: Uh and as you can probably tell from that kind of language, uh that is not well defined.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: Uh and in fact, the couple of judges from the Supreme Court of Canada who dissented on this decision to create this brand new tort, the concerns that they expressed was they said this is just not clear what behavior would make out this coercive control, and there's no meaningful guidance uh in terms for courts about things like, well, how much money should be awarded, or how that should that be determined.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: What behavior does amount to this kind of coercive control or quote intimate partner violence, which of course doesn't include violence in the ordinary English meaning of that term.
- 4:28Michael Mulligan: And so it's very unclear what is going to be captured.
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: But what is clear, what the minority here dissenting judges pointed out, is this is likely to lead to a complete change uh in terms of how family cases are litigated, uh, and it is likely to massively increase the amount of time spent in court litigating these things.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: And it's a complete change because currently in Canada we have for sort of things like property division in a divorce circumstance, we don't have fault as one of the things that's being considered there.
- 5:01Michael Mulligan: It's not like, oh, you cheated on your husband, therefore you get less money, or you were a very bad husband in some way or other, right?
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: You were not very attentive and loving, and so therefore you should get less money for that purpose.
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: We don't do that uh because you would well, it's a variety of public policy reasons for that, but you can imagine what that litigation would look like, right?
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: It would go on potentially forever.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: Well, this is going to add that element to many family law cases.
- 5:29Michael Mulligan: Um, and one of the reactions I had to this, just reading this decision and and the uh decision from the dissenting judges, uh, was that, you know, in BC we got rid of uh we've introduced no fault for car accidents, right?
- 5:43Michael Mulligan: As we talked about before, I think there's lots of reason to think that's not the best idea, right?
- 5:48Michael Mulligan: But in terms of how people are treated.
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: But uh there were a bunch of lawyers who used to spend their time and still do, because there's still uh sort of some of those cases that are still in the system, spend their time litigating um serious car accidents, you know, sort of who was at fault and was there, as I mentioned, the tort there, tort of negligence, right?
- 6:05Michael Mulligan: That was the one that used to apply, uh, although no longer uh in British Columbia negligence and the car accident context doesn't matter anymore.
- 6:13Michael Mulligan: There's going to be a whole team of lawyers out there who had spent their time litigating those things, who I suspect will almost immediately begin litigating this, right?
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: Um and the in this case, the award uh originally made by the trial judge who created this tort um gave three awards of fifty thousand dollars uh for different heads of damages.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: I think it was slightly reduced on appeal, I think, to a hundred thousand dollars.
- 6:38Michael Mulligan: But there's potentially a bunch of money there.
- 6:41Michael Mulligan: There's no uh guidance in terms of how that should be calculated, and the way this is framed, we'll come to that in a moment, in terms of the things that might be this, um, are not precisely delineated, and there's no case law on it because it's a brand new thing that's been made up.
- 6:58Michael Mulligan: Um, and so all of that is going to be a a recipe for uh litigation.
- 7:05Michael Mulligan: I I don't know what else is so and the idea is that it sounds like this could be either a free-floating thing, like somebody might bring an action for this coercive controlling conduct or intimate partner violence as a free-floating thing, or the other thing it seems likely, as in this case, is it will get bolted on to uh like the divorce process where the court is dealing with the division of property, right?
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: And usually now, as I said, no fault hasn't been an issue, and so the division of property is things like how much is the house worth, and was she should this property being brought into the marriage be considered, or how should the business assets be divided, right?
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: But those are sort of economic things.
- 7:46Michael Mulligan: There would be litigation currently over um often uh children, right?
- 7:51Michael Mulligan: That that can become a focus, particularly in sort of high conflict cases.
- 7:55Michael Mulligan: There's this language used of like high conflict divorces where the people sort of hate each other uh and spend their time litigating for you know forever over what you know, the wagon wheel coffee table and why somebody was ten minutes late dropping off Johnny.
