Latest / Raising Men / Why Parenting Boys is Harder Than Ever with Jennifer L. W. Fink
Transcript
- 0:00because you are at a point in time
- 0:02when you are actively searching for ideas
- 0:05and testing out ideas and identity
- 0:07and developmentally appropriately
- 0:09you know
- 0:09trying to differentiate yourself from your parents
- 0:12and testing you know
- 0:13maybe their value system is not my value system
- 0:16and that's healthy to a point
- 0:26welcome back to raising men
- 0:28I'm your host Shawn Dawson
- 0:29as parents we navigate completely uncharted territory
- 0:34especially these days and we're
- 0:36you know I
- 0:37I've talked a lot about how we're
- 0:39caught in this bizarre cultural crossfire
- 0:42where we're trying to reject toxic masculinity
- 0:45without falling into some sort of empty opportunity
- 0:48empty alternative of no masculinity at all
- 0:50lately
- 0:52I think there's been a a
- 0:53a fantastic upswing
- 0:56in the global conversation surrounding boys
- 0:59and what they need to thrive
- 1:01but if you look closely at who
- 1:05is involved and leading that dialogue
- 1:08it's heavily dominated by men
- 1:10but moms are in the trenches of boyhood
- 1:13every single day and
- 1:16it doesn't make a whole lot of sense
- 1:18to leave their voices out of the broader
- 1:21cultural conversation on modern masculinity
- 1:24so returning to the show is a phenomenal guest
- 1:29a writer a nurse
- 1:30a mother of four boys just like my mom
- 1:34and the brilliant mind behind the On boys podcast
- 1:38her groundbreaking book Building Boys
- 1:41Raising Great Guys in a world That Misunderstands Males
- 1:45is officially hitting shelves in paperback
- 1:48in early August
- 1:50Jennifer welcome back to Raising Men
- 1:53now
- 1:54you know your book has been out for a while
- 1:57since 2,023 I believe and
- 2:00and you are releasing it in paperback
- 2:03talk to me about you know
- 2:04how's it been received what
- 2:06what at what rate
- 2:08do you want to bring that into the world
- 2:10in the first place
- 2:12what made me want to bring it in the world
- 2:14in the first place was uh
- 2:17that I saw first of all
- 2:19in myself how
- 2:22what I didn't understand about boys
- 2:24what I didn't understand about boy culture
- 2:26what I didn't understand
- 2:28about the world that they faced or
- 2:30and didn't understand about male development
- 2:33all interfered with effective parenting of boys
- 2:38with helping boys become good men
- 2:40it's really hard to do a good job at something
- 2:44if you don't understand
- 2:46the world in which you're operating
- 2:48if you don't I mean
- 2:50you've done business for years and years
- 2:52if you're trying to launch a product
- 2:54but you don't understand the market forces
- 2:58and the social um
- 3:00pressures and the culture
- 3:02in which you are trying to
- 3:04build and release this product
- 3:06it's not going to be a successful launch
- 3:09and I think that's really
- 3:11really similar for parents
- 3:13we start especially moms
- 3:16we start with this idea of who we want our boys to be
- 3:20and in the beginning of my book
- 3:21I say actually
- 3:22right now a lot of us
- 3:23start with what we don't want
- 3:25we know we don't want to raise a violent man
- 3:27we don't want to raise a mass shooter
- 3:29and yes
- 3:30these are very very low bars
- 3:34but it's also it speaks to all of these fears
- 3:37we know that there have been a lot of men
- 3:39and boys in the headlines
- 3:40for doing some pretty horrendous things
- 3:42and we're like hmm
- 3:43something's wrong there how do I not do that
- 3:47it's an okay starting point
- 3:49but if you don't understand all of the cultural forces
- 3:54all of the male development pieces
- 3:56it's very difficult to be effective
- 3:58so that's initially why I wrote Building Boys
- 4:01why that subtitle is
- 4:03in a world that misunderstands males
- 4:05and so the book came out in 2023
- 4:09and there has been an increase
- 4:11I believe in talking about boys
- 4:14in talking about raising great guys
- 4:16raising men you're part of that conversation
- 4:19increased
- 4:20national and international conversations about boys
- 4:23but
- 4:23I still feel like there is a lot of misunderstanding
- 4:27in that space
- 4:28and that's a space that I hope that my book helps fill
- 4:32and I have always personally felt like paperback is
- 4:36it is the best format for a book
- 4:38that's my personal preference curious what yours is
- 4:42yeah actually my
- 4:43my favorite format is digital because I find
- 4:47you know I
