Latest / Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning / Joe Henrich and Cosimo Posth: the weirdest people in the world and the genetics of Ice Age Europe
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by the Albany Public Library
- 0:03Main Branch and the
- 0:04SPEAKER_01: generosity of listeners like you.
- 0:09SPEAKER_01: What is a podcast?
- 0:16SPEAKER_01: God, Daddy, these people talk as much as you do.
- 0:26SPEAKER_01: Razeeb Khan's Unsupervised Learning.
- 0:33SPEAKER_02: The Insight.
- 0:34SPEAKER_02: The Insightum.
- 0:35SPEAKER_01: Podcast.
- 0:36SPEAKER_02: Genetics.
- 0:36SPEAKER_01: Human.
- 0:37SPEAKER_02: Archaeology.
- 0:38SPEAKER_02: Denisovans.
- 0:39SPEAKER_02: Neanderthals.
- 0:40SPEAKER_02: Metabolism.
- 0:41SPEAKER_02: Ancestry.
- 0:41SPEAKER_02: Where in the world did we come from?
- 0:44SPEAKER_02: I am.
- 0:44SPEAKER_02: Unique.
- 0:45SPEAKER_02: DNA.
- 0:45SPEAKER_02: Genome.
- 0:46SPEAKER_02: From.
- 0:46SPEAKER_02: Austin.
- 0:47SPEAKER_02: Texas.
- 0:55SPEAKER_02: Hey everybody.
- 0:57SPEAKER_02: Welcome to this week's episode of The Insight.
- 0:58SPEAKER_02: I got a very special episode with Dr. Joe Henrich.
- 1:02at Harvard,
- 1:03and he has a new book coming out with a very interesting title.
- 1:07SPEAKER_02: Can you tell us about that, Joe?
- 1:10SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:10SPEAKER_02: So the title of the new book is The Weirdest People in the World.
- 1:14SPEAKER_02: And it actually is,
- 1:16SPEAKER_02: in 2010,
- 1:17I published a paper with some colleagues in the journal
- 1:19Behavioral and Brain
- 1:20SPEAKER_02: Sciences.
- 1:21SPEAKER_02: And that paper was called The Weirdest People in the World.
- 1:23SPEAKER_02: We had a question mark.
- 1:25SPEAKER_02: So the new book has it without a question mark.
- 1:27SPEAKER_02: So I guess I'm sure now.
- 1:29SPEAKER_02: So it builds on the idea in that book,
- 1:32SPEAKER_02: which was that,
- 1:33SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 1:34SPEAKER_02: so we had looked at the available psychological evidence at the time,
- 1:38and we found that not only was there a lot more psychological
- 1:40variation than the
- 1:42SPEAKER_02: behavioral sciences had been assuming,
- 1:46but that the populations most commonly used by researchers at
- 1:51the time were
- 1:52university undergraduates were often anchoring the extreme ends
- 1:55of the global
- 1:56SPEAKER_02: distributions on a whole bunch of psychological outcomes.
- 1:59SPEAKER_02: So that took me on a kind of 10 year odyssey.
- 2:01So the last decade,
- 2:02I've been really focused on this and trying to explain why
- 2:07that's the case.
- 2:08And so the weirdest people in the world is this is the best
- 2:10thing I've come up with to explain
- 2:13SPEAKER_02: Certainly not all of the psychological variation we found by any means,
- 2:16SPEAKER_02: but at least a substantial swap of it.
- 2:18SPEAKER_02: Try to try to develop a theory for explaining that.
- 2:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:22SPEAKER_02: And,
- 2:22SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:23SPEAKER_02: I want to back up a little,
- 2:24SPEAKER_02: talk more broadly about cultural evolution,
- 2:26SPEAKER_02: because would you call yourself a cultural evolutionist?
- 2:29SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I'm happy with that.
- 2:31SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:31SPEAKER_02: So what is what is cultural evolution for the listeners?
- 2:35SPEAKER_02: How does it differ from evolution evolution?
- 2:37SPEAKER_02: If you want a biological evolution,
- 2:39SPEAKER_02: if you want to separate it,
- 2:40SPEAKER_02: can you walk us into that a little?
- 2:43SPEAKER_02: Well, so in my formation of it, it's part of evolutionary theory.
- 2:49SPEAKER_02: And it flows directly out of thinking about genetic evolution.
- 2:52SPEAKER_02: So humans are a cultural species.
- 2:55SPEAKER_02: And unlike other species,
- 2:56we evolve to make use of the information that's implicitly
- 3:00stored in the minds and
- 3:01SPEAKER_02: behaviors of those around us.
- 3:03SPEAKER_02: And so we're geared up to be able to learn from those.
- 3:05SPEAKER_02: And so we call that cultural learning.
- 3:07And I think there's good evidence to suggest that humans are
- 3:09really good at this,
- 3:11SPEAKER_02: at watching,
- 3:12SPEAKER_02: listening to,
- 3:13SPEAKER_02: and observing others,
- 3:14SPEAKER_02: interacting with them,
- 3:15SPEAKER_02: then being able to learn,
- 3:16SPEAKER_02: acquire ideas,
- 3:17SPEAKER_02: beliefs,
- 3:18SPEAKER_02: values,
- 3:18SPEAKER_02: practices,
- 3:19SPEAKER_02: and ways of thinking from other people's behavior.
- 3:22SPEAKER_02: And so that's cultural evolution.
- 3:23So culture in this view is information that's stored in
- 3:26people's brains that got
- 3:28SPEAKER_02: there through some sort of learning process,
- 3:30SPEAKER_02: broadly defined.
- 3:32And this is really important for humans because other species
- 3:34don't seem to be
- 3:35SPEAKER_02: quite as good at this cultural learning as we are.
- 3:38SPEAKER_02: And so in our case,
- 3:39it creates long processes that can go on over millennia or
- 3:44centuries that alters
- 3:45SPEAKER_02: our behavior.
- 3:46And so a proper theory of human behaviors within a biological
- 3:50framework has to
- 3:51SPEAKER_02: account for culture.
- 3:54SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 3:54And,
- 3:54you know,
- 3:54just for the listener,
- 3:55I think one thing to emphasize here is,
- 3:58you know,
- 3:59SPEAKER_02: people often think about evolutionary psychology, human universals.
- 4:04SPEAKER_02: And this is a different way of thinking of evolution,
- 4:09SPEAKER_02: human behavior,
- 4:09SPEAKER_02: human history,
- 4:10SPEAKER_02: and the human past,
- 4:11SPEAKER_02: right?
- 4:12SPEAKER_02: In terms of just like cognitive modules in the brain,
- 4:15you're more focusing on cultural variation and trying to think
- 4:19about how that
- 4:20SPEAKER_02: variation might have been selected or not selected,
- 4:23SPEAKER_02: just like we think of alleles in population genetics,
- 4:25SPEAKER_02: right?
- 4:27SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 4:28SPEAKER_02: but I would,
- 4:29SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 4:29SPEAKER_02: I don't want to separate it off entirely from evolutionary psychology.
- 4:33SPEAKER_02: So there's lots of features of the human mind.
- 4:36SPEAKER_02: So for example,
- 4:37SPEAKER_02: kin-based altruism,
- 4:38SPEAKER_02: or our version to sex with siblings,
- 4:42SPEAKER_02: incest aversion,
- 4:43SPEAKER_02: which I think are,
- 4:44SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 4:45best explained as being the way evolutionary psychologists
- 4:47proper think of them.
- 4:49SPEAKER_02: And in fact,
- 4:49the way we might think of our capacities for cultural learning
- 4:53might be as
- 4:54SPEAKER_02: specialized
- 4:55pieces of cognition that evolved and reliably developed in
- 4:58young children that
- 4:59SPEAKER_02: allow us to acquire ideas,
- 5:01SPEAKER_02: beliefs,
- 5:01SPEAKER_02: and values from others.
- 5:03So it's just kind of a richer version of the more standard
- 5:06canonical views of
- 5:07SPEAKER_02: evolutionary psychology.
- 5:09SPEAKER_02: Maybe we think of it as an extension rather than overturning.
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah, it's an extension.
- 5:15And the biggest point of interest or the biggest point of
- 5:18discussion would be just
- 5:19SPEAKER_02: how much of our psychology is shaped by the cultural learning process.
- 5:24SPEAKER_02: So,
- 5:24SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 5:24the typical picture you might get from evolutionary
- 5:27psychologists would be it's
- 5:28SPEAKER_02: mostly modules and whatnot.
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: And there's a little bit of learning that kind of fills in some slots.
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: That's kind of one extreme.
- 5:34And the other extreme would be,
- 5:35you know,
- 5:36substantial rewiring whole new cognitive modules.
- 5:41So what would you say is the biggest non-obvious insight from
- 5:44cultural evolution?
- 5:47SPEAKER_02: Well, I mean, there are several of them.
- 5:49SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 5:49SPEAKER_02: one thing that comes out of the field that was predicted theoretically,
- 5:53SPEAKER_02: which is kind of interesting,
- 5:54SPEAKER_02: because so in the 1980s,
- 5:55SPEAKER_02: Rob Boyd and Pete Richardson,
- 5:57SPEAKER_02: along with Mark Feldman and Cavalli Sforza,
- 6:00SPEAKER_02: came up with this idea of gene culture co-evolution.
- 6:03So a lot of people tend to think about human genetic evolution
- 6:06as there was a long
- 6:06SPEAKER_02: period of genetic evolution,
- 6:08SPEAKER_02: and then
- 6:09SPEAKER_02: Depending on who you're reading,
- 6:10SPEAKER_02: that stops either 50,000 years ago,
- 6:12SPEAKER_02: 10,000 years ago,
- 6:13SPEAKER_02: or 200,000 years ago.
- 6:15SPEAKER_02: And then cultural evolution.
- 6:17SPEAKER_02: The rest is history and the social sciences.
- 6:19But the gene culture co-evolutionary perspective says that
- 6:23there was this long
- 6:24SPEAKER_02: period of time,
- 6:24SPEAKER_02: I think it was older than a million years,
- 6:26SPEAKER_02: in which genes and culture were co-evolving.
- 6:29And culture was actually the primary driver of much of our
- 6:32genetic evolution.
- 6:33SPEAKER_02: So in my previous book,
- 6:34SPEAKER_02: The Secret of Our Success,
- 6:36SPEAKER_02: I make the case that you can't understand the human colon,
- 6:39SPEAKER_02: the size of our stomachs,
- 6:40SPEAKER_02: the fact that we have nuchal ligaments,
- 6:42SPEAKER_02: without understanding how our physiology was shaped by culture.
- 6:47SPEAKER_02: Is this related to the social brain hypothesis?
- 6:50SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 6:51so there's a couple different ideas out there about what drove
- 6:55the massive
- 6:55expansion in human brains that has occurred over about the last
- 6:58two million years.
- 7:00And the cultural brain hypothesis argues that it was an
- 7:03accumulating body of
- 7:04SPEAKER_02: cultural information.
- 7:06that the reason why our brains got bigger is that we had to be
- 7:09getting better at
- 7:10acquiring all this information about how to make fires and find
- 7:13food and make
- 7:14SPEAKER_02: tools,
- 7:15SPEAKER_02: and it was available in the minds of other members of our social group.
- 7:18SPEAKER_02: And as we got better,
- 7:19SPEAKER_02: that cumulative body of cultural information got bigger,
- 7:22SPEAKER_02: and we needed brains that were bigger for acquiring,
- 7:25SPEAKER_02: storing,
- 7:25SPEAKER_02: and organizing all that information.
- 7:28SPEAKER_02: The typical social brain hypothesis,
- 7:30SPEAKER_02: there's a couple of different variables,
- 7:31SPEAKER_02: is quite different.
- 7:32SPEAKER_02: So there's no cultural information,
- 7:34There's this idea that we need to be able to track social
- 7:36relationships to live in
- 7:37SPEAKER_02: large groups.
- 7:39SPEAKER_02: So in that, there's no selection pressure there to expand human brains.
- 7:43You need to posit some kind of external force that drives up
- 7:47the size of human
- 7:48SPEAKER_02: groups,
- 7:49SPEAKER_02: and then you could explain human brain expansion.
- 7:52SPEAKER_02: So it's kind of an incomplete thought.
- 7:54SPEAKER_02: Okay, okay.
- 7:55So,
- 7:55you know,
- 7:56I want to,
- 7:56before we move on to your new book,
- 7:58I wanted you to talk about...
- 8:01manioc preparation in africa um which is from the secret of of
- 8:06our success i think
- 8:07that's a really great illustration of uh just non-obvious
- 8:11insights and what
- 8:12cultural evolution can you know do to help us understand how
- 8:16practices emerge can
- 8:17you talk about that a little sure so quick background so the
- 8:20one of the key ideas
- 8:21in the secret of our success is that humans are dependent on
- 8:24cumulative cultural
- 8:25SPEAKER_02: evolution
- 8:26SPEAKER_02: that over generations,
- 8:27this ability to learn from each other produces complex
- 8:30practices that are more
- 8:31SPEAKER_02: complex than any individual could figure out on their own.
- 8:34SPEAKER_02: And one of the examples I use is manioc processing or cassava processing.
- 8:39SPEAKER_02: And when Europeans arrive in the Americas,
- 8:42they find that lots of populations in South America are using a
- 8:47kind of manioc
- 8:48SPEAKER_02: called bitter manioc that has high levels of cyanide.
- 8:51SPEAKER_02: And if you eat it without processing it,
- 8:53SPEAKER_02: You can make it sick, it can even kill you because it has cyanide in it.
- 8:56But it grows really well in certain kinds of soils,
- 8:59especially soils that aren't very fertile.
- 9:01So people had moved into various parts of the Amazon and they
- 9:03had a complex process
- 9:06SPEAKER_02: for detoxifying,
- 9:07SPEAKER_02: for removing the cyanide from the cassava.
- 9:10SPEAKER_02: And it involves scrubbing the cassava and leaching it.
- 9:14SPEAKER_02: And it takes several days and gradually,
- 9:16researchers have done studies to show how the cyanide
- 9:19concentrations gradually
- 9:20SPEAKER_02: decline until you can eventually eat it.
- 9:23SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 9:23SPEAKER_02: the Europeans,
- 9:23SPEAKER_02: actually the Portuguese,
- 9:24immediately took this crop and shipped it to Africa and other
- 9:27places because it
- 9:28SPEAKER_02: grows really well.
- 9:29SPEAKER_02: But in Africa,
- 9:31SPEAKER_02: long periods of time went by centuries,
- 9:33and people there were still getting poisoned by the cyanide
- 9:37because they hadn't
- 9:38developed the full package of detoxification processes that had
- 9:41developed in South
- 9:42SPEAKER_02: America probably over millennia.
- 9:44SPEAKER_02: So it's a case where it's hard to figure something out,
- 9:47SPEAKER_02: and it has real health and fitness consequences.
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 9:52SPEAKER_02: it just,
- 9:52SPEAKER_02: it shows also,
- 9:53SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 9:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 9:56one of the things when I read cultural evolution literature is
- 9:58interesting is how a
- 9:59lot of these practices that are useful are encapsulated where
- 10:04people don't have
- 10:04conscious understanding of the reason for the different
- 10:07interlocking parts.
- 10:09SPEAKER_02: But you are a researcher at Harvard.
- 10:12SPEAKER_02: You're going to spend your time figuring it out.
- 10:13SPEAKER_02: And eventually, you kind of figure it out.
- 10:15SPEAKER_02: But most people don't have your resources, your leisure to do this.
- 10:19SPEAKER_02: But it works.
- 10:20SPEAKER_02: And they're good at it.
- 10:21And they could probably do a better job than you in the
- 10:24preparation,
- 10:25even if you understand it.
