Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Van Showdown: Ford E-Transit Versus Renault Master E-Tech
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're really getting into
- 0:13a huge decision for, well for any commercial operator out
- 0:16there. We're looking at which electric
- 0:18van is the true workhorse for a really high mileage schedule.
- 0:22That's right. Our whole mission here is to
- 0:25break down the data on the 4D Transit and the Renault Master E
- 0:28tech, and we're doing it specifically for you, the driver
- 0:32who's covering, say, around 40,000 kilometers a year.
- 0:35Yeah. And at that mileage, you're not
- 0:37just buying a van, you're investing in the backbone of
- 0:39your business every single kilometer.
- 0:41It all counts towards that total cost of ownership and maybe more
- 0:45importantly, uptime. And we have two major players
- 0:48here, but they are coming at this from completely different
- 0:51angles. Ford is really gone all in on
- 0:54driver comfort, on dynamics. It's almost like a giant
- 0:57electric SUV. Right.
- 0:58And Renault. Renault is doubled down on pure
- 1:01utility, on efficiency, on just squeezing every last meter out
- 1:05of the battery. So for you, the high mileage
- 1:07driver, the choice really boils down to which one of these, you
- 1:12know, engineering philosophy is going to save you more time and
- 1:14money out on the road. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:17I think we have to start with the core strategies because the
- 1:20the price and the power, they tell you most everything you
- 1:22need to know right from the get go.
- 1:24The Renault Master E tech, it's deliberately set up as the more,
- 1:28let's say accessible option. You're looking at a starting
- 1:31price around €52,000 before VAT. And the Ford?
- 1:36The Ford D Transit is asking for a bit more upfront.
- 1:39It starts closer to 56,000. So, OK, Renault saves you a bit
- 1:42of cash right out of the gate, but that Ford seems to be
- 1:46selling a very different kind of drive experience and the specs
- 1:49really show that. Oh.
- 1:50Absolutely. I mean, look at the power.
- 1:52The Ford E Transit delivers 160 kilowatts.
- 1:54Which is a potent 214 horsepower.
- 1:57A very potent 214 horsepower and the rental Master E tech offers
- 2:01105 kilowatts. So what about 140 horsepower?
- 2:04That is a huge gap in performance.
- 2:06It is, and the engineering underneath is why Ford built the
- 2:10E Transit on a completely new dedicated EV platform.
- 2:14So it's not a converted diesel van?
- 2:16Not at all. They put the battery right into
- 2:18the floor, which lowers the center of gravity, but the real
- 2:21key for the driver was the independent rear suspension.
- 2:24That's a big deal in a commercial van.
- 2:26It's almost a luxury feature. It is.
- 2:28It signals that Ford put the feel of the drive, the comfort,
- 2:33right at the top of their list. Which is interesting.
- 2:35So why didn't Renault do that? Why not build their own
- 2:37dedicated platform for, you know, maximum power and all
- 2:40that? They just chose a different
- 2:42fight. The master E tech is on a multi
- 2:45energy platform and they poured their R&D money into
- 2:48aerodynamics. They spent a huge amount of time
- 2:51on wind tunnel analysis, shaping the body not for looks but for
- 2:55pure efficiency. Their goal wasn't performance,
- 2:59it was making every single kWh take you further.
- 3:03So that makes the trade off really clear.
- 3:04Then four gives you the power and that car like feel.
- 3:07Renault gives you maximum efficiency and I'm guessing
- 3:10range. That's the idea.
- 3:12But, you know, speed doesn't matter if you can't actually
- 3:14carry your gear. So how do these philosophies
- 3:16really translate to, you know, the practical side, the cargo
- 3:20capacity? They create a really clear
- 3:22split. I mean a massive 1 if you're
- 3:2440,000 kilometers a year, involves heavy duty hauling or
- 3:28if you need to tow anything significant.
- 3:30The Renault Master E tech is the absolute winner, no contest.
- 3:34It has a class leading payload of up to 1625 kilograms.
- 3:38Wow. And it has a genuinely superior
- 3:41towing capacity of 2500 kilograms.
- 3:44Wait, hold on 2 1/2 tons 2. And a half tons.
- 3:46That's almost four times what the Ford can do.
- 3:49How can the Ford on its fancy EV platform be so limited?
- 3:53The E transit is fine for say volume based logistics.
- 3:57You know parcels. Bulky but light stuff.
- 3:59It gives you about 1011kg of payload, but the towing it's
- 4:04severely capped at just 750 kilograms.
- 4:06That's tiny. It is.
- 4:07The Renault is just engineered for when mass and brute utility
- 4:10what matters. They even obsessed over small
- 4:12things like making the sliding side door the largest in its
- 4:15class, specifically for easier forklift access.
- 4:18And there's a really interesting legal thing here too for
- 4:20operators in Europe. Oh, this is a game changer.
- 4:22The exemption. Right.
- 4:23Tell me about that. The 4.25 ton version of the
- 4:26electric Master E tech can be driven on standard car license.
- 4:30So you don't need a special commercial license.
- 4:32Exactly, in a diesel van once you hit that weight you need AC1
- 4:36license, but because the Renault is electric you can Max out that
- 4:39massive payload without needing specially licensed drivers.
