Latest / Bloomberg Law / Life and Legacy of Justice O'Connor, Outlook for Sackler Family in Opioid Lawsuit
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 0:05Speaker 1: at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 0:09Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business app, or listen on demand wherever
- 0:12Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 0:16Speaker 2: I'm Kimbilly Robinson and I'm Lydia Wheeler. We're filling in
- 0:19Speaker 2: for June Grasso, who's out this week ahead. In the hour,
- 0:22Speaker 2: we'll talk about the fight at the Supreme Court over
- 0:24Speaker 2: a six billion dollar bankruptcy settlement that could release the
- 0:27Speaker 2: billionaire owners of Purdue Pharma from all liability related to
- 0:30Speaker 2: the opioid overdose deaths.
- 0:32Speaker 3: But first we'll talk about the late Justice Saunder Day O'Connor,
- 0:35Speaker 3: the first woman to sit on the US Supreme Court.
- 0:38Speaker 4: So today I'm pleased to announce that, upon completion of
- 0:42Speaker 4: all the necessary checks by the Federal Bureau of Investigation,
- 0:46Speaker 4: I will send to the Senate the nomination of Judge
- 0:48Speaker 4: Sandra Day O'Connor of Arizona Court of Appeals for confirmation
- 0:53Speaker 4: as an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court.
- 0:57Speaker 4: She is truly a person for all seasons, possessing those
- 1:01Speaker 4: unique qualities of temperament, fairness, intellectual capacity, and devotion to
- 1:05Speaker 4: the public good, which have characterized the one hundred and
- 1:08Speaker 4: one brethren who have preceded her.
- 1:11Speaker 3: That was President Ronald Reagan, who nominated O'Connor in July
- 1:14Speaker 3: nineteen eighty one. The justice died last week at the
- 1:17Speaker 3: age of ninety three. Joining us to talk about her
- 1:20Speaker 3: trailblazing time on the bench is New York University law
- 1:23Speaker 3: professor Melissa Murray, who co hosts a podcast on the
- 1:26Speaker 3: Supreme Court called Strick Scrutiny. Thanks so much for joining us.
- 1:29Speaker 5: Thanks for having me.
- 1:31Speaker 3: Hey, Melissa, I was wondering if you could start by
- 1:33Speaker 3: telling us a little bit about how Justice O'Connor got
- 1:36Speaker 3: on the High Court bench. Just wondering what was the
- 1:38Speaker 3: moment like when she was nominated to the Court as
- 1:42Speaker 3: the first female justice.
- 1:44Speaker 5: Well, obviously, this is a campaign promise that Ronald Reagan
- 1:47Speaker 5: made in sort of the wake of the women's rights movement.
- 1:51Speaker 5: But when he had to actually go about finding a
- 1:54Speaker 5: Republican women to nominate, he didn't have a lot of choices.
- 1:58Speaker 5: On the federal bench didn't really have a great track
- 2:01Speaker 5: record of putting women on the bench, and in fact,
- 2:04Speaker 5: most of the women who had been on the federal
- 2:07Speaker 5: bench at that point had been appointed by Jimmy Carter,
- 2:10Speaker 5: and that included Ruth Bader Ginsburg. So while there were
- 2:14Speaker 5: a number of choices on the federal bench, they weren't
- 2:16Speaker 5: necessarily ideologically aligned with Reagan and his electorate. So he
- 2:22Speaker 5: had to look a little further afield. He cast his
- 2:25Speaker 5: gaze across the state courts, and he settled on Arizona,
- 2:29Speaker 5: where Sandra D. O'Connor had been a politician. She had
- 2:33Speaker 5: been the majority leader of the Arizona Senate and from
- 2:36Speaker 5: there she had gone on to be a trial judge
- 2:38Speaker 5: in the Arizona State system and then a judge on
- 2:41Speaker 5: the Intermediate Court of Appeals in Arizona. And she'd been
- 2:44Speaker 5: very active in Republican politics in the state, worked very
- 2:48Speaker 5: closely with the Goldwater Campaign, a real mover and shaker
- 2:52Speaker 5: in Republican circles in Arizona, and she really rose to
- 2:56Speaker 5: the top.
- 2:57Speaker 2: Now, despite being appointed by a Republican and Justice O'Connor
- 3:01Speaker 2: became really a decisive vote on a number of big issues.
- 3:04Speaker 2: We're talking abortion, affirmative action. So I'm wondering, can you
- 3:08Speaker 2: tell us about a few of those notable decisions?
- 3:10Speaker 5: Sure, even straight away when she joined the court, she
- 3:15Speaker 5: definitely had some decisions that really have become canonical the
- 3:19Speaker 5: things that you know we teach now in constitutional law.
