Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1064: From Formula Recall to Federal Grants: How Public Health Responds Under Pressure
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review MORNING Edition for Thursday,
- 0:03February 5th, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:10Today we'll hear about a rare and unprecedented infant
- 0:13Botulism outbreak linked to contaminated infant formula from
- 0:17Doctor Eric Upon, director and state Public health officer for
- 0:20the California Department of Public Health and ASTO member.
- 0:24California is home to the only infant Botulism treatment in the
- 0:27world. Later, we'll change gears and
- 0:30hear how ASTO is helping US island jurisdictions navigate
- 0:33complex federal grant systems. Our guest, Alex Wheatley, Senior
- 0:37Director of Island Support at ASTO, joins us to discuss a new
- 0:41resource designed to bridge gaps between federal funders and
- 0:44local health agencies. But let's start with Doctor Eric
- 0:48Upon. I wanted to know how
- 0:49California's Infant Botulism Treatment Prevention Program
- 0:52first detected the most recent increase in cases and what
- 0:56sparked the investigation. We have a really unique program
- 1:00here in the California Department of Public Health,
- 1:02where we had developed this product called Baby Big, which
- 1:06is the only treatment in the world actually much less the
- 1:09country, for infant Botulism specifically.
- 1:12It was developed in the 1990s. We actually got FDA approval to
- 1:16produce this drug in 2003. So it's the only source.
- 1:20And our clinicians who run this program received calls from
- 1:24clinicians all over the country with suspect cases.
- 1:28And then after they determine if it's an actual case or or
- 1:31worrisome for a case, they actually send the treatment out
- 1:34and also facilitate making sure that the infant gets tested.
- 1:38So because they get that first line call on these suspect
- 1:42cases, they started to notice this pattern of, gosh, it seems
- 1:46like we've heard a few Times Now that these cases have consumed
- 1:50this particular brand of infant formula.
- 1:52So that's sort of the the background of how it evolved and
- 1:55why a California specifically started noting a national
- 1:58outbreak. This is the only product we have
- 2:00like this. It's definitely a unique role
- 2:02for a health department to have and just due to some really
- 2:04amazing scientists and dedicated people who who worked on this
- 2:08decades ago. And Doctor Pan, was there
- 2:10anything unusual about this outbreak?
- 2:14Yes, I think it's important for people to kind of know and
- 2:18recognize that infant Botulism in general is typically what we
- 2:21would call a sporadic disease. And we often don't find out what
- 2:24the source is. It's it's a common spore in the
- 2:28environment. It can be in dust and soil.
- 2:30So most of the time we actually don't know what an exposure is
- 2:33for infants. It was really unusual and
- 2:36remarkable that this was the first contamination of infant
- 2:39formula and the first outbreak like this of a contaminated
- 2:42infant formula. And what can other states do to
- 2:48coordinate? With with.
- 2:50CDC with the FDA. If.
- 2:52If they start seeing their own rising cases.
- 2:56Yes, all of these cases are reportable to the CDC and
- 3:00there's been a lot of great coordination with our department
- 3:03and the CDC and the FDA that does the investigation of the
- 3:07actual formula manufacturer and producer.
- 3:10And this works like many other reportable infectious diseases
- 3:13or outbreak investigations. So frontline health departments
- 3:18end up hearing about, you know, a rise in cases or see a pattern
- 3:22and then there can be a multi state coordination and
- 3:25investigation. So this happens with again, many
- 3:28other large infectious disease outbreaks as well.
- 3:31And that coordination has gone well between the CDCFDA, our
- 3:35department and then the other states that have had cases.
- 3:38It strikes me as. Kind of incredible that the
- 3:42California Department has such a this robust program that it
- 3:45developed Baby big, the only treatment for infant Botulism.
- 3:50How does that? Distribution work.
- 3:52How are you able to distribute? It nationally.
- 3:56Yeah. We've spent a lot of time,
- 3:57especially recently with this outing making sure we have a
- 4:00sufficient supply. We do have a fee that gets sent
- 4:05for the treatment and then, you know, that goes into a special
- 4:08fund to help do the production and manufacturing.
- 4:12We've definitely been watching very closely over time.
- 4:15There are lots that are created and then, you know, projections
- 4:20that have happened historically on how much do we think we, you
- 4:23know, need and use. And we were concerned during the
- 4:26peak of this outbreak that we might need to do some other
- 4:29things to make sure there was enough.
- 4:30Thankfully, the outbreak does seem to have subsided.
- 4:33We have once the recall happened of the Bahart and the formula,
- 4:36we've not seen new cases since December, I believe.
- 4:40So we seem to be on track to have sufficient supply of this
- 4:44baby big product. But it is something that we were
- 4:48working closely with the FDA and others to make sure we would
- 4:50have enough. That would that should have been
- 4:53one of my earlier questions is what is the status of the
- 4:56outbreak. So cases are are are going down.
- 4:59The worst seems to be behind us. Yes, that's right.
- 5:02There was a total of 51 cases nationally especially they
- 5:06looked back at before this year and there were a few additional
- 5:10infants that had consumed the same by heart formula, but 51
- 5:13cases as of mid-december and no new cases that we've identified
- 5:17since then. And another aspect of of the
- 5:21response has been a a hotline set up to specifically address
- 5:27infant Botulism. Can you tell us about it?
- 5:30Sure. And I would just say that this
- 5:32is definitely an area that I have encountered both in my work
- 5:36at the local level and at the state level.
- 5:38Occasionally when there is a big public health emergency, there
- 5:41are a lot of important questions from the public and ideally you
- 5:44set up a way to triage those so that the public can get some of
- 5:48their questions answered. But people who are doing the
- 5:51investigations of highly suspicious cases or in this
- 5:53case, clinicians are able to get through as well to get the
- 5:58information and the potential treatment and testing needed.
- 6:01So this evolved because we have a hotline in general for
- 6:04clinicians across the country to call when they have a suspect
- 6:06case. But as the news got out about
- 6:08this outbreak, there were more and more calls.
- 6:11So we tried to offload that first with some of our own
- 6:14staff. And so we actually cross trained
- 6:17some of our staff within the state health department to help
- 6:19answer some of the calls from the public or families or
- 6:22concerned families related to the outbreak.
- 6:24We were also at the same time thinking about trying to
- 6:27reactivate a contract that we used during the COVID pandemic
- 6:30when we stood up a public hotline as well.
- 6:32But I will say this is a real challenge in public health in
- 6:35general where we are often trying to have things on the
- 6:38ready or standby for surges or emergencies and often have
- 6:43challenges in the administrative processes or the resources to do
- 6:46that. In the end, thankfully, again,
- 6:48because the outbreak subsided and the calls subsided, we were
- 6:52able to redirect to our our sort of normal processes and we've
- 6:56been able to allow the staff that had been redirected to
- 7:00answer calls go back to their normal work.
- 7:02And we didn't activate this other contract.
- 7:04But I do think it's, it's an ongoing challenge that I would
- 7:07actually love to learn from other health departments as
- 7:09well, if they've been able to figure this out on how to have
- 7:12some sort of standby call Center for these kinds of situations.
- 7:16Because it very quickly becomes an important issue.
- 7:19And you can get your sort of usual investigators or
- 7:23responders can get flooded when you want to be able to offload
- 7:26that so that you don't delay the investigation or or in this case
- 7:29treatment of cases. And something that goes sort of
- 7:33hand in hand with the hotline is making sure that people know
- 7:36that a hotline exists or just that there are rising cases and
- 7:40and for the public to be aware of it.
- 7:42Can you talk about sort of the challenges?
- 7:44Of just getting. That word out?
- 7:47Sure. I think it's another important
- 7:49role of health departments. When you have these outbreaks
- 7:51and you're looking to increase awareness and also increase
- 7:54detection, sometimes many of these diseases might start very
- 7:58non specifically this particular disease of infant Botulism can
- 8:03be quite distinctive once it progresses.
- 8:04So babies are very weak and floppy.
- 8:07They don't have head control, but really making sure people
- 8:10are alerted quickly to get seen by their health care provider
- 8:14and doing health alerts and or public information is the other
- 8:17thing that we encourage health departments across the country
- 8:20to do. When we were all learning about
- 8:22this multi state outbreak because this product was
- 8:25distributed to many states. So that's just another role I
- 8:28think we're always working on together as a public health
- 8:31community to get information out to help providers and also
- 8:34families and the public's that they know to look for certain
- 8:37signs or symptoms and report them so they can get the help
- 8:40they need. Doctor Eric Upon is director and
- 8:44state public health officer for the California Department of
- 8:46Public Health and an ASTO member.
- 8:50Now let's hear from Alex Wheatley, senior director of
- 8:52Island Support at ASTO, who will explain a new resource designed
- 8:56to help island and territorial public health systems navigate
- 8:59federal grant requirements. So we have a lot of wisdom in
- 9:03our island areas workgroup, health financing subgroup.
- 9:06These are the folks that get asked difficult questions around
- 9:10grants management all the time. And they said, you know, it'd be
- 9:12great if there was a centralized resource that had all of this.
- 9:16It felt particularly important with all the federal
- 9:18uncertainty. Right now, as funding shifts or
- 9:22is a little bit unclear, it's more important than ever to have
- 9:24strong relationships between grand tours and grantees.
- 9:28So what kind of information were they?
- 9:30Were they being asked to share? A wide variety.
- 9:33So some of the common paying points are around federal grant
- 9:38platforms and processes, who needs access to what and when.
- 9:42They also got sort of the inverse of that question.
- 9:44Grant grantor is not understanding what the local
- 9:47processes were. So they said, well, why can't
- 9:49you fix this? And the health agency would say,
- 9:51because that's the Department of Finance's job.
- 9:54So just clarifying some expectations there.
- 9:57And this sort of gets to this sense of foundational knowledge
- 10:00that gets mentioned a lot. And in the report, what are some
- 10:04other sort of common misconceptions that that both
- 10:08sides were not seeing? Yeah, I think it's really
- 10:11important for project officers and technical monitors to
- 10:14understand what's happening on the ground.
- 10:16Just as important as grantees understanding the current
- 10:21federal guidance, I think those sorts of details are what prompt
- 10:27effective spend down and actually prompts the impacts
- 10:30that federal grantors and grantees want to see.
- 10:33But those conversations don't always come up at the start of
- 10:36the grant period, and that's what this resource is really
- 10:38trying to prompt. Yeah.
- 10:40Can you give us some examples of the kinds of things that that
- 10:45are in the resource? Sure.
- 10:47So the resources really built around conversation prompts.
- 10:50It's broken into five different sections of sorts of pain points
- 10:53that we know come up frequently. And then within those, it
- 10:57provides a little bit of background about what grantors
- 11:00need to know and what grantees need to know, and then questions
- 11:03to help a productive conversation at the start of the
- 11:05grant period to identify some of those pain points and then avoid
- 11:09them. The Federated States of
- 11:11Micronesia is 1 of Asto's members.
- 11:14Their National Health agency. I'm going to refer to them as
- 11:17FSM National. Before FSM National can spend
- 11:21down funds that CDC has awarded to them, the FSM Congress has to
- 11:26approve those funds and establish an account.
- 11:28Congress meets once 1/4. In addition, where the funds
- 11:31actually get spent is at the local level.
- 11:33For FSM National to pass the funds to local, local
- 11:36legislature also has to meet and set up an account.
- 11:39That whole process can mean 6 to 8 months before any dollars can
- 11:43be spent, and it's important that federal funders understand
- 11:46that. Gotcha.
- 11:48And because it's relying on 2 systems that don't necessarily
- 11:52talk to each other or wouldn't have been consulted ahead of
- 11:56this grant, it's important to have some kind of link to
- 12:01explain those differences. Exactly.
- 12:04Federal funders say, well, we haven't seen the request come
- 12:07through to draw down the funds. And FSM says of course you
- 12:10haven't, it's only in stage 2 of 17, but that's not always clear.
- 12:15And so to to that point there are there are suggested changes
- 12:20within the report. What kinds?
- 12:22What kinds of changes do you suggest, and is it for the
- 12:25grantees? Or the grantors.
- 12:27It's for both. I think we really leaned on the
- 12:31wisdom of the health financing subgroup.
- 12:33It is the grants management staff from islands, from federal
- 12:36agencies, from nonprofits suggesting just some best
- 12:39practices that they've seen work in terms of how do you monitor
- 12:42your spend down? How do you keep up to date on
- 12:45the most recent federal guidance?
- 12:47How do you troubleshoot when things come up?
- 12:49There are best practices, but they're not easy to find.
- 12:53So this resource, we hope, makes them easy to find.
- 12:56Yeah. And are there other steps for
- 12:59just improving the? Overall relationship.
- 13:02I think it's it's all about. Trust.
- 13:04It's all about communication and it's about setting feasible
- 13:07expectations. And I think those things are
- 13:09hard. There isn't an easy answer, but
- 13:13prompting some conversations to get at some of these issues
- 13:17early and then sort of making it clear that you're on the same
- 13:21team and you want these funds to be used for these purposes with
- 13:24these impacts, that can go a long way.
- 13:27You touched on this a little, but could you explain a little
- 13:29bit more how how these questions can lead to?
- 13:33To better understanding. Absolutely.
- 13:36I think meaningful dialogue early on is what strengthens
- 13:39working relationships. And by fostering mutual
- 13:43understanding, having some of the same vocabulary and the same
- 13:46understanding of some of the basics, I think that strengthens
- 13:50engagement. It sets the ground for more
- 13:51collaboration and it just opens lines of communications so that
- 13:56both grant tours and grantees set themselves up for successful
- 14:00grant implementation and the positive impacts that everybody
- 14:03wants. Yeah.
- 14:04And and also to your point, we could be talking about
- 14:09conversations between communities half a globe away.
- 14:14I feel like there's a lot of, there's a lot of room from his
- 14:18communication. Absolutely.
- 14:19If you send, if you have office hours from 1:00 to 2:00 PM
- 14:23Eastern, that's the middle of the night in the Pacific.
- 14:25So how do you work around it? Alex Wheatley is senior director
- 14:29of Island support at ASTO. Earlier we heard from.
- 14:32Doctor Eric Upon, Who's director and state public health officer
- 14:35for the California Department of Public Health and an ASTO
- 14:38member. State health agencies lay the
- 14:42groundwork for sustainable and equitable contraceptive access.
- 14:45They play a pivotal role in expanding access to
- 14:48contraception by supporting the implementation of Pharmacist
- 14:51Prescribed contraception PPC. The new ASTO report, State
- 14:55Health Agency's Role in Implementing Pharmacist
- 14:58Prescribed Contraception, walks readers through three major
- 15:02areas for doing so, mechanisms that expand pharmacist roles and
- 15:05contraceptive access, payment for services, and workforce
- 15:09education and consumer awareness.
- 15:11Find a link to the report in the show notes.
- 15:15Join Manisha Juthani, MD, commissioner at the Connecticut
- 15:17Department of Public Health and ASTO President, and John
- 15:21Auerbach, MBA, senior vice president for Public Health at
- 15:24ICF, for an insight and inspiration webinar that
- 15:27examines how clear, purposeful leadership strengthens both
- 15:30internal and external trust. Through discussion and
- 15:33reflection, we will examine how leaders embodies steadiness amid
- 15:37uncertainty, set a sustainable pace, and provide calm direction
- 15:40that builds trust and drives performance.
- 15:43This conversation aims to inspire participants to
- 15:46recognize their composure and capacity not as a personal
- 15:49indulgence, but as a fundamental leadership function that shapes
- 15:52the overall tone, focus, and confidence of their
- 15:55organizations. Join us for this Steady Hands,
- 15:58steady teams leading with Confidence and composure session
- 16:02happening February 11th at 4:00 PM Eastern.
- 16:06The link to register is in the show notes.
- 16:09This has been Public Health Review MORNING Edition.
- 16:11I'm John Sheehan for the Association of State and
- 16:14Territorial Health Officials.