- 10:26So it's different from the kind of skill-based thought that I
- 10:31think maybe weird
- 10:32SPEAKER_02: people think as the norm,
- 10:35SPEAKER_02: where it's like something you go and you learn in school.
- 10:38and it's novel and you know exactly why you're doing this that
- 10:42you know each step
- 10:43you know yeah and so uh yeah you mentioned weird people uh so
- 10:48we should probably
- 10:49say that weird is an acronym it stands for western educated
- 10:51industrialized rich and
- 10:52democratic and one of the cultural models on weird people is
- 10:55that uh there's a lot
- 10:57of conscious uh intentional thinking so there's the myth of the
- 11:02heroic inventor so
- 11:03SPEAKER_02: fancy things are invented by
- 11:05SPEAKER_02: big brain geniuses who kind of figure it all out and put it together.
- 11:08SPEAKER_02: But what we find a cultural evolution does,
- 11:10SPEAKER_02: whether it's the grammar of languages or manioc processing,
- 11:13SPEAKER_02: is that it can assemble complex phenomena,
- 11:18complex adaptations non-genetically without anybody consciously
- 11:23even acting on it
- 11:24SPEAKER_02: or individuals themselves even understanding it.
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 11:29SPEAKER_02: And which is for weird people, I think that's a non-obvious insight.
- 11:32SPEAKER_02: Although maybe for other people,
- 11:34SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 11:34SPEAKER_02: well,
- 11:34SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 11:35SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:35SPEAKER_02: traditions have value just because we don't know all the details.
- 11:38SPEAKER_02: And maybe we'll get back to that later.
- 11:39SPEAKER_02: I want to ask about the backstory of weird just in the 2000s.
- 11:46SPEAKER_02: Why did you come to think about this problem?
- 11:50SPEAKER_02: Because it's been a big problem in psychology.
- 11:52SPEAKER_02: And like, I mean, what was the lead up to that?
- 11:55SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 11:55SPEAKER_02: so I had my first tenure track job was at Emory University,
- 11:59SPEAKER_02: and I was in cultural anthropology.
- 12:01SPEAKER_02: So I was hired as a psychological anthropologist.
- 12:03And I did four years there,
- 12:05and then I got an offer from the University of British
- 12:07Columbia.
- 12:09SPEAKER_02: And the offer there came jointly from psychology and economics.
- 12:13SPEAKER_02: So I actually changed disciplines,
- 12:14and I moved two-thirds of my position into psychology and
- 12:17one-third into economics.
- 12:18SPEAKER_02: And when I arrived at UBC,
- 12:20SPEAKER_02: I started hanging out with these two cultural psychologists,
- 12:23SPEAKER_02: Steve Heine and Aronor and Zion.
- 12:26SPEAKER_02: And over a period of lunches,
- 12:27SPEAKER_02: Steve and I were kind of talking through the stuff we were working on.
- 12:30And we'd each realized in different separate areas of
- 12:33psychology that not only were
- 12:35SPEAKER_02: the subjects commonly studied by psychologists and others unusual,
- 12:40SPEAKER_02: but they often,
- 12:41SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 12:41SPEAKER_02: they anchored the end of the distribution.
- 12:43SPEAKER_02: So it wasn't,
- 12:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 12:44SPEAKER_02: wherever you had more than two populations,
- 12:45SPEAKER_02: there was usually an odd one out.
- 12:47And so this led us into this research project where we began
- 12:50putting together all
- 12:51the data we could find from the literature and writing the
- 12:54weird people paper.
- 12:55SPEAKER_02: And the term weird actually came up.
- 12:56I was calling them like typical subjects or undergraduates or
- 13:00something like that.
- 13:01SPEAKER_02: But it didn't seem very catchy because it didn't,
- 13:03SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 13:03SPEAKER_02: not every time it was an undergraduate.
- 13:06SPEAKER_02: About 70% of them are American undergraduates.
- 13:08SPEAKER_02: So we thought about using that for a while.
- 13:11SPEAKER_02: But then we came up with the acronym.
- 13:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 13:14I was against it because it seemed kind of a little bit too
- 13:18playful and maybe not
- 13:19SPEAKER_02: quite serious enough for me at the time.
- 13:21SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 13:21SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 13:22I think this relates to a little bit of Nance Berber's
- 13:24epidemiology of ideas where
- 13:27the selection of that word probably accelerated the acceptance
- 13:31of the idea in a
- 13:32SPEAKER_02: way.
- 13:32SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 13:33SPEAKER_02: So I had all the wrong intuitions.
- 13:35SPEAKER_02: Your intuitions were off.
- 13:36So can you talk about how weird is different than non-weird in
- 13:39general on the worldwide scale?
- 13:41SPEAKER_02: Like what are the big salient points?
- 13:42SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 13:43So although the first thing I always like to start off with is
- 13:46a cautionary note.
- 13:47There's the weird term is meant as a consciousness raising
- 13:49device to kind of
- 13:52SPEAKER_02: Initially,
- 13:52it was to focus researchers on the idea that the subjects they
- 13:55were using were the
- 13:56SPEAKER_02: unusual ones.
- 13:57SPEAKER_02: And then,
- 13:57SPEAKER_02: in fact,
- 13:57they themselves as researchers might be bringing particular
- 14:00intuitions like I was
- 14:02SPEAKER_02: that turn out not to be right about human psychology.
- 14:05SPEAKER_02: But really, there's a distribution of psychological variation.
- 14:09SPEAKER_02: There's no dichotomy between weird versus non-weird.
- 14:12SPEAKER_02: And this is a multidimensional dichotomy.
- 14:15But some of the interesting features of psychology that I try
- 14:18to explain in the
- 14:18SPEAKER_02: book,
- 14:19one is a big category called impersonal sociality or impersonal
- 14:24pro-sociality.
- 14:25SPEAKER_02: And that's things like trust in strangers,
- 14:27SPEAKER_02: cooperation with strangers,
- 14:29fairness towards anonymous others that we find varies a lot
- 14:32across societies.
- 14:33SPEAKER_02: And this is not to say that other societies are uncooperative.
- 14:36SPEAKER_02: It's just that your cooperation is based on the relationships you have.
- 14:40SPEAKER_02: or people within your ethnic group,
- 14:42SPEAKER_02: or kind of just not the general generic person you might encounter,
- 14:45SPEAKER_02: but some kind of relationship constrained social interaction.
- 14:50SPEAKER_02: And so there's also another area called individualism,
- 14:54SPEAKER_02: which is the tendency to focus on one's self,
- 14:57on cultivating certain attributes and thinking of oneself as a
- 15:01unitary whole rather
- 15:02SPEAKER_02: than a nexus in a network of relationships.
- 15:06SPEAKER_02: Analytic versus holistic thinking.
- 15:08So this tendency to look at backgrounds and contexts and in
- 15:11relationships when
- 15:12approaching a new problem versus trying to break things down
- 15:15into discrete
- 15:15SPEAKER_02: categories and assign properties to those categories.
- 15:20SPEAKER_02: Conformity.
- 15:21SPEAKER_02: How much do you want to go along with peers versus act independently?
- 15:25SPEAKER_02: Another one is the use of intentions in judging others.
- 15:28So people in Western societies tend to place a lot of weight on
- 15:32whether a person
- 15:33meant to do something and relatively less weight on what
- 15:36actually happened compared
- 15:37SPEAKER_02: to folks in other societies.
- 15:38SPEAKER_02: And I think this has to do with the focus on the individual.
- 15:41SPEAKER_02: So if you're really focused on that person as an atom,
- 15:44SPEAKER_02: Then you care about the dispositions and the underlying intentions.
- 15:48If you're seeing that person as animated by a web of social
- 15:51relationships,
- 15:52and really it's his family and friends and cousins and stuff
- 15:54that are going to
- 15:55SPEAKER_02: bring him into line,
- 15:56then the details of what's inside don't matter as much as all
- 15:59the network of social
- 16:00SPEAKER_02: relationships that he's or she is bound by.
- 16:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 16:05SPEAKER_02: So before we get into,
- 16:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 16:07SPEAKER_02: the trajectory of the weird,
- 16:08SPEAKER_02: which has a particular,
- 16:09SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 16:10SPEAKER_02: historical sequence,
- 16:11SPEAKER_02: I think that listeners will be fascinated by and,
- 16:14SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 16:14SPEAKER_02: hopefully readers.
- 16:15Can you talk about intergroup competition and perhaps the rise
- 16:19of religion and big
- 16:20gods and how that might set the stage for the emergence of
- 16:23these weird peoples who
- 16:25SPEAKER_02: obviously they had a history in the past before they were weird.
- 16:28SPEAKER_02: They weren't born weird like Athena from the head of Zeus.
- 16:31SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 16:32SPEAKER_02: Sure,
- 16:32so one of the lines in my research is thinking about the
- 16:37evolution of increasingly
- 16:38SPEAKER_02: complex human societies.
- 16:40So trying to go back well back into human history and think how
- 16:45humans went from
- 16:46SPEAKER_02: relatively less complex hunter-gatherers,
- 16:50SPEAKER_02: mobile groups,
- 16:52SPEAKER_02: no higher level political institutions,
- 16:55to larger scale societies with increasingly complex political
- 16:59institutions,
- 17:00SPEAKER_02: webbing together larger and larger networks of people.
- 17:03SPEAKER_02: And one of the things that comes out of that repeatedly across the world,
- 17:07SPEAKER_02: ethnographically,
- 17:09SPEAKER_02: historically,
- 17:10SPEAKER_02: is the role of religion.
- 17:12So my collaborators and I made the case that one of the tools
- 17:15the cultural
- 17:16evolution deployed was rituals and beliefs in certain kinds of
- 17:21supernatural agents.
- 17:22SPEAKER_02: So it looks like that supernatural agents became increasingly moralizing,
- 17:26and the circle of who's counted as someone you should be nice
- 17:30to expands over time,
- 17:32and gods begin to be concerned about behavior towards people
- 17:36inside that expanding
- 17:37SPEAKER_02: circle.
- 17:38SPEAKER_02: So you might,
- 17:39SPEAKER_02: just to simplify things,
- 17:41SPEAKER_02: lots of groups have clans,
- 17:43SPEAKER_02: and those clans have a god,
- 17:44SPEAKER_02: and they're concerned about your behavior to fellow clan members.
- 17:49SPEAKER_02: But then you can have a tribal group,
- 17:51SPEAKER_02: which consists of many different clans,
- 17:52SPEAKER_02: and you might have a tribal god that's concerned about people who
- 17:55speak the same language or share your dress or other other
- 17:58ethnic markers and then
- 17:59you can go from there all the way up to the big gods that most
- 18:02people think of as
- 18:03religion are relatively late in human history and everyone gets
- 18:07put under the under
- 18:08the umbrella of the big gods so we think that that helps scale
- 18:11up human sociality
- 18:13and we have a bunch of experiments where we unconsciously
- 18:16remind people of god and
- 18:17SPEAKER_02: see if believers behave more pro-socially with strangers for example
- 18:21SPEAKER_02: or co-religionists.
- 18:22We've done experiments around the world where we show that
- 18:24people who express more
- 18:26belief in a punishing God or a God who's monitoring their
- 18:29behavior are kinder to
- 18:31SPEAKER_02: co-religionists who live in a distant town or city.
- 18:35SPEAKER_02: Well, so let's talk about religion for a little while.
- 18:39SPEAKER_02: I've actually followed this literature pretty closely.
- 18:41SPEAKER_02: It's fascinating.
- 18:42SPEAKER_02: I've read Big Gods and a bunch of those books.
- 18:45SPEAKER_02: The one qualm that I recently started having about some of the psychology
- 18:50SPEAKER_02: experiments,
- 18:51SPEAKER_02: they kind of remind me of priming a little bit.
- 18:53SPEAKER_02: Do you worry a bit?
- 18:55I will put out there,
- 18:57I'm broadly persuaded by the general outline of your thesis.
- 19:00But in the specific contemporary experiment literature where
- 19:03you have eyes and
- 19:05SPEAKER_02: you know, it makes people behave more morally.
- 19:08Do you worry a little bit about like,
- 19:10you know,
- 19:10the replication,
- 19:11you know,
- 19:11bias type stuff?
- 19:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 19:14SPEAKER_02: So I'd be worried if everything hinged on the priming.
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: So we do use priming as a tool.
- 19:20And there are good meta-analyses that put together all the
- 19:23available priming evidence.
- 19:25SPEAKER_02: And it looks like a pretty well-behaved literature.
- 19:28It doesn't always replicate,
- 19:30but there's reasons why you think it might not always
- 19:32replicate.
- 19:33SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 19:33SPEAKER_02: there's a little bit of a file drawer,
- 19:35SPEAKER_02: but if you compensate for that,
- 19:36SPEAKER_02: the effects still hold.
- 19:37The other thing that's tricky about the whole literature is
- 19:40researchers haven't
- 19:41SPEAKER_02: always been careful that they're testing believers.
- 19:44And so you're going to get negative results if you have too
- 19:46many non-believers in there.
- 19:49So we get any stronger effects when we're able to remove and
- 19:51focus only on the believers.
- 19:54SPEAKER_02: And then I mentioned we have all this correlational work showing –
- 19:58even just comparing people within the same village or with a
- 20:00couple of villages,
- 20:01SPEAKER_02: people who believe more are more pro-social to these distant individuals.
- 20:05SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 20:06SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 20:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 20:07SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 20:08SPEAKER_00: That's interesting.
- 20:09SPEAKER_02: So I would not lean very hard on the eye stuff.
- 20:11SPEAKER_02: And that's, that's always been a worry of mine because, uh,
- 20:15SPEAKER_02: Humans shouldn't be generally susceptible to eyes.
- 20:18SPEAKER_02: I mean, our world is full of eyes that we don't worry about.
- 20:20SPEAKER_02: So baby's eyes, dog's eyes, bird's eyes.
- 20:23There's all these eyes around us,
- 20:25and we can't be monitoring for all those eyes.
- 20:28SPEAKER_02: So it should be specific other eyes.
- 20:30And so that's why God's eyes,
- 20:31a lot of religious iconography are actually eyes.
- 20:34So I would expect God's eyes to work,
- 20:37you know,
- 20:37kind of the symbol of God.
- 20:39SPEAKER_02: symbol.
- 20:40And the original work done by Dan Fessler actually uses a kind
- 20:43of cultural symbol
- 20:45SPEAKER_02: for a supernatural eye.
- 20:48SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 20:49SPEAKER_02: Well, so before we move to
- 20:53SPEAKER_02: to the weird, you know, the big topic.
- 20:55SPEAKER_02: I want to ask you about a paper that came out last year.
- 20:57SPEAKER_02: And,
- 20:58SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 20:58SPEAKER_02: there was kind of a controversy,
- 20:59SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 21:00SPEAKER_02: related to religion between two groups of cultural evolutionists.
- 21:03And I don't think it was as intense as say selectionists versus
- 21:06neutralists and
- 21:07SPEAKER_02: population genetics,
- 21:08SPEAKER_02: but it got kind of intense,
- 21:09SPEAKER_02: at least on social media.
- 21:11And,
- 21:11you know,
- 21:11I think I'm friendly with,
- 21:13you know,
- 21:13people in both groups.
- 21:14SPEAKER_02: So I'm not taking sides here.
- 21:15Complex societies precede moralizing God throughout world
- 21:18history,
- 21:19White House et al.
- 21:21SPEAKER_02: And so this paper is claiming,
- 21:23that basically the big gods are an effect of big societies
- 21:29rather than the reverse,
- 21:30I think.
- 21:32SPEAKER_02: And there were some issues with data analysis.