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: And and so this is going to now add just a massive fuel to that fire.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh the it is, at least to me, and at least to the minority of judges who dissented from the Supreme Court of Canada, clear that there is going to be a need for a significant increase in the number of judges uh required uh to hear family law disputes uh because they are now going to, in all probability, given how broad and ill-defined this is, uh to have allegations maybe in both directions, claiming, hey, my ex-spouse was coercively controlling me uh in form of uh financial abuse or in terms of um, you know, they talk about things like undermining the victim's ability to make meaningful choices about their life.
- 8:56Michael Mulligan: You just think about the how broad that is, right?
- 8:59Michael Mulligan: Or the language like a person could be is deprived of their ability to live free of coercion uh as an equal to their spouse, um, and uh the autonomous equality of the relationship being violated.
- 9:11Michael Mulligan: Now, on one level, you can say, well, sure, who who could be against the idea of people being free of coercion and equality in relationships, of course, are good things, right?
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: I don't think many people disagree with that, right?
- 9:22Michael Mulligan: But you could just imagine how many things could be poured into the bucket of my life was not free of coercion, and it undermined my autonomy uh my equality and autonomous capacity to uh and the whole list of things like you know, financial autonomy or autonomy to pursue work opportunities or school opportunities.
- 9:43Michael Mulligan: Um and so uh this is a very, very major change in terms of how these things are gonna work.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: It's likely to change uh the lawyers doing that work.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: Many of the people that used to do civil things are likely to get into this.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: Um and uh it's going to get bolted on to just many cases.
- 10:02Michael Mulligan: We see that already, and I should say, you know, I I see this in the context because I practice criminal law.
- 10:07Michael Mulligan: I don't do family law or sue people for money, right?
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: That's not what I do.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: Uh but you will see in some of those sort of high conflict family law cases, one of the things which is uh unfortunately uh common uh is for one or both of the spouses to make criminal allegations about the other, right?
- 10:27Michael Mulligan: To say, oh, my wife hit me or my husband pushed me or whatever it is.
- 10:31Michael Mulligan: And then when the criminal justice system gets engaged, you then wind up with things like one person gets an order that they get possession of the house, and the other person can't have contact, and that means has an impact on, you know, for example, uh custody of children, at least on an interim basis, right?
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: And so there's already a powerful incentive to do that, and some of the allegations, of course, are true, right?
- 10:53Michael Mulligan: But not all of them are, right?
- 10:55Michael Mulligan: I mean, that's I guess the unfortunate reality of things, and those of us who spend our days doing this know that the fact that somebody got to the phone and made a complaint of something doesn't mean that's what happened.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: Um sometimes it did, sometimes it didn't, and really there's no other way to sort that out than have a trial.
- 11:10Michael Mulligan: And so there's already that incentive to create those kind of allegations because it does advantage family law cases.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: Now there's going to be a direct financial benefit uh if you're successful in making out a claim that you are coercively controlled.
- 11:25Michael Mulligan: Um and so uh that is likely to lead in addition to an increase in uh sort of the family law litigation over money and fighting about whether it was coercive controlling financial behavior or um whether um what's some of the other language used in here, um wrong coercive control.
- 11:46Michael Mulligan: They separated this, I should say, from the existing sort of intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: They found that that wasn't enough to capture everything here.
- 11:55Michael Mulligan: Uh they included that this concept of intimate partner, quote, violence, close quote, can take the form of things including manipulation, isolation, uh, or financial abuse.
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 12:07Michael Mulligan: And so, in addition to the direct fighting over those things in the context of family law cases, making them now we're gonna have trials rather than settlements over things, um, it also because it it can include, it it would appear from this decision, and bear in mind this is the only decision on this case, which is the other concern that was expressed by the minority.
- 12:28Michael Mulligan: Like many of these things, if you ask the lawyer, is something or other uh let's say, well, let's pick a tort here, a uh deducing a breach of contract.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: That's a tort.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: Yeah um, you would be able to look up previous cases to figure that out.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: You say, okay, well, there are a thousand cases that have decided that, and he's the courts very carefully delineated what is and what isn't, and so your lawyer would be able to look at those things and look at your fact pattern and give you an opinion about it.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: Like, yeah, I think this probably is, or no, this probably is not.
