Latest / Interfaiths / Nund Rishi and the Negative Theology of Kashmiri Pluralism
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today, we are
- 0:02going to challenge a concept that I think most
- 0:05of us, especially in the modern world, sort of
- 0:08consider a gold standard. And that is interfaith
- 0:11dialogue. Exactly. It's a phrase that sounds
- 0:14incredibly civilized, doesn't it? It does. It
- 0:16evokes a very specific image. I always picture,
- 0:19you know, a round table, maybe a conference center
- 0:22somewhere. People from different religions, they're
- 0:24all politely nodding at one another. You have
- 0:27your tea. I have mine. You stay in your theological
- 0:29lane. I stay in mine. And we just agree to be
- 0:32nice. Right. It's safe. It's sanitized. It's
- 0:35what we call tolerance. But the stack of research
- 0:38we are unpacking today suggests that this version
- 0:41of dialogue, this polite, guarded exchange, might
- 0:46actually be a little superficial. Or at least
- 0:48it's not the only way to do it. And for that,
- 0:50we're traveling back in time today, about 600
- 0:52years, to the Valley of Kashmir. We're going
- 0:55to look at a radical experiment in how to bridge
- 0:57the gap between two totally different worldviews.
- 1:00And the central figure here isn't a diplomat.
- 1:03He's a mystic. And he didn't use polite conversation
- 1:07to bridge that gap. He used something much, much
- 1:10heavier. He used the concept of death. This is
- 1:13the Deep Dive on Nandrishi. also known as the
- 1:16Elimdar or flag bearer of Kashmir. And we're
- 1:19basing this conversation on the fascinating research
- 1:21of scholar Abir Bashir Bazaz, specifically his
- 1:25work on negative theology. And just to set the
- 1:28stakes here. Bazaz's argument is that Nun Rishi
- 1:31didn't just preach coexistence. No. He practiced
- 1:34interfaith translation. And that is a much messier,
- 1:37much more dangerous, and honestly a much more
- 1:39effective game than what we usually see today.
- 1:42Translation is the key word there. We aren't
- 1:44talking about swapping words in a dictionary.
- 1:46Not at all. We are talking about translating
- 1:48your entire soul into the language of the other.
- 1:51So let's set the scene. If we drop into Kashmir
- 1:54in the late 1300s. What are we walking into?
- 1:57It was a moment of just absolute seismic shifts.
- 2:01You have to imagine the ground literally moving
- 2:03beneath people's feet. For centuries, Kashmir
- 2:06had been this incredible intellectual powerhouse
- 2:09of Hinduism, specifically Shaivism and Buddhism,
- 2:13a real center of Sanskrit learning. But by the
- 2:1614th century, the political structures were collapsing.
- 2:18And you have the rise of the Muslim sultanate.
- 2:22So the king is now a sultan. The entire political
- 2:25order has just flipped. Exactly. And with that
- 2:28political flip, you get a new religion. Is Islam
- 2:30becoming the dominant political force? But, and
- 2:33this is crucial, the research highlights that
- 2:35there wasn't just one type of Islam arriving.
- 2:38It wasn't a monolith. Right. The sources distinguish
- 2:41between the elites and the vernacular. Let's
- 2:44start with the elites. Who were they? OK, so
- 2:45these were the immigrants. Think Persian Sufis,
- 2:48like the Kuberwiyah order. These guys were the
- 2:51cosmopolitan intellectuals of the medieval world.
- 2:53They came from Central Asia, they spoke Persian,
- 2:56and they headed straight for the royal court.
- 2:58They were the high church equivalent, if you
- 3:00will. So these are the top -down guys. They hang
- 3:02out with the sultan, they focus on Islamic la
- 3:04shara, and for them, being Muslim is about being
- 3:09distinct from the locals. Precisely. Their whole
- 3:12project was about boundaries. We are Muslims.