- 4:50it's out in digital form as well
- 5:00isn't that something
- 5:04I can cross reference things
- 5:06I can I mean there
- 5:07if I had to design that from scratch
- 5:09I would I
- 5:11I might do it differently but
- 5:13but man
- 5:14it is uh
- 5:14so yeah
- 5:15I um
- 5:16I hardly ever and it's limited
- 5:18um it's not
- 5:19the kind of experience you can get from
- 5:21from an actual physical paper copy of the book but uh
- 5:24it also doesn't keep my wife up if I read it at night
- 5:28so there there there
- 5:31there you go you know I
- 5:33um
- 5:34what you describe is like
- 5:37the difference between health and absence of sickness
- 5:42and and if all you were trying to do is oh
- 5:45I want to avoid getting
- 5:48getting the flu and I want to avoid getting cancer
- 5:50and I want to avoid getting
- 5:52yes
- 5:53you would never necessarily do things that you
- 5:58I mean
- 5:58you might walk around wearing a mask all the time
- 6:01and then you're you're excluding the psychological help
- 6:07health that you need from
- 6:09you know talking to people face to face and and
- 6:11and all of those things and
- 6:12and that's what your you know
- 6:14health is not the absence of sickness
- 6:16it is something forward thinking
- 6:20and it is something active and
- 6:22and that's that's what you're describing with boys
- 6:25I that the
- 6:25the conversation around boys has gotten pathologized
- 6:30in a way where you're just like
- 6:31oh well
- 6:32you know you yeah
- 6:32you have to avoid becoming a
- 6:34a school shooter
- 6:36of course you do um
- 6:38just like you have to avoid jumping off of a cliff
- 6:42in order to remain healthy but it's not sufficient
- 6:45you know as you said
- 6:47that I think it's a uniquely American approach right
- 6:51I mean in the United States
- 6:53we have had this model
- 6:54where health is avoiding sickness
- 6:57and most of us at this point
- 6:59can look around and see how
- 7:01and why that's sort of
- 7:02inadequate as a healthcare system
- 7:03many of us feel let down by that system
- 7:06or neglected by that system
- 7:07and similarly you know
- 7:09with health there's been this look and search for it
- 7:12we we want a pill
- 7:14we want a treatment we want a quick and easy thing
- 7:18and health isn't that simple
- 7:21raising boys isn't that simple
- 7:23both are very complex endeavors
- 7:25and they're multifaceted
- 7:26involve a lot of different pieces
- 7:28but as you alluded to with health
- 7:30when we pay attention to those individual determinants
- 7:33and to the environment
- 7:35it's a difference between surviving and thriving
- 7:40I've been doing this a lot of thinking recently about I
- 7:42I I
- 7:43came upon this concept that that uh
- 7:48uh it was a definition of suffering
- 7:50that I thought was really operational
- 7:52and really useful which is that
- 7:54suffering is when your expectations don't match reality
- 7:59and so that might be because you
- 8:03desire something that you can't have
- 8:07and
- 8:09it might be because
- 8:11you have a mental model of the world
- 8:14that isn't true right
- 8:18and those things cause suffering
- 8:20and what that means is that suffering is a choice
- 8:24and it can be
- 8:26um
- 8:28it can be intentional like OK
- 8:30I'm going to decide that I want that thing up there
- 8:34I wanna be at the top of that mountain
- 8:36and so I'm going
- 8:38the the
- 8:39the fact that I am not
- 8:40right now at the top of the mountain
- 8:43versus my vision of myself on top of that mountain
- 8:46is suffering
- 8:48and that suffering motivates me to climb upward
- 8:52and that's good right
- 8:55and in a lot of cases so not all suffering is bad
- 8:59but unintentional suffering
- 9:01or suffering that you don't feel that you chose is
- 9:06or potentially bad and so I
- 9:09you know I wonder
- 9:12to what extent this model is there
- 9:14that way of thinking about things is about
- 9:19like really
- 9:19about what we need to do to build our boys into men
- 9:25in terms of getting them to choose their suffering
- 9:28you know what I mean as opposed to
- 9:31it feels to me like a very masculine thing
- 9:37it is is identifying and being
- 9:40able to choose your own suffering
- 9:42and recognizing that that is
- 9:44that is a choice and it is something that
- 9:47that you opted into and it can be good and bad
- 9:53there's a lot to think about there
- 9:54and um
- 9:56as you said it
- 9:57I saw a very direct parallel to parents of boys
- 10:01and especially moms suffering
- 10:04is when your expectation don't match reality