- 3:22Speaker 5: One of them was a decision in the nineteen eighties
- 3:24Speaker 5: called Mississippi University for Women Versus Hogan, which was a
- 3:28Speaker 5: challenge brought by a man, Joe Hogan. He sought admission
- 3:32Speaker 5: to a nursing program at the University of Mississippi for women,
- 3:36Speaker 5: and he was denied admission because the program was exclusively
- 3:39Speaker 5: for women. So this is a sort of predecessor to
- 3:41Speaker 5: the VMI case that was later decided by the Court
- 3:44Speaker 5: in nineteen ninety six. In that case, the University of
- 3:48Speaker 5: Mississippi said, this program is exclusively for women because we
- 3:51Speaker 5: are trying to remedy the historic exclusion that women have
- 3:55Speaker 5: faced in the employment market. And just as that's on
- 3:59Speaker 5: our kind of smell tests on this, and was like,
- 4:01Speaker 5: you know, women really haven't had a lot of barrier
- 4:03Speaker 5: to being nurses. This actually seems like a program that's
- 4:08Speaker 5: rooted in a stereotype that the only kind of medical
- 4:11Speaker 5: profession for which women are well suited is nursing. And
- 4:14Speaker 5: so on that ground, she said this was not really
- 4:17Speaker 5: a program where a gender classification could be upheld. This
- 4:21Speaker 5: was something more insidious, more of a stereotype, and she invalidated,
- 4:26Speaker 5: and she got a majority of the court to do so.
- 4:28Speaker 5: She would later go on to broker some really important
- 4:31Speaker 5: compromises on landmark issues like abortion. For example, as a
- 4:36Speaker 5: justice of the Court, she evinced a real skepticism of abortion,
- 4:41Speaker 5: not necessarily in whether or not in right existed, but
- 4:44Speaker 5: whether or not the right existed and could coexist with
- 4:47Speaker 5: the state's interests in regulating the procedure itself. And recall,
- 4:51Speaker 5: she had been a legislature at the state level, and
- 4:54Speaker 5: so she very much believed in the prerogatives of states
- 4:57Speaker 5: over certain things like health and welfare. And so she
- 5:00Speaker 5: really brought this to her judging on the issue of abortion.
- 5:05Speaker 5: And she was the one who articulated in a series
- 5:07Speaker 5: of separate opinions in cases like Webster and Thornberg, this
- 5:11Speaker 5: idea of an undue burden. And then in nineteen ninety two,
- 5:13Speaker 5: when the Court took up Planned Parenthood versus Casey, this
- 5:17Speaker 5: challenge to versus Wade, she really had an opportunity to
- 5:21Speaker 5: put that into practice. It seemed to everyone that the
- 5:24Speaker 5: Court was poised to strike down Row versus Wade, But she,
- 5:28Speaker 5: along with Justices Kennedy and Suitor, formed detroika that really
- 5:32Speaker 5: compromised on this question. Reading the public mood, recognizing the
- 5:36Speaker 5: interest and story decisive, they broke her to compromise that
- 5:40Speaker 5: would give states the opportunity to broadly regulate abortion while
- 5:44Speaker 5: still upholding the idea that there was a constitutionally protected
- 5:47Speaker 5: right of a woman to choose an abortion. And that
- 5:50Speaker 5: was one of her most significant decisions, and you see
- 5:53Speaker 5: some real glimmers of her interests in women's rights in
- 5:56Speaker 5: that opinion. One of the provisions of the broader abortion
- 6:00Speaker 5: law that was invalidated in that decision was a spouthal
- 6:03Speaker 5: notification provision that she said really endangered the lives of
- 6:07Speaker 5: women in abusive relationships and made clear that women who
- 6:12Speaker 5: were in marriages were not necessarily equal to their husbands
- 6:15Speaker 5: in terms of decision making authority. And so she did
- 6:18Speaker 5: not like the idea that women would be subservient to
- 6:21Speaker 5: husbands or would depend on husbands for making such a
- 6:24Speaker 5: decision like this, and so she invalidated it and then
- 6:27Speaker 5: again really emphasized the threat to women who were in
- 6:30Speaker 5: an abusive or violent.
- 6:32Speaker 3: Relationship you started off talking Melissa about barriers from women
- 6:35Speaker 3: that may or may not exist in the nursing space.
- 6:39Speaker 3: Even once Justice O'Connor got on the bench, there must
- 6:42Speaker 3: have been some barriers to being the first woman on
- 6:45Speaker 3: the court. Can you talk a little bit about what
- 6:47Speaker 3: that must have been like for her day in and
- 6:49Speaker 3: day out.
- 6:50Speaker 5: She mentioned this a few times when she talked about
- 6:53Speaker 5: her tenure on the floard, like it was hard to
- 6:55Speaker 5: be the first. I think she very much felt the
- 6:57Speaker 5: weight of her historic appointment. She said, you know, very frankly,
- 7:02Speaker 5: it was great to be the first, but she didn't
- 7:03Speaker 5: want to be the last. She didn't believe that her
- 7:05Speaker 5: gender necessarily said or influenced the way that she judged.
- 7:11Speaker 5: She said, you know, a wise old man and a
- 7:12Speaker 5: wise old woman would reach the same conclusions. But it
- 7:15Speaker 5: was really clear that in some of these cases, particularly
- 7:19Speaker 5: in cases involving women's rights and gender rights, she very
- 7:24Speaker 5: much came down in favor of women's rights and had
- 7:28Speaker 5: perhaps a more keen eye for the kinds of injustices
- 7:31Speaker 5: that women had experienced, and she experienced some of them herself.
- 7:36Speaker 5: Very famously. She graduated near the top of the class
- 7:39Speaker 5: at Stanford Law school and could not find a job
- 7:42Speaker 5: in the legal field as a lawyer. She was told
- 7:45Speaker 5: to get a job as a legal secretary, was offered
- 7:47Speaker 5: jobs as as a legal secretary. So I think she
- 7:51Speaker 5: understood that very well, and she also spoke about how
- 7:54Speaker 5: much of a relief it was and a joy when
- 7:58Speaker 5: Ruth Bader Ginsberg joined the Core in nineteen ninety three,
- 8:01Speaker 5: which she was no longer the only woman on the court.
