Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Breakfast at Tiffany's (1961): The Limits of Escapism
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:32We're sitting here in my attic room. The walls
- 0:35are bare, painted antique white. Most of this
- 0:39space is used for storage, boxes of old papers
- 0:42we should have sorted through years ago and moved
- 0:45with instead. But this nook, it belongs to me.
- 0:50I'm not much of a decorator, but I have a few
- 0:52pieces of art on the walls. Behind me are a couple
- 0:56of prints. One is an illustration of the Fellowship
- 1:00of the Ring arriving in Lothlorien, all in glowing
- 1:03blues and silvers. The other is a piece done
- 1:07by a friend of mine. It's a watercolor in the
- 1:10style of a Victorian fairy painting. A female
- 1:14figure, the embodiment of night, crowned with
- 1:17stars, holding the moon, gliding over a brightly
- 1:22lit A -frame house. If you turn around a little,
- 1:27you can see the painting above you. At first
- 1:30glance, it looks like a sunset behind a mountain.
- 1:35But if you look closer, you'll realize it's actually
- 1:38a picture of a wildfire all along a ridge, little
- 1:42blazes reflecting in the street below. It's based
- 1:46on a picture a friend of mine took from her street
- 1:49of the mountains near where I grew up. I did
- 1:52it in high school, so the quality isn't awesome,
- 1:55but I'm pretty proud of it. The things we put
- 2:00on our walls do say something about us. About
- 2:03what we love, or who we are, or who we want to
- 2:07be. Even mass -produced canvas prints bought
- 2:10at Target say something. Hotel art, too. It can
- 2:14be as simple as, this space needs to be filled
- 2:18with some sort of color and pattern so you forget
- 2:20it's a tiny box. Or it could just be, isn't that
- 2:24pretty to look at? Today we're talking about
- 2:29an absolutely iconic movie poster movie, 1961's
- 2:35Breakfast at Tiffany's, directed by Blake Edwards.
- 2:39You may not have seen this movie, which is fine,
- 2:42but I guarantee you've encountered it, either
- 2:46because you've heard the eponymous song by Deep
- 2:49Blue Something while shopping at the hardware
- 2:51store, which actually has very little to do with
- 2:54the movie, or because you've seen its most iconic
- 2:57image. Audrey Hepburn as Holly Golightly in a
- 3:02slinky, black, sleeveless, cocktail -length dress
- 3:06with exaggerated hips and a neckline made out
- 3:10of costume jewelry, big, chunky rhinestones draped
- 3:14across her collarbones. Her hair is swept into
- 3:18a curving updo embedded with a tiny tiara. She's
- 3:22accompanied by different accessories, depending
- 3:24on the image, long black gloves, large round
- 3:29black sunglasses, an absurdly long cigarette
- 3:33holder, and an orange tabby cat perched on her
- 3:37shoulders. You may have seen a picture of Hepburn
- 3:40herself staring down the camera, or perhaps her
- 3:44looking to the side, cigarette holder dangling
- 3:47out of her mouth at a diagonal. Or illustrated,
- 3:51her arm raised above her head in a performative
- 3:54gesture. Or maybe you've seen some other drawing
- 3:58mass -produced on a tote bag or a t -shirt. I
- 4:02don't know what girls' college dorm rooms are
- 4:05like today, but this character was everywhere
- 4:08when I was in college, around 15 years ago. It
- 4:12captured the spirit of the current aesthetic
- 4:14trends. Glam! peplum costume jewelry a little
- 4:20bump in your hair large bug -eyed sunglasses
- 4:23and it was this image of sophistication of what
- 4:27life could be if you knew a little more of the
- 4:31context of the image it meant free -spiritedness
- 4:36Maybe you knew the song Moon River from the film,
- 4:39about chasing rainbows with a fellow wild thing,
- 4:43accompanied by Audrey on a tiny guitar as a proto
- 4:47-ukulele girl. You could almost picture Zooey
- 4:51Deschanel singing it, or Ingrid Michaelson. I
- 4:55would not be surprised to find out that one of
- 4:57them has covered it. At first glance, Holly Golightly
- 5:02matches the spirit of the young people gentrifying
- 5:04Brooklyn, pursuing their dreams in New York City,
- 5:08wide -eyed and seeking authenticity. So I don't
- 5:14blame people for putting that picture on their
- 5:17walls. We're wanting whimsical sophistication
- 5:21and wispy glamour. I do wonder how many of them
- 5:27had actually seen the movie. Now, I want to be
- 5:33upfront. I actually don't like this movie very
- 5:37much. It's okay. It's fine. I don't dislike it.