- 10:08I know and have talked to so many moms who are stressed
- 10:14overwhelmed and suffering
- 10:16they feel this very deeply
- 10:19and part of it is
- 10:20their expectations don't match reality
- 10:22and what I mean by that and this is what we
- 10:24part of what I talk about in the book
- 10:26what they expect of their boy is a
- 10:32based on a misunderstanding of who boys are
- 10:37and how they grow
- 10:39and what they're capable of at different points
- 10:42so for instance
- 10:44the pace of male development
- 10:46is different than female development there
- 10:49are so many little boys who are developmentally
- 10:55not ready to sit still for long periods
- 10:58to write to listen
- 11:00to pay attention to read when they are 5 years old
- 11:03but if our expectation is they should be able to
- 11:07and they aren't
- 11:09so often the parents conclude there is something
- 11:12a wrong with the boy and moms especially
- 11:15and I'm not I don't know about dad Sean
- 11:16I'll let you answer that part
- 11:18because I've not been a dad
- 11:19but moms especially assume I'm doing something wrong
- 11:23that I can't make this kid do what he should be doing
- 11:27oh that is so true
- 11:28I you know
- 11:29when we spoke last time my son um
- 11:32was in a school and all of the teachers
- 11:35except for the PE teacher and the principal
- 11:40were all women
- 11:41and including his she was in kindergarten last
- 11:44when we spoke last and boy
- 11:46he was having a tough time
- 11:48um in exactly the way that you described
- 11:51and he's old for his class
- 11:54he was born in January
- 11:55so he's relatively old for the rest of his class
- 11:59he's also much bigger than everybody
- 12:00which has its own
- 12:03uh challenges associated with it
- 12:05but he had this male principal
- 12:09that he could connect with it
- 12:12a different way than with his
- 12:15you know female teachers
- 12:17and I think that really helped
- 12:20and I you know
- 12:21that profession there are far fewer men in in
- 12:25in education now than there were when I was growing up
- 12:28for example and I
- 12:30I remember being young
- 12:32and really feeling that need to connect with well
- 12:37you know I would
- 12:38I felt the need to connect with all my teachers
- 12:39but I connected with my male teachers
- 12:41in a different way than my female teachers
- 12:43and me and maybe
- 12:43maybe it's different as as I got older
- 12:46certainly more of the teachers were men um
- 12:49but that seems to me that
- 12:55you know we have to deal with this
- 12:57this culture
- 12:58in which the school that our boys are gonna go to is
- 13:02there are a lot more women than there are men
- 13:05and we have to somehow figure out how to
- 13:08help the school realize
- 13:11you know how to work with the boy in such a way
- 13:14to make him thrive in that that
- 13:16that world like and and and that happened to us I mean
- 13:20we ended up just having to work with the teachers
- 13:24to go yeah
- 13:24here's the deal with him like
- 13:27I know he freaked out in this one situation
- 13:30and that makes you think that he's uncontrollable
- 13:33but he's really it's not that he's controllable
- 13:39but you can you can get the result you want out of him
- 13:42you just have to give him in my boy's case
- 13:46he really likes having a plan
- 13:52and he really likes
- 13:54being able to do the thing that he's
- 13:57concocted in his head so he creates his plan
- 14:03often just by himself on his way
- 14:05you know recently
- 14:07it's the summertime now
- 14:08and so we're taking him to daycare
- 14:11and he had this horrible meltdown in daycare or sorry
- 14:15in camp not daycare um
- 14:18the other day where I mean he was just
- 14:22you know went off by himself and was kicking the the
- 14:25the dirt and all that stuff
- 14:26he was really really upset for a while and you know
- 14:28and you know
- 14:29the the the camp counselors came to us and said
- 14:31you know what do we do about you know
- 14:33what how can we work with him about this
- 14:36and it really it just we we said yeah
- 14:40this is the way he gets when he gets frustrated
- 14:42that he can't do what he expected to do
- 14:44and in this case he you know
- 14:45they had a Lego station
- 14:47and he wanted to play in the Lego station
- 14:48but they were closing the Lego station
- 14:50because they were moving on to the
- 14:51something else and he wasn't aware of that
- 14:53so he created this plan in his head
- 14:55where he got to do the Lego station
- 14:58for a certain period of time