- 8:04Speaker 5: And you know, they were two very different jurists in
- 8:07Speaker 5: some cases diametrically opposed in terms of their jurisprudence, but
- 8:11Speaker 5: on the question of women's rights they were often in
- 8:14Speaker 5: its alignment and voted together ninety percent of the time
- 8:17Speaker 5: in women's rights cases.
- 8:19Speaker 2: So, you know, Justice O'Connor was known for being the
- 8:22Speaker 2: first female justice on the Court, but she was also
- 8:24Speaker 2: known for being the last justice to have any prior
- 8:27Speaker 2: elected political experience, you know, before she was confirmed to
- 8:30Speaker 2: the court. Can you tell us more about that. I
- 8:32Speaker 2: know you mentioned it before about you know, her time
- 8:35Speaker 2: in Arizona, but can you walk us through what her
- 8:39Speaker 2: background was there?
- 8:40Speaker 6: Well.
- 8:40Speaker 5: I think to today's listener, the idea of a judge
- 8:44Speaker 5: who was also a politician seems a little far field,
- 8:46Speaker 5: because we just don't have that profile on the Court anymore.
- 8:49Speaker 5: I think the person who comes closest to it is
- 8:52Speaker 5: someone like Justice Kagan, who had to be relatively political
- 8:56Speaker 5: as the dean of Harvard Law School, but certainly was
- 8:59Speaker 5: not an elected in that way. But for a very
- 9:02Speaker 5: long time, this was not an unusual profile for a
- 9:06Speaker 5: justice to have. Earl Warren very famously came from California politics. HUGO.
- 9:10Speaker 5: Black had been a senator from Alabama, and Jessice O'Connor,
- 9:14Speaker 5: of course, spent a lot of time in the Arizona
- 9:17Speaker 5: State legislature, and it did inform her judging. She very
- 9:22Speaker 5: much believed in this question of federalism. She was one
- 9:26Speaker 5: of the stalwart people on the Court on the sort
- 9:30Speaker 5: of new federalism that really sought to make a clear
- 9:33Speaker 5: divide between the progatives of the states and that which
- 9:36Speaker 5: was then reserved for the federal government, and making sure
- 9:38Speaker 5: there was a clean line and that states maintained their
- 9:41Speaker 5: regulatory progatives. She also, i think applied those clients of
- 9:47Speaker 5: political experiences in the way she approached her colleagues and
- 9:52Speaker 5: the way she approached judging with an eye toward where
- 9:55Speaker 5: the public mood was right, so she was very good
- 9:59Speaker 5: at broke compromises. I think the Casey decision stands out
- 10:03Speaker 5: in that way. But she also was very adapt at
- 10:06Speaker 5: sort of understanding where the mood of the country was
- 10:09Speaker 5: on hot button issues and making sure the Court didn't
- 10:12Speaker 5: get too far out ahead of the country or lag
- 10:15Speaker 5: too far behind. And that often meant that she wasn't
- 10:18Speaker 5: advancing a broad ideological or theoretical agenda about what the
- 10:23Speaker 5: Constitution should mean, but rather was making very incremental, narrow
- 10:27Speaker 5: decisions that really huge to the four corners of each
- 10:31Speaker 5: case that was presented.
- 10:32Speaker 2: Coming up on the program, we'll talk more with Melissa
- 10:34Speaker 2: Murray about the late Justice Sandradale O'Connor. Remember you can
- 10:38Speaker 2: always get the latest legal news by listening to our
- 10:40Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law podcast on Apples, Spotify, or wherever it is
- 10:43Speaker 2: you get your podcasts. I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Kimberlee Robinson.
- 10:47Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg.
- 10:56Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch the program
- 11:00Speaker 1: weekdays at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg Radio, the tune
- 11:03Speaker 1: in app, Bloomberg dot Com, and the Bloomberg Business app.
- 11:06Speaker 1: You can also listen live on Amazon Alexa from our
- 11:09Speaker 1: flagship New York station. Just Say Alexa play Bloomberg eleven thirty.
- 11:15Speaker 2: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Kimberly Robinson in for June Grosso.
- 11:20Speaker 7: You may be surprised that I'm promoting civics teaching and
- 11:25Speaker 7: learning using online media. I'm not an expert in it,
- 11:29Speaker 7: but these are the new tools of civic engagement for
- 11:33Speaker 7: the digital generation, the young people, and even a retired
- 11:37Speaker 7: cowgirl like me knows that we need to use these
- 11:40Speaker 7: tools to educate if we're going to inspire an interest
- 11:44Speaker 7: today's young people to become active and knowledgeable civic leaders.
