Latest / When Killers Get Caught with Brittany Ransom / Andrea Yates: Strangely Sympathetic and Local Legends
Transcript
- 0:20Hey everybody. Its serial killer country.
- 0:22My name is Brittany. Ransom, my name is Brian jr.
- 0:26And this is what Killers get caught.
- 0:29A podcast devoted to deep dives into the lives and psyches The
- 0:32Killers. We love to learn about each
- 0:34week, Brian. And I find a True Crime Story
- 0:36that resonated with us and then I discussed one, well-known or
- 0:39lesser known killer, I go deeper into their childhood lives
- 0:42methodology, and most importantly how and why they got
- 0:45caught and then we get a little spooky, we learned something
- 0:48about Cryptids or the supernatural.
- 0:49Keep it kind of light after the lately very depressing stories
- 0:55that I've been talking about Yes.
- 1:03Yeah, that's really the general consistency of things lately and
- 1:06it's not going to change tonight.
- 1:08If you've clicked on this podcast, you already know what
- 1:11this is about. Yeah, we're sorry.
- 1:15Yeah, it's it's heavy but uh I guess there's sort of a
- 1:19reasoning that goes along with it.
- 1:22I don't don't you dare. Don't you dare that's have a
- 1:26greater conversational situation but before we even get into the
- 1:32subject of tonight's podcast, let's instead talk about this
- 1:37week in True Crime. Something really cool was not
- 1:40cool. It's such a weird thing when
- 1:42stuff like this happens So, I don't know if you know who Fred
- 1:46and rosemary West are Brian. No, I did, Kanye West's parents
- 1:50and now they were a killer couple from the UK who were
- 1:54particularly horrible to young girls, including some of their
- 1:58own children. But in the 1960s, there was a
- 2:05girl who suspected of being one of their victims and she has
- 2:11been missing since 68 and they've never been able to find
- 2:16it Fred West, they think that Fred Killed her because he also
- 2:20did some gross stuff separate from his wife sometimes they
- 2:23work together. Sometimes I work separate very
- 2:25of course, Ian Brady Myra. Hey yeah.
- 2:29Funny enough the to both Myra and rosemary were in the same
- 2:34prison. And there were rumors that they
- 2:36were well robbers. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:40And also enemies. So yeah, this is the same woman.
- 2:46Well, police Nice. Okay, so it's it's the city in
- 2:52Gloucester, Gloucester Gloucester UK and they think
- 2:59that they have found the bones of one of his victims.
- 3:03Okay. Who has been missing since 1968
- 3:08like all his victims were young women?
- 3:09They both had very weird fixations on brutalizing women
- 3:13in many different ways Rape torture bondage, you name it.
- 3:19They were typically buried in the cellar of their home and
- 3:23Glock is Stir which that was referred to in the media.
- 3:27As like the House of Horrors. They were charged in 1994 and
- 3:31Fred hung himself while he was in prison in 1995, to avoid
- 3:38being charged with the nine women who were discovered on
- 3:41their property. Of course.
- 3:43Yeah. But yeah.
- 3:43So that's the news that's like This is today.
- 3:47So they're thinking it might be her body.
- 3:49They think it might be her body May 17 21 like this is happening
- 3:54this week. Nice.
- 3:55This is like pipe quite possibly.
- 3:57I'm like the first time but yeah.
- 4:00They have some ground-penetrating cameras and
- 4:04they appear to have discovered this like dark blue material
- 4:09that they think matched the coat of her name was Mary bastogne.
- 4:14She was 15 when she went missing.
- 4:15Oh, and yeah. This is 39.
- 4:23Well, it's this comes days after this, like police force of like
- 4:2639, different cops, led by a team of archaeologists began.
- 4:31Analyzing the basement of a cafe and God caster, which is about
- 4:35half a mile from the West's house.
- 4:39And essentially, Like West worked there when it was being
- 4:46built. So they think that he might have
- 4:49stored that's at this point. They're like, well, maybe some
- 4:51of the bodies, we haven't been able to find from him, are ones
- 4:54that he might have buried at some of the locations where he
- 5:00worked right when he was a builder.
- 5:02And that's not exactly something crazy.
- 5:05Because there was a man in California who they think buried
- 5:08bodies under highways, that he worked on in the 70s and That
- 5:13California has discussed the idea of trying to find those
- 5:16bodies but also that the costs but is so prohibitive that they
- 5:22might just leave them there. So, I mean, this isn't entirely
- 5:25in heard of, but yeah, they had cameras that have seen like a
- 5:28navy blue coat that she was wearing and they definitely
- 5:30think that they're seeing human bones there.
- 5:32So I mean, they're at this point.
- 5:34Now they're going to be looking at doing like a major excavation
- 5:37right? Yeah.
- 5:39But yeah. And of course, his wife is
- 5:43still, of course, in jail. Yeah.
- 5:45She's she's only 67. So she got plenty of years to be
- 5:49in prison and be dealing with the crimes that she committed
- 5:55and yeah, that's good. But yeah, it's like I was really
- 5:58excited when that popped up on my feet today I was like oh crap
- 6:03Serial killer do is we have it had some new serial, killer news
- 6:05and months. It's gonna be on every podcast
- 6:10that any of you listen to this week.
- 6:12That's how like hype most of us are going to be about But what
- 6:17did you come across this week? Okay, let me ask you a question.
- 6:23Sure. So for example, How would, how
- 6:31would you go about getting followers or you have followers
- 6:36on your Tick? Tock, like, if like, if you had
- 6:40to go out and like, I don't know, like, if you were like low
- 6:43on views and follows, how would you Brittany?
- 6:47Go out and find followers for Tick-Tock.
- 6:49I, I wouldn't go out and invite Tic-Tac followers because I
- 6:53would be, I'm strangely shy in person.
- 6:58You don't say so, The only thing I know how to do is what I do
- 7:02right now which is make daily content and hope hope somebody
- 7:09likes it. Okay?
- 7:10Okay. Well, there is a woman in
- 7:15Florida, Miami who posed as a student to promote her Instagram
- 7:21page. If you ain't saw this, somebody
- 7:25posted this on Twitter and it showed up in our feet of like
- 7:29People who we follow on Twitter, like one of those crime news
- 7:33aggregate blog thing. Yeah, I didn't click on it.
- 7:37Please tell me more about this lady.
- 7:40All right. So apparently she's 28 years old
- 7:42and she wanted to promote her Instagram page and she attempted
- 7:46to blend in with students at a Miami area high school.
- 7:50Wasn't there? A Drew Barrymore movie where she
- 7:52went back to the high school? Yeah she was a reporter was
- 7:55reporter. Yeah but still and everything
- 7:57kiss. We're having right?
- 7:59Right. That's it.
- 8:01That's get something like that, done.
- 8:02Like that with this. Good enough?
- 8:04Yeah. But yeah, this happened.
- 8:08I guess, I last Monday. Wow, so yeah, sure.
- 8:13It landed her in jail. So she's facing charges of
- 8:17burglary and it fearing with a school function and resisting
- 8:21arrest without violence. So let me read this.
- 8:27So she started hitting at her name, is who I can't pronounce
- 8:31that last name. Goodness gracious.
- 8:33Oh, it's her name is Audrey. Francisco!
- 8:37Whitney. Yeah, I'm going with that.
- 8:42Yes. Uh-huh.
- 8:44So apparently she started handing out pantless at you
- 8:47know, for her Instagram. Okay.
- 8:49You can't do that. That's not how you.
- 8:50Yes, not cool. Can you imagine being like, what
- 8:54is the equivalent of when we were in high school of the
- 8:56person who hands Pamphlets about their Instagram recruiters,
- 8:59these look like that. It's even worse because that's a
- 9:02hey, sign up for potentially die for college.
- 9:06Yeah, no I'm trying to think of like what would have been
- 9:08equally as uncool as handing out a pamphlet for your social
- 9:12media. Oh, putting up flyers and I feel
- 9:16like, yeah. A flyer for a party.
- 9:19Yeah. At a high school.
- 9:20That would have been like cringy.
- 9:22Let me tell you for like, we had this one.
- 9:25Like and Senior year, right? Okay.
- 9:26So seeing you here, I'm just like comedian now.
- 9:29Okay, this is my Persona. I've taken along because I'm
- 9:32funny as guy anyway, I think you're funny.
- 9:37Oh, my one teacher, she suggested that I like start an
- 9:40improv group of people. So I put up flyers for like
- 9:45improv, okay. That's different cause that's
- 9:47like a school function if our school functions but can you
- 9:50imagine was like there's gonna be a rager at Brian's house.
- 9:54Here's a flyer like Say those kinds of words and no, no, I
- 10:00just pulled like a total like 80s phrase, out of nowhere.
- 10:03I'm not that old y'all. We didn't have ragers but I'm
- 10:08just saying that's how the equivalent of leg you you
- 10:10handing someone a flyer to come to your party tomorrow?
- 10:12Yeah. It feels awkward like like hey
- 10:15come to my party. Hey come to my party.
- 10:17He's like listen you can come don't tell anybody else and then
- 10:22of course everybody shows up because no one could keep a
- 10:24secret in high school. This is how that goes, yeah,
- 10:28sure trip. But yeah, she snuck on the
- 10:31campus at 8:30 a.m. she had a black backpack, and she carried
- 10:36a skateboard. She walking the whole shoe
- 10:40recording herself as she was doing this.
- 10:44She had a black backpack. If she cares game for, she act
- 10:47like a total like I guess that's what she taught high schoolers.
- 10:49I don't, how old is she 28 28? Come on now.
- 10:52No, no, no. Even when that cause that's only
- 10:54a couple years younger than Us and like I don't nobody was
- 10:58wearing not even when we were Highschool.
- 11:01No, nobody was you. I mean okay.
- 11:03Skateboard. Yes, very 90s.
- 11:05Like, okay, when we were in school, people dress like
- 11:09skaters. Yeah, but they didn't like skate
- 11:11through the hallways of the school.
- 11:12That's very like movie 90s movies Centric.
- 11:16But like, yeah, sure. Like people wore like skater
- 11:18clothes, like, one of my co-workers, got his like, very
- 11:20cool like skater Vibes. Like, I'm like, this is
- 11:23obviously, like, who he is outside of work and I'm a, you
- 11:25know, Bryant. I'm a giant fruit Pop-Tart of a
- 11:30person. This is Lisa.
- 11:32It like, you know, yet Lisa Frank.
- 11:34These are frankly staff Rankin, Miss frazil.
- 11:36That's really what I work with as you so you know like we all
- 11:39have little bits of that like from our high school identities,
- 11:42you do who we are now. But like I don't think even
- 11:46people who were skateboarders like Tony Hawk.
- 11:49He is a skateboarder, he's not like oh let me walk through this
- 11:52area with my board on my arm like it.
- 12:03But yeah. So apparently let's see.
- 12:05What is this? A school security tracked her
- 12:07down? As she wandered hallways while
- 12:09students were in their classrooms and she was heading
- 12:13towards the registration office but she did not enter instead
- 12:16she continued walking through the hallways talking to students
- 12:19news outlets reported. So she never went to any
- 12:22classes. No, no, of course not.
- 12:23You have to act like you're actually in high school You're
- 12:26trying to act like you're in high school. 28.
- 12:28Come on now. I'm free.
- 12:29I mean she could probably like at 18 years old.
- 12:31I need to I need to know what she looks like.
- 12:33Now I don't think there's a picture of her.
- 12:35I could have sworn. It was a picture.
- 12:36Okay, not on this one. I got this one off the
- 12:37Associated. Press press.
- 12:42But as she kept walking security officers, still try to catch up
- 12:45with her. You know, that's bad.
- 12:47That's like it's terrible because Like that's shorter.
- 12:52I don't know. Like nowadays, you know, what?
- 12:54School shooters and stuff like that.
- 12:55You can't just be like I have like little logins.
- 12:59Exact, thanks to open doors, like you can't just be walking
- 13:01in the schools like that. Like, that's not okay.
- 13:05What'd she look like you could give me a face.
- 13:07She looks like a mother of three.
- 13:10Oh, come on. Yeah, the guy high school
- 13:12student Advocate teenager. Come on.
- 13:15Oh my god. Listen and I get it.
- 13:17Hispanic and black people aged very well.
- 13:20But, huh? Honey, you look like you have at
- 13:22least one or two babies. Yeah.
- 13:27Apparently the school system is going through.
- 13:30They're going to be reviewing how she got into the school.
- 13:34She got onto the property, you know, and was able to evade
- 13:39security settings brand, they don't they don't run.
- 13:43They just kind of jump my God. It but yeah, it was just like
- 13:46it's hilarious. And then finally authorities
- 13:49tracked, her down for her Instagram page.
- 13:50Interested her of Monday last Monday at her house.
- 13:54Oh man. So she got away from the
- 13:58security officers in school but she got she went home and then
- 14:01he found her anyway through her Instagram that she.
- 14:03You know, she was trying to promote.
- 14:05I want to see her Instagram. I bet it's Wack.
- 14:08He kind of look up her face, I don't know.
- 14:10I bet you if I pulled this up on Reddit, somebody found her over.
- 14:14I think about it now she probably has like a million
- 14:16followers. I feel like she probably has a
- 14:20bunch of Of gems ears and her comment roast in her.
- 14:23Yeah. Probably.
- 14:23They just roast all of us. I mean, that's like she did have
- 14:26a side part though. Oh she does see we have a side.
- 14:30Part was a side parting. No, it was.
- 14:33My parts are bad and so are skinny jeans.
- 14:35Damn her damn Millennials. Then our what you gonna do?
- 14:42Let us live our lives. I'm good.
- 14:46That's a thing. People are like, I'm like, this
- 14:47is our I hate to say and that situation that happened with
- 14:50Millennials versus Zoomers. It was people were like side
- 14:56parts of skinny jeans. I'm like, this seems like a
- 14:59thing that like, I hate to say it this way, but it seems like a
- 15:02thing that like, the white people are arguing about because
- 15:05amongst like, the minority community.
- 15:07No one's like trash talking like Zoomers.
- 15:11Know, we're more. Like, I like your style.
- 15:13Pretty cool. Yeah, your hair's dope like you
- 15:16didn't he like it's all very like Good Vibes in our
- 15:19community. I don't know why.
- 15:20I like all the white Zoomers and Millennials are fighting right
- 15:23now. Y'all need to stop.
- 15:25Oh no. I know.
- 15:25I know those gen Z kids. They do love my hair now so you
- 15:29have magnificent hair. I do have wonderful beautiful
- 15:32hair. It's a dollar to touch by the
- 15:35way, you better charge one. That's right, no paid a mick.
- 15:40Pandemic fee, there you go. Five extra dollars.
- 15:47Oh my God. When Killers get caught is
- 15:56sponsored by the magic class Boutique.
- 16:00Now, why does that name sound so familiar?
- 16:03Well, it's because as a business ran by our very own Britney,
- 16:08that's right into the magic class.
- 16:10Boutique is not only a black-owned business.
- 16:12It's a woman-owned is well, this is a jewelry company and I make
- 16:16some pretty awesome earrings. Reading from cute little sushis
- 16:192spooky mermaid skeletons. There are even adorable, son Of
- 16:24Defense key change for those, just in case moments, and
- 16:29introducing this Arrow collection, this set of earrings
- 16:32is based off of serial killers and the official merch for the
- 16:37podcast, The Collection features, everything, a serial
- 16:42killer would need to pull off their crimes from hunting knives
- 16:45at the beginning of the crimes to Warden keys for when they
- 16:49eventually get caught. Check out the magic class.com
- 16:53today where you can use our promo, code caught to receive
- 16:5815% off of your online order. That's th e magicc, elas p.com
- 17:08and use promo code cult for 15% off and make sure you tell
- 17:11Brittany that I sent you. So let's get through this
- 17:22horrible story, you talking about, it's not okay there's
- 17:25just a little bit of horribleness which is, you know,
- 17:27the whole parent killing their children aspect.