- 4:43For a fleet manager that has a huge plus.
- 4:46It opens up your driver pool. OK, so Renault is the undisputed
- 4:49champ for heavy work. Let's step inside the cabin now.
- 4:52I mean, this is your mobile office for 40,000 kilometers a
- 4:56year. What's the experience like?
- 4:58Ford went all in on the driver. The design is super ergonomic.
- 5:02They've got this unique squirkle steering wheel, a squirkle.
- 5:06It's slightly flattened on the top and bottom to make it easier
- 5:09for the driver to slide in and out on.
- 5:11You know those multi drop routes.
- 5:12It's a small thing, but it's really clever.
- 5:14That is smart. And the centerpiece is that big
- 5:1613 inch SYN C4 touchscreen. It's fast, it's intuitive, and
- 5:21they offer this optional mobile office pack.
- 5:23Yeah, I read about this. The steering wheel folds down
- 5:26into a desk. It does.
- 5:28It tilts and becomes a flat work surface, perfect for laptop, for
- 5:31paperwork, for eating your lunch.
- 5:34It properly turns the van into a functional workspace that's a.
- 5:37Huge feature for anyone who has to do admin on the road.
- 5:40It is no. Renault's cabin is also all
- 5:42about utility, just in a different way.
- 5:44They went on Pure Storage, an incredible 135 liters of storage
- 5:49space in the cabin. Wow, that's a.
- 5:51Lot far more than the Ford and their tech is strong too.
- 5:54A 10 inch screen with Google built in so you get native
- 5:57Google Maps, Google Assistant which is fantastic for
- 6:00commercial routing and workflow. But I did read about one kind of
- 6:04an odd choice in the Renault. Yes, the slight anomaly, an old
- 6:08fashioned manual handbrake lever right between the seats.
- 6:12In an EV. In an EV, it feels a little
- 6:14dated compared to the electronic brake in the Ford, and it could
- 6:17get in the way if you're trying to move across the cab A.
- 6:18Small thing, but it's there. And if if it connect this back
- 6:22to the bigger picture, for an operator doing 40,000 kilometers
- 6:25a year range isn't just a nice to have, it's everything.
- 6:28It's your operational viability. This is the real high mileage
- 6:31decider, isn't it? This is it, and this is where
- 6:34Renault's obsession with aerodynamics really pays off big
- 6:37time. So how far can they actually go?
- 6:39Renault has a decisive, I mean a game changing advantage here.
- 6:44With their larger 87 kWh battery, they can get a maximum
- 6:47WLTP range of up to 460 kilometers. 460 kilometers.
- 6:52That's massive. For some routes, that could mean
- 6:54not needing to stop and charge at all during the.
- 6:56Day it's the difference between getting the job done and
- 6:59returning to base versus having to plan for an expensive, time
- 7:02consuming public charge mid shift.
- 7:04So what's the Ford E Transit it got in response?
- 7:07With all its focus on dynamics, What's the sacrifice on range?
- 7:11Well, the Ford comes with just one battery option, a 64 kWh
- 7:15usable battery, and that gives you a maximum WLTP range of
- 7:19around 317 kilometers. OK, so the difference is stark.
- 7:22We're talking nearly 150 kilometers more range in the
- 7:25Renault. We are if your roots regularly
- 7:29push past that 300 kilometer mark, or if the charging network
- 7:32is, you know, a bit patchy where you operate that 416, the
- 7:36Renault is a huge safety net. It gives you so much more
- 7:39flexibility. That extra radius just means
- 7:41less anxiety and fewer mandatory stops.
- 7:43But when you do have to stop and charge, how quickly can you get
- 7:46back on the road? That's the good news on DC fast
- 7:49charging. They're both very, very
- 7:51competitive. OK, the Renault can peak at 130
- 7:55kilowatts. It'll go from 15 to 80% in just
- 7:5838 minutes. The Ford is right there with it
- 8:00at 124 kilowatts. So either way, a quick coffee
- 8:03stop can get you a serious amount of range.
- 8:05Absolutely. Downtime is minimal for a mid
- 8:07shift top up. But what about overnight
- 8:09charging back at the depot? That's what most operators rely
- 8:12on. And here the advantage swings
- 8:14back to Ford. The E Transit has a more
- 8:16powerful onboard AC charger. It's 11 kilowatts compared to
- 8:20Renault's 7.4. OK, so translate that for me.
- 8:23What does that actually mean in terms of hours overnight?
- 8:26Well. Let's say you get back to the
- 8:27depot with 15% charge to get back to 100%.
- 8:32That 11 kilowatt charger in the Ford could save you several
- 8:35hours compared to the Renault. So you're guaranteed to be at
- 8:38100% by morning. Exactly, for a fleet manager who
- 8:41needs every van ready to go every single morning, that
- 8:44faster depot top up is a really substantial benefit, right?
- 8:48Now let's shift to the long term view, the driver experience and
- 8:52of course the total cost of ownership.
- 8:54I mean over 40,000 kilometers a year, you are spending hundreds
- 8:58of hours in this vehicle. And comfort really does impact
- 9:01driver fatigue and ultimately driver retention.