- 11:49Speaker 3: You just heard Justice Sunderday O'Connor introducing her online teaching
- 11:52Speaker 3: tool is Civics. We've been talking to New York University
- 11:56Speaker 3: law professor Melissa Murray about the life of Justice O'Connor,
- 11:59Speaker 3: who passed away last week. Melissa, Justice O'Connor's legacy was
- 12:03Speaker 3: solidified long before she retired in two thousand and six,
- 12:06Speaker 3: but she continued to be a public servant for many
- 12:09Speaker 3: years after her retirement, champion causes like judicial independence and
- 12:13Speaker 3: civics education. Can you tell us a little bit about
- 12:16Speaker 3: some of the things that she did after she left
- 12:18Speaker 3: the court, and you know how that sort of compares
- 12:21Speaker 3: with what we see from you know, justicis who have
- 12:23Speaker 3: recently retired.
- 12:24Speaker 5: Well, I mean isavics Is perhaps the cornerstone of her
- 12:28Speaker 5: post retirement work. And she did retire in two thousand
- 12:31Speaker 5: and five, and she wanted to be engaged. I think
- 12:35Speaker 5: at this point in time, I'm only speculating here, but
- 12:38Speaker 5: you know, at this point, I think she probably realized
- 12:41Speaker 5: that her vote in Bush versus Gore in two thousand,
- 12:45Speaker 5: which propelled George W. Bush to the presidency and set
- 12:48Speaker 5: the stage for John Roberts and then Samuel Alito to
- 12:52Speaker 5: be appointed to the cord and in d Justice Alito
- 12:54Speaker 5: took her seat, I think she understood that that had
- 12:58Speaker 5: really changed the tenor of the court, had really sort
- 13:01Speaker 5: of pushed the court in a right word direction, And
- 13:03Speaker 5: it was really clear, even before the addition of the
- 13:06Speaker 5: Trump justices that the addition of Justice Alido in her
- 13:09Speaker 5: seat had really moved the court to the writing. She
- 13:14Speaker 5: had been among the majority in a decision to pull
- 13:18Speaker 5: the McCain fein gold campaign finance law in McConnell, and
- 13:22Speaker 5: that was principally undermined by a big part of the
- 13:25Speaker 5: decision and Citizens United in twenty ten, and so, you know,
- 13:29Speaker 5: I think perhaps we might understand her work in civic
- 13:32Speaker 5: education and focusing on young people. This was an opportunity
- 13:36Speaker 5: for her to sort of re engage this question about
- 13:38Speaker 5: what democracy is, what is required of a democracy, and
- 13:41Speaker 5: what is the role of a judge in a democracy.
- 13:44Speaker 2: Now you mentioned her retirement before. At the time, the
- 13:48Speaker 2: circumstances were a little tumultuous, particularly as it came to
- 13:51Speaker 2: the timing of her retirement. So can you tell listeners
- 13:54Speaker 2: a bit about that.
- 13:55Speaker 5: So back in two thousand and five, this as O'Connor
- 13:58Speaker 5: was dealing with this family situation. Her husband was suffering
- 14:02Speaker 5: from Alzheimer's and his needs had sort of ballooned, and
- 14:07Speaker 5: she really did need to be with him more frequently.
- 14:10Speaker 5: But she was also at the height of her authority
- 14:12Speaker 5: on the court, and she really was the fulcrumbs around
- 14:15Speaker 5: which the entire court pivoted. And you know, if you
- 14:18Speaker 5: wanted to form a majority, you needed Sandra J. O'Connor
- 14:21Speaker 5: in most instances. But she didn't make the decision to
- 14:24Speaker 5: step back because of these family responsibilities when she stepped down.
- 14:29Speaker 5: John Roberts was nominated by George W. Bush to fill
- 14:33Speaker 5: her seat, and then very quickly thereafter, William Renqlist, she
- 14:37Speaker 5: was the Chief Justice at the time, unexpectedly passed away
- 14:40Speaker 5: from complications from syroid cancer. And O'Connor and Renklist were
- 14:45Speaker 5: very good friends. They had known each other at Stanford
- 14:47Speaker 5: Law School. Apparently, according to her biographer Evan Smith Evan Tannas,
- 14:52Speaker 5: they had dated at one point time and that when
- 14:55Speaker 5: christ had proposed marriage and was rejected. So they were
- 14:59Speaker 5: very good friends. But it seemed to come as a
- 15:01Speaker 5: surprise to a lot of people, and no more so
- 15:03Speaker 5: than her. And so when that vacancy presented itself, the President,
- 15:08Speaker 5: George W. Bush, nominated John Roberts to fill the seat
- 15:13Speaker 5: that Renquist had left unoccupied, and that left O'Connor seat available.
- 15:19Speaker 5: There was a lot of tumult around this. The first
- 15:22Speaker 5: person nominated to fill that seat with Harriet Meyer, who
- 15:25Speaker 5: was part of the White House Council team and someone
- 15:28Speaker 5: that President Bush knew very well from his time in Texas.
- 15:33Speaker 5: She was viewed with considerable skepticism from those in the
- 15:37Speaker 5: then nascent conservative legal movement. She didn't really have a
- 15:41Speaker 5: lot of bonus fides with conservatives, she wasn't a member
- 15:44Speaker 5: of the Federal Society. Ultimately, she withdrew from the process,
- 15:49Speaker 5: and Samuel Alido, who was perhaps a more conventional pick,
- 15:54Speaker 5: was identified and was nominated to fill her sieede. And
- 15:58Speaker 5: you know, when asked about it, she made all of
- 16:01Speaker 5: the very familiar gestures praising the nominee, but she did
- 16:04Speaker 5: note that she wished it had been a woman.