- 17:31But so this happened when I was probably this would have been
- 17:37before I started High School. Okay.
- 17:41This sort of been like spring of a, the grade for me, you say I
- 17:44you mean we don't know. I wasn't sure if I could
- 17:48remember. I was like technically a year
- 17:50ahead. And because I have a late
- 17:51birthday. Dear me?
- 17:53Yes. Yes.
- 17:53It's a year of school but we're like Danny of the same age.
- 17:56Yeah, but yeah. So I'm just going to, I'm going
- 18:01to set a stage And I'll go into more about these people.
- 18:05Okay? So it was approximately 10 a.m.
- 18:07June 20th 2001, A Man, by the name of Rusty Gates.
- 18:11Gets a phone call from his wife, he'd only been at work for about
- 18:14an hour. She just said, you need to come
- 18:16home confused. He was just like what's going on
- 18:21and she's like, you need to come home, it's time, I did it.
- 18:26He knew that she'd been struggling recently and dealing
- 18:29with her depression and so he asked her again, what's wrong?
- 18:33And she said it's the children. And the NASA engineer realized
- 18:41something was very wrong. And he said, which one and which
- 18:46Andrea Yates responded? All of them.
- 18:50Oh, when he reached his house, 15 minutes later, they were
- 18:54ambulances. And police cars at his home in
- 18:57Houston, Texas. A Time article said that when he
- 19:02wasn't allowed into the house, he went to the back door and
- 19:06screamed. How could you do this?
- 19:08Collapse in the yard and the fetal position pounding, the
- 19:11ground as his wife. Andrea Yates was led away in
- 19:15handcuffs today. I am discussing a crime.
- 19:18Like I said, I didn't happen that long ago for both you and I
- 19:22the case surrounding Andrea Gates and the murder of her five
- 19:25children on June 20th, 2001. It was a bit of a landmark case
- 19:31and trial surrounding the discussion of real.
- 19:33Mental health issues for mothers in a state known to Be very
- 19:38aggressive in handling it handing out Capital sentences
- 19:43for murder but like every week before I discuss the crime and
- 19:49inevitably the lengthy and convoluted trial, let's just
- 19:54talk about Andrea Yates and who she was before this day.
- 20:02I found her strangely sympathetic and I didn't expect
- 20:07to you, okay? I heard she's born Andrea Pia.
- 20:11Kennedy on July 2nd, 1964 and Hallsville Texas.
- 20:16She was born to German immigrant kuta, jutta, Karen Koller and
- 20:22Andrew and Mike. Kennedy who is second generation
- 20:24Irish that you had five children and Andrea was their youngest
- 20:29They were a devout Catholic Family and Andrea was very
- 20:32active in church and Charities. As a young child, she was
- 20:36incredibly considered to be very, very smart.
- 20:40But her troubles with her mental health began, rather Young Some
- 20:46people speculate that it's kind of like what happens with a lot
- 20:50of teenagers. You're very smart driven,
- 20:53super-active. You feel this pressure to be
- 20:56perfect? She was in like the National
- 21:01Honor Society. She graduated from high school
- 21:03as for valedictorian and of course, doing really knows when
- 21:08you're struggling with that. Kind of stuff that behind that
- 21:10like perfect facade is somebody who's struggling to look perfect
- 21:14and also be perfect. Right?
- 21:16Right. So she did struggle with both
- 21:18bulimia and depression and actually was suicidal.
- 21:21When she was in high school, she did not receive treatment for
- 21:26any of these issues while she was a child and very much
- 21:29endured a lot. a lot of these things in silence, I can't say
- 21:33that at that time in our history that there would have been a
- 21:40whole lot of resources for her either.
- 21:43No. After High School, she applied
- 21:47to the University of Houston to become a nurse, perhaps kind of
- 21:51free from some of that parental stress.
- 21:53She didn't struggle as much with her mental health in college.
- 21:56She finished her program and just two years and accepted a
- 21:59job at the MD Anderson Cancer, Center caring for cancer
- 22:02patients. It was part of the medical
- 22:04facility, that was attached to her school and she would work
- 22:08there her entire career as a nurse from 1986 to 1994.
- 22:13As somebody who had really serious body image issue, she
- 22:16didn't really date a whole lot but she met her future, husband,
- 22:20Rusty Gates, and the summer of 1989, she was swimming at the
- 22:25pool in her apartment complex and he saw her and liked her as
- 22:29many young men are want to do of course.
- 22:32Yes, they move it together. Fairly shortly after that, a
- 22:36couple months later, and Rusty. Said that his name is Russell,
- 22:42but I will continue to call him Rusty as they do.
- 22:44And all of the books that I read on this, He said that she was
- 22:50always very uncomfortable being naked around him, she would get
- 22:53dressed and undressed in the closet and she never seemed to
- 22:56enjoy sex. Some people say that this is due
- 23:01to her Catholic upbringing and you know, extremely religious
- 23:05families can be very overbearing when it comes to young women.
- 23:07Sexualities other people have brought up that this could also
- 23:11be a symptom of mental illness. That was also overlooked rather
- 23:16early in her. I guess her young, adult life
- 23:20personally, I can't imagine feeling very sexy when your
- 23:24boyfriend is into the religious stuff that Rusty was in two.
- 23:28And I know I need to go into this because Shapes who this
- 23:32woman becomes so Rusty. Was a big follower of this
- 23:36preacher named Michael warneke who was a traveling preacher.
- 23:41That was big into like the fire and brimstone, you know?
- 23:45And of course like it's hard to know with all the different
- 23:47preachers like this in the 80s and 90s.
- 23:50Like this was a big deal for a long time.
- 23:52They were like be on TV on Sunday and those big mega
- 23:56churches. Those kinds of people in the
- 23:58freaking, like, turd something. Does mega church creators.
- 24:01I don't think we're in a key created like a mega church but
- 24:04he did have the same kind of fundamental most views.
- 24:09So Michael and Rusty met during the 80s and the two started
- 24:13writing letters back and forth to each other and they kind of
- 24:15became sort of religious friends.
- 24:18And we're Nicky had some very horrible views about women.
- 24:25He preached that women were evil witches and they were born evil
- 24:30because of Eve that women shouldn't educate themselves.
- 24:34They should never work outside of the home and should never use
- 24:37birth control. Wives should submit to their
- 24:40husbands fully. And you know that old adage we
- 24:43were taught as kids, children should be seen and not heard
- 24:46totally believe in that too. Uh-huh.
- 24:47And if you needed to keep your child silent.
- 24:50Absolutely. You know what's that Fraser?
- 24:53You don't spare the rod spoil the child.
- 24:55Yeah that that was part of his ideology to.
- 24:57Yeah. Opens.
- 24:59So Rusty comes into this relationship with this intense
- 25:03fundamentalist, Christian Vibe and introduces Andrea to it.
- 25:09And strangely enough, the two of them spend like a lot of their
- 25:12free time just studying the Bible and praying when they live
- 25:14together. Rusty, was very serious about
- 25:18his religion, his relationship with Andrea and so he actually
- 25:21introduced her to warneke weirdly enough.
- 25:26We're in a key, gave them solid advice and was like, you
- 25:30shouldn't get married quickly, which was apparently, a lot of
- 25:33the advice he gave to young couples, he met on college
- 25:35campuses, which is so wild because I was, like, here's
- 25:38this, And with this horrible crazy, like religious message,
- 25:44given actual dollops of good advice here and there.
- 25:47Yeah, like know, when you are 22, you definitely probably
- 25:51shouldn't get married. No, don't do it Andrea.
- 25:57And Rusty, did not take the preachers advice and instead it
- 25:59got married. Two years later.
- 26:01April 17th 1983. Well doing it very quickly, they
- 26:04waited two years for them. I think this was probably, as I
- 26:08They waited as long as they possibly could, as long as they
- 26:11want, yeah, they're like this. Give us some time, okay.
- 26:13Okay, you good. Yeah, they were, like, you know,
- 26:15he's like, wait, longer they were, like, no, we had this.
- 26:18We waited long enough to years is long enough who enter our
- 26:22lives to be together. Come on now.
- 26:24But, you know, what's so funny? I went to a Catholic High School
- 26:26and I distinctly have a very solid memory of one of my
- 26:30religion classes. I think it was sophomore year
- 26:32for some reason. My one religion teacher like
- 26:35went off on a rant about how you shouldn't, just get married to
- 26:38have sex. And one of the boys in my class
- 26:40raised his hand and he was just like, then, why get married.
- 26:45Ha ha ha and mind you. We were 15 and 16 years old.
- 26:49So, of course, in a 15 and 16 roll brain, that makes sense.
- 26:52But I have a friend who's very religious and she goes on like
- 26:55Christian Mingle and stuff. And there are a lot of people
- 26:57with this mindset, like I just have to get married so I can
- 27:01just start having sex. Yeah, because it's not.
- 27:04Okay for me to do it outside of that.
- 27:07So like maybe that was part. Out of this to like why they
- 27:10were rushing and why he was telling so many of his
- 27:13followers, like, don't rush into this, they'll be plenty of time
- 27:16for you, do all the things you want to do in your life and
- 27:20then, you know, people are just like, well, I can't do what I
- 27:22want, ha ha ha, because God, what was it?
- 27:24Let's be because, yeah, I'll be a sinner and go to hell.
- 27:28Oh, no. Because like, they literally
- 27:29told their wedding guests that they wanted as many babies as
- 27:34nature would allow season. That's order thinking about,
- 27:37that's all they were thinking of give me.
- 27:39That's why I said that, of course, now, married to Rusty,
- 27:42Andrea, quits her job as a nurse, and she gets immediately
- 27:45pregnant with their son. Noah, he was born February 1994
- 27:50and almost immediately after his birth, Andrea begins, having
- 27:55visions of knives and stabbing her loved ones.
- 27:59She also heard voices but she kept this to herself, Down to
- 28:04one income, they have to move from their nice four-bedroom
- 28:07house in Houston to a trailer in Seminole, Florida for a temp
- 28:12job, that Rusty took and like this is the, the not smartness
- 28:16of this whole concept of the man needs to be the provider.
- 28:19Exactly. I absolutely support the idea
- 28:22that a man as a provider. If he's got the job to provide
- 28:26for this family. Exactly.
- 28:28And I'm just like, you going to make me, give up my job and now
- 28:32we broke. This is terrible.
- 28:35And as soon as you like it don't have kids.
- 28:37Thank you. All right, you got all this
- 28:38money. You got to spend on this now but
- 28:40either way. Exactly, from four bedroom to a
- 28:43trailer. Come on.
- 28:44I mean it's nothing wrong. Trailers at all because there's
- 28:46some nice. That's a nice one.
- 28:47Oh, hell yeah. I know leopard trailers are
- 28:50nicer than what I live in but now I Like they move into this
- 28:55really actually, from what I understand the trailer was
- 28:57smaller than the apartment. We are in right now.
- 28:59Oh damn. And this apartment is 410 square
- 29:02feet and it's a studio. Oh, so the one that you're in
- 29:07right now, we're yeah. There's was 350.
- 29:11That that trailer and she had two more babies.
- 29:16No. Yes, she did.
- 29:20Two more sense. I December of 1995.
- 29:22John was born, and then September of 1887 Paul was born,
- 29:27so that's Mom. A toddler.
- 29:34A baby and a newborn and Dad and an apartment smaller than where
- 29:39we are right now, they all sleep in the same bed, I've had one
- 29:43person, stay the night with me over the like weekend here and
- 29:47it's cramped. Like you like one more than one
- 29:50day and all of a sudden, I'm like, you need to go home.
- 29:56I just can't imagine two adults and three kids in this space.
- 29:59No, just imagine having to sleep in the same bed, kids kicking
- 30:02your ribs and your backing like smacking you in the face when
- 30:05you're trying to sleep. What I live with my sister, I
- 30:07used to watch like we work different shifts.
- 30:09So I work during the day and she worked at night and her son, I
- 30:13would like sleep, I would like lay in bed next to him.
- 30:17I could never sleep comfortably. You want this baby next to me?
- 30:21I was convinced. He was going to fall out the Ed.
- 30:24I was going roll over him and kill him.
- 30:26Like something was going to happen, that's bad.
- 30:28It was constantly me like nodding off for a couple minutes
- 30:30and then waking up and looking at them.
- 30:33And then fall back asleep and waking up at looking.
- 30:35It was the most unknown like restful sleep of my life
- 30:42watching. This Nike six-month-old baby,
- 30:45they were hurt. You believe me and he was hot,
- 30:48he's always hot. I really have any would somehow
- 30:51may. I should take up like half of a
- 30:53full size bed. Yeah, are so small.
- 30:55What is wrong with you? Yeah, that's what they do.
- 30:57But back on to Andrea and Rusty, they kept up with the war in a
- 31:04key family through letters and videos.
- 31:06Um, and for some reason, Michael Wernicke kept diagnosing Andrea
- 31:11as evil and telling her that her life was cursed.
- 31:15I really couldn't find a reason for this and like I went through
- 31:19a lot of sources. I've heard two different books
- 31:21for this but then you say you said, well women are evil and he
- 31:24did say all women are even, but like I felt like it was almost
- 31:27like Like personal. like I can only imagine what kind of effect
- 31:32this must have been having on Andrea because Michael is like
- 31:35the leader of this little church and he set himself up to be like
- 31:38the voice of God and she's getting constant messages from
- 31:42the voice of God saying that God hates you like So, 98 the gates
- 31:50family visits the war in a keys in Miami, because Michaels gonna
- 31:53sell his motor home. And by motor home, I mean, a
- 31:57Greyhound bus that he converted into a little apartment to
- 32:01travel across the country and preach from.
- 32:04They stay there for about a week and during that time, Michael
- 32:08and Rusty got into a fight in another stunning bit of wisdom.
- 32:14Michael said that Rusty was neglecting his family for his
- 32:18Year and sacrificing his wife and children.
- 32:22Hmm, Rusty. Did not agree that leaving
- 32:25Andrea with a newborn toddler and preschool or every day in a
- 32:29tiny house. Was it all bad?
- 32:30No, not at all and Rusty. Michael kind of stopped being
- 32:34friendly after this, russki Rusty, like talked about this
- 32:39later on and like said that they like drifted apart, but it seems
- 32:43like he wasn't open to even a religious figure telling him
- 32:47that he need to be a better husband and father.
- 32:50Oh my God. So you weren't trying to change.
- 32:52You just want to have kids and just keep doing what you're
- 32:55doing. Basically after they bought the
- 32:57mobile home, they moved back to Houston to put it, simply Andrea
- 33:02was overwhelmed. She had to home-school the
- 33:06oldest boy. Breastfeed keep a toddler
- 33:08occupied feed. Her family, wash cloth diapers
- 33:13to save money. She was also caring for her own
- 33:15father who had Alzheimer's Oh no.
- 33:18Friends of their family of the family.
- 33:20Tried to tell Rusty. This is too much for one person
- 33:23to handle, but he wouldn't listen and he was just like,
- 33:25this is Andrews job as a wife and a mother.
- 33:30Well yeah, they were still following the Wernicke's church
- 33:34and Andrea was still receiving guidance from them that she need
- 33:37to beat her children more often. And that, like, normal child
- 33:41behavior was disrespectful. They also were consistently
- 33:45telling her that like not hitting her kids.
- 33:48Was damning them to Hell. Well then I guess my kids are
- 33:52going to have right Andrea had therefore child Luca February of
- 33:581989. When Luke was four months old
- 34:01and recalled Rusty and was just like I can't take this when
- 34:06Rusty got home. She was sitting in the corner
- 34:08like in an almost catatonic State she'd been chewing on her
- 34:11fingers for hours. Rusty was like you know we
- 34:15should do we're gonna take a nice family walk on the beach.
- 34:18Beach, that'll fix, you know and um, seeing as Rusty's, not at
- 34:21all, a mental health, professional the next day, she
- 34:24attempted to kill herself for the first time she was admitted
- 34:28to hospice. She, I think she tried to use
- 34:30her father's medicine to have an overdose.
- 34:34She was admitted to a hospital and prescribed antidepressants.
- 34:38This was the first time in her life that she was diagnosed with
- 34:41major depressive disorder, the whole Hospital wanted to hold
- 34:44her longer to see if the meds were going to have some help.
- 34:48But unfortunately, as anybody, who has been on where they
- 34:53ssris, I think it's what their official term is for them, but
- 34:56there are serotonin receptor Inhibitors.
- 35:01I think called ssris these take weeks to take effect.
- 35:06Oh, in fact, one of the things I tell you, when you're on them
- 35:09because I also have major depressive disorder.
- 35:13They ask like my doctors would ask, like, repeatedly are you
- 35:16feeling suicidal? Here's why, because you're
- 35:20inside a really dark place and you get this medication and it
- 35:23starts working on your brain, right?
- 35:24But it takes such a long time to pull you out and like
- 35:27essentially, like kind of give your brain the serotonin that
- 35:31it's needing, right? That sometimes you only feel
- 35:35like sort of good, you don't feel like real good yet but you
- 35:39feel like good enough that if you are suicidal you might
- 35:42decide to actually do it. Oh yes.
- 35:45You've got enough motivation. Now to hurt.
- 35:48Yourself, but not enough motivation to go to work or
- 35:52clean. Your house will be motivations
- 35:54you not doing in this. It's one of the things that is,
- 35:57it's part of the warnings. So that repeatedly, they were
- 36:00like, you have more energy now, don't you Brittany?
- 36:03And I was like, yes, you're not see, they were like constantly
- 36:07checking with me, so then they should have done here.
- 36:12Because they sent her home because her insurance didn't
- 36:17cover any more inpatient days, some of that's going to be a
- 36:21consistent thing that pops up at This Woman's life insurance.
- 36:25But her insurance limiting, the amount of care she can access,
- 36:29lovely. She did briefly visit with
- 36:31another doctor who put her on an anti-psychotic drug.
- 36:37But the Warren Equis believe that medicine and drugs were the
- 36:41tool of the devil. So she flushed them come on
- 36:45before. She could even really know
- 36:47whether this was going to help her.
- 36:49Oh my God, things got worse for Andrea.
- 36:53She was pulling out her hair and clumps picking at her skin until
- 36:56it bled. The voices that come back.
- 36:58She'd stopped eating entirely one night, Rusty came home from
- 37:02work and he found Andrea holding a knife to her throat and she
- 37:06was begging. Being Rusty to let her and her
- 37:09life. She was hospitalized again and
- 37:13given an antipsychotic medicine was called, like Haldol.
- 37:19This is the one that had the best effect on her.
- 37:22She approved immediately and they said home friends.
- 37:27And family were like, this is definitely the bus you living on
- 37:31this stupid bus with four children is causing trouble.
- 37:34So Rusty bought a three-bedroom house in clear Texas.
- 37:38And for a little bit of time, Andrew was doing, all right.
- 37:41She was seeing a doctor bi-weekly.
- 37:43She had a washer and dryer, she was on good medication.
- 37:46Yes, they are on the up-and-up doctors work, couldn't they
- 37:51were? They thought that this was
- 37:53postpartum, depression, made worse by her, major depressive
- 37:58disorder, and the gates were advised, they should either
- 38:02abstain, for set from sex, or Andrea should stay on birth
- 38:06control. They did actually opted to
- 38:10ignore the church and go on birth control, right?
- 38:15But they didn't stick with this very long.
- 38:17Yeah. You know what would help?
- 38:19What him? Get a goddamn vasectomy.
- 38:24No. Because remember they want
- 38:26babies but there's supposed to be a controlled, get a goddamn
- 38:30vasectomy. You got enough kids already.
- 38:33Nope not enough. So one of the things we know now
- 38:36is that women who Suffer from postpartum already higher risk
- 38:40of getting in again during subsequent pregnancies and the
- 38:43episodes tend to get worse each, with each pregnancy, Andrea was
- 38:49on the way to recovery, but another birth would absolutely
- 38:52destroy the progress. She had made.
- 38:55So they were advised. You should stop having kids
- 38:57right now. Give it a couple years.
- 38:58You're still pretty young, you know, let Andrea get more
- 39:01stable. Do you want to know how quickly
- 39:05they decided that they should have another kid?
- 39:07This is a week later. Seven weeks.
- 39:10After she was discharged, God, Rusty kind of looked at it.
- 39:16Andrea's mental illness and postpartum and the suicide
- 39:19attempts is like kind of like her having the flu and that's
- 39:22literally a direct quote, just like the flu.
- 39:25Come on. His thought was, if she relapses
- 39:27has, we'll just go back to the hospital and get new maps.
- 39:29No, that's not how it works, though.
- 39:31It's not how that works and that's definitely something he
- 39:33In realize which is that like the kind of medications that
- 39:35she's on take a while to set in and she's going to have to come
- 39:39off of them to get pregnant and going off of these meds, very
- 39:44quickly is very dangerous. Yeah, I can imagine so yes, she
- 39:48stopped taking her medication, seven weeks, after being
- 39:50discharged from the hospital in 2000, and she had her fifth
- 39:54child Mary in November of 2000. Oh, finally a girl.
- 39:59She, she actually seemed to be doing, all right?
- 40:03Though there was like a weird situation where she tried to
- 40:05feed like a very young baby, real food and the baby like
- 40:10start choking. I don't know why she was doing
- 40:13that but also like this is a woman clearly in distress.
- 40:16Yeah, but March 2001, Andrea's father dies.
- 40:22She starts picking at her skin, pulling out her hair again,
- 40:25ignoring her own health for the next few months.
- 40:29She's in and out of psychiatric facilities.
- 40:31On a revolving door of medicines, trying to find the
- 40:34right combination here. Doctors, tell Rusty, do not
- 40:38leave. Andrea alone at all.
- 40:42Something that Rusty ignored. He arranged for his mother to
- 40:46come and watch the kids with Andrea, but he still left her
- 40:49alone for small. Bouts of time.
- 40:51He thought that she would become dependent on him and his mother
- 40:55for help with her wifely duties. Dude, they told you not to leave
- 40:59her alone for a reason April 2001.
- 41:04She began seeing a new doctor. His name is dr.
- 41:06Mohammad Sayeed a month after that.
- 41:10May 3rd, 2001. She regresses to almost a
- 41:13catatonic State. When afternoon Rusty's mom, her
- 41:16name is Dora Yates finds her. She had filled the The bathtub
- 41:21in the middle of the afternoon and when Dora was like, what's
- 41:27the bathtub for? She is just like I just wanted
- 41:30to of course later on Andrea would say that that was enough,
- 41:34that was a day that she had intended on killing the children
- 41:37but she changed her mind. She and tell her children that
- 41:43at all. I shouldn't tell the doctors at
- 41:44it. Of course, of course she was
- 41:46hospitalized. Again, the next day, the
- 41:48psychiatrist there are met for thought she was suicidal and
- 41:53they thought that the tub had been for her.
- 41:58Rusty was useless and actually, quite frustrating through this
- 42:02whole process. He actually told Andrea at one
- 42:04point that she should think happy thoughts.
- 42:07I'm gonna punch you in the nuts. Three common phrase of
- 42:10neurotypical. People who do not understand how
- 42:12any of this works at. All right, there you can Sucker
- 42:16Punch right in your boys. Yeah.
- 42:19God, he's super, super frustrating.
- 42:22Andrea continued to see, dr. Syed.
- 42:24Until June 20th 2001. When she was arrested that De
- 42:27Rossi left for work. He left her alone to watch the
- 42:30children, which was directly against sites.
- 42:33Instructions Rusty's. Mother Dora was scheduled to get
- 42:36there at 10:00 a.m. to help her for the rest of the day.
- 42:39So Rusty, was only going to be gone for an hour.
- 42:42They could have stayed that damn our I think so too.
- 42:48This is the part where I'm going to explain what happens?
- 42:53I have no issue with you. Skipping over like the next like
- 42:57Four minutes. To anyone listening?
- 43:01Yeah. She filled the bathtub with
- 43:04water and she drowned a five year old John first, then she
- 43:11carried him. Hugh her and Rusty's bedroom,
- 43:13laid him on the bed, covered him with the sheet, she did this
- 43:16again to Paul who was three, Luke who was too and then six
- 43:20month old Mary while she was in the process of drowning, Mary
- 43:25Noah walked into the bathroom. He was now 7 and he was like,
- 43:30what's wrong with Barry? Little boy, tried to run away,
- 43:34but Andrea caught him and drowned him to.
- 43:39She left his body in the tub and took Mary and laid him in John's
- 43:43arms. Andrew called the police.
- 43:52The I actually saw the transcript of the call to the
- 43:59police. It was very weird.
- 44:01She was just like, I need him to come and they were like the 911.
- 44:05Operators, like, who, who do you need to come?
- 44:08And she's like, my husband, and he's like, she's a car.
- 44:10You? Okay.
- 44:11Are you ill? And she said, yes, I'm Ill.
- 44:15And They're like, do you need a police officer?
- 44:21Oh, gee. A firefighter.
- 44:23And she's just like, yes, firefighters should come.
- 44:26Send an ambulance to And then she called her husband.
- 44:33Hmm again I already told you the situation where she told them
- 44:38it's time. Yeah.
- 44:40When the police arrived Andrea was still wet and she greeted
- 44:44them at the door, she said very calmly.
- 44:46I just killed my kids. Then she sat down in the living
- 44:50room and the officers checked. Every account that I read of
- 44:55this, and I don't go, I don't have any, I don't go to into
- 44:58details on this in my notes, but that it was a very, just a
- 45:02life-altering experience for the police officers, who checked
- 45:09horrible to walk in, and see the little boy in the tub.
- 45:15And then to walk down the hall and see the other four children
- 45:17laid out, She told she spoke to detective.
- 45:24His name was Ed, Mel saying I'm a bad mother and I deserve to be
- 45:28punished. She didn't struggle with the
- 45:30police as the EMTs came into the house.
- 45:32To see if her children were still alive, she just looked
- 45:35kind of blankly at her neighbors as they led her away.
- 45:39The police reported that, this is the part that really like
- 45:42annoyed me, I just really frustrated me because Rusty was
- 45:45like, you're not living up to your wifely duties.
- 45:47I'm like, bro. Nobody was doing anything in the
- 45:49house because don't lie. They said the house was like
- 45:52just super cluttered dishes were everywhere.
- 45:55Everything was super messy. like, if she's in such a state
- 46:01where she can do nothing, Like, what wifely duties, do you
- 46:08think? She's like, becoming dependent
- 46:10on you? She can't even wash a dish.
- 46:13That's a whole different level. Yeah.
- 46:16But the children were confirmed dead when the The medical
- 46:22examiner. Got there.
- 46:25Rusty was not allowed to enter the home for five hours.
- 46:28He told the police that his wife was depressed and that she was
- 46:31on medication at the police station.
- 46:35They recorded an interview of Andrea Yates and she confessed,
- 46:40she's like nearly emaciated at this point she is like
- 46:45stuttering. She is, filthy, her scalp is
- 46:49covered in bald patches from her.
- 46:51Pulling her hair out and scabs from her like Like scratching at
- 46:55her scalp, on top of that, the recorded confession was bizarre,
- 47:00it was a mixture of her discussing what she did.
- 47:03But also it was like all of that, like religious mumbo-jumbo
- 47:09Twisted into it. Like this, that she'd like
- 47:12internalized over the lack last eight years of being with Rusty,
- 47:17like she told him, she killed her children because she was a
- 47:19bad mother. She explained exactly.
- 47:21Like, I told you in detail like, which one, and how she did it?
- 47:25She told the police, like, they were like, well, did the
- 47:27children do anything wrong? She's like, no, she's like, mm,
- 47:32were you mad at them? She's like, no, they weren't
- 47:35developing correctly. And so, they're like, what does
- 47:38that mean? And she's just like, well, you
- 47:40know, I've been thinking about Doing this for the last two
- 47:42years and that she said that she needed to be punished for not,
- 47:47raising them correctly, and the officer realized that she wanted
- 47:52the criminal justice system to punish her for being a bad mom.
- 47:55According to her own religion, she was sure that if things went
- 47:59on the way they were going, her evilness would, in fact, these
- 48:03children and they would never get to go to heaven, she
- 48:06believed that just like the war in Equis.
- 48:08Told her, she was damned, but at least she could save her
- 48:11children. From Souls.
- 48:13She said that she had nearly killed him two months ago,
- 48:16chant, but changed her mind. Gave him a name of her current
- 48:18psychiatrist. She said she hadn't killed them
- 48:21because someone was at home with her at the time, the officer
- 48:25interviewing her, shut off the recording, 18 minutes later
- 48:30after asking, Andrea to give all the birth dates of her children.
- 48:33So for his records that day, she was charged with two counts of
- 48:38capital, murder for intentionally and knowingly
- 48:41called. The death of three of her
- 48:42children with water as the weapon.
- 48:45There was no mention on this report at all, of her mental
- 48:49illness. Exactly, on the flip side, Rusty
- 48:56began telling the press that she had been dealing with serious
- 48:58mental health issues, since the birth of their fourth child in
- 49:011989. Dr. Syed called Rusty the day of
- 49:06the murders and was shocked. He was like, doctors.
- 49:09I eat was under the belief that Rusty's mother lived there with
- 49:12them. And she was always there, right?
- 49:15Not that she was showing up every morning and then going
- 49:18home and I mean, yeah, the latter would make sense and
- 49:21former will make sense. One day because this is like a
- 49:27media Firestorm at this part. No one can imagine this.
- 49:29You know, horrible thing happened and beautiful medical
- 49:32Middle America. One day Rusty, goes outside with
- 49:36a picture of his family, and tells the group of reporters
- 49:39everything he remembers from that day and he publicly
- 49:42supports Andrea telling the reporter.
- 49:44She's a good. Mom, she just wasn't in her
- 49:46right frame of mind. June, 22nd and reappears in
- 49:51front of Johnny Belinda Hill and listens to prosecutor kahlan
- 49:55will afford. It was well for its first
- 49:57capital, murder case, and whole she gave it everything she had.
- 50:01No Andrea said, she didn't have her attorney, didn't have an
- 50:05attorney and was given a public defender named Bob Scott who
- 50:08immediately requested a gag order on everything that was
- 50:12going to be investigated. So that it wasn't leaked to the
- 50:14Press, he wanted the state to keep quiet.
- 50:17On whether they were going to seek the death penalty, the
- 50:20prosecution complied. At this point, Rusty got a
- 50:24family friend named George parnham to help with the case
- 50:28and George. Negotiated a meeting between
- 50:30Rusty and Andrea because at this point he wasn't even allowed to
- 50:33see her and laughing singing. Here would be the best rejected
- 50:37the attorney. There you go.
- 50:39She told Rusty, you will be greatly rewarded and then said
- 50:42have a nice life and tell him to leave.
- 50:49The reason why she was so weird during this interview, this,
- 50:53this time was that the president didn't have like the medication
- 50:56that she needed, right? So they just were putting her on
- 50:58sedatives, so she was just high as a kite that day.
- 51:01Like have a nice life by a man, by the name of Wendell Odom was
- 51:08enlisted to help parnham when he went to see Andrea.
- 51:13She only wanted to know what plea, they were going to submit.
- 51:17Her because she said she was not going to plead guilty at this
- 51:22point. Wonder was like, I'm not even
- 51:24sure you can stand trial for yourself.
- 51:28She still even while she was in prison, she still wasn't bathing
- 51:31and she was barely aware of the world around her.
- 51:34She was still shaking and like scratching at her scalp.
- 51:37There was a Doctor by the name of Lucy per year who ended up
- 51:41evaluating her for the defense and said that Andrea was
- 51:46suffering from something. Called postpartum psychosis and
- 51:49described her as the sickest person I have ever seen in my
- 51:52life. No, I'm pause this because a lot
- 51:56of people know what postpartum depression has.
- 51:57Mmm, I didn't actually know what postpartum psychosis was.
- 52:01I started reading about that. Yeah, I didn't know that was a
- 52:03thing. So postpartum depression occurs
- 52:05in about 20 percent of women who have children attended, 20% is
- 52:08the, the general percentage. It just happens because there
- 52:13are a extreme amount of hormonal shifts.
- 52:17Being within the pregnant woman and it, they have weird
- 52:23thoughts. They feel unsure.
- 52:25Sometimes they have trouble bonding with the child.
- 52:29Postpartum psychosis is actually quite where and only occurs in
- 52:34about Point 1 to point, 2 percent of all women, who give
- 52:38birth, it's treatable but very severe and it can happen to
- 52:45women who've never had any Mental Health.
- 52:47Issues before, but women who already have a history of mental
- 52:50illness or at a higher risk for it.
- 52:53It starts within weeks of the pregnancy like the birth, and if
- 52:59its treated like quickly, you're perfectly fine.
- 53:02But like, as for the symptoms of this, Andrea had them all
- 53:06strained believes hearing and seeing things that aren't there.
- 53:09Severe confusion. Bouts of mania with a loss of
- 53:12touch of reality, Andrews medical records were subpoenaed
- 53:17and psychiatrist were ordered to speak to her.
- 53:21She very consistently told all of them that God would accept
- 53:25her children to heaven, when one of the doctors reverse, the
- 53:30question and was like, what would happen if you'd left the
- 53:32children alive? Andrea told them, the children
- 53:36would continue stumbling in their lives and go to hell.
- 53:39When I asked like, what were the children doing to show you that
- 53:43you were being a bad mom? Andrea said that they didn't
- 53:46treat Rusty's mother with respects and weren't doing the
- 53:49things that God liked, which is so vague.
- 53:53Yeah. What did the judge did Issue the
- 53:56gag order, five days later which is the same way that the
- 53:59children were buried. But it didn't really matter
- 54:03because information just leaked constantly to the process,
- 54:06right? A funeral was reported on the
- 54:08media Rusty was Graham and sad and spoke at at each of his
- 54:13children's coffins tongue. Labor and good hands and placing
- 54:17the Child's favorite toy inside the coffin.
- 54:20He gave a eulogy for his children, discussing their
- 54:22personalities and he showed pictures of them.
- 54:25He read a few Bible verses called it, God's Will and sat
- 54:28down. Andrea was not permitted to
- 54:31attend her children's funeral but other family members did by
- 54:36June 28th. The media were predicting what
- 54:38was going to happen here. Texas juries are very apt to
- 54:44recommend. The death penalty but they have
- 54:46always found it. Hard to kill mother's.
- 54:50Hmm, as of May 17th 2021. There are 17.
- 54:54Women on death, row for killing their children, but roughly 180
- 54:59children are killed by their mothers, every year in the u.s.
- 55:03Oh my God. So Of the ones that happened
- 55:07every year, like what less than one percent of them actually end
- 55:10up on death row. For some reason, as a culture,
- 55:13we really struggle to Put a woman to death.
- 55:17Put a mother to death. Yeah it's rigged.
- 55:21It's weird. You child enough.
- 55:25Texas indicted Andrea for the deaths of Noah John and Mary on
- 55:30July 31st, 2001. They Prevail Leaf earring as to
- 55:33why they did not include the all the children is that.
- 55:37If the initial charges didn't go the way the state wanted, they
- 55:41could prosecute her again and not fall under.
- 55:45Look at them using their brain. Yep, so they like listen, we're
- 55:48going to do these first three and if this doesn't go the way
- 55:50we want, we're going to prosecute the other two.
- 55:52There you go. Judge Hill ordered a third
- 55:54Psych. For Andrea for her arraignment
- 55:58be Raymond. Is when you're expected to
- 56:00submit your plea and here, the formal charges against you, she
- 56:04appeared in court, August 8, 2001.
- 56:06She was thinner than she first appeared in.
- 56:08June, she been put back on the same antipsychotic that had
- 56:11worked for her in 1989, but it didn't seem to be working.
- 56:14Now she was very clearly deteriorating.
- 56:18But the Texas court appointed psychiatrist is like nah, she's
- 56:21good. Her legal team did not agree and
- 56:24they wanted to draw To see and decide for themselves.
- 56:32Since the psychiatrist they'd all hired said that Andrea was
- 56:35not competent enough to just to stand trial, competency, hearing
- 56:40meeting that she's able to participate in her own defense
- 56:43and fully comprehend what's happening in court, right?
- 56:47The judge would agree. Look at the medical testimony
- 56:49from dr. Syed.
- 56:50That was given to the grand jury before her indictment and they
- 56:53set up a competency hearing the day.
- 56:58After they say, the judge agreed to the competency hearing the
- 57:03prosecution was like, yeah. So we're going to be seeking the
- 57:05death penalty so much for that gag order, right?
- 57:10The judge ordered. No one could speak publicly
- 57:12about this. But Rusty did a 60 Minutes
- 57:15interview oh my God, where he showed videos of the children
- 57:18and talked about his life with Andrea, but he was careful.
- 57:21Not to give any opinions about the trial or talk about anything
- 57:25involving the try. Well.
- 57:26Okay. I mean, that's not too bad.
- 57:28He did everything, but so I'm jury selection began a week
- 57:30after September 11th because everything.
- 57:34Shut down for September 11th. Yes, that wild doesn't want this
- 57:38happened. That year.
- 57:40So, aim of the books that I read for this cop, Breaking Point by
- 57:44Suzie Spencer, it goes into some intense details about this
- 57:49competency trial, there were hundreds of pages of documents
- 57:52submitted to the court defense, experts saying, she's not come,
- 57:56you know, competent prosecution saying.
- 57:58She is lawyers arguing about the state psychologist.
- 58:02Being allowed to visit Andrea without the defense knowledge.
- 58:06The judge ruled that that interview couldn't be used but
- 58:09the end of the While it's still got used those all crazy.
- 58:13There's this, his name is dr. Joan Harris.
- 58:15And he testified that he met Andrea four times and that she
- 58:18showed signs of psychosis an hallucination on June 25th.
- 58:23That's five days after the murder.
- 58:25Hmm. She was seeing visions of Satan
- 58:27in her jail cell. He told the court.
- 58:29She had a hard time understanding questions and it
- 58:31would take her like a really long time to like process.
- 58:37What he was asking her. The one thing that Andrea seemed
- 58:41to be certain of, is that she deserved to be executed and go
- 58:44to hell. Because once she was killed the
- 58:47Devil Within her would be destroyed.
- 58:51She insisted, she didn't need a lawyer, she was not going to
- 58:54plead guilty and then she wanted to shave her head to prove that
- 58:58she had been given the mark of Satan and it was on her scalp.
- 59:02And if she shaved her head, then won't be able to see it.
- 59:05Oh, my God, dr. Harris did tell the court that
- 59:08after three months of being medicated, she did seem to stop
- 59:11having hallucinations and could hold on to like have a
- 59:15conversation, but she still struggled with delusions.
- 59:18And while she was a Rather like average intelligence woman.
- 59:23She struggled with remembering things, which is kind of
- 59:26important for a trial where you're supposed to remember the
- 59:29details of what you did, right? And it's like I said, if someone
- 59:32with MVD, your memory like long-term depression, and your
- 59:38memory, it's just shot, I just forget stuff, I know it's awful,
- 59:44it makes me feel terrible. Goodness, there's another doctor
- 59:49named Laura. Marin gel who testified about
- 59:53the changes that happen to your brain at different psychological
- 59:56States dr. Mary and Joe is actually an
- 59:59expert on depression and she walks the court through the
- 1:00:02previous two years of Andrea's life and said that with
- 1:00:06extensive treatment Andrea could become competent.
- 1:00:10But at this moment she was not the prosecution used the prison
- 1:00:14staff to support their assertion that Andrea was okay, there was
- 1:00:18a doctor named Steve rubin's. Sir, who spent 10 hours with her
- 1:00:22and done tests? This was the one that the
- 1:00:25defense was disputing because the defense wasn't there when
- 1:00:28they did these competency time, September 24th, 2001, a jury of
- 1:00:3511 men and one woman deemed her fit to stand trial on October
- 1:00:3930th. Andrea's attorneys filed, 36,
- 1:00:43pretrial, motions, everything in the book that they could file,
- 1:00:48they did. But the most important one was
- 1:00:50that, the court reconsider part of the Texas criminal code that
- 1:00:54would stop jurors from knowing that a verdict of Not Guilty.
- 1:00:58By reason of insanity was not actually Acquittal, and I didn't
- 1:01:03realize this either, like, I think, you know, it kind of but
- 1:01:07you people always say, like, oh, that person got away with, you
- 1:01:10know, Murder By reason of insanity.
- 1:01:13No, but the reality of that is that you don't like get to go
- 1:01:16free. No, no.
- 1:01:17You agree to like go to a mental facility, roughly for the rest
- 1:01:21of your life. Yep.
- 1:01:22You just aren't going to prison. But I mean, really, if we're
- 1:01:25arguing if some psychiatric facilities are like present
- 1:01:28mostly in his prison. Yeah.
- 1:01:30So People like the common. I think general idea in America
- 1:01:36is that you get to walk away from this but that's not true at
- 1:01:39all. So what her attorneys wanted was
- 1:01:43for them to essentially say, like, know if you do this if you
- 1:01:47give her, you know, guilty, not guilty.
- 1:01:49By reason of insanity, it doesn't mean she gets away with
- 1:01:52murder. I just mean she's going to go to
- 1:01:54a facility that can actually help her, right?
- 1:01:56But apparently in Texas, you can't do that.
- 1:02:01We're not allowed to know that whatnot.
- 1:02:04It's against the rules. It's against the rules are
- 1:02:07against the law. It's part of the Texas criminal
- 1:02:10code. That jurors are not supposed to
- 1:02:12understand like that about that verdict.
- 1:02:15That's some bullshit. It's weird.
- 1:02:17And it's something that after this case has been disputed,
- 1:02:20like, why wouldn't you want your jurors to be fully like before
- 1:02:23we understand what's going on? That's what I said too.
- 1:02:28Now, Andrea is defense. Also wanted her Russian thrown
- 1:02:32out because it was done about an hour after the murders where she
- 1:02:35was not on any medication and she was definitely not competent
- 1:02:39enough to waive her right to an attorney that day.
- 1:02:40Yeah, but it's what you didn't do, it was the freshest.
- 1:02:43So at this end, they were trying and November a psychiatrist for
- 1:02:48the prosecution interviewed Andrea, his name was dr.
- 1:02:52Park Dietz, and he is a nationally well-known forensic
- 1:02:56psychiatrist who worked on Jeffrey, Dahmer's case for the
- 1:03:00FBI. Oh as well as Susan Smith.
- 1:03:03Who also drowned her children. Oh wait, you said Jeffrey
- 1:03:06Dahmer? You mean your boy?
- 1:03:07No Dahmer know until my Bundy. Well no not but probably not
- 1:03:12your voice. Not my boy, not your boy.
- 1:03:18Oh my God. Okay Dahmer is not my boy.
- 1:03:22Despite him being a very well respected forensic psychiatrist.
- 1:03:27He knew virtually nothing about postpartum depression or
- 1:03:30psychosis. It wasn't his area of expertise
- 1:03:35that interview was taped and released to the public.
- 1:03:39Oh, they probably eat him alive. She know, she repeated a lot of
- 1:03:42what I've told though, but she I told you to dr.
- 1:03:45Dietz. December was really tough month.
- 1:03:47The defense lost nearly all of their emotions, specifically,
- 1:03:50the one about the jury, they begin what year which is jury
- 1:03:56selection. January 6, 2002, eight women,
- 1:03:59and four men were chosen. Seven of those jurors had
- 1:04:02children and to had degrees in Psychology.
- 1:04:04Hmm. All were aware that they were
- 1:04:07allowed to choose the death penalty trial was set for
- 1:04:10February. Eighteenth, two thousand two.
- 1:04:12This was super high profile and the literally like Every night,
- 1:04:17the media's medical experts were debating, whether Andrea Yates
- 1:04:21was actually crazy. We should she get off like The
- 1:04:26prosecution was like, listen, Andrew Greg Yates drowned, her
- 1:04:28five kids. She knew it was wrong.
- 1:04:30She known because she didn't kill them when her husband was
- 1:04:34home the month before and she waited until he was gone the day
- 1:04:37that she did it then she called the police.
- 1:04:41Both Williford and her partner. Joseph own be tried to keep the
- 1:04:45jury focused on the fact that she knew what was right when it
- 1:04:48happened and that her mental health wasn't really a factor.
- 1:04:52Of course the defense was that she didn't know What she was
- 1:04:55doing, because she is insane as we discussed during the Herbert
- 1:04:59Mullin case. And episode 13, this is still
- 1:05:02very hard to prove in court. Andrea's defends said that she'd
- 1:05:07been suffering from postpartum depression.
- 1:05:08Since her second son was born postpartum psychosis since the
- 1:05:12final child was born her lawyer. Parnham said that Andrea's
- 1:05:17mental illness was so severe. And so long-standing that Andrea
- 1:05:22Yates ability to think is at an abstract To give narrative
- 1:05:26responses and to be able to connect the dots is impaired.
- 1:05:31Hmm? Really?
- 1:05:33He specifically avoided bringing up the religious stuff because
- 1:05:39he thought that her fixation on religion was a manifestation of
- 1:05:43the bigger problem. Like it wasn't.
- 1:05:45Just the devil made me do it. It was that's a movie coming
- 1:05:48out. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:50Oh wow. It's about the warrants to.
- 1:05:52Oh wow. Yeah, we have to watch it.
- 1:05:55I'm sorry. They were going to leave it up
- 1:05:57to the jurors decide if she was in the midst of a debilitating
- 1:06:00psychotic State, when she killed her children.
- 1:06:03This is rough because now after a year of consistent, medical
- 1:06:06treatment, Andrea looked a lot better.
- 1:06:09And it would be unethical to remove her from the medications
- 1:06:12to show how she behaves when she's not on.
- 1:06:14Yeah, please don't know where the enough during Yates
- 1:06:18testified for the prosecution on how Andrea did nothing at home,
- 1:06:24but you sit and stare into space.
- 1:06:27And so like, a lot of people who reported on this guy, read a
- 1:06:30couple of years, our curls news articles and they were just like
- 1:06:34This kind of was more helpful to the defense.
- 1:06:37Yeah, absolutely saying that. Like she pretty much was at home
- 1:06:40in a catatonic State all the time.
- 1:06:42Thank you. Regardless.
- 1:06:43We appreciate your help. One of the other things that the
- 1:06:46prosecution did was they showed a picture of one of the
- 1:06:52children's like clenched Fist and it had some of Andrea's hair
- 1:06:56in it. So I let the baby have fought
- 1:06:58back when I have the baby but one of the other children for
- 1:07:01that, right? And also too Show how small
- 1:07:04their little hands were when they died.
- 1:07:07Andrea's lawyer was like, this is just an attempt to work up
- 1:07:11the jury. It was, right.
- 1:07:17They also showed the pajamas, they like literally entered the
- 1:07:20children's pajamas into evidence to show how small they were come
- 1:07:24on and how Andrea was so much bigger.
- 1:07:26We know how big seven-year-old five, right.
- 1:07:29So we don't like, literally this is like a 50 pound child.
- 1:07:32Yeah, we know how big they are, you know.
- 1:07:33Shows us the phone in to see it. The defense launch their portion
- 1:07:37of the trial. They started with the prison
- 1:07:39psychiatrist. Melissa Ferguson to give the
- 1:07:42court, an idea of what Andrea looked like, when she entered
- 1:07:44the prison, how she couldn't answer any questions or really
- 1:07:47talk much. One of the books that I read for
- 1:07:50this podcast is called, are you there alone?
- 1:07:52And it was from Suzanne O'Malley and one of the most bizarre
- 1:07:56things that Suzanne points out about this entire relationship.
- 1:08:00But specifically, the trial is that Rusty Yates is almost As
- 1:08:03delusional as his wife. He made team this almost
- 1:08:06childish naivete, that Andre would be found innocent and that
- 1:08:11they would have more children after she left a mental health,
- 1:08:16facility boy know at some point, while he was testifying in her
- 1:08:21defense, I think it might have, he might have finally really
- 1:08:24understood the breadth of his wife's illness because before
- 1:08:28the murders Rusty, was very much.
- 1:08:29The type of person to tell, you know, people just didn't think
- 1:08:32happy thoughts, Or. Brian Kennedy.
- 1:08:38Andrea's brother said that one time, he even said that, like
- 1:08:42depressed people just needed like a swift kick in the rear.
- 1:08:45You need a swift kick and to get you know in gear and your face.
- 1:08:48Sir you fucking cloning during Rusty's testimony though he had
- 1:08:54a bone to pick with dr. Sayid So mind, you doctor say
- 1:09:00eat is the one who said don't leave her alone, you ever.
- 1:09:03Yeah. What's his problem with dr.
- 1:09:06So rusty said, doctor said he is responsible for my wife's mental
- 1:09:09care. Not me.
- 1:09:10I'm not a mental health care, professional.
- 1:09:12And since Andrea hadn't told him about the hallucinations, he's
- 1:09:16like, I assume that what was being done, you know, was being
- 1:09:19done boy as your wife, right know this stuff but he, that's
- 1:09:24what I'm saying. He was neglectful of heard
- 1:09:26throughout their entire relationship.
- 1:09:27It's not yours. Not the doctors fault.
- 1:09:30You it's like partly your fault too, because you weren't paying
- 1:09:32attention to her. You weren't there for her, you
- 1:09:36are sure your fucking asshole. God, I'm sorry.
- 1:09:41Well, Rusty also said that if she was as sick as dr.
- 1:09:45Syed had told the cops, then she should have never been released
- 1:09:50at all. She should have been left alone,
- 1:09:52like, which astral fucking left her alone.
- 1:09:54She should have been released but doc Dr. Saeed also told the
- 1:09:58cops that he didn't want to release Andrea, but her
- 1:10:02insurance, only covered her stay, in an inpatient facility
- 1:10:06for 10 days. Hmm.
- 1:10:10So they were at a loss. Doctor said he did testify in
- 1:10:16the third week of the trial that when he met with Andrea two days
- 1:10:20before the murder, she was not displaying psychosis at that
- 1:10:23time and that he had diagnosed her with depression with
- 1:10:26psychotic features. The defense questioned his notes
- 1:10:33and said, did you add these after she got arrested for
- 1:10:37murder and say he was like, no, because they were saying that he
- 1:10:41didn't do his job. And that he should have been a
- 1:10:44little more thorough. I'm pretty like I'm pretty sure
- 1:10:48he did the best he could do what he could like.
- 1:10:54Nobody else was there to help, right?
- 1:10:56Like she was lucky enough to get like a doctor like let her
- 1:11:00husband. Her husband actually took her
- 1:11:02right? Yeah.
- 1:11:02At that point. Well Andrews mother spoke on her
- 1:11:05behalf she was not cross-examined and then they
- 1:11:08brought out their big guns. Three very well-known
- 1:11:11psychiatrist Philip Resnick Steve rosenblatt and Lucy per
- 1:11:16year this was a three-part plan so rosenblatt had interviewed
- 1:11:19Andrea five days after the killing and say that Andrea was
- 1:11:22in a deep sleep. Of psychosis and that it would
- 1:11:25have taken weeks for her to get this bad.
- 1:11:27Not days, which directly cuts into dr.
- 1:11:31Saeed's diagnosis of saying, that two days before the murder.
- 1:11:33She was all right, hmm. Per year, focused on the
- 1:11:37internalized. Shame from her first to it, that
- 1:11:40suicide attempt and how she had had a lot of secrecy about her
- 1:11:43suicidal, ideation after that because after that, she didn't
- 1:11:46tell anybody about any of the stuff she was thinking, or
- 1:11:49seeing or hearing, right prayer. Also handled the main chunk of
- 1:11:52explaining to the The jury the difference between postpartum
- 1:11:55depression and psychosis. Then Resnick, his speciality was
- 1:12:01parasite. He referred to the killings as
- 1:12:04being altruistic in nature, and that she knew what she was doing
- 1:12:10was illegal. But she believed that her choice
- 1:12:12to override this, right? And wrong, was because she was
- 1:12:19doing it for the betterment of the child.
- 1:12:20That actually makes sense, right?
- 1:12:22So this wasn't like, I'm killing my kids because I don't know.
- 1:12:26Some man wants me to move to, you know.
- 1:12:29Yeah. North Carolina or something dumb
- 1:12:31like that. Like this was done with her
- 1:12:33thinking about their best interest at heart, but she knew
- 1:12:36it was wrong but she does, she didn't know.
- 1:12:38It was wrong to kill people. Yeah.
- 1:12:41Resident met her in her cell on two separate occasions and he
- 1:12:45was just like, I'm pretty sure she's schizophrenic as well.
- 1:12:49His diagnosis did contradict the other doctors but he's just
- 1:12:52simply Stated like listen this is just my interpretation of the
- 1:12:55same data that we're all looking at right after that, the
- 1:13:00prosecution had their opportunity for rebuttal and
- 1:13:03that is when they bought it, brought in dr.
- 1:13:05Park Dietz. This was a big deal.
- 1:13:08Because dr. Dietz and dr.
- 1:13:10Resnick had been on the opposite side of the courtroom before and
- 1:13:13dates usually 100. He was very good at explaining
- 1:13:17complex things in simple ways forgeries, which tends to earn
- 1:13:22you favor in courtroom. Do you like to be talked to like
- 1:13:25I don't know things. This is because sometimes
- 1:13:27actually explain to me like I'm five like playing a courtroom
- 1:13:30like because sometimes I am stupid and you need to talk to
- 1:13:33me like a child. Like these cases are long.
- 1:13:35They go on for weeks. Like you need somebody to
- 1:13:37explain like, okay. Can you just say and basic words
- 1:13:40with psychosis says, because I'm tired of hearing, my 12th grades
- 1:13:4413th grade language. Y'all need to move on from there
- 1:13:47to youth green 13th, grade. Listen, I'm not ready for 13th,
- 1:13:50grave right now, sir. In fact, during the trial Deets
- 1:13:55used PowerPoint and he admitted yes Andrea Yates is seriously
- 1:14:00mentally ill, but she a, he said, she hadn't acted like a
- 1:14:03mother who was saving her children.
- 1:14:05He said she was aware of her delusions and had not done
- 1:14:08anything to protect her children Dietz point out that in Yates
- 1:14:11own words. She had committed a sin and she
- 1:14:14knew what she had done was wrong.
- 1:14:16He also pointed out that Yates deserve the death penalty for
- 1:14:19crimes and that her covering the children's bodies with.
- 1:14:23His sheet was a sign of guilt. He also wondered why she hadn't
- 1:14:28comforted her children or reassured them afterward.
- 1:14:32That this was an act of love. Dietz.
- 1:14:37Also, blamed Rusty to thank you. He remind the court that doctor
- 1:14:41Sayid and also another doctor who did she had worked with
- 1:14:46before dr. Eileen star Branch had.
- 1:14:48Advised her not to go off her meds to get pregnant and not to
- 1:14:52leave Andrea alone. This is true.
- 1:14:55He said that Russia should have realized that.
- 1:14:56If a doctor was saying, don't leave her alone.
- 1:15:00It means you can't leave her alone with the kids.
- 1:15:04He Point out that Andrea had been living in an unhealthy
- 1:15:07condition for a very long time and had not received the
- 1:15:10Continuous Care that she needed to recover.
- 1:15:14And that's the really big word here.
- 1:15:16Continuous Care. It's one thing for Rusty to
- 1:15:19compete. Taking her back to the doctors
- 1:15:20every couple months. Yeah.
- 1:15:22But she need ongoing consistent. Medical Healthcare really
- 1:15:26hourly. Like that's like it's one of
- 1:15:30those interesting things. After my mom passed, I was
- 1:15:33seeing a therapist twice a week. every week for months, that That
- 1:15:39matters. So like if you're saying that
- 1:15:42somebody's in this like deep psych psychosis, I was nowhere
- 1:15:45near anything like that and you were at least and I was a weed.
- 1:15:49Yeah I was still going to see a therapist twice a week so I feel
- 1:15:53like honestly like I said like dr.
- 1:15:55Sagan said she should have been committed.
- 1:15:57Yeah and she was only getting hit like we just like once a
- 1:15:59month naughty. Yeah.
- 1:16:00It was like one time, will the year that this happened?
- 1:16:03Yeah, April May a couple of June, like, I'm like once a
- 1:16:08month is not enough, that's that's what you Like you get put
- 1:16:12on once a month, appointments, when you're in like, full-on
- 1:16:15like recovery and they're like, I was going to check on you
- 1:16:18every so often you're doing good.
- 1:16:20That's what I'll do for counseling once a month.
- 1:16:22Yeah, that's that's kind of, like, where would be now for me
- 1:16:26like, hey, you know, what did you stop by once a month to keep
- 1:16:29up with you. Exactly.
- 1:16:30But like, once a month for somebody who is this far down
- 1:16:34the rabbit hole? It's at, it's not enough.
- 1:16:38Now, Dietz also said in court that when Was imprisoned.
- 1:16:42She told him, I shouldn't have done this, he did concede that.
- 1:16:46It's possible that Andrea psychosis could have gotten
- 1:16:48worse after she killed the children, so that the other
- 1:16:51doctors weren't lying, but that he did say that the delusions
- 1:16:56that she told him and the delusion, she told the other
- 1:17:00doctors days and weeks later were different.
- 1:17:05It was his opinion that her motive for murder was the same
- 1:17:09as her motive for suicide. She saw, no way out of her life
- 1:17:13with a man who gave her no help and left her with five children.
- 1:17:16This was a way for her to escape and the same way that she was
- 1:17:19trying to escape by killing herself.
- 1:17:22He also liquid on this weird tangent where he said that
- 1:17:25Andrea had seen a law-and-order episode about a mother who
- 1:17:29killed her children. I had gotten away with murder.
- 1:17:32Hmm. That's going to come up later.
- 1:17:37Closing arguments happen. Williford dramatically asked the
- 1:17:40jury to sit in silence for the three minutes that would have
- 1:17:44taken for each of the children to die.
- 1:17:47I know very dramatic parnham, just decided to reiterate what
- 1:17:51the psychiatrist said and let their work speak for him.
- 1:17:55The jury deliberated for three hours and returned with a
- 1:17:58verdict on March 12th. 2002 Andrea was guilty, Rusty cried
- 1:18:03in the courtroom. Andrea tried to give her brother
- 1:18:06Brian a smile. But cried as they, let her out
- 1:18:10the nation debated, whether she could have death penalty or not.
- 1:18:13Every imaginable concept was run through the verdict was unfair.
- 1:18:17Give her life in prison. The verdict is fair as you
- 1:18:19deserve to die. Would it have been different if
- 1:18:21the jurors had known about the Not Guilty by insanity?
- 1:18:25You rolling. Yes.
- 1:18:26Why are they allowed to know this information?
- 1:18:28They would have definitely been different.
- 1:18:30And can I say something, I all the psychologists in this, I
- 1:18:34just noticed a Galaxy psychology going on with it.
- 1:18:38Just give me like a huge brain boner.
- 1:18:40Right now, I'm just learning all this cool stuff.
- 1:18:43It was like, oh my God. Yes.
- 1:18:44Well, are you ready for this bombshell?
- 1:18:47Yeah. Go ahead.
- 1:18:48The defense discover that Park Dietz.
- 1:18:52Lied. That episode of Law & Order that
- 1:18:55he was sure that Andrea had seen in told him about never
- 1:18:59happened. And the best part about this is
- 1:19:02the reason why they even found out about this is because of one
- 1:19:05of the women who wrote the book because she was that, I read the
- 1:19:09one that came out in 2005. I'm her name is Suzanne.
- 1:19:15I forget her last name that fast.
- 1:19:16I've already mentioned her like four times Suzanne O'Malley was
- 1:19:20she like, I'm Dan Suzanne. O'Malley was a writer for Law
- 1:19:23and Order. See her name and yes.
- 1:19:25Yes, Susie and O'Malley is a writer for the writer, for Law
- 1:19:29and Order and almost immediately she could, she was working.
- 1:19:34She was writing for this what she's writing this book, but she
- 1:19:36was also working for Oprah and the New York Times covering the
- 1:19:41case. So she immediately was like, no,
- 1:19:44I I checked with everyone who I know who still writes on this
- 1:19:48show. There's no episode about a woman
- 1:19:52killing her family in a bathtub and getting away with murder.
- 1:19:54Oh, you know. Now they did release an episode
- 1:19:58about that in 2004, but that is three years after this case,
- 1:20:02yeah, that happened later, right?
- 1:20:05So that kind of crazy that's wild.
- 1:20:11That one of the, the people like, this is a former writer
- 1:20:14for a An order who is also a at this point.
- 1:20:17Honestly, I should just like I've read a lot of Susan,
- 1:20:20O'Malley's books for these podcasts.
- 1:20:23I need to send her an email me. Like you know, you want to be on
- 1:20:25our podcast because I like you. But I who knew that?
- 1:20:30Like I didn't realize that that like, that's why that detail,
- 1:20:35the fact that this woman was doing this case. is ultimately
- 1:20:41the reason why this case gets overturned, I don't mind that
- 1:20:48because die, I don't don't be like, come on now.
- 1:20:51So the funny thing here is that Dietz sends a letter and he's
- 1:20:53just like, I'm an error. I guess Andrea.
- 1:20:56Never told me about this, his reputation does take a little
- 1:20:59bit of a hit, but he is still considered to be a renowned
- 1:21:02successful forensic psychiatrist parnham and Odom, ask for a
- 1:21:07mistrial immediately but judge held declines it.
- 1:21:10I mean, it was just that one line though.
- 1:21:12We can't blink cause a mistrial for me.
- 1:21:16Yeah, really okay. Leo that's bring the jury meets
- 1:21:20again, to discuss sentencing and in under an hour actually was
- 1:21:23under 40 minutes. They come back and they give her
- 1:21:26life in prison option for parole in 2041, the jury even like
- 1:21:31barely even discuss the death penalty, which is exactly what
- 1:21:34we were talking about earlier, which is that we just do not
- 1:21:37want to put a mom in jail, like, Mom on death row.
- 1:21:39Yeah. Andrea didn't seem to really
- 1:21:43react Snooze in the courtroom. She was sent to Mountain View
- 1:21:48unit which is a state. Psychiatry president Eastern,
- 1:21:50Texas. Rusty did all manner of
- 1:21:53interviews he could I'd his name popped up.
- 1:21:55So often in my research he insisted his family had been a
- 1:21:58victim of the poor mental health system in the United States that
- 1:22:02he, he ignored that he had been warned and said that Andrea had
- 1:22:06never properly been treated and then he set up a website to
- 1:22:10describe his side of things and show pictures of his family's
- 1:22:13and yes. Yes, I did.
- 1:22:14Look up that website. It's called Yates kids.org and
- 1:22:17currently it is not working. Look here, I want to call.
- 1:22:21I want to call. Now, many people believe like
- 1:22:25you, I'm dying, many, many people believe like you though,
- 1:22:32that Rusty was culpable and that's the fish.
- 1:22:35Absolutely others also said that dr.
- 1:22:38Sayed should have looked further into her medical history and
- 1:22:41maybe put her on the medicine and she had been on a 99.
- 1:22:45In fact dozens of emails were sent to the local Harris County,
- 1:22:48DA Chuck, Rosenthal to investigate both of them, do
- 1:22:52nice Rusty, repeatedly was just like listen it was just an hour
- 1:22:56and my mom was going to be there.
- 1:22:57An hour. Yeah.
- 1:22:58But you know how long it takes to kill somebody.
- 1:23:01Not very long. Really?
- 1:23:02It takes three minutes to drop someone what this is.
- 1:23:04Or at least the child green children though.
- 1:23:06This, what they charge her for right to become children?
- 1:23:09Yeah, one minute per Jack. Yeah, actually, every year
- 1:23:13before summer camp, we have to go through water, safety
- 1:23:15training, and our head lifeguard tells us that 30 seconds, that's
- 1:23:21how quickly a kid can receive lose.
- 1:23:25So much oxygen at. They have permanent brain
- 1:23:27damage. Really.
- 1:23:28Yep. Scared the crap out of me.
- 1:23:29The first year I ever started working for them.
- 1:23:31Oh my God. That's like 30 seconds.
- 1:23:33Oh God. What never let them out of your
- 1:23:36sight when they're near water? No, not at all terrifying.
- 1:23:39Oh my God. Okay.
- 1:23:41Well swimming. This Rusty.
- 1:23:42Blame the hospital and the doctors he threatened to sue
- 1:23:45them but there was no investigation into Rusty and no
- 1:23:48lawsuit. Ultimately January 6, 2005.
- 1:23:56So Three years. After the initial verdict, the
- 1:24:02Texas court of appeals overturns, Andrea sentence, dr.
- 1:24:06Parks Dietz, false statement, had Prejudice, the jury, and
- 1:24:10that was considered to be a miscarriage of Justice.
- 1:24:13Because essentially Dietz was saying that she had
- 1:24:16premeditated. Like this was a premeditated
- 1:24:19murder. Okay, so, okay, so if they
- 1:24:22thought that she had planned this ahead of time, yeah, and
- 1:24:25there's no way they were ever going to consider.
- 1:24:28That she was insane. Prosecutors insisted.
- 1:24:32They did not purposefully mislead the court but it didn't
- 1:24:35matter. January 9th, 2006, Andrea
- 1:24:38submitted, a plea of Not Guilty. By reason of insanity and on
- 1:24:41February 1st 2006, she was granted release on bail on the
- 1:24:45condition that she would stay at a mental health facility and
- 1:24:48complete her treatment. So she was actually allowed out
- 1:24:51of prison during the trial. Okay?
- 1:24:53July 25th, 2006 after three days of deliberation, Andrea Yates
- 1:24:58Was found not guilty and committed to the North Texas
- 1:25:02State Hospital at Vernon campus about a year later.
- 1:25:05She was deemed well enough to go to a low-security facility and
- 1:25:09Kerrville Texas where she has been at the Kerrville state
- 1:25:13hospital. She's currently 56 years old and
- 1:25:17enjoys arts and crafts. Nice Mystery of Life in there
- 1:25:20then yeah she the she could potentially be released its
- 1:25:28Highly unlikely that. Yeah I don't think with
- 1:25:30everything that she went through and how many years she went
- 1:25:33untreated unfortunately, mental like severe mental health stuff
- 1:25:41does change not your brain chemistry, but it almost changes
- 1:25:44like the way your brain works. They have done, they've taken, I
- 1:25:50forget what those CAT scan. Yes, cat-scans of people with
- 1:25:55different mental illnesses, and compared those to people who are
- 1:25:59neurotypical and you're like, your synapses fire differently.
- 1:26:05Hmm. Since we're being so open about
- 1:26:09my mental health, this episode, one of the things that I learned
- 1:26:14after having a very traumatic childhood before I was adopted,
- 1:26:19is that I am consistently in fight or flight mode.
- 1:26:23My brain automatically assumes, the worst thing is going to
- 1:26:28happen. How can I navigate?
- 1:26:30How to deal with this? And I am 33 years old.
- 1:26:34It's just something that I've learned to deal with and that I
- 1:26:36have, I cannot trust my instant reaction to things.
- 1:26:41I have to stop and go. You can work through this, this
- 1:26:49is not life or death, but because when I was so little so
- 1:26:54much was life and death and more than likely when I was, my brain
- 1:27:00was forming itself and becoming a big people brain.
- 1:27:03I didn't get a chance to not constantly be in that sense of
- 1:27:08anxiety and fear as a kid. I mean speaking from Like my
- 1:27:14son, like I can just see like how all this.
- 1:27:18He's very anxious to is. He does suffer from anxiety.
- 1:27:22He does and I can just see like, if you learn how to deal with
- 1:27:26it. Exactly, if you didn't have any
- 1:27:27help for it at all, then, you know, then I can just see him
- 1:27:31growing up with just. Just two biggest, I don't know,
- 1:27:36just having like a bad time. Basically, the nice thing about
- 1:27:39it is that you have, you know, sort, Help with this.
- 1:27:45Yes, you don't have to just be anxious all the time.
- 1:27:47It was amazing to me. I'd like 28 years old.
- 1:27:50I remember like telling my ex at the time like do you know how
- 1:27:55wonderful it is? Not to worry about you all the
- 1:27:57time because I just assumed that, that was how all people
- 1:27:59were I assumed that if I called like that normal, like the
- 1:28:03everybody freaked out when you called your parent and they
- 1:28:06didn't pick up the phone and like, when I was a teenager, I
- 1:28:10would call my parents repeatedly over and over and over and Over
- 1:28:13again. If they weren't home on time, I
- 1:28:15was always afraid. I didn't think I didn't think
- 1:28:18that was, I thought that was how everybody was.
- 1:28:20I thought that was normal. And then all of a sudden I'm
- 1:28:23like it's not only it's you know, so you have to constantly
- 1:28:26they call them automatic negative thoughts, ants and you
- 1:28:29just have to learn how to challenge your own brain.
- 1:28:32And go is this is this as bad as you're making it out to be?
- 1:28:37Probably not need some bug spray froz ants.
- 1:28:40But remember we talked about how Andrea Yates was.
- 1:28:43Suffering from depression and things when she was a teenager.
- 1:28:46Yeah. Or in middle school.
- 1:28:48So, it's very likely that some of these Pathways and things
- 1:28:52that she struggled, you know, this was happening during her
- 1:28:54formative years to and the thing is, your brain also doesn't stop
- 1:28:58developing until you hit your leg mid-20s.
- 1:29:01So that's also when she first met Rusty and she got
- 1:29:05indoctrinated into that weird religion.
- 1:29:09So, all these things are going on in her brain and she was
- 1:29:12constantly led to believe that. I mean, it was honestly it
- 1:29:15sounds very cold like you and I talked about cults every so
- 1:29:19often, it sounds very cult-like. So I really doubt that she will
- 1:29:21probably ever be released but at least she will have some
- 1:29:24semblance of A okay life. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:29:27And that's, you know, that's the best you can do is for her as
- 1:29:31for Rusty. Hmm, he got divorced.
- 1:29:33They, he filed for divorce in 2004 before her trial was
- 1:29:37overturned, he no longer works for NASA.
- 1:29:40He remarried in 2006 but has since gotten divorced, they have
- 1:29:44a little boy who is 12 years old?
- 1:29:46Hmm. Apparently he calls Andrea once
- 1:29:49a month and he visits her once a year and they talk about the
- 1:29:54good times, okay? Good times.
- 1:29:58According to them. Okay.
- 1:30:00And that's kind of how that goes for the two of them.
- 1:30:03Okay, this is lovely. Yep.
- 1:30:06It's an interesting, like I said, like this was a weird
- 1:30:09thing to discuss because we still don't probably give enough
- 1:30:13respect or acknowledgement to women who have postpartum that
- 1:30:21people really don't understand that it especially, probably for
- 1:30:25somebody who's never experienced any of those.
- 1:30:28And if thoughts or suicidal ideation or things of that
- 1:30:30nature, it's probably very scary for somebody who has had never
- 1:30:36had any mental health issues and now all of a sudden, why do I
- 1:30:40want to kill myself and my baby? Yeah, you know.
- 1:30:43Yeah. But if we did better with that
- 1:30:46we would probably save a lot of children's lives and also women
- 1:30:49to because it is, it's totally a completely treatable issue.
- 1:30:55You just have to one being a place where you can tell people
- 1:30:59about it and not feel guilty to be able to get the medical care
- 1:31:04that you need and move. You know, and then could get
- 1:31:09that Continuous Care. It's not, this is not a
- 1:31:12one-and-done thing. Nothing mental health-related is
- 1:31:15one and no, no, no. I'm sure anybody listening has
- 1:31:20any sort of diagnosis knows that it's nonstop.
- 1:31:25Yeah, I definitely will Freaky refer to it as recovery, I'm
- 1:31:31fine. Most of the time.
- 1:31:33Every once in a while say I'm not and you just gotta work
- 1:31:38through those days. Save but yeah like I said I
- 1:31:42started out being like there is absolutely no justification for
- 1:31:46why a woman would kill her children and as I was going
- 1:31:48through these two different books and all these noodles news
- 1:31:51articles like well yeah when I got to the trial I was like I
- 1:31:55don't know which side I want to be.
- 1:31:57All right now, right is because on one hand you totally are like
- 1:32:00oh these poor babies. And on the other hand And you're
- 1:32:03just like, poor Andrea. Yeah.
- 1:32:07Let's did she ever have a chance?
- 1:32:09Yeah, that's poor babies before. So, if you are a Christian in
- 1:32:14one of these weird fundamentalist organizations,
- 1:32:17get out Brad, like being forced to do that whole Barefoot
- 1:32:21pregnant thing sounds like, oh, just a raw deal.
- 1:32:24What the hell is that? That's where you just hang out.
- 1:32:26You know, you're barefoot and pregnant.
- 1:32:28You cook in the kitchen and you make babies, that's what they
- 1:32:30want. The women to do is some of those
- 1:32:32work. So just like a Housewife, pretty
- 1:32:34much. Yeah.
- 1:32:34Pretty much. But a housewife with absolutely
- 1:32:36no power, like, it's really interesting because like, I hear
- 1:32:39like the old, like black ladies talk about, like, you know,
- 1:32:41listen, I might have been at home, but I was in charge of the
- 1:32:43house, right? Of course, in their churches,
- 1:32:45you're at home and you're not in charge.
- 1:32:48Oh, basically a slave. Yeah, pretty much popping out
- 1:32:52babies like, you know, my grandma would have been like,
- 1:32:54listen, he comes home and he gives the check to me and then I
- 1:32:57make sure all the bills are paid and I give him some of his money
- 1:33:01back so he can do what he wants. Was this all goes.
- 1:33:04So yeah. That's I mean that's how it is
- 1:33:06sometimes with these you know because Who would know what the
- 1:33:08house needs better than the person who's there all the time.
- 1:33:11Absolutely. But regardless, oh my God, it
- 1:33:14was a, it was a pretty intense. That was, yeah, that was a
- 1:33:18roller coaster. It.
- 1:33:20There you go. That's what we're going to say.
- 1:33:22It was a fucking roller coaster ride.
- 1:33:38Oh my God. What do you have for me today?
- 1:33:41All right, so I know a lot of people may know that me and
- 1:33:49Brittany Live in Pennsylvania. We do.
- 1:33:55Yeah and a lot of my friends listen to the podcast and it
- 1:33:59mean when they can and know a lot of you know your people who
- 1:34:02listen to the podcast too. So oh yes my friends from
- 1:34:05Lancaster listen to us. Yeah there you go some of your
- 1:34:08co-workers right? Oh yeah and some people I work
- 1:34:10with to worry about that. My-my boss will randomly be like
- 1:34:16and then you were talking about and I'm like you're right you're
- 1:34:19right that's what we say. But we do often mention that we
- 1:34:26are from central Pennsylvania. I know we like you mentioned it
- 1:34:29like another, that's good or not, you never know.
- 1:34:32And people don't know where central Pennsylvania is there.
- 1:34:34Like, what the hell central Pennsylvania?
- 1:34:35Like you not at all Adelphia friggin truth.
- 1:34:40This is true. Well today, I'll be bringing you
- 1:34:43some urban legends and / hauntings from our little neck
- 1:34:48of the woods. Oh that's lovely.
- 1:34:49And that may be new to some and who chew others.
- 1:34:54I mean I'm pretty sure everybody from around the area they know
- 1:34:57all of the legends from the area.
- 1:35:04Oh most of the info was brought to me by a very good friend of
- 1:35:07mine named is Christine and this lady.
- 1:35:15She she basically like helped me when I first started skating.
- 1:35:19Oh cool. So my roller derby career.
- 1:35:22Yeah. And she's always down the skate
- 1:35:25whenever if she's free that's important.
- 1:35:31But yeah, yeah, like I asked her, you know, what are some
- 1:35:36local Tales from your - would I could talk.
- 1:35:39About and like she gave me like this whole as she blew up my
- 1:35:43messenger about this only pixel. Like I think one from her whole
- 1:35:48list because other ones I like I can talk about this but it'd
- 1:35:51probably be like too long. Well, okay, yeah, I don't know.
- 1:35:56But whatever, I'm pretty sure she's listening so.
- 1:36:00Hi Christine, thanks for the info.
- 1:36:02Hi. Christine All right.
- 1:36:05Now we're giving out our actual location.
- 1:36:08We don't need stalkers at all. Amen.
- 1:36:11I'll be talking about different stories from different cities
- 1:36:14and Central PA, or I think one's actually not in Central PA is
- 1:36:18the one, the last one I'm going to be telling you, but two are
- 1:36:22from central Pennsylvania. Oh, interesting.
- 1:36:25I don't know. Like okay, you don't know a lot
- 1:36:28from Central think. I know some about some of the
- 1:36:30the far reaches of our state, you know, up near Eerie, you
- 1:36:34don't know anything from From our, I don't think so huh.
- 1:36:37Okay. And I also won't be talking
- 1:36:40about Gettysburg because one that's Gettysburg has too many
- 1:36:45fucking ghost stories choose from and to everybody knows
- 1:36:49Gettysburg. Yeah, his Holiness fuck.
- 1:36:51So. All right.
- 1:36:56Okay, so wait, have you heard of seven?
- 1:37:00Gates of? Hell yes.
- 1:37:02Okay great. I was going to tell you that one
- 1:37:06first, but, It's a, I mean you can still tell the people I was
- 1:37:10gonna tell tell I was just going to go over it because it's not
- 1:37:14like something as not like something I wrote down those
- 1:37:17ones where I feel like every okay, I hate to say it this way.
- 1:37:21But like every middle of like nowhere, place kind of has won
- 1:37:27the user have something like this or like the portal to
- 1:37:30portal to hell, or some shit. Like yeah.
- 1:37:33Like I think New Jersey has some type of shit like that.
- 1:37:35Yeah, everyone always has like a place.
- 1:37:38I swear, if you go through it, things will happen, well, always
- 1:37:44wanted to go. There's no such place.
- 1:37:49I mean there is but there's not I can get to it later but not
- 1:37:53really wanna get into it right now.
- 1:37:55I wanted to be real, it's sort of real but its not real.
- 1:37:59It's not I don't know how else to explain it.
- 1:38:03Anyway, let's start off with one story.
- 1:38:05That oh, by the way, this story like you said everywhere has a
- 1:38:09place like this. Basically, everywhere everywhere
- 1:38:13has a place like this one too. And this is place a place that
- 1:38:18many people had tested out and there seems to be an answer for
- 1:38:21it, so yeah. Stop.
- 1:38:27Stop it. Christian is also tested this
- 1:38:29out. I think I know what this is.
- 1:38:31Oh my God. Continue.
- 1:38:33Okay, Louis Barre. Pennsylvania.
- 1:38:36Now this one is, I think it's off of Route. 83 there's a hill
- 1:38:44and if you just so happen to a, put your car in neutral at the
- 1:38:48bottom of this hill, it will seem to roll backwards up the
- 1:38:53hill as this the The one with the handprint.
- 1:38:57Yeah, on your car? Okay, sure is.
- 1:38:59So I have heard about these. I just didn't realize they were
- 1:39:02in Pennsylvania. I heard about this like in like
- 1:39:05Virginia. Well, this is called Gravity
- 1:39:07Hill and like, like you said, Virginia.
- 1:39:11This isn't the only one in Pennsylvania and like, there are
- 1:39:14two other places in Pennsylvania with gravity hills.
- 1:39:17Oh, and this isn't the only place in America that has a
- 1:39:21Gravity Hill. Oh, okay.
- 1:39:23Then like, Over the place. That would explain that then no.
- 1:39:31But this one is close to home. So, I know totally.
- 1:39:34So this is the one that your friend is actually.
- 1:39:37Yeah, absolutely experienced. Now, there is, of course, a
- 1:39:42legend behind this from what I could piece together.
- 1:39:46There was a school bus that whose brakes just gave out and
- 1:39:52bus, just rolled into the intersection down this road and
- 1:39:56of course, I got into an accident and the children on
- 1:39:59board. All died.
- 1:40:01Poor babies. Poor baby for babies.
- 1:40:04Yes. Now, if you happen to try it,
- 1:40:07it's said that the reason why the car moves backwards is
- 1:40:11because the children from the accident are said to be the
- 1:40:15ones. Pushing your car back from the
- 1:40:17intersection to save you from their fate.
- 1:40:20Yep. Remember hearing about this one
- 1:40:23is a kid. Yeah.
- 1:40:25Now, our gravity hills and I'm pretty sure any other Gravity
- 1:40:30Hill is actually just an optical illusion.
- 1:40:33Oh yeah, it makes you. It makes it seem like you're
- 1:40:38rolling backwards uphill when you're inside the car.
- 1:40:41That's it. Yeah.
- 1:40:43Huh I don't like I talk to Christine, she said she didn't
- 1:40:49test out the handprint thing because her car was white.
- 1:40:55So she didn't see any hand prints on the car.
- 1:40:58I mean, she could put a little, you know, brown dirt on it.
- 1:41:00Rub it around a little bit. Yeah get your Carter.
- 1:41:02Yeah, listen for science. Christine for Sian my God.
- 1:41:08So apparently, the one in the lose, Barry is the best one to
- 1:41:13visit in Pennsylvania. Hmm.
- 1:41:16Because you can't like what I read for.
- 1:41:19His one article is that the other two gravity hills you can
- 1:41:23see the optical illusion like you can see how it how it does
- 1:41:28it when you're outside of the car.
- 1:41:29I'm actually really interested in seeing the Illusion part of
- 1:41:32this. Yeah I do.
- 1:41:33I got a like it's the thing that we don't we might have to do but
- 1:41:36I don't want to do it. It and I'll tell you why it's do
- 1:41:39during the daytime. I'll tell you why.
- 1:41:43So, It's also advised to use as much caution as you can sense
- 1:41:51this gravity. He'll lose Barry is on a busy
- 1:41:54road. Well actually never mind that
- 1:41:58we're not going to like, put ourselves in actual danger.
- 1:42:00No, no. I actually like the two roads
- 1:42:02that at the intersection is on our two busy roads.
- 1:42:06So, it's advised to do this, which makes sense because the
- 1:42:10legend is about like a car accident.
- 1:42:12So, like, don't cause a car accident, you know, you're
- 1:42:15trying to do. This thing, like if you visit
- 1:42:18PA, you can go to lose. Barry PA just be and you look
- 1:42:21for this Gravity Hill. Please be cautious because you
- 1:42:27don't want to cause another accident and we don't want to be
- 1:42:29title. Telling ghost stories about your
- 1:42:30ass. Oh, also, I want I want to
- 1:42:37mention that this story in the next one will be telling they
- 1:42:41are not advertised at all, by the towns.
- 1:42:45Like they like nobody advertisers, that know these are
- 1:42:49things. You like, I'm pretty sure I
- 1:42:51heard about these or read about these randomly.
- 1:42:53When I was like a teenager reading like spooky forums and
- 1:42:57stuff and people talking about doing things haunted houses in
- 1:43:02Pennsylvania. You know, haunted Has stuff like
- 1:43:05that. Yeah, because nobody ever wants
- 1:43:07like nobody who lives there. Once randoms coming.
- 1:43:10No, no, they don't. No not at all.
- 1:43:13Please don't ya. Oh goodness.
- 1:43:16Okay, so next door that was Story.
- 1:43:19One number two, I'm pretty sure you're going to notice one as
- 1:43:23soon as I start talking about it.
- 1:43:24Okay, so if you play horror video games, like me and
- 1:43:29Brittany do. Yes, once again, I am bringing
- 1:43:33up games. Because the center, this is just
- 1:43:37what we do, this is what you, this is what I do like video
- 1:43:39games and if they, you know, connect with stuff I want to
- 1:43:41talk about, I won't talk about it.
- 1:43:44So if you know anything about video games, horror video games,
- 1:43:47you might know this one as well, and Columbia County.
- 1:43:52There's a near ghost town with a population of nine.
- 1:43:57As of 2019, it just sort. It was 12:00.
- 1:44:02Yes, as a population. You gave me a look like you
- 1:44:05already knew what I was talking. Everybody knows about this.
- 1:44:08Of course it's name is Centralia, Centralia,
- 1:44:12Pennsylvania and it is what they base, Silent Hill.
- 1:44:17Well, the movie, the movie and the game, actually, the first, I
- 1:44:21don't remember, I didn't know that the game was based on.
- 1:44:23This is the, the first game was based off of it too.
- 1:44:27I know the movie was definitely based off of it is not a movie.
- 1:44:29Definitely, they totally pulled everything.
- 1:44:31Oh, yeah, absolutely. now, if you don't know what Silent Hill
- 1:44:36is, Google it. I'm not telling you about it.
- 1:44:40No no this is worth. This is worth talking about
- 1:44:44Silent Hill was one of the I would say one of the forerunners
- 1:44:48of survival Horror. Oh yeah.
- 1:44:51I mean you walked through this. You were a man on a quest for
- 1:44:55your daughter. Yeah.
- 1:44:57In this town that you'd never heard of before called Silent
- 1:45:00Hill and one of the interesting things about the game itself was
- 1:45:04that the game engine that the time could not, Render the
- 1:45:08entire game at the same time, not like now where it loads a
- 1:45:13whole level in 30 seconds, it would load as you were walking.
- 1:45:16So what they did to allow the game to slowly render and you
- 1:45:21not to be aware of, it was the entire town is covered in fog.
- 1:45:26Yes. And as you walk through the fog,
- 1:45:28it just gave a great Ambiance and experience and just straight
- 1:45:33chills of you not knowing and then your guy had a little
- 1:45:36radio. And the radio would begin to
- 1:45:39like get staticky when it was somewhere near a monster.
- 1:45:43But of course, you couldn't tell where it was coming from because
- 1:45:45you are walking through the fog. It was very sick.
- 1:45:47It's wonderful. The story itself is a little
- 1:45:49weird, but yeah, as they progressed as the movies and
- 1:45:53games per guest to get some more, we're not talking about
- 1:45:55the game and the movies, every, it's is worth it for the first
- 1:45:58one alone. Absolutely the first, and second
- 1:46:00one, actually, I like those bills.
- 1:46:01Yeah. But yet, now, you ask, why is
- 1:46:06this basement on the hill? Is it?
- 1:46:07Because there's a pyramid headed dude.
- 1:46:09Stalking around with a huge sword.
- 1:46:11Nope. No.
- 1:46:12It's because of the coal fire burning beneath the town.
- 1:46:16Yep. Back in 1966, a fire started and
- 1:46:21one of the coal mining towns. Well I guess one of the and not
- 1:46:27going to say one of the cool money.
- 1:46:28Yeah there you go. Officials had tried to light a
- 1:46:32fire there too. I guess control something and it
- 1:46:36got out of control. Troll and it hit a coal vein and
- 1:46:40which led down to the mine in. Control burns aren't entirely
- 1:46:45all that like new. It's, it's something that places
- 1:46:48that have a lot of wildfires and things do consistently but I
- 1:46:51guess they just didn't do a good job.
- 1:46:53No because it destroyed the entire town.
- 1:46:56I sure as fuck did. So as I went down to the mine
- 1:47:00deep in the mind it slowly began to spread I can't remember.
- 1:47:06I'm sure you probably wrote this.
- 1:47:07This down how long they think this is going to be burning for
- 1:47:10because it's already been, like 70, 80 years, isn't it?
- 1:47:13It's been 50 years. It's been 50 years.
- 1:47:15Okay. How long are they think it's
- 1:47:16going to continue burning on? They said it can burn for like
- 1:47:18another Century. Holy crap, if it's not contain,
- 1:47:20so we'll be long gone before this is Dunya.
- 1:47:25But the cool thing is that people do in Pennsylvania.
- 1:47:27At least that I've seen people do is during winter.
- 1:47:30They go out there. It's like a six hour drive for
- 1:47:32us. It's real far away, is it?
- 1:47:35I heard it was way, way way. Way out and the road to get
- 1:47:39there. Now has been destroyed.
- 1:47:41Britney, you know, how to get there?
- 1:47:43Brittany, mr. Ransome, yes, you're really with
- 1:47:46deep story. Oh, I'm sorry.
- 1:47:51I thought it was really far away though.
- 1:47:53No, it's in Colombia now I got it to a GPS.
- 1:47:57We're gonna tear your story ygp. Oh my god.
- 1:48:02Oh so since the fire burns so deeply there's no real way to
- 1:48:07control it or contain it soon on the ground fire.
- 1:48:12Reach the actual Town causing the roads to split and crack and
- 1:48:18toxic smoke would start spreading start.
- 1:48:20Being out of the cracks air quality, started getting
- 1:48:24dangerous and it took about 20 years before the government gave
- 1:48:29the order to evacuate town. Now, there are very few
- 1:48:34buildings left in the town, including a church, which is,
- 1:48:41I'm pretty sure they based the movie, Silent Hill awful.
- 1:48:43Because there's a church in there and that was the only safe
- 1:48:45place for them to be in. Yeah, you're right and the
- 1:48:49church there is one thing. I've been back in this area for
- 1:48:53so long. Not knowing that Centralia is
- 1:48:56like an hour and change away. I told you, it's me.
- 1:48:58Could have gone there any time now?
- 1:49:01We gotta wait till next winter. Not really.
- 1:49:05No. So a part of the central area is
- 1:49:10the graffiti Highway. Oh, yeah.
- 1:49:12Yeah, I heard about that. Yeah, it was once Route 61 now
- 1:49:18in abandoned highway where everyone has been except for me.
- 1:49:21Apparently, we gotta go. Yeah.
- 1:49:23And Brittany, I guess, we take my friend Jenna.
- 1:49:26Yeah, in general joke. Oh, you know what we can't?
- 1:49:32You could see, like, if you look at pictures, I was in pictures.
- 1:49:35Okay, as you can see like the splitting of the highway where
- 1:49:37we were, the fire has reached in just a cracks and sometimes
- 1:49:42actually smoke Rises up from it. That's the part I want to see
- 1:49:48well as of last year we're not gonna be able to see it.
- 1:49:53The highway was planned to be covered with dirt and have other
- 1:49:57things that have a trees and other plants planted on it,
- 1:50:00right. I heard that it was going to
- 1:50:02just become a big like place but Then what is a road?
- 1:50:07But a place that people just go, like if we just go there with
- 1:50:11you guys. Yeah, we just gone drive through
- 1:50:13the grass, but it's not a highway anymore.
- 1:50:16It was just my way anymore. It's just a big old thing.
- 1:50:19Also did that get like, you know, pushed to the side because
- 1:50:22the Covenant, I'm not sure, I didn't see, we might still be
- 1:50:26able to go before they do it when he was article.
- 1:50:28I read about it. I didn't say anything about it.
- 1:50:30Being pushed back because in 2020 when they posted it, right?
- 1:50:32They didn't say anything about it was an April.
- 1:50:34When they actually We had. Actually, it was back in, you
- 1:50:39know, what's weird. We have a couple of different
- 1:50:41abandoned highways, there's another one.
- 1:50:44There's another one that's like right sort of next to a highway.
- 1:50:47Yes. Abandon turnpike I think it's a
- 1:50:49part of the turnpike that just starts turning off and then goes
- 1:50:53nowhere. Yeah.
- 1:50:54And it's like why do we do this? Look government.
- 1:51:00I've definitely seen one before and I'm like oh they're going to
- 1:51:02finish that and the answer is no.
- 1:51:05Definitely not. It's abandon and there's just a
- 1:51:08nice under past that, you know, people like to hang out and I
- 1:51:13won't be there. Exactly.
- 1:51:14So you All right, so that way, we know now is officially nobody
- 1:51:19there, because a couple years ago, there were like 10 people
- 1:51:21still there. Yeah.
- 1:51:22That was in 2000, was the 2019 when what I read that the
- 1:51:25population was, I'm not sure if anyway, so I would probably
- 1:51:29still go to the ghost town. Yeah, that's where I want to go.
- 1:51:32I don't want to see the highway but we probably can't get to the
- 1:51:34highway, okay, because it's probably covered by dirt by now,
- 1:51:39let's see population 9 as a 20-19.
- 1:51:43I guess we'll find out soon because the census was just
- 1:51:45done. Yes.
- 1:51:46It's true. So if nobody is there anymore, I
- 1:51:48guess there was no wonderful. Census report out.
- 1:51:51Yeah. We'll see.
- 1:51:52We'll see. But you know, that's a cool.
- 1:51:55I yeah. I forgot about the graffiti
- 1:51:57Highway though. That's like the anything know
- 1:52:01what I've always wanted to do is that people go and they take
- 1:52:03pictures there and wintertime. Yeah.
- 1:52:05Because the steam coming out of the ground is extra visible.
- 1:52:08When it's so cold. This is true.
- 1:52:10And you take cool pictures. I just remember being in high
- 1:52:13school and I was, and I found out and I Was telling people
- 1:52:16about Silent. Hills are like, you notice a
- 1:52:18real Silent Hill, right? And I was like what, where it'll
- 1:52:21like Pennsylvania in Pennsylvania.
- 1:52:23I don't like where you're like, Colombia.
- 1:52:25It was like that's like a half an hour away because I live in
- 1:52:27Lancaster at this time. Yeah.
- 1:52:28I'm like that's a half an hour away.
- 1:52:30We can go there. Anytime I noticed that I
- 1:52:32realized was so close. Yeah that's what they do.
- 1:52:34Call it the real side of Hell to I so surprising I remember after
- 1:52:38the movie came out reading something that said that the
- 1:52:40film was based off of central. Yeah and then I had to learn
- 1:52:44everything about it. But I did forget about the
- 1:52:48graffiti Highway used to be the place where everybody would just
- 1:52:50show up in chalk, all over everything and graffiti all over
- 1:52:53everything. Absolutely.
- 1:52:54That was a where our Urban explorers were go.
- 1:52:59Yeah, I'm not really into urban exploring.
- 1:53:02I'm here honest, there's a think they're called, like, the proper
- 1:53:06people or something on YouTube, the something people, and they
- 1:53:09go into places all around the world that have been abandoned
- 1:53:11and they get approval to go for the most part occasionally, they
- 1:53:14just do what they want. But most of the time, they get
- 1:53:17approval to go to these locations and it's just so
- 1:53:20unnerving seeing something that was once.
- 1:53:24Flourishing recently, they went to a movie theater, that was
- 1:53:28only like 40 years old. I had been abandoned I can't and
- 1:53:32it just looked so freaky. Do you know how many freakin
- 1:53:37abandoned, amusement parks are in Pennsylvania, so many,
- 1:53:40they've gone to some of those too many.
- 1:53:43There's so many ways and Knoebels is still going.
- 1:53:45Strong Scruples is going strong, it's never gonna close go.
- 1:53:49Heck noble people go there, man, I go there more.
- 1:53:52They go to Hershey Park. I actually really like the
- 1:53:54place. It's just so freaking far away.
- 1:53:56It really isn't like, well it's a stupid long, dirt, an hour and
- 1:53:59a half from here or something. Not even.
- 1:54:01I felt like when I was a kid, it took forever to get there.
- 1:54:03I'm sure in my little child brain, that was like a six hour.
- 1:54:05Drive. I just wanna go to Knoebels
- 1:54:10again and sit inside that stupid little cart for the haunted
- 1:54:14house because I was so afraid when I was little, look, we went
- 1:54:18there. What time?
- 1:54:19What year did we go there? And it goes before.
- 1:54:21Jaden was born. Was the last time I went to
- 1:54:23Knoebels and when you are babe I was a young and what he was
- 1:54:31here. Early twenties.
- 1:54:32Okay. Yeah, true.
- 1:54:33True true. Listen.
- 1:54:34I think I'll go. I saw a picture of myself when I
- 1:54:36was 23 and I was like, oh look at my face.
- 1:54:38I was such a baby. So you when we later, all right,
- 1:54:43yeah, we went to with there for, like the first time for me, and
- 1:54:46I went through the haunted house, I was like this is some
- 1:54:47bullshit. I remember being terrified of it
- 1:54:51as a kid. I kept my eye screws almost the
- 1:54:53whole time and I want to go through and look at it as a
- 1:54:55grownup. Yeah.
- 1:54:56I don't really do haunted houses either because it's so I don't,
- 1:55:00I just don't like people yelling at me.
- 1:55:02He's like, I don't like people jumping out at me because I have
- 1:55:04reflexes yelling at me for A money and I have reflexes and my
- 1:55:08reflexes might tell me the punch you.
- 1:55:11I don't know. So I don't do those things
- 1:55:13because I don't want to attack somebody trying to draw, just
- 1:55:16slide your around exactly fine. But walking through a haunted
- 1:55:19house or like that, Phil the screens and stuff like that.
- 1:55:22No, thank you. I'm going to those because I
- 1:55:25might go to jail for punching a worker and I'm sorry.
- 1:55:30Anyway, who's gonna do my final story today?
- 1:55:34I'm ready. All right and what's
- 1:55:38Pennsylvania? There is or was is Pittsburgh
- 1:55:44area. Okay.
- 1:55:45Um Western Pennsylvania there is or was an urban legend of the
- 1:55:52Green Man. Also known as Charlie no, face.
- 1:55:57I don't know this person. Yeah, I know.
- 1:56:00It's good, it's good. Yeah, I try to find ones that I
- 1:56:05can't spoil, you know, I'm trying, yeah, I'm sorry, like
- 1:56:10all my stories, like Brittany's, like, oh, wait a second, I do
- 1:56:13this one. Very exciting for me when I know
- 1:56:15things. Okay, so Legend, has it that?
- 1:56:20There's a man that grows that glows green due to a lightning
- 1:56:28strike, or he was shocked by in an industrial accident.
- 1:56:34Who knows? But we know actually, I know,
- 1:56:39I'll tell you what. Okay, apparently he would haunt
- 1:56:43multiple places but like, multiple spots were kids used to
- 1:56:48hang out or people, you hang out at, like Parks, her lookout
- 1:56:51spots like that. But that make out spa and he
- 1:56:58would Chase off, you know, parked cars and, you know,
- 1:57:01people just loitering around the place. now, some people call
- 1:57:05this a legend, but This was an actual person is, this was an
- 1:57:13actual person walking around. Was he just pretending to be a
- 1:57:16haunted? No, no, no.
- 1:57:19Why was he great? Um, so his name was Raymond
- 1:57:25Robinson. Okay, look him up.
- 1:57:28Did Raymond, just not enjoy fun. Is that the situation?
- 1:57:31No, that's not why. In 1919 when he was 8 years old,
- 1:57:36Raymond was reaching for bird's nest on On top of an electrical
- 1:57:40pole when he was shocked with 11,000 volts of electricity,
- 1:57:45which sent him falling to the ground, the shock burn his face
- 1:57:51and arms, leaving his eyes and nose completely burned off or
- 1:57:55out. Oh yeah.
- 1:57:59So it was actually is actual be wasn't actual person.
- 1:58:02Oh, this is sad. So, even though this was a
- 1:58:07terrible injury for him, he was still in like, in good spirits.
- 1:58:10He didn't let his injuries get him down, there's actually get
- 1:58:14him down. Adulthood, he kept himself, he
- 1:58:19kept himself home making wallets belts you know during mads for
- 1:58:22people just so he can make some type of small income.
- 1:58:24What? He was a crafter.
- 1:58:27Look, I love crafty people, he really only left his house in a
- 1:58:33dead of night. To go for a walk as not to scare
- 1:58:37people, not to scare anyone. These are really, really
- 1:58:42thoughtful. Dude.
- 1:58:43You really like against just walk in all this Sudden somebody
- 1:58:47screams and runs away. Yeah, base terrible.
- 1:58:52So this is when the story is with start beginning.
- 1:58:55When he's doing his walks, high school, kids would see him
- 1:59:01walking from the Cars along Route 351 and they just gonna go
- 1:59:06spread the word. Is this guy, he's apparently he
- 1:59:09was green because probably because of his like, flannel
- 1:59:13day, he was wearing. Yeah, I just saw a picture, he's
- 1:59:15wearing like a An army jacket. Yeah, there you go.
- 1:59:20See ya now. Your right.
- 1:59:21Is that, I guess it's a. What is that fabric?
- 1:59:24Yeah, like Dickies that like fabric.
- 1:59:27What is this like, you know like those pants?
- 1:59:30Yeah, khaki. Yeah, Green khaki there.
- 1:59:32Yeah, I couldn't figure out what it was called.
- 1:59:35Army fatigues or something. There you go.
- 1:59:36Yeah, he's wearing like, one of those jackets.
- 1:59:38Sure. So many people knew Raymond,
- 1:59:41many people who knew Raymond were very friendly to him, even
- 1:59:46offering him beer for his walks. Or cigarettes, like a good time.
- 1:59:51Like everybody who knew this guy.
- 1:59:53Super cool people. People who didn't know Raymond,
- 1:59:58they were scared of him. Of course you don't see him for
- 2:00:01the first time and they'd run off and try to call the cops
- 2:00:03saying. There's some buddy out there and
- 2:00:09you need to come get him. But you know, his neighbors or
- 2:00:12people in the neighborhood, they would explain to these people.
- 2:00:15Hey, don't call the cops. It's just Raymond.
- 2:00:17This is what happened to him on use Only child and you know
- 2:00:19this. Why he looks like this now, no
- 2:00:21reason to be no reason to be afraid of him.
- 2:00:23He's a cool guy. All that good stuff.
- 2:00:26Um, I guess now if you see him, he's a fucking ghost.
- 2:00:31Yeah, so some other people, unfortunately, we're cruel, they
- 2:00:39would give him rides. They pick them up off the side
- 2:00:42of the road when he's walking like, hey, I'll give you a ride
- 2:00:44home. Only to take him somewhere, he
- 2:00:46had no idea where he was going because he was blind.
- 2:00:51Yes. Yeah.
- 2:00:52This is a very wow, kind of picture.
- 2:00:57Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:00:59How do you elect people are amazing?
- 2:01:02Their bodies? You mean yeah.
- 2:01:04He legitimately like I see why they people referred to him as
- 2:01:07no face like he really doesn't. He's a mouth obviously because
- 2:01:10no eyes. Yeah like his skin healed over
- 2:01:12that. So I'm like he's just Vibing
- 2:01:16with the world. Yeah.
- 2:01:18Yeah. Basically, anybody who knew him
- 2:01:22would, you know, tell you how nice he was, and how awesome he
- 2:01:25was. He did pass away from natural
- 2:01:28causes and 1985 but the legend lives on wasn't even born yet.
- 2:01:33No, neither of us were born. Yeah.
- 2:01:37But yeah, but yeah, I guess they still talk about him to this
- 2:01:41day. There goes my pain, I was
- 2:01:44looking for. I was like, what the hell is it?
- 2:01:45My hair? Spooky, Pennsylvania.
- 2:01:50Those are some stories that I like, I've looked at and I
- 2:01:55wanted to do like earlier in the podcast because You know, this
- 2:02:00is where we're from. I want to, you know, give you a
- 2:02:02little heads-up and that we like spooky stuff in this is what
- 2:02:08raised us. Great stories.
- 2:02:09They were good. Good good stuff.
- 2:02:10Yeah. I definitely want to go Central.
- 2:02:13I like this still a thing I want to do but um is it the ghost
- 2:02:17him? Ghost Town?
- 2:02:18Yes, I'm pretty sure it was a ghost towns around.
- 2:02:20Oh yeah we could probably visit a couple more.
- 2:02:22Oh yeah. Buts in Charlie's the one that I
- 2:02:24believe is an actually haunted, it's not haunted.
- 2:02:27I don't want to go to one. That's actually haunted.
- 2:02:29Well, good. Because we're going to get lost
- 2:02:30there and by the ghost or something.
- 2:02:33Don't get eaten by Ghosts. No.
- 2:02:41Oh, oh Brian. I know.
- 2:02:44Oh me. Anyway though, that's all we got
- 2:02:49for you tonight. Yeah.
- 2:02:53Or this morning for some of you, there's like a good 30 or 40
- 2:02:56people who listened at like, 5 a.m.
- 2:02:58As soon as the podcast comes out.
- 2:03:00Bless you all. That's very lovely.
- 2:03:02Yeah, I mean, if so, why get that time too?
- 2:03:04But as because I'm working, I'm pretty sure is why you guys are
- 2:03:07listening to get. Probably yeah, we got a couple.
- 2:03:09Belen night crew, who are with you.
- 2:03:10Yeah. Hey guys, thanks.
- 2:03:12Thanks for listening to me and thank you.
- 2:03:16If you listen, all the way through for this is last week,
- 2:03:20was the second time that we broke into the top, 100, your
- 2:03:24kind podcasts and America. So that's pretty fancy.
- 2:03:27It was awesome. And as usual, I still sell all
- 2:03:31kinds of jewelry and making Pride things for June.
- 2:03:35Yes, I can't wait. I got you some pit.
- 2:03:39I got some pens to. I'm going to be making a cool
- 2:03:41looking. You can wear a pen.
- 2:03:43I can wear pants. I got it here.
- 2:03:44I got my that. You want me.
- 2:03:45Give you one ear? Yes.
- 2:03:46Just one ear. I'm good.
- 2:03:47I think it's over there. Yes, Larry give you the one.
- 2:03:49I just says, hi. I'm Pam.
- 2:03:51There you go. Appreciate it.
- 2:03:54And yeah, those are what we're doing these days.
- 2:03:56You can always find us on crease with Brian or caught podcasts on
- 2:04:02Tick-Tock. You can watch us as we are
- 2:04:05currently playing through the Each Resident Evil eight.
- 2:04:09Yes, on Twitch foxy trainer every Sunday night.
- 2:04:15Yeah, I try to get on at 6:00 6:30.
- 2:04:19What do we do? Oh well we just had her fight
- 2:04:21with our first plate with Lady Democratic demouth risk and
- 2:04:25actually you know what it she says, da mattress.
- 2:04:30She says yes, that's it, listen that again, yeah.
- 2:04:32Like at the how dare you defile house dumb address or the How's
- 2:04:38da mattress bloodline? Has been fooled by you.
- 2:04:41How dare you and stuff like that?
- 2:04:43Yeah, I missed that. I'll have to do that again.
- 2:04:46When I watch somebody else play through it.
- 2:04:47Yeah, but yeah. And yeah, if you have any if you
- 2:04:52want to like leave us like an email.
- 2:04:55Absolutely. If you send an email, definitely
- 2:04:56shout you out. Just like we did last week was
- 2:04:59last week or week before, I believe it was, it was whatever
- 2:05:02it was. She responded to us.
- 2:05:05She's like I said my name and I was like, of course.
- 2:05:07Course. Yes, I think it was the week
- 2:05:09before. Okay.
- 2:05:10He was a Nica but yeah, caught podcasts at gmail.com.
- 2:05:13There you go. And that's also there's like 300
- 2:05:17people following on YouTube right now and I've only put up
- 2:05:20two of the podcast. Look, I'm working on it, I'm
- 2:05:23getting to it. I gotta work on getting some
- 2:05:26sort of some software done, I can probably I don't know, we'll
- 2:05:29get, we'll get to it. I swear over this break, I'll
- 2:05:32get it done probably But yeah, you have yourself a good night
- 2:05:39or good morning. Hey, good morning to my night
- 2:05:42crew and we'll see you next week.
- 2:05:45Yep. Bye.