- 14:59and he got to build this particular thing
- 15:01and then he got to play with it in this particular way
- 15:03he didn't share that plan with other people
- 15:05by the way that's part of what I need to do
- 15:07in order to help him thrive is dude
- 15:09you gotta share your plans with people so they know
- 15:12so they can help you and they can
- 15:14they can they can you can help adjust your plan
- 15:20yes yes
- 15:21but once they were once they understood oh
- 15:24this is really about him
- 15:27just being able to do the thing that he wants to do
- 15:31and then they can help him with that they can say hey
- 15:36OK
- 15:37oh well
- 15:37that's not gonna work we're gonna do it
- 15:39how about we do this instead
- 15:40and then it was totally smooth and he's totally
- 15:44it was perfect
- 15:46and you know I think we think about these institutions
- 15:50or these constructs the school is this
- 15:53monolithic thing that is unchangeable
- 15:57and well this is just the way things are
- 15:59and we're gonna have to this
- 16:00we're gonna have to work with it
- 16:02and to some extent
- 16:03that's true and that's a healthy attitude
- 16:05but there's another side of that tension
- 16:06which is no you don't really have to you
- 16:11you don't have to let it impose
- 16:15on you
- 16:15you don't have to change yourself for that necessarily
- 16:18unnecessarily and I
- 16:21I think that was an important thing
- 16:24that that's something that has helped us really succeed
- 16:28in some ways and you know
- 16:30it's not like we're fully successful there um
- 16:33but I mean why let me ask you this
- 16:37it seems to me that being the mother of boys
- 16:43now is way harder than it was a decade ago
- 16:47and way harder than it was 20 years ago
- 16:50do you agree with that and then and why
- 16:55uh let me go back
- 16:56you said first way harder than a decade ago
- 16:59OK so a decade ago is really when I was in the trenches
- 17:03right now my youngest is 20
- 17:05so a decade ago he was ten
- 17:07um my oldest is now uh 28
- 17:10so a decade ago he was 18
- 17:12so I had I was right in that teen mess a decade ago
- 17:18for me I think
- 17:20one of the biggest challenges that has changed
- 17:22and made it more difficult now than then
- 17:26two things I actually think there is
- 17:31simultaneously us collectively
- 17:34expressing more concern about boys and young men
- 17:38I feel like there's also increasing intolerance
- 17:43for boys and young men
- 17:45when they say and do stupid things especially uh sexism
- 17:51misogyny racism
- 17:53and to be clear I am anti all of those things
- 17:57I I don't support sexism
- 17:58I don't support misogyny
- 18:00I don't support misandry I don't support uh racism
- 18:03however young boys say and do stupid things
- 18:06that is part of the learning process
- 18:08part of the growing process
- 18:10so I feel like the
- 18:12they feel like they are under a microscope
- 18:15all of the time because they are
- 18:17when everybody has a phone
- 18:19and can put up anything at any moment
- 18:21there's that and then there is the social media
- 18:25online world as it exists today
- 18:28where a boy today he's going to be online
- 18:32whether you let him or not
- 18:33he is going to be online
- 18:34and because of the way the algorithms is built
- 18:37whether he goes looking at it or not
- 18:40he will be exposed to extreme thoughts
- 18:44Allah Andrew Tate and I'm using the term manosphere
- 18:48because a lot of people know
- 18:50kind of what we mean by that
- 18:52but I don't necessarily think that term is helpful
- 18:54because a lot gets lumped into that
- 18:56but extreme views and um
- 19:00very unhelpful body image and expectations
- 19:04and gambling content
- 19:07all of this stuff is being fed to our boys
- 19:12and that's why I think
- 19:13parenting boys now is even harder
- 19:16like there is all of
- 19:17the external world
- 19:18is literally reaching into their bedrooms and minds
- 19:21all of the time
- 19:24yeah you have access to
- 19:28a lot more opinions and a lot more
- 19:32potentially false data than I I had when I was a kid
- 19:37right
- 19:40information diet was a lot more curated
- 19:42and so now it's a lot less curated
- 19:47which is nice because you have access to things that
- 19:51you know there wasn't there's not a gatekeeper
- 19:53but it also means that you have to be that much more
- 19:58vigilant about what you're putting into your mind
- 20:01and at a point
- 20:03at a time when you're really susceptible to
- 20:07um to
- 20:10unhelpful ways of thinking
