Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️118 |Public Inquiry Last Day |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Curranalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series. That will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Well, that's it. Today, the public inquiry into Dalradian's proposed gold mine in The Sperrins has finally come to an end, and what a day it was! If you'd arrived outside the art centre in Oma yesterday, you might have wondered what on earth was going on. There were people singing, people
- 1:15protesting, some very imaginative costumes, and a wonderful gathering of familiar faces who had come to support us and mark the occasion, or in Gaelic, viri raw Augustulia boole. Inside the hearing room, however, the atmosphere was somewhat different. We were back to the drudgery of discussing
- 1:36carbon emissions, statutory carbon budgets, diesel consumption, overseas gold processing, and the important question of what happens if a mining company fails to deliver on its environmental promises. To say it was a bit of a contrast would be putting it lightly. Outside, a community
- 1:56was celebrating its determination to defend its landscape and its rights to decide what sort of future it wanted. Inside, we were witnessing the extraordinary contradiction at the heart of this inquiry: a system that invites people to have their say, listen to their objections,
- 2:14examine their evidence, and can still deliver a decision that profoundly changes their lives against their wishes. We began the morning with Northern Ireland's carbon budgets and the question of how emissions from the proposed mine should be assessed. Now, if you've been following these podcasts over
- 2:32the past few days, you'll know that we've spent a large amount of time examining Dalradian's carbon calculations. The updated assessment puts the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions associated with the project at approximately 305,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent. That's the broader picture
- 2:54covering emissions associated with the development over its lifetime. However, not all of those emissions would occur in Northern Ireland. Some would arise from activities elsewhere, including the processing of gold concentrate overseas. Under Northern Ireland's statutory carbon budgets, the emissions
- 3:15counted against our territorial targets are those attributed to activities within Northern Ireland, the emissions associated with processing the gold somewhere else are treated differently. Now, there's a perfectly legitimate reason for territorial carbon counting. Government needs a consistent
- 3:35way of measuring the emissions for which they are responsible, but there's also an obvious difficulty: the atmosphere doesn't recognise national boundaries. A tonne of carbon dioxide emitted overseas has exactly the same effect on climate as a tonne emitted in County Tyrone. And if a mining
- 3:57project depends on activities taking place elsewhere, surely those emissions remain relevant when we're trying to understand its overall environmental impact. During the inquiry, we have heard about the uncertainties surrounding the eventual processing of the gold concentrate. Questions still
- 4:18hang over: where will it go? How will it be processed? What emissions will those processes generate? And if those arrangements change after planning permission has been granted, what happens to the calculations presented to the commissioners? The discussion returned to the distinction
- 4:38between the statutory carbon budget figures and the wider assessment of the project's greenhouse gas emissions. Dalradian continued to argue that the contribution would be negligible and not significant. One of the figures referred to was 0.017. Of the relevant Northern Ireland carbon budget
- 5:02period, which mathematically is a very small percentage. But I am increasingly wary of percentages presented without their wider context, because the question isn't just about how small a project's emissions look when compared with an entire national carbon budget, it is also whether those emissions
- 5:27have been properly calculated, whether reasonable opportunities to reduce them have been taken, and whether reductions being claimed will actually happen. There's another important clarification from the Department for Infrastructure.