- 3:15You are non -Muslims. Here is the line. Cross
- 3:18it if you want to be saved, but otherwise, stay
- 3:20over there. Yes. They brought a kind of potted
- 3:23plant version of Islam, keeping it in the soil
- 3:26of Persia, just moving the pot to Kashmir. They
- 3:29didn't want to get their hands dirty with the
- 3:30local culture. And then on the complete other
- 3:32side of the spectrum, you have Nun Rishi. The
- 3:35vernacular, the little tradition. Nun Rishi wasn't
- 3:39an immigrant. He was born in a village in Kashmir
- 3:41around 1378. He didn't hang out in courts. He
- 3:46walked the forests. He didn't speak Persian.
- 3:48He spoke, and more importantly, he composed poetry
- 3:51in Kashmiri. That seems like a small detail.
- 3:54But in that context, speaking the local language
- 3:57was a political statement, wasn't it? Oh, it
- 3:58was a radical claim to authority. By speaking
- 4:01Kashmiri, he was saying, God speaks your language,
- 4:03too. He established the Rishi Order, which was
- 4:06an indigenous Muslim ascetic movement. But, and
- 4:10here is the kicker, he's so entangled with the
- 4:12local traditions that even today he has two names.
- 4:15The Muslims call him Shaikh Lalam, teacher of
- 4:18the world, and the Hindus call him Sahazanand,
- 4:20the bliss of the natural. There is a legend in
- 4:23the source material that just perfectly captures
- 4:26this entanglement. It involves Lal Dede, the
- 4:28famous Hindu mystic. I think this story really
- 4:31sets the tone for everything else. You absolutely
- 4:33cannot tell Nun Rishi's story without Lal Dede.
- 4:37She was a wandering yogini, a real giant of Kashmiri
- 4:41Shaivism. And legend says that when Nun Rishi
- 4:43was an infant, he refused to breastfeed. From
- 4:46his own mother, yeah. He wouldn't eat. The family
- 4:49was distraught. They thought the child was going
- 4:51to die. And then Laldeh enters the scene. Right.
- 4:53A Hindu ascetic enters a Muslim household. She
- 4:56picks up the baby Nun Rishi and whispers to him,
- 4:59You are not ashamed to be born, so why are you
- 5:01ashamed to drink? And then, in this incredibly
- 5:04potent, almost shocking image, she offers him
- 5:07her own breast. And he feeds. That is, wow. A
- 5:11Hindi yogini literally nursing the future Muslim
- 5:13saint of Kashmir. It's so intimate. It's the
- 5:16foundational myth of Kashmiri pluralism. It's
- 5:19saying that his spiritual DNA, his vitality,
- 5:21it flows directly from the Hindu past. He isn't
- 5:25erasing the old religion. He is imbibing it.
- 5:27He is nourished by it. And this gave him immense
- 5:30credibility with the common people. Which brings
- 5:33us to this concept of translation. Because Nandrishi
- 5:36didn't just borrow milk. He borrowed language.
- 5:39Yeah. Bazaaz talks a lot about this term sahaja.
- 5:42What does that mean here? Sahaja is a Sanskrit
- 5:44word. It means innate or spontaneous. In the
- 5:48local spiritual ecology, it meant the truth that
- 5:51you were born with something natural, not forced
- 5:53by rituals. It's the water, not the bottle. And
- 5:56Nun Rishi does something audacious here. He takes
- 6:00the Sanskrit concept and applies it to the Quran.
- 6:02He calls the Quran the sahaja Quran. Which changes
- 6:05everything. If the Quran is sahaja, then it's
- 6:08not a foreign import from Arabia. Right. It's
- 6:11an awakening of something you already have inside
- 6:13you. He's telling the Kashmiri peasant, you don't
- 6:15have to become an Arab or a Persian to follow
- 6:17this path. This path is already in your blood.
- 6:20He even gave the Prophet Muhammad a new title,
- 6:22didn't he? He called him the first rishi. That
- 6:25is bold. Taking the prophet of Islam and categorizing
- 6:28him as a rishi of Vedic sage, that feels like
- 6:31it would upset the orthodox elites. Oh, the elites
- 6:35hated it. But for the common person, it was a
- 6:38masterclass in translation. By calling Muhammad
- 6:40a rishi, he validates Islam through the lens
- 6:43of the ancestors. It creates a genealogy. It
- 6:47does. It says, look, this new message is just
- 6:49the latest chapter of our own story. It's interreligious
- 6:53entanglement at its best. He's refusing to let
- 6:56the religions be separate categories. Okay, so
- 6:58he hooks them with the local language and these
- 7:00familiar concepts. But once he has their attention,
- 7:03the actual message he delivers is, well, it's
- 7:06heavy. Yes. This is where we get to the negative
- 7:08theology. This is the core of the Zaz's research.