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: But when you have this new very broad concept with no authority for this in the past at all, uh, and you ask a lawyer, could this amount to manipulation, isolation, or financial abuse?
- 13:05Michael Mulligan: The response is likely to be, yeah, sure, maybe.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 13:08Michael Mulligan: And if you say, Well, how much money should you get for that?
- 13:10Michael Mulligan: Okay, what have previous people got for that?
- 13:12Michael Mulligan: You say, Well, I have no idea.
- 13:13Michael Mulligan: There's only one case about this.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Um, and so uh off to court we go.
- 13:18Michael Mulligan: Uh, and they've even there's even language in here in this case, remembering this is the entirety of the description of what this tort is, because it was just created.
- 13:26Michael Mulligan: Uh, and there's even the suggestion that a single incident of something or other might qualify for this, and that it can be something physical, which is what most people would refer to as violence, right?
- 13:37Michael Mulligan: Something that might already be captured by like the existing torts um for things like uh assault, right, or battery.
- 13:44Michael Mulligan: Um you could have that as well, which may lead to police complaints as well, now that there's uh people are gonna think pretty quickly recognize there's a financial um uh incentive to do that when diving what really what it amounts to is the division dividing up of property, because that's the occasion where most people might have, you know, when the house is getting sold and things are being divided up, that's when there may be a substantial pool of money to be divided in a uh in uh other than an equal way.
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: So it's a sea change in terms of how these things are going to be sorted out, and uh I hope they uh are prepared for that uh and start hiring the requisite family judges with family experience in the BC Supreme Court to start hearing these things because there's likely to be an absolute flood of them.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: So that's the least from the Supreme Court of Canada, creating a brand new tort.
- 14:30Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyer.
- 14:32Adam Stirling: Legally speaking will continue right after the airport legally speaking.
- 14:37Adam Stirling: In fact, Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyer.
- 14:45Adam Stirling: Bulletproof unquote quest or vest, excuse me.
- 14:48Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 14:50Michael Mulligan: Well, first of all, you should bear in mind that the new term bulletproof vest is perhaps not indicative of how in fact they operate.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: They're not bulletproof.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: They are bullet resistant.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: So this is a the this is a local case, uh, and the fact pattern is that these two friends uh who uh apparently had uh engaged in this quote game for some period of time, uh they on a pr the evening in question, they first of all started at a wrestling show, then they moved on to a brewery, then they went to the Legion, then a house party, all of where it's it sounds like there was drinking going on.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: Uh so they were drinking, clearly drunk, there's some cocaine use, so then they decided to get in a truck after gathering some guns, ammunition, and bulletproof vests, uh, and they drove out to a logging road near Jordan River to go shooting.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh as they had apparently done in the past, the game that they had uh come up with was shooting each other with bulletproof vests on.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: Um and the fellow who uh got shot and died uh put on a bulletproof vest and then said to the accused in this case, don't be a bitch, fucking do it.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: Sorry about the language, that's a quote.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: Uh and the uh accused shot him in the bulletproof vest.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: Unfortunately, as we started with, bulletproof vests are not bulletproof, they're bullet resistant.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: Um, and the bullet penetrated the vest, uh, and then uh bits of it uh went into his chest and uh sack around his heart, caused massive bleeding, uh, and he fell to the ground.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: The man who shot him thought he was faking it, um, and uh after realizing that wasn't so, dragged him through the snow, snowing, uh, put pressure on the wound, did his best, but he he expired.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so, first of all, what a terrible uh uh state of affairs in terms of uh planning and activity.
- 16:42Michael Mulligan: Um and then uh he's charged with a number of things, and here's the legal aspect of it.
- 16:48Michael Mulligan: So one of the things he was uh charged, he was charged with a number of things.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: Uh he was charged with some offenses relating to the firearm itself, like being in possession of a firearm without the required license and so on.