- 21:34And honestly,
- 21:35I think this is a very big question and it's very important.
- 21:38SPEAKER_02: And that's why I'm asking you.
- 21:39SPEAKER_02: I'm assuming you guys are having a reaction or a follow-up soon.
- 21:44SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 21:44SPEAKER_02: so first,
- 21:46SPEAKER_02: I have a hugely positive opinion of the authors of that paper,
- 21:50SPEAKER_02: Peter Turchin,
- 21:50SPEAKER_02: Harvey Whitehouse,
- 21:52SPEAKER_02: great guys.
- 21:53SPEAKER_02: We do disagree on this topic.
- 21:55SPEAKER_02: And so a couple of notes here.
- 21:59SPEAKER_02: So you can think of them as having two possible findings in that paper.
- 22:03SPEAKER_02: The first finding is, are bigger gods...
- 22:08SPEAKER_02: Do they precede the scaling up of societies?
- 22:10And then the second finding is,
- 22:12do big gods help the society stay big for longer?
- 22:15SPEAKER_02: So both of those are,
- 22:18SPEAKER_02: in our paper in BBS,
- 22:20SPEAKER_02: which is the place where we lay all this out,
- 22:22SPEAKER_02: we actually make that prediction as,
- 22:24SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 22:25cultural group selection will favor religion if it either helps
- 22:28scale up and or if
- 22:30SPEAKER_02: it helps keep it stable over time.
- 22:32SPEAKER_02: So they show evidence for keeping stable over time.
- 22:35So that paper could have easily been rewritten as providing
- 22:38evidence for the Big
- 22:39SPEAKER_02: God's hypothesis.
- 22:41And the problem,
- 22:42but they emphasized the other side,
- 22:44which is the scaling upside.
- 22:45SPEAKER_02: The problem is they made basically an error.
- 22:48SPEAKER_02: And when they, the data had a bunch of data that was missing.
- 22:52SPEAKER_02: And what they did is replace all that with absences.
- 22:55So they took an absence of evidence and turned it into evidence
- 22:58of absence.
- 23:00SPEAKER_02: And that's the entire result.
- 23:02SPEAKER_02: There's nothing left if you remove that.
- 23:04SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 23:04SPEAKER_02: We demonstrated it.
- 23:06SPEAKER_02: So we've written a reply.
- 23:09SPEAKER_02: We sent it to Nature.
- 23:10SPEAKER_02: Nature had it reviewed.
- 23:11SPEAKER_02: The reviewer said, absolutely, you must publish this.
- 23:15SPEAKER_02: This is devastating.
- 23:16SPEAKER_02: And Nature then asked the authors to retract it.
- 23:21SPEAKER_02: Several of the authors decided that, yes, they would retract it.
- 23:25SPEAKER_02: Some authors refused and wanted to fight.
- 23:28SPEAKER_02: And Nature's been sitting on it for months.
- 23:32SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 23:32SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 23:33SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 23:33SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 23:34SPEAKER_02: for the geneticists,
- 23:35SPEAKER_02: for a lot of data scientists in the audience,
- 23:38SPEAKER_02: missing data is a big deal.
- 23:40And there's always discussions on how to deal with missing data
- 23:44and various questions.
- 23:45SPEAKER_02: So it sounds like a simple thing, but it's not trivial at all.
- 23:50SPEAKER_02: It's always something that crops up because, believe it or not,
- 23:54SPEAKER_02: imperfect, incomplete data is actually the norm in most things.
- 23:59SPEAKER_02: And so that's not surprising.
- 24:00SPEAKER_02: So let's talk about weird, the origins of weird societies.
- 24:06SPEAKER_02: The historical scope here,
- 24:07SPEAKER_02: like let's say the past 2000 years,
- 24:09SPEAKER_02: you start with Rome and you have the modern world,
- 24:12SPEAKER_02: the Western world,
- 24:13SPEAKER_02: the developed world.
- 24:14SPEAKER_02: So you said you had a joint appointment in economics back at UBC.
- 24:18SPEAKER_02: And this book actually overlaps with literature and
- 24:22SPEAKER_02: economic history that I'm quite familiar with,
- 24:24SPEAKER_02: related to the great divergence,
- 24:26SPEAKER_02: the origins of Western capitalism,
- 24:27SPEAKER_02: et cetera,
- 24:28SPEAKER_02: et cetera.
- 24:28SPEAKER_02: And so it threads a lot of things together.
- 24:30And so there's going to be a lot of stages and moving parts
- 24:34that we're going through here.
- 24:35But first,
- 24:35can you start with the church,
- 24:38the family,
- 24:39Rome and its fall,
- 24:40and that great hinge?
- 24:42SPEAKER_02: Because I think that's where it starts.
- 24:45SPEAKER_02: Sure.
- 24:45SPEAKER_02: So the case the book makes is that a particular religion
- 24:53SPEAKER_02: in what became the Roman Catholic Church,
- 24:56SPEAKER_02: which was just one branch of Christianity at the time,
- 24:59adopted a particular package of norms related to marriage and
- 25:03the family that
- 25:05altered the structure of kinship and families and marriage in
- 25:08parts of Europe.
- 25:10SPEAKER_02: And these things were held in place for centuries.
- 25:14And that that put Europe,
- 25:15that parts of Europe,
- 25:17on a different cultural evolutionary trajectory
- 25:19than we see in other places where people can build extended
- 25:22family networks,
- 25:23SPEAKER_02: develop clans,
- 25:25SPEAKER_02: and kind of cultivate a kind of different kind of cooperation,
- 25:28SPEAKER_02: different approach to cooperation.
- 25:30So I make the case that that's a key event and that that is
- 25:33really important.
- 25:34SPEAKER_02: And then I kind of flow through the ramifications of that,
- 25:37SPEAKER_02: both in terms of psychology,
- 25:39SPEAKER_02: it's easy to show.
- 25:40SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 25:40we showed in our science paper last year that you can relate
- 25:43intensive kinship to
- 25:45SPEAKER_02: these aspects of psychology that I call weird psychology,
- 25:48But then it also has implications for the kinds of formal
- 25:51institutions and social
- 25:52SPEAKER_02: forms that we see developing by the high Middle Ages in Europe.
- 25:57And Rome is a nice case because part of the Western Roman
- 26:01Empire falls and then the
- 26:02church is able to have a substantial influence in what was
- 26:06previously the Roman
- 26:07SPEAKER_02: Empire and then expanding out beyond that.
- 26:10SPEAKER_02: Meanwhile, the Roman Empire continues for a thousand years.
- 26:13SPEAKER_02: in Byzantine Empire.
- 26:16SPEAKER_02: And so does the church.
- 26:17SPEAKER_02: So does another version of Catholicism.
- 26:20SPEAKER_02: And so we get this, that's kind of a nice comparative case.
- 26:23SPEAKER_02: So for example,
- 26:24SPEAKER_02: people would suggest it's Rome or Roman institutions,
- 26:27SPEAKER_02: but we have a control case,
- 26:28SPEAKER_02: which is Byzantine.
- 26:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 26:30SPEAKER_02: so I mean,
- 26:31SPEAKER_02: I think the key point here is,
- 26:33SPEAKER_02: in your telling,
- 26:34SPEAKER_02: and it seems broadly correct to me,
- 26:38SPEAKER_02: the Roman Empire,
- 26:39SPEAKER_02: Roman culture,
- 26:39SPEAKER_02: and Roman society,
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: in many ways,
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: are much more intelligible to non-Western people than,
- 26:46SPEAKER_02: say,
- 26:46SPEAKER_02: medieval European society.
- 26:49SPEAKER_02: And so the great break here is after the fall of the Roman Empire, when
- 26:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 26:55SPEAKER_02: the kindred,
- 26:55SPEAKER_02: kinship-related institutions collapsed and,
- 27:00SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 27:00SPEAKER_02: were kind of burned away by the church through these,
- 27:05SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 27:06SPEAKER_02: banning on cousin marriage and stuff like that,
- 27:08SPEAKER_02: which can we talk about,
- 27:10SPEAKER_02: like,
- 27:10SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 27:10SPEAKER_02: you kind of addressed it a little bit.
- 27:12What do you think,
- 27:13is there an origin for this program or is it just kind of
- 27:17historical chance?
- 27:18SPEAKER_02: I mean, was it inevitable?
- 27:19SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 27:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 27:21so one of the kind of big tools of cultural evolutionary
- 27:24thinking is that we have a
- 27:26tendency to focus on the winner or on whatever the case is
- 27:29we're trying to explain.
- 27:31And I think an important kind of mental tool is to zoom out and
- 27:35think about what's
- 27:36SPEAKER_02: happening more generally.
- 27:38SPEAKER_02: So if you think about what happened in Rome,
- 27:41SPEAKER_02: it's just,
- 27:41SPEAKER_02: well,
- 27:42SPEAKER_02: different religious groups are trying different
- 27:44things to ways to manipulate the family,
- 27:47different religious beliefs are coming into existence.
- 27:49SPEAKER_02: So over in Iran,
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: you have Zoroastrianism,
- 27:53which is encouraging marriage to cousins and even incestuous
- 27:56marriages between
- 27:57SPEAKER_02: brothers and sisters amongst the elite.
- 28:00SPEAKER_02: Meanwhile,
- 28:00SPEAKER_02: Islam comes along a bit later,
- 28:02SPEAKER_02: but there there's a restriction of polygyny just down to four wives.
- 28:07But there's an inheritance system which encourages parallel
- 28:10cousin marriage.
- 28:11So societies influenced by Islam are virtually unique in the
- 28:15anthropological record
- 28:16SPEAKER_02: in marrying patrilateral cousins.
- 28:19SPEAKER_02: So fathers, brothers, children married.
- 28:22SPEAKER_02: If you're a woman, it's fathers, brothers, sons.
- 28:25And,
- 28:26you know,
- 28:27that's going to create a whole different set of network
- 28:29dynamics.
- 28:30SPEAKER_02: So different groups are trying different things.
- 28:32And the Roman Catholic Church just happened to pick this
- 28:35peculiar set of taboos,
- 28:37SPEAKER_02: extreme incest taboos and regulations on monogamy,
- 28:41SPEAKER_02: bilateral inheritance.
- 28:42SPEAKER_02: Other groups were doing different kinds of inheritance.
- 28:44SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 28:45And,
- 28:45you know,
- 28:46if you look at the genetic data,
- 28:48you can see this difference pretty obviously.
- 28:51SPEAKER_02: And I'm sure you know some of this work,
- 28:54SPEAKER_02: Joe,
- 28:54where it's like you see in some of these Islamic societies in
- 28:57the Middle East,
- 28:58SPEAKER_02: they have like huge long runs of homozygosity all over the place.
- 29:02SPEAKER_02: And it's...
- 29:04SPEAKER_02: when you look at the summary statistics on the snip frequencies,
- 29:06SPEAKER_02: well,
- 29:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 29:07SPEAKER_02: they look like other Eurasians,
- 29:09SPEAKER_02: but then you look at the segments,
- 29:10SPEAKER_02: there's just like a lot of inbreeding in recent history.
- 29:13SPEAKER_02: Whereas like if you look at Europeans,
- 29:15SPEAKER_02: um,
- 29:15SPEAKER_02: it's not Western Europeans in particular,
- 29:17SPEAKER_02: but Europeans in general,
- 29:18SPEAKER_02: it's not like that at all.
- 29:19They're not actually genetically very diverse because of the
- 29:21ancient bottlenecks,
- 29:22SPEAKER_02: but in terms of their recent,
- 29:24SPEAKER_02: um,
- 29:24SPEAKER_02: recent marriage patterns, it is exactly as you described.
- 29:28And so I think that's a great synthesis between just like
- 29:30looking at genetic level
- 29:31SPEAKER_02: data and what you see in the history and the anthropology.
- 29:35SPEAKER_02: So, you know, you have this situation where you have
- 29:40like lack of familialism,
- 29:41I don't know,
- 29:42like a society where the family isn't as important.
- 29:45SPEAKER_02: And this relates obviously,
- 29:48SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 29:48to the listeners that's been paying attention to what you were
- 29:50saying earlier about
- 29:51SPEAKER_02: weird,
- 29:51but can you make it explicit when you have a society where the
- 29:54family is not
- 29:55SPEAKER_02: important,
- 29:55SPEAKER_02: like what happens then?
- 29:57SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 29:58So I think that the contrast you want to have in your mind is
- 30:02in a world where you
- 30:03SPEAKER_02: inherit lots of relationships,
- 30:04SPEAKER_02: when you're trying to find,
- 30:05SPEAKER_02: say,
- 30:05SPEAKER_02: someone to open a business with,
- 30:07SPEAKER_02: the key thing is how they're connected to you.
- 30:09And you can guarantee that they're going to be trustworthy if
- 30:12they have dense
- 30:12SPEAKER_02: connections to you for various ways,
- 30:15SPEAKER_02: and that will keep them trustworthy.
- 30:17Once you're in a world with small families where you're
- 30:19interacting with strangers,
- 30:21SPEAKER_02: you've got to focus,
- 30:21SPEAKER_02: like,
- 30:22SPEAKER_02: is this person an honest person?
- 30:24Is this someone I want to kind of bet on and I'm going to go
- 30:26into business with or
- 30:27SPEAKER_02: I'm going to marry?
- 30:28Whereas in the complex kinship world,
- 30:30intensive kinship,
- 30:31marriages are arranged.
- 30:32So you're building strategic links amongst families so
- 30:35everybody can be stronger
- 30:37SPEAKER_02: through shared resources and shared alliances and whatnot.
- 30:40So you change the world into a more individualistic world where
- 30:44what you need to
- 30:45SPEAKER_02: make your way in the world is to cultivate attributes.
- 30:49What do you have unique to give to others in order to build
- 30:52social relationships,
- 30:53SPEAKER_02: whether that's friends,
- 30:54SPEAKER_02: spouses,
- 30:55SPEAKER_02: partners,
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: things like that.
- 30:57SPEAKER_02: And this freed people.
- 30:59SPEAKER_02: In some sense, it's bad because people lost the security blankets.
- 31:04And,
- 31:05you know,
- 31:05if you get injured,
- 31:06you would have this big network to take care of you.
- 31:08SPEAKER_02: If you have children or someone dies,
- 31:09SPEAKER_02: your spouse dies,
- 31:10SPEAKER_02: you have a big network to take care of you.
- 31:12SPEAKER_02: And they were sort of thrust out into this world.
- 31:14SPEAKER_02: And one of the things they did is they built voluntary associations.
- 31:17SPEAKER_02: So these are groups of strangers that come together as a club.
- 31:19SPEAKER_02: They take oaths.
- 31:20SPEAKER_02: They're all Christians.
- 31:21SPEAKER_02: They take oaths to take care of each other, essentially.
- 31:24SPEAKER_02: And this is the beginning of guilds.
- 31:27And then you get a whole proliferation of guilds that
- 31:29eventually becomes occupational.
- 31:31SPEAKER_02: You get things like universities and charter towns.
- 31:34SPEAKER_02: So people even come together and they join towns like a club.
- 31:37And as with the club comes membership,
- 31:39you have responsibilities,
- 31:41but you also have privileges.
- 31:42SPEAKER_02: And this is notions of citizenship begin developing.
- 31:45SPEAKER_02: But it's a voluntary thing.
- 31:46SPEAKER_02: You join.
- 31:47SPEAKER_02: You don't join as a member of a lineage or anything like that.
- 31:50SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 31:50SPEAKER_02: so I mean,
- 31:51SPEAKER_02: this is basically a very rich civil society,
- 31:53SPEAKER_02: like a thick network of institutions and ties that are not family based.