- 5:43It's just not my kind of thing. If I were to
- 5:47rank it on my personal taste, I'd only give it
- 5:51two stars. But... I do think this is a movie
- 5:56worth talking about, and I thought it would be
- 5:59good for you to hear me talk about something
- 6:01I don't like, but still think has a good deal
- 6:04of value. With regards to depth, I think this
- 6:08movie has clear and deep themes, interesting
- 6:12ideas it is exploring. And in terms of quality,
- 6:16it's solidly made, with three distinct flaws.
- 6:22I'll mention the first here. It's important to
- 6:25talk about before you get into any of the real
- 6:28meat of the story. This film contains one of
- 6:32the most infamous examples of yellowface in film
- 6:36history. Yellowface is when an actor of European
- 6:40descent plays a character of East Asian descent.
- 6:44This usually requires not just yellowish makeup,
- 6:48but face taping, and prosthetics, a gross distortion
- 6:53of features. In this movie, Holly's landlord,
- 6:58Mr. Yunioshi, is played by Mickey Rooney, squinting
- 7:03in a terrible black wig and gross false teeth,
- 7:08looking like the disgusting propaganda posters
- 7:11produced during World War II, always bumbling
- 7:15around and shouting, either aggressive or lecherous.
- 7:20It is horrible. It is meant to be comic relief,
- 7:25which is somehow worse. And this isn't just modern
- 7:31sensibilities bumping into old norms. When the
- 7:34film was released in 1961, the reviews in both
- 7:38The Hollywood Reporter and Variety found the
- 7:42character unnecessary and offensive. Producer
- 7:46Richard Shepard later claimed he had wanted an
- 7:50Asian actor for the role, and screenwriter George
- 7:53Axelrod tried to get the scenes with Holly and
- 7:56Yunioshi reshot so they could be easily edited
- 8:00out. But the director and Rooney were good friends
- 8:04and former roommates, so the scenes stayed. Which
- 8:09is one reason the movie is harder to access than
- 8:13its images. now for those of you who haven't
- 8:18watched the film or don't have any desire to
- 8:21especially because of this first flaw i'll provide
- 8:25a rundown of the movie breakfast at tiffany's
- 8:29is told from the perspective of paul varjak a
- 8:33young writer who has just moved into a new apartment
- 8:36in New York City as he gets to know his airy
- 8:39-fairy, free -spirited, utterly fascinating and
- 8:43clearly disassociating from some kind of trauma,
- 8:46neighbor, Holly Golightly. She makes a living
- 8:50as a sort of freelance escort. She wouldn't call
- 8:55herself a prostitute, but she's definitely in
- 8:58the spectrum of sex work. She also earns $100
- 9:01a week visiting a gangster in prison and relaying
- 9:05coded messages to his lawyer. She either pretends
- 9:08or is in denial about the messages, calling them
- 9:12mere weather reports. She's attempting to save
- 9:15up money so that she can support her brother
- 9:18Fred, who is currently serving in the military
- 9:21and who, it's implied, is unable to fully take
- 9:26care of himself. Holly takes a shine to Paul
- 9:29because he looks like Fred and because he's financially
- 9:33existing in a similar space as she. He's working
- 9:37on a novel under the sponsorship of an older
- 9:40woman. Basically, he's a sugar baby with a sugar
- 9:44mama. Over the course of several vignettes, we
- 9:48learn Holly's backstory. She's actually from
- 9:52Texas, where she was known as Lula Mae Barnes.
- 9:56She and Fred ran away from a bad foster home
- 9:59and were found stealing food from the farm of
- 10:02a vet named Doc Golightly. He married her when
- 10:06she was 14. According to Holly, the marriage
- 10:10was later annulled. Eventually, she ran away
- 10:14to California, where she tried to become a movie
- 10:17star. Her agent gave her French lessons, which
- 10:20got rid of her accent, and then... Just before
- 10:24her first screen test, she ran off for New York.