- 20:12that are not gonna serve you long term
- 20:15because you are at a point in time
- 20:17when you are actively searching for ideas
- 20:20and testing out ideas and identity
- 20:23and developmentally appropriately
- 20:25you know
- 20:25trying to differentiate yourself from your parents
- 20:27and testing you know
- 20:28maybe their value system is not my value system
- 20:32and that's healthy to a point
- 20:35but but then
- 20:36then we're also in a situation where everything
- 20:38goes on your permanent record
- 20:40so you try on some marginally unhelpful point of view
- 20:47like you know
- 20:48some kind of you know
- 20:50a a
- 20:52I like like
- 20:53something that would come across as misogynist
- 20:55to some people but not to other people right
- 20:57it's it you know
- 20:58and and it used to be the case when I was in college
- 21:02that you might try something like that on
- 21:05and this the culture would gently push back on you
- 21:11and now it feels like okay no
- 21:13you're pushing the edge of the herd
- 21:15like the one tiny little misstep and it's you're
- 21:17you're sort of done for
- 21:19and so then that creates this I mean
- 21:25it
- 21:25it creates this situation where you either have to be
- 21:27hyper conformist to everything
- 21:30you have to sort of predict
- 21:32what people might get offended about right
- 21:34you know because offense is in the eye of the beholder
- 21:36in that respect
- 21:37or you can go the other way and just be okay
- 21:41well I'm gonna
- 21:45right
- 21:48that's not healthy
- 21:50nope
- 21:52I feel like mothers have a particular
- 21:56role in helping our boys temper
- 22:01their role and
- 22:06and
- 22:08you know I
- 22:08I think that I think that's where
- 22:11that's where mothers come in
- 22:12is helping our boys try things out in a way that is
- 22:20protected
- 22:21and and and
- 22:21and the the venues that they can do that are shrinking
- 22:26right I mean it's
- 22:26you know it's
- 22:27since if you're always on
- 22:28if everything you do is recorded
- 22:29then you can't
- 22:31that then that
- 22:32you don't really have freedom
- 22:34and personally I think that pressure is
- 22:37contributing to why a lot of boys
- 22:40and young men
- 22:41aren't doing much of anything right
- 22:44it is easier to stay still and not take risks
- 22:48and just stay in my room and play video games
- 22:51than to do something that could get me in trouble
- 22:56nope I'm opting out of all of that
- 22:58yeah I
- 22:59so do you think that that's
- 23:01and do you see that that's what's happening
- 23:05I have a theory that that's what's happening yes
- 23:08I don't have you know
- 23:10swaths of data necessarily to prove it
- 23:11but I think those correlations are there right
- 23:13like
- 23:13we are seeing increasing numbers of boys and young men
- 23:17who are out of education out of work
- 23:20you know
- 23:20who are really being pretty static in their lives
- 23:24which isn't healthy for them
- 23:25and it is not healthy for our communities
- 23:28right yeah I
- 23:29one of the things I I like to say is that our
- 23:33our culture thirsts for healthy men
- 23:37and we're it seems
- 23:42it seems
- 23:43empirically true that we're creating fewer of them and
- 23:52but we're not really
- 23:54investing in the things that build healthy men and
- 23:58and I'm not just talking about money
- 24:00certainly money is part of it because resources but
- 24:03but time and space and and freedom
- 24:07like we are not
- 24:09we're not building the things that help boys become
- 24:14healthy men
- 24:16yeah let me
- 24:16let me restate that
- 24:18in a way that I can definitely agree with
- 24:20which is that
- 24:21the institutions that used to do that for us are gone
- 24:27are are crumbling
- 24:28and so it is up to us to do it ourselves now
- 24:32and we're not necessarily going to do that
- 24:36unless we're intentional about it
- 24:39and this is where moms especially
- 24:43and dads also right
- 24:45we are feeling all of this pressure
- 24:48we are feeling this pressure to raise good men
- 24:53and absolutely it is part of our responsibility
- 24:56it's a lot
- 24:58it's a lot to do on our own
- 24:59so I feel like the society
- 25:02at large is kind of looking at parents like
- 25:05raise a good man
- 25:07but sort of keeping their hands off
- 25:11and also judging parents as they are
- 25:14also doing their best to function in the society
- 25:18without enough accurate information or support
- 25:22and that's a frustrating position for parents to be in