- 31:57And obviously,
- 31:58in other societies,
- 31:59there are non family based institutions.
- 32:02SPEAKER_02: So you know,
- 32:02SPEAKER_02: you go Buddhist temple in China,
- 32:04SPEAKER_02: but the history and the philosophy and just,
- 32:09SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 32:09SPEAKER_02: the way the Chinese think about the world is kindred family based.
- 32:13SPEAKER_02: And they're not
- 32:15SPEAKER_02: the strange ones there.
- 32:16SPEAKER_02: I mean, that's most societies, right?
- 32:18SPEAKER_02: It's like, you know, it's like the question in some societies.
- 32:21So,
- 32:22you know,
- 32:22like the question you ask new,
- 32:23new,
- 32:24new people tells you about a society.
- 32:26SPEAKER_02: So in American society, people are often asked, what do you do?
- 32:31SPEAKER_02: So like your job is what's important.
- 32:33SPEAKER_02: I mean, which that's actually offensive in a lot of cultures.
- 32:35SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 32:35SPEAKER_02: why are you,
- 32:36SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 32:37SPEAKER_02: whereas in other societies,
- 32:39SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 32:39SPEAKER_02: people be like,
- 32:40SPEAKER_02: who are your people?
- 32:42SPEAKER_02: If you asked an American that, that would just not register.
- 32:45I think most Americans would actually just not understand what
- 32:49you were asking,
- 32:50SPEAKER_02: which when I first heard that,
- 32:51SPEAKER_02: I actually didn't understand either.
- 32:53SPEAKER_02: What are you even talking about?
- 32:55SPEAKER_02: I mean, my neighbors.
- 32:56I actually,
- 32:57I think,
- 32:57defaulted to weird because I was like,
- 32:59well,
- 32:59what people?
- 33:00SPEAKER_02: My coworkers, my neighbors, my family.
- 33:03SPEAKER_02: I didn't automatically think of the families.
- 33:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 33:06SPEAKER_02: So I want to ask you real quickly.
- 33:07SPEAKER_02: I'll just comment on that.
- 33:09I do research in Fiji and Fijians start looking for some kind
- 33:12of relationship link.
- 33:13Like they talk about possible people they could have in common
- 33:16and they're just
- 33:16SPEAKER_02: searching for some way in which they're linked through relationships.
- 33:20Yeah,
- 33:21my family's from Bangladesh,
- 33:22and I can tell you Bengali's,
- 33:23I've seen the same thing.
- 33:25SPEAKER_02: And a lot of times it's pretty obviously made up or fake,
- 33:28SPEAKER_02: where it's like,
- 33:29SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 33:29SPEAKER_02: they know two people from some town that have the same name.
- 33:32SPEAKER_02: They're like, let's just go with that.
- 33:34SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 33:34SPEAKER_02: you can tell that,
- 33:35SPEAKER_02: you can tell they're both like,
- 33:36SPEAKER_02: that's fake,
- 33:37SPEAKER_02: but we're just going to pretend because we want to hang out or,
- 33:40SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 33:40SPEAKER_02: we want to do this.
- 33:42SPEAKER_02: I want to ask you a question.
- 33:43So,
- 33:44you know,
- 33:44this is like a book to some extent of history and anthropology
- 33:47and evolution.
- 33:49SPEAKER_02: Have you...
- 33:50Have you given much thought to Walter Scheidel's theories in
- 33:52Escape from Rome on
- 33:54the polycentrism and geographic diversity and how that relates
- 33:57to what you're
- 33:57SPEAKER_02: talking about here?
- 33:58SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 33:59SPEAKER_02: So I really like that book.
- 34:01SPEAKER_02: And a lot of what I describe is,
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: this competition amongst cities,
- 34:07SPEAKER_02: free cities,
- 34:08SPEAKER_02: and then eventually it becomes competition amongst countries.
- 34:10SPEAKER_02: And so I think polycentrism is really important.
- 34:13And the way it fits into cultural evolution is the importance
- 34:16of intergroup competition.
- 34:17SPEAKER_02: So in Europe,
- 34:18SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:18SPEAKER_02: if you had a great invention or you wrote an important book,
- 34:21SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:21SPEAKER_02: it could be banned by your local ruler.
- 34:23SPEAKER_02: But there was always somewhere else to head.
- 34:25SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 34:25SPEAKER_02: Galileo gets imprisoned,
- 34:26but his books gets printed like crazy in the Netherlands and
- 34:30eventually makes its
- 34:31SPEAKER_02: way back to Rome.
- 34:32SPEAKER_02: And then people are reading the Dutch copy.
- 34:34SPEAKER_02: So are the books printed in the Netherlands?
- 34:38SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 34:39SPEAKER_02: So that's really important.
- 34:41SPEAKER_02: The thing that I would,
- 34:42SPEAKER_02: the place where I think our two ideas meet would be why this polycentrism
- 34:47maintained so long in Europe and these independent city states
- 34:50that persist for so
- 34:51SPEAKER_02: long.
- 34:53SPEAKER_02: So I think that it kind of,
- 34:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:55SPEAKER_02: you kind of put our two books together and get a more complete theory.
- 34:58SPEAKER_02: It's not that I don't think that geography played some part.
- 35:02SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 35:02SPEAKER_02: there is a way in which Europe is different,
- 35:04SPEAKER_02: but you can find other places in the world which have
- 35:07similar patterns of geography,
- 35:08but they didn't,
- 35:09they didn't have the same societal.
- 35:13SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 35:14SPEAKER_02: So again, complimentary.
- 35:15Um,
- 35:16so let me ask you,
- 35:18so we're talking about inbreeding and relatives and family.
- 35:21Um,
- 35:21but you know,
- 35:22obviously part of the weird package is,
- 35:24is monogamy,
- 35:25um,
- 35:25obligate monogamy.
- 35:27SPEAKER_02: And, um,
- 35:28SPEAKER_02: your work on monogamy and polygamy and mostly polygyny in general.
- 35:33SPEAKER_02: So it's like,
- 35:33SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 35:34SPEAKER_02: one man with,
- 35:34SPEAKER_02: with many wives to,
- 35:38SPEAKER_02: to be frank,
- 35:38it's kind of frightening in terms of polygamous societies or
- 35:41polygynous societies
- 35:42SPEAKER_02: and how they're organized.
- 35:43SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 35:44SPEAKER_02: I know that you're a scientist,
- 35:45SPEAKER_02: you're not like presenting a normative thesis here,
- 35:47SPEAKER_02: but can you talk about the differences between a polygamous society and a
- 35:53SPEAKER_02: monogamous society in terms of competition and cooperation?
- 35:58SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 35:58so the key thing I am interested in and point out is that most
- 36:02societies throughout
- 36:03SPEAKER_02: human history have been polygynous.
- 36:05SPEAKER_02: So one man being able to take multiple lives.
- 36:08And then what's interesting about monogamy is how it affects
- 36:10the competition among men.
- 36:12SPEAKER_02: So if you have a society with any kind of status differentiation,
- 36:15SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 36:16you'll even see this operative in hunter-gatherer societies
- 36:19where the hunting is
- 36:19SPEAKER_02: difficult.
- 36:20SPEAKER_02: But anything that differentiates the men,
- 36:23SPEAKER_02: the higher status,
- 36:24SPEAKER_02: more productive males end up getting additional wives.
- 36:27And that creates an increasing pool of low status unmarried men
- 36:31that have few mating prospects.
- 36:33And they just end up permanently residing at the bottom of the
- 36:36status pool with no
- 36:38SPEAKER_02: matings unless they can take a big risk.
- 36:40SPEAKER_02: and somehow fling themselves up the status hierarchy.
- 36:43SPEAKER_02: And the more polygynous society,
- 36:45SPEAKER_02: the steeper the climb,
- 36:46SPEAKER_02: the further they have to fling themselves up.
- 36:48SPEAKER_02: So they can't just kind of work hard and keep their head down.
- 36:52Climbing up the status by 10% often won't get you into the
- 36:56mating and marriage market.
- 36:57SPEAKER_02: You've got to go up 40% or some large amount.
- 37:00SPEAKER_02: So this leads to higher crime rates.
- 37:03SPEAKER_02: In some societies, it could lead to raiding from other societies.
- 37:06It leads to minor marriages where families will promise brides
- 37:10at a young age
- 37:10SPEAKER_02: because there's so few females,
- 37:12SPEAKER_02: they've got to kind of get their bets in early.
- 37:15SPEAKER_02: So all those kinds of consequences.
- 37:17SPEAKER_02: And so I make the case that intergroup competition will favor monogamy,
- 37:22SPEAKER_02: normative monogamy,
- 37:22because it reduces male-male competition within the group and
- 37:25then makes that group
- 37:26SPEAKER_02: more competitive with other groups.
- 37:29SPEAKER_02: Did you see the,
- 37:31it was kind of a dumb Twitter debate about monogamy a couple of
- 37:33years ago triggered
- 37:34SPEAKER_02: by Jordan Peterson.
- 37:36SPEAKER_02: Did you see that?
- 37:37SPEAKER_02: I didn't see it.
- 37:37SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 37:38SPEAKER_02: Well, good for you then.
- 37:40SPEAKER_02: You didn't miss anything, but it was very weird.
- 37:45SPEAKER_02: In a literal sense,
- 37:46because I think people were trying to grasp at some of the
- 37:48things that you're
- 37:49SPEAKER_02: talking about,
- 37:50SPEAKER_02: but not in a very sophisticated way.
- 37:51SPEAKER_02: I want to ask, do you think this theory you have...
- 37:59SPEAKER_02: It's kind of,
- 38:00SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 38:02SPEAKER_02: it's not like necessarily Western exceptionalism,
- 38:06SPEAKER_02: but it does feel like,
- 38:07SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 38:08SPEAKER_02: this is how the West is weird and it's the exception to the rule.
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: And I know that there's no normative valence in what you're saying here.
- 38:15SPEAKER_02: You're just describing, you're trying to see how the world is around you.
- 38:18But I mean,
- 38:19do you think some of the criticisms will be that this is
- 38:22Eurocentric?
- 38:23SPEAKER_02: I mean, it kind of by definition is, because you're talking about
- 38:26SPEAKER_02: Western Europe.
- 38:27SPEAKER_02: But I mean,
- 38:28do you understand what I'm getting at there in terms of like
- 38:30the ethical normative
- 38:31SPEAKER_02: framework and how this is going to be interpreted by some people?
- 38:34Well,
- 38:34yeah,
- 38:35I mean,
- 38:35so it's a sensible worry that people might misunderstand it
- 38:38that way.
- 38:39SPEAKER_02: I kind of think of it as the opposite of ethnocentric.
- 38:42SPEAKER_02: Because I mean,
- 38:42SPEAKER_02: at a scientific level,
- 38:44one of the things the book is doing is trying to raise concerns
- 38:46about the extreme
- 38:47SPEAKER_02: bias in psychological sampling.
- 38:50SPEAKER_02: So, you know, I'm calling for a more
- 38:53a thorough kind of homo sapiens level of psychology where we
- 38:57canvas the species and
- 38:58SPEAKER_02: we try to understand all the psychological variation.
- 39:01SPEAKER_02: Right now, the psychological database is about 95% weird subjects.
- 39:06SPEAKER_02: So we really have only a thin fraction of the total global variation.
- 39:10SPEAKER_02: The other way in which I think that that would be wrong,
- 39:14SPEAKER_02: that concern or that criticism,
- 39:16SPEAKER_02: I guess,
- 39:18SPEAKER_02: would be that,
- 39:19SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 39:19SPEAKER_02: the whole book is about how the things that
- 39:22SPEAKER_02: at least some people take pride in from Western civilization,
- 39:25SPEAKER_02: so democracy,
- 39:27SPEAKER_02: science,
- 39:28SPEAKER_02: individualized,
- 39:28SPEAKER_02: individual-centered law,
- 39:30SPEAKER_02: so Western law,
- 39:31SPEAKER_02: were,
- 39:31SPEAKER_02: in my telling of it,
- 39:33myopic products that emerged through an unconscious cultural
- 39:37transmission that
- 39:38SPEAKER_02: occurred over centuries,
- 39:40and it wasn't due to reason or rationality or some enlightened
- 39:44thinker suddenly
- 39:44SPEAKER_02: giving birth to,
- 39:45SPEAKER_02: I invented democracy because I'm finally rational enough.
- 39:49SPEAKER_02: Instead, those things are very much a sideshow
- 39:52and that it's this kind of long cultural evolutionary process
- 39:55and facts about
- 39:56SPEAKER_02: cultural evolution which would apply to any society.
- 39:59SPEAKER_02: And it traces back these institutions
- 40:02SPEAKER_02: to the strange sexual taboos of a group of religious zealots.
- 40:06SPEAKER_02: So in that sense,
- 40:08that wouldn't be what I think most people who want to put the
- 40:11West on a pedestal,
- 40:14SPEAKER_02: that's not the story they would want to tell.
- 40:15SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 40:16SPEAKER_02: Without rationality and reasoning,
- 40:18not a bunch of religious guys who were obsessed with sex and
- 40:21people not having it.
- 40:22SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 40:25SPEAKER_02: Do you think weirdness is spreading?
- 40:28SPEAKER_02: Well, I mean, I think...
- 40:30SPEAKER_02: Certainly in some ways, in some dimensions.
- 40:32SPEAKER_02: So, I mean, the diffusion of institutions that emerge from Europe.
- 40:37SPEAKER_02: So countries,
- 40:39SPEAKER_02: whether they succeed or not,
- 40:41SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 40:42SPEAKER_02: at least are superficially trying to be nation states.
- 40:45SPEAKER_02: They write constitutions.
- 40:46SPEAKER_02: They have elections.
- 40:48SPEAKER_02: And these are things that are all spilling out of Europe.
- 40:50SPEAKER_02: Monogamy spread.
- 40:51SPEAKER_02: So China.
- 40:52adopts monogamy in the mid 20th century,
- 40:54Japan in the 1880s,
- 40:55Turkey in 1926.
- 40:56SPEAKER_02: So there's all these institutions that are spilling out around the world.
- 41:04SPEAKER_02: There's new data suggesting that,
- 41:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 41:06SPEAKER_02: being close to missions in Africa makes,
- 41:10SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 41:11you can find some variation in people's psychology that's
- 41:14consistent with the
- 41:14SPEAKER_02: account I lay out in my book.
- 41:16SPEAKER_02: So Western missions spread all over the world,
- 41:19SPEAKER_02: including in Africa,
- 41:20and seem to have had an impact on people's psychology by
- 41:23promoting all these
- 41:23SPEAKER_02: institutions.
- 41:24SPEAKER_02: So,
- 41:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 41:25how much monogamy an African village has is actually predicted
- 41:28by its distance from
- 41:29SPEAKER_02: the nearest historical mission.
- 41:31SPEAKER_02: So the missionaries were busy.
- 41:34SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that's fascinating.
- 41:37SPEAKER_02: I do have a question.
- 41:38SPEAKER_02: With the demographic transition, there are fewer relatives out there.
- 41:43Have you ever thought about the fact that huge families
- 41:47relatively recently with
- 41:50low infant mortality in some societies resulted in an increase
- 41:54of familialism
- 41:55SPEAKER_02: temporarily that might just fade due to demographic structural forces?
- 42:00SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 42:01SPEAKER_02: So,
- 42:01SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 42:02SPEAKER_02: if you get the demographic transition to spread,
- 42:05then that should reduce your ability to build those large
- 42:08families just as a kind
- 42:09SPEAKER_02: of mechanical product of the fact that the people have fewer relatives.
- 42:13SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 42:13And so things like Western education is one of the biggest
- 42:17spreaders of the
- 42:18SPEAKER_02: demographic institution.