- 9:04And how did they stack up? Ford sets the gold standard
- 9:07here, no question. That independent rear suspension
- 9:10we mentioned? It just eliminates the bumpy,
- 9:12jarring ride you usually get in an empty van.
- 9:15It drives more like a car. It drives like a comfortable
- 9:17SUV, and that powerful motor with 415 Newton meters of
- 9:20instant torque makes pulling away, merging it all feels
- 9:24effortless. The handling is crisp.
- 9:26It's refined. And that reduction in fatigue is
- 9:29a real operational asset. A less stressed driver is a
- 9:34safer, more productive driver over that long year.
- 9:36Precisely. The Renault is comfortable.
- 9:39Don't get me wrong. It's predictable.
- 9:40The steering is light to nimble around town, it's easy to
- 9:43manage. But it just prioritizes
- 9:46simplicity over that dynamic refinement you get from Ford.
- 9:49It's perfectly competent, but it's not sporty or engaging.
- 9:53And on safety, they both sound pretty good, but Ford seems to
- 9:55have nabbed the top. Spot they have the E transit got
- 9:58the highest possible rating, the Euro NCIP platinum rating for
- 10:03its active safety systems. Their sensors and avoidance tech
- 10:06are the current benchmark. Also very strong, a five star
- 10:11Euro NCIP rating. They offer a suite of 20
- 10:14advanced driver assistance systems and they've included
- 10:16specific features for city driving like cyclist detection.
- 10:19So for you, if you're doing a lot of urban work, that focus is
- 10:22invaluable. OK.
- 10:23Let's wrap this all up with the TCO, the total cost of
- 10:25ownership, that's the initial price, maintenance and crucially
- 10:29for a high mileage asset, the warranty.
- 10:32Right. So Ford, it has that higher
- 10:34initial price, the 56 K, but they counter it with a much
- 10:37better warranty package. And what does that look like?
- 10:39Five years, unlimited kilometers on the vehicle itself.
- 10:43Unlimited kilometers. That is huge Peace of Mind for
- 10:47someone doing 40,000 KS a year. You're not getting penalized for
- 10:50high use, not. At all, and then you get an 8
- 10:52year 160,000 kilometer warranty on the battery.
- 10:56Plus, Ford claims your running costs could be up to 40% lower
- 11:00than the diesel version. And what's Reno's argument on
- 11:02TCO? Their strength is that lower
- 11:05initial price, the 52 K, and it's amazing efficiency.
- 11:08They claim just 21 kilowatt hours per 100 kilometers.
- 11:12It gives them the best price to autonomy ratio out there.
- 11:15And the warranty? It's a bit shorter, three years
- 11:17or 100,000 miles, Yeah, but they do have a practical plus after
- 11:21the first year, their service intervals are longer, two years
- 11:24or 24,000 miles, which could mean less time with the van off
- 11:28the road. So OK, we've got all the pieces
- 11:30on the table for you, the driver clocking 40,000 kilometers a
- 11:33year, relying on this van for your livelihood.
- 11:37What's the final verdict? I think we can draw some very
- 11:39clear lines here based on all this data.
- 11:41Go on. You should choose the rental
- 11:42master E tech if you're 40,000 kilometer operation needs
- 11:46maximum capability, full stop. That 460 kilometer range is the
- 11:50decider for long routes and the huge payload and towing, plus
- 11:54that license exemption that means unmatched asset
- 11:57utilization, the machine for carrying more for longer.
- 12:00And the Ford? You should choose the Ford E
- 12:03Transit if your priority is driver welfare, driver
- 12:05retention, and best in class safety.
- 12:08The platinum rating that refined car like handling.
- 12:11It all adds up to reducing fatigue on those long shifts.
- 12:15It's a comfort choice, but with one big condition.
- 12:17Which is. That the 317 kilometer range is
- 12:20actually enough for your daily routes and that you have
- 12:22reliable charging you can count on.
- 12:25The whole decision really just hinges on one question.
- 12:27Which risk is bigger for your specific operation?
- 12:30Is it range anxiety or is it driver burnout?
- 12:33You put forwards refinement and safety up against Renault's raw
- 12:36utility and range, and the right choice for you will become
- 12:39pretty clear. A truly comprehensive deep dive,
- 12:43we'll leave you with one final thought to Mull over.
- 12:46When you are planning for a 40,000 kilometer year, which
- 12:50feature gives you more practical Peace of Mind?
- 12:53Is it Ford's five year unlimited mileage warranty, meaning you
- 12:56never worry about overusing the van?
- 12:59Or is it Renault's class leading 460 kilometer range, meaning you
- 13:03rarely have to worry about running out of power?
- 13:06Something to think about. Thank you so much for allowing
- 13:09us to conduct this deep dive into your essential source
- 13:11material. We really hope this breakdown
- 13:14gives you the clarity you need to make this critical
- 13:16investment. Yeah, we really appreciate you
- 13:17tuning in and letting us dig into these important details.
- 13:21Be sure to follow the channel so you catch all our future in
- 13:23depth analysis. See you next time.