- 25:24and I think that that is part of why parents
- 25:26and especially parents of boys
- 25:28feel this this tension in this stress
- 25:30they feel this expectation
- 25:32I think parents of boys
- 25:34at least the moms that I speak to
- 25:35and I'll let you tell me what you hear from the dads
- 25:38are very aware of this acute pressure
- 25:41to raise a good man and
- 25:42just as the boys feel like that microscope is on them
- 25:45if they do a misstep
- 25:48the moms feel that is on them too
- 25:50that if my son does this thing
- 25:52eyes are looking back at me
- 25:53well why didn't you do better
- 25:55you know I
- 25:56I I
- 25:57I absolutely see that and I think that there's a
- 25:59there's a dad's version of that too um
- 26:04and it has a lot less to do
- 26:06with conforming to social norms
- 26:11in my experience it has a lot less to do with that
- 26:14than it is about performing well
- 26:18like being good at sports or
- 26:20or or doing well at school work and
- 26:23and those sorts of things
- 26:24sure
- 26:28succeeding on the basketball court
- 26:30then I have done something wrong as a dad
- 26:33um so I
- 26:34I don't know if that's a generalized experience
- 26:36or if that's just mine um
- 26:39but that's definitely there
- 26:42do you
- 26:45I think the I
- 26:46I think one of the other things that makes it really
- 26:49really difficult
- 26:50and I love your feedback on this for one for
- 26:53for moms today is that their
- 27:00for the reasons that we've discussed
- 27:02there are fewer and fewer
- 27:04really good masculine
- 27:07role models
- 27:09and it is impossible for a mother
- 27:15to be a masculine role model
- 27:18um I mean
- 27:19certainly mothers can have
- 27:23uh
- 27:24you you know
- 27:25can exhibit masculine virtues
- 27:27but your son is not going to see that for
- 27:34as a model for himself he needs that difference
- 27:39he needs to see a man doing stuff he admires
- 27:45so that he can emulate that
- 27:47and those men are becoming fewer and farther between
- 27:53and so what is a mom to do if
- 27:56you know
- 27:57often times so so in a lot of families
- 28:00you have a mother and a father
- 28:03and the father can be that good
- 28:06masculine male role model
- 28:07okay great
- 28:08we've got one
- 28:09but you know we might need more and and
- 28:12and in a lot of cases these days you have
- 28:17mom's raising sons without a father
- 28:21or without a father in the home
- 28:23and so
- 28:24she needs to seek out other masculine male role models
- 28:27what what do you
- 28:29you know how
- 28:30and then obviously
- 28:31there's risks on the other side of that right
- 28:33you know um
- 28:35you you might be suspicious of somebody that's taking
- 28:37an interest in your young boy reasonably
- 28:41how do you navigate that minefield in your opinion
- 28:44I don't have any easy answers to that
- 28:47because there are no easy answers to that
- 28:48you're absolutely right I mean
- 28:49a lot of the
- 28:51previous institutions that existed to do that
- 28:55don't exist in the same form anymore
- 28:57you know we know broadly speaking
- 28:59like there there's less community clubs
- 29:01and just less community gatherings
- 29:06there's fewer mentoring programs
- 29:08all of those things are true
- 29:10and the question for moms
- 29:12that are looking for other adults to be interested in
- 29:15and care about their sons
- 29:17I hear from those moms all the time
- 29:18and you give you give the standard answers
- 29:22and it feels incomplete
- 29:24because you know that the world's not ideal
- 29:26so yes
- 29:27there's the obvious places ideally
- 29:29ideally hopefully
- 29:32perhaps you have extended family
- 29:34you know uncles or older cousins
- 29:37and
- 29:37it doesn't necessarily have to be people that you are
- 29:40biologically related to aunts uncles
- 29:43cousins um
- 29:44can also be people in your neighborhood
- 29:46in your church in your community
- 29:47other people that see and spend time with your child
- 29:52but getting somebody to actually take an
- 29:54interest in your child to spend time with your child
- 29:57that can be really hard um
- 30:00as you said there are fewer male teachers now
- 30:03than there were when we were in school
- 30:06and especially in those early elementary stages
- 30:09um this is
- 30:14one thing I wanna
- 30:15I wanna touch on is this suspicion that is there right
- 30:20we and especially moms
- 30:22do tend to be suspicious of men
- 30:25who show an interest in our boys
- 30:27and there are reasons for that