- 5:45The Planning Appeals Commission is examining the evidence and will report its findings and recommendations, but it is the department that must ultimately carry out the relevant statutory assessment and make the planning decision. So the commissioners are not themselves deciding whether the mine should go
- 6:05ahead. Their task is to examine the evidence, identify the issues, and provide recommendations to inform the department's decision. So once this inquiry is over, responsibility passes back to the department. Even on this final morning, the commissioners were continuing to examine the
- 6:28assumptions behind the carbon calculations. There were questions about diesel consumption, the operation of plant and machinery, heavy goods vehicle movements, and staff travel. And here's an example of the level of detail involved. Take staff commuting. The calculations included
- 6:49assumptions about the number of people travelling together in cars. During construction, the figure was four people per car. During operation, it was two. Clearly, Dalradian is expecting to recruit not just miners but enthusiastic members of a car-sharing cooperative. But assumptions about travel
- 7:11arrangements feed into calculations, and those calculations feed into the overall emissions assessment. If the assumptions turn out to be optimistic; the emissions could be higher. The commissioners were also examining whether the transport figures used in different parts of the
- 7:31application were consistent, and this has been a recurring difficulty throughout the climate examination. There are figures in the carbon assessment, figures in the transport assessment, figures for diesel consumption and operating hours, and assumptions about how different activities
- 7:54will be carried out. All of them have to fit together because you cannot properly assess the environmental impact of a development by looking at each calculation in isolation. By Wednesday morning, I had developed considerable sympathy for anyone attempting to reconcile these documents,
- 8:18although I was beginning to suspect that a working knowledge of advanced mathematics and a touch of clairvoyance might also be useful, and that brings me to what I think was the most important discussion of the entire final day: giving the carbon conditions some teeth. After lunch, attention turned to
- 8:43the proposed planning conditions. Throughout the climate examination, Dalhousie has relied upon a range of measures intended to reduce, manage, or compensate for the project's greenhouse gas emissions. These included proposed mitigation measures, carbon management arrangements,
- 9:07and carbon neutrality certification. The company has presented these commitments as part of its case that the project's climate effects would not be significant. But what happens if the commitments aren't delivered? Suppose the actual emissions are higher than predicted. Suppose the
- 9:31anticipated reductions are not achieved. Suppose the carbon neutrality certification cannot be obtained. Well, what then? And this was precisely the territory the commissioners began exploring. Rather than simply accepting the proposed carbon management condition as it stood, the department
- 9:56suggested strengthening it. The. Discussion included requirements for approval of carbon management arrangements, independent verification, monitoring, corrective measures, and consequences if the necessary commitments were not met. And among the possibilities being discussed was the
- 10:19suspension or cessation of operation, if the required certification or measures could not be achieved. Now that certainly caught my attention, because for much of this inquiry we have heard about what Dalradian intends to do, we have heard about future management plans, proposed monitoring,
- 10:40anticipated reductions, and commitments that would be secured through conditions. There is quite a difference between a company promising to do something, and a planning condition that provides a clear, enforceable consequence if it doesn't. And I was pleased to see this particular line of
- 10:59thinking being examined. And then. then, in a discussion about whether the department's proposed conditions had sufficient teeth, we found ourselves contemplating the state of its dentures, not quite where I had expected the final afternoon to take us. There was talk of teeth, dentures, and
- 11:19incisors as the participants considered whether the proposed conditions had sufficient bite, after weeks of geology, hydrology, ecology, and carbon cancellations, it seemed only fitting we should finish with a little dentistry. But there we were. The question is: Would these conditions actually
- 11:40protect the environment, or would they simply require the company to produce more paperwork explaining why things hadn't gone according to plan? Because if a condition requires monitoring but doesn't provide an effective remedy when the monitoring reveals a problem, what exactly has been achieved?