- 16:07Speaker 3: Interesting. Yeah, I do want to make sure that we
- 16:09Speaker 3: talk a lot about that swap for Justice O'Connor for
- 16:12Speaker 3: Justice Lito and sort of all the things that have
- 16:14Speaker 3: happened since then and what that means for her legacy.
- 16:17Speaker 3: But first, just want to give listeners a little idea
- 16:21Speaker 3: about you know, I think most people know a lot
- 16:24Speaker 3: about her trow blazing career, but what about her upbringing?
- 16:27Speaker 3: What was that like, because that seems very different from
- 16:30Speaker 3: a lot of the justices that we have on the
- 16:31Speaker 3: bench today as well.
- 16:32Speaker 5: Well, by her own admission, she was a cowgirl from
- 16:36Speaker 5: the American stuff. Last. She grew up principally on her parents'
- 16:39Speaker 5: ranch out in Arizona, and not a super populated place,
- 16:44Speaker 5: but you know, ranches are notoriously isolated. This was no exception.
- 16:48Speaker 5: She grew up with her her brother, and her mother
- 16:51Speaker 5: and father, and you know the ranch cans who were there.
- 16:55Speaker 5: There wasn't really an opportunity for formal schooling on the ranch.
- 16:59Speaker 5: So when it was time for her to go to school,
- 17:01Speaker 5: she went to El Paso, which is the nearest large city,
- 17:04Speaker 5: which at the time I think wasn't what we think
- 17:07Speaker 5: of as El Paso today, but that was the nearest
- 17:10Speaker 5: larger city where she was able to attend school, and
- 17:13Speaker 5: she attended school while living with an aunt in El Paso,
- 17:17Speaker 5: and then from there she went on to Stanford University
- 17:21Speaker 5: for college. She graduated early and matriculated at Stanford Law School,
- 17:25Speaker 5: where she had a very distinguished career, more distinguished than
- 17:28Speaker 5: her husband apparently, and was a member of the Law Review.
- 17:32Speaker 5: And then found as she graduated that despite her impeccable credentials,
- 17:36Speaker 5: despite her amazing training as a young woman, she could
- 17:41Speaker 5: not actually get a job as a lawyer.
- 17:43Speaker 2: Kimberly alluded to this before about you know, how a
- 17:46Speaker 2: lot has changed in some of the legal areas that
- 17:48Speaker 2: we've talked about. Can you tell us, like how consequential
- 17:52Speaker 2: it was that Justsice O'Connor was replaced by Samuel Alito
- 17:55Speaker 2: on the bench.
- 17:56Speaker 5: I think lots of ink will be spilled in the
- 17:58Speaker 5: next few months of how you know, sort of what
- 18:00Speaker 5: it meant to shift from a Justice O'Connor to a
- 18:05Speaker 5: Justice Alito. First, Justice O'Connor very much was sort of
- 18:09Speaker 5: the media and justice the center of the court, the
- 18:12Speaker 5: swing justice. I don't think anyone would describe Justice Alito
- 18:15Speaker 5: in that way. I mean, he is very firmly on
- 18:18Speaker 5: the court's right wing, right flank. He's never really been
- 18:23Speaker 5: in the middle during his time on the Court, and
- 18:25Speaker 5: in fact, I think he's probably moved more salsily to
- 18:29Speaker 5: the right as his tenure on the Court has progressed.
- 18:32Speaker 5: In twenty twenty two, we saw Justice Alito write the
- 18:36Speaker 5: majority opinion in Jobs versus Jackson Women's Health Organization, overruling
- 18:41Speaker 5: on a five to four vote Roe versus Wade, and
- 18:45Speaker 5: Planned Parenthood versus Casey, and of course Justice O'Connor was
- 18:48Speaker 5: absolutely pivotal in upholding Row and brokering that compromise in Casey.
- 18:54Speaker 5: We also see a very different set of votes from
- 18:57Speaker 5: that seat in the arena of a firmative action mean
- 19:01Speaker 5: Justice O'Connor was very skeptical of race conscious remedies. She
- 19:06Speaker 5: was in the majority in Croson in nineteen eighty nine
- 19:09Speaker 5: case that determined that strict scrutiny was the appropriate standard
- 19:12Speaker 5: of review for any kind of racial classification, even ones
- 19:16Speaker 5: that supportedly benefited minorities, like affirmative action. In the most
- 19:20Speaker 5: recent Supreme Court term, we saw Justice Alito with that
- 19:23Speaker 5: six to three conservative super majority to dismantle affirmative action
- 19:26Speaker 5: in students with fair admissions versus Harvard. But I think
- 19:30Speaker 5: another place where you see the real shift from a
- 19:33Speaker 5: Justice O'Connor to a Justice Alito is just generally in
- 19:37Speaker 5: the collegialities of the group. Much has been made in
- 19:40Speaker 5: the last couple of years about us sort of eroding
- 19:43Speaker 5: collegiality on the Supreme Court.
- 19:45Speaker 2: She just had a really, really remarkable career and definitely
- 19:49Speaker 2: very collegial. I'd heard that from from several sources, But
- 19:53Speaker 2: we really appreciate you joining us. That was a New
- 19:57Speaker 2: York University law professor Melissa Murray chatting with us about
- 20:00Speaker 2: Sandradale O'Connor's remarkable career. She's also the co host of
- 20:04Speaker 2: a podcast on the Supreme Court called strict scrutiny. Melissa,
- 20:08Speaker 2: thanks so much for joining.