- 10:29Paul and Holly grow closer. He gives up the novel
- 10:33and is able to sell a short story. They spend
- 10:36a delightfully silly day together, getting a
- 10:39Cracker Jack ring engraved at Tiffany's, Holly's
- 10:41favorite place. And at the end of the day, they
- 10:45sleep together. Paul, convinced he's in love
- 10:48with Holly, breaks things off with his sugar
- 10:51mama. but is surprised to discover that Holly
- 10:54viewed their day as purely transactional. She's
- 10:57preparing to pursue a relationship with a wealthy
- 11:00Brazilian. Before Paul moves out, Holly receives
- 11:04news that her brother Fred has been killed in
- 11:07a Jeep accident. She's devastated. Later, she
- 11:13invites Paul back for a visit the day before
- 11:16she leaves for Brazil. She believes... or is
- 11:19in denial, that the Brazilian will marry her
- 11:22when they get there. But after she's arrested
- 11:26for her connection with the gangster, the Brazilian
- 11:29abandons her. She decides to go to Brazil anyway.
- 11:33Paul explains that's a terrible idea, as she
- 11:37would be breaking bail if nothing else, and finally
- 11:39comes out and says what he thinks of her. That
- 11:43she isn't a free spirit, or a wild thing. She's
- 11:47a coward. A scared little girl who, no matter
- 11:51how far she runs, will always run into herself.
- 11:56And that he loves her. Holly doesn't take any
- 12:00of this well. Paul leaves Holly behind in a cab
- 12:04while he goes to find her cat, which she had
- 12:07abandoned. And Holly decides, after a good cry
- 12:11looking at the Cracker Jack ring from Tiffany's,
- 12:13to come back to be with him and the cat. They
- 12:17kiss. If you can't tell, Breakfast at Tiffany's
- 12:23doesn't actually have much of a plot. It's the
- 12:27kind of story we would call a character study.
- 12:30Every vignette, every adventure is just another
- 12:33way to get to know Holly and how her mind works.
- 12:38Holly's backstory is part of the whole point
- 12:40of the movie, as is her character's journey.
- 12:43Who is this woman, we are meant to ask? And will
- 12:47she ever change? There are some viewers of this
- 12:51movie who argue that Holly is just a manic pixie
- 12:55dream girl, a term that was coined in 2005 that
- 12:59applies to a whole host of female characters
- 13:02popular in films of the late 90s to the early
- 13:052010s. quirky, adorkable young women with optimistic
- 13:11perspectives on the world whose narrative function
- 13:14is to fall in love with morose and melancholic
- 13:17young men experiencing a crisis and help them
- 13:21solve their problems. Polly has far too much
- 13:25character focus to be the former, and Paul has
- 13:28too little narrative focus to be the latter.
- 13:32Though I do think we can learn something from
- 13:35the comparison. The current perspective on manic
- 13:39pixie dream girls is that they're all actually
- 13:42just neurodivergent, having some flavor of autism
- 13:46or ADHD that their love interests took for a
- 13:49character quirk, but that was probably a personal
- 13:52struggle. And what I find really interesting
- 13:56is that there's a big overlap between the expressions
- 13:59of ADHD and PTSD. Holly's so forgetful. always
- 14:06losing her keys and struggling to keep track
- 14:09of what day it is. Problems with working memory
- 14:12and executive dysfunction are common with both
- 14:16ADHD and PTSD, as is a general restlessness and
- 14:22a struggle to make and commit to plans. And Holly
- 14:26is definitely struggling with PTSD, including
- 14:30nightmares involving her brother. I think it's
- 14:34also worth noting that exhibiting sexually risky
- 14:38behavior is a very common indicator of sexual
- 14:41abuse, and that seems very likely in Holly's
- 14:45story. As Lula Mae Barnes, Holly ran away from
- 14:50home with her brother and stole food to keep
- 14:52them both alive, marrying Doc Golightly so they
- 14:56could have a place to live. She may have moved
- 15:00across the country, changed her accent, changed
- 15:03her whole vibe, but she is still very much a
- 15:06runaway, using her body to provide for her brother.