- 42:19SPEAKER_02: So when you go to school means they get pregnant later,
- 42:22SPEAKER_02: which means they have fewer lower lifetime fertility.
- 42:25But,
- 42:26but school is a Western universal schooling is a Western
- 42:28institution.
- 42:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 42:31So this is,
- 42:32I mean,
- 42:32in some ways it's like,
- 42:33okay,
- 42:33is everyone going to become Western or not?
- 42:35SPEAKER_02: I mean, that is, I guess, the question.
- 42:37SPEAKER_02: Well, the thing, one thing that I think that,
- 42:40SPEAKER_02: again, my term, and this could be my fault, right?
- 42:43SPEAKER_02: Just saying weird suggests that there's like one thing.
- 42:46SPEAKER_02: But what I think we're going to see is a kind of,
- 42:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 42:49SPEAKER_02: there's a kind of homogenizing,
- 42:51SPEAKER_02: and then I'm going to expect a wide range of different ways of thinking.
- 42:56SPEAKER_02: Because you're going to get different forms of government,
- 42:59SPEAKER_02: different ways of organizing people that are going to be popping up at
- 43:03SPEAKER_02: As each of these,
- 43:04SPEAKER_02: as the Western institutions are reinterpreted locally,
- 43:07people add some of their own cultural institutions and then
- 43:10they have to interface.
- 43:11And so I think cultural evolution will recreate a lot of
- 43:14psychological diversity.
- 43:15SPEAKER_02: It'll just be different than we've been accustomed to in the past.
- 43:18SPEAKER_02: I don't think we're heading towards a one size fits all.
- 43:21SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 43:21SPEAKER_02: So,
- 43:21SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 43:22SPEAKER_02: in a way,
- 43:22this is actually like kind of the argument or discussion I have
- 43:25with people who
- 43:25SPEAKER_02: think,
- 43:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 43:27people from different ethnic groups coming together is going to
- 43:29like create some
- 43:30SPEAKER_02: like one homogenous whole,
- 43:31SPEAKER_02: which is like,
- 43:32SPEAKER_02: that's just not how genetics works.
- 43:33SPEAKER_02: Like the variation is going to be there.
- 43:34You're just going to see new configurations that you didn't
- 43:37expect before.
- 43:38And so you're saying the same thing with cultural evolution
- 43:40where weird might expand,
- 43:42but...
- 43:44SPEAKER_02: As part of the expansion, it's going to diversify and regionalize.
- 43:47SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 43:48That's a kind of gut feeling just based on how cultural
- 43:51evolutionary processes go.
- 43:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 43:54Well,
- 43:54I mean,
- 43:54the past and the future often have some relationships,
- 43:57so we'll see.
- 43:58SPEAKER_02: So one question.
- 44:00SPEAKER_02: Let me just make one more point on the...
- 44:05SPEAKER_02: question you asked about ethnocentrism.
- 44:06And one of the other points I make is that innovation and
- 44:09economic growth are one
- 44:10SPEAKER_02: of the things I take on at the end of the book.
- 44:12SPEAKER_02: And there the key is not,
- 44:16societies that are more innovative are not because individuals
- 44:18are individually,
- 44:20SPEAKER_02: people are individually smarter,
- 44:21SPEAKER_02: but because there's a greater collective mind.
- 44:25So these things are rooted in things like tolerance,
- 44:28trust in strangers,
- 44:29openness to new ideas.
- 44:31SPEAKER_02: And then the more people you can have interacting with
- 44:34SPEAKER_02: sharing ideas, you get faster innovation, faster cumulative culture.
- 44:38SPEAKER_02: And that puts us,
- 44:39SPEAKER_02: that emphasizes the importance of integration,
- 44:43SPEAKER_02: bringing people together,
- 44:45SPEAKER_02: tolerance,
- 44:45SPEAKER_02: things like that.
- 44:48So,
- 44:48so diversity of different kinds of cognition can really drive
- 44:51innovation in that case.
- 44:53SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 44:53this is the kind of reason that economists would say that you
- 44:55want density in big
- 44:56SPEAKER_02: cities,
- 44:57SPEAKER_02: right?
- 44:57SPEAKER_02: You interact with lots of different types of people,
- 44:59SPEAKER_02: you get a lot of synthesis,
- 45:01SPEAKER_02: and everything just happens a lot faster.
- 45:03SPEAKER_02: So I think,
- 45:04SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 45:04SPEAKER_02: your book,
- 45:05SPEAKER_02: your ideas actually kind of dovetail with other disciplines,
- 45:09SPEAKER_02: which is good because reality is one thing.
- 45:12SPEAKER_02: What are the big questions in cultural evolution that,
- 45:14SPEAKER_02: as the 2020s progress,
- 45:16SPEAKER_02: are making you excited or driving your research program right now?
- 45:20SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 45:20SPEAKER_02: so the big thing,
- 45:22SPEAKER_02: one of the big things that I want to get to,
- 45:23SPEAKER_02: and the book is kind of my first pass at this,
- 45:26is really taking cultural evolution into history and trying to
- 45:30get longitudinal
- 45:31SPEAKER_02: data where we can track cultural changes through time.
- 45:35SPEAKER_02: So I have two postdocs starting in the lab,
- 45:37and we're going to be trying to look at kind of both century
- 45:40timescale change using
- 45:41SPEAKER_02: literary sources and newspapers and things like that,
- 45:44and trying to track changes in psychology or other cultural
- 45:47traits through time.
- 45:50the book i have a little bit of that but mostly i'm trying to
- 45:53attack things that
- 45:53happened historically to contemporary psychological variation
- 45:56now i want to get the
- 45:57whole trajectory wherever i can well i mean how are historians
- 46:02feeling about this
- 46:02attempt at imperialism are they pretty chill about it or you
- 46:05know uh well we'll see
- 46:07um there's at least a few historians who seem supportive and my
- 46:11guess is the vast
- 46:11SPEAKER_02: majority will will not like it but i mean you do have yeah
- 46:16SPEAKER_02: I'm a collaborator, right?
- 46:17SPEAKER_02: So I want to work with historians and learn from them.
- 46:21SPEAKER_02: And, you know, this is a, I think science is a team sport.
- 46:24SPEAKER_02: And so we have to,
- 46:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 46:26bring as many people in as possible and take advantage of
- 46:29everyone's individual
- 46:30SPEAKER_02: expertise.
- 46:33SPEAKER_02: The problem is within at least part of history,
- 46:35SPEAKER_02: there's a kind of epistemology,
- 46:36which is anti-scientific and still has the old guy squirreled
- 46:40away with his
- 46:41SPEAKER_02: manuscripts,
- 46:41SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 46:42SPEAKER_02: writing his independent monographs.
- 46:44SPEAKER_02: Well, yeah.
- 46:45SPEAKER_02: It's just,
- 46:46SPEAKER_02: it's just,
- 46:46SPEAKER_02: it's just one fact after the other sometimes,
- 46:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 46:49SPEAKER_02: like in terms of,
- 46:50SPEAKER_02: and I think in your,
- 46:51SPEAKER_02: and you know,
- 46:51SPEAKER_02: for the listeners who don't know,
- 46:52you've been part of a group of researchers that have said
- 46:56theory is very important
- 46:57SPEAKER_02: in science to avoid problems like the replication crisis.
- 47:01SPEAKER_02: Um,
- 47:03SPEAKER_02: that's,
- 47:03I think something that's sellable to people who think of
- 47:05themselves as scientists,
- 47:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 47:07SPEAKER_02: psychologists.
- 47:08SPEAKER_02: But when you go to historians,
- 47:10SPEAKER_02: that's an order of magnitude,
- 47:12SPEAKER_02: more difficult lift,
- 47:14SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 47:14SPEAKER_02: where it's like,
- 47:15SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 47:16SPEAKER_02: as Peter Turchin has found,
- 47:17SPEAKER_02: but I mean,
- 47:17SPEAKER_02: some historians are quite open,
- 47:19SPEAKER_02: but the vast majority,
- 47:20SPEAKER_02: it's just not their bias.
- 47:23SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 47:23So I've been involved with this database of religious history
- 47:27led by the historian
- 47:29SPEAKER_02: and Chinese philosopher,
- 47:31SPEAKER_02: Ted Slingerland.
- 47:32SPEAKER_02: And,
- 47:33SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 47:33they've done well at getting historians to participate and make
- 47:37entries into this
- 47:38SPEAKER_02: historical database.
- 47:39SPEAKER_02: But I remember I was speaking at a conference we'd put together,
- 47:42SPEAKER_02: invited a whole bunch of historians.
- 47:45SPEAKER_02: And there was a kind of general skepticism permeating the room.
- 47:48And it was the rebels who were willing to kind of cooperate and
- 47:51collaborate.
- 47:52SPEAKER_02: And the rest of them didn't want any part of it.
- 47:56SPEAKER_02: Awesome, awesome.
- 47:57SPEAKER_02: So, you know, that's your big project, I guess, for the next decade.
- 48:03SPEAKER_02: I mean, that is a big thing to tackle.
- 48:08SPEAKER_02: But I do have like one last question.
- 48:11SPEAKER_02: A couple of years ago,
- 48:12SPEAKER_02: was it a couple of years ago,
- 48:13Tyler Cowen said that some of your ideas seemed quite
- 48:18conservative in a way.
- 48:20SPEAKER_02: Like, how do you feel about that impression
- 48:25SPEAKER_02: you know, thinking about it.
- 48:26SPEAKER_02: He meant conservative in the,
- 48:30I guess in the classical sense or in the enlightenment sense or
- 48:33something like
- 48:33SPEAKER_02: that.
- 48:34And I think the key idea that I think I should ask Tyler
- 48:37exactly what he meant
- 48:38SPEAKER_02: because we never kind of debriefed on that.
- 48:41The way I now interpret his question is that it's about the
- 48:44idea that there can be
- 48:45SPEAKER_02: institutions can have functional elements that we don't understand.
- 48:49SPEAKER_02: And I take that to be one of the main messages about, you know,
- 48:54SPEAKER_02: the new book, which is that take something like monogamy.
- 48:57SPEAKER_02: So I was involved in this trial in British Columbia,
- 49:00SPEAKER_02: and we had months,
- 49:01SPEAKER_02: months of long debate,
- 49:02SPEAKER_02: scientists,
- 49:02SPEAKER_02: I gave testimony to the court for three hours,
- 49:05trying to understand whether they should decriminalize the law
- 49:08against polygyny,
- 49:10SPEAKER_02: or the law that criminalizes polygyny.
- 49:12SPEAKER_02: And
- 49:13You know,
- 49:13so we're trying to understand what the imposition of monogamy
- 49:17does to societies.
- 49:19SPEAKER_02: And there's a huge debate about it.
- 49:20SPEAKER_02: We clearly don't know.
- 49:22SPEAKER_02: But people have been imposing monogamy for centuries in Europe,
- 49:25SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 49:25SPEAKER_02: a thousand years or longer.
- 49:28So this just is an example of an institution which we can't
- 49:31even agree in this
- 49:32SPEAKER_02: courtroom on how it works with the kind of latest psychological evidence.
- 49:35There's no way people in the past had a chance of figuring out
- 49:38how their institutions work.
- 49:39SPEAKER_02: And I think that's generally true of our institutions.
- 49:42They spread and we have them because they were successful in
- 49:45competition with other
- 49:46SPEAKER_02: versions of institutions.
- 49:47SPEAKER_02: So there's something functional about them.
- 49:49But the idea that we understand exactly what they do,
- 49:52I think,
- 49:53is why Tyler made that point.
- 49:56SPEAKER_02: I made the same point in the book about competition among firms.
- 50:01SPEAKER_02: So I think it affects people's trust.
- 50:02And if you have competition among firms composed of individuals
- 50:06who can move around
- 50:07SPEAKER_02: between firms,
- 50:08SPEAKER_02: you actually increase the overall trust levels in the society.
- 50:11SPEAKER_02: But that's not something anybody who's,
- 50:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:13no economist who theorizes the firm has said it changes
- 50:15people's psychology.
- 50:18SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 50:19SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think you're exactly right.
- 50:21This whole idea that we don't rationally understand all the
- 50:24details of all these
- 50:26SPEAKER_02: customs,
- 50:26SPEAKER_02: traditions,
- 50:27SPEAKER_02: and institutions.
- 50:28SPEAKER_02: And that's why I was asking you about cassava,
- 50:30SPEAKER_02: because I think that illustrates that really clearly.
- 50:33SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 50:33SPEAKER_02: so the book is The Weirdest People in the World,
- 50:36SPEAKER_02: How the West Became Psychologically Peculiar and Particularly Prosperous.
- 50:40It is out September 8,
- 50:422020,
- 50:42and it's been really great talking to you,
- 50:44Joe.
- 50:45SPEAKER_02: All right, thanks.
- 50:45SPEAKER_02: Good to be with you.
- 50:51SPEAKER_02: This week, the genetic history of Ice Age Europe.
- 50:54SPEAKER_02: Hey everybody, this is Razeeb Khan.
- 50:57I am Director of Scientific Content at Insight Home and I am
- 51:00here with Cosimo Post.
- 51:20SPEAKER_00: Hello, everybody.
- 51:21SPEAKER_00: I'm Cosimo Post.
- 51:22I'm a postdoc researcher at the Max Planck Institute for the
- 51:26Science of Human
- 51:27SPEAKER_00: History in Vienna,
- 51:29SPEAKER_00: Germany.
- 51:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 51:30SPEAKER_02: and we're going to talk about prehistory,
- 51:32SPEAKER_02: in particular the Pleistocene and Pleistocene Europe.
- 51:35Can you talk about what the Pleistocene is and what it means
- 51:38for Europe in general?
- 51:39SPEAKER_00: Yeah, sure.
- 51:40SPEAKER_00: So Pleistocene is, of course, a huge time period.
- 51:44SPEAKER_00: It is spanning between 2 billion years ago until 11,000 years ago.
- 51:51SPEAKER_00: So the time period of our interest is specifically the late Pleistocene.
- 51:56that is actually starting around 120,000 years ago and is
- 52:00finishing exactly around
- 52:02SPEAKER_00: 12,000 years ago.
- 52:03And this period of the late Pleistocene actually largely
- 52:09overlap with what has been
- 52:12SPEAKER_00: known as the last ice age,
- 52:15SPEAKER_00: the last glaciation.
- 52:18SPEAKER_00: And during this period,
- 52:19SPEAKER_00: it was not all glaciated,
- 52:21SPEAKER_00: but it was,
- 52:21SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 52:22SPEAKER_00: a phase of warmer and colder phase,
- 52:26SPEAKER_00: so-called glacial and interglacial phases.
- 52:30But the coldest period of this last ice age was the so-called
- 52:36last glacial maximum.
- 52:38SPEAKER_00: And this was around 22,000 years ago.
- 52:41SPEAKER_00: And this is a period where,
- 52:43SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 52:45modern humans were ready in Europe and had a strong impact on
- 52:50their living.
- 52:51SPEAKER_02: So,
- 52:51SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 52:52SPEAKER_02: the beginning part of this,
- 52:54SPEAKER_02: the 120,000 years up until about like 45,
- 52:56SPEAKER_02: like Europe is occupied by Neanderthals,
- 52:59SPEAKER_02: correct?
- 52:59SPEAKER_00: Correct, yes.
- 52:59They were really dominating this side of the world,
- 53:05West and West Eurasia.
- 53:08SPEAKER_00: And they were living there and producing different,
- 53:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 53:14SPEAKER_00: different techno-complexes,
- 53:16SPEAKER_00: the so-called Musterian.
- 53:19And it's this period where Neanderthals were around in Europe
- 53:23is called Middle Paleolithic.