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: The firearm in question, the one used to do the shooting, apparently there's more than one, but the one he had used, because the plan was he would shoot the friend, and then the the game of the past was that person would then shoot the person, other person back with another gun, I guess.
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: Um the gun was uh described as a polymer 80, which is interesting.
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: I did a little bit of reading about what that is.
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: Uh it's from a company that now has gone bankrupt.
- 17:20Michael Mulligan: It appears to be their business model was selling like 80% complete kits to make guns, like handguns.
- 17:27Michael Mulligan: Um, and so I'm not sure that it's like a 3D printed thing, but like the company was selling all the pieces you could use to, well, 80% of them, uh, to put together your own handgun.
- 17:37Michael Mulligan: And so while it's not specified in the sentencing decision, it sounds like that may be the reason why they wound up with some gun they weren't prohibited to you weren't permitted to have, right?
- 17:46Michael Mulligan: Handguns are restricted or prohibited, and they need to be registered, you need to have a, you know, there's kind of training which would include don't shoot somebody in the chest wearing a bulletproof vest.
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: Um, and it appears that the gun may be of a sort that uh none of those things went on uh for.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: There's a semi-automatic handgun.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: Um and so he was charged with offenses related to simply possessing that without the proper license or registration, but he was also charged with manslaughter.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: Um and the thing about that, right, for murder, most people are familiar with the idea that you have to be uh you have to intend to kill the person, which is plainly not the case here.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: Um, you know, they uh they had played this quote game close quote before.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: He thought the test was genuinely bulletproof, um uh, and so there was clearly no intent to kill the friend.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: But the way manslaughter works is you can wind up with a conviction for manslaughter if you uh kill somebody, uh, and you do so in the course of committing some other offense, like you know, in this case, it would be uh I guess possessing this uh uh un you know restricted firearm without a license, right?
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: That would be an offense.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: It would also be an offense, in fact, to uh uh of assaulting somebody because you can uh you can consent to uh like a fist fight or something, right?
- 19:05Michael Mulligan: It makes it not an assault, because an assault has to be a like a non-consensual application of force or threatened application of force to somebody else.
- 19:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: And so you can consent to like if you say to your friend, let's go out and punch each other, well, that's probably fine, right?
- 19:18Michael Mulligan: At least uh legally, uh, but uh you can't consent to grievous bodily harm.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: Like you can't consent, and this is just a policy decision from the Supreme Court of Canada, you just can't consent to you know having a sword fight or having a duel um or something of that sort, right?
- 19:35Michael Mulligan: Even though you might have agreed to it, we've just as a policy decision concluded we're not going to recognize consent to grievous bodily harm uh lest we have people engaging in, you know, sword fights and duels.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: Um and so as a result, you would also have uh an underlying offense here of assault because you can't consent to that kind of grievous bodily harm.
- 19:55Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's how you can have a manslaughter charge when there's no intent to um, in fact, even harm the other person, let alone kill them.
- 20:03Michael Mulligan: And then under the criminal code, if you have a uh manslaughter involving a firearm, carries a mandatory minimum sentence of at least four years imprisonment.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: And so in this case, the man pled guilty uh to the offenses, including manslaughter, and there was in fact a joint submission for the judge to impose that, which is the mandatory minimum of four years in prison, uh, and then he got various other sentences less than that uh for the various firearms offenses.
- 20:29Michael Mulligan: And so that's what was imposed here is a four-year penitentiary uh term for shooting his friend in the chest when the friend had asked him to do it uh immediately before doing it.
- 20:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and so I thought that was uh interesting, both in terms of the stupidity of the conduct, um, but also in terms of how those issues of consent and so on apply in a manslaughter charge when you have, as in this case, the person begging the person on to uh shoot him.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: And so that's the uh latest censing decision on manslaughter uh out of Victoria.
- 21:01Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulgan Defense Lawyers Legally Speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 21:06Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:07Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:07Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:08Adam Stirling: All right, quick break news next.