- 15:11That never changed. Right now, I do have to bring
- 15:18up what I believe is the second flaw of Breakfast
- 15:22at Tiffany's. Try as I might, I can never really
- 15:27believe that this backstory belongs to Audrey
- 15:30Hepburn. Don't get me wrong, she gives a wonderful
- 15:35performance as Holly. Daffy, in denial, sophisticated
- 15:39and girlish all at once, suppressing a deep well
- 15:44of trauma and pain. But I can't ever believe
- 15:48that she was a country girl from Texas. Truman
- 15:52Capote, who wrote the novella on which the film
- 15:55is based, reportedly wanted Marilyn Monroe, and
- 15:59while the timing for this film wouldn't have
- 16:01worked out with her, both due to her age and
- 16:05life at this point, I definitely agree that a
- 16:08Marilyn type would have made much more sense
- 16:11in this part. Audrey never reads as anything
- 16:15but a transatlantic socialite. A traumatized
- 16:18one, sure, but... Not a country girl transplant,
- 16:21even when she's drunk. And the idea of Audrey
- 16:26at 14 seeming like full woman marriage material
- 16:30to Doc makes him seem creepier than I think he's
- 16:34meant to be. It stretches credulity in a way
- 16:38that breaks their scene together, which gets
- 16:41in the way of the realities of this character.
- 16:45Petburn's casting makes Holly look as if she's
- 16:49escaped Texas, but the character never, ever
- 16:54has. The way Doc Golightly tells it, which, yes,
- 17:00is definitely biased, it was Holly's idea for
- 17:04them to get married. By marrying Doc, she made
- 17:08a financially secure way to support Fred. and
- 17:12she didn't have to work, as Doc's daughter from
- 17:15a previous marriage did all the housework. Holly's
- 17:19plan to marry the wealthy Brazilian is the same
- 17:23plan repeated, just with more money at stake.
- 17:27She ran away from Doc like she ran away from
- 17:31her first Texas home, and yet ended up playing
- 17:35the same gambit. The clothes have changed, and
- 17:39the accent, and the trappings, and even her name.
- 17:43But she's still that same girl. When she first
- 17:48meets Paul, she explains that she's often struck
- 17:51by a feeling she calls the mean reds, in contrast
- 17:55to the blues. What she describes sounds very
- 17:58much like crushing anxiety. Her solution is to
- 18:03visit Tiffany's, the jewelry store. surrounded
- 18:06by all that glamorous wealth, she feels at peace.
- 18:10She explains to Paul that she really is just
- 18:13wandering around, searching, until she finds
- 18:16a place that gives her that same sense of security
- 18:19she gets from her dreams of glamour. She hasn't
- 18:23even unpacked her boxes or named her cat. Again,
- 18:27that sounds very much like disassociation from
- 18:30trauma. Even her silly day with Paul seems very
- 18:35much like the kind of day a child would enjoy.
- 18:38Let's buy something fancy with the money we have
- 18:40in our pocket. Wouldn't it be silly to make them
- 18:43engrave a Cracker Jack ring? Let's be obnoxious
- 18:47to a librarian and deface a library book by Paul
- 18:52signing his own story collection. Let's steal
- 18:55Halloween masks from a 5 and 10 store. That's
- 19:00part of Holly's appeal. And what you come to
- 19:03realize is what all these men see in her, why
- 19:07they're willing to give her generous tips for
- 19:10their time together. To them, Holly is the escapist
- 19:15fantasy of youth. Become a child again, flit
- 19:19about, go on an adventure. Paul finds himself
- 19:23taken in by it all. and realizes that what felt
- 19:28like real love and connection to him was only
- 19:31just Holly continuing to disassociate, to play
- 19:36a part, to play a game. She's a child fawning
- 19:41her way out of trauma, stunted, not thriving.