- 53:27SPEAKER_00: And around 45,000,
- 53:28SPEAKER_00: there is the beginning of this upper paleolithic,
- 53:33SPEAKER_00: that is techno-complexes,
- 53:35SPEAKER_00: so cultures associated with arrival of Homo sapiens,
- 53:41SPEAKER_00: so of modern humans into Europe.
- 53:44SPEAKER_02: And about when did modern humans arrive in Europe?
- 53:47SPEAKER_00: Yeah, exactly.
- 53:47SPEAKER_00: So the oldest dates are right now around 45,000 years ago.
- 53:53SPEAKER_00: And they are coming from Southern Europe,
- 53:57SPEAKER_00: in particular Italy in Puglia,
- 54:00SPEAKER_00: but also Central Europe,
- 54:02SPEAKER_00: like Southwest Germany,
- 54:06SPEAKER_00: all the way to the UK,
- 54:10SPEAKER_00: all with dates that are ranging between 43,000 and 45,000.
- 54:14So that means that modern humans may have been in Eastern
- 54:18Eurasia and even
- 54:20SPEAKER_02: Australia before they were occupying Europe.
- 54:23SPEAKER_00: Correct.
- 54:23There are a lot of theories and a lot of hypotheses that this
- 54:28was the case.
- 54:31SPEAKER_00: It's really still hard to date precisely when
- 54:40modern humans left Africa but there are more and more
- 54:44archaeological evidence
- 54:46indeed around the region of Australia as well as Indonesia and
- 54:54in general eastern
- 54:56SPEAKER_00: Eurasia with very very old
- 55:00archaeological findings associated to modern humans the
- 55:05question is though if those
- 55:09SPEAKER_00: modern humans did live or did not live descendants in later period so far
- 55:19The common idea is that there was a major out-of-Africa event
- 55:22that both spread
- 55:25SPEAKER_00: towards the east and towards west,
- 55:28SPEAKER_00: Eurasia.
- 55:29And this is the one that was successful and happened around
- 55:3450,000 years ago.
- 55:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 55:36SPEAKER_02: And so in Europe,
- 55:37SPEAKER_02: I want to talk about a paper that you were a second author on,
- 55:40SPEAKER_02: Genetic History of Ice Age Europe.
- 55:41SPEAKER_02: What is the major finding from this paper for a listener?
- 55:46SPEAKER_00: So,
- 55:46SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 55:47SPEAKER_00: in the Ice Age Europe paper,
- 55:49we found several population turnover throughout these 35,000
- 55:55years of human
- 55:56SPEAKER_00: history,
- 55:57SPEAKER_00: spanning between 45,000 and around 15,000 or 10,000 years ago.
- 56:06SPEAKER_00: So here we are talking about hunter-gatherers' populations.
- 56:09SPEAKER_00: Farming is not yet established, and...
- 56:14SPEAKER_00: And this population were extremely mobile,
- 56:17but they were also producing different kinds of culture
- 56:21throughout different time
- 56:24SPEAKER_00: period.
- 56:25SPEAKER_00: And what we observe that in this time interval, there are a lot of
- 56:32SPEAKER_00: genetic transformations.
- 56:34SPEAKER_00: Some of them we could find a good link,
- 56:36SPEAKER_00: a good match with archaeological transition,
- 56:40SPEAKER_00: so change in culture.
- 56:43SPEAKER_00: Some other genetic transformation is that we could associate them to
- 56:51SPEAKER_00: climatic changes.
- 56:52SPEAKER_00: So there was not one-to-one correlation,
- 56:56but there were multiple situations and multiple parameters that
- 57:04played a role in
- 57:06SPEAKER_00: this genetic transformation that we observed.
- 57:10SPEAKER_02: So, yeah.
- 57:11SPEAKER_02: Can you talk about the last glacial maximum?
- 57:14SPEAKER_02: What areas of Europe were inhabited?
- 57:16SPEAKER_02: Was that a major turnover event?
- 57:19SPEAKER_00: Absolutely, yes.
- 57:20So the last glacial maximum is,
- 57:24as I said before,
- 57:24the coldest phase of the last ice age.
- 57:28And this spans,
- 57:29at least in the coldest period,
- 57:31between 25,000 and 19,000 years ago.
- 57:35SPEAKER_00: And we have to imagine this phase in Europe,
- 57:40SPEAKER_00: where the ice sheet,
- 57:42SPEAKER_00: a thick layer of ice sheet,
- 57:45SPEAKER_00: was covering the
- 57:46almost entirely all Northern and Central Europe was reaching
- 57:53basically France and
- 57:56SPEAKER_00: Central France as well as Central Germany.
- 57:58SPEAKER_00: And this was not only the...
- 58:02the only ice that was present in Europe because of course also
- 58:05all the mountainous
- 58:06regions like the Pyrenees as well as the Alps and the
- 58:10Carpathians were of course
- 58:12much larger and the extension of the glaciation was much larger
- 58:16also in that
- 58:18SPEAKER_00: respect.
- 58:19So we have to imagine this is a phase where there is a
- 58:23contraction of human population
- 58:26SPEAKER_00: uh, and, uh, resulting in a genetic bottlenecks.
- 58:30And then,
- 58:31uh,
- 58:31only after the last question maximum,
- 58:33there is a re-expansion.
- 58:35SPEAKER_00: And of course there is a,
- 58:36SPEAKER_00: during this time period,
- 58:37SPEAKER_00: there is,
- 58:38SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 58:39SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 58:39SPEAKER_00: a loss of genetic variation.
- 58:43SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah.
- 58:43SPEAKER_02: So I think one of the primary things is the extent of turnover.
- 58:47I actually had a bet with Chris Stinger that the first modern
- 58:54Europeans would not
- 58:56SPEAKER_02: have left any descendants before you guys' paper came out years ago.
- 58:59It just seemed that with human turnover,
- 59:02especially in northern regions...
- 59:04SPEAKER_02: the probability of continuity is low.
- 59:07SPEAKER_02: So,
- 59:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 59:07SPEAKER_02: for the listeners,
- 59:08SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 59:08SPEAKER_02: I think we should like go over some of these cultures and what they mean.
- 59:13SPEAKER_02: And they probably heard some of the words.
- 59:14SPEAKER_02: So the word Cro-Magnon, that's not a scientific term, right?
- 59:18SPEAKER_00: No, not anymore.
- 59:19SPEAKER_00: So Cro-Magnon man is a terminology,
- 59:24was the type specimen to describe these early modern humans
- 59:29that arrived in Europe.
- 59:31SPEAKER_00: However,
- 59:33SPEAKER_00: it has been really replaced by this terminology,
- 59:37SPEAKER_00: early modern human,
- 59:39SPEAKER_00: because it is only related to a specific site.
- 59:43SPEAKER_00: And when we refer to early modern humans,
- 59:48SPEAKER_00: we refer to Europeans that spans from the first arrival,
- 59:54so modern humans that are spent from the first arrival all the
- 59:57way to the advent of
- 1:00:02SPEAKER_00: agriculture.
- 1:00:03SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:00:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:00:04And so we have these,
- 1:00:05um,
- 1:00:05these cultures,
- 1:00:06I think they're mostly defined by tools.
- 1:00:08SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_02: um,
- 1:00:09SPEAKER_02: like we have like the Arignation,
- 1:00:11SPEAKER_02: the Gravitian,
- 1:00:12SPEAKER_02: the Solutrean,
- 1:00:13SPEAKER_02: the Magdalenian and the Epigravidian and I'm,
- 1:00:17SPEAKER_02: I'm kind of like labeling them by order of time.
- 1:00:20SPEAKER_02: Can you just like give like a quick overview of these cultures?
- 1:00:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:00:25SPEAKER_00: Yes,
- 1:00:25so all these names of this culture come from archaeological
- 1:00:30sites where some
- 1:00:31SPEAKER_00: specific tools,
- 1:00:33SPEAKER_00: stone tools,
- 1:00:34have been discovered and they take the name after those sites
- 1:00:42and those stone tools
- 1:00:43SPEAKER_00: are spread and
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_00: and also, of course, distributed in different geographical regions.
- 1:00:50SPEAKER_00: So starting with the Aurignacian,
- 1:00:54SPEAKER_00: it's really the first widespread technology that we find in Europe.
- 1:00:59And this has been associated with one of the first arrivals of
- 1:01:04modern humans around Europe.
- 1:01:06SPEAKER_00: And this culture, starting around, let's say, 43,000 years ago,
- 1:01:14SPEAKER_00: then gets replaced by a different culture,
- 1:01:17SPEAKER_00: the Gravetian,
- 1:01:19SPEAKER_00: that starts a little bit later,
- 1:01:22SPEAKER_00: around 30,000 years ago or 35,000 years ago,
- 1:01:26SPEAKER_00: and depends on the geographical region.
- 1:01:29SPEAKER_00: And these also have a huge spread.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_00: It goes from Western Europe all the way to Eastern Europe.
- 1:01:35And it's still not clear if this is one single group or if
- 1:01:39there are multiple groups involved.
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_00: But the Gravetians are the people that face...
- 1:01:47SPEAKER_00: this last glacial maximum,
- 1:01:49and that the people that kind of retreat in climatic refugia
- 1:01:54during this cold space
- 1:01:55SPEAKER_00: of the last ice age,
- 1:01:57SPEAKER_00: and then in this period,
- 1:01:59SPEAKER_00: other cultures emerge.
- 1:02:01SPEAKER_00: One of those,
- 1:02:02SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 1:02:02is the Solutrean that is distributed mainly in one of these
- 1:02:08climatic refugia that
- 1:02:09SPEAKER_00: is southwest Europe,
- 1:02:12SPEAKER_00: like Iberia,
- 1:02:13SPEAKER_00: as well as southern France,
- 1:02:15SPEAKER_00: And from there,
- 1:02:16it's supposed that people spread again after the last glacial
- 1:02:21maximum with this
- 1:02:23transformed culture that is so-called Magdalenian from the
- 1:02:27southwest to the
- 1:02:29SPEAKER_00: northeast,
- 1:02:31SPEAKER_00: re-peopling Europe that was depopulated during the last glacial maximum.
- 1:02:38SPEAKER_00: What happens south of the Alps in Italy, it's a little bit different.
- 1:02:46SPEAKER_00: So there is not this strong cut,
- 1:02:50SPEAKER_00: strong transition between,
- 1:02:53SPEAKER_00: strong divide between the Gravetian and the Magdalenian,
- 1:02:57SPEAKER_00: but there is more continuity.
- 1:03:01SPEAKER_00: So in Southern Europe,
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_00: in the Balkans and in Italy,
- 1:03:06the period after the last glacial maximum is called
- 1:03:11Epigravettian to strengthen
- 1:03:13SPEAKER_00: this connection with the previous,
- 1:03:15SPEAKER_00: the pre-last glacial maximum period called Gravettian.
- 1:03:18Can you talk about the genetics and what you guys found out
- 1:03:21about the relatedness
- 1:03:22SPEAKER_02: of these groups to modern populations in each other?
- 1:03:24SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:03:25SPEAKER_00: So we were quite,
- 1:03:27SPEAKER_00: at the beginning of when we started to work on this paper,
- 1:03:30we really decided to let the genetics speak without associating
- 1:03:37these ancient human
- 1:03:39SPEAKER_00: remains to any species.
- 1:03:42archaeological culture so we just really analyzed them
- 1:03:46independently and we saw
- 1:03:48that individuals from different locations from different time
- 1:03:52periods start to
- 1:03:53group together in different clusters and we gave names to this
- 1:03:57cluster not based on
- 1:03:58the culture of those people but based on the geographic
- 1:04:03location or the site where
- 1:04:05SPEAKER_00: the oldest individuals belonging to this culture this cluster came from
- 1:04:11SPEAKER_00: But then we realized that actually we could draw some association.
- 1:04:16SPEAKER_00: For example,
- 1:04:19we found that many individuals associated to this Gravetian
- 1:04:25time period indeed
- 1:04:27share a higher genetic affinity than people that were there
- 1:04:33even in the same
- 1:04:34SPEAKER_00: geographic location before and after.
- 1:04:37SPEAKER_00: So we could indeed see that
- 1:04:40SPEAKER_00: the Gravetian were not only sharing a similar culture,
- 1:04:46SPEAKER_00: but also were sharing similar genes together.
- 1:04:49And for the origination,
- 1:04:51unfortunately,
- 1:04:52so the previous period,
- 1:04:54we don't have many skeletons.
- 1:04:56So far,
- 1:04:56we have only one individual that is associated to this
- 1:05:01technocomplex.
- 1:05:02SPEAKER_00: So it's really hard to extend this conclusion.
- 1:05:07SPEAKER_00: But after the last glacial maximum,
- 1:05:10SPEAKER_00: so during the period called Magdalenian,
- 1:05:13SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:05:14SPEAKER_00: we find a strong correlation between
- 1:05:19SPEAKER_00: genes and this techno complex called Magdalenian.
- 1:05:25SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 1:05:25SPEAKER_00: however,
- 1:05:26SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:05:27SPEAKER_00: I have to stress also that this is not always the case because the,
- 1:05:31SPEAKER_00: the,
- 1:05:31SPEAKER_00: the phase after the Magdalenian,
- 1:05:33SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:05:35SPEAKER_00: that start around 14,000 years ago, we see a genetic shift.
- 1:05:41SPEAKER_00: We see what we call a population turnover from 14,000 years ago onwards.
- 1:05:48SPEAKER_00: And this is not followed by any remarkable archaeological shift.
- 1:05:55SPEAKER_00: So we think that in that case, it was not really...
- 1:06:02SPEAKER_00: the archaeological shift driving the genetic shift,
- 1:06:05but we think that actually climate played a major role in the
- 1:06:10expansion of a new
- 1:06:12SPEAKER_00: population from the Southeastern Europe,
- 1:06:17SPEAKER_00: so from the Balkans,
- 1:06:18SPEAKER_00: that moved and migrated into Central Europe,
- 1:06:22SPEAKER_00: bringing this new genetic type.
- 1:06:27So do you think Europe is exceptional in the amount of turnover
- 1:06:30because of the
- 1:06:31SPEAKER_02: northerly position?
- 1:06:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah, this is a really good question.
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_00: I think that,
- 1:06:35SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 1:06:36the geography of Europe indeed plays a major role in this
- 1:06:40climatic turnover,
- 1:06:42SPEAKER_00: not only for the...
- 1:06:44SPEAKER_00: latitude,
- 1:06:45SPEAKER_00: but also for the elevation of certain region,
- 1:06:50SPEAKER_00: like this mountainous region that are present in Europe.
- 1:06:53So indeed,
- 1:06:55this geomorphology facilitate the formation of structured
- 1:07:04population.
- 1:07:05It means that population that are not in contact among each
- 1:07:10other during colder phases.
- 1:07:12And so it facilitated the formation of genetic cluster and then
- 1:07:17eventually also the
- 1:07:20SPEAKER_00: admixture or replacement between those groups.
- 1:07:26SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:07:26SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:07:27SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:07:27SPEAKER_02: all of those like cave paintings,
- 1:07:29SPEAKER_02: those people did not leave many descendants,
- 1:07:31SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:07:31I mean,
- 1:07:31for the listener,
- 1:07:32like that's one of the things that you guys discovered.
- 1:07:35SPEAKER_00: I have to say,
- 1:07:37SPEAKER_00: actually,
- 1:07:37SPEAKER_00: that our paper found out that the initial people,
- 1:07:43SPEAKER_00: the initial Europeans,
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_00: dated between 40,000 and 45,000,
- 1:07:49SPEAKER_00: indeed did not leave descendants in modern-day Europeans.