- 7:10So why negative? Is he just being pessimistic?
- 7:12Is this about being depressed about the world?
- 7:14No. Negative here doesn't mean bad or sad. It
- 7:17refers to the via negativa, the negative way.
- 7:22It's a theological method where you try to understand
- 7:24the ultimate reality, God, truth, whatever you
- 7:27call it, by stripping away everything that it
- 7:30is not. You clear the deck. You clear the deck,
- 7:32you negate the finite to find the infinite. And
- 7:35for Nun Rishi, the ultimate tool for clearing
- 7:38the deck was death. The sources say his poetry
- 7:40is obsessed with death and the void shunya. Why
- 7:44focus on that? Why not paradise or blessings
- 7:47or how great God is? Because blessings and rituals
- 7:50divide us. My rituals are better than yours.
- 7:52My heaven looks different than yours. My God
- 7:55has a beard, yours has many arms. Exactly. But
- 7:58death, death is the great equalizer. Nunon Rishi
- 8:01realized that if you strip away the labels, Hindu,
- 8:04Muslim, Brahmin, outcast what is left, we are
- 8:07all temporary. We are all going to die. There
- 8:09is this one shruk. That's what his verses are
- 8:12called, right? Shruks. Yes. Shruk implies a knot.
- 8:15They are like riddles you have to untie. Right.
- 8:17They aren't meant to be consumed easily. You
- 8:19have to chew on them. So there's this one shirk
- 8:21about shop closing. Yeah. It really stuck with
- 8:24me because it feels so modern. We're all so busy
- 8:26doing our thing. The shop closing metaphor is
- 8:28haunting. He compares human life to a bazaar.
- 8:32During the day, it's loud. It's busy. People
- 8:34are trading, cheating, arguing over prices. It
- 8:37feels so important. The hustle. Right. But then.
- 8:41Evening comes, the shutters go down, the shopkeepers
- 8:45leave, and the marketplace is just empty. Like
- 8:48water absorbed by new clay vessels. Yeah. That's
- 8:51the line he uses to describe how death takes
- 8:53youth. It just sucks it dry. It's about the suddenness
- 8:56of the end. He's forcing the listener to confront
- 8:58the fact that their business, their ego, their
- 9:01status, their religious arguments is all going
- 9:03to vanish when the sun sets. But isn't that just
- 9:06depressing? Hey, everyone, nothing matters. We're
- 9:08all dust. How is that a bridge between people?
- 9:10Usually we try to build bridges on hope, not
- 9:12despair. That's the genius of it. If we are all
- 9:15dust, then why are we fighting? If I admit that
- 9:18I am nothing and you admit that you are nothing,
- 9:20we suddenly have something profound in common,
- 9:22our shared fragility. It levels the playing field.
- 9:25It reminds me of that phrase the sources mentioned,
- 9:28die before you die. That sounds like a riddle.
- 9:31It is, and it's a concept found in both Sufism
- 9:33and Buddhism, which Nand Rishi harmonizes perfectly.
- 9:38Die before you die means dismantling your ego
- 9:42now. While you're alive. Don't wait for physical
- 9:45death. Kill your greed, kill your pride, kill
- 9:48your tribalism while you are still alive. So
- 9:50it's an active process. It's not just waiting
- 9:52for the end. Yes. He writes, death is a sweet
- 9:55drink without which you shall not heal. Without
- 9:57which you shall not heal. That flips the script.
- 10:00Usually we think of death as the sickness. He's
- 10:03saying the ego is the sickness and the awareness
- 10:05of death is the medicine. It's a call to kenosis,
- 10:08self -emptying. If you empty yourself of you,
- 10:11you make room for the divine. And in that empty
- 10:14space, a Hindu and a Muslim can actually meet.