- 12:00And if a company is allowed to continue operating while it works out how to meet a commitment it was supposed to have satisfied already, the consequences could be very different from those described in the environmental assessment. That is why the details of these conditions matter so much. Then
- 12:23mr. Fagan raised another important issue. Before imposing a planning condition requiring carbon neutrality certification, shouldn't the decision maker first establish that there is a realistic prospect of the company achieving it. This was a significant point because a planning condition is not a
- 12:47magic wand. You cannot necessarily make an environmental problem disappear by writing a condition requiring somebody to solve it at some point in the future. There has to be a reasonable basis for believing that the condition can actually be complied with, and in this case, the question is
- 13:08especially important because carbon neutrality was central to the company's proposed approach to manage its climate impact. The discussion then turned to carbon offsets. For listeners who aren't familiar with the term, offsets are arrangements intended to compensate for emissions, often by funding
- 13:30projects that reduce or remove greenhouse gases elsewhere. They can have a role in climate strategies, but they are not the same thing as preventing emissions in the first place, and they raise their own questions about verification, permanence, and whether the claim benefits are genuine. One
- 13:50issue being examined was whether offsets should be secured in advance, rather than left to be obtained later. If Dalhousie is counting on carbon offsets to achieve neutrality. Wouldn't it be sensible to establish that those offsets actually exist, are available, and meet the necessary standards? I was also
- 14:15concerned about something slightly different. What happens if the company fails to achieve the actual emissions reductions on which its assessments depend. Could it simply purchase additional offsets and claim that the overall position remains acceptable? Because that would be a very different
- 14:36proposition. Imagine that a company's environmental assessment predicts a particular level of emissions on the basis that certain equipment, fuels, or operating practices will be used. Those assumptions are then relied upon when assessing the likely environmental effects of the project. But once the
- 14:56development is operating, some of those measures are not. Delivered, the actual emissions are higher. If the response is simply to buy more offsets, the company may be able to maintain some form of carbon neutrality claim, but the underlying project would no longer be operating in the way that was
- 15:19assessed. There is a difference between reducing the emissions generated by inactivity and compensating for them somewhere else. What matters is that the proposed conditions distinguished between achieving carbon neutrality through offsets and delivering the actual emission reductions upon
- 15:40which the project's environmental assessment was based. Nor should the purchase of offsets provide an easy escape route from commitments that were presented as part of the justification for granting permission. The applicant responded to the issues raised during the condition discussion,
- 16:00and there was considerable debate about how the various requirements might operate. But what I took from the exchange was that the enforceability of these arrangements remain a matter requiring very careful attention. Trouble is, who's going to check? Monitoring, verification, certification, and
- 16:21enforcement all sound reassuring, but they only work if somebody is prepared to carry them out properly. Who will examine the monitoring reports? Who will check whether the company's calculations reflect what is actually happening on the ground? Who will decide whether a failure is serious
- 16:40enough to require corrective action, and if the ultimate sanction is suspension or closure, who will be prepared to enforce it? These are questions that go right to the heart of public confidence in environmental regulation. For communities living beside major industrial developments, the
- 17:05existence of a planning condition is only as reassuring as the willingness and the ability of the authorities to enforce it. And I think that is one of the wider lessons emerging from this inquiry. We have an extraordinary amount of environmental legislation, policy guidance, technical
- 17:27standards, and assessment procedures, but none of these things by themselves guarantee a good environmental outcome. They depend on the quality of the evidence, the decisions made by public authorities, and the systems put in place to ensure that commitments are honoured.
- 17:44The department will have to consider those matters very carefully when it receives the commissioner's report, because the responsibility for determining the application will ultimately rest with government. And that responsibility now returns to the department for infrastructure. There is
- 18:02something. deeply unsettling about that, given the questions raised throughout the inquiry about the preparedness, scrutiny, and judgement of various government departments. For a community whose confidence in the planning system has been steadily eroded, the prospect of entrusting the future of The
- 18:22Sperrins to that same system is hardly reassuring. As the afternoon drew towards its conclusion, the discussion moved away from carbon calculations and into the procedures governing the commissioner's report. mr. Fagan raised the question of what form the recommendations should take.