- 30:29there have been horrible stories of abuse and grooming
- 30:33and we are all acutely aware of those
- 30:35and our first priority as parents
- 30:38is to protect our children
- 30:40so be aware of that but I think
- 30:45deliberately
- 30:47interrogate that inclination within yourself
- 30:50I feel like there is this um
- 30:53the first reaction is suspicion instead of appreciation
- 30:59the first reaction is
- 31:00if there is a guy who shows interest in my child
- 31:03that it is automatically a bad thing
- 31:04and it isn't necessarily
- 31:06you have to do your due diligence
- 31:10but don't assume the worst without reason
- 31:13I think it is is thing 1
- 31:14I wanna say question your own biases
- 31:17your own prejudices second of all
- 31:21a man does not have to be a perfect man to be a good
- 31:28healthy masculine influence for your son
- 31:31and I ran across a beautiful essay about this
- 31:33a few years ago and um
- 31:35I would have to dig really hard to find it again
- 31:38but it was written by an adult man
- 31:40but he was talking about some of the men
- 31:41who helped raise him and one was like
- 31:45uh somebody in his community
- 31:47and the guy had a lot of issues
- 31:50he was a drunk he was
- 31:52you know these things
- 31:55but he made time and he spent time
- 31:58and he listened to this boy when he was a teenager
- 32:02what I mean is
- 32:04a man does not have to check all of the perfect guy
- 32:082026 boxes to be a good influence for your son yep
- 32:12he can swear yes
- 32:13he may have
- 32:14he may even have some values that you don't like
- 32:16he may occasionally say derogatory things about people
- 32:19that doesn't mean he can't be a good influence
- 32:22in other ways
- 32:24my best advice to parents who are
- 32:26looking for masculine influence for your boy
- 32:29whatever your boy is interested in
- 32:33whatever your boy is interested in
- 32:34try to go places where other people are interested in
- 32:37those things for my oldest son
- 32:40one of those things was fishing right
- 32:44and when he was about 10 I think um
- 32:47and he specifically loves muskies
- 32:50the muskellunge is like the state fish of Wisconsin
- 32:53it is a big fish it's like a huge northern pike
- 32:56very similar there was a Musky Expo
- 32:59trade show that was going on in Milwaukee
- 33:01about an hour from our home
- 33:02he wanted to go to that
- 33:05Sean I don't like fishing
- 33:06that's not my thing at all
- 33:08but you know it's my kid
- 33:09we went to that together
- 33:11this 10 year old boy was in heaven
- 33:15and so were the predominantly adult men
- 33:19who saw in this boy somebody that was interested in
- 33:21what they weren't interested in
- 33:23and so even though none of those men became
- 33:26like regular influences in his life
- 33:29in that day he saw and met people
- 33:33many people doing different things
- 33:35that kind of showed him what could be possible
- 33:37and they importantly showed an interest in him
- 33:40and I think you can speak to that as a former boy
- 33:43and as a father
- 33:44when an adult man kind of sees and affirms your spark
- 33:49that's powerful isn't it
- 33:52it is the most powerful thing
- 33:54and I think you know
- 33:56I'll call out something you
- 33:58you you made reference to this
- 34:00but you didn't drive it home as hard as I
- 34:03I think it deserves
- 34:06which is this thing about
- 34:08you don't have to be the perfect man to be a good um
- 34:11to be a good role model that's absolutely right
- 34:14and not only that your
- 34:17your imperfections are also instructive
- 34:20yes
- 34:22yeah and and so like this
- 34:25the boy gets to see that the boy gets to see an actual
- 34:29real life man in real circumstances
- 34:31deal with real things
- 34:33and succeed or fail on his own merits
- 34:36and the more examples of that you see
- 34:41the more well rounded you could be as a boy
- 34:44if you don't see that in real live men
- 34:48you're going to look for proxies
- 34:50you're going to look for TV shows
- 34:52you're going to look for online
- 34:53influencer personalities and those are curated feeds
- 34:58they are not healthy ways of getting those skills
- 35:02they're
- 35:04they're performatives they're
- 35:06they're performances and they're better than nothing
- 35:09I guess sometimes
- 35:12but the real thing is the real thing it is and
- 35:16and getting that rich experience is
- 35:21you know the
- 35:22that's where the gold is and if you're
- 35:24if you're searching for perfection
- 35:26you're letting the the perfect be the enemy of the good