- 10:17Because the walls of dogma have been knocked
- 10:19down. The walls which are built by the ego, yes.
- 10:22Now, this wasn't just mystical navel -gazing,
- 10:24though, was it? Bazaz argues that this negative
- 10:26theology had real -world political teeth. He
- 10:29calls it negative political theology. It was
- 10:32incredibly political. You have to remember the
- 10:34context. You have sultans building massive monuments
- 10:37claiming divine right. You have elites hoarding
- 10:40wealth. When Nun Rishi comes along and says,
- 10:43all of this is fleeting, the void is coming for
- 10:46everything, he is delegitimizing their power.
- 10:48It's the ultimate reality check for a dictator.
- 10:51You can't really intimidate a guy who's already
- 10:53focused on the void. Exactly. There's a poem
- 10:56where he describes the palaces of the rich. High
- 10:59walls, guarded gates, turning the poor away.
- 11:02They look so permanent. Right. But then he fast
- 11:04forwards the tape. He says, I saw those same
- 11:07palaces in ruins and now people are growing cotton
- 11:09over them. Cotton growing over the ruins of the
- 11:11palace. That is such a specific, humble image.
- 11:15Nature reclaiming the monument. It tells the
- 11:17peasant. Don't be intimidated by the sultan.
- 11:20His power is dust. And it tells the sultan, watch
- 11:23out. It's a critique of power rooted in the apocalypse.
- 11:27He also redefines what a true believer is. Yeah.
- 11:30And he does it in a way that seems designed to
- 11:32bypass the religious gatekeepers. This is the
- 11:34poem, He Alone is a True Muslim. Now remember
- 11:38the elites. To them, a true Muslim follows Shari,
- 11:42wears the right clothes, prays in Arabic. Nandrishi
- 11:46says, no. A true Muslim is one who conquers anger,
- 11:50one who conquers greed, one who shares his food
- 11:53with the hungry. Which are virtues that a Buddhist
- 11:56monk or a Hindu peasant would immediately nod
- 11:58along with. Exactly. He shifted the definition
- 12:01from tribal identity to ethical substance. He
- 12:04made it so that a non -Muslim could look at a
- 12:07Muslim and recognize shared values rather than
- 12:10just seeing a foreign conqueror. I want to go
- 12:12back to the poetry itself for a minute. You mentioned
- 12:14these are knots. They aren't linear lectures.
- 12:16Bazaz highlights a couple of metaphors that are
- 12:19really... Well, they're tricky. One is the pomegranate.
- 12:22The pomegranate and the fire. It's a complex
- 12:24image interpreted by the critic Rahman Rahi.
- 12:27Imagine a child who wants to steal pomegranates
- 12:29from a tree, but it's dark. Okay. So to see the
- 12:32fruit, the child lights a bundle of grass. Okay,
- 12:34so he's shedding light on the prize. Makes sense.
- 12:36But the fire gets out of control. It threatens
- 12:38the whole orchard. And suddenly the child is
- 12:40stuck. He has the desire for the fruit, but he's
- 12:43created a disaster, and now he's terrified of
- 12:46the return journey home. Afraid of the punishment.
- 12:48Yes. That feels like a metaphor for everything.
- 12:53We want the fruit, money, power, pleasure. We
- 12:55burn things down to get it, and then we're left
- 12:57staring at the ashes, terrified of the consequences.
- 13:00It captures the anxiety of existence. It's not
- 13:03a comforting, here's the answer poem. It's a
- 13:06poem that forces you to feel the tension between
- 13:08your desire and your inevitable end. And then
- 13:12there's the crow. That one felt very visual to
- 13:15me. The crow shedding its feathers. Imagine a
- 13:17bird standing there and all its beautiful plumage,
- 13:19the things that let it fly, the things that give
- 13:21it shape and identity, just fall off and pile
- 13:24up at its feet. That is a stark image. A naked
- 13:27bird. It's the shedding of the self. The feathers
- 13:30are our pretensions, our titles, our I -ness,
- 13:33I -am -that. When you face the truth, the nothing,
- 13:36you lose your feathers. And Bazaz calls what's
- 13:39left the form of the nothing, Shunyakar. Right.