- 1:07:55SPEAKER_00: But actually,
- 1:07:56SPEAKER_00: all individuals in our time series,
- 1:07:58SPEAKER_00: starting from 37,000 onwards,
- 1:07:59SPEAKER_00: they left descendants in
- 1:08:04SPEAKER_00: later European.
- 1:08:06SPEAKER_00: Maybe a small proportion,
- 1:08:09but indeed they show some level of genetic continuity
- 1:08:13throughout 37,000 years.
- 1:08:16SPEAKER_00: So also the people that were painting the caves in,
- 1:08:19SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:08:20SPEAKER_00: these famous caves in France,
- 1:08:21SPEAKER_00: like Lascaux,
- 1:08:24SPEAKER_00: they indeed left traces in the genome of modern day Europeans.
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 1:08:34SPEAKER_02: So one thing that I'm curious about,
- 1:08:36SPEAKER_02: it doesn't look like there was much,
- 1:08:39SPEAKER_02: if any,
- 1:08:40SPEAKER_02: gene flow over Gibraltar,
- 1:08:41SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_00: Correct.
- 1:08:44SPEAKER_00: Correct.
- 1:08:45So it's really highly debated,
- 1:08:50the contacts in the Paleolithic time between
- 1:08:55SPEAKER_00: between Northern Africa and Iberian Peninsula through Gibraltar.
- 1:09:01One of the reasons why people think that this was not a viable
- 1:09:07connection is
- 1:09:08SPEAKER_00: because of the high current that is always in this trade.
- 1:09:15SPEAKER_00: And there are not convincing evidence of early contacts.
- 1:09:20SPEAKER_00: So most of the contacts between Africa and
- 1:09:24SPEAKER_00: And Europe happened through the Levant region,
- 1:09:28where there are multiple evidence of alternation between
- 1:09:32Neanderthals and modern
- 1:09:33SPEAKER_00: humans throughout time.
- 1:09:35SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 1:09:36SPEAKER_02: so it seems like,
- 1:09:37SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:09:37SPEAKER_02: we're not going to be talking about the agriculturalists,
- 1:09:39but it's a recurrent pattern that the Middle East or the
- 1:09:43Balkans serves as a
- 1:09:44SPEAKER_02: reservoir for modern humans,
- 1:09:46SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:09:47SPEAKER_02: During the ups and downs of the climatic cycle.
- 1:09:49SPEAKER_00: Totally, yes.
- 1:09:51SPEAKER_00: And the kind of...
- 1:09:54genetic turnover that I was telling you about that happened
- 1:09:57around 14,000 years
- 1:09:58SPEAKER_00: ago,
- 1:09:59SPEAKER_00: it's indeed associated with a spread of people with a higher percentage,
- 1:10:04SPEAKER_00: a higher proportion of Near Eastern ancestry.
- 1:10:07SPEAKER_00: So indeed,
- 1:10:08that's the reason why we think that this population movement of
- 1:10:11hunter-gatherers
- 1:10:12SPEAKER_00: happened also from the
- 1:10:14SPEAKER_00: southeast towards the northwest,
- 1:10:17SPEAKER_00: towards central Europe,
- 1:10:20SPEAKER_00: probably because this was,
- 1:10:21SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:10:22SPEAKER_00: a climatic refusion during colder phases.
- 1:10:25SPEAKER_00: And it is interesting that 6,000 years after,
- 1:10:29SPEAKER_00: again,
- 1:10:30SPEAKER_00: a similar movement happened around basically 8,000 years ago,
- 1:10:36SPEAKER_00: spreading that time a new kind of way of lifestyle,
- 1:10:40SPEAKER_00: so spreading the agriculture.
- 1:10:43SPEAKER_02: So a quick question about that.
- 1:10:45SPEAKER_02: So Neanderthal ancestry and Oasi,
- 1:10:47SPEAKER_02: and then later,
- 1:10:48SPEAKER_02: like your paper found that it declined over time.
- 1:10:50SPEAKER_02: Like what is the update on that result since that paper came out?
- 1:10:54SPEAKER_00: Yeah, we are still confirming this pattern.
- 1:10:57SPEAKER_00: The pattern is that despite Oasi,
- 1:11:00SPEAKER_00: that is clearly what has been defined as a hybrid because it,
- 1:11:07SPEAKER_00: it,
- 1:11:08SPEAKER_00: carries in his family pedigree one ancestor that is a Neanderthal,
- 1:11:15SPEAKER_00: so in the four to six generations before the individual lived.
- 1:11:20And that's why it has an elevated percentage of Neanderthal
- 1:11:25proportion,
- 1:11:26up to 10%.
- 1:11:28All other individuals have a much lower percentage of
- 1:11:32Neanderthal contribution,
- 1:11:34But what we observe is lining this individual through time from
- 1:11:39the oldest 45,000
- 1:11:40SPEAKER_00: to actually modern day individuals.
- 1:11:44So today we could really find out the percentage of
- 1:11:49Neanderthals decline over time.
- 1:11:54SPEAKER_00: And if we look specifically where there is this depletion,
- 1:11:58SPEAKER_00: so this reduction of Neanderthal ancestry,
- 1:12:00SPEAKER_00: is in the proximity of genes,
- 1:12:03SPEAKER_00: so of coding regions.
- 1:12:06SPEAKER_00: And that's why we interpreted this fact as...
- 1:12:11SPEAKER_00: negative selection towards Neanderthal introgressed blocks that are,
- 1:12:19there were disadvantages for the population and so were
- 1:12:24depleted from the modern
- 1:12:26SPEAKER_00: human genome through time.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_02: Yeah, so basically natural selection was purifying the genome.
- 1:12:32SPEAKER_02: So I have a question about Neanderthals.
- 1:12:34There's been a lot of stuff recently that's been coming out
- 1:12:36about Neanderthals and
- 1:12:37SPEAKER_02: Neanderthal art and Neanderthal culture.
- 1:12:39SPEAKER_02: I don't know if you have a strong opinion on it or not,
- 1:12:43but what was the interaction of the modern first humans and
- 1:12:46Neanderthals like?
- 1:12:47Do you have any intuition about why modern humans 45,000 years
- 1:12:51ago finally replaced
- 1:12:52SPEAKER_02: Neanderthals after hundreds of thousands of years of back and forth?
- 1:12:57SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:12:58SPEAKER_00: So I don't have a clear answer.
- 1:12:59SPEAKER_00: Of course, I think this is a huge question.
- 1:13:02SPEAKER_00: Many scientists and many researchers are trying to answer this question.
- 1:13:05SPEAKER_00: There are, of course, multiple hypotheses and probably multiple...
- 1:13:12SPEAKER_00: causes for this replacement.
- 1:13:14SPEAKER_00: What I can say is,
- 1:13:15SPEAKER_00: like,
- 1:13:15there was indeed a period of overlapping between the 100,000 of
- 1:13:20the humans,
- 1:13:21SPEAKER_00: and we all know the outcomes of this period of overlapping.
- 1:13:26It was indeed genetic exchange and so admixture between these
- 1:13:29two groups,
- 1:13:31hominin groups.
- 1:13:33SPEAKER_00: But it's hard to tell the reason why Neanderthal got extinct.
- 1:13:40SPEAKER_00: One explanation,
- 1:13:41and actually it is in line with this decline of Neanderthal
- 1:13:45ancestry through time,
- 1:13:47SPEAKER_00: is the fact that...
- 1:13:49the population size of Neanderthal was shrinking,
- 1:13:55was reducing through time.
- 1:13:58And this,
- 1:13:58of course,
- 1:13:59led them accumulating slightly deleterious mutations.
- 1:14:04SPEAKER_00: When this population had mixed,
- 1:14:06the late Neanderthal population had mixed with an expanding
- 1:14:10population of modern
- 1:14:11SPEAKER_00: humans,
- 1:14:11SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 1:14:13natural selection started to kick in and remove this slightly
- 1:14:19deleterious mutation
- 1:14:20SPEAKER_00: from their genome.
- 1:14:22SPEAKER_00: So this is probably one reason.
- 1:14:25SPEAKER_00: So population size probably was one reason why...
- 1:14:31neanderthal disappeared as soon as mother human arrived okay
- 1:14:37all right so um you
- 1:14:38know we have we have like all of this data on europe now from
- 1:14:41ancient dna for
- 1:14:42various reasons how representative do you think europe is of
- 1:14:47the dynamics we see
- 1:14:48SPEAKER_02: around the world i think
- 1:14:50SPEAKER_00: is not really representative because what is happening in East Asia,
- 1:15:00it's probably a completely different pattern and we still need
- 1:15:04to investigate much
- 1:15:05SPEAKER_00: more.
- 1:15:05SPEAKER_00: So far,
- 1:15:06SPEAKER_00: there is only one upper paleolithic genome from East Asia,
- 1:15:11SPEAKER_00: that is Tian Yuan,
- 1:15:12SPEAKER_00: this famous Chinese specimen.
- 1:15:16SPEAKER_00: But we cannot really...
- 1:15:20yet assess if also Asia or other regions of the world were also
- 1:15:24influenced by this
- 1:15:26SPEAKER_00: massive genetic turnover that we see throughout time in Europe.
- 1:15:31SPEAKER_00: So definitely we need much more data from that side of the world.
- 1:15:36SPEAKER_02: And what do you think about, you know,
- 1:15:40SPEAKER_02: In terms of genetic homogeneity,
- 1:15:41SPEAKER_02: we see it in the Neanderthals,
- 1:15:42SPEAKER_02: and then we see it in a lot of the hunter-gatherer populations as well,
- 1:15:45SPEAKER_02: later on,
- 1:15:46SPEAKER_02: modern human hunter-gatherer populations.
- 1:15:48SPEAKER_02: Do you think the behavioral ecology,
- 1:15:49SPEAKER_02: basically,
- 1:15:50SPEAKER_02: like the distribution and density of humans during the Pleistocene,
- 1:15:55was qualitatively different in a way that would affect the
- 1:15:57parameters like gene
- 1:15:58SPEAKER_02: flow and stuff like that,
- 1:15:59SPEAKER_02: population structure?
- 1:16:03SPEAKER_00: Yes, yes, indeed.
- 1:16:05I think the population size indeed is playing a huge role,
- 1:16:10not only in the population,
- 1:16:15technological advancements but also in the possibility of those
- 1:16:21people to interact
- 1:16:23and to spread I think though we have to imagine this
- 1:16:29hunter-gatherer society in a
- 1:16:31different way than what we usually think about population in
- 1:16:36the past like
- 1:16:37sedentary population in the past from the advent of the
- 1:16:41agriculture onwards
- 1:16:43SPEAKER_00: because this hunter-gatherer society were highly mobile,
- 1:16:48SPEAKER_00: and they were really moving a lot during different time of the years,
- 1:16:53SPEAKER_00: but also different years,
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_00: according to the climate,
- 1:16:55SPEAKER_00: how it was changing.
- 1:16:57SPEAKER_00: So this,
- 1:16:57SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 1:16:58gave the possibility of this population to meet and to exchange
- 1:17:03genes in certain
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_00: periods.
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_00: But, of course, isolation...
- 1:17:13SPEAKER_00: allow them also to form some genetic structure.
- 1:17:18And this is really good for us as archaeogeneticists because it
- 1:17:22allows us to
- 1:17:23distinguish one group from the other and really observe much
- 1:17:29more clearly when two
- 1:17:30SPEAKER_00: groups get into contact.
- 1:17:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:17:35SPEAKER_02: in this paper,
- 1:17:36SPEAKER_02: you guys didn't use the standard methods,
- 1:17:40SPEAKER_02: inference of structure,
- 1:17:41SPEAKER_02: and you said in there,
- 1:17:44SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 1:17:44that it was because the populations were so different from
- 1:17:47modern populations.
- 1:17:49SPEAKER_02: Do you think whole genome sequencing,
- 1:17:51SPEAKER_02: without the ascertainment bias of that snipper capture array,
- 1:17:54SPEAKER_02: will improve that sort of analysis?
- 1:17:59SPEAKER_00: I think...
- 1:18:01SPEAKER_00: There is a big hope.
- 1:18:04SPEAKER_00: And the big hope is,
- 1:18:06SPEAKER_00: I think personally,
- 1:18:07I'm really fascinated by the idea of generating high coverage
- 1:18:10genome of those
- 1:18:11SPEAKER_00: individuals to see which regions and which variants are
- 1:18:18present in the genome of modern-day individuals and potentially
- 1:18:23identify regions
- 1:18:24that are under selection so they are positive or negative for
- 1:18:29modern humans.
- 1:18:30So this is something that,
- 1:18:32of course,
- 1:18:32we need shotgun genome to answer those questions.
- 1:18:36SPEAKER_00: However,
- 1:18:37SPEAKER_00: generally speaking,
- 1:18:38I think the captured data that we have generated for those
- 1:18:42individuals allow us to
- 1:18:44SPEAKER_00: really finally detect
- 1:18:47the admixture pattern between those groups and also to relate
- 1:18:55them through time
- 1:18:57SPEAKER_00: with the following population.
- 1:19:00SPEAKER_00: However,
- 1:19:00SPEAKER_00: when we want to study modern-day Europeans,
- 1:19:05we cannot really compare them directly to people that lived
- 1:19:1230,000 years ago
- 1:19:12SPEAKER_00: because the variation that is present
- 1:19:16SPEAKER_00: genetic variation that is present in modern day Europeans,
- 1:19:19SPEAKER_00: it's limited compared to what was present 35,000 years ago.
- 1:19:25So we need to really analyze those genome slide by slide and
- 1:19:29create the genetic map
- 1:19:31SPEAKER_00: of Europe through time.
- 1:19:33SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that's pretty ambitious.
- 1:19:36SPEAKER_02: So there has been a fair amount of work since you guys' paper came out.
- 1:19:41There's a recent paper out of Spain that talked about the
- 1:19:45different population
- 1:19:47structure or the groups that you guys identified and how they
- 1:19:49persisted in Spain.
- 1:19:51SPEAKER_02: And also there has been some work,
- 1:19:54SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 1:19:54out of Max Planck about maybe Martin Petter about gene flow
- 1:19:59back into Africa from
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_02: Europe.
- 1:20:03What are the biggest things that have happened on Pleistocene
- 1:20:07genetics and our
- 1:20:07understanding of these population structure and relatedness
- 1:20:10since that paper came
- 1:20:11SPEAKER_02: out?
- 1:20:12SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:20:13SPEAKER_00: So,
- 1:20:14SPEAKER_00: indeed,
- 1:20:15SPEAKER_00: there is a paper that was published last week about Iberian population,
- 1:20:20SPEAKER_00: and I'm also part of this study,
- 1:20:24and we could actually show in the study that there was a much
- 1:20:30earlier connection
- 1:20:31SPEAKER_00: between southern...
- 1:20:34SPEAKER_00: Southern Europe, like Italy and the Balkans, with Spain.
- 1:20:39SPEAKER_00: And this connection probably was during the last glacial maximum.
- 1:20:43So I think we should really stop thinking about this climatic
- 1:20:47refugia as a
- 1:20:51where there was not contact among them,
- 1:20:55but a much more dynamic condition.
- 1:20:58SPEAKER_00: So what we figure out that the older genome associated with this Elmiron
- 1:21:06SPEAKER_00: Magdalenian culture,
- 1:21:07SPEAKER_00: so-called Elmiron genome,
- 1:21:09SPEAKER_00: is already admixed between different populations
- 1:21:16SPEAKER_00: So we could identify much earlier contact than what we thought.
- 1:21:22On the other hand,
- 1:21:24on the eastern side of Europe,
- 1:21:25we recently published a paper on Anatolia.