- 19:47There's a difference, you see, between being
- 19:50childish and childlike. To be childish, is to
- 19:56be stuck as a child, either from immaturity or
- 20:00trauma. You cannot understand the seriousness
- 20:04of the real world because either the world is
- 20:07a game to you or you cannot confront the horrors
- 20:11therein. To be childlike is to know the seriousness
- 20:16of the real world and to choose joy and wonder
- 20:21in spite of it. And Holly cannot bear to face
- 20:25the seriousness of the real world, even as she
- 20:29cannot escape it. What I think is the most stunning
- 20:34scene in this whole film is when she receives
- 20:38the news about her brother's death. Holly, dressed
- 20:42in a bright pink gown, a tall jeweled pink tiara
- 20:46in her hair, a pink cape tossed over her shoulder.
- 20:50Looks like a little girl playing glamorous princess.
- 20:53And after reading the news of her brother's death,
- 20:56she throws a devastating tantrum, screaming,
- 21:01throwing every object in her apartment, shattering
- 21:05glass and china. Paul rushes in and holds her
- 21:09back like a parent holding a child, and she whacks
- 21:13at him with a feather pillow. He gets her to
- 21:16her bed and leaves. And there she remains, curled
- 21:21up in the fetal position in the dark, a broken
- 21:25little girl sobbing on her mattress, feathers
- 21:29swirling over her head. Polly might play dress
- 21:34-up, but she cannot run from the real world.
- 21:39Tiffany's is not a solution to trauma. And Paul...
- 21:47isn't either. He knows this. He has the maturity
- 21:53to realize he can't fix her. He just needs to
- 21:57move on. Until the ending. Which brings me to
- 22:03my third flaw with this film. The end doesn't
- 22:07work. I don't believe for one second that a big
- 22:12speech from Paul, even a direct, honest one,
- 22:16is going to change Holly's mind. The unfortunate
- 22:21truth is that lovely, broken people have to come
- 22:26to the realization of their brokenness on their
- 22:29own. Interventions only work if the person genuinely
- 22:34chooses to let them work. And I don't think Holly's
- 22:39capable of making that choice yet. I sincerely
- 22:43doubt that Paul is the first person who has told
- 22:46Holly the truth about herself in a desperate
- 22:49attempt to save her from self -sabotage. And
- 22:54I don't see an engraved Cracker Jack ring really
- 22:57bringing Holly the peace to be able to go back
- 23:00to Paul and Kat. Even if Holly did stay with
- 23:04Paul for a little while, she'd run away again.
- 23:08Because Holly needs to want to change. And I
- 23:13don't believe she's ready for that yet. Capote
- 23:17didn't. In the original novella, Holly does go
- 23:21to Brazil, and the young writer genuinely hopes
- 23:24that she will find a place that feels like home
- 23:27one day. Also in the original novel, the young
- 23:31writer is heavily implied to be gay, which really
- 23:35couldn't fly in 1961, hence the romance made
- 23:39up whole cloth for this film. Personally, I don't
- 23:44think the romance is bad from a character or
- 23:47thematic perspective. I just don't find Holly's
- 23:52choice to be truthful. Instead, we're left with
- 23:57a strange sort of cognitive dissonance. This
- 24:01film is a critique of escapism. And yet, it wants
- 24:07us to escape in the last few minutes, to imagine
- 24:11that Holly could change and that she and Paul
- 24:14will have a happy relationship. It wants us to
- 24:18remember Holly as childlike, not childish, and
- 24:23hold her in our hearts as an aspirational image
- 24:27of whimsical sophistication. But I find that
- 24:31image false. It's a large reason why I don't
- 24:36really like this movie. So, here's my pitch for
- 24:41the ending. Paul gives his speech. He gets out
- 24:46of the cab. to go look for Cat. We still see
- 24:50Holly looking sadly at the ring, leading us to
- 24:53wonder if she'll go back after him. And then
- 24:57we cut to Paul finding Cat. He looks back at
- 25:02the street, hoping Holly has returned, but the
- 25:06cab is gone. And he walks off, smiling sadly,
- 25:10Cat in his arms, as the choir begins to sing
- 25:14Moon River. Then he and Cat could be the two
- 25:20drifters looking for the same rainbow's end for
- 25:24the hope that one day Holly will change, that
- 25:29she will stop running, that she will find peace,
- 25:33that she will know both safety and contentment
- 25:39and true childlike joy in spite. of the real
- 25:46world. Thanks for coming.