- 18:46Should the commissioners recommend that planning permission be granted or refused, or should they identify the issues requiring consideration and leave the ultimate conclusion to the department? Was an important final procedural point because the nature of the commission's
- 19:01recommendations will influence how the next stage of the process unfolds. There was also a clarification concerning the proposed replacement road and the abandonment of an existing road. The department confirmed that it wanted recommendations on those matters too, and so even in the closing minutes
- 19:23there were still details to be clarified. I suppose that was entirely fitting. After everything we have heard over the course of this inquiry, it would have been rather surprising if we'd reached the end without one last procedural complication. But eventually the proceedings came to a close. The
- 19:45commissioners now have the considerable task of examining the evidence, weighing the arguments, and preparing the report. And the Department for Infrastructure will then have to make its decision. But the public examination. Of the proposal has now ended, and that was a very significant moment. I
- 20:07want to finish the podcast here by taking you back outside the Strool Arts Centre because, because while all of this was happening inside, something rather wonderful was taking place outside. People had travelled to Omer to mark the final day. Some had been involved in the campaign for
- 20:22years, some had attended countless meetings, organised events, written submissions, raised money, studied documents, and spent more hours than they would probably care to remember trying to understand the extraordinary complexity of this proposed development. Others had come to show their support and
- 20:41stand alongside the people who have carried so much of this work. There was singing and laughter and protest and a good deal of good humour. Looking around, I was reminded of something that can easily get lost when you spend your days immersed in environmental assessment and planning
- 20:57legislation. This campaign has never simply been about stopping a mine; it has been about people's relationship with a place. The Sperrins are so much more than an area on a planning map or a collection of environmental designations. They are a living landscape, a place of rivers and peatlands,
- 21:20wildlife, farms, homes, and communities cannot be reduced to the minerals beneath it, and the people who have fought to protect it have done something quite remarkable. They have challenged a major industrial proposal and insisted that its consequences be examined in public. They have refused to
- 21:43accept that technical complexity should exclude ordinary people from decisions affecting their lives, and they have demonstrated time and again that local knowledge, persistence, and a willingness to ask difficult questions have a very important place in environmental decision making. I have watched
- 22:02people who never imagined themselves becoming involved in planning law or environmental science develop an extraordinary understanding of subjects ranging from groundwater chemistry and waste management to air pollution, biodiversity, and carbon accounting, and I've seen the friendships that have
- 22:20grown out of that shared determination, and that matters too, because campaigns like this demand an enormous amount from people. They take time, energy, and emotional resilience. They intrude into family life, consume evenings and weekends, and leave people exhausted by the sheer scale of the work
- 22:40involved. And yet, people keep turning up, not because they enjoy reading environmental impact statements, although I suspect a few of us may now be beyond help in that department, but because they care about the place they call home, and because they believe that its future deserves more than a
- 22:58cursory examination, and I think that is something worth celebrating. So what happens now?
- 23:06Throughout it all, the commissioners have had the difficult responsibility of working through the evidence and establishing what can reasonably be relied upon. Their report will now be awaited with enormous interest. There will be plenty of time to reflect on what this inquiry has revealed
- 23:24about environmental regulation, planning decisions, and the responsibilities of government. For today, I want to acknowledge the people, the people who have stood outside in the rain, sat through long days of evidence, travelled to OMA, ask questions, supported one another, and refused to give up. The people
- 23:45who have made sure that the future of this extraordinary landscape has been examined in detail and that the concerns of those who live here have been heard. We don't know what the final decision will be, and I certainly wouldn't pretend that the end of the inquiry means the end of the struggle to protect
- 24:00The Sperrins, but something important has been achieved. A community has stood together, challenged powerful interests, and demanded that decisions with potentially profound consequences for its future be properly scrutinised. And when I look around at everyone gathered in Oma on this final day, I felt
- 24:18an enormous sense of gratitude and pride. That is the thing I most want to remember about the last day: the people, their humour, their determination, their friendship, and their extraordinary love of place. The hearing may be over, but The Sperrins are still here, and so are the people who care about
- 24:38them. And whatever happens next, that is something worth holding on to. Thank you for listening, for following these proceedings, and for sharing this journey with us, and to everyone who has played a part in bringing us to this point. Thank you. We'll speak again when there's more to tell. You've been listening to
- 24:59the Save Our Sperrins podcast. Podcast Voices from the Front Line. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes.
- 25:17Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for
- 25:37listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.