- 1:21:28SPEAKER_00: Actually, it was published two days ago.
- 1:21:30And it's quite interesting because we published the first
- 1:21:34hunter-gatherer genome from Anatolia.
- 1:21:37And what we see is that we could show that there is genetic
- 1:21:41continuity between the
- 1:21:44SPEAKER_00: hunter-gatherer and the Neolithic people.
- 1:21:48SPEAKER_00: It means that the local population acquired agriculture
- 1:21:53SPEAKER_00: and then spread this agriculture a few thousand years after into Europe.
- 1:21:59So I think this situation is actually quite a good example to
- 1:22:04show that not always
- 1:22:05SPEAKER_00: there are population turnovers,
- 1:22:07but sometimes we also show that there is population continuity
- 1:22:12in certain areas of
- 1:22:13SPEAKER_00: the world.
- 1:22:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, that was a fascinating work.
- 1:22:16SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:22:17SPEAKER_02: There's just so much ancient DNA stuff that's coming out.
- 1:22:20SPEAKER_02: What are you excited about for the future of this particular project?
- 1:22:25I mean,
- 1:22:27the sample sizes that you guys have for Europe and the Middle
- 1:22:29East are quite large.
- 1:22:31Obviously,
- 1:22:32there are other areas of the world that are not as well
- 1:22:35sampled.
- 1:22:36SPEAKER_00: Yes, it's true.
- 1:22:37SPEAKER_00: There are,
- 1:22:38SPEAKER_00: however,
- 1:22:39really also some complications work in other regions of the
- 1:22:44world at that time,
- 1:22:45SPEAKER_00: at that horizon in terms of time.
- 1:22:49SPEAKER_00: Complications that are either political,
- 1:22:52SPEAKER_00: where it's not possible to excavate or to actually do...
- 1:23:00SPEAKER_00: research with specimen from those countries.
- 1:23:06SPEAKER_00: Other complication is preservation.
- 1:23:08Of course,
- 1:23:09Europe with this temperate climate is ideal for preservation of
- 1:23:13ancient DNA.
- 1:23:14SPEAKER_00: Whereas if you go to more lower latitude, DNA preservation is much more
- 1:23:23SPEAKER_00: I am personally still really interested in what's happening in Europe,
- 1:23:27SPEAKER_00: because despite we see these big numbers that you're describing now,
- 1:23:32SPEAKER_00: it's also 35 or 40,000 years of human history.
- 1:23:35SPEAKER_00: So it's the largest period of modern humans outside of Africa.
- 1:23:43And so I think these are only the first picture of the
- 1:23:48complexity that is actually
- 1:23:52SPEAKER_00: emerging between those different groups.
- 1:23:55SPEAKER_00: So I am really hoping to fill some gaps in terms of time and space.
- 1:24:02SPEAKER_00: And as I told you,
- 1:24:04SPEAKER_00: to reconstruct this genetic map that is indeed ambitious,
- 1:24:07SPEAKER_00: but there are new specimens coming along.
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_02: So, you know, there has been some work on, like, traits, phenotypes.
- 1:24:16SPEAKER_02: What do you think are the possibilities of inferring,
- 1:24:19SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:24:20genetic variants that are causing an outcome today and how that
- 1:24:25relates to genetic
- 1:24:25SPEAKER_02: variants that cause an outcome in the past?
- 1:24:27SPEAKER_02: I know some people are pretty skeptical of it, other people's less so.
- 1:24:30SPEAKER_02: Where do you stand?
- 1:24:33SPEAKER_00: Yes, so far...
- 1:24:36SPEAKER_00: only the genetic SNPs that have been,
- 1:24:38SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:24:38SPEAKER_00: the phenotypic SNPs that have been analyzed are,
- 1:24:43SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:24:43SPEAKER_00: like eye color,
- 1:24:44SPEAKER_00: skin color,
- 1:24:46SPEAKER_00: um,
- 1:24:46SPEAKER_00: lactose persistence is really like a limit,
- 1:24:49SPEAKER_00: limited set of SNPs.
- 1:24:52SPEAKER_00: Um, and, uh, I think, uh, finding, let's say correlation between, uh, uh,
- 1:25:02SPEAKER_00: those snips and, um, and modern day people is really, is really hard.
- 1:25:07SPEAKER_00: The, the, the, the problem, the point is, I'll give you an example.
- 1:25:10SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 1:25:11SPEAKER_00: we have,
- 1:25:11SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:25:12SPEAKER_00: certain snips that are associated with the,
- 1:25:14SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:25:15SPEAKER_00: light skin color in modern day,
- 1:25:17SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:25:18SPEAKER_00: Europeans.
- 1:25:19And what we find out is that population like the Neanderthals
- 1:25:24and as well as,
- 1:25:24SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:25:25SPEAKER_00: early modern humans.
- 1:25:27SPEAKER_00: So these hunt together population from Europe, uh, they, uh,
- 1:25:32SPEAKER_00: have the ancestral veil.
- 1:25:33SPEAKER_00: So according to our knowledge, these people were, uh, had a dark skin.
- 1:25:41SPEAKER_00: However,
- 1:25:42we don't know if there are other variants that in the past were
- 1:25:46responsible for a
- 1:25:48SPEAKER_00: lighter skin,
- 1:25:49SPEAKER_00: a color of the skin,
- 1:25:50SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:25:51SPEAKER_00: in order to survive at those latitudes.
- 1:25:54SPEAKER_00: So, um, it's, we can of course tested variants that are known,
- 1:25:58SPEAKER_00: in modern day individuals,
- 1:26:01but discover new variants and know how these are affecting the
- 1:26:06phenotypes of modern
- 1:26:07SPEAKER_00: day individuals is,
- 1:26:09SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 1:26:10SPEAKER_00: really complicated.
- 1:26:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, for sure.
- 1:26:12So,
- 1:26:13you know,
- 1:26:13I want to close out just like talking about the big picture.
- 1:26:16SPEAKER_02: At least 10,
- 1:26:17SPEAKER_02: 15 years ago,
- 1:26:18SPEAKER_02: we were talking about out of Africa 50,000,
- 1:26:21SPEAKER_02: 60,000 years ago,
- 1:26:22SPEAKER_02: et cetera,
- 1:26:23SPEAKER_02: et cetera.
- 1:26:23Now we have a lot of evidence that there's a lot of deep
- 1:26:26structure in Africa and
- 1:26:28that modern humans may have flourished for hundreds of
- 1:26:31thousands of years within
- 1:26:32SPEAKER_02: Africa before they left Africa.
- 1:26:34I'm kind of confused at this point at where we're going and
- 1:26:40what we're going to discover.
- 1:26:41SPEAKER_02: What are your thoughts on that?
- 1:26:44Yes,
- 1:26:45Africa is,
- 1:26:48of course,
- 1:26:50placed with the highest genetic diversity in the entire world.
- 1:26:53So I think that ancient DNA studies from Africa would be
- 1:27:00extremely revealing to
- 1:27:01SPEAKER_00: understand this great population structure that existed in
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_00: They exist today, but even higher than existed in the past.
- 1:27:13So I see that studies from Africa are really going to be a game
- 1:27:21changer in our
- 1:27:22SPEAKER_00: understanding of the evolution of our own species.
- 1:27:26The biggest limitation is that this is a preservation of DNA
- 1:27:31from those regions.
- 1:27:32SPEAKER_00: So, so far,
- 1:27:33the oldest genome published is from 15,000 years ago from a
- 1:27:37cave in,
- 1:27:38in Morocco.
- 1:27:39SPEAKER_00: Uh,
- 1:27:40SPEAKER_00: but it's going to be extremely hard to,
- 1:27:42SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:27:43SPEAKER_00: obtain,
- 1:27:43SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:27:44SPEAKER_00: as old material as from Europe,
- 1:27:47SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:27:48SPEAKER_00: from,
- 1:27:48SPEAKER_00: from,
- 1:27:48SPEAKER_00: from,
- 1:27:49SPEAKER_00: from Africa.
- 1:27:50SPEAKER_00: But in terms of the big picture, I, I agree with you.
- 1:27:53SPEAKER_00: Uh,
- 1:27:54SPEAKER_00: we should indeed investigate much more,
- 1:27:57SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:27:57SPEAKER_00: different populations and different time period of,
- 1:28:01SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:28:01SPEAKER_00: this,
- 1:28:01SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:28:02SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:28:03SPEAKER_00: African diversity.
- 1:28:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:28:05SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:28:05SPEAKER_02: so I guess like the two things that you're saying is,
- 1:28:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:28:07SPEAKER_02: there's political issues,
- 1:28:09SPEAKER_02: but also just like the preservation,
- 1:28:11like there's a reason we have all these Siberian remains and
- 1:28:14remains from Europe
- 1:28:15SPEAKER_02: and we don't have them from Africa.
- 1:28:16SPEAKER_02: It's just like DNA degrades, right?
- 1:28:18SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 1:28:19SPEAKER_00: So it degrades over time, but,
- 1:28:23SPEAKER_00: generally speaking,
- 1:28:24SPEAKER_00: but also climatic condition,
- 1:28:27SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 1:28:28SPEAKER_00: humidity or temperature,
- 1:28:32SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 1:28:32SPEAKER_00: plays play a major role in the,
- 1:28:34SPEAKER_00: in the preservation of those,
- 1:28:36SPEAKER_00: of those ancient genomes.
- 1:28:37SPEAKER_00: So I think not only we need to increase the sample size, um,
- 1:28:44SPEAKER_00: And of course,
- 1:28:45SPEAKER_00: also to increase the bioinformatic approaches,
- 1:28:49SPEAKER_00: how we can study best those genomes.
- 1:28:52SPEAKER_00: But at the same time,
- 1:28:54we also need to develop new methods to efficiently extract DNA
- 1:29:00from this limited,
- 1:29:02SPEAKER_00: extremely valuable human material.
- 1:29:06SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 1:29:07SPEAKER_02: So I guess the last thing I want to talk about is just surprises.
- 1:29:11SPEAKER_02: So I think the Goyet sample shared some drift with Tianyun,
- 1:29:15SPEAKER_02: the East Asian one that you're talking about.
- 1:29:17Do you think that that's an artifact or do you think that
- 1:29:20there's basically gene
- 1:29:22flow and connectedness in northern Eurasia that we just don't
- 1:29:26know and understand
- 1:29:27SPEAKER_02: very well right now?
- 1:29:29SPEAKER_00: We have investigated a lot, the first possibility.
- 1:29:36That is the possibility that there was some sort of artifacts
- 1:29:39so that this
- 1:29:40SPEAKER_00: attraction between the oldest Aurignacian genome,
- 1:29:44SPEAKER_00: so this Goyer Q116,
- 1:29:46SPEAKER_00: and this oldest East Asian genome,
- 1:29:49SPEAKER_00: that is Tianyuan,
- 1:29:51SPEAKER_00: was due to some sort of shared damage or processing.
- 1:29:59SPEAKER_00: We could, all the tests that we had done, we could exclude this
- 1:30:05uh artifacts and so we really think that there is something
- 1:30:08real there we really
- 1:30:09think that there was a contact uh between people with west
- 1:30:13eurasian ancestry and
- 1:30:14the east eurasian ancestry however we have so little data still
- 1:30:19from this early
- 1:30:21time period between uh before 40 000 we have only two
- 1:30:25individuals one from siberia
- 1:30:27SPEAKER_00: and one from uh from from romania that is uh uh
- 1:30:31SPEAKER_00: highly mixed with Neanderthals.
- 1:30:33So we really need to have more genome from this time period to
- 1:30:36understand the
- 1:30:37SPEAKER_00: spread of those two ancestries.
- 1:30:39SPEAKER_00: And maybe we will figure out why there is this genetic link.
- 1:30:46SPEAKER_02: Well, I mean, could it be that...
- 1:30:50SPEAKER_02: as these groups were in the near East,
- 1:30:51SPEAKER_02: in the middle East,
- 1:30:52SPEAKER_02: as they were moving,
- 1:30:53SPEAKER_02: there was like structure there that was preserved,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: that,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: that sort of thing,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: instead of like going from East Asia to Europe or vice versa.
- 1:31:02SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 1:31:02SPEAKER_00: I understand what you are,
- 1:31:03SPEAKER_00: what you're talking about,
- 1:31:04SPEAKER_00: like some sort of incomplete lineage sorting,
- 1:31:08SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:31:08SPEAKER_00: between those groups,
- 1:31:09SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_00: splitting up in,
- 1:31:11SPEAKER_00: in the near East.
- 1:31:12SPEAKER_00: I think in this case, um,
- 1:31:16SPEAKER_00: this population are already quite defined.
- 1:31:21SPEAKER_00: So this East Asian branch and the West Eurasian branch.
- 1:31:27So I see this affinity more as really a movement of people or
- 1:31:36at least the
- 1:31:37SPEAKER_00: existence of people with an East Asian ancestry closer to
- 1:31:46SPEAKER_00: to Europe than China.
- 1:31:48So we are really highly limited from the location where those
- 1:31:54genomes were found.
- 1:31:55SPEAKER_00: But of course,
- 1:31:56those ancestries might have been once not only limited to
- 1:32:02eastern Eurasia,
- 1:32:05SPEAKER_00: but could have been much more westward.
- 1:32:08SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_02: I see.
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 1:32:10SPEAKER_02: So I guess the last question is,
- 1:32:11what surprised you the most from this paper as you guys were
- 1:32:14looking at the
- 1:32:15SPEAKER_02: results?
- 1:32:17um hard hardest question and i think uh what surprised most us
- 1:32:25is this genetic
- 1:32:26turnover that we see around 14 000 bp because i actually
- 1:32:31already um described that
- 1:32:33genetic turnover in a previous paper the same year based on
- 1:32:36mitochondrial dna and
- 1:32:37we were not sure from where this source uh new genetic source
- 1:32:41come from and uh
- 1:32:43SPEAKER_00: It was a big debate because,
- 1:32:45SPEAKER_00: as I told you before,
- 1:32:46SPEAKER_00: this is not really associated with any major archaeological change.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_00: So some people were skeptical of this result.
- 1:32:56SPEAKER_00: But then also with the nuclear genome,
- 1:32:58we could show this higher affinity of population after 14,000
- 1:33:03with people from the
- 1:33:06SPEAKER_00: Near East,
- 1:33:08SPEAKER_00: This was indeed a major surprise and also led many,
- 1:33:13SPEAKER_00: many researchers,
- 1:33:14SPEAKER_00: both in the field of archaeology and genetics,
- 1:33:18to really go back and investigate their material to see if
- 1:33:26there is any sign of a
- 1:33:29SPEAKER_00: shift also in the material culture.
- 1:33:32SPEAKER_02: All right.
- 1:33:33SPEAKER_02: You know, it's been a great conversation, definitely.
- 1:33:36I think the listeners have been keeping track of ancient DNA
- 1:33:38for the last couple of
- 1:33:39SPEAKER_02: years,
- 1:33:39SPEAKER_02: and it's a very exciting field,
- 1:33:42SPEAKER_02: and I'm sure we're going to be hearing from you,
- 1:33:44SPEAKER_02: Cosimo.
- 1:33:44SPEAKER_02: It was great talking to you.
- 1:33:45SPEAKER_00: Also for me.
- 1:33:46SPEAKER_00: It's a great pleasure.
- 1:33:49This podcast is brought to you by the Albany Public Library
- 1:33:52Main Branch and the
- 1:33:53SPEAKER_01: generosity of listeners like you.
- 1:33:59SPEAKER_01: What is a podcast?
- 1:34:06SPEAKER_01: Thank God Daddy, these people talk as much as you do.
- 1:34:15SPEAKER_01: Razeeb Khan's unsupervised learning.