- 20:09Speaker 5: Us, Thanks for having me.
- 20:10Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll talk
- 20:12Speaker 2: about the six billion dollar bankruptcy settlement involving Purdue Pharma
- 20:16Speaker 2: that's being fought over at the United States Supreme Court.
- 20:18Speaker 2: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Kimberly Robinson. This is Bloomberg.
- 20:30Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 20:34Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 20:38Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand wherever
- 20:41Speaker 1: you get your podcast.
- 20:44Speaker 3: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Kimberly Robinson in for June Grosso.
- 20:48Speaker 3: Let's now get to the Supreme Court fight over a
- 20:50Speaker 3: six billion dollar bankruptcy settlement involving Purdue Pharma, the maker
- 20:54Speaker 3: of the highly addictive opioid oxycotton.
- 20:57Speaker 8: In the views of the opioid victims and their family is.
- 21:02Speaker 6: Doesn't matter. I'm not saying it doesn't matter. Right you are.
- 21:05Speaker 8: I think your position is saying it doesn't matter.
- 21:08Speaker 3: That was Justice Brett Kavanaugh expressing skepticism with the federal
- 21:11Speaker 3: government's argument that the settlement should be scuttled. Bloomberg News
- 21:15Speaker 3: reporter Jonathan Randalls joins us to discuss. So, Jonathan, can
- 21:19Speaker 3: you start by telling us what exactly the settlement does
- 21:21Speaker 3: and why the Biden administration is fighting it?
- 21:24Speaker 6: Sure? So, the settlement would resolve tons of litigation against
- 21:30Speaker 6: Purdue Pharma and members of the Sackler family that own
- 21:33Speaker 6: Purdue Pharma related to produce aggressive marketing of oxyconton. And
- 21:42Speaker 6: the reason the settlement is controversial is because it forces
- 21:46Speaker 6: opioid victims who would be otherwise against the plan into
- 21:52Speaker 6: the deal and forces them to drop their claims and
- 21:56Speaker 6: their ability to present their case against the Sacklers to
- 21:59Speaker 6: a jury, regardless of they want the deal or not.
- 22:02Speaker 6: So that's why it's being challenged by the Biden administration.
- 22:06Speaker 2: Is there anybody that supports the settlement and if so.
- 22:10Speaker 6: Why, Yeah, it's widely supported by different creditor groups, so
- 22:15Speaker 6: like state attorneys general like uniformally support the deal. Different
- 22:20Speaker 6: counties and cities, municipalities that are all trying to get
- 22:24Speaker 6: money from Purdue and the Sacklers to pay for opioid
- 22:30Speaker 6: abatement programs support the deal, and groups and personal injury
- 22:36Speaker 6: lawyers that represent tens of thousands of opioid victims or claimants.
- 22:41Speaker 6: People who either directly have been impacted by opioid addiction
- 22:46Speaker 6: or family members who they have lost people to overdose
- 22:52Speaker 6: also support the plan. The reason why the people who
- 22:56Speaker 6: are proponents of the deal want the Supreme Court to
- 22:59Speaker 6: uphold it is because it provides up to six billion
- 23:03Speaker 6: dollars in funding and you know, thousands of dollars for
- 23:08Speaker 6: individual claimants that supporters say they wouldn't otherwise have available
- 23:14Speaker 6: to them. So if the Justice Department's bankruptcy unit it's
- 23:20Speaker 6: called the US Trustee Program, if they succeed in scuttling
- 23:24Speaker 6: the deal, supporters of the plan say, you know, billions
- 23:28Speaker 6: of dollars in aid that they would otherwise receive would
- 23:31Speaker 6: just evaporate and they'd lose this money that is desperately
- 23:36Speaker 6: needed to address the addiction crisis.
- 23:40Speaker 3: So, I mean, if this is it really for people
- 23:43Speaker 3: who are seeking, you know, some sort of relief, really
- 23:48Speaker 3: the issue for them is this one particular provision of
- 23:51Speaker 3: the settlement. Wondering if you can tell us what that
- 23:54Speaker 3: provision is all about.
- 23:56Speaker 6: Yeah, So the jargony term is it's called a non
- 24:02Speaker 6: consensual third party release produe Pharma of file bankruptcy in
- 24:06Speaker 6: twenty nineteen, and as a part of the bankruptcy, they
- 24:11Speaker 6: reached this settlement with the Sackler family. The Sacklers are
- 24:16Speaker 6: not in bankruptcy, but the settlement essentially extends the benefits
- 24:20Speaker 6: of produced bankruptcy to members of the Sackler family. And
- 24:25Speaker 6: the non consensual third party release is the mechanism that
- 24:29Speaker 6: binds individuals who oppose the deal to it. It's something
- 24:37Speaker 6: that was first used in the late eighties and authorized
- 24:41Speaker 6: by Congress in the early nineties to deal with aspetis litigation,
- 24:45Speaker 6: and it's been expanded over the last three decades to
- 24:49Speaker 6: address all types of product liability lawsuits and waves of
- 24:56Speaker 6: litigation over sexual abuse and used to resolve sex abuse
- 25:03Speaker 6: litigation brought against different different Catholic archdioceses, USA Gymnastics, Harvey
- 25:11Speaker 6: Weinstein's former film studio, directors and officers of that film studio.