- 13:43Nandrishi says that when life, zoo, and greed
- 13:46blob finally the stage, what remains is the form
- 13:50of the nothing. It implies that our true reality,
- 13:53our sahaja state, is what's left when the frantic
- 13:56noise of living stops. It's the silence after
- 13:59the song. So bringing this all together, we have
- 14:01a mystic who used the local language, bridged
- 14:05the gap with Hindu philosophy, and used the terrifying
- 14:07reality of death to level the playing field.
- 14:11between the powerful and the poor. That's a great
- 14:13summary, yes. Why does this matter to us sitting
- 14:15here today? We aren't in medieval Kashmir. But
- 14:19Bazaz seems to think this Nundurishi model is
- 14:21actually urgent for us. It is urgent because
- 14:23our current model of tolerance is failing. We
- 14:26built a world where we tolerate each other, but
- 14:28we don't engage. We just ignore the differences
- 14:30to keep the peace. Bazaz calls what Nonarishi
- 14:33did interreligious entanglement. Entanglement
- 14:35sounds messy. It sounds like something you get
- 14:37stuck in. It is messy, and that's the point.
- 14:39True pluralism isn't about ignoring differences
- 14:41or building walls. It's about being willing to
- 14:43translate your sacred concepts into the language
- 14:46of your neighbor. Nandrishi wasn't afraid to
- 14:49let his Islam be contaminated. And I use that
- 14:52word in a positive way, the way a scholar would.
- 14:54He wasn't afraid to let it be contaminated by
- 14:56the Hindu worldview. He risked his own purity
- 14:59to make a connection. Yes. He suggests that if
- 15:02we only speak our own theological language, we
- 15:04are just shouting into the void. But if we translate,
- 15:07if we say, okay, I call it monotheism, you call
- 15:10it the void, but let's look at what we both fear.
- 15:12Death. Suffering. Fragility. That's where you
- 15:16find the connection. That is where you find the
- 15:18sahaja, the innate connection. It's moving the
- 15:20conversation from my doctrine versus your doctrine
- 15:24to we are all in the same sinking boat. Or to
- 15:27use Nun Rishi's metaphor, we are all in the same
- 15:30shop and the shutters are coming down. So how
- 15:32do we want to treat each other in these final
- 15:34minutes? That is a powerful question. It shifts
- 15:37the stakes completely. It makes kindness urgent.
- 15:40It does. It reminds us that religion at its best
- 15:43isn't a fortress. It's a bridge. And sometimes
- 15:46the only way to cross that bridge is to leave
- 15:48your heavy armor, your ego, your rigid definitions
- 15:51behind. Bazaz uses a great phrase for this. Apophatic
- 15:55boldness. The boldness to speak about what cannot
- 15:58be spoken. And the boldness to cross frontiers.
- 16:01Nun Rishi negated the power structures of his
- 16:04time to open a space where a Hindu yogini could
- 16:07be the spiritual mother of a Muslim saint. That
- 16:09is a radical act of love. It's much harder than
- 16:12just sitting at a conference table sipping tea.
- 16:14So here is the challenge for you listening today.
- 16:16We often think of understanding someone else
- 16:18as learning their facts. Oh, they believe X,
- 16:21Y, and Z. But Nun Rishi challenges us to go deeper.
- 16:25He challenges us to translate. What would it
- 16:28look like for you to translate your core beliefs
- 16:30into the language of the person you disagree
- 16:32with most? Not to convert them. And not to lose
- 16:35yourself. But just to find that innate ground
- 16:38beneath all the arguments. If you stripped away
- 16:40the labels, the politics, and the jargon, and
- 16:43you were both just facing the nothing, what would
- 16:46you say to each other then? It's a scary question.
- 16:49But as Nandrishi would say, it's a sweet drink
- 16:53without which you shall not heal. Couldn't have
- 16:56said it better. Thanks for taking this deep dive
- 16:58into the mystic world of Kashmir with us. We'll
- 17:00catch you on the next one.