- 35:29and you end up with nothing
- 35:32I really appreciate you elaborating on that
- 35:34you're right the imperfection is so
- 35:37so important none of us are done
- 35:40we're all still dealing with our stuff
- 35:42so for a boy to see a human
- 35:46adult male living with his imperfection and
- 35:50and how the world responds to him
- 35:52positively or negatively
- 35:54really really helpful
- 35:56and broadly speaking the more men
- 36:01the more people in your son's life
- 36:03the better
- 36:04because he doesn't just need a masculine role model
- 36:06he doesn't just need to see men
- 36:08he needs to see a variety of men
- 36:11because
- 36:13there are so many different
- 36:14and beautiful ways of being a man in the world
- 36:17and it gives him that opportunity to
- 36:19to realize there's no one right way
- 36:22which I think
- 36:23is one of the lies that the internet is kind of
- 36:25selling our boys right now
- 36:26like this is the way to be a man
- 36:29right yeah
- 36:30and then you'll see another one oh
- 36:32this is the way and this is the way
- 36:34and this is the way and there's a
- 36:35there's a thousand the ways
- 36:38and you know
- 36:39but yeah I
- 36:40I the
- 36:41those are kind of yeah
- 36:42the internet is kind of a grift
- 36:45a grift mill right
- 36:46and it and
- 36:47you know there's
- 36:49you you can get rich making the world worse
- 36:54and given that that is our world
- 36:56that is a conversation that we all have to have
- 36:58with our sons these days
- 37:01it was really wish I'd studied harder for this one Sean
- 37:03that we we
- 37:04but we have to recognize the world the
- 37:06the the way it is
- 37:07not the way it ought to be and
- 37:08and we have to deal with the culture the way it is
- 37:11and the world the way it is
- 37:12the internet the way it is
- 37:13and the social media the way it is
- 37:16yeah you know
- 37:17I well
- 37:17and you you know
- 37:18from the last time you were here
- 37:20I always like to finish these conversations
- 37:22by asking more or less the same question of everybody
- 37:25and so I'm gonna put you on the spot for a second time
- 37:29what is one principle that you think
- 37:33that comes to mind when I ask you
- 37:35whatever parent listening
- 37:37should think about when trying to raise excellent men
- 37:46I should have known you were gonna ask this again
- 37:49you should have known last time
- 37:51he asked me for this thing
- 37:52but you can take your time and it is not a timed exam
- 38:00connect with the boy in front of you
- 38:06and what I mean by that is
- 38:08look at him and respond to him
- 38:11and his needs and his interest in the moment
- 38:14and I think that is foundational
- 38:17because that is the thing that you can carry
- 38:19from his infancy all the way through to his adulthood
- 38:22because even though it's the same human
- 38:25he will change
- 38:26yeah
- 38:30and so yes
- 38:31you can and and I will say should
- 38:35listen to podcast and read books
- 38:37and learn more about what our boys are experiencing
- 38:42and learn about their development
- 38:43cause building that knowledge
- 38:44will help you be able to effectively respond
- 38:47but your absolute best guide
- 38:50for raising a good man is to look at
- 38:53and respond to that boy in front of you
- 38:59I love that
- 39:01well the book is called Building Boys
- 39:04Raising Great Guys in a world That Misunderstands Male
- 39:08I I really recommend it wholeheartedly
- 39:11I uh
- 39:12to be candid I haven't read the whole thing
- 39:14I haven't quite finished it yet
- 39:15but I have uh
- 39:17read a large portion of it and it is really
- 39:19really really good
- 39:21Jennifer L W
- 39:22Fink
- 39:23thank you so much for joining us again on Raising Men
- 39:27I really appreciate it
- 39:29thanks so much Shawn
- 39:30and to everybody who's listening uh
- 39:32the links to all of Jennifer's uh
- 39:36her podcast and the book and all of those things
- 39:39they're in the show notes
- 39:40please check them out um
- 39:42she's absolutely fantastic as you can see
- 39:45and uh it
- 39:46it'll give you the tools to communicate better
- 39:48and connect better with your boys
- 39:50and as always thank you for listening to raising men
- 39:54thank you for like liking sharing
- 39:56subscribing and uh
- 39:58and and sharing us with your friends
- 39:59it is uh
- 40:00it is really an honor to serve you in this way
- 40:03and remember that you are a great parent
- 40:14raising men is produced by Phil Hernandez
- 40:18this episode was edited by Ralph Tolentino