- 25:18Speaker 6: What are the beneficiaries of this type of arrangement as well?
- 25:22Speaker 6: And the thought is lawsuits can be complicated when there's
- 25:26Speaker 6: you know, tons of litigation brought by hundreds or in
- 25:29Speaker 6: this case, hundreds of thousands of individual claimants. These types
- 25:34Speaker 6: of deals. While you know it's not great to force
- 25:39Speaker 6: holdouts into a deal, it's the argument goes necessary to
- 25:44Speaker 6: distribute bankrupt companies limited funds as fairly as possible.
- 25:50Speaker 2: So does this actually protect the Sackler family from future litigation?
- 25:54Speaker 6: Then yes, any any claim related to produce, mar getting
- 26:00Speaker 6: or sale of opioids would be resolved or extinguished. However
- 26:07Speaker 6: you want to describe it. Any future lawsuit that would
- 26:10Speaker 6: be brought would You can get into the specific like
- 26:16Speaker 6: legal mechanics of how this works, but it would essentially
- 26:18Speaker 6: be blocking any future lawsuits against the vibar was related
- 26:22Speaker 6: to the opioid business?
- 26:24Speaker 3: What about lawsuits by the federal government? Would those who
- 26:27Speaker 3: blocked If this deal gets the green light from the
- 26:30Speaker 3: Supreme Court.
- 26:31Speaker 6: It would resolve civil lawsuits. So I think that the
- 26:35Speaker 6: Department of Justice, god, it is probably twenty twenty Department
- 26:40Speaker 6: Justice settled their civil claims against the members of the
- 26:44Speaker 6: Sackler family for I don't have the number right off
- 26:48Speaker 6: the top, but I think it's like two hundred and
- 26:50Speaker 6: twenty five million dollars. The Sackler family agreed to play
- 26:53Speaker 6: to resolve the federal government's civil liability. So this would
- 26:58Speaker 6: resolve you know, any kind of lawsuits seeking money against
- 27:02Speaker 6: the family brought by the federal government or individual state authorities,
- 27:09Speaker 6: local counties, or personal injury victims. It does not prevent
- 27:14Speaker 6: any federal authority or state authority from bringing any potential
- 27:20Speaker 6: criminal charges against anybody related to Purdue. But you know,
- 27:28Speaker 6: the Sacklers have always maintained and continued to maintain that
- 27:33Speaker 6: these are merely allegations. They've you know, deny liability and
- 27:38Speaker 6: all wrongdoing, and of course they've never been criminally charged.
- 27:41Speaker 2: Now, the justices today seemed really divided. You know, there
- 27:44Speaker 2: were several justices that were skeptical of the Sackler's arguments
- 27:48Speaker 2: and others that were skeptical of the government's attempt to
- 27:51Speaker 2: scuttle this deal. So can you talk about kind of
- 27:54Speaker 2: where the justices were shaking out, Like were they following
- 27:58Speaker 2: kind of on their ideological lines here, or you know,
- 28:02Speaker 2: was there was the divide kind of across across the.
- 28:06Speaker 6: Aisle the latter. It's kind of interesting, you know, bankruptcy
- 28:12Speaker 6: doesn't always get as much attention in the Supreme Court
- 28:16Speaker 6: as other more and rightfully so, more high profile or
- 28:21Speaker 6: or you know, controversial or contested kind of legal issues
- 28:25Speaker 6: of the day. So it's always kind of interesting when
- 28:28Speaker 6: something from you know, bankruptcy court finds its way all
- 28:32Speaker 6: the way up to the Supreme Court, and as is
- 28:35Speaker 6: often the case, as it was today too. Yeah, this
- 28:41Speaker 6: issue kind of cut through the normal conservative liberal ideological lines.
- 28:47Speaker 6: So you had Neil Gorsich was pointing to the fact that,
- 28:53Speaker 6: you know, by stripping holdouts potentially of the right to
- 28:57Speaker 6: a jury trial, that raised constitutional problems potentially to the deal,
- 29:04Speaker 6: and you had liberal justices, you know, raising different arguments
- 29:08Speaker 6: against it, like the fact that Purdue transferred like ten
- 29:14Speaker 6: billion dollars in funds from the company between two thousand
- 29:19Speaker 6: and eight and before they filed in twenty nineteen. The
- 29:23Speaker 6: point being that the reason why Purdue says it needs
- 29:28Speaker 6: this settlement is arguably because the Sacklers took money out
- 29:32Speaker 6: of the business before bankruptcy. I think that was Justice
- 29:36Speaker 6: Jackson who raised that point. So a different point, but
- 29:39Speaker 6: similar skepticism, and it's cutting you know, both ways, liberal
- 29:44Speaker 6: and conservative.
- 29:46Speaker 8: If there's one thing you take away from my argument today,
- 29:49Speaker 8: it is this, And let me be crystal clear, without
- 29:53Speaker 8: the release, the plan will unravel Chapter seven, liquidation will follow,
- 29:59Speaker 8: and there will there be no viable path to any
- 30:02Speaker 8: victim recovery.
- 30:04Speaker 3: That was Attorney Critique Shaw urging the justices to greenlight
- 30:08Speaker 3: the six billion dollars settlement involving Purdue Pharma. Jonathan, I
- 30:12Speaker 3: wonder if you can talk to us a little bit
- 30:13Speaker 3: about the future implications of the case if the court
- 30:16Speaker 3: were to side against Purdue Pharma. Is Shaw right that
- 30:20Speaker 3: there likely won't be any relief for the victims and
- 30:22Speaker 3: their families.
- 30:23Speaker 6: That's really hard to say, obviously, what Shaw was arguing,
- 30:27Speaker 6: and a lot of proponents of the deal who represent
- 30:31Speaker 6: the interest of the opioid victims that have been adamant
- 30:34Speaker 6: for years now as this has been tied up in appeals,
- 30:37Speaker 6: that this is the best and only deal available to
- 30:41Speaker 6: opioid victims, and without it, you know, there's a whole
- 30:44Speaker 6: parade of horribles that will happen, including a loss of
- 30:48Speaker 6: up to six billion dollars that could you know, help
- 30:51Speaker 6: address or rectify at least some of the harm caused
- 30:55Speaker 6: by Purdue. You know, they've accused of obviously fueling the
- 31:00Speaker 6: opiate epandemic. What will happen? I don't really know that
- 31:03Speaker 6: Purdue and proponents, including victims who have no love loss
- 31:08Speaker 6: with the Sacklers say there will be nothing left for
- 31:12Speaker 6: victims if this is unwound by the Supreme Court.
- 31:16Speaker 2: What happens if the court sides with Purdue Pharma. You know,
- 31:18Speaker 2: what is the government saying will happen here?
- 31:21Speaker 6: Yeah, that's a good question. They're much more like a
- 31:23Speaker 6: straightforward argument being as good as this settlement might be
- 31:27Speaker 6: for everyone involved, it's not permitted under the bankruptcy Code.
- 31:31Speaker 6: It's kind of that simple. They also say that if
- 31:36Speaker 6: the deal is unwound, well and the Sacklers can, they're
- 31:40Speaker 6: just going to have to make a different deal. You know,
- 31:42Speaker 6: they're not preventing anybody that wants to be a part
- 31:45Speaker 6: of this deal from consenting to it. The problem is
- 31:49Speaker 6: forcing people that don't consent to it to take it.
- 31:53Speaker 6: So what the Justice Department is saying is that, like, look,
- 31:56Speaker 6: if this goes back to the bankruptcy court, they'll just
- 31:58Speaker 6: have to work out another deal. Potentially that would mean
- 32:01Speaker 6: maybe the Sacklers would have to put up even more
- 32:03Speaker 6: money than they already have to buy peace. And it
- 32:06Speaker 6: doesn't prevent anybody that wants to be a part of
- 32:08Speaker 6: this deal from being a part of the deal. It
- 32:10Speaker 6: just prevents people who don't want to be a part
- 32:12Speaker 6: of it from being forced to take it.
- 32:15Speaker 3: So reading the team leaves on a Supreme Court argument
- 32:18Speaker 3: is always a very dangerous game. That seems particularly so
- 32:22Speaker 3: in this case. Did you get a sense of where
- 32:24Speaker 3: this is actually going to end up at the end
- 32:26Speaker 3: of the day.
- 32:27Speaker 6: No, I wish I did, But you know, I mean,
- 32:30Speaker 6: I think the most interesting thing is getting you know,
- 32:34Speaker 6: justices that wouldn't otherwise agree kind of raising similar arguments
- 32:40Speaker 6: or kind of being in agreement either against the deal
- 32:44Speaker 6: or the same you know, raising questions about the challenge
- 32:49Speaker 6: to the deal. I kind of found interesting.
- 32:51Speaker 2: What about the broader impact here? Is there any concern
- 32:54Speaker 2: that this deal could up end bankruptcies in general going forward?
- 32:58Speaker 6: For sure? I think this was what the Purdue lawyers said,
- 33:02Speaker 6: that what is at risk here is potentially the Justice
- 33:05Speaker 6: Department taking like a wrecking ball to the bankruptcy code.
- 33:09Speaker 6: These types of settlements are pretty common when companies that
- 33:13Speaker 6: are like overwhelmed by lawsuits wound up in bankruptcy and
- 33:17Speaker 6: the Supreme Court says you can't make this type of deal.
- 33:21Speaker 6: You know, maybe it means that companies that would file
- 33:24Speaker 6: bankruptcy to try and you know, come to some sort
- 33:27Speaker 6: of like grand settlement of litigation. Maybe they don't file
- 33:30Speaker 6: bankruptcy in the future. So yeah, if the Supreme Court
- 33:35Speaker 6: agrees with the Justice Department, it would have pretty broad
- 33:40Speaker 6: implications for bankruptcy in general and its use as a
- 33:46Speaker 6: forum to resolve this type of mass litigation in the future.
- 33:51Speaker 2: Wow, So lots to watch for in that case. That's
- 33:54Speaker 2: Bloomberg News reporter Jonathan Randalls, thanks so much for joining us,
- 33:57Speaker 2: Thanks for having me. By the way, the sac Our
- 34:00Speaker 2: family denies all liability and hasn't been criminally charged. And
- 34:04Speaker 2: that does it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 34:06Speaker 2: I'm Lydio Wheeler.
- 34:07Speaker 3: And I'm Kimberly Robinson